Texture evaluation method and information processing device
The method and device generate evaluation items and results for jelly-like compositions based on ingestion and swallowing stages, addressing the limitations of existing texture evaluation methods by capturing essential swallowing textures, enhancing texture analysis for improved food development.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2021045513
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-03-19
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-21
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-03-19
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for evaluating the texture of food and drink compositions, such as viscometers and sensory evaluations, fail to capture the differences in texture experienced during ingestion and swallowing, which are crucial for developing compositions suitable for individuals with swallowing difficulties.
A method and device for evaluating the texture of jelly-like compositions by generating evaluation items based on texture expression terms related to the ingestion and swallowing process, including stages like putting in the mouth, crushing with the tongue, and swallowing, and generating texture evaluation results through an information processing system.
Accurately evaluates textures that cannot be measured by analyzers, providing insights into textures relevant for swallowing ease and preference, especially for individuals with swallowing difficulties, and enabling precise texture analysis of jelly-like compositions.
Smart Images

Figure 0007588013000001 
Figure 0007588013000002 
Figure 0007588013000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present technology relates to a method and an information processing device for evaluating the texture of a composition, and in particular to a method and an information processing device for evaluating the texture of a jelly-like composition. [Background technology]
[0002] In order to evaluate the texture of a food or beverage composition, the physical properties of the food or beverage composition may be used. For example, the physical properties of the food or beverage composition are measured using an analytical device such as a viscometer or texture analyzer, and the texture of the food or beverage composition is evaluated based on the measurement results.
[0003] It has also been proposed to use indices other than the physical properties of food and drink compositions for texture evaluation. For example, Patent Document 1 below discloses "a sensory evaluation method for food and drink, comprising: 1) collecting binary data for a plurality of sensory properties evaluated dynamically by a human after the food or drink is placed in the mouth, and 2) carrying out step 1) at least twice in one session" (Claim 1). Patent Document 2 below discloses "a texture evaluation method for quantitatively evaluating the texture of food that requires chewing in eating, comprising obtaining a ratio of chewing time to the total time spent by a subject eating a sample" (Claim 1). [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0004] [Patent Document 1] JP 2018-124106 A [Patent Document 2] JP 2019-052901 A Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0005] When the textures of multiple types of food and beverage compositions are evaluated by an analytical device, there is no difference in the measured values obtained by the analytical device, but when a person eats and swallows the multiple types of food and beverage compositions, the textures are often recognized as different. In addition, there are textures related to physical properties that cannot be measured by analytical devices. If such textures can be more accurately grasped, it is considered to be useful in the development of food and beverage compositions. For example, in the development of food and beverage compositions for people with dysphagia, it is particularly important to improve the texture recognized in the eating and swallowing process, and it is considered to be particularly important to accurately grasp such textures. [Means for solving the problem]
[0006] The inventors have found that certain evaluation methods are useful for evaluating the texture of a composition.
[0007] That is, the present technology includes an evaluation item generating step of generating at least one evaluation item for evaluating the texture of a jelly-like composition based on texture describing terms selected from a plurality of texture describing terms related to the eating and swallowing process; generating an evaluation result of the texture of the jelly-like composition based on the evaluation result regarding the at least one evaluation item; The present invention provides a texture evaluation method, comprising: Each of the at least one evaluation item may be an evaluation item corresponding to one of a plurality of stages constituting the eating and swallowing process. The at least one evaluation item may be an evaluation item generated based on a selected set of texture describing terms. The evaluation result for the at least one evaluation item may be a result of a texture evaluation performed using symmetrically scorable evaluation axes or symmetrically scored evaluation axes. The evaluation result generating step may include calculating an average value of the evaluation results for each evaluation item. The evaluation result generating step may include determining a correlation between evaluation results between evaluation items. The evaluation result generating step may include adjusting a manner in which the evaluation result is output based on at least the correlation. The step of generating an evaluation result may include generating a graph of the evaluation result. The graphed evaluation results may include a graph in which the arrangement of the evaluation items is adjusted based on the correlation coefficient. The present technology also includes an evaluation item generating step of generating at least one evaluation item for evaluating the texture of a composition based on texture description terms selected from a plurality of texture description terms related to the eating and swallowing process; generating an evaluation result for evaluating the texture of the composition based on the evaluation result for at least one evaluation item; Also provided is a texture evaluation method, comprising: The present technology also includes an evaluation item generating step of generating at least one evaluation item for evaluating the texture of a jelly-like composition based on texture describing terms selected from a plurality of texture describing terms related to the eating and swallowing process; generating an evaluation result of the texture of the jelly-like composition based on the evaluation result regarding the at least one evaluation item; Also provided is an information processing device that executes the above. Effect of the Invention
[0008] This technique allows accurate evaluation of the texture of a composition, and is useful for evaluating the texture of a jelly-like composition, for example. Note that the effects of the present technology are not limited to the effects described in this paragraph, and may be any of the effects described in this specification. [Brief description of the drawings]
[0009] [Figure 1] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of the flow of a texture evaluation method according to the present technology. [Diagram 2] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of an expression term list. [Diagram 3] FIG. 13 shows an example of a data table including multiple stages constituting the eating and swallowing process and texture description terms associated with each stage. [Figure 4] FIG. 1 is a diagram showing examples of evaluation axes included in evaluation items used in the texture evaluation method according to the present technology. [Diagram 5] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of an evaluation table used in the texture evaluation method according to the present technology. [Figure 6] 1 shows an example block diagram of a texture assessment system in accordance with the present technique. [Figure 7] FIG. 1 illustrates an example of the configuration of an information processing device. [Figure 8] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of a data table including a group of categorized expressions. [Figure 9] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of a radar chart included in the texture evaluation result. [Figure 10] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of a radar chart included in the texture evaluation result. [Figure 11] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of a radar chart included in the texture evaluation result. [Figure 12] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of a radar chart included in the texture evaluation result. [Figure 13] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of a scatter diagram included in the texture evaluation result. [Figure 14] FIG. 13 is a diagram showing an example of a scatter diagram included in the texture evaluation result. [Figure 15] FIG. 1 shows mechanical measurement results and texture evaluation results obtained by the present technique. [Figure 16] FIG. 1 is a schematic diagram showing an example of an instrument used in texture evaluation. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0010] Preferred embodiments of the present technology will be described below. However, the present technology is not limited to the following preferred embodiments and can be freely modified within the scope of the present technology.
[0011] 1.Texture evaluation method
[0012] The texture evaluation method of the present technology may include a presentation step S1, an evaluation item generation step S2, an evaluation result generation step S3, and an output step S4, as shown in Fig. 1. Each of these steps will be described below.
[0013] 1-1. Presentation process S1
[0014] In the presentation step S1, a plurality of texture description terms for describing textures in at least one stage of the eating and swallowing process are presented. The plurality of texture description terms may be preferably associated with any one or more stages among a plurality of stages constituting the eating and swallowing process.
