Method and device for judging measurement quality of water quality on-line instrument

By laying out water quality online instruments in the biological pool of the sewage treatment plant and comparing laboratory data, and using statistical analysis methods to judge the accuracy and stability of the instrument, the problem of difficulty in evaluating the quality of water quality online instruments in the existing technology is solved, and simple Reliable quality judgment and selection basis provide effective instrument selection basis for sewage treatment plants.

CN118937430APending Publication Date: 2024-11-12BEIJING DRAINAGE GRP CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410998512.5
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-24
Publication Date
2024-11-12

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

It is difficult for the existing technology to effectively judge the inspection quality of water quality instruments, especially domestically produced instruments, which leads to confusion in sewage treatment plants when choosing suitable water quality instruments.

Method used

By laying out water quality online instruments in the biological pool of the sewage treatment plant, obtaining online instrument data, and performing sewage sampling in the same area for laboratory analysis, using statistical analysis methods to compare the data of the two to judge the accuracy and stability of the water quality online instrument.

Benefits of technology

It provides a basis for judging the quality of water quality online instruments. It is simple, stable and reliable in operation, suitable for large-scale applications, and can effectively evaluate the accuracy and stability of the instrument.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118937430A_ABST
    Figure CN118937430A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to the technical field of sewage detection, and particularly discloses a water quality on-line instrument measurement quality judgment method and device, and the method comprises the steps: arranging a water quality on-line instrument in a biological pool of a sewage treatment plant, and carrying out the on-line measurement of the water quality of sewage in the biological pool through the water quality on-line instrument to obtain on-line instrument data; sewage sampling is carried out in the same area where the water quality on-line instruments are arranged, and laboratory analysis is carried out on the sampled sewage to obtain laboratory test data; and carrying out statistical analysis on the online instrument data and the laboratory test data in the same time period, and judging the accuracy and stability of the water quality online instrument measurement according to the statistical analysis result. According to the method for judging the measurement quality of the water quality on-line instrument, the water quality on-line instrument is installed, laboratory test data and on-line instrument data of the water quality on-line instrument are compared, the quality measured by the water quality on-line instrument is judged through a statistical analysis method, and a judgment basis is provided for selection of the water quality on-line instrument.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of sewage detection, and in particular to a method and a device for judging the quality of water quality online instrument measurement. Background Art

[0002] With the continuous improvement of automation level, the demand for online water quality instruments in sewage treatment plants is increasing. With the strong promotion of the country, domestic online water quality instruments are also emerging, especially those based on ion electrode method, which are easy to use and operate and are loved by the majority of users. However, how to judge the detection quality of each online water quality instrument and better choose the appropriate online water quality instrument has always been a puzzle for the relevant managers of sewage treatment plants. It is also the difficulty of the widespread application of online water quality instruments (especially domestic instruments).

[0003] Based on this technical background, the present invention studies a method and device for judging the quality of water quality online instrument measurement. Summary of the invention

[0004] In view of the shortcomings of the prior art, the present invention proposes a method and device for judging the measurement quality of an online water quality instrument. The method installs an online water quality instrument, compares laboratory test data with the online water quality instrument data, and uses a statistical analysis method to judge the quality of the online water quality instrument measurement, thereby providing a judgment basis for the selection of the online water quality instrument.

[0005] In order to achieve the above-mentioned object, the first aspect of the present invention provides a method for determining the quality of water quality online instrument measurement, comprising:

[0006] Arrange a water quality online instrument in the biological pool of the sewage treatment plant, and use the water quality online instrument to measure the sewage quality in the biological pool online to obtain online instrument data;

[0007] Sewage sampling is performed in the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, and laboratory analysis is performed on the sampled sewage to obtain laboratory test data;

[0008] Perform statistical analysis on the online instrument data and laboratory test data in the same time period, and judge the accuracy and stability of the water quality online instrument measurement based on the results of the statistical analysis.

