Method and apparatus for determining the relative permittivity of a material using ground-penetrating radar

The method employs a MIMO GPR with a novel algorithm to accurately estimate soil layer permittivities and thicknesses, enhancing GPR detection precision by analyzing impulse responses and correlation coefficients, thus improving target detection in multi-layered soils.

FR3142553B1Active Publication Date: 2024-11-15COMMISSARIAT A LENERGIE ATOMIQUE ET AUX ENERGIES ALTERNATIVES
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
FR2022012411
Authority / Receiving Office
FR · FR
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-11-28
Publication Date
2024-11-15
Estimated Expiration
2042-11-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing ground penetrating radar (GPR) methods for estimating the relative permittivity of soil layers are imprecise, especially when the soil is composed of multiple layers with different permittivities, leading to uncertainties in target detection and characterization.

Method used

A method using a ground penetrating radar with multiple transmitting and receiving antennas (MIMO) and a specific algorithm to estimate the relative permittivities and thicknesses of each soil layer by analyzing impulse responses, correlation coefficients, and hyperbolic curve models to refine the estimation process.

Benefits of technology

Precisely determines the relative permittivities and thicknesses of soil layers, improving the accuracy of GPR detection algorithms and reducing uncertainties in target localization.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 00000020_0000
    Figure 00000020_0000
  • Figure 00000021_0000
    Figure 00000021_0000
  • Figure 00000021_0001
    Figure 00000021_0001
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention relates to a new method for accurately estimating the relative permittivities and thicknesses of each layer of a material such as soil. The method is based on measurements acquired by a ground-penetrating radar equipped with multiple transmitting and receiving antennas (MIMO radar, "Multiple Input Multiple Output"). The proposed method relies on a specific algorithm that aims to estimate the most probable pairs (delay, relative permittivity) corresponding to the different layers composing the soil structure. Figure 1
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Title of the invention: Method and device for determining the relative permittivity of a material using ground penetrating radar

[0001] The invention relates to the field of ground penetrating radars and more specifically to non-destructive devices and methods for characterizing the composition of the soil or more generally of a material.

[0002] The invention relates more specifically to a method and a device for determining the dielectric characteristics of the ground, in other words the relative permittivities and the thicknesses of the different layers which constitute the ground. This information then makes it possible to improve radar detection techniques in order to locate and identify underground targets such as pipes, pipelines or even mines or more generally any type of object buried in the ground or in any material.

[0003] Methods for detecting buried targets using ground penetrating radar are generally based on algorithms that require, in their parameters, an accurate estimation of the relative permittivities of the different soil layers. In general, this information is not known or is roughly estimated in the form of an average value for the entire soil structure. These approximations can increase the uncertainties in the results of detection and characterization of underground targets.

[0004] There is therefore a need for a method for precisely estimating the relative permittivities of the different layers of the ground as well as their thicknesses in order to subsequently use this information to improve target detection algorithms using ground penetrating radars.

[0005] In the remainder of the text, the invention is described in the context of the detection of targets buried in the ground, but the invention applies more generally to targets buried in any material which may be different from the ground. The invention also applies to microwave medical imaging to detect, for example, veins under the skin or to non-destructive testing by microwave to estimate the thickness of concrete layers of an industrial structure.

[0006] Several methods for estimating permittivity have been proposed over the years using data from ground penetrating radars (GPR), for example references [1-2]. Most of these techniques are analogous to the velocity analysis approaches used in seismic data processing as described in [3]. Each of these methods depends, in a to some extent, from the comparison of known measurements with data acquired by a GPR ground penetrating radar. The two most widely used prior art methods are hyperbola curve fitting and migration.

[0007] The first known method is based on fitting a hyperbola curve. When the GPR radar antenna is moved over the ground surface and the penetrating wave encounters buried targets or interfaces between different soil layers, hyperbolas can be formed by the travel times of the reflected waves over the distance traveled by the radar. The shape of each hyperbola is given mainly from two elements: the design of the radar, in particular the geometric arrangement of the antennas, and the dielectric properties of the propagation medium. The shape of the radar system is static but the portion of the target illuminated by the radar increases with depth, and the contour of the curve then changes with depth. The shape of each individual hyperbola is therefore a function of the depth and the dielectric properties of the medium.Knowing the target depth, one can estimate the average dielectric properties of the medium by fitting a numerical curve to the hyperbola contour in the data as described in reference [4]. This is a very common method for calibrating GPR data; nevertheless, this method can have two potential shortcomings. The first drawback is that the acquired data must contain several sufficiently clear hyperbolas for known target depths to exploit this method. The other potential problem is that there is usually a small range of values ​​that correspond to the same hyperbola contour. This latter problem, however, can be refined more precisely using a mathematical technique known as migration and described in reference [5].

