Post-evaluation method for high-capacity energy storage science and technology project of hydropower enterprise
By building a quantitative and process-based evaluation system, the problem of insufficient comprehensive evaluation after large-capacity energy storage technology projects was solved, and a comprehensive examination of the project's sustainability effect and output results was achieved, which improved the scientificity and accuracy of the evaluation. , provides systematic evaluation support for hydropower enterprises.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202411042642.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-31
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-06
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology lacks scientific methods to evaluate the sustainability effects and results of large-capacity energy storage technology projects and the results after completion, resulting in incomplete and accurate evaluation.
Build a quantitative, process-based and standardized evaluation system for large-capacity energy storage application-based scientific and technological projects that are suitable for hydropower development enterprises, and track it through basic indicator databases, key indicator screening and hierarchical systems, archiving evaluation standards and comprehensive quality evaluation models. The scientific and technological value, economic benefits, social benefits, environmental benefits and sustained impact of the project.
It provides a systematic evaluation method to ensure that the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects can comprehensively examine the sustainability effects of the project and the results after completion, improve the scientificity and accuracy of the evaluation, and provide hydropower enterprises with Theoretical and technical support.
Smart Images

Figure CN119090291A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of scientific and technological project evaluation, and in particular to a post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage scientific and technological project of a hydropower enterprise. Background Art
[0002] According to the development plan of large-capacity energy storage technology, the large-capacity energy storage technology plan focuses on supporting projects that break through key technologies in related fields, develop new products, and are expected to achieve good economic and social benefits after the promotion of technological achievements. Large-capacity energy storage technology projects are an important part of the scientific and technological innovation work of power grid companies and hydropower development companies. They aim to enhance the scientific and technological innovation capabilities in this field, play the supporting role of science and technology, and promote the scientific and technological progress and level of scientific and technological innovation of enterprises, so as to promote the transformation and upgrading of the large-capacity energy storage industry and further promote the development of the hydropower high-tech industry. However, at present, there is a lack of scientific evaluation methods to evaluate projects from the completion of the project to the implementation of the project. Summary of the invention
[0003] The purpose of the present invention is to provide a post-evaluation method for large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises. This method defines the research scope of post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage projects as the period from project completion to project post-evaluation implementation. The evaluation focuses on tracking the project after project completion, examining the sustainable effects of the results of large-capacity energy storage technology projects after completion, and taking the output results and benefits at the time of project completion as part of the evaluation content; this method provides theoretical and technical system support for the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises by constructing a quantitative, process-based, and standardized post-evaluation system and standards for large-capacity energy storage application-oriented technology projects suitable for hydropower development enterprises.
[0004] In order to realize the above technical features, the purpose of the present invention is achieved as follows: a post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise comprises the following steps:
[0005] Step 1: Establishment of basic indicator library:
[0006] Based on bibliometrics and historical data, and taking into account the actual scientific and technological project management needs of hydropower enterprises, a basic index database for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects is constructed;
[0007] Step 2: Screening of key indicators and establishment of a hierarchical system:
[0008] Based on the basic indicator library established in step 1, the quantitative methods of multivariate data constraint sorting, principal component analysis and redundancy analysis are integrated to quantitatively screen the key indicators for post-evaluation of energy storage technology projects layer by layer in the constructed basic indicator library, and to build a streamlined and effective key indicator system for post-evaluation of technology projects;
[0009] Step 3: Setting of secondary indicator evaluation criteria:
[0010] The evaluation indicators for the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects are evaluated in a graded manner;
[0011] Step 4, identification of primary and secondary indicator weights:
[0012] The identification of the weights of the primary and secondary indicators uses pairwise comparison and analytic hierarchy process to determine the indicator weights in a quantitative manner;
[0013] Step 5: Establishment of comprehensive quality evaluation model:
[0014] The comprehensive quality index of the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises is the weighted sum of scientific and technological value, economic benefits, social benefits, environmental benefits and sustainable impact;
[0015] Step 6: Setting of comprehensive quality evaluation criteria:
[0016] The comprehensive quality of post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises adopts a tiered evaluation standard.
[0017] Preferably, the step 1 specifically includes:
[0018] Step 1.1, apply system theory to decompose the first and second level evaluation indicators step by step;
[0019] Step 1.2, integrate bibliometrics and historical data to build a basic indicator framework;
[0020] Step 1.3, establish a basic indicator library.
[0021] Preferably, the step 1.1 specifically includes:
[0022] Step 1.1.1, primary indicator identification:
[0023] The large-capacity energy storage technology project is regarded as a system. For the post-evaluation of the system, the system theory is applied. According to the goals and completion indicators set when the project was established, the post-evaluation of the large-capacity energy storage technology project is carried out from the aspects of project management level, technical value, academic value, economic benefits, social benefits, environmental benefits and sustainable impact as the first-level indicators;
[0024] Step 1.1.2, secondary indicator screening:
[0025] According to the characteristics and types of the first-level indicators, the first-level indicators are further subdivided into second-level indicators. Similarly, each first-level indicator is divided one by one to obtain the second-level indicator clusters.
[0026] Step 1.1.3, primary and secondary evaluation indicator clusters are established:
[0027] Through the progressive decomposition of primary and secondary indicators, the hierarchical indicator clusters were established using the analytic hierarchy process, and a preliminary model of post-evaluation indicators for large-capacity energy storage technology projects was obtained.
[0028] Preferably, the step 1.2 specifically includes:
[0029] Step 1.2.1, based on the project evaluation requirements, comprehensively analyze the characteristics of the first and second level indicators, and combine multi-source literature to establish a basic indicator library for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects to ensure the scientificity and representativeness of the selected evaluation indicators;
[0030] Step 1.2.2, design a questionnaire for the post-evaluation indicators of large-capacity energy storage technology projects and conduct a large-scale survey of indicators;
[0031] Step 1.2.3, summarize the basic evaluation indicators, integrate bibliometrics and pairwise comparison methods, narrow the scope of post-evaluation indicators, reduce indicator redundancy, and narrow the scope of post-evaluation indicators;
[0032] Step 1.2.4, based on the above preliminary selection results, analyze the problems existing in the post-evaluation management process of large-capacity energy storage technology projects, modify and improve the evaluation indicators, add necessary indicators and eliminate unnecessary indicators in combination with the technological innovation needs of hydropower enterprises;
[0033] Step 1.2.6, establish the framework of the post-evaluation index system for large-capacity energy storage technology projects, determine the level of the evaluation index system, and the number of indicators at each level.
[0034] Preferably, the step 1.3 is specifically as follows: according to relevant documents and policy provisions, a post-evaluation index system for science and technology projects is established with reference to similar or similar science and technology projects, the connotation of basic indicators is clarified, and the post-evaluation index system for large-capacity energy storage science and technology projects obtained includes: 7 first-level indicators and 20 second-level indicators.
