Road surface diagnostic device and method therefor
The road surface diagnosis device improves accuracy by scoring tire conditions and generating an index based on temporal tire score fluctuations, effectively filtering out noise from driving conditions to provide precise road surface roughness assessment.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023086362
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-25
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
AI Technical Summary
Conventional road surface diagnosis methods using tire speed changes and speed differences between tires are prone to noise due to tire condition changes caused by the probe car's driving conditions, leading to inaccurate diagnosis results.
A road surface diagnosis device that scores tire conditions and generates an index based on temporal fluctuations in tire scores, canceling out tire condition changes caused by the probe car's driving, using a scoring unit, index generation unit, and standard score patterns to refine the road surface roughness assessment.
The device provides a more accurate road surface roughness index by isolating tire condition changes from driving conditions, allowing for precise road surface evaluation.
Smart Images

Figure 2024169142000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a road surface diagnostic device and method, which are preferably used for inspecting road pavement. [Background technology]
[0002] According to the Road Pavement Inspection Guidelines (Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism), inspection methods for damage to road pavement are set appropriately by the road administrator, and inspection methods using equipment are permitted. As an example of a road surface diagnosis method, one that uses a probe car is proposed in Patent Document 1. In this method, the roughness (unevenness) of the road surface is estimated based on the change over time in tire speed. Additionally, the road surface diagnosis method described in Patent Document 2 uses the speed difference between the left and right tires. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2020-013537 A [Patent Document 2] JP 2021-189627 A [Patent Document 3] JP 2013-184650 A DISCLOSURE OF THEINVENTION [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0004] In conventional diagnostic methods, information on the time-dependent change in tire speed (Patent Document 1) and the speed difference between the left and right tires (Patent Document 2) is processed to estimate and diagnose the road surface condition. However, according to the inventor's investigations, a change in tire speed over time can occur when the probe car simply accelerates or decelerates, and a speed difference between the left and right tires can also occur when the probe car simply turns right or left. When diagnosing road surfaces, there is no method proposed to cancel changes in tire conditions caused by the driving state of the probe car, so there is a risk that the obtained diagnosis results will contain noise and accurate road surface diagnosis will not be possible. [Means for solving the problem]
[0005] The present invention has been made to solve the above problems, and a first aspect thereof is defined as follows. A road surface diagnosis device that generates an index of road surface roughness, a tire condition specifying unit that specifies the conditions of a plurality of tires of the probe car; a score assigning unit that assigns a score to each tire representing the state of the tire at the nth time and the (n+1)th time specified by the tire state specifying unit; an index generating unit that generates an index corresponding to the roughness of a road surface based on a time variation of the score of each tire; A road surface diagnosis device comprising:
[0006] According to the road surface diagnosis device of the first aspect defined as above, the score assigning unit assigns a score to the condition of the tires of the probe car, and the roughness of the road surface is indexed based on the temporal variation of the score assigned to each tire. The index obtained in this way reflects the road surface conditions more accurately than conventional road surface diagnosis methods.
[0007] This is thought to be because the condition of each tire is scored and an index is generated based on the temporal fluctuation, so that the tire condition caused by the driving condition of the probe car itself is cancelled. For example, when a rear-wheel drive probe car turns right, if the ranking of the speeds of the front left tire (front left), front right tire (front right), rear left tire (rear left) and rear right tire (rear right) on a smooth road surface is taken as the score, it will be: front left: 3, front right: 4, rear left: 1, rear right: 2. As long as the probe car continues to turn right, this ranking (score) is maintained as an absolute value regardless of the steering angle or deceleration / acceleration. Here, if there is a change in the roughness of the road surface, this will affect the tire speed, and the above ranking (score) will change. In the index generated by the index generation unit of the first aspect of the present invention, this change in score is made visible, and as a result, the change in tire condition caused by the driving state of the probe car is canceled or attenuated, and the change in tire condition caused by the roughness of the road surface is emphasized.