[0015] (Stages in the eating and swallowing process) The eating and swallowing process may be divided into a plurality of stages. In the present technology, the number of at least one of the stages of the eating and swallowing process may be, for example, 1 to 5, preferably 2, 3, 4, or 5, more preferably 2, 3, or 4, and particularly preferably 3. These stages may be stages into which the eating and swallowing process is divided chronologically. Note that the eating and swallowing process does not have to be divided chronologically, and may be classified into a plurality of stages based on, for example, the actions included in the eating and swallowing process (e.g., one or more of a chewing action, a tongue crushing action, an intraoral movement action, and a swallowing action). Dividing the eating and swallowing process into multiple stages allows for more appropriate texture evaluation. For example, the texture of the composition can be comprehensively evaluated. In addition, more appropriate evaluation items can be generated in the evaluation item generation step S2 described below. However, if there are too many stages, the evaluator is overburdened in the evaluation. Dividing the ingestion and swallowing process into stages is particularly suitable for evaluating the texture of a gelatinous composition, as the optimal texture can be identified by performing a texture evaluation for each stage. Jelly compositions (including not only jellies but also, for example, chawanmushi (steamed custard) described below) are often consumed by people who have difficulty swallowing or who have poor appetite. For such people, slight differences in the texture of the jelly composition can significantly affect the ease of swallowing, preference, or amount of food eaten. By carrying out texture evaluation in multiple steps according to the present technology as described above, such slight differences in texture can be evaluated, which is very effective in identifying or developing compositions that are more suitable for such people.
[0016] At least one stage of the ingestion and swallowing process may include, for example, one, two, or all three of the following: placing the composition in the mouth, crushing the composition with the tongue (or teeth), and swallowing the composition. Dividing the ingestion and swallowing process into these three stages is suitable for evaluating the texture of a composition, particularly for evaluating the texture of a gelatinous composition.
[0017] The swallowing process may be divided into five stages, for example: oral intake stage, posterior tongue thrust stage, posterior tongue thrust stage to pharynx stage, pharyngeal thrust stage, and pharyngeal transit stage. (Ichiro Fujishima: Eating and Swallowing Disorders in Stroke, 2nd ed., Ishiyaku Shuppan, Tokyo, 2005; pp. 19-29, and https: / / www.terumo.co.jp / consumer / guide / symptom / enge / about / index.html). In the present technology, the feeding and swallowing process may be divided into these five stages. Of these five stages, the stage of taking into the mouth corresponds to the stage of putting the composition into the mouth among the three stages, the stage of sending to the back of the tongue and the stage of sending from the back of the tongue to the pharynx correspond to the stage of crushing the composition with the tongue, and the stage of sending to the pharynx and the stage of passing through the pharynx correspond to the stage of swallowing the composition.
[0018] (Multiple texture descriptions related to the feeding and swallowing process) A plurality of texture expression terms relating to the eating and swallowing process may be, for example, listed. The plurality of expression terms may be expression terms prepared in advance according to the type of composition. An example of a plurality of expression terms is shown in FIG. 2. In the figure, the plurality of expression terms are listed. The list shown in FIG. 2 includes a group of expression terms (left column) for expressing the texture at the stage of putting the composition in the mouth, a group of expression terms (center column) for expressing the texture at the stage of crushing the composition with the tongue, and a group of expression terms (right column) for expressing the texture at the stage of swallowing the composition. In FIG. 2, the group of expression terms is shown in a state associated with each stage, but may not be associated. In this way, the plurality of expression terms used in the presenting step S1 may be associated with each of the at least one stage.
[0019] The texture expression terms used in the present technology may include, for example, the expression terms described in the Japanese Texture Terminology System (published on the website of the National Agriculture and Food Research Organization, Food Research Institute). In particular, the texture expression terms may be configured to include a plurality of terms listed in the terminology column in the Japanese Texture Terminology System (the plurality of terms may be all the terms in the system or terms characteristic of each composition).
[0020] (composition) The composition may be a composition that can be ingested and swallowed. The composition is preferably in the form of a jelly. The jelly-like composition is preferably a food that can be eaten without chewing with teeth, and can be crushed and eaten between the tongue and palate (upper jaw). Specific examples of the composition include jelly, chawanmushi, pudding, mousse, thickened liquid food, tofu, ice cream, yogurt, etc. The composition may be a food or drink composition or a pharmaceutical composition.
[0021] The composition may be, for example, a composition for people with dysphagia, particularly a jelly-like composition for people with dysphagia. Compared with food eaten by chewing with teeth, a jelly-like composition has a large contact area between the food and the tongue or the mucous membrane in the oral cavity, so the texture is more strongly felt. Therefore, a slight difference in the texture of a jelly-like composition may greatly affect the ease of swallowing, the food preferences, or the amount of food that can be ingested. Therefore, in the development of a food and drink composition for people with dysphagia, it is particularly important to improve the texture recognized in the eating and swallowing process. The present technology is particularly useful for such development because it contributes to accurate texture evaluation.
[0022] (Term selection process using multiple presented expression terms) In the presentation step S1, the plurality of texture describing terms are presented to a human. The human may be an evaluator who performs texture evaluation of a composition. The human who is presented with the list may ingest and swallow the composition, and may select a texture describing term for describing the texture of the composition at each of the at least one stage from the plurality of texture describing terms. The human may be a human who has received training in texture evaluation, or may be a human who has not received such training. In this technology, even if the untrained human selects the describing term and / or performs the evaluation of the composition in 1-3 below, an appropriate texture evaluation result can be obtained. Therefore, in one preferred embodiment of the technology, the human may be a human who has not received the training. Since the number of trained humans is limited, this embodiment can reduce the cost required for training and selecting evaluators.
[0023] A texture description term not included in the plurality of texture description terms may be selected, for example, a human being presented with the plurality of texture description terms may select a texture description term that is considered appropriate for describing the texture in each of the at least one stage but that is not included in the plurality of texture description terms.
[0024] (Eating utensils) The evaluator preferably performs the eating and swallowing using a specific tool. The specific tool may be, for example, a tool used to quantify the composition. This allows the conditions for texture evaluation to be unified, and the accuracy of the texture evaluation to be improved. For example, the tool can reduce variation in temperature or amount of a mouthful of the composition, and the accuracy of the texture evaluation to be improved. The tool may be, for example, a dish for putting the composition into the oral cavity. For example, when the composition is a jelly-like composition, the tool may be a spoon or a spoon-like tool. The tool may be a fork, chopsticks, or a cup. In this specification, a tool used to put the composition to be evaluated into the oral cavity is also called an "eating tool".
[0025] In a preferred embodiment of the present technology, the eating utensil is a spoon or spoon-like utensil (e.g., a spatula, etc.). The eating utensil in this embodiment will be described with reference to FIG. 16. This figure is a schematic diagram of an example of a spoon or spoon-like utensil, which is an example of the eating utensil. The spoon 13 shown in this figure has a dish portion 131 and a handle portion 132. The composition to be evaluated is placed on the dish portion 131 and is eaten by the evaluator.
[0026] The width L1 of the dish portion 131 may be, for example, 10 mm to 35 mm, particularly 20 mm to 30 mm, and more particularly 24 mm to 28 mm. The length L2 of the dish portion 131 may be, for example, 20 mm to 60 mm, particularly 30 mm to 55 mm, and more particularly 40 mm to 50 mm. The length L3 of the handle 132 may be, for example, 100 mm to 200 mm, particularly 110 mm to 180 mm, and more particularly 120 mm to 160 mm. The total length (L2+L3) of the spoon 13 may be, for example, 100 mm to 250 mm, in particular 120 mm to 240 mm, more in particular 150 mm to 230 mm, and even more in particular 170 mm to 220 mm.
[0027] By having the above dimensions of the dish portion 131, the amount of composition put into the evaluator's mouth is appropriately limited. That is, the eating utensil is preferably capable of measuring 3 to 30 g of a composition (particularly a jelly-like composition) as a single intake amount, more preferably 5 to 17 g, and even more preferably 6 to 8 g. Such an amount is suitable for texture evaluation according to the present technology. That is, the eating utensil is particularly suitable for texture evaluation because it is configured to scoop up such an amount of composition. In addition, the length of handle 132 or the total length of the spoon 13 makes it difficult for the heat of the hand holding the spoon 13 to be conducted to the composition to be evaluated on the plate 131, enabling a more appropriate evaluation. The material of the tool is preferably plastic, which makes it difficult for the heat of the hand holding handle 132 to be conducted to the composition to be evaluated. The shape of the tip T side of the disk portion 131 may be rounded as shown in the figure, or may be flat.