[0035] Preferably, the step 2 specifically includes:
[0036] Step 2.1, preliminary screening of key indicators based on bibliometric, analytic hierarchy process and empirical method;
[0037] Step 2.2, identify key indicators based on multivariate data constraint ranking method;
[0038] Step 2.3, key indicators are established.
[0039] Preferably, step 2.1 specifically includes:
[0040] Step 2.1.1, preliminary screening and identification of evaluation indicators:
[0041] In the initial screening and identification stage of large-capacity energy storage technology project evaluation indicators, based on various academic resource databases, with technology projects, hydropower, energy storage, and post-evaluation as keywords, relevant academic journals, master's and doctoral dissertations, and conference documents were collected and sorted out;
[0042] Step 2.1.2, revision of primary and secondary indicators:
[0043] According to the characteristics of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises, the frequency statistics and analysis of relevant evaluation indicators are carried out with the help of hierarchical analysis method, and the indicators with high attention are identified, so as to significantly narrow the scope of post-evaluation indicators of large-capacity energy storage technology projects;
[0044] Step 2.1.3, key indicators determination:
[0045] We have targetedly selected the fields of mechanical energy storage, electrochemical energy storage, electromagnetic energy storage, and electric hydrogen energy storage, and have consulted with high-level experts in the industry. We have used experience to further eliminate inappropriate indicators, determine key indicators, and clarify the connotation of indicators.
[0046] Preferably, step 2.2 specifically includes screening key indicators based on the hierarchical analysis method, and further integrating the detrended correspondence analysis, redundancy analysis and typical correspondence analysis methods to carry out quantitative screening of the leading post-evaluation factors that affect the changes in various value characteristics; the key indicator identification process for post-evaluation of scientific and technological projects is as follows:
[0047] Step 2.2.1, standardization of original variables:
[0048] Obtain the data of each basic post-evaluation indicator, and use statistical analysis to transform the data and standardize the data;
[0049] Step 2.2.2, analysis of changes in evaluation indicators:
[0050] The detrended correspondence analysis method is used to analyze the evaluation index data to determine the distribution form of data changes;
[0051] Step 2.2.3, sorting model selection:
[0052] Select the sorting model for the relationship analysis of two groups of variables based on the results of the detrended correspondence analysis:
[0053] ① If the maximum value of the four-axis gradient length is >4, select the single-peak canonical correlation analysis;
[0054] ②If the gradient length value is <3, select linear redundancy analysis;
[0055] ③ If the gradient length is between 3 and 4, you can choose either redundancy analysis or canonical correspondence analysis;
[0056] Step 2.2.4, analysis of the relationship constraints between the basic and post-evaluation indicators:
[0057] ①Use the canonical correspondence analysis method to establish a unimodal model, and transform the correlation between two groups of variables into the correlation between two new variables for research;
[0058] ② Redundancy analysis method was used to establish a linear model, and regression analysis and principal component analysis were used to analyze the relationship between the five major values and various basic post-evaluation indicators;
[0059] Step 2.2.5, determine the main axis of the coordinates:
[0060] Determine the main coordinate axis according to the axis explanation rate;
[0061] Step 2.2.6, draw a sorting diagram:
[0062] Draw a two-dimensional plane diagram consisting of basic evaluation indicator arrows, environmental variable arrows, and coordinate axes;
[0063] Step 2.2.7, ranking of basic evaluation indicators:
[0064] With the help of redundancy analysis method, the basic evaluation index rays are sorted according to their vertical projection lengths on the post-evaluation rays:
[0065] ①The farther the projection point is in the direction indicated by the arrow, the higher the correlation;
[0066] ②The projection point near the origin of the coordinate system indicates that the correlation coefficient is close to 0;
[0067] ③If the projection point is in the opposite direction, the predicted correlation is negative;
[0068] Step 2.2.8, identification of driving factors of basic evaluation indicators:
[0069] The comparative analysis method is used to identify the driving factors of basic evaluation indicators. The longer the comprehensive projection, the more relevant the changes in the characteristics of basic evaluation indicators;
[0070] Step 2.3 specifically integrates the qualitative and quantitative indicator screening processes in steps 2.1 and 2.2 to determine the exclusive post-evaluation key indicator system for large-capacity energy storage technology projects, with a total of 2 layers, 5 categories and 15 indicators.
[0071] Preferably, the step 3 specifically includes: dividing each evaluation level into three grades: A, B, C, D, and E, corresponding to five grades: excellent, good, medium, poor, and low, respectively;
[0072] The evaluation criteria for the 15 secondary indicators are as follows:
[0073] (1) Theoretical innovation: refers to the number of new ideas, new laws, and new technological breakthroughs related to the development of large-capacity energy storage technology brought about after the completion of the project;
[0074] (2) Academic achievements: refers to academic papers, academic reports, the level of publications, and the number of monographs published related to large-capacity energy storage technology generated during the implementation of scientific and technological projects;
[0075] (3) Technical level: refers to whether the key large-capacity energy storage technology achieved by the project is feasible in the international, domestic or energy industry, whether it is advanced and innovative, whether the key technology can become an industry standard, and whether it has the value of promotion and application;
[0076] (4) Technological achievements: refers to the number of new products / processes / materials developed in large-capacity energy storage technology projects, the number of invention and utility patents accepted or authorized, the number of software copyrights obtained, the number of standards formed, and the number of large-capacity energy storage-related awards obtained;
[0077] (5) Direct economic benefits: refers to the added output value, added profits and taxes, and reduced expenditure cost ratio generated by the transformation of new products / processes / technical achievements related to large-capacity energy storage technology projects;
[0078] (6) Indirect economic benefits: refers to the potential benefits of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in promoting regional economic development and improving industry productivity;
[0079] (7) Scientific and technological talent training: refers to the number of national / provincial / industry scientific and technological awards or honors won for the implementation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects, the number of people promoted to intermediate or senior professional titles, and the number of scientific and technological talents trained in the team;
[0080] (8) Newly employed persons: refers to the number of jobs created and increased during the implementation or application and promotion of large-capacity energy storage technology projects;
[0081] (9) Impact on local society:
[0082] Refers to the impact of the implementation and application of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on local social politics, security, production, income, etc.;
[0083] (10) Contribution to energy conservation and emission reduction: refers to the contribution of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in energy conservation, resource utilization, pollution reduction, and carbon emission reduction;
[0084] (11) Environmentally harmonious development: refers to the impact of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on the ecological environment system of the demonstration application area and its radiation area;
[0085] (12) Impact on disciplinary research: refers to the continuous impact of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on disciplinary development;
[0086] (13) Impact on improving corporate competitiveness: refers to the successful transformation and application of the results of large-capacity energy storage technology projects, which can lead to emerging industries and drive industrial technology upgrades;
[0087] (14) Promoting effect on regional economy: refers to the effect of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on the sustainable development of regional economy;
[0088] (15) Promotion of local scientific and technological progress: refers to the role of the core results of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in promoting local scientific and technological progress.
