Evaluation program allowing reflection of margin, device and method, and selection program, device, system and method

The system evaluates devices or device sets by incorporating device and performance information with margin adjustments for condition variations, addressing inaccuracies in existing methods and ensuring suitable selections.

JP2024168952AInactive Publication Date: 2024-12-05DAIKIN INDUSTRIES LTD
View PDF 1 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
JP2023086040
Authority / Receiving Office
JP · JP
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-05-25
Publication Date
2024-12-05
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing evaluation methods for devices and device sets fail to account for fluctuations and changes in usage conditions, leading to inaccurate assessments and inappropriate selections.

Method used

A system that evaluates devices or device sets by incorporating device information, performance information, and estimated evaluation information, with a margin reflecting potential variations in conditions, using a computer to determine evaluation results and select suitable equipment.

Benefits of technology

This approach provides accurate evaluations and selections by accounting for fluctuations and changes in usage conditions, ensuring appropriate device or device set choices.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure 2024168952000001_ABST
    Figure 2024168952000001_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide an evaluation program capable of evaluating an apparatus or an apparatus set in consideration of variations or changes in preconditions for evaluation.SOLUTION: An evaluation program makes a computer function as evaluation determination means that estimates evaluation information about evaluation for an apparatus or an apparatus set, by using both obtained apparatus information about configurations, capabilities, or specifications of the apparatus or the apparatus set and obtained performance information about a performance or an experimental result of the apparatus or the apparatus set. In addition, the evaluation determination means reflects a set margin on at least one of the apparatus information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information, and determines the evaluation information as an evaluation result. It is also preferable that the evaluation program further makes the computer function as margin setting means that sets the margin for at least one of the apparatus information, the performance information, and the evaluation information.SELECTED DRAWING: Figure 1
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

[Technical field]

[0001] The present disclosure relates to techniques for rating an instrument or set of instruments. [Background technology]

[0002] Appropriate evaluation of the cost and performance of a device or a device set under certain usage conditions is very important, for example, in selecting a more suitable device or device set.

[0003] As an example of an equipment selection technique that includes such an evaluation technique, Patent Document 1 discloses a heating and cooling equipment selection support system that selects heating and cooling equipment suited to the characteristics of a room. This system calculates the amount of heat required for heating and cooling in each room based on past information on the use of heating and cooling equipment and room information related to the flow of heat in and out of each room in which a heating and cooling equipment is installed, and selects heating and cooling equipment suited to each room from multiple commercially available heating and cooling equipment based on the calculation results. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]

[0004] [Patent Document 1] JP 2017-027433 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]

[0005] When evaluating equipment or equipment sets, the usage conditions set as the premise for the evaluation often fluctuate or change in reality. For example, when evaluating an air conditioner for the whole year, it is possible that the summer will actually be cool and the outdoor temperature will fall below the set value. Also, the furniture and layout of the room in which the air conditioner is used may be changed from what was set.

[0006] As a result, the evaluation results of the equipment or equipment set may deviate from the actual cost or performance, and, for example, an inappropriate equipment or equipment set may be selected. However, the conventional technology disclosed in Patent Document 1 has not taken any measures to address such problems by considering fluctuations and changes in the conditions of use.

[0007] In view of the above, the present disclosure aims to provide an evaluation program, device, and method capable of evaluating a device or device set while taking into account fluctuations and changes in the evaluation premise, and a selection program, device, system, and method capable of selecting a device or device set using the evaluation results. [Means for solving the problem]

[0008] According to the present disclosure, making a computer function as evaluation determination means for estimating evaluation information relating to the evaluation of the equipment or equipment set, using the acquired equipment information relating to the configuration, capacity or specifications of the equipment or equipment set, and the acquired performance information relating to the performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set; The evaluation determination means determines the evaluation information as an evaluation result by reflecting the set margin in at least one of the device information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information. An evaluation program is provided.

[0009] The present disclosure also provides an evaluation determination means for estimating evaluation information relating to an evaluation of the equipment or equipment set using acquired equipment information relating to the configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set, and acquired performance information relating to the performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set, the evaluation determination means determining the evaluation information as an evaluation result by reflecting a set margin in at least one of the equipment information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information; an equipment selection means for performing a selection process using a value including evaluation information determined as an evaluation result for the equipment or equipment set, or a value including information derived using the evaluation information as an evaluation result, as a target variable for a plurality of candidate equipment information that is equipment information related to a plurality of equipment or equipment sets that are candidates for selection, and determining selected equipment information that is equipment information related to the equipment or equipment set to be selected; A selection program is provided that causes a computer to function as the selection program.

[0010] According to the present disclosure, further comprising: an evaluation determination means for estimating evaluation information relating to an evaluation of the equipment or equipment set by using acquired equipment information relating to a configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set and acquired performance information relating to a performance or experimental result of the equipment or equipment set; The evaluation determination means determines the evaluation information as an evaluation result by reflecting the set margin in at least one of the device information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information. An evaluation device is provided.

[0011] According to the present disclosure, further, an evaluation determination means for estimating evaluation information relating to an evaluation of the equipment or equipment set using acquired equipment information relating to the configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set, and acquired performance information relating to the performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set, the evaluation determination means determining the evaluation information as an evaluation result by reflecting a set margin in at least one of the equipment information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information; an equipment selection means for performing a selection process using a value including evaluation information determined as an evaluation result for the equipment or equipment set, or a value including information derived using the evaluation information as an evaluation result, as a target variable for a plurality of candidate equipment information that is equipment information related to a plurality of equipment or equipment sets that are candidates for selection, and determining selected equipment information that is equipment information related to the equipment or equipment set to be selected; A selection device or system is provided having the following:

[0012] The present disclosure also provides A step of setting a margin for at least one of equipment information related to the configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set, performance information related to the performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set, and evaluation information related to the evaluation of the equipment or equipment set; a step of estimating evaluation information using the acquired device information, or the acquired device information with a margin reflected thereon, or the acquired device information and a margin, and the acquired performance information, or the acquired performance information with a margin reflected thereon, or the acquired performance information and a margin, and determining the estimated evaluation information, or, if a margin is set in the evaluation information, the evaluation information with the margin reflected thereon as the evaluation result; A computer-implemented evaluation method is provided, comprising:

[0013] According to the present disclosure, further comprising: A step of setting a margin for at least one of equipment information related to the configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set, performance information related to the performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set, and evaluation information related to the evaluation of the equipment or equipment set; a step of estimating evaluation information using equipment information on the equipment or equipment set that is a candidate for selection, or equipment information reflecting a margin set for the equipment information on the equipment or equipment set that is a candidate for selection, or the equipment information and the margin, and performance information as an evaluation condition, or performance information reflecting a margin set for the performance information as an evaluation condition, or the performance information and the margin, and determining the estimated evaluation information, or the evaluation information reflecting the margin set for the estimated evaluation information, as the evaluation information as an evaluation result; a step of performing a selection process for a plurality of candidate device information, which is device information related to a plurality of devices or device sets that are candidates for selection, using a value including evaluation information determined as an evaluation result for the device or device set, or a value including information derived using the evaluation information as an evaluation result, as a target variable, and determining selected device information, which is device information related to the device or device set to be selected; A computer-implemented selection method is provided, comprising: [Brief description of the drawings]

[0014] [Figure 1] 1 is a functional block diagram showing a functional configuration of an evaluation device and a selection device according to an embodiment of the present disclosure. [Diagram 2] FIG. 2 is a schematic diagram for explaining an example of an air conditioning equipment set. [Diagram 3] FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram for explaining a flow of an embodiment of an evaluation method and a selection method according to the present disclosure. [Figure 4] 1A to 1C are schematic diagrams for explaining various embodiments of a margin setting process according to the present disclosure. [Diagram 5] 1A to 1C are schematic diagrams for explaining various embodiments of a margin setting process according to the present disclosure. [Figure 6] 1A to 1C are schematic diagrams for explaining various embodiments of a margin setting process according to the present disclosure. [Figure 7] 1A to 1C are schematic diagrams for explaining various embodiments of a device selection process according to the present disclosure. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS

[0015] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present disclosure will be described in detail with reference to the drawings.

[0016] [Evaluation equipment / system, selection equipment / system] FIG. 1 is a functional block diagram showing a functional configuration of an evaluation device and a selection device according to an embodiment of the present disclosure.

[0017] The server 1 shown in FIG. 1 is an embodiment of the evaluation device and selection device according to the present disclosure, and includes: (A1) an evaluation determination unit 114 that estimates “evaluation information R” relating to the evaluation of a device or device set that is an evaluation target, using “device information P” and “performance information Q” acquired for the device or device set that is an evaluation target; In addition, the evaluation determination unit 114 has (A2) The “equipment information P”, “performance information Q”, and estimated “evaluation information R” are all calculated based on the set “margin (Δ M P, Δ M Q, Δ M The evaluation information (hereinafter sometimes abbreviated as "evaluation result information") (R, R+Δ M R) is determined.

[0018] Here, "device information P" is information related to the configuration, capabilities, or specifications of the target device or device set, and in this embodiment, is stored and managed in the device information storage unit 103. Also, "performance information Q" is information related to the performance or experimental results of the target device or device set. In this embodiment, this "performance information Q" is the following measured performance data (a) and the following measured performance data (b).

[0019] (a) (Actual measurement) performance data acquired from a device information management server 3 that collects and manages actual measurement performance data (actual measurement performance information) of (existing) devices or device sets 2 installed at least at one site (in this embodiment, multiple (multiple) sites), via a communication interface unit 101 and a communication control unit 121, and stored and managed in an actual measurement performance information storage unit 102. (b) Performance data (actual measurement performance information) measured in advance for a plurality of devices or sets of devices that are candidates for the selection process described later, which is also stored and managed in the actual measurement performance information storage unit 102. The "performance information Q" may be, for example, actual equipment experiment data as the measurement results of an actual equipment in a laboratory, or simulation experiment data as the simulation results of an equipment model.

[0020] In this embodiment, the "evaluation information R" is information related to the cost or performance of the target device or device set. The estimation of this "evaluation information R" can be performed by various simulations, machine learning such as deep learning, or a combination of these, as will be described in detail later.

[0021] In this way, the server 1 calculates the margin Δ M P" or "Margin Δ M Q" or estimate "evaluation information R" with "margin Δ M R” as the evaluation result of the equipment or equipment set. M In other words, the server 1 can evaluate the device or device set taking into account fluctuations and changes in the evaluation premise.

