Foaming agent drainage effect evaluation method and system for shale gas reservoir development
By calculating the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent and building a gas core and foam film model, the drainage effect of the foaming agent in the shale gas wellbore was evaluated, and the problem of insufficient liquid accumulation and gas carrying accuracy of the wellbore in the existing technology was solved, and the Prediction accuracy and effect of shale gas reservoir development.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202310531104.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-11
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
AI Technical Summary
In the development of existing shale gas reservoirs, wellbore effusion problems have led to wellbore blockage and production capacity reduction. The existing foaming agent performance evaluation methods cannot accurately predict the foam drainage effect, especially considering the wellbore fluid carrying mode and gas carrying process. Inadequate accuracy.
Provide a method for evaluating the drainage effect of foaming agents for shale gas reservoir development. By calculating the liquid carrying coefficient of foaming agents, constructing the flow rate of gas core and foam film and the interface friction coefficient model, the critical flow rate of gas carrying foam is established. and the surface tension calculation model, combined with the influence of the wellbore pressure gradient, evaluate the drainage effect of the foaming agent.
Improve the prediction accuracy of the effect of the foaming agent, with an error of less than 10%, which can comprehensively reflect the effect of the foaming agent in the actual wellbore bubble drainage process, provide a more accurate evaluation method and system, and optimize the shale gas reservoir. Development plan.
Smart Images

Figure CN118940651A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of shale gas exploitation, and in particular to a method and system for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent used in the development of shale gas reservoirs. Background Art
[0002] In the later stage of shale gas reservoir development, due to factors such as insufficient reservoir pressure and bottom water coning, a large amount of liquid accumulation often occurs in the wellbore, causing wellbore blockage, reduced production capacity, and even gas well shutdown in severe cases. Therefore, the problem of wellbore liquid accumulation restricts the later development of shale gas reservoirs.
[0003] Foam drainage technology is an important method to solve the problem of fluid accumulation in wellbore. However, during its implementation, this method still faces problems such as unreasonable evaluation methods and inability to accurately predict the wellbore construction effect of foaming agents. Therefore, reasonable evaluation of foaming agents is the key to predicting the effect of foam drainage.
[0004] There are two main evaluation methods for the existing performance analysis of foaming agents. One is based on indoor experiments, by testing the surface tension, contact angle, foaming performance and liquid carrying performance of the foaming agent solution, to indirectly judge the foaming effect of the foaming agent. However, these evaluation methods cannot comprehensively reflect the effect of the foaming agent in the actual wellbore foaming process through quantitative evaluation criteria such as wellbore foam carrying rate, wellbore pressure drop and gas fraction trapped in the foam. Another evaluation method is to establish a gas-liquid carrying model in the wellbore, and calculate the critical liquid carrying flow rate of the gas in the wellbore through the surface tension test results of the foaming agent. This simulation method assumes a calculation model for gas carrying wellbore liquid accumulation, and does not take into account the foam carrying liquid mode after the foaming agent is added to the wellbore, and the calculation accuracy is poor relative to the foaming process. Therefore, establishing a gas-carrying foam analysis model in the wellbore is of great significance to improve the prediction accuracy of the effect of the foaming agent. Summary of the invention
[0005] In order to solve the above problems, the present invention provides a method and system for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development, and also provides a computer device and a computer-readable storage medium.
[0006] The first object of the present invention is to provide a method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development, comprising:
[0007] S1: basic parameters are calculated based on the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent;
[0008] S2: Construct the calculation model of flow velocity and interface friction coefficient of air core and foam film according to basic parameters;
[0009] S3: According to the interface friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film:
[0010] A calculation model for the critical velocity of gas-carried foam after adding surfactant is constructed to obtain the critical velocity of gas-carried foam;
[0011] Constructing the correlation function between the surface tension of the foaming agent and the foaming flow rate of the wellbore to obtain the surface tension of the foaming agent;
[0012] According to the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and foam film, the relationship between the foaming agent and the wellbore pressure gradient is constructed to obtain the wellbore pressure drop;
[0013] S4: Evaluate the drainage effect of the foaming agent based on the critical flow rate of the gas-carrying foam, the surface tension of the foaming agent, and the wellbore pressure drop.
[0014] In an optional embodiment, the basic parameters include the average liquid holdup and foam holdup of the wellbore, the gas volume fraction in the foam, the foam density, and the size parameters of the gas core and the bubbles.
[0015] In an optional embodiment, the average liquid holdup and bubble holdup of the wellbore are calculated based on the relationship between the gas content and the superficial flow rates of the gas phase and the liquid phase;
[0016] The gas volume fraction in the foam is calculated based on the empirical relationship between the wellbore's bubble holding rate and the superficial flow rates of the gas and liquid phases;
[0017] The foam density is calculated based on linear interpolation.
[0018] In an optional embodiment, a flow rate calculation model of the gas core and the foam film is constructed based on the relationship between the tube diameter, the dimensionless foam film thickness, the gas volume fraction in the bubble, and the gas phase apparent flow rate;
[0019] The gas core flow rate is:
[0020]
[0021] In the formula, v c is the air core flow rate before adding the foaming agent, is the dimensionless foam film thickness, v sg is the gas phase superficial velocity, f g is the volume fraction of gas in the bubble, v sl is the liquid phase superficial velocity;
[0022] The foam film flow rate is:
[0023]
[0024] In the formula, v f is the foam film flow rate, D is the oil pipe diameter; d f is the foam film thickness, v sl is the liquid phase superficial velocity, f g is the volume fraction of gas in the bubble.
[0025] In an optional embodiment, a calculation model for the interface friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film is constructed based on an empirical relationship between the Reynolds number and the dimensionless foam film thickness;
[0026]
[0027]
[0028] In the formula, f i1 is the interfacial friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film, Re is the apparent gas phase Reynolds number, is the dimensionless foam film thickness, ρ g is the gas phase density, v sg is the gas phase superficial velocity, D is the oil pipe diameter, μ g is the gas phase viscosity.
