A deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method

Through the combination of entropy weight-hierarchical analysis fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method and the difference coefficient, the problem of low subjectivity and accuracy of factor weight determination in the stability evaluation of deep foundation pits is solved, and the detailed division of the safety status level of deep foundation pits is realized and Accurate evaluation enhances the credibility and reliability of the evaluation results.

CN114548725BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-26DALIAN UNIV OF TECH +1
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202210138883.7
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-02-15
Publication Date
2024-11-26
Estimated Expiration
2042-02-15

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing deep foundation pit stability assessment method has the problems of too subjective determination of factor weights, lack of systematic quantitative considerations and low accuracy, especially when dividing safety levels, the impact of factors such as risk occurrence and damage losses is ignored.

Method used

The fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method based on entropy weight-hierarchical analysis is adopted. By constructing a transit hierarchical evaluation index system, combining the hierarchical analysis method and the entropy weight method, the difference coefficient is proposed to combine the index weights linearly, and the safety status of deep foundation pit construction is refined. Level assessment, combining the probability of risk occurrence and the degree of damage loss of accidents, improve safety level classification.

Benefits of technology

The objectivity and calculation credibility of index weights are improved, and the safety status levels of deep foundation pit construction are carefully divided to ensure the accuracy and reliability of the evaluation results, and to better realize early warning grading.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN114548725B_ABST
    Figure CN114548725B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

A deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method belongs to the field of geotechnical mechanics and engineering. The present invention takes into account the objectivity of indicator weight assignment, as well as the probability of risk occurrence and the degree of accident damage loss. The main steps include: constructing an evaluation index system; determining the evaluation index weight based on the analytic hierarchy process; modifying the evaluation index weight based on the entropy weight method; determining the comprehensive weight of the index; dividing the safety level; determining the safety level; fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, and obtaining the evaluation score. The present invention proposes a difference coefficient, and based on this coefficient, linearly weighted combinations are performed on the weights of various indicators calculated by the analytic hierarchy process and the entropy weight method, and combined with the refined deep foundation pit construction safety status grade assessment table, the stability of the deep foundation pit is comprehensively and quantitatively evaluated. The present invention solves the problem that the judgment matrix A in the existing analysis method is affected by the expert experience level, and can objectively and accurately assign weights to the evaluation indicators, thereby improving the credibility of the weight calculation.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention belongs to the technical field of building engineering construction, and relates to a deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on an entropy weight-analysis-by-hierarchy fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method. Background Art

[0002] The stability of deep foundation pits is affected by many factors such as stratum conditions, groundwater distribution, and surrounding building environment. There is often a certain deviation between the design of the support structure and the actual engineering needs. The monitoring data can reflect the stress and deformation of the rock and soil in the corresponding parts in real time, and play an important guiding role in the design and adjustment of the foundation pit support structure. Therefore, it is of great engineering value and scientific significance to carry out the research on the monitoring data analysis method for the stability assessment of deep foundation pits.

[0003] At present, the commonly used deep foundation pit stability assessment methods are mainly: fault tree method, WBS method, hierarchical analysis method, fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method, and entropy weight method. Among them, the fault tree method and WBS method can make a concise and vivid description of the factors and logical relationships affecting the stability of deep foundation pits through qualitative analysis. However, their analysis process is relatively complicated, and there is a lack of systematic quantitative consideration of the stability of deep foundation pits. Although the hierarchical analysis-fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method systematically considers the factors affecting the stability of deep foundation pits and comprehensively decomposes them, the structure is clear, which makes up for the shortcomings of the above two methods. However, the hierarchical analysis method overemphasizes the role of the decision maker's experience level, which makes the determination of the evaluation index weight contain certain subjective factors. The entropy weight method can objectively consider the role of a single influencing factor, but because a set of recognized standard evaluation index models has not yet been formed in the current field of deep foundation pit construction research, it is easy to deviate from the actual results if the index weight analysis is simply performed using the entropy weight method. Moreover, in the previous classification of safety status of deep foundation pit construction, the safety level was often divided into 3-4 levels, with low accuracy. The selection and determination of warning values ​​needed to be set based on expert experience, ignoring the impact of factors such as risk occurrence and damage losses on the stability assessment of deep foundation pits. Summary of the invention

[0004] According to the technical problems raised above, the present invention provides a deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method. The present invention proposes a difference coefficient, and based on this coefficient, linear weighted combination of the weights of various indicators calculated by analytic hierarchy process and entropy weight method is performed, combined with the refined deep foundation pit construction safety status rating table, to comprehensively and quantitatively consider the stability of the deep foundation pit.