[0089] Preferably, the step 4 specifically includes:
[0090] Step 4.1, combined with the bibliometric results, using pairwise comparison and analytic hierarchy process to determine the first-level indicator judgment matrix;
[0091] Step 4.2, combined with the bibliometric results, using pairwise comparison and analytic hierarchy process, determine the secondary indicator judgment matrix of scientific value, economic benefit, social benefit, environmental benefit, and sustainable impact;
[0092] Step 4.3, comprehensively analyze and calculate the first and second level indicator judgment matrix of scientific value, economic benefit, social benefit, environmental benefit, and sustainable impact, and obtain the weight values of the first and second level indicators of the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects;
[0093] The comprehensive quality evaluation model in step 5 is:
[0094] CQI=ST*W ST +EE*W EE +SE*W SE +ME*W ME +CI*W CI ;
[0095] Where CQI is the comprehensive quality index; ST is the technology value index, EE is the economic benefit index, SE is the social benefit index, ME is the environmental benefit index, and CI is the sustainable impact index, which are the weighted sum of each secondary index; W ST , W EE , W SE , W ME , W CI is the weight value of each first-level indicator;
[0096] In step 6, each evaluation level is divided into 5 grades: A, B, C, D, and E, corresponding to 5 grades: excellent, good, medium, low, and poor, respectively.
[0097] The present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0098] The scope of the post-evaluation study of large-capacity energy storage projects in this invention is defined as the period from project completion to project post-evaluation implementation. The evaluation focuses on tracking the project after the project is completed, examining the sustained effects of the results of the large-capacity energy storage technology project after the completion, and taking the output results and benefits at the completion of the project as part of the evaluation content. The patent constructs a quantitative, process-based, and standardized post-evaluation system and standards for large-capacity energy storage application-oriented technology projects that are suitable for hydropower development companies, providing theoretical and technical system support for the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in hydropower companies. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0099] In order to more clearly illustrate the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention, the drawings required for use in the embodiments are briefly introduced below. It should be understood that the following drawings only show certain embodiments of the present invention and therefore should not be regarded as limiting the scope. For ordinary technicians in this field, other related drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without creative work.
[0100] Figure 1 This is a pie chart of the first-level indicator weights in implementation 2 of the present invention.
[0101] Figure 2 This is a radar chart of secondary index weights in implementation 2 of the present invention.
[0102] Figure 3 This is the evaluation result of the secondary indicators in implementation 2 of the present invention.
[0103] Figure 4 It is the comprehensive index of the secondary indicators in implementation 2 of the present invention.
[0104] Figure 5 This is the first-level indicator evaluation result of implementation 2 of the present invention.
[0105] Figure 6 It is the comprehensive index of the first-level indicators in 2 of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0106] In order to make the purpose, technical solutions and advantages of the embodiments of the present invention clearer, the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are part of the embodiments of the present invention, rather than all of the embodiments. The components of the embodiments of the present invention generally described and shown in the drawings here can be arranged and designed in various different configurations. Therefore, the following detailed description of the embodiments of the present invention provided in the drawings is not intended to limit the scope of the claimed invention, but merely represents selected embodiments of the present invention. Based on the embodiments in the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without making creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0107] Embodiment 1:
[0108] A post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise comprises the following steps:
[0109] Step 1: Establishment of basic indicator library:
[0110] By integrating bibliometrics, historical data and analytic hierarchy process, a basic index database for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects was constructed;
[0111] Step 1.1, apply system theory to decompose the first and second level evaluation indicators step by step:
[0112] Step 1.1.1, primary indicator identification:
[0113] In essence, a large-capacity energy storage technology project is a system. For the post-evaluation of this system, the system theory is applied. According to the goals and completion indicators set when the project was established, the post-evaluation of the large-capacity energy storage technology project can be used as the first-level indicators from the aspects of project management level, technical value, academic value, economic benefits, social benefits, environmental benefits, and sustainable impact.
[0114] Step 1.1.2, secondary indicator screening:
[0115] According to the characteristics and types of the first-level indicators, the first-level indicators are further subdivided into second-level indicators, and so on, and each first-level indicator is divided one by one to obtain a second-level indicator cluster. For example: the technical value can be further divided into technical level, technical achievements, and scientific and technological awards.
[0116] Step 1.1.3, primary and secondary evaluation indicator clusters are established:
[0117] Through the progressive decomposition of primary and secondary indicators, the hierarchical indicator clusters were established using the analytic hierarchy process, and a preliminary model of post-evaluation indicators for large-capacity energy storage technology projects was obtained.
[0118] Step 1.2: Integrate bibliometrics and historical data to build a basic indicator library framework:
[0119] Step 1.2.1, based on the project evaluation requirements, comprehensively analyze the characteristics of the first and second level indicators, and combine multi-source literature to establish a basic indicator library for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects to ensure the scientificity and representativeness of the selected evaluation indicators;
[0120] Step 1.2.2, design a questionnaire for the post-evaluation indicators of large-capacity energy storage technology projects and conduct a large-scale survey of indicators;
[0121] Step 1.2.3, summarize the basic evaluation indicators, integrate bibliometrics and pairwise comparison methods, narrow the scope of post-evaluation indicators, and reduce indicator redundancy;
[0122] Step 1.2.4, based on the analytic hierarchy process, evaluate the suitability of basic evaluation indicators and narrow the scope of post-evaluation indicators;
[0123] Step 1.2.5, based on the results of literature measurement and questionnaire survey, combined with the problems existing in the post-evaluation management process of large-capacity energy storage in scientific and technological projects, modify and improve the evaluation indicators, add necessary indicators, and eliminate unnecessary indicators;
[0124] Step 1.2.6, establish a large-capacity energy storage technology project post-evaluation indicator system framework, determine the evaluation indicator system level, and the number of indicators at each level;
[0125] Step 1.3, establish a basic indicator library:
[0126] According to relevant documents and policy regulations, a post-evaluation index system for scientific and technological projects was established by referring to similar or similar scientific and technological projects, and the connotation of basic indicators was clarified. The resulting post-evaluation index system for large-capacity energy storage scientific and technological projects includes: 7 first-level indicators and 20 second-level indicators.
[0127] Table 1 Basic evaluation index system
[0128]
[0129] Step 2: Establishment of key indicator system:
[0130] There are many basic indicators for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects, and there is a large redundancy problem. It is necessary to further quantify and scientifically screen the existing basic indicators to reduce the one-sidedness of the evaluation results. Based on the construction of the basic indicator library in the previous step, this step focuses on the indicator characteristics that are most relevant to the post-evaluation of the project. Combining qualitative and quantitative methods, we gradually screened out a set of streamlined and effective key indicator systems for post-evaluation of science and technology projects based on the constructed basic set and indicator basic set indicators.