[0029] In an optional embodiment, based on the relationship between the shear stress derivative function between the gas and foam film interface and the dimensionless foam film thickness, a Newton iteration method is used to construct a critical flow rate calculation model for gas-carrying foam.
[0030] In an optional embodiment, the critical gas-carrying foam velocity calculation formula is:
[0031]
[0032] In the formula, v gc is the critical gas phase foam carrying velocity, f i1 is the interfacial friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film, ρ f is the foam density, D is the tubing diameter, β is the well inclination, C f is the constant for calculating the friction coefficient of the foam film, μ f is the foam viscosity, v sl is the liquid phase superficial velocity, n f is the calculation index of the foam friction coefficient, and g is the acceleration due to gravity.
[0033] In an optional embodiment, based on the proportional relationship between surface energy and turbulent energy, a correlation function between the surface tension of the foaming agent and the wellbore foaming flow rate is established, wherein the wellbore foaming flow rate includes the gas phase flow rate and the liquid phase flow rate required for foam formation.
[0034] In an alternative embodiment, N t =N s ;
[0035] Where N t is the turbulent kinetic energy; N s is the foam surface energy;
[0036] Under the condition of foam, water and gas three-phase flow, vfe The surface energy flux generated by the rate of breaking into bubbles is as follows:
[0037]
[0038] Where N s is the surface energy flux; σ is the surface tension; d 32 is the characteristic particle size; v fe The gas phase flow rate required for foam formation;
[0039] The liquid phase flow rate required for foam formation is calculated as follows:
[0040] v lf =(U gc -U lf )(1-ε f );
[0041] The expression of gas phase flow rate for foam formation is:
[0042]
[0043] In the formula, v lf The liquid phase flow rate required for foam formation; U gc The air core flow rate after adding the foaming agent; U lf is the liquid film velocity on the wall side; ε f is the air content in the foam; C J is the empirical coefficient; d crit is the maximum size that the foam can reach in a stable state; We is a dimensionless number that affects the foam flow; We c is the critical value of the Weber number.
[0044] In an optional embodiment, based on the principle of foam force balance, a relationship equation for the influence of the foaming agent on the wellbore pressure gradient is constructed:
[0045]
[0046]
[0047] Where dp / dh is the wellbore pressure gradient, τ l is the shear stress at the gas phase and foam interface, S l is the perimeter of the gas phase and foam film interface, A c is the cross-sectional area of the air core, ρ c is the foam density, β is the well inclination angle, f i1 is the interfacial friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film, v c and v f are the air core and foam film flow rates, respectively.
[0048] The second object of the present invention is to provide a foaming agent drainage effect evaluation system for shale gas reservoir development, comprising: a liquid carrying coefficient acquisition module, used to obtain the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent;
[0049] A parameter acquisition module, used to calculate basic parameters according to the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent;
[0050] The first model building module is used to build a calculation model of the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and the foam film according to basic parameters;
[0051] The second model building module is used to construct a critical velocity calculation model of gas-carrying foam after adding a surfactant according to the interface friction coefficient between the gas core and the foam film, so as to obtain the critical velocity of gas-carrying foam; and to construct a correlation function between the surface tension of the foaming agent and the foaming velocity of the wellbore to obtain the surface tension of the foaming agent;
[0052] The third model building module is used to construct a relationship between the foaming agent and the wellbore pressure gradient according to the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and the foam film to obtain the wellbore pressure drop.
[0053] The third object of the present invention is to provide a computer device, comprising a memory, a processor, and a computer program stored in the memory and executable on the processor, wherein when the processor executes the computer program, the method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development as described in any one of the above items is implemented.
[0054] A fourth object of the present invention is a computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, wherein when the computer program is executed by a processor, the method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development as described in any one of the above items is implemented.
[0055] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following advantages and beneficial effects:
[0056] The foaming agent drainage effect evaluation method provided by the present invention is based on an indoor foam drainage simulation evaluation device, and a calculation model for the friction coefficient of the gas core and foam film interface is constructed. The model comprehensively considers the influence of factors such as the complex wellbore structure, wellbore trajectory, temperature, pressure and salinity of water in each formation during the foam drainage implementation process; the provided effect evaluation method also comprehensively considers the interaction between the gas phase and the foam and the annular foam flow theoretical analysis method. It solves the problem that the existing wellbore liquid carrying model does not consider the foam flow, and constructs a foam carrying analysis model that is easy to calculate and solve, and the critical foam carrying flow rate calculation error is less than 10%; and the results obtained by indoor simulation experiments can be combined to combine the indoor evaluation with the wellbore foaming analysis model, and the effect of the foaming agent is comprehensively reflected through the macroscopic pressure gradient, the critical flow rate of gas carrying foam and the surface tension required to generate bubbles. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0057] In order to more clearly illustrate the technical solutions of the exemplary embodiments of the present invention, the following briefly introduces the drawings required for use in the embodiments. It should be understood that the following drawings only illustrate certain embodiments of the present invention and should not be regarded as limiting the scope. For those of ordinary skill in the art, other relevant drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without creative work. In the drawings:
[0058] Figure 1 This is a flow chart of the method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development of the present invention;
[0059] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of the analysis of the interfacial shear stress during the gas-carrying foam process;
[0060] Figure 3 This is a graph showing the variation of the foaming agent liquid carrying coefficient with concentration in Application Example 1;
[0061] Figure 4 This is a comparison chart between the predicted critical bubble entrainment velocity and the observed result in Application Example 1;
[0062] Figure 5 This is a result diagram showing the effect of the type and amount of foaming agent on the critical bubble-carrying velocity of gas in Application Example 1;
[0063] Figure 6 This is a comparison chart between the predicted pressure gradient and the observed result in Application Example 1;
[0064] Figure 7 This is the result diagram of the effect of the type and amount of foaming agent on the wellbore pressure gradient in Application Example 1;
[0065] Figure 8 This is a graph showing the relationship between the wellbore foaming flow rate and the surface tension in Application Example 1;
[0066] Fig. 9 This is a graph showing the variation of the foaming agent liquid carrying coefficient with concentration in Application Example 2;
[0067] Fig.10 This is a comparison chart of the predicted critical bubble entrainment velocity and the observed results in Application Example 2;
[0068] Fig.11 This is the result diagram of the effect of the type and amount of foaming agent on the critical bubble-carrying velocity of gas in Application Example 2;
[0069] Fig.12 This is a comparison chart of the predicted pressure gradient and the observed results in Application Example 2;
[0070] Fig.13 This is the result diagram of the effect of the type and amount of foaming agent on the wellbore pressure gradient in Application Example 2;
[0071] Fig.14 This is the relationship diagram between the wellbore foaming flow rate and the surface tension in Application Example 2;
[0072] Fig.15 This is a graph showing the variation of the foaming agent liquid carrying coefficient with concentration in Application Example 3;
[0073] Fig.16 This is a comparison chart of the predicted critical bubble entrainment velocity and the observed results in Application Example 3;
[0074] Fig.17 This is a result diagram showing the effect of the type and amount of foaming agent on the critical bubble-carrying velocity of gas in Application Example 3;
[0075] Fig.18 This is a comparison chart of the predicted pressure gradient and the observed results in Application Example 3;
[0076] Fig.19 This is the result diagram of the effect of the type and amount of foaming agent on the wellbore pressure gradient in Application Example 3;
[0077] Fig. 20 This is the relationship diagram between the wellbore foaming flow rate and surface tension in Application Example 3. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0078] In order to make the objectives, technical solutions and advantages of the present invention more clearly understood, the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with embodiments and drawings. The exemplary embodiments of the present invention and their description are only used to explain the present invention and are not intended to limit the present invention.
