Method for evaluating x-bevel welding joint
The method for evaluating X-groove welded joints using CTOD tests to measure ductile crack lengths addresses the brittle fracture risk in dissimilar metal joints, ensuring safety in cryogenic environments by assessing the crack length ratios, thereby preventing brittle fracture.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023084663
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-05-23
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-05
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
Dissimilar metal X-groove welded joints combining ferritic alloy steel and austenitic welding materials face a high risk of brittle fracture due to lower ductile crack propagation resistance in the weld metal, posing a safety concern for structures like LNG tanks.
A method for evaluating X-groove welded joints using CTOD tests to measure ductile crack lengths in both base metal and weld metal, ensuring the lengths satisfy specific ratios to assess the risk of brittle fracture, involving a CTOD test piece with a notch at equal occupancy of the fatigue pre-crack and observation of fracture surfaces.
Accurately determines the risk of brittle fracture in dissimilar metal X-groove welded joints, enhancing the safety of steel structures in cryogenic environments by preventing brittle fracture.
Smart Images

Figure 2024168197000001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to an X-groove welded joint (hereinafter also referred to as a dissimilar metal X-groove welded joint) in which ferritic alloy steel is welded with an austenitic welding material, and in particular to a method for evaluating an X-groove welded joint that can evaluate the occurrence of brittle fracture. [Background technology]
[0002] Steel materials with excellent fracture toughness are required for welded steel structures used in extremely low temperature environments, such as cryogenic tanks that store liquefied petroleum gas (LPG) and liquefied natural gas (LNG). As a method for evaluating the fracture safety of welded steel structures to prevent brittle fracture, the CTOD test for welded joints has been standardized as ISO15653 by the ISO, for example.
[0003] For low-temperature welded steel structures, for example, LNG tanks use 9% Ni steel plate as the base material, but from the viewpoint of fracture safety, austenitic welding materials are used for welding.
[0004] For example, Patent Document 1 proposes a welded joint and a manufacturing method thereof that can ensure fracture safety even when high heat input welding is applied to 9% Ni steel to improve the efficiency of welding. In the technology described in Patent Document 1, a welded joint is formed using an austenitic welding material, with the hardness of the weld metal being HV250 or less, and the difference between the hardness of the weld heat affected zone and the hardness of the weld metal being adjusted to a certain value or less (200HV or less). This increases the critical CTOD value, and provides high resistance to brittle fracture. On the other hand, if the difference between the hardness of the weld heat affected zone and the hardness of the weld metal is too large, the decrease in the critical CTOD value will be significant, in the sense that brittle fracture of the weld heat affected zone will be promoted. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0005] [Patent Document 1] International Publication No. WO2007 / 049367A1 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0006] The welded joint described in Patent Document 1 has a high resistance to brittle fracture. However, in dissimilar metal welded joints in which austenitic welding materials are combined with low carbon 9% Ni steel, which is a ferritic alloy steel, brittle fracture does not usually occur in joint types such as V-groove welded joints. However, in cases where the ductile crack propagation resistance of the austenitic weld metal is lower than that of the base material, brittle fracture may occur only in the case of X-groove welded joints. In general, the combination of base material and welded material is not changed for each joint shape, so in steel structures in which dissimilar metal X-groove welded joints exist in some locations, the risk of brittle fracture is high, which is a problem in terms of the safety of the structure.
[0007] Therefore, an object of the present invention is to provide a method for evaluating an X-groove welded joint, which can evaluate the risk of brittle fracture in a dissimilar metal X-groove welded joint. [Means for solving the problem]
[0008] In order to achieve the above-mentioned object, the inventors have fabricated dissimilar metal X-groove welded joints by combining ferritic alloy steel (9% Ni steel) with various austenitic welding materials, performed CTOD tests, and observed the crack propagation shape and fracture initiation point. As a result, it was newly discovered that in dissimilar metal X-groove welded joints that cause brittle fracture, a ductile crack formed at the tip of a fatigue pre-crack on the fracture surface after CTOD tests propagates more significantly in the weld metal than in the base metal.
