Onboard design device and onboard design method

The mounting design device optimizes ECU placement by using topology and coefficient acquisition units with mathematical programming to address suboptimal conventional methods, achieving efficient and cost-effective ECU arrangement.

JP2024165783AActive Publication Date: 2024-11-28DENSO CORP
View PDF 5 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2023082277
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-18
Publication Date
2024-11-28
Estimated Expiration
2043-05-18

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Conventional methods for determining the mounting position of vehicle electronic control units (ECUs) do not optimize initial settings and fail to consider various design patterns beyond wire harness length, leading to suboptimal arrangements.

Method used

A mounting design device and method that utilize a topology information acquisition unit, a coefficient acquisition unit, and a calculation unit to determine the optimal number and positions of ECUs based on objective functions and constraints, considering factors like wire length, installation cost, and power supply, using graph theory and mathematical programming to optimize ECU placement.

Benefits of technology

Accurately determines the number and positions of ECUs, reducing calculation time and costs while ensuring efficient wiring and power supply, thus optimizing the ECU mounting process.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2024165783000001_ABST
    Figure 2024165783000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide technology for accurately determining onboard positions, including the number of electronic control units to be mounted, in designing the onboard positions of the electronic control units.SOLUTION: In S130, a processing unit 5 acquires a coefficient that defines an onboard function set including a first decision variable and a second decision variable, and an onboard condition that limits a range that the first decision variable and the second decision variable may take. The first decision variable represents whether to mount zone ECUs, for each of onboard candidate positions. The second decision variable represents whether a peripheral device is connected to the zone ECUs mounted in the onboard candidate positions. In S140, the processing unit 5 determines an onboard position and the number of electronic control units to be mounted by calculating the first decision variable and the second decision variable that minimize an evaluation value calculated by the onboard function in a range that satisfies the onboard condition.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 6
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present disclosure relates to a technique for designing a mounting position of an in-vehicle electronic control unit. [Background technology]

[0002] The following Patent Document 1 describes a method for determining the mounting positions of in-vehicle electronic control units (hereinafter, ECUs). This method is based on the premise that the mounting positions of all ECUs required to realize the full specifications are set in advance (hereinafter, initial settings). Then, when an empty mounting position where an ECU is not mounted occurs depending on the grade of the vehicle, if there is an ECU that can be moved to the empty mounting position to shorten the wire length of the wire harness, the ECU is moved to the empty mounting position. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0003] [Patent Document 1] JP 2011-5914 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0004] However, as a result of the inventors' investigation, it was found that the initial setting of the ECU mounting position in the conventional technology is not necessarily optimized, and that the conventional technology cannot evaluate a large number of design patterns based on factors other than the wire length of the wire harness.

[0005] One aspect of the present disclosure provides a technique for accurately determining mounting positions, including the number of electronic control units, in designing mounting positions of electronic control units. [Means for solving the problem]

[0006] An aspect of the present disclosure is an installation design device, comprising a topology information acquisition unit (5: S120), an installation coefficient acquisition unit (5; S130), and an installation calculation unit (5: S140). The topology information acquisition unit is configured to acquire topology information that is information including a plurality of candidate installation positions, one or more device installation positions, and a wiring route. The candidate installation positions represent positions at which an electronic control unit can be installed in a vehicle to be designed. The device installation positions represent positions at which peripheral devices that are installed in the vehicle to be designed and connected to the electronic control unit are installed. The wiring route is a wiring route between the candidate installation positions and from the device installation positions to the candidate installation positions. The installation coefficient acquisition unit is configured to acquire coefficients that define an installation function and installation conditions that are determined according to the vehicle to be designed. The installation function is set using a first decision variable and a second decision variable, and is an objective function used to calculate an evaluation value that represents the acceptability of the placement of the electronic control unit. The first decision variable is a variable that represents whether or not the electronic control unit is installed for each of a plurality of candidate installation positions. The second decision variable is a variable that indicates, for each peripheral device, which of the electronic control units mounted at the candidate mounting positions is to be connected to the peripheral device. The mounting condition is a constraint condition that limits the range of values ​​that the first decision variable and the second decision variable can take. The mounting calculation unit is configured to determine the mounting positions and the number of electronic control units to be mounted by calculating the first decision variable and the second decision variable that maximize or minimize the evaluation value calculated by the mounting function within a range that satisfies the mounting condition.

[0007] According to this configuration, the mounting positions of the electronic control units, as well as the number of electronic control units to be mounted, can be determined accurately. One aspect of the present disclosure is an installation design method executed in an installation design device constructed using a computer. In the installation design method, first, a topology information acquisition unit included in the computer acquires topology information including a plurality of candidate installation positions, one or more device installation positions, and wiring paths (S120). The candidate installation positions represent positions at which an electronic control unit can be installed in a vehicle to be designed. The device installation positions represent positions at which peripheral devices that are installed in the vehicle to be designed and connected to the electronic control unit are installed. The wiring paths are wiring paths between the candidate installation positions and from the device installation positions to the candidate installation positions. Next, an installation coefficient acquisition unit included in the computer acquires coefficients of an installation function and installation conditions that are determined according to the vehicle to be designed (S130). The installation function is an objective function used to calculate an evaluation value that represents the suitability of the placement of the electronic control unit using a first decision variable and a second decision variable. The first decision variable is a variable that represents whether or not the electronic control unit is installed for each of a plurality of candidate installation positions. The second decision variable is a variable that indicates which of the electronic control units mounted at the candidate mounting positions each of the peripheral devices is to be connected to. The mounting condition is a constraint condition that limits the range of values ​​that the first decision variable and the second decision variable can take. Next, the mounting calculation unit included in the computer determines the mounting positions and the number of electronic control units to be mounted by calculating the first decision variable and the second decision variable that maximize or minimize the evaluation value calculated by the mounting function within a range that satisfies the mounting condition (S140).

