Improved deflectometry method and associated system

The use of binarized light images and defocusing techniques in phase shift deflectometry addresses phase noise and non-linearity issues, enhancing precision and simplicity in surface shape measurement, particularly for low-slope surfaces.

FR3138691B1Active Publication Date: 2024-11-01CENT NAT DE LA RECH SCI (C N R S)
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
FR2022008107
Authority / Receiving Office
FR · FR
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-08-04
Publication Date
2024-11-01
Estimated Expiration
2042-08-04

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing phase shift deflectometry methods are limited by phase noise and non-linearity, leading to complex calibrations and reduced precision in measuring surface shapes, especially for surfaces with low slopes and small defects.

Method used

A method and system utilizing binarized light images and defocusing techniques to improve phase shift deflectometry, allowing the use of patterns other than sinusoids, which reduces phase noise and enhances precision by averaging high spatial frequencies, enabling measurement of small slopes and surface defects.

Benefits of technology

The method achieves improved measurement precision and simplicity by suppressing phase noise, allowing for clearer detection of surface defects and slopes, with enhanced sensitivity and dynamic range compared to traditional methods.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 00000022_0000
    Figure 00000022_0000
  • Figure 00000023_0000
    Figure 00000023_0000
  • Figure 00000023_0001
    Figure 00000023_0001
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to a method for analyzing a reflective surface (S) by deflectometry, with a system comprising a display (Disp) and an imaging optic (IO). The method comprises the steps of: A. successively displaying on the display (Disp) n luminous images Ili, a luminous image Ili having a binarized luminous intensity obtained by dithering the pattern M(x-xi); B. detecting on the matrix detector (Det) n images Idi obtained by reflection of the n luminous images Ili on the reflective surface (S); C. determining a function called the object absolute phase function (fapS) from the n detected images Idi, the function g further satisfying the relation: g(kM) = g(M) with k any real number; D. comparing the object absolute phase function (fapS) to a reference absolute phase function (fapMref), and deducing information on the shape of said surface. Figure to be published: Figure 3
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Title of the invention: Improved deflectometry method and associated system FIELD OF THE INVENTION

[0001] The present invention relates to the field of deflectometry for analyzing the shape of a surface. STATE OF THE ART

[0002] The principle of phase shift deflectometry or PSD (for "Phase Shifted Deflectometry" in English) is known for analyzing a surface S of an object Obj. A conventional assembly of a PSD device 5 is illustrated [Fig.l]. It comprises a display DispO configured to successively display 4 images I10i(x,y), i index varying from 1 to 4, the 4 images being a sinusoidal pattern in intensity MS(x) along an X axis respectively shifted by 0, ji / 2, ji, 3ir / 2. [Fig.2] illustrates in A the sinusoidal pattern MS(x) and in B the four intensity profiles along x of the images / patterns MSi(x) with MSl(x) corresponding to a phase of 0, MS2(x) corresponding to a phase of ji / 2, MS3(x) corresponding to a phase of ir and MS4(x) corresponding to a phase of 3ir / 2. In the example of [Fig.2] the amplitude of 1 of the sinusoid is coded in B between 0 and 255 (8 bits). We define the reference (X,Y) in the plane of the displayed image.

[0003] Considering that I10i(x,y) represents the intensity between 0 and 1 (amplitude) of an image and (x,y) the horizontal and vertical positions in pixels on the screen, we can say that for example MSi(x) = I10i(x,0) because the pattern is variable only according to x.

[0004] Thus, for all y, MSi(x) = I10i(x,y) = 0.5.[cos((2ir / A).x + <pi) +1 ]

[0005] where A is the spatial period in pixels on the screen of the sine (or cosine) and <pi est la phase of the ith image and takes for example 0, ji / 2, ji, 3ir / 2.

[0006] The display DispO is arranged so that the displayed light images IlOi are reflected on the surface S to be characterized (locally exhibiting a normal N) of the object Obj. Here we are interested in specular reflection and the reflection on the surface is oblique. The device also comprises an imaging optic (not shown) and a matrix detector DetO, the imaging optic being configured to image the surface S on the detector DetO. The imaging optic and detector assembly is for example a camera, which sequentially takes 4 images IdOi corresponding to the part of the sinusoidal pattern MSi (displayed on DispO) reflected by S, imaged, and detected by DetO. The 4 images IdOi are then processed by a processing unit (not shown) which determines, from these 4 detected images, the properties of the surface of the object Obj, and more particularly its relief, in order typically to identify surface defects.

[0007] In a typical deflectometry configuration such as that shown in [Fig.l], the camera must be kept inclined relative to the part of the surface to be inspected in order to be able to image the reflected light coming from the display. The display and the optical axis of the camera must therefore be positioned beyond a minimum angle relative to the part of the surface to be inspected. Indeed, without adding an angle, the camera would block the light from the screen or vice versa. To recover all the light, it is sufficient to reach the minimum angle from which visibility is total.

[0008] The angle of the ray reflected by the surface S depends on the local slope of the surface at the point of impact of the ray. We call (x,y) the coordinates of the displayed images I10i(x,y) (X,Y reference), and (x',y') the coordinates of the detected images Id0i(x',y'), there is typically a magnification factor between the two systems.

