Mapping sensor error data from coordinate positioning machines
A spatial error map unifies multiple error sources into a single representation, simplifying the interpretation of sensor data in coordinate positioning machines and facilitating informed engineering decisions.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024523565
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-01-14
- Filing Date
- 2022-10-18
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-13
AI Technical Summary
Interpreting and deriving informed engineering decisions from sensor error data in coordinate positioning machines, particularly with multiple error sources, is challenging for machine operators.
Generating a spatial error map that combines multiple error sources into a unified representation, such as a transformed cuboid or square, to facilitate easy interpretation and identification of trends or patterns in sensor error data.
Enables machine operators to make informed technical decisions by providing a clear, intuitive visualization of multi-dimensional error data, allowing for effective machine calibration and operation.
Smart Images

Figure 2024541874000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to spatial mapping of sensor error data from a coordinate positioning machine, such as a machine tool or coordinate measuring machine. [Background technology]
[0002] Figure 1 of the accompanying drawings shows a coordinate measuring machine 1 of a known type having three mutually orthogonally arranged and systemic linear axes x, y, z, the z-axis being aligned with gravity g. A measuring probe 3 is mounted on a vertical column 8 which is slidable in the z-direction within a carriage 2, this relative movement defining the z-axis. The carriage 2 is itself supported on a horizontal beam 7 along which it is slidable in the y-direction, this relative movement defining the y-axis. The beam 7 in turn is slidable in the x-direction on a pair of rails 6, this relative movement defining the x-axis. A computer controller 5 operates to drive each component (column 8, carriage 2, beam 7) to the appropriate position along their respective axes to position the measuring probe 3 at the desired location within the working volume of the machine and then move it into sensing relationship with a workpiece 9 supported on a fixed platform 4.
[0003] Each axis x, y, z is driven independently of the other axes by a respective motor (not shown). Each axis x, y, z is also encoded or sensed independently of the other axes by a respective sensor, and outputs from the sensors are used to determine the position of the measurement probe 3 (or any tool mounted on the column 8). Each axis is provided with a length measuring transducer having an encoder scale (shown diagrammatically as a series of parallel lines along each axis in FIG. 1) paired with a read head (not shown). To measure the relative movement between two parts, the encoder scale is suitably mounted on one part and the read head is suitably mounted on the other part.
[0004] Figure 2 of the accompanying drawings is a schematic diagram of a machine tool 10 generally installed in a manufacturing or machine shop environment. The machine tool 10 is for performing machining operations on a workpiece 16, which is shown in Figure 1 as resting on a base or bed 17 of the machine tool 10. The machine tool 10 comprises a spindle 13 on which is mounted a drill bit 12 for performing machining operations on the workpiece 16. The spindle 13 is in turn supported by a support member 14 which is itself moved by a movement system 15, thereby enabling the drill bit 12 to be moved into position for working on the workpiece 16. The movement system 15 generally provides movement of the drill bit 12 in three degrees of freedom x, y, z (along three axes), and the spindle 13 can be controlled to rotate at high speed about its longitudinal axis R in order to cause the drill bit 12 to machine a feature of the workpiece 16.
[0005] The movement system 15 is controlled by a machine controller 20, and these elements are connected via a communication link 21, which is generally a wired connection. To the left of the window of the machine tool 10 shown in Figure 2 is a tool holder or rack 18, which is shown holding a measurement probe 22. After the machine tool 10 has finished working on the workpiece 16, or a particular feature of the workpiece 16, the machine controller 20 can be utilized to execute a series of movements in which the drill bit 12 of Figure 2 is replaced with the measurement probe 22, so that the workpiece 16 can be measured. Apart from that, the machine 10 also comprises a probe interface 22 for communicating with the probe 22, and a user interface 24 (e.g., machine controller 20) that is utilized by the machine operator to set up and program the machine tool 10. The user interface 24 comprises a graphical user interface in the form of a display device 28, and an input device in the form of a keyboard 29.