[0022] For example, consider a case where a measured throughput (performance information) Q (related to a specific process) is obtained for a device with a capacity (device information) P. In this case, a margin Δ M Set Q and this margin Δ M The amount of processing that reflects Q (Q+Δ M For example, power consumption (evaluation information) R is estimated from the power consumption Q) and the capacity P. In addition, a margin Δ M R is set, and finally, the power consumption (R+Δ M R) can be determined.

[0023] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the server 1 (B) An equipment selection unit 115 that performs a "selection process" on multiple "candidate equipment information Pc" that is equipment information related to multiple equipment or equipment sets that are candidates for selection (hereinafter, may be abbreviated as candidate equipment / sets) and determines "selected equipment information Ps" that is equipment information related to the equipment or equipment set to be selected. Here, the "selection process" further includes "evaluation result information (R, R+Δ M R)" or "Evaluation result information (R, R+Δ M This is a process in which a value containing information derived using RBF (R) is used as the "objective variable" (the value of the function to be optimized in the selection process).

[0024] In this manner, in this embodiment, the server 1 generates “evaluation result information (R, R+Δ M R) to select the device or device set. The above selection process may be performed by a black-box optimization method such as a local search method or Bayesian optimization, which will be described in detail later.

[0025] Moreover, the evaluation determination unit 114 of (A1) and (A2) and the device selection unit 115 of (B) may be functional components of two devices that can communicate with each other. In this case, the device including the evaluation determination unit 114 is regarded as an embodiment of the evaluation device according to the present disclosure. Moreover, these two devices constitute an embodiment of the selection system according to the present disclosure. Furthermore, it is also possible to adopt an embodiment in which at least one of the candidate setting unit 111, the fluctuation estimation unit 112, and the margin setting unit 113 shown in FIG. 1, which will be described in detail later, is a functional component of a device other than the evaluation device including the evaluation determination unit 114. For example, the candidate setting server including the candidate setting unit 111, the fluctuation estimation and margin setting server including the fluctuation estimation unit 112 and the margin setting unit 113, and the evaluation server including the evaluation determination unit 114, which are all capable of communicating with each other, may be an embodiment of the evaluation system according to the present disclosure. Moreover, it is also possible to incorporate a device setting server including the device selection unit 115 to constitute an embodiment of the selection system according to the present disclosure as a whole.

[0026] Each functional component of the server 1 will be described in detail below. In the embodiment according to this description, the devices or device sets to be evaluated (e.g., candidates for selection), including the device or device set group 2 installed at multiple sites, are air conditioners or air conditioner sets (hereinafter, may be abbreviated as air conditioner sets). Here, the air conditioners are indoor units, outdoor units, ventilation devices, etc. Furthermore, they may be chillers, refrigerators, cooling towers, boilers, AHUs (Air Handling Units), FCUs (Fan Coil Units), RTUs (Roof Top Units), outdoor air conditioners, etc. Also, the air conditioner set is a combination of these devices, and when the devices are connected to each other, it also includes the connection configuration.

[0027] As an example, an air-conditioning equipment set can be a combination of two outdoor units Ea and Eb, six indoor units Ia to If, and two ventilators Va and Vb, as shown in FIG. 2. In this example, the outdoor units Ea and Eb are connected to three indoor units Ia to Ic and three indoor units Id to If by refrigerant piping Pa and Pb, respectively. The indoor units Ia and Ib are installed in a room Ra, which is a space to be air-conditioned, and perform air conditioning processing for the room Ra in conjunction with the outdoor unit Ea. The indoor units Ic and Id are installed in a room Rb, which is a space to be air-conditioned, and perform air conditioning processing for the room Rb in conjunction with the outdoor units Ea and Eb, respectively. Furthermore, the indoor units Ie and If are installed in a room Rc, which is a space to be air-conditioned, and perform air conditioning processing for the room Rc in conjunction with the outdoor unit Eb. The ventilator Va is installed for the room Ra, and performs ventilation for the room Ra. On the other hand, the ventilator Vb is installed for sharing between the rooms Rb and Rc, and ventilates the rooms Rb and Rc. The "equipment information P" of the air-conditioning equipment set in this example may include information on the connection configuration between these devices (Ea, Eb, Ia-If, Va, Vb) (for example, piping information for Pa and Pb).

[0028] In any case, in the embodiment described below, the "device information P" may be information including air conditioning capacity information such as the maximum output and maximum operating speed (maximum operating frequency) of the air conditioner or air conditioner set. It is also preferable to include configuration information such as the installation position, installation mode, and connection relationship, and specification information. Furthermore, the "performance information Q" may be information including at least one of the air conditioning load and the operating speed (operating frequency) of the air conditioner or air conditioner set, which are actual results measured on-site or measured in advance as a selection candidate. Furthermore, the "evaluation information R" may be information including at least one of the power consumption, cost, unprocessed load, actual temperature, and actual humidity of the air conditioner or air conditioner set.

[0029] Incidentally, the equipment or equipment set related to this disclosure is, of course, not limited to the air conditioning equipment or air conditioning equipment set (air conditioning equipment set) described above. For example, any equipment or equipment set whose specifications and capabilities (equipment information) can be specified as numerical values, whose processing volume (performance information) related to the intended specified processing can be measured, and whose performance and cost (evaluation information) can be expressed numerically can be used as the evaluation or selection subject of this disclosure. For example, manufacturing and production equipment (systems) for equipment, parts, devices, functional materials, etc., light control equipment (systems), Internet-related equipment (systems), etc. may be evaluation or selection subjects related to this disclosure.

[0030] [Equipment function configuration, evaluation and selection program] According to the functional block diagram of Figure 1, a server 1 as one embodiment of the evaluation device and selection device according to the present disclosure has a communication interface unit 101, an actual measurement performance information storage unit 102, an equipment information storage unit 103, an equipment operation information storage unit 104, a space operation information storage unit 105, a space configuration information storage unit 106, an environmental information storage unit 107, and a processor / memory (a calculation processing system with a memory function).

[0031] This processor memory stores an embodiment of a selection program including an embodiment of an evaluation program according to the present disclosure. The processor memory also has a computer function, and executes this selection program (evaluation program) to perform equipment selection processing (equipment evaluation processing). For this reason, the selection device (evaluation device) according to the present disclosure may be a device dedicated to equipment selection (equipment evaluation), but it may also be a cloud server, a non-cloud server, a personal computer (PC), a portable computer, or various communication terminals equipped with the selection program (evaluation program) according to the present disclosure.

[0032] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the above processor memory functions as a candidate setting unit 111, a fluctuation estimating unit 112 including a fluctuation setting unit 112a, a margin setting unit 113, an evaluation determination unit 114, an equipment selection unit 115, and a communication control unit 121. These functional components can be considered as functions realized by executing a selection program (including an evaluation program) stored in the processor memory. Incidentally, the fluctuation estimating unit 112, the margin setting unit 113, and the evaluation determination unit 114 are functional components realized by executing an evaluation program (including the selection program). In addition, the process flow shown by connecting the functional components of the server 1 in FIG. 1 with arrows can also be understood as one embodiment of the evaluation method and selection method according to the present disclosure.

[0033] <Candidate setting method> Similarly, in the functional block diagram of FIG. 1, the candidate setting unit 111 of this embodiment sets a plurality of candidate air conditioning equipment sets (hereinafter, may be abbreviated as candidate air conditioning equipment sets) from which a target air conditioning equipment set is selected. In addition, it determines candidate equipment information Pc, which is equipment information of these candidate air conditioning equipment sets. Specifically, the candidate setting unit 111 may select air conditioning equipment that is judged to have a possibility of being selected later (for example, air conditioning capacity is within a predetermined range) from a large number of air conditioning equipment (equipment information P) registered in advance in the equipment information storage unit 103, and set it as a candidate air conditioning equipment. In addition, it may configure an air conditioning equipment set that is judged to have a possibility of being selected later (for example, the air conditioning capacity of each equipment or the total of the air conditioning capacity is within a predetermined range) using an appropriate selection from a large number of air conditioning equipment and air conditioning equipment sets (equipment information P) registered in advance, and set this as a candidate air conditioning equipment set.

[0034] In either case, the candidate setting unit 111 of this embodiment sets a large number of candidate air conditioning equipment sets that have the possibility of being selected. The candidate setting unit 111 also determines candidate equipment information Pc, which is equipment information for each candidate air conditioning equipment set, and causes the equipment information storage unit 103 to store and manage information on the candidate air conditioning equipment sets linked to the candidate equipment information Pc.

[0035] <Means for estimating fluctuation> Similarly, in the functional block diagram of FIG. 1, the fluctuation estimation unit 112 of this embodiment estimates the future margin (Δ M P, Δ M Q, Δ M The “variation ΔQ” of the performance information Q that can be used to set the target value R is estimated.

[0036] Specifically, the fluctuation estimation unit 112 estimates the "fluctuation ΔQ" of the performance information Q by using "at least one" of the following (a) to (d). Here, this "at least one" means that at least one of them is information that reflects the fluctuations (ΔA, ΔB, ΔC, ΔD) or information that includes the fluctuations (ΔA, ΔB, ΔC, ΔD).

[0037] (a) "Appliance operation information A" acquired (in this embodiment, read from the apparatus operation information storage unit 104) of the air conditioning apparatus set to be evaluated, or "appliance operation information (A+ΔA)" in which "variation ΔA" is reflected in the acquired "appliance operation information A", or the acquired "appliance operation information A" and "variation ΔA" (b) "Space operation information B" acquired (in this embodiment, read from the space operation information storage unit 105) relating to a space related to the air conditioning equipment set to be evaluated, which is the air conditioned space in this embodiment, or "space operation information (B+ΔB)" in which a "variation amount ΔB" is reflected in the acquired "space operation information B", or the acquired "space operation information B" and "variation amount ΔB" (c) "Spatial configuration information C" acquired (read from the spatial configuration information storage unit 106 in this embodiment) relating to a space related to the air conditioning equipment set to be evaluated, which is the air conditioned space in this embodiment, or "spatial configuration information (C+ΔC)" in which the acquired "spatial configuration information C" is reflected with a "variation ΔC", or the acquired "spatial configuration information C" and "variation ΔC" (d) "Environment information D" acquired (in this embodiment, read from the environment information storage unit 107) relating to the environment related to the air conditioning equipment set to be evaluated, which in this embodiment relates to the environment including the outside air surrounding the air conditioned space, or "environment information (D+ΔD)" in which "variation D" is reflected in the acquired "environment information D", or the acquired "environment information D" and "variation D" In this embodiment, the "variation ΔQ" is basically estimated using all of the above (a) to (d) in order to obtain an estimated value that is more realistic.