[0008] According to this method, the same effects as those of the above-mentioned mounting design device can be obtained. [Brief description of the drawings]

[0009] [Figure 1] 1 is a block diagram showing a configuration of an installation design device for an in-vehicle electronic control unit; [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a wire harness topology diagram showing an overview of topology information. [Diagram 3] 1 is a table showing the contents of topology information. [Figure 4] 11 is a table showing the contents of coefficient information. [Diagram 5] FIG. 11 is an explanatory diagram showing the relationship between the presence or absence of a loop connection, the number of mounted nodes, and the number of links. [Figure 6] 1 is a flowchart of an installation design process. [Figure 7] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram showing the relationship between the number of zone ECUs and the amount of wiring between the zone ECUs and peripheral devices. [Figure 8] 11 is a graph showing the results of measuring the relationship between the number of candidate mounting positions for a zone ECU and the calculation time required for design for the method of the embodiment and the comparative method. [Figure 9] 11 is a graph showing the results of calculating the total cost of the design results for the method of the embodiment and the comparative method. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0010] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present disclosure will be described with reference to the drawings. [1. First embodiment] [1-1. Configuration] The first embodiment of the on-board electronic control unit (ECU) installation design device 1 is used to design the number and installation positions of zone ECUs in a vehicle that employs a zone architecture, and also to design the wiring structure of the power lines connecting the zone ECUs.

[0011] The zonal architecture is a type of vehicle electric / electronic architecture (i.e., EEA). Currently, the mainstream EEA is the domain-distributed architecture. In the domain-distributed architecture, multiple ECUs are placed for each specific system (i.e., domain), such as the powertrain, body, and chassis. In contrast, the zonal architecture consolidates control functions and information in a small number of computers with high processing capabilities, called zone ECUs. This allows for a simple wiring structure and more efficient system development.

[0012] As shown in FIG. 1, the installation design device 1 includes an input unit 2, a display unit 3, a storage unit 4, and a processing unit 5. The input unit 2 includes a keyboard, a pointing device, and the like, and is used to input various commands and various information for operating the on-board design device 1. The input unit 2 may include a communication interface for communicating with other devices (e.g., a server) directly or via a network, and a reading device for reading information from various recording media. The input unit 2 may be configured to input necessary information via the communication interface and the reading device.

[0013] The display unit 3 includes, for example, a liquid crystal display, and displays an information input screen for inputting various information via the input unit 2, and a result display screen for displaying the processing results in the processing unit 5, etc. The input unit 2 and the display unit 3 may be integrated using a touch panel display or the like.

[0014] The storage unit 4 includes a recording medium such as a hard disk and a USB memory. The storage unit 4 stores various information necessary for processing in the processing unit 5. The information stored in the storage unit 4 may be acquired from the outside via the input unit 2 or may be updated. When the storage unit 4 is configured with a removable recording medium, the information may be updated by replacing the recording medium.

[0015] The processing unit 5 includes a CPU 51, a ROM 52, and a RAM 53. Various functions of the processing unit 5 are realized by the CPU 51 executing a program stored in a non-transitive real recording medium. In this embodiment, the ROM 52 corresponds to the non-transitive real recording medium storing the program. Furthermore, the execution of this program executes a method corresponding to the program. The processing unit 5 executes at least an installation design process that designs the number and installation positions of zone ECUs and the wiring structure of power lines connecting the zone ECUs.

[0016] [1-2. Memory information] The storage unit 4 stores at least topology information 41, installation coefficient information 42, and power supply coefficient information 43.

[0017] The topology information 41 is prepared for each type of vehicle. As shown in Fig. 2, the topology information 41 has a graph-type data structure expressed by a graph defined by a plurality of nodes and a plurality of edges connecting the nodes. As shown in Fig. 3, the nodes N1 to N m+n are m device location nodes ND1 to ND m and n candidate location nodes NE1 to NE n Here, m and n are any positive integers. In the following, each node N1 to N m+n When there is no need to distinguish between them, they are referred to as node N. m When there is no particular distinction between the candidate location nodes NE1 to NE2, the candidate location nodes NE3 to NE4 are referred to as the device location node ND. n When there is no particular distinction between the candidate location nodes, they are referred to as candidate location nodes NE.

[0018] The equipment location node ND represents a position where the peripheral equipment DV is mounted in the vehicle (hereinafter, equipment mounting position). The peripheral equipment DV is a sensor, an actuator, etc. connected to the zone ECU. The candidate location node NE represents a position where the zone ECU can be mounted in the vehicle (hereinafter, candidate mounting position). The topology information 41 includes the number m of equipment location nodes ND (i.e., equipment mounting positions and peripheral equipment mounted in the equipment mounting positions) and the number n of candidate location nodes NE (i.e., candidate mounting positions) as information.