[0006] As mentioned above, the coordinate measuring machine 1 and the machine tool 10 shown in Figures 1 and 2 respectively, both have a motion system with a series of linear motion axes x, y, z. When the controller 5 in Figure 1 or the controller 20 in Figure 2 commands the machine to move a certain distance along one of these axes x, y, z, it will ideally actually move exactly that distance along the associated axis. However, there will inevitably be a motion error associated with each axis such that the actual position will not be the same as the commanded position, i.e. there will be positional errors. These positional errors must be measured so that they can be taken into account and calibrated, and so that they do not affect the positioning accuracy of the machine.
[0007] A Renishaw Ltd. XL-80 linear axis calibrator is provided for this purpose, allowing accurate measurement of the actual linear displacement of the machine along the machine axes. Figure 3 shows a machine tool 10 with such a linear axis calibrator 32 in place. The calibrator 32 emits a laser beam onto a target unit 34 supported on the spindle 13 (at the location of the drill 12 or probe 22), which reflects the laser beam back to the calibrator 32. In the example shown, the target unit 34 is moved along the x-axis of the machine and measurement data D at various positions along this machine axis are sent to a processor 30 for processing.
[0008] From the received measurement data D, the processor 30 calculates (or modifies) the spacing between the calibrator 32 and the target unit 34. A comparison between the actual linear displacement (as measured by the calibrator 32) and the expected linear displacement (as commanded by the machine controller 20) results in an error value for that position along the machine axis. These error values (sometimes referred to as sensor error data) are then sent as results R to the user interface 24 and plotted on the user interface 24 so that the performance of the machine axis can be analyzed and appropriate action can be taken by the machine operator based on the error plot. Such a plot is shown diagrammatically in FIG. 4 (also on the user interface 24 in FIG. 3), where the linear error values are plotted against the position along the x machine axis. Corresponding plots can also be generated for the y and z machine axes. Of course, some machines may have only a subset of the machine axes, such as only the z axis, or only the x and z axes.
[0009] Along with the XL-80 and XM-60 calibrators, Renishaw Ltd. also offers the CARTO software suite, which has three separate modules: (a) Capture (for acquiring measurement / error data from the machine), (b) Explorer (for visualizing and exploring the measurement / error data), and (c) Compensation (for performing error compensation, such as volumetric compensation, based on the measurement / error data). The applicants have recognized that even experienced machine operators may have difficulty understanding and interpreting such error plots (e.g., utilizing the Explorer module of the CARTO software suite) and drawing appropriate engineering conclusions from these error plots. It is desired to address this issue and make it easier for machine operators to make informed engineering decisions based on machine axis error data. Summary of the Invention
[0010] According to a first aspect of the invention, there is provided a method of generating a spatial map of sensor error data from a coordinate positioning machine comprising the steps of receiving measurement data collected by measuring or tracking an artefact moved by the machine along at least one machine axis, deriving error data by comparing the received measurement data to an expected or ideal value for the measurement data, and generating from the error data a spatial error map with each cell containing an error representation derived from a plurality of sources of error in the error data.
[0011] Each cell in the spatial error map may correspond to one of multiple positions in the machine, for example, along a corresponding machine axis.
[0012] The multiple error sources may include errors in two or more degrees of freedom associated with the movement of the artifact.
[0013] The representation of each cell may be generated based on a transformation performed depending on the error in two or more degrees of freedom. The transformation may be a rotation and / or a translation. The transformation may be a geometric and / or spatial and / or three-dimensional transformation.
[0014] The representation of each cell may be transformed, eg rotated and / or translated, relative to the representation of the other cell depending on the difference in the respective errors of the two cells in two or more degrees of freedom.
[0015] The method may include providing the ability to generate a spatial error map from the error data, where each cell contains an error representation derived from only a single error source in the error data, such as a single degree of freedom.
[0016] The method may include controlling which one or more of the multiple error sources are utilized at any one time to generate the spatial error map.
[0017] The error representation may be a discrete and / or a single error representation.
[0018] At least one of the error representations may be or may be based on a representation of a cuboid.
[0019] At least one of the error representations may be or may be based on a square or rectangular representation.