[0038] Here, the "apparatus operation information A" in (a) above is information related to the operation, management, or settings of the air conditioning equipment set, and in this embodiment is registered in advance, stored, and managed in the equipment operation information storage unit 104. Specifically, the "apparatus operation information A" is, for example, information for each unit time (for example, each hour of each day) in a predetermined period (for example, one year), and can be at least one of the following pieces of information (a1) to (a3) ​​about the air conditioning equipment set. (a1) Operation schedule information (information on whether the air conditioning equipment / set will be started or stopped in that unit time (1 hour), in other words, information on which unit time (1 hour) in a specified period (1 year) it will be started, and information on starting / stopping pre-cooling residual heat) (a2) Environmental target setting information (information on the set temperature, set humidity, set ventilation volume, etc. for that unit time (1 hour) for the air conditioning equipment set) (a3) Maintenance information (whether or not maintenance of the air conditioning equipment / set is to be performed in that unit time (1 hour), in other words, information on which unit time (1 hour) in a specified period (1 year) the maintenance is to be performed in)

[0039] Moreover, the "space operation information B" in (b) above is information related to the operation, management, or settings of a space related to an air-conditioning device / set, which in this embodiment is information related to the operation, management, or settings of a space to be air-conditioned, and in this embodiment is registered in advance and stored / managed in the space operation information storage unit 105. Specifically, the "space operation information B" is, for example, information for each unit time (for example, each hour of each day) in a predetermined period (for example, one year), and can be at least one of the following pieces of information (b1) to (b3). (b1) Operation schedule information for the equipment (sun shading equipment, lighting equipment, heat-generating equipment, etc.) installed in the air-conditioned space (information on whether each equipment is to be operated in that unit of time (1 hour), in other words, information on which unit of time (1 hour) during a specified period (1 year) it is to be operated) (b2) Maintenance information for the equipment (sun shading equipment, lighting equipment, heat-generating equipment, etc.) installed in the air-conditioned space (information on whether or not maintenance of each equipment is to be performed in that unit time (1 hour), in other words, information on which unit time (1 hour) in a specified period (1 year) the maintenance is to be performed in) (b3) Maintenance information on the components of the air conditioned space, which in this embodiment is building components such as wall materials (information on whether or not maintenance of each building component is to be performed in that unit time (1 hour), in other words, information on which unit time (1 hour) in a specified period (1 year) maintenance is to be performed) Furthermore, the "space operation information B" may include information regarding the type, number, and level of heat generation of heat-generating objects (including humans).

[0040] The "space configuration information C" in (c) above is information related to the configuration, performance, or specifications of the space related to the air-conditioning equipment set, which is the air-conditioned space in this embodiment, and is registered in advance in the space configuration information storage unit 106 and stored and managed in this embodiment. Specifically, the "space configuration information C" can be at least one of information on the arrangement, shape, performance, and specifications of the components of the air-conditioned space, such as building materials such as wall materials, and information on the partitioning of the air-conditioned space. For example, it may also include information on the purpose or usage of a room that is the air-conditioned space. Incidentally, if the air-conditioning equipment set has multiple rooms as air-conditioned spaces, it is also preferable that the "space configuration information C" be information on all of these rooms. The "space configuration information C" can also be information for each unit time (for example, every hour of every day) in a predetermined period (for example, one year). For example, if the interior decoration or partition of the air-conditioned space may be changed within a predetermined period (one year), it is also preferable to include information on the interior decoration and partition for each unit time (for example, every hour of every day) in the predetermined period (one year).

[0041] The "environmental information D" in (d) above is information on the environment related to the air conditioning equipment set. Specifically, for example, it can be at least one of information on the outdoor air temperature, outdoor air humidity, solar radiation, wind speed, etc., around the air conditioned space for each unit time (for example, every hour of each day) in a predetermined period (for example, one year). In this case, the "environmental information D" may be acquired, for example, from the external weather information management server 4 via the communication interface unit 101 and the communication control unit 121, and stored and managed in the environmental information storage unit 107. The "environmental information D" may also include information on events (for example, the temperature in the adjacent room) that may affect the temperature and humidity of the air conditioned space in a space adjacent to the air conditioned space (for example, the adjacent room or the adjacent building).

[0042] Furthermore, the "variations (ΔA, ΔB, ΔC, ΔD)" of (a) to (d) above are set by the variation setting unit 112a of the variation estimation unit 112 in this embodiment. The variation setting unit 112a may set the "variations (ΔA, ΔB, ΔC, ΔD)" to a predetermined value, or may set the "variations (ΔA, ΔB, ΔC, ΔD)" to a value assumed or estimated by experience, calculation, or a separately performed simulation. For example, when it is desired to estimate the "variation ΔQ" under a condition in which the outdoor air temperature from 10:00 to 15:00 in summer (June to August) is higher by an average of 2°C than the outdoor air temperature (environmental information) D for one year (predetermined period) related to the actual measurement performance information Q, the "variation ΔD" for the time from 10:00 to 15:00 in summer for this one year can be set to 2 (°C). In addition, when it is desired to estimate the "fluctuation ΔQ" when air conditioning operation from 8 p.m. to 11 p.m. on weekdays in the summer is added to the one-year operation plan information (equipment operation information) A related to the actual measured performance information Q, the "fluctuation ΔA" may be taken as (the difference between the start value and the stop value) for the time period from 8 p.m. to 11 p.m. on weekdays in the summer during this one year.

[0043] (Air conditioning performance model, air conditioning performance simulation) A specific method for estimating the "fluctuation amount ΔQ" will be described below. The fluctuation estimation unit 112 (i) A trained air conditioning performance model constructed using machine learning algorithms such as neural network algorithms such as MultiLayer Perceptron (MLP), (ii) By simulating the performance of air conditioning on a constructed physical model of the space to be air-conditioned; or (iii) Combining a machine learning model related to air conditioning performance (e.g., an air conditioning performance error estimation model) with an air conditioning performance simulation, A "variation ΔQ" of performance information Q is estimated. In this embodiment, this "variation ΔQ" is the "variation ΔQ" for each unit time (for example, every hour of each day) in a predetermined period (for example, one year). Incidentally, in this embodiment, the variation ΔQ(t) at each time (date and time) t is derived using the objective variable and simulation conditions described later at that time (date and time) t.

[0044] Of these, the air conditioning performance model is a trained machine learning model. Specifically, the air conditioning performance model uses at least one of the following as explanatory variables, and in this embodiment, all of them: "equipment operation information A" and "variation ΔA" (when the variation ΔA is not set, ΔA=0), "space operation information B" and "variation ΔB" (when the variation ΔB is not set, ΔB=0), "space configuration information C" and "variation ΔC" (when the variation ΔC is not set, ΔC=0), and "environment information D" and "variation D" (when the variation ΔD is not set, ΔD=0). In addition, the "variation ΔQ" or "performance information (Q+ΔQ)" (reflecting the variation ΔQ) is used as the objective variable. Here, when the objective variable is "performance information (Q+ΔQ)," the "performance information Q" of the air conditioning equipment set to be evaluated (in this embodiment, the actual performance information of the air conditioning equipment set installed at the site or which is a selection candidate) is subtracted from the output (Q+ΔQ) of the air conditioning performance model to obtain the "fluctuation ΔQ" (estimated time series value).

[0045] In addition, as another form of air conditioning performance model, (a) A trained first air conditioning performance model is constructed using at least one of "equipment operation information A", "space operation information B", "space configuration information C", and "environment information D", and in this embodiment, all of them as explanatory variables, and using "performance information Q" as a target variable, and further, (b) A trained second air conditioning performance model is constructed using at least one of, and in this embodiment all of, "equipment operation information (A+ΔA)" (if fluctuation ΔA is not set, ΔA=0), "space operation information (B+ΔB)" (if fluctuation ΔB is not set, ΔB=0), "space configuration information (C+ΔC)" (if fluctuation ΔC is not set, ΔC=0), and "environmental information (D+ΔD)" (if fluctuation ΔD is not set, ΔD=0) as explanatory variables, and "performance information (Q+ΔQ)" as the objective variable, (c) It is also possible to obtain the “fluctuation ΔQ” (estimated time series value) by subtracting the output (Q) of the first air conditioning performance model from the output (Q+ΔQ) of the second air conditioning performance model.

[0046] In either case, the "performance information (Q + ΔQ)" of the air-conditioning equipment set being evaluated (existing or candidate for selection) can be determined as the sum of the actual measured performance information Q of the air-conditioning equipment set and this estimated value, the "fluctuation ΔQ."

[0047] Meanwhile, the air conditioning performance simulation in this embodiment is a dynamic heat load (air conditioning load) simulation, and can be implemented using known simulation software such as EnergyPLus (registered trademark). In this case, a dynamic load (air conditioning load) simulation is performed on a constructed physical model (such as a simple heat balance model or a model provided in the simulation software) for the air conditioned space, thereby obtaining "variation ΔQ" (estimated time series value). Specifically, (a) "Device operation information A", "space operation information B", "space configuration information C", and "environment information D" are used to construct a physical model or set as simulation conditions to calculate a first simulation result (Q); (b) "Equipment operation information (A+ΔA)" (if fluctuation ΔA is not set, ΔA=0), "space operation information (B+ΔB)" (if fluctuation ΔB is not set, ΔB=0), "space configuration information (C+ΔC)" (if fluctuation ΔC is not set, ΔC=0), and "environment information (D+ΔD)" (if fluctuation ΔD is not set, ΔD=0) are used to construct a physical model or set as simulation conditions to calculate a second simulation result (Q+ΔQ); (c) By subtracting the first simulation result (Q) from the second simulation result (Q+ΔQ), the “fluctuation ΔQ” (estimated time series value) can be obtained.

[0048] Furthermore, as described above, the fluctuation estimation unit 112 may estimate the "fluctuation ΔQ" of the performance information Q by using a combination of a machine learning model related to the air conditioning performance and an air conditioning performance simulation, for example, using the method disclosed in Patent Document: JP 2022-044555 A. Specifically, (a) A first simulation result (Q) from an air-conditioning performance simulation is corrected using an air-conditioning performance error estimated by an air-conditioning performance error estimation model (which has learned the error of the simulation result under the simulation conditions), and a corrected first simulation result (Q') is calculated; (b) correcting the second simulation result (Q+ΔQ) from the air-conditioning performance simulation using the air-conditioning performance error estimated by the above-mentioned air-conditioning performance error estimation model to calculate the corrected first simulation result (Q'+ΔQ'); (c) By subtracting the corrected first simulation result (Q') from the corrected second simulation result (Q'+ΔQ'), the corrected "variation ΔQ'" can be obtained. This makes it possible to suppress errors in the air-conditioning performance simulation caused by insufficient simulation conditions or deviations of the simulation conditions from reality, and to obtain a more accurate estimated value of the fluctuation in the performance information Q.