[0028] (adjustment device) The composition may be provided to the evaluator in a state adjusted to have a predetermined size and / or shape. This contributes to obtaining a more appropriate evaluation result. In order to provide the composition to the evaluator in the above state, for example, an adjustment tool for adjusting the size and / or shape of the composition may be used. The adjustment tool may be, for example, a die. When the composition is a jelly-like composition, the jelly-like composition may be provided to the evaluator in a state in which it is placed in, for example, a jelly cup (or a pudding cup). The evaluator may eat the jelly-like composition placed in the cup using the utensil (for example, a spoon). In this case, each cup may contain, for example, 30 g to 100 g, particularly 40 g to 80 g of the jelly-like composition. The jelly composition may also have a brick-type shape. In this case, for example, 30 g to 100 g, particularly 40 g to 80 g, more particularly 40 g to 60 g of the jelly composition is provided to the evaluator. For example, the jelly composition may be cut into a predetermined shape and provided to the evaluator. The jelly composition may be cut into a shape of, for example, 2 cm to 6 cm square, particularly 3 cm to 5 cm square, and provided to the evaluator.
[0029] (container) The composition may be provided to the evaluator in a predetermined container. The container may be, for example, the cup described above. The size of the opening of the cup (diameter when the opening is circular, and the length of the long side when the opening is rectangular) is, for example, 40 mm to 100 mm, particularly 50 mm to 80 mm. The bottom of the cup (diameter when the bottom is circular, and the length of the long side when the opening is rectangular) is, for example, 20 mm to 80 mm, particularly 30 mm to 60 mm. The height of the cup is, for example, 30 mm to 100 mm, particularly 30 mm to 70 mm. The capacity of the cup is, for example, 50 mL to 180 mL, particularly 60 mL to 140 mL.
[0030] (Temperature control equipment) The composition to be ingested and swallowed is preferably temperature-regulated in a temperature-regulating device that regulates temperature. The device may be, for example, a heating device, a thermostatic device, or a refrigerating device. The composition may be ingested by the evaluator at a predetermined temperature. Alternatively, the composition may be ingested by the evaluator after being taken out of the device and left at room temperature for a predetermined time. These temperatures and times may be selected as appropriate.
[0031] (Processing selected expressions) The selected texture describing term is input, for example, to a recording medium in a state in which it is associated with any one of the at least one stage. For example, the selected texture describing term group may be input to the recording medium as a data table including the at least one stage and a texture describing term group associated with each stage. FIG. 3 shows an example of a data table generated by the input. The data table includes a "stage of putting into mouth" column, a "stage of crushing with tongue" column, and a "stage of swallowing" column, and the selected describing term group is listed in each column. Note that the format of the data table is not limited to this. The recording medium may be a writing medium on which a term can be written. The writing medium may be, for example, paper, a paper-like sheet, or a plastic sheet. Alternatively, the recording medium may be, for example, an information processing device, and in particular, a storage medium or a recording medium provided in the information processing device. The storage medium may be, for example, a memory. The recording medium may be, for example, an optical recording medium or a magnetic recording medium. Thus, the texture evaluation method according to the present technology includes a data table generation step of generating a data table including at least one stage included in the eating and swallowing process and a texture description term group associated with each stage, which allows the generation of the evaluation items described below to be performed more efficiently. The data table can be constructed depending on the purpose of the evaluation, for example. Therefore, by performing such a data table generation process, the accuracy of the texture evaluation can be improved. The selection of the expression terms may be performed by, for example, an expert (medical professional or product developer, etc.), and thus it is possible to build a data table using technical terms used in a particular technical field.
[0032] As described above, the selected group of texture describing terms is input to an information processing device. That is, the texture evaluation method according to the present technology may include an input receiving step of receiving input of texture describing terms associated with at least one respective stage included in the eating and swallowing process. The information processing device may execute the input receiving step. For example, the texture evaluation method according to the present technology may include the input receiving step and an evaluation result generating step of generating a texture evaluation result of the composition based on an evaluation result related to an evaluation item generated based on the input texture describing terms.
[0033] The selection may be made for each of a plurality of compositions, for example, for each of two or more compositions for which it is desired to ascertain differences in texture, or alternatively, for one composition.
[0034] (Entity performing the presentation process) In the presentation step S1, a presentation device that presents the list or a medium on which the plurality of texture description terms are displayed may perform the presentation. The medium may be, for example, a print medium such as paper, a paper-like sheet, or a plastic sheet on which the list is written. The presentation device may be a device that can output the list in a visible or audible manner, and may be, for example, a display device or a projection device. Furthermore, the presentation of the plurality of texture describing terms may be performed by an information processing device. For example, the information processing device may cause the presentation device to present the plurality of texture describing terms stored in the information processing device. An example of the configuration of the information processing device will be described in Section 2 below.
[0035] (Modification) In the present technology, it is not necessary to present a plurality of texture describing terms. For example, a term that comes up as a term expressing the texture of each of the at least one stage when a human ingests and swallows a composition may be selected as the texture describing term. For example, a human may be made to ingest and swallow a composition to be evaluated, and the human may be made to select a term expressing the texture of each of the at least one stage. The selected term may be processed as described above.
[0036] 1-2.Evaluation item generation process S2
[0037] In the evaluation item generation step S2, at least one evaluation item for evaluating the texture of the composition is generated based on the texture description terms selected for the composition. The evaluation item may be generated for at least one stage of the eating and swallowing process described in 1-1 above.
[0038] (Examples of evaluation items) Each of the evaluation items generated may be an evaluation item corresponding to one of a plurality of stages constituting the eating and swallowing process. Each of the plurality of stages corresponds to one of the at least one stage described in 1-1 above. In the evaluation item generating step S2, one or more (e.g., 2 to 10, particularly 2 to 5) evaluation items for evaluating the texture of the composition may be generated for each of the at least one stage mentioned in 1-1 above.
[0039] The at least one evaluation item may be generated based on a selected set of texture-depicting terms. By generating an evaluation item based on a selected set of texture-depicting terms, for example, the evaluation item may be more suitable as a scale for evaluating the texture of a composition.
[0040] Evaluation items generated according to the present technology may include "evaluation items corresponding to physical properties that can be measured by a machine" and / or "evaluation items that do not correspond to physical properties that can be measured by a machine." An "evaluation item corresponding to a physical property value that can be measured by a machine" may mean an evaluation item that correlates with a physical property value quantified by measurement by a machine. The "evaluation item not corresponding to a physical property value measurable by a machine" may mean an evaluation item that does not correlate with a physical property value quantified by a machine measurement. For example, as will be described in the Examples below, with respect to the hardness of a jelly, there are cases where the measurement result by a machine does not correspond to the texture evaluation result. An evaluation item that brings about such a texture evaluation result corresponds to an "evaluation item not corresponding to a physical property value measurable by a machine." Since the present technology makes it possible to perform texture evaluation regarding evaluation items that do not correspond to physical properties measurable by a machine, it is particularly useful for accurately grasping the texture of a composition.
[0041] For example, in the evaluation item generating step S2, each evaluation item may be generated based on a group of expressions having the same or similar meaning among the expressions selected as a result of performing the presenting step S1. In generating each evaluation item, each evaluation item may be generated based on a group of expressions having the same or similar meaning and a group of expressions having the opposite meaning to the group of expressions.
