Heel shield with stress concentration reduction geometry and enhanced durability for construction machines
By designing the internal angle and stress reduction geometry in the heel shield, the service life of heavy equipment bucket shields in high stress and abrasive environments is solved, achieving longer service life and reduced maintenance costs.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202380024296.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-03-09
- Filing Date
- 2023-03-02
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is difficult to effectively reduce the service life of the heel shield of heavy equipment buckets in high stress and abrasive environments, resulting in excessive early maintenance costs.
A heel guard consisting of bottom legs and side legs is designed to form an inner corner, and a wear indicator and stress reduction geometric structure such as curved inner surfaces and concave curved surfaces are provided at the inner corners to reduce stress concentrated.
By reducing stress concentration, the service life of the heel shield is extended and maintenance costs are reduced.
Smart Images

Figure CN118922603A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to heel guards for protecting work tools such as buckets of heavy equipment such as hydraulic mining shovels, etc. In particular, the present invention relates to such heel guards that can have stress concentration reducing geometry and / or durability enhancing features. Background Art
[0002] In various mining applications, the curved shell of a bucket or other work tool used in heavy equipment such as a hydraulic mining shovel may be subject to heavy loads and / or abrasive environments. As a result, a heel guard may be provided that is intended to extend the life of the bucket. However, the amount of material required to make such a heel guard may increase the cost and may need to act as a stress riser or the like. This may result in unnecessary maintenance of the heel guard or its work tool early in its useful life at a higher cost than desired.
[0003] U.S. Patent No. 10,562,257 B2 (the '257 patent) discloses a track slider for use on heavy equipment, such as a power rope shovel, etc. The slider includes an elongated base coupled to a frame and a sliding portion extending from the elongated base. The sliding portion includes an outer surface configured to slidably engage a track link of a track assembly. The sliding portion includes a set of wear indicators defined in the outer surface. The set of wear indicators includes a first wear indicator and a second wear indicator. The first and second wear indicators are located at a first predetermined thickness and a second predetermined thickness, respectively, measured along a central axis of the sliding portion. In addition, the first wear indicator indicates partial wear of the sliding portion and the second wear indicator indicates substantial wear of the sliding portion. However, the '257 patent does not mention a possible stress reducing geometry for a heel guard.
[0004] On the other hand, U.S. Patent No. 4,052,802A (the '802 patent) discloses a ground engaging tool with a plurality of wear inserts. According to the '802 patent, the wear inserts are secured between flanges, which can minimize the peeling of the inserts during use. However, the '802 patent does not describe how to increase the durability of a heel guard having a right-angle configuration to protect a curved shell of a bucket or the like.
[0005] Therefore, there remains a need for a heel guard that can have features for extending its useful life. Summary of the invention
[0006] According to an embodiment of the present invention, the heel guard may include a bottom leg and a side leg extending perpendicularly from the bottom leg, which forms an inner angle with the bottom leg. The heel guard may define a first side surface, a second side surface, and the bottom leg may include a curved inner surface extending from the first side surface to the second side surface, at least partially forming the inner angle. The first side surface may define a first wear indicator or stress reduction geometry disposed at the inner angle.
[0007] According to another embodiment of the present invention, the heel guard may include a bottom leg and a side leg extending perpendicularly from the bottom leg, which forms an inner angle with the bottom leg. The heel guard may define a first side surface, a second side surface, and the bottom leg may include a curved inner surface extending from the first side surface to the second side surface, at least partially forming the inner angle, and the first side surface defines a first wear indicator disposed at the inner angle.
[0008] According to yet another embodiment of the present invention, the heel guard may include a bottom leg and a side leg extending perpendicularly from the bottom leg, which forms an inner angle with the bottom leg. The heel guard may define a first side surface, a second side surface, and the bottom leg may include a curved inner surface extending from the first side surface to the second side surface, at least partially forming the inner angle. The first side surface may define a stress concentration reducing geometry including a concave arcuate surface at the inner angle. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0009] The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and constitute a part of this specification, illustrate several embodiments of the present invention and, together with the description, serve to explain the principles of the present invention. In the drawings:
[0010] Figure 1 A machine in the form of a hydraulic mining shovel is shown having a work implement in the form of a bucket with a heel shroud constructed in accordance with various embodiments disclosed herein.