[0131] The main steps are as follows:
[0132] Step 2.1, screening key indicators based on analytic hierarchy process;
[0133] Step 2.1.1, preliminary screening and identification of evaluation indicators:
[0134] In the initial screening and identification stage of large-capacity energy storage technology project evaluation indicators, we can collect and organize relevant academic journals, master's and doctoral dissertations, conference documents, etc. based on various academic resource databases, such as China National Knowledge Infrastructure (CNKI) and Sci-hub, with technology projects, hydropower, energy storage, post-evaluation, etc. as keywords;
[0135] Step 2.1.2, revision of primary and secondary indicators:
[0136] According to the characteristics of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises, the frequency statistics and analysis of relevant evaluation indicators are carried out with the help of hierarchical analysis method, and the indicators with higher attention are identified, so as to significantly narrow the scope of post-evaluation indicators of large-capacity energy storage technology projects.
[0137] Step 2.1.3, key indicators determination:
[0138] We specifically select high-level experts (more than 15 people with senior professional titles) in the fields of mechanical energy storage, electrochemical energy storage, electromagnetic energy storage, and electric hydrogen energy storage for consultation, and use their experience to further eliminate inappropriate indicators, determine key indicators, and clarify the connotation of indicators.
[0139] Step 2.2, identify key indicators based on multivariate data constraint ranking method;
[0140] After screening key indicators based on the analytic hierarchy process, the detrended correspondence analysis (DCA), redundancy analysis (RDA) and canonical correspondence analysis (CCA) methods are further integrated to carry out quantitative screening of the leading post-evaluation factors that affect the changes in various value characteristics; the key indicator identification process for post-evaluation of scientific and technological projects is as follows:
[0141] Step 2.2.1, standardization of original variables:
[0142] Obtain the data of each basic post-evaluation indicator, and use statistical analysis to perform lg(X+1) transformation on the data to standardize the data;
[0143] Step 2.2.2, analysis of changes in evaluation indicators:
[0144] The detrended correspondence analysis (DCA) method was used to analyze the evaluation index data to determine the distribution form of data changes;
[0145] Step 2.2.3, sorting model selection:
[0146] Select the ranking model for the relationship analysis of two groups of variables based on the DCA results:
[0147] ① If the maximum value of the four-axis gradient length is >4, select the single-peak canonical correlation analysis (CCA);
[0148] ②If the gradient length value is <3, select linear redundancy analysis (RDA);
[0149] ③If the gradient length is between 3 and 4, you can choose either RDA or CCA;
[0150] Step 2.2.4, analysis of the relationship constraints between the basic and post-evaluation indicators:
[0151] ①Use CCA method to establish a unimodal model, and transform the correlation between two groups of variables into the correlation between two new variables for research;
[0152] ② The linear model was established using the RDA method, and regression analysis and principal component analysis were used to analyze the relationship between the five major values and various basic post-evaluation indicators;
[0153] Step 2.2.5, determine the main axis of the coordinates:
[0154] Determine the main coordinate axis according to the axis explanation rate;
[0155] Step 2.2.6, draw a sorting diagram:
[0156] Draw a two-dimensional plane diagram consisting of basic evaluation indicator arrows, environmental variable arrows, and coordinate axes;
[0157] Step 2.2.7, ranking of basic evaluation indicators:
[0158] With the help of RDA method, the basic evaluation index rays are ranked according to their vertical projection lengths on the post-evaluation rays:
[0159] ①The farther the projection point is in the direction indicated by the arrow, the higher the correlation;
[0160] ②The projection point near the origin of the coordinate system indicates that the correlation coefficient is close to 0;
[0161] ③If the projection point is in the opposite direction, the predicted correlation is negative;
[0162] Step 2.2.8, identification of driving factors of basic evaluation indicators:
[0163] Comparative analysis is used to identify driving factors of basic evaluation indicators. The longer the comprehensive projection, the more relevant the changes in the characteristics of basic evaluation indicators.
[0164] Step 2.3, key indicators are established.
[0165] According to the above process, combined with the above qualitative + quantitative indicator screening process, an exclusive post-evaluation key indicator system for large-capacity energy storage technology projects can be determined, with a total of 2 layers, 5 categories and 15 indicators.
[0166] Table 2 Key indicator system for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects
[0167]
[0168] Step 3: Setting of secondary indicator evaluation criteria:
[0169] The post-evaluation indicators of large-capacity energy storage technology projects are evaluated in a graded evaluation method. Each evaluation level is divided into three grades: A, B, C, D, and E, corresponding to five grades: excellent, good, medium, poor, and low.
[0170] Table 3 Post-evaluation index standards for large-capacity energy storage technology projects
[0171]
[0172] The evaluation criteria for the 15 secondary indicators are as follows:
[0173] (1) Theoretical innovation:
[0174] Refers to the number of new ideas, new laws, and new technological breakthroughs related to the development of large-capacity energy storage technology brought about after the completion of the project.
[0175] Evaluation criteria: A-level > 10 items; B-level > 8 items; C-level > 6 items; D-level > 4 items; E-level < 2 items.
[0176] (2) Academic achievements:
[0177] Refers to the academic papers, academic reports, level of publications, and number of monographs published related to large-capacity energy storage technology generated during the implementation of scientific and technological projects.
[0178] Evaluation criteria: A grade ≥ 5; 4 ≥ B grade ≥ 3; 3>C grade ≥ 2; 2>D grade ≥ 1; 1>D grade ≥ 0.
[0179] (3) Technical level:
[0180] Refers to whether the key large-capacity energy storage technology achieved by the project is feasible in the international, domestic or energy industry, whether it is advanced and innovative, whether the key technology can become an industry standard, and whether it has the value of promotion and application. Evaluation criteria:
[0181] Category A: Key technologies for large-capacity energy storage are at the international leading level, and the results are original innovations with value for promotion to the international market;
[0182] Category B: The key technologies of large-capacity energy storage are leading in China, the achievements are original innovations, and have the value of being promoted to the domestic market;
[0183] Category C: The key technologies of large-capacity energy storage are advanced in China, and the achievements are integrated innovations with promotion value in the energy industry;
[0184] D: Key technologies for large-capacity energy storage have not reached the domestic advanced level, and the achievements are mainly imitation innovations, which can be promoted within hydropower or energy companies;
[0185] Category E: The key technologies for large-capacity energy storage have not reached the domestic advanced level, there are no innovative technological achievements, and there is no value for promotion and application in the international, domestic or energy industry.
[0186] (4)Technological achievements:
[0187] It refers to the number of new products / processes / materials developed in large-capacity energy storage technology projects, the number of invention and utility patents accepted or authorized, the number of software copyrights obtained, the number of standards formed, and the number of large-capacity energy storage-related awards obtained.
