Non-nominal troposphere delay integrity monitoring method based on double-frequency GBAS
By using carrier phase difference processing and adaptive moving smoothing windows in GBAS, ionosphere-independent detection statistics are constructed, and high sensitivity monitoring of tropospheric delay is achieved, and real-time non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring in the existing technology is solved. The problem of insufficient sensitivity improves the accuracy and integrity of navigation services.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410879076.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-02
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
Existing non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring methods are difficult to provide real-time monitoring services for GBAS navigation positioning, and the conservative expansion strategy of tropospheric delay estimation method limits monitoring sensitivity.
Based on dual-frequency GBAS signal, geometrically independent-deionized ionospheric combined observation measurement is constructed through carrier phase difference processing, and wide lane ambiguity is fixed using adaptive moving smooth window and Rounding estimator to construct ionospheric independent detection statistics to achieve false alarms Dual control of missed detection, promptly alerting non-nominal troposphere delay.
The sensitivity of non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring and navigation and positioning service accuracy are improved, and the problems of insufficient real-time performance of external auxiliary methods and low monitoring sensitivity of tropospheric delay estimation methods are solved.
Smart Images

Figure CN118915091A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of global satellite navigation system integrity monitoring, and in particular to a non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring method based on dual-frequency GBAS, which realizes in-flight monitoring of non-nominal tropospheric delay, ensures that aviation users are not affected by non-nominal tropospheric delay, and improves the integrity and availability of navigation services of a ground-based augmentation system. Background Art
[0002] The Ground Based Augmentation System (GBAS) is a new generation of civil aviation navigation system used to replace the traditional instrument landing system. The GBAS master control station broadcasts the pseudo-range differential correction and integrity information of the global navigation satellite system to aviation users within the range of action, providing aircraft precision approach and landing services. With the development of GNSS, the International Civil Aviation Organization recommends the use of dual-frequency GBAS to provide precision approach and landing guidance services. Compared with single-frequency GBAS, dual-frequency GBAS has higher observation information redundancy, can provide higher-precision navigation and positioning services and higher-level GBAS integrity monitoring performance, which is of great significance for GBAS to support CAT II / III level services. Among the many risk sources that affect the reliability of precision approach, non-nominal tropospheric delay is an important risk source that needs to be monitored during the approach and landing phase.
[0003] When the Global Navigation Satellite Systems (GNSS) signal passes through the troposphere, it will be affected by the refraction of gaseous matter and water vapor in the troposphere, causing a 2.3m tropospheric delay in the zenith ranging observation. Tropospheric delay can be divided into vertical and horizontal components. Among them, the vertical component is determined by the height difference between the user and the reference receiver and the tropospheric refractive index, and can usually be corrected using a standard model. In short baseline applications, the residual of the horizontal component after differential correction can also be regarded as observation noise and ignored. It can be seen that the tropospheric delay under nominal meteorological conditions is corrected in two steps by empirical models and differential techniques, which will not threaten the accuracy and integrity of differential positioning. However, with the development of GNSS meteorology, a large number of decorrelation phenomena of the horizontal component of tropospheric delay, namely non-nominal tropospheric delays, have been discovered. Specifically, when local meteorological parameters (such as temperature, air pressure and relative humidity) change rapidly, neither the tropospheric empirical model nor the differential technique can effectively correct the horizontal component of the tropospheric delay, resulting in intolerable non-nominal tropospheric delay in the observed value[1][2].
[0004] At present, the non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring methods are mainly divided into three categories:
[0005] The first type is the external assistance method. This type of method is usually based on obtaining atmospheric data such as temperature, pressure, and relative humidity from a local atmospheric monitoring network, and then uses tropospheric inversion technology to achieve non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring [3]. Its advantage is that it can directly monitor the non-differential tropospheric delay and the inversion accuracy is similar to that of the tropospheric delay measured by GNSS. However, the external assistance method is only applicable to post-processing and analysis in the field of model construction and surveying and mapping, and it is difficult to provide on-board monitoring results for navigation and positioning.