[0042] The at least one evaluation item is preferably an evaluation item related to a combination of a pair of symmetrical expression terms. In this specification, "a combination of a pair of symmetrical expression terms" may be "a combination of a texture expression term and a texture expression term having an opposite meaning to the texture expression term" or "a combination of a texture expression term and a texture expression term having a negated meaning to the texture expression term". Evaluation items related to a combination of a pair of symmetrical expression terms make it easier to perform scoring, which will be described later. In addition, evaluation items related to a combination of a pair of symmetrical expression terms make it easier to perform calculation of an average value and adjustment of the output method, which will be described later.
[0043] Examples of "combinations of a texture description term and a texture description term having the opposite meaning" and evaluation items related to the combinations are as follows. One or more of the following may be included in the evaluation table described below. <Examples of combinations; Examples of evaluation items related to combinations> A combination of "smooth" and "rough"; smoothness of the surface A combination of "smooth" and "sticky"; surface adhesion A combination of "hard" and "soft"; hardness A combination of "crushed" and "crushed smoothly"; Crushed style A combination of "disintegrate in the mouth" and "hold together in the mouth"; the holding together of a food bolus
[0044] Examples of "combinations of a texture description term and a texture description term having the negated meaning of the same" and evaluation items related to the combinations are as follows. One or more of the following may be included in the evaluation table described below. <Examples of combinations; Examples of evaluation items related to combinations> A combination of "elastic" and "inelastic"; elasticity A combination of "easy to swallow" and "difficult to swallow"; Ease of swallowing A combination of "little residue in the mouth" and "lots of residue in the mouth"; Residual sensation A combination of "good melt in the mouth" and "bad melt in the mouth"; A combination of "sticks in the mouth" and "doesn't stick in the mouth"; adhesiveness A combination of "good mouthfeel" and "bad mouthfeel"; Mouthfeel
[0045] In the present technology, the evaluation items are evaluation items for evaluating the texture of the composition, and may be evaluation items related to somatosensation in particular. From an anatomical and physiological viewpoint, human senses are broadly divided into special senses (e.g., taste, smell, hearing, vision, and balance), somatosensation (e.g., touch), and visceral senses. In the present technology, the evaluation items do not need to include evaluation items related to special senses and evaluation items related to visceral senses, and may be only evaluation items related to somatosensation.
[0046] (Evaluation axis included in the evaluation items) Each evaluation item may have, for example, an evaluation axis that can be scored symmetrically or an evaluation axis that is scored symmetrically, which makes it easier to calculate the average value and adjust the output method, as described below.
[0047] The "symmetrically scorable evaluation axis" may be generated using a modifying expression such as an adverb, particularly an adverb of degree. Examples of the modifying expression include "very", "quite", and "somewhat". Examples of the modifying expression include "most", "very", "quite", "fairly", "somewhat", and "slightly". For example, the evaluation axis may be formed by a group of expressions in which the same modifying expression (adverb) is added to each of the two expressions constituting the combination of the pair of symmetrical expressions. For example, for the evaluation item "hardness", as shown in FIG. 4A, the evaluation axis may include a group of expressions such as "very soft", "quite soft", "slightly soft", "slightly hard", "quite hard", and "very hard". These groups of expressions may be arranged symmetrically on the evaluation axis as shown in the same figure. In addition to these groups of expressions, the evaluation axis may include an expression term located in the center of the evaluation axis, such as "neither". Such an evaluation axis allows for symmetric scoring. For example, consider an evaluation item in which the expression term groups "very soft", "fairly soft", "slightly soft", "neutral", "slightly hard", "fairly hard", and "very hard" are arranged on the evaluation axis. Each of these expression term groups is scored into a symmetrical score in this step or the next evaluation result generation step S3. The above seven expression term groups can be scored into, for example, "-3", "-2", "-1", "0", "1", "2", and "3", but the scores after scoring are not limited to these values.
[0048] The "symmetrically scorable evaluation axis" may include, for example, symbols representing the degree of each of the two expression terms constituting the combination of the pair of symmetric expression terms. For example, the evaluation axis may include symbols such as "---", "--", and "-" as the degree of hardness, and may include symbols such as "+", "++", and "+++" as the degree of hardness, as shown in FIG. 4B. These symbols may be arranged symmetrically on the evaluation axis. In addition to the symbols representing these degrees, the evaluation axis may include a symbol located in the center of the evaluation axis, for example, a symbol such as "±". Such an evaluation axis allows for symmetric scoring. For example, "---", "--", "-", "±", "+", "++", and "+++" may be scored to "-3", "-2", "-1", "0", "1", "2", and "3", respectively.
[0049] The "symmetrically scored evaluation axis" may include, for example, a numerical value representing the degree of each of the two expressions constituting the combination of the pair of symmetrical expressions. For example, as shown in FIG. 4C, the evaluation axis may include numerical values such as "-3", "-2", and "-1" as the degree of softness, and may include numerical values such as "+1", "+2", and "+3" as the degree of hardness. These numerical values may be symmetrically arranged on the evaluation axis. In addition to the numerical values representing these degrees, the evaluation axis may include a numerical value located in the center of the evaluation axis, for example, a numerical value such as "0". The evaluation axis may be symmetrically scored in this way.
[0050] (Evaluation sheet including evaluation items) In the evaluation item generation step S2, an evaluation table used in the texture evaluation may be generated. The evaluation table may include one or more evaluation items for texture evaluation in each of the at least one stage. Each of the evaluation items may include the evaluation axis described above. An example of the evaluation table is shown in FIG. 5. The evaluation table shown in FIG. 5 has two evaluation items for the "stage of putting into the mouth", namely, "surface smoothness" and "surface adhesiveness". The evaluation axis of the evaluation item "surface smoothness" has seven evaluation stages, namely, "very smooth", "fairly smooth", "slightly smooth", "neutral", "fairly rough", "fairly rough", and "very rough". These evaluation stages may be assigned scores of "-3", "-2", "-1", "0", "1", "2", and "3", respectively, in advance. Scores may be assigned to the evaluation stages in the evaluation axis of other evaluation items in the same manner.
[0051] Such an evaluation table or evaluation items are useful for systematically and precisely understanding the texture characteristics of a composition. In addition, such an evaluation table or evaluation items can be freely arranged so as to perform an appropriate evaluation according to the purpose. For example, when verifying the difference before and after product improvements or when approaching specific feeding and swallowing disorders (such as feeding disorders and decreased saliva), it is expected that the following ideas will lead to the resolution of various issues. First, by using the above-mentioned data table prepared in advance, the content and number of evaluation items can be set more appropriately or more professionally. Next, evaluation items are set for each stage of the eating and swallowing process. Evaluation items specialized for a specific stage make it easier for the evaluator to concentrate on the evaluation at that stage. This improves the accuracy of the answers, and furthermore makes it possible to suppress variation or improve reproducibility. In addition, by setting evaluation items for each stage as described above, data with a certain quality can be obtained even by people who have not been trained in sensory evaluation or people who cannot be trained in sensory evaluation (such as patients). In addition, by setting evaluation items for each stage as described above, the number of evaluators can be reduced. For example, data with a certain quality can be obtained even with 10 or fewer people. Furthermore, such an evaluation method can be used for product evaluation that is routinely performed in product development, making it easier to accumulate data.
[0052] (Processing generated evaluation items) The evaluation items (or an evaluation table including the evaluation items) generated as described above are input to a recording medium. For example, the generated evaluation items may be input to a recording medium in the form of an evaluation table including the at least one stage and evaluation items associated with each stage. The recording medium may be a writable recording medium, for example, paper, a paper-like sheet, or a plastic sheet. Alternatively, the recording medium may be, for example, a storage medium or a recording medium provided in an information processing device. The storage medium may be, for example, a memory. The recording medium may be, for example, an optical recording medium or a magnetic recording medium.