[0008] Migration is a form of mathematical processing whose main purpose is to more accurately define linear objects. Properly applied, the process reduces hyperbolas to a point in the data acquired by the radar. For linear objects, this makes their position and depth much easier to define because it is no longer necessary to exploit the full hyperbola. There are a wide variety of different migration methods among which the one described in reference [5]. The main parameter required to reduce the hyperbola to a point corresponds to the dielectric properties of the ground as taught in reference [6]. This makes the migration process a means of increasing the accuracy of the curve fitting since the process only works correctly if the applied ground transmission velocity is accurate.

[0009] Generally, the methods of the prior art use an average estimate of the relative permittivity of a material for a given depth.

[0010] A disadvantage of these methods is their relative imprecision when the material, in particularly the soil, is composed of several layers of different permittivities.

[0011] The invention proposes a new method for precisely estimating the relative permittivities and thicknesses of each layer of a material such as soil.

[0012] The method is based on measurement acquisitions carried out by a ground penetrating radar equipped with several transmitting antennas and several receiving antennas (MIMO radar “Multiple Input Multiple Output”).

[0013] The proposed method is based on a particular algorithm which aims to estimate the most probable couples (delay, relative permittivity) which correspond to the different layers making up the structure of the soil.

[0014] The subject of the invention is a method for determining the relative permittivity of a material comprising the steps of: - Acquire a set of measurements using a ground penetrating radar equipped with NRx transmitting antennas and NTx receiving antennas arranged in a plane parallel to the surface of the material, with NRx and NTx two positive integers at least equal to two, the set of measurements being made up of impulse responses for each pair made up of a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna, - Extract from each impulse response, the components relating to multiple paths of the radar signal, in the form of a vector giving the amplitude of the signal as a function of different delay values ​​corresponding to different paths, - Estimate, for each transmitting antenna, a coordinate, in the radar plane, of each target associated with a path by searching for the coordinate of the receiving antenna which maximizes the impulse response, - Calculate, for several hypotheses of relative permittivity values ​​of the material, an estimate of a radar signal delay from a hyperbolic curve model defined by the radar characteristics and the coordinates of the target associated with a signal path, - Search, in the set of components extracted from the impulse responses, for each pair consisting of a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna, at least one amplitude associated with a delay closest to the estimate of a delay calculated in the previous step, - Calculate, for each transmitting antenna, a correlation coefficient of said amplitudes on all the receiving antennas, - Iterate the three previous steps for several values ​​of relative permittivity of the material, - Iterate the previous four steps for all delay values ​​corresponding to multiple paths of the radar signal to obtain NTx matrices correlation giving, for each pair of relative permittivity value of the soil and delay value, a correlation coefficient value, - Eliminate the values ​​from the correlation matrices for which the correlation coefficient is lower than a predetermined detection threshold, - Filter the remaining values ​​to keep only a vector containing a set of all different delay values ​​and an associated value of relative permittivity of the soil, - Deduce, for each layer of the soil, an estimate of its relative permittivity and its thickness.

[0015] According to a particular aspect of the invention, the step of extracting from each impulse response the components relating to multiple paths of the radar signal is carried out by means of a high-resolution algorithm.

[0016] According to a particular aspect of the invention, the step of calculating an estimate t of a delay of the radar signal is carried out by means of the following hyperbolic equation: With Xcp the estimated target coordinate, xTx the coordinate of each transmitting antenna, xRxj the coordinate of each receiving antenna, Ay the distance between a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna, vz the average propagation speed of the signal in the material, tp the estimated delay value.

