United country sustainable development target localization evaluation method
By building a localized indicator system and sustainable development index of SDGs, the problem of poor data monitoring and statistical support capabilities in various regions has been solved, and the localized assessment of the Sustainable Development Goals has been achieved, which is the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development Implementation provides a basis for decision-making.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410654768.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-24
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
AI Technical Summary
In the implementation of the United Nations "2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development", different development stages and levels of regions are different, resulting in poor data monitoring and statistical support capabilities, making it difficult to achieve localized assessment of the Sustainable Development Goals.
Design a method for localized assessment of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, including building a system of localized indicators for SDGs, a method for SDGs indexes and dashboards, and a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities, and identify statistical rules by obtaining and screening localized indicators. and thresholds, build a human sustainable development index, a resource and environmental sustainable utilization index and a social and economic development driving force sustainability index, and form a comprehensive local sustainable development index.
This method can provide decision-making basis for national and local assessments of their contribution to the SDGs, help accurately plan and implement the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development and achieve accurate assessments of different administrative regions.
Smart Images

Figure CN119026931A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of localized assessment of sustainable development goals, and in particular to a localized assessment method for United Nations sustainable development goals. Background Art
[0002] The United Nations 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development proposes a system of sustainable development goals (SDGs). At present, countries have localized SDGs according to their own actual conditions and development demands, promoted the integration of SDGs into local development plans and implementation plans, and built a localized sustainable development indicator system. However, due to the insufficiency and imbalance of development, as well as the different development stages and levels of various regions, the main problems and focuses of the implementation of SDGs are different, and there are also large differences in data monitoring and statistical support capabilities. It is very difficult to achieve localized evaluation of sustainable development goals. Therefore, it is very necessary to design a localized evaluation method for the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. Summary of the invention
[0003] The purpose of this invention is to provide a localized assessment method for the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, which can evaluate the contribution of national and local sustainable development actions to the SDGs, calculate the progress of SDGs in administrative regions at different levels, such as national, provincial, city, district, county and township, and provide a decision-making basis for the precise planning and implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.
[0004] To achieve the above object, the present invention provides the following solutions:
[0005] A localized assessment method for the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, comprising the following steps:
[0006] Step 1: Build a localized indicator system for SDGs;
[0007] Step 2: Constructing the SDG Index and Dashboard methodology;
[0008] Step 3: Conduct a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities.
[0009] Optionally, in step 1, a localized indicator system for SDGs is constructed, specifically:
[0010] Obtain a localized indicator system that conforms to the SDGs context and screen it to form a localized evaluation indicator system for SDGs.
[0011] Optionally, in step 2, a method for constructing a SDG index and dashboard is as follows:
[0012] Determine the statistical rules and evaluation thresholds for each indicator in the SDGs localized evaluation indicator system. For the SDGs native indicators, the indicator monitoring statistics determined by IAEG-SDGs are adopted. For the local characteristic indicators, the statistical rules of the local area are adopted. The Sustainable Development Goals Index and Dashboard method are constructed based on the statistical rules of the indicators. The specific steps include:
[0013] Step 201: Determine upper and lower thresholds;
[0014] Step 202: Standardize the data of all indicators;
[0015] Step 203: weighting and aggregating the standardized data;
[0016] Step 204: Build an SDG dashboard based on the weighted and aggregated data.
[0017] Optionally, in step 3, a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities is conducted, specifically:
[0018] Construct the human sustainable development index, resource and environmental sustainable utilization index and social and economic development driving force sustainability index; construct the local sustainable development comprehensive index based on the human sustainable development index, resource and environmental sustainable utilization index and social and economic development driving force sustainability index; conduct a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities based on the local sustainable development comprehensive index.
[0019] According to the specific embodiments provided by the present invention, the present invention discloses the following technical effects: the present invention provides a localized assessment method for the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, which includes constructing a localized indicator system for SDGs that complies with United Nations rules and adapts to China's national conditions, establishing a sustainable development goal index and dashboard accounting method considering the level of social and economic development and resource endowment conditions, and conducting a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities. This method can evaluate the contribution of national and local sustainable development actions to SDGs, calculate the progress of SDGs in administrative regions at different levels such as national, provincial, urban, district, county and township, and provide a decision-making basis for the precise planning and implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0020] Figure 1 This is a flow chart of a method for localizing assessment of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0021] Figure 2 Diagram of the decision tree for selecting the localized indicator system for SDGs;
[0022] Figure 3 This is a diagram showing the comprehensive score of sustainable development and the scores of each pillar of development in Chenzhou City from 2005 to 2019;
[0023] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram of the overall development process of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals localization assessment method according to an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0024] The purpose of this invention is to provide a localized assessment method for the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, which can evaluate the contribution of national and local sustainable development actions to the SDGs, calculate the progress of SDGs in administrative regions at different levels, such as national, provincial, city, district, county and township, and provide a decision-making basis for the precise planning and implementation of the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development.