[0188] Evaluation criteria:
[0189] Category A: ≥2 new products / processes / materials related to energy storage technology, ≥2 invention / utility model patents related to energy storage technology, ≥2 software copyrights related to energy storage technology, ≥1 standard related to energy storage technology, ≥1 national / provincial / municipal / industry award related to energy storage technology (choose 3 from 5);
[0190] Category B: ≥2 new products / processes / materials related to energy storage technology, ≥2 invention / utility model patents related to energy storage technology, ≥1 software copyright related to energy storage technology, ≥1 standard related to energy storage technology, 1 national / provincial / municipal award related to energy storage technology (choose 2 from 5);
[0191] Category C: ≥1 new product / process / material related to energy storage technology, ≥1 invention / utility model patent related to energy storage technology, ≥1 software copyright related to energy storage technology, ≥1 standard related to energy storage technology, 1 national / provincial / municipal award related to energy storage technology (choose 2 from 5);
[0192] D-level: ≥1 new product / process / material related to energy storage technology, ≥1 invention / utility model patent related to energy storage technology, ≥1 software copyright related to energy storage technology, ≥1 standard related to energy storage technology, 1 national / provincial / municipal award related to energy storage technology (choose 1 from 5);
[0193] File E: No new products / processes / materials related to energy storage technology, no patents related to energy storage technology, no software copyrights related to energy storage technology, no standards related to energy storage technology, and no awards related to energy storage technology.
[0194] (5) Direct economic benefits:
[0195] Refers to the proportion of increased output value, increased profits and taxes, and reduced expenditure costs generated by the transformation of new products / processes / technical achievements related to large-capacity energy storage technology projects. Evaluation criteria:
[0196] Category A: Sales revenue accounts for ≥50% of main business revenue, profit accounts for ≥50%, and expenditure cost is reduced by ≥50% (choose 1 from 3);
[0197] B: 30% ≤ sales revenue to main business revenue ratio <50%, 30% ≤ profit ratio <50%, 30% ≤ expenditure cost reduction <50% (choose 1 from 3);
[0198] C: 10% ≤ sales revenue to main business revenue ratio < 30%, 10% ≤ profit ratio < 30%, 10% ≤ expenditure cost reduction < 30% (choose 1 from 3);
[0199] D: Sales revenue accounts for less than 10% of main business revenue, profit accounts for less than 10%, and expenditure cost reduction is less than 10% (choose 1 from 3);
[0200] Category E: No direct economic benefits are generated, and expenditure costs have not decreased or increased.
[0201] (6) Indirect economic benefits:
[0202] Refers to the potential benefits of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in promoting regional economic development and improving industry productivity. Evaluation criteria:
[0203] Category A: The key technological achievements of large-capacity energy storage have reached the international advanced level, and have great potential to promote regional economic development and increase industry production;
[0204] Category B: The innovation of key technologies for large-capacity energy storage has reached the domestic leading level, and has great potential to promote regional economic development and increase industry production;
[0205] C: The innovation of key technologies for large-capacity energy storage has reached the domestic advanced level, and has a medium potential to promote regional economic development and increase industry production;
[0206] D: The innovation of key technologies for large-capacity energy storage has not reached the domestic advanced level, and the potential for promoting regional economic development and improving industry production is poor;
[0207] Category E: The innovation of key technologies for large-capacity energy storage has not reached the domestic advanced level, the results have no value for promotion and application, and cannot promote regional economic development and improve industry productivity.
[0208] (7) Training of scientific and technological personnel:
[0209] Refers to the number of national / provincial / industry science and technology awards or honors won for the implementation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects, the number of people promoted to intermediate or senior professional titles, and the number of scientific and technological talents trained in the team. Evaluation criteria:
[0210] Category A: ≥2 people who have won national / provincial / industry science and technology awards, ≥2 people who have been promoted to intermediate or senior professional titles, ≥2 people who have been promoted to master's or doctoral degrees, and ≥2 people who have participated in large-capacity energy storage technology training;
[0211] Category B: ≥1 person has won a national / provincial / industry science and technology award, ≥1 person has been promoted to a middle or senior professional title, ≥1 person has been promoted to a master's or doctoral degree, and ≥2 people have participated in large-capacity energy storage technology training;
[0212] Category C: ≥1 person has won a national / provincial / industry science and technology award, ≥1 person has been promoted to a middle or senior professional title, ≥1 person has been promoted to a master's or doctoral degree, and ≥1 person has participated in large-capacity energy storage technology training (choose 2 from 4);
[0213] D category: ≥1 person has won a national / provincial / industry science and technology award, ≥1 person has been promoted to a middle or senior professional title, ≥1 person has been promoted to a master's or doctoral degree, and ≥1 person has participated in large-capacity energy storage technology training (choose 1 from 4);
[0214] File E: Only the project leader has output results, and team members have no awards / titles / degrees / technical training results.
[0215] (8) Number of new jobs:
[0216] Refers to the number of jobs created and increased during the implementation or application and promotion of large-capacity energy storage technology projects. Evaluation criteria:
[0217] Category A: ≥3 new full-time employees, ≥15 new part-time employees;
[0218] Category B: ≥2 new full-time employees, ≥10 new part-time employees;
[0219] C level: ≥1 new full-time employee and ≥5 new part-time employees;
[0220] D file: ≥3 new part-time employees;
[0221] File E: No new full-time / part-time employees.
[0222] (9) Impact on local society:
[0223] Refers to the impact of the implementation and application of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on local social politics, safety, production, income, etc. Evaluation criteria:
[0224] Category A: The implementation and application of large-capacity energy storage technology projects significantly improve the local political outlook, project management level, production safety, and local income capacity;
[0225] Category B: The implementation and application of large-capacity energy storage technology projects significantly improve the local political outlook, project management level, production safety, and local income capacity;
[0226] Category C: The implementation and application of large-capacity energy storage technology projects can improve local political outlook, project management level, production safety, and local income to a certain extent;
[0227] D: The implementation and application of large-capacity energy storage technology projects cannot improve productivity and safety, but can only boost local people’s income to a certain extent;
[0228] Category E: The implementation and application of large-capacity energy storage technology projects may have no promoting effect on local social development.
[0229] (10) Contribution to energy conservation and emission reduction:
[0230] Refers to the contribution of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in energy conservation, resource utilization, pollution reduction, and carbon emission reduction. Evaluation criteria:
[0231] Category A: Outstanding contribution, far-reaching impact, can significantly reduce carbon emissions, and the project has strong scalability;
[0232] B-level: Greater contribution and impact, can significantly reduce carbon emissions, and has strong project scalability;
[0233] Category C: There is a certain degree of contribution and impact, carbon emissions are reduced to a certain extent, and the project scalability is average;
[0234] D: The contribution and impact are average, the contribution to carbon emission reduction is small, and the project has no scalability;
[0235] Category E: No contribution and average impact, resulting in an increase in carbon emissions instead of a decrease, and the project has no scalability.
[0236] (11) Environmentally harmonious development:
[0237] Refers to the impact of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on the ecological environment system of the demonstration application area and its radiation area. Evaluation criteria:
[0238] Category A: Outstanding contribution, far-reaching impact, can significantly improve the regional ecological environment, help regional carbon sequestration, and the project has strong scalability;
[0239] B-level: Greater contribution and impact, can improve the regional ecological environment to a greater extent, help regional carbon sequestration, and the project has strong extensibility;
[0240] C: There is a certain degree of contribution and impact, improving the regional ecological environment to a certain extent, helping regional carbon sequestration, and the project scalability is average;
[0241] D: The contribution and impact are average, the improvement of regional ecological environment and the support of regional carbon sequestration capacity are small, and the project has no scalability;
[0242] Category E: No contribution and average impact, unable to improve regional ecological environment and assist regional carbon sink, the project has no scalability.