[0008] As described above, the tire speed can be used as a score representing the tire condition. Here, the speed may be a speed obtained from the tire radius and angular velocity, or simply the angular velocity may be used. Those skilled in the art can easily conceive of the use of acceleration obtained by differentiating this speed as the index. The score of the tire condition is not particularly limited as long as it reflects the road surface condition, and for example, the air pressure or the repulsive force from the road surface can be used. It is preferable that the tire condition detection unit detects the condition of each of the four tires, front left, front right, rear left, and rear right, of the vehicle.
[0009] The score representing the tire condition is not particularly limited as long as it is a value that can express the time variation, but it is preferable that it is a value that quantifies the absolute relationship between tires, such as the ranking of the speed of each tire. Here, "absolute" means that it is not affected by the difference in the condition between tires. The magnitude of the score can be set arbitrarily, and for example, in the above-mentioned example when a probe car turns right on a smooth road, scores can be assigned in order of slowest speed (score: front left: 2, front right: 1, rear left: 4, rear right: 3), or the numerical value representing the ranking can be processed (score: rank 1 = 1 x 1, rank 2 = 2 x 2, rank 3 = 3 x 2, rank 4 = 4 x 4).
[0010] The second aspect of the present invention is defined as follows: In the road surface diagnosis device according to the first aspect, the index generating unit includes a first counting unit and a second counting unit, and the first counting unit includes a first calculation unit that calculates, for each tire, a relationship between the score of each tire at the n time and the score of each tire at the n+1 time; a second calculation unit that collects the calculation results for each tire calculated by the first calculation unit, The second counting unit causes the first counting unit to repeat the calculation k times (k is an integer equal to or greater than 4), where n+1 is n, and counts up the calculation results of the second calculation unit each time. According to the road surface diagnosis device of the second aspect thus defined, the time variation of the score of each tire is reflected in the calculation of the first calculation unit. The calculation result for each tire in which the time variation of the score is reflected is tallied by the second calculation unit. The second talliation unit repeats the counting by the second calculation unit k times, and further tallies the tallied results obtained each time. Since the probe car continues to run for a predetermined period of time, the influence of the probe car's running state on the index of each tire can be reduced by repeating the calculation as described above.
[0011] A third aspect of the present invention is defined as follows. In the road surface diagnosis device according to a second aspect, the score assigning unit assigns a score to each tire based on a ranking of the tire speeds, The first calculation unit calculates a difference between the scores for each tire, The second calculation unit adds up the score differences for all tires, The second counting unit repeats the calculation of the first counting unit k times (k is an integer equal to or greater than 4, for example) where n+1 is n, and adds up the addition results of the second calculation unit each time.
[0012] The sum thus obtained becomes an index and is expressed as a scalar. Here, the interval between time n and time n+1 can be 10 to 100 ms, and k can be 4 to 20. For example, if the interval is 50 ms and k = 20, the condition (roughness) of the road surface on which the probe car traveled in 1 second can be expressed as a scalar. At this time, by referring to the probe car's speed v (m / sec), the road surface conditions at vm can be expressed as a scalar.
[0013] An index represented as a scalar can be associated with the results of actual road surface diagnosis obtained by other methods such as visual inspection. Based on such an association, by setting a threshold value for the scalar, it becomes possible to extract a road surface that requires actual road surface diagnosis such as visual inspection.
[0014] In another aspect of the present invention, changes in the state of each tire due to the driving state of the probe car are more actively canceled. Therefore, based on the driving information of the probe car such as the steering angle, the opening of the brake and the accelerator, the pattern of the score of each tire on a smooth road surface (standard score pattern) is stored in advance in the standard score pattern storage unit. Here, the driving information includes, in addition to the probe information (position information, time information) generally obtained from the probe car, the vehicle inner information of the probe car. Here, the vehicle inner information is information regarding various states of the vehicle output from sensors, control units, etc. provided in the vehicle, and is information that can be transmitted by various communication protocols including CAN (Controller Area Network) on the network mounted on the vehicle. This vehicle inner information includes driving speed information, acceleration information, brake operation information, steering angle information of the steering wheel, and other information.
