FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback

Through the signal voting method based on deviation feedback, the signal voting weight is adjusted in real time, which solves the problem of engine control abnormalities caused by signal acquisition deviation of FADEC system, and realizes accurate control and safe operation of engine status.

CN118997927AActive Publication Date: 2024-11-22CHINA AERONAUTICAL CONTROL SYST RES INST
View PDF 5 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202411103911.7
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-08-13
Publication Date
2024-11-22
Estimated Expiration
2044-08-13

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

During the signal acquisition process, the signal voting results deviate from reality due to differences in sensor characteristics and installation position during the FADEC system, causing the engine to operate in an unexpected state, affecting the accuracy and safety of engine control.

Method used

The signal voting method based on deviation feedback is adopted, and the signal voting weight is adjusted in real time by calculating the engine control deviation, so as to achieve effective integration of the redundant sensor signal and ensure that the engine control meets the expected state. The specific steps include obtaining the engine expectations and actual status, calculating the control deviation, adjusting the signal voting results and weights of the previous cycle, updating the signal voting weights of the current cycle, and finally calculating and applying the new signal voting results for control.

Benefits of technology

This method has strong adaptability and does not rely on precise mathematical models. It can stabilize the voting results under different signal conditions, ensure that the engine is controlled in the expected state, and improve the safety and stability of the system.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN118997927A_ABST
    Figure CN118997927A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to the technical field of FADEC system signal processing, and particularly discloses an FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback, which comprises the following steps: acquiring an expected working state interval of an engine in a current period, an actual working state of the engine in the current period and a signal voting result in a previous period; according to the expected working state interval of the engine in the current period and the actual working state of the engine in the current period, the control deviation of the engine in the current period is calculated; calculating the adjusting quantity of the signal voting result of the previous period according to the engine control deviation of the current period, and adjusting the signal voting result of the previous period according to the adjusting quantity to obtain the adjusted signal voting result of the previous period; calculating the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous period according to the adjusted signal voting result of the previous period, and taking the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous period as the signal voting weight of the current period so as to update the signal voting weight; calculating a signal voting result of the current period according to the acquisition signal of each sensor in the current period and the signal voting weight of the current period; and controlling the working state of the engine in the current period according to the signal voting result in the current period. According to the method, the signal voting weight can be dynamically adjusted according to the engine control deviation, a voting result beneficial to engine operation is formed, it is guaranteed that engine overall control meets the expectation, and the safety of the engine and an aircraft is further guaranteed.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of FADEC system signal processing, and more specifically, to a FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback. Background Art

[0002] As a key subsystem of aircraft engines, the FADEC (Full Authority Digital Electronic Control) system includes sensors, servo mechanisms, digital electronic controllers and other major components. During the operation of the engine, the FADEC system is responsible for receiving aircraft instructions, integrating engine inlet conditions and operating restrictions, and calculating the expected state of the engine. At the same time, the FADEC system identifies the current state of the engine based on the collected signals of the sensors. Based on the deviation between the expected state and the current state of the engine, the control unit calculates the control law and adjusts the working position of the servo mechanism, thereby changing the working state of the engine to meet the flight needs. In this process, the signal acquisition and processing module plays an important role. The FADEC system collects engine speed, temperature, pressure, servo mechanism position and other signals through sensors to judge the engine's operating environment and working state, thereby executing a reasonable control strategy. If there is a deviation in signal acquisition, it will directly lead to misjudgment of the FADEC system and execution of wrong control instructions, resulting in abnormal engine control, which may seriously endanger the safety of the engine and even the aircraft.

[0003] As engine indicators continue to improve, FADEC system functions become more and more complex, and the reliability requirements for collected signals are also getting higher and higher. In order to ensure the safe operation of the engine, FADEC systems are generally designed with redundant sensors to collect the same signal. The collected signals of each sensor undergo necessary conversion and processing to form a pre-voting signal, which is then integrated through a voting algorithm to obtain the final voting result for control.

