A method for predicting high temperature creep variability of asphalt mixtures
Through high-temperature creep test and fractional creep damage model, a random damage evolution model is established to predict the creep performance variability of asphalt mixture at high temperatures, and the variability of creep performance in the prior art is solved. The problem has improved the quality of pavement construction and reduced maintenance costs.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202210233250.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-03-10
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-03-10
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is difficult to accurately predict the variability of creep performance of asphalt mixtures at high temperatures, resulting in unclear development laws of rut diseases, affecting the quality of road construction and maintenance costs.
The uniaxial creep curve was obtained through high-temperature creep test, and the fractional creep damage model fitted the model parameters, established a damage random evolution model, and predicted the creep performance variability under any load.
Accurate research on the high-temperature creep performance and rut development laws of asphalt mixtures is achieved, and feasible solutions are provided to predict the occurrence time of asphalt pavement ruts, reducing maintenance costs.
Smart Images

Figure CN114741843B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the field of road engineering, and specifically relates to a method for predicting the variability of creep performance of asphalt mixture at high temperature through a small amount of field tests, which can be applied to the evaluation of the variability of creep performance of asphalt mixture and the prediction of the development of rutting disease on asphalt pavement. Background Art
[0002] Rutting is a kind of vertical cumulative permanent deformation caused by repeated wheel loads during the long-term service of asphalt pavement. It is one of the main diseases of asphalt pavement. It not only affects the flatness of the road surface and the driving comfort, but also threatens the safety of driving. The road surface temperature and vehicle load have a significant impact on the deformation resistance of asphalt mixture, and are the most important factors affecting the rutting deformation of asphalt pavement. As a temperature-sensitive material, the deformation resistance of asphalt mixture decreases with the increase of temperature. Therefore, high temperature accelerates the generation and development of rutting disease in asphalt pavement. Therefore, rutting is also called high-temperature stability disease. In my country, asphalt pavement rutting is mainly caused by instability rutting of asphalt surface layer. The main reason is that the shear stress generated by vehicle load in the asphalt mixture exceeds the shear strength of the asphalt mixture, causing the flow deformation to accumulate and form rutting.
[0003] Indoor static and dynamic creep tests show that the development of rutting has three distinct stages, namely the initial compaction stage, the stable growth stage, and the accelerated instability stage. The cumulative loading times corresponding to the critical points of the stable growth stage and the accelerated instability stage are defined as the rheological times F N , the corresponding cumulative loading time is called the rheological time F t Studies have shown that the rheological number and rheological time have a certain correlation with the rutting depth, which can be used as indicators to evaluate the difference in creep performance between different mixtures. N Or flow time F t The variability of the asphalt mixture is large. For example, the coefficient of variation of the rheological times of multiple parallel mixture specimens of the same material can reach 30%. Therefore, the approximate range of the rheological times (rheological time) of a certain asphalt mixture can only be obtained by conducting multiple parallel tests and then averaging the average value. The number of parallel tests directly affects the accuracy of the index. Limited by the test conditions and energy, most studies have two or three parallel tests, which is far from enough for the index with large variability. Therefore, in order to master the law of high-temperature creep performance of asphalt pavement, the variability of the creep process of asphalt mixture must be considered. By studying the variability of high-temperature creep performance, we can fully grasp the mechanical state of asphalt pavement during service and effectively apply it to guide the maintenance and management of actual pavement, which is of great significance to improving the quality of pavement construction and reducing the maintenance cost of asphalt pavement during operation.
[0004] Most of the existing studies on the variability of high-temperature creep performance are based on probability statistics of a large amount of test data, but no research has been conducted on the mechanism of randomness in the creep process. Existing studies have shown that the variability of asphalt mixtures is small in the initial compaction stage of creep, but large variability occurs in the accelerated instability stage of creep, which is attributed to the variability of damage evolution during the creep process of asphalt mixtures. Therefore, it is an effective method to predict the variability of high-temperature creep performance of asphalt mixtures from the perspective of randomness of damage evolution. Summary of the invention
[0005] In view of this, in order to more accurately evaluate and study the high-temperature creep performance of asphalt mixtures, the present invention proposes a method for predicting the variability of high-temperature creep of asphalt mixtures. The invention predicts the variability of creep performance under different loads by considering the randomness of damage evolution during the high-temperature creep of asphalt mixtures and a small number of on-site high-temperature creep tests, thereby being able to more accurately and systematically study the high-temperature creep performance of asphalt mixtures and the development law of pavement rutting.
