Redundant controls for compressor systems
The Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT) in compressor systems addresses surge issues by substituting failed sensor data with Last Good Values and estimates, ensuring reliable and cost-effective operation without additional hardware redundancy.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- US19/089948
- Authority / Receiving Office
- US · United States
- Patent Type
- Applications(United States)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2025-03-25
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-12
AI Technical Summary
Industrial compressor systems face instability and potential damage due to surge when field instrument failures disrupt antisurge and capacity control, leading to unsafe operation and increased costs from dual or triple redundant transmitters.
Implement a Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT) that uses Last Good Value and estimated values, combined with statistical correlation and physical principles, to substitute failed sensor data, maintaining system operation without additional hardware redundancy.
Enhances system reliability and safety by allowing continuous operation with reduced costs and complexity, using existing measurements and digital models to ensure steady-state conditions and adjust control strategies.
Smart Images

Figure US20260357809A1-D00000_ABST
Abstract
Description
TECHNICAL FIELD
[0001] This disclosure is generally directed to the operation of industrial compressor systems. More specifically, the disclosure relates to redundant control systems used to control and provide safe operation of industrial compressors.BACKGROUND
[0002] Various industries, such as but not limited to the oil and gas industry, utilize centrifugal and axial compressors for raising the pressure of various fluids, such as natural gas, for the purpose of transporting them from one location to another, or as a part of the refining and petrochemical process. Using natural gas as an example, natural gas may be supplied to an inlet of a compressor system, which may include one compressor or multiple compressors, wherein in multiple compressor systems the individual compressors may be arranged in series or in parallel with one another. Moreover, each compressor may be comprised of several sections, each having its own inlet and outlet. The compressed natural gas, after exiting the compressor system, may be coupled to a pipeline for transporting to one or more different locations, or directed for further processing, such as fractionation, or other processes that may be present in oil and gas industries. Compressors play a crucial role in many processes and consume a major portion of the overall energy needs. Therefore, reliable and efficient operation of compressors constitutes a key priority for the operators. To this end, each compressor may be equipped with a control system, which includes antisurge control and protection, and capacity control. Actions of the capacity control systems result in varying the energy input to the compressor driver, which may be a steam or a gas turbine, or an electric motor, resulting in changing the rotational speed of the compressor and hence its throughput, or it may act on the compressor throughput directly via, for example, a throttling valve. Capacity control system matches the throughput of the compressor network to the needs of the overall process, thus minimizing power consumption. Centrifugal and axial compressors, or turbo-compressors, have a low throughput limitation, which depends on the maximum pressure rise that the machine can deliver. The low flow boundary is termed Surge Limit; beyond Surge Limit the compressor's operating point enters the so-called surge region leading to unstable operation, which may lead to machine damage. Anitsurge control system monitors compressor throughput and, if the flow decreases below a minimum acceptable level, acts on the recirculating (recycle) or blow-off valve in order to prevent any further decrease in the throughput. In general, safe operation of turbo-compressors requires antisurge control for preventing process upsets, outages, and machine damage. Proper operation of both capacity and antisurge control systems depends on receiving correct field measurements, such as flows, pressures, and temperatures, via sensors and transducers installed at various locations in the process and around the machine. Failure of the field instruments may prevent normal operation of the control system, leading to decreased efficiencies, or potential unsafe operation with respect to compressor surge.SUMMARY
[0003] Embodiments as described in this disclosure include systems, apparatus, methods, and techniques for providing redundant control of compressor system, such as but not limited to industrial compressor systems.
[0004] An illustrative and non-limiting embodiment incudes a method comprising: determining one or more control values to be applied by a compressor control application to control operations being performed by a compressor system, wherein determining the one or more control values includes: determining that a transmitter of data indicative of an operational parameter of the compressor system has failed, determining an alternative input value for the operational parameter of the control system that was previously provided by the transmitted that has failed; and providing, through a Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT), the alternative input value to the compressor control application for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value, wherein determining the alternative input value comprises using a Last Good Value provided by the transmitter prior to the failure of the transmitter based on a determination that the compressor system is operating in a steady state condition despite the failure of the transmitter, and using an estimated value for the alternative input value when a determination is made that the compressor system is not operating in a steady state condition following the failure of the transmitter.
[0005] Additionally or alternatively, the method may further include wherein the operational parameter represents a required control input parameter to the process control application in order to maintain control of the compressor system. Additionally or alternatively, the method may further include wherein a steady state condition of the operation of the compressor system is defined as having data provided for the operating parameters of the compressor system from a set of all transmitters that have not failed and that are providing data indicative of operating parameter values that are all within ranges determined to represent normal operating ranges for each of the parameters. Additionally or alternatively, the method may further comprise: continuing to operate the compressor system using a primary signal value comprising the Last Good Value that existed prior to the failure of the transmitter. Additionally or alternatively, the method may further include wherein the determination that the compressor system is operating in a steady state condition despite the failure of the transmitter uses the physical principles of turbomachinery operation to determine whether the compressor system is or is not operating in a steady-state condition.
[0006] Additionally or alternatively, the method may further include wherein the Last Good Value for use as the alternative input value is generated internally by the VRT based on a plurality of input signals provided to the VRT from an input signal processing algorithm operating on a plurality of input signals provided by a plurality of transmitters of the compressor system. Additionally or alternatively, the method may further comprise: providing the Last Good Value as the alternative input value to the compressor control application for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value while the compressor system remains operating in the steady state condition; determining that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition; and providing the estimated value for the alternative input value for the continued operation of the compressor system based on the determination that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition. Additionally or alternatively, the method may further comprise: determining regions of the operation of the compressor system where it is safe to use the estimated value for the alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system.
[0007] Additionally or alternatively, the method may further comprise: applying a statistical correlation, covering both a static and a dynamic behavior of the compressor system, for determining the validity of using the estimated value as an alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system. Additionally or alternatively, the method may further comprise: automatically adjusting a configuration of the compressor system, including adjusting the configuration of the anti-surge system, so that a surge margin increases when Last Good Value or the estimated value is used. Additionally or alternatively, the method may further comprise: performing a mathematical transformation of a secondary signal being provided by a healthy transmitter operating to provide data indicative of an operational parameter of the compressor system to match a value of a primary signal previously being provided by the failed transmitter.
[0008] Another non-limiting illustrative embodiments includes a process control system for controlling the operation of a compressor system, the process control system comprising: a computer system including a processor and at least one memory device communicatively coupled to the processor, the at least one memory device including program instructions, which when executed by the processor, cause the processor to: determine one or more control values to be applied by a compressor control application to control operations being performed by a compressor system while the compressor system is operating to receive a gas or vapor at an input to the compressor system at a first pressure, and to output the gas or vapor in a compressed state at an output of the compressor system at a second pressure that is higher than the first pressure; wherein the instructions for determining the one or more control values include instructions to cause the processor to: determine that a transmitter of data indicative of an operational parameter of the control system has failed, determining an alternative input value for the operational parameter of the control system that was previously provided by the transmitted that has failed; and provide, through a Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT), the alternative input value to the compressor control system for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value, wherein determining the alternative input value comprises using a Last Good Value provided by the transmitter prior to the failure of the transmitter based on a determination that the compressor system is operating in a steady state condition despite the failure of the transmitter, and using an estimated value for the alternative input value when a determination is made that the compressor system is not operating in a steady state condition following the failure of the transmitter.
