Simplified evaluation method for vibration of energy-saving device in front of propeller
Through parameter sensitivity analysis and simplified finite element modal analysis, the problem of long-term vibration performance evaluation of energy-saving devices in front of the paddle is solved, and rapid and accurate vibration performance evaluation is achieved, improving the efficiency and safety of structural design.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411150191.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-08-21
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-08-21
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is complex and time-consuming when evaluating the vibration performance of energy-saving devices in front of the paddle, making it difficult to quickly achieve accurate vibration performance evaluation, especially due to the low stiffness of the catheter and the prone to resonance.
Through parameter sensitivity analysis, the influence of the catheter outer plate thickness, internal diaphragm and elbow plate on the modality of the energy-saving device in front of the paddle was determined, and a simplified finite element mode analysis model was established, and a simple branch boundary condition was applied, and a finite element mode calculation was performed. Use the first three-order vibration modes to improve evaluation efficiency and accuracy.
The rapid vibration performance evaluation of the energy-saving device in front of the paddle is achieved, the efficiency is greatly improved, the calculation results are close to the traditional finite element method, and have good practical value, guiding structural design to avoid resonance.
Smart Images

Figure CN118965584A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of vibration performance evaluation of a ship propeller front energy-saving device, and in particular to a simplified vibration evaluation method of a propeller front energy-saving device using a modal analysis method. Background Art
[0002] like Figure 1 As shown in the figure, the propeller front energy-saving device (also called "front duct") is a device installed in front of the propeller to improve the energy efficiency of the ship by improving the flow field. It has a simple structure, is easy to install, has excellent energy-saving effects, and is widely used by domestic and foreign shipowners. It mainly includes guide pipes, guide fins (if any), connected brackets or guide plates and other appendages. The guide pipe has a ring-shaped structure and is referred to as a guide pipe; the guide fin has a radial structure and is referred to as a fin.
[0003] From a structural point of view, the cross section of the duct (fin) is usually wing-shaped, such as Figure 2 As shown. The duct (fin) is welded by transverse and longitudinal partitions and inner and outer shell plates, and the ends are generally round tubes or round steel. The front duct is a slender structure with an aspect ratio of up to 14.5. Due to its weak stiffness, the first-order natural frequency of the duct is also relatively low. In particular, the pre-swirl duct is prone to low-frequency resonance with the propeller, causing vibration fatigue damage. Once the duct falls off, it may even damage the propeller. There have been cases in China where cracks were found at the fixed end of the front duct at the stern of an oil tanker and the hull. Analysis showed that the damage was caused by the resonance of the duct with the hull in the water.
[0004] Since there is a certain vibration risk in the propeller front energy-saving device, its product development needs to use the finite element method to evaluate the vibration performance. This method is mature and reliable, but the modeling workload is large and time-consuming. Summary of the invention
[0005] The purpose of the present invention is to solve the technical problems existing in the background technology. To this end, a simplified vibration evaluation method for a propeller-front energy-saving device is provided. In order to reveal the vibration characteristics of the propeller-front energy-saving device, a parameter sensitivity analysis is firstly carried out on the component structure of the propeller-front energy-saving device, including the stern, toggle plate, internal partition, outer plate thickness, etc., so as to determine the structure that plays a dominant role in the mode of the propeller-front energy-saving device: the thickness of the outer plate of the duct, the internal cross partition, and the toggle plate.
[0006] In order to achieve the above object, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is as follows:
[0007] A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy-saving device comprises the following steps:
[0008] Step S1: performing parameter sensitivity analysis on the component structure of the propeller front energy-saving device;
[0009] Step S2: determining the component structure that plays a leading role in the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device;
[0010] Step S3: Based on the component structure determined in step S2, a simplified model for vibration evaluation of the propeller front energy-saving device is established;
[0011] Step S4: applying simply supported boundary conditions to the unit nodes connecting the energy-saving device in front of the propeller and the hull;
[0012] Step S5: adjust the unit normal, start the fluid domain, define the single / double-sided immersion unit, and set the VMOPT parameters;
[0013] Step S6: Perform finite element modal calculation and output the first three vibration modes of the propeller front energy-saving device.
[0014] The following is a technical solution further defined by the present invention. Factors that are sensitive to parameters of the composition structure of the propeller front energy-saving device include: the stern, the toggle plate, the internal partition, and the thickness of the outer plate of the duct.
