Heating device with prediction of the residual life of the filament
Patent Information
- Application Number
- PCT/IB2024/055400
- Authority / Receiving Office
- WO · WO
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-06-05
- Filing Date
- 2024-06-03
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-12
Smart Images

Figure IB2024055400_12122024_PF_FP_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] HEATING DEVICE WITH PREDICTION OF THE RESIDUAL LIFE OF THE FILAMENT
[0002] FIELD OF THE INVENTION
[0003] The present invention relates to a system, and an associated method, for estimating the residual life of the electrical resistors forming a heating element.
[0004] BACKGROUND ART
[0005] Armored heating elements consist of a spiral of resistive metal wire immersed in a dielectric consisting of thermally conductive magnesium oxide powder, pressed inside a metal tube (armor).
[0006] The passage of electric current through the resistive metal wire causes it to heat up due to the Joule effect; the heat generated by the Joule effect is then brought outside by conduction by the magnesium oxide and the metal tube of the armor.
[0007] The materials usually employed for resistive wires are iron- or nickel-based alloys which shall resist operating temperatures without oxidizing too quickly and so as to ensure an adequate electrical resistivity and a low dependence of resistivity on temperature.
[0008] For applications up to 800°C (measured on the sheath), one of the most used alloys for armored tubular resistor wire is FeCrAI135 which has a conventional chemical composition of 22% Or and 4.8% Al.
[0009] For higher temperatures, 80 / 20 nickel and chromium alloys are instead used.
[0010] These alloys both have a very low dependence of resistivity on temperature, i.e., a very small Positive Temperature Coefficient effect (PTC effect), in a wide temperature range (0-1200°C).
[0011] Usually, the lifespan of an armored heating element is established during the design / development step by means of a sizing such as to meet the product specifications in well-established operating conditions, verified with reliability tests carried out in the laboratory and aimed at estimating the so-called Mean Time To Failure (MTTF) in such operating conditions. The prior art includes other estimation methods which are capable of calculating a residual life value of a heating element, MTTF, on the basis of current operating conditions (in particular, the temperature).
[0012] Patent documents US20080183404A1 and US6336083B1 describe predictive methods based on the use of databases of experimental parameters obtained in the laboratory, which are compared with real-time measurements of the electrical parameters of the resistor (current, ohmic value, etc.). These methods, however, are applicable to well-defined heating elements, since they are based on characteristic experimental data. Furthermore, these methods may not directly take temperature into account, since they do not exploit the PTC effect; therefore, they are not capable of updating the estimate of the remaining time based on new, changed operating conditions.
[0013] The current operating conditions of a heating element are often different from the nominal conditions, they deeply affect residual life and may lead to MTTF values which are very distant from those estimated during the design step. The need is therefore apparent to introduce new heating systems comprising electrical resistors and provided with means for estimating the residual life of said electrical resistors which are capable of overcoming the drawbacks of the prior art.
[0014] BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0015] It is therefore an object of the present invention to provide a heating element comprising at least one electrical resistor and provided with means for estimating the residual life of the at least one electrical resistor.
[0016] It is another object of the present invention to provide a device for estimating the residual life of the electrical resistor of a heating element, which may be integrated into new heating elements and / or may be applied to existing heating elements.
[0017] It is another object of the present invention to provide a method for estimating the residual life of the electrical resistor of a heating element.
[0018] The present invention takes advantage of the chemical-physical phenomena characteristic of the alloy of which the resistor filament is composed, and it is therefore independent of the particular construction of the resistor itself. Furthermore, the present invention allows the average temperature of the filament to be known in each operating session, and therefore it allows the estimate of the residual useful life time to be updated on the basis of the new, changed operating conditions, in a manner similar to what occurs when estimating the residual fuel range of a vehicle, which decreases when accelerating and increases when slowing down and takes into account what has been done previously.