[0015] The score of each tire given by the score assigning unit is compared with the standard score pattern by the score comparison unit. When there is a difference between the two, it is presumed that the road surface is rough at the time when the score assigning unit assigns the score. Therefore, it can be corrected so that the calculation result of the second calculation unit is enhanced. For example, when the calculation of the first calculation unit represents the difference in the scores of each tire and the calculation of the second calculation unit adds the difference, the addition result of the second calculation unit can be multiplied by a parameter m (1 < m) or a parameter n (1 < n) can be added.
[0016] The invention of the method using the invention of the apparatus defined in the first aspect is defined as follows. That is, A road surface diagnosis method using a road surface diagnosis device that generates an index of roughness of a road surface, the road surface diagnosis device comprising: a tire condition specification unit, a score assignment unit, and an index generation unit; causing the tire condition specifying unit to specify conditions of a plurality of tires of a probe car; causing the score assigning unit to assign to each tire a score representing the state of the tire at the nth time and the (n+1)th time specified by the tire state specifying unit; a road surface diagnosis method for causing the index generation unit to generate an index corresponding to roughness of a road surface based on a temporal variation in the score of each tire.
[0017] The program for causing a computer to execute the program used in the device defined in the first aspect of the present invention is defined as follows: A computer program for use in a road surface diagnosis device that generates an index of roughness of a road surface, the road surface diagnosis device comprising: a tire condition specification unit; a score assignment unit; and an index generation unit; causing the tire condition specifying unit to specify conditions of a plurality of tires of a probe car; causing the score assigning unit to assign to each tire a score representing the state of the tire at the nth time and the (n+1)th time specified by the tire state specifying unit; A computer program that causes the index generation unit to generate an index corresponding to the roughness of a road surface based on a temporal variation in the score of each of the tires. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0018] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a block diagram showing the configuration of a road surface diagnosis device according to an embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing the configuration of the road surface information display device according to the embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 3] Figure 3 shows the relationship between a map reflecting the indicators generated by the road surface diagnostic device and on-site photographs. [Figure 4] FIG. 4 is a block diagram showing the configuration of a road surface diagnosis device according to another embodiment of the present invention. [Diagram 5]FIG. 5 is a schematic diagram showing the structure of a computer applied to the road surface diagnosis device. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0019] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention will be described with reference to the drawings. 1 shows a road surface diagnosis device 1 according to an embodiment of the present invention. This road surface diagnosis device 1 includes a travel information storage unit 10, a tire speed identification unit 20, a score assignment unit 30, and an index generation unit 40. The driving information of the probe car is stored in the driving information storage unit 10. More specifically, the speed information of each tire of the probe car, the acceleration information of the probe car itself, the steering angle information, etc. are stored.
[0020] The tire speed identification unit 20 is equipped with a front left tire speed identification unit 21, a front right tire speed identification unit 22, a rear left tire speed identification unit 25 and a rear right tire speed identification unit 26, and determines the speed of each tire of the probe car based on the driving information of the probe car stored in the driving information storage unit 10.
[0021] Table 1 shows an example of the speed of each tire (front left, front right, rear left, rear right) of the probe car identified by each tire speed identification unit 21, 22, 25, 26. This speed indicates the speed in the vehicle movement direction calculated from the tire radius x angular velocity, for example. [Table 1] In Table 1, the probe car is identified by its individual vehicle ID, and the time at which the speed of each tire was obtained, as well as the coordinates and acceleration at that time, are also identified.
[0022] The score assigning section 30 assigns a rank to the speed of each tire, and the rank is used as a score. The index generating unit 40 includes a first counting unit 50 and a second counting unit 60. The first counting unit 50 includes a first calculation unit 51 and a second calculation unit 52 . The first calculation unit 51 calculates the ranking difference of each tire at each time point n and the following time point n+1 (see Table 2). [Table 2] In Table 1, time 31:49:10 is n, time 31:09:20 is n+1, and time 31:39:20 is n+2. The ranking difference (absolute value) for each tire is shown in column A of Table 2.
[0023] The second calculation unit 52 tallies (adds up) the ranking differences of each tire (column B of Table 2). The second calculation unit 52 calculates the subtotal of the rank difference shown in column B of Table 2 for all time points.