[0015] The following is a technical solution further defined by the present invention, which performs parameter sensitivity analysis on the component structure of the stern to the propeller front energy-saving device, so as to determine the influence of the stern on the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device, including: setting two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices, and the two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices respectively adopt independent models and overall models; the model range of the independent model only includes the propeller front energy-saving device itself, and a simply supported constraint is applied at the connection between the propeller front energy-saving device and the main hull structure; the model range of the overall model is connected to the stern casting through the root of the fin, and is connected to the hull through the elbow plate at the front end of the duct; and the modal calculation results of the two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices using independent models or overall models are compared.
[0016] The following is a technical solution further defined by the present invention, in which the first-order natural frequency error value between the independent model and the overall model is within 13%.
[0017] The following is a technical solution further defined by the present invention, in which a parameter sensitivity analysis of the component structure of the toggle plate on the propeller front energy-saving device is performed to determine the influence of the toggle plate on the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device, including: setting two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices, both using an overall model; the overall model of one group of propeller front energy-saving devices has a toggle plate, and the overall model of the other group of propeller front energy-saving devices does not have a toggle plate; and comparing the modal calculation results of the two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices.
[0018] The following is a technical solution further defined by the present invention. For the propeller-front energy-saving device, the duct located above the axis is connected to the mid-longitudinal section through a vertical bracket. To avoid lateral vibration of the duct, a bracket parallel to the outer side surface of the duct is provided at the upper front end of the duct and connected to the outer plate of the hull.
[0019] The following is a technical solution further defined by the present invention, which performs parameter sensitivity analysis on the component structure of the propeller-front energy-saving device of the internal baffle, so as to determine the influence of the internal baffle on the mode of the propeller-front energy-saving device, including: setting up two groups of propeller-front energy-saving devices, both using an overall model; comparing the modes of the two groups of propeller-front energy-saving devices containing different types of baffles.
[0020] The following is a technical solution further limited by the present invention, and different types of partitions include: no partition, only longitudinal partition, only transverse partition, and original model.
[0021] The following is a technical solution further defined by the present invention, which performs parameter sensitivity analysis on the component structure of the propeller-front energy-saving device according to the thickness of the outer plate of the duct, so as to determine the influence of the outer plate thickness on the mode of the propeller-front energy-saving device, including: setting two groups of propeller-front energy-saving devices, both of which adopt an overall model; adjusting the outer plate thickness of the duct based on the main plate thickness of the duct, so as to compare the modal calculation results of the two groups of propeller-front energy-saving devices under different duct outer plate thicknesses.
[0022] The following is a technical solution further defined by the present invention, and the components that play a leading role in the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device include: the thickness of the outer plate of the duct, the internal diaphragm, and the toggle plate.
[0023] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following technical effects:
[0024] The present invention establishes a simplified vibration evaluation method based on finite element modal analysis, which can be implemented quickly and achieve a certain accuracy, thereby realizing a rapid evaluation of vibration performance in the design stage of the propeller front energy-saving device.
[0025] The first-order natural frequency of the propeller front energy-saving device obtained by the simplified vibration evaluation method of the present invention is very close to the calculation result of the traditional finite element method, but the efficiency is greatly improved, and it has good practical value;
[0026] Through parameter sensitivity analysis, the present invention finds that the diaphragm and bracket play a leading role in the first-order natural frequency of the duct, while the thickness of the outer plate has little effect on the first-order natural frequency. These conclusions can guide the structural design of the propeller front energy-saving device and help designers take more effective measures to avoid resonance.
[0027] The present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and embodiments. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0028] In order to more clearly illustrate the embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the prior art will be briefly introduced below. Obviously, the drawings described below are only some embodiments of the present invention. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without paying creative work.