[0006] The second type is the tropospheric delay estimation method. In order to evaluate the impact of non-nominal tropospheric delay on the integrity of navigation positioning, a direct method is to broadcast the non-nominal tropospheric delay bias estimation parameters to the user end to build the positioning error boundary in real time, and then evaluate the integrity and availability of the navigation service by comparing the error boundary with the required warning limit [4]. However, this method requires defining a new bias parameter in the differential correction of each satellite, which not only changes the existing aeronautical radio space signal interface file but also increases the burden of the very high frequency data broadcast bandwidth. To this end, the bias parameter can be Gaussianized and expanded, and the original non-nominal distribution can be replaced by the expanded unbiased Gaussian distribution. However, the bias model constructed based on a limited data set is difficult to accurately reflect extreme weather conditions, and a conservative Gaussian expansion strategy is usually required to ensure the integrity of navigation positioning, resulting in this method being only applicable to monitoring large-scale non-nominal tropospheric delays.
[0007] In summary, the main problems of the existing non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring methods are concentrated in two aspects: 1. The external auxiliary method is only applicable to post-processing and analysis in the field of model construction and surveying and mapping, and it is difficult to provide non-nominal tropospheric delay in-flight monitoring services for GBAS navigation and positioning; 2. The overly conservative expansion strategy of the tropospheric delay estimation method greatly restricts the sensitivity of non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring without changing the space signal interface file.
[0008] [1]Huang J,FV Graas(2007)Comparison of Tropospheric DecorrelationErrors in the Presence of Severe Weather Conditions in Different Areas andOver Different Baseline Lengths.Navigation 54.3(2007):207–226;
[0009] [2]Van Graas, F., Zhu, Z., Tropospheric Delay Threats for the GroundBased Augmentation System, Proceedings of the 2011International Technical Meeting of The Institute of Navigation, San Diego, CA, January 2011, pp.959-964;
[0010] [3]Chen Q,Song S,Heise S,Liou Y,Zhu W,Zhao J(2011)Assessment of ZTDderived from ECMWF / NCEP data with GPS ZTD over China,GPS Solut 15:415-425(2011);
[0011] [4] Zhang Y, Wang Z (2018) The Impact of Tropospheric Anomalies on Sea-Based JPALS Integrity, Sensors, 2018; 18(8): 2579. https: / / doi.org / 10.3390 / s18082579. Summary of the invention
[0012] The purpose of the present invention is to fully exploit the advantages of the dual-frequency GBAS signal system and propose a non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring method based on carrier phase differential processing based on the dual-frequency GBAS signal system.
[0013] In order to achieve the above-mentioned object of the invention, the technical solution of the present invention is to provide a non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring method based on dual-frequency GBAS, comprising the following steps:
[0014] According to the dual-frequency pseudo-range wide-lane combined observations and the carrier phase wide-lane combined observations, the geometrically independent-ionospheric elimination combined observations are constructed; the carrier phase wide-lane combined observations include the L1 frequency point carrier phase observations and the L2 frequency point carrier phase observations;
[0015] Adaptive moving smoothing window is used to filter and reduce noise of geometrically independent and ionospheric-free combined observations and wide lane ambiguity is fixed based on Rounding estimator.
[0016] The L1 frequency carrier phase observation is subtracted from the carrier phase wide-lane combined observation to eliminate the geometric error term, and the fixed wide-lane ambiguity is substituted to solve the L1 frequency ambiguity and the L2 frequency ambiguity.
[0017] Based on the original dual-frequency carrier phase observations, an ionosphere-independent detection statistic is constructed.
[0018] According to the statistical distribution characteristics of the detection statistics when there is or is not ambiguity resolution failure and when there is or is not non-nominal tropospheric delay, false alarm error constraints are constructed, and the false alarm probability requirements are obtained using Markov model conversion. The smoothing window width and the required false alarm probability requirements are traversed to generate an offline detection threshold distribution table. By comparing the ionosphere-independent detection statistics and the detection threshold, the false alarm errors of non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring are constrained.