[0009] A second aspect of the present invention provides a water quality online instrument measurement quality judgment device, comprising:

[0010] An online data acquisition module is used to arrange an online water quality instrument in the biological pool of the sewage treatment plant, and use the online water quality instrument to measure the sewage quality in the biological pool online to obtain online instrument data;

[0011] A test data acquisition module, used to sample sewage in the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, and perform laboratory analysis on the sampled sewage to obtain laboratory test data;

[0012] The statistical analysis module is used to perform statistical analysis on the online instrument data and laboratory test data in the same time period, and to judge the accuracy and stability of the water quality online instrument measurement according to the results of the statistical analysis.

[0013] The technical effects of the present invention include:

[0014] (1) The method for judging the quality of water quality online instrument measurement proposed in the present invention is to install the water quality online instrument, compare the laboratory test data and the water quality online instrument data, and judge the quality of the water quality online instrument measurement through statistical analysis methods, thereby providing a judgment basis for the selection of the water quality online instrument.

[0015] (2) The method for judging the quality of online water quality instrument measurement proposed in the present invention can judge the quality of laboratory test data and online instrument data through data statistical analysis, and can further judge the accuracy and stability of online water quality instrument measurement. The method is simple, stable, reliable, and highly operable, and is suitable for large-scale application.

[0016] Other features and advantages of the present invention will be described in detail in the following detailed description. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0017] The above and other objects, features and advantages of the present invention will become more apparent through a more detailed description of exemplary embodiments of the present invention in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, wherein like reference numerals generally represent like components throughout the exemplary embodiments of the present invention.

[0018] Figure 1 The present invention provides a flow chart of the method for determining the quality of water quality measured by an online water quality instrument.

[0019] Figure 2 The present invention provides a flowchart of a specific implementation of the method for determining the quality of water quality measured by an online water quality instrument.

[0020] Figure 3 This is a schematic diagram of the first group of ion electrode method ammonia nitrogen quality data judgment in a specific implementation of the water quality online instrument measurement quality judgment method proposed by the present invention.

[0021] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram of the second group of ion electrode method ammonia nitrogen quality data judgment in a specific implementation of the water quality online instrument measurement quality judgment method proposed by the present invention.

[0022] Figure 5 This is a schematic diagram of the change of ammonia nitrogen value of online instrument No. 1 over time in a specific implementation of the water quality online instrument measurement quality judgment method proposed by the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0023] The preferred embodiments of the present invention will be described in more detail below. Although the preferred embodiments of the present invention are described below, it should be understood that the present invention can be implemented in various forms and should not be limited to the embodiments set forth herein.

[0024] In the present invention, unless otherwise specified, the directional words used, such as "upper and lower", generally refer to the upper and lower parts of the device in normal use, and "inside and outside" refer to the outline of the device. In addition, the terms "first, second, third" are used for descriptive purposes only and cannot be understood as indicating or implying relative importance or implicitly indicating the number of technical features indicated. Therefore, the features defined as "first, second, third" may explicitly or implicitly include one or more of the features. In the description of the present invention, "multiple" means two or more, unless otherwise clearly and specifically defined.

[0025] The present invention provides a method for determining the quality of water quality by online instrument measurement. Figure 1 As shown, including:

[0026] Arrange water quality online instruments in the biological pool of the sewage treatment plant, and use the water quality online instruments to measure the sewage quality in the biological pool online to obtain online instrument data;

[0027] Sewage sampling is carried out in the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, and laboratory analysis is performed on the sampled sewage to obtain laboratory test data;

[0028] Perform statistical analysis on the online instrument data and laboratory test data in the same time period, and judge the accuracy and stability of the water quality online instrument measurement based on the results of the statistical analysis.

[0029] In the present invention, by installing an online water quality meter, comparing laboratory test data with the online water quality meter data, and using statistical analysis methods, the quality of the online water quality meter measurement is judged, providing a basis for the selection of the online water quality meter.

[0030] According to the present invention, a PLC system is also arranged in the biological pool;

[0031] The PLC system is connected to the online water quality instrument for real-time transmission and recording of online instrument data;

[0032] The online water quality instrument is an instrument that uses the ion electrode method to measure water quality.