[0079] Embodiment 1:
[0080] The existing performance analysis of foaming agents is based on indoor tests. Since indoor tests cannot truly simulate the actual wellbore, they cannot comprehensively reflect the effect of the foaming agent in the actual wellbore foaming process. The gas-liquid carrying model in the wellbore does not consider the foam carrying mode after the foaming agent is added to the wellbore, resulting in poor calculation accuracy of the foaming process.
[0081] In order to solve the above problems, the present invention provides a method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development, which specifically adopts the following steps:
[0082] S1: The basic parameters are calculated based on the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent; the basic parameters include the average liquid holding rate and foam holding rate of the wellbore, the gas volume fraction in the foam, the foam density, and the size parameters of the gas core and the bubble.
[0083] The specific process is as follows: S101: Test the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent through an indoor simulation experimental device:
[0084] The experimentally obtained liquid carrying flow rate: In the formula, v lce is the experimentally obtained bubble-carrying liquid flow rate, Q le is the experimental liquid volume flow rate, A e is the cross-sectional area of the experimental pipeline.
[0085] The gas superficial velocity obtained from the experiment is: In the formula, v sge is the gas superficial velocity obtained from the experiment, Q sge is the gas superficial flow rate obtained from the experiment.
[0086] The experimentally obtained foaming agent liquid carrying coefficient is: Where R is the foaming agent liquid carrying coefficient.
[0087] S102: Based on the relationship between gas content and gas and liquid superficial velocity, calculate the average liquid holdup and bubble holdup of the wellbore:
[0088] Average wellbore liquid holdup: H l =1-α (4);
[0089]
[0090] In the formula, H l is the average liquid holdup in the wellbore, α is the gas content, v sl is the liquid phase apparent velocity, v sg is the superficial velocity of gas phase, and R is the liquid carrying coefficient of foaming agent.
[0091] Wellbore average bubble retention rate:
[0092] In the formula, H f is the average bubble holding rate of the wellbore, H l is the average liquid holdup in the wellbore, v sl is the liquid phase apparent velocity, v sg is the gas phase superficial velocity.
[0093] S103: Based on the empirical relationship between the wellbore bubble holding rate and the superficial flow rates of the gas phase and liquid phase, calculate the gas volume fraction in the foam:
[0094]
[0095] In the formula, f g is the volume fraction of gas in the bubble, H f and H l are the average bubble holding rate and liquid holding rate of the wellbore, v sl is the liquid phase apparent velocity, v sg is the gas phase superficial velocity.
[0096] S104: Calculate the foam density based on linear interpolation: ρ f=ρ g f g +ρ l (1-f g ) (8);
[0097] In the formula, ρ f , g , l are respectively the foam density, gas phase density and liquid phase density, f g is the gas volume fraction.
[0098] S105: Calculate the size parameters of the air core and foam:
[0099]
[0100]
[0101] d c =D-2d l (11);
[0102] S f =πD (12);
[0103] S l =π(D-2d f ) (13);
[0104] A f =πd f (D f ) (14);
[0105]
[0106] Where, d f is the thickness of the foam film, D is the diameter of the oil pipe, is the dimensionless foam film thickness, d l is the thickness of the liquid film, S f is the perimeter of the foam film, S l is the perimeter of the gas phase and foam film interface, A f is the cross-sectional area of the foam film, A c is the cross-sectional area of the air core, d c is the diameter of the air core.
[0107] S2: Construct a calculation model for the flow velocity and interface friction coefficient of the air core and foam membrane based on basic parameters.
[0108] S201: Based on the relationship between the tube diameter, the dimensionless foam film thickness, the gas volume fraction in the bubbles, and the gas phase apparent flow velocity, a flow velocity calculation model for the gas core and the foam film is constructed.
[0109] The gas core flow rate is:
[0110] In the formula, v c is the gas core flow rate, is the dimensionless foam film thickness, v sg is the gas phase superficial velocity, f g is the volume fraction of gas in the bubble.
[0111] The foam film flow rate is:
[0112] In the formula, v f Foam film flow rate, D is the oil pipe diameter, d f is the foam film thickness, v sl is the liquid phase superficial velocity, f g is the volume fraction of gas in the bubble.
[0113] S202: Based on the empirical relationship between the Reynolds number and the dimensionless foam film thickness, a calculation model for the interface friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film is constructed:
[0114]
[0115]
[0116] In the formula, f i1 is the interfacial friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film, Re is the apparent gas phase Reynolds number, is the dimensionless foam film thickness, ρ g is the gas phase density, v sg is the gas phase superficial velocity, D is the oil pipe diameter, μ g is the gas phase viscosity.