[0009] The idea is that when the surface S presents locally at a point P (xp,yp) a local slope aP (a^, ayP) with respect to the plane reference surface, a fringe reflected by this surface S will be shifted on the detector by a shift dx'P in the x direction and dy'P in the y direction, these two quantities depending directly and respectively on the local slopes (a^, ayP). Thus, knowing the geometric parameters of the system, from the shift dP(dx'P, dy'P) we can deduce the local slope aP(axP, ayP) on the surface S at P. From these slopes aP we obtain by derivation the curvature of S at each point and by integration the altitude of S at each point (distribution of heights).

[0010] Thus, in the processing we compare the 4 detected images IdOi with 4 images IdOrefi obtained by reflection of the images IlOi on a flat reference surface Sref positioned in place of the object Obj.

[0011] IdOrefi images are undistorted sinusoidal patterns similar to the displayed images, except for the magnification factor.

[0012] We define a set called object consisting of the 4 images IdOi and a set called reference consisting of the 4 reference images IdOrefi.

[0013] For the comparison, we calculate a so-called absolute phase function for each of the two sets of object and reference images, respectively called absolute object phase function fapOs and absolute reference phase function fapORef, by applying a mathematical function gO on the 4 images corresponding to 4 variables that we will call for the formula fl, f2, f3 and f4, equal to:

[0014] gO = arctg((f4-f2) / (fl-f3)) (1)

[0015] Thus:

[0016] fap0s(x',y') = g0(Id01(x',y'), Id02(x',y'), Id03(x',y'), Id04(x',y'))

[0017] = arctan[(IdO4(x',y') -Id02(x',y')) / (Id01(x',y')-Id03(x',y'))].

[0018] fap0Ref(x',y') = g0(Id0refl(x',y'), IdOref2(x',y'), Id0ref3(x',y'), IdOref4(x',y'))

[0019] = arctan[(IdOref4(x',y') -IdOref2(x',y')) / (Id0refl(x',y')-Id0ref3(x',y'))].

[0020] For illustration purposes, the reference absolute phase function calculated with the 4 shifted sinusoidal patterns of [Fig.2] is also shown [Fig.2]. The reference absolute phase function calculated from the 4 shifted sinusoidal patterns is shown [Fig.2] (curve 20).

[0021] We note that this function is a ramp on intervals of 2ir and that it is therefore bijective on an interval of 2ir: a value of x (or x') in this interval corresponds to a unique value of y (or y'): the use of 4 images with a different phase shift makes it possible to create a bijective phase function at each point.

[0022] The absolute object phase function fapOs is also calculated in the same way from the 4 detected deformed images Id0i(x',y').

[0023] We thus obtain a “mapping” of the surface in absolute object phase and in absolute reference phase.

[0024] From fapOs and fapORef, the paths of the different rays are reconstructed using an algorithm. The bijective nature of the reference and object absolute phase functions makes it possible to connect a straight fringe of the reference images with the corresponding deformed fringe of the detected images, and thus to find the shift dP (measured in number of pixels in the sensor frame then transformed into distance) between these two fringes at a point P on the surface S. The bijective nature is necessary to create a perfect “mapping” to properly identify the fringes between them.

[0025] From this shift, we link this displacement / shift dP determined in the frame of the sensor x' and y' to angles seen by the optical imaging system coupled to the sensor. For this we use conjugation and / or geometric optics formulas. Once we know from which direction each absolute phase comes, we know that each ray strikes the surface S at a point, is reflected by the Snell-Descartes laws to a point on the screen. We thus determine, via the Snell-Descartes laws, the slope of the surface aP at point P of the surface S.

[0026] The method is then repeated in the Y direction (the pattern of the four displayed images is MSi(y)) to have the slope information in both X and Y directions.

[0027] From the information on the slopes along X and Y, the curvature and / or the altitude are deduced as explained above.

[0028] The PSD method therefore processes at least 8 images in total, an object set of 4 images detected via a shift of the pattern along X and an object set of 4 images detected via a shift of the pattern along Y.

[0029] It has been demonstrated that 4 phases as previously described per direction are necessary and sufficient to obtain the absolute phase function.

[0030] The classic PSD method as described above has drawbacks.

[0031] To make the best use of the camera's dynamics, several fringes are used of the displayed pattern. This induces phase jumps in the absolute phase function corresponding to phase discontinuities over several periods (visible on ramp 20 of [Fig.2]). To process them, it is necessary to "unroll the phase", i.e. to implement complex two-dimensional algorithms which search for the real phase jumps in relation to the calculation errors. In the case of several periods, the artan function of gO does not give the absolute phase; the phase must be unrolled to obtain it.

[0032] The implementation of this “phase progression” lengthens the analysis time and the complexity of the associated algorithms, and generates errors at discontinuities.

[0033] As the camera focus is set on the surface to be characterized, and not on the virtual image of the displayed image, this induces contrast problems (defocus blur) of the detected fringes. To overcome this in conventional PSDs, the imaging optics are closed (which increases the size of the Airy spot) and the integration times of the detector are increased, which limits the analysis speed.

