Application of volume weighted mean diameter in the evaluation of post-heat-treated yogurt particle perception
By testing the volume-weighted average diameter D[4,3] and the particle size distribution of whey dispersant, combined with a power-law fitting model and yogurt mixing scheme, the accuracy of post-heat-treated yogurt particle texture assessment and the uncertainty of sensory assessment were solved, achieving more efficient and accurate particle texture control.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410100543.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-11-15
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-10
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-11-15
AI Technical Summary
Existing particle size distribution testing and microscopic image analysis methods cannot effectively guide the study of particle texture in post-heat-treated yogurt, and sensory analysis methods are greatly affected by individual oral tactile sensitivity, resulting in inaccurate particle texture assessment.
The volume-weighted average diameter D[4,3] was used as the particle size distribution test index, whey was used as the dispersant, and the oral sensitivity of sensory members was identified by a power-law fitting model. A yogurt mixing scheme with a specific volume-weighted average diameter was combined to reduce the graininess.
It improves the accuracy of testing for graininess in post-heat-treated yogurt and the precision of sensory evaluation, reduces graininess, reduces the manpower required for sensory evaluation, and is simple and efficient to operate.
Smart Images

Figure CN117907168B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] This invention is a divisional application of patent application No. 202311517245.7, filed on November 15, 2023, entitled "Application of Volume-Weighted Average Diameter in Evaluating the Granularity of Post-Heat-Treatment Yogurt". This invention relates to the field of yogurt technology, and more particularly to the volume-weighted average diameter D... [4,3] Application in the evaluation of graininess in post-heat-treated yogurt. Background Technology
[0002] Yogurt is a traditionally chilled snack enjoyed at the breakfast table, but the emergence of room-temperature yogurt has revolutionized this tradition. For millions of young people in China, room-temperature yogurt is now a portable beverage, a trend that is spreading across Asia, Africa, and Latin America. Driving the popularity of room-temperature yogurt in China and other countries is the growing consumer demand for convenience, nutritional value, and flavor. Shelf-stable room-temperature yogurt offers similar nutritional value to traditional fermented frozen yogurt, but without probiotics, and can be consumed on the go because it doesn't require refrigeration.
[0003] Post-heat treatment (“secondary pasteurization”) is a critical procedure in the production of room-temperature yogurt (stirred yogurt). Its purpose is to inactivate microorganisms to extend shelf life (4–25°C / 150–180 days), but this can easily lead to a grainy texture, reduced creaminess, and heterogeneous product structure. Different post-heat treatment temperatures result in varying degrees of sensory defects in yogurt. Sensory texture characteristics are considered a prominent indicator of yogurt quality and a driver of consumer choice. Generally, when sensory texture defects are not easily perceived, they have a smaller impact on acceptability decisions. However, once these defects are perceived, even slightly as an undesirable texture, they are likely to be a major factor leading to sensory rejection.
[0004] Therefore, this invention is proposed. Summary of the Invention
[0005] The post-heat-treated yogurts mentioned in this invention refer to stirred yogurts, and a grainy texture is a common texture defect in post-heat-treated yogurt products. Fermentation causes casein to aggregate into a weak gel network. Through further post-treatment, such as stirring or smoothing, this network is broken down into dense clusters of aggregated proteins, ranging in size from 10 to 250 μm, or occasionally larger than 1 mm. These clusters are defined as microgels, in which interactions occur between the microgels. Post-heat treatment plays an important role in promoting the aggregation and rearrangement of these microgels. Increasing the post-heat treatment temperature alters the balance between hydrophobic interactions and electrostatic repulsion of the microgels, increasing the thermal motion of the microgel particles and leading to further aggregation of microgel clusters. Therefore, the aggregation process must be controlled during post-heat treatment to avoid large-scale particle aggregation, which is related to common texture defects such as a grainy texture.
[0006] Particle characteristics (such as size, hardness, and shape), dispersion matrix characteristics (such as viscosity), and composition (such as particle concentration) are considered the main factors determining the particle recognition threshold, especially for typical semi-solid foods. Yogurt and cheese have been widely recognized for the following: (i) "higher viscosity tends to increase the particle perception threshold"; (ii) "when mass or number concentration remains constant, larger, harder, and more angular particles are more easily perceived as particulate than smaller, softer, round / flat particles"; and (iii) "particle size, hardness, and shape determine the concentration range for perceiving particulate properties." These views offer insights into producing smooth and acceptable textures by adjusting properties such as the particle distribution within the matrix in which the particles reside.
[0007] However, through comparative research, this invention found that when testing the particle size distribution of post-heat-treated yogurt, conventional testing procedures and evaluation indicators of average particle size cannot effectively guide the application research of post-heat-treated yogurt in terms of particle texture.
[0008] Specifically, the present invention provides a volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] Application in post-heat treated yogurt.
[0009] The threshold for particle texture recognition is defined as the minimum detectable change in the number and / or size of particles that results in a perceptible particle texture. However, few studies have explored this in depth. As mentioned above, particle texture is related to the gel network structure in room-temperature yogurt. Existing methods for testing gel network structure commonly employ microscopic image analysis, specifically obtaining the gel structure in post-heat-treated yogurt through a process of sample preparation, image acquisition, and particle analysis. This invention unexpectedly discovered that, in particle size distribution testing, the volume-weighted average diameter D... [4,3] Compared to other particle size indicators, this method can more accurately reflect the gel structure in post-heat-treated yogurt, achieving test accuracy comparable to microscopic image analysis. Moreover, this method is simpler, more efficient, and has a wider range of applications than existing microscopic image analysis methods.
[0010] The application provided by the present invention as described above includes: the volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] Used to evaluate the microgel structure in post-heat-treated yogurt.
[0011] In particle size distribution testing, the heat-treated yogurt sample to be tested cannot be used directly for testing, but needs to be diluted with a dispersant. During dilution, different dispersants will have different effects on the microgel structure in the heat-treated sample to be tested. In order to avoid test errors caused by test conditions, this invention preferably uses whey from the heat-treated yogurt sample to be tested as the dispersant for particle size distribution testing. Compared with other dispersants, such as water and simulated ultrafiltrate, it is more consistent with the results of existing microscopic image analysis methods.
[0012] The applications provided by the present invention as described above include:
[0013] Whey was obtained by centrifugation from the heat-treated yogurt sample to be tested;
[0014] The whey is filtered using an ultrafiltration membrane to obtain filtered whey, which is the dispersant;
[0015] The dispersant is used for particle size distribution testing of the heat-treated yogurt sample to obtain the volume-weighted average diameter D. [4,3] .
[0016] Different post-heat-treated yogurt samples may yield different test results. For post-heat-treated yogurt samples, viscosity is the main factor affecting the dispersion or aggregation of microgel structures. This invention found that when the viscosity of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample to be tested is 100–500 mPa·s, the volume-weighted average diameter D can be effectively measured. [4,3] Furthermore, this value is consistent with the results of existing microscopic image analysis methods.