[0004] Due to differences in sensor characteristics and installation locations, different sensors have certain differences in collecting the same object, and it is necessary to design a suitable algorithm for signal voting. Otherwise, the voting results used for control will deviate from reality, causing the engine to operate in an unexpected state. Summary of the invention

[0005] In view of the above-mentioned drawbacks existing in the prior art, the present invention provides a FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback to solve the problem of redundant acquisition signal voting in the FADEC system. It can adjust the signal voting weight in real time according to the engine control deviation, realize the effective integration of redundant sensor signals, and ensure that the overall control of the engine meets expectations.

[0006] As a first aspect of the present invention, a FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback is provided, comprising the following steps:

[0007] Step S1: obtaining the expected working state interval of the engine in the current cycle, the actual working state of the engine in the current cycle, and the signal voting result of the previous cycle; wherein the signal voting result of the previous cycle is calculated based on the collected signals of each sensor in the previous cycle and the signal voting weight of the previous cycle;

[0008] Step S2: calculating the engine control deviation of the current cycle according to the expected engine operating state interval of the current cycle and the actual engine operating state of the current cycle;

[0009] Step S3: calculating the adjustment amount of the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the engine control deviation of the current cycle, and adjusting the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the adjustment amount to obtain the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle;

[0010] Step S4: calculating the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle according to the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle, and using the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle as the signal voting weight of the current cycle to update the signal voting weight;

[0011] Step S5: Calculate the signal voting result of the current period according to the collected signals of each sensor in the current period and the signal voting weight of the current period;

[0012] Step S6: Controlling the engine operating state of the current cycle according to the signal voting result of the current cycle.

[0013] Furthermore, the obtaining of the expected engine operating state interval of the current cycle further includes the following steps:

[0014] Determine an expected engine operating state interval e0 of the current cycle according to aircraft instructions, engine operating environment and engine operating constraints of the current cycle;

[0015] Among them, any expected engine working state e in the expected engine working state interval e0 i It is a state space composed of the expected value of engine speed, the expected value of engine pressure ratio and the expected value of engine exhaust temperature.

[0016] Further, the calculating of the engine control deviation of the current cycle according to the expected engine operating state interval of the current cycle and the actual engine operating state of the current cycle also includes the following steps:

[0017] The calculation formula of the engine control deviation Δe of the current cycle is as follows:

[0018]

[0019] Wherein, e is the actual working state of the engine in the current cycle. When the actual working state of the engine e is within the expected working state interval e0 of the engine, Δe=0.

[0020] Further, the step of calculating the adjustment amount of the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the engine control deviation of the current cycle, and adjusting the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the adjustment amount to obtain the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle also includes the following steps:

[0021] The calculation formula of the adjustment amount Δv of the signal voting result of the previous cycle is as follows:

[0022] Δv=k·Δe

[0023] Where k represents the adjustment step length;

[0024] The voting result v of the adjusted signal of the previous cycle + The calculation formula is as follows:

[0025] v + =v 0 +Δv

[0026] Among them, v 0 It is the signal voting result of the previous cycle.

[0027] Further, the method of calculating the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle according to the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle, and using the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle as the signal voting weight of the current cycle to update the signal voting weight, further includes the following steps:

[0028] The voting weight u of the adjusted signal of the previous cycle + The calculation formula is as follows:

[0029]

[0030] Where A=[s 0 1 D] T , b=[v + 1d] T ,s 0 is the collected signal of each sensor in the previous cycle, 1∈R n×1 , D∈R n ×m is the predefined projection matrix, d∈R 1×m is the corresponding projection length constraint vector, D and d jointly represent the distribution coefficient of the signal voting weight in different signal dimensions, and m is the dimension of the distribution coefficient.

[0031] The voting weight u of the adjusted signal of the previous cycle is + As the signal voting weight u of the current cycle, the signal voting weight is updated.