[0033] According to the present invention, sewage sampling is performed in the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, and laboratory analysis of the sampled sewage is performed to obtain laboratory test data including:

[0034] In the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, sewage sampling is carried out at continuous fixed intervals and the sampling time is recorded;

[0035] Conduct laboratory analysis on the sampled sewage to obtain at least 20 sets of laboratory test data;

[0036] The water quality of online instrument data and laboratory test data is both ammonia nitrogen or nitric nitrogen.

[0037] According to the present invention, statistical analysis of online instrument data and laboratory test data in the same time period includes:

[0038] By recording the sampling time, the online instrument data of the water quality online instrument at the corresponding time is obtained. The number of online instrument data is the same as the number of laboratory test data, and the time of the two data corresponds one to one;

[0039] By comparing laboratory test data and online instrument data, the experimental error, error mean, error standard deviation and absolute value of relative error of actual water sample comparison are obtained.

[0040] Preferably, the expression of the experimental error is:

[0041] D=B n -X n ;

[0042] Where D is the experimental error, B n is the laboratory test data, X n is the online instrument data, n is the number of comparisons;

[0043] The expression of the error mean is:

[0044] AVGD=(D1+D2+......+D n ) / n;

[0045] Among them, AVGD is the average error, D n is the nth trial error;

[0046] The expression for the standard deviation of the error is:

[0047]

[0048] Where SD is the standard deviation of the error, D i is the error of the ith trial.

[0049] The absolute value of the relative error is expressed as:

[0050] A=|(X n -B n )*100% / B n |;

[0051] Among them, A is the absolute value of the relative error.

[0052] According to the present invention, judging the accuracy and stability of water quality online instrument measurement based on the results of statistical analysis includes:

[0053] The qualification of online instrument data and laboratory test data is determined by the test error within the range of AVGD±2SD and AVGD±3SD;

[0054] The accuracy of water quality online instrument measurement is judged by the absolute value of the test error.

[0055] Preferably, judging whether the online instrument data and the laboratory test data are qualified by the test error being within the range of AVGD±2SD and AVGD±3SD includes:

[0056] When the test errors of each group are within the range of AVGD±3SD, and the amount of data outside the range of AVGD±2SD is no more than 2, the online instrument data and laboratory test data are qualified, and the accuracy of subsequent water quality online instrument measurements is judged;

[0057] When at least one of the test errors in each group is not within the range of AVGD±3SD, or the amount of data outside the range of AVGD±2SD is greater than 2, the online instrument data and laboratory test data are unqualified, and the online instrument data and laboratory test data are re-obtained for statistical analysis.

[0058] According to the present invention, judging the accuracy of water quality online instrument measurement by the absolute value of the test error includes:

[0059] When the absolute value of the relative error of each group is not greater than 20% and the proportion is 85% or above, or the absolute value of the relative error of each group is not greater than 15% and the proportion is 75% or above, the accuracy of the water quality online instrument measurement meets the standard and the online instrument data is used to guide practical applications; otherwise, the water quality online instrument is recalibrated.

[0060] According to the present invention, judging the accuracy and stability of water quality online instrument measurement based on the results of statistical analysis also includes:

[0061] The stability of the online water quality instrument is determined by performing periodic analysis, sudden change value analysis, and post-calibration numerical accuracy duration analysis on the online instrument data over a period of time.

[0062] In the present invention, the quality of laboratory test data and online instrument data can be judged by the data statistical analysis method, and the accuracy and stability of water quality online instrument measurement can be further judged. The method is simple, stable, reliable, highly operable, and suitable for large-scale application.

[0063] The present invention will be described in more detail below through specific embodiments.