[0017] According to the application provided by the present invention as described above, the viscosity of the heat-treated yogurt sample to be tested is 100-500 mPa·s;
[0018] Preferably, the components of the heat-treated yogurt sample to be tested mainly include: 0.1-0.4% low-ester pectin, 4-8% white sugar, 2.8-3.2% protein, and 3.0-4.0% fat; more preferably, 0.3% low-ester pectin, 6.0% white sugar, 2.8-3.2% protein, and 3.0-4.0% fat.
[0019] More preferably, in the particle size distribution test, the shading range is 4-6%.
[0020] The particle size distribution test in this invention can be performed using a commonly used laser diffractometer (Malvern Mastersizer S, Malvern Instruments, Worcs), which is simple to operate and has a wide range of applications. The particle size distribution test is carried out under stirring conditions, and the stirring speed can be 1000-2000 rpm.
[0021] Specifically, the volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] The process for evaluating the microgel structure in post-heat-treated yogurt can be as follows: The post-heat-treated yogurt sample to be tested is centrifuged (5000g × 30min, 4℃) to obtain the corresponding whey, then filtered using an ultrafiltration membrane (molecular weight cutoff of 10000 Da), and heated in a water bath to 37±2℃. This whey is then used to disperse the post-heat-treated yogurt sample during particle size measurement. The particle size distribution is determined using a laser diffractometer (Malvern Mastersizer S, Malvern Instruments, Worcs), where the dispersant refractive index is set to 1.32 and the particle refractive index is set to 1.46. The stirring speed is 1500 rpm, and the opacity range is 4–6%. Measurement is performed automatically after the opacity stabilizes within this range for 30 seconds. The particle size result for each sample is obtained from the average of six consecutive measurements, with each sample subjected to three repeated measurements.
[0022] The grainy sensation is a complex biological process caused by the interaction between food and mechanoreceptors in the oral cavity. This depends not only on the nature of the grain and the matrix in which it is situated, but also on the neural impulses carried by multiple afferent nerves. Evaluation of the microgel structure of the heat-treated samples is still insufficient to accurately assess the grainy sensation of the heat-treated yogurt samples. Furthermore, even for samples with the same grainy texture and matrix characteristics, consumers' perception of the grainy sensation may vary due to individual oral tactile sensitivity.
[0023] Currently, commonly used sensory analysis methods involve evaluation by a number of trained professional sensory members or a large group of consumers (more than 50 people). The evaluation results are then qualitatively categorized. For example, in the generalized labeled magnitude scale (gLM), sensory members rate the graininess of the heat-treated yogurt sample. Different graininess scores correspond to different qualitative descriptions: 0 is defined as "hard to detect," 1 as "very weak," 2 as "extremely weak," 3 as "weak," 4 as "somewhat weak," 5 as "moderate (neither strong nor weak)," 6 as "somewhat strong," 7 as "strong," 8 as "very strong," and 9 as "extremely strong." Therefore, considering individual differences in oral tactile sensitivity, understanding the sensory members' perception and recognition thresholds of graininess in the context of their evaluation is crucial for product development. This will help to better understand the sensory texture defects of optimized heat-treated yogurt.
[0024] The application provided by the present invention as described above includes: the volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3]Oral sensitivity test for the grainy texture of post-heat-treated yogurt.
[0025] As mentioned above, individual differences in oral tactile sensitivity are an important influencing factor when sensory members assess particle texture. This invention found in its research that the volume-weighted average diameter D of post-heat-treated yogurt samples... [4,3] A significant power-law correlation was found between the particle sensitivity scores of sensory members and the particle sensitivity scores. Therefore, this invention further investigated and found that the high-sensitivity group among sensory members can be identified through the correlation, thereby improving the accuracy of the oral sensitivity test for particle sensitivity.
[0026] According to the application provided by the present invention as described above, the oral sensitivity test for granular texture includes: identifying sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities;
[0027] The identification includes:
[0028] The volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample [4,3] Within the range of 14–65 μm, the particle texture score was determined as a function of the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample. [4,3] Sensory members with increasing values.
[0029] The term "incremental" here does not refer to a point-by-point incremental relationship, but rather to a sensory member to be identified that exhibits an overall increasing trend in multiple particle perception evaluation tests.
[0030] According to the application provided by the present invention as described above, the oral sensitivity test for granular texture includes:
[0031] Identify all sensory members;
[0032] The particle sense score is evaluated by all the sensory members. The particle sense score is described according to the intensity level corresponding to the generalized label level: 0-3 points is defined as weak level, 3-6 points is defined as medium level, and 6-9 points is defined as strong level. In this invention, the above "weak", "medium" and "strong" are relative concepts.
[0033] Identify sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities among all sensory members;
[0034] The identification includes:
[0035] The particle size score for each sensory member was correlated with the volume-weighted average diameter D of the corresponding post-heat-treated yogurt sample. [4,3] Perform a power-law fit, and the fitted relationship follows Y = mX n+k power-law fitting model, where Y is the particle size score, and X is the volume-weighted average diameter D of the heat-treated yogurt sample corresponding to the particle size score. [4,3] Value, n is the power-law fitting exponent, m and k are constants, R 2 The fitting accuracy of this power-law fitting model;
[0036] The power-law fitting exponent n and the fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting model are given by... 2 To determine the sensitivity of each sensory member.
[0037] Preferably, sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities are divided into three groups according to their sensitivity level: high sensitivity group, low sensitivity group, and medium sensitivity group.
[0038] The fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting exponent n and the power-law fitting model 2 After sorting, determine one or more of the sensory members from the high-sensitivity group, the low-sensitivity group, and the medium-sensitivity group.
[0039] More preferably, in the application provided by the present invention as described above, the identification includes:
[0040] The fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting exponent n and the power-law fitting model 2 Sort the data in ascending order to determine the first, second, and third percentiles of all clustering parameters;
[0041] The identification and clustering of each sensory member are performed using the first percentile, the second percentile, and the third percentile to determine the sensory members in the high-sensitivity group, the low-sensitivity group, and the medium-sensitivity group.
[0042] Specifically, when n is higher and R is higher 2 The closer to 1, the better, as this indicates that the sensory member's ability to distinguish particle size is closer to the instrument's testing accuracy; the lower the value of n and the higher the value of R... 2 The closer to 0, the worse, as this indicates that the sensory member's ability to distinguish particle size deviates significantly from the objective test results of the instrument.