[0117] S3: According to the interfacial friction coefficient between the gas core and the foam film: construct a critical flow rate calculation model of the gas-carried foam after adding a surfactant to obtain the critical flow rate of the gas-carried foam;
[0118] Constructing the correlation function between the surface tension of the foaming agent and the foaming flow rate of the wellbore to obtain the surface tension of the foaming agent;
[0119] According to the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and foam film, the relationship between the foaming agent and the wellbore pressure gradient is constructed to obtain the wellbore pressure drop.
[0120] The wellbore foaming flow rate includes the liquid phase flow rate and gas phase flow rate required to form foam.
[0121] S301: Based on the relationship between the shear stress derivative function between the gas and foam film interface and the dimensionless foam film thickness, the Newton iteration method is used to calculate the minimum foam film thickness and construct a critical flow rate calculation model for gas-carrying foam:
[0122] The relationship between the shear stress derivative function between the gas and foam film interface and the dimensionless foam film thickness is as follows:
[0123]
[0124]
[0125] In the formula, ρ g and ρ f are gas phase and foam density respectively, D is the tubing diameter, β is the well inclination angle, is the dimensionless foam film thickness, C f is the calculation constant of the foam film friction coefficient, which is 18.36 according to experience, μ f and μ l are the viscosities of the foam and liquid phase, respectively, and f g is the volume fraction of gas in the bubble, n f is the calculation index of foam friction coefficient, which is taken as 0.97, and n is the calculation index of foam viscosity, which is taken as 0.49.
[0126] Depend on Figure 2 It can be seen that when the foam thickness is small, the interface shear stress is large, and the gas phase and the carried foam move upward; when the shear stress between the foam and the wellbore wall is zero, the carrying effect of the gas phase on the foam reaches a critical point. At this time, if the gas phase flow rate decreases, affected by factors such as gravity, the interface shear stress between the foam and the wellbore moves upward, and the edge foam slides downward.
[0127] The minimum value of the bubble film thickness is the minimum velocity at which the gas phase carries the foam upward. Therefore, the Newton iteration method is used to calculate the minimum value of the bubble film thickness, which is the zero point of the shear stress derivative at the interface between the gas core and the foam film. The formula for calculating the minimum bubble film thickness using the Newton iteration method is as follows:
[0128]
[0129] In the formula, is the function in formula (21) The first derivative of .
[0130] When calculating formula (23), first give the foam thickness an initial value d f0 , substitute into formula (23) to calculate d f1 If d f1 With d f0 If the time error does not meet the requirements, the d obtained by this solution will be f1 Substitute it as the initial value into formula (23) and continue to solve until we get d fn+1 With d fn The error between them meets the requirement, and the obtained d fn+1 is the minimum foam film thickness, is the foam film thickness calculated at the n+1th iteration.
[0131] The critical gas-carrying foam velocity is calculated as follows:
[0132]
[0133] In the formula, v gc is the critical gas phase foam carrying velocity, f i1 is the interfacial friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film.
[0134] S302: Based on the proportional relationship between surface energy and turbulent energy, a correlation function between the surface tension of the foaming agent and the foaming flow rate of the wellbore is established, and the optimal amount of surfactant can be selected.
[0135] The turbulent kinetic energy of the surfactant solution to generate foam is equal to the surface energy of the foam after formation: N t =N s (27);
[0136] Where N t is the turbulent kinetic energy; N s is the surface energy of the foam.
[0137] Under the condition of foam, water and gas three-phase flow, v fe The surface energy flux generated by the rate of breaking into bubbles is as follows:
[0138]
[0139] Where N s is the surface energy flux (i.e., foam surface energy); σ is the surface tension; d 32 is the characteristic particle size; v fe The gas phase flow rate required for foam formation.
[0140] The turbulent kinetic energy expression for foam formation is:
[0141] N t =0.5ρ l (u 2 +v 2 +w 2 )v lf (29);
[0142] Where N t is the turbulent kinetic energy; ρ l is the liquid density; u, v, w are the components of velocity in three directions respectively; v lf The turbulent flow rate of the liquid phase required for foam formation.
[0143] According to the experimental statistical analysis data, the equivalent formula of the velocity component is obtained:
[0144] u 2 +v 2 +w 2 =0.03(U ls -U lf ) 2 (30);
[0145] Where U ls is the flow rate after foam formation; U lf is the liquid film velocity on the wall side.
[0146] The specific calculation formula for the liquid phase turbulent flow velocity required for foam formation is:
[0147] v lf =(U gc -U lf )(1-ε f ) (31);
[0148] In the formula, v lf The turbulent flow rate of the liquid phase required for foam formation; U gc U is the air core flow rate after adding the foaming agent; lf is the liquid film velocity on the wall side; ε f is the air content in the foam.
[0149] According to the law of conservation of energy, the gas phase flow rate expression for forming foam can be obtained as follows:
[0150]
[0151] In the formula, v fe The gas phase flow rate required to form foam; v lf Liquid phase flow rate required to form foam; C J is an empirical coefficient, generally set to 1. The adjustment of this value can also explain the combined impact of the imprecision introduced by the estimated numerical constants used in various sub-models; d crit is the maximum size that the foam can reach in a stable state; We is a dimensionless number that affects the foam flow; We c is the critical value of the Weber number.
[0152] The dimensionless number We affecting foam flow and its critical value We c The calculation formula is:
[0153]
[0154]
[0155] In the formula, ρ l is the liquid density; D is the pipe diameter; U ls is the flow rate after foam formation; Ulf is the liquid film velocity on the wall side; σ is the surface tension of the foaming agent; C is the empirical coefficient, generally taken as 2 / 3; d crit It is the maximum size that the foam can reach in a stable state.
[0156] The maximum size that the foam can reach in a stable state is expressed as:
[0157] Where β' is the function of the well inclination angle; E od It is a dimensionless coefficient describing the flow characteristics of three phases of gas, water and foam.