[0049] In this embodiment, as already described, the "variation ΔQ" is an estimated variation for the actual measurement performance information Q of the air-conditioning equipment set (existing or a candidate for selection) to be evaluated. Therefore, in this embodiment, the variations (ΔA, ΔB, ΔC, ΔD) can be determined, assumed, or estimated values ​​for the actual information (A, B, C, D) for this air-conditioning equipment set. For example, for the outdoor air temperature (environmental information D) = Temp (°C), 2°C can be set as the estimated temperature variation (ΔD), and the variation in the air-conditioning load reflecting the variation in the outdoor air temperature (ΔD = 2°C), in other words, the variation (ΔQ) in the amount of heat (Q) that the air-conditioning equipment set should exchange with the air, can be estimated.

[0050] In this embodiment, the fluctuations in the information (A, B, C, D, Q) are the differences (ΔA, ΔB, ΔC, ΔD, ΔQ) after the fluctuations with respect to the original values. For example, A , α B , α C , α D, α Q In this case, the fluctuation estimator 112 may take the form of "fluctuation amount α Q " Also, the information reflecting the fluctuations (A+ΔA, B+ΔB, C+ΔC, D+ΔD, Q+ΔQ) is calculated by the information (A×α A , B×α B , C×α C , D×α D , Q×α Q ) can be rewritten as follows: Q " = "Estimated performance information (Q × α Q ) / "Actual measurement information Q" is used to calculate the fluctuation amount α Q " can also be calculated.

[0051] <Margin setting method> Similarly, in the functional block diagram of FIG. 1, the margin setting unit 113 sets a margin (Δ M P, Δ M Q, Δ M R).

[0052] Specifically, the margin setting unit 113 sets the margin (Δ M P, Δ M Q, Δ M R) may be set to a predetermined value, or may be set to a value assumed or estimated based on experience, calculation, or a separately performed simulation. For example, when it is desired to obtain an evaluation result for an air conditioning device with an air conditioning capacity (device information) P, where the air conditioning capacity is 5% higher, the margin Δ M P (Δ M P can be set to 0.05×P.

[0053] In this embodiment, the margin setting unit 113 determines a margin (Δ M Q, Δ M P, ΔM R).

[0054] For example, when the fluctuation estimation unit 112 estimates a fluctuation ΔQ for an air conditioning load (performance information) Q actually measured in an air conditioning equipment set to be evaluated, the margin setting unit 113 sets a margin Δ M Q is set to, for example, 3% margin (Δ M It may be set as Q = 1.03 x ΔQ.

[0055] In addition, the margin Δ M P is set as, for example, (Δ M You can set P = P × (Q + ΔQ) / Q, for example, with a 3% margin, (Δ M P = 1.03 × P × (Q + ΔQ) / Q. The margin Δ M P can also be considered as a response to the estimated fluctuation ΔQ in the air conditioning load by changing (increasing) the air conditioning capacity P of the air conditioning equipment set (rather than changing the air conditioning load to be processed).

[0056] Furthermore, the margin Δ M Let R be, for example, (Δ M You can set R = R × (Q + ΔQ) / Q, for example, with a 3% margin, (Δ M The margin Δ can be set to R = 1.03 × R × (Q + ΔQ) / Q. M R can also be understood as a measure to deal with the estimated fluctuation in air conditioning load ΔQ by making the evaluation of the air conditioning equipment set more stringent (for example, by overestimating power consumption).

[0057] Next, a specific example (typical example) of the margin setting process will be described. In this specific example, the fluctuation estimation unit 112 estimates a fluctuation ΔQ (hereinafter, ΔQ>0) of the air conditioning load Q by taking the difference between the outdoor air temperature (environmental information) D at the peak value (maximum value) of the actually measured air conditioning load (performance information) Q and the outdoor air temperature as a statistical value at the same location and date as the fluctuation ΔD. In this case, the margin setting unit 113: (a) The negative value (multiplied by (-1)) of the increase in the operating speed of the outdoor unit (compressor) corresponding to this estimated air conditioning load fluctuation ΔQ is taken as the margin Δ M P(<0) may be used, (b) This estimated air conditioning load fluctuation ΔQ is taken as the margin Δ M It can also be Q(>0), (c) The increase in power consumption (evaluation information) R corresponding to this estimated air conditioning load fluctuation ΔQ is taken as the margin Δ M R(>0) may also be used.

[0058] The margin setting unit 113 sets the margins (Δ M P, Δ M Q, Δ M It is also preferable to set at least one, for example all, of the margins (Δ M P, Δ M Q, Δ M R), the equipment selection unit 115 determines the power consumption and unprocessed load (evaluation result information) R that have changed according to the margin Δ M When P(<0) is set, the evaluation determination unit 114 determines whether the maximum operating speed (device information) P is within the margin Δ M The power consumption and unprocessed load (evaluation result information) R are determined under stricter conditions that are lowered by P.

[0059] Furthermore, the margin setting unit 113 determines a margin (Δ M Q, Δ M P, Δ M It is also preferable to set R. (a) Information on the estimated period (e.g., the length of the period and the type of period, such as summer or winter) (a) Information on the purpose or usage of air-conditioning equipment / sets or air-conditioned spaces for the estimated period (c) Information on the accuracy of the estimation or the degree of deviation from reality

[0060] For example, the longer the estimation period in the estimation process of the fluctuation ΔQ, the larger the estimation error of ΔQ may be. M Q may be set to a value obtained by multiplying the estimated ΔQ by a "coefficient (≧1) that is a monotonically increasing function of the estimation period (the longer the estimation period, the larger it becomes)." In the subsequent equipment evaluation process, in order to absorb and compensate for such estimation errors of ΔQ in the equipment information P, the negative value (-1) of the value obtained by multiplying the estimated ΔQ by the similar "coefficient that is a monotonically increasing function of the estimation period" is set as the margin Δ M It may also be P. The reason for using a negative value here is that in the later equipment evaluation process, for example, in a situation where the air conditioning load (performance information) to be processed increases by ΔQ, the air conditioning capacity (equipment information), which is an explanatory function or a simulation condition, is reduced (the air conditioning capacity is considered to be lower).

[0061] Furthermore, in the subsequent equipment evaluation process, in order to absorb and compensate for the estimation error of ΔQ in the evaluation information R, the estimated ΔQ is multiplied by a similar "coefficient that is a monotonically increasing function of the estimation period" to obtain the margin Δ MIt may be R. The reason why the value multiplied by the "coefficient that is a monotonically increasing function of the estimation period" is used as is, rather than a negative value, is that in the later equipment evaluation process, for example, a situation in which the air conditioning load to be processed increases by ΔQ can be handled by adding to the power consumption (making the evaluation stricter).

[0062] In addition, the estimated ΔQ is multiplied by a period-type coefficient that is set individually in advance depending on whether the estimated period of ΔQ is summer (June to August), winter (December to February), or intermediate season (spring and autumn) to obtain the margin Δ M In the subsequent equipment evaluation process, in order to absorb and compensate for the influence of the type of estimated period of ΔQ in the equipment information P and evaluation information R, the value obtained by multiplying ΔQ by the same period type coefficient is set as the margin Δ M P and margin Δ M For example, if it is known or predicted that the amount of solar radiation, the insulation load of wall materials, and the loads that affect air conditioning operation, such as humidity, are significantly different between summer and winter and the estimation error in summer tends to be larger than that in winter, the period type value in summer can be set to a larger value than that in winter.

[0063] In addition, the estimated ΔQ is multiplied by a pre-set usage (use) coefficient depending on whether the space to be air-conditioned during the estimated period is a company office, a school classroom, a commercial space, or other usage (use) space to obtain a margin Δ M In the subsequent equipment evaluation process, in order to absorb and compensate for the influence of the use and usage mode on the estimated ΔQ in the equipment information P and the evaluation information R, the estimated ΔQ may be multiplied by a similar use (usage mode) coefficient to obtain a margin Δ M P and margin Δ MR may be calculated. For example, if it is known or expected that the estimation error for offices tends to be larger than that for commercial spaces, the use (use) coefficient for offices may be set to a larger value than that for commercial spaces. Incidentally, air conditioning in offices is only operated on weekdays and the time periods during which air conditioning is operated tend to vary, whereas air conditioning in commercial spaces tends to be operated at roughly the same time every day. Therefore, it is fully expected that the estimation error for offices will generally be larger.

[0064] Furthermore, a margin Δ is calculated using a reliability score calculated from the output of the air-conditioning performance model used in the estimation process or output as a function of the air-conditioning performance simulation software. M You can also set Q. Specifically, the margin Δ M Q may be set to a value obtained by multiplying the estimated ΔQ by a "coefficient (≧1) that is a monotonically decreasing function of the reliability score (the lower the reliability score, the larger it becomes)." In addition, in the subsequent equipment evaluation process, the value obtained by multiplying the estimated ΔQ by the same "coefficient that is a monotonically decreasing function of the reliability score" is set to the margin Δ M P and margin Δ M R may be used. This makes it possible to absorb and compensate for the influence of the reliability of the estimation process on the estimated ΔQ in the device information P and evaluation information R. Furthermore, instead of the reliability score, the difference between the output (Q) of the first air-conditioning performance model or the first simulation result (Q) and the actual measurement performance information Q (degree of deviation from reality) may be used.

[0065] In any case, various embodiments relating to margin setting, including those described above, will be described in detail later with reference to FIGS.