[0034] Conventionally, PSD systems have an oblique incidence configuration. It is then difficult to be in focus on the entire surface. When one seeks to analyze very flat surfaces (wafer type for example) not being in focus on the entire surface is a limitation. Indeed, if the depth of field decreases, the fact that one is in oblique incidence implies that a decreasing portion of the surface to be measured is found in the sharpness zone, and one then loses details on the edges. In addition, in oblique incidence, one must close the optical system to gain depth of field. In addition to increasing the depth of field, closing the optical system reduces depth blur and this allows one to regain contrast when there are several fringes to distinguish on the screen. The cost is a longer exposure time since the system is closed and less light is collected. - Finally, the pixels of the screens used for the implementation of the PSD do not emit an intensity transmitted in a linear way in relation to the initial information. Because of this non-linearity, the intensity emitted by the screen does not present exactly a sinusoidal variation: it is not a true sine wave that is generated. This induces, at the time of the calculation of the absolute phase, the appearance of a periodic noise called non-linearity that cannot be easily eliminated. To try to attenuate it, it is necessary: ​​- to carry out a sophisticated calibration of the system or - to finely characterize the non-linearity of the screen in order to send a pre-distorted signal to the pixel in an attempt to correct the non-linearity and emit a “true” sine wave.

[0035] Such an approach is for example described in the publication “Non linearity response correction in phase shifting deflectometry” by Nguyen et al (2018 Meas. Sci. Technol. 29,045012).

[0036] An object of the present invention is to overcome the aforementioned drawbacks by proposing an improved method and system for analyzing a reflective surface by deflectometry, which does not have some of the aforementioned drawbacks and furthermore has better performance than a conventional phase shift deflectometry method. DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

[0037] The present invention relates to a method for analyzing a reflective surface by deflectometry, with a system comprising a display arranged so that light images displayed on the display are reflected on said reflective surface and an imaging optic configured to image said surface on a matrix detector, the method comprising the steps of: A. successively display on the display n light images Ili indexed i with n>2, the n light images being obtained by n spatial shifts xi along a direction X of the same pattern, a light image Ili having a binarized light intensity obtained by screening the pattern M(x-xi), B. detect on the matrix detector n images ldi called detected images, obtained by reflection of the n light images Ili on the reflecting surface, C. determine a function called absolute object phase function from the n detected images ldi, by applying a mathematical function g on said n detected images, the function g and the number of images n being determined so that the absolute phase function is bijective, the function g further verifying the relation: g(kM) = g(M) with k any real number, D. compare the object absolute phase function to a so-called reference absolute phase function, determined by replacing the surface to be characterized by a plane mirror defining a so-called reference plane, and deduce information on the shape of said surface.

[0038] According to a variant, the pattern is a sinusoid, n=4, the four spatial shifts correspond to phase shifts respectively equal to 0, ji / 2, ji, 3ir / 2.

[0039] According to one embodiment, the function g is defined by: g= arctg[(fc4-fc2) / (fcl-fc3)] with fci corresponding to n=4 variables.

[0040] According to one embodiment, each light image displays only one period of the sinusoidal pattern.

[0041] According to another variant, the pattern is a Gaussian, n=2, a first spatial shift corresponding to a Gaussian centered on an edge of the light image 111, and a second spatial shift corresponding to a Gaussian centered on another edge of the image 112, and in which the function g is defined by: g=Ln(fcl) - Ln(fc2) with fci corresponding to n=2 variables.

[0042] According to one embodiment, the pattern is invariant by Fourier transform.

[0043] According to one embodiment, the screening is carried out by the Floyd- algorithm Steinberg.

[0044] According to one embodiment, the imaging optics has an optical axis coincident with a normal to the reference plane, in which said light images illuminate said surface perpendicular to said reference plane, in which the following are defined: - an optical center O of the imaging optics, - a positive distance Ddp between the display and the reference plane Pref and a positive distance Dpo between the reference plane and the optical center O, and in which step D comprises the sub-steps consisting of: - determine for points of the surface S, an angle [3 determined from the offset between the absolute phase function object and the absolute phase function reference to said point of the surface, - determine said slope a with the following formula: a = 0.5. [P − j + acos (cos (P + f))]

[0045] According to another aspect, the invention relates to a system for analyzing a reflective surface by deflectometry comprising: - a display arranged so that light images displayed on the display are reflected on said reflective surface, and configured to successively display n light images Ili indexed i with n>2, the n light images being obtained by n spatial shifts xi along a direction X of the same pattern M(x), a light image Ili(x,y) having a binarized light intensity obtained by rasterizing the pattern M(x-xi), - an imaging optic and a matrix detector, the imaging optic being configured to image said surface on said matrix detector, the matrix detector being configured to detect n images ldi called detected images, obtained by reflection of the n light images Ili on the reflective surface, - a processing unit configured to: - determine a function called the object absolute phase function, from the n detected images ldi, by applying a mathematical function g to said n detected images, the function g and the number of images n being determined so that the absolute phase function is bijective, the function g further verifying the relation: g(kM) = g(M) with any real k, - compare the object absolute phase function with a so-called reference absolute phase function, determined by replacing the surface to be characterized by a plane mirror defining a so-called reference plane, and deduce information on the shape of said surface.

[0046] According to one embodiment, the imaging optics has an optical axis arranged perpendicular to said reference plane, and in which the optical system further comprises a splitter plate configured to send said light images onto said surface perpendicular to said reference plane.