[0009] Additionally or alternatively, the process control system may further include wherein the process control system is configured to continue to operate the compressor system using a primary signal value comprising the Last Good Value that existed prior to the failure of the transmitter. Additionally or alternatively, the process control system may further include the process control system further configured to: provide the Last Good Value as the alternative input value to the compressor control application for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value while the compressor system remains operating in the steady state condition; determine that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition; and provide the estimated value for the alternative input value for the continued operation of the compressor system based on the determination that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition. Additionally or alternatively, the process control system may further include wherein the process control system is further configured to determine regions of the operation of the compressor system where it is safe to use the estimated value for the alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system.
[0010] Additionally or alternatively, the process control system may further include wherein the process control system is further configured to apply a statistical correlation, covering both a static and a dynamic behavior of the compressor system, for determining the validity of using the estimated value as an alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system. Additionally or alternatively, the process control system may further include wherein the process control system is further configured to perform a mathematical transformation of a secondary signal being provide by a healthy transmitter operating to provide data indicative of an operational parameter of the compressor system to match a value of a primary signal previously being provided by the failed transmitter.
[0011] Another non-limiting illustrative embodiment includes a non-transitory computer readable medium storing computer readable instructions that, when executed by a processor, cause the processor to: determine one or more control values to be applied by a compressor control application to control operations being performed by a compressor system while the compressor system is operating, wherein the instructions for determining the one or more control values include instructions to cause the processor to: determine that a transmitter of data indicative of an operational parameter of the control system has failed, determining an alternative input value for the operational parameter of the control system that was previously provided by the transmitted that has failed; provide, through a Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT), the alternative input value to the compressor control system for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value, wherein determining the alternative input value comprises using a Last Good Value provided by the transmitter prior to the failure of the transmitter based on a determination that the compressor system is operating in a steady state condition despite the failure of the transmitter, and using an estimated value for the alternative input value when a determination is made that the compressor system is not operating in a steady state condition following the failure of the transmitter.
[0012] Additionally or alternatively, the non-transitory computer readable medium may further include wherein the computer readable instructions, when executed by the processor, cause the processor to apply a statistical correlation, covering both a static and a dynamic behavior of the compressor system, for determining the validity of using the estimated value as an alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system. Additionally or alternatively, the non-transitory computer readable medium may further include wherein the computer readable instructions, when executed by the processor, cause the processor to: provide the Last Good Value as the alternative input value to the compressor control application for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value while the compressor system remains operating in the steady state condition; determine that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition; and provide the estimated value for the alternative input value for the continued operation of the compressor system based on the determination that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition.BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0013] For a more complete understanding of this disclosure, reference is now made to the following description, taken in conjunction with the accompanying drawings. The figures discussed below, and the various embodiments used to describe the principles of the present invention in this patent document are by way of illustration only and should not be construed in any way to limit the scope of the invention. Those skilled in the art will understand that the principles of the invention may be implemented in any type of suitably arranged device or system.
[0014] FIG. 1 is a schematic block diagram of a multi-section compressor system incorporating various flow, pressure, and temperature measurement points, in accordance with various embodiments.
[0015] FIG. 2 is a block diagram illustrating the implementation of a Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT) in a compressor control system, in accordance with various embodiments.
[0016] FIG. 3 is a functional block diagram of an implementation of a VRT logic, in accordance with various embodiments.
[0017] FIG. 4 is a diagram of a state machine that defines states of operation of a VRT functional block, in accordance with various embodiments.
[0018] FIG. 5 is flowchart of a method for operating a compressor control system, in accordance with various embodiments.
[0019] FIG. 6 is a block diagram illustrating computer system, in accordance with various embodiments.DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0020] The software implementation of a compressor control systems may be comprised of one or more applications, for example, capacity control or performance application, and an antisurge application. Each application receives process measurements regarding the operation of a compressor system from transmitters coupled to sensors measuring one or more parameters of the compressor control system, such as temperatures, pressures, and flow rates. The transmitters produce signals indicative of the sensed parameters to a control system, such as a computer control system, configured to oversee and control the operation of the compressor system. Whenever a transmitter or sensor fails, control applications switch to a special mode of operation called “fallback strategy”. These fallback strategies are designed to improve robustness of the control system and ultimately, availability of the equipment. At the same time, in many situations activation of fallback strategies introduces disturbances to the overall process since they have to balance between keeping the process running as efficiently as possible and keeping the unit safe in a situation when not all measurements are available.
[0021] To prevent a situation when transmitter failure results in a process upset, unsafe operation, or a complete loss of production, users sometimes install dual redundant or even triple redundant transmitters, resulting in an increased cost and complexity of the installation, considering additional wiring and instrumentation. At the same time, often the measurements that the compressor control system receives may already have a degree of redundancy, since gas parameters, such as pressure, may not vary significantly at different sensor locations along the gas path. The measurements may not be identical due to friction losses or the presence of other equipment, such as heat exchangers and valves between the measurement locations, however their behavior may be such, that, under certain conditions, one can be used in lieu of the other.
[0022] Traditional redundancy requires additional materials and physical space relative to non-redundant (simplex) installation and therefore results in increased installation and maintenance costs. This new approach will allow users to benefit from redundancy without installing additional physical devices, for those measurements where it is possible, for example as shown in FIG. 1. Such an approach will increase the reliability of the system without the need for additional equipment.
[0023] This disclosure describes embodiments of a method of increasing the reliability of the control system for turbomachinery, such as compressors, by substituting the primary process measurement with a secondary measurement in case the primary measurement fails, and the secondary measurement has been determined to be a valid representation of the primary measurement. Turbomachinery in process applications, such as Oil and Gas and Petrochemical industries, has multiple operating modes, some of which may preclude using secondary value as a valid representation of the primary. Secondary measurement can be another transmitter signal connected to the system, or a value generated by the digital model of the compressor and the associated process in the control system. The proposed method uses statistical correlation and physical relationship between the primary and secondary measurements, as well as the physical operating principles of the turbomachinery unit to determine:
[0024] When the turbomachinery unit can continue to operate with the primary signal value that existed prior to the failure (Last Good Value or LGV) and without the need to use the secondary value. The method uses the physical principles of turbomachinery operation to determine the unit's steady-state condition. If steady-state condition exists, then the system uses LGV, avoiding switching to the secondary signal altogether.
[0025] Mathematical transformation of the secondary signal is used to match the primary signal for minimizing the effect on the process when the control system switches from the primary signal to the secondary signal, since the secondary signal will not, in general, have the same value as the primary signal. The system begins using the secondary signal when the steady state conditions no longer exist and LGV is no longer a valid representation of the associated process parameter. Transformation may use other parameters, besides the primary signal itself, for developing an estimation of the primary signal.