[0053] That is, the texture evaluation method according to the present technology may include an input receiving step of receiving input of texture evaluation items associated with at least one respective stage included in the eating and swallowing process. For example, the texture evaluation method according to the present technology may include the input receiving step and an evaluation result generating step of generating a texture evaluation result of the composition based on the evaluation results related to the evaluation items.
[0054] (Entity that executes the evaluation item generation process) The generation of the evaluation items may be executed, for example, by an information processing device. For example, the information processing device may acquire a group of expressive terms selected by the term selection described in 1-1 above, and generate the evaluation items based on the acquired group of expressive terms.
[0055] 1-3. Evaluation result generation process S3
[0056] In the evaluation result generating step S3, a texture evaluation result of the jelly composition is generated based on the evaluation results for the evaluation items generated in the evaluation item generating step S2.
[0057] (Presentation of evaluation items) The texture evaluation method according to the present technology may include an evaluation item presenting step of presenting evaluation items (or an evaluation table including the evaluation items) to an evaluator. The presentation may be performed by a medium on which the evaluation item (or the evaluation table) is displayed or a presentation device that presents the evaluation item (or the evaluation table). The medium may be, for example, a print medium such as paper, a paper-like sheet, or a plastic sheet on which the evaluation item is written. The presentation device may be a device that can output the evaluation table in a visible or audible manner, and may be, for example, a display device or a projection device. The presentation may be performed by an information processing device. For example, the information processing device may cause the presentation device to present the evaluation items (or the evaluation table) stored in the device. In this manner, the present technology also provides a method for evaluating the texture of a composition, the method including carrying out the evaluation table presentation step. For example, the present technology also provides a method for evaluating texture, the method including the evaluation table presentation step and a texture evaluation result generation step of generating a result of the texture evaluation of the composition using the evaluation table.
[0058] (Evaluation of the composition) To generate an evaluation result, a texture evaluation of the composition may be performed for the evaluation items generated in the evaluation item generation step S2. To perform the texture evaluation, for example, an evaluation sheet including one or more evaluation items for texture evaluation at each of the multiple stages may be used. The evaluation sheet may be configured as a print medium such as paper or plastic, or may be displayed by a display device such as a display.
[0059] A texture evaluator of a composition eats and swallows the composition, and then writes or inputs the results of the texture evaluation for each evaluation item during the eating and swallowing into the evaluation sheet. The texture evaluator preferably performs the eating and swallowing exercise using a predetermined eating utensil, to which the description of the eating utensil described in 1-1 above applies. Preferably, the predetermined tool is the same as the tool used in the above-mentioned presenting step S1, which can further improve the evaluation accuracy. Also in this evaluation, as explained in 1-1 above, the composition may be provided to the evaluator in a state in which it has been adjusted to have a predetermined size and / or shape, and the composition may be provided to the evaluator in a state in which it is placed in a predetermined container. The composition to be ingested and swallowed is preferably temperature-adjusted in a temperature-adjusting device. This allows the conditions for texture evaluation to be unified, and the accuracy of texture evaluation to be improved. The device may be, for example, a heating device, a thermostatic device, or a refrigerating device. The composition may be ingested by the evaluator at a predetermined temperature. Alternatively, the composition may be ingested by the evaluator after being taken out of the device and after a predetermined time has elapsed at room temperature, for example. These temperatures and times may be selected as appropriate. The evaluation table may be as described in relation to the evaluation item generation step S2. For example, the evaluation items included in the evaluation table have symmetrically scorable evaluation axes or symmetrically scored evaluation axes. Evaluation is performed with respect to the evaluation items to obtain a texture evaluation result performed using the symmetrically scorable evaluation axes or symmetrically scored evaluation axes. The result may be used to generate a texture evaluation result for the composition.
[0060] The evaluation items do not have to be continuously or chronologically evaluated throughout the process of eating and swallowing the composition. For example, the evaluation items do not have to be continuously evaluated throughout the entire process of eating and swallowing when one mouthful of the composition is taken. That is, the evaluation of the composition in the present technology does not have to be an evaluation that follows the change in sensation in the eating and swallowing process over a continuous period of time. In the present technology, in the evaluation of the composition, any score among the evaluation items as described above may be selected. Such a selection places less of a burden on the evaluator than the continuous or chronological evaluation as described above. In addition, the evaluation item does not have to be evaluated by an analysis device such as a myoelectric potential measuring device. In the present technology, not only textures that can be captured by an analysis device but also textures that cannot be captured by an analysis device can be evaluated.
[0061] (Processing of evaluation results) In the evaluation result generating step S3, the information processing device accepts input of the evaluation result for each evaluation item. The input may be performed, for example, by an input device (for example, a keyboard or a mouse) provided in the information processing device. In this manner, the information processing device may obtain the evaluation result for each evaluation item. Alternatively, the information processing device may obtain the evaluation result for each evaluation item via a network.
[0062] The evaluation result generating step S3 preferably includes calculating an average value of the evaluation results for each evaluation item. For the calculation of the average value, the number of texture evaluators of the composition may be more than one, for example, 3 or more, 4 or more, or 5 or more. The number of texture evaluators of the composition may be, for example, 100 or less, 50 or less, or 30 or less.
[0063] To calculate the average value in the evaluation result generation step S3, the scores on the evaluation axis described above may be used, or scores generated by scoring the expressions or symbols on the evaluation axis may be used. An average value of the evaluation results obtained by multiple evaluators evaluating the same composition may be calculated. The average value may be calculated for each evaluation item. The average value may be used as the evaluation result for the evaluation item.
[0064] The evaluation result generating step S3 may include executing a step of calculating the correlation of the evaluation results between the evaluation items. More specifically, the correlation is a correlation coefficient. The correlation of the evaluation results between the evaluation items may be a correlation coefficient between the average value of one evaluation item and the average value of another evaluation item. The correlation of the evaluation results may be calculated, for example, for all or some of the combinations of two evaluation items selectable from all evaluation items. The correlation of the evaluation results can adjust the way in which the evaluation results are output so that they are easier to understand or easier to see. For example, when creating a graph such as a radar chart, a scatter plot, or a bar graph based on the evaluation results, the evaluation results can be made easier to understand or easier to see by adjusting the way in which the evaluation items are arranged based on the correlation.
[0065] The radar chart may be, for example, a radar chart in which each evaluation item is an axis and the average value of each evaluation item is plotted on the axis. The number of axes included in the radar chart may be, for example, 3 or more, 4 or more, or 5 or more. The upper limit of the number of axes may be, for example, 20 or less, 18 or less, or 15 or less. The radar chart may use all of the generated evaluation items as axes, or may use only some of them as axes. The radar chart may plot the texture evaluation results of multiple different compositions, or may plot the texture evaluation results of one composition at two or more different time points or under two or more different conditions.
[0066] The scatter diagram may be, for example, a scatter diagram in which one or two of the generated evaluation items are used as axes and the average values of these evaluation items are plotted. In the scatter diagram, texture evaluation results of multiple different compositions may be plotted, or texture evaluation results of one composition at two or more different time points or under two or more different conditions may be plotted. When the scatter plot has one of the generated evaluation items as an axis, for example, time may be used as another axis, thereby showing, for example, changes in texture when texture evaluation is performed on one composition at two or more different time points.
[0067] The bar graph may be a bar graph in which the average value of each evaluation item is displayed as each bar. In the bar graph, all of the generated evaluation items may be used as axes, or only some of them may be used as axes. The bar graph may have, for example, one or two quadrants. When the bar graph has two quadrants, some of the bars may be displayed in one quadrant and the remaining bars may be displayed in the other quadrant.