[0024] The second counting unit 60 counts (adds) the rank difference subtotals shown in column B of Table 2 from time n to n+k (k=10) to obtain an index, and an example of repeating this process is shown in Table 3. The value in the column for the rank difference total for 10 frames in Table 3 is the index, and is expressed as a scalar. [Table 3] The higher the index, the more the speed rankings of the tires are swapped, and thus the rougher the road surface is.
[0025] This index can be expressed as a numerical value (scalar), so the threshold can be set arbitrarily. Also, the coordinates in Table 3 can be used to identify the area of the road that corresponds to this index. FIG. 2 is a block diagram showing the configuration of a device (road surface information display device 70) that reflects the indicators of identified road areas on a map. The coordinates of the identified road area and the markers are stored in the marker storage unit 71, and the markers are superimposed on the map data stored in the map data storage unit 73 by the road surface information superimposition unit 75, thereby making it possible to display the markers on the map as shown in Fig. 3. In Fig. 3, the markers are shaded (colored) based on a preset threshold value.
[0026] The road within the square frame shown on the map on the right side of Figure 3 includes dark areas (large indicators) and light areas (small indicators), and a photograph of the road in question is shown on the left. It can be seen that there is a change in the roughness of the road surface in the square frame area. This allows road managers, when inspecting road pavement, to focus their attention on road areas with large indicators.
[0027] Fig. 4 shows a road surface diagnosis device 100 according to another embodiment. Elements that operate in the same manner as in Fig. 1 are given the same reference numerals and their explanation will be omitted. It is assumed that the probe car was making a right turn in frames 1 to 20 in Table 1 (times n to n+20, frame numbers are assigned in order from the top of the table, the same applies below). The standard score pattern for each tire of a rear-wheel drive probe car turning right on a smooth road surface is front left: 3, front right: 4, rear left: 1, rear right: 2.
[0028] Frames 1-10 contain three such patterns, whereas frames 11-20 contain no such patterns. In other words, the road area shown in frames 1-10 contains the standard score pattern when the probe car turns right, so the area is estimated to be relatively smooth. On the other hand, the road area shown in frames 11-20 is estimated to be rough. The results are shown as indices "14" and "38".
[0029] 4, a standard pattern of the scores of each tire in a driving state (e.g., a right turn state) of the probe car is stored in advance in the standard score pattern storage unit 154. The driving state specification unit 153 specifies the driving state of the probe car from the driving information storage unit 10. The score comparison unit 155 reads out the standard score pattern corresponding to the driving state specified by the driving state specification unit 153 from the standard score pattern storage unit 154, and compares it with the score of each tire at each time given by the score assignment unit 30. If the road surface is smooth, the scores of each tire on the probe car should show the standard pattern above (front left: 3, front right: 4, rear left: 1, rear right: 2), but the more the pattern differs from this, the rougher the road surface is presumed to be.
[0030] Therefore, the score comparison unit 155 compares the standard score pattern with the score pattern output by the score assignment unit 30, and when the difference between the two (the sum of the score differences of each tire) exceeds a predetermined threshold, it sends an abnormality signal to the correction unit 156. Upon receiving this abnormality signal, the correction unit 156 sends a correction signal to the first calculation unit 157, which corrects the ranking difference score of each tire. For example, a predetermined value (e.g., 1) is added to a ranking difference score of zero. This emphasizes the roughness of the road surface in the score, and thus is reflected in the index. The method of correcting the scores is not particularly limited, and the value of the rank difference subtotal calculated by the second calculation unit 52 can be increased or decreased by adding or multiplying a predetermined parameter to the value.
[0031] FIG. 5 shows a hardware configuration of the road surface diagnosis device shown in FIG. 1 or FIG. The calculation unit 300 includes a CPU 301, a ROM 303, and a RAM 305, and controls the entire system. It also controls the calculation parts of the tire speed identification unit 20 and the index generation unit 40. The ROM 303 is a non-volatile memory in which a control program for controlling the calculation unit 300 and the like are stored. The RAM 305 provides a working area for the CPU 301. The control program for controlling the calculation unit 300 may be stored not only in the ROM 303, but also in the RAM 305 or the first and second storage devices 340 and 350. Various data are output via the output device 320.