[0032] Furthermore, the step of calculating the signal voting result of the current period according to the collected signals of each sensor in the current period and the signal voting weight of the current period further includes the following steps:

[0033] The calculation formula of the signal voting result v of the current cycle is as follows:

[0034] v=s T ·u

[0035] Among them, s T is the collected signal of each sensor in the current cycle, and u is the signal voting weight of the current cycle.

[0036] Furthermore, the collected signals of each sensor in the current cycle are s=[s1 s2 ...s n ] T , the signal voting weight of the current cycle u=[u1 u2...u n ] T ; where s1,s2,…,s n The collected values ​​of the same physical signal collected by each sensor in the current cycle; u1,u2,…,u n It is the voting weight of the collected values ​​of each sensor in the current cycle.

[0037] The FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback provided by the present invention has the following advantages:

[0038] (1) This method has strong adaptability and only needs to clarify the qualitative impact of the collected signal on engine control. It does not rely on an accurate mathematical model and has wide applicability.

[0039] (2) When the acquisition signals of each redundancy are consistent, the voting result of this method is insensitive to the voting weight, and the voting result is consistent with the acquisition results of each redundancy, which is conducive to system stability;

[0040] (3) When the differences between the redundant acquisition signals are large, the voting results obtained by adjusting the voting weights can control the engine in the expected state, which is beneficial to engine safety. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0041] The accompanying drawings are used to provide further understanding of the present invention and constitute a part of the specification. Together with the following specific embodiments, they are used to explain the present invention, but do not constitute a limitation of the present invention.

[0042] Figure 1The present invention provides a flow chart of a FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback.

[0043] Figure 2 A flowchart of a specific implementation of the FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback provided by the present invention.

[0044] Figure 3 The schematic diagram of the FADEC system to which this method is applied is shown in FIG.

[0045] Figure 4 The specific schematic diagram of the FADEC system to which this method is applied.

[0046] Figure 5 A schematic diagram of the engine speed, fuel flow and voting weight changing over time provided by the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0047] In order to further explain the technical means and effects adopted by the present invention to achieve the predetermined invention purpose, the specific implementation method, structure, characteristics and effects of the FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback proposed by the present invention are described in detail below in combination with the accompanying drawings and preferred embodiments. Obviously, the described embodiments are part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of them. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work belong to the protection scope of the present invention.

[0048] In this embodiment, a FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback is provided, such as Figure 1 As shown, the FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback includes the following steps:

[0049] Step S1: obtaining the expected working state interval of the engine in the current cycle, the actual working state of the engine in the current cycle, and the signal voting result of the previous cycle; wherein the signal voting result of the previous cycle is calculated based on the collected signals of each sensor in the previous cycle and the signal voting weight of the previous cycle;

[0050] Preferably, if Figure 2 As shown, the step of obtaining the expected engine operating state interval of the current cycle also includes the following steps:

[0051] The FADEC system controls the engine by integrating the aircraft instructions, engine operating environment and engine operating constraints. According to the aircraft instructions, engine operating environment and engine operating constraints of the current cycle, the expected engine operating state interval e0 of the current cycle is determined; wherein e0 can be obtained through engine design parameters or test data;

[0052] Among them, any expected engine working state e in the expected engine working state interval e0 i It is a state space composed of the expected value of engine speed, the expected value of engine pressure ratio and the expected value of engine exhaust temperature.

[0053] For example, Figure 4 As shown in the figure, the speed control planning module of the FADEC system obtains the expected engine speed value n of the current cycle according to the aircraft command. dem , the FADEC system collects the actual value n of the engine speed in the current cycle, and the FADEC system obtains the fuel flow collection values ​​s1 and s2 through sensor 1 and sensor 2 respectively. The expected engine speed interval n0 is used to represent the expected engine working state interval e0, and the expected engine working state interval e0 is defined as {n0||n0-n dem |≤0.01}, where n0 represents the expected engine speed range. Without loss of generality, in this example, the expected engine speed value n is taken dem =0.

