Natural hydrogen mud logging
Through the combination of mass spectrometer and multiple degassing technologies, the problem of hydrogen quantization in underground formations is solved, high-accuracy measurement of natural hydrogen is achieved, the problems of low solubility and rapid degassing of hydrogen are overcome, and the drilling operation is improved Accuracy and efficiency.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202380033265.9
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-01-24
- Filing Date
- 2023-03-28
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-06
AI Technical Summary
The existing technology is difficult to effectively quantify natural hydrogen in underground formations, especially the low solubility and rapid degassing of hydrogen during drilling lead to measurement challenges, and it is difficult to distinguish naturally occurring hydrogen from hydrogen produced by the deterioration of the drill bit.
Use mass spectrometer to perform degassing and gas sample measurement of drilling fluid, remove hydrogen generated by the deterioration of the drill bit through calibration algorithms, combine gas sampling in the headspace and return pipes, and use a variety of degassing techniques such as heating and recirculation degassing, combined with DBM Correction method to accurately estimate the amount of natural hydrogen in the underground formation.
Highly accurate quantification of hydrogen in the underground formation is achieved, the problems of low solubility and rapid degassing of hydrogen are overcome, and the hydrogen generated by the deterioration of natural hydrogen is effectively distinguished from the hydrogen produced by the deterioration of drill bits is improved, and the accuracy and efficiency of drilling operations are improved.
Smart Images

Figure CN119096032A_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0002] This application claims priority to European Patent Application No. 22305389.3, filed on March 28, 2022, European Patent Application No. 22305620.1, filed on April 26, 2022, and U.S. Provisional Application No. 63 / 481,189, filed on January 24, 2023. Each of the above-identified patent applications is incorporated herein by reference in its entirety. Background Art
[0003] The global demand for hydrogen continues to grow. As of this disclosure, most of the global use of hydrogen is for refining oil and gas and producing industrial fertilizers. In recent years, the development and use of renewable energy has increased significantly, and many people expect hydrogen to play an important role as a clean energy carrier and currency. As a result, some forecasters expect that the demand for hydrogen will increase five to ten times in the next 20 years.
[0004] Currently more than 90% of commercial hydrogen is produced by burning oil and gas (e.g., natural gas) in the presence of steam. To meet the projected growth in demand, there is great interest in developing new sources of hydrogen. For example, methods are being explored to extract naturally occurring hydrogen from underground formations (e.g., by drilling in a manner similar to that used to obtain oil and gas). There is a need in the industry for methods and systems for sensing and quantifying naturally occurring hydrogen in underground formations, such as during drilling operations. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0005] For a more complete understanding of the disclosed subject matter and advantages thereof, reference is now made to the following description taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0006] Figure 1 An example drilling rig including a surface system for sensing and quantifying naturally occurring hydrogen is depicted.
[0007] Figure 2 Another embodiment of a terrestrial system for sensing and quantifying naturally occurring hydrogen is depicted.
[0008] Figure 3 A flow chart of an example method embodiment for estimating the naturally occurring hydrogen content of a subterranean formation is depicted.
[0009] Figure 4 Depicted is a logarithmic plot of gas concentration (in ppm by weight) versus time as the drilling fluid is recirculated in an example logging operation.
[0010] Figure 5 Well logs including headspace and degasser gas concentrations versus time are depicted.
[0011] Figure 6 A flow chart of an example method embodiment for calibrating a mass spectrometer for measuring hydrogen gas concentration is depicted.
[0012] Figure 7 Depicted is a logarithmic plot of gas concentration (in ppm by weight) versus time as the drilling fluid is recirculated in an example logging operation.
[0013] Figure 8 A flow chart depicts another example method for estimating the amount of naturally occurring hydrogen in a subsurface formation.
[0014] Fig. 9 Depicted in Figure 8 A flow chart of an example method of applying DBM correction is depicted in the flow chart above.
[0015] Fig. 10A and Fig. 10B (collectively, FIG. 10 ) depicts a graph of hydrogen gas concentration versus carbon monoxide gas concentration ( 10A ) and a graph of hydrogen gas concentration versus olefin gas concentration ( 10B ) (all in ppm) for an example drilling operation.
[0016] Fig.11 A schematic diagram of cavity-enhanced Raman spectroscopy is depicted.
[0017] Fig.12 Depicted are the Raman spectra of various gases, including hydrogen. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0018] The disclosed embodiments may provide an improved method for quantifying natural hydrogen in a subsurface formation, for example in which drill bit metamorphic hydrogen is removed from the measurement. In one embodiment, a method for estimating the amount of natural hydrogen in a subsurface formation includes: degassing a drilling fluid obtained from a wellbore to obtain a gas sample including a certain amount of hydrogen; measuring the hydrogen concentration in the gas sample; and applying a correction to the measured hydrogen concentration to estimate the amount of natural hydrogen in the subsurface formation. In an example embodiment, the concentration of hydrogen may be measured using a mass spectrometer calibrated for hydrogen measurements.
[0019] Figure 1 An example drilling rig 20 including a system for sensing and quantifying naturally occurring hydrogen is depicted. The drilling rig 10 may be positioned above a subterranean formation (not shown). The drilling rig may include, for example, a derrick and hoisting equipment (also not shown) for raising and lowering a drill string 30, which extends into a wellbore 40 as shown and includes, for example, a drill bit 32 and one or more downhole measurement tools 50 (e.g., a logging while drilling tool or a measurement while drilling tool). Suitable drilling systems, for example, including drilling, steering, logging, and other downhole tools, are well known in the art.
