Ammonia stress corrosion cracking acceleration test method
The cathodic polarization method with ammonium carbamate and controlled oxygen in liquid ammonia promotes hydrogen generation, addressing the inefficiency of existing SCC evaluation methods by enabling rapid and accurate susceptibility assessment.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2023098058
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2023-06-14
- Publication Date
- 2024-12-26
- Estimated Expiration
- 2043-06-14
AI Technical Summary
Existing ammonia stress corrosion cracking (SCC) evaluation methods in liquid ammonia environments are inadequate as they suppress hydrogen generation, making it difficult to assess SCC susceptibility in a short period.
A cathodic polarization method in a specific potential range with ammonium carbamate and controlled oxygen partial pressure in liquid ammonia, promoting hydrogen generation and cracking, allowing for rapid SCC evaluation.
Enables accurate and rapid assessment of ammonia SCC susceptibility in metal materials, simulating long-term exposure in a short period, typically within 720 hours or less.
Smart Images

Figure 2024179313000001 
Figure 2024179313000002
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for accelerated ammonia stress corrosion cracking testing of metal materials such as tanks used in a liquid ammonia environment. [Background technology]
[0002] In recent years, liquid ammonia has been attracting attention as a clean energy source because it does not emit CO2 when burned, and large-scale demand is expected. This has led to a demand for larger facilities to transport and store liquid ammonia. In general, when making tanks larger, thinner steel is used in order to reduce weight and construction costs, and therefore the use of high-strength steel is desirable.
[0003] On the other hand, in a liquid ammonia environment, there is concern that carbon steel may suffer from stress corrosion cracking due to liquid ammonia (hereinafter referred to as ammonia SCC). Therefore, for carbon steel structures that handle liquid ammonia, such as piping, storage tanks, tank cars, and line pipes, steel materials with low ammonia SCC susceptibility have been used and operational measures have been taken to suppress ammonia SCC.
[0004] SCC is a phenomenon that leads to destruction due to the superposition of corrosion reactions and stress, and occurs when material factors, environmental factors, and stress factors meet certain conditions. For example, ammonia SCC is known to correlate with the strength and hardness of a material. In other words, it is known that the higher the strength and hardness, the more ammonia SCC occurs, and when using carbon steel, it is considered desirable to use materials with a tensile strength of less than 600 MPa.
[0005] Therefore, when applying new steel materials that have both high strength and excellent ammonia SCC resistance, it is necessary to accurately evaluate the ammonia SCC susceptibility.On the other hand, since evaluation of ammonia SCC susceptibility by exposure testing in an actual liquid ammonia tank requires long-term testing, an accelerated test that can evaluate the ammonia SCC susceptibility of steel materials in a short period of time is desired.
[0006] Such accelerated tests using liquid ammonia are disclosed in Patent Document 1 and Non-Patent Document 1. Patent Document 1 and Non-Patent Document 1 describe a test method for evaluating ammonia SCC susceptibility in a short period of time by anodic polarizing a test piece in liquid ammonia containing O2 and saturated CO2, thereby accelerating the dissolution of iron. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0007] [Patent Document 1] Special Publication No. 60-10575 [Non-patent literature]
[0008] [Non-Patent Document 1] Yoichi Nakai, "Development of an accelerated test method for stress corrosion cracking in liquid ammonia", Iron and Steel, Vol. 67, No. 14, 1981, pp. 2226-2233 Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0009] In the test methods described in Patent Document 1 and Non-Patent Document 1, the test specimens are polarized anodically at +2V vs Pt, but the cathodic reaction, which is the counter reaction of the anodic reaction, is significantly suppressed, and the amount of hydrogen generated, which is an important factor in promoting cracking due to hydrogen embrittlement, is significantly suppressed. As a result, ammonia SCC is not promoted, and it is difficult to say that ammonia SCC susceptibility can be evaluated in a short period of time.
