Notification of distinction for system characterization modeled with finite state machine
Through FSM technology, the notification distinction of state transitions is quantified and evaluated in a finite state machine modeling system, the problem of unclear feedback on state transitions is solved, and the accuracy and user experience of HMI design are improved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202311404213.6
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-05-23
- Filing Date
- 2023-10-26
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
AI Technical Summary
Existing finite state machine (FSM) modeling systems are difficult to effectively distinguish and quantify the distinction between notifications during state transitions, resulting in users or entities not being able to clearly perceive, notice, or recognize feedback during state transitions.
A discrimination tool was designed to use FSM technology to describe and measure feedback discrimination provided by state transitions, calculate the discrimination rating through notification attribute differences before and after state transitions, and quantify it using a set of indicators for visual, auditory and tactile attributes. Generate a distinction abstract table for easy analysis and verification.
The quantification and rating of notification distinction during state transitions is realized, helping designers and users determine whether reasonable feedback is provided, improving the accuracy and user experience of HMI design, and reducing design complexity and errors.
Smart Images

Figure CN119025192A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present disclosure relates to characterizing the discrimination of notifications for a modeled system, such as, but not necessarily limited to, characterizing the discrimination of notifications used to discern transitions between states of a system modeled as a finite state machine (FSM). Background Art
[0002] Finite state machine (FSM) can be used to promote the design and verification of the expected behavior of the modeled system. For example, FSM can be used to represent countless different software programs, physical systems, states, models and other structures that form the modeled system. FSM can be graphically represented in the form of a state diagram, which has an initial state, one or more additional states, related state transitions between states, and various inputs and / or events. The model can also be given in other forms, such as a state transition table. Based on the current state of the modeled system and a given event or event combination, the corresponding FSM can depict one or more state transitions between different states. When the modeled system includes a certain degree of interaction with a user or other entity, it may be expected or required that the system provide a reasonably perceptible, noticeable, visible and / or cognitively clear notification as feedback when completing one or more state transitions. Summary of the invention
[0003] One non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure relates to a discriminability tool configured to characterize notification discrimination for a system modeled with a finite state machine (FSM). The discriminability tool can employ FSM techniques to depict and measure the discrimination of notifications used to provide feedback for state transitions. The discriminability tool can be configured to generate a discrimination rating for a state transition based on the relative discrimination difference between state notifications associated with the state transition, for example, based on the change in notifications between a transitioned-from state and a transitioned-to state. The discrimination rating can be used to quantify the difference between notifications as a function of size, prominence, etc. between sets of indicators associated therewith. The set of indicators can, for example, include one or more visual, auditory, and / or tactile attributes such that these attributes can be compared to generate the discrimination rating. The ability to quantify the discrimination of the notifications in this manner can be beneficial in providing an FSM-based analysis of whether the modeled system provides a user, machine, or other entity with a notification that is reasonably perceptible, noticeable, visible, and / or cognitively clear as feedback when one or more state transitions are completed, i.e., when transitioning between states.
[0004] One non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure relates to a method for characterizing the discrimination of notifications for a system modeled as a finite state machine (FSM). The method may include: identifying a plurality of states for the system modeled as the FSM, and identifying a notification to be presented for each state. Each notification may present one or more indicators selected from a set of indicators, optionally comprising at least one visual, auditory, and tactile attribute. The method may also include: identifying a plurality of state transitions between the states, optionally each state transition defining an event of transitioning from a pre-transition state in the state to another post-transition state in the state. The method may also include: generating a discrimination rating for each state transition, optionally each discrimination rating quantifying in a comparable manner the relative discrimination between notifications for the pre-transition state and notifications for the post-transition state of the state transition associated therewith.
[0005] The method may include generating a discrimination rating based at least in part on attributes of the notification of the pre-transition state and the notification of the post-transition state associated with the discrimination rating.
[0006] The method may include assigning a value to each attribute; and generating the discrimination rating as a function of the values of the notification of the pre-transition state and the notification of the post-transition state associated therewith.
[0007] The method may include generating the discrimination rating as proportional to a delta difference between the values of the notification of the pre-transition state and the notification of the post-transition state with which it is associated.
[0008] The method may include including as part of each discrimination rating a number representing the magnitude of the delta difference in the discrimination rating associated therewith.
[0009] The method may include including as part of each discrimination rating a color coding wherein the magnitude of the delta difference in the discrimination rating associated therewith is represented by color, or wherein the color coding represents the color magnitude of the delta difference in the discrimination rating associated therewith.