[0020] The method may include displaying (to a user) the spatial error map on or via a user interface, which may be a graphical user interface.
[0021] The method may include collecting measurement data by measuring or tracking an artefact moved by a machine along at least one machine axis.
[0022] The generation of the spatial error map may be performed in real time, for example, as the measurement data is collected or shortly thereafter.
[0023] A coordinate positioning machine may be a machine tool or a coordinate measuring machine. A coordinate positioning machine may be a linear positioning stage (sometimes simply referred to as a linear stage) or a rotary positioning stage (rotary stage) and may be part of a larger motion system or may be a motion system itself. A coordinate positioning machine may be a parallel kinematic machine having multiple positioning struts, or may be or include one or more struts of such a parallel kinematic machine, for example a hexapod having six such struts. In fact, a coordinate positioning machine may be considered to be the motion system (i.e. just the motion system itself, which may be manufactured quite separately from the rest of the machine) for a machine such as a machine tool or a coordinate measuring machine or a parallel kinematic machine.
[0024] The spatial error map may be a graphical spatial error map. The error representation of each cell may be a graphical error representation. The error representation of each cell may be represented in graphical or image form. A graphical representation may be understood to be a representation adapted or suitable for display on a graphical user interface. A graphical user interface may be understood to be a form of user interface that allows a user to interact with an electronic device, such as a computer or a machine controller, through graphical icons or images. A graphical user interface may include a display device and may be an output device (for displaying / outputting images alone) or an input / output device (for example, capable of accepting user input and displaying / outputting images, such as a touch screen device). At least one of the graphical error representations may be a graphical representation of a three-dimensional object, which may be represented in a two-dimensional form, for example, for displaying on a two-dimensional graphical user interface. The three-dimensional object may be a cuboid object, in which case the error representation is a cuboid representation.
[0025] The error representations associated with the error data for movement along the or each machine axis may be adapted such that, despite being derived from multiple different error sources, they are locatable and / or displayable along a single corresponding axis in the spatial error map. The display and / or location of these error representations may be on a user interface, such as a graphical user interface, for example.
[0026] The method may include displaying and / or arranging error representations associated with error data relating to movement along the or each machine axis along a single corresponding axis in a spatial error map, where the display and / or arrangement of these error representations may be on a user interface, such as a graphical user interface.
[0027] The single corresponding axis may be an axis in a multi-dimensional (eg, three-dimensional) spatial error map.
[0028] The machine axes and / or error factors utilized to derive the spatial error map may be selectable, for example, by a machine operator.
[0029] It will be seen where information is presented to the user and the perceptual content of the information presented to the user (e.g. spatial error map) is related to the prevailing internal state in a technical system (e.g. machine tool) and enables the user to operate this technical system (e.g. machine tool) appropriately, and therefore it must be considered to have a technical effect. An internal state in this context can be considered as an error (in one or more degrees of freedom) associated with a motion system utilized by the system (e.g. machine tool). This can be considered as a dynamically changing and automatically detectable technical condition related to the internal functioning of the system, the representation of which generally prompts the user to interact with the system, for example to avoid technical failures.
[0030] The measurement data and / or error data can therefore be considered as relating to internal conditions prevailing within the technical system, the technical system being a coordinate positioning machine.
[0031] It should be noted that the "axes" described herein do not necessarily lie along straight lines but may be curved. The term "path" may be used in place of "axis" where appropriate (e.g., "machine path" rather than "machine axis").
[0032] According to a second aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method of operating a coordinate positioning machine, comprising the steps of: (a) generating a spatial error map utilising a method according to the first aspect of the present invention, or receiving such a spatial error map; and (b) identifying trends, patterns or regions in the spatial error map based on pre-determined criteria.
[0033] The method may include controlling or configuring a machine based on the identified trends or patterns or areas.
[0034] The trends or patterns or regions may be identified without substantial human intervention. Alternatively, the trends or patterns or regions may be identified by a human operator based on the spatial error map and, optionally, based on guidance included in, added to, or associated with the spatial error map. Such guidance may include, for example, highlighting or emphasising particular portions of the error map (such as those portions identified as actual or potential problematic based on pre-determined criteria) or other messages or indications displayed to the machine operator.