[0026] Regions of the operation of the turbomachinery unit where it is safe to use the secondary signal as a substitution for the primary signal.
[0027] Statistical correlation, covering both static and dynamic behavior of the signals, for determining the validity of using the secondary signal as a representation of the primary signal. Automatic adjustment in the configuration of the control system, and particularly the of anti-surge system, in a way so that surge margin increases when secondary value is used.
[0028] The anti-surge control system for turbo-compressors uses several measurements, including pressures, temperatures, and differential pressure from a flow measuring device (FMD). In case of failure of any one of these signals, a so-called fallback strategy is used in order to continue to operate the unit, albeit most likely with reduced throughput, negatively affecting plant Key Performance Indicators (KPIs). Fallback strategies use different algorithms, which exclude failed signals, however the system operates assuming worst-case scenarios, often resulting in recirculation around the compressor and thus a reduction in the efficiency.
[0029] In many process compressor applications, there may be several measurements that under certain circumstances provide similar readings. For example, for a multi-section compressor, suction measurements of the second section will be closely related to the discharge pressure of the first section when the unit is running and there is forward flow from the first section to the second. Please see FIG. 1. PT-12 and PT-21 may provide similar measurements if the non-return valve between the sections remains open. The measurements will differ due to the pressure losses across piping, heat exchanger and the inlet scrubber. Therefore, under these circumstances, it may be beneficial to use a healthy signal from one section in place of a failed signal from the adjacent section. However, two issues precluded using adjacent measurements in lieu of each other:
[0030] 1. The signals are not identical—there will be differences due to the piping, vessel, and cooler pressure drops. The differences may be large enough to cause either overly conservative operation of the control system (resulting in recirculation), or unsafe operation, i.e., surging of the compressor. The signals may also have a varying degree of time delays in between them.
[0031] 2. The signals may not be used in lieu of each other under certain circumstances, for example, when each section is recirculating and the non-return valve between the sections is closed. In this case the pressures between the first and second sections represent different measurement points, not related to each other.
[0032] Embodiments of the methodology and techniques as described herein solve issues related to item 1. above by:
[0033] 1. Transforming the secondary signal to match the primary signal, using physical principles, for example, pressure drop is proportional to the square of the mass flow in a pipe, and statistical regression methods. The secondary value may include safety factor or bias, representing the uncertainty in its calculation. This bias, when used, is always applied in the direction of increasing the protection of turbomachinery based on its usage in the control algorithms including limiting loops.
[0034] 2. Determining the region of operation where the substitution can be applied with high reliability. For example, the transformation described in (a) may be derived while the unit has been operating within a certain region. If the operating point moves outside of this region, then the substitution may no longer be valid. This also applies in case where a model generates the secondary signal. Such a model may have a high degree of reliability only within a certain operating region.
[0035] 3. Automatically adjusting the parameters of the control system to operate in a more conservative manner. For example, anti-surge margin can be increased when operating with a secondary signal value by an amount that may be dynamically determined according to the degree of uncertainty in utilizing the secondary signal (e.g. predicted maximum error).
[0036] Embodiments of the methodology and techniques described herein solve issues related to item 2. above by:
[0037] Using statistical correlation, thus ensuring that substitution can occur with a high degree of confidence; and
[0038] Using physical principles, for example, estimating the forward flow of a compressor section for determining the position of the non-return valve as a condition for allowing substitution. Physical signals, such as position indication of the isolating valves, can be used as well.
[0039] Embodiments as disclosed herein also include a steady-state detector, which allows the use of LGV of a failed signal for while steady-state conditions remain valid, thus avoiding switching to a secondary value for as long as possible. Steady-state detector monitors several turbomachinery parameters (i.e., pressures, flows, rotating speed, etc.). As long as these are determined to be stationary, the entire unit is considered as operating at a steady state.
[0040] Advantages of the systems, apparatus, methods, and techniques as described in this disclosure over existing compressor control system include at least but are not limited to the following:
[0041] 1. Use of Last Good Value as an alternative value for data no longer being provided to a compressor control application due to a transmitter failure;
[0042] 2. Use of continuous monitoring to determine steady state model for operation of the compressor control system;
[0043] 3. Correlation between adjacent data sensors / transmitters providing data from different locations within the compressor system but determined to be related in a definable manner, so that the correlations can be used to generate a virtual redundant transmitter capable of outputting acceptable values to replace the operational data no longer being provide by a failed or unhealthy transmitter; and
[0044] 4. Use of a safety factor when substituting control parameter(s) for operating a compressor system that has been generated by a virtual redundant transmitter for measured data that is no longer being provided to the compressor control application controlling the operation of the compressor system.
[0045] FIG. 1 is a schematic block diagram of a multi-section compressor system 100 incorporating typical sensors and transmitters, in accordance with various embodiments. Multi-section compressor system (system 100) as shown in FIG. 1 includes a three-section compressor, including a first compressor section 110, a second compressor section 120, and a third compressor section 130. All sections are coupled to the same compressor shaft 102 and connected to the prime mover 101, which provides rotational motion to the compressor. Prime mover may be a steam or a gas turbine, an electric motor or the like. From the inlet suction header 103, gas flows into suction scrubber 119, and then into the suction pipe 113 of the first compressor section 110, where it is compressed and delivered to the discharge pipe 115. Cooler 116 reduces gas temperature before entering suction vessel 129 of the second compressor section via suction pipe 123. Section 120 further compresses the gas and delivers it via discharge pipe 125 and second section cooler 126 to the suction scrubber 139 of the third Section 130. From there via pipe 133 the gas enters the third Section, discharging into pipe 135. Finally, the gas is cooled in the third Section cooler 136 and is delivered to the discharge header 104.
[0046] Each compressor section 110, 120, and 130 has a corresponding recycle line and an antisurge control valve 111, 121, and 131. Control system 150 acts to prevent surging of the compressor sections by recirculating part or all of the flow via the Antisurge control valves (ASV's) 111, 121, and 131. Non-return or check valves 117, 127, and 137 prevent reverse flow into each compressor section, respectively, from the downstream piping and vessels, as may occur when there is no forward flow from the suction header 103 into the compressor and the flow into each section is being recirculated via the corresponding antisurge valve, with no flow coming from the preceding section. Control system 150 may also maintain a relevant process parameter, such as the flow from the compressor to the downstream process, or compressor suction or discharge pressure by adjusting the rotational speed of the driver to match the process demand. The type of compressors utilized as compressor sections 110, 120, and 130 are centrifugal and axial type of compressors, commonly referred to as turbocompressors.