[0047] According to another aspect, the invention relates to a computer program comprising instructions which cause the system according to the invention to execute the steps of the method according to the invention.

[0048] The following description presents several exemplary embodiments of the device of the invention: these examples are not limiting of the scope of the invention. These exemplary embodiments present both the essential characteristics of the invention as well as additional characteristics linked to the embodiments considered.

[0049] The invention will be better understood and other characteristics, aims and advantages thereof will appear during the detailed description which follows and with reference to the appended drawings given as non-limiting examples and in which:

[0050] The [Fig.l] already cited illustrates a classic assembly of a phase shift deflectometry device.

[0051] The [Fig.2] already cited illustrates in A the sinusoidal pattern MS(x) and in B the four shifted patterns MSi(x) and the associated absolute phase function.

[0052] [Fig.3] illustrates the method according to the invention.

[0053] [Fig.4] illustrates the system according to the invention.

[0054] [Fig.5] illustrates an example of a binarized image by dithering a sinusoidal pattern displayed on the display in the method / system according to the invention.

[0055] [Fig.6] illustrates in A the intensity distribution of the displayed image in three successive planes during the propagation of light in space: I: on the display (d0=0); II: at a distance dl from Disp for which the averaging is not yet sufficient; III: at a distance d2 sufficiently far from the screen Disp for the averaging to be successful. In B is illustrated, for the three situations, an example of the variation of the intensity I of the image along the X axis.

[0056] [Fig.7] shows schematically an example of the MTF of the detected image: in A in situation I and in B in situation III.

[0057] [Fig.8] illustrates an embodiment of the invention in which each light image displays only one period of the sinusoidal pattern and the associated reference absolute phase function.

[0058] [Fig.9] illustrates an example of a measurement carried out with a system according to the invention displaying a single period of the binarized sinusoidal pattern for the measurement of a concave surface S. The concavity has been deduced to reveal the surface defects.

[0059] [Fig. 10] illustrates a measurement of the same concave surface (concavity deduced) carried out with a conventional PSD system

[0060] [Fig. 1 IA] illustrates the measurement of a 2-inch silicon wafer carried out with the system according to the invention.

[0061] [Fig. 1 IB] illustrates the measurement of this same wafer with a commercial device of the laser interferometer type (Zygo).

[0062] [Fig. 12] illustrates a second variant of the invention in which the pattern is a Gaussian and the associated absolute phase function is a reference. At an=2, the image 111 consists of the pattern Ml(x) Gaussian function centered on one edge of the image, and the image 112 consists of the pattern M2(x) Gaussian function centered on the opposite edge of the image.

[0063] [Fig. 13] illustrates the shift dP corresponding to a slope a at a point C of the surface to be characterized.

[0064] [Fig. 14] is an optical diagram illustrating different quantities useful for understanding the invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE INVENTION

[0065] The subject of the present invention is a method 100 for analyzing a reflective surface S by deflectometry, illustrated [Fig. 3], which constitutes an improvement of the conventional PSD method as described previously. According to another aspect, the invention also relates to a system 10 illustrated [Fig. 4] which implements the method 100. The system 10 comprises a display Disp arranged so that light images displayed on the display are reflected on the reflective surface S, and an imaging optic IO configured to image the surface on a matrix detector Det. The imaging optic / detector assembly forms for example a camera CA.

[0066] The method according to the invention is a generalization of the classic PSD in the sense that it does not only work with a sinusoidal M(x) pattern but also with other patterns, and makes it possible to resolve certain problems inherent in the PSD, which improves its performance.

[0067] The method comprises a first step A in which n light images Ili indexed i with n>2 are successively displayed on the display Disp, the n light images being obtained by n spatial shifts xi along a direction X of the same pattern M(x). X and Y are defined as the two directions of the reference frame of the image Ili(x,y).

[0068] Unlike a light image used in a conventional PSD, the light images Ili have a binarized light intensity obtained by dithering the pattern M(x-xi) also called Mi(x). After numerous experiments and simulations, the inventors established that such dithering was surprisingly compatible with a characterization of the surface by phase-shift deflectometry, significantly improving its performance while allowing the use of patterns other than a sinusoid (see below). The term "binarized image obtained by dithering" means the transformation of a gray-level image, typically coded between 1 and 255 (8 bits), into an image comprising only points having a non-zero intensity, preferably of maximum intensity (coded 1 or 255) and points having zero intensity (coded 0).The rasterization thus generates an image whose spatial density of points varies according to the pattern M(x) along the X direction. There are many rasterization algorithms and the inventors have tested several which give good results. We cite, without limitation: - the algorithm consisting of generating a random image in which each pixel has a probability of the form (sin(x)+l) / 2 of being 1 (or 0). - the Floyd-Steinberg algorithm,

[0069] Other “dithering” algorithms are easily accessible on the internet.

[0070] [Fig.5] illustrates an example of a binarized image by dithering a sinusoidal pattern of period T.

[0071] In a second step B, n images Idi(x',y') are detected on the matrix detector Det, called detected images, obtained by reflection of the n light images Ili on the reflecting surface S. The coordinates (x', y') of the detected image are linked to the coordinates (x, y) of the displayed image by a magnification factor. The directions of the reference frame of the detected image are always called (X, Y).