[0010] The method may include presenting the discrimination rating in a discrimination abstract table. The discrimination abstract table may be configured to cross-reference a plurality of cells relative to a plurality of columns and rows, each column and row being associated with one of the states, and each cell representing a state transition of the column and row cross-referenced thereto.
[0011] The method may include determining each state transition as one of feasible and infeasible; and including a callout for each discrimination rating of a state transition that is considered feasible and omitting the callout for each discrimination rating of a state transition that is considered infeasible.
[0012] One non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure relates to a method for characterizing the notification discrimination of a system modeled as a finite state machine (FSM). The method may include: based on a state transition table (or any other form of FSM model) configured to define multiple state transitions between multiple states of the system modeled as the FSM, or directly based on multiple state transitions between multiple states of the system modeled as the FSM, identifying an event that transitions from a pre-transition state in the state to another post-transition state in the state, and a post-transition notification to be presented when each post-transition state is reached. The method may also include: generating a discrimination rating for each post-transition notification, optionally, each discrimination rating quantifies the discrimination of the post-transition notification of the post-transition state associated with it.
[0013] The method may include generating the discrimination rating to quantify the discrimination of the post-transition notification relative to a pre-transition notification of a pre-transition state of a state transition associated therewith.
[0014] The method may include: each post-conversion notification and pre-conversion notification presenting one or more indicators selected from a set of indicators, the set of indicators including at least one visual, auditory, and tactile attribute. The method may also include: generating a discrimination rating based at least in part on a difference between the attributes of the post-conversion notification and the pre-conversion notification associated with the discrimination rating.
[0015] The method may include assigning a value to each attribute; and generating the discrimination rating as a function of a difference between the values of the post-conversion notification and the pre-conversion notification associated therewith.
[0016] The method may include generating the discrimination rating as proportional to a delta difference between the values of the post-conversion notification and the pre-conversion notification associated therewith.
[0017] The method may include including as part of each discrimination rating a value or number representing the magnitude of the delta difference in the discrimination rating associated therewith.
[0018] The method may comprise including as part of each discrimination rating a colour coding, optionally representing the (colour) magnitude of the delta difference in discrimination rating associated therewith.
[0019] The method may include presenting the discrimination rating in a discrimination abstract table. The discrimination abstract table may be configured to cross-reference a plurality of cells relative to a plurality of columns and rows, each column and row being associated with one of the states, and each cell representing a state transition of the column and row cross-referenced thereto.
[0020] The method may include determining each state transition as one of feasible and infeasible; and including a feasibility annotation for each discrimination rating of a state transition that is considered feasible and omitting the feasibility annotation for each discrimination rating of a state transition that is considered infeasible.
[0021] One non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure relates to a system for characterizing the discrimination of notifications of a system modeled with an FSM. The system may include a tabulation module configured to determine a state discrimination abstract table of a finite state machine. The discrimination abstract table defines a plurality of state transitions between a plurality of states, and optionally, each state transition defines an event that transitions from a pre-transition state in the state to another post-transition state in the state. The system may also include a discrimination tool configured to: determine a notification to be presented for each state; and generate a discrimination rating for each state transition, and optionally, each discrimination rating quantifies the relative discrimination between notifications of a pre-transition state and a post-transition state of the state transition associated therewith in a comparable manner.
[0022] The discrimination tool may be configured to: determine one or more attributes for each notification; and generate the discrimination rating based at least in part on differences between attributes of the notification in the pre-transition state and the notification in the post-transition state associated with the discrimination rating.
[0023] The discrimination tool may be configured to present the discrimination rating in a discrimination abstract table, the discrimination abstract table cross-referencing a plurality of cells relative to a plurality of columns and rows, each column and row being associated with one of the states, each cell representing a state transition of the column and row cross-referenced thereto.
[0024] These and other features and advantages of the present teaching will become apparent from the following detailed description of the mode for implementing the present teaching when considered in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. It should be understood that even though the following figures and embodiments may be described separately, individual features therein may also be combined in additional embodiments. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0025] The accompanying drawings, which are incorporated in and constitute a part of this specification, illustrate implementations of the present disclosure and, together with the description, serve to explain the principles of the present disclosure.
[0026] Figure 1 A computerized modeling system according to one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure is shown.
[0027] Figure 1A An exemplary embodiment of a distributed processing node according to one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure is shown.