[0019] Edge E1~E p is information representing a wiring route connecting nodes N. In the following, each edge E1 to E pWhen there is no particular distinction between them, they are represented as edges E. The edges E are set to form the following graph. Each device location node ND has one or more edges E leading to any of the candidate location nodes NE. Each candidate location node NE has one or more edges E leading to other candidate location nodes NE. One of the candidate location nodes NE includes a battery BT as a connection node. However, in FIG. 2, only edges E connecting candidate location nodes NE are shown, and edges E connecting candidate location nodes NE and device location nodes ND, and edges E connecting candidate location nodes NE and battery BT are omitted.

[0020] 3, each edge E has information about connection nodes and edge length. The connection nodes are information that identifies the nodes N connected to both ends of the edge E. The edge length is information that represents the length of the wiring path on the vehicle that corresponds to the edge E.

[0021] As shown in FIG. 4, the installation coefficient information 42 and the power supply coefficient information 43 are prepared for each type of vehicle. The installation coefficient information 42 includes a plurality of installation coefficients used to define an installation function and installation conditions. The installation function is an objective function used to determine which candidate installation position (i.e., the candidate position node NE) the zone ECU should be installed in. The installation conditions are constraint conditions used to define the range of values ​​that the decision variables used in the installation function can take.

[0022] The power supply coefficient information 43 includes a power supply function and a plurality of power supply coefficients used to define the power supply conditions. The power supply function is an objective function used to determine the wiring structure of the power lines between the zone ECUs whose installation positions and number are determined according to the installation function and the installation conditions. The power supply conditions are constraint conditions used to limit the range of values ​​that the decision-making variables used in the power supply function can take. The objective function and constraint conditions are expressed by equations or inequalities using the decision-making variables and the installation coefficients or power supply coefficients.

[0023] The installation coefficient is the installation cost b and the equipment wiring cost c. i The installation cost b is the cost per zone ECU required for installing the zone ECU in the vehicle. The device wiring cost c i is the device location node ND i Peripheral device DV installed at the position indicated i is the cost per unit length of wiring required to connect to

[0024] The power supply coefficients are constants A, B, and the equipment load current L k At least Constants A and B are the power line wiring cost C i This is used as an approximation to calculate the power line wiring cost C i is the cost per unit length of the power line used to supply power to the zone ECU that has been determined to be installed in the installation candidate position indicated by the candidate position node NEi. i is the device location node ND i Peripheral device DV installed at the position indicated i is the load current.

[0025] [1-2. Objective function and constraints] The mounting functions and mounting conditions used by the processing unit 5 for designing the mounting positions and the number of zone ECUs will be described.

[0026] The mounting function is expressed by equation (1).

[0027]

number

[0028] In equation (1), Z is the evaluation value. In formula (1), x j , y ij x is the decision variable. j =1 is the candidate location node NE j This means that the zone ECU will be installed in the candidate location indicated by x. j =0 is the candidate location node NEj This means that the zone ECU is not to be installed at the candidate installation position indicated by the candidate location node NE. j The zone ECU that is installed at the candidate installation position indicated by y is denoted as installed ECUj. ij =1 is the device location node ND i Peripheral equipment DV installed at the equipment mounting position indicated i This means that the on-board ECU j is connected to the ij =0 means that the peripheral device DVi is not connected to the installed ECUj.

[0029] In equation (1), d ij is the device location node ND i from the candidate location node NE j The length of the wiring path to the peripheral device DB i The length of the signal line required to connect the ECU j to the ECU j is shown. ij Based on the edge length included in the topology information 41, the equipment location node ND i from the candidate location node NE j The length of the wiring path d is calculated by adding up the edge lengths of all edges that belong to the shortest path to ij For example, the Dijkstra algorithm, which is an algorithm used in graph theory, can be used to calculate the wiring path length d ij is the device location node ND i and candidate location node NE j Alternatively, values ​​calculated in advance for each of all combinations of the wiring path length d may be used. ij If the wiring route length d ij may be included in the topology information 41.

[0030] In equation (1), m is the number of peripheral devices DV (ie, device location nodes ND), and n is the number of mounting candidate locations (ie, candidate location nodes NE), both of which are included in the topology information 41.

[0031] In equation (1), b is the installation cost per zone ECU, and c i Peripheral Devices DVi Both are included in the installation coefficient information 42.

[0032] In equation (1), the first term on the right hand side is the total installation cost determined by the number of zone ECUs installed (hereafter, total installation cost). Also, in equation (1), the second term on the right hand side is the total wiring cost between the zone ECUs and each peripheral device DV determined by the installation location of the zone ECUs (hereafter, total wiring cost). In other words, equation (1) sets the total of the total installation cost and the total wiring cost as the evaluation value Z, and determines the decision variable x so that evaluation value Z is minimized. i , y ij In this case, the quality of the design is judged by the evaluation value Z, and the smaller the evaluation value Z, the better the design is judged to be.

[0033] The installation conditions applied to the installation functions are expressed by equations (2) to (4).

[0034]

number

[0035] The installation conditions expressed by equations (2) to (4) are the decision variables x i , y ij is a condition that limits the range of values ​​that can be taken. Equation (2) is the candidate location nodes NE1 to NE n The zone ECU must be installed in at least one of the candidate installation locations indicated by (i.e., x1 to x n This indicates the condition that at least one of the

[0036] Equation (3) is the peripheral devices DV1 to DV m must be connected to one of the on-board ECUs j (i.e., y i1 ~y in This indicates the condition that only one of the following two conditions is true:

[0037] Equation (4) is the peripheral device DVi The connection destination of is the installed ECU j (i.e., x j Candidate location node NE where j In other words, the condition is limited to the case where the zone ECU is not installed (i.e., x j = 0) candidate location node NE j DV peripherals i (That is, y ij = 0).