[0243] (12) Impact on disciplinary research:
[0244] Refers to the sustained impact of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on the development of disciplines. Evaluation criteria:
[0245] Category A: Thorough research on major disciplines, which can significantly promote the development of interdisciplinary, emerging, and highly applied disciplines;
[0246] B: The research on major disciplines is relatively thorough and can promote the development of interdisciplinary, emerging and highly applied disciplines to a certain extent;
[0247] C-level: has a certain degree of research in major disciplines, and has research in interdisciplinary, emerging, and highly applied disciplines;
[0248] D: There is a certain degree of research on major disciplines, but no research on interdisciplinary, emerging, or highly applied disciplines;
[0249] Category E: Research on major disciplines is mainly based on imitation, with no research on interdisciplinary, emerging, or highly applied disciplines.
[0250] (13) Impact on improving corporate competitiveness:
[0251] Refers to the successful transformation and application of the results of large-capacity energy storage technology projects, which can lead emerging industries and drive industrial technology upgrades. Evaluation criteria:
[0252] Category A: Project results have been successfully transformed and widely used in the energy industry at home and abroad, which can significantly lead the emerging energy storage industry and drive industrial technology upgrades;
[0253] Category B: The project results have been successfully transformed and well applied in the domestic energy industry, making a significant contribution to leading the energy storage industry and driving industrial technology upgrades;
[0254] C: The project results have been successfully transformed and have been applied to a certain extent within the enterprise;
[0255] D: The project results have not been successfully transformed, but have certain application potential;
[0256] E: The project results have not been successfully transformed and have no application potential.
[0257] (14) Promoting effect on regional economy:
[0258] Refers to the role of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in the sustainable development of the regional economy. Evaluation criteria:
[0259] Grade A: The project results are widely used, the subsequent capital investment is high and sustainable, and the improvement and promotion of regional economic sustainable development are significant;
[0260] B-level: The project has good application results, high subsequent capital investment, and is good at improving and promoting sustainable development of the regional economy;
[0261] C: The project results are generally applicable, and the subsequent capital investment is moderate, which can improve and promote regional economic development to a certain extent;
[0262] D: The project has certain application value and has certain potential for subsequent capital investment and promotion of regional economic development;
[0263] Category E: The project has no application value, no subsequent capital investment, and no potential to promote regional economic development.
[0264] (15) Promoting local scientific and technological progress:
[0265] Refers to the role of the core results of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in promoting local scientific and technological progress. Evaluation criteria:
[0266] Category A: The core results can enhance the depth of local industry understanding, promote the optimal allocation of local science and technology funds, achieve domestic substitution of foreign products, and significantly promote local scientific and technological progress and economic growth;
[0267] Category B: The core achievements can promote the optimal allocation of local science and technology funds, can be localized to a certain extent, can be widely used in the industry, and have a good contribution to reducing science and technology investment, promoting local scientific and technological progress and economic growth;
[0268] C: The core research results can be applied to a certain extent in the industry and make a general contribution to promoting local scientific and technological progress and economic growth;
[0269] D: The core results are only used within the enterprise and cannot promote local scientific and technological progress and economic growth;
[0270] Category E: The core results cannot be applied within the enterprise and cannot promote local scientific and technological progress and economic growth.
[0271] Step 4, identification of primary and secondary indicator weights:
[0272] The identification of the weights of the first and second level indicators mainly adopts pairwise comparison, analytic hierarchy process (AHP), and quantitative + qualitative comprehensive determination of the indicator weights. The main steps are as follows:
[0273] Step 4.1, using pairwise comparison and analytic hierarchy process, determine the first-level indicator judgment matrix;
[0274] Table 4 First-level indicator judgment matrix
[0275] index Technology Value Economic Benefits Social Benefits Environmental benefits Lasting Impact Scientific value 1.00 0.50 0.25 0.33 0.33 Economic Benefits 2.00 1.00 0.33 0.50 0.33 Social Benefits 4.00 3.00 1.00 3.00 2.00 Environmental benefits 3.00 2.00 0.33 1.00 0.50 Lasting Impact 3.00 3.00 0.50 2.00 1.00
[0276] Step 4.2, using pairwise comparison and analytic hierarchy process, determine the secondary indicator judgment matrix of scientific value, economic benefit, social benefit, environmental benefit, and sustainable impact;
[0277] Table 5 Judgment matrix of secondary indicators of scientific value
[0278] Scientific value Theoretical Innovation Academic Achievements Technical Level Technical achievements Theoretical Innovation 1.00 2.00 3.00 5.00 Academic Achievements 0.50 1.00 2.00 3.00 Technical Level 0.33 0.50 1.00 2.00 Technical achievements 0.20 0.33 0.50 1.00
[0279] Table 6 Economic value secondary indicator judgment matrix
[0280] Economic Benefits Direct economic benefits Indirect economic benefits Direct economic benefits 1.00 7.00 Indirect economic benefits 0.14 1.00
[0281] Table 7 Social Benefit Secondary Index Judgment Matrix
[0282] Social Benefits Training of scientific and technological talents New employment Impact on local society Training of scientific and technological talents 1.00 0.25 0.20 New employment 4.00 1.00 0.33 Impact on local society 5.00 3.00 1.00
[0283] Table 8 Ecological Benefit Secondary Index Judgment Matrix
[0284] Ecological benefits Contribution to energy conservation and emission reduction Ecologically harmonious development Contribution to energy conservation and emission reduction 1.00 0.33 Ecologically harmonious development 3.00 1.00
[0285] Table 9 Secondary indicator judgment matrix for sustainable impact of achievements
[0286]
[0287] Step 4.3, comprehensively analyze and calculate the first- and second-level indicator judgment matrix of scientific value, economic benefit, social benefit, environmental benefit, and sustainable impact, and obtain the weight values of the first- and second-level indicators for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects.
[0288] Table 10 Weight values of primary and secondary indicators in post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects
[0289]
[0290] Step 5: Establishment of comprehensive quality evaluation model:
[0291] The comprehensive quality index of the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises is the weighted sum of scientific and technological value, economic benefits, social benefits, environmental benefits and sustainable impact. The calculation model is as follows:
[0292] CQI=ST*W ST +EE*W EE +SE*W SE +ME*W ME +CI*W CI ;
[0293] Where CQI is the comprehensive quality index; ST is the technology value index, EE is the economic benefit index, SE is the social benefit index, ME is the environmental benefit index, and CI is the sustainable impact index, which are the weighted sum of each secondary index; W ST , W EE , W SE , W ME , W CI is the weight value of each first-level indicator.
[0294] Step 6: Setting of comprehensive quality evaluation criteria:
[0295] The comprehensive quality of the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises adopts a graded evaluation standard. Each evaluation level is divided into 5 grades: A, B, C, D, and E, corresponding to 5 levels: excellent, good, medium, low, and poor.