[0011] Figure 2 It was removed from the machine to improve clarity. Figure 1 A perspective view of a bucket and its heel shroud.
[0012] Figure 3 is from Figure 2 A perspective view of a removed heel shroud on a bucket constructed in accordance with an embodiment of the present invention including stress reducing geometry in its interior corners.
[0013] Figure 4 yes Figure 3 Front view of the heel guard.
[0014] Figure 5 yes Figure 4 Side view of the heel guard.
[0015] Figure 6 is with Figure 3 A perspective view of another embodiment of a similar or identical heel guard, except with the addition of durability enhancements, such as laminated wear protection strips, etc.
[0016] Figure 7 yes Figure 6 Front view of the heel guard.
[0017] Figure 8 yes Figure 6 An enlarged detail of the heel shroud of the , more clearly showing its stress reducing geometry.
[0018] Fig. 9 yes Figure 6 A rear perspective view of the heel guard of FIG.
[0019] Fig.10 A rear perspective view of a heel guard configured with a wear indicator positioned near the interior of an inner corner of the heel guard is shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0020] Reference will now be made in detail to embodiments of the present invention, examples of which are shown in the accompanying drawings. Whenever possible, the same reference numerals are used throughout the drawings to refer to the same or similar parts. In some cases, the reference numerals will be indicated in this specification, and the drawings will show the reference numerals followed by letters, such as 100a, 100b, etc. It should be understood that the use of letters following the reference numerals indicates that these features have similar shapes and have similar functions, as is often the case when geometric shapes are mirrored about a plane of symmetry. For ease of explanation in this specification, letters are generally not included herein, but may be shown in the drawings to indicate repeated features discussed in this written specification.
[0021] Although the arrangement is illustrated in conjunction with a hydraulic mining shovel, the arrangement disclosed herein has general applicability in various other types of machines that typically employ track systems rather than wheels. The term "machine" may refer to any machine that performs some type of operation associated with an industry such as mining, earthmoving, or construction, or any other industry known in the art. For example, the machine may be an excavator, a wheel loader, a cable shovel, or a dragline, among others. In addition, one or more implements may be connected to the machine. These implements may be used for various tasks, including, for example, lifting and loading. Among other uses, a hydraulic mining shovel can be used to load overburden and ore into a haul truck during mining in various open pit mines.
[0022] See also Figure 1, a machine 100, such as a hydraulic mining shovel, can use a work implement 110, such as a bucket using heel guards 200, 300 constructed according to various embodiments of the present invention. The machine 100 can include a body 104 with a cab 106 to accommodate a machine operator. The machine can also include a boom system 108 pivotally connected to the body 104 at one end and supporting the implement 110 at an opposite distal end. In an embodiment, the implement 110 can be any suitable implement, such as a bucket, a clamshell, a blade, or any other type of suitable equipment. A control system can be housed in the cab 106, which can be adapted to allow the machine operator to steer and articulate the implement 110 for mining, excavation, or any other suitable application.
[0023] The body 104 may be supported on a main frame 112, which in turn is supported on an undercarriage structure 114. The undercarriage structure 114 includes a support structure 118 that supports a track system 102 for movement of the machine 100. The track system 102 may include first and second track roller frame assemblies 116 spaced apart from and adjacent respective first and second sides of the undercarriage structure 114. Figure 1 Only one of the track roller frame assemblies 116 is visible.
[0024] Each track roller frame assembly 116 carries an idler wheel 120, a drive sprocket 122, and a plurality of track guide rollers 124. The drive sprocket 122 is powered in both forward and reverse directions by the machine 100 (via a motor such as an internal combustion engine). An endless track chain assembly 126 surrounds each drive sprocket 122, idler wheel 120, and track guide roller 124. The track chain assembly 126 includes a plurality of interconnected track shoes 128. When the track chain assembly 126 is driven by the drive sprocket 122, the track guide roller 124 guides the track shoes 128.
[0025] See also Figure 2 , the bucket 110a may have a curved shell 130 to which one or more heel guards 200, 300 configured in accordance with various embodiments of the present invention may be attached via welding, fastening, etc. In addition, a plurality of tips 132, adapters 134, and guards 136 may be attached to a front lip 138 of the bucket.