[0066] In this embodiment, the margin of the information (Q, P, R) is the difference (Δ M Q, Δ M P, Δ M R), but for example, the margin factor (α Q , α P , α R) in the form of the margin information (Q + Δ M Q, P+Δ M P, R+Δ M R) is information (Q × α Q , P×α P , R×α R ) will be rewritten as

[0067] <Method of evaluation> Also in the functional block diagram of FIG. 1, the evaluation determination unit 114 of this embodiment estimates evaluation information R using the following information (a) and the following information (b) for the air conditioning equipment set to be evaluated (existing or to be selected): (a) The acquired device information P (in this embodiment, read from the device information storage unit 103) or (the device information P plus a margin Δ M If P is set, the margin Δ M Equipment information reflecting P (P+Δ M P), or the acquired device information P and margin Δ M P (b) The acquired performance information Q (in this embodiment, the actual measurement performance information Q read from the actual measurement performance information storage unit 102) or the (actual measurement) performance information Q plus a margin Δ M If Q is set, the margin Δ M Performance information reflecting Q (Q+Δ M Q), or the acquired actual measurement information Q and margin Δ M Q The evaluation determination unit 114 also calculates the estimated evaluation information R or the evaluation information R plus a margin Δ M If R is set, the margin Δ M Evaluation information reflecting R (R+Δ M R) is the evaluation result information (R, R+Δ M R) is decided.

[0068] (Air conditioning evaluation model, air conditioning evaluation simulation) Below is the device information (P, P+Δ MP) and performance information (Q, Q+Δ M A specific method for estimating the evaluation information R using Q will be described. The evaluation determination unit 114 (i) A trained air conditioning evaluation model constructed using machine learning algorithms such as neural network algorithms, such as multi-layer perceptrons, (ii) By an air conditioning evaluation simulation for a constructed physical model of the air conditioning equipment set, or (iii) Combining a machine learning model related to air conditioning evaluation (e.g., an air conditioning evaluation error estimation model) with an air conditioning evaluation simulation, In this embodiment, the evaluation information R is estimated for each unit time (for example, every hour of each day) in a predetermined period (for example, one year). Here, in this embodiment, the evaluation information R(t) at each time (date and time) t is derived using the objective variables and simulation conditions described below at that time (date and time) t.

[0069] Of these, the air conditioning evaluation model is a trained machine learning model. Specifically, the air conditioning evaluation model is M P(Margin Δ M If P is not set, Δ M P=0), performance information Q (actual performance information Q) and margin Δ M Q(Margin Δ M If Q is not set, Δ M Q = 0) are the explanatory variables, and the evaluation information R is the objective variable. In addition, as another form of the air conditioning evaluation model, the equipment information (P + Δ M P) (Margin Δ M If P is not set, Δ M P=0) and performance information (Q+Δ M Q) (Margin Δ M If Q is not set, Δ M A trained machine learning model may be adopted in which Q=0) and R are explanatory variables and the evaluation information R is the objective variable.

[0070] On the other hand, if the air conditioning evaluation simulation uses power consumption as the evaluation information R, it is a power consumption simulation and can be performed using known simulation software such as EnergyPLus (registered trademark). In this case, the equipment information (P+Δ M P) (Margin Δ M If P is not set, Δ M P=0) and performance information (Q+Δ M Q) (Margin Δ M If Q is not set, Δ M Q=0) may be used to construct a physical model or set as a simulation condition to calculate the simulation result (R).

[0071] Furthermore, as described above, the evaluation determination unit 114 may estimate the evaluation information R using a combination of a machine learning model related to air conditioning evaluation and an air conditioning evaluation simulation, for example, using the method disclosed in Patent Document: JP 2022-044555 A. Specifically, the result (R) of the air conditioning evaluation simulation may be corrected using an air conditioning evaluation error estimated by an air conditioning evaluation error estimation model (which has learned the error of the result under the simulation conditions), and the corrected result (R') may be calculated as the estimated result of the evaluation information R. This makes it possible to suppress errors in the air conditioning evaluation simulation caused by insufficient simulation conditions or deviation of the simulation conditions from reality, and to obtain a more accurate evaluation information estimate value.

[0072] <Equipment selection method> Also in the functional block diagram of FIG. 1, the equipment selection unit 115 of this embodiment performs a "selection process" on "multiple candidate equipment information Pc" and determines selected equipment information Ps, which is equipment information P related to the air conditioner or air conditioner set to be selected (hereinafter, may be abbreviated as selected air conditioner set). Here, the "multiple candidate equipment information Pc" is equipment information related to the candidate air conditioner set set by the candidate setting unit 111. In addition, the "selection process" performs a selection process on the evaluation result information (R, R+Δ MR) or evaluation result information (R, R+Δ M This is a process in which a value containing information derived using R is used as the "objective variable" (the value of the function to be optimized in the selection process).

[0073] Specifically, in this embodiment, the device selection unit 115: (a) The total cost of the candidate air conditioning equipment and set, (b) Constraint condition values ​​related to PMV (Predicted Mean Vote), which is an index related to the environment of the candidate air-conditioning equipment and set, and (c) Constraint value for the unprocessed load in the candidate air-conditioning equipment set and The sum of these, which in this embodiment is a predetermined weighted sum, is taken as the "objective variable". Next, the equipment selection unit 115 determines the candidate equipment information Pc that is judged to minimize this "objective variable" as the selected equipment information Ps by a local search method, which is a typical black box optimization method, or Bayesian optimization. Note that in this embodiment, the "objective variable" set for each candidate air conditioning equipment set is linked to the candidate equipment information Pc of the candidate air conditioning equipment set, and is stored and managed in the equipment information storage unit 103.

[0074] Here, the total cost of the candidate air conditioning equipment set in (a) above can be calculated as the sum of (a1) the cost of electricity consumed by the operation of the candidate air conditioning equipment set, (a2) the introduction cost of the equipment to be installed in the air conditioned space, (a3) ​​the maintenance cost of the equipment to be installed in the air conditioned space, (a4) the introduction cost of the building materials as components of the air conditioned space, and (a5) the maintenance cost of the building materials as components of the air conditioned space. The smaller this total cost is, the smaller the "objective variable" is.

[0075] Among these, the price of the electricity in (a1) is calculated based on the evaluation result information (R, R+Δ MR) and an electricity rate table obtained from an electric power company. The introduction cost of the facility equipment in (a2) and the introduction cost of the building material in (a4) are linked in advance to space configuration information C related to the candidate air-conditioning equipment set, and are information stored and managed in the space configuration information storage unit 106. The maintenance cost of the facility equipment in (a3) ​​and the maintenance cost of the building material in (a4) are linked in advance to space operation information B related to the candidate air-conditioning equipment set, and are information stored and managed in the space operation information storage unit 105.

[0076] The PMV in (b) above is a thermal comfort index that indicates how comfortable a person feels, and is an index of the ISO international standard. Specifically, the PMV is: (b1) A set temperature and a set humidity that are linked in advance to the equipment operation information A related to the candidate air-conditioning equipment set and stored and managed in the equipment operation information storage unit 104, (b2) The radiation amount, wind speed, activity amount, and clothing amount that are linked in advance (as assumed values ​​or hypothetical values) to the space operation information B (or environmental information D) related to the candidate air-conditioning equipment set and stored and managed in the space operation information storage unit 105 (or the environmental information storage unit 107) The constraint value for the PMV is set to a larger value the more the PMV deviates from the predetermined optimum range. Therefore, the more the PMV deviates from the predetermined optimum range, the larger the "objective variable" becomes.

[0077] Furthermore, the unprocessed load in (c) above is calculated based on the evaluation result information (R, R+Δ M R). The constraint condition value related to this unprocessed load is set to a smaller value as the unprocessed load becomes smaller than a predetermined reference value. Therefore, the smaller the unprocessed load becomes compared to the predetermined reference value, the smaller the "objective variable" becomes.

[0078] When the "objective variable" is set using the above-described (a) to (c), the equipment selection unit 115 can determine a selected air conditioning equipment set (selected equipment information Ps) that keeps the total cost as low as possible while satisfying constraint conditions such as PMV and unprocessed load as much as possible. However, the "objective variable" is of course not limited to this, and can also be set to, for example, only the power consumption of the candidate air conditioning equipment set, only the constraint condition value related to the unprocessed load, the constraint condition value related to the power consumption and PMV, the constraint condition value related to the power consumption and unprocessed load, or the constraint condition value related to the unprocessed load and the constraint condition value related to the PMV.

[0079] (Local Search Method) Hereinafter, an embodiment of the device selection process using the local search method will be described. In this embodiment, the local search method is used to find the minimum value of an objective function that is a function of the candidate device information Pc and takes the value of the "objective variable" linked to the candidate device information Pc. Next, the candidate device information Pc related to this minimum value (a value judged to be the minimum value) is set as the selected device information Ps. In other words, a process is performed to find the minimum value of an unknown objective function in a coordinate space spanned by the axis of the candidate device information Pc and the axis of the "objective variable". Note that the closer the candidate device information Pc is to each other, the more "near" they are arranged on the axis of the candidate device information Pc.

[0080] Specifically, first, one candidate device information Pc is randomly selected as the first initialization, and the coordinate point (within the above coordinate space) corresponding to the "objective variable" value associated with this candidate device information Pc is set as the "original coordinate point." Next, a search is performed for candidate device information Pc that is 'nearby' enough to satisfy a predetermined condition with respect to the candidate device information Pc associated with this original coordinate point. Here, if the "objective variable" value associated with the candidate device information Pc found by this neighborhood search is smaller than the "objective variable" value associated with the original coordinate point, the coordinate point corresponding to this newly found candidate device information Pc is set as the "new coordinate point." On the other hand, if the "objective variable" value is equal to or greater than the "objective variable" value associated with the original coordinate point, the original coordinate point is set as the new coordinate point as it is.

[0081] Furthermore, the new coordinate point obtained as described above is set as the next original coordinate point, and a neighborhood search process for determining a new coordinate point from this set original coordinate point is repeated until the new coordinate point is the same as the original coordinate point, with a predetermined number of neighborhood searches T1 as the upper limit. The new coordinate point finally obtained here (which is the same as the original coordinate point) is set as coordinate point P(1).

[0082] Next, the process of determining new coordinate points as described above (including this first process) is repeated a predetermined number of initialization times T2 to determine T2 coordinate points P(1) to P(T2). Finally, among these coordinate points P(1) to P(T2), the coordinate point P(N) with the smallest corresponding "objective variable" value is determined, and the candidate device information Pc related to this coordinate point P(N) is set as the selected device information Ps. In other words, the candidate air conditioner set related to the candidate device information Pc related to this coordinate point P(N) is determined as the selected air conditioner set.

[0083] (Bayesian Optimization) Next, an embodiment of the device selection process using Bayesian optimization will be described. In this embodiment, an objective function that is a function of the candidate device information Pc and takes the value of the "objective variable" linked to the candidate device information Pc is estimated by Bayesian optimization. Next, the minimum value of the estimated objective function is set as the selected device information Ps. In other words, in the coordinate space spanned by the axis of the candidate device information Pc and the axis of the "objective variable", an unknown objective function (graph) is estimated and a process of determining its minimum value is performed. As described above, the closer the candidate device information Pc is to each other, the more "near" they are arranged on the axis of the candidate device information Pc.