[0035] According to a third aspect of the invention there is provided a data visualization or coordinate positioning machine adapted to carry out a method according to the first aspect of the invention.
[0036] According to a fourth aspect of the invention there is provided a computer program which, when executed by a computer, causes the computer to perform a method according to the first or second aspect of the invention. The program may be carried on a carrier medium. The carrier medium may be a storage medium. The carrier medium may be a transmission medium.
[0037] According to a fifth aspect of the present invention there is provided a computer readable medium having stored thereon computer program instructions for controlling a computer to perform a method according to the first or second aspects of the present invention.
[0038] According to a sixth aspect of the invention there is provided a data carrier having instructions carried thereon which, when executed by a processor, cause the processor to perform a method according to the first or second aspect of the invention.
[0039] Reference is now made, by way of example, to the accompanying drawings in which: [Brief description of the drawings]
[0040] [Figure 1] FIG. 1, as previously described, is a schematic diagram of a Cartesian coordinate positioning machine having a motion system that includes three machine axes. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2, also discussed above, is a schematic diagram of a machine tool having a motion system including three machine axes. [Diagram 3] FIG. 3 also shows the machine tool of FIG. 2 having a linear axis calibrator for measuring linear errors in the machine axes, as previously described. [Figure 4] FIG. 4, also discussed above, is a plot showing diagrammatically how the straightness error associated with one of the machine axes varies with position along the machine axis. [Diagram 5] FIG. 5 shows six separate plots, each showing diagrammatically how the error associated with a different one of the six degrees of freedom varies with position along the machine axes. [Figure 6] FIG. 6 shows a system according to an embodiment of the invention including a machine tool similar to that of FIG. 2, a multi-axis calibrator for measuring errors in six degrees of freedom for movement along each machine axis, and a spatial error mapping derived from measurement data from the calibrator. [Figure 7] FIG. 7 is a flow chart illustrating a method for generating a spatial error map of sensor data based on measurement data from a calibrator, according to an embodiment of the invention. [Figure 8] FIG. 8 illustrates the concept of a spatial error map according to an embodiment of the present invention, based on a cuboid representation of the error values. [Figure 9] FIG. 9 illustrates another type of spatial error map according to an embodiment of the present invention, based on a square representation of the error values. [Figure 10]FIG. 10 shows a more detailed example of a user interface for presenting the spatial error map to a machine operator and for controlling the inputs utilized to generate the spatial error map, as well as other aspects of its appearance. [Figure 11] FIG. 11 is similar to FIG. 10 and shows a representation of how the spatial error map can be varied by the various controls available to the machine operator. [Figure 12] FIG. 12 shows in graphical form the same error values represented in FIG. 11 as a spatial error map. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0041] The problems associated with interpreting sensor error data from a machine have been described above with reference to Figures 3 and 4. The previous description was based on measuring linear errors along the machine axis being calibrated. However, when a component such as the probe 3 or drill 12 is moved by the machine's motion system along a single machine axis, in addition to the desired motion along that machine axis (i.e. the primary linear degree of freedom), in practice there will also be unwanted motion in one or more of the other five degrees of freedom, potentially giving rise to errors in up to six degrees of freedom.
[0042] The Renishaw XM-60 multi-axis calibrator can measure errors in all six degrees of freedom, namely (1) linear, (2) pitch, (3) yaw, (4) roll, (5) horizontal straightness, and (6) vertical straightness. This results in six error plots, one for each of the six degrees of freedom, as shown diagrammatically in FIG. 5. The applicants have recognized that even for an experienced machine operator, it can be particularly difficult to understand and interpret six separate error plots and to draw appropriate engineering conclusions from these error plots. This problem is even more pronounced than that described above for a single error plot such as that shown in FIG. 4, and it is particularly desirable to facilitate machine operators in making informed engineering decisions based on machine axis error data from multiple sources (e.g., multiple degrees of freedom).