[0072] This step B is identical to what is classically practiced in PSD, except that classically we always have n=4 and M(x) sinusoid.

[0073] In a step C, a function called the absolute phase function faps object is determined from the n detected images ldi, by applying a mathematical function g to the n detected images, the function g and the number of images n being determined so that the absolute phase function is bijective, that is to say:

[0074] y' = faps(x') with y' unique for each x' (2)

[0075] When the pattern is sinusoidal and n=4 the mathematical function g is equal to gO given by formula (1).

[0076] The function g further verifies the relation:

[0077] g(kM) = g(M) (3)

[0078] with any real k.

[0079] This condition (3) comes from the fact that the operator g must be insensitive to the reflectivity of the surface, the intensity reflected by the surface S and detected by the detector Det being proportional to this reflectivity. The function g applied to the images must therefore not keep this reflectivity which must cancel. An example is a cancellation of the reflectivity by means of a ratio between the images (see formula 1). When a pattern other than a sinusoid is used, the function g is different from formula (1).

[0080] In a step D, the object absolute phase function faps is compared to an absolute phase function fapMref called reference, determined by replacing the surface S to be characterized by a plane mirror Mref defining a plane Pref called reference illustrated [Fig.4] and information on the shape of said surface is deduced from it, in the same spirit as what is done in classic PSD. The absolute reference phase function is obtained from the 4 detected images of references Idrefi.

[0081] Note that the imaging optics IO are configured to image the surface S and not the virtual image of the display (as for a conventional PSD). The image displayed on Disp is therefore not in focus on the detector Det, it is blurred.

[0082] As in the classic PSD, steps A to D are repeated along the Y axis to obtain slope information along the Y direction.

[0083] When the geometric parameters of the system are not changed, the same reference absolute phase function can be used for several measurements of different surfaces. If the parameters are changed, for example the display-surface distance, and / or the surface-imaging optics distance, and / or the focal length of the imaging optics, it is appropriate to proceed with the detection of the 4 images Idrefi (with the mirror Mref in place of S) and the determination of the reference absolute phase function from these 4 images in the new configuration.

[0084] The system 10 according to the invention illustrated [Fig.4] therefore comprises: - a display Disp arranged so that light images displayed on the display are reflected on the reflective surface S, and configured to successively display the n binarized light images Ili, - an imaging optic IO and a matrix detector Det, the imaging optic being configured to image the surface S on the detector Det, the matrix detector being configured to detect the n images ldi obtained by reflection of the n light images Ili on the reflective surface S, - a processing unit (PU) configured to implement steps C of determining the absolute object phase and D of comparing the absolute object and reference phase functions and determining information on the shape of S.

[0085] In a non-limiting manner, [Fig. 4] illustrates a normal incidence configuration which is preferred for implementing the method according to the invention. “Normal incidence” means a configuration in which the optical axis OA of the imaging optics 10 is perpendicular to the reference plane Pref and in which the system comprises a beam splitter BS configured to send the light images onto the surface S perpendicular to the reference plane Pref. This normal incidence configuration is rarely used in conventional PSD. Since we are seeking to determine very small slope angles a, the entire surface S is in focus on the detector.

[0086] The inventors have established that the binarization of the displayed image II, combined with the defocusing of the image of II carried out by IO, makes it possible to obtain on the surface S a light coming from the display corresponding to a “true” sine, rather than a degraded sine as is the case in conventional PSD.

[0087] This is due to the fact that the binarized image is averaged as it propagates in space and gives, if the display is placed at a sufficient distance from the surface S, a sinusoidal function close to a perfect sine. [Fig.6] illustrates in A the intensity distribution of the displayed image II in three successive planes during the propagation of the light in space: I: on the display (d0=0); II: at a distance dl from Disp for which the averaging is not yet sufficient; III: at a distance d2 sufficiently far from the screen Disp for the averaging to be successful. In B is illustrated, for the three situations, an example of the variation of the intensity I of the image along the X axis (which oscillates between 1 (255) and 0) for a cross-section along an axis 50, showing the averaging as the propagation progresses. The Gaussian blur of the binarized image corresponds to the propagation of light in free space.

[0088] In other words, the image in I corresponds to what the detector detects when the camera is focused on the virtual image Ivir (the image in I is here a real image of the virtual image of the screen Ivir created by the surface S), and the image in III corresponds to what the detector detects when the camera is focused on the surface S, i.e. when the measurement is carried out.

[0089] [Fig.7] shows schematically an example of the MTF (for “Modulation Transfer Function” in English or modulation transfer function, function of the spatial frequency fs in cycles / mm) of the image detected by Det: in A in situation I (focus on the virtual image of the display) for which the image has high spatial frequencies, and in B in situation III (focus on the surface S) for which the high spatial frequencies have been eliminated: the high spatial frequencies present in the image binarized are eliminated during propagation and a “true” sine is created on the surface S.

[0090] Thus, the binarization of the displayed image makes it possible to considerably reduce or even eliminate the non-linear periodic phase noise present in the conventional PSD, which no longer exists here since the displayed image is binarized and no longer analog. This is true because LCD screens are very homogeneous for a given intensity, but are non-linear for intensity variations. This noise suppression avoids complex calibrations of the system and greatly simplifies its implementation.