[0068] The evaluation result generating step S3 may include adjusting the manner of outputting the evaluation result based on at least the correlation. For example, the evaluation result generating step S3 may include adjusting the manner of outputting the evaluation result based on the correlation and the stage with which the evaluation item is associated. The adjustment based on the stage with which the evaluation item is associated may be performed so that a plurality of evaluation items associated with one stage included in the eating and swallowing process are displayed together. In other words, the adjustment may be performed so that an evaluation result for an evaluation item associated with one stage included in the eating and swallowing process is not placed between evaluation results for a plurality of evaluation items associated with other stages. For example, the output method is adjusted so that an evaluation result for an evaluation item related to the stage of putting in the mouth is not placed between evaluation results of two evaluation items related to the stage of swallowing. Then, the arrangement adjustment based on correlation described below may be performed so that the set is maintained.
[0069] For example, the adjustment of the manner in which the evaluation results are output may be an adjustment of the arrangement of the evaluation items, which may be the arrangement of the evaluation items in a graph or the arrangement of the evaluation items in a table. The adjustment of the arrangement of evaluation items based on the correlation may be, for example, placing two evaluation items with a stronger correlation closer together, and in particular, placing two evaluation items with a larger correlation coefficient closer together.
[0070] The adjustment of the manner in which the evaluation results are output may include an adjustment process of the score obtained from the filled-in or input evaluation table. The adjustment process of the score may be, for example, an inversion process of the positive / negative sign of the score obtained from the filled-in or input evaluation table, or an inversion process of the positive / negative sign of the average value calculated from the score group. When the evaluation results include a radar chart, these inversion processes may be performed, for example, so that the radar chart becomes more circular or so that the concave portions of the radar chart become less. If the evaluation results include a bar graph or scatter plot, these inversions may be performed so that more of the bars or points that make up the bar graph or scatter plot fall within one quadrant.
[0071] The evaluation result generating step S3 may include generating a graph of the evaluation result. The graph of the evaluation result may be, for example, a radar chart, a bar graph, or a scatter plot, but is not limited thereto. The graph of the evaluation result may include a graph in which the arrangement of the evaluation items is adjusted based on the correlation coefficient.
[0072] (Entity that executes the texture evaluation result generation process) The evaluation result generating step S3 may be executed by, for example, an information processing device. The information processing device may be the information processing device that executes the evaluation item generating step S2, but may also be another information processing device.
[0073] 1-4.Output process S4
[0074] The texture evaluation method according to the present technology may include an output step S4 of outputting the evaluation result generated in the evaluation result generation step S3. In the output step S4, the evaluation result may be output to a print medium such as paper or a plastic sheet, or may be output to a display medium such as a display device. For example, an information processing device that has executed the evaluation result generation step S3 may execute the output step S4.
[0075] 2.Texture evaluation system
[0076] The present technology also provides a texture evaluation system, which may be configured to perform one, two, three, or four of steps S1 to S4 described in 1 above.
[0077] An example of a texture evaluation system of the present technology is shown in Fig. 6. As shown in the figure, the texture evaluation system 1 may include, for example, one, two, or all three of an information processing device 10, a medium (particularly a list of texture describing terms) 11 in which a plurality of texture describing terms are described, and an evaluation table 12. Furthermore, the texture evaluation system 1 may include an apparatus (not shown) used to quantify the composition to be subjected to texture evaluation (or for the evaluator to eat), equipment for adjusting the temperature of the composition, or both the apparatus and the equipment. The present technology also provides a texture evaluation system including the evaluation table 12. The texture evaluation system may include the above-mentioned tool and / or facility in addition to the evaluation table 12. The texture evaluation system may further include an information processing device 10 and / or a medium 11. Using the evaluation table 12 or a combination of the evaluation table 12 with the tool and / or facility, it is possible to appropriately perform texture evaluation of a composition (particularly a jelly-like composition). These components are described below.
[0078] The information processing device 10 may be configured to execute, for example, step S3, or may be configured to execute steps S2 and S3. Specifically, the information processing device may be configured to execute an evaluation item generating step of generating evaluation items for evaluating the texture of a composition based on texture describing terms selected from a texture describing term list related to the eating and swallowing process, and an evaluation result generating step of generating texture evaluation results of the composition based on evaluation results related to the evaluation items. The information processing device 10 may further be configured to execute a presentation step S1 and / or an output step S4.
[0079] An example of the configuration of the information processing device is shown in Fig. 7. The information processing device 10 shown in Fig. 7 includes a processing unit 101, a storage unit 102, an input unit 103, an output unit 104, and a communication unit 105. The information processing device 10 may be configured by, for example, a general-purpose computer.
[0080] The processing unit 101 may include, for example, a CPU (Central Processing Unit) and a RAM. The CPU and the RAM may be connected to each other, for example, via a bus. An input / output interface may be further connected to the bus. An input unit 103, an output unit 104, and a communication unit 105 may be connected to the bus via the input / output interface.
[0081] The processing unit 101 may further be configured to obtain data from the storage unit 102 or record data in the storage unit 102. The storage unit 102 stores various data. The storage unit 102 may be configured to store, for example, any one or more of the following data: Data on the list of expressions presented in the presentation step S1; data relating to the set of descriptive terms selected in the presentation step S1 (e.g. a data table including the at least one stage and a set of texture descriptive terms associated with each stage); Data regarding the evaluation items generated in the evaluation item generation step S2; Data used to generate the evaluation items generated in the evaluation item generation step S2; Data on an evaluation table including the evaluation items generated in the evaluation item generation step S2; and Texture evaluation result data generated in the evaluation result generating step S3; The storage device may be configured to store data related to the judgment results in the judgment step.
[0082] The storage unit 102 may also store an operating system (e.g., WINDOWS (registered trademark), UNIX (registered trademark), or LINUX (registered trademark), a program for causing the information processing device 10 (particularly, the processing unit) to execute a texture evaluation method according to the present technology (particularly, at least one step included in the method), and various other programs. Note that these programs may be recorded on a recording medium, not limited to the storage unit 102.
[0083] The input unit 103 may include an interface configured to be able to accept input of various data, and may include, for example, a mouse, a keyboard, a touch panel, and the like as devices for accepting such operations.
[0084] The output unit 104 may include an interface configured to be able to output various data. For example, the output unit 104 may output a texture evaluation result in the output process. The output unit 104 may include, for example, a display device and / or a printing device as a device for performing the output.
[0085] The communication unit 105 may be configured to connect the information processing device 10 to a network in a wired or wireless manner. The communication unit 105 allows the information processing device 10 to acquire various data via the network. The acquired data may be stored in the storage unit 102, for example. The configuration of the communication unit 105 may be appropriately selected by a person skilled in the art.
[0086] The information processing device 10 may include, for example, a drive (not shown). The drive can read data (for example, the various data listed above) or programs recorded in a recording medium and output them to the RAM. The recording medium is, for example, a microSD memory card, an SD memory card, or a flash memory, but is not limited to these.
[0087] The description term list 11 includes a plurality of texture description terms and is referred to in selecting a description term for generating an evaluation item for evaluating the texture of a composition. The description term list may be as described in 1 above.
[0088] Evaluation sheet 12 is filled in with the texture evaluation results when the composition is ingested and swallowed. The evaluation sheet may be as described in 1 above, and may include, for example, evaluation items for texture evaluation at each of a plurality of stages included in the ingestion and swallowing process, and evaluation axes corresponding to the evaluation items. The evaluation items and the evaluation axes may also be as described in 1 above. Evaluation sheet 12 may be presented to the evaluator in a state where it is printed on a print medium (i.e., as an evaluation sheet), or may be presented to the evaluator in a state where it is displayed on a display device.