[0038] Next, a description will be given of power supply functions and power supply conditions used by the processing unit 5 to determine a power supply line connection structure between zone ECUs whose number and positions have been determined using the installation functions. Next, the power supply functions are defined by equations (5) to (8).

[0039]

number

[0040] In equation (5), X ij is a decision variable. In the following, the candidate location node NE i The zone ECU that has been selected for installation in the candidate installation position indicated by X is called the installed ECUi. ij =1 means that a power line is connected from the installed ECU i to another installed ECU j. ij = 0 means that the power line is not connected from the installed ECU i to the installed ECU j. In other words, the decision variable X ij In this table, the presence or absence of a connection is indicated, including the connection direction in which mounted ECUi is on the upstream side as the power supply source and mounted ECUj is on the downstream side as the power supply destination.

[0041] In equation (5), D ij is the candidate location node NE i from the candidate location node NE j The length of the wiring path from the ECU i to the ECU j, i.e., the length of the wiring required to connect the mounted ECU i and the mounted ECU j. ij is the wiring path length d ijSimilar to the case of (1), the candidate location node NE is selected based on the edge length included in the topology information 41. i from the candidate location node NE j The length of the wiring path D is calculated by adding up the edge lengths of all edges that belong to the shortest path to ij To calculate the wiring path length d ij As in the case of , for example, the Dijkstra algorithm can be used. ij is the candidate location node NE i and candidate location node NE j Alternatively, values ​​calculated in advance for each of all combinations of the wiring path length D may be used. ij If the wiring route length D ij may be included in the topology information 41.

[0042] In equation (5), C i represents the wiring cost per unit length of the power line that supplies power to the installed ECUi. i is calculated for each installed ECU i according to equation (6). In equation (6), t i represents the input current required by the installed ECU i. i is calculated for each installed ECU i according to equation (7).

[0043] In equation (7), Y ij Y is a variable that indicates whether the mounted ECU i is an ancestor node of the mounted ECU j in the wiring structure of the power lines that is designed to have a tree structure. ij = 1 means that the installed ECU i is the ancestor node of the installed ECU j. ij = 0 means that the installed ECU i is not an ancestor node of the installed ECU j. The ancestor nodes are all the installed ECUs located on the battery BT (i.e., the power supply source) side of the installed ECU of interest on the path from the battery BT to the installed ECU of interest. Y ij is calculated using the constraints shown in equations (11) and (12) below, and the decision variable X ij The value is determined by the setting.

[0044] In equation (7), r k represents the load current that the on-board ECU k supplies to the peripheral device DV connected to it. The load current r k is calculated for each installed ECU i according to equation (8). In equation (8), y ik is the decision variable determined using equation (1), and y ik =1 indicates that the installed ECUk is a peripheral device DV i y ik =0 means that the installed ECUk is i This means that the connection destination of L i DV peripherals i This is a load current of r, which is included in the power supply coefficient information 43. k is connected to the on-board ECU k (i.e., y ik (=1) The load current L of all peripherals DVi i It is calculated by summing up the above.

[0045] Equations (5) to (8) define the total wiring cost of the power lines connecting the installed ECUs as the evaluation value Z, and the decision variable X that minimizes the evaluation value Z ij However, the wiring cost per unit length of the power line that supplies power to the installed ECU i is C i The ancestor node of the installed ECU is Y ik = 1) The load current r of all installed ECUs k k The sum of the input current t i is set according to

[0046] Next, the power supply conditions applied to the power supply functions are defined by equations (9) to (12).

[0047]

number

[0048] The power supply conditions expressed by equations (9) to (12) are the decision-making variables Xij A variable Y that specifies the range of values ​​that can be taken by and whether there is an ancestor-descendant relationship between the two installed ECUs. ij The following shows the constraints on the value of

[0049] Equations (9) and (10) show the conditions for forming a tree structure of connections between on-board ECUs. Equation (9) indicates the condition that the lead ECU has inputs from non-lead ECUs, and each non-lead ECU has at least one input from another non-lead ECU other than itself. The lead ECU is the mounted ECU j that is directly connected to the battery BT and located at the top of the tree structure, where j=g. The non-lead ECU is another mounted ECU j other than the lead ECU, where j≠g.

[0050] Equation (10) is a constraint for preventing loop connections from occurring in the connection structure between on-board ECUs. Specifically, the constraint is that when a subset of on-board ECUs is arbitrarily selected, the number of connections between on-board ECUs included in that subset (hereinafter referred to as the number of links) is less than the number of on-board ECUs (hereinafter referred to as the number of nodes). As shown in Figure 5, in a subset that includes loop connections in the power line connection structure, the number of links is equal to or greater than the number of nodes. This relationship is used to eliminate connection structures that include loop connections.

[0051] Equations (11) and (12) are constraints for defining the ancestor-descendant relationship between installed ECU i and installed ECU j, that is, the relationship between the power supply source (i.e., upstream) and the power supply destination (i.e., downstream).

[0052] Equation (11) is a constraint that defines the basic parent (i.e., ancestor) and child (i.e., descendant) relationship. For example, the installed ECU i is connected upstream and the installed ECU j is connected downstream (i.e., X ij =1), then the installed ECU i is an ancestor of the installed ECU j (i.e., Y ij = 1).