[0019] In a preferred embodiment, the heating element according to the present invention comprises an armored tubular resistor and an associated electronic controller.
[0020] The armored tubular resistor is constructed using a resistive wire made of metal material which, over time, degrades due to the high temperature and varies the resistivity and PTC effect electrical features thereof.
[0021] The electronic controller associated with the armored tubular resistor is adapted to measure the electrical absorption features of the resistor both upon the first ignition as well as during normal operation and to detect the changes in the electrical properties of the metal material forming the resistive wire as it gradually degrades. Furthermore, said electronic controller is adapted to process the measurements made so as to estimate the updated value of the residual life time, MTTF, of the resistive wire of the armored tubular resistor.
[0022] The method for processing the measurements carried out by the aforesaid electronic controller implements a calculation algorithm which exploits the known trend of the cold ohmic value and the increase in the resistive value due to the PTC effect of the filament of the armored tubular resistor, as a function of the operating time at high temperature. In essence, the electrical absorption features are measured during normal operation and the variations in the electrical properties of the material forming the resistive wire are detected as the latter degrades. Since the mathematical relationship that links life time, operating temperature, resistivity and temperature coefficient is known, it is possible to estimate the residual life time with considerable accuracy.
[0023] The device according to the present invention - provided with means for estimating the residual life of an electrical resistor - and the method associated therewith may be used with resistors comprising resistive filaments of different compositions which may be used, in particular, in heating elements of the resistive type.
[0024] Particularly satisfactory results are achieved with resistive metal filaments made of FeCrAI135 alloy. The FeCrAI135 alloy, in fact, proves to be particularly adapted for use in the present invention since, at temperatures above 900°C, it tends to reduce the aluminum content thereof in favor of the formation of aluminum oxide on the surface of the wire. This reduction increases the electrical conductivity as well as the temperature coefficient.
[0025] BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0026] Further features and advantages of the invention will become more apparent in the light of the detailed description of preferred, but not exclusive, embodiments of a system, and the associated method, for estimating the residual life of the electrical resistors which make up a resistive heating element, shown, by way of explanation and not by way of limitation, with the help of the accompanying drawing tables in which:
[0027] Figure 1 shows a graph of the cold ohmic value trend and of the increase in the resistive value due to the PCT effect, of a resistive metal filament as a function of the operating time at high temperature;
[0028] Figure 2 shows an electrical functional diagram of a preferred embodiment of the device according to the present invention;
[0029] Figure 3 shows a graph of the trend of the electrical properties of FeCrAI alloys as a function of the chemical composition thereof;
[0030] Figure 4 shows a graph of the trend of the variation of the ohmic value of a resistive filament as a function of the temperature, parameterized according to the value of the PCT ratio;
[0031] Figure 5 shows a graph of the trend of the variation of the cold ohmic value of a resistive filament as a function of the operating time at high temperature, parameterized according to the current operating temperature;
[0032] Figure 6 shows a flow diagram relating to the steps of the method according to the present description carried out at the first ignition, and Figure 7 shows a flow diagram relating to the steps of the method according to the present description carried out during the ignitions subsequent to the first one.
[0033] The same reference numerals refer to the same elements or to elements having the same functional and / or structural features. Said elements are shown in the drawings, where appropriate, with conventional symbols, showing only those specific details which are pertinent to understanding the embodiments of the present invention, so as not to highlight details which will be immediately apparent, to those skilled in the art with reference to the description given herein.
[0034] DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION
[0035] With reference to the accompanying Figure 2, the device according to the present invention, in a preferred embodiment, comprises: a voltage reading module 10 and a current reading module 11 of a heating element 12 with electrical resistor 13; a control module 15 adapted to process the data detected by said module 10 for reading the voltage and by said module 11 for reading the current of the electrical resistor 13, to calculate an estimated residual life value of the electrical resistor 13; a user interface 14 for reading the estimated residual life value of the electrical resistor 13.