[0017] According to a particular aspect of the invention, the step of searching for at least one amplitude associated with a delay closest to the estimate of a delay calculated in the previous step is carried out by: - Searching, for each pair consisting of a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna, the amplitude a'P associated with the delay closest to the estimate of a calculated delay, - Define a time window of N+1 samples, N being a positive integer at least equal to 1, the window being centered on the amplitude selected in the previous step and select N / 2 amplitude values ​​corresponding to the delay values ​​included in the time window.

[0018] According to a particular aspect of the invention, the correlation coefficient is calculated by means of the following relation: ]2 with U'P ' amP'itude associated with the delay closest to M'hp .-p-Nj the estimate of a calculated delay, p is the index of said delay and aiPj is the amplitude corresponding to the time index Pj in said time window, is the hypothesis of relative permittivity value.

[0019]

[0020]

[0021]

[0022]

[0023]

[0024] According to a particular aspect of the invention, the threshold value is within the interval ] 0.5; 1 [ According to a particular aspect of the invention, the step of filtering the remaining values ​​comprises the sub-steps of: - Select the pairs which present approximately the same delay values ​​for all transmitting antennas, - Order the couples according to the value of the delays, - When several consecutive relative permittivity values ​​are substantially equal, keep only the pair with the highest delay value. According to a particular aspect of the invention, when several pairs have substantially the same delay values ​​for all the transmitting antennas but different relative permittivity values, only the relative permittivity value which maximizes the correlation coefficient is retained. According to a particular aspect of the invention, the step of deducing, for each layer of the material, an estimate of its relative permittivity and its thickness comprises the sub-steps of: - Estimate the apparent depth of each layer from each pair of retardation and relative permittivity values, - Iteratively determine the relative permittivity of each layer by applying Dix's equation to the propagation delay and velocity values, derived from the relative permittivity value, - Determine the thickness of each layer from the propagation delay and speed values. According to a particular aspect of the invention, during the step of iteratively determining the relative permittivity of each layer, when two consecutive paths lead to obtaining an imaginary propagation speed, the path, among the two paths, having the lowest correlation factor is eliminated. According to a particular aspect of the invention, the material is multi-layered and the method comprises a preliminary phase of estimating the relative permittivity of the first layer of the material for which the hyperbolic curve model for the first layer of the material is a linear asymptotic model and the preliminary phase comprises: - a step of determining the path corresponding to the first layer as the one which maximizes the correlation coefficient, - the selection of the relative permittivity associated with said path as corresponding to the first layer, - calculation of the thickness of the first layer from the delay values ​​and relative permittivity associated with the path.

[0025] According to a particular aspect of the invention, the detection threshold used for the first layer during the preliminary phase has a value lower than the detection threshold used for the subsequent layers.

[0026] According to a particular aspect of the invention, the material is the ground.

[0027] The invention also relates to a device for determining the relative permittivity of a material comprising a ground penetrating radar equipped with NRx transmitting antennas and NTx receiving antennas and a processing unit configured to implement the steps of the method according to the invention.

[0028] The invention also relates to a computer program comprising code instructions which cause the device according to the invention to execute the steps of the method according to the invention as well as a computer-readable medium, on which the computer program according to the invention is recorded.

[0029] Other characteristics and advantages of the present invention will appear better on reading the description which follows in relation to the following appended drawings.

[0030] [Fig.l] represents a flowchart detailing the steps of implementing a method for determining the permittivity of the soil according to an embodiment of the invention,

[0031] [Fig.2a] represents a first diagram of a multi-antenna ground penetrating radar,

[0032] [Fig.2b] represents a second diagram of a multi-antenna ground penetrating radar,

[0033] [Fig.3a] represents an example of a measured impulse response matrix for a transmitting antenna,

[0034] [Fig.3b] illustrates a step of detecting multiple paths in the matrix of the [Fig.3a],

[0035] [Fig.3c] represents an example of a correlation matrix according to a step of the method according to the invention,

[0036] [Fig.4] represents a simplified diagram of a device configured to implement implements the invention.

[0037] [Fig.l] represents, on a flowchart, the steps of implementing a method for determining dielectric characteristics of the soil according to a first embodiment of the invention.

[0038] This first embodiment is advantageously applied when the thickness of the first layer of the ground is sufficiently large compared to the temporal resolution of the radar which depends on its operating carrier frequency.