[0296] Table 11 Comprehensive quality grading evaluation standards for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises
[0297]
[0298]
[0299] Embodiment 2:
[0300] Post-evaluation empirical case of large-capacity energy storage technology project:
[0301] Based on the large-capacity energy storage technology project post-evaluation index system, weights, models and standards established in Example 1, this example selects an applied technology project for empirical analysis.
[0302] 1. Key indicator evaluation:
[0303] 1.1, Establish indicator evaluation table:
[0304] Collect a large amount of data on each indicator layer, and compile an indicator system evaluation table for evaluating a large-capacity energy storage technology project. Make a separate evaluation table for each project according to the name of the large-capacity energy storage technology project.
[0305] Table 12 Evaluation table of post-evaluation indicators for a certain scientific and technological project
[0306]
[0307] 1.2, Key indicator evaluation:
[0308] The analytic hierarchy process and model calculation method (qualitative + quantitative) are combined to obtain the average value of each key indicator.
[0309] Table 13 Evaluation criteria for post-evaluation indicators of large-capacity energy storage technology projects
[0310] Target value (full score 100) ≥ (90,80) (80,70) (70,60) <60 Rating excellent good middle Difference Low
[0311] Table 14 Evaluation results of post-evaluation indicators of a large-capacity energy storage technology project
[0312]
[0313] 2. Comprehensive quality evaluation calculation:
[0314] Table 15 Post-evaluation calculation table for a large-capacity energy storage technology project
[0315]
[0316] 3. Comprehensive evaluation conclusion:
[0317] (1) The comprehensive evaluation result of the post-evaluation of the large-capacity energy storage technology project was 69.48 points.
[0318] (2) According to the comprehensive evaluation criteria, the post-evaluation results of the large-capacity energy storage technology project are good.
[0319] The above is only a specific embodiment of the present invention, but the protection scope of the present invention is not limited thereto. Any person skilled in the art can easily think of changes or substitutions within the technical scope disclosed by the present invention, which should be included in the protection scope of the present invention. Therefore, the protection scope of the present invention should be based on the protection scope of the claims.
Claims
1. A post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Step 1: Establishment of basic indicator library: Based on bibliometrics and historical data, and taking into account the actual scientific and technological project management needs of hydropower enterprises, a basic index database for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects is constructed; Step 2: Screening of key indicators and establishment of a hierarchical system: Based on the basic indicator library established in step 1, the quantitative methods of multivariate data constraint sorting, principal component analysis and redundancy analysis are integrated to quantitatively screen the key indicators for post-evaluation of energy storage technology projects layer by layer in the constructed basic indicator library, and to build a streamlined and effective key indicator system for post-evaluation of technology projects; Step 3: Setting of secondary indicator evaluation criteria: The evaluation indicators for the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects are evaluated in a graded manner; Step 4, identification of primary and secondary indicator weights: The identification of the weights of the primary and secondary indicators uses pairwise comparison and analytic hierarchy process to determine the indicator weights in a quantitative manner; Step 5: Establishment of comprehensive quality evaluation model: The comprehensive quality index of the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises is the weighted sum of scientific and technological value, economic benefits, social benefits, environmental benefits and sustainable impact; Step 6: Setting of comprehensive quality evaluation criteria: The comprehensive quality of post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises adopts a tiered evaluation standard.
2. According to claim 1, a method for post-evaluation of a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise is characterized in that: The step 1 specifically includes: Step 1.1, apply system theory to decompose the first and second level evaluation indicators step by step; Step 1.2, integrate bibliometrics and historical data to build a basic indicator framework; Step 1.3, establish a basic indicator library.
3. According to claim 2, a method for post-evaluation of a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise is characterized in that: The step 1.1 specifically includes: Step 1.1.1, primary indicator identification: The large-capacity energy storage technology project is regarded as a system. For the post-evaluation of the system, the system theory is applied. According to the goals and completion indicators set when the project was established, the post-evaluation of the large-capacity energy storage technology project is carried out from the aspects of project management level, technical value, academic value, economic benefits, social benefits, environmental benefits and sustainable impact as the first-level indicators; Step 1.1.2, secondary indicator screening: According to the characteristics and types of the first-level indicators, the first-level indicators are further subdivided into second-level indicators. Similarly, each first-level indicator is divided one by one to obtain the second-level indicator clusters. Step 1.1.3, primary and secondary evaluation indicator clusters are established: Through the progressive decomposition of primary and secondary indicators, the hierarchical indicator clusters were established using the analytic hierarchy process, and a preliminary model of post-evaluation indicators for large-capacity energy storage technology projects was obtained.
4. A post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise according to claim 3, characterized in that: The step 1.2 specifically includes: Step 1.2.1, based on the project evaluation requirements, comprehensively analyze the characteristics of the first and second level indicators, and combine multi-source literature to establish a basic indicator library for post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects to ensure the scientificity and representativeness of the selected evaluation indicators; Step 1.2.2, design a questionnaire for the post-evaluation indicators of large-capacity energy storage technology projects and conduct a large-scale survey of indicators; Step 1.2.3, summarize the basic evaluation indicators, integrate bibliometrics and pairwise comparison methods, narrow the scope of post-evaluation indicators, reduce indicator redundancy, and narrow the scope of post-evaluation indicators; Step 1.2.4, based on the above preliminary selection results, analyze the problems existing in the post-evaluation management process of large-capacity energy storage technology projects, modify and improve the evaluation indicators, add necessary indicators and eliminate unnecessary indicators in combination with the technological innovation needs of hydropower enterprises; Step 1.2.6, establish the framework of the post-evaluation index system for large-capacity energy storage technology projects, determine the level of the evaluation index system, and the number of indicators at each level.
5. A post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise according to claim 4, characterized in that: The step 1.3 is specifically as follows: according to relevant documents and policy provisions, refer to similar or similar scientific and technological projects to establish a post-evaluation index system for scientific and technological projects, clarify the connotation of basic indicators, and then obtain a post-evaluation index system for large-capacity energy storage scientific and technological projects, which includes 7 first-level indicators and 20 second-level indicators.
6. A post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise according to claim 5, characterized in that: The step 2 specifically includes: Step 2.1, preliminary screening of key indicators based on bibliometric, analytic hierarchy process and empirical method; Step 2.2, identify key indicators based on multivariate data constraint ranking method; Step 2.3, key indicators are established.
7. A post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise according to claim 6, characterized in that: Step 2.1 specifically includes: Step 2.1.1, preliminary screening and identification of evaluation indicators: In the initial screening and identification stage of large-capacity energy storage technology project evaluation indicators, based on various academic resource databases, with technology projects, hydropower, energy storage, and post-evaluation as keywords, relevant academic journals, master's and doctoral dissertations, and conference documents were collected and sorted out; Step 2.1.2, revision of primary and secondary indicators: According to the characteristics of large-capacity energy storage technology projects of hydropower enterprises, the frequency statistics and analysis of relevant evaluation indicators are carried out with the help of hierarchical analysis method, and the indicators with high attention are identified, so as to significantly narrow the scope of post-evaluation indicators of large-capacity energy storage technology projects; Step 2.1.3, key indicators determination: We have targetedly selected the fields of mechanical energy storage, electrochemical energy storage, electromagnetic energy storage, and electric hydrogen energy storage, and have consulted with high-level experts in the industry. We have used experience to further eliminate inappropriate indicators, determine key indicators, and clarify the connotation of indicators.