[0028] Figure 2A state transition table according to one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure is shown.
[0029] Figure 3 A feedback form according to one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure is shown.
[0030] Figure 4 An abstract table of discriminability in accordance with one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure is shown.
[0031] Figure 5 A flow chart of a method for characterizing notification discrimination according to one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure is shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0032] Detailed embodiments of the present disclosure are disclosed herein as needed; however, it should be understood that the disclosed embodiments are merely examples of the present disclosure that may be implemented in various alternative forms. The figures are not necessarily drawn to scale; some features may be enlarged or minimized to show details of particular components. Therefore, the specific structural and functional details disclosed herein should not be interpreted as limiting, but should only be interpreted as a representative basis for teaching those skilled in the art to use the present disclosure in various ways.
[0033] Figure 1 A computerized modeling system 10 is shown in accordance with one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure. The computerized modeling system 10 is shown for exemplary purposes relating to performing data entry, automatic error checking, notification verification, and other operations during FSM design. The modeling system 10 may include a host computer 12, such as a laptop computer, tablet computer, desktop computer, mobile application ("app"), etc., that may be configured to assist a designer, programmer, or another user 11 in modeling a complex hardware and / or software-based system ("FSM-modeled system"). Although the host computer 12 may be depicted as a single device for simplicity of illustration, those skilled in the art will appreciate that the host computer 12 may be implemented as a distributed host computer system 120 having multiple processing nodes (e.g., 12A, 12B, ..., 12N), such as Figure 1A Such processing nodes may communicate with each other via suitable wired or wireless networking connections. The modeling system 10 may be used to model the performance of a human-machine interface ("HMI") or another device onboard a motor vehicle or aircraft, ship, rail vehicle, or another dynamic system, or to model the performance of a medical device, power equipment, or another static system.
[0034] Figure 1The modeling system 10 may include one or more peripheral devices 13, including a display screen 14 that can operate as an output device of the host computer 12. When developing or designing a system modeled with an FSM (including the functionality of its resident software and / or hardware), a user 11 may interact with the host computer 12 through one or more additional peripheral devices 13 (not shown), such as a mouse, a keyboard, touch input to the display screen 14, etc. As is understood in the art, when designing an FSM model suitable for an application, the task faced by the user 11 may often be complicated by the high complexity of the system modeled with the FSM. For example, while the operation of a binary system such as turning a desk lamp on / off can be represented by its two possible states ("on" and "off"), two possible state transitions ("on-off" and "off-on"), and two inputs or events ("switch is turned off" and "switch is turned on"), accurate FSM modeling of more complex systems may require the same user 11 to consider hundreds or thousands of different states, state transitions, events, and other possible system features. As a result, the user 11 may inadvertently overlook or miss one or more states, state transitions, or event combinations ("super events"), which in turn may degrade the performance and quality of the modeled system.
[0035] As part of this strategy, Figure 1 The host computer 12 or Figure 1A Its constituent processing nodes 12A, 12B, ..., 12N may be equipped with an error checking module ("ECM") 52, a non-tangible computer readable storage medium or memory (M) 54, and one or more processors (P) 53, such as logic circuits, (one or more) combinational logic circuits, (one or more) application specific integrated circuits (ASICs), (one or more) electronic circuits, (one or more) central processing units, semiconductor IC devices, etc., and (one or more) input / output (I / O) circuits, appropriate signal conditioning and buffering circuits, and other components such as high-speed clocks to provide the described functions. The associated memory 54 may include a number and type of non-transitory memory suitable for the application, including read-only, programmable read-only, random access, hard disk drives, etc., whether resident, remote, or a combination of both. The host computer 12 may be configured to receive system characteristics 15 from the user 11. This may require receiving various states, state transitions and events of the system being modeled, as well as possible super events (event combinations), hierarchy definitions and other system characteristics 15. In response to the received system signature 15, the host computer 12 automatically generates and outputs an initial state transition table (T i) 19. The initial state transition table 19 is indexed by a population of possible states and events of the modeled system that is as complete as possible, and has the system characteristics 15 entered by the user 11. In addition, the host computer 12 automatically fills the initial state transition table 19 with the second data set 18, thereby generating a third data set 19S, which includes the populated state transition table (T P )20.