[0005] In order to achieve the above object, the technical means adopted by the present invention are as follows:

[0006] A deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method comprises the following steps:

[0007] S1. Construct an evaluation index system;

[0008] S2. Determine the weights of evaluation indicators based on the analytic hierarchy process;

[0009] S3. Based on the entropy weight method, the weights of evaluation indicators are modified;

[0010] S4. Determine the comprehensive weight of indicators;

[0011] S5. Classification of security levels;

[0012] S6. Determine the security level;

[0013] S7. Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation to obtain evaluation scores.

[0014] Furthermore, the specific implementation process of step S1 is as follows:

[0015] S11. According to the main deformation of the foundation pit during the construction process, such as deformation of the supporting structure, deformation of the surrounding environment and monitoring of the pit environment, determine the index factors affecting the stability of the deep foundation pit and construct a hierarchical evaluation index system;

[0016] S12. Set the probability level of indicators and build a multi-level indicator evaluation model that affects the safety and stability of deep foundation pits. Example: The first-level indicators include the deep foundation pit support structure, the surrounding environment, and the pit environment. Each first-level indicator is determined by several second-level indicators. The content of the second-level indicators can be divided into horizontal displacement of structural piles, vertical displacement of structural piles, settlement of surrounding buildings, inclination of surrounding buildings, changes in groundwater levels inside and outside the foundation pit, etc.

[0017] Furthermore, the implementation process of step S2 is as follows:

[0018] S21. Use the analytic hierarchy process to compare the indicators and factors in the same level with those in the previous level. Make a certain judgment on the relative importance of each indicator and factor in each level. Combine the 1-9 scale method to score their importance and construct a judgment matrix A for each level.

[0019] S22. Make assumptions about the judgment matrix A. The assumptions are as follows:

[0020]

[0021] Among them, a ij is the relative importance ratio of indicator i and indicator j;

[0022] S23, multiply each row of the judgment matrix A to obtain a new vector

[0023]

[0024] S24, raise each component of w to the nth power and normalize it, and finally obtain the weight vector W i :

[0025] Where (i = 1, 2, ..., n)

[0026] S25, introduce consistency indicators as follows:

[0027]

[0028] Among them, λ max It represents the maximum characteristic root of the judgment matrix. The larger the CI value is, the worse the consistency of the judgment matrix is.

[0029] S26. Use the consistency index and random consistency index RI to perform consistency check:

[0030] When the consistency ratio It means that the test has passed, and the sorting result of the hierarchical analysis meets the consistency, and the eigenvector is the weight vector; if it fails, the judgment matrix is ​​reconstructed or the elements in the matrix are adjusted until the consistency test is met.

[0031] Furthermore, the implementation process of step S3 is as follows:

[0032] S31. After passing the consistency test, the judgment matrix A is standardized and recorded as R:

[0033] in

[0034] S32, after standardizing the judgment matrix A, calculate the entropy E of each evaluation index j :

[0035]

[0036] In the evaluation process, if the entropy value is larger, the credibility of the evaluation result is lower; conversely, the smaller the entropy value is, the more credible the evaluation result is;

[0037] S33. Using the deviation degree d of each indicator j , calculate the correction coefficient μ for each indicator j :

[0038] where d j =1-E j

[0039] S34, using the correction factor μ j The initial weight W calculated by the modified analytic hierarchy processj , and the weight coefficient θ after the entropy weight method correction is obtained j :

[0040]

[0041] Furthermore, the implementation process of step S4 is as follows:

[0042] The weight index difference coefficient ρ is proposed, and the weight W is linearly weighted. j and weight correction coefficient θ j Perform combined calculations to determine the comprehensive weight of the indicator w j :

[0043] w j =ρW j +(1-ρ)θ j

[0044] Among them, ρ represents the proportion of the weights determined by the hierarchical analysis method to the combined weights; 1-ρ represents the proportion of the weights calculated by the entropy weight method to the combined weights.