[0019] When the ionosphere-independent detection statistic is within the detection threshold, the missed detection error is evaluated, the calculated missed detection rate is compared with the required missed detection rate, the missed detection error is constrained, and then the presence of non-nominal tropospheric delay is verified;
[0020] If both false alarm and missed detection dual control are satisfied, the non-nominal tropospheric delay is considered normal, otherwise, an alarm is given in time.
[0021] Preferably, the construction formula of the geometrically independent-ionospheric-eliminating combined observation is as follows:
[0022]
[0023] In the formula, R GIF is the geometrically independent-ionospheric elimination combined residual, Δ▽ is the inter-satellite-inter-station double difference operator, f is the observation frequency point, f1 is the observation frequency point of the L1 frequency point, f2 is the observation frequency point of the L2 frequency point, φ is the carrier phase, P is the pseudorange observation, φ1 is the carrier phase of the L1 frequency point, φ2 is the carrier phase of the L2 frequency point, P1 is the pseudorange observation at the L1 frequency point, and P2 is the carrier phase of the L2 frequency point.
[0024] Preferably, the formula for fixing the wide lane ambiguity of the Rounding estimator is as follows:
[0025]
[0026] Where N WL represents the wide lane ambiguity, c represents the speed of light, [·] represents the Rounding estimator, λ WL represents the widelane ambiguity wavelength.
[0027] Preferably, the formula for solving the L1 frequency point ambiguity and the L2 frequency point ambiguity is as follows:
[0028]
[0029] Δ▽N2=Δ▽N1-Δ▽N WL
[0030] Where N1 and N2 represent the L1 frequency ambiguity and L2 frequency ambiguity, λ1 and λ2 represent the L1 frequency wavelength and L2 frequency wavelength, respectively.
[0031] Preferably, the ionosphere-independent detection statistic obeys a mixed Gaussian distribution.
[0032] Preferably, the construction of the ionosphere-independent detection statistic t tro The formula is as follows:
[0033]
[0034] r f =Δ▽φ f -(▽e) T b-λ f Δ▽N f =Δ▽T-α f Δ▽I+ε Δ▽φ
[0035] Where T represents the tropospheric delay, e represents the unit line of sight vector, b represents the baseline vector, I represents the ionospheric delay, ε represents Gaussian noise, and r f Represents the double-difference carrier phase observation residual.
[0036] Preferably, the formula of the false alarm error constraint is as follows:
[0037] P fa ≤P{|t tro |>T h |H0,CF}P{CF}+(1-P CF )
[0038] Where P fa Indicates the false alarm rate requirement, T h It indicates the detection threshold, CF indicates that the ambiguity resolution is correct, and H0 indicates that the tropospheric activity is normal.
[0039] Preferably, the calculation of the missed detection rate P md And the formula for the required missed detection rate is as follows:
[0040]
[0041] In the formula, H1 represents the abnormal tropospheric activity, IF i Represents different ambiguity resolution failure modes.
[0042] Preferably, when the satellite detection statistic exceeds the detection threshold, the non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring promptly issues an alarm.
[0043] The technical solution of the present invention proposes a non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring method based on dual-frequency GBAS. When the integer ambiguity is successfully fixed, thanks to the high sensitivity and high precision of the dual-frequency carrier phase observations, short-baseline carrier phase difference technology is used to carry out monitoring, so that small-scale non-nominal tropospheric delays can be detected in the airborne sensing, thereby improving the accuracy and integrity of GBAS navigation and positioning services. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0044] Figure 1 A flow chart of a non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring method based on dual-frequency GBAS provided in an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0045] The present invention will be further described below in conjunction with specific embodiments. It should be understood that these embodiments are only used to illustrate the present invention and are not intended to limit the scope of the present invention. In addition, it should be understood that after reading the content taught by the present invention, those skilled in the art can make various changes or modifications to the present invention, and these equivalent forms fall within the scope limited by the appended claims of the application equally.