[0036] The host computer 12 can automatically generate a populated state transition table 20 as a third data set 19S. This occurs in response to a set of user inputs 16. The host computer 12 ultimately outputs a final state transition table (TF) 21. The final state transition table 21 is then used as needed, typically as a starting point for further research by the user 11, and as a basis for developing state diagrams and scenario simulations of the modeled system. As part of the disclosed solution, Figure 1 The host computer 12 schematically shown in FIG. 1 processes the third data set 19S through the ECM 52 to error check the populated state transition table 20. This action occurs using predetermined error checking criteria. For example, the host computer 12 may search the populated state transition table 20 for missing critical features, such as missing states, state transitions, events, and / or (one or more) other features of system-critical or functionally critical components of the modeled system. As part of this strategy as described below, the host computer 12 may also send an alarm signal (CC 22 ) is transmitted to the display screen 14 or an external device ("Ext") 22, such as a smart phone or Figure 1A Such action occurs in response to the missing key feature at one of the various processing nodes 12A, 12B, ..., 12N.
[0037] Figure 2 A state transition table 60 is shown in accordance with one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure. Figure 1 The various state transition tables 19, 20, and 21 schematically illustrated in the diagram can be visualized as a simplified state transition table 60. In the exemplary illustration, the state transition table 60 is organized into a row of symbolic states 64, e.g., A, B, C, ..., ZZ, for simplicity, and an "event" column 62 containing symbolic events E1, E2, E3, ..., EN. Each event in column 62 may in turn trigger a transition to a corresponding state in column 63. For example, in the illustrated state transition table 60, event E2 occurring in state A may cause the modeled system to transition to state E. As part of the present method, each state defined by the user 11 is listed in the exemplary state transition table 60. The user 11 may be able to access the state transition table 60 and edit it directly, e.g., in response to a request from Figure 1The host computer 12 may provide a prompt indicating a missing critical state, state transition or event. That is, the host computer 12 may allow the user 11 to edit the state transition table 60 from within, for example, by opening a drop-down menu in response to the user 11 selecting a particular state or event from the state transition table 60. For simplicity, this function may be illustrated at the symbolic event E3 by its framed outline and the indication "manual" or "M" indicating the possibility for the user 11 to edit or enter the corresponding state into the state transition table 60. Thus, the user 11 may be guided when constructing, filling, error checking and updating the state transition table 60.
[0038] One non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure relates to the modeling system 10 including a discriminability tool 210. The discriminability tool 210 may be configured to characterize the discriminability of notifications 216 of a system modeled in an FSM. The discriminability tool 210 may employ FSM techniques to characterize and measure the discriminability of feedback provided for state transitions. Figure 3 A feedback table 214 is shown according to one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure. The feedback table 214 illustrates a plurality of notifications 216 configured to provide feedback on the current state and state transitions. The notifications 216 can be used to provide a user, machine, or other entity with notifications 216 that are reasonably perceptible, noticeable, visible, and / or cognitively clear as feedback. This may be helpful when completing one or more state transitions, i.e., when transitioning between states. For exemplary purposes, the notifications 216 are shown as corresponding to a set of indicators 222 for providing feedback. The notification column 220 may include multiple rows, each row representing a notification 216 to be presented when the modeled system is in a corresponding one of the states listed in the state column 226. The notifications 216, or more specifically the information, content, etc. of each notification 216, may be selected from a set of indicators 222. The set of indicators 222 may include one or more visual, auditory, tactile, and / or other types of attributes.
[0039] The indicator 222 itself may be further defined to include one or more of a plurality of optional attributes, however, there may be a different number of indicators 222 depending on the system being modeled. Each attribute may be selected separately to define a granularity parameter of a set of indicators 222 to be included in a corresponding notification 216. For non-limiting purposes, the feedback table 214 is shown with respect to the following case: a notification 216 is generated based on a first indicator 224, a second indicator 226, a third indicator 228, a fourth indicator 230, a fifth indicator 232, and a sixth indicator 234, each of which includes a variable (not individually labeled) of one or more of a plurality of optional attributes. Additional indicators 222 may be included, including sound and tactile indicators. The optional attributes of the first indicator 224 may be selected from a first list of available attributes, which is shown as a list corresponding to light color outputs, such as no color ("none"), color a, color b, color c, etc. The optional attributes of the second indicator 226 can be selected from a second list of available attributes, which are shown as corresponding to defining blinking feedback, such as no blinking (“no”) and blinking (“yes”) and / or a blinking pattern—a function of the pulse frequency, envelope shape, and inter-stimulus duration of the pulse, which can also be adapted to the urgency of the message or status. The optional attributes of the third indicator 228 can be selected from a third list of available attributes, which are shown as corresponding to icon color output, such as no color (“none”) and colors a, b, c, d. The optional attributes of the fourth indicator 230 can be selected from a fourth list of available attributes, which are shown as corresponding to defining icon positions, such as primary position (1) and secondary position (2). The optional attributes of the fifth indicator 232 can be selected from a fifth list of available attributes, which are shown as corresponding to a color display sequence, such as no color (“none”) and / or a combination of colors a, b, c, d, and e. The selectable attributes of the sixth indicator 234 may be selected from a sixth list of available attributes, which are shown corresponding to a blink setting display sequence, such as no blink ("off") and blink ("on") and / or other configurations capable of presenting a generic identity.