[0047] System 100 includes a plurality of sensor and transmitter devices positioned at various locations throughout system 100, sensing various parameters, such as pressure, temperature, and flow rates, which are occurring within system 100 and transmitting these values to the control system 156. By way of non-limiting examples, PT-1 and PT-2 are pressure transmitters measuring pressure at the inlet header 103 and outlet header 104, respectively, to system 100. Each compressor section has suction and discharge pressure transmitters: PT-11 and PT-12 for Section 110, PT-21 and PT-22 for Section 120, and PT-31 and PT-32 for Section 130. Temperature is also measured at the suction and discharge of each section, using TT-11, TT-12, TT-21, TT-22, TT-31 and TT-32. Flow for each section may be measured via flow measuring devices installed in suction piping of each section using transmitters FT-1, FT-2, and FT-3.
[0048] Control System 156 receives input signals from the various transmitters via electrical connections, or other communication means, processes these signals in the software control applications and calculates and sends its response via output signals to the antisurge valves of each section 111, 121, and 131, respectively, and to the prime mover 101.
[0049] As shown in FIG. 1, controller 150 includes Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT) 154 and control applications 156. VRT 154 includes software modules or blocks. Each VRT block receives and processes the data being provided by those transmitters including in system 100, which have similar values during normal operation, such as, for example PT-12 and PT-21. The transmitters having similar values are shown connected by links 151, 152, and 153. Other input signals are passed directly to the control applications. As part of processing the data received from the transmitters included in system 100, each VRT block of 154 detects failure, of the input signal based on the data being provided by the associated transmitter, or due to the wiring or control system hardware malfunction.
[0050] In a first possible scenario for operating system 100, all the transmitters included in system 100 are operating properly, and are sending valid data to controller 150. In this first scenario, VRT 154 processes the incoming data, determines that all the transmitters are healthy, (i.e., are transmitting valid data), and passes the data, as the actual measured data values, to the control application 156. Control application 156 is configured to process the inputs received from VRT 154, and to provide control outputs to various devices included in system 100 in order to control the operation of the compressor system.
[0051] In a second possible scenario of operating system 100, a transmitter either fails completely and stops transmitting data to controller 150, or is otherwise faulty, and is transmitting invalid data values. VRT 154 is configured to detect the loss of transmission of data from the transmitters, or to determine that the data being provided by the transmitter is invalid in instance where some data is still being transmitted from the transmitter to controller 150, and therefore determine that the transmitter is unhealthy. Upon making the determination that the transmitter is unhealthy, VRT 154 is configured to generate, if possible, a virtual redundant transmitter (VRT) alternative value to replace the data previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter. VRT 154 has several options for generating the VRT alternative value. In one embodiment, VRT 154 utilizes the data received from a different but still healthy transmitter operating in system 100. The data received from the different but still healthy transmitter is deemed to be an acceptable replacement, in some embodiments with a bias factor and / or a safety factor added in, as replacement data for the data the was previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter.
[0052] As an illustrative example, at some point in time PT-12, located at the output 115 of compressor 110, as an example of a failed or faulty transmitter. In views of a lack of data or the invalid data being received from the transmitter associated with PT-12, VRT 154 determines that the data being provided by PT-21, located at the input 123 to compressor 120, is an acceptable substitute, as indicated by link 152, for the data previously being provide by the unhealthy transmitter of PT-12, because these point within system 100 are coupled, through cooler 116, check valve 117, and scrubber 129, but still should have similar ranges of values and responses. VRT 154 can be configured to add a correction factor to the data being provided by the transmitter associated with PT-21 account for the intervening devices 116, 117, and 129, and / or to add a safety factor to the data values, and then provide these alternative values to control application 156 in place of the measured values previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter associated with PT-12. Using the alternative values generated by VRT 154, the operation of compressor system 100 may continue uninterrupted.
[0053] When steady-state conditions exist, as determined by monitoring other healthy inputs of the compressor system 100, as an alternative to using data from a different and healthy transmitter to replace data previously provided by a now unhealthy transmitter, VRT 154 may determine a Last Good Value as that previously received from the now unhealthy transmitter, and to provide the Last Good Value as the alternative value to the control application 156 to replace the measured data values previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter. On the other hand, when steady-state conditions no longer exist, or the failure occurred when steady-state conditions did not exist in the first place, VRT 154 may determine an estimated value that is determined to be an acceptable replacement value to the data values being previously provided by the now unhealthy transmitter, and to provide the estimated value as the alternative value to the control application 156 to replace the measured data values previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter, as discussed in paragraph 037. The acceptability criteria are based on the statistical correlation, computed just prior to the failure of the primary measurement, and may have additional logic, based on, for example, estimation of the forward flow from section 110 into section 120. Again, the estimated value may be a factor with a safety margin or bias before providing the estimated value to the control application 156. Using the alternative values generated by VRT 154, either as Last Good Value or as an estimated value, the operation of compressor system 100 may continue uninterrupted. Additional details of the embodiments of methods and techniques used generate Last Good Value and estimated values are further described below.
[0054] In limited instances VRT 154 determines that no acceptable value(s) can be generated or otherwise provided to replace the data previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter, or as a result for example of the failure of multiple transmitters within system 100. Under such circumstances, VRT 154 may be configured to indicate to control application 156 a “FAILURE” state exists. upon receiving the indication of a “FAILURE” state, control application 156 can be configured to provide output control signals to one or more devices of system 100 in order to safely control further operation of the system, which may include shutting down one or more of the compressors included in system 100.
[0055] The ability to have virtual transmitters created in place of failed or otherwise unhealthy transmitters within system 100 allows system 100 to continue to operate in a safe manner at some capacity without the need for double or even triple redundancy with respect to hardware sensors and transmitters. As such, the embodiments as described herein provide an improvement to the technical field of compressor system operations by reducing cost, eliminating downtime, and assuming safe and continuous operation of a compressor system despite a failure of sensor(s) and / or associated transmitter(s) configured to provide data related to physical parameter(s) of the compressor system while the compressor system is operating. The use of the alternative values as generated by a Virtual Redundant Transmitter, such as but not limited to VRT 154, to provide data inputs to a control application, such as but not limited to control application 156, and to allow the compressor system to continue to operate despite one or more unhealthy transmitters, provides a preictal application of the use the Virtual Redundant Transmitter as described herein and any equivalents thereof.
[0056] FIG. 2 is a block diagram 200 illustrating the implementation of a Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT) 230 in a compressor control system, in accordance with various embodiments. Diagram 200 includes a main signal input processing block 210, an alternative value input processing block 212, and an application specific logic block 214 coupled to inputs of VRT 230, and outputs provided by VRT 230 coupled to compressor control application 260 through output block 250. One, some, or all of these functional blocks as illustrated in FIG. 2 may be implemented as computer circuitry executing program applications included in a compressor controller, such as but not limited to any of the embodiments of compressor controller applications 156 as illustrated and described above with respect to FIG. 1, and may be configured to perform any of the function and to provide any of the features ascribed to compressor control applications 156, and / or as illustrated and described below with respect to computer system 602 and FIG. 6. In various embodiments, VRT 230 is VRT 154 of FIG. 1, and may be configured to perform any of the functions and to provide any of the features ascribed to VRT 154. In various embodiments, compressor control application 260 is compressor control application 156 of FIG. 1, and may be configured to perform any of the function and to provide any of the features ascribed to compressor control application 156.