[0089] The tool may be used to quantify the composition to be texture-evaluated and / or to allow the evaluator to eat the composition. The tool may be configured to enable the quantification and / or eating. The quantification allows the conditions for texture evaluation to be standardized, and the accuracy of the texture evaluation to be improved. The tool preferably has a predetermined capacity, and may be configured, for example, to accommodate the amount of the composition to be eaten for texture evaluation. The shape of the tool may be appropriately selected depending on the type of composition to be texture-evaluated. The tool may be, for example, a dish for putting the composition into the oral cavity. For example, when the composition is a jelly-like composition, the tool may be a spoon or a spoon-like dish. The tool may be a fork, chopsticks, or a cup. The equipment is configured to adjust the temperature of the composition, and may be, for example, a heating equipment, a thermostatic equipment, or a refrigeration equipment. For example, when the composition is a jelly-like composition, the equipment may be a refrigeration equipment. The equipment can standardize the conditions for texture evaluation, and can improve the accuracy of the texture evaluation.
[0090] The present technology will be described in more detail below with reference to examples, but the present technology is not limited to these examples.
[0091] 3. Working Example
[0092] The texture assessment method according to the present technique may be carried out, for example, as follows.
[0093] 3-1. Selection of expression terms The following terms are selected to describe the texture of jelly foods for medical and nursing care. (1) Prepare multiple types of jellies, and have multiple evaluators eat the multiple types of jellies using a specified utensil. The jellies may be stored in a temperature-controlled facility (e.g., a refrigerator) and may be removed from the facility when eaten. (2) Each evaluator divides the process from putting the jelly in the mouth to swallowing it into three stages: "when you put it in your mouth (for example, the moment you put it in your mouth)," "when you crush it with your tongue," and "when you swallow it," and writes down on a sheet of paper the terms that come to mind for the texture felt at each stage. This procedure is repeated for each of the multiple types of jelly.
[0094] 3-2. Tabulation of expression terms For each of the above three stages, the expressions selected by the multiple evaluators are input into an information processing device and categorized, for example, as follows: (1) The evaluation terms selected in 3-1 above are input to an information processing device in a state associated with each stage. The information processing device, which receives the input of the expressions, generates a data table including a group of expressions associated with each stage. An example of the data table is shown in FIG. 3 described above. (2) The information processing device generates a data table in which, for each stage, a certain expression term, an expression term similar to the certain expression term, an expression term having an opposite meaning to the certain expression term, and an expression term similar to the expression term having the opposite meaning are grouped together as one category. For example, the category of the expression term may be changed or the expression term may be deleted by a person performing the evaluation. An example of the data table is shown in FIG. 8. The data table includes one or more categories for each stage. One or more expression terms are associated with each category.
[0095] 3-3. Creating a texture evaluation sheet Based on the expressions categorized as above, evaluation items are generated, for example, as follows: (1) The name of the evaluation item is selected based on the expression term group included in each category. The name of each evaluation item may be set based on the characters present in the expression term group included in each category. The name of the evaluation item may be automatically given by, for example, an information processing device based on the expression term group included in each category. Alternatively, the information processing device may accept an input of the name of the evaluation item selected by a human being based on the expression term group included in each category. In addition, the name of the evaluation item may be selected for all the generated categories, or the name of the evaluation item may be selected only for some of all the generated categories. For example, the name of the evaluation item may be selected only for the category with a large number of expression terms included in the category, for example, the name of the evaluation item may be selected only for the category with the top 1 to 10, for example, 1 to 5, in terms of the number of expression terms, and the selected name may be adopted as the evaluation item. The evaluation item adopted in this way is more suitable for texture evaluation of the composition. (2) An evaluation axis is set for each evaluation item. For example, the evaluation axis for the evaluation item "hardness" includes seven symmetrically structured evaluation stages: "very hard," "fairly hard," "slightly hard," "neither hard nor hard," "fairly soft," "fairly soft," and "very soft." Symmetrical scores of "+3," "+2," "+1," "0," "-1," "-2," and "-3" are assigned to each of these evaluation stages. The evaluation axis of each evaluation item may be generated by the information processing device based on the name of the evaluation item and / or the expression term included in the category to which the name of the evaluation item is attached, and predetermined evaluation axis setting information. The evaluation axis setting information may include, for example, information on the number of evaluation stages, information on the type of modifier, and information on the score assigned to each evaluation stage. Alternatively, the information processing device may accept input of the names of evaluation items selected by a human being based on the group of expressions included in each category. (3) For other categories, the names of the evaluation items are assigned and the evaluation axis is set in the same manner as in (2) above. The number of evaluation stages on the evaluation axis may be the same for the evaluation items included in each stage, or may be the same for all evaluation items. The assigned scores may also be the same for the evaluation items included in each stage, or may be the same for all evaluation items. (4) The information processing device generates an evaluation table including the evaluation items set as described above and the evaluation axis for each evaluation item. An example of the evaluation table is as described above with reference to FIG. 5. The information processing device may output the evaluation table to a printing device to obtain an evaluation sheet. Alternatively, the information processing device may output the evaluation table to a display device, and the output evaluation table may be used as the evaluation sheet.
[0096] 3-4. Preparation and evaluation of the composition to be evaluated A plurality of evaluators eat and swallow a plurality of types of jellies to be evaluated using a specified tool, and enter the evaluation results of the texture during eating and swallowing in the evaluation sheet. For example, the corresponding evaluation level is selected from among a plurality of evaluation levels on the evaluation axis of each evaluation item in the evaluation sheet. The jelly may be stored in a temperature-controlled facility (eg, a refrigerator) and removed from the facility prior to the ingestion.
[0097] 3-5. Input and graph evaluation results The evaluation results obtained in 3-4 above are input to an information processing device. The information processing device calculates an average value from the scores of all evaluators for each evaluation item. The information processing device then uses these average values to generate texture evaluation results. The texture evaluation results may include, for example, a table including the average values and / or a graph generated based on the average values. The graph may be, for example, a radar chart, a scatter plot, or a bar graph, but is not limited to these.
[0098] In the graphing, the information processing device may perform a process of inverting the positive and negative values of the average values, for example, so that a radar chart becomes more circular, or so that more points in a scatter plot or more bars in a bar graph are included in one quadrant.
[0099] In the graphing, the information processing device may execute a process of calculating a correlation coefficient between the average values. Then, the information processing device may execute an arrangement adjustment process of adjusting the arrangement of the evaluation items in the graph based on the calculated correlation coefficient. The arrangement adjustment process may be executed, for example, so that a radar chart becomes closer to a circle, or so that more points in a scatter plot or more bars in a bar graph are included in one quadrant. The arrangement adjustment process may be executed so that an evaluation item associated with a certain stage is not placed between two evaluation items associated with other stages.
[0100] The information processing device may execute one of the positive / negative reversal process and the layout adjustment process, or may execute both of them.
[0101] 3-6. Example of texture evaluation results 1 (Radar chart)
[0102] As described above in 3-1. to 3-5., the texture evaluation was performed for three types of jelly compositions (referred to as samples 1 to 3), and the average value for each evaluation item was calculated. Figures 9 and 10 show radar charts generated using the calculated average values. The line connecting the plots of each sample in the radar chart shown in FIG. 9 includes a concave portion toward the center, and it is also difficult to compare the evaluation results of the three samples. Therefore, the positive / negative inversion process was performed on a portion of the average values of each evaluation item used to generate the radar chart of FIG. 9. In addition, the layout adjustment process was performed based on the average values between each evaluation item. The radar chart obtained by performing these processes is shown in FIG. 10. In the layout adjustment process, the correlation coefficient of the average values was calculated for all combinations of two evaluation items. Then, the layout of the evaluation items was adjusted so that the group of evaluation items included in each stage was maintained in a clustered state, and so that combinations with higher correlation coefficients were arranged closer to each other. The radar chart shown in Fig. 10 makes it easier to compare the texture evaluation results of the three types of samples compared to the radar chart shown in Fig. 9. In this way, the positive / negative reversal process and / or the arrangement adjustment process make it possible to more accurately grasp the texture change.