[0040] Notifications 216, or more specifically indicators 222 and / or attributes associated therewith, are merely examples of various variables that may be used with notifications 216. This is done for exemplary and non-limiting purposes, as the present disclosure fully contemplates the use of other types of notifications 216, including notifications 216 that may interface with other systems, machines, computers, entities, etc., optionally without user interaction. The present disclosure also contemplates the use of notifications 216 with other types of modeled systems other than motor vehicles, such as the aforementioned aircraft, ships, rail vehicles, dynamic or static systems, medical devices, power equipment, etc. Figure 3 The notifications 216 presented in are merely examples of the various notifications 216 that may be generated based on a large set of indicators 222, attributes, and variables. Notifications 216 may be generated accordingly depending on the activity of the system being modeled, such that the present disclosure fully contemplates indicators 222 that include a wide combination of visual, auditory, tactile, or other types of attributes, including those that may be considered machine or computer attributes, at least insofar as they are intended to interface with a machine rather than a person, such as to provide data, information, metrics, etc. as feedback to another system. Non-textual auditory content may be distinguished based on selected timbre, pulse duration, pulse rate, frequency, loudness, etc. Haptic content may be distinguished based on pulse pattern, inter-pulse interval, pulse duration, pulse repetition rate or number of pulses, vibration intensity, etc.
[0041] The discrimination tool 210 can be configured to utilize the properties of each notification 216 to help generate a discrimination rating for the corresponding notification 216. In other words, the discrimination tool 210 can be configured to generate a discrimination rating for each notification 216 based on the indicators 222 and attributes associated with the notification 216. One non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure contemplates generating a discrimination rating for each state transition. The discrimination rating can be used in this manner to quantify the relative discrimination between the notifications 216 of each state transition in a comparable manner based on the difference between the pre-transition state and the post-transition state associated therewith. Figure 4 A discriminability abstract table 250 is shown in accordance with one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure. The discriminability abstract table 250 can be configured to visually display a discriminability rating generated for each state transition. The state transitions can correspond to activities, events, etc. associated with transitioning from one state to another state, i.e., from a pre-transition state to a post-transition state. The discriminability abstract table 250 can include a plurality of cells cross-referenced with respect to pre-transition states from one of the states and post-transition states from one of the states, and for non-limiting purposes, the states are shown corresponding to listing the pre-transition states along a vertical axis 252 and listing the post-transition states along a horizontal axis 254.
[0042] The discrimination abstract table 250 can be used in this way to depict each state transition according to the FSM principle. The discrimination rating included in each cell can be used to represent the discrimination of the notification 216 associated with the relevant state transition. The discrimination rating can be used in this way to quantify the relative discrimination between the notification 216 of the pre-conversion state and the post-conversion state associated with it. The discrimination rating can be used to represent or otherwise standardize how much difference there is between the notification 216 at the beginning of the state transition and the notification 216 at the end of the corresponding state transition. In other words, the discrimination rating can be configured to represent or standardize how much difference there is between the pre-conversion notification and the post-conversion notification. The ability to provide a discrimination rating for each state transition may be beneficial in helping designers, software programs, etc. determine information, which is conducive to comparing whether the modeled system provides a user, machine or other entity with a notification 216 that can be reasonably perceived, noticed, seen and / or cognitively clear as feedback when completing one or more state transitions. The discrimination rating can be used to quantify the differences between the notifications 216 according to the size, prominence, etc. of the indicator 222 and attributes associated with the notification 216.