[0043] FIG. 6 shows a machine tool 100 incorporating an embodiment of the present invention. The machine tool 100 is similar to that of FIG. 3, so a detailed description of the common parts is not necessary. Instead of the linear calibrator 32 of FIG. 3, a multi-axis calibrator 42 (such as an XM-60) is provided to measure errors in six degrees of freedom for movement along each machine axis. FIG. 7 is a flow chart illustrating a method according to an embodiment of the present invention for generating a spatial error map of sensor data based on measurement data from the calibrator 42.
[0044] As part of step S1 of Figure 7, the multi-axis calibrator 42 emits multiple laser beams to a receiving unit 44, which reflects them back to the calibrator 42. The resulting measurement data D is transmitted from the calibrator 42 to the processor 40 for processing and is received by the processor 40 in step S2 of Figure 7. In step S3, the processor 40 derives error data (sometimes referred to as sensor error data) from the measurement data and generates a spatial error map in step S4.
[0045] The concept underlying the spatial error map according to an embodiment of the present invention is to represent multiple error sources in the sensor error data using a single or unified representation. In this regard, the spatial error map can be considered to have multiple cells, each cell including an error representation derived from multiple error sources in the error data. The terms "positions" or "locations" or "coordinates" can alternatively be used in place of the term "cell". Each cell in the spatial error map corresponds to one of multiple positions in the machine (in this example, positions along the relevant machine axis). In this example, the multiple error sources include errors in two or more degrees of freedom associated with the movement of the artifact (receiving unit 44) relative to the machine (as represented by a calibrator 42 fixed relative to the machine).
[0046] This will now be explained in more detail with reference to Figure 8 which shows five representative cells C1-C5 of a spatial error map M generated from error data D. The top left cell C1 of Figure 8 contains an error representation which corresponds to a starting position along the x mechanical axis, with each subsequent cell corresponding to a different position along the x mechanical axis. The error representation of each cell in the spatial error map is in the form of a cuboid, which is skewed and / or translated and / or rotated based on the underlying error data from the calibrator 42.
[0047] At the starting position, the errors measured by the calibrator 42 are zero in all six degrees of freedom, and the error representation of this cell C1 in the spatial error map M is an undistorted cuboid with six flat faces with all angles at right angles. At the next position along the x mechanical axis, the calibrator 42 measures the error in the x direction (linear error along the x mechanical axis), and the measurement errors in all other degrees of freedom are still zero, which is represented in cell C2 of the spatial error map M by a translated (or deformed or distorted) version of the starting cuboid. In particular, the cuboid representation of cell C2 has a length in the x direction that is modified (reduced or increased) compared to cell C1 by an amount Tx that corresponds to the measured error value in the x direction. In the example shown, the cuboid of cell C2 is compressed in the x direction compared to the cuboid of cell C1. Alternatively, to derive a cuboid representation of cell C2, the cuboid of cell C1 can be translated in x (relative to a zero-error position along the x mechanical axis) without any change in dimensions; indeed, as shown in FIG. 8, the cuboid of cell C2 can also be considered as having one face of the cuboid (perpendicular to the x-axis) translated by an amount Tx relative to its opposite face.
[0048] Similarly, at the next position along the machine axes, the error (horizontal straightness error) is measured in the y direction without any change in the errors in the other degrees of freedom (i.e. there is still the same error in the x direction, represented in cell C2, as there was in cell C1). The cuboid representation of cell C3 is therefore translated in the y direction relative to cell C2 by an amount Ty corresponding to the error value measured in the y direction, without any further change in dimensions. Alternatively, to derive the cuboid of cell C3, the cuboid of cell C2 may be stretched or shrunk in the y direction rather than (or along with) simply being translated in the y direction.
[0049] At the next position along the machine axes, corresponding to cell C4, the rotation error around the x-axis (roll error) is measured without any changes in the errors in the other degrees of freedom compared to cell C3. This is represented in cell C4 by rotating the cuboid from cell C3 by an amount Rx, which corresponds to the measured rotation error around the x-axis. At the last position along the machine axes, corresponding to cell C5, the error in sensing rotation around the y-axis (pitch error) is measured without any changes in the errors in the other degrees of freedom compared to cell C4. This is represented in cell C5 by rotating the cuboid from cell C4 by an amount Ry, which corresponds to the measured rotation error around the y-axis.