8. A post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise according to claim 7, characterized in that: Step 2.2 specifically includes screening key indicators based on the hierarchical analysis method, and further integrating the detrended correspondence analysis, redundancy analysis and typical correspondence analysis methods to carry out quantitative screening of the leading post-evaluation factors that affect the changes in various value characteristics; the key indicator identification process for post-evaluation of scientific and technological projects is as follows: Step 2.2.1, standardization of original variables: Obtain the data of each basic post-evaluation indicator, and use statistical analysis to transform the data and standardize the data; Step 2.2.2, analysis of changes in evaluation indicators: The detrended correspondence analysis method is used to analyze the evaluation index data to determine the distribution form of data changes; Step 2.2.3, sorting model selection: Select the sorting model for the relationship analysis of two groups of variables based on the results of the detrended correspondence analysis: ① If the maximum value of the four-axis gradient length is >4, select the single-peak canonical correlation analysis; ②If the gradient length value is less than 3, select linear redundancy analysis; ③ If the gradient length is between 3 and 4, you can choose either redundancy analysis or canonical correspondence analysis; Step 2.2.4, analysis of the relationship constraints between the basic and post-evaluation indicators: ①Use the canonical correspondence analysis method to establish a unimodal model, and transform the correlation between two groups of variables into the correlation between two new variables for research; ② Redundancy analysis method was used to establish a linear model, and regression analysis and principal component analysis were used to analyze the relationship between the five major values and various basic post-evaluation indicators; Step 2.2.5, determine the main axis of the coordinates: Determine the main coordinate axis according to the coordinate axis explanation rate; Step 2.2.6, draw a sorting diagram: Draw a two-dimensional plane diagram consisting of basic evaluation indicator arrows, environmental variable arrows, and coordinate axes; Step 2.2.7, sorting of basic evaluation indicators: With the help of redundancy analysis method, the basic evaluation index rays are sorted according to their vertical projection lengths on the post-evaluation rays: ①The farther the projection point is in the direction indicated by the arrow, the higher the correlation; ②The projection point near the origin of the coordinate system indicates that the correlation coefficient is close to 0; ③If the projection point is in the opposite direction, the predicted correlation is negative; Step 2.2.8, identification of driving factors of basic evaluation indicators: The comparative analysis method is used to identify the driving factors of basic evaluation indicators. The longer the comprehensive projection, the more relevant the changes in the characteristics of basic evaluation indicators; Step 2.3 specifically integrates the qualitative and quantitative indicator screening processes in steps 2.1 and 2.2 to determine the exclusive post-evaluation key indicator system for large-capacity energy storage technology projects, with a total of 2 layers, 5 categories and 15 indicators.
9. A post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise according to claim 8, characterized in that: The step 3 specifically includes: dividing each evaluation level into three grades: A, B, C, D, and E, corresponding to five grades: excellent, good, medium, poor, and low respectively; The evaluation criteria for the 15 secondary indicators are as follows: (1) Theoretical innovation: refers to the number of new ideas, new laws, and new technological breakthroughs related to the development of large-capacity energy storage technology brought about after the completion of the project; (2) Academic achievements: refers to academic papers, academic reports, the level of publications, and the number of monographs published related to large-capacity energy storage technology generated during the implementation of scientific and technological projects; (3) Technical level: refers to whether the key large-capacity energy storage technology achieved by the project is feasible in the international, domestic or energy industry, whether it is advanced and innovative, whether the key technology can become an industry standard, and whether it has the value of promotion and application; (4) Technological achievements: refers to the number of new products / processes / materials developed in large-capacity energy storage technology projects, the number of invention and utility patents accepted or authorized, the number of software copyrights obtained, the number of standards formed, and the number of large-capacity energy storage-related awards obtained; (5) Direct economic benefits: refers to the added output value, added profits and taxes, and reduced expenditure cost ratio generated by the transformation of new products / processes / technical achievements related to large-capacity energy storage technology projects; (6) Indirect economic benefits: refers to the potential benefits of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in promoting regional economic development and improving industry productivity; (7) Scientific and technological talent training: refers to the number of national / provincial / industry scientific and technological awards or honors won for the implementation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects, the number of people promoted to intermediate or senior professional titles, and the number of scientific and technological talents trained in the team; (8) Newly employed persons: refers to the number of jobs created and increased during the implementation or application and promotion of large-capacity energy storage technology projects; (9) Impact on local society: Refers to the impact of the implementation and application of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on local social politics, security, production, income, etc.; (10) Contribution to energy conservation and emission reduction: refers to the contribution of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in saving energy, utilizing resources, reducing pollution, and reducing carbon emissions; (11) Environmentally harmonious development: refers to the impact of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on the ecological environment system of the demonstration application area and its radiation area; (12) Impact on disciplinary research: refers to the continuous impact of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on disciplinary development; (13) Impact on improving corporate competitiveness: refers to the successful transformation and application of the results of large-capacity energy storage technology projects, which can lead to emerging industries and drive industrial technology upgrades; (14) Promoting effect on regional economy: refers to the effect of large-capacity energy storage technology projects on the sustainable development of regional economy; (15) Promotion of local scientific and technological progress: refers to the role of the core results of large-capacity energy storage technology projects in promoting local scientific and technological progress.
10. A post-evaluation method for a large-capacity energy storage technology project of a hydropower enterprise according to claim 9, characterized in that: The step 4 specifically includes: Step 4.1, combined with the bibliometric results, using pairwise comparison and analytic hierarchy process to determine the first-level indicator judgment matrix; Step 4.2, combined with the bibliometric results, using pairwise comparison and analytic hierarchy process, determine the secondary indicator judgment matrix of scientific value, economic benefit, social benefit, environmental benefit, and sustainable impact; Step 4.3, comprehensively analyze and calculate the first and second level indicator judgment matrix of scientific value, economic benefit, social benefit, environmental benefit, and sustainable impact, and obtain the weight values of the first and second level indicators of the post-evaluation of large-capacity energy storage technology projects; The comprehensive quality evaluation model in step 5 is: CQI=ST*W ST +EE*W EE +SE*W SE +ME*W ME +CI*W CI ; Where CQI is the comprehensive quality index; ST is the technology value index, EE is the economic benefit index, SE is the social benefit index, ME is the environmental benefit index, and CI is the sustainable impact index, which are the weighted sum of each secondary indicator; W ST , W EE , W SE , W ME , W CI is the weight value of each first-level indicator; In step 6, each evaluation level is divided into 5 grades: A, B, C, D, and E, corresponding to 5 grades: excellent, good, medium, low, and poor, respectively.