[0043] One non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure contemplates including one or more values, metrics, or other factors as part of a discrimination rating. As such, the discrimination rating may be presented in a variety of forms, optionally including a combination of alphanumeric text, indicia, icons, annotations, color coding, and the like. For non-limiting purposes, Figure 4 The discrimination rating is shown to be configured to include a value, a color coding, and a feasibility annotation. The value can be obtained by assigning a value to each attribute and generating the discrimination rating as a function of the difference between the values of the post-conversion notification and the pre-conversion notification associated therewith. The discrimination rating can be calculated as a delta difference between the values of the post-conversion notification and the pre-conversion notification associated therewith.
[0044] The value included as part of the discrimination rating may be generated as the difference between the sum of the weighted values assigned to each attribute 222 of each notification 216. The value as a number may be calculated using the following formula:
[0045] N=w_1*|f_1-t_1|+w_2*|f_2-t_2|+… (Formula 1)
[0046] where w_1, w_2, etc. are weights, f_i is the value of a single indicator assigned to the "from" state, and t_i is the value of a single indicator assigned to the "to" state.
[0047] You can also use the following formula:
[0048] N=w_1*c_1+w_2*c_2+…
[0049] Here, if f_i=t_i, then c_i=0, and if f_i!=t_i, then c_i=1 (Formula 2). The operator != denotes strict inequality.
[0050] In this manner, a number (N) may be used to represent the magnitude of the delta difference between the discrimination rating values of notifications 216 of associated state transitions.
[0051] Color coding or other visual representations such as shading included as part of the discrimination rating may calculate a color magnitude representing the delta difference in discrimination rating associated therewith. The color coding shown is shown as limited to Figure 4 A color-coded diagram is shown to the right, where the color-coded diagram converts numbers into visual indicators 222, which for exemplary purposes are shown to correspond to darker colors representing less differentiation and lighter colors representing greater differentiation.
[0052] A feasibility annotation may be a visual representation included as part of each discrimination rating, which for non-limiting purposes is shown as corresponding to a boxed annotation being present or omitted from the relevant cell. A feasibility annotation may be based on a determination as to whether a corresponding state transition is determined to be one of feasible and infeasible. Figure 4 A number of solid-colored cells without a discrimination rating are shown because the corresponding cells are aligned with a state transition, and thus the notification 216 associated therewith may not be reached or used. A state transition from state A back to the same state A may not be feasible and / or relevant for the purposes of notification 216, because the corresponding notifications 216 will be identical. For purposes of theoretical possibility and / or to satisfy FSM principles for generating a truth table or other table for each notification 216, Figure 4 The state transitions in may be included in the discrimination abstract table 250. However, it may be impossible, impractical, or otherwise infeasible for the modeled system to make the corresponding state transitions or to make the corresponding state transitions when operating within normal operating boundaries or capabilities. Feasibility annotations may be used to indicate state transitions in this manner, thereby indicating corresponding discrimination ratings associated with feasible state transition teams. Another method of accounting for state transition feasibility may be based on omitting or removing color for those state transitions that are determined to be infeasible.
[0053] The discriminability abstract table 250 is believed to be beneficial in providing an output that a host computer 12 or other device operable in accordance with the present disclosure may generate from processing the state transition table 60 and the feedback table 214. The host computer 12 and / or another entity operable with the modeled system may include corresponding non-transitory instructions stored on a computer-readable storage medium that, when executed by one or more processors, may be sufficient to facilitate generating and / or presenting a discriminability rating in the manner described herein, i.e., via the discriminability abstract table 250 in a manner that may be visually interfaced with an individual and / or in another manner that may generate an equivalent file or data construct that can be provided to another computer or logic-programmed entity. Thus, the discriminability tool 210 is believed to be a substantial, technical, and functional improvement that can implement the underlying computational and logical processes described herein in a manner that an individual operator may not be able to reproduce on their own and in a manner that presents the underlying information and converts it into a significantly more helpful and beneficial form.