[0045] The proportion of the weight determined by the hierarchical analysis method to the combined weight, that is, the weight index difference coefficient ρ, is determined according to the specific situation required. The solution of the difference coefficient ρ is calculated as follows:

[0046]

[0047] Among them, P i (i=1,2,3,…n) is the vector of AHP weight values ​​arranged in ascending order, and n is the number of evaluation indicators.

[0048] Furthermore, in step S5: the safety level is divided according to the probability of risk occurrence and the degree of loss caused by accident damage.

[0049] Furthermore, the implementation process of step S6 is as follows:

[0050] S61. Substitute the measured data of the evaluation index into the standard range of the reference index for the deep foundation pit construction safety status level assessment, and determine the membership degree of the single index to each status level, recorded as r ij ;

[0051] S62. Form a judgment set of all status levels for any single indicator, and determine the safety and stability status level of the evaluation indicator according to the maximum membership principle. The judgment set is as follows:

[0052] r i = {r i1 , r i2 , r i3 ,…r im}

[0053] S63, the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation at the bottom level is integrated to the upper level in turn to obtain the total evaluation matrix R′:

[0054]

[0055] Furthermore, the implementation process of step S7 is as follows:

[0056] S71, according to the comprehensive weight w of the index determined in step S4 j And the total evaluation matrix R' obtained in step S63, the fuzzy evaluation result is obtained as follows:

[0057] B=W×R′=(b1, b2,…,b m )

[0058] Among them, B is the fuzzy evaluation result, W is the modified weight matrix, R' is the membership matrix, according to the maximum membership principle max{b j}(j=1,2,3,…m), determine the comprehensive safety and stability level of deep foundation pit;

[0059] S72. Select the weight components for each level and perform weighted average on them to obtain an evaluation score. The weighted average formula is as follows:

[0060]

[0061] Among them, b j represents the level value corresponding to the j-th state level in the evaluation vector B, v j It represents the score of the j-level environmental quality situation, m is a selected positive real number, and F is the final score value.

[0062] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:

[0063] (1) The deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on the entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method provided by the present invention proposes a difference coefficient ρ, and based on this coefficient, a linear weighted combination of the weights of various indicators calculated by the analytic hierarchy process and the entropy weight method is performed, thereby enhancing the objectivity of the indicator weight determination. The present invention solves the problem that the judgment matrix A in the existing analysis method is affected by the expert experience level, and can objectively and accurately assign weights to the evaluation indicators, thereby improving the credibility of the weight calculation.

[0064] (2) The deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method provided by the present invention is based on the "Technical Standards for Monitoring of Construction Foundation Pit Engineering". By statistically analyzing the measured time data series of deep foundation pit engineering in various regions of my country, the monitoring data feature points with a 95% assurance rate are used as monitoring and control indicators. In combination with the probability of risk occurrence and the degree of accident damage and loss, the previous 4-level foundation pit safety grade classification standard is improved, and a 5-level assessment reference index table for the safety status of deep foundation pit construction is formulated, which makes the classification of foundation pit safety grade assessment more detailed and more convincing for the determination of deep foundation pit stability grade. It can accurately and reliably grade deep foundation pits and better realize early warning classification.

[0065] Based on the above reasons, the present invention can be widely promoted in the fields of building engineering construction. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0066] Figure 1 The figure is a flow chart of the method of the present invention.

[0067] Figure 2 This is a multi-level evaluation index structure diagram provided by the present invention.

[0068] Figure 3 A deep foundation pit engineering safety status evaluation index system is provided in an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0069] In order to enable those skilled in the art to better understand the scheme of the present invention, the technical scheme in the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work should fall within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0070] It should be noted that the terms "first", "second", etc. in the specification and claims of the present invention and the above-mentioned drawings are used to distinguish similar objects, and are not necessarily used to describe a specific order or sequence. It should be understood that the data used in this way can be interchanged where appropriate, so that the embodiments of the present invention described herein can be implemented in an order other than those illustrated or described herein. In addition, the terms "including" and "having" and any variations thereof are intended to cover non-exclusive inclusions, for example, a process, method, system, product or device that includes a series of steps or units is not necessarily limited to those steps or units that are clearly listed, but may include other steps or units that are not clearly listed or inherent to these processes, methods, products or devices.