[0032] The first storage device 340 functions as the driving information storage unit 10 . The second storage device 350 functions as the standard score pattern storage unit 154 . The first and second storage devices 340 and 350 preferably utilize a partial area of a memory device of the server system, such as a hard memory or a flash memory. A part of the RAM of the calculation unit can be used as a so-called buffer memory for temporarily storing data. A communication interface 13 is connected to an external communication network. The devices constituting the computer are connected via a system bus 370 .
[0033] The present invention is not limited to the above-mentioned embodiment and examples. Various modifications within the scope of the claims and within the scope that can be easily conceived by a person skilled in the art are also included in the present invention. [Explanation of symbols]
[0034] 1, 100 Road surface diagnostic device 10 Driving information storage unit 20 Tire speed identification unit 30 Score Assignment Section 40 Indicator generator 50 First Tabulation Section 60 2nd Tabulation Section
Claims
1. A road surface diagnosis device that generates an index of road surface roughness, a tire condition specifying unit that specifies the conditions of a plurality of tires of the probe car; a score assigning unit that assigns scores to each tire representing the tire conditions at the nth time and the n+1th time specified by the tire condition specifying unit; an index generating unit that generates an index corresponding to the roughness of a road surface based on a time variation of the score of each tire; A road surface diagnosis device comprising:
2. The index generating unit includes a first calculation unit and a second calculation unit, and the first calculation unit calculates, for each tire, a relationship between the score of each tire at the nth time and the score of each tire at the n+1th time. a second calculation unit that collects the calculation results for each tire calculated by the first calculation unit, The device according to claim 1 , wherein the second counting unit causes the first counting unit to repeat the calculation k times, where n+1 is n, and counts up the calculation results of the second calculation unit for each iteration.
3. the score assigning unit assigns a score to each tire based on the ranking of the tire speed; The first calculation unit calculates a difference between the scores for each tire, The second calculation unit adds up the score differences for all tires, 3. The device according to claim 2, wherein the second counting unit repeats the calculation of the first counting unit k times, where n+1 is n, and adds up the sums of the second calculation unit each time.
4. a standard score pattern storage unit that stores a score pattern corresponding to the running state of the probe car as a standard score pattern; a running state specification unit that specifies a running state of the probe car; a score pattern comparison unit that reads out the standard score pattern corresponding to the running state identified by the running state identification unit from the standard score pattern storage unit and compares the read out standard score pattern with the calculation result of the first calculation unit; The apparatus according to claim 2 , further comprising: a correction unit that applies a correction to a calculation result of the second calculation unit based on a comparison result of the score pattern comparison unit.
5. A road surface information display device that reflects an indicator generated by the road surface diagnosis device according to any one of claims 1 to 4 on a map.
6. A road surface diagnosis method using a road surface diagnosis device that generates an index of roughness of a road surface, the road surface diagnosis device comprising: a tire condition specification unit, a score assignment unit, and an index generation unit; causing the tire condition specifying unit to specify conditions of a plurality of tires of a probe car; causing the score assigning unit to assign to each tire a score representing the state of the tire at the nth time and the n+1th time specified by the tire state specifying unit; a road surface diagnosis method for causing the index generation unit to generate an index corresponding to roughness of a road surface based on a temporal variation in the score of each tire.
7. A computer program for use in a road surface diagnosis device that generates an index of roughness of a road surface, the road surface diagnosis device comprising: a tire condition specification unit; a score assignment unit; and an index generation unit; causing the tire condition specifying unit to specify conditions of a plurality of tires of a probe car; causing the score assigning unit to assign to each tire a score representing the state of the tire at the nth time and the n+1th time specified by the tire state specifying unit; A computer program that causes the index generation unit to generate an index corresponding to the roughness of a road surface based on a temporal variation in the score of each of the tires.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
JP2020‐013537A
JP2021‐189627A
JP2013‐184650A