[0050] Figure 9 shows an alternative type of spatial error map embodying the invention. The spatial error map of Figure 9 is based on performing a translation and rotation transformation of a square (or rectangle) instead of the cuboid of Figure 8, and is based on the error values in six degrees of freedom exactly the same way as described above for the cuboid representation of Figure 8. Thus, in the example shown in Figure 9, the error representation of each cell is in the form of a square (or rectangle) transformed (rotated and / or translated) based on the error value. Optionally, a solid or semi-transparent surface can be fitted around the resulting error representation to combine the discrete representations together and provide a more continuous form of the spatial error map M, which may be easier to interpret in some cases.
[0051] Returning to the flow chart of FIG. 7, where the spatial error map M was generated in step S4 as described above, the spatial error map M is transmitted to and received by the user interface 24 (see FIG. 6) and displayed on the user interface 24 in step S5. By considering the spatial error map M displayed on the user interface 24, in step S6, the machine operator can identify trends or patterns in the error data much more easily than would be possible using six separate error plots as shown in FIG. 5. Additional guidance may be included or added to or associated with the spatial error map M, including, for example, highlighting or emphasizing certain portions of the spatial error map M (portions identified as actual or potential problems based on pre-determined criteria) or other messages or indications displayed to the machine operator. Based on this analysis and review, in step S7, the machine operator may control or configure one or more aspects of the machine.
[0052] For example, the resulting spatial error map M, shown in FIG. 9, is similar to visualizing how a sample square (or rectangular) artifact is moved by the machine along the relevant machine axis, which can provide useful technical insights to the machine operator to assist in making technical evaluations and decisions, for example identifying the presence of a specific issue in the drive mechanism along a portion of the machine axis resulting in an increase in the total amount of roll and pitch (step S6) and concluding that appropriate measures need to be taken to address the identified technical issue (step S7).
[0053] It will be appreciated that displaying the spatial error map M is optional, in which case steps S6 and S7 may be automated (e.g., performed by processor 40), as indicated by the dotted direct path between steps S4 and S6 in FIG. 7 (bypassing step S5). In this regard, it may be easier to automatically determine trends and patterns from a type of representation in which multiple error sources are condensed into a single error representation for each cell location. In this regard, the error representation need not be a visual representation, but may instead represent multiple error sources numerically. 3-3
[0054] FIG. 10 shows a more specific example of how the spatial error map M of FIG. 9 may be represented on the display of the user interface 24. The spatial error map M of FIG. 10 is similar to that shown in FIG. 9, with the addition of solid surfaces as a possibility, as described above. On the left side of the display is a control panel with various controls available to the operator to customize the error map. For example, there are six switches labeled ZRX, ZRY, ZRZ, ZTX, ZTY, ZTZ, each corresponding to six degrees of freedom, where the first letter "Z" indicates that the error map pertains to movement along the Z machine axis, and the subsequent letters indicate the degree of freedom (e.g., "RZ" is rotation about the Z axis, i.e., roll error in the Z axis, and "TZ" is translation along the Z axis, i.e., linear error in the Z axis). These switches can be individually switched on and off, thereby changing the spatial error map to be based only on the selected degree of freedom.
[0055] For example, FIG. 11 shows the display on the user interface 24 when only the "ZRZ" switch is enabled (switched to the "on" position). The spatial error map then shows the effect of only roll error about the Z axis, with errors in all other degrees of freedom being ignored for the spatial error map. FIG. 12 shows a conventional graphical plot corresponding to this error data in a format similar to FIGS. 4 and 5. These toggle switches provide a powerful technical capability to explore the error data and identify trends and patterns within the error data, allowing the machine operator to isolate a particular degree of freedom or combination of degrees of freedom. This allows the machine operator to understand the error data on a more intuitive level, assisting the machine operator in making a correct technical assessment. For example, referring to FIG. 11, the machine operator can easily see that there is a technical problem associated with twisting (or rotation) of the moving machine part in the second portion of the Z axis, which is not immediately apparent from the plot of FIG. 12. By switching to other error sources (errors in other degrees of freedom), the machine operator can explore error combinations and whether any of those combinations may be related to a particular problem in the machine axis of interest.