[0036] The heating element 12 is connected to a power supply voltage which may be the AC mains voltage. Relays, power semiconductor switches, thermostats, contactors or other devices for controlling the temperature or the operation of the heating element 12 may be inserted between the heating element and the power supply voltage.
[0037] On the power supply line, a device 10 for measuring the effective voltage at the ends the resistor 13 of the heating element 12 and a device 11 for measuring the effective current absorbed by the resistor 13 will also be present. The measured current and voltage values will be processed by the control unit 15 which will calculate the V / l ratio to continuously determine the ohmic value of the resistor 13 in the different situations (and at the different temperatures) in which it will operate. The control algorithm implemented in the control unit 15 will also record in a memory the ohmic value at the moment of the first ignition (cold, on a new element) and for all other ignitions, comparing them. On the basis of the difference, the MTTF will be calculated from time to time by taking advantage of the relationship linking the MTTF to the variation in ohmic value for the metal alloy forming the resistor 13.
[0038] This variation is also a function of the operating temperature of the filament which is therefore taken into consideration by the algorithm as a variable. The average temperature used by the algorithm to calculate the MTTF is measured based on the ratio between the resistance value measured at ignition and the resistance value measured at thermal regime.
[0039] The values calculated by the control unit 15, such as the estimated average temperature of the filament, the power, the PTC ratio (expressible as the ratio between the electrical resistor at thermal equilibrium temperature, and the electrical resistor at room temperature), and the MTTF, may be sent to a user interface 14 which makes the data available to third party systems such as user displays, PLC, network etc.
[0040] Said control module 15, in a preferred embodiment of the invention, will comprise at least one microcontroller and a memory on which, for example, program instructions and data tables may be stored.
[0041] Said data tables link, for example, pairs of power supply voltage and current values of the heating element 12 (and therefore ohmic values of the electrical resistor 13), to temperature values of the electrical resistor 13 in various operating conditions.
[0042] Furthermore, said data tables may contain pairs of values (abscissa and ordinate) corresponding to functions representative of the trend of characteristic parameters of the resistor 13 during the operation thereof, based on the material forming said resistor. Therefore, the following trends may be tabulated: the cold ohmic value as a function of the operating time for different operating temperature values; the PTC ratio as a function of the operating time; the PTC ratio as a function of the chemical composition of the resistive filament (for FeCrAI alloy resistors, the PTC ratio as a function of the percentage of Al present); the resistivity of the resistive filament as a function of the chemical composition (or of the percentage of Al present); the variation of the ohmic value of the resistive filament as a function of the average operating temperature for different PTC ratio values (or of the chemical composition or percentage of Al in the resistive filament alloy); the variation of the cold ohmic value of the resistive filament as a function of the operating time for different average operating temperature values, etc.
[0043] The program instructions, instead, when executed by the aforesaid at least one microcontroller, may implement the steps of the method for estimating the residual life of electrical resistors, and in particular of the electrical resistors forming a heating element, according to the present invention.
[0044] During the normal operation thereof, the heating element 12 is electrically powered by an alternating voltage and a corresponding alternating current. In a preferred embodiment of the invention, said voltage reading module 10 detects the effective value (rms) of the alternating voltage applied to the heating element 12 and said current reading module 11 detects the effective value (rms) of the alternating current absorbed by the heating element 12.
[0045] The control module 15 therefore processes the effective voltage and current values detected, calculating the ratio so as to calculate the current ohmic value of the electrical resistor 13 of the heating element 12 (R=V / I). Finally, said control module 15 saves the measured and calculated quantities on said memory.
[0046] According to a preferred embodiment of the invention, with reference to the accompanying Figures 6 and 7, the program instructions stored in the microcontroller of said control module 15 ensure that the ohmic values of the electrical resistor 13 at first ignition, i.e., on a new element (measuring the cold resistance value), and for all subsequent ignitions (measuring the cold resistance value and the resistance value upon reaching the thermal regime) are stored in the memory of said control module 15. These stored ohmic values are then compared and, on the basis of the detected variation, the MTTF of the electrical resistor 13 is calculated from time to time since, for the metal alloy forming the electrical resistor 13, the relationship linking the MTTF to the variation in ohmic value may be obtained.