[0025] In order to make the above-mentioned objects, features and advantages of the present invention more obvious and easy to understand, the present invention is further described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments.
[0026] like Figure 1 As shown, the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals localization assessment method provided by the embodiment of the present invention includes the following steps:
[0027] Step 1: Build a localized indicator system for SDGs;
[0028] Step 2: Constructing the SDG Index and Dashboard methodology;
[0029] Step 3: Conduct a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities.
[0030] The present invention takes the localized assessment of China's sustainable development goals as an example to introduce the above steps in detail;
[0031] In step 1, a localized indicator system for SDGs is constructed, specifically:
[0032] The system considers the basic conditions for the assessment of 17 goals, 169 sub-goals, and 231 indicators in the context of SDGs, coordinates the progress of SDGs localization at home and abroad, retains the indicators proposed by IAEG-SDGs for which China has reliable data sources, and for the indicators determined by IAEG-SDGs that cannot be used directly, considers the existing domestic target indicators and local statistical indicators determined by the "National Sustainable Development Pilot Zone Innovation Capacity Evaluation Index System", "Ecological Civilization Construction Assessment Target System", "Sustainable Development Pilot Zone Annual Statistical Indicators" and "Green Development Index System", and replaces the SDGs indicators that cannot be used directly to form a set of Chinese localized indicator systems that conform to the SDGs context. On this basis, according to China's national conditions and the resource and environmental endowment conditions of different cities, key indicators are selected to form an SDGs localized evaluation indicator system. The selection process is as follows: Figure 2 As shown, a brief introduction is given:
[0033] (1) Eliminate indicators that are not suitable for assessing China’s progress. Since the global indicator framework officially recognized by the United Nations evaluates progress at the global and regional levels, it cannot be directly used to evaluate the sustainable development progress of specific countries. Therefore, it is necessary to first examine the indicators proposed by the IAEG-SDGs and eliminate those that are not suitable for direct assessment at the national level and are inconsistent with China’s national conditions.
[0034] (2) Retain indicators that are assessable and measurable in China. China’s sustainable development indicator system is built based on the country’s monitoring needs for implementing the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development. It is necessary to retain indicators in the United Nations context to the greatest extent possible to facilitate the connection between evaluation results and international standards and to more clearly demonstrate the progress of China’s implementation of the SDGs.
[0035] (3) Replace indicators that are inconsistent with local indicator expressions but can be revised and improved. For indicators that do not have data sources in China, consider the similarity of some indicators in the alternative indicators of the China Sustainable Development Index Database and look for indicators with the same connotation as the IAEG-SDGs indicators, reliable data sources, and high search frequencies for replacement, so as to ensure both the reliable availability of indicator data and the universality of indicator expressions.
[0036] (4) Eliminate the remaining indicators that do not meet the conditions for localization. For the indicators proposed by IAEG-SDGs, a large part of them have no data sources in China and are replaced by local indicators that do not have the same connotations. Under China's current assessment system, they will not be included in the SDGs China localization evaluation indicator system for the time being.
[0037] (5) Add indicators with clear domestic assessment requirements that can reflect innovative practices and are consistent with the content of the 169 specific goals. Taking into full consideration China's national conditions and national assessment needs, the indicators in the China Sustainable Development Index Database that have clear national assessment requirements and are consistent with the content of the 169 specific goals are added to the SDGs China localized evaluation indicator system, such as "safe utilization rate of polluted cultivated land", "contribution rate of scientific and technological progress", "coverage rate of digital infrastructure", "coverage rate of agricultural products' three products and one standard' certification" and other indicators.
[0038] In step 2, the SDG index and dashboard methodology is constructed, specifically:
[0039] Determine the statistical rules and evaluation thresholds for each indicator in the SDGs localized evaluation indicator system. For the native SDGs indicators, the indicator monitoring statistics determined by IAEG-SDGs are adopted. For the local characteristic indicators, the statistical rules of the local area are adopted. The Sustainable Development Goals Index and Dashboard method are constructed based on the statistical rules of the indicators. The specific steps include:
[0040] Step 201: Determine upper and lower thresholds;
[0041] To make the data across indicators comparable, each variable is rescaled from 0 to 100, where 0 represents the worst performance and 100 represents the best performance. Rescaling is often very sensitive to the choice of the limits of the two tails of the distribution and extreme values (outliers). The latter may become unexpected thresholds and introduce spurious variability in the data. Therefore, the choice of upper and lower limits may affect the relative ranking of countries or regions in the index. The upper limit for each indicator is determined using a five-step decision tree, specifically:
[0042] (1) Use of absolute numerical thresholds in the Sustainable Development Goals and targets: for example, zero poverty, universal school completion, universal access to water and sanitation, and full gender equality.