[0053] In equation (12), when i = j, it means that all mounted ECUs define themselves as their ancestors. In equation (12), when i ≠ j, it means that the relationship between ancestors and descendants of two or more generations, such as grandfather and grandchild, is a constraint. In other words, mounted ECU i is defined as the ancestor of mounted ECU k (i.e., Y ik =1), and the installed ECU k is defined as the ancestor of the installed ECU j (i.e., Y kj =1), then the installed ECU i is the ancestor of the installed ECU j (i.e., Y ij =1).

[0054] In addition, the reason why the ancestor-descendant relationship is defined in (12) so that the installed ECU includes itself as an ancestor node is that the input current t i When calculating the load current r i is the input current t i This is to ensure that it is included in the

[0055] [1-2. Processing] Next, the mounting design process executed by the processing unit 5 will be described with reference to the flowchart of Fig. 6. A design process program, which is a program for implementing the mounting design process, is stored in the ROM 52 included in the processing unit 5. The mounting design process is started when a predetermined start command is input via the input unit 2.

[0056] When the installation design process is started, in S110, the processing unit 5 selects a vehicle to be designed. Specifically, a screen for vehicle selection is displayed on the display unit 3, and the vehicle selected via the input unit 2 is set as the vehicle to be designed.

[0057] In the next step S120, the processing unit 5 acquires from the storage unit 4 the topology information 41 relating to the vehicle to be designed. In the next step S130, the processing unit 5 acquires from the storage unit 4 the installation coefficient information 42 related to the vehicle to be designed.

[0058] In the next S140, the processing unit 5 applies the topology information 41 and the installation coefficient information 42 acquired in S120 and S130 to the installation function shown in the formula (1) and the installation conditions shown in the formulas (2) to (4). Then, the processing unit 5 determines the first decision variable x i and the second decision variable y ij The number and locations of zone ECUs to be installed are determined by finding a combination of the above. The mathematical model shown in equations (1) to (4) is classified as a mixed integer linear programming problem (MILP). This refers to an optimization problem (i.e., a linear programming problem) in which the objective function and constraints are expressed linearly, but which includes variables that must be integers. Using a mathematical programming solver, which is software equipped with an algorithm for solving mathematical programming problems, the decision-making variable x that minimizes the installation function under the installation conditions is found. i ,y ij A combination of the following is searched for. There are various mathematical programming solvers, but for example, Gurobi Optimizer can be used. Gurobi Optimizer is a registered trademark.

[0059] In the next S150, the processing unit 5 acquires the power supply coefficient information 43 related to the vehicle to be designed from the storage unit 4. In the next step S160, the processing unit 5 calculates the load current r for each mounted ECUk by using the formula (8) based on the calculation result in S140 and the power supply coefficient information 43 acquired in S150. k Calculate.

[0060] In the next S170, the processing unit 5 applies the calculation result in S140 and the power supply coefficient information 43 acquired in S150 to the power supply function shown in the formulas (5) to (7) and the power supply conditions shown in the formulas (9) to (12). Then, the processing unit 5 determines the wiring structure of the power lines connecting the zone ECUs by finding a third decision variable that minimizes the evaluation value Z calculated by the power supply function within a range that satisfies the power supply conditions, and ends the process. Note that in S170, as in the case of S140, a mathematical programming solver is used to find a decision variable X that minimizes the power supply function under the power supply conditions.ij Explore combinations of.

[0061] [1-3. Estimation] When implementing a zone architecture, it is necessary to design how many zone ECUs to install and where in the vehicle to install them. Figure 7 shows examples of installing eight zone ECUs and installing three zone ECUs. As shown in the figure, the more zone ECUs are installed, the shorter the wiring required to connect the peripheral devices to the zone ECUs. Conversely, the fewer zone ECUs are installed, the longer the wiring required to connect the peripheral devices to the zone ECUs. In other words, there is a trade-off between the number of zone ECUs installed and the amount of wiring.

[0062] There are a huge number of patterns for the number and location of zone ECUs. For example, if there are 100 possible locations for installing zone ECUs, there are patterns for installing or not installing zone ECUs for each possible location, so the number of design patterns to be considered is 2 100 It becomes.

[0063] 8 is a graph showing the calculation time required for designing the number and location of zone ECUs using the method of this embodiment (hereinafter, this method) and using a method that does not define a mathematical model and brute-force verification of all patterns (hereinafter, comparison method). As the calculation environment, a computer with 6 Cores / 12 Threads, a CPU operating at 32 GHz, and a main memory of 32 GB was used.

[0064] In the comparative method, the calculation time increases exponentially with the number of candidate mounting positions, n, and is approximately 9000 seconds when n=20. In contrast, in the present method, the calculation time when n=20 is approximately 0.64 seconds, which is less than 0.01% of the time required by the comparative method. In addition, in the present method, the increase in calculation time with respect to n is roughly linear, and even when n=432, the calculation is completed in less than 10 seconds. Note that n=432 is the value when all connectors present in the EEA model used this time are considered as candidate mounting positions. In other words, with the present method, the design can be completed within a realistic time, even if there are a sufficient number of candidate mounting positions for practical use.

[0065] Fig. 9 shows the results of calculating the total cost of mounting the zone ECU, the cost of wiring between the zone ECUs, and the cost of wiring for peripheral devices based on the results of the design using this method and the comparative method. In Fig. 9, the cost shown is normalized to 100 as the cost per ECU required for mounting the ECU.