[0047] The aforesaid variation of the measured ohmic values is also a function of the operating temperature of the filament of the electrical resistor 13. Therefore, said operating temperature is considered by the method according to the invention as a variable. The average temperature used by the method for calculating the MTTF is measured on the basis of the ratio between the inrush power measured at ignition and the power measured at thermal regime.
[0048] In further detail and with reference to the accompanying Figure 3 - which shows the trend of the resistivity and of the so-called PTC ratio of FeCrAI alloys as a function of the chemical composition of the filament alloy (in terms, for example, of the percentage of Al present in the alloy) - it is possible to see that the PTC ratio of the alloy forming the filament of the electrical resistor 13 varies with the deterioration of the filament itself, since the alloy forming it (in the exemplary case, FeCrA1135) becomes depleted of aluminum. In fact, the aforesaid PTC ratio may be expressed as the ratio between the resistance value at thermal regime and the resistance value measured when cold: PTC ratio = Rm / Rf.
[0049] With reference to the accompanying Figure 6, according to the method described herein, upon first ignition (i.e., upon the first connection to the supply voltage) of the heating element 12, the voltage, V, and the current, linrush_o, of the electrical resistor 13 are measured 60, and the cold ohmic value of the electrical resistor 13 at first ignition is calculated 61 Ro, by means of the ratio V / linnjsh_o. The value RQ = V / linrush_o is stored 62 in the memory of said control module 15.
[0050] Subsequently, and with reference to the accompanying Figure 7 and Figure 3, at each subsequent ignition, the voltage, V, and the current, hnmshj, of the electrical resistor 13 are measured again 70, and the current cold ohmic value Rf is calculated 71 , by means of the V / hnrush_i ratio of the current operating session (i-ma). The current cold ohmic value, Rf = V / hnrush_i, is also saved 72 in the memory of said control module 15. From the current cold ohmic value, Rf, of the filament of the electrical resistor 13 it is possible to calculate 73, given the features of the electrical resistor 13, what the resistivity p{20 of the filament itself is (from the relation R = p*l / S, being R = resistance , p = resistivity, I = length of the filament and S = section of the filament).
[0051] From the calculated resistivity value p[ = Rf*S / l, knowing the resistivity curve as a function of the chemical composition of the filament alloy (shown in the accompanying Figure 3 and having a substantially linear trend of the pf= k[%Al] + j type, where k and j are known constants), the new chemical composition 21 of the filament alloy of the electrical resistor 13 is determined 74. Advantageously, the values obtained from the aforesaid function may be suitably tabulated and stored in the memory of the said control module 15 so as to facilitate and immediately extract the values of the chemical composition of the filament alloy, once the resistivity value is known.
[0052] Subsequently, from the curve of the trend of the PTC ratio as a function of the chemical composition of the filament alloy (curve, also shown in the accompanying Figure 3, which has a trend of the type PTCratio = f[%Al]3+ g [%4Z]2+ h[%Al]1+ i with f, g, h and i being known constants), finally, the current PTC ratio 22 of the current operating session is determined 75. Also in this case, the values obtained from the aforesaid function may be suitably tabulated and stored in the memory of said control module 15 so as to extract them in an easier and immediate manner.