[0039] The first step 101 consists of acquiring a set of measurements by means of a ground penetrating radar having NTx antennas operating in transmission and NRx antennas operating in reception, with NTx,NRx positive integers at least equal to 2. [Fig.2a] shows schematically an example of an RPS radar having five antennas in transmission and four antennas in reception and moving on the surface of the ground S while carrying out several successive temporal acquisitions.

[0040] [Fig.2b] shows another example of a ground penetrating radar RPS in a top view in a plane (x,y) parallel to the ground plane. The NRx receiving antennas are each arranged at a fixed distance Ay from the NTx transmitting antennas. Each transmitting antenna has a coordinate xRxi along the x axis and is separated by a distance Ay from a corresponding receiving antenna along the y axis.

[0041] Without departing from the scope of the invention, other geometries for the arrangement of the radar antennas are conceivable. In all cases, the RPS radar is arranged close to the ground to operate in the near field.

[0042] Step 101 of acquiring radar measurements thus consists of moving the RPS radar over the surface of the ground S to be analyzed and measuring, for each pair associating a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna, an impulse response of the radar signal Txp where denotes a receiving antenna, Tx, denotes a transmitting antenna and T denotes the time delay. In other words, the impulse response gives the amplitude values ​​as a function of the delay T.

[0043] The impulse responses can be organized in the form of a number NTx of vectors of dimension NRx.

[0044] In step 102, a method for extracting components relating to multiple paths is then applied to the impulse responses. For example, the method used is the CLEAN method or a high-resolution method or any other appropriate method.

[0045] Step 102 aims to detect multiple paths of the signal which correspond to reflections on buried targets. Each path is characterized by a delay tp and an amplitude ^(Rxb Txj, tp ).

[0046] In a particular embodiment of step 102, the CLEAN method is applied by means of a rectangular filter which is defined by a number of samples whose amplitudes are forced to zero around the detected local maximum. A so-called beamwidth filter approach consists of searching for the nearest local minima around the detected local maximum, then forcing the sample forming the detected pulse to zero. Examples of implementation of the CLEAN method are given in references [7] and [8].

[0047] At the end of step 102, for each transmission antenna Txj, a 2D matrix of dimension NP by NRx is obtained which gives the values ​​of the amplitudes of each path tp detected for each reception antenna with NP the number of paths detected.

[0048] The following steps 103,104 consist of modeling each signal path by means of a hyperbolic curve which depends on the geometry of the radar, the characteristics dielectrics of the ground and the position of the targets on which the signal paths are reflected.

[0049] An example of a path modeled by a hyperbolic curve is given by the equation (1) following:

[0050] , (1)

[0051] h? is the speed of propagation of the signal towards a point of a soil layer which is linked to the average relative permittivity e>- of the medium constituting the soil layer by equation (2):

[0052] ^ = ^(2)

[0053] 6 is the speed of light in free space.

[0054] is the distance, along the y axis of Figure 2b, between a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna

[0055] tp is the delay associated with the path of index p

[0056] Xcp is the abscissa, along the x axis of Figure 2b, of the target associated with the index path P

[0057] xTxj and are the respective abscissas of the transmitting and receiving antennas.

[0058] Without departing from the scope of the invention, equation (1) which models a hyperbolic curve can be adapted according to the geometry of the radar.

[0059] In step 103, an estimate of the coordinate Xc? of the target is first determined by searching, for each transmitting antenna and each path of index p, for the coordinate of the receiving antenna which maximizes the impulse response determined in step 102:

[0060] xCp = argmaxj / i (RXj, TXj, rp) | (3)

[0061] Then, in step 104, equation (1) is applied to estimate the delay t modeled from a hyperbolic curve, for different hypotheses of relative permittivity values ​​and for all the receiving antennas.

[0062] In step 105, the impulse responses are then searched for, for each reception antenna, the amplitude aip associated with the delay tp which is closest to the delay t calculated in step 104. In other words, the index p is retained which minimizes the difference between t and tp among all the delays detected for a reception antenna.

[0063] In other words, using tp and Xc? for a given permittivity, step 104 consists of calculating a delay vector t of dimension equal to the number of antennas in reception NRx. This vector has the shape of the hyperbola formed by a target of delay tp andx^.