[0084] Specifically, first, in the first search process, multiple candidate device information Pc are randomly selected, and multiple coordinate points (in the above coordinate space) corresponding to the "objective variable" values ​​linked to these candidate device information Pc are set as "reference coordinate points". Next, based on these reference coordinate points, the expected value of the objective function (the expected value curve in the coordinate space representing it) and the standard deviation of the objective function (the standard deviation contour line in the coordinate space representing it) are estimated using a Gaussian process (which estimates the probability of the existence of other data between two data). Next, from the estimated expected value and standard deviation, the coordinate point that is most likely to minimize the "objective variable" value is determined, and this is set as the new reference coordinate point.

[0085] Next, as described above, the process of determining a new reference coordinate point using the already obtained reference coordinate point is repeated a predetermined number of searches S (including this first process), and a new reference coordinate point is determined each time. Incidentally, the process is repeated to bring a function composed of estimated expected values ​​closer to the true (target) objective function. Finally, the reference coordinate point with the smallest corresponding "objective variable" value among all the determined reference coordinate points is determined, and the candidate device information Pc related to this reference coordinate point is set as the selected device information Ps. In other words, the candidate air-conditioning equipment set related to the candidate device information Pc related to this reference coordinate point is determined as the selected air-conditioning equipment set.

[0086] The above describes the equipment selection process using the local search method and Bayesian optimization. However, it is natural that the local search method or Bayesian optimization using a procedure different from the above may be used in this equipment selection process, and other black box optimization methods may also be used. Incidentally, the local search method generally requires more searches to reach the optimal solution (selected equipment information Ps) than Bayesian optimization, but the calculation cost for each search can be kept lower. Therefore, for example, when a sufficient number of evaluation information R of the selected air-conditioning equipment set is determined within a predetermined calculation cost in the evaluation determination unit 114, it is also preferable that the equipment selection unit 115 performs the equipment selection process using the local search method in order to reduce the total calculation cost.

[0087] The following describes the margin (Δ M Q, Δ M P, Δ M R) handling and significance will be explained. For example, (a) Margin ΔQ from the fluctuation ΔQ of actual measured data (e.g., measured air conditioning load) Q estimated by taking into account the fluctuation ΔD of environmental data (e.g., outdoor temperature) D M Determine Q (e.g., Δ M Q = ΔQ) (b) This margin Δ M Performance information reflecting Q (Q+Δ M Q), determine evaluation result information (e.g., power consumption) R corresponding to each candidate device information Pc, and further (c) determining selected device information Ps from multiple candidate device information Pc using a value including this evaluation result information R as a target variable; In this case, as one example, it is possible to set an appropriate margin for the air conditioning load (cooling load) to be processed, anticipating a situation in which the outside air temperature will be higher by a certain amount (compared to the environment in which the air conditioning load is actually measured). This makes it possible to select an air conditioning equipment set that is suitable for anticipating an increase in the outside air temperature, taking into account the estimated power consumption when processing the air conditioning load including this margin for each candidate air conditioning equipment set.

[0088] For example, (a) Estimate evaluation information (e.g., power consumption) R corresponding to each candidate device information Pc under the acquired actual measurement performance information Q (e.g., actual measured air conditioning load), (b) A margin (e.g., a margin for power consumption) Δ M Evaluation result information reflecting R (R+Δ M R) is determined, and further, (c) This evaluation result information (R+Δ M R) is used as the objective variable to determine the selected device information Ps from multiple candidate device information Pc. In this case, as one example, it is possible to anticipate a situation in which the power consumption of each candidate air conditioning equipment set will be a certain amount higher than the estimated power consumption (under conditions in which the air conditioning load to be processed is the actual measured air conditioning load), and to select an air conditioning equipment set that has the capacity to handle this increased power consumption.

[0089] For example, (a) For each candidate device information (e.g., maximum output) Pc, a set margin (e.g., reduction in maximum output: negative margin) Δ M Candidate device information reflecting P (Pc+Δ M P) is determined, (b) Each candidate device information (Pc+Δ M P), and further, determine evaluation result information (e.g., power consumption) R corresponding to the (c) Using the evaluation result information R as a target variable, the selected device information Ps is determined from the multiple candidate device information Pc. In this case, which is just one example, it is possible to anticipate a situation in which the maximum output of each candidate air conditioning equipment set will decrease by a certain amount due to, for example, aging deterioration of the equipment, and to select an air conditioning equipment set that is still deemed suitable even after anticipating a decrease in maximum output in the future.

[0090] Furthermore, for example, (a) For each candidate equipment information (e.g., maximum output) Pc, a set margin (e.g., improvement in maximum output in a higher grade (standard) air conditioning equipment set) Δ M Candidate device information reflecting P (Pc+Δ M P) is determined, (b) Each candidate device information (Pc+Δ M P), and further, determine evaluation result information (e.g., power consumption) R corresponding to the (c) Using this evaluation result information R as the objective variable, multiple candidate device information (Pc + Δ M From P, the selected equipment information (Ps+Δ M Determine P In this case, it is possible to select an air conditioning equipment set with a higher grade (standard) than the air conditioning equipment set that would have been selected originally, in order to realize a more generous air conditioning operation. M P is the device information (P+Δ M P) (for example, a higher-end model) candidate air-conditioning equipment set will be present.

[0091] Similarly, in the functional block diagram of FIG. 1, selected equipment information Ps, which is equipment information P of the selected air conditioning equipment set selected by the equipment selection unit 115, may be transmitted to the terminal 5 that is the source of the equipment selection request, for example, via the communication control unit 121 and the communication interface unit 101. In addition, evaluation result information (R, R+Δ M R) may also be transmitted to the terminal 5 that is the source of the device evaluation request, for example, via the communication control unit 121 and the communication interface unit 101.

[0092] Furthermore, the terminal 5 may include actual measurement performance information Q, which is a condition for equipment evaluation processing, in the equipment selection request or equipment evaluation request transmitted to the server 1. Also, the terminal 5 may include equipment operation information A, space operation information B, space configuration information C, and environment information D corresponding to the actual measurement performance information Q, which are conditions for estimating the fluctuation amount ΔQ for margin setting. In this case, the server 1 can use these pieces of information included in the received equipment selection request or equipment evaluation request to perform equipment selection processing or equipment evaluation processing in accordance with the requested content.

[0093] [Evaluation and selection method] Fig. 3 is a schematic diagram for explaining a flow in one embodiment of the evaluation method and selection method according to the present disclosure. Each step of the flow in this embodiment will be briefly explained below with reference to Fig. 3. Incidentally, the selection method of this embodiment is made up of the steps below as a whole, and the evaluation method of this embodiment is made up of steps S201 to S203. In addition, the contents of each step below are merely contents in one embodiment, and do not limit the contents of the evaluation method and selection method according to the present disclosure.

[0094] (Step S1) The equipment selection unit 115 takes in (the candidate equipment information of) a plurality of candidate air conditioning equipment sets. (Step S2) The equipment selection unit 115 requests the equipment evaluation unit (the fluctuation estimation unit 112, the margin setting unit 113, and the evaluation determination unit 114) to perform equipment evaluation processing for each candidate air conditioning equipment set (the candidate equipment information Pc of each candidate air conditioning equipment set) (outputs an evaluation request). After that, the equipment evaluation unit transmits evaluation result information (e.g., power consumption) (R, R+Δ M Receive R).

[0095] (Step S3) The equipment selection unit 115 performs equipment selection processing for the candidate air conditioning equipment set by a local search method, using a value including information (e.g., total cost) derived using the received evaluation result information (e.g., power consumption) as the objective variable, and determines a selected air conditioning equipment set (selected equipment information Ps).

[0096] (Step S201) The fluctuation estimation unit 112 uses equipment operation information A, space operation information B, space configuration information C, and environmental information D related to the candidate air conditioning equipment set for the received evaluation request, as well as the set fluctuations (ΔA, ΔB, ΔC, ΔD), to estimate a fluctuation ΔQ (for example, of the air conditioning load) using a trained multilayer perceptron. (Step S202) The margin setting unit 113 determines a margin (Δ M Q, Δ M P, ΔM R) is determined and set.

[0097] (Step S203) The evaluation determination unit 114 receives the actual measurement performance information Q and the equipment information P (candidate equipment information Pc) related to the candidate air conditioning equipment set for the received evaluation request, and further receives the set margin (Δ M Q, Δ M P, Δ M The evaluation determination unit 114 further estimates evaluation result information (e.g., power consumption) (R, R+Δ M R) and the determined evaluation result information (e.g., power consumption) (R, R+Δ M R) to the equipment selection unit 115 as a response to the evaluation request.

[0098] [Various embodiments relating to margin setting processing] 4, 5, and 6 are schematic diagrams for explaining various embodiments of the margin setting process according to the present disclosure.

[0099] 4, the fluctuation ΔQ estimated by the fluctuation estimation unit 112 is time-series information for each unit time (for example, every hour of each day) in a predetermined period (for example, one year), and is a function of time (date and time) t. (a) Time series information obtained by multiplying this fluctuation ΔQ(t) by a constant coefficient Ccon, (b) Time series information obtained by multiplying this fluctuation ΔQ(t) by a coefficient c(t), which is a function of time (date and time) t, or (c) Time series information obtained by converting this fluctuation ΔQ(t) using a predetermined conversion formula F(t) The margin (Δ M Q(t), Δ M P(t), Δ M R(t)).

[0100] Specifically, the margin setting unit 113 determines (a) a coefficient Ccon, (b) a coefficient c(t), or (c) a conversion formula F(t) based on at least one of the following (a) to (c) in the estimation process of the fluctuation estimating unit 112 for the fluctuation Q(t), and sets the margin (Δ M Q(t), Δ M P(t), Δ M R(t)) may be set. (a) Information on the estimated period (e.g., the length of the period and the type of period, such as summer or winter) (a) Information on the purpose or usage of air-conditioning equipment / sets or air-conditioned spaces for the estimated period (c) Information on the accuracy of the estimation or the degree of deviation from reality

[0101] For example, the margin setting unit 113 may determine a larger (absolute value) coefficient Ccon or coefficient c(t) to ensure a margin for the estimation error, which may become larger as the estimation period in the estimation process of the fluctuation ΔQ(t) becomes longer. Also, the margin setting unit 113 may determine a conversion formula F(t) that increases the (absolute value of) the converted ΔQ(t) value. Furthermore, the coefficient Ccon, coefficient c(t) and conversion formula F(t) that are individually set in advance may be adopted depending on whether the space to be air-conditioned in the estimation period is a company office, a school classroom, a commercial space, or a space for other purposes (modes of use).