[0043] In this invention, when the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample... [4,3] Within the range of 14–65 μm, and the particle size score of sensory members increased with the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample. [4,3] When the value increases and exhibits a strictly increasing trend of power-law fitting (i.e., the power-law fitting exponent n and the fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting model), 2 Both are greater than the third percentile mentioned above, and both strictly follow the formula Y = mX.n +k power-law fitting model), the sensory members are the sensory members of the high-sensitivity group;
[0044] In this invention, when the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample... [4,3] Within the range of 14–65 μm, the particle size score of sensory members increased with the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt samples. [4,3] When the value increases and shows a poor increasing trend in power-law fitting (i.e., the power-law fitting exponent n and the fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting model), the power-law fitting model exhibits a poor increasing trend. 2 Both are less than the aforementioned first percentile, and they almost do not follow the formula Y=mX. n +k power-law fitting model), the sensory members are the sensory members of the low-sensitivity group;
[0045] In this invention, when the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample... [4,3] Within the range of 14–65 μm, the particle size score of sensory members increased with the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt samples. [4,3] When the value increases and exhibits a moderately increasing trend in power-law fitting (i.e., the power-law fitting exponent n and the fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting model), 2 For values greater than the first percentile and / or less than the third percentile, the general rule is Y = mX. n +k power-law fitting model), the sensory members are sensory members of the medium sensitivity group.
[0046] In short, sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities exhibit varying degrees of compliance with the "power-law fitting increasing relationship." Strict compliance indicates high sensitivity, basic compliance indicates moderate sensitivity, and non-compliance or poor compliance indicates low sensitivity. The degree of compliance can be determined based on both the power-law exponent and the fitting accuracy.
[0047] According to the application described above, the oral sensitivity test is used in a particle sensory evaluation test.
[0048] Based on the above research findings, in evaluation trials involving a large number of sensory personnel (more than 50 people), for a smaller number of highly sensitive sensory members (approximately 80% of whom are of moderate or higher sensitivity, according to the power-law fitting model described above), the sensory evaluation results can be consistent with those of all sensory members (more than 50 people) under the simpler correspondence described above. Specifically, in sensory evaluation trials involving only highly sensitive members (approximately 15% of all sensory personnel, according to the power-law fitting model described above), results closer to the accuracy of instrument testing can be obtained than those of all sensory members, with less manpower required.
[0049] This study also found that higher post-heat treatment temperatures promote particle aggregation, leading to larger microgels, increased microgel surface area, and a decrease in the number of small-sized microgels. This is because yogurt can be considered a weak gel network, primarily composed of four different particle sizes generated by the aggregation of casein (0.1–0.3 μm) during acidification. The protein bonds contained in these weak gel particles are mainly controlled by hydrophobic interactions. Higher post-heat treatment temperatures may enhance the hydrophobic interactions between these gel particles and provide a stronger initial driving force for particle aggregation, ultimately leading to two results: on the one hand, the structural units, volume fractions, and contact areas between two particles may be smaller; on the other hand, more extensive particle rearrangement may lead to changes in the relative positions of particles and the formation of dense aggregated particle swarms, which in turn increases the density of aggregated particles by increasing the number of connections between particles. Therefore, increasing the post-heat treatment temperature causes these microgels of different surface area categories to rearrange and promote their aggregation and growth. In a sense, post-heat treatment promotes the growth of large particle swarms within the microgels, and this "growth effect" comes at the expense of small particle swarms.
[0050] The experiments of this invention demonstrate that post-heat treatment temperature alters the balance between hydrophobic interactions and electrostatic repulsion in microgels, increasing the thermal motion of microgel particles and leading to further aggregation of microgel clusters. Therefore, the aggregation process must be controlled during post-heat treatment to avoid large-scale particle aggregation, which is related to common texture defects such as graininess. This invention also unexpectedly discovered that when different volume-weighted average diameters D... [4,3] When post-heat-treated yogurt is mixed, the graininess of the mixed yogurt will be significantly different. In order to control the graininess of the post-heat-treated yogurt to below medium, in other words, to reduce the graininess of the post-heat-treated yogurt, specifically, according to the application provided by the present invention as described above, the application is a method for reducing the graininess of post-heat-treated yogurt, comprising: mixing post-heat-treated yogurt A with a volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] Yogurt B with a particle size ≤46μm is mixed, and the post-heat treated yogurt A is obtained by post-heat treating and sterilizing the yogurt B; the volume ratio of the yogurt B to the post-heat treated yogurt A is ≥3:7.
[0051] According to the application provided by the present invention as described above, the volume-weighted average diameter D of the yogurt B is... [4,3] ≤20μm, preferably ≤15μm.
[0052] When the post-heat treatment temperature is 60-70°C, during the mixing process, the volume-weighted average diameter D of yogurt B... [4,3] ≤15μm, the volume ratio of yogurt B to post-heat treated yogurt A is ≥3:7;
[0053] When the post-heat treatment temperature is 80-85°C, during the mixing process, the volume-weighted average diameter D of yogurt B... [4,3] ≤15μm, the volume ratio of the yogurt to the post-heat-treated yogurt A is ≥7:3.
[0054] According to the application provided by the present invention as described above, the application is a method for reducing the grainy texture of post-heat-treated yogurt, comprising: mixing post-heat-treated yogurt A with a volume-weighted average diameter D. [4,3] A mixture of post-heat treated yogurt C with a particle size of ≤46μm is prepared, wherein the post-heat treated yogurt A and the post-heat treated yogurt C are obtained by sterilizing the same yogurt at different post-heat treatment temperatures;
[0055] Preferably, the heat treatment temperature of the post-heat treated yogurt A is 65-85°C, the heat treatment temperature of the post-heat treated yogurt C is below 65°C, and during mixing, the volume ratio of the post-heat treated yogurt C to the post-heat treated yogurt A is ≥7:3.
[0056] More preferably, the volume-weighted average diameter D of the yogurt is... [4,3] ≤15μm.
[0057] Since post-heat treated yogurt A and post-heat treated yogurt C are obtained by sterilizing the same yogurt at different post-heat treatment temperatures, when the post-heat treatment temperature of post-heat treated yogurt A is 65°C, the post-heat treatment temperature of post-heat treated yogurt C is <65°C.
[0058] In this invention, when preparing any type of post-heat-treated yogurt (such as post-heat-treated yogurt A, post-heat-treated yogurt B, post-heat-treated yogurt C), the only difference between the yogurt required for the post-heat-treated yogurt and the post-heat-treated yogurt is the different post-heat-treatment (sterilization) temperature.
[0059] This invention provides a volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] Application in the evaluation of particle texture in post-heat-treated yogurt: When testing the particle size distribution of post-heat-treated yogurt, this invention found that the volume-weighted average diameter D... [4,3] This method can be used to evaluate the microgel structure in post-heat-treated yogurt, and the results are comparable to those of existing microscopic image analysis methods. Furthermore, it was found that the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt... [4,3] A significant power-law correlation exists between the particle size score and the sensory member's score, which can be used to identify high-sensitivity groups among the sensory members, improving the accuracy of the particle size sensory assessment test. Furthermore, when different volume-weighted average diameters D are considered... [4,3] When post-heat-treated yogurt is mixed, the grainy texture of the mixed yogurt will be significantly different. In order to reduce the grainy texture of yogurt after post-heat treatment and sterilization, this invention proposes to use a specific volume-weighted average diameter D.[4,3] A technical solution for mixing yogurt with post-heat-treated yogurt that has a higher particle texture score after post-heat treatment sterilization. Attached Figure Description
[0060] To more clearly illustrate the technical solutions in this invention or the prior art, the drawings used in the description of the embodiments or the prior art will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are some embodiments of this invention. For those skilled in the art, other drawings can be obtained from these drawings without creative effort.