[0010] The present invention aims to solve the above problems and provide an accelerated ammonia SCC test method capable of evaluating, in a short period of time, the ammonia SCC susceptibility of metal materials used in tanks for transporting and storing liquid ammonia.
[0011] In order to solve the above problems, the present inventors conducted a detailed study on the ammonia SCC mechanism of steel sheets in liquid ammonia and obtained the following findings.
[0012] In a liquid ammonia environment, the following corrosion reactions occur on steel plates: Anode reaction: Fe → Fe 2+ +2e - (Formula 1) Cathodic reaction: 2NH4 + +2e - →H2+2NH3 (Formula 2)
[0013] In conjunction with the above corrosion reaction, hydrogen generated by the cathodic reaction is absorbed into the steel from the steel plate surface, and diffuses and accumulates at the tip of the crack, accelerating the crack. Therefore, in order to promote ammonia SCC, it was thought that the cathodic reaction should be promoted to increase the amount of hydrogen generated.
[0014] Liquid ammonia also contains trace amounts of CO2 as an impurity. In liquid ammonia, CO2 dissociates and reaches an equilibrium state according to the following reaction formula: 2NH3+CO2⇔NH4CO2NH2⇔NH4 + +NH2CO2 - (Formula 3)
[0015] When ammonium carbamate (NH4CO2NH2) is added to liquid ammonia, the above dissociation reaction causes the NH4 + It was recalled that the ammonia SCC is promoted because the cathode reaction of the above-mentioned formula 2 is promoted by increasing the ammonia concentration, thereby promoting hydrogen generation.
[0016] Furthermore, when O2 is added to liquid ammonia, the following reaction occurs: O2+2NH4 ++4e - →2OH - +2NH3 (formula 4)
[0017] When O2 is added to liquid ammonia, NH4 is produced by the reaction shown in formula 4. + It was recalled that ammonia SCC is suppressed because the hydrogen evolution reaction in equation 2 is suppressed by consuming the ammonia.
[0018] From the above, it was found that by performing cathodic polarization in liquid ammonia, adding ammonium carbamate to the liquid ammonia, and limiting the O2 content in the liquid ammonia, the hydrogen evolution reaction is promoted rather than inhibited. Therefore, it was found that ammonia SCC is promoted and ammonia SCC susceptibility can be evaluated in a short period of time.
[0019] The present invention has been made based on the above findings, and the gist of the present invention is as follows.
[0020] [1] An accelerated ammonia stress corrosion cracking test method, characterized in that a metal test piece to which an external stress has been applied or which has residual stress is immersed in liquid ammonia containing 0.01 mass% or more ammonium carbamate and an O2 gas partial pressure of 0.25 bar or less, and cathodically polarized in a potential range up to -3.0 V relative to the corrosion potential.
[0021] [2] The method for accelerated ammonia stress corrosion cracking testing according to [1] above, wherein the liquid ammonia is stirred during the test. Effect of the Invention
[0022] According to the accelerated ammonia stress corrosion cracking test method of the present invention, it is possible to evaluate, in a short period of time, the ammonia SCC susceptibility of metallic materials applied to tanks and the like used in a liquid ammonia environment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0023] Hereinafter, an embodiment of the present invention (hereinafter, simply referred to as the present embodiment) will be described in detail. The present invention is not limited to the following embodiment, and can be modified in various ways within the scope of the present invention. In the embodiment of the present invention, A (numerical value) to B (numerical value) means A or more and B or less.
[0024] [Cathodic polarization in the potential range up to -3.0 V relative to the corrosion potential] In the test method of the present invention, a metal test piece to which an external stress has been applied or which has residual stress is immersed in liquid ammonia containing 0.01 mass% or more of ammonium carbamate and O2 at a gas partial pressure of 0.25 bar or less, and is cathodically polarized in a potential region up to -3.0 V with respect to the corrosion potential. Note that "up to -3.0 V" refers to a potential between -3.0 V and less than 0 V.