[0054] Step S2: calculating the engine control deviation of the current cycle according to the expected engine operating state interval of the current cycle and the actual engine operating state of the current cycle;

[0055] Preferably, the step of calculating the engine control deviation of the current cycle according to the expected engine operating state interval of the current cycle and the actual engine operating state of the current cycle further includes the following steps:

[0056] The calculation formula of the engine control deviation Δe of the current cycle is as follows:

[0057]

[0058] Wherein, e is the actual working state of the engine in the current cycle. When the actual working state of the engine e is within the expected working state interval e0 of the engine, Δe=0.

[0059] For example, Figure 4 As shown, the actual value of the engine speed n = the actual working state of the engine e. Under normal circumstances, through the adjustment of the FADEC system, the actual value of the engine speed n should be within the expected working state range of the engine e0, that is, Δe = 0; if sensor 1 or sensor 2 is abnormal, it will cause a deviation in the engine fuel flow control of the current cycle, and ultimately cause a deviation in the engine speed control of the current cycle. At this time, the engine speed control deviation Δe of the current cycle is calculated.

[0060] Step S3: calculating the adjustment amount of the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the engine control deviation of the current cycle, and adjusting the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the adjustment amount to obtain the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle;

[0061] Preferably, the step of calculating the adjustment amount of the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the engine control deviation of the current cycle, and adjusting the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the adjustment amount to obtain the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle also includes the following steps:

[0062] According to the influence of the signal voting result of the previous cycle on the actual working state e of the engine in the current cycle, the adjustment amount Δv of the signal voting result of the previous cycle is determined; the calculation formula of the adjustment amount Δv of the signal voting result of the previous cycle is as follows:

[0063] Δv=k·Δe

[0064] Wherein, k represents the adjustment step size; for example, k=1;

[0065] The voting result v of the adjusted signal of the previous cycle + The calculation formula is as follows:

[0066] v + =v 0 +Δv

[0067] Among them, v 0 It is the signal voting result of the previous cycle.

[0068] Step S4: calculating the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle according to the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle, and using the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle as the signal voting weight of the current cycle to update the signal voting weight;

[0069] Preferably, the step of calculating the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle according to the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle, and using the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle as the signal voting weight of the current cycle to update the signal voting weight, further includes the following steps:

[0070] The voting weight u of the adjusted signal of the previous cycle + The calculation formula is as follows:

[0071]

[0072] Where A=[s 0 1 D] T , b=[v + 1d]T ,s 0 is the collected signal of each sensor in the previous cycle, 1∈R n×1 , D∈R n ×m is the predefined projection matrix, d∈R 1×m is the corresponding projection length constraint vector, D and d jointly represent the distribution coefficient of the signal voting weight in different signal dimensions, and m is the dimension of the distribution coefficient.

[0073] For example, Figure 4 As shown, s 0 is the collected signal of sensor 1 and sensor 2 in the previous cycle, 1∈R 1×1 , D=O is an empty matrix, d=O is an empty matrix, that is, no additional constraints are imposed on the voting weights of sensor 1 and sensor 2.

[0074] The voting weight u of the adjusted signal of the previous cycle is + As the signal voting weight u of the current cycle, the signal voting weight is updated.

[0075] Step S5: Calculate the signal voting result of the current period according to the collected signals of each sensor in the current period and the signal voting weight of the current period;

[0076] Preferably, the step of calculating the signal voting result of the current period according to the collected signals of each sensor in the current period and the signal voting weight of the current period further includes the following steps:

[0077] The calculation formula of the signal voting result v of the current cycle is as follows:

[0078] v=s T ·u

[0079] Among them, s is the collected signal of each sensor in the current cycle, and u is the signal voting weight of the current cycle.