[0026] See now Figures 3 to 5 and Figure 8 Various embodiments of heel guards 200 , 300 will now be discussed that may have one or more features for indicating wear and reducing stress or wear.
[0027] from Figures 3 to 5Initially, such a heel guard 200 may include a bottom leg 202 and a side leg 204 extending perpendicularly from the bottom leg 202. This may resemble an L-shaped body with an inner corner 206 formed by the intersection of the side leg 204 with the bottom leg 202. In addition, the heel guard 200 may define a first side surface 208, a second side surface 210, and the bottom leg may include a curved inner surface 212 intended to mate with a curved shell of a bucket or the like. The curved inner surface 212 (see also Fig. 9 ) may extend from the first side surface 208 to the second side surface 210 , at least partially forming the inner corner 206 .
[0028] like Figure 5 and Figure 8 As best seen in FIG. 2 , first side surface 208 may define first wear indicator 214 and / or stress reduction geometry 216 disposed at interior corner 206. In some embodiments, the same geometry may function as Figure 5 and Figure 8 Both functions are shown, but not necessarily so. In some embodiments, only a wear indicator or a stress reduction geometry may be provided.
[0029] We will now discuss in detail Figures 3 to 5 It should be noted that for any of the embodiments discussed herein, such as Figure 4 The side midplane shown may represent a symmetry plane 218 such that all or substantially all features of the heel guard 200 are symmetrical about the plane. Thus, the second side surface 210 is understood to also define a second wear indicator 214a (also referred to as the second side surface 210) that is symmetrical to the first wear indicator 214. Fig. 9 ). This may not be the case for other embodiments of the invention.
[0030] See also Figure 5 , the side leg 204 can define a flat inner surface 220 that at least partially forms or leads to the inner corner 206. The inner corner can be configured to provide an angle stop that is spaced a predetermined distance 223 from a theoretical sharp angle 222 defined by the intersection of the flat inner surface 220 of the side leg 204 and the curved inner surface 212 of the bottom leg 202.
[0031] The first wear indicator 214 defines a top beveled wall 224 (so called because it extends neither purely horizontally nor vertically), a bottom beveled wall 226 parallel to the top beveled wall 226 , and a gap distance 228 measured perpendicular to the top beveled wall 224 and the bottom beveled wall 226 .
[0032] See together Figure 5 and Fig. 9In some embodiments of the present invention, the first wear indicator 214 may define a lateral depth 230, and a ratio of the gap distance 228 to the lateral depth 230 may be in a range of 0.8 to 1.2.
[0033] exist Figure 5 , bottom leg 202 may define a bottom outer surface 232, a first minimum distance 234 measured from first wear indicator 214 to bottom outer surface 232, and side leg 204 may define a side outer surface 236 and a second minimum distance 238 measured from first wear indicator 214 to side outer surface 236. It should be appreciated that Figure 5 As shown, these dimensions are measured in (or projected onto) the first side plane 208. In some embodiments of the present invention, the ratio of the first minimum distance 234 to the second minimum distance 238 is in the range of 0.75 to 1.0, or vice versa.
[0034] Specifically, Figure 5 As shown, first wear indicator 214 may include a vertical surface 240 that at least partially defines second minimum distance 238 and a horizontal surface 242 (also referred to as a “horizontal surface”) that at least partially defines first minimum distance 234 .
[0035] See now Figure 8 , a stress concentration reducing geometry 216 is shown at an interior corner 306 including a concave arcuate surface 244. More specifically, the stress reducing geometry 216 includes a first recess 246 extending from the concave arcuate surface 244, the first recess 246 having a recess bottom surface 248 connected to the concave arcuate surface 244 by a plurality of convex arcuate surfaces 250 (see also Figure 5 ).
[0036] like Figure 5 As best seen in FIG. 2 , the concave arcuate surface 244 can define a radius of curvature ROC 244 that can range from 5.0 mm to 12.0 mm (e.g., approximately 8.0, 8.5, or 9.0 mm in some embodiments). As previously described, see Fig. 9 , a second recess 246a symmetrical to the first recess 246 (and thus another stress reduction geometry) may be provided.
[0037] Again, see Figure 5 and Figure 8 , the first recess 246 may include a first planar sidewall (e.g., top beveled wall 224) extending from the recess bottom surface 248 to the first side surface 208, and a second planar sidewall (e.g., bottom beveled wall 226) extending from the recess bottom surface 248 to the first side surface 208. These walls may be parallel, but need not be.