[0091] For the measurement, the adjustment of the display-surface distance must be sufficient for the propagation averaging to be effective, that is to say for the filtering of the high frequencies of the binarized image to take place. This adjustment is carried out, for example, by visually verifying that the detected pattern presents a variation considered satisfactory or by characterizing the variation curve of the detected intensity along an axis parallel to X (see curves in [Fig.6] part B for II and IIII).

[0092] To adjust the aperture of the system, open it to the maximum to reduce the depth of field and maximize the averaging (not too much however if the optics used are less efficient at maximum apertures).

[0093] In summary, the adjustment variables for properly averaging the "dither" are: - take a screen with a higher pixel density, - open the optical system, - move the screen further away, - possibly move the lens closer to the target, - optionally stick a frosted glass on the screen in order to exacerbate the averaging in addition to the propagation.

[0094] The system 10 according to the invention with a normal incidence configuration makes it possible to bring the IO imaging optics closer to the surface to be characterized (see below). This makes it possible to increase the relative value of the difference between the straight fringe and the aforementioned curved fringe, directly linked to the value of the slope a sought, and therefore to measure smaller values ​​of a than with the conventional PSD. The normal incidence configuration also allows focusing on the entire surface, which is very useful for the characterization of very flat surfaces, i.e. with very low slopes a.

[0095] At a sufficient distance from the display, the emitted Fonde propagation is similar to a Fourier transform. Preferably, a pattern M(x) is chosen that is invariant by Fourier transform, to obtain on the surface S a pattern of the same nature as that displayed on Disp.

[0096] As explained above, according to a first variant, the pattern M(x) is a sinusoidal pattern (binarized). In this case an=4 and the four spatial shifts xi correspond to phase shifts respectively equal to 0, ji / 2, ji, 3ir / 2.

[0097] Preferably, the mathematical function g applied to the 4 detected images ldi (object) and to the 4 reference images Idrefi, corresponding to 4 variables called fci, is:

[0098] g=arctg[(fc4-fc2) / (fcl-fc3)].

[0099] with fci = ldi (for the calculation of faps) and fci = Idrefi (for the calculation of fapref)

[0100] This formula is identical to formula (1) used for a conventional PSD process.

[0101] According to an embodiment of the method 100 and of the system 10, according to the invention, each light image displays only one period of the pattern, as illustrated [Fig.8] for the sinusoidal pattern: the spatial frequency of the sine of the pattern is reduced. Indeed, with the invention, the objective is opened, which optimizes the spatial frequencies near the sample to be characterized, and reduces the contrast of the fringes displayed on the screen. To recover good contrast on the display, it is therefore necessary to lower the spatial frequency of the displayed fringes.

[0102] The absolute object phase function calculated with formula (1) is equal to curve 80 which no longer presents discontinuities (phase jumps).

[0103] Using only one period means that the phase does not have to be "unrolled" (see state of the art), which makes the algorithm for going back to the dy and the slopes much less complex and faster. In addition, with a single fringe, we have more signal because we do not lose contrast on the detected fringes. Indeed, if we use several fringes, i.e. a higher spatial frequency on the display, as mentioned above, the contrast of the high spatial frequencies decreases. A reduction in contrast implies a loss in the dynamic range of the camera. With a single fringe, looking at the MTF, we see that the low frequencies are transmitted much better than the high frequencies, regardless of the focus. We therefore maintain good contrast, and we have more signal because max-min tends towards 1: we then exploit the dynamic range of the camera to the maximum.

[0104] [Fig.9] illustrates an example of a measurement carried out with a system according to the invention displaying a single period of the binarized sinusoidal pattern for the measurement of a concave S surface. The concavity has been deducted to reveal the surface defects. The right-hand scale shows that the measurement sensitivity on residual surface defects is approximately + / - 30 nm. The surface defects are clearly visible.

[0105] The system has the following characteristics: - Optical center distance O of the imaging optics - sample: 47 cm - Screen-Pref distance: 71 cm - Imaging optics focal length: 50 mm - Detector resolution: 4512x4512 pixels, pixel size 2.74 pm - Opening of the imaging device: N=2 - Screen used: classic computer LCD screen

[0106] For comparison, [Fig. 10] illustrates a measurement of the same concave surface (concavity deduced) carried out with a conventional PSD system displaying one period of an analog pattern, without precorrection of the nonlinearity of the display and with the same system as described above. We see on the right-hand scale that the measurement sensitivity on the residual defects of the surface is approximately + / - 150 nm. This is due to the phase noise which adds a parasitic modulation. This modulation corresponds to the dark and light areas in the image. Because of this parasitic signal the measurement precision is lower and the defects are less visible.

[0107] [Fig. 11 A] illustrates a measurement carried out with the system according to the invention of a 2-inch silicon wafer-like surface (overall curvature deduced) The nanometric-thick polishing grooves are visible and the surface image is complete. The measured thickness variation amplitude is + / - 100 nm or 200 nm (see scale on the right).