[0080] Specifically, the collected signal s of each sensor in the current cycle is [s1 s2 ...s n ] T , the signal voting weight of the current cycle u=[u1 u2...u n ] T ; where s1,s2,…,s n The collected values ​​of the same physical signal (such as engine speed, temperature, pressure or displacement signal) collected by each sensor in the current cycle; u1, u2, ..., u n It is the voting weight of the collected values ​​of each sensor in the current cycle.

[0081] For example, Figure 4As shown, s is the collected signal of sensor 1 and sensor 2 in the current cycle.

[0082] Step S6: Controlling the engine operating state of the current cycle according to the signal voting result of the current cycle.

[0083] In this embodiment, if Figure 5 As shown, after t=0.1s, the fuel flow collection value s2 of sensor 2 is set to be wrong, and the fuel flow collection value s2 is always 0.2 larger than the actual value of the fuel flow. Through the voting algorithm described in the present invention, the voting weights u of s1 and s2 are dynamically adjusted, so that the fuel flow voting result v of the current cycle can be close to the actual value of the fuel flow, and finally the actual value of the engine speed can meet expectations.

[0084] It should be noted that during the operation of the engine, multiple sensors are used to collect the same physical signal, and then the voting method provided by the present invention is used to integrate the collected values ​​of multiple sensors into a signal voting result for participating in engine control.

[0085] like Figure 3 As shown, in each operation cycle of the FADEC system, the above steps S1 to S6 are executed once. When the actual working state e of the engine is within the interval e0, it indicates that the engine control is normal, and the voting result v of the signal s better reflects the actual working state of the engine; at this time, since Δe = 0, v + =v 0 , the voting weight u remains unchanged. When the engine control deviates, Δe≠0, feedback regulation takes effect, v + ≠v 0 , the voting weight u is adjusted accordingly, changing the signal voting result v, and then changing the control output of the FADEC system and the engine state, reducing Δe until Δe=0. At this time, the actual working state e of the engine is within the interval e0, and the voting weight u is stopped from being adjusted.

[0086] like Figure 4 As shown in the figure, the speed control planning module of the FADEC system obtains the expected engine speed value n of the current cycle according to the aircraft command. dem The FADEC system collects the actual engine speed value n of the current cycle, and the speed control module calculates the expected engine speed value n dem Adjust the expected fuel flow rate Wf with the actual engine speed n dem The FADEC system obtains the fuel flow acquisition values ​​s1 and s2 through sensor 1 and sensor 2 respectively, and integrates the fuel flow acquisition values ​​s1 and s2 into the signal voting result v of the current cycle through the signal voting method of the present invention. The fuel control module calculates the fuel flow expected value Wf demThe deviation from the signal voting result v of the current cycle is used to adjust the control current i, so that the fuel flow Wf actually output by the fuel metering device meets the expectations, and finally the engine speed control meets the expectations.

[0087] The above description is only a preferred embodiment of the present invention and does not limit the present invention in any form. Although the present invention has been disclosed as a preferred embodiment as above, it is not used to limit the present invention. Any technician familiar with this profession can make some changes or modifications to equivalent embodiments of equivalent changes using the technical contents disclosed above without departing from the scope of the technical solution of the present invention. However, any simple modification, equivalent change and modification made to the above embodiments based on the technical essence of the present invention without departing from the content of the technical solution of the present invention still falls within the scope of the technical solution of the present invention.

Claims

1. A FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback, characterized in that: The steps include: Step S1: obtaining the expected working state interval of the engine in the current cycle, the actual working state of the engine in the current cycle, and the signal voting result of the previous cycle; wherein the signal voting result of the previous cycle is calculated based on the collected signals of each sensor in the previous cycle and the signal voting weight of the previous cycle; Step S2: calculating the engine control deviation of the current cycle according to the expected engine operating state interval of the current cycle and the actual engine operating state of the current cycle; Step S3: calculating the adjustment amount of the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the engine control deviation of the current cycle, and adjusting the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the adjustment amount to obtain the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle; Step S4: calculating the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle according to the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle, and using the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle as the signal voting weight of the current cycle to update the signal voting weight; Step S5: Calculate the signal voting result of the current period according to the collected signals of each sensor in the current period and the signal voting weight of the current period; Step S6: Controlling the engine operating state of the current cycle according to the signal voting result of the current cycle.