[0020] The drilling rig 20 also includes a surface system 80 for controlling the flow of drilling fluid used on the drilling rig (e.g., used when drilling out the wellbore 40). In the depicted example drilling rig, the drilling fluid 35 is pumped downhole (as depicted at 92) via a conventional mud pump 82. The drilling fluid 35 may be pumped, for example, through a riser 83 and a mud hose 84 on its way to the drill string 30. The drilling fluid typically emerges from the drill string 30 at or near the drill bit 32 and creates an upward flow 94 of mud through the wellbore annulus (the annular space between the drill string and the wellbore wall). The drilling fluid then flows to the mud pit 81 through a return pipe 88. It should be understood that the terms drilling fluid and mud are used synonymously herein.
[0021] The disclosed embodiments may include methods and systems for sensing and quantifying naturally occurring hydrogen in drilling fluids. By naturally occurring, it is meant that the hydrogen originates from the subterranean formation. The naturally occurring hydrogen migrates from the formation (e.g., via cracks and interstitial spaces in the rock) into the wellbore 40 and is transported to the surface via the drilling fluid (in the upwardly flowing liquid 94). The naturally occurring hydrogen is sampled in the surface system, such as via one or more drilling fluid degassers 97, 98 ( Figure 2 ), and / or a headspace gas probe 99 ( Figure 2 ) to take samples.
[0022] Further references Figure 1 The drilling rig 20 may also include a hydrogen measurement facility 60 (e.g., a laboratory trailer including one or more instruments suitable for detecting hydrogen in a gas stream). The instruments may include, for example, a calibrated mass spectrometer, such as a quadrupole mass spectrometer, a gas chromatograph, a thermal conductivity detector, an infrared or near infrared spectrometer, and / or a Raman spectrometer, etc. An example quadrupole mass spectrometer is the portable DQ1000 wellsite mass spectrometer gas analyzer available from SLB. The instrument may also be portable (and not necessarily limited to a laboratory or wellsite).
[0023] Figure 2Another embodiment of a surface system 80 is depicted, the surface system including a return pipe 88 configured to transport drilling fluid 35 (sometimes including gas bubbles 37) from a wellbore 40 to a mud pit 91. The example system 80 includes a degasser 98 deployed, for example, adjacent to the mud pit 91 and a shale shaker 89 (at the outlet of the return pipe 88), and / or a degasser 97 deployed along the pipe 88 and including a probe configured to sample the drilling fluid before it is exposed to air as depicted. The system 80 may also include a gas probe 99 configured to sample gas in the pipe 88 or the wellbore headspace. The degasser 97, 98 and / or the gas probe 99 may be connected to a laboratory 60 (as depicted at 65) via a pipe, for example, to automatically transport the sampled gas to the laboratory for testing. The system 80 may include substantially any suitable degasser 97, 98, including, for example, a vacuum degasser, a centrifugal degasser, and an impeller degasser. The degassers 97, 98 may also be configured to heat the drilling fluid 35 to facilitate complete degassing of the fluid. The disclosed embodiments are not limited in the type of degasser employed. In addition, although not depicted, the system 80 may include one or more pumps (e.g., suction pumps or pressure booster pumps) configured to pump sampled gas from the degassers 97, 98 and / or the probe 99 to the laboratory 60. Of course, the disclosed embodiments are not limited in any pumping or gas delivery conduit.
[0024] Figure 3 A flow chart of an example method 100 for estimating the amount of naturally occurring hydrogen in a subterranean formation is depicted. The method includes: degassing a drilling fluid to obtain a gas sample at 102; evaluating the amount of hydrogen (e.g., hydrogen concentration) in the gas sample at 104; and applying a correction to the amount of hydrogen measured at 104 to obtain an estimate of natural formation hydrogen at 106.
[0025] As above relative to Figure 2 As described above, substantially any suitable degasser may be used to obtain the gas sample at 102. The degasser may be deployed along a return pipeline that transports drilling fluid from the well to the mud pit. In other embodiments, the degasser may be configured to degas drilling fluid located near or even in the mud pit.
[0026] One anticipated challenge in obtaining a gas sample with a representative amount (e.g., concentration) of hydrogen is the low solubility of hydrogen (e.g., about 1-2 ppm by weight in water). Thus, in certain embodiments, the degasser probe may be deployed directly in the liquid in the return line (e.g., as in Figure 297 above) or by using a drilling fluid flowline bypass (not depicted), it may be advantageous to sample the drilling fluid before it is exposed to air. For example, such a configuration may be advantageous when a water-based drilling fluid is employed because it is believed that the solubility of hydrogen in water-based fluids is less than that in oil-based fluids. Nonetheless, the disclosed embodiments are not limited in these respects.
[0027] Obtaining a gas sample at 102 may also include obtaining a gas sample from the head space at the top of the wellbore (e.g., just below the pipe joint) or along the return pipe (e.g., as shown in FIG. Figure 2 A gas sample is obtained by drilling fluid (as depicted in FIG. 1 ). A person of ordinary skill will readily appreciate that drilling fluid tends to begin to degas as it returns to the surface (and atmospheric pressure). Due to the natural degassing process of the liquid as it returns to atmospheric pressure, the headspace may sometimes include hydrogen (as well as other gases).