[0054] Figure 5 A flowchart 260 of a method for characterizing the discrimination of notifications 216 according to one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure is shown. The method may be used to facilitate characterizing the discrimination of notifications 216 for a system modeled with an FSM or other system in which it may be desirable to provide notifications 216 as feedback to a user, machine, computer, etc. when the system transitions from one state to another, i.e., when a new post-transition state is reached. Block 262 involves an analysis process in which a tabulation module or other feature of the host computer 12 may be configured to determine a state transition table 60 for the system modeled with an FSM. The state transition table 60 may correspond to the above Figure 2 , wherein a plurality of state transitions between a plurality of states 63 may be identified, each state transition event defining a rule for transitioning from a pre-transition state in the states to another post-transition state in the states. Block 264 relates to discrimination or other features, and the host computer 12 may be configured to generate a discrimination rating for each state transition based on quantifying the relative discrimination between the notification 216 of the pre-transition state and the notification 216 of the post-transition state associated with the state transition in a comparable manner. The discrimination ratings may be generated in the above manner by arranging the discrimination ratings in a discrimination abstract table 250 for visual inspection and / or by distributing the discrimination ratings in another form (e.g., a table, an electronic data set, etc.). Block 268 relates to a discrimination analysis process, wherein the discrimination tool 210 and / or another feature of the host computer may be configured to process the discrimination abstract table 250 or other discrimination representation output from block 264. For example, the discrimination analysis process may include the host computer outside the distribution device automatically identifying or otherwise drawing attention to discrimination ratings that are below a desired threshold (e.g., a threshold selected according to design parameters).
[0055] As described above, the differentiation tool 210 and other features of the present disclosure can be used to formally (verify) improve the identification of state transition issues that are perceptible, noticed, seen, and / or cognitively clear to the HMI, automatically highlight topics for focused empirical verification, improve the speed and accuracy of the HMI design process, and / or automatically verify the notification of state transitions. For example, the system may be useful for advanced automation systems composed of multiple modes and system states within modes, each mode and system state within a mode involving different control behaviors and responsibilities of the system, wherein the transitions between system modes and states can be clearly visible to the user to promote correct understanding and appropriate usage behavior. The present disclosure proposes a state transition visibility tool (STVT) or other tool configured in multiple modes to identify HMI notification issues. Verification can be done manually through visual inspection, or automatically through a computerized system, such as based on a description of system modes, such as a state transition table with a set of visual characteristics, which can then produce a system evaluation of HMI notifications according to a set of rules. Modern automation systems can be extremely complex because such systems may include various modes and transition rules, some of which are automatically executed, while others are based on various timers with hidden logic.
[0056] The present disclosure contemplates a tool for providing clear user feedback when a state transition is the result of a direct user action, but nevertheless, a clear state transition that can be reasonably perceived, noticed, seen, and / or recognized may be necessary when the transition is automatic, which may be triggered by the system following specific rules associated with internal system events, external events not initiated by the user, or timeout events. Without state transition notification, confusion may arise in perceiving the exact pattern. Such inaccuracy or inconsistency in interaction may affect the ease of learning / understanding of the system. The elements described herein can provide a set of properties for quantifying notifications of state transitions, so that using this approach, the potential for improving and developing more user-friendly designs in future HMI systems can also be identified. In at least this manner, one non-limiting aspect of the present disclosure relates to validating state transition notifications in critical or otherwise complex finite state machine (FSM) type systems, automatically verifying design correctness based on an evaluation of, for example, visual, auditory, tactile, and / or multi-modal state transition notifications to highlight potential user confusion, mode errors, and learnability difficulties, which is particularly advantageous when cognitive clarity may be difficult to achieve without sufficient distinction between different states and / or when it may be desirable to identify design errors prior to implementing the system.
[0057] In the case where the discriminability tool determines that the discriminability is poor or lower than the expected after the state transition, a sign or low additional score or rating can be provided. For example, when negative feedback (such as when the indicator disappears) is used as the only indication of the state transition, a sign or low score should be given. After the automated check, if the discriminability between different states after the state transition is low, or in other words, when high visual similarity may occur between two different states, a sign can be provided. The present disclosure can advantageously rate the differences in terms of shape, size, color, pulse, pattern, position, and optionally also have the additional characteristics mentioned above for other modalities, such as the rating can be affected by the size of each component and its viewing angle, such as when the steering wheel light bar has a weight 9 times greater than the indicator due to its size, prominence and proximity to normal sight. Following this strategy, it may not be enough to change the color of the indicator and keep the steering wheel color unchanged after the transition (for example, when converting from one state to another, the change may be very subtle, while the important steering wheel light bar is still green). The discriminability tool can help identify the lack of discrimination in this regard and draw attention to the need to correct it.