[0025] By cathodically polarizing the metal test piece in the potential range of -3.0V with respect to the corrosion potential, hydrogen is generated by cathodic reaction on the surface of the metal test piece in liquid ammonia. The generated hydrogen is absorbed into the metal from the surface of the test piece, and diffuses and accumulates at the tip of the crack propagation, promoting cracking, and ammonia SCC susceptibility can be evaluated in a short period of time. On the other hand, when the metal test piece is held at the corrosion potential or anodically polarized with respect to the corrosion potential, cathodic polarization on the surface of the test piece is not promoted, so that it may be difficult to evaluate the ammonia SCC susceptibility of the test piece in a short period of time. In addition, when the metal test piece is cathodically polarized in the potential range exceeding -3.0V with respect to the corrosion potential, hydrogen generation is excessively promoted, so that the surface of the test piece is covered with bubbles of the generated hydrogen, and the cathodic reaction of the above formula 2 is hindered in that portion, and as a result, it may be impossible to evaluate the ammonia SCC susceptibility. Therefore, cathodically polarizing in the potential range of -3.0V with respect to the corrosion potential is specified. The potential region for cathodic polarization relative to the corrosion potential is preferably −2.5 V or higher, more preferably −2.0 V or higher, and is preferably −0.2 V or lower, more preferably −0.5 V or lower, and further preferably −1.0 V or lower.
[0026] The corrosion potential is the potential measured by immersing a metal test piece to be evaluated for ammonia SCC susceptibility or a metal test piece taken from the metal material to be evaluated in liquid ammonia for 5 minutes or more while applying external stress or with residual stress. The method for measuring the potential is not particularly limited, but it can be measured by the two-electrode method or the three-electrode method.
[0027] The polarization (application of electric potential) and the measurement of the corrosion potential of the metal test piece can be performed, for example, by using a potentiostat (a constant potential electrolysis device) with the metal test piece as the working electrode (sample electrode). In this case, it is preferable to use platinum (Pt) electrodes, which are stable in liquid ammonia, as the counter electrode and the reference electrode.
[0028] <Test solution> In the test method of the present invention, liquid ammonia containing 0.01 mass % or more of ammonium carbamate and O2 at a gas partial pressure of 0.25 bar or less is used as the test solution.
[0029] [Ammonium carbamate content: 0.01 mass or more] Liquid ammonia normally contains a small amount of CO2 as an impurity, and in liquid ammonia, CO2 dissociates as shown in formula 3 above and reaches an equilibrium state.
[0030] When ammonium carbamate (NH4CO2NH2) is added to liquid ammonia in equilibrium, the NH4 + increases, and hydrogen generation is promoted by promoting the cathode reaction of the above-mentioned formula 2, and thus ammonia SCC is promoted. If the ammonium carbamate content in liquid ammonia is less than 0.01 mass%, such an effect cannot be obtained. Therefore, the ammonium carbamate content in liquid ammonia is specified to be 0.01 mass% or more. It is preferably 0.03 mass% or more, more preferably 0.05 mass% or more, and further preferably 0.10 mass% or more, and may be, for example, 0.50 mass%, 1.00 mass%, or 5.00 mass%.
[0031] The upper limit of the content of ammonium carbamate in the liquid ammonia is not particularly limited, and may be up to the saturated amount, for example, 5.00 mass% or less, 1.00 mass% or less, or 0.50 mass% or less.
[0032] Although the method of adding ammonium carbamate to liquid ammonia is not particularly limited, it is preferable to place a predetermined amount of ammonium carbamate in the test vessel before introducing liquid ammonia. Moreover, the placement of the ammonium carbamate can be replaced by blowing in an amount of CO2 gas or placing solid CO2 (dry ice) that will give the predetermined amount of ammonium carbamate content.