[0102] Also, the lower the reliability score obtained from the air-conditioning performance model or air-conditioning performance simulation software used in the estimation process, the larger (absolute value) the coefficient Ccon or coefficient c(t) may be determined to ensure a margin for the estimated error that is deemed to be larger. Furthermore, a conversion formula F(t) that increases the (absolute value of) ΔQ(t) value after conversion may be determined. Also, instead of the reliability score, it is possible to use the difference between the output (Q) of the first air-conditioning performance model or the first simulation result (Q) and the actually measured performance information Q (degree of deviation from reality).

[0103] Furthermore, the margin setting unit 113 determines (a) a coefficient Ccon, (b) a coefficient c(t), or (c) a conversion formula F(t) based on the magnitude of the fluctuation (ΔA(t), ΔB(t), ΔC(t), ΔD(t)) related to at least one of the device operation information A, the space operation information B, the space configuration information C, and the environment information D, and sets a margin (Δ M Q(t), Δ M P(t), Δ M For example, the margin setting unit 113 may determine a coefficient Ccon or a coefficient c(t) having a larger (absolute value) in order to secure a larger margin (for compensating for an estimation error that may become larger) as the fluctuations (ΔA(t), ΔB(t), ΔC(t), ΔD(t)) become larger, or may determine a conversion formula F(t) that increases the (absolute value of) ΔQ(t) value after conversion as the fluctuations (ΔA(t), ΔB(t), ΔC(t), ΔD(t)) become larger.

[0104] As a specific example, consider the case of estimating the fluctuation ΔQ(t) under the condition that the outdoor air temperature in summer (June to August) is higher by ΔD(t) (°C) on average than the outdoor air temperature (environmental information) D(t) for one year (predetermined period) related to the actual measurement result information Q. In this case, since it is expected that the estimation error will increase as ΔD(t) (°C) is set to a larger value, it is possible to determine a larger (absolute) coefficient Ccon or coefficient c(t) in order to secure a larger margin (for compensating for the estimation error in the later equipment evaluation). It is also preferable to determine a conversion formula F(t) that increases the converted value (absolute value) as ΔD(t) (°C) is set to a larger value.

[0105] Furthermore, for example, consider a case where the operation of equipment (space operation information B) in one building, which is an air-conditioned space, is expected to fluctuate significantly. In this case, a larger coefficient Ccon or coefficient c(t) (in absolute value) may be determined from the set larger fluctuation ΔB(t). It is also preferable to determine a conversion formula F(t) that increases the converted value (absolute value). In this way, a larger margin Δ M It is also possible to set R(t).

[0106] The margin setting unit 113 determines the margin (ΔA(t), ΔB(t), ΔC(t), ΔD(t)) based on at least one of the above-mentioned (A) information on the estimated period, (B) information on the application or usage mode, and (C) information on the accuracy of the estimation or the degree of deviation from the reality, and on the magnitude of the above-mentioned fluctuations (ΔA(t), ΔB(t), ΔC(t), ΔD(t)). M Q(t), Δ M P(t), Δ M It is also preferable to determine the coefficient Ccon, the coefficient c(t) and the conversion formula F(t) in another simple embodiment. It is also possible to make the coefficient Ccon, the coefficient c(t) and the conversion formula F(t) predetermined (for example, appropriately set based on experience). In this case, the margin (Δ M Q(t), Δ M P(t), Δ M R(t)) is determined based only on the fluctuation ΔQ(t).

[0107] Next, another embodiment of the margin setting process will be described with reference to Fig. 5. In this embodiment, the change over time Dp (actual value, set value, expected value or estimated value) of equipment information (e.g., air conditioning capacity) P of the air conditioning equipment set to be evaluated over a predetermined period (e.g., 5 years) is obtained. In addition, the change over time Dq (actual value, set value, expected value or estimated value) of performance information (e.g., air conditioning load) Q of the air conditioning equipment set to be evaluated over a predetermined period (e.g., 5 years) is obtained.

[0108] The margin setting unit 113 of the present embodiment determines a margin (Δ M Q(t), Δ M P(t), Δ M For example, when a change in the air conditioning load (performance information) Q(t) over time Dq (in the direction in which the air conditioning load decreases) is obtained, the larger this change in the air conditioning load Dq is, the larger the margin Δ (of the air conditioning load to be processed) that can absorb this change in the equipment evaluation later is set. M It is also preferable to determine Q(t). In addition, assuming that the time-dependent change in the air conditioning load Dq will be covered by increasing the capacity of the air conditioning equipment / set, a larger margin (in air conditioning capacity) Δ M It is also possible to determine P(t).

[0109] In addition, the margin setting unit 113 sets the (A) estimated period T ESTI (b) information on the intended use or usage, and (c) information on the likelihood of the estimate or the degree of deviation from reality, as well as the magnitude of the fluctuations (ΔA(t), ΔB(t), ΔC(t), ΔD(t)). M Q(t), Δ M P(t), Δ M R(t) may be determined.

[0110] Next, a typical margin setting process for an air-conditioning equipment set, including the margin setting described above, will be described with reference to FIG. 6. In the typical example shown in FIG. 6, (a) the fluctuation estimating unit 112 estimates a fluctuation ΔQ(t) using a fluctuation ΔD(t) set for at least the outside air temperature (environmental information) D(t) related to the air-conditioning equipment set to be evaluated. (b) Next, the margin setting unit 113 sets a margin ΔQ(t) for the performance information Q(t) based on the estimated fluctuation ΔQ(t). M(c) Furthermore, the margin setting unit 113 sets a margin Δ M Set P(t).

[0111] This makes it possible to estimate the fluctuation ΔQ(t) under conditions where the outdoor air temperature in summer (June to August) is higher by ΔD(t) (℃) on average than the outdoor air temperature D(t) for one year related to the actual measurement information Q. This also makes it possible to estimate a more suitable air conditioning load margin Δ M In addition, it is possible to set a more suitable maximum output margin Δ M It is also possible to set P(t).

[0112] [Various embodiments relating to device selection processing] FIG. 7 is a schematic diagram for explaining various embodiments of the device selection process according to the present disclosure.

[0113] 7, the device selection unit 115 performs an "device selection process" that determines selected device information Ps from multiple candidate device information Pc using the set "constraint condition." Here, as described above, in this embodiment, the "device selection process" and the "constraint condition" are "selection process using a local search method or Bayesian optimization" and "at least one of the constraint condition value related to the PMV (which constitutes the objective variable together with the total cost) and the constraint condition value related to the unprocessed load," respectively.

[0114] In this embodiment, the device selection unit 115 (a) The set margin (Δ M Q(t), Δ M P(t), Δ M R(t)), and (b) Information on the accuracy of the estimation in the estimation process of the evaluation information R in the evaluation determination unit 114 or the degree of deviation from reality Then, the device selection unit 115 sets "at least one of the constraint condition value related to the PMV and the constraint condition value related to the unprocessed load" which is a constraint condition that reflects at least one of the constraint condition values. Next, the device selection unit 115 performs a selection process by a local search method or Bayesian optimization using such "constraint condition value" (constraint condition).

[0115] As an example of such equipment selection processing, the air conditioning load margin Δ M Consider the case where Q is set. In this case, this air conditioning load margin Δ M The larger Q(t) is, the larger the constraint condition value related to PMV and the constraint condition value related to the unprocessed load can be set (the constraint conditions can be made stricter). This makes it possible to select an air conditioning equipment set that has the capacity to process the expected increased air conditioning load.

[0116] Also, for example, the lower the reliability score obtained from the air conditioning evaluation model or air conditioning evaluation simulation software used in estimating power consumption (evaluation information) R, the higher the constraint condition value related to PMV and the constraint condition value related to unprocessed load can be set (the constraint conditions can be made stricter). This makes it possible to select an air conditioning equipment set that has a margin that can compensate for the possibility that the actual total cost (including power consumption) may be higher.

[0117] Furthermore, in this embodiment, the device selection unit 115 performs the following with respect to the candidate device information Pc selected by the device selection process using the local search method or Bayesian optimization: (a) The set margin (Δ M Q(t), Δ M P(t), Δ M R(t)), and (b) Information on the accuracy of the estimation in the estimation process of the evaluation information R in the evaluation determination unit 114 or the degree of deviation from reality The selected device information Ps may be determined to be information reflecting at least one of the above.

[0118] As an example of such equipment selection processing, the air conditioning load margin Δ M Consider the case where Q is set. In this case, this air conditioning load margin Δ M The larger Q(t) is, the greater the air conditioning capacity Pc of the selected candidate air conditioning equipment set can be compared to reselect a candidate air conditioning equipment set with a larger air conditioning capacity, and the reselected candidate air conditioning equipment set's air conditioning capacity Pc can be determined as the selected equipment information Ps. This makes it possible to finally select an air conditioning equipment set with a margin capable of handling the expected increased air conditioning load.

[0119] Also, for example, the lower the reliability score, the greater the air conditioning capacity Pc of the selected candidate air conditioning equipment set may be selected again, and the air conditioning capacity Pc of the reselected candidate air conditioning equipment set may be determined as the selected equipment information Ps. This makes it possible to finally select an air conditioning equipment set that has a margin capable of compensating for the possibility that the actual power consumption may exceed the estimated value, resulting in a higher total cost.

[0120] As described above in detail, according to the present disclosure, a margin is reflected in the device information P of a device or a device set, and a margin Δ is reflected in the performance information Q. M In other words, the evaluation result information can be determined as the evaluation result of the equipment or equipment set, taking into consideration fluctuations and changes in the evaluation premise, for example, by reflecting Q or a margin in the estimated evaluation information R. In addition, using this evaluation result information, it becomes possible to select an equipment or equipment set from multiple candidates.

[0121] Furthermore, for example, when one embodiment of the present disclosure is appropriately implemented, it is possible to collect operating history data of an equipment set installed at the delivery destination, and use this operating history data to make appropriate and effective proposals for updating or improving the equipment set, taking into account future environmental changes (e.g., global warming), changes in installation conditions, changes in operation, etc.