[0064] Example 1

[0065] In this embodiment, the expressions of the experimental error, the error mean, the error standard deviation and the absolute value of the relative error used in the statistical analysis are respectively as follows:

[0066] The expression of experimental error is:

[0067] D=B n -X n ;

[0068] The expression of the error mean is:

[0069] AVGD=(D1+D2+......+D n ) / n;

[0070] The expression for the standard deviation of the error is:

[0071]

[0072] The absolute value of the relative error is expressed as:

[0073] A=|(X n -B n )*100% / B n |;

[0074] Where D is the experimental error, B n is the laboratory test data, X n is the online instrument data, n is the number of comparisons, AVGD is the average error, D n is the error of the nth test, SD is the standard deviation of the error, D i is the error of the ith test, A is the absolute value of the relative error;

[0075] like Figure 2 As shown, this embodiment provides a method for determining the quality of water quality online instrument measurement, which specifically includes the following steps:

[0076] 1) At the end of the anoxic biological pool of the sewage treatment plant, two nitrate nitrogen online meters (ion electrode method) and corresponding PLC systems are configured to achieve real-time online data transmission;

[0077] 2) Manual sampling and laboratory testing of nitrate nitrogen data were performed at 10:00 and 16:00 every day for 10 consecutive days to obtain 20 sets of laboratory test data;

[0078] 3) Obtain online data of two nitric nitrogen online instruments at 10:00 and 16:00. The data quantity is consistent with the laboratory data quantity and corresponds to each other at all times;

[0079] 4) By comparing the laboratory test data and the online instrument data, the actual water sample comparison test errors D1 and D2 of the two nitrate nitrogen online instruments were obtained as shown in Table 1. The average error AVGD1 was 0.44925, AVGD2 was 0.98975, and the standard deviations SD1 and SD2 were 1.1683 and 1.5612, respectively;

[0080] Table 12 nitrate nitrogen online instrument actual water sample comparison test error

[0081]

[0082] 5) Compare the actual water sample comparison test error D within the range of AVGD±2SD and AVGD±3SD to obtain the data quality of the online data; through comparison, it is found that Figure 3 and Figure 4 As shown, the data of the two groups of water samples are qualified;

[0083] 6) By comparing the absolute value A of the relative error of the two sets of data, the accuracy of the online instrument data is judged; the A value of the first nitrate nitrogen online instrument is less than or equal to 20% of the data, accounting for 90%, and the data is less than or equal to 15%, accounting for 75%. The accuracy of the first instrument meets the standard, and the data can guide practical application; the A value of the second nitrate nitrogen online instrument is less than or equal to 20% of the data, accounting for 70%, and the data is less than or equal to 15%. There are 10 data, accounting for 50%, and the accuracy of the second instrument does not meet the standard, and the instrument needs to be recalibrated;

[0084] 7) If Figure 5 As shown in the figure, a 21-day online data analysis was conducted on the first instrument. During the monitoring period, the online data was within a reasonable range, and the 24-hour regularity of each day was consistent without sudden changes. After calibration on August 8, the online data recovered periodically without sudden changes and could last for 10 days. Therefore, the stability of the instrument was qualified.

[0085] 8) Through the analysis of steps 1-7, it is finally determined that the accuracy and stability of the first nitrate nitrogen online instrument (ion electrode method) are good, and its data can guide practical applications; the accuracy of the second nitrate nitrogen online instrument is unqualified and needs to be recalibrated before the instrument measurement quality can be judged.

[0086] Example 2

[0087] like Figure 1 As shown, this embodiment provides a method for determining the quality of water quality online instrument measurement, including:

[0088] Arrange water quality online instruments in the biological pool of the sewage treatment plant, and use the water quality online instruments to measure the sewage quality in the biological pool online to obtain online instrument data;

[0089] Sewage sampling is carried out in the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, and laboratory analysis is performed on the sampled sewage to obtain laboratory test data;

[0090] Conduct statistical analysis on online instrument data and laboratory test data in the same time period, and judge the accuracy and stability of online water quality instrument measurement based on the results of statistical analysis;

[0091] A PLC system is also arranged in the biological pool;

[0092] The PLC system is connected to the online water quality instrument for real-time transmission and recording of online instrument data;

[0093] The online water quality instrument is an instrument that uses the ion electrode method to measure water quality;

[0094] Water quality is measured as ammonia nitrogen or nitrate nitrogen;