[0006] In order to achieve the above invention content, the present invention adopts the following technical solutions:
[0007] A method for predicting high temperature creep variability of asphalt mixtures.
[0008] Firstly, the uniaxial creep curves under various load levels were obtained through creep tests;
[0009] Then, the uniaxial creep curves under various levels of load are fitted by the fractional creep damage model to obtain the model parameters; and a prediction model between the model parameters and stress is established;
[0010] Through the creep damage model, a unified damage evolution model between damage value and damage strain is constructed; in the creep damage process, a mesoscopic random damage model is introduced to establish a damage random evolution model, and the damage evolution variation range is obtained by analyzing the test samples;
[0011] Finally, the variability of high-temperature creep performance of asphalt mixture under arbitrary loads is predicted through the prediction model and the damage evolution variation range.
[0012] A method for predicting high temperature creep variability of asphalt mixture comprises the following steps:
[0013] Step 1, high temperature creep test: the formed asphalt mixture is subjected to uniaxial creep tests under different loads at the temperature of the indoor rutting test (60°C ± 1°C) to obtain creep curves under various loads, and three parallel tests are performed for each group.
[0014] Step 2, determination of fractional creep damage model and parameters: The creep model parameters of asphalt mixture are obtained by fitting the proposed creep damage model with the creep results of each level of load obtained in step 1. The creep damage process is composed of creep hardening process and creep damage process. The creep damage model expression is:
[0015]
[0016]
[0017]
[0018] D=1-(1-t / t f ) 1(v+1) (4)
[0019] Among them, σ 0 is the magnitude of the applied load; t is the creep test time; ε(t), ε h (t) and ε d (t) are the total creep strain, creep hardening strain and damage strain of asphalt mixture respectively; α, β are the fractional orders of the Abel model describing the creep hardening process and creep damage process respectively; ξ 1 ,ξ 2 are the material coefficients describing the creep hardening process and creep damage process respectively; D is the damage value; t f is the creep failure time; v is the material parameter describing the damage.
[0020] Step 3: Establishment of creep model parameter and stress relationship prediction model: Based on the creep damage model parameters under various loads obtained in step 2, establish model parameters α, β, ξ 1 ,ξ 2 Prediction models related to stress respectively.
[0021] Step 4: Establishment of a unified damage evolution model: The establishment of a unified damage evolution model includes the following steps:
[0022] Step 4-1, determination of damage value: according to the creep failure time t under each level of load obtained in step 2 f With the damage parameter v, the change of damage value D with time under various load levels can be obtained using formula (4).
[0023] Step 4-2, determination of damage strain: According to formula (1), the damage strain can be expressed as follows:
[0024]
[0025] The creep curves obtained by creep tests at various load levels can be compared with the α, ξ obtained in step 2. 1The damage strain ε under each level of load is obtained d Changes over time.
[0026] Step 4-3, establishment of unified damage evolution model: Through steps 4-1 and 4-2, the damage value D and damage strain ε under various load levels can be constructed. d The damage evolution model between the loads is independent of the applied load size, that is, the damage evolution under various levels of load can be described by a unified model, and the unified damage evolution model satisfies the Weibull distribution function.
[0027] Step 5: Analysis of the randomness of damage evolution: The analysis of the randomness of damage evolution includes the following steps:
[0028] Step 5-1, establishment of mesoscopic random damage model: A mesoscopic random damage model is introduced in the creep damage process, that is, the Abel micro-unit model describing the damage has a random fracture strain, then the mean and variance of the random damage variable are expressed as:
[0029]
[0030]
[0031] Where Δ(x) is the ultimate failure strain of the Abel microunit describing the damage, which is a random variable obeying a certain probability distribution; f(δ; x) is the one-dimensional probability distribution function density of the ultimate failure strain at position x; F(ε) and F(ε,ε; η) are the one-dimensional distribution function and the two-dimensional distribution function, respectively, η = |x 1 -x 2 |Defined as x 1 , x 2 The relative distance; H(t) is the unit jump function.