[0066] However, in the comparison method, if the number of candidate zone ECU installation positions n is increased, it becomes impossible to obtain results within a realistic time frame, so n = 20 was used. In this method, n = 432, which is the upper limit for the EEA model mentioned above. The same data was provided for both methods except for the candidate zone ECU installation positions.

[0067] As shown in FIG. 9, it was confirmed that the total cost based on the design in the comparative method was 2824.1, while the total cost based on the design in the method of this embodiment was 2637.5, which is approximately 6.6% smaller.

[0068] The number of zone ECUs determined by design was 10 for this method and 8 for the comparison method, and the mounting locations of the zone ECUs showed a similar tendency. [1-4. Correspondence of terms] In this embodiment, the processing unit 5 that executes the process of S120 corresponds to the topology information acquisition unit of the present disclosure, the processing unit 5 that executes the process of S130 corresponds to the on-board coefficient acquisition unit of the present disclosure, and the processing unit 5 that executes the process of S140 corresponds to the on-board calculation unit of the present disclosure. Also, in this embodiment, the processing unit 5 that executes the process of S150 corresponds to the power supply coefficient acquisition unit of the present disclosure, and the processing unit 5 that executes the processes of S160 to S170 corresponds to the power supply calculation unit of the present disclosure. In this embodiment, the on-board ECU corresponds to the on-board unit of the present disclosure, the leading ECU corresponds to the leading unit of the present disclosure, and the non-leading ECUs correspond to the non-leading units of the present disclosure.

[0069] [1-5. Effects] According to the first embodiment described above in detail, the following effects are achieved. (1a) In the installation design device 1, as a decision variable of the installation function, which is an objective function, x which decides whether or not to install a zone ECU in each installation position candidate is used. i , Decide whether to connect peripheral devices to the candidate mounting positions. ij Therefore, it is possible to optimize the installation location of the zone ECU, including the number of ECUs to be installed.

[0070] (1b) In the installation design device 1, the sum of the installation cost of the zone ECU and the wiring cost between the installed zone ECU and the peripheral device DV is used as the evaluation value calculated by the installation function. In other words, not only the wiring cost but also the number of zone ECUs to be installed can be correctly evaluated. In addition, by appropriately changing the installation function, various elements can be included as evaluation targets.

[0071] (1c) The on-board design device 1 regards the design of the mounting position of the zone ECU as an optimization problem, and uses the objective function and constraint conditions set by mathematical programming to search for a combination of decision variables that minimizes or maximizes the objective function while satisfying the constraint conditions by a solver. Therefore, the on-board design device 1 can significantly reduce the calculation time compared to a method that searches for the optimal design by exhaustively searching design patterns (i.e., a comparison method).

[0072] (1d) In the onboard design device 1, design constraints can be expressed as constraint conditions of mathematical programming, making it possible to carry out a design taking into account various constraints. (1e) In the on-board design device 1, the topology information 41 is represented in a graph data structure. Therefore, by using a known method that is applied to a graph data structure, such as Dijkstra's algorithm, the processing load can be further reduced.

[0073] [2. Second embodiment] [2-1. Differences from the first embodiment] The second embodiment has a basic configuration similar to that of the first embodiment, and therefore differences will be described below. Note that the same reference numerals as those in the first embodiment indicate the same configuration, and the preceding description will be referred to.

[0074] In the above-described first embodiment, the installation function uses the sum of the installation cost of the zone ECU and the wiring cost between the zone ECU and the peripheral device DV as the evaluation value Z. In contrast, the second embodiment differs from the first embodiment in that it uses an evaluation value Z that takes into account the weight of the wiring between the zone ECU and the peripheral device DV in addition to the above-described installation cost and wiring cost.

[0075] [2-2. Functions for installation] In the second embodiment, an installation function shown in equation (13) is used instead of equation (1).

[0076]

number

[0077] In equation (13), w i DV peripherals i is the weight per unit length of the wiring required to connect the In equation (13), C cost is a coefficient for converting the total cost of mounting and wiring into an evaluation value.

[0078] In equation (13), Cweight is a coefficient for converting the wiring weight into an evaluation value. In addition, w i ,C cost ,C weight is information included in the installation coefficient information 42.

[0079] That is, in the second embodiment, the weighted sum of the total cost and the wiring weight is used as the evaluation value Z. [2-3. Effects] According to the second embodiment described above in detail, in addition to the effects (1a) to (1e) of the first embodiment described above, the following effect is also obtained.

[0080] (2a) According to the second embodiment, it is possible to realize a design that takes into account the wiring weight, which affects the total weight of the vehicle. 3. Other embodiments Although the embodiments of the present disclosure have been described above, the present disclosure is not limited to the above-described embodiments and can be implemented in various modified forms.

[0081] (3a) In the above second embodiment, the mounting function is used to perform evaluation including wiring weight, but the power supply function may be configured to perform evaluation including the wiring weight of the power line. Furthermore, the mounting function and the power supply function may include evaluation elements other than mounting cost, wiring cost, and wiring weight, or one or more of mounting cost, wiring cost, and wiring weight may be excluded as evaluation elements.

[0082] (3b) The processing unit 5 and the method described in the present disclosure may be realized by a dedicated computer provided by configuring a processor and a memory programmed to execute one or more functions embodied in a computer program. Alternatively, the processing unit 5 and the method described in the present disclosure may be realized by a dedicated computer provided by configuring a processor with one or more dedicated hardware logic circuits. Alternatively, the processing unit 5 and the method described in the present disclosure may be realized by one or more dedicated computers configured by a combination of a processor and a memory programmed to execute one or more functions and a processor configured with one or more hardware logic circuits. In addition, the computer program may be stored in a computer-readable non-transitory tangible recording medium as instructions executed by a computer. The method for realizing the functions of each unit included in the processing unit 5 does not necessarily need to include software, and all of the functions may be realized using one or more hardware.