[0064] Next, it is necessary to search for this hyperbola in the measurement data. To do this, we search for the amplitudes corresponding to the vector t ([IxNRx] = [tl t2 t3 tNRx]) in the data h(xTxi, xRxj,t).

[0065] Sometimes the values ​​of t are not found identically in the measurements. In this case, two options are possible. A first option consists of searching for the delay tp closest to t and selecting the corresponding amplitude.

[0066] Another option consists of performing an interpolation on the amplitude obtained for the delay tp in order to estimate the value of the amplitude corresponding to the delay t.

[0067] In a particular embodiment of step 105, several amplitudes are retained in a time window of dimension N+1 around the amplitude aip associated with the delay tp which is closest to the delay t.

[0068] In step 106, a correlation coefficient, also called a resemblance metric, is then calculated, which aims to estimate the level of resemblance between the amplitudes determined in step 105 across all the receiving antennas. The objective of step 105 is to identify whether the amplitudes of the chosen path are substantially identical for all the receiving antennas, which should normally be the case if the path is correctly estimated.

[0069] The correlation coefficient is for example determined by means of the relation next:

[0070] , Y'NRx -, ^îp.

[0071] M is a normalization factor sized such that the correlation coefficient is 1 when all amplitudes are equal and tends towards 0 when they are strongly different.

[0072] As indicated, in one embodiment, N is taken equal to 0 and relation (4) simplifies to: 100731 J 1 [CW \ I atP:

[0074] Without departing from the scope of the invention, other metrics can be used to calculate a resemblance coefficient.

[0075] Steps 104 to 106 are iterated for all relative permittivity hypotheses. Steps 103 to 106 are iterated for all delay indices p.

[0076] At the end of these steps we obtain NTx correlation matrices also called coherence matrices of dimensions NP by NE, where NP is the number of delays and NE the number of hypotheses of relative permittivities. The values ​​of a correlation matrix are the correlation coefficients R(t, s,) for each delay, per- relative mittivity.

[0077] Then in step 107, all the values ​​of the NTx correlation matrices are compared to a predetermined detection threshold thl whose value is included in the interval ]0.5; 1[.

[0078] Only values ​​that exceed this threshold are retained. A high value of the thl threshold allows for greater selectivity in order to eliminate a greater number of values. Conversely, a lower value can be chosen when the hyperbolic curve model presents more uncertainties.

[0079] At the end of step 107, a 3D matrix (delay, relative permittivity and correlation coefficient) of dimensions NP' by NTx by NE' is obtained, where NP' and NE' correspond respectively to the maximum number of paths and permittivity hypotheses for each transmitting antenna.

[0080] The matrix obtained is of the following form, where each column represents the significant events detected by all the receiving antennas for a single transmitting antenna.

[0081] ®11 "■ «lArx \ A = î ! («NPI "■ ^'NTxl

[0082] With aPl is a 2D matrix of the form:

[0083] [tpï epX R(epi,Tp^p[ \ pi: '. : y pi &pNE' ^Ap^^Tpi)pNE'l

[0084] The first column of this matrix contains the same delay value tp' on each entry, the second column contains the different values ​​retained for relative permittivity and the third column contains the correlation coefficient values ​​associated with the delay, permittivity pair.

[0085] Step 108 then consists of filtering the values ​​of matrix A in order to keep only one vector of delay, permittivity pairs for which all the delay values ​​are different.

[0086] To this end, step 108 firstly consists of retaining the common multiple paths between the different transmitting antennas. Each path is defined by a pair (delay, relative permittivity). The common paths are those which have similar delays based on a given error criterion. The difference between two delays is compared in absolute value to an error threshold which depends on the intended scenario and in particular on the speed of movement of the radar during its displacement during the acquisition step 101 but also on the size of the antenna array. When several common paths are detected having substantially the same delay value but different relative permittivity values, the path with the highest correlation factor is kept, the others are eliminated.

[0087] After this step, the paths are sorted in ascending order of the delay values. If two consecutive paths have substantially equal relative permittivities, only the path with the highest delay is kept, the others are deleted.

[0088] At the output of step 108, we therefore obtain a final vector whose dimension corresponds to the number of layers of the estimated soil and each component of which corresponds to a delay, relative permittivity pair.