[0029] Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram of the energy-saving device in front of the propeller installed on a real ship;
[0030] Figure 2 It is a cross-sectional view of the duct wing shape of the energy saving device in front of the propeller;
[0031] Figure 3 This is a comparison chart of the modal analysis results of the energy-saving device in front of the 177K-BC propeller;
[0032] Figure 4 This is a comparison chart of the modal analysis results of the energy-saving device in front of the propeller of 308K-VLCC;
[0033] Figure 5 is a schematic diagram of the structure of the bracket;
[0034] Figure 6 This is a comparison chart of the effect of the bracket of the propeller front energy-saving device of 177K-BC and 308K-VLCC on the natural frequency of the duct;
[0035] Figure 7 It is a schematic diagram of the structure of the transverse / longitudinal partition inside the catheter;
[0036] Figure 8 This is a comparison chart of the effect of the partition of the energy-saving device in front of the propeller of 177K-BC and 308K-VLCC on the natural frequency of the energy-saving device;
[0037] Fig. 9 This is the outer plate thickness cloud diagram of the energy-saving device in front of the propeller of 177K-BC and 308K-VLCC;
[0038] Fig.10 This is a comparison chart of the effect of the outer plate thickness of the energy-saving device in front of the propeller of 177K-BC and 308K-VLCC on the mode of the front duct;
[0039] Fig.11 is a method flow chart;
[0040] Fig.12 This is the modal analysis result diagram of the energy-saving device in front of the 114K-OT propeller;
[0041] Fig.13 This is the modal analysis result diagram of the energy-saving device in front of the 76K-BC propeller;
[0042] Fig.14 This is the modal analysis result diagram of the energy-saving device in front of the 57K-BC propeller. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0043] In order to make the above-mentioned objects, features and advantages of the present invention more obvious and easy to understand, the specific embodiments of the present invention are described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. In the following description, many specific details are set forth to facilitate a full understanding of the present invention. However, the present invention can be implemented in many other ways different from those described herein, and those skilled in the art can make similar improvements without violating the connotation of the present invention, so the present invention is not limited by the specific embodiments disclosed below.
[0044] like Fig.11 As shown, a simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy-saving device is provided, comprising the following steps:
[0045] Step S1: performing parameter sensitivity analysis on the component structure of the propeller front energy-saving device;
[0046] Step S2: determining the component structure that plays a leading role in the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device;
[0047] Step S3: Based on the component structure determined in step S2, a simplified model for vibration evaluation of the propeller front energy-saving device is established;
[0048] Step S4: applying simply supported boundary conditions to the unit nodes connecting the energy-saving device in front of the propeller and the hull;
[0049] Step S5: adjust the unit normal, start the fluid domain, define the single / double-sided immersion unit, and set the VMOPT parameters;
[0050] Step S6: Perform finite element modal calculation and output the first three vibration modes of the propeller front energy-saving device.
[0051] (1) Modal influence of the stern of the hull on the energy-saving device in front of the propeller
[0052] The model range only includes the energy-saving device itself (referred to as the "independent model"), and a simple support constraint is applied at the connection between the energy-saving device and the main hull structure. Generally speaking, the "overall model" can accurately reflect the natural mode of the front duct compared to the "independent model". The "independent model" takes much less time to pre-process than the "overall model" and has higher modal calculation efficiency. However, the accuracy of the results, that is, the influence of the model range on the front duct mode, needs further analysis. Comparison of the modal calculation results of the 177K-BC and 308K-VLCC models Figure 3 and 4 shown.
[0053] The error values of the first-order natural frequencies calculated by the two models are within 13%, and the first three vibration modes are relatively close. The pre-swirl duct is mainly connected to the stern casting through the root of the fin, and the front end of the duct is connected to the hull through the bracket. The error generated by the modal calculation of the "independent model" and the "integral model" mainly comes from the boundary difference of the bracket, but the error value can be controlled within a reasonable range.
[0054] In summary, the “independent model” has the advantage of high computational efficiency, and the error value of the “independent model” is within an acceptable range.
[0055] (2) Effect of bracket on propeller front energy saving device mode
[0056] For the propeller front energy-saving device, the duct located above the axis is usually connected to the mid-longitudinal section through a vertical bracket. In order to avoid lateral vibration of the duct, a bracket parallel to the outer side of the duct is generally set at the front end of the upper part of the duct (set on both sides of the mid-longitudinal vertical bracket) and connected to the outer plate of the hull, such as Figure 5 shown.
[0057] The “overall model” is used for both 177K-BC and 308K-VLCC energy-saving devices. Figure 6 As shown in the figure, by comparing the influence of the bracket on the natural frequency of the energy-saving device, it can be seen that the addition of the bracket has a significant impact on the first three-order natural frequencies of the duct. The bracket will significantly increase the first three-order natural frequencies of the duct, especially for the first-order natural frequency, which increases by 83% for the 177K-BC energy-saving device and 240% for the 308K-VLCC energy-saving device.
[0058] For structural designers, in order to prevent resonance between the pre-swirl duct and the propeller, the vibration mode and natural frequency of the duct can be significantly changed by adding a bracket, so as to avoid the blade frequency and double blade frequency of the propeller. Therefore, during the vibration assessment stage, the vibration assessment model must consider the influence of the bracket.
[0059] (3) Analysis of the influence of internal partitions on the propeller front energy-saving device mode
[0060] The interior of the propeller front energy saving device duct and the fin is provided with longitudinal and transverse supporting partition members, and the partition schematic diagram is shown in FIG. Figure 7 shown.