[0043] (2) In the absence of clear sustainable development goals, the principle of “leaving no one behind” should be applied when setting universal access or zero deprivation ceilings for the following types of indicators.
[0044] (3) Where there are science-based targets that must be achieved by 2030 or later, use these to set a 100% cap (e.g., requiring zero CO2 greenhouse gas emissions by 2050 to stay within the 1.5°C temperature limit, or 100% sustainable management of fisheries).
[0045] (4) In cases where several countries have exceeded the SDG targets, the average of the top five performing countries is used (e.g., child mortality).
[0046] (5) For all other indicators, the average values of the best performing countries are used; for indicators related to resource and environmental performance, the single-factor ecological deficit method is used for calculation based on the ecological footprint and biocapacity accounting techniques, with ecological surplus as the goal orientation. The higher the deficit, the lower the score.
[0047] These principles interpret the SDGs as "stretch goals" and focus attention on the indicators where a country is lagging behind. The lower limit is defined at the bottom 2.5 percentile. Each indicator distribution is censored so that all values above the upper limit are scored 100 points and those below the lower limit are scored 0 points.
[0048] Step 202: Standardize the data of all indicators;
[0049] After determining the upper and lower limits, the variables are linearly transformed to the range 0 to 100 using the following rescaling formula in the range [0; 100]:
[0050]
[0051] In the formula, x is the original data value, max / min represent the best and worst performance extremes of all data under the same indicator, and are the standardized values after calculation;
[0052] After this calculation process, the data of all indicators can be compared in ascending order, that is, a higher value means that the country or region is closer to achieving the sustainable development goals. For example, if a country or region scores 50 on an indicator, it means that the implementation effect of the sustainable development goal of the country or region has reached half of the optimal value. If it scores 75 on an indicator, it means that the country or region has gone three quarters of the way to achieve the optimal effect.
[0053] Step 203: weighting and aggregating the standardized data;
[0054] The results of several rounds of expert consultations on early drafts of the Sustainable Development Index showed that there was no consensus among different communities of thought to give some SDGs higher weights than others. Therefore, as a normative assumption, the report chose to give each SDG a fixed, equal weight to reflect policymakers’ commitment to treat all SDGs equally and as a set of “integrated and indivisible” goals. This means that in order to improve their SDG Index score, countries need to focus on all goals, with a particular focus on the goals for which they are furthest from being achieved and the goals for which incremental progress is expected to be the fastest.
[0055] To calculate the SDG Index, we first estimate the score for each goal using the arithmetic mean of the indicators for that goal. Then, we average these scores across all 17 SDGs to obtain the SDG Index score. Various sensitivity tests have been provided in the report, including a comparison of the arithmetic mean with the geometric mean, and Monte Carlo simulations at the index and target levels. Monte Carlo simulations require caution in interpreting small differences in index scores and rankings between countries, as these scores and rankings may be sensitive to the weighting scheme.
[0056] Step 204: constructing an SDG dashboard based on the weighted and aggregated data;
[0057] The SDG Dashboards uses available data to reflect the overall implementation of the 17 SDGs through four color codes: red, orange, yellow, and green. When using the color coding table, quantified critical values are introduced according to each indicator of all countries, and then the overall score of each SDG goal and each country is calculated by aggregating the indicators of each goal;
[0058] In order to assess the progress of a country or region on a certain SDG target, the present invention considers four color indication levels: green means that the country or region faces fewer challenges in achieving the 17 SDGs, and some targets have even reached the critical values required to achieve the target; from yellow to orange to red, it means that the distance to achieving the SDG target is getting farther and farther, and there are increasing challenges in achieving the 2030 Sustainable Development Goals. Since 2016, the thresholds have been determined using statistical techniques and through rounds of consultations with experts, and all thresholds are stipulated in absolute form and apply to all countries. The indicator or target status description table is shown in Table 1;
[0059] Table 1 Indicator or target status description table
[0060]
[0061] Averaging all indicators for each SDG has the potential to obscure areas of policy concern if a country or region performs well on most indicators for a goal but faces significant shortfalls on one or two (often referred to as the “substitutability” or “compensation” problem). This is particularly true for high-income and upper-middle-income countries, which have made significant progress on many SDGs but may face significant shortfalls on individual ones;
[0062] Therefore, the SDG dashboard uses the average of the two lowest-scoring indicators of each SDG to represent the color of the SDG. If a country has only one indicator for an SDG goal, the color level of the indicator determines the overall rating of the goal. A new rule is added: only when the two lowest-scoring indicators are both green, the corresponding SDG goal can be scored green - otherwise the goal will be rated yellow; similarly, only when the two lowest-scoring indicators are both red, the corresponding SDG goal will use red. If there is only one indicator for a certain sustainable development goal in the country with data available, the color level of the indicator will determine the overall evaluation of the SDG goal.