[0071] The present invention proposes a weight index difference coefficient, improves the entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model, refines the deep foundation pit construction safety status level, and proposes a new method for deep foundation pit stability analysis on this basis. The solution is:

[0072] (1) A difference coefficient ρ is proposed, and based on this coefficient, a linear weighted combination of the weights of various indicators calculated by the analytic hierarchy process and the entropy weight method is performed. This enhances the objectivity of the indicator weight determination and solves the problem that the judgment matrix A in the existing analysis method is affected by the expert experience level. It can objectively and accurately assign weights to the evaluation indicators and improve the credibility of the weight calculation.

[0073] (2) The deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method provided by the present invention is based on the "Technical Standards for Monitoring of Construction Foundation Pit Engineering". By statistically analyzing the measured time data series of deep foundation pit engineering in various regions of my country, the monitoring data feature points with a 95% assurance rate are used as monitoring and control indicators. In combination with the probability of risk occurrence and the degree of accident damage and loss, the previous 4-level foundation pit safety grade classification standard is improved, and a 5-level assessment reference index table for the safety status of deep foundation pit construction is formulated, which makes the classification of foundation pit safety grade assessment more detailed and more convincing for the determination of deep foundation pit stability grade. It can accurately and reliably grade deep foundation pits and better realize early warning classification.

[0074] like Figure 1 As shown, the present invention provides a deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method, comprising the following steps:

[0075] S1. Construct an evaluation index system;

[0076] S2. Determine the weights of evaluation indicators based on the analytic hierarchy process;

[0077] S3. Based on the entropy weight method, the weights of evaluation indicators are modified;

[0078] S4. Determine the comprehensive weight of the indicators;

[0079] S5. Classification of security levels;

[0080] S6. Determine the security level;

[0081] S7. Fuzzy comprehensive evaluation to obtain evaluation scores.

[0082] In specific implementation, as a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the specific implementation process of step S1 is as follows:

[0083] S11. Determine the index factors that affect the stability of deep foundation pits and construct a hierarchical evaluation index system, such as Figure 2 As shown;

[0084] At present, the commonly used methods for determining the stability evaluation index of deep foundation pits are: (1) work breakdown structure (WBS), (2) risk breakdown structure (RBS), (3) WBS-RBS, (4) expert survey, (5) checklist, (6) graphic method, (7) brainstorming, etc. Since the scope of application of each analysis method is different, there are certain differences between the index factors. In previous research results, the deformation that can be detected during the construction of the foundation pit can be roughly divided into the following types according to its structural type: foundation pit support structure (horizontal displacement of structural piles, vertical displacement of structural piles, lateral displacement of maintenance wall, etc.), surrounding environment (settlement of surrounding buildings, inclination of surrounding buildings, width of cracks in surrounding buildings, etc.), and environment inside the foundation pit (uplift of the bottom of the foundation pit, groundwater level inside and outside the foundation pit, etc.).

[0085] S12. Set the probability level of indicators and build a multi-level indicator evaluation model that affects the safety and stability of deep foundation pits.

[0086] In specific implementation, as a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the implementation process of step S2 is as follows:

[0087] S21. Use the hierarchical analysis method to compare the indicators and factors in the same level with those in the previous level, and make a certain judgment on the relative importance of each indicator and factor in each level (the evaluation process of the hierarchical analysis method mainly depends on the experience level of experts, and the evaluation results are given in combination with the 1-9 scaling method. Therefore, the results obtained contain a certain degree of subjectivity. This is the shortcoming of the hierarchical analysis method, and it is also the improvement of the hierarchical analysis method by the entropy weight method in this patent. Among them, the entropy weight method is one of the objective weighting methods. The weighting process mainly considers the characteristics of the data itself and is not affected by human subjective factors). Combined with the 1-9 scaling method, score its importance (see Table 1) to construct the judgment matrix A of each level.