[0056] It will be appreciated that the rotational (angular) and linear error values may be appropriately scaled to appear more exaggerated for visualization purposes, such that, for example, the rotation of a square representation of each cell in the spatial error map may be larger than would be the case in real life. In reality, machine errors tend to be very small and they are not always immediately apparent in the spatial error map unless the errors are appropriately scaled. For example, a rotational (angular) error measured in degrees may be scaled, for example, by a factor of 3600, such that a measured rotational (angular) error of 10 arc seconds (1 arc second equals 1 / 3600th of a degree) is represented in the spatial error map as a rotational (angular) rotation of 10 degrees. Slider controls for these scale factors are shown in the control panel on the left side of Figures 10 and 11. The control panel also includes controls to control other aspects of the spatial error map, such as whether to add a wire frame (as shown in Figures 9 and 11) to the spatial error map, and whether to add a solid (shaded) surface (as shown in Figure 10) around the spatial error map. A variety of other controls are available for controlling the appearance and content of the spatial error map.
[0057] Although two types of error representations (3D cuboid and 2D square, respectively) for each cell of the spatial error map are shown in Fig. 8 and Fig. 9, it will be appreciated that many other types of representations can be used instead. For example, different shapes other than a cuboid or a square can be utilized. The representations can also be color-based, e.g., different colors along an axis can represent different error values from different error factors (such as degrees of freedom). It is believed that a common feature of these types of representations is that they can be arranged or displayed along a single axis (even when they are derived from multiple different error factors), unlike the type of representation shown in Fig. 5, which requires multiple error values to be plotted along multiple different axes, e.g., one axis (degree of freedom) for each error factor. These various embodiments of the present invention provide a technical effect, since each of them relates to the internal conditions prevailing within the technological system (e.g., errors in multiple different degrees of freedom along the machine axes of a machine tool), enabling an operator to properly operate this technological system.
[0058] It should be noted that the processing of the measurement data D and the generation of the spatial error map M can be performed in real time while measurements are being made by the calibrator 42. Alternatively, the measurement data D can be stored for later analysis. Furthermore, although the processor 40 and the user interface 24 are shown in FIG. 6 as part of the machine tool 100 itself, it should be appreciated that one or both of these components can be provided separately from the machine tool 100, for example, implemented by a general purpose computer that receives the measurement data D from the calibrator 42. These components, whether implemented by hardware or software or a combination thereof, can be considered together as forming a data visualization machine. Such a computing system or data visualization machine 50 is shown in FIG. 6 separately from the machine tool 100 (which can be separate from the location where the machine tool 100 is located).
[0059] The machine 50 comprises a housing 52 in which a data storage device 54 and a CPU 56 are provided. The machine 50 also comprises a display device 58 and a keyboard 59. The machine 50 receives measurement data D from the calibrator 42 (wirelessly or by direct link) and stores it in the data storage device 54. Instructions from a computer program data held in the storage device 54 are transmitted to the CPU 56 for processing and executed by the CPU 56 which requests and receives the data D from the storage device 54. A spatial error map M is generated and stored on the storage device 54 for subsequent analysis (e.g., identifying trends) and / or transmitted to the display device 58 for display thereon (allowing a user to utilize the keyboard 59 to manipulate and / or modify the spatial error map M and to interpret the error map M and make appropriate engineering decisions based on these interpretations).
[0060] It will be appreciated that the operation of the data visualization machine (either provided as part of the machine tool 100 or separately as the data visualization machine 50) may be controlled by a program running on the machine. Such a program may be stored on a computer readable medium or may be embodied in a signal, for example a downloadable data signal provided from an internet website. The appended claims are intended to be interpreted as covering the program as such, or as a record on a carrier, or as a signal, or in any other form.