[0158] The specific expression of the contact angle function is:
[0159] Where β is the well inclination angle.
[0160] The dimensionless coefficient expression of the three-phase flow characteristics of air, water and foam is:
[0161] Where Δρ is the liquid density difference; g is the gravitational acceleration; D is the pipe diameter; σ is the surface tension of the foaming agent.
[0162] The flow rate expression after foam formation is:
[0163] Where U m is the mixed phase flow rate of gas, water and foam; ε w is the gas content in the gas-liquid mixed phase; U gls is the bubble velocity in the gas-liquid mixed phase.
[0164] The specific expression of bubble velocity in gas-liquid mixed phase is: U gls =C w U m +U w (39);
[0165] In the formula, C w is a coefficient related to bubble concentration and velocity; U m is the mixed phase flow rate of gas, water and foam; U w is the drift speed.
[0166] The expression of drift velocity is:
[0167] Where σ is the surface tension; g is the acceleration due to gravity; ρ l is the liquid density; ρ g is the gas phase density; β is the well inclination angle; ε w is the gas fraction of the gas-liquid miscible phase.
[0168] The expression of the air core flow rate after adding the foaming agent is: U gc =C f U m +U f (41);
[0169] In the formula, C f is the coefficient related to velocity distribution; U m is the mixed phase flow rate of gas, water and foam; U f It is the rising speed of foam in the three-phase mixture of air, water and foam.
[0170] The specific expression of the rising speed of foam in a mixture of air, water and foam is:
[0171]
[0172]
[0173]
[0174] Where Δρ is the density difference; ρ l is the liquid density; g is the gravitational acceleration; D is the pipe diameter; β is the well inclination angle.
[0175] S303: According to the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and the foam film, a relationship between the foaming agent and the wellbore pressure gradient is constructed to obtain the wellbore pressure drop. The optimal treatment agent type can also be selected with the maximum pressure drop effect as the goal.
[0176] Specifically: Based on the principle of foam force balance, the relationship between the foaming agent and the wellbore pressure gradient is constructed:
[0177] The effect of foaming agent on wellbore pressure drop is calculated according to the following formula:
[0178]
[0179]
[0180] Where dp / dh is the wellbore pressure gradient, τ l is the shear stress at the gas phase and foam interface, S l is the perimeter of the gas phase and foam film interface, A c is the cross-sectional area of the air core, ρ c is the foam density, β is the well inclination angle, f i1 is the interfacial friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film, v c and v f are the air core and foam flow rates, respectively.
[0181] S4: According to step S3, the critical flow rate of the gas-carrying foam, the surface tension of the foaming agent, and the wellbore pressure drop are obtained, and the drainage effect of the foaming agent is evaluated, thereby comprehensively reflecting the effect of the foaming agent.
[0182] The foaming agent drainage effect evaluation method provided by the present invention is based on an indoor foam drainage simulation evaluation device, and a calculation model for the friction coefficient of the gas core and foam film interface is constructed. The model comprehensively considers the influence of factors such as the complex wellbore structure, wellbore trajectory, temperature, pressure and salinity of water in each formation during the foam drainage implementation process; the provided effect evaluation method also comprehensively considers the interaction between the gas phase and the foam and the annular foam flow theoretical analysis method. It solves the problem that the existing wellbore liquid carrying model does not consider the foam flow, and constructs a foam carrying analysis model that is easy to calculate and solve, and the critical foam carrying flow rate calculation error is less than 10%; and the results obtained by indoor simulation experiments can be combined to combine the indoor evaluation with the wellbore foaming analysis model, and the effect of the foaming agent is comprehensively reflected through the macroscopic pressure gradient, the critical flow rate of gas carrying foam and the surface tension required to generate bubbles.
[0183] The present invention can also evaluate the influence of the foaming agent on factors such as liquid holdup, foam holdup, gas volume fraction in foam, and friction coefficient between foam and gas phase according to the obtained foaming analysis model; and use the above foaming analysis model to evaluate the influence of the foaming agent on the wellbore pressure gradient and critical foaming flow rate. And obtain the optimal type and optimal addition amount of the foaming agent, and obtain an optimized design scheme.
[0184] The present invention is described below through specific application examples.
[0185] Application Example 1:
[0186] (1) The liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent is obtained by testing with an indoor simulation experimental device;
[0187] Fluorinated surfactant HXJ-1 and sodium dodecylbenzene sulfonate SDBS were selected to test their liquid carrying coefficients. By adjusting the concentration of different surfactants, the corresponding foaming agent liquid carrying coefficient can be calculated, such as Figure 3 As shown. Figure 3 It can be seen that with the increase of surfactant concentration, the liquid carrying coefficient gradually increases and remains stable. Fluorine surfactant HXJ-1 can achieve a large liquid carrying coefficient at a relatively low concentration, so it has a better foaming effect.
[0188] (2) According to S102 to S105, basic parameters are calculated;
[0189] (3) According to S201 and S202, the flow rate of the air core and the foam film, and the interface friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film are calculated;
[0190] (4) Calculate the critical velocity of gas-carrying foam as the amount of foaming agent added changes;
[0191] According to S301, the critical gas phase bubble velocity of the solution after adding the surfactant is calculated and compared with the experimental observation value. Figure 4 As shown in . Figure 4 It can be seen that the predicted critical entrainment velocity is well consistent with the observed critical velocity, which indicates that the entrainment analysis model of the present invention has good calculation accuracy and the calculation error is less than 10%.
[0192] The model of the present invention predicts the influence of the type and amount of the foaming agent on the critical bubble entrainment velocity of the gas phase, such as Figure 5 As shown. Figure 5 It can be seen that the fluorine-based surfactant HXJ-1 has a more significant effect on reducing the critical flow rate. Therefore, the influence of the surfactant on the critical bubble flow rate of the gas can be calculated through the model of the present invention to determine its bubble removal effect.