[0088] Table 1 1-9 scaling method

[0089]

[0090] S22. Make assumptions about the judgment matrix A. The assumptions are as follows:

[0091]

[0092] Among them, a ij is the relative importance ratio of indicator i and indicator j;

[0093] S23, multiply each row of the judgment matrix A to obtain a new vector

[0094]

[0095] S24, will Each component is raised to the nth power and normalized to obtain the weight vector W. i :

[0096] Where (i = 1, 2, ..., n)

[0097] S25, introduce consistency indicators as follows:

[0098]

[0099] Among them, λ max It represents the maximum characteristic root of the judgment matrix. The larger the CI value is, the worse the consistency of the judgment matrix is.

[0100] S26. Use the consistency index and random consistency index RI (see Table 2) to perform consistency test:

[0101] When the consistency ratio It means that the sorting result of the hierarchical analysis meets the consistency through the test, and the characteristic vector is the weight vector;

[0102] If it fails, the judgment matrix is ​​reconstructed or the elements in the matrix are adjusted until the consistency check is satisfied.

[0103] Table 2 Random consistency index RI value

[0104]

[0105] In specific implementation, as a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the implementation process of step S3 is as follows:

[0106] S31. After passing the consistency test, the judgment matrix A is standardized and recorded as R:

[0107] in

[0108] S32, after standardizing the judgment matrix A, calculate the entropy E of each evaluation index j :

[0109]

[0110] In the evaluation process, if the entropy value is larger, the credibility of the evaluation result is lower; conversely, the smaller the entropy value is, the more credible the evaluation result is;

[0111] S33. Using the deviation d of each indicator j , calculate the correction coefficient μ for each indicator j :

[0112] where d j =1-E j

[0113] S34, using the correction factor μ j The initial weight W calculated by the modified analytic hierarchy process j , and the weight coefficient θ after the entropy weight method correction is obtained j :

[0114]

[0115] In specific implementation, as a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the implementation process of step S4 is as follows:

[0116] In order to make the weight assignment take into account the advantages of decision makers’ experience and avoid the arbitrary subjectivity of weight assignment as much as possible, the weight index difference coefficient ρ is proposed, and the weight W is linearly weighted. j and weight correction coefficient θ j Perform combined calculations to determine the comprehensive weight w of the indicator j :

[0117] w j =ρW j +(1-ρ)θ j

[0118] Among them, ρ represents the proportion of the weights determined by the hierarchical analysis method to the combined weights; 1-ρ represents the proportion of the weights calculated by the entropy weight method to the combined weights.

[0119] The proportion of the weight determined by the hierarchical analysis method to the combined weight ρ is determined according to the specific situation required, and the difference coefficient ρ is calculated as follows:

[0120]

[0121] Among them, P i (i=1,2,3,…n) is the vector of AHP weight values ​​arranged in ascending order, and n is the number of evaluation indicators.

[0122] In specific implementation, as a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the basis for dividing the safety level in step S5 is the probability of risk occurrence and the degree of loss caused by accident damage.

[0123] In order to solve the problem of inaccurate quantitative standards for the monitoring and alarm classification strategy, the monitoring warning value should follow the following principles: (1) meet the design calculation requirements and cannot exceed the design value; (2) meet the safety requirements of the monitored object and achieve the purpose of protection; (3) for the protected objects under the same conditions, it should be determined in combination with the requirements of the surrounding environment and the specific construction conditions; (4) meet the requirements of the current relevant standards and regulations; (5) meet the requirements put forward by the competent authorities of each protected object. By comparing the monitoring alarm values ​​of the "Technical Standards for Monitoring of Construction Foundation Pit Engineering", combined with the probability of risk occurrence and the degree of accident damage and loss, a reference index for the safety status assessment of the five-level deep foundation pit construction was established, as shown in Table 3.

[0124] Table 3 Reference indicators for safety status assessment of deep foundation pit construction

[0125]

[0126] Note: 1. f1 - design value of component bearing capacity, ultimate pull-out bearing capacity of anchor rod; f y - Design value of prestressing of steel supports and anchor rods.