[0032] According to step 4, the damage and damage strain satisfy the Weibull distribution function. Therefore, the fracture strain of the Abel microscopic model describing the damage also satisfies the Weibull distribution function. Then the damage distribution probability density function is
[0033]
[0034] Among them, p and q are temperature-dependent material parameters.
[0035] The two-dimensional distribution function can be obtained based on the Frank-Copula function, and its expression is:
[0036]
[0037] In the formula, θ F is the autocorrelation coefficient and θ F(η) = exp(-ω·η), where ω is the relevant scale parameter.
[0038] Step 5-2, determination of sample set: According to steps 1 to 4, the damage value D and damage strain ε under each level of load can be obtained. d (t) and randomly select parallel specimens under various load levels in step 1 as the sample set.
[0039] Step 5-3, determination of random damage model parameters: According to the mesoscopic random damage model, modeling is performed based on the test sample set to obtain the random damage model parameters. This method is divided into two calculation processes:
[0040] Step 5-3-1: Discretize the damage strain into intervals for the curve of damage strain and strain value, and take the midpoint of the interval as the base point to calculate the mean value and standard deviation (ε i ,μ i ,V i );
[0041] Step 5-3-2: Use the above theoretical model (Equation 6 and Equation 7) to calculate the strain as ε i The stress mean and standard deviation at the time of the model are identified by minimizing the sum of squares of the differences between the corresponding theoretical values and the measured values as the optimization criteria. The Powell search method is used to perform a nonlinear equation on equation (6) and the average value of the sample set at the corresponding point to obtain the optimal solution to obtain the parameters p and q, and then the Powell search method is used to perform a nonlinear equation on equation (7) and the standard deviation of the sample set at the corresponding point to obtain the relevant scale parameter ω.
[0042] Step 5-4, determination of the discrete range of damage: Parameters such as p, q and ω are obtained according to step 5-3, and the mean value and variance of the damage are obtained according to step 5-1, so as to give the discrete range of damage in a probabilistic sense, that is, the upper and lower limits of the damage in the probability interval.
[0043] Step 6, prediction of high temperature creep performance: Based on step 5, the upper and lower limits of the damage probability interval are determined, that is, the relationship between the damage value and the upper and lower limits of the damage strain. The upper and lower limit damage relationship is substituted into formula (3) respectively. The model parameters under any load are obtained according to the creep model parameters and stress relationship prediction model obtained in step 3. The relationship between the damage strain and time is solved by Matlab, and finally superimposed with the creep hardening formula (2), thereby realizing the prediction of the variation range of the asphalt mixture creep curve under any load.
[0044] At the same time, repeating steps 1 to 6 can predict the variability of high-temperature creep properties of different types of mixtures under any load. At the same time, the variability of creep properties of asphalt mixtures at different temperatures can also be predicted based on this method.
[0045] Beneficial effects:
[0046] (1) Based on the mechanism of variability in the creep process, the present invention introduces the randomness of damage evolution to predict the variability of high-temperature creep performance of asphalt mixtures, which is an effective and practical prediction method.
[0047] (2) In view of the lack of existing research on the mechanism of variability and randomness of high-temperature creep performance of asphalt mixtures, the present invention analyzes the variability in the creep process from the perspective of the randomness of damage evolution. Through the fractional-order creep damage model, a mesoscopic random damage model is introduced to explain the randomness of damage evolution from a physical mechanism.
[0048] (3) Furthermore, by obtaining the discrete range of damage, the variation range of the creep curve of asphalt mixture under any load can be predicted, which provides a feasible solution for evaluating the variability of the creep performance of asphalt mixture and the prediction range of the occurrence time of instability rutting of asphalt pavement. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0049] Figure 1 It is a mesoscopic physical random fracture model;
[0050] Figure 2 are the stress mean, standard deviation of damage strain and damage value, and the upper and lower limits of the probability interval of damage;
[0051] Figure 3 Comparison between the random damage prediction model and the test results. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0052] The present invention is further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments:
[0053] Example 1
[0054] Select the raw materials of the asphalt mixture required for the study, and conduct corresponding performance tests on them. All performances must meet the test requirements. Select the gradation of the asphalt mixture, and determine the optimal oil-stone ratio and target void ratio. Use a rotary compactor to form test pieces. According to the requirements of specification JTG E20-2011, use a rotary compactor to form cylindrical specimens with a diameter and height of 150mm and 170mm respectively; then, core sample the formed specimens to obtain cylindrical specimens with a diameter of 100mm and a height of 150mm. In this embodiment, AC-13 gradation is used, the optimal oil-stone ratio is 4.9%, and the porosity of the asphalt mixture is controlled at 4.0%.