[0009] Furthermore, it was found by stress calculation using finite element analysis that when such a ductile crack propagates farther in the weld metal than in the base metal, the stress at the tip of the ductile crack in the base metal becomes very high. It was also newly discovered that inducing such a peculiar stress state is the cause of brittle fracture in dissimilar metal X-groove welded joints.
[0010] Further investigation revealed that the length of the ductile crack formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the base metal in dissimilar metal X-groove welded joints (a BM :mm) and the length of the ductile crack formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the weld metal (a WM1 , a WM2 :mm) is expressed by the following formulas (1) to (3). a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 ≧0.2 ……(1) a WM1 / a BM ≦ 2.0 ……(2) a WM2 / a BM ≦ 2.0 ……(3) It has been found that when the above conditions are satisfied, the dissimilar metal X groove welded joint does not undergo brittle fracture.
[0011] The present invention has been completed based on these findings and further investigations. That is, the gist of the present invention is as follows. [1] A method for evaluating X-groove welded joints using austenitic welding materials for ferritic alloy steel, comprising: A CTOD test piece is taken from the X-groove welded joint, and a notch is introduced at a position where the occupancy rate of the fatigue pre-crack front edge is equal between the base metal and the weld metal, and a CTOD test is performed; The fracture surface of the test piece after the CTOD test was observed, and the ductile crack length a formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the base material was BM (mm), and the length of the ductile crack formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the weld metal a WM1 (mm), a WM2 (mm) to evaluate the brittle fracture properties of the X-groove welded joint. [2] The measured ductile crack length a BM (mm), and a WM1 (mm), a WM2 The method for evaluating an X groove welded joint according to [1], characterized in that if (mm) satisfies the following formulas (1) to (3), the X groove welded joint is evaluated to have a low risk of brittle fracture. Note a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 ≧0.2 ……(1) a WM1 / a BM ≦ 2.0 ……(2) a WM2 / a BM ≦ 2.0 ……(3) Here, a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 : Ductile crack length at each part (mm) [3] The method for evaluating an X-groove welded joint according to [1] or [2], characterized in that the CTOD test is carried out at a test temperature of -196 to 25°C. [4] The evaluation method for a dissimilar metal X groove welded joint according to [1], characterized in that the ferritic alloy steel is a 9% Ni steel. [5] The evaluation method for a dissimilar metal X groove welded joint according to [1], characterized in that the austenitic welding material is a Ni-based alloy welding material or a high Mn steel welding material. Effect of the Invention
[0012] According to the present invention, the occurrence or non-occurrence of brittle fracture in dissimilar metal X groove welded joints in steel structures in which ferritic alloy steels are welded with austenitic welding materials can be evaluated more accurately using CTOD test pieces, which is of great industrial benefit. In addition, according to the present invention, there is also an advantage that the safety of welded structures used in cryogenic environments such as LNG tanks is further improved. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0013] [Figure 1]FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram showing a schematic shape of an X groove welded joint used in the examples. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is an explanatory view (perspective view) that illustrates a schematic diagram of a pre-crack introduction position of a three-point bending test piece used in the examples. [Diagram 3] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram showing a schematic overview of a four-point bending test used in the examples. [Figure 4] FIG. 2 is an explanatory diagram showing a schematic fracture surface state of a test piece (three-point bending test piece) after a CTOD test. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0014] The present invention is directed to an X-groove welded joint (dissimilar metal X-groove welded joint) formed by butting ferritic alloy steels together with an X-groove shape and welding them using an austenitic welding material.
[0015] [Steel] An example of a ferritic alloy steel is a low-carbon low-alloy steel such as 9% Ni steel.
[0016] [Welding materials] Examples of austenitic welding materials include Ni-based alloy welding materials and high Mn steel welding materials.
[0017] [Welding method] The groove shape of the welded joint is an X groove, but the specific groove angle and the specific welding method are preferably determined appropriately depending on the welding method of the target structure (welded joint). For example, as shown in FIG. 1, the groove angles α1, α2, the root gap rg, etc. can be determined appropriately, but it is preferable that α1 and α2 are in the range of 50 to 60° and the root gap rg is in the range of 0 to 2 mm. Also, different laminations may be used on the upper side and the lower side. Incidentally, the welding method may be selected from commonly used welding methods such as TIG welding. Incidentally, TIG welding is preferable from the viewpoint of suppressing the occurrence of blowholes.