[0053] Subsequently, when the electrical resistor 13 has reached the thermal regime, i.e., the temperature thereof has substantially exhausted the initial growth transient to become stable, the measurements carried out at ignition are repeated, i.e., the voltage V and the current lregimej of the electrical resistor 13 are measured again 76, and the hot ohmic value, R^m, of the filament of the electrical resistor 13 is calculated 77; this value is stored 78 in the memory of the control module 15, and subsequently the variation 23 of the ohmic value of the electrical resistor 13 due to the temperature is calculated 79: R{ / Rm. Again, with reference to Figure 7 and with reference to the accompanying Figure 4 (which shows the curves of the variation of the ohmic value as a function of the average temperature of the resistive filament, parameterized according to different PTC ratio values), starting from the variation of the ohmic value 23 previously calculated, and from the value of the current PTC ratio 22 of the current operating session, the average operating temperature Tmi 24 of the filament of the electrical resistor 13 is identified 80. At this point, and with reference to the accompanying Figure 5 (which shows the trend of the deterioration of the cold ohmic value of the filament of the electrical resistor 13 as a function of the operating time, and parameterized according to the average operating temperature), knowing the current average operating temperature Tmi, 24 of the filament of the electrical resistor 13, previously calculated, the curve of interest 25 corresponding to this value of current average operating temperature Tmi is selected.
[0054] Therefore, using the current cold ohmic value, Rj, and the first ignition cold ohmic value, Ro, both previously stored, the variation 26 of the cold ohmic value with respect to the initial value, Rf / RQ, is calculated 81.
[0055] Then, on the selected curve 25, the abscissa value of the operating time at current high temperature, tiavj, is obtained 82, which corresponds to the value of the variation 26 of the cold ohmic value with respect to the initial value, Rf I Rf, previously calculated and reported on the ordinate.
[0056] Finally, the residual life time (or MTTF) 27, updated to the current operating temperature, which is equal to the difference, on the abscissa, between the maximum theoretical value of the operating time at the end of the selected curve 25, and the aforesaid value of the current operating time, tiavj, previously identified, is calculated 83.
[0057] Thereby, the estimate of the residual life of the electrical resistor 13 is very accurate since it is updated from time to time with respect to the current operating conditions.
[0058] The system and the method described may be applied to tubular heating elements as well as to bare wire heating elements, provided with single-phase, multi-phase, alternating or direct current power supply, even within thermoregulated systems with controls, for example, of the PID type.
[0059] The system and the method described may also be extended, in particular, to all resistive elements which use wires formed with metal alloys containing chemical elements which oxidize quickly at high temperatures, such as chromium and aluminum, but also Silicon, Yttrium, Titanium, Zirconium, Niobium, Manganese, etc.
[0060] Warning for very harsh operating conditions which lead to a drastic reduction in residual life.
[0061] Finally, the system and the method described offer new and valuable opportunities for controlling and intervening in the management of resistive electric heaters such as, for example, the possibility of reducing the operating temperature if the time distance from the end of the useful life is found to be below a certain threshold and the reduction of machine downtime required in the event of failure by virtue of the possibility of carrying out preventive maintenance which thus becomes predictive maintenance.
Claims
CLAIMS1 . A method for estimating the residual life of an electrical resistor (13), said method comprising: at the first connection to the power supply voltage of said electrical resistor (13), measuring (60) the voltage, V, and current, linrush_o, of said electrical resistor (13), and calculating (61 ) and storing (62) the first ignition cold ohmic value of the electrical resistor (13), RQ = V / ljnrush_o; for each subsequent connection to the power supply voltage of said electrical resistor (13), measuring (70) the voltage, V, and current, linrushj, of said electrical resistor (13); calculating (71) and storing (72) the current cold ohmic value of the electrical resistor (13), Rf = V / nrushj; calculating the resistivity of the filament of the electrical resistor, p-, (13); determining (74) the new chemical composition (21) of the metal alloy of the filament of the electrical resistor (13) from the calculated value of the resistivity of the filament of the electrical resistor (13); determining (75) the current PTC ratio value (22) of the filament of the electrical resistor (13) from the determined value of the chemical composition of the filament alloy; when the electrical resistor (13) has reached the thermal regime, measuring (76) the voltage, V, and the current I regimejj of said electrical resistor (13); calculating (77) and storing (78) of the hot ohmic value of the filament of the electrical resistorcalculating (79) the variation (23) of the ohmic value of the electrical resistor (13) due to temperature: Rf / R^m;determining (80) the average operating temperature, Tmi (24) of the filament of the electrical resistor (13), from the variation (23) of the ohmic value RJ / Rj ■ and from the value of the current PTC ratio (22); calculating (81) the variation (26) of the cold ohmic value of the electrical resistor f f(13) with respect to the initial value, RJ / Ro; determining (82) the current high temperature operating time, tiav_i, of the electrical resistor (13), from the current average operating temperature Tmi, (24) and from the variation (26) of the cold ohmic value with respect to the initial value, Rf / RQ; calculating (83) the residual life time (27) of the electrical resistor (13), updated to the current operating temperature, as the difference between the maximum theoretical value of the operating time foreseen for the electrical resistor (13) and the current high temperature operating time value, tiavj.