[0028] Various degasser configurations have been tested. In one example test, drilling fluid was sampled directly from the mud flowline bypass to the degasser (where the liquid was not exposed to air prior to the degassing chamber). The sampled gas from the bypass showed high and reliable hydrogen readings. In addition, after drilling was stopped and the drill bit was lifted from the bottom of the hole, the liquid was recovered through the open mud pit and returned to the well circuit. During the recirculation period, the gas was sampled and evaluated for 30 minutes.
[0029] Figure 4 A logarithmic plot of the gas concentration (in ppm by weight) measured versus time while the drilling fluid was recirculated through the well is depicted. The concentrations of hydrogen, ethylene, carbon monoxide, and methane gases were measured. As the fluid naturally degassed, the gas concentrations were observed to decrease over time. The degassing rate can be estimated from the slope of the corresponding curve over time. It should be noted that the degassing rate of hydrogen in the circulating liquid is similar to the degassing rate of carbon monoxide and ethylene, where the gas concentration decreases by about an order of magnitude in about 20 minutes. This surprising result means that despite its low solubility, hydrogen tends to remain in the drilling fluid and only degasses slowly (even during fluid recirculation).
[0030] Although the disclosed embodiments are not limited to the use of any particular type of degasser, it should be understood that certain degasser configurations may be advantageous in various operations. For example, in applications where hydrogen degassing is relatively slow (compared to Figure 4In operations where hydrogen degassing is more likely to occur than in ... Figure 2 Sampling of the headspace gas as described may be advantageous.
[0031] In another example test, gas is sampled from both: an in-line gas trap (probe) that samples the headspace in the return line (e.g., Figure 2 99 in ); and a degasser located at the outlet of the pipeline adjacent to the mud pit (e.g., as Figure 2 The collected gases were analyzed using a corresponding DQ1000 mass spectrometer.
[0032] Figure 5 A record of gas concentration versus time is depicted for a headspace gas referred to as 'test' gas and a degasser gas referred to as 'main' gas. The record depicts hydrogen concentration at 121, helium concentration at 123, carbon dioxide concentration at 125, butane (C4) concentration at 127 and methane (C1) concentration at 129. The concentration of each gas (hydrogen, helium, carbon dioxide, butane and methane) is indicated on the horizontal axis (e.g., for hydrogen and carbon dioxide, the concentration is 0 to 5000 ppm). Due to the inferred low solubility of hydrogen in the drilling fluid, it is expected that higher hydrogen concentrations will be observed in the headspace gas. However, counterintuitively, it is observed that the hydrogen level in the headspace gas remains below 1000 ppm, while much greater hydrogen levels are observed in the degasser gas (e.g., up to 5000 ppm as depicted at 122).
[0033] The behavior of hydrogen is significantly different from that of carbon dioxide, which has a significantly higher concentration in the headspace (e.g., about 3 times in the peak observed at 126). These results demonstrate the surprising affinity of hydrogen to remain in the drilling fluid (or to be slowly degassed from the flowing mud) despite its volatility and low solubility. In certain operations (using specific drilling fluids), the release of hydrogen in the flowing drilling fluid may be low enough to permit the use of a conventional degasser at the outlet of the return pipe. In such embodiments, the release of hydrogen may be slow enough that it may be advantageous to use a heated degasser and / or a recirculating degasser to ensure that most / all of the hydrogen is degassed from the liquid.
[0034] Reference again Figure 3 , the amount of hydrogen in the gas sample may be assessed at 104 using substantially any suitable technique or sensor, including, for example, mass spectrometry, gas chromatography, and / or a solid-state hydrogen sensor. In certain embodiments, the gas assessment at 104 may utilize mass spectrometry techniques commonly employed at the rig site to assess other wellbore gases, such as methane, butane, and carbon dioxide. Although not always required, it may be advantageous to calibrate a rig site mass spectrometer to detect and quantify hydrogen in a degassed gas stream. A suitable calibration procedure may include assessing multiple gas samples having known hydrogen concentrations, and establishing a correlation between the mass spectrometry measurements and the known hydrogen concentrations in the samples.
[0035] In an example embodiment, the mass spectrometer may include a DQ1000 mass spectrometer (a portable quadrupole mass analyzer often used in drilling operations). Calibration of the DQ1000 may utilize a multi-point calibration technique that uses multiple gas mixtures with different hydrogen concentrations. The calibration may advantageously cover a wide range of hydrogen concentrations, for example, from parts per million (ppm) levels to nearly 100%. Use of a mass spectrometer such as the DQ1000 may advantageously provide a shorter analysis cycle time, thereby providing high frequency data in time and depth (e.g., as drilling proceeds), which enables the generation of a hydrogen log that depicts the relationship between naturally occurring hydrogen levels and measured depth of the wellbore.
[0036] Although the disclosed embodiments are not limited in this regard, it is expected that hydrogen (and helium in certain formations) often exists in relatively small-scale (dimension) geological features, such as fractures (e.g., in crystalline rocks) or near faults, which can act as conduits from deeper source rocks or lower crust / upper mantle vents. Examples include fractured granite basement or uplifted and fractured shallow mafic rocks, which may undergo hydrogen generation reactions when exposed to water. The disclosed embodiments can advantageously enable the generation of a record of naturally occurring hydrogen, which in turn can enable drilling operators to find underground hydrogen sources (or conduits).