[0095] In this embodiment, sewage sampling is performed in the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, and laboratory analysis of the sampled sewage is performed to obtain laboratory test data including:

[0096] In the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, sewage sampling is carried out at continuous fixed intervals and the sampling time is recorded;

[0097] Conduct laboratory analysis on the sampled sewage to obtain at least 20 sets of laboratory test data;

[0098] Statistical analysis of online instrument data and laboratory test data in the same time period includes:

[0099] By recording the sampling time, the online instrument data of the water quality online instrument at the corresponding time is obtained. The number of online instrument data is the same as the number of laboratory test data, and the time of the two data corresponds one to one;

[0100] By comparing laboratory test data and online instrument data, the test error, error mean, error standard deviation and absolute value of relative error of actual water sample comparison are obtained;

[0101] In this embodiment, the expression of the experimental error is:

[0102] D=B n -X n ;

[0103] Where D is the experimental error, B n is the laboratory test data, X n is the online instrument data, n is the number of comparisons;

[0104] The expression of the error mean is:

[0105] AVGD=(D1+D2+......+D n ) / n;

[0106] Among them, AVGD is the average error, D n is the nth trial error;

[0107] The expression for the standard deviation of the error is:

[0108]

[0109] Where SD is the standard deviation of the error, D i is the error of the ith trial;

[0110] The absolute value of the test relative error is expressed as:

[0111] A=|(X n -B n )*100% / B n |;

[0112] Among them, A is the absolute value of the relative error.

[0113] The accuracy and stability of water quality online instrument measurement are judged based on the results of statistical analysis, including:

[0114] The qualification of online instrument data and laboratory test data is determined by the test error within the range of AVGD±2SD and AVGD±3SD;

[0115] The accuracy of water quality online instrument measurement is determined by the absolute value of the test error;

[0116] Judging whether the online instrument data and laboratory test data are qualified by the test error within the range of AVGD±2SD and AVGD±3SD includes:

[0117] When the test errors of each group are within the range of AVGD±3SD, and the amount of data outside the range of AVGD±2SD is no more than 2, the online instrument data and laboratory test data are qualified, and the accuracy of subsequent water quality online instrument measurements is judged;

[0118] When at least one of the test errors in each group is not within the range of AVGD±3SD, or the amount of data outside the range of AVGD±2SD is greater than 2, the online instrument data and laboratory test data are unqualified, and the online instrument data and laboratory test data are re-obtained for statistical analysis;

[0119] The accuracy of water quality online instrument measurement is judged by the absolute value of relative error, including:

[0120] When the absolute value of the relative error of each group is not greater than 20% and the proportion is 85% or above, or the absolute value of the relative error of each group is not greater than 15% and the proportion is 75% or above, the accuracy of the water quality online instrument measurement reaches the standard, and the online instrument data is used to guide practical applications; otherwise, the water quality online instrument is recalibrated;

[0121] The stability of the online water quality instrument is determined by performing periodic analysis, sudden change value analysis, and post-calibration numerical accuracy duration analysis on the online instrument data over a period of time.

[0122] The method for judging the quality of online water quality meter measurement in the embodiment of the present invention installs an online water quality meter, compares laboratory test data and online water quality meter data, and uses statistical analysis methods to judge the quality of online water quality meter measurement, thereby providing a judgment basis for the selection of online water quality meters.

[0123] The embodiments of the present invention have been described above, and the above description is exemplary, not exhaustive, and is not limited to the disclosed embodiments. Many modifications and changes will be apparent to those skilled in the art without departing from the scope and spirit of the described embodiments.

Claims

1. A method for determining the quality of water quality by online instrument measurement, characterized in that: include: Arrange a water quality online instrument in the biological pool of the sewage treatment plant, and use the water quality online instrument to measure the sewage quality in the biological pool online to obtain online instrument data; Sewage sampling is performed in the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, and laboratory analysis is performed on the sampled sewage to obtain laboratory test data; Perform statistical analysis on the online instrument data and laboratory test data in the same time period, and judge the accuracy and stability of the water quality online instrument measurement based on the results of the statistical analysis.