[0193] (5) Calculate the effect of the foaming agent on the wellbore pressure gradient;
[0194] According to S303, the effect of the surfactant on the wellbore pressure drop is calculated and compared with the wellbore pressure drop obtained by experimental testing, such as Figure 6 As shown. Figure 6 It can be seen that the error between the predicted wellbore pressure drop and the experimental value is small, indicating that the model has good calculation accuracy and the calculation error is less than 10%.
[0195] According to the model, the influence of the type and amount of foaming agent on the pressure drop in the wellbore is predicted, such as Figure 7 As shown. Figure 7 It can be seen that HXJ-1 has a better effect in reducing the wellbore pressure drop. As the concentration of the foaming agent increases, the pressure drop in the wellbore decreases. The foaming agent with better foaming performance also has a lower wellbore pressure drop. Therefore, the performance of the foaming agent can be judged by the size of the wellbore pressure drop.
[0196] (6) Calculate the surface tension properties of surfactants required for foaming
[0197] According to S302, the relationship between the wellbore foaming flow rate and the surface tension is calculated. The calculation results are as follows Figure 8 As shown. Figure 8 It can be seen that as the surface tension decreases, the gas mass flow rate required for wellbore foaming gradually decreases. When the actual gas mass flow rate is 1.4 kg·m 2 / s, the gas surface tension needs to be reduced to below 47mN / m; when the actual gas mass flow rate is 1.2kg·m 2 / s, the gas surface tension needs to be reduced to below 41mN / m.
[0198] Application Example 2:
[0199] (1) The liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent is obtained by testing with an indoor simulation experimental device;
[0200] Betaine surfactant TCJ-1 and zwitterionic Gmini surfactant were selected to test their liquid carrying coefficients. By adjusting the concentration of different surfactants, the corresponding foaming agent liquid carrying coefficient can be calculated, such as Fig. 9 shown.
[0201] Depend on Fig. 9 It can be seen that with the increase of surfactant concentration, the liquid carrying coefficient gradually increases and remains stable. Zwitterionic Gmini surfactant can achieve a large liquid carrying coefficient at a relatively low concentration, so it has a better foaming effect.
[0202] (2) According to S102 to S105, basic parameters are calculated;
[0203] (3) According to S201 and S202, the flow rate of the air core and the foam film, and the interface friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film are calculated;
[0204] (4) Calculate the critical velocity of gas-carrying foam as the amount of foaming agent added changes;
[0205] According to S301, the critical gas phase bubble velocity of the solution after adding the surfactant is calculated and compared with the experimental observation value. The results are as follows: Fig.10 As shown. Fig.10 It can be seen that the predicted critical bubble entrainment velocity is consistent with the observed critical velocity, which shows that the model has good calculation accuracy and the calculation error is less than 10%.
[0206] According to the model, the influence of the type and amount of foaming agent on the critical bubble velocity of the gas phase is predicted, such as Fig.11 As shown. Fig.11 It can be seen that the zwitterionic Gmini surfactant has a more significant effect on reducing the critical flow velocity. Therefore, the model can be used to calculate the effect of surfactants on the critical bubble flow velocity of gas and determine its bubble removal effect.
[0207] (5) Calculate the effect of the foaming agent on the wellbore pressure gradient;
[0208] According to S303, the effect of the surfactant on the wellbore pressure drop is calculated and compared with the wellbore pressure drop obtained by experimental testing. Fig.12 As shown. Fig.12 It can be seen that the error between the predicted wellbore pressure drop and the experimental value is small, indicating that the model has good calculation accuracy and the calculation error is less than 10%.
[0209] According to the model, the influence of the type and amount of foaming agent on the pressure drop in the wellbore is predicted, such as Fig.13 As shown. Fig.13 It can be seen that as the concentration of the foaming agent increases, the foam can carry more liquid phase, so the pressure drop in the wellbore increases. The foaming agent with better foaming performance also has a larger wellbore pressure drop. Therefore, the performance of the foaming agent can be judged by the size of the wellbore pressure drop. From the wellbore pressure drop effect, it can be seen that the zwitterionic Gmini surfactant has the best effect in reducing the wellbore pressure drop.
[0210] (6) Calculate the surface tension properties of surfactants required for foaming
[0211] Select Gemini surfactant and calculate the relationship between wellbore foaming velocity and surface tension according to S302. The calculation results are as follows: Fig.14 As shown. Fig.14 It can be seen that as the surface tension decreases, the gas mass flow rate required for wellbore foaming gradually decreases. When the actual gas mass flow rate is 1.4 kg·m 2 / s, the gas surface tension needs to be reduced to below 55mN / m; when the actual gas mass flow rate is 1.2kg·m 2 / s, the gas surface tension needs to be reduced to below 54mN / m.
[0212] Application Example 3:
[0213] (1) The liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent is obtained by testing with an indoor simulation experimental device;
[0214] Gemini surfactant SJS and amino acid surfactant AJS were selected to test their liquid carrying coefficients. By adjusting the concentration of different surfactants, the corresponding foaming agent liquid carrying coefficient can be calculated, such as Fig.15 As shown. Fig.15 It can be seen that with the increase of surfactant concentration, the liquid carrying coefficient gradually increases and remains stable. The Gemini surfactant SJS can achieve a larger liquid carrying coefficient at a relatively low concentration, and therefore has a better foaming effect.
[0215] (2) According to S102 to S105, basic parameters are calculated;
[0216] (3) According to S201 and S202, the flow rate of the air core and the foam film, and the interface friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film are calculated;
[0217] (4) Calculate the critical velocity of gas-carrying foam as the amount of foaming agent added changes;
[0218] According to S301, the critical gas phase bubble velocity of the solution after adding the surfactant is calculated and compared with the experimental observation value. The results are as follows: Fig.16 shown.
[0219] Depend on Fig.16 It can be seen that the predicted critical bubble entrainment velocity is consistent with the observed critical velocity, which shows that the model has good calculation accuracy and the calculation error is less than 10%.
[0220] According to the model, the influence of the type and amount of foaming agent on the critical bubble velocity of the gas phase is predicted, such as Fig.17 shown.