[0037] Now go to Figure 6 , depicts a flow chart of an example method 140 for calibrating a mass spectrometer (such as a quadrupole mass spectrometer) for quantitatively measuring hydrogen. At 142, a background noise level is determined for the mass spectrometer. The background noise level can be determined, for example, by taking hydrogen measurements while flushing the spectrometer with air (e.g., within at least two hours before taking the measurements). A mass spectrometer having a background noise level less than a predetermined threshold (e.g., less than 1000 ppm or less than 500 ppm) can be selected at 144 for further calibration. The selected mass spectrometer can be used at 146 to evaluate at least three calibration gas mixtures having three different hydrogen concentrations. The calibration gas mixtures can have essentially any suitable hydrogen concentration, provided that they span the hydrogen concentration of interest (e.g., spanning at least two orders of magnitude of concentration). In an example embodiment, three calibration gas mixtures having hydrogen concentrations of 0.1%, 1.0%, and 10% (1000 ppm, 10000 ppm, and 100000 ppm) of hydrogen can be evaluated. The remainder of the calibration gas mixture can include, for example, nitrogen. The hydrogen concentration measurements made at 146 may be evaluated at 148 to calculate a correlation or best fit between the measured hydrogen concentration and the actual (or known) hydrogen concentration. In certain advantageous embodiments, the correlation may be a linear logarithmic fit or an exponential fit.
[0038] Continue to refer Figure 6 , the background noise and hydrogen concentration of the calibration sample can be evaluated at 142 and 146 via evaluating a mass to charge ratio equal to two (i.e., m / z=2, where m represents mass and z represents charge). A mass to charge ratio of two corresponds to a hydrogen species (H2) having a diatomic molecular structure. In the example calibration, it has been found that each mass spectrometer has a considerable hydrogen background noise (or offset), generally in the range of about 300 to about 3000 ppm. Although not wishing to be bound by theory, it is believed that this background noise is caused by the so-called "m / z=1 explosion effect". It has been observed that the background noise varies between mass spectrometers, and it is believed that it may fluctuate as the mass spectrometer ages. Therefore, only mass spectrometers with background noise less than a threshold value (e.g., 1000 ppm or 500 ppm) are selected for further calibration at 104. Table 1 lists the background hydrogen levels of five example mass spectrometers.
[0039] Table 1
[0040] Mass spectrometer <![CDATA[Background H2 (ppm)]]> A 2565 B 999 C 366 D 416 E 346
[0041] Continue to refer Figure 6It has been further discovered that the mass spectrometer overestimates (exaggerates or amplifies) the hydrogen concentration in the calibration gas mixture. The pattern of hydrogen amplification is complex, where the amplification rate (also referred to herein as the bias) decreases as the hydrogen concentration in the calibration sample increases. Table 2 lists the measured hydrogen concentrations obtained using the same five example mass spectrometers listed in Table 1. Three calibration gas mixtures were measured, in this example, the actual hydrogen concentrations were 1000ppm (0.1%), 10000ppm (1%), and 100000ppm (10%), respectively. It should be noted that for each mass spectrometer, the measured hydrogen concentration is at least three times the actual hydrogen concentration. In addition, it has been found that the bias (amplification rate) has a weak correlation with the background noise level, where mass spectrometers with higher background noise levels generally also have higher amplification rates. In addition, it has been found that the bias decreases as the hydrogen content in the calibration sample increases.
[0042] Table 2
[0043]
[0044] Figure 7 A graph is depicted of actual hydrogen concentration in three calibration samples (0.1%, 1%, and 10%) versus mass spectrometer measurements obtained at 106 using mass spectrometers A, B, C, D, and E. Figure 7 The best fit (mathematical correlation) that equates the actual hydrogen concentration to the measured hydrogen concentration for each of the mass spectrometers is also depicted. It has been observed that the correlation for a mass spectrometer with a background noise less than 1000 ppm has an R greater than 0.999 2 value.
[0045] Figure 7 Further depicted is a hypothetical measurement of an unknown sample using mass spectrometer E. In this example, the original hydrogen (H2) concentration was measured to be 18100 ppm (1.81%), indicating that the actual hydrogen (H2) concentration in the unknown sample is 6080 ppm (0.608%). As indicated in the figure, the measured H2 concentration is substituted into the correlation (0.1697·(original H2) 1.0696 ) to obtain the actual hydrogen concentration of the unknown sample.
[0046] It will be appreciated that due to the amplification factor (bias), saturation of any particular mass spectrometer is reached at hydrogen concentrations less than 100%. For example, if the bias is approximately equal to five, saturation will occur at a hydrogen concentration of 20%. As discussed above, the bias has also been found to decrease with increasing hydrogen concentration (where r 2 >0.9).
[0047] It should be appreciated that the calibration method described above can be further improved, for example, by taking into account other measured variables, such as the temperature of the calibration gas sample (or the temperature of the laboratory environment in which the calibration measurement is performed, or the temperature within the mass spectrometer base), the water content of the calibration gas sample (e.g., by evaluating the mass to charge ratio of 18 in the mass spectrometer measurement), and / or the nitrogen concentration in the air (e.g., by evaluating the mass to charge ratio of 28). These other measured variables can be further correlated with the actual hydrogen concentration in the calibration gas sample to obtain a multivariate calibration. Of course, the disclosed embodiments are not limited in this regard.