[0061] Figure 1 This is a particle size distribution curve of different test samples provided by the present invention;
[0062] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of the particle analysis process using Image J2 software provided by the present invention;
[0063] Figure 3 These are fluorescence microscopy images of different test samples provided by the present invention; the fluorescence images are generally green, where (A) is the NT group, (B) is the 55℃ and 65℃ group, and (C) is the 75℃ and 85℃ group;
[0064] Figure 4 The particle texture score is caused by the different post-heat treatment temperatures provided by this invention.
[0065] Figure 5 These are representative fitting results for each sensitivity group provided by this invention; where (A) corresponds to the high sensitivity group, (B) corresponds to the low sensitivity group, and (C) corresponds to the medium sensitivity group.
[0066] Figure 6 The average graininess score and D for each sensitivity group provided by this invention. [4,3] The relationship between them; where (A) corresponds to the high sensitivity group, (B) corresponds to the low sensitivity group, and (C) corresponds to the medium sensitivity group; the points of the circle, square, upper triangle, lower triangle and rhombus represent the NT group, 55℃25s group, 65℃25s group, 75℃25s group and 85℃25s group respectively.
[0067] Figure 7These are the particle texture evaluation results of different mixing systems provided by this invention; wherein, (A) corresponds to the mixing test of the NT group and the 65℃ / 25s group, (B) corresponds to the mixing test of the NT group and the 85℃ / 25s group, and (C) corresponds to the mixing test of the 65℃ / 25s group and the 85℃ / 25s group; the points of solid square, upper triangle, rhombus, lower triangle and hollow square represent the volume ratios during mixing in turn: 9:1, 7:3, 5:5, 3:7 and 1:9, respectively; in (A) the solid circle and the hollow circle represent the NT group and the 65℃ / 25s group in turn, respectively; in (B) the solid circle and the hollow circle represent the NT group and the 85℃ / 25s group in turn, respectively; and in (C) the solid circle and the hollow circle represent the 65℃ / 25s group and the 85℃ / 25s group in turn, respectively. Detailed Implementation
[0068] To make the objectives, technical solutions, and advantages of this invention clearer, the technical solutions of this invention will be clearly and completely described below with reference to the accompanying drawings. Obviously, the described embodiments are only some, not all, of the embodiments of this invention. All other embodiments obtained by those skilled in the art based on the embodiments of this invention without creative effort are within the scope of protection of this invention.
[0069] The following is combined Figures 1 to 7 The volume-weighted average diameter D of the present invention is described. [4,3] Application in post-heat treated yogurt.
[0070] Where specific techniques or conditions are not specified in the examples, they shall be performed in accordance with the techniques or conditions described in the literature in this field, or in accordance with the product instructions. Reagents or instruments whose manufacturers are not specified are all conventional products that can be purchased through legitimate channels.
[0071] Example 1: Particle Size Distribution Test
[0072] (1) Sample preparation
[0073] (1.1) Ultra-high temperature treated milk (3.2% protein, 4.0% fat) (Inner Mongolia Mengniu Dairy (Group) Co., Ltd., Hohhot, China) was heated to 45°C to 50°C in a fermentation tank. Then, 6.0% (w / w) of granulated sugar and 0.30% (w / w) of low-ester pectin were added and stirred at 550 rpm until they were uniformly mixed with the milk base. Heating was continued to 60°C, and the mixture was homogenized at 40 bar / 150 bar. After homogenization, the mixture was continuously heated to 85°C and held for 20 minutes, then cooled to 42°C for inoculation and fermentation (0.03% (w / w), Streptococcus thermophilus). Fermentation was terminated when the pH of the yogurt dropped to 4.50 ± 0.04. Stirring at 550 rpm was used to disrupt the gel system of the yogurt.
[0074] (1.2) Divide the yogurt obtained in step (1.1) into five portions; leave one portion untreated, which is the NT group, and heat the other four portions to a core temperature of 55℃, 65℃, 75℃ and 85℃ respectively and hold for 25s. Then immediately cool them to 25℃ with running water and store them overnight at 4℃ together with the NT group. Label them as: NT group, 55℃25s group, 65℃25s group, 75℃25s group and 85℃25s group respectively. Perform viscosity tests on each group, and the corresponding viscosities are 175.39±10.42mPa·s, 329.98±8.64mPa·s, 436.63±33.04mPa·s, 363.47±7.68mPa·s and 267.29±1.85mPa·s respectively.
[0075] (2) Particle size distribution test
[0076] (2.1) Dispersant preparation
[0077] Dispersant 1: Take a portion of the yogurt obtained in step (1.1), centrifuge it (5000g×30min, 4℃) to obtain whey, then filter it using an ultrafiltration membrane (molecular weight cutoff of 10000Da), and heat it in a water bath to 37±2℃ to obtain filtered whey.
[0078] Dispersant 2: Ultrapure water.
[0079] Dispersant 3: Simulated ultrafiltrate, using ultrapure water as solvent. The remaining components and their contents are shown in Table 1 below:
[0080] Table 1
[0081]
[0082]
[0083] (2.2) The filtered whey (dispersant 1) obtained in step (2.1) was used to disperse the test samples (NT group, 55℃ 25s group, 65℃ 25s group, 75℃ 25s group, and 85℃ 25s group) obtained in step (1) during particle size measurement. The particle size distribution was determined using a laser diffractometer (Malvern Mastersizer S, Malvern Instruments, Worcs), with the dispersant refractive index set to 1.32 and the particle refractive index set to 1.46. The stirring speed was 1500 rpm, and the shading range was 4–6%. Automatic measurement was performed after the shading stabilized within the range for 30 seconds. The particle size result for each sample was obtained from the average of six consecutive measurements. Each sample was measured three times. The obtained particle size distribution diagram is shown below. Figure 1As shown in the figure, the different particle size parameters determined from the figure are shown in the following table:
[0084] Table 2
[0085] <![CDATA[D
[10] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[50] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[90] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D [4,3] (μm)]]> NT group <![CDATA[7.70±0.10 d ]]> <![CDATA[13.70±0.36 e ]]> <![CDATA[22.98±1.07 e ]]> <![CDATA[14.55±0.39 e ]]> 55℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[7.27±0.02 d ]]> <![CDATA[15.20±0.48 d ]]> <![CDATA[41.15±0.37 d ]]> <![CDATA[20.15±0.10 d ]]> 65℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[9.78±0.01 c ]]> <![CDATA[21.09±0.06 c ]]> <![CDATA[53.00±1.09 c ]]> <![CDATA[27.20±0.36 c ]]> 75℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[14.42±0.13 b ]]> <![CDATA[40.18±0.56 b ]]> <![CDATA[88.18±1.68 b ]]> <![CDATA[46.32±0.69 b ]]> 85℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[17.40±0.38 a ]]> <![CDATA[60.63±1.54 a ]]> <![CDATA[123.17±3.13 a ]]> <![CDATA[65.98±1.67 a ]]>
[0086] Note: In Table 2, if the same letter is in the same column, the difference between groups is not significant (p>0.05), and if the same letter is not in the same column, the difference between groups is significant (p≤0.05).