[0055] A method for predicting high temperature creep variability of asphalt mixture comprises the following steps:
[0056] Step 1, high temperature creep test: The formed asphalt mixture is subjected to unconfined uniaxial compression test and uniaxial creep test under different loads at the temperature of indoor rutting test (60℃±1℃) to obtain the unconfined compressive strength value σ of the asphalt mixture. u And creep curves at various levels of load.
[0057] In this embodiment, the uniaxial creep test is set to four levels of load σ n , level 4 load σ n are the unconfined compressive strength σ u 0.35, 0.5, 0.65, and 0.8 times of the control group, and three parallel experiments were carried out in each group.
[0058] Step 2, determination of creep damage model and parameters: The creep model parameters of asphalt mixture are obtained by fitting the proposed creep damage model with the creep results of various loads obtained from the test in step 1. The creep damage process is composed of creep hardening process and creep damage process. The creep damage model expression is:
[0059]
[0060]
[0061]
[0062] D=1-(1-t / t f ) 1(v+1) (4)
[0063] Among them, σ 0 is the magnitude of the applied load; ε(t), ε h (t) and ε d (t) are the total creep strain, creep hardening strain and damage strain of asphalt mixture respectively; α, β are the fractional orders of the Abel model describing the creep hardening process and creep damage process respectively; ξ 1 ,ξ 2 are the material coefficients describing the creep hardening process and creep damage process respectively; D is the damage value; t f is the creep failure time; v is the material parameter describing the damage.
[0064] Step 3, establishing the relationship between creep model parameters and stress: Based on the creep damage model parameters under various loads obtained in step 2, establish the model parameters α, β, ξ 1 ,ξ 2 Prediction models associated with each level of load stress.
[0065] Step 4: Establishment of a unified damage evolution model: The establishment of a unified damage evolution model includes the following steps:
[0066] Step 4-1, determination of damage value: according to the creep failure time t under each level of load obtained in step 2 f With the damage parameter v, the variation of the damage value D with time t under each level of load can be obtained using formula (4).
[0067] Step 4-2, determination of damage strain: According to formula (1), the damage strain can be expressed as:
[0068]
[0069] The creep curves obtained by creep tests at various load levels can be compared with the α, ξ obtained in step 2. 1 The damage strain ε under each level of load is obtained d Changes over time.
[0070] Step 4-3, establishment of unified damage evolution model: Through steps 4-1 and 4-2, the damage value D and damage strain ε under various load levels can be constructed. d The damage evolution model between the loads is independent of the applied load size, that is, the damage evolution under various levels of load can be described by a unified model, and the unified damage evolution model satisfies the Weibull distribution function.
[0071] Step 5: Analysis of the randomness of damage evolution: The analysis of the randomness of damage evolution includes the following steps:
[0072] Step 5-1, establishment of mesoscopic random damage model: Introduce mesoscopic random damage model in the creep damage process, that is, the Abel micro-unit model describing the damage has random fracture strain, such as Figure 1 As shown. Then the mean and variance of the random damage variable are expressed as:
[0073]
[0074]
[0075] Where Δ(x) is the ultimate failure strain of the Abel microunit describing the damage, which is a random variable obeying a certain probability distribution; f(δ; x) is the one-dimensional probability distribution function density of the ultimate failure strain at position x; F(ε) and F(ε,ε; η) are the one-dimensional distribution function and the two-dimensional distribution function, respectively, η = |x 1 -x 2 |Defined as x 1 , x 2 The relative distance; H(t) is the unit jump function. According to step 4, the damage and damage strain satisfy the Weibull distribution function, so the fracture strain of the Abel microscopic model describing the damage also satisfies the Weibull distribution function, then the damage distribution probability density function
[0076]
[0077] Among them, p and q are temperature-dependent material parameters.
[0078] The two-dimensional distribution function can be obtained based on the Frank-Copula function, and its expression is:
[0079]
[0080] In the formula, θ F is the autocorrelation coefficient and θ F (η) = exp(-ω·η).