[0083] (3c) Multiple functions possessed by one component in the above embodiments may be realized by multiple components, or one function possessed by one component may be realized by multiple components. Also, multiple functions possessed by multiple components may be realized by one component, or one function realized by multiple components may be realized by one component. Also, part of the configuration of the above embodiments may be omitted. Also, at least part of the configuration of the above embodiments may be added to or substituted for the configuration of another of the above embodiments.

[0084] (3d) In addition to the above-mentioned on-board design device 1, the present disclosure can also be realized in various forms, such as a system including the on-board design device 1 as a component, a program for causing a computer to function as the on-board design device 1, a non-transient physical recording medium such as a semiconductor memory on which this program is recorded, and an on-board design method.

[0085] [4. Technical Concepts Disclosed in This Specification] [Item 1] a topology information acquisition unit (5: S120) configured to acquire topology information including a plurality of candidate mounting positions representing positions where an electronic control unit can be mounted in a vehicle to be designed, one or more device mounting positions representing positions where peripheral devices to be mounted in the vehicle to be designed and connected to the electronic control unit are mounted, and wiring paths between the candidate mounting positions and from the device mounting positions to the candidate mounting positions; an installation coefficient acquisition unit (5; S130) configured to acquire coefficients that define the installation function and the installation conditions that are determined according to the vehicle to be designed, the installation function being set using a first decision variable that indicates whether or not the electronic control unit is to be installed at each of the plurality of installation candidate positions, and a second decision variable that indicates, for each of the peripheral devices, which of the electronic control units installed at the installation candidate positions the peripheral devices are to be connected to, the installation function being an objective function used to calculate an evaluation value that indicates whether the placement of the electronic control unit is good or bad, and the installation conditions being constraint conditions that limit the ranges of values ​​that the first decision variable and the second decision variable can take; an installation calculation unit (5: S140) configured to determine the installation positions and the number of the electronic control units by calculating the first decision variable and the second decision variable that maximize or minimize the evaluation value calculated by the installation function within a range that satisfies the installation condition; An on-board design device equipped with

[0086] [Item 2] The on-board design device according to item 1, the mounting function is set to calculate, as the evaluation value, a total value of a mounting cost determined depending on whether or not the electronic control unit is mounted and a wiring cost between the electronic control unit and the peripheral device. Onboard design equipment.

[0087] [Item 3] The on-board design device according to item 1, The mounting function is set to calculate, as the evaluation value, a weighted sum of a mounting cost determined depending on whether or not the electronic control unit is mounted, a wiring cost between the electronic control unit and the peripheral device, and a wiring weight between the electronic control unit and the peripheral device. Onboard design equipment.

[0088] [Item 4] An on-board design device according to any one of items 1 to 3, The constraint conditions include disposing the electronic control unit in at least one of the plurality of candidate mounting positions, and each of the peripheral devices being connected to one of the electronic control units disposed in the candidate mounting positions. Onboard design equipment.

[0089] [Item 5] An on-board design device according to any one of items 1 to 4, The topology information is represented by a graph in which the mounting candidate positions and the equipment mounting positions are nodes and the wiring routes are edges. Onboard design equipment.

[0090] [Item 6] An on-board design device according to any one of items 1 to 5, a power supply coefficient acquisition unit (5: S150) configured to acquire coefficients that define the power supply function and the power supply condition, using a third decision variable that indicates the presence or absence of wiring of a power supply line between the mounted units as an objective function for calculating an evaluation value that indicates the quality of a wiring structure of a power line connecting the mounted units, the electronic control unit whose mounting position has been determined to be one of the mounting candidate positions by the mounted calculation unit, and a constraint condition that limits a range of values ​​that the third decision variable can take as a power supply condition; a power supply calculation unit (5: S160 to S170) configured to determine a wiring structure of the power lines by obtaining the third decision variable that maximizes or minimizes the evaluation value calculated by the power supply function within a range in which the power supply condition is satisfied; An on-board design device equipped with

[0091] [Item 7] Item 6. An on-board design device according to item 6, the power supply function is set to calculate, as the evaluation value, a wiring cost of a power supply line connecting the mounted units; Onboard design equipment.

[0092] [Item 8] Item 6. An on-board design device according to item 6, the power supply function is set to calculate, as the evaluation value, a weighted sum of a wiring cost of the power supply lines connecting the mountable units and a wiring weight of the power supply lines connecting the mountable units. Onboard design equipment.

[0093] [Item 9] An on-board design device according to any one of items 6 to 8, The power supply conditions include that a head unit, which is the mounted unit directly connected to a battery, does not have an input from a non-head unit, which is the mounted unit other than the head unit, and that each of the non-head units has an input from one of the mounted units other than itself, and that the number of links connecting the mounted units is less than the number of nodes, which is the number of the mounted units. Onboard design equipment. [Explanation of symbols]

[0094] 1...mounting design device, 2...input section, 3...display section, 4...storage section, 5...processing section, 41...topology information, 42...mounting coefficient information, 43...power supply coefficient information, 51...CPU, 52...ROM, 53...RAM.