[0089] Step 109 consists of the final step which aims to estimate the relative permittivities of each layer of the soil and its thickness.

[0090] Step 109 firstly consists of calculating an apparent depth between the ground surface and the bottom of each successive layer using the following equation:

[0091] Zk=-^rk(5)

[0092] For each layer of the soil with index k, we therefore obtain its apparent depth and the average relative permittivity of all the layers between the surface of the soil and the layer with index k.

[0093] To obtain the thickness and relative permittivity of each individual layer, we use Dix's equation:

[0094] ? (6) y

[0095] vsjl is the average speed of propagation of the signal from the ground surface to the bottom of the layer of index n,

[0096] is the average speed of propagation of the signal from the ground surface to the bottom of the layer of index n-1,

[0097] is the round trip travel time between the ground surface and the bottom of the layer of index n

[0098] is the round trip travel time between the ground surface and the bottom of the layer of index n-1

[0099] n = 1 corresponds to the ground surface.

[0100] are calculated from equation (2)

[0101] vim,n corresponds to an average speed of propagation of the signal inside the layer of index n.

[0102] Alternatively, equation (6) can be replaced by equation (7):

[0103] v. _ vv (7)

[0104] By applying equation (6) or (7), we deduce the value of l then the final value of relative permittivity of the layer n using equation (2), then finally the thickness of the layer with the equation:

[0105] wn =(tn- ) x vintjr where - Zn - ZnA

[0106] In the case where < tvint^ is an imaginary value. In order to eliminate the possibilities of obtaining an imaginary value, before applying Dix's equation, at each iteration, we check if tnv^i > If this is not the case, we keep only the parameters that give the highest correlation factor and remove the others.

[0107] A second embodiment of the invention is now described which is advantageously applicable when the thickness of the first layer is low in comparison with the temporal resolution of the radar which is linked to its carrier frequency.

[0108] In such a situation, the round-trip travel time between the ground surface and the bottom of the first layer can be considered to be the same as the simple direct path of the signal. In this case, the diffraction curve takes a linear form which corresponds to the asymptote of a hyperbola. A linear model is then more appropriate for estimating the paths between the ground surface and the interface between the first layer and the second layer.

[0109] In this second embodiment of the invention, the method described in [Fig.l] is modified in order to apply certain specific steps only for the estimation of the first layer.

[0110] Steps 101 to 108 are applied identically except that equation (1) used to calculate the delay t is replaced by the following equation: [YES] Z = + (7)

[0112] Step 109 first involves determining the path that most likely corresponds to the first layer as having the highest correlation factor.

[0113] Then the thickness of the first layer is calculated using equation (5).

[0114] ^ = -^7]

[0115] This path therefore makes it possible to define the relative permittivity £ri and the thickness M'i of the first layer.

[0116] Advantageously, the detection threshold used in step 107 for the first layer has a lower value than that used for the upper layers because the model used for the first layer is less precise.

[0117] In an alternative embodiment of the second embodiment, when calculating the characteristics of the subsequent layers, the correlation coefficient for the path obtained for the first layer on the basis of equation (7) is compared with that obtained for the first layer on the basis of equation (1) and only the one with the highest correlation coefficient is retained.

[0118] In another variant embodiment of the invention, the permittivity values relative permittivity obtained for each layer of the soil are interpolated in order to determine a curve of evolution of the relative permittivity as a function of the depth of the soil or a probability distribution of the relative permittivity as a function of the depth of the soil.

[0119] Figures 3a, 3b and 3c give examples of the outputs of certain intermediate steps of the method according to the invention for a transmitting antenna.

[0120] [Fig.3a] represents the impulse responses obtained in step 101 for a transmitting antenna in the form of a matrix giving the values ​​of the path amplitudes measured for different receiving antennas, with a number of receiving antennas N_Rx equal to 8.

[0121] [Fig.3b] represents the results obtained at the output of step 102 in the form of circles positioned on the matrix of [Fig.3a] to identify the detected multiple paths.

[0122] [Fig.3c] represents an example of a correlation matrix giving the values ​​of the correlation coefficients for each pair of delay and relative permittivity.