[0018] [CTOD test] From the obtained X-groove welded joint, a CTOD test piece (three-point bending test piece) is taken in accordance with the WES1109 standard. A notch is introduced into the taken CTOD test piece (three-point bending test piece) at a position where the occupancy rate of the pre-crack front edge is equal between the base metal and the weld metal. As the notch (pre-crack), a mechanical notch and further a fatigue crack are introduced so as to have a predetermined pre-crack length a0. After the mechanical notch is introduced, it is preferable to perform four-point reverse bending to remove residual stress. Here, "the occupancy rate is equal" refers to a case where the notch width of the pre-crack front edge included in the weld metal at two locations and the notch width included in the base metal are 50:50, but a range of 45:55 to 55:45 is acceptable.
[0019] In the present invention, a CTOD test is performed using a CTOD test piece (three-point bending test piece) with a pre-crack introduced. The CTOD test is performed at a prescribed temperature in accordance with the provisions of WES1109. The prescribed temperature can be, for example, the service temperature of the target actual structure or the temperature of liquid nitrogen. The CTOD test is performed until brittle fracture occurs and the test piece breaks, or, if brittle fracture does not occur, until the load exceeds the maximum load and drops by 10%.
[0020] [Fracture surface observation after CTOD test] After the CTOD test, the CTOD specimens that did not undergo brittle fracture were subjected to a fatigue load at room temperature, and after a fatigue fracture surface was formed directly below the ductile fracture surface, the specimens were broken and separated. This makes it possible to clearly identify the boundary of the ductile crack fracture surface that developed during the CTOD test.
[0021] The obtained fracture surface is observed with a scanning electron microscope or the like to identify the boundaries of the fatigue pre-crack fracture surface, ductile crack fracture surface, etc.
[0022] As shown in an example in Fig. 4, the ductile crack length a formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the base material BM from the boundary of the identified fracture surface is BM , and the length of the ductile crack formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the weld metal part WM is a WM1 , a WM2 Each is measured. BMis the minimum ductile crack length in the base material, a WM1 , a WM2 is the maximum ductile crack length (mm) in the weld metal.
[0023] [Evaluation method] In the present invention, the brittle fracture properties of the X groove welded joint are evaluated from the obtained ductile crack length of each portion.
[0024] In the present invention, the ductile crack length a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 However, the following equations (1), (2), and (3) a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 ≧0.2 ……(1) a WM1 / a BM ≦ 2.0 ……(2) a WM2 / a BM ≦ 2.0 ……(3) Here, a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 : Ductile crack length at each part (mm) If all of the above conditions are met, the X-groove welded joint is evaluated as having a low risk of brittle fracture.
[0025] In the present invention, first, whether or not stable ductile crack growth is observed is evaluated using formula (1). If formula (1) is not satisfied, that is, if the ductile crack growth does not reach 0.2 mm or more, the specimen falls outside the elastic-plastic fracture region targeted by the present invention.
[0026] In addition to satisfying formula (1), the present invention also satisfies formulas (2) and (3). When the ratio of the ductile crack length in the weld metal part WM to the base metal part BM exceeds 2.0 and becomes large, the stress at the tip of the ductile crack in the base metal part becomes very high, inducing a peculiar stress state that induces brittle fracture.
[0027] For this reason, in the present invention, when the ratio of the ductile crack length of the weld metal portion WM to the base metal portion BM is 2.0 or less, that is, when formulas (2) and (3) are satisfied, the dissimilar metal X-groove welded joint is evaluated as having a low risk of brittle fracture.
[0028] The present invention will be further described below with reference to examples. EXAMPLES
[0029] As the base material, a 9% Ni steel plate (plate thickness t: 20 mm) having the composition and mechanical properties shown in Table 1 was prepared. The prepared 9% Ni steel plates were butted together in the X groove shape shown in Figure 1, and TIG welding (shielding gas: Ar) was performed using austenitic welding materials to produce dissimilar metal X groove welded joints. The austenitic welding materials used were the two types of welding materials 70Ni and 20Mn (wire diameter: 1.2 mm) shown in Table 2. The welding conditions were as shown in Table 3. The shape of the X groove was root gap rg: 2 mm, groove angle α1: 60°, α2: 50°. The lamination was the same on the upper and lower sides.