[0108] [Fig. 1 IB] illustrates a measurement of this same wafer (overall curvature deduced) carried out with a commercial device of the Zygo laser interferometer type. We see an area 11 without measurements corresponding to a measurement artifact. The object is in fact too curved for the measurement to be possible with the Zygo, the latter having a measurement dynamic of + / -80 nm or 160 nm maximum. The areas corresponding to a variation in thickness going beyond this are not treated and appear in white.

[0109] The system according to the invention is thus more efficient than the Zygo for this measurement: the dynamics are much greater and the details at high spatial frequencies (grooves) are better defined.

[0110] The inventors have shown that the method according to the invention is compatible with patterns other than the sinusoidal pattern.

[0111] According to a second variant, the pattern is a Gaussian and n=2. Image 111 consists of the pattern Ml(x) Gaussian function centered on one edge of the image, and image 112 consists of the pattern M2(x) Gaussian function centered on the opposite edge of the image, as illustrated [Fig. 12]. The maximum of the Gaussian is coded at 1. The two Gaussians have the same parameters (amplitude, width).

[0112] The inventors have shown that a function g defined by formula (4) below is bijective and verifies condition (3):

[0113] g=Ln(fcl) - Ln(fc2) (4)

[0114] The reference absolute phase function calculated with the function g of formula (4) is also illustrated [Fig. 12] (curve 12). It does not show any discontinuity. A note that the function g of formula (4) verifies the condition g(kM) = g(M), and that a Gaussian function is invariant under Fourier transform.

[0115] It is advisable to ensure that the maximum of the Gaussian does not saturate the camera and that its minimum of the Gaussian is not below the noise level of the camera.

[0116] The advantage of this Gaussian pattern is that 2x2 images are necessary and sufficient for implementing the method according to the invention, compared to 2x4 images with the use of a sinusoidal pattern. This allows for faster acquisition, processing, and therefore measurement.

[0117] The system according to the invention has great flexibility because the geometric parameters can be modified according to the desired precision, i.e. the order of magnitude of the angle a of the local slope on the surface S. [Fig. 13] illustrates the shift dP corresponding to an angle a at a point C of S. This shift dP measured in the (x', y') reference frame of the detector is the distance between the absolute phase of a fringe when a = 0 (reference) and the absolute phase of the same fringe when the surface C has an angle a locally. This shift is measured separately along x' (pattern displayed along x) and along y' (pattern displayed along y).

[0118] We define the optical center O of the imaging optics and we call [3 the angle corresponding to this shift dP measured with respect to the center O (O is the vertex of |3). Thus, the angle [3 is determined from the shift dP between the absolute object phase function and the absolute reference phase function at point C of the surface.

[0119] The inventors determined a relationship between a and [3 as a function of the system parameters for the preferred normal incidence configuration. This relationship involves only two quantities: a positive distance Ddp between the display and the reference plane Pref, and a positive distance Dpo between the reference plane Pref and the optical center O.

[0120] The diagram in [Fig. 14] illustrates these different quantities in an optical diagram for a digital example with Ddp = 11 cm and Dpo = 31 cm. PDisp is the plane in which the display Disp is arranged and PDet is the plane in which the detector Det is arranged.

[0121] Point A' is a point on the display.

[0122] Point A is the virtual image of A' when the reference mirror Mref is arranged at Pref (perpendicular to OA). A ray from A' is reflected at point C (ray 3) and focused at point F in the plane PDet.

[0123] Point A” is the virtual image of A' when it is the surface S with a local slope a at C which reflects the ray coming from A'. This ray reflected by C (ray 4) is focused at point G in the plane PDet. This is valid for small angles. The ray is reflected by a point very close to point C. For small angles, and to establish the formula below, we considered that this point is C.

[0124] The distance FG corresponds to the offset dP.

[0125] Thus, the angle [3 is the angle formed between the points F, O (optical center-vertex) and G where F is the position of the absolute phase on the detector of a fringe of the screen (A1) after reflection on the reference and G is the position of the absolute phase on the detector of the same fringe after reflection on the sample presenting an angle a.

[0126] The relationship established by the inventors is:

[0127] a = 0.5.[ / ?-f +aco^^^cos{ fi + j ) ) ] ^

[0128] This formula is of course to be applied according to X and Y independently.

[0129] The absolute phase of a reference fringe falls in F, the absolute phase of the same fringe after reflection on the sample falls at G. When the phase varies in the X direction, then F in the frame (x', y') is at x'F and G at x'G, and we have: dx' = x'g-x'f , distance between F and G

[0130] For the simplified case of a thin lens we have:

[0131] [3x = arctan(dx' / f) f focal length of the imaging optics

[0132] For a more complex objective, the position of the main planes is taken into account.

[0133] ax is then determined with formula (5).

[0134] Thus, according to an embodiment of the method 100, according to the invention in step D, the angle [3] is first determined then the angle a using the formula (5).

[0135] It can be seen from this formula (5) that the relationship between a and [3 can be adjusted according to the values ​​of the distances Dpo and Ddp chosen. This is an important advantage of the system / method according to the invention.

[0136] In a classic PSD system in oblique incidence, these two distances are classically equal and we therefore have a = [3. See for example the publication “Review of phase measuring deflectometry” by Huang et al (Optics and Lasers Engineering, volume 107, August 2018, pages 247-257).