[0081] Step 5-2, determination of sample set: According to steps 1 to 4, the damage value D and damage strain ε under each level of load can be obtained. d (t) relationship curve, randomly select the parallel specimens under each level of load in step 1 as the sample set. In this embodiment, a total of 5 test sample sets under each level of load are taken, such as Figure 2 shown.
[0082] Step 5-3, determination of random damage model parameters: According to the above model, modeling is performed based on the test sample set to obtain random damage model parameters. This method is divided into two calculation processes:
[0083] Step 5-3-1: Discretize the damage strain into intervals for the curve of damage strain and strain value, and take the midpoint of the interval as the base point to calculate the mean value and standard deviation (ε i ,μ i ,V i );
[0084] Step 5-3-2: Use the above theoretical model (Equation 6 and Equation 7) to calculate the strain as ε i The stress mean and standard deviation at the time of the model are identified by minimizing the sum of squares of the differences between the corresponding theoretical values and the measured values as the optimization criteria. The Powell search method is used to perform a nonlinear equation on equation (6) and the average value of the sample set at the corresponding point to obtain the optimal solution to obtain the parameters p and q, and then the Powell search method is used to perform a nonlinear equation on equation (7) and the standard deviation of the sample set at the corresponding point to obtain the relevant scale parameter ω.
[0085] Step 5-4, determination of the discrete range of damage: According to step 5-3, the parameters such as p, q and ω are obtained, and the damage mean value and standard deviation are given using equations 6 and 7, so as to give the discrete range of damage in the sense of probability, that is, the upper and lower limits of the damage in the probability interval. In this embodiment, the range of the damage mean plus or minus one standard deviation is given, such as Figure 2shown.
[0086] Step 6, prediction of high temperature creep performance: Based on step 5, the upper and lower limits of the damage probability interval are determined, and the upper and lower limit damage relationship equations are respectively substituted into equation (3). The model parameters under any load are obtained according to the creep model parameter and stress relationship prediction model obtained in step 3. The relationship between damage strain and time is solved by Matlab, and finally superimposed with creep hardening equation (2), so as to realize the prediction of the variation range of the asphalt mixture creep curve under any load. In this embodiment, the damage 0.7σ is given. u The creep test curve and prediction range are as follows: Figure 3 shown.
[0087] Repeating steps 1 to 6 can predict the variability of high-temperature creep properties of different types of mixtures under any load. The method can also be used to predict the variability of creep properties of asphalt mixtures at different temperatures.
[0088] The examples described above are only some embodiments of the present invention, not all embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for predicting high temperature creep variability of asphalt mixture, characterized in that: The steps include: Step 1, high temperature creep test: the formed asphalt mixture is subjected to uniaxial creep tests under different loads at the temperature of the indoor rutting test to obtain creep curves under various loads, and three parallel tests are performed for each group; the temperature of the rutting test is 60°C ± 1°C; Step 2, determination of fractional creep damage model and parameters: The creep model parameters of asphalt mixture are obtained by fitting the proposed creep damage model with the creep results of each level of load obtained in step 1. The creep damage process is composed of creep hardening process and creep damage process. The creep damage model expression is: D=1-(1-t / t f ) 1 / (v+1) (4) Among them, σ0 is the magnitude of the applied load; t is the creep test time; ε(t), ε h (t) and ε d (t) are the total creep strain, creep hardening strain and damage strain of asphalt mixture respectively; α, β are the fractional orders of Abel model describing creep hardening process and creep damage process respectively; ξ1, ξ2 are the material coefficients describing creep hardening process and creep damage process respectively; D is the damage value; t f is the creep failure time; v is the material parameter describing the damage; Step 3, establishing a prediction model of the relationship between creep model parameters and stress: based on the creep damage model parameters under various levels of load obtained in step 2, a prediction model is established in which the model parameters α, β, ξ1, ξ2 are respectively related to stress; Step 4: Establishment of a unified damage evolution model: By establishing the damage value and damage strain ε d Model, which makes the damage evolution model independent of the applied load size, that is, the damage evolution under various levels of load can be described by a unified model, and the unified damage evolution model satisfies the Weibull distribution function; The establishment of the unified damage evolution model specifically includes the following steps: Step 4-1, determination