[0057] As shown in diagram 200, input processing block 210 is configured to receive or access inputs 203 from transmitters 202. Inputs 203 can comprise data, in the form of measured values, provided as data signals from each of transmitters 202, the data signals related to sensed physical parameters of the compressor system where VRT 230 is configured to oversee. In various embodiments, input processing block 210 is configured to determine, based for example on the most recently received data from each of the transmitters, that the transmitter is healthy and functioning properly. A determination as to the health of a particular transmitter may be based on comparing the most recent data values received from the transmitter (i.e., at input 203), to a range of expected values for that particular transmitter.
[0058] If the most recent value(s) for the data received from a particular transmitter is / are within the range of expected values, the input processing block 210 can consider the transmitter to be heathy. Based on making a determination that the transmitter in question is healthy, input processing block 210 is configured to pass the measured values provided from the transmitter, as indicated by arrow 211, to the VRT 230, along with an indication signal to the VRT 230, as represented by arrow 213, that the measured value is being provided by a healthy transmitter. Based on receiving the measured value and a corresponding healthy signal indication from the input processing block 210, VRT 230 is configured to pass the measured value from the VRT 230 to the compressor control application 260, through one of VRT switches 240, 242, as further described below. In addition to passing the measured value for a particular transmitter to compressor control application 260, VRT 230 may be configured to also pass along, for example using output 250, a status indication that the particular measured value being provided at output 250 is valid.
[0059] Upon receiving the measured output value and the indication that the value is valid from output block 250, compressor control application 260 is configured to apply the output values to the control process being provided by the compressor control application 260 to operate and control a compressor system. A plurality of measured output values may be provided at output block 250, along with a set of corresponding validity indications for each of the output values, at output block 250 at a same time and in parallel, for example as provided by one cycle of the operation of the VRT 230. In various embodiments, VRT 230 may be implemented as a function block in the PLC / Programmable Logic Controller / , which runs the control applications such as anti-surge or speed control applications. Inputs of this function block are connected to the controller's system inputs through the input processing blocks 210 and 212 and to the application-specific logic block 214. The outputs of this block are connected to the control application 260.
[0060] As shown in FIG. 2, VRT 230 includes a plurality of virtual switches 240, 242. While shown as have two switches 240 and 242, embodiments of VRT 230 may comprise any number of switches, as illustratively represented by dashed line 233, the number of virtual switches in some embodiments being equal at least to the number of transmitters 202 that the VRT 230 is configured to control on an individual basis with respect to which output representing each transmitter is coupled though output block 250 to pass along a control value to control application 260. Using switch 240 as an example, switch 240 has a first input 240A coupled to measured input block 220, a second input 240B coupled to VRT logic block 232, and an output 240C coupled to output block 250. VRT logic block 232 is configured to control the operational state of virtual switch 240 using switch control line 241. In various embodiments, with respect to switch 240, VRT logic block 232 is configured to use control line 241 to set switch 240 so that switch 240 couples the input 240A, having the measured value for a particular one of transmitters 202, to output 240C and to output block 250, where the value provided at output block 250 is passed on to the control application 260. The setting of switch 240 to couple input 240A to output 240C may be based on a determination by VRT logic block 232 that the input provided by main signal processing block 210 for the particular transmitter value associated with switch 240 is valid, for example based on the validity signal provided by the main signal processing block 210 for that same transmitter.
[0061] VRT logic block 232 is also configured to set switch 240, again using control line 241, so that instead of input 240A being coupled to output 240C of the switch, input 240B is coupled to output 240C. When set so that input 240B of switch 240 is coupled to output 240C, a value provided by VRT logic block 232 may be provided through switch 240 to output block 250, along with any validity signals provided to output block 250, wherein the value provided to output block 250 from VRT logic block 232 through switch 240 is passed on to control application 260 through output block 250.
[0062] In a similar manner, switch 242 is configured to be set, using control line 243 as provided by VRT logic block 232 through control line 243, to operate switch 242 to couple input 242A to output 242C to provide a measured value for a transmitter associated with switch 242 to output block 250 when a determination is made that the transmitter is providing valid data, and to operate switch 242 to couple input 242B to output 242C to provide a value provide at input 242B from VRT logic block 232 to output block 250 when a determination is made that the transmitter associated with switch 242 is not providing valid data.
[0063] As such, each switch in VRT 230, including switches 240, 242 and all additional switches 233 included in VRT 230, are configured to be operated on an individual basis based on output signals provided to each switch individually from VRT logic block 232. The setting of each switch may be individually determined by VRT logic block 232 based on a determination made for that particular switch as to whether the measured value for the transmitter associated with each respective switch is valid or not valid. For transmitters determined to be providing valid measured data values, the switch associated with that particular transmitter may be set by VRT logic block 232 to provide the measured data value as an output from the switch to output block 250. For transmitters determined to not be providing valid data, the switch associated with that particular transmitter may be set to provide an alternative value, for example as generated by the VRT logic block 232 and / or as provided to VRT logic block 232 by alternative value input processing block 212, and provided as an output from the switch to output block 250.
[0064] At some point in time, for example based on the scan cycle of the operation of the VRT 230, and for example based on a trigger signal provided to output block 250 from VRT logic block 232 through control line 251, the output values provided from all the switches included in VRT 230 may be transferred from output block 250 to control application 260. Upon receiving these control values from output block 250, control application 260 is configured to apply the received control values for use in the operation of a compressor system. In some embodiments, the outputs provided by output block 250 include only measured values for the transmitters in instances where all of the transmitters 202 are determined to be providing valid data. In other instances, the outputs provide by output block 250 include one or more alternative value(s) provided by VRT logic block 232 as substitute value(s) for one or more transmitters that were determined to not be providing valid data.
[0065] In various embodiments one or both of blocks 210 and 212 may determine that the data being provided by a transmitter is unhealthy, and should not be forwarded on for use by the compressor control application 260, or that the transmitter has failed, and is providing no data at all. The determination of unhealthy data or no data from a particular transmitter may be made using any combination of the criteria described above, or some combination of these determination techniques, or some other method that block 210 may be configured to utilize.
[0066] In various embodiments, the determination of unhealth data or no data from a particular transmitter may be provided as an indication, for example via link 213, from the input processing block 210 to the VRT 230. Upon receiving the indication of unhealthy data or no data from input processing block 210, the VRT 230 is configured to determine, for example using a state machine process and / or a machine learning tool, if a valid alternative value is available to be used in place of the unhealthy or missing measured value. In various embodiments, VRT 232 is configured to utilize a state machine process, as further illustrated and described below, to determine if a valid alternative value is available, embodiments of which include:
[0067] determining that measured data from a different and healthy transmitter can be safely substituted as the app input values to be used by the compressor control application 260, in place of the data values previously being provided by the now failed transmitter;
[0068] determining that a Last Good Value received from the now unhealthy transmitter can be safely utilized going forward as the app input value to be provided for use by the compressor control application 260 in place of the data values previously being provided by the now failed transmitter;
[0069] determining that an estimated value generated by the model input processing block 220, for example using a machine learning tool, can be safely utilized going forward as the app input value to be provide for use by the compressor control application 260 in place of the data values previously being provided by the now failed transmitter; and
[0070] determining that there is no valid alternative value available that can be safely utilized going forward as the app input value to be provide for use by the compressor control application 260 in place of the data values previously being provided by the now failed transmitter.