[0221] Depend on Fig.17 It can be seen that the gemini surfactant SJS has a more significant effect on reducing the critical flow velocity. Therefore, the model can be used to calculate the effect of surfactants on the critical bubble flow velocity of gas and determine its bubble removal effect.
[0222] (5) Calculate the effect of the foaming agent on the wellbore pressure gradient;
[0223] According to S303, the effect of the surfactant on the wellbore pressure drop is calculated and compared with the wellbore pressure drop obtained by experimental testing. Fig.18 As shown. Fig.18 It can be seen that the error between the predicted wellbore pressure drop and the experimental value is small, indicating that the model has good calculation accuracy and the calculation error is less than 10%.
[0224] According to the model, the influence of the type and amount of foaming agent on the pressure drop in the wellbore is predicted, such as Fig.19 As shown. Fig.19 It can be seen that the Gemini surfactant SJS has a better effect in reducing the wellbore pressure drop. As the concentration of the foaming agent increases, the pressure drop in the wellbore decreases. The foaming agent with better foaming performance also has a lower wellbore pressure drop. Therefore, the performance of the foaming agent can be judged by the size of the wellbore pressure drop.
[0225] (6) Calculate the surface tension properties of surfactants required for foaming
[0226] According to S302, the relationship between the wellbore foaming flow rate and the surface tension is calculated. The calculation results are as follows: Fig. 20 As shown. Fig. 20 It can be seen that as the surface tension decreases, the gas mass flow rate required for wellbore foaming gradually decreases. When the actual gas mass flow rate is 1.4 kg·m 2 / s, the gas surface tension needs to be reduced to below 42mN / m; when the actual gas mass flow rate is 1.2kg·m 2 / s, the gas surface tension needs to be reduced to below 39mN / m.
[0227] Through the above Examples 1 to 3, it can be seen that the error between the predicted result obtained by the foaming agent drainage effect evaluation method of the present invention and the experimental measured result is less than 10%, and the calculation accuracy is high and the prediction accuracy is high.
[0228] The present invention also provides an effect evaluation system, a computer device, and a computer-readable storage medium, which are described below through embodiments.
[0229] Embodiment 2:
[0230] The present invention also provides a foaming agent drainage effect evaluation system for shale gas reservoir development. The system described below and the foaming agent drainage effect evaluation method for shale gas reservoir development described above can be referenced to each other.
[0231] A foaming agent drainage effect evaluation system for shale gas reservoir development, comprising:
[0232] A liquid carrying coefficient acquisition module is used to obtain the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent;
[0233] A parameter acquisition module, used to calculate basic parameters according to the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent;
[0234] The first model building module is used to build a calculation model of the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and the foam film according to basic parameters;
[0235] The second model building module is used to construct a critical velocity calculation model of gas-carrying foam after adding a surfactant according to the interface friction coefficient between the gas core and the foam film, so as to obtain the critical velocity of gas-carrying foam; and to construct a correlation function between the surface tension of the foaming agent and the foaming velocity of the wellbore to obtain the surface tension of the foaming agent;
[0236] The third model building module is used to construct a relationship between the foaming agent and the wellbore pressure gradient according to the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and the foam film to obtain the wellbore pressure drop.
[0237] Embodiment 3:
[0238] The present invention also provides a computer device, and the device described below and the method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development described above can be referenced to each other.
[0239] A computer device comprises a memory, a processor and a computer program stored in the memory and executable on the processor, wherein the processor implements the above-mentioned method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development when executing the computer program.
[0240] Embodiment 4:
[0241] The present invention provides a computer-readable storage medium. The computer-readable medium described below and the method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development described above can be referred to each other.
[0242] A computer-readable storage medium stores a computer program, which, when executed by a processor, implements the above-mentioned method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development.
[0243] The processes and methods not mentioned in the present invention are all known technologies or obtained through known technologies and will not be described in detail here.
[0244] It will be appreciated by those skilled in the art that embodiments of the present invention may be provided as methods, devices, or computer program products. Therefore, the present invention may take the form of a complete hardware embodiment, a complete software embodiment, or an embodiment combining software and hardware. Moreover, the present invention may take the form of a computer program product implemented on one or more computer-usable storage media (including but not limited to disk storage, CD / ROM, optical storage, etc.) containing computer-usable program codes.
[0245] The present invention is described with reference to flowcharts and / or block diagrams of methods, devices (apparatus), and computer program products according to embodiments of the present invention. It should be understood that each process and / or block in the flowchart and / or block diagram, as well as the combination of processes and / or blocks in the flowchart and / or block diagram, can be implemented by computer program instructions. These computer program instructions can be provided to a processor of a general-purpose computer, a special-purpose computer, an embedded processor, or other programmable data processing device to generate a machine, so that the instructions executed by the processor of the computer or other programmable data processing device generate instructions for implementing the processes in the flowchart and / or block diagram. Figure 1 A process or multiple processes and / or boxes Figure 1 A device that provides the functions specified in a block or multiple blocks.
[0246] These computer program instructions may also be stored in a computer-readable memory capable of directing a computer or other programmable data processing device to operate in a specific manner, so that the instructions stored in the computer-readable memory produce an article of manufacture comprising an instruction device, which implements the process Figure 1 A process or multiple processes and / or boxes Figure 1 A function specified in one or more boxes.
[0247] These computer program instructions can also be loaded onto a computer or other programmable data processing device so that a series of operating steps are executed on the computer or other programmable device to produce a computer-implemented process, thereby providing instructions for implementing the process. Figure 1A process or multiple processes and / or boxes Figure 1 The steps for the functions specified in one or more boxes.