[0087] As can be seen from the above figure and table, the particle size distribution (PSD) curves of yogurts obtained with different post-heat treatments are unimodal, and the peak width of the curves shifts towards larger particle sizes as the post-heating temperature increases. Except for the NT group and the 55℃ / 25s group, D...
[10] In addition, all particle size parameters, especially D
[90] and D [4,3] All parameters increased significantly with increasing post-heat treatment temperature (p≤0.05). The results indicate that the post-heat treatment temperature has a considerable impact on the particle size distribution in yogurt; the higher the temperature, the greater the effect. The increased D...
[90] and D [4,3] The study revealed the particle growth behavior of microgel particles in post-heat-treated yogurt. Increased post-heat-treatment temperature can provide a stronger driving force for interparticle fusion, leading to rearrangement of particles and clusters across all length scales, resulting in particle fusion and increased structural unit size.
[0088] (2.3) is basically the same as step (2.2), except that dispersant 1 is replaced by an equal volume of dispersant 2. The particle size test results are shown in the table below:
[0089] Table 3
[0090] <![CDATA[D
[10] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[50] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[90] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D [4,3] (μm)]]> NT group <![CDATA[6.04±0.04 c ]]> <![CDATA[10.19±0.15 c ]]> <![CDATA[16.74±0.49 d ]]> <![CDATA[13.23±0.15 c ]]> 55℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[6.37±0.11 c ]]> <![CDATA[10.53±0.18 c ]]> <![CDATA[16.69±0.21 d ]]> <![CDATA[13.61±0.18 c ]]> 65℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[8.14±0.02 b ]]> <![CDATA[16.53±0.10 b ]]> <![CDATA[33.10±0.77 c ]]> <![CDATA[18.80±0.29 b ]]> 75℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[9.07±0.02 a ]]> <![CDATA[19.28±0.17 a ]]> <![CDATA[37.68±0.71 b ]]> <![CDATA[21.50±0.28 a ]]> 85℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[8.50±0.03 ab ]]> <![CDATA[18.78±0.05 a ]]> <![CDATA[42.15±1.53 a ]]> <![CDATA[22.45±0.45 a ]]>
[0091] Note: In Table 3, if the same letter is in the same column, the difference between groups is not significant (p>0.05), and if the same letter is not in the same column, the difference between groups is significant (p≤0.05).
[0092] (2.4) is basically the same as step (2.2), except that dispersant 1 is replaced by an equal volume of dispersant 3. The particle size test results are shown in the table below:
[0093] Table 4
[0094] <![CDATA[D
[10] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[50] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[90] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D [4,3] (μm) <!-- 8 -->]]> NT group <![CDATA[7.95±0.02 b ]]> <![CDATA[14.63±0.22 d ]]> <![CDATA[25.25±0.75 e ]]> <![CDATA[15.70±0.28 e ]]> 55℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[8.57±0.03 b ]]> <![CDATA[17.73±0.12 c ]]> <![CDATA[38.00±2.02 d ]]> <![CDATA[20.97±0.78 d ]]> 65℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[8.78±0.04 b ]]> <![CDATA[18.63±0.17 c ]]> <![CDATA[41.68±2.23 c ]]> <![CDATA[22.38±0.80 c ]]> 75℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[10.00±0.18 a ]]> <![CDATA[25.10±0.61 b ]]> <![CDATA[62.75±7.71 b ]]> <![CDATA[31.30±2.46 b ]]> 85℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[11.13±0.05 a ]]> <![CDATA[29.48±0.43 a ]]> <![CDATA[71.70±2.71 a ]]> <![CDATA[36.08±0.93 a ]]>
[0095] Note: In Table 4, if the same letter is in the same column, the difference between groups is not significant (p>0.05), and if the same letter is not in the same column, the difference between groups is significant (p≤0.05).
[0096] (3) Fluorescence microscopy image testing
[0097] (3.1) Sample preparation
[0098] The sample preparation was essentially the same as in step (1), except that a 0.2% solid green solution was added to the emulsion base simultaneously with the addition of low-ester pectin. Subsequently, the sample was stirred and heat-treated in the dark, then left to stand overnight for later use. The samples were labeled as follows: Microscope image - NT group, Microscope image - 55℃ 25s group, Microscope image - 65℃ 25s group, Microscope image - 75℃ 25s group, and Microscope image - 85℃ 25s group.
[0099] (3.2) Microscopic image analysis was performed according to the procedures modified by Gilbert et al. (2020) and Li et al. (2020). Specifically, for each sample, 1 mL of the sample prepared in step (3.1) was pipetted and diluted 10-fold with the filtered whey obtained in step (2.1). The sample was then gently shaken and mixed. Finally, 25 μL of the labeled and diluted sample was transferred and spread evenly on a microscope slide (25 mm × 76 mm) fitted with a microscope coverslip (25 mm × 25 mm × 0.13–0.16 mm) and observed under a 10x objective lens in fluorescence mode using an inverted microscope. Three slides were prepared for each of the three replicates in each treatment group (one for each replicate). Three images were randomly acquired on each slide. Particle analysis was performed on the acquired images using Image J2 software according to the method of Gilbert et al. (2020), as follows: Figure 2 As shown. In short, background noise in the image is first removed using a "Bandpass Filter," with the threshold adjustment defined as the default mode in red. The image is then bipolarized, and a "watershed process" is used to distinguish particles. It should be noted that particles segmented at image boundaries are excluded and not included in the analysis. A total of nine images are obtained from three replicates of each sample group. The surface area of individual particles varies after software processing in each image, but overall, they can be divided into four different categories: i.e., particle surface area <1000 μm. 2 The particle surface area is 1000-2000 μm 2 Between 2000 and 3000 μm in particle surface area 2 Between particles and particle surface area >3000μm 2 Furthermore, by statistically analyzing the number of particles and their surface area in each image, the average surface area of the particles in each sample group can be calculated. Based on this average surface area, the particle diameter can then be calculated. The average surface area and calculated diameter of the microgels measured using image analysis are listed in the table below:
[0100] Table 5
[0101] <![CDATA[Average surface area (μm 2 )]]> Calculate the diameter (μm). Microscope images - NT group <![CDATA[183.77±6.77 e ]]> <![CDATA[15.30±0.28 e ]]> Microscope images -55℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[272.52±9.12 d ]]> <![CDATA[18.61±0.29 d ]]> Microscope images -65℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[427.66±3.80 c ]]> <![CDATA[23.32±0.12 c ]]> Microscope images -75℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[1400.17±86.30 b ]]> <![CDATA[42.22±1.30 b ]]> Microscope images -85℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[2930.57±91.50 a ]]> <![CDATA[61.09±0.96 a ]]>
[0102] Note: In Table 5, if the same letter is in the same column, the difference between groups is not significant (p>0.05), and if the same letter is not in the same column, the difference between groups is significant (p≤0.05).