[0058] The terms "include", "comprises" and "have" are open-ended inclusions, thus indicating the presence of the stated features, steps, operations, elements or parts, but not excluding the presence or addition of one or more other features, steps, operations, elements or parts. When possible, the order of steps, processes and operations can be changed, and additional or alternative steps can be adopted. As used in this specification, the term "or" includes any and all combinations of the associated listed items. The term "any of" should be understood to include any possible combination of the referenced items, including "any of" the referenced items. "One", "one", "the", "at least one" and "one or more" are used interchangeably to indicate that at least one item exists. Unless the context clearly indicates otherwise, there may be multiple such items. Unless otherwise clearly or clearly indicated by the context (including the attached claims), all values of parameters (e.g., quantities or conditions) should be understood to be modified by the term "approximately" in all cases, regardless of whether "approximately" actually appears before the value. A component that is "configured to" perform a specified function is able to perform the specified function without modification, not just having the possibility to perform the specified function after further modification. In other words, the described hardware, when expressly configured to perform a specified function, is specifically selected, created, implemented, utilized, programmed, and / or designed to perform the specified function.
[0059] Although various embodiments are described, the description is intended to be exemplary rather than restrictive, and it is obvious to those of ordinary skill in the art that there may be many more embodiments and implementations within the scope of these embodiments. Unless explicitly limited, any feature of any embodiment may be used or replaced in combination with any other feature or element in any other embodiment. Therefore, the embodiments should not be subject to other restrictions except according to the attached claims and their equivalents. In addition, various modifications and changes may be made within the scope of the attached claims. Although several modes for implementing many aspects of this teaching have been described in detail, technicians familiar with the fields to which these teachings are related will recognize various alternative aspects for practicing this teaching within the scope of the attached claims. It is intended that all of the contents contained in the above description or shown in the accompanying drawings be interpreted as explanations and examples of alternative embodiments of the full range, and ordinary technicians will recognize the alternative embodiments of the full range, as implied by the included content, structurally and / or functionally equivalent to the included content, or otherwise apparent based on the included content, and not limited to those embodiments that are explicitly depicted and / or described.
Claims
1. A method for characterizing notification discrimination of a system modeled as a finite state machine (FSM), comprising: Identify multiple states for a system modeled with an FSM; for each state identifying notifications to be presented, each notification presenting one or more indicators selected from a set of indicators, the set of indicators comprising at least one of a visual, an audible, and a tactile attribute; identifying a plurality of state transitions between the states, each state transition defining an event for transitioning from a pre-transition state in the state to another post-transition state in the state; as well as A discrimination rating is generated for each state transition, each discrimination rating quantifying in a comparable manner the relative discrimination between notifications of a pre-transition state and notifications of a post-transition state of the state transition with which it is associated.
2. The method according to claim 1, further comprising: The discrimination rating is generated based at least in part on attributes of the notification of the pre-transition state and the notification of the post-transition state associated with the discrimination rating.
3. The method according to claim 2, further comprising: Assign a value to each attribute; as well as The discrimination rating is generated as a function of the values of the notification of the pre-transition state and the notification of the post-transition state with which it is associated.
4. The method according to claim 3, further comprising: The discrimination rating is generated as being proportional to a delta difference between the values of the notification of the pre-transition state and the notification of the post-transition state with which it is associated.
5. The method according to claim 4, further comprising: Included as part of each discrimination rating is a number representing the magnitude of the delta difference in discrimination rating associated therewith.
6. The method according to claim 5, further comprising: Included as part of each discrimination rating is a color code that represents the color magnitude of the delta difference in discrimination rating associated therewith.
7. The method according to claim 6, further comprising: The discrimination ratings are presented in a discrimination abstract table that cross-references a plurality of cells relative to a plurality of columns and rows, each column and row being associated with one of the states, each cell representing a state transition of the column and row cross-referenced thereto.
8. The method according to claim 7, further comprising: Identify each state transition as either feasible or infeasible; as well as Each discrimination rating for a state transition that is considered feasible includes a feasibility annotation, and each discrimination rating for a state transition that is considered infeasible omits a feasibility annotation.
9. A method for characterizing notification discrimination of a system modeled as a finite state machine (FSM), comprising: Based on multiple state transitions between multiple states of a system modeled with an FSM, identify: An event of transitioning from a pre-transition state in the state to another post-transition state in the state; as well as A post-transition notification to be rendered when each post-transition state is reached; as well as A discriminability rating is generated for each post-transition notification, each discriminability rating quantifying the discriminability of the post-transition notification for the post-transition state with which it is associated.
10. The method according to claim 9, further comprising: The discrimination rating is generated to quantify the discrimination of the post-transition notification relative to the pre-transition notification of the pre-transition state of the state transition associated therewith.