[0048] Still further reference Figure 3 , applying corrections to the hydrogen measurements at 106 may include, for example, correcting the hydrogen measurements for drill bit metamorphism (DBM) byproducts. One aspect of the disclosed embodiments is the recognition that hydrogen arriving within the drilling fluid flowline (e.g., in the liquid or headspace), even if perfectly extracted and analyzed, may not be representative of naturally occurring hydrogen originating from the drilled formation. It should be further recognized that the hydrogen content of the drilling fluid may be artificially increased by the drilling process.
[0049] For example, when the drill bit temperature is high (especially when using oil-based drilling fluids), hydrogen may sometimes be generated at the interface between the drill bit and the formation. In such operations, when the local heating exceeds the activation energy of the alkanes, the alkanes in the oil-based mud (OBM) may "crack", thereby partially converting the OBM alkanes into shorter chain molecules (including hydrogen when the temperature is high enough). This DBM is often related to many drilling and rock parameters, such as rock strength, abrasiveness, cutting element hardness, sliding surface area, friction area, bit pressure, vibration, torque, drill bit cooling effect corresponding to mud flow rate, and mud and tool / drill bit heat transfer rate. For example, DBM may occur more frequently when the drill bit rotation speed is particularly high and the drilling fluid flow rate is low, resulting in increased drilling temperature. An example DBM correction method will be described in more detail below.
[0050] Now go to Figure 8 , depicts a flow chart of an example method 160 for estimating the amount of naturally occurring hydrogen in a subterranean formation. The method includes: degassing a drilling fluid at 162 to obtain a gas sample; and measuring the amount of hydrogen (e.g., hydrogen concentration) in the gas sample using a calibrated mass spectrometer (e.g., a DQ1000 mass spectrometer calibrated using method 140) at 164. At 166, the amount of hydrogen measured at 164 is corrected using a calibration correlation (e.g., as calculated at 148 of method 140) to calculate the hydrogen concentration in the gas sample. The hydrogen concentration calculated at 166 may then optionally be further processed, e.g., corrected for DBM hydrogen at 168 to obtain an estimate of natural formation hydrogen.
[0051] Fig. 9 Depicted is a method 160 for correcting Figure 8 ) of a flow chart of an example method 180 for measuring hydrogen at 168 in ). The method 180 may include measuring at 182 Figure 8 ) in the gas sample obtained at 164. For example, the second gas may be measured simultaneously with the hydrogen measurement made at 164 (e.g., using a mass spectrometer for measuring hydrogen concentration). The second gas may include, for example, carbon monoxide or an olefin, such as ethylene, butene, or propylene. The method 180 for correcting the hydrogen measurement may also include: correlating the second gas measurement with a model (or mathematical equation) at 184 to determine the amount (or concentration) of DBM hydrogen in the gas sample; and calculating from 164 (or a plurality of second gases) at 186. Figure 8 ) to obtain an estimate of formation hydrogen.
[0052] It has been found that the concentration of DBM hydrogen is closely correlated with the concentration of other gases in the gas stream, including, for example, carbon monoxide, ethylene, butene, and / or propylene. Empirical data can be used to generate a correlation between DBM hydrogen and the concentration of another gas (e.g., carbon monoxide). The correlation may also include other variables, such as temperature measurements taken at the drill bit, drill string rotation rate, drill string torque, bit pressure, drilling fluid flow rate, etc. The correlation may also include the type of formation (e.g., shale, sandstone, granite, etc.) and the type of drilling fluid (e.g., oil-based or water-based drilling fluid) and / or the composition of the drilling fluid (e.g., the composition of the base oil in the drilling fluid).
[0053] Fig. 10A and Fig. 10B (collectively, FIG. 10 ) depicts a graph ( 10A ) of hydrogen concentration versus carbon monoxide gas concentration and a graph ( 10B ) of hydrogen concentration versus olefin gas concentration (all in ppm) for an example drilling operation. In this example operation, an oil-based mud (OBM) was used to drill the well through pure sandstone (containing no native oil or hydrogen). These graphs show the correlation between the measured hydrogen and carbon monoxide, ethylene, and propylene gas concentrations, with the hydrogen concentration increasing approximately linearly with the concentrations of carbon monoxide, ethylene, and propylene. Fig. 10A It was observed that the hydrogen concentration increased linearly with the increase of carbon monoxide gas concentration, with a slope of about 6. Fig. 10BIn the example, the hydrogen concentration was observed to increase linearly with increasing ethylene and propylene gas concentrations, with corresponding slopes of about 20 and about 380, respectively. In this example, the increased heating due to the controlled increase in power input to the drill bit resulted in increased levels of hydrogen, carbon monoxide, ethylene, and propylene gases. Since the formation does not include any naturally occurring hydrogen, it is presumed that the hydrogen is essentially DBM hydrogen. The depicted correlation allows DBM hydrogen levels to be obtained from carbon monoxide, ethylene, and / or propylene measurements. Determining DBM hydrogen levels based on carbon monoxide measurements may be particularly advantageous because carbon monoxide is generally not present in unexploited deep underground geological formations (without access to atmospheric oxygen).
[0054] Although FIG. 10 depicts example correlations between measured carbon monoxide, ethylene, and propylene and DBM hydrogen, it should be understood that the disclosed embodiments are not limited to any particular correlation (empirical or otherwise). Suitable correlations may be linear or non-linear, and may include, for example, an analytical equation relating the concentration of a second gas (e.g., carbon monoxide, ethylene, and / or propylene) to the concentration of DBM hydrogen. In another embodiment, the correlation may include a lookup table relating the concentration of a second gas (e.g., carbon monoxide) to the concentration of DBM hydrogen. The disclosed embodiments are not limited in these respects.