Claims

1. a topology information acquisition unit (5: S120) configured to acquire topology information including a plurality of candidate mounting positions representing positions where an electronic control unit can be mounted in a vehicle to be designed, one or more device mounting positions representing positions where peripheral devices to be mounted in the vehicle to be designed and connected to the electronic control unit are mounted, and wiring paths between the candidate mounting positions and from the device mounting positions to the candidate mounting positions; an installation coefficient acquisition unit (5; S130) configured to acquire coefficients that define the installation function and the installation conditions that are determined according to the vehicle to be designed, the installation coefficient acquisition unit being set using a first decision variable that indicates whether or not the electronic control unit is to be installed at each of the plurality of installation candidate positions, and a second decision variable that indicates, for each of the peripheral devices, which of the electronic control units installed at the installation candidate positions the peripheral devices are to be connected to, an objective function used to calculate an evaluation value that indicates whether the placement of the electronic control unit is good or bad is an installation function, and constraint conditions that limit the ranges of values ​​that the first decision variable and the second decision variable can take are installation conditions; an installation calculation unit (5: S140) configured to determine the first decision variable and the second decision variable that maximize or minimize the evaluation value calculated by the installation function within a range that satisfies the installation condition, thereby determining the installation positions and the number of the electronic control units; An on-board design device equipped with

2. 2. The on-board design device according to claim 1, the mounting function is set to calculate, as the evaluation value, a total value of a mounting cost determined depending on whether or not the electronic control unit is mounted and a wiring cost between the electronic control unit and the peripheral device. Onboard design equipment.

3. 2. The on-board design device according to claim 1, The mounting function is set to calculate, as the evaluation value, a weighted sum of a mounting cost determined depending on whether or not the electronic control unit is mounted, a wiring cost between the electronic control unit and the peripheral device, and a wiring weight between the electronic control unit and the peripheral device. Onboard design equipment.

4. 2. The on-board design device according to claim 1, The constraint conditions include disposing the electronic control unit in one or more of the plurality of candidate mounting positions, and each of the peripheral devices being connected to one of the electronic control units disposed in the candidate mounting positions. Onboard design equipment.

5. 2. The on-board design device according to claim 1, The topology information is represented by a graph in which the mounting candidate positions and the equipment mounting positions are nodes and the wiring routes are edges. Onboard design equipment.

6. 2. The on-board design device according to claim 1, a power supply coefficient acquisition unit (5: S150) configured to acquire coefficients defining the power supply function and the power supply condition, the power supply function being an objective function that calculates an evaluation value representing the quality of a wiring structure of a power line connecting the mounted units using a third decision variable representing the presence or absence of wiring of a power line between the mounted units, the power supply function being an objective function that calculates coefficients defining the power supply function and the power supply condition, the power supply condition being a constraint condition that limits a range of values ​​that the third decision variable can take; a power supply calculation unit (5: S160 to S170) configured to determine a wiring structure of the power lines by obtaining the third decision variable that maximizes or minimizes the evaluation value calculated by the power supply function within a range in which the power supply condition is satisfied; An on-board design device equipped with

7. 7. The mounting design device according to claim 6, the power supply function is set to calculate, as the evaluation value, a wiring cost of a power supply line connecting the mounted units; Onboard design equipment.

8. 7. The mounting design device according to claim 6, the power supply function is set to calculate, as the evaluation value, a weighted sum of a wiring cost of the power supply lines connecting the mountable units and a wiring weight of the power supply lines connecting the mountable units. Onboard design equipment.

9. 7. The mounting design device according to claim 6, The power supply conditions include that a head unit, which is the mounted unit directly connected to a battery, does not have an input from a non-head unit, which is the mounted unit other than the head unit, and that each of the non-head units has an input from one of the mounted units other than itself, and that the number of links connecting the mounted units is less than the number of nodes, which is the number of the mounted units. Onboard design equipment.

10. An installation design method executed in an installation design device constructed using a computer, comprising: A topology information acquisition unit included in the computer acquires topology information, which is information regarding a plurality of candidate mounting positions representing positions where an electronic control unit can be mounted in a vehicle to be designed, one or more device mounting positions representing positions where peripheral devices mounted in the vehicle to be designed and connected to the electronic control unit are mounted, and wiring paths between the candidate mounting positions and from the device mounting positions to the candidate mounting positions (S120); an installation coefficient acquisition unit included in the computer acquires coefficients of the installation function and the installation conditions determined according to the vehicle to be designed, the installation function being set using a first decision variable representing whether or not the electronic control unit is to be installed at each of the plurality of installation candidate positions, and a second decision variable representing, for each of the peripheral devices, which of the electronic control units installed at the installation candidate positions the peripheral devices are to be connected to; the installation function being an objective function used to calculate an evaluation value representing the acceptability of the placement of the electronic control unit, and the installation conditions being constraint conditions that limit the ranges of values ​​that the first decision variable and the second decision variable can take; An installation calculation unit included in the computer determines the first decision variable and the second decision variable that maximize or minimize the evaluation value calculated by the installation function within a range that satisfies the installation condition, thereby determining the installation positions and the number of the electronic control units (S140). Mounting design method.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Multi-objective optimization method and device for automotive electronic and electrical architecture and storage medium

    CN113343349A

  • Device and method for design support of vehicle control unit

    JP2009211351A

  • Method for determining mounting position of on-vehicle electronic control unit

    JP2011005914A

  • Method for setting wire harness path for vehicle

    JP2011210174A

  • Wiring harness evaluation device

    JP2014235601A