[0071] In various embodiments, based on a determination by VRT 230 that there is at least one alternative value that may be safely used by the compressor control application 260 in place of the measured value previously being provide by the now unhealthy transmitter, VRT 230 is configured to provide the alternative value through the setting of a switch associated with that particular transmitter, to output block 250, along with an indication that the alternative value is valid, again using control line 251 to provide the validity indications. Based on receipt of the alternative or substitute input value and the indication that the alternative or substitute value is valid, compressor control application 260 can be configured to continue to operate, in some embodiments in a normal mode of operation, utilizing the alternative or substitute value provided by model input processing block 220 though the switch 242 of VRT 230.
[0072] In embodiments where no acceptable value is available or can be determine to be used safely as the application input value in place of the measured data previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter, a signal can be provided, for example through a switch or directly from VRT 232 logic block, and provided at output block 25 to indicated to the compressor control application 260 and indicative of a failure mode, based on the unavailability of alternative data as a replacement for the data previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter. In various embodiments, in response to receiving the indication of a failure mode, compressor control application 260 can be configured to generate output control signals to one or more devices included in the compressor system being controlled by compressor control application 260 that will safety control the further operation of the compressor system in view of the lack of data being provided to the compressor control application.
[0073] FIG. 3 is a functional block diagram 300 of an implementation of a VRT logic block 320, in accordance with various embodiments. VRT logic block 320 includes VRT logic 321, which may comprise software, software application, hardware, and / or firmware configured to allow VRT logic block 320 to perform any of the function and to provide any of the features ascribed to a Virtual Redundant Transmitter as described herein. The VRT logic block 320 as shown in diagram 300 includes VRT block 320 having inputs including Main Input, Alt Value, and Alt Valid, and outputs Out, Estimated Value, Status, and AE. Main Input may include measured data provided directly from transmitters of the compressor control system, and / or data processed by a main input processing block, such as main signal input processing block 210 (FIG. 2). The Alt Value input of the VRT logic block 320 is coupled to receive data inputs provided as a potential alternative value for-the Main measured data and supplemented with quality Healthy or Unhealthy of the alternative value. The Alt Value input may be provided by an Input Processing block such as block 212 (FIG. 2). The Alt Valid input may be coupled to receive a signal, in some embodiments a binary “valid” or “not valid” signal, indicative of whether or not the data provided at the Alt Value input is valid. In various embodiments, the Alt Valid input may be provided from an application specific logic block, such as application specific logic block 214 (FIG. 2).
[0074] In various embodiments, the Signal-1, Signal-2, and Signal-3 inputs to VRT block 320 are the process-monitoring signals related to measured data directly from transmitters and / or transmitter data that has been processed by Input Processing blocks of the same type as blocks 210 and 212 (FIG. 2), which can be used to determine the stability of the operating state of the compressor system. These signals can be used to make a determination as to whether data provided by another transmitter providing sensed information related to the compressor system can be substituted as an alternative value for data previously provide by a transmitter that has now been determined to no longer be valid data. For example, the Signal-1, Signal-2, and Signal-3 inputs may be used to confirm that a Last Good Value being substituted for measured transmitter data is valid as further described below.
[0075] In various embodiments, a process monitoring block, such as main signal input processing block 210 (FIG. 2), may be configured to provide continuous process monitoring of the parameter values provided by all transmitters providing data for a compressor system with respect to allowing the VRT block 320 to determine when a usable Last Good Value can be used for an operational parameter when a transmitter previously providing sensed data for that operational parameter has failed. Inputs 308 may include measurement data from the transmitters, and which may or may not be further processed by the process monitoring block, are provided to VRT 320 as inputs 308. Deviation Analysis block 310 receives measured value over link 302 and estimated value 304 as inputs and provides an output to the VRT block 320 over link 311 that is indicative of the deviation between the estimated value and the main measured value when both values are healthy. The estimated value may be determined using engineering documents and templates, including technical manuals for example for the compressors, work instructions including typical application cases, application templates, templates of the user manuals, and other engineering data pertinent to the devices and the configuration of the compressor system.
[0076] Embodiments of VRT 300 may include a fbVRTDevAnalysis block 310. In various embodiments, block 310 performs analysis of the difference between the estimated value and the Main input of the VRT block 320. The analysis of the difference (Estimated Value−Main Input) is performed continuously in the period starting from Time Window seconds before the last execution of the block and ending at the last execution of the block. The Time Window is a configured value in the fbVRTDevAnalysis block 310. Results of the analysis of the difference (Estimated Value−Main Input) include but not limited to average value, minimum and maximum values, steadiness of the difference, and statistical correlation of the Estimated Value and the Main Input. Results of the analysis are provide from the Status output of block 310 to the Deviation Analysis input of VRT 320 through link 311.
[0077] With respect to inputs to VRT block 320, signal-1, signal-2, and signal-3 are input signals from a process monitoring block, and are used to verify the Last Good Value (LGV) state. The Deviation Analysis input 311 is a data structure with the results of the analysis of the (Estimated Value−Main Input) difference. In various embodiments, VRT 320 operates as a state machine determining when to use measured values and when to use an alternative value, and which alternative value to use, as an output provide to the compressor control application at output 330 for any given operational parameter being provided by the VRT 320 to the compressor control application 330.
[0078] In various embodiments, Out is the output used to provide control values to a control application, such as control application 260 (FIG. 2), using output 330. The Estimated Value output may be fed back into block 310 for use in determining the Status output being provided by block 310, which in turn may be used by block 320 to determine the validity of one or more alternative values being provided to block 320 at Alt Value input and / or being generated by the VRT block itself. The Status output of the VRT block 320 provides diagnostics and other information related to the processes being performed by VRT block 320, and / or related to other aspects, such as the transmitter data being received and processed by the VRT block. The AE output may provide an output of alarm signals and / or event outputs configured to alert system users of various alarm conditions that exist or may exist related to the operation of the compressor system being monitored by VRT 320.
[0079] FIG. 4 is a diagram of a state machine 400 that defines states of operation of a VRT functional block, in accordance with various embodiments. In various embodiments, state machine 400 represents a state machine that implemented in the operation of VRT block 230 as illustrated and described above with respect to FIG. 2 and / or VRT block 320 as illustrated and described above with respect to FIG. 3.
[0080] Referring back to FIG. 4, diagram 400 begins at Initialization block 410. Process steps included at block 410 may include checking input connections, such as input connections from Input processing like blocks 210 and 212 (see FIG. 2), checks on the proper configuration for process control operations, including computed values, which depend only on configuration parameters. In various embodiments, if the initial checks fail, then the function block raises output flag, for example—“AE.bad_config”—and remains in the Initialization state. If the initial checks pass, then the block leaves the Initialization state and proceeds on to the Normal state, block 420.