[0038] exist Figure 5 252, and in some embodiments of the present invention, the first recess 246 extends toward the outer corner 252. In addition, a concave curved surface 254 (as used herein, "curved" may be interpreted as an "arc" having a non-planar shape) may extend from the first planar sidewall (e.g., see the top beveled wall 224) to the second planar sidewall (e.g., see the bottom beveled wall 226). A plurality of concave arc blends 256 may extend from the recess bottom surface t248 toward the first planar sidewall, the second planar sidewall, and the concave curved surface 254. Similarly, a plurality of convex arc blends 258 may extend from the first planar sidewall, the second planar sidewall, and the concave curved surface 254 to the first side surface 208.
[0039] These various curved or cambered surfaces can help reduce stress concentrations, thereby helping to extend the useful life of the heel guard. As will be discussed later herein, the inventors have performed FEA (finite element analysis) that shows that this geometry will reduce stress concentrations in the heel guard in use.
[0040] Now we will see Figure 6 and Figure 7 Discussion of the heel guard 300 and / or the wear members 400, 500, 600 attached to the side leg 304 and / or the wear members 400, 500, 600 attached to the bottom leg 302 that may have some stress reduction geometry 216. The wear members may be characterized as "reinforced" so that the wear members wear slower or are more durable than cast heel guards that are typically made of iron, gray cast iron, etc. For example, any "wear member" described herein may be made of chrome white cast iron that is heat treated to ASTM 2 Class B, with a minimum hardness of Rockwell C, and has high wear resistance.
[0041] Geometrically, bottom leg 302 includes a curved inner surface 312 extending from first side surface 308 to second side surface 310, at least partially forming inner corner 306, and a flat bottom surface 314 defining a lower wear member receiving recess 316. Similarly, side leg 304 may define an outer flat surface 318 defining a side wear member receiving recess 320. As shown, lower wear member receiving recess 316 and side wear member receiving recess 320 are continuous, forming an L-shaped cavity 322. In other embodiments of the present invention, they may be separated by a rib or other structure.
[0042] See also Figure 7, the heel guard 300 defines a lateral width W300 measured from the first side surface 308 to the second side surface 310, and the L-shaped cavity 322 can define a lateral cavity width W322. In some embodiments of the present invention, the ratio of the lateral width of the heel guard to the lateral cavity width can be between 1.09 and 1.32. Therefore, the L-shaped cavity 322 can be bounded by a first side rib 360 and a second side rib 362 symmetrical to the first side rib 360 (about the side midplane, as explained earlier herein). These ribs can provide protection for the wear member and its mounting structure.
[0043] Additionally, side leg 304 may include a tapered portion 364 (i.e., tapering toward the inner surface of the side leg) that includes an outer top cavity 366 disposed vertically above side wear member receiving pocket 320 and separated from side wear member receiving pocket 320 by a laterally extending rib 368. Still another of these features may be omitted in other embodiments of the present disclosure.
[0044] Laterally extending wear member 400 may be disposed in side wear member receiving recess 320. As shown, wear member 400 may be in the form of a laminated wear guard strip 400a with four sections 402 separated by V-shaped cutouts 404 to increase the removal of the section to adjust the length of the laminated wear guard strip.
[0045] like Figure 6 As best seen in FIG. 3 , the mounting plate 370 is inserted between the side legs 304 and the laminated wear protection strip 400a. Figure 1 ) is used to attach the mounting plate and laminated wear protection strip to the side leg. Other forms of attachment structures, such as fastening, may be used in other embodiments of the present invention. Any "mounting plate" discussed herein may be made with a mild steel backing plate that can absorb impact forces for greater durability.
[0046] Additionally, a pair of laterally extending wear members 500 may be disposed in the lower wear member receiving recess 316. Similar mounting techniques are used, including providing a pair of mounting plates 374 that are inserted between the bottom leg 302 and the pair of laterally extending wear members 500. In this case, the pair of laterally extending wear members 500 are also laminated wear guard strips 500a with seven sections 502, etc. The hook 376 may be disposed laterally between the pair of laterally extending wear members 500. In other embodiments of the invention, the hook may be located in other locations, such as at the top of the side legs. Another wear member 600 is also employed in the form of a wear button 600a that is disposed laterally between the pair of laterally extending wear members 500. This may not be the case in other embodiments of the present disclosure.