[0063] In step 3, a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities is conducted, specifically:
[0064] According to the basic principles of sustainable development, focusing on the actual assessment needs of social sustainable development, economic sustainable development and sustainable development of resources and environment, and taking full account of the mature international sustainable development assessment indexes, the localized sustainable development indicators that have been obtained are classified according to human sustainable development, sustainable use of resources and environment, and sustainability of social and economic development dynamics. According to China's national conditions and the resource and environmental endowment conditions of different cities, key indicators are selected to form a sustainable development indicator evaluation technology system. Drawing on the United Nations Human Development Index and considering indicators related to human sustainable development, it is planned to establish a human sustainable development index composed of life expectancy per capita, consolidation rate of nine-year compulsory education, gross enrollment rate of three years of preschool education, gross enrollment rate of higher education, average years of education of the working-age population, per capita GDP and Gini coefficient (an indicator that considers fairness and consequence); drawing on the ecological deficit accounting system based on ecological footprint and biocapacity provided by the "Earth Vitality Report" and "China Ecological Footprint Report" published annually by the World Wildlife Fund (WWF), connecting with the current "Regulations on the Audit of Natural Resource Assets of Leading Cadres (Trial)" and environmental protection assessment in my country (especially the "Environmental Protection Responsibility Assessment Index System" issued by some identities), establish a human sustainable development index composed of the proportion of direct economic losses from natural disasters to GDP, environmental quality improvement rate The resource and environmental sustainable utilization index is composed of the following: (ratio of days with good air quality in cities at or above the prefecture level, proportion of surface water quality reaching or better than Class III water bodies, proportion of urban centralized drinking water sources with water quality reaching or better than Class III, proportion of black and odorous water bodies eliminated in urban built-up areas, annual average concentration of PM2.5), effective protection level of ecological space (green space coverage rate in built-up areas, newly added area for soil and water loss control, forest coverage rate, wetland area, comprehensive vegetation coverage of grassland), and improvement level of resource utilization (arable land reserves, safe utilization rate of polluted cultivated land, comprehensive utilization rate of crop straw, reduction rate of water consumption per unit of GDP, reduction rate of energy consumption per unit of GDP, carbon dioxide emissions per unit of GDP, and land development intensity) to ensure that the current core goals of environmental quality do not decline, ecological diversity does not decline, and resource supply and demand can be balanced. Taking into full consideration the new situation and new requirements of innovative development, combined with the new needs of the transformation of old and new kinetic energy and high-quality development, we will establish a social and economic development driving force sustainability index consisting of labor productivity (agricultural labor productivity, total labor productivity), the proportion of research and experimental development (R&D) expenditure in GDP, the proportion of energy conservation and environmental protection expenditure in fiscal expenditure, technology market turnover, patent ownership per 10,000 people, and the contribution rate of scientific and technological progress (taking into account the current science and technology assessment tasks to add result indicators). Finally, we will form a local sustainable development comprehensive index composed of the human sustainable development index, the resource and environmental sustainable utilization index, and the social and economic development driving force sustainability index, as shown in Table 2.