of damage value: according to the creep failure time t under each level of load obtained in step 2 f With the damage parameter v, the change of the damage value D with time t under each level of load can be obtained by using formula (4); Step 4-2, determination of damage strain: According to formula (1), the damage strain can be expressed as follows: The damage strain ε under each level of load can be obtained by combining the creep curves obtained from the creep test at each level of load with α and ξ1 obtained in step 2. d Changes over time; Step 4-3, establishment of unified damage evolution model: Through steps 4-1 and 4-2, the damage value D and damage strain ε under various load levels can be constructed. d Evolutionary models between Step 5: Analysis of the randomness of damage evolution: The analysis of the randomness of damage evolution includes the following steps: Step 5-1, establishment of mesoscopic random damage model: Introducing mesoscopic random damage model in the creep damage process, that is, the Abel micro-unit model describing the damage has a random fracture strain, then the mean and variance of the random damage variable can be obtained as: Wherein, Δ(x) is the ultimate failure strain of the Abel micro-unit describing the damage, which is a random variable obeying a certain probability distribution; f(δ; x) is the one-dimensional probability distribution function density of the ultimate failure strain at position x; F(ε) and F(ε,ε; η) are the one-dimensional distribution function and the two-dimensional distribution function respectively, η = x1-x2 is defined as the relative distance between x1 and x2; H(t) is the unit jump function; Step 5-2, determination of sample set: According to steps 1 to 4, the damage value D and damage strain ε under each level of load can be obtained. d The relationship curve between them is obtained, and the parallel specimens under various levels of load in step 1 are randomly selected as the sample set; Step 5-3, determination of random damage model parameters: According to the mesoscopic random damage model, modeling is performed based on the test sample set to obtain the random damage model parameters. This method is divided into two calculation processes: Step 5-3-1: Discretize the damage strain into intervals for the curve of damage strain and strain value, and take the midpoint of the interval as the base point to calculate the mean value and standard deviation (ε i ,μ i ,V i ); Step 5-3-2: Use the random model in step 5-1 to calculate the strain as ε i The stress mean and standard deviation at the time of , the model parameters are identified by taking the minimum sum of squares of the corresponding theoretical value and measured value as the optimization criterion; Step 5-4, determination of the discrete range of damage: Based on the damage mean value and standard deviation obtained in step 5-3, the discrete range of damage in a probabilistic sense can be given, that is, the upper and lower limits of the probability interval of damage; Step 6, prediction of high temperature creep performance: Based on step 5, the upper and lower limits of the damage probability interval, that is, the upper and lower limit relationship between the damage value and the damage strain, are determined. The model parameters under any load are obtained according to the creep model parameter and stress relationship prediction model obtained in step 3. The relationship between the damage strain and time is solved by Matlab, and finally superimposed with the creep hardening formula (2), thereby realizing the prediction of the variation range of the asphalt mixture creep curve under any load.
2. A method for predicting high temperature creep variability of asphalt mixture according to claim 1, characterized in that: The establishment of the mesoscopic random damage model in step 5-1 is based on the proposed fractional creep damage model. The Abel microscopic unit model describing the damage has a random fracture strain and satisfies the Weibull distribution function. The damage distribution probability density function is: Among them, p and q are material parameters related to temperature; the two-dimensional distribution function can be obtained according to the Frank-Copula function, and its expression is: In the formula, θ F is the autocorrelation coefficient and θ F (η) = exp(-ω·η), where ω is the relevant scale parameter.
3. A method for predicting high temperature creep variability of asphalt mixture according to claim 1, characterized in that: The parameters of the random damage model in step 5-3 are determined by performing a nonlinear equation on equation (6) and the average value of the sample set at the corresponding point through the Powell search method to obtain the optimal solution to obtain parameters p and q, and then performing a nonlinear equation on equation (7) and the standard deviation of the sample set at the corresponding point through the Powell search method to obtain the optimal solution to obtain the related scale parameter ω.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Asphalt mixture multi-stage loaded high-temperature creep curve analysis method based on axle load spectrum
CN105486845A
Method for determining number of times of flowing deformation of high-temperature creep instability points of asphalt mixture
CN105891013A
Method and system for determining properties of an asphalt material
US20120016601A1