[0047] See also Figure 6 and Figure 7 , another embodiment of heel guard 300 may be described as follows. Flat bottom surface 314 defines a lower wear member receiving recess 316, and side leg 304 defines a side wear member receiving recess 320 in communication with lower wear member receiving recess 316. A first wear member (e.g., see 500 or 600) may be disposed in lower wear member receiving recess 316, and a second wear member (e.g., see 400) may be disposed in side wear member receiving recess 320.
[0048] For example, the first wear member may be one of the laminated wear guard strip 500a or the wear button 600a, and the second wear member may be the other of the laminated wear guard strip 400a or the wear button. Figures 6 to 8 304. As shown, the first wear member is a laminated wear guard strip 500a and the second wear member is a wear button 600a. In this case, a pair of laminated wear guard strips are laterally disposed on either side of the wear button. This may not be the case in other embodiments of the invention. In addition, the hook 376 extends laterally from adjacent the wear button 600a toward the side leg 304.
[0049] The heel guard may be a unitary body as shown, or an assembly of different components including wear members, mounting plates, etc. Typically, the heel guard consists essentially of a metallic material such as cast iron, steel, grey cast iron, or the like.
[0050] Any of the foregoing features and their associated dimensions may be varied from that shown or mentioned in other embodiments of the invention.
[0051] Industrial Applicability
[0052] In fact, the work tool, bucket, heel and / or portions thereof may be sold, manufactured, purchased, etc. and attached to a machine in an aftermarket or original equipment situation in accordance with any of the embodiments discussed herein. That is, the machine may be sold with the work tool or bucket and / or heel guard and / or portions thereof in accordance with the embodiments described herein, or the machine may be modified, repaired, or refurbished to use any of the embodiments discussed herein. The various components, including but not limited to the heel guard, may be made of any suitable material, such as cast iron, gray cast iron, steel, etc.
[0053] The inventors have performed design iterations, placing wear indicator / stress reduction geometry at various locations on the heel shroud. For example, the wear indicator / stress reduction geometry (see, e.g., Fig.10 The cavity 702 of the heel guard 700 (providing a non-limiting example in FIG. 1 ) is placed toward the inner corner of the heel guard. Fig. 9As shown, the size, shape and placement of the cavity were changed eleven times and then placed on the outer side. Finite element analysis showed that when the cavity was placed on the side of the heel guard, the stress was reduced by 10%, while the internal stress only increased by 3%, but it was still far below the acceptable value. Therefore, those skilled in the art expect to improve the durability of the heel guard.
[0054] In various embodiments, the heel shroud is designed with external wear indicators on both the left and right sides. By placing the indicator features on the left and right sides of the external shroud geometry, the stress concentrations that would otherwise be created by the internal indicator features are eliminated (as shown in the virtual heat treatment analysis). This solution has wear indicators visible on both sides of the shroud, provides guidance on when to replace the shroud, and has indicators visible throughout the life of the shroud to estimate the remaining life.
[0055] In other embodiments, wear protection for laminated wear protection (LWP) welds on the heel shield is provided. Typically, the heel shield is designed with designated locations for attaching the LWP and a protective feature in the form of a rib surrounding the weld for attaching the layer LWP. The feature is designed to protrude above the height of the welds used in this application to protect them from wear materials and extend the life of the LWP. The feature can also serve as an indicator of critical locations to add LWP, which will maximize the life of the heel shield. This feature also allows the heel shield to be used without the LWP if desired. It is also capable of protecting different types of overlay welds, including wear resistant material (ARM) and plasma transferred arc (PTA) welding.
[0056] It will be apparent to those skilled in the art that various modifications and variations can be made to the embodiments of the apparatus and assembly methods discussed herein without departing from the scope or spirit of the invention. Other embodiments of the invention will be apparent to those skilled in the art in view of the specification and practice of the various embodiments disclosed herein. For example, the construction and function of some apparatuses may be different from those already described herein, and particular steps of any method may be omitted, performed in an order different from that specifically mentioned, or in some cases performed simultaneously or in sub-steps. In addition, changes or modifications may be made to particular aspects or features of the various embodiments to produce additional embodiments, and features and aspects of the various embodiments may be added to or substituted for other features or aspects of other embodiments in order to provide yet further embodiments.