[0033] [O2 content: gas partial pressure 0.25 bar or less] In liquid ammonia, O2 reacts as shown in formula 4. When liquid ammonia contains O2, the reaction produces NH4 + is consumed, and the hydrogen generation reaction of the above formula 2 is suppressed, so that ammonia SCC is suppressed. If the O2 content in liquid ammonia is set to 0.25 bar or less in gas partial pressure, this effect does not occur. Therefore, the O2 content in liquid ammonia is specified to be 0.25 bar or less in gas partial pressure. It is preferably 0.20 bar or less, more preferably 0.15 bar or less, and even more preferably 0.10 bar or less.
[0034] The lower limit of the O2 content in liquid ammonia may be 0 bar, but 0.002 bar is preferable. Ammonia stress corrosion cracking starts from the surface film destruction caused by stress load. On the other hand, O2 has the effect of forming an oxide film on the surface of a metal test piece in liquid ammonia, so that adding an appropriate amount of O2 has the effect of promoting stress corrosion cracking. If the O2 content is less than 0.002 bar in gas partial pressure, such an effect cannot be obtained, so the lower limit of the O2 content is preferably 0.002 bar, and more preferably 0.01 bar or more. Although the method of adding O2 to liquid ammonia is not particularly limited, from the viewpoint of a stable supply of O2, it is preferable to blow a predetermined amount of O2 gas into the test vessel before introducing liquid ammonia. The blowing of the O2 gas can be replaced with blowing of an amount of air gas that can obtain the predetermined amount of O2 gas partial pressure.
[0035] [Liquid ammonia] The purity of the liquid ammonia used in the test solution is not particularly limited, but if it contains HO and oil, stress corrosion cracking of the metal test piece is more likely to be suppressed. Therefore, it is preferable that the amount of HO and oil contained as impurities in the liquid ammonia is less than 0.05 mass% each.
[0036] [Liquid ammonia stirred during testing] The corrosion reaction is affected by the composition of the liquid ammonia solution on the metal test piece surface. As the corrosion reaction continues, the reactants on the metal test piece surface decrease. In other words, as the corrosion reaction continues, the 2NH4 + The amount of hydrogen produced also decreases as the amount of ammonia decreases. By stirring the liquid ammonia, the amount of NH4 + This promotes the supply of ammonia, which allows the promotion of hydrogen generation to be maintained, and the period required for ammonia SCC susceptibility evaluation to be further shortened. Therefore, it is preferable to stir the liquid ammonia during the test. Since ammonia SCC susceptibility is affected by nitrogen, carbon dioxide, oxygen, etc., it is preferable to stir the liquid ammonia using a stirrer. In order to stabilize the supply of ions to the test piece surface, it is preferable to stir the liquid ammonia continuously at 10 rpm or more.
[0037] <Metal test piece> The test method of the present invention is a method for promoting ammonia SCC by applying an electric potential, and therefore can be applied to conductive metal materials. The metal materials are not particularly limited in terms of their component composition or metal structure. Specific examples of the metal materials include those containing metal elements (e.g., Fe, Cu, Al, Ni, Ti, etc.) as the main component (i.e., 50 mass% or more), such as steel (iron alloy), copper alloy, aluminum alloy, nickel alloy, titanium alloy, etc. In particular, since these materials are generally used in structures exposed to a liquid ammonia environment and resistance to ammonia SCC is important, it is preferable to apply the method to steel materials.
[0038] The steel material to which this accelerated ammonia stress corrosion cracking test method can be applied is not particularly limited. However, high-strength steels with a surface Vickers hardness of 280 HV10 or more are particularly prone to cracking due to hydrogen embrittlement, and are therefore suitable for evaluating ammonia SCC susceptibility using the test method of the present invention. The metal test piece used in the test method of the present invention may be one taken from a metal material whose ammonia SCC susceptibility is to be evaluated, or one taken from a metal material having the same or similar component composition and metal structure as the said metal material.