[0046] like Figure 1 As shown, an embodiment of the present invention provides a non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring method based on dual-frequency GBAS, which uses a combination of GBAS dual-frequency carrier phase observations to construct an ionosphere-independent detection statistic to achieve high-sensitivity in-flight integrity monitoring of the non-nominal troposphere, including the following steps:
[0047] Step 1: Construct the geometry-independent-ionospheric-eliminating combined observation Δ▽R based on the dual-frequency pseudorange wide-lane combined observation and the carrier phase wide-lane combined observation GIF .
[0048] The carrier phase wide lane combined observation and the dual frequency pseudorange wide lane combined observation are subtracted to eliminate the geometric information and ionospheric delay information, and the geometrically independent-ionospheric-eliminating combined observation Δ▽R is obtained. GIF , as shown in formula (1).
[0049] To ensure the simplicity of the formula, the satellite and receiver subscripts are ignored in the subsequent implementation examples.
[0050]
[0051] In the formula, R GIFrepresents the geometry-independent-ionospheric-eliminating combined residual, Δ▽ represents the inter-satellite-inter-station double difference operator, the subscript f represents the observation frequency point, f1 represents the observation frequency point of the L1 frequency point, f2 represents the observation frequency point of the L2 frequency point, φ and P represent the carrier phase and pseudorange observations, respectively.
[0052] Step 2: Use an adaptive moving smoothing window to calculate the geometry-independent-ionospheric combined observation Δ▽R GIF Filtering is performed to reduce noise and fix wide-lane ambiguity based on the Rounding estimator.
[0053] Ambiguity fixation is the premise for constructing detection statistics. In order to further improve the success rate of ambiguity resolution, a moving smoothing window is used to suppress the combined observation noise and improve the carrier-to-noise ratio. At the same time, considering the advantage of the Rounding estimator in having an accurate probability density distribution function, the Rounding estimator can be used to fix the wide lane ambiguity as shown in formula (2):
[0054]
[0055] Where N WL represents the wide lane ambiguity, c represents the speed of light, [·] represents the Rounding estimator, λ WL represents the widelane ambiguity wavelength.
[0056] Step 3: Use the L1 frequency carrier phase observation and the carrier phase wide-lane combined observation to perform a difference to eliminate the geometric error term, and then fix the wide-lane ambiguity N WL Substitute in fixed L1 and L2 frequency ambiguities.
[0057] The L1 phase observation is used to make a difference with the wide-lane phase observation to eliminate the geometric error term, and the fixed wide-lane ambiguity is substituted into the solution of the L1 and L2 frequency point ambiguities as shown in equation (3):
[0058]
[0059] Where N1 and N2 represent the L1 frequency ambiguity and L2 frequency ambiguity respectively.
[0060] Step 4: Construct an ionosphere-independent detection statistic that obeys a mixed Gaussian distribution based on the original dual-frequency carrier phase observations.
[0061] In order to realize the decorrelation of the first-order ionospheric delay and the tropospheric delay and avoid the interference of ionospheric health fluctuations in the non-nominal tropospheric monitoring false alarm error control, the embodiment of the present invention eliminates the first-order ionospheric delay based on the inter-frequency combination of phase observations to realize the decorrelation monitoring of non-nominal tropospheric delay. Then, the ionospheric independent detection statistic t tro It can be expressed as:
[0062]
[0063] Where T represents the tropospheric delay, e represents the unit line of sight vector, b represents the baseline vector, I represents the ionospheric delay, ε represents Gaussian noise, and r f represents the residual of the double-difference carrier phase observation. Due to different ambiguity resolution failure modes, the detection statistic t tro It will obey the zero-mean mixed Gaussian distribution. From formula (4), we can see that although the ionosphere-independent detection statistic suppresses the first-order ionosphere delay risk source, its detection statistic noise is expanded by about 3 times, that is, the decorrelation monitoring capability is exchanged for the loss of part of the accuracy. However, thanks to the high-precision characteristics of the carrier phase observation, the detection statistic t tro Still sensitive to small-scale non-nominal tropospheric delays.