[0061] Based on the two sets of energy-saving devices, 177K-BC and 308K-VLCC, the “overall model” is used to compare the modes of energy-saving devices containing different types of partitions (no partition, only longitudinal partition, only transverse partition, original model), such as Figure 8 As shown in the figure. The internal partition has a significant impact on the mode of the front duct. Adding a transverse partition or a longitudinal partition will increase the first three natural frequencies of the energy-saving device. As can be seen from the figure, if the duct containing only the outer plate is directly subjected to vibration evaluation, the first-order frequency will be within the range of the propeller blade frequency or double blade frequency, which can easily cause resonance of the energy-saving device and pose a hidden danger to the safety of the energy-saving device and the propeller.
[0062] It is worth noting that although adding transverse / longitudinal diaphragms will increase the fundamental frequency, there are differences in the effects of transverse and longitudinal diaphragms on the fundamental frequency of the front duct. Taking the first-order frequency as an example, the ratios of the longitudinal diaphragm energy-saving device and the original model are: 177K-BC (43%), 308K-VLCC (67%); the ratios of the transverse diaphragm energy-saving device and the original model are: 177K-BC (90%), 308K-VLCC (94%). The ratios of the first-order frequency of the energy-saving device containing only transverse diaphragms to the original model are all above 90%, which is closer to the modal results of the original model than the longitudinal diaphragm duct, indicating that the transverse diaphragm has a dominant influence on the overall modal of the front duct, and the longitudinal diaphragm has limited influence on the modal when the transverse diaphragm is already present. Since the number and arrangement of transverse diaphragms can be quickly determined according to the main dimensions of the duct, it is recommended not to consider the longitudinal diaphragm when conducting a rapid vibration assessment in the initial design stage, and only designing the transverse diaphragm can obtain more accurate vibration results.
[0063] (4) Analysis of the influence of the duct outer plate thickness on the propeller front energy saving device mode
[0064] During the structural design stage of the propeller front energy-saving device, the outer plate thickness of the duct and fin must meet the requirements of the specification for the hull tail outer plate, and also meet the requirements of the specification for the plate thickness under the tail slamming pressure. Taking the 177K-BC and 308K-VLCC energy-saving devices as examples, Fig. 9 This is a cloud diagram of the duct outer plate thickness. Generally, the duct plate thickness is slightly greater than the fin outer plate thickness, and the outer plate at the connection with the hull is partially thickened (mainly at the end of the fin), but the main body of the outer plate thickness does not change much.
[0065] The change of the outer plate thickness of the duct will affect the weight distribution of the energy-saving device, and thus have a certain impact on the mode of the energy-saving device. Based on the two sets of energy-saving devices, 177K-BC and 308K-VLCC, the "overall model" is used to adjust the plate thickness of the duct based on the main plate thickness of the duct. Based on this, the influence of the outer plate thickness on the mode of the energy-saving device is analyzed as follows Fig.10 As shown in Figure 2, with the gradual increase of the plate thickness, the first three natural frequencies of the type-four pre-duct tend to increase.
[0066] Structural designers are more concerned about the change in the first-order frequency after the local plate thickness is modified. Here, the calculation results of the type 2 duct are taken as an example. The initial design plate thickness of the 177K-BC duct is 15mm, and the first-order frequency is 15.1Hz. The thickness of the fin outer plate is reduced to 14mm in the detailed design stage, and the first-order frequency is reduced to 15Hz, with a frequency change of 0.6%; the initial design plate thickness of the 308K-VLCC duct is 20mm, and the first-order frequency is 13.8Hz. The thickness of the fin outer plate is reduced to 14mm, and the end outer plate is thickened. The first-order frequency increases to 13.5Hz, and the frequency changes by 2%. Since the local adjustment of the plate thickness has little effect on the first-order frequency, in the initial design stage, a simplified vibration evaluation based on the plate thickness recommended by the specification can obtain more accurate results.
[0067] In order to verify the correctness of this method, Figure 12-14 As shown in the figure, the first three natural frequencies calculated by the “simplified model” and “overall model” of the three propeller front energy-saving devices 114K-OT, 76K-BC and 57K-BC are compared, and the results of the “overall model” are used as a reference to evaluate the error value of the “simplified model” results.
[0068] By comparison, it is found that the first-order frequency calculated by the simplified model has an error value of 5% (114K-OT), 1% (76K-BC), and 8% (76K-BC) compared with the overall model result, which meets the calculation accuracy requirements. Compared with the traditional vibration assessment method that requires vibration assessment of the overall model, the pre-processing time of the simplified model is shortened by an average of 60%, greatly shortening the vibration assessment cycle.