[0122] It should be noted that all of the above-described embodiments are illustrative of the present disclosure and are not limiting, and the present disclosure can be implemented in various other modified and altered forms. Therefore, the scope of the present disclosure is defined only by the claims and their equivalents. [Explanation of symbols]

[0123] 1 Server (evaluation device, selection device) 101 Communication interface section 102 Actual measurement information storage unit 103 Device information storage section 104 Equipment operation information storage unit 105 Spatial Operation Information Storage Department 106 Spatial configuration information storage section 107 Environmental Information Preservation Department 111 Candidate Setting Section 112 Fluctuation Estimation Unit 112a Fluctuation portion setting section 113 Margin setting section 114 Evaluation and Decision Department 115 Equipment Selection Department 121 Communication control section 2. Equipment and Equipment Sets 3. Device information management server 4. Weather information management server 5. Terminal Ea, Eb outdoor unit Ia, Ib, Ic, Id, Ie, If Indoor unit Pa, Pb refrigerant piping Ra, Rb Room (air-conditioned space) Va, Vb Ventilation Equipment

Claims

1. making a computer function as evaluation determination means for estimating evaluation information relating to the evaluation of the equipment or equipment set, using the acquired equipment information relating to the configuration, capacity or specifications of the equipment or equipment set, and the acquired performance information relating to the performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set; the evaluation determination means determines evaluation information as an evaluation result by reflecting a set margin in at least one of the device information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information; Evaluation program.

2. causing the computer to further function as a margin setting means for setting the margin for at least one of the device information, the performance information, and the evaluation information; the evaluation determination means estimates the evaluation information using the acquired device information, or the acquired device information with the margin reflected thereon, or the acquired device information and the margin, and the acquired performance information, or the acquired performance information with the margin reflected thereon, or the acquired performance information and the margin, and determines the estimated evaluation information, or, if the margin is set in the evaluation information, the evaluation information with the margin reflected in the estimated evaluation information, as the evaluation information as the evaluation result; The evaluation program according to claim 1 .

3. Acquired equipment operation information relating to the operation, operation or setting of the equipment or equipment set, or equipment operation information reflecting a set, expected or estimated fluctuation in the acquired equipment operation information, or the acquired equipment operation information and said fluctuation, and acquired space operation information relating to the operation, operation or setting of a space related to the equipment or equipment set, or acquired space operation information reflecting a set, expected or estimated fluctuation in the acquired space operation information, or acquired space operation information and said fluctuation, and acquired space configuration information relating to the configuration, performance or specifications of the space, or acquired making the computer further function as a variation estimation means for estimating a variation in the performance information using at least one of: space configuration information in which a set, expected or estimated variation is reflected in the space configuration information, or the acquired space configuration information and the variation; and acquired environmental information relating to an environment related to the device or device set, or environmental information in which a set, expected or estimated variation is reflected in the acquired environmental information, or the acquired environmental information and the variation, at least one of which is information reflecting the variation or information including the variation; the margin setting means sets the margin for at least one of the performance information, the device information, and the evaluation information based on the estimated fluctuation of the performance information. The evaluation program according to claim 2 .

4. 4. The evaluation program according to claim 3, wherein the margin setting means sets the margin for at least one of the performance information, the equipment information, and the evaluation information based on at least one of information relating to a period in an estimation process of a fluctuation in the performance information, information relating to the purpose or usage manner of the equipment or equipment set or the space relating to the period, and information relating to the accuracy of the estimation in the estimation process or the degree of deviation from reality.

5. 4. The evaluation program according to claim 3, wherein the margin setting means sets, as the margin for at least one of the performance information, the device information, and the evaluation information, time series information obtained by multiplying a fluctuation in the estimated performance information, which is time series information, by a fixed coefficient or a coefficient that is a function of time related to the time series, or time series information obtained by performing a conversion process using a predetermined conversion formula.

6. The evaluation program according to any one of claims 2 to 5, wherein the margin setting means sets the margin for at least one of the performance information, the equipment information, and the evaluation information based on the magnitude of the fluctuation relating to at least one of the equipment operation information, the space operation information, the space configuration information, and the environmental information.

7. 6. The evaluation program according to claim 2, wherein the margin setting means sets the margin for at least one of the performance information, the device information, and the evaluation information based on a change over time in at least one of the device information and the performance information.

8. 6. The evaluation program according to claim 1, wherein the equipment or equipment set is an air conditioning equipment or an air conditioning equipment set, the equipment information includes capacity information relating to the air conditioning equipment or air conditioning equipment set, the performance information includes at least one of air conditioning load information, operating frequency information, and operating rotation speed information relating to the air conditioning equipment or air conditioning equipment set, and the evaluation information includes at least one of power consumption information, cost information, unprocessed load information, actual temperature information, and actual humidity information relating to the air conditioning equipment or air conditioning equipment set.

9. the equipment or equipment set is an air conditioning equipment or an air conditioning equipment set, The fluctuation estimation means estimates a fluctuation of the performance information by using a fluctuation set for at least the outside air temperature information as the environmental information, the margin setting means sets the margin for the performance information based on an estimated fluctuation in the performance information, and sets the margin for the equipment information based on a deterioration over time from a reference time or after maintenance in the air conditioning capacity of the air conditioning equipment or the air conditioning equipment set. The evaluation program according to any one of claims 3 to 5.

10. an evaluation determination means for estimating evaluation information relating to an evaluation of an equipment or equipment set by using acquired equipment information relating to a configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set, and acquired performance information relating to performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set, and for determining the evaluation information as an evaluation result by reflecting a set margin in at least one of the equipment information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information; an equipment selection means for performing a selection process for a plurality of candidate equipment information, which is equipment information relating to a plurality of equipment or equipment sets that are candidates for selection, using a value including evaluation information determined as the evaluation result for the equipment or equipment set, or a value including information derived using the evaluation information as the evaluation result, as an objective variable, and determining selected equipment information, which is equipment information relating to the equipment or equipment set to be selected; A selection program that enables a computer to function.

11. causing the computer to further function as a margin setting means for setting a margin for at least one of the device information, the performance information, and the evaluation information; the evaluation determination means estimates the evaluation information using the equipment information relating to the equipment or equipment set that is a candidate for selection, or the equipment information reflecting the margin set for the equipment information relating to the equipment or equipment set that is a candidate for selection, or the equipment information and the margin, and the performance information as an evaluation condition, or the performance information reflecting the margin set for the performance information as an evaluation condition, or the performance information and the margin, and determines the estimated evaluation information, or the evaluation information reflecting the margin set for the estimated evaluation information, as the evaluation information as the evaluation result; The selection program according to claim 10.

12. The selection process is a process of determining the selected device information from a plurality of pieces of candidate device information using a set constraint condition, the device selection means sets the constraint condition reflecting at least one of the set margin and information related to the certainty of the estimation in the estimation process of the evaluation information or the degree of deviation from reality, and performs the selection process using the at least one reflected constraint condition. The selection program according to claim 10 or 11.

13. The selection program according to claim 10 or 11, wherein the equipment selection means determines, for the candidate equipment information selected by the selection process, information that reflects at least one of the set margin and information relating to the certainty of the estimation in the estimation process of the evaluation information or the degree of deviation from reality, as the selected equipment information.

14. an evaluation determination means for estimating evaluation information relating to an evaluation of the device or equipment set by using acquired device information relating to a configuration, capacity or specification of the device or equipment set and acquired performance information relating to a performance or experimental result of the device or equipment set; the evaluation determination means determines evaluation information as an evaluation result by reflecting a set margin in at least one of the device information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information; Evaluation equipment.

15. an evaluation determination means for estimating evaluation information relating to an evaluation of an equipment or equipment set by using acquired equipment information relating to a configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set, and acquired performance information relating to performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set, and for determining the evaluation information as an evaluation result by reflecting a set margin in at least one of the equipment information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information; an equipment selection means for performing a selection process for a plurality of candidate equipment information, which is equipment information relating to a plurality of equipment or equipment sets that are candidates for selection, using a value including evaluation information determined as the evaluation result for the equipment or equipment set, or a value including information derived using the evaluation information as the evaluation result, as an objective variable, and determining selected equipment information, which is equipment information relating to the equipment or equipment set to be selected; A selection device having the above configuration.

16. an evaluation determination means for estimating evaluation information relating to an evaluation of an equipment or equipment set by using acquired equipment information relating to a configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set, and acquired performance information relating to performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set, and for determining the evaluation information as an evaluation result by reflecting a set margin in at least one of the equipment information, the performance information, and the estimated evaluation information; an equipment selection means for performing a selection process for a plurality of candidate equipment information, which is equipment information relating to a plurality of equipment or equipment sets that are candidates for selection, using a value including evaluation information determined as the evaluation result for the equipment or equipment set, or a value including information derived using the evaluation information as the evaluation result, as an objective variable, and determining selected equipment information, which is equipment information relating to the equipment or equipment set to be selected; A selection system having the above.

17. A step of setting a margin for at least one of equipment information related to the configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set, performance information related to the performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set, and evaluation information related to the evaluation of the equipment or equipment set; a step of estimating the evaluation information using the acquired device information, or the acquired device information with the margin reflected thereon, or the acquired device information and the margin, and the acquired performance information, or the performance information with the margin reflected thereon, or the acquired performance information and the margin, and determining the estimated evaluation information, or, if the margin is set in the evaluation information, the evaluation information with the margin reflected thereon in the estimated evaluation information, as evaluation information as the evaluation result; 13. A computer-implemented evaluation method comprising:

18. A step of setting a margin for at least one of equipment information related to the configuration, capacity or specification of the equipment or equipment set, performance information related to the performance or experimental results of the equipment or equipment set, and evaluation information related to the evaluation of the equipment or equipment set; a step of estimating the evaluation information using device information on the device or device set that is a candidate for selection, or device information reflecting the margin set for the device information on the device or device set that is a candidate for selection, or the device information and the margin, and the performance information as an evaluation condition, or performance information reflecting the margin set for the performance information as an evaluation condition, or the performance information and the margin, and determining the estimated evaluation information, or the evaluation information reflecting the margin set for the estimated evaluation information, as evaluation information as an evaluation result; a step of performing a selection process for a plurality of candidate device information, which is the device information related to a plurality of devices or device sets that are candidates for selection, using a value including evaluation information determined as the evaluation result for the devices or device sets, or a value including information derived using the evaluation information as the evaluation result, as a target variable, and determining selected device information, which is the device information related to the devices or device sets to be selected; A computer-implemented selection method comprising:

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Air conditioning apparatus selection assist system

    JP2017027433A