[0055] In certain embodiments, DBM hydrogen may be measured (or estimated) based on other drilling fluid logging measurements, such as gas chromatography. By way of example only, DBM hydrogen values may be estimated based on measurements from a commercially available wellsite gas analyzer, such as the PureFlex-DBM measurements available from Schlumberger, that is configured to measure continuous total gas, alkanes, and olefins. In such embodiments, correlations (e.g., Fig. 10B The olefin measurements are processed by a process (as shown) to obtain DBM hydrogen levels as described above. As described above, the disclosed embodiments may include compiling a log of naturally occurring hydrogen and measured wellbore depths. Such a log may further depict the amount of hydrogen measured, the amount of other gases measured (such as carbon monoxide, ethylene, and propylene), and the associated DBM hydrogen levels.
[0056] Although the disclosed embodiments may advantageously utilize a calibrated mass spectrometer as described above, it should be appreciated that other techniques for measuring hydrogen concentration may also be employed. For example, a dedicated hydrogen analyzer may include, for example, laser absorption spectroscopy techniques such as tunable diode laser absorption spectroscopy or cavity attenuation spectroscopy. These absorption-based techniques tend to achieve high resolution and low detection limits (e.g., down to the parts per billion level), and therefore may be suitable for operations where low amounts of hydrogen are expected.
[0057] Still other embodiments may utilize Raman spectroscopy as another optical method for evaluating hydrogen content in a gas sample. Raman spectroscopy may be advantageous for complex gas mixtures often encountered in drilling fluid logging operations. However, Raman spectroscopy may not be sufficiently sensitive to trace (low) gas concentrations (e.g., due to weak Raman scattering signals) and may be limited to operations expected to be higher hydrogen concentrations. In certain example embodiments, cavity enhanced Raman spectroscopy (CERS) may be used to enhance measurement sensitivity at low hydrogen concentrations, for example, by using a cavity or multi-pass cell to enhance the interaction length. In other embodiments, increasing laser power or gas pressure may also improve measurement sensitivity.
[0058] Fig.11 Depicted is a method 100 that can be used to evaluate Figure 3 ) is a schematic diagram of an example cavity enhanced Raman spectrometer 200 for measuring hydrogen content in a ). The spectrometer 200 includes a laser source 202 that emits monochromatic light through a mode matching lens 204 and a beam splitter 206. The transmitted laser light enters the cavity 210, and the reflected light is received at a photodetector 208. The intensity of the received light is input into a Pound-Drever-Hall (PDH) electronics module 212, and feedback is provided to modulate the width of the cavity via a piezoelectric element 214. Raman scattered photons can then be detected as depicted at 216.
[0059] exist Fig.11 In , cavity modulation is used to increase the interaction path length (in the cavity) to enable detection of small gas concentrations. Although not depicted, notch or dichroic filters can be used to filter out the laser and enable detection of the Raman signal, especially for small Raman shifts. Because mechanical vibrations can offset the cavity length, different precautions may need to be implemented to ensure stable enhancement for those cavities that rely on a resonant setup. Optical feedback frequency locking can also be used to modulate the frequency of the laser (e.g., instead of the cavity path length).
[0060] In one example configuration, a resonant cavity and a 100 mW laser with a wavelength of 532 nm can be used to achieve an intracavity power of about 100 watts. Such an example system can enable the measurement of the most common analytes (e.g., including carbon monoxide, carbon dioxide, and hydrogen) in a gas stream with a lower detection limit of about 10 to about 100 ppm and an integration time of about 10 to about 100 seconds. Such a configuration can also enable the measurement of the most common hydrocarbons, such as lower alkanes and alkenes including in the range of 10 ppm to 100 ppm.
[0061] Fig.12Raman spectra (Raman intensity vs. wavenumber) of various gases, including hydrogen, are plotted. The plots depicted include carbon dioxide, oxygen, carbon monoxide, nitrogen, and hydrogen. The amount of hydrogen and other gases can be determined based on the Raman intensity measured at a specific frequency (wavenumber).
[0062] It should be understood that the present disclosure includes many embodiments. These embodiments include but are not limited to the following embodiments.
[0063] In a first embodiment, a method for estimating the amount of natural hydrogen in a subsurface formation includes: degassing drilling fluid obtained from a wellbore to obtain a gas sample including a certain amount of hydrogen; measuring the hydrogen concentration in the gas sample; and applying a correction to the measured hydrogen concentration to estimate the amount of natural hydrogen in the subsurface formation.
[0064] The second embodiment may include the first embodiment, wherein the degassing includes drilling a wellbore in the subterranean formation; circulating a drilling fluid in the wellbore during drilling; and degassing the drilling fluid during the circulating to obtain a gas sample.
[0065] A third embodiment may include any one of the first to second embodiments, wherein the degassing further comprises sampling the gas in the wellbore head space or the return pipe head space, wherein the return pipe head space is located between the wellbore and the mud pit; or sampling the drilling fluid from the wellbore before the drilling fluid is exposed to air and degassing the sampled drilling fluid to obtain a gas sample.
[0066] A fourth embodiment may include any of the first to third embodiments, further comprising: generating a well log that plots an estimated amount of natural hydrogen in a subsurface formation relative to a measured depth in the wellbore.