[0081] At Normal state 420 and based on a determination that the Main input providing data to the VRT is healthy, input 411, state machine 400 operates in normal state 420. In normal state 420, the output from VRT to the compressor control application at OUT is equal to the input IN provided to VRT as the Main measured input provided by the Input processing block like 210 (see FIG. 2). At NOT 421, a determination is made that an input of a measured value is not healthy. In response to NOT 421, state machine 400 progresses to Last Good Value (LGV) 430. At LGV 430, the output from VRT to the compressor control application at OUT is set to the last good value from the main input plus a safety bias value “SafetyBiasValue.” In various embodiments, SafetyBiasValue is a preconfigured safety bias.
[0082] Checking the process-monitoring signal-1, signal-2, and signal-3 continue to stay within a predefined range of their last good values. When signal-1, signal-2, and signal-3 deviate from their memorized values at the moment when state machine switched to LGV state, the LGV state 430 fails, and state machine 400 progresses to the estimated value state 440. At estimated value state 440, the output OUT provided by the VRT to the compressor control application is equal to the estimated value OUTest plus a predefined SafetyBiasValue. In the estimated value state 440, the estimated output OUTest is based on the Alternative value (see the Alt value input of the block 320 in FIG. 3). In various embodiments, the alternative value is transformed in the VRT to generate the estimated value. In various embodiments, a programming configuration is provided in the VRT to determine how the transform is to operate, and / or which transform among a plurality of transforms is to be used. In various embodiments, there are several alternative algorithms. In various embodiments, by default, Estimated value=Alternative value. In the gain and bias mode, Estimated value=gain*(Alternative value)+bias. A characterizer can be applied: Estimated value=f(gain*(Alternative value)+bias). A default value may be used if Alternative value fails: Estimated value=default value. More complex models may be implemented outside of the VRT block in the application-specific logic like block 214 in FIG. 2. If an external model is used, output of the external model is connected to the Alt value input of the VRT block 320, see FIG. 3.
[0083] If quality of the Alternative value becomes Unhealthy or Alternative valid input of the VRT block 320 (see FIG. 3) becomes False, state machine 400 progresses to Failure 450. When at failure state 450, VRT may provide values for operational parameters to the compressor control application that allow the compressor system to operate in a safety mode, such as slowing the speed and / or pressures allowed to exist in the compressor system, or in some instance causing the compressor(s) including in the compressor system to shut down completely.
[0084] FIG. 5 is flowchart of a method 500 for operating a compressor control system, in accordance with various embodiments. The method 500 may be performed by the components included in and / or coupled to a Virtual Redundant Transmitter, such as Virtual Redundant Transmitter 154 included as part of controller 150 configured to provide control inputs to a compressor control application 156, as illustrated and describe above with respect to FIG. 1. Embodiments of method 500 may be performed by computer processing circuitry including one or more processors operating on computer instructions, which may be stored in one or more computer memory devices, for example as illustrated and described below with respect to computer system 600 and FIG. 6.
[0085] Embodiments of method 500 include determining one or more control values to be applied as inputs a compressor control application to control operations being performed by a compressor system, (block 510). In various embodiments, determining one or more control values to be applied as inputs to a compressor control application includes determining that each of the transmitters providing sensed data related to the operating parameters of the compressor system are providing healthy data, and there the inputs to the compressor control application consists of measured data provided by the transmitters, and the VRT is operating in a normal state by providing the measured data as inputs to the compressor control application.
[0086] Embodiments of method 500 at block 510 further include applying the control values to a compressor control application, such as control application 156 (FIG. 1), or compressor control application 260 (FIG. 2), for use by the control application in controlling the operation of a compressor system. In various embodiments, the control values applied to the control application include only measured values provided by the sensors and transmitters of a compressor system being controlled by the control application In other embodiments, the control values applied to the control application may include one or more alternative values generated by and provided as an output from a Virtual Redundant Transmitter using any of the methods and techniques as described in this disclosure, and any equivalents thereof.
[0087] Embodiments of method 500 include determining that a transmitter of data indicative of an operational parameter of the control system is unhealthy, (block 512). In various embodiments, a determination that the data provided by the transmitter is unhealthy is made by determining that the data values being provided by the transmitter are out of a range of expected values which the overall operation of the compressor system remain in a steady state condition. In various embodiments, a determination that the data provided by the transmitter is unhealthy is made based on a determination that data is no longer being received from the transmitter.
[0088] Embodiments of method 500 include determining an alternative input value for the operational parameter of the control system that was previously provided by the transmitted that has been determined to be unhealthy, (bock 514). Embodiments of determining an alternative input value may include determining a Last Good Value, for the operational parameter previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter, and providing the Last Good Value as the alternative input value to be used by the compressor control application. Embodiments of determining an alternative input value may include determining an estimated value for the operational parameter previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter, and providing estimated value as the alternative input value to be used by the compressor control application. The estimated value may be determined using any of the techniques described in this disclosure.
[0089] After determining an alternative input value for the operational parameter of the control system that was previously provided by the transmitted that has been determined to be unhealthy, embodiments may return to block 510, as indicated by arrows 520, where the inputs to the compressor control application includes providing as inputs to the compressor control application the control values being provided by the healthy transmitter along with the determined alternative value(s) for the operational parameter previously being provided by the unhealthy transmitter.
[0090] In various embodiments, method 500 includes determining the there are no alternative values that can be safely utilized by the compressor control application for the operation of the compressor system. In such instances, embodiments of method 500 include transitioning to a failure state, (block 522). In the failure state, an indication may be provided to the compressor control application, indicating that no valid or safe-to-use alternative value is availed to replace the inputs related to the operational parameter previously being provided by the now unhealthy transmitter. Based on receiving the indication that no valid or safe-to-use alternative value is available to replace the previously provided operational parameter, the compressor control application may be configured to control the operation of the compressor system is a safety mode, or in some embodiments in a shutdown mode, in order to prevent damage to the compressor system and / or to avoid operating the compressor system in a configure that may be unsafe for equipment and / or personnel in the area of the compressor system.
[0091] Embodiments of method 500 include determining that the transmitter determined to be unhealthy has been restored and is providing healthy data, (block 516). A determination that the transmitter that was previously unhealthy is now healthy can be made by receiving data from the transmitter having value(s) that are within the expected range for the sensed operational parameters associated with that transmitter.
[0092] Embodiments of method 500 include, in response to the determination of the restoration of the unhealthy transmitter at block 516, begin using data values from the restored transmitter in place of the alternative input values as inputs to the compressor control application, (block 518). The return to using data values from the restored transmitter returning to block 510, as represented by arrows 520, where the inputs to the compressor control application includes providing as inputs to the compressor control application the control values being provided by the healthy transmitter, including the data from the restored transmitter.