[0103] In addition, to more intuitively reflect the changes in sample microstructure and particle cluster size, fluorescence micrographs of each sample were recorded as follows: Figure 3 As shown.
[0104] The data above show that the average surface area and diameter of the microgels increase significantly with increasing post-heating temperature (p≤0.05).
[0105] More importantly, the diameter calculated based on image analysis and the results based on laser diffraction measurements show that the particle sizes of the samples in the NT group, 55℃ / 25s group, 65℃ / 25s group, 75℃ / 25s group, and 85℃ / 25s group are 15.30±0.28μm, 18.61±0.29μm, 23.32±0.12μm, 42.22±1.30μm, and 61.09±0.96μm, respectively. Compared with the image analysis results, the Di of the ultrapure water (dispersant 2) dilution system... [4,3] The particle size values are generally small, deviating significantly from the actual particle size levels reflected in imaging; the D values of the simulated ultrafiltrate (dispersant 3) dilution system are... [4,3] The agreement between particle size values and imaging results is conditional. Good consistency is observed in yogurt samples heat-treated below 65℃ / 25s, while in yogurt samples heat-treated above 65℃ / 25s, due to the larger aggregate size of the microgel particles, some size loss occurs after dispersion in the simulated ultrafiltration solution, resulting in a significant deviation from the actual imaging results. Considering all factors, the whey (dispersant 1) dilution system can more accurately reproduce the particle size results of the yogurt system and can be used as a technical means for yogurt particle size identification.
[0106] Example 2: Evaluation of Particle Texture
[0107] (1) Traditional sensory analysis methods
[0108] (1.1) Sensory members: The evaluation was conducted by 58 semi-trained professional sensory members (32 women, 26 men, mean age: 35 years), who had been engaged in dairy product development for more than 3 years and were familiar with the descriptive evaluation of the sensory and textural characteristics of dairy products.
[0109] (1.2) Sample preparation
[0110] The NT group, 55℃25s group, 65℃25s group, 75℃25s group and 85℃25s group obtained in step (1.2) of Example 1.
[0111] (1.3) Testing process
[0112] After being removed from the container at 4°C, the samples were randomly arranged. Approximately 60g of each sample was placed in a 100mL odorless transparent plastic cup, coded with a 3-digit random number, and equilibrated at room temperature for 30 minutes. Sensory evaluation was required to be completed within two days, with 58 semi-trained sensory members (i.e., the sensory members defined in (1.1) above) evaluating the particle texture of five randomly selected samples each morning and afternoon. Sensory analysis was conducted in a separate compartment of the sensory laboratory at the Mengniu Dairy Group's ambient temperature dairy product R&D center. The evaluation was determined using the generalized marked magnitude (gLM), with scores of 0–3 defined as "weak" particle intensity, 3–6 as "medium" particle intensity, and 6–9 as "strong" particle intensity. The evaluation results are as follows: Figure 4 As shown in the figure, the increase in particle size caused by post-heat treatment not only affects the microstructure of yogurt but also its sensory characteristics, especially its grainy texture. Figure 4 As shown, different post-heat treatment temperatures resulted in different graininess in the yogurt samples. According to the intensity rating defined by gLM, the NT group and the 55℃ / 25s group were classified as "weak", the 65℃ / 25s group was classified as "medium", and the 75℃ / 25s group and the 85℃ / 25s group were classified as "strong".
[0113] Microscopic image analysis revealed that the microgel areas of each group below 55℃ / 25s were mainly distributed within 2000μm. 2 Below, the microgel areas of the groups at 75℃ / 25s and above were mainly distributed in the range of 2000–3000 μm. 2 Between or 3000μm 2 In general, larger and harder microgels tend to have a higher perceived granular intensity, likely because larger shear-resistant particles are more prone to granular defects when pressed against the palate with the tongue. However, there were no significant differences in sensory scores between the NT group and the 55℃ / 25s group, or between the 75℃ / 25s group and the 85℃ / 25s group (p>0.05). These findings are inconsistent with the significant differences in microgel size (p≤0.05) observed from laser diffraction (Table 1) and image analysis (Table 4). This inconsistency between sensory perception and instrumental analysis in particle size assessment is thought to be related to individual differences in oral tactile sensitivity.
[0114] Therefore, in order to identify and cluster sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities, selecting highly sensitive sensory members is of certain significance for improving the accuracy of the oral sensitivity test for granularity.
[0115] (2) Identify and cluster sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities.
[0116] (2.1) The present invention performs power-law fitting on the evaluation results, specifically:
[0117] The particle size score for each sensory member was correlated with the volume-weighted average diameter D of the corresponding post-heat-treated yogurt sample. [4,3] Perform a power-law fit, and the fitted relationship follows Y = mX n +k power-law fitting model, where Y is the granularity score and X is D. [4,3] Value, n is the power-law fitting exponent, m and k are constants, R 2 The fitting accuracy of this power-law fitting model;
[0118] The following is a list of the fitted data for each sensory member:
[0119] Table 6
[0120]
[0121]
[0122]
[0123]
[0124] (2.2) The fitting parameters are arranged in ascending order, as shown in the table below:
[0125] Table 7
[0126]
[0127]
[0128]
[0129] (2.3) Summarize the n and R values for power-law fitting from Tables 6 and 7 above. 2 The description results are as follows:
[0130] Table 8
[0131] n <![CDATA[R 2 ]]> Minimum value 0.18 0.30 Maximum value 1.43 0.96 average value 0.88 0.73 100th percentile 0.71 0.69 Second percentile 0.81 0.76 Third percentile 1.07 0.85
[0132] The power-law fitting exponent n and the R-value derived from the power-law fitting model 2The power-law fit index n was selected as the sensitivity criterion and used to characterize the perceived particle size score as a function of the volume-weighted average diameter D. [4,3] Increased growth rate, R 2 This is used to characterize the fitting accuracy of the power-law fitting model. Furthermore, the criteria for dividing the high-sensitivity group are defined as the power-law fitting exponent n and R0. 2 It is also greater than the third percentile (Rc) of the clustering parameter distribution. 2 The 75% distribution of the coefficients and the power-law fit exponent n is equal to 0.85 and 1.07, respectively. The criterion for dividing the low-sensitivity group is defined as the power-law fit exponent n and R². 2 The coefficients are both less than the first percentile (R0) of the clustering parameter distribution. 2 The 25% of the distribution of the coefficients and the power-law fit exponent n are equal to 0.69 and 0.71, respectively. The dividing criterion for the moderately sensitive group is defined as the power-law fit exponent n and R². 2 The coefficient is greater than the first percentile and / or less than the third percentile of the clustering parameter distribution.