[0067] A fifth embodiment may include any one of the first to fourth embodiments, wherein applying the correction includes: measuring the amount of a second gas in the obtained gas sample; correlating the measured amount of the second gas with the amount of drill bit metamorphic (DBM) hydrogen in the obtained gas sample; and subtracting the DBM hydrogen amount from the measured hydrogen concentration of the gas sample to calculate an estimated amount of natural hydrogen in the underground formation.
[0068] A sixth embodiment may include the fifth embodiment, wherein the second gas is selected from the group consisting of carbon monoxide, ethylene, and propylene.
[0069] The seventh embodiment may include any one of the first to sixth embodiments, further comprising: calibrating a mass spectrometer for performing hydrogen measurements to obtain a calibrated mass spectrometer including a correlation between a measured hydrogen concentration and an actual hydrogen concentration; and wherein the hydrogen concentration of a gas sample is measured using the calibrated gas spectrometer.
[0070] An eighth embodiment may include any one of the first to seventh embodiments, wherein: calibrating the mass spectrometer includes flushing the mass spectrometer with air and taking a background hydrogen concentration measurement; and the method further includes selecting a mass spectrometer having a background hydrogen concentration measurement of less than 1000 parts per million.
[0071] A ninth embodiment may include the eighth embodiment, wherein calibrating the mass spectrometer further comprises: using the selected mass spectrometer to perform hydrogen concentration measurements on corresponding first, second, and third calibration samples, the first, second, and third calibration samples having different first, second, and third actual hydrogen concentrations; and evaluating the fit between the first, second, and third actual hydrogen concentrations and the first, second, and third hydrogen concentration measurements to calculate a correlation.
[0072] The tenth embodiment may include the ninth embodiment, wherein the background hydrogen concentration measurement and the hydrogen concentration measurements of the first, second, and third calibration samples are performed via evaluation of a mass to charge ratio equal to two.
[0073] In an eleventh embodiment, a system for estimating the amount of natural hydrogen in a subterranean formation comprises: a degasser configured to degas drilling fluid at a drilling rig site to obtain a gas sample; at least one gas sensor configured to measure the amount of hydrogen and the amount of a second gas in the gas sample; and a processor configured to evaluate the measured amount of hydrogen and the measured amount of the second gas to estimate the amount of natural hydrogen in the subterranean formation.
[0074] A twelfth embodiment may include the eleventh embodiment, wherein the at least one gas sensor comprises a calibrated mass spectrometer; and the processor is further configured to apply a correlation to hydrogen gas concentration measurements made with the calibrated mass spectrometer to obtain a measured amount of hydrogen gas.
[0075] A thirteenth embodiment may include any one of the eleventh to twelfth embodiments, wherein the processor is further configured to: evaluate the measured amount of the second gas to obtain a drill bit metamorphic (DBM) hydrogen amount; and subtract the DBM hydrogen amount from the measured amount of hydrogen to obtain an estimate of natural hydrogen in the underground formation.
[0076] The fourteenth embodiment may include any one of the eleventh to thirteenth embodiments, wherein the processor is further configured to generate a drilling log depicting an estimated amount of natural hydrogen in the subsurface formation and a measured amount of hydrogen and at least one of a measured amount of a second gas relative to a depth of a wellbore penetrating the subsurface formation.
[0077] A fifteenth embodiment may include any of the eleventh to fourteenth embodiments, wherein the degasser is configured to degas the drilling fluid from a wellbore penetrating the subterranean formation before the drilling fluid is exposed to air.
[0078] In a sixteenth embodiment, a method for calibrating a mass spectrometer includes: obtaining a drilling fluid gas sample including a certain amount of hydrogen; evaluating the drilling fluid gas sample to measure the amount of hydrogen and measure the amount of a second gas in the obtained drilling fluid gas sample; correlating the measured amount of the second gas with the amount of drill bit metamorphic (DBM) hydrogen in the obtained drilling fluid gas sample; and subtracting the DBM hydrogen amount from the measured amount of hydrogen to calculate an estimated amount of natural hydrogen in a subsurface formation.
[0079] The seventeenth embodiment may include the sixteenth embodiment, wherein the second gas includes at least one of carbon monoxide, ethylene, and propylene.
[0080] An eighteenth embodiment may include any one of the sixteenth to seventeenth embodiments, wherein evaluating the drilling fluid gas sample includes using a calibrated mass spectrometer to measure an amount of hydrogen and an amount of the second gas in the obtained drilling fluid gas sample.
[0081] The nineteenth embodiment may include the eighteenth embodiment, wherein measuring the amount of hydrogen using a calibrated mass spectrometer comprises: measuring the concentration of hydrogen in a drilling fluid gas sample obtained by using a calibrated mass spectrometer; and calculating the amount of hydrogen based on the measured hydrogen concentration and a calibration correlation of the calibrated mass spectrometer.
[0082] A twentieth embodiment may include any one of the eighteenth to nineteenth embodiments, wherein the calibrated mass spectrometer has a background hydrogen concentration measurement of less than 1000 parts per million.
[0083] Although mud logging of natural hydrogen has been described in detail, it should be understood that various changes, substitutions and alterations can be made herein without departing from the spirit and scope of the disclosure as defined by the appended claims.