[0123] [Fig.4] shows schematically a device 400 for determining dielectric characteristics of the ground according to the invention. The device 400 comprises at least one GPR radar signal acquisition module, for example a multi-antenna ground penetrating radar, and a processing unit UT configured to execute the steps of implementing the invention from the measurements provided by the GPR radar.

[0124] The processing unit UT can be implemented in software and / or hardware form, in particular by using one or more processor(s) and one or more memory(s). The processor can be a generic processor, a specific processor, an application-specific integrated circuit (also known as ASIC for “Application-Specific Integrated Circuit”) or an in situ programmable gate array (also known as FPGA for “Field-Programmable Gate Array”).

[0125] The invention can be used in conjunction with a state-of-the-art radar target detection algorithm. In particular, the invention can be used to detect mines or underground pipelines. References

[0126] [1] Serkan, S., and V. Borecky. "Estimation methods for obtaining GPR signal velocity." Proceedings of the Third Interlational Conference on ACSEE, Zurich, Switzerland. 2015.

[0127] [2] Forte, Emanuele, and Michèle Pipan. "Review of multi-offset GPR applications: Data acquisition, processing and analysis." Signal processing 132 (2017): 210-220.

[0128] [3] Schneider, William A. "Developments in seismic data processing and analysis (1968-1970)." Geophysics 36.6 (1971): 1043-1073.

[0129] [4] Grote, K., S. Hubbard, and Y. Rubin. "GPR monitoring of volumetric water content in soils applied to highway construction and maintenance." The Leading Edge 21.5 (2002): 482-504.

[0130] [5] Ôzdemir, Caner, et al. "A review on migration methods in B-scan ground pe- netrating radar imaging." Mathematical Problems in Engineering 2014 (2014).

[0131] [6] Dong, Zejun, et al. "3D Migration Depth Focus Velocity Analysis of Hand-Held Ground Penetrating Radar." Geosciences 12.4 (2022): 178.

[0132] [7] R.-M. Cramer, R. A. Scholtz, and M. Z. Win, “Evaluation of an ultrawide-band propagation channel,” IEEE Transactions on Antennas and Propagation, vol. 50, no. 5, pp. 561-570, 2002.

[0133] [8] U. Schwarz, “Mathematical-statistical description of the itérative beam removing technique (method clean),” Astronomy and Astrophysics, vol. 65, p. 345, 1978.

Claims

1. Claims Method for determining the relative permittivity of a material comprising the steps of: - Acquire (101) a set of measurements using a ground penetrating radar equipped with NRx transmitting antennas and NTx receiving antennas arranged in a plane parallel to the surface of the material, with NRx and NTx two positive integers at least equal to two, the set of measurements consisting of impulse responses for each pair consisting of a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna, - Extract (102) from each impulse response, the components relating to multiple paths of the radar signal, in the form of a vector giving the amplitude of the signal as a function of different delay values ​​corresponding to different paths, - Estimate (103), for each transmitting antenna, a coordinate, in the radar plane, of each target associated with a path by searching for the coordinate of the receiving antenna which maximizes the impulse response, - Calculate (104), for several hypotheses of relative permittivity values ​​of the material, an estimate of a delay of the radar signal from a hyperbolic curve model defined by the characteristics of the radar and the coordinates of the target associated with a signal path, - Search (105), in the set of components extracted from the impulse responses, for each pair consisting of a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna, at least one amplitude associated with a delay closest to the estimate of a delay calculated in the previous step, - Calculate (106), for each transmitting antenna, a correlation coefficient of said amplitudes on all the receiving antennas, - Iterate steps 104 to 106 for several values ​​of relative permittivity of the material, - Iterate steps 103 to 106 for all delay values ​​corresponding to multiple paths of the radar signal to obtain NTx correlation matrices giving, for each pair of soil relative permittivity value and delay value, a correlation coefficient value, Eliminate (107) the values ​​of the correlation matrices for which the correlation coefficient is lower than a predetermined detection threshold, Filter (108) the remaining values ​​to keep only a vector containing a set of all different delay values ​​and an associated value of relative permittivity of the soil, Deduce (109), for each layer of the soil, an estimate of its relative permittivity and its thickness.

2.

3.