[0064] Step 5: Select the mixed Gaussian distribution detection threshold according to the false alarm rate required for non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring to constrain the false alarm error.
[0065] Although a series of measures such as adaptive moving smoothing window and rounding estimator are used to ensure the success rate of ambiguity fixation, the ambiguity fixation result is still random. The wrong ambiguity fixation value will cause the detection statistic to deviate, affecting the integrity of non-nominal tropospheric monitoring. Based on the error propagation law between models, according to the statistical distribution characteristics of the detection statistic when there is or is no ambiguity resolution failure and when there is or is no non-nominal tropospheric delay, the false alarm error constraint of the monitoring algorithm under the mixed Gaussian distribution is constructed, as shown in formula (5):
[0066] P fa ≤P{t tro |>T h |H0,CF}P{CF}+(1-P CF ) (5)
[0067] Where P fa Indicates the false alarm rate requirement, T h Represents the detection threshold, CF indicates that the ambiguity resolution is correct, and H0 indicates that the tropospheric activity is normal. The false alarm probability requirement is obtained by using the Markov model conversion, and the smoothing window width and the required false alarm probability requirement are traversed to generate an offline detection threshold distribution table. During online use, the detection threshold T is adaptively selected according to the moving smoothing window. h By comparing the test statistic t tro and detection threshold T h , the false alarm errors of non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring can be constrained. When the detection statistics of a pair of satellites exceed the detection threshold, the non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring should give an alarm in time.
[0068] Step 6: Determine the required missed detection rate based on the non-nominal tropospheric delay prior failure probability, compare the calculated missed detection rate under the mixed Gaussian distribution assumption with the required missed detection rate, and constrain the missed detection error.
[0069] When the detection statistic t tro At the detection threshold T h When the protection level is within the range, the missed detection error needs to be evaluated to avoid the loss of availability of the proposed non-nominal tropospheric monitoring algorithm. The missed detection probability under the mixed Gaussian distribution can be calculated based on the worst-case protection principle, as shown in formula (6):
[0070]
[0071] Compare the calculated missed detection rate P obtained by formula (6) md The missed detection error can be controlled with the required missed detection rate, and then the presence of non-nominal tropospheric delay can be verified, where H1 indicates abnormal tropospheric activity, IF i Represents different ambiguity resolution failure modes.
[0072] Step 7: If both false alarm and missed detection dual control are satisfied, the non-nominal tropospheric delay is considered normal, otherwise, an alarm is given in time.
[0073] Of course, the present invention may have many other embodiments. Without departing from the spirit and essence of the present invention, technicians familiar with the field may make various corresponding adjustments based on the present invention, but these corresponding adjustments should all fall within the scope of protection of the claims attached to the present invention.
[0074] The beneficial effects of the embodiments of the present invention are:
[0075] Non-nominal tropospheric delay is a key risk source that needs to be considered in GBAS space signal quality monitoring. The embodiment of the present invention performs on-board non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring on an epoch-by-epoch basis based on real-time carrier phase observations, thereby solving the problem of insufficient real-time monitoring of the external auxiliary method. An ionosphere-independent non-nominal tropospheric delay detection statistic is constructed based on high-precision carrier phase observations, thereby improving the sensitivity of non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring and solving the problem of low monitoring sensitivity of the tropospheric delay estimation method.