Claims
1. A method for estimating the amount of natural hydrogen in a subterranean formation, the method comprising: Degassing drilling fluid obtained from a wellbore to obtain a gas sample including a certain amount of hydrogen; measuring a hydrogen concentration in the gas sample; as well as A correction is applied to the measured hydrogen concentration to estimate the amount of natural hydrogen in the subsurface formation.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein the degassing comprises: drilling the wellbore in the underground formation; circulating drilling fluid in said wellbore during said drilling; as well as The drilling fluid is degassed during the circulation to obtain the gas sample.
3. The method of claim 1, wherein the degassing further comprises: sampling gas in a wellbore headspace or a return piping headspace between the wellbore and a mud pit; or Drilling fluid from the wellbore is sampled before the drilling fluid is exposed to air, and the sampled drilling fluid is degassed to obtain the gas sample.
4. The method of claim 1, further comprising: A drilling log is generated that plots the estimated amount of natural hydrogen in the subsurface formation relative to a measured depth in the wellbore.
5. The method of claim 1, wherein applying the correction comprises: measuring an amount of a second gas in the obtained gas sample; correlating the measured amount of the second gas to an amount of drill bit metamorphic (DBM) hydrogen in the obtained gas sample; and The DBM hydrogen amount is subtracted from the measured hydrogen concentration of the gas sample to calculate the estimated natural hydrogen amount in the subsurface formation.
6. The method of claim 5, wherein the second gas is selected from the group consisting of carbon monoxide, ethylene and propylene.
7. The method of claim 1, further comprising: calibrating a mass spectrometer for making hydrogen measurements to obtain a calibrated mass spectrometer including a correlation between the measured hydrogen concentration and the actual hydrogen concentration; as well as The hydrogen concentration of the gas sample is measured using the calibrated gas spectrometer.
8. The method of claim 1, wherein: The calibrating the mass spectrometer includes flushing the mass spectrometer with air and taking a background hydrogen concentration measurement; and The method further includes selecting the mass spectrometer such that the background hydrogen concentration measurement is less than 1000 parts per million.
9. The method of claim 8, wherein calibrating the mass spectrometer further comprises: using the selected mass spectrometer to perform hydrogen concentration measurements on respective first, second, and third calibration samples, the first, second, and third calibration samples having different first, second, and third actual hydrogen concentrations; and The fit between the first actual hydrogen concentration, the second actual hydrogen concentration, and the third actual hydrogen concentration and the first hydrogen concentration measurement, the second hydrogen concentration measurement, and the third hydrogen concentration measurement is evaluated to calculate the correlation.
10. The method of claim 9, wherein the background hydrogen concentration measurement and the hydrogen concentration measurements of the first, second, and third calibration samples are performed via evaluation of a mass to charge ratio equal to two.
11. A system for estimating the amount of natural hydrogen in a subterranean formation, the system comprising: a degasser configured to degas drilling fluid at a drilling rig site to obtain a gas sample; at least one gas sensor configured to measure an amount of hydrogen and an amount of a second gas in the gas sample; as well as A processor is configured to evaluate the measured amount of hydrogen gas and the measured amount of the second gas to estimate the amount of natural hydrogen in the subterranean formation.
12. The system of claim 11, wherein: The at least one gas sensor comprises a calibrated mass spectrometer; and The processor is further configured to apply a correlation to the hydrogen gas concentration measurements made with the calibrated mass spectrometer to obtain the measured hydrogen gas amount.
13. The system of claim 11, wherein the processor is further configured to: evaluating the measured amount of the second gas to obtain a drill bit quality (DBM) hydrogen amount; and The DBM hydrogen amount is subtracted from the measured hydrogen amount to obtain an estimate of natural hydrogen in the subsurface formation.
14. The system of claim 11, wherein the processor is further configured to generate a drilling log depicting the estimated amount of natural hydrogen in the subsurface formation and at least one of the measured amount of hydrogen and the measured amount of the second gas relative to the depth of a wellbore penetrating the subsurface formation.
15. The system of claim 11, wherein the degasser is configured to degas drilling fluid from a wellbore penetrating the subterranean formation before the drilling fluid is exposed to air.
16. A method for calibrating a mass spectrometer, the method comprising: obtaining a drilling fluid gas sample including a certain amount of hydrogen; evaluating the drilling fluid gas sample to measure the amount of hydrogen and to measure an amount of a second gas in the obtained drilling fluid gas sample; correlating the measured amount of the second gas to an amount of drill bit bad (DBM) hydrogen in the obtained drilling fluid gas sample; and The DBM hydrogen amount is subtracted from the measured hydrogen amount to calculate an estimated natural hydrogen amount in the subsurface formation.
17. The method of claim 16, wherein the second gas comprises at least one of carbon monoxide, ethylene, and propylene.
18. The method of claim 16, wherein said evaluating said drilling fluid gas sample comprises measuring said amount of hydrogen and said amount of said second gas in said obtained drilling fluid gas sample using a calibrated mass spectrometer.
19. The method of claim 18, wherein said measuring the amount of hydrogen using said calibrated mass spectrometer comprises: using the calibrated mass spectrometer to measure the concentration of hydrogen in a drilling fluid gas sample obtained by the gas; as well as The amount of hydrogen is calculated based on the measured hydrogen concentration and a calibration correlation of the calibrated mass spectrometer.
20. The method of claim 18, wherein the calibrated mass spectrometer has a background hydrogen concentration measurement of less than 1000 parts per million.