4. Method for determining the relative permittivity of a material according to claim 1 in which the step of extracting (102) from each impulse response, the components relating to multiple paths of the radar signal is carried out by means of a high resolution algorithm. Method for determining the relative permittivity of a material according to any one of the preceding claims in which the step (104) of calculating an estimate t of a delay of the radar signal is carried out by means of the following hyperbolic equation: , 11 / \ 2 / Jv \ 2 , VgT >2 I / v 2 / Jv \ 2 / vr \ 2 + ( / 7) + (~2~) + (t) +(-V / With Xc" the coordinate of the target estimated in step 103, xTxj the coordinate of each transmitting antenna, ^Rx, the coordinate of each receiving antenna, dy the distance between a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna, the average speed of propagation of the signal in the material, tp the value of a delay estimated in step 102. Method for determining the relative permittivity of a material according to any one of the preceding claims in which step (105) is carried out by: Searching, for each pair consisting of a transmitting antenna and a receiving antenna, the amplitude a'p associated with the delay closest to the estimate of a delay calculated in step 104, Define a time window of N+1 samples, N being a positive integer at least equal to 1, the window being centered on the amplitude selected in the previous step and select N / 2 amplitude values ​​corresponding to the delay values ​​included in the time window.

5. Method for determining the relative permittivity of a material according to claim 4 in which the correlation coefficient is calculated (106) by means of the following relation: / \ f y'tÀ'Tèl' j “ .J [ K t P 1 — ......................................... with a'p the amplitude associated with the delay closest to the estimate of a delay calculated in step 104, p is the index of said delay and ülPj is the amplitude corresponding to the time index pj in said time window, er is the hypothesis of the relative permittivity value.

6. A method of determining the relative permittivity of a material according to any preceding claim wherein the threshold value is in the range ] 0.5; 1 [

7. Method for determining the relative permittivity of a material according to any one of the preceding claims in which the step of filtering (108) the remaining values ​​comprises the sub-steps of: - Selecting the pairs which have substantially the same delay values ​​for all the transmitting antennas, - Ordering the pairs according to the value of the delays, - When several consecutive relative permittivity values ​​are substantially equal, retaining only the pair having the highest delay value.

8. Method for determining the relative permittivity of a material according to claim 7 in which, when several pairs have substantially the same delay values ​​for all the transmitting antennas but different relative permittivity values, only the relative permittivity value which maximizes the correlation coefficient is retained.

9. Method for determining the relative permittivity of a material according to any one of the preceding claims in which the step of deducing (109), for each layer of the material, an estimate of its relative permittivity and its thickness comprises the sub-steps of: - Estimating the apparent depth of each layer from each pair of delay and relative permittivity values, - Iteratively determine the relative permittivity of each layer by applying Dix's equation to the delay and propagation speed values, derived from the relative permittivity value, - Determine the thickness of each layer from the delay and propagation speed values.

10. A method for determining the relative permittivity of a material according to claim 9 wherein, during the step of iteratively determining the relative permittivity of each layer, when two consecutive paths result in obtaining an imaginary propagation speed, the path, among the two paths, having the lowest correlation factor is eliminated.

11. A method for determining the relative permittivity of a material according to any preceding claim, wherein the material is multi-layered and the method comprises a prior phase of estimating the relative permittivity of the first layer of the material for which the hyperbolic curve model for the first layer of the material is a linear asymptotic model and the prior phase comprises: - a step of determining the path corresponding to the first layer as the one that maximizes the correlation coefficient, - selecting the relative permittivity associated with said path as corresponding to the first layer, - calculating the thickness of the first layer from the delay and relative permittivity values ​​associated with the path.

12. A method of determining the relative permittivity of a material according to claim 11 wherein the detection threshold used for the first layer during the preliminary phase has a value lower than the detection threshold used for the subsequent layers.

13. A method of determining the relative permittivity of a material according to any preceding claim wherein the material is soil.

14. Device for determining the relative permittivity of a material comprising a ground penetrating radar provided with NRx transmitting antennas and NTx receiving antennas and a processing unit configured to implement the steps of the method according to any one of the preceding claims.

15. A computer program comprising code instructions that cause the device of claim 14 to perform the steps of the method of any one of claims 1 to 13.

16. A computer-readable medium on which the computer program according to claim 15 is recorded.