[0248] The above is only a specific embodiment of the present invention, and cannot be used to limit the scope of the invention. Therefore, the replacement of equivalent components, or equivalent changes and modifications made according to the protection scope of the patent of the present invention, should still fall within the scope of this patent. In addition, the technical features of the present invention can be freely combined with each other, with each other and with each other, and with each other.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development, It is characterized in that include: S1: basic parameters are calculated based on the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent; S2: Construct the calculation model of flow velocity and interface friction coefficient of air core and foam film according to basic parameters; S3: According to the interface friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film: A calculation model for the critical velocity of gas-carried foam after adding surfactant is constructed to obtain the critical velocity of gas-carried foam; Constructing the correlation function between the surface tension of the foaming agent and the foaming flow rate of the wellbore to obtain the surface tension of the foaming agent; According to the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and foam film, the relationship between the foaming agent and the wellbore pressure gradient is constructed to obtain the wellbore pressure drop; S4: Evaluate the drainage effect of the foaming agent based on the critical flow rate of the gas-carrying foam, the surface tension of the foaming agent, and the wellbore pressure drop.
2. A method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to claim 1, It is characterized in that The basic parameters include the average liquid holdup and foam holdup of the wellbore, the gas volume fraction in the foam, the foam density, and the size parameters of the gas core and the bubble.
3. A method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to claim 2, It is characterized in that Based on the relationship between gas content and gas and liquid superficial velocity, the average liquid holdup and bubble holdup of the wellbore are calculated. The gas volume fraction in the foam is calculated based on the empirical relationship between the wellbore's bubble holding rate and the superficial flow rates of the gas and liquid phases; The foam density is calculated based on linear interpolation.
4. A method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to claim 1, It is characterized in that Based on the relationship between the tube diameter, dimensionless foam film thickness, gas volume fraction in the bubble, and gas phase apparent velocity, a velocity calculation model for the gas core and foam film is constructed. The gas core flow rate is: In the formula, v c is the air core flow rate before adding the foaming agent, is the dimensionless foam film thickness, v sg is the gas phase superficial velocity, f g is the volume fraction of gas in the bubble, v sl is the liquid phase superficial velocity; The foam film flow rate is: In the formula, v f is the foam film flow rate, D is the oil pipe diameter; d f is the thickness of the liquid film, v sl is the liquid phase superficial velocity, f g is the volume fraction of gas in the bubble.
5. A method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to claim 1, It is characterized in that Based on the empirical relationship between Reynolds number and dimensionless foam film thickness, a calculation model for the interface friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film is constructed. In the formula, f i1 is the interfacial friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film, Re is the apparent gas phase Reynolds number, is the dimensionless foam film thickness, ρ g is the gas phase density, v sg is the gas phase superficial velocity, D is the oil pipe diameter, μ g is the gas phase viscosity.
6. A method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to claim 1, It is characterized in that Based on the relationship between the shear stress derivative function between the gas and foam film interface and the dimensionless foam film thickness, a calculation model for the critical flow velocity of gas-carrying foam was constructed using the Newton iteration method.
7. A method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to claim 6, It is characterized in that The critical gas-carrying foam velocity calculation formula is: In the formula, v gc is the critical gas phase foam carrying velocity, f i1 is the interfacial friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film, ρ f is the foam density, D is the tubing diameter, β is the well inclination, C f is the constant for calculating the friction coefficient of the foam film, μ f is the foam viscosity, v sl is the liquid phase superficial velocity, n f is the calculation index of the foam friction coefficient, and g is the acceleration due to gravity.
8. The method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to claim 1, It is characterized in that Based on the proportional relationship between surface energy and turbulent energy, a correlation function between the surface tension of the foaming agent and the wellbore foaming flow rate is established, wherein the wellbore foaming flow rate includes the gas phase flow rate and the liquid phase flow rate required for foam formation.
9. A method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to claim 8, It is characterized in that N t =N s ; Where N t is the turbulent kinetic energy; N s is the foam surface energy; Under the condition of foam, water and gas three-phase flow, v fe The surface energy flux generated by the rate of breaking into bubbles is as follows: Where N s is the surface energy flux; σ is the surface tension; d 32 is the characteristic particle size; v fe The gas phase flow rate required for foam formation; The liquid phase flow rate required for foam formation is calculated as follows: v lf =(U gc -U lf )(1-ε f ); The expression of gas phase flow rate for foam formation is: In the formula, v lf The liquid phase flow rate required for foam formation; U gc U is the air core flow rate after adding the foaming agent; lf is the liquid film velocity on the wall side; ε f is the air content in the foam; C J is the empirical coefficient; d crit is the maximum size that the foam can reach in a stable state; We is a dimensionless number that affects the foam flow; We c is the critical value of the Weber number.
10. The method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to claim 1, It is characterized in that Based on the principle of foam force balance, the relationship between the foaming agent and the wellbore pressure gradient is constructed: Where dp / dh is the wellbore pressure gradient, τ l is the shear stress at the gas phase and foam interface, S l is the perimeter of the gas phase and foam film interface, A c is the cross-sectional area of the air core, ρ c is the foam density, β is the well inclination angle, f i1 is the interfacial friction coefficient between the air core and the foam film, v c and v f are the air core and foam film flow rates, respectively.
11. A foaming agent drainage effect evaluation system for shale gas reservoir development, It is characterized in that include; A liquid carrying coefficient acquisition module is used to obtain the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent; A parameter acquisition module, used to calculate basic parameters according to the liquid carrying coefficient of the foaming agent; The first model building module is used to build a calculation model of the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and the foam film according to basic parameters; The second model building module is used to construct a critical velocity calculation model of gas-carrying foam after adding a surfactant according to the interface friction coefficient between the gas core and the foam film, so as to obtain the critical velocity of gas-carrying foam; and to construct a correlation function between the surface tension of the foaming agent and the foaming velocity of the wellbore to obtain the surface tension of the foaming agent; The third model building module is used to construct a relationship between the foaming agent and the wellbore pressure gradient according to the flow rate and interface friction coefficient of the air core and the foam film to obtain the wellbore pressure drop.
12. A computer device comprising a memory, a processor, and a computer program stored in the memory and executable on the processor, wherein when the processor executes the computer program, the method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 10 is implemented.
13. A computer-readable storage medium having a computer program stored thereon, wherein when the computer program is executed by a processor, the method for evaluating the drainage effect of a foaming agent for shale gas reservoir development according to any one of claims 1 to 10 is implemented.