[0127] 2. When the cumulative change of the monitored items exceeds the specified value or the rate of change exceeds 70% of the specified value in the table for three consecutive times, the disaster warning response should be initiated immediately.

[0128] Risk factors can directly or indirectly lead to the occurrence of engineering safety accidents, and to a certain extent cause relevant economic losses and casualties of on-site workers to the project itself, materials and equipment, construction machinery and tools, third parties, etc. In order to better manage and control the occurrence of risks, and to promptly and effectively investigate and prevent major hazard sources, the safety and stability of deep foundation pit projects are divided into grades according to the probability of risk occurrence and the degree of loss caused by accident damage, as shown in Table 4.

[0129] Table 4 Risk probability and accident loss level during deep foundation pit construction

[0130]

[0131]

[0132] Note: EL is the ratio of direct economic loss to total investment; CL is the ratio of lost construction period to planned construction period; MW is the number of minor injuries; SW is the number of serious injuries; D is the number of deaths.

[0133] In specific implementation, as a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the implementation process of step S6 is as follows:

[0134] S61. Substitute the measured data of the evaluation index into the standard range of the reference index for the deep foundation pit construction safety status level assessment, and determine the membership degree of the single index to each status level, recorded as rij ;

[0135] S62. Form a judgment set of all status levels for any single indicator, and determine the safety and stability status level of the evaluation indicator according to the maximum membership principle. The judgment set is as follows:

[0136] r i = {r i1 , r i2 , r i3 ,…r im}

[0137] S63, the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation at the bottom level is integrated to the upper level in turn to obtain the total evaluation matrix R':

[0138]

[0139] In specific implementation, as a preferred embodiment of the present invention, the implementation process of step S7 is as follows:

[0140] S71. In order to take into account the influence of all evaluation indicators on the safety and stability assessment process of the deep foundation pit and to more truly reflect the comprehensive stability of the deep foundation pit during the on-site construction process, the comprehensive weight w of the indicators determined in step S4 is j And the total evaluation matrix R' obtained in step S63, the fuzzy evaluation result is obtained as follows:

[0141] B=W×R′=(b1,b2,…,b m )

[0142] Among them, B is the fuzzy evaluation result, W is the modified weight matrix, R' is the membership matrix, according to the maximum membership principle max{b j}(j=1,2,3,…m), determine the comprehensive safety and stability level of deep foundation pit;

[0143] S72. In order to reflect the comparability of the evaluation objects, the weighted components of each level are selected and weighted averaged to obtain the evaluation score. The formula for weighted average is as follows:

[0144]

[0145] Among them, b j represents the level value corresponding to the j-th state level in the evaluation vector B, v j It represents the score of the j-level environmental quality situation, m is a selected positive real number, and F is the final score value.

[0146] Example

[0147] This example uses a deep foundation pit project in Shenzhen, which is located on the southeast side of the intersection of Guangzhou-Shenzhen Yanjiang Expressway and Tinghai Avenue, in the green garden on the south side of the under-construction Metro Line 5. The perimeter of the foundation pit is about 317.425m and the area is about 7683m 2 , with 3 basements, the height of the 3rd underground floor is 10.0m, the depth of the foundation pit is 18.75m-24.75m, it is supported by underground continuous wall, and the thickness of the fill layer is 6.0m-14.0m. The northwest side of the foundation pit is about 15.0m away from the tunnel edge of the extension line of Metro Line 5, and the southwest side is about 30.0m away from the pile foundation of Yanjiang Expressway. The site environmental conditions are relatively complex.

[0148] Step 1: Construct evaluation indicators and systems:

[0149] During the construction of the deep foundation pit, the surrounding surface and trench settlements have changed significantly. According to the actual safety and stability needs of the Qianwan Information Hub Center foundation pit project, combined with Figure 2 The indicator system construction principle is to build a four-layer safety evaluation system from two aspects: the pit structure and the surrounding environment. Figure 3 shown.