[0133] Ultimately, all sensory members were divided into high (N=9), low (N=11), and medium (N=38) sensitivity groups, and the representative fitting results for each sensitivity group are as follows: Figure 5 As shown in (A) to (C). Meanwhile, the average graininess score for each sensitivity group and D [4,3] The relationship between them is as follows Figure 6 As shown in (A) to (C). From the figure, we can see that:
[0134] Regarding the high-sensitivity group, such as Figure 6 (A), with D [4,3] The significant increase in parameters led to a significant increase in the particle size score of the sensory members (p≤0.05). This indicates that they have a discrimination ability similar to that of instrumental tests, and can distinguish samples as “weak” (approximately 14–20 μm, Table 2), “medium” (approximately 27 μm, Table 2), and “strong” (approximately 46–65 μm, Table 2).
[0135] Regarding the low-sensitivity group, such as Figure 6 (B) The particle perception scores were significantly different between the groups below 55℃ / 25s and above 55℃ / 25s (p≤0.05). The 75℃ / 25s group was classified as “strong”, while the other treatment groups were classified as “moderate”.
[0136] Regarding the moderately sensitive group, such as Figure 6 (C) The “weak,” “moderate,” and “strong” levels were also clearly distinguished similarly to the high-sensitivity group, but no significant differences were observed between the groups below 55°C / 25s (p>0.05) and the groups above 75°C / 25s (p>0.05).
[0137] Ultimately, regarding the overall impact of individual sensitivity on graininess, approximately 81% of sensory members categorized as "medium" and "high" sensitivity achieved broadly consistent results, namely, the volume-weighted average diameter D. [4,3] <20μm is usually classified as "weak", with a volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] >46μm is classified as "strong", with a volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] Those falling between the two are classified as "medium".
[0138] When the vast majority of sensory members have a similar ability to distinguish yogurt particles of different sizes, this does not affect the overall assessment result of the particle size rating.
[0139] Example 3: Method for reducing the grainy texture of post-heat-treated yogurt
[0140] As can be seen from the above embodiments, yogurt with a post-heat treatment temperature above 75℃ / 25s exhibits more pronounced particle characteristics compared to yogurt with a post-heat treatment temperature below 55℃ / 25s. Therefore, this invention further focuses on the volume-weighted average diameter D. [4,3] Research has shown that, using volume-weighted average diameter D... [4,3] As a key indicator, it can effectively guide how to reduce the grainy texture of post-heat-treated yogurt.
[0141] The specific experiment is as follows:
[0142] Mixing different volume ratios (1:9, 3:7, 5:5, 7:3, and 9:1) results in mixtures with different volume-weighted average diameters D. [4,3] The yogurt includes: the NT group, the 65℃ / 25s group, and the 85℃ / 25s group obtained in step (1.2) of Example 1, and the post-heat-treated yogurt obtained by mixing them, wherein the mixing test is as follows:
[0143] For the mixed test of the NT group and the 65℃ / 25s group, the mixing ratio and particle size parameters are shown in the table below. Among them, A1, A2, A3, A4 and A5 represent the volume ratios of the NT group and the 65℃ / 25s group as 1:9, 3:7, 5:5, 7:3 and 9:1, respectively.
[0144] Table 9
[0145] <![CDATA[D
[10] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[50] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[90] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D [4,3] (μm)]]> 65℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[9.78±0.01 a ]]> <![CDATA[21.09±0.06 a ]]> <![CDATA[53.00±1.09 b ]]> <![CDATA[27.20±0.36 a ]]> A1 <![CDATA[7.61±0.05 b ]]> <![CDATA[17.04±0.38 b ]]> <![CDATA[59.36±1.16 a ]]> <![CDATA[25.80±2.55 a ]]> A2 <![CDATA[7.64±0.04 b ]]> <![CDATA[17.42±0.16 b ]]> <![CDATA[59.78±1.36 a ]]> <![CDATA[26.14±0.45 a ]]> A3 <![CDATA[7.36±0.03 b ]]> <![CDATA[15.68±0.13 c ]]> <![CDATA[49.02±0.98 c ]]> <![CDATA[22.80±0.39 b ]]> A4 <![CDATA[7.40±0.03 b ]]> <![CDATA[15.34±0.11 c ]]> <![CDATA[43.14±1.28 d ]]> <![CDATA[20.80±0.37 c ]]> A5 <![CDATA[7.35±0.03 b ]]> <![CDATA[15.64±0.09 c ]]> <![CDATA[40.40±0.59 e ]]> <![CDATA[20.14±0.23 c ]]> NT group <![CDATA[7.70±0.10 b ]]> <![CDATA[13.70±0.36 c ]]> <![CDATA[22.98±1.07 f ]]> <![CDATA[14.55±0.39 d ]]>
[0146] Note: In Table 9, if the same letter is in the same column, the difference between groups is not significant (p>0.05), and if the same letter is not in the same column, the difference between groups is significant (p≤0.05).
[0147] Accordingly, the graininess of the post-heat-treated yogurt obtained from the mixed test of the NT group and the 65℃ / 25s group was evaluated using the method of Example 2. The results are shown in the table below:
[0148] Table 10
[0149]
[0150]
[0151]
[0152] For the mixing test of the NT group and the 85℃ / 25s group, the mixing ratio and particle size parameters are shown in the table below. Among them, B1, B2, B3, B4 and B5 represent the volume ratios of the NT group and the 85℃ / 25s group as 1:9, 3:7, 5:5, 7:3 and 9:1, respectively.
[0153] Table 11
[0154] <![CDATA[D
[10] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[50] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D
[90] (μm)]]> <![CDATA[D [4,3] (μm)]]> 85℃ / 25s group <![CDATA[17.40±0.38 a ]]> <![CDATA[60.63±1.54 a ]]> <![CDATA[123.17±3.13 a ]]> <![CDATA[65.98±1.67 a ]]> B1 <![CDATA[16.95±0.13 a ]]> <![CDATA[58.03±0.66 a ]]> <![CDATA[138.25±10.01 a ]]> <![CDATA[68.83±3.04 a ]]> B2 <![CDATA[14.33±0.10 b ]]> <![CDATA[49.83±0.51 b ]]> <![CDATA[116.00±1.83 b ]]> <![CDATA[58.28±0.73 b ]]> B3 <![CDATA[14.17±0.25 b ]]> <![CDATA[40.87±2.03 c ]]> <![CDATA[90.93±7.87 c ]]> <![CDATA[47.40±3.04 c ]]> B4 <![CDATA[10.60±0.35 c ]]> <![CDATA[25.24±0.46 d ]]> <![CDATA[66.98±1.89 d ]]> <![CDATA[32.78±0.37 d ]]> B5 <![CDATA[8.19±1.48 d ]]> <![CDATA[17.93±4.04 e ]]> <![CDATA[50.87±2.67 e ]]> <![CDATA[24.53±2.78 e ]]> NT group <![CDATA[7.70±0.10 d ]]> <![CDATA[13.70±0.36 f ]]> <![CDATA[22.98±1.07 f ]]> <![CDATA[14.55±0.39 f ]]>
[0155] Note: In Table 11, if the same letter is in the same column, the difference between groups is not significant (p>0.05), and if the same letter is not in the same column, the difference between groups is significant (p≤0.05).