2. A method according to the preceding claim, wherein the calculation of the resistivity of the filament of the electrical resistor (13) occurs by means of the formula p{ = Rf*S / l, wherein I = length of the filament of the electrical resistor (13) and S = section of the filament of the electrical resistor (13).
3. A method according to one or more of the preceding claims, wherein, if the filament of the electrical resistor (13) is of a FeCrAI alloy, said chemical composition of the alloy of the filament comprises the percentage of Al of the alloy.
4. A method according to one or more of the preceding claims, wherein the new chemical composition (21) of the metal alloy of the filament of the electrical resistor (13) is determined (74) from the resistivity curve expressed as a function of the chemical composition of the filament alloy.
5. A method according to one or more of the preceding claims, wherein the current PTC ratio value (22) of the filament of the electrical resistor (13) is determined (75) from the PCT ratio curve expressed as a function of the chemical composition of the filament alloy.
6. A method according to one or more of the preceding claims, wherein said determining (80) of the average operating temperature, Tmi (24), of the filament of the electrical resistor (13) is done from the curve of the variation of the ohmic value Rf / Rmas a function of the average temperature of the resistive filament, parameterized according to the current PTC ratio value (22).
7. A method according to one or more of the preceding claims, wherein said determining (82) of the current high temperature operating time, tiavj, of the electrical resistor (13) is done from the curve of the cold ohmic value with respect to the initial value, Rf / Ro, parameterized according to the current average operating temperature Tmi.
8. A method according to one or more of the preceding claims, wherein said resistive filament is made of FeCrAI135 alloy.
9. A device for estimating the residual life of the filament of an electrical resistor (13) comprising: a module (10) for reading the voltage at the ends an electrical resistor (13); a module (11) for reading the current of the electrical resistor (13); a control module (15) configured to process the data detected by said module (10) for reading the voltage and by said module (11) for reading the current of the electrical resistor (13), to calculate an estimated residual life value of the electrical resistor (13); a user interface (14) for reading said estimated residual life value of the electrical resistor (13), wherein said control module (15) comprises at least one microcontroller and a memory on which data tables and program instructions are storable, adapted to carry out the method according to one or more of claims 1 to 7.
10. A device according to the preceding claim, wherein said memory comprises tables of values of the following functions: resistivity of the filament as a function of the chemical composition of the filament alloy;PCT ratio of the filament as a function of the chemical composition of the filament alloy; variation of the ohmic value, R{ / Rm, of the filament as a function of the average temperature of the filament, Tmi, parameterized according to PTC ratio values; variation of the cold ohmic value as a function of the initial value, R{ / RQ, parameterized according to the average temperature of the filament, Tmi.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Method of predicting service life of resistance heating type heater, and thermal processing device
JP2012253222A
Monitoring heater condition to predict or detect failure of a heating element
US20080183404A1
Method and apparatus for predicting heater failure
US6336083B1
Heating element condition monitor
WO2004008043A2