[0150] First layer: U = [B1, B2];

[0151] Second layer: B1 = [C1, C2, C3, C4, C5, C6]; B2 = [C7, C8, C9];

[0152] The third layer: C1 = [D1, D2]; C2 = [D3, D4]; C3 = [D5, D6]; C4 = [D7, D8]; C5 = [D9, D 10 ]; C6 = [D 11 ,D 12 ]; C7 = [D 13 ,D 14 ]; C8 = [D 15 ,D 16 ]; C9 = [D 17 ,D 18 ].

[0153] Step 2: Determine the weight coefficient of the evaluation index;

[0154] Taking the foundation pit structure as an example, the analytic hierarchy process (AHP) judgment matrix was constructed according to the 1-9 scaling method, as shown in Tables 5 and 6.

[0155] Table 5 Overall judgment matrix BU

[0156]

[0157] Table 6 Pit structure judgment matrix B1-C

[0158]

[0159] The above evaluation matrix was tested for consistency according to the consistency index formula. The calculated consistency ratios all satisfied CR < 0.1, indicating that the matrix had good consistency and met the requirements for deep foundation pit construction.

[0160] Step 3: Entropy weight-AHP method combined weight;

[0161] Based on the judgment matrix A constructed by the analytic hierarchy process (AHP), the standardized judgment matrix is ​​obtained according to the formula for calculating the entropy of all indicators affecting the stability evaluation of deep foundation pits:

[0162]

[0163] According to R1, the index entropy E1 and deviation d1, correction coefficient μ1, corrected weight coefficient θ1 and combined weight w1 of the foundation pit structure evaluation index are calculated.

[0164] E1=(0.8759 0.8759 0.8540 0.8540 0.8540 0.9488)

[0165] d1=(0.1241 0.1241 0.1460 0.1460 0.1460 0.0512)

[0166] μ1=(0.8759 0.8759 0.8540 0.8540 0.8540 0.9488)

[0167] θ1=(0.3250 0.3250 0.1387 0.0832 0.0935 0.0346)

[0168] w1=(0.3246 0.3246 0.1282 0.0769 0.0864 0.0592)

[0169] Step 4: Establish the evaluation index affiliation matrix and evaluation model at each level;

[0170] The measured engineering data are used according to the reference index of deep foundation pit construction safety status assessment to construct the membership matrix of the pit structure:

[0171]

[0172] Pit structure:

[0173] B1=W1×R1′=(0.9057 0.2585 0.0942 0.0766 0)

[0174] Deep foundation pit as a whole:

[0175] B=W×R′=(0.5720 0.2681 0.1159 0.0440 0)

[0176] Fuzzy subset of the overall safety level of the foundation pit:

[0177] B=[0.5720(Grade I) 0.2681(Grade II) 0.1159(Grade III) 0.0440(Grade IV) 0(Grade V)]

[0178] Step 5: Overall assessment of the safety status of deep foundation pit;

[0179] Combined with the above analysis of the grade status of evaluation indicators at each level of deep foundation pit, the comprehensive evaluation results of a deep foundation pit project in Shenzhen were obtained according to the weighted average formula, see Table 7.

[0180] Table 7 Results of safety status assessment of deep foundation pit engineering

[0181]

[0182] According to the above data analysis, the deep foundation pit is in a Class I safety state as a whole, and in the first-level safety fuzzy subset, the membership degree of Class I is 0.572. The score of the surrounding environment is lower than that of the pit structure, indicating that when the horizontal displacement of the wall (pile) and the change of the deep horizontal displacement during the construction of the foundation pit exceed the warning value, the impact on the surrounding environment is relatively large. In this regard, the relevant departments attached great importance to it during the on-site construction and took corresponding treatment measures in time. The evaluation results are consistent with the actual situation of the project, indicating the effectiveness of the foundation pit safety assessment model and can better guide the construction process of the foundation pit.

[0183] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention, rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or replace some or all of the technical features therein with equivalents. However, these modifications or replacements do not cause the essence of the corresponding technical solutions to deviate from the scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention.