Claims
1. A non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring method based on dual-frequency GBAS, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: According to the dual-frequency pseudo-range wide-lane combined observations and the carrier phase wide-lane combined observations, the geometrically independent-ionospheric elimination combined observations are constructed; the carrier phase wide-lane combined observations include the L1 frequency point carrier phase observations and the L2 frequency point carrier phase observations; Adaptive moving smoothing window is used to filter and reduce noise of geometrically independent and ionospheric-free combined observations and wide lane ambiguity is fixed based on Rounding estimator. The L1 frequency carrier phase observation is subtracted from the carrier phase wide-lane combined observation to eliminate the geometric error term, and the fixed wide-lane ambiguity is substituted to solve the L1 frequency ambiguity and the L2 frequency ambiguity. Based on the original dual-frequency carrier phase observations, an ionosphere-independent detection statistic is constructed. According to the statistical distribution characteristics of the detection statistics when there is or is not ambiguity resolution failure and when there is or is not non-nominal tropospheric delay, false alarm error constraints are constructed, and the false alarm probability requirements are obtained using Markov model conversion. The smoothing window width and the required false alarm probability requirements are traversed to generate an offline detection threshold distribution table. By comparing the ionosphere-independent detection statistics and the detection threshold, the false alarm errors of non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring are constrained. When the ionosphere-independent detection statistic is within the detection threshold, the missed detection error is evaluated, the calculated missed detection rate is compared with the required missed detection rate, the missed detection error is constrained, and then the presence of non-nominal tropospheric delay is verified; If both false alarm and missed detection dual control are satisfied, the non-nominal tropospheric delay is considered normal, otherwise, an alarm is given in time.
2. The method for monitoring non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity based on dual-frequency GBAS according to claim 1, characterized in that: The construction formula of the geometrically independent-ionospheric combined observation is as follows: In the formula, R GIF is the geometrically independent-ionospheric elimination combined residual, Δ▽ is the inter-satellite-inter-station double difference operator, f is the observation frequency point, f1 is the observation frequency point of the L1 frequency point, f2 is the observation frequency point of the L2 frequency point, φ is the carrier phase, P is the pseudorange observation, φ1 is the carrier phase of the L1 frequency point, φ2 is the carrier phase of the L2 frequency point, P1 is the pseudorange observation at the L1 frequency point, and P2 is the carrier phase of the L2 frequency point.
3. The non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity monitoring method based on dual-frequency GBAS according to claim 1, characterized in that: The formula for fixing the wide lane ambiguity by the Rounding estimator is as follows: Where N WL represents the wide lane ambiguity, c represents the speed of light, [·] represents the Rounding estimator, λ WL represents the widelane ambiguity wavelength.
4. The method for monitoring non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity based on dual-frequency GBAS according to claim 1, characterized in that: The formula for solving the L1 frequency ambiguity and the L2 frequency ambiguity is as follows: Where N1 and N2 represent the L1 frequency ambiguity and L2 frequency ambiguity, λ1 and λ2 represent the L1 frequency wavelength and L2 frequency wavelength, respectively.
5. The method for monitoring non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity based on dual-frequency GBAS according to claim 1, characterized in that: The ionosphere-independent detection statistic obeys a mixed Gaussian distribution.
6. The method for monitoring non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity based on dual-frequency GBAS according to claim 1, characterized in that: The construction of the ionosphere-independent detection statistic t tro The formula is as follows: Where T represents the tropospheric delay, e represents the unit line of sight vector, b represents the baseline vector, I represents the ionospheric delay, ε represents Gaussian noise, and r f Represents the double-difference carrier phase observation residual.
7. The method for monitoring non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity based on dual-frequency GBAS according to claim 1, characterized in that: The formula for the false alarm error constraint is as follows: P fa ≤P{t tro |>T h |H0,CF}P{CF}+(1-P CF ) Where P fa Indicates the false alarm rate requirement, T h It indicates the detection threshold, CF indicates that the ambiguity resolution is correct, and H0 indicates that the tropospheric activity is normal.
8. The method for monitoring non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity based on dual-frequency GBAS according to claim 1, characterized in that: The calculation of missed detection rate P md And the formula for the required missed detection rate is as follows: In the formula, H1 represents the abnormal tropospheric activity, IF i Represents different ambiguity resolution failure modes.
9. The method for monitoring non-nominal tropospheric delay integrity based on dual-frequency GBAS according to claim 1, characterized in that: When the satellite detection statistic exceeds the detection threshold, the non-nominal tropospheric delay monitoring promptly issues an alarm.