[0030] [Table 1]
[0031] [Table 2]
[0032] [Table 3]
[0033] Three three-point bending test pieces (CTOD test pieces) were taken from each of the obtained welded joints in accordance with WES1109. The dimensions of the three-point bending test pieces were 20 (B) x 40 (W) x 184 (L) mm. A mechanical notch was introduced at a position where the occupancy rate of the pre-crack front was equal between the base metal and the weld metal. Next, four-point reverse bending was performed with a load of 78 N in order to relieve residual stress. Furthermore, a fatigue test was performed with a maximum load of 14 kN and a minimum load of 1.4 kN to introduce a fatigue pre-crack.
[0034] Using the obtained three-point bending test pieces, a CTOD test was carried out at a specified temperature of -80°C in accordance with WES1109. Note that the CTOD test was stopped when the load suddenly decreased, i.e., when the maximum load was exceeded without the occurrence of brittle fracture, and the load decreased by 10% from the maximum load.
[0035] After the CTOD test, the specimens that did not show brittle fracture were subjected to fatigue loading at room temperature, and after a fatigue fracture surface was formed directly below the ductile fracture surface, the specimens broke and separated. The fracture surfaces were then observed using a scanning electron microscope, etc., to identify the boundaries between the fatigue pre-crack fracture surface, the ductile crack fracture surface, etc.
[0036] The length of the ductile crack formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the base material BM from the boundary of the identified fracture surface is a BM (mm), and the length of the ductile crack formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the weld metal part WM, a WM1 (mm), a WM2 The results are shown in Table 4.
[0037] [Table 4]
[0038] For specimens No. 1 and No. 2, a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 are all 0.2 mm or more, satisfying formula (1). WM1 / a BM , and aWM2 / a BM was 2.0 or less, satisfying formulas (2) and (3), and test pieces No. 1 and No. 2 were evaluated as having a "low risk of brittle fracture." In fact, brittle fracture did not occur in test pieces No. 1 and No. 2.
[0039] In addition, for test pieces No. 3 to No. 5, a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 are all 0.2 mm or more and satisfy formula (1), but WM1 / a BM , and a WM2 / a BM exceeds 2.0, does not satisfy formula (2) and formula (3), and is evaluated as having a "high risk of brittle fracture." In fact, brittle fracture occurred in test pieces No. 1 to No. 3. [Explanation of symbols]
[0040] 1. Three-point bending test piece (CTOD test piece)
Claims
1. A method for evaluating an X groove welded joint using an austenitic welding material for a ferritic alloy steel, comprising: A CTOD test piece is taken from the X-groove welded joint, and a notch is introduced at a position where the occupancy rate of the fatigue pre-crack front edge is equal between the base metal and the weld metal, and a CTOD test is performed; The fracture surface of the test piece after the CTOD test was observed, and the length of the ductile crack formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the base material was determined as a BM (mm), and the length of the ductile crack formed at the tip of the fatigue pre-crack in the weld metal a WM1 (mm), a WM2 (mm) to evaluate the brittle fracture properties of the X-groove welded joint.
2. The measured ductile crack length a BM (mm), a WM1 (mm), a WM2 The method for evaluating an X-groove welded joint according to claim 1, characterized in that, when the thickness (mm) satisfies the following formulas (1) to (3), the X-groove welded joint is evaluated to have a low risk of brittle fracture. Note a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 ≧0.2 … (1) a WM1 / a BM ≦ 2.0 …… (2) a WM2 / a BM ≦ 2.0 …… (3) Here, a BM , a WM1 , a WM2 : Ductile crack length at each part (mm)
3. The method for evaluating an X-groove welded joint according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that the CTOD test is performed at a test temperature of -196 to 25°C.
4. The method for evaluating an X groove welded joint according to claim 1, characterized in that the ferritic alloy steel is a 9% Ni steel.
5. 2. The method for evaluating an X-groove welded joint according to claim 1, wherein the austenitic welding material is a Ni-based alloy welding material or a high Mn steel welding material.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Weld joint and process for producing the same
WO2007049367A1