[0069] The above is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention, and does not limit the present invention in any form. Any technician familiar with the art can make many possible changes and modifications to the technical solution of the present invention by using the above disclosed methods and technical contents without departing from the scope of the technical solution of the present invention, or modify it into an equivalent embodiment of equivalent changes. Therefore, all equivalent changes made according to the shape, structure and principle of the present invention without departing from the content of the technical solution of the present invention should be included in the protection scope of the present invention.
Claims
1. A simplified vibration assessment method for propeller front energy saving device, It is characterized in that The following steps are involved: Step S1: performing parameter sensitivity analysis on the component structure of the propeller front energy-saving device; Step S2: determining the component structure that plays a leading role in the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device; Step S3: Based on the component structure determined in step S2, a simplified model for vibration evaluation of the propeller front energy-saving device is established; Step S4: applying simply supported boundary conditions to the unit nodes connecting the energy-saving device in front of the propeller and the hull; Step S5: adjust the unit normal, start the fluid domain, define the single / double-sided immersion unit, and set the VMOPT parameters; Step S6: Perform finite element modal calculation and output the first three vibration modes of the propeller front energy-saving device.
2. A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy-saving device as claimed in claim 1, It is characterized in that The factors that are sensitive to the composition and structure of the propeller front energy-saving device include the stern, bracket, internal bulkhead, and duct outer plate thickness.
3. A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy-saving device as claimed in claim 2, It is characterized in that A parameter sensitivity analysis of the component structure of the stern to the propeller-front energy-saving device is carried out to determine the influence of the stern on the mode of the propeller-front energy-saving device, including: setting two groups of propeller-front energy-saving devices, and the two groups of propeller-front energy-saving devices adopt independent models and overall models respectively; the model range of the independent model only includes the propeller-front energy-saving device itself, and a simply supported constraint is imposed at the connection between the propeller-front energy-saving device and the main hull structure; the model range of the overall model is connected to the stern casting through the root of the fin, and is connected to the hull through a bracket in the front end of the duct; and the modal calculation results of the two groups of propeller-front energy-saving devices using independent models or overall models are compared.
4. A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy-saving device as claimed in claim 3, It is characterized in that The first-order natural frequency error value between the independent model and the overall model is within 13%.
5. A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy-saving device as claimed in claim 2, It is characterized in that A parameter sensitivity analysis of the component structure of the toggle plate on the propeller front energy-saving device is carried out to determine the influence of the toggle plate on the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device, including: setting two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices, both of which adopt the overall model; the overall model of one group of propeller front energy-saving devices has a toggle plate, and the overall model of the other group of propeller front energy-saving devices does not have a toggle plate; and comparing the modal calculation results of the two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices.
6. A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy-saving device as claimed in claim 5, It is characterized in that For the propeller-front energy-saving device, the duct located above the axis is connected to the mid-longitudinal section through a vertical bracket. To avoid lateral vibration of the duct, a bracket parallel to the outer side of the duct is provided at the upper front end of the duct and connected to the outer plate of the hull.
7. A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy saving device as claimed in claim 2, It is characterized in that A parameter sensitivity analysis of the internal baffle on the component structure of the propeller front energy-saving device is carried out to determine the influence of the internal baffle on the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device, including: setting up two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices, both using the overall model; and comparing the modes of the two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices containing different types of baffles.
8. A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy-saving device as claimed in claim 7, It is characterized in that Different types of partitions include: no partition, only longitudinal partition, only transverse partition, and original model.
9. A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy saving device as claimed in claim 2, It is characterized in that A parameter sensitivity analysis of the duct outer plate thickness on the component structure of the propeller front energy-saving device is carried out to determine the influence of the outer plate thickness on the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device, including: setting two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices, both using the overall model; taking the main plate thickness of the duct as the benchmark, adjusting the outer plate thickness of the duct, and comparing the modal calculation results of the two groups of propeller front energy-saving devices under different duct outer plate thicknesses.
10. A simplified vibration assessment method for a propeller front energy-saving device according to any one of claims 1 to 9, It is characterized in that The components that play a leading role in the mode of the propeller front energy-saving device include: the thickness of the duct outer plate, the internal diaphragm and the bracket.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Machine tool machining precision reliability and sensitivity analyzing method based on quick Markov chain
CN105760662A
Methods and apparatuses for etch profile optimization by reflectance spectra matching and surface kinetic model optimization
CN112526819A
Energy-saving guide wheel and ship
CN115959275A
Energy-saving guide wheel and ship
CN219524214U