[0039] The shape and size of the test specimen are not particularly limited and may be appropriately determined depending on the test cell and the external stress application method to be used or may be selected from known standards. However, the exposed area (cm2) of the test specimen may be set to a value smaller than that of the test specimen so that the effect of the corrosion reaction on the solution composition is reduced. 2 The specific liquid volume, which is the amount of liquid ammonia solution (mL) relative to the 2 The upper limit of the specific liquid volume is not particularly limited, but if the specific liquid volume is excessively large, the cost of the test equipment etc. will increase, so it is preferable that the upper limit is 500 mL / cm 2 It is preferable that:
[0040] [External stress / residual stress] Since the test method of the present invention is an accelerated ammonia stress corrosion cracking test, a metal test piece to which an external stress has been applied or which has a residual stress is immersed in a test solution. The method of applying the external stress or the residual stress is not particularly limited, but for example, an external stress can be applied by a known method such as four-point bending, U-bending, or a constant load method, and a residual stress can be applied by carrying out a heat treatment, welding, processing, or the like.
[0041] The magnitude of the applied external stress or residual stress may be appropriately set depending on the test purpose (for example, the intended use of the material to be evaluated), but it is preferable to load 20% or more of the yield strength YS (MPa) of each test piece. Since ammonia SCC can be promoted as the applied external stress or residual stress is increased, there is no particular upper limit as long as damage such as cracks is not caused to the metal test piece itself.
[0042] <Other test conditions> The test temperature (temperature of the test solution) used in the test method of the present invention can be appropriately selected depending on the purpose of the test. However, since the corrosion reaction is suppressed at low temperatures and the test period tends to become longer, a temperature of 0 to 60°C is preferable.
[0043] The test period for carrying out the test method of the present invention is not particularly limited and can be set appropriately depending on the intended use of the metallic material to be evaluated, but in order to apply a new material, the shorter the test period, the better, and it is preferably within 720 hours. Since an ammonia SCC test under an actual tank environment (actual liquid ammonia) generally requires a test period of about one year, the use of the test method of the present invention can shorten the test period to about 1 / 10 or less.
[0044] The test conditions other than those mentioned above are not particularly limited, and may be appropriately selected from known conditions used in corrosion tests. Test equipment, test cells, and the like may be those known in the art, such as those described in Patent Document 1 and Non-Patent Document 1. EXAMPLES
[0045] The present invention will be described in more detail below with reference to examples, but the present invention is not limited to the following examples in any way.
[0046] [Ammonia SCC occurrence in actual tank environment] As a preliminary study to confirm the effectiveness of the test method of the present invention, four types of steel (steel types A to D) with different chemical compositions were used as test steels, and an ammonia SCC test was performed in an actual tank environment using actual liquid ammonia to evaluate their ammonia SCC susceptibility.
[0047] The yield strength (YS) and Vickers hardness (HV0.5) of the steel materials subjected to the ammonia SCC test are shown in Table 1. The yield strength and Vickers hardness were measured at the 1 / 4 position of the plate thickness in accordance with JIS Z 2241 and JIS Z 2244. The Vickers hardness was measured at 20 points using a Vickers test with a load of 500g, and the average value was calculated.
[0048] Test pieces measuring 5 mm thick x 15 mm wide x 115 mm long were taken from the 1 / 4 plate thickness position of test steels A to D. The taken test pieces were ultrasonically degreased in acetone for 5 minutes, and then an external stress (100% YS) equal to the yield strength of each test piece was applied by four-point bending. The four-point bent test pieces were immersed in a real liquid ammonia tank and removed after one year. After removing the corrosion products from the surface of the removed test pieces, the surface and cross section of the test pieces were visually observed for cracks and the presence or absence of cracks was evaluated.
[0049] Those that had cracks were judged as having SCC (good), and those that did not have cracks were judged as having no SCC (bad). The judgment results are shown in Table 1 as the occurrence of SCC in actual liquid ammonia tanks.
[0050] [Table 1]
[0051] As can be seen from Table 1, in an actual liquid ammonia tank, SCC did not occur in steels A and B. SCC did occur in steels C and D.
[0052] [Ammonia SCC accelerated test] The ammonia SCC acceleration test of the present invention was carried out on the test steels A to D for which the ammonia SCC occurrence state in an actual tank environment was examined as described above, and the ammonia SCC susceptibility was evaluated.