[0065] Table 2 Comprehensive evaluation indicator system for sustainable development based on SDGs
[0066]
[0067]
[0068] The present invention provides a detailed case, taking Chenzhou City, Hunan Province as an example:
[0069] Based on the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs) system, combined with the planetary boundary theory, and starting from the characteristics of sustainable development of resource-based cities, an evaluation index system for sustainable development of resource-based cities oriented to SDGs was established, consisting of two systems, namely the human development system and the natural environment, four pillars, 12 fields and 48 indicators. Drawing on the global SDGs practical experience and considering the indicator attribute categories, the indicator thresholds were comprehensively determined, and the principal component analysis was introduced to establish a comprehensive evaluation technology system using improved deviation standardization, obstacle analysis and coupling coordination analysis, as shown in Table 3;
[0070] Table 3 Evaluation index system of human development system in resource-based cities
[0071]
[0072]
[0073]
[0074]
[0075] When selecting indicators, in addition to considering general evaluation indicators for resources and environment, it is also necessary to combine the characteristics of resource utilization and environmental damage in resource-based cities to determine indicators in a targeted and flexible manner. The final natural environment system indicator system is shown in Table 4;
[0076] Table 4 Evaluation index system of natural environment system in resource-based cities
[0077]
[0078]
[0079]
[0080]
[0081] When determining the upper limit of the indicator threshold, the principle of "leaving no one behind" in the 2030 Agenda for Sustainable Development is taken as the basic criterion. With reference to the current domestic and international practical exploration and typical experience in evaluating the progress of SDGs, the scenario method is used to determine the optimal value of the indicator. The specific rules are shown in Table 5.
[0082] Table 5 Optimal value determination rules
[0083]
[0084]
[0085] According to the comprehensive evaluation method of sustainable development, the comprehensive score of sustainable development and the scores of each pillar in Chenzhou City from 2005 to 2019 are calculated as follows: Figure 3 As shown in the figure, the broken line represents the comprehensive score of sustainable development in Chenzhou City. The sustainable development of Chenzhou City can be divided into three stages: in 2005, Chenzhou City was in a relatively weak sustainable development stage, in 2006-2015, it was in a medium sustainable stage, and in 2016-2019, it was upgraded to a relatively strong sustainable development stage. The overall level showed a steady upward trend, but it has been declining in the past three years. Further exploration combined with the bar chart (scores of each pillar development) found that welfare security and ecological environment development have always been at a good level, from a medium development level to a strong development level; natural resources were initially at a relatively weak development level, and after more than 10 years of development, there has been a significant improvement overall, with the largest improvement of 71.3%, but it has declined significantly in the past four years, and only reached a relatively strong development level in 2016; and the pillar of development momentum performed the worst, always at a relatively weak and medium development level, with extremely slow progress, lower than the overall progress level. Compared with other pillars, the score of the development momentum pillar has become the main obstacle to improving Chenzhou's sustainable development score. Development momentum has become a potential constraint on Chenzhou's sustainable development and green transformation, and attention should be paid to the obstacle factors within this pillar.
[0086] The present invention provides a localized assessment method for the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, which includes constructing a localized indicator system for SDGs, constructing a sustainable development goal index and dashboard method, and conducting a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities. The method can achieve localized assessment of sustainable development goals, provide technical support for local progress assessments, and is easy to use.
[0087] The present invention uses specific examples to illustrate the principles and implementation methods of the present invention. The above examples are only used to help understand the method and core ideas of the present invention. At the same time, for those skilled in the art, according to the ideas of the present invention, there will be changes in the specific implementation methods and application scope. In summary, the content of this specification should not be understood as limiting the present invention.
Claims
1. A localized assessment method for the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, characterized by: The steps include: Step 1: Build a localized indicator system for SDGs; Step 2: Constructing the SDG Index and Dashboard methodology; Step 3: Conduct a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities.
2. The localized assessment method for the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In step 1, a localized indicator system for SDGs is constructed, specifically: Obtain a localized indicator system that conforms to the SDGs context and screen it to form a localized evaluation indicator system for SDGs.
3. The localized assessment method of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals according to claim 2 is characterized in that: In step 2, the SDG index and dashboard methodology is constructed, specifically: Determine the statistical rules and evaluation thresholds for each indicator in the SDGs localized evaluation indicator system. For the SDGs native indicators, the indicator monitoring statistics determined by IAEG-SDGs are adopted. For the local characteristic indicators, the statistical rules of the local area are adopted. The Sustainable Development Goals Index and Dashboard method are constructed based on the statistical rules of the indicators. The specific steps include: Step 201: Determine upper and lower thresholds; Step 202: Standardize the data of all indicators; Step 203: weighting and aggregating the standardized data; Step 204: Build an SDG dashboard based on the weighted and aggregated data.
4. The method for localized assessment of the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals according to claim 3, characterized in that: In step 3, a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities is conducted, specifically: Construct the human sustainable development index, resource and environmental sustainable utilization index and social and economic development driving force sustainability index; construct the local sustainable development comprehensive index based on the human sustainable development index, resource and environmental sustainable utilization index and social and economic development driving force sustainability index; conduct a comprehensive assessment of sustainable development capabilities based on the local sustainable development comprehensive index.
Citation Information
Cited By
SDGs-oriented natural resource sustainability comprehensive evaluation and partition governance method
CN121526442A