[0057] Accordingly, the specification and examples are considered to be exemplary only, with a true scope and spirit of the invention being indicated by the following claims and their equivalents.
Claims
1. A heel guard (200, 300), include: Bottom legs (202, 302); as well as A side leg (204, 304), the side leg (204, 304) extending perpendicularly from the bottom leg (202, 302) and forming an inner angle (206, 306) with the bottom leg (202, 302); The heel guard (200, 300) defines a first side surface (208, 308), a second side surface (210, 310), and the bottom leg (202, 302) includes a curved inner surface (212, 312) extending from the first side surface (208, 308) to the second side surface (210, 310), at least partially forming the inner corner (206, 306), and the first side surface (208, 308) defines a first wear indicator (214) disposed at the inner corner (206, 306).
2. The heel guard (200, 300) according to claim 1, in, The second side surface (210, 310) defines a second wear indicator (214a) symmetrical to the first wear indicator (214).
3. The heel guard (200, 300) according to claim 2, in, The side leg (204, 304) defines a flat inner surface (220) that at least partially forms the inner corner (206, 306), and the inner corner (206, 306) is configured to provide corner relief and is spaced from a theoretical sharp angle (222) defined by the intersection of the flat inner surface (222) of the side leg (204, 304) and the curved inner surface (212, 312) of the bottom leg (202, 302).
4. The heel guard (200, 300) according to claim 1, in, The first wear indicator (214) defines a top beveled wall (224), a bottom beveled wall (226) parallel to the top beveled wall (224), and a gap distance (228) measured perpendicularly from the top beveled wall (224) to the bottom beveled wall (226), and the first wear indicator (214) defines a lateral depth (230), and a ratio of the gap distance (228) to the lateral depth (230) is in the range of 0.8 to 1.
2.
5. The heel guard (200, 300) according to claim 1, in, The bottom leg (202, 302) defines a bottom outer surface (232), a first minimum distance (234) measured from the first wear indicator (214) to the bottom outer surface (232), and the side leg (204, 304) defines a side outer surface (236) and a second minimum distance (238) measured from the first wear indicator (214) to the side outer surface (236).
6. The heel guard (200, 300) according to claim 5, in, A ratio of the first minimum distance (234) to the second minimum distance (238) is in a range of 0.75 to 1.0, and the first wear indicator (214) includes a vertical surface (240) that at least partially defines the second minimum distance (238) and a horizontal surface (242) that at least partially defines the first minimum distance (234).
7. A heel guard (200, 300), include: Bottom legs (202, 302); as well as a side leg (204, 304) extending perpendicularly from the bottom leg (202, 302) and forming an inner angle (206, 306) with the bottom leg (202, 302); The heel guard (200, 300) defines a first side surface (208, 308), a second side surface (210, 310), and the bottom leg (202, 302) includes a curved inner surface (212, 312) extending from the first side surface (208, 308) to the second side surface (210, 310), at least partially forming the inner corner (206, 306), and the first side surface (208, 308) defines a stress concentration reducing geometry (216) including a concave arcuate surface (244) at the inner corner (206, 306).
8. The heel guard (200, 300) according to claim 7, in, The stress reducing geometry (216) includes a recess (246) extending from the concave arcuate surface (244), the recess (246) including a recess bottom surface (248) connected to the concave arcuate surface (244) by a plurality of convex arcuate surfaces (250), and the concave arcuate surface (244) defines a radius of curvature (ROC244) ranging from 5.0 mm to 12.0 mm, and also includes a second recess (246a) symmetrical to the first recess (246).
9. The heel guard (200, 300) according to claim 7, in, The first recess (246) includes a first planar sidewall (224) extending from the recess bottom surface (248) to the first side surface (208, 308) and a second planar sidewall (226) extending from the recess bottom surface (248) to the first side surface (208, 308).
10. The heel guard (200, 300) according to claim 9, in, The first planar side wall (224) and the second planar side wall (226) are parallel, the bottom leg (202, 302) and the side leg (204, 304) intersect at an outer corner (252), and the first recess (246) extends toward the outer corner (252), and also includes a concave arcuate surface (254) extending from the first planar side wall (224) to the second planar side wall (226).