2. The FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step of obtaining the expected engine operating state interval of the current cycle further includes the following steps: Determine an expected engine operating state interval e0 of the current cycle according to aircraft instructions, engine operating environment and engine operating constraints of the current cycle; Among them, any expected engine working state e in the expected engine working state interval e0 i It is a state space composed of the expected value of engine speed, the expected value of engine pressure ratio and the expected value of engine exhaust temperature.

3. The FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback according to claim 2, characterized in that: The step of calculating the engine control deviation of the current cycle according to the expected engine operating state interval of the current cycle and the actual engine operating state of the current cycle further includes the following steps: The calculation formula of the engine control deviation Δe of the current cycle is as follows: Wherein, e is the actual working state of the engine in the current cycle. When the actual working state of the engine e is within the expected working state interval e0 of the engine, Δe=0.

4. The FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback according to claim 3 is characterized in that: The method further comprises the following steps: calculating the adjustment amount of the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the engine control deviation of the current cycle, and adjusting the signal voting result of the previous cycle according to the adjustment amount to obtain the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle. The calculation formula of the adjustment amount Δv of the signal voting result of the previous cycle is as follows: Δv=k·Δe Where k represents the adjustment step length; The voting result v of the adjusted signal of the previous cycle + The calculation formula is as follows: v + =v 0 +Δv Among them, v 0 It is the signal voting result of the previous cycle.

5. The FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback according to claim 4, characterized in that: The method further includes calculating the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle according to the adjusted signal voting result of the previous cycle, and using the adjusted signal voting weight of the previous cycle as the signal voting weight of the current cycle to update the signal voting weight, and further includes the following steps: The adjusted signal voting weight u of the previous cycle + The calculation formula is as follows: Where A=[s 0 1 D] T , b=[v + 1d] T ,s 0 is the collected signal of each sensor in the previous cycle, 1∈R n×1 , D∈R n ×m is the predefined projection matrix, d∈R 1×m is the corresponding projection length constraint vector, D and d jointly represent the distribution coefficient of signal voting weight on different signal dimensions, and m is the dimension of the distribution coefficient; The voting weight u of the adjusted signal of the previous cycle is + As the signal voting weight u of the current cycle, the signal voting weight is updated.

6. The FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback according to claim 5, characterized in that: The step of calculating the signal voting result of the current cycle according to the collected signals of each sensor in the current cycle and the signal voting weight of the current cycle also includes the following steps: The calculation formula of the signal voting result v of the current cycle is as follows: v=s T ·u Among them, s T is the collected signal of each sensor in the current cycle, and u is the signal voting weight of the current cycle.

7. The FADEC system signal voting method based on deviation feedback according to claim 6, characterized in that: The collected signals of each sensor in the current cycle are s=[s1 s2 ...s n ] T , the signal voting weight of the current cycle u=[u1u2...u n ] T ; where s1,s2,…,s n The collected values ​​of the same physical signal collected by each sensor in the current cycle; u1,u2,…,u n It is the voting weight of the collected values ​​of each sensor in the current cycle.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Weighted average voting method considering priorities of multi-system redundancy signals

    CN110889232A

  • Aero-engine control method and device and electronic equipment

    CN113311771A

  • Gas turbine parameter redundancy voting method based on confidence coefficient weight floating

    CN113946122A

  • Aero-engine high-pressure rotating speed signal voting method based on four redundancies

    CN114235420A

  • Control system

    US20240166377A1