[0103] Next, the texture of the three types of jelly compositions (samples 4 to 6) was evaluated using a texture evaluation sheet. The texture evaluation sheet had 10 evaluation items, which was more than the sheet used in the evaluation of samples 1 to 3 (which had 6 evaluation items). The average value for each evaluation item was calculated. Figures 11 and 12 show radar charts generated using the calculated average values. Among the results shown in Figs. 11 and 12, evaluation items 1-1 and 1-2 are evaluation items related to "when placed in the mouth". Evaluation items 2-1 to 2-4 are evaluation items related to "when crushed with the tongue". Evaluation items 3-1 to 3-4 are evaluation items related to "when swallowed". The line connecting the plots of each sample in the radar chart shown in FIG. 11 includes a concave portion toward the center, and it is also difficult to compare the evaluation results of the three samples. Therefore, the above-mentioned positive / negative inversion process was performed on some of the average values of each evaluation item used to generate the radar chart in Fig. 11. In addition, the above-mentioned layout adjustment process was performed based on the average values between each evaluation item. The radar chart obtained by performing these processes is shown in Fig. 12. The radar chart shown in Fig. 12 makes it easier to compare the texture evaluation results of the three types of samples than the radar chart shown in Fig. 11. In this way, the positive / negative reversal process and / or the arrangement adjustment process make it possible to more accurately grasp the texture change.
[0104] Furthermore, in the radar chart, it may be difficult to compare the evaluation results between samples, especially when there are many evaluation items, as shown in Fig. 11 where the number of evaluation items is 10. Therefore, by performing the positive / negative inversion process and / or the layout adjustment process according to the present technology, it becomes easier to compare the evaluation results between samples, as shown in Fig. 12. Therefore, the present technology is particularly effective when there are many evaluation items, for example, when the number of evaluation items is 6 or more, 7 or more, 8 or more, 9 or more, or 10 or more. That is, the number of evaluation items shown in the radar chart may be 6 or more, 7 or more, 8 or more, 9 or more, or 10 or more. The number of evaluation items shown in the radar chart may be, for example, 20 or less, 15 or less.
[0105] 3-7. Example 2 of texture evaluation results (scatter plot)
[0106] As described in 3-1. to 3-5. above, texture evaluation was performed on four types of jelly compositions (referred to as samples 7 to 10), and the average value for each evaluation item was calculated. The texture evaluation was performed immediately after taking these jelly compositions out of the refrigerator (approximately 2°C to 5°C) and into a room temperature environment (15°C to 25°C) (0 minutes after leaving them at room temperature) and after taking them out of the room temperature environment for 40 minutes (40 minutes after leaving them at room temperature). Figures 13 and 14 show scatter plots of the average values of hardness (when placed in the mouth) and adhesiveness (when swallowed).
[0107] 13 and 14 show that the texture changes between 0 minute and 40 minutes after being left at room temperature. Although the texture of the same composition changes depending on the temperature, the change in texture is difficult to grasp and to quantify. From the above graph, it can be seen that such a change in texture can be accurately grasped by the texture evaluation method according to the present technology. Thus, the evaluation method according to the present technology may be used to evaluate the texture change with change in temperature of a composition, or may be used to evaluate the texture change of a composition over time.
[0108] 3-8. Example 3 of texture evaluation results (bar graph)
[0109] As described in 3-1. to 3-5. above, texture evaluation was performed on one type of jelly composition (referred to as sample 11), and the average value for each evaluation item was calculated. The texture evaluation was performed at the start of storage of the sample, after 3 weeks of storage, after 6 weeks of storage, and after 12 weeks of storage. Furthermore, the hardness was measured at these four time points using an analytical machine (creep meter, Yamaden Co., Ltd.). Figure 15 shows the results of the hardness measurement using the analytical machine for sample 11 and the average value for the evaluation item "hardness."
[0110] From the results shown in FIG. 15, it can be seen that the hardness of sample 11 measured by the analytical instrument remains almost unchanged after 12 weeks of storage, but the texture evaluation method according to the present technology shows that the texture has changed, in particular that it has gradually become softer. The above results show that the texture evaluation method according to the present technology makes it possible to accurately grasp texture and its changes that cannot be grasped by physical property values quantified by an analytical device.
Claims
1. an evaluation item generating step of generating evaluation items corresponding to three or more stages obtained by classifying the eating and swallowing process into a plurality of stages based on time series or action, for evaluating the texture of the jelly-like composition based on texture describing terms selected from a plurality of texture describing terms related to the eating and swallowing process; and performing an evaluation result generating step of generating a texture evaluation result of the jelly-like composition based on the evaluation results for the evaluation items; The texture evaluation method, wherein the evaluation result generating step includes calculating a correlation coefficient of evaluation results by evaluators between the evaluation items.
2. The texture evaluation method according to claim 1 , wherein each of the evaluation items corresponds to one of a plurality of stages constituting the eating and swallowing process.
3. The texture evaluation method according to claim 1 , wherein the evaluation items are generated based on a selected group of texture describing terms.
4. The texture evaluation method according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein the evaluation results for the evaluation items are the results of texture evaluation performed using evaluation axes that can be scored symmetrically or evaluation axes to which scores are set symmetrically.
5. 5. The texture evaluation method according to claim 1, wherein the evaluation result generating step includes calculating an average value of the evaluation results for each evaluation item.
6. 6. The texture evaluation method according to claim 1, wherein the evaluation result generating step includes adjusting a manner of outputting the evaluation result based on at least the correlation coefficient.
7. 7. The texture evaluation method according to claim 1, wherein the evaluation result generating step includes generating a graph of the evaluation result.
8. The texture evaluation method according to claim 7 , wherein the graphed evaluation results include a graph in which a layout of evaluation items is adjusted based on the correlation coefficient.
9. an evaluation item generating step of generating evaluation items corresponding to three or more stages obtained by classifying the eating and swallowing process into a plurality of stages based on time series or action, for evaluating the texture of the composition, based on texture describing terms selected from a plurality of texture describing terms related to the eating and swallowing process; and performing an evaluation result generating step of generating a texture evaluation result of the composition based on the evaluation results regarding the evaluation items; The texture evaluation method, wherein the evaluation result generating step includes calculating a correlation coefficient of evaluation results by evaluators between the evaluation items.
10. an evaluation item generating step of generating evaluation items corresponding to three or more stages obtained by classifying the eating and swallowing process into a plurality of stages based on time series or action, for evaluating the texture of the jelly-like composition based on texture describing terms selected from a plurality of texture describing terms related to the eating and swallowing process; carrying out an evaluation result generating step of generating a texture evaluation result of the jelly-like composition based on the evaluation results for the evaluation items; The information processing device, wherein the evaluation result generating step includes calculating a correlation coefficient of evaluation results by evaluators between the evaluation items.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Organoleptic estimation system
JP1998267912A
Method for evaluating stickiness in food
JP2014062897A
Dynamic time sensory evaluation method of food and food
JP2018124106A
Method for evaluating food product texture and method for manufacturing food products
JP2018134361A
Method for evaluating texture of food
JP2019052901A