[0053] Table 2 shows the test conditions for the ammonia SCC accelerated test. Test pieces measuring 5 mm thick x 15 mm x 115 mm were taken from the 1 / 4 position of the plate thickness of test steels A to D, and ultrasonically degreased in acetone for 5 minutes, and then an external stress equal to the yield strength of each test piece (100% YS) was applied by four-point bending. Ammonium carbamate and O2 were introduced into the test cell containing the four-point bending test pieces in the amounts shown in Table 2, and then 2 L of liquid ammonia was filled. The specific liquid volume was 42.1 mL / cm 2 After that, the corrosion potential of the test piece was measured by a potentiostat, and the test was started by controlling the corrosion potential after 1 hour to be a predetermined potential. After 168 to 1440 hours of immersion, the test piece was taken out of the test cell, the corrosion products on the surface of the test piece were removed, and the surface and cross section were visually observed for cracks to evaluate the presence or absence of cracks.
[0054] The immersion test used liquid ammonia with a purity of 99.999% or more. The measurement of potential using a potentiostat and the application of potential were performed using the three-electrode method, with platinum electrodes used as the reference electrode and counter electrode. The test temperature was set at 25°C. Stirring during the test was performed continuously at 10 rpm using a stirrer placed in the test cell.
[0055] The occurrence of SCC was evaluated by performing the immersion test 10 times for each test number. If one or more cracks occurred throughout the entire test, it was judged as having SCC (good), and if no cracks occurred, it was judged as having no SCC (bad).
[0056] If the SCC occurrence status matched the SCC occurrence status in an actual liquid ammonia tank for the same steel type shown in Table 1, the evaluation accuracy was judged to be "good." For tests where the evaluation accuracy was judged to be good, those with a test period of 720 hours or less were judged to have a "good" evaluation period. Evaluation accuracy and evaluation period other than those judged to be "good" were judged to be "poor."
[0057] Table 2 shows the SCC occurrence status, evaluation accuracy, and evaluation period as accelerated test results.
[0058] [Table 2]
[0059] As can be seen from Table 2, in the examples of the present invention, the same SCC susceptibility as in the environment simulating an actual liquid ammonia tank could be evaluated within 720 hours. On the other hand, in Comparative Examples 10 and 12, SCC did not occur in the steel product in which SCC had occurred in the environment simulating an actual liquid ammonia tank, and SCC susceptibility could not be evaluated. Also, in Comparative Example 11, although SCC occurred in the steel product in which SCC had occurred in the environment simulating an actual liquid ammonia tank, the test period was long, and ammonia SCC susceptibility could not be evaluated in a short period of time. [Industrial Applicability]
[0060] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide an accelerated ammonia stress corrosion cracking test method capable of evaluating the ammonia stress corrosion cracking susceptibility of a metallic material in a short period of time. By using the test method of the present invention, it is possible to evaluate the ammonia stress corrosion cracking susceptibility of a metallic material in a short period of time. The test method of the present invention is very useful for evaluating the ammonia stress corrosion cracking susceptibility of a steel material, and can be advantageously used for the selection and development of metallic materials having excellent ammonia stress corrosion cracking resistance that can be suitably used for structures for transporting or storing liquid ammonia.
Claims
1. A metal test piece to which external stress has been applied or which has residual stress is subjected to a gas partial pressure of 0.25 bar or less containing 0.01 mass% or more of ammonium carbamate. 2 and cathodically polarizing the specimen in a potential range up to -3.0 V with respect to the corrosion potential.
2. 2. The method of claim 1, wherein the liquid ammonia is stirred during the test.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Low hydrogen type coated electrode
JP1982137096A
Corrosion environment sensor and corrosion environment controller
JP1993340858A
Crack growth test apparatus
JP2001153789A
Method and apparatus for manufacturing stress corrosion crack test specimen
JP2006010427A
Steel material
JP2019094563A