[0137] When we want to measure very low slopes a, we try to increase the proportionality factor between a and [3. A study of formula (5) shows that increasing this proportionality factor amounts to decreasing / minimizing the Dpo / Ddp coefficient. At constant focal length this amounts to moving the camera closer (reducing Dpo) and moving the screen further away (increasing Ddp).

[0138] A measurement of very low slopes a is also obtained by increasing the focal length of the imaging optics.

[0139] The document “Phase measuring deflectometry for obtaining 3D shape of specular surface: a review of the State of the art” by Zhang et al (Optical Engineering, vol. 60(2), 020903-1; 2021) describes a classic PSD method with these two different distances Dpo and Ddp. But it is then necessary to carry out a very complex calibration in the camera space to ultimately obtain the correct values ​​(see §4 Error source analysis).

Claims

1.

2.

3. Claims Method for analyzing a reflective surface (S) by deflectometry, with a system comprising a display (Disp) arranged so that light images displayed on the display are reflected on said reflective surface (S) and an imaging optic (10) configured to image said surface on a matrix detector (Det), the method comprising the steps of: - To display successively on the display (Disp) n light images Ili indexed i with n>2, the n light images being obtained by n spatial shifts xi along a direction X of the same pattern M(x), a light image Ili having a binarized light intensity obtained by screening the pattern M(x-xi), - B detect on the matrix detector (Det) n images ldi called detected images, obtained by reflection of the n light images Ili on the reflecting surface (S), - C determine a function called the absolute object phase function (faps) from the n detected images ldi, by applying a mathematical function g to said n detected images, the function g and the number of images n being determined so that the absolute phase function is bijective, the function g also verifying the relation: g(kM) = g(M) with any real k, - D compare the object absolute phase function (faps) to an absolute phase function (fapMref) called reference, determined by replacing the surface (S) to be characterized by a plane mirror (Mref) defining a plane (Pref) called reference, and deduce information on the shape of said surface. Method according to the preceding claim in which the pattern is a sinusoid, n=4, the four spatial shifts correspond to phase shifts respectively equal to 0, ji / 2, ji, 3ir / 2. Method according to the preceding claim in which the function g is defined by: g= arctg[(fc4-fc2) / (fcl-fc3)] with fci corresponding to n=4 variables, fci corresponding to the images detected with said reflecting surface for the calculation of the object absolute phase function, and to the images detected with said reference mirror for the calculation of the reference absolute phase function.

4. Method according to one of claims 2 or 3 in which each light image displays only one period of the sinusoidal pattern.

5. Method according to claim 1 in which the pattern is a Gaussian, n=2, a first spatial shift corresponding to a Gaussian centered on an edge of the light image 111 and a second spatial shift corresponding to a Gaussian centered on another edge of the image 112, and in which the function g is defined by: g=Ln(fcl) - Ln(fc2) with fci corresponding to n=2 variables, fci corresponding to the images detected with said reflecting surface for the calculation of the object absolute phase function, and to the images detected with said reference mirror for the calculation of the reference absolute phase function.

6. Method according to one of the preceding claims in which the pattern is invariant by Fourier transform.

7. Method according to one of the preceding claims in which the screening is carried out by the Floyd-Steinberg algorithm.

8. Method according to one of the preceding claims in which the imaging optics has an optical axis coincident with a normal to the reference plane, in which said light images illuminate said surface perpendicular to said reference plane, in which the following are defined: • an optical center 0 of the imaging optics, • a positive distance Ddp between the display and the reference plane Pref and a positive distance Dpo between the reference plane and the optical center 0, and in which step D comprises the sub-steps consisting in determining, for points of the surface S: • an angle [3, determined from the offset between the object absolute phase function and the reference absolute phase function at said point of the surface, • a slope a with the following formula: a = 0.5.[ / ?-y + acos[j^cos( fi + ) ) ]

9. System (10) for analyzing a reflective surface (S) by deflectometry comprising: • a display (Disp) arranged so that light images displayed on the display are reflected on said reflective surface (S), and configured to successively display n light images Ili indexed i with n>2, the n light images being obtained by n spatial shifts xi along a direction X of the same pattern M(x), a light image Ili(x,y) having a binarized light intensity obtained by rasterizing the pattern M(x-xi), • an imaging optic (10) and a matrix detector (Det), the imaging optic being configured to image said surface (S) on said matrix detector, the matrix detector being configured to detect n images ldi called detected images, obtained by reflection of the n light images Ili on the reflective surface (S),• a processing unit (PU) configured to: • determine a function called the object absolute phase function (faps), from the n detected images ldi, by applying a mathematical function g to said n detected images, the function g and the number of images n being determined so that the absolute phase function is bijective, the function g further verifying the relationship: g(kM) = g(M) with any real k, • compare the object absolute phase function (faps) with an absolute phase function (fapMref) called the reference function, determined by replacing the surface (S) to be characterized by a plane mirror (Mref) defining a plane (Pref) called the reference plane, and deduce therefrom information on the shape of said surface.,

10. System according to the preceding claim in which the imaging optics has an optical axis (OA) arranged perpendicular to said reference plane, and in which the

11. optical system further comprises a beam splitter (BS) configured to send said light images onto said surface perpendicular to said reference plane. Computer program comprising instructions which cause the system of claim 9 to execute the steps of the method according to one of claims 1 to 8.