Claims

1. A deep foundation pit stability assessment method based on entropy weight-analytic hierarchy process fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method, characterized in that: The steps include: S1. Construct an evaluation index system; S11. According to the main deformation of the foundation pit during the construction process, determine the index factors affecting the stability of the deep foundation pit and construct a hierarchical evaluation index system; S12. Set the probability level of indicators and build a multi-level indicator evaluation model that affects the safety and stability of deep foundation pits; S2. Determine the weights of evaluation indicators based on the analytic hierarchy process; S21. Use the analytic hierarchy process to compare the indicators and factors in the same level with those in the previous level. Make a certain judgment on the relative importance of each indicator and factor in each level. Combine the 1-9 scale method to score their importance and construct a judgment matrix A for each level. S22. Make assumptions about the judgment matrix A. The assumptions are as follows: Among them, a ij is the relative importance ratio of indicator i and indicator j; S23, multiply each row of the judgment matrix A to obtain a new vector S24, will Each component is raised to the nth power and normalized to obtain the weight vector W. i : S25, introduce consistency indicators as follows: Among them, λ max It represents the maximum characteristic root of the judgment matrix. The larger the CI value is, the worse the consistency of the judgment matrix is. S26. Use the consistency index and random consistency index RI to perform consistency check: When the consistency ratio If the test is passed, it means that the sorting result of the hierarchical analysis meets the consistency, and the eigenvector is the weight vector; if it fails, the judgment matrix is ​​reconstructed or the elements in the matrix are adjusted until the consistency test is met; S3. Based on the entropy weight method, the weights of evaluation indicators are modified; S31. After passing the consistency test, the judgment matrix A is standardized and recorded as R: in S32, after standardizing the judgment matrix A, calculate the entropy E of each evaluation index j : S33. Using the deviation degree d of each indicator j , calculate the correction coefficient μ for each indicator j : S34, using the correction factor μ j The initial weight W calculated by the modified analytic hierarchy process j , and the weight coefficient θ after the entropy weight method correction is obtained j : S4. Determine the comprehensive weight of the indicators; The weight index difference coefficient ρ is proposed, and the weight W is linearly weighted. j and weight correction coefficient θ j Perform combined calculations to determine the comprehensive weight of the indicator w j : w j =ρW j +(1-p)θ j Among them, ρ represents the proportion of the weight determined by the hierarchical analysis method to the combined weight; 1-ρ represents the proportion of the weight calculated by the entropy weight method to the combined weight; The weight determined by the hierarchical analysis method accounts for the proportion of the combined weight, and the weight index difference coefficient ρ is determined according to the specific situation required. The solution of the difference coefficient ρ is calculated as follows: Among them, P i (i=1,2,3,…n) is the vector of AHP weight values ​​arranged in ascending order, and n is the number of evaluation indicators; S5. Classification of security levels; The safety levels are divided according to the probability of risk occurrence and the degree of loss caused by accident damage; the safety levels are shown in the following table: Note: EL is the ratio of direct economic loss to total investment; CL is the ratio of lost construction period to planned construction period; MW is the number of minor injuries; SW is the number of serious injuries; D is the number of deaths; S6. Determine the security level; S61. Substitute the measured data of the evaluation index into the standard range of the reference index for the deep foundation pit construction safety status level assessment, and determine the membership degree of the single index to each status level, recorded as r ij ; S62. Form a judgment set of all status levels for any single indicator, and determine the safety and stability status level of the evaluation indicator according to the maximum membership principle. The judgment set is as follows: r i ={r i1 ,r i2 ,r i3 ,…r im} S63, the fuzzy comprehensive evaluation at the bottom level is integrated to the upper level in turn to obtain the total evaluation matrix R′: S7, fuzzy comprehensive evaluation, to obtain the evaluation score; S71, according to the comprehensive weight w of the index determined in step S4 j And the total evaluation matrix R′ obtained in step S63, the fuzzy evaluation result is obtained as follows: B=W×R′=(b1,b2,…,b m ) Among them, B is the fuzzy evaluation result, W is the modified weight matrix, R′ is the membership matrix, and according to the maximum membership principle max{b j }(j=1,2,3,…m), determine the comprehensive safety and stability level of deep foundation pit; S72. Select the weight components for each level and perform weighted average on them to obtain an evaluation score. The weighted average formula is as follows: Among them, b j represents the level value corresponding to the j-th state level in the evaluation vector B, v j It represents the score of the j-level environmental quality, m is a selected positive real number, and F is the final score value.