Claims
1. 1. A method of generating a spatial map of sensor error data from a coordinate positioning machine, comprising the steps of: receiving measurement data collected by measuring or tracking an artefact moved by the machine along at least one machine axis; deriving error data by comparing the received measurement data with expected or ideal values of the measurement data; generating a spatial error map from the error data, each cell of the map containing an error representation derived from a plurality of error sources in the error data; A method comprising:
2. displaying the spatial error map on a user interface. The method of claim 1.
3. The user interface is a graphical user interface. The method of claim 2.
4. the error representation for each cell is a graphical error representation. The method of claim 1, 2 or 3.
5. each cell in the spatial error map corresponds to one of a plurality of locations within the machine; 2. A method according to any preceding claim.
6. The plurality of error factors include errors in two or more degrees of freedom related to the movement of the artifact.
2. A method according to any preceding claim.
7. the error representation for each cell is generated based on a transformation, e.g., a rotation and / or a translation, depending on the error in the two or more degrees of freedom. The method according to claim 6.
8. the error representation of each cell is transformed, e.g. rotated and / or translated, with respect to the error representations of the other cells depending on the difference between the respective errors of the two cells in the two or more degrees of freedom; The method according to claim 6 or 7.
9. providing the ability to generate a spatial error map from said error data, each cell of which contains an error representation derived from only a single error source in said error data, such as a single degree of freedom; 2. A method according to any preceding claim.
10. controlling which one or more of the plurality of error sources are utilized at one time to generate the spatial error map.
2. A method according to any preceding claim.
11. The generation of the spatial error map is performed in real time, e.g., as the measurement data is collected or shortly thereafter.
2. A method according to any preceding claim.
12. collecting the measurement data by measuring or tracking the artefact moved by the machine along at least one machine axis; 2. A method according to any preceding claim.
13. The coordinate positioning machine is a machine tool.
2. A method according to any preceding claim.
14. - the measurement data and / or error data relate to internal conditions prevailing in a technical system, said technical system being said coordinate positioning machine; 2. A method according to any preceding claim.
15. the error representation for each cell is a discrete and / or unitary error representation; 2. A method according to any preceding claim.
16. At least one of the error representations is a representation of a rectangular solid.
2. A method according to any preceding claim.
17. At least one of the error representations is a square or rectangular representation.
2. A method according to any preceding claim.
18. the error representation relating to the or each machine axis is adapted to be locatable and / or displayable along a single corresponding axis; 2. A method according to any preceding claim.
19. for the or each machine axis, displaying and / or arranging along a single corresponding axis a representation of the error associated with that machine axis; 2. A method according to any preceding claim.
20. The error factors utilized to derive the machine axis and / or the spatial error map are selectable; 2. A method according to any preceding claim.
21. 1. A method of operating a coordinate positioning machine, comprising the steps of: (a) generating a spatial error map utilizing a method according to any preceding claim, or receiving a spatial error map generated utilizing a method according to any preceding claim; (b) identifying trends, patterns or regions within the spatial error map based on pre-determined criteria; A method comprising:
22. controlling or configuring said machine based on said identified trends, patterns or areas.
22. The method of claim 21.
23. the trends or patterns or areas are identified substantially without human intervention; 23. The method of claim 21 or 22.
24. A data visualization machine adapted to carry out a method according to any preceding claim.
25. A coordinate positioning machine adapted to carry out the method of any one of claims 1 to 23.
26. A computer program which, when executed by a computer, causes the computer to carry out the method according to any one of claims 1 to 23.
27. A computer readable medium having stored therein computer program instructions for controlling a computer to perform the method of any one of claims 1 to 23.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Positional error evaluating method of moving device, and moving accuracy improving method based on result of evaluation
JP2002059340A
Calibration of dimension measuring equipment
JP2018511046A
Method and Apparatus for Estimating Error in Multi-Axis Controlled Machine
US20110218780A1
Cited By
Display device and display method
WO2026196458A1
Display device and display method
WO2026196465A1