2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that The water quality online instrument arranged in the biological pool is used to record and export online test data in real time; The real-time recording and exporting are realized by the instrument header itself or the PLC system; The PLC system is connected to the water quality online instrument for real-time transmission and recording of the online instrument data; The water quality online instrument is an instrument that uses the ion electrode method to measure water quality; The online instrument data and laboratory test data are both ammonia nitrogen or nitric nitrogen.

3. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that Sewage sampling is carried out in the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, and laboratory analysis is performed on the sampled sewage to obtain laboratory test data including: In the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, sewage sampling is carried out at continuous fixed intervals and the sampling time is recorded; The sampled sewage is subjected to laboratory analysis to obtain at least 20 sets of laboratory test data.

4. The method according to claim 3, characterized in that The statistical analysis of the online instrument data and laboratory test data in the same time period includes: By recording the sampling time, the online instrument data of the water quality online instrument at the corresponding time is obtained, the number of the online instrument data is the same as the number of laboratory test data, and the time of the two data corresponds one to one; By comparing the laboratory test data and the online instrument data, the test error, the error mean value, the error standard deviation and the absolute value of the relative error of the actual water sample comparison are obtained.

5. The method according to claim 4, characterized in that The expression of the test error is: D=B n -X n ; Where D is the experimental error, B n is the laboratory test data, X n is the online instrument data, n is the number of comparisons; The expression of the error mean value is: AVGD=(D1+D2+......+D n ) / n; Among them, AVGD is the average error, D n is the nth trial error; The expression for the standard deviation of the error is: Where SD is the standard deviation of the error, D i is the error of the ith trial; The absolute value of the relative error is expressed as: A=|(X n -B n )*100% / B n |; Where A is the absolute value of the relative error.

6. The method according to claim 5, characterized in that Judging the accuracy and stability of the water quality online instrument measurement based on the results of the statistical analysis includes: Judging whether the online instrument data and laboratory test data are qualified by the test error being within the range of AVGD±2SD and AVGD±3SD; The accuracy of the water quality online instrument measurement is judged by the absolute value of the relative error.

7. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that Judging whether the online instrument data and laboratory test data are qualified by the test error within the range of AVGD±2SD and AVGD±3SD includes: When the test errors of each group are within the range of AVGD±3SD, and the amount of data outside the range of AVGD±2SD is not more than 2, the online instrument data and laboratory test data are qualified, and the accuracy of the subsequent water quality online instrument measurement is judged; When at least one of the test errors in each group is not within the range of AVGD±3SD, or the amount of data outside the range of AVGD±2SD is greater than 2, the online instrument data and laboratory test data are unqualified, and the online instrument data and laboratory test data are re-obtained for statistical analysis.

8. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that The accuracy of the water quality online instrument measurement is determined by the absolute value of the relative error, including: When the absolute value of the relative error of each group is not greater than 20% and the proportion is 85% or above, or the absolute value of the relative error of each group is not greater than 15% and the proportion is 75% or above, the accuracy of the water quality online instrument measurement meets the standard, and the online instrument data is used to guide practical applications; otherwise, the water quality online instrument is recalibrated.

9. The method according to claim 6, characterized in that Judging the accuracy and stability of the water quality online instrument measurement based on the results of the statistical analysis also includes: The stability of the water quality online instrument is determined by performing periodic analysis, sudden change value analysis and post-calibration numerical accuracy duration analysis on the online instrument data over a period of time.

10. A water quality online instrument measurement quality judgment device, characterized in that: include: An online data acquisition module is used to arrange an online water quality instrument in the biological pool of the sewage treatment plant, and use the online water quality instrument to measure the sewage quality in the biological pool online to obtain online instrument data; A test data acquisition module, used to sample sewage in the same area where the water quality online instrument is arranged, and perform laboratory analysis on the sampled sewage to obtain laboratory test data; The statistical analysis module is used to perform statistical analysis on the online instrument data and laboratory test data in the same time period, and to judge the accuracy and stability of the water quality online instrument measurement according to the results of the statistical analysis.