[0156] Accordingly, the graininess of the post-heat-treated yogurt obtained from the mixed test of the NT group and the 85℃ / 25s group was evaluated using the method of Example 2. The results are shown in the table below:
[0157] Table 12
[0158]
[0159]
[0160]
[0161] The mixing ratios and particle size parameters of the 65℃ / 25s and 85℃ / 25s groups are shown in the table below. C1, C2, C3, C4, and C5 represent the volume ratios of the 65℃ / 25s and 85℃ / 25s groups as 1:9, 3:7, 5:5, 7:3, and 9:1, respectively.
[0162] Table 13
[0163]
[0164]
[0165] Note: In Table 13, if the same letter is in the same column, the difference between groups is not significant (p>0.05), and if the same letter is not in the same column, the difference between groups is significant (p≤0.05).
[0166] Accordingly, the graininess of the post-heat-treated yogurt obtained from the mixed test of the 65℃ / 25s group and the 85℃ / 25s group was evaluated using the method of Example 2. The results are shown in the table below:
[0167] Table 14
[0168]
[0169]
[0170]
[0171] As can be seen from the table above, the volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] When yogurt with a diameter ≤46μm is mixed with yogurt obtained by post-heat sterilization, or when the volume-weighted average diameter D is calculated... [4,3] Post-heat-treated yogurt with a diameter ≤46μm was mixed with another volume-weighted average diameter D. [4,3] In post-heat-treated yogurt with a diameter >46 μm, the volume-weighted average diameter D was reduced to varying degrees. [4,3] The volume-weighted average diameter D of post-heat-treated yogurt with a diameter ≤46μm [4,3] This is followed by a decrease in the perceived graininess.
[0172] Specifically:
[0173] In the mixing experiment of the NT group and the 65℃ / 25s group, as the volume percentage (vol%) of the NT group exceeded 30%, the D of the yogurt mixed at volume ratios of A3, A4, and A5... [4,3] The values were significantly lower (p≤0.05) than those in the 65℃ / 25s group, as shown in Table 8. Meanwhile, as... Figure 7 As shown in (A), the graininess assessment also revealed that the corresponding score decreased from "moderate" to "weak".
[0174] In the mixing experiment of the NT group and the 85℃ / 25s group, as the volume percentage (vol%) of the NT group exceeded 10%, the D of the yogurt mixed with the B2, B3, B4 and B5 volume ratios increased. [4,3] The values were significantly lower (p≤0.05) than the 85℃ / 25s group, as shown in Table 11. However, as... Figure 7As shown in (B), in the particle texture evaluation, the particle texture scores of the mixed yogurt with a volume percentage of 30% (B2) and 50% (B3) in the NT group were still classified as "strong". As the vol% of the NT group further increased to 70% (B4) and 90% (B5), the particle texture scores of the mixed yogurt decreased from "strong" to "moderate" (B4) and "weak" (B5).
[0175] In the mixing experiments of the 65℃ / 25s and 85℃ / 25s groups, as the vol% of the 65℃ / 25s group exceeded 10%, the D of the mixed yogurt at the volume ratios of C2, C3, C4, and C5 increased. [4,3] The values were significantly lower (p≤0.05) than those in the 85℃ / 25s group, as shown in Table 13. However, as... Figure 7 As shown in (C), in the particle texture evaluation, the particle texture scores of the mixed yogurt with a volume percentage of 30% (C2) and 50% (C3) in the 65℃ / 25s group were still classified as "strong". Further increasing the volume percentage in the 65℃ / 25s group to 70% (C4) and 90% (C5) reduced the particle texture score of the mixed yogurt from "strong" to "moderate".
[0176] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention, and not to limit them; although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the foregoing embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that modifications can still be made to the technical solutions described in the foregoing embodiments, or equivalent substitutions can be made to some of the technical features; and these modifications or substitutions do not cause the essence of the corresponding technical solutions to deviate from the spirit and scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention.
Claims
1. Volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] Application in post-heat-treated yogurt; characterized in that include: The volume-weighted average diameter D [4,3] Oral sensitivity test for the grainy texture of post-heat-treated yogurt; Identify sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities; The identification includes: The volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample [4,3] Within the range of 14–65 μm, the particle texture score was determined as a function of the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample. [4,3] Sensory members with increasing values; Following Y=mX n The +k power-law fitting model correlates the particle size score for each sensory member with the volume-weighted average diameter D of the post-heat-treated yogurt sample. [4,3] A power-law fit is performed; where Y is the sensory member's particle perception score, and X is the volume-weighted average diameter D. [4,3] Value, n is the power-law fitting exponent, m and k are constants, R 2 The fitting accuracy of the power-law fitting model; The power-law fitting exponent n and the fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting model are given by... 2 To determine the sensitivity of each sensory member.
2. The application according to claim 1, characterized in that, The oral sensitivity test for granular texture includes: Identify all sensory members; The particle sense score is evaluated by all the sensory members. The particle sense score is described according to the intensity level corresponding to the generalized label level: 0~3 points is defined as weak level, 3~6 points is defined as medium level, and 6~9 points is defined as strong level. Identify sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities.
3. The application according to claim 2, characterized in that, include: Sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities were divided into three groups according to their sensitivity level: high sensitivity group, low sensitivity group, and medium sensitivity group.
4. The application according to claim 3, characterized in that, include: The fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting exponent n and the power-law fitting model 2 After sorting, determine one or more of the sensory members from the high-sensitivity group, the low-sensitivity group, and the medium-sensitivity group.
5. The application according to claim 4, characterized in that, The determination of the sensitivity of each sensory member includes: The fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting exponent n and the power-law fitting model 2 Sort the data in ascending order and determine the first, second, and third percentiles of all clustering parameters; The identification of each sensory member is performed using the first percentile, the second percentile, and the third percentile to determine the sensory members in the high-sensitivity group, the low-sensitivity group, and the medium-sensitivity group.
6. The application according to claim 5, characterized in that, The power-law fitting exponent n and the fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting model 2 When all values are greater than the third percentile, the sensory member is a sensory member of the high-sensitivity group; The power-law fitting exponent n and the fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting model 2 At the same time, when it is less than the first percentile, the sensory member is a sensory member of the low sensitivity group; The power-law fitting exponent n and the fitting accuracy R of the power-law fitting model 2 When the sensory member is greater than the first percentile and / or less than the third percentile, the sensory member is a sensory member of the medium sensitivity group.
7. The application according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that, The oral sensitivity test is used in the particle sensory evaluation test.
8. The application according to claim 7, characterized in that, The total number of sensory members with different oral tactile sensitivities is more than 50.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Method for physico-chemically and structurally evaluating food texture of yogurt
JP2022187490A