[0093] FIG. 6 is a block diagram 600 illustrating computer system 602, in accordance with various embodiments. Computer system 602 may be configured to provide any of the features and to perform any of the functions described in this disclosure related to controlling operations of a compressor control system, including providing input values for execution of a compressor control application used to control the operation of a compressor system using both measured parameter values and alternative operational parameters generated using a Virtual Redundant Transmitter, as described above. In some embodiments, computer system 602 is included or incorporated into controller 150 (FIG. 1), and is configured to perform any of the functions and provide any of the features ascribed and / or attributable to controller 101.
[0094] Referring back to FIG. 6, computer system 602 includes processor(s) 610, possibly including multiple processors, multiple cores, multiple nodes, and / or implementing multi-threading, etc., communicatively coupled to computer memory 612 by a bus system 615. Example types of processor(s) 610 include microprocessors, microcontrollers, digital signal processors, field programmable gate arrays, application specific integrated circuits, and discreet circuitry.
[0095] As shown in FIG. 6, memory 612 may be an example of storage devices that represent any structure(s) capable of storing and facilitating retrieval of information, such as data, program code, and / or other suitable information on a temporary or permanent basis. Memory 612 may represent a random-access memory, or any other suitable volatile or non-volatile storage device(s). Memory 612 may include short-term memory, and may contain one or more components or devices supporting longer-term storage of data, such as a ready only memory, hard drive, flash memory, or optical disc.
[0096] Memory 612 includes additional data and software modules that may be executed by processor(s) 610 to provide any of the features and to perform any of the functions ascribed to the control and messaging of controller and workload communications, as described above. As shown in FIG. 6, memory 612 includes a machine learning tool 617 that may be executed to perform functions, such as providing estimations for operating parameters associated with a compressor system, as described above.
[0097] Additional programs and application may be stored, either in memory 612, or in memory 630. memory 630 may be communicatively coupled to bus 615, and include programming, data, and / or instructions comprising VRT 632, configuration data 634, and compressor control application 636. In various embodiments, VRT 632 is configured to perform any of the functions, and to provide any of the features ascribed to a Virtual Redundant Transmitter throughout this disclosure, and any equivalents thereof. Configuration data 634 may include any data, such as but not limited to engineering manual data, values for safety margins, ranges of values for normal operating conditions, and other data related to the operation and control of a compressor system. Configuration data 634 may include a mapping of transmitters that may be utilized as providing related or similar data values that can be used to evaluate Last Good Valued for a replacing the values previously provided by a now unhealthy transmitter. Compressor control application 636 may comprise instructions, that when executed provides outputs configured to control the operation of a compressor system, including using operating parameters provided to the compressor control application 636 by the VRT 632.
[0098] Processor(s) 610 may be configured to execute any instructions stored in and / or provided by memory 612 and additional memory storage 630, in order to perform any of the functions and to provide any of the features of the various embodiments related to the monitoring and control of the operation of a compressor system as described in this disclosure, and any equivalents thereof.
[0099] As shown in FIG. 6, computer system 602 includes a network interface 620 is communicatively coupled to bus system 615, and therefore to processor(s) 610 and memory devices 612 and 630. The computer system 602 can communicate via transmissions to and / or from other devices (not specifically shown in FIG. 6). via the network interface 620 in accordance with a network protocol corresponding to the type of network interface, whether wired or wireless and depending upon the carrying medium. In addition, a communication or transmission can involve other layers of a communication protocol and or communication protocol suites (e.g., transmission control protocol, Internet Protocol, user datagram protocol, virtual private network protocols, etc.).
[0100] Signal processor 614 may be configured to communicate messages to and from other devices in a process control system, such as but not limited to sensors and actuators included in the compressor control system. In some embodiments, signals including sensed data provided by sensors of the compressor system may be processed by signal processor 614, for example including analog to digital and noise cancellation processing, before being provided to processor(s) 610 and / or to memory 612 and additional memory 630 for further processing by the devices.
[0101] User interface 640 may be configured to operate as an interface for providing communicative coupling between computer system 602 and one or more user input devices 642, as well as one or more output devices 644. User input devices 642 may include one or more devices such as a computer mouse, computer keyboard, voice recognition hardware and software, and / or other devices such as a touch screen, which allow a user to provide inputs to computer system 602. Output devices 644 may include one or more devices, such as a computer monitor and / speaker(s), which are configured to provide output information, such as visual graphical displays and / or sounds, perceivable by a user such as a process control engineer or a technician. Output devices 644 may include other types of output devices, such as a printer. In various embodiments, the input devices 642 may be used to input information, such as controller configurations, and other parameters related to the operation of the compressor system, such as but not limited to system 100 (FIG. 1). In various embodiments, graphical information and depictions related to the status and operation of the compressor system where computer system 602 is incorporating may be generated and displayed for example on a monitor or display provided as part of output devices 644 for use by a user, such as a process control engineer or technician, ad for example as illustrated and described above with respect to FIG. 2.
[0102] Any one of the previously described functionalities may be partially (or entirely) implemented in hardware and / or on the processor(s) 610. For example, the functionality may be implemented with an application specific integrated circuit, in logic implemented in the processor(s) 610, in a co-processor on a peripheral device or card, etc. Further, realizations may include fewer or additional components not illustrated in FIG. 6 (e.g., video cards, audio cards, additional network interfaces, peripheral devices, etc.). Although illustrated as being coupled to the bus 615, one or more of the memory and storage devices included in computer system 602 may be coupled directly to the processor(s) 610.
[0103] Although FIG. 6 illustrates one example of a computer system 602 supporting industrial process utilizing compressor systems, variations in the configuration of computer system 602 are possible. For example, various components in computer system 602 could be combined, further subdivided, or omitted and additional components could be added according to particular needs. Also, processor(s) 610 can come in a wide variety of configurations, and the configuration of computer system 602 as illustrated in FIG. 6 does not limit this disclosure to any particular configuration of computing devices.
[0104] While the aspects of the disclosure are described with reference to various implementations and exploitations, it will be understood that these aspects are illustrative, and that the scope of the claims is not limited to them. In general, techniques for controlling and regulating the operation of a process control system as described herein may be implemented with facilities consistent with any hardware system or hardware systems. Many variations, modifications, additions, and improvements are possible.
[0105] Plural instances may be provided for components, operations or structures described herein as a single instance. Finally, boundaries between various components, operations and data stores are somewhat arbitrary, and particular operations are illustrated in the context of specific illustrative configurations. Other allocations of functionality are envisioned and may fall within the scope of the disclosure. In general, structures and functionality presented as separate components in the example configurations may be implemented as a combined structure or component. Similarly, structures and functionality presented as a single component may be implemented as separate components. These and other variations, modifications, additions, and improvements may fall within the scope of the disclosure.
[0106] In some embodiments, various functions described in this patent document are implemented or supported by a computer program that is formed from computer readable program code and that is embodied in a computer readable medium. The phrase “computer readable program code” includes any type of computer code, including source code, object code, and executable code. The phrase “computer readable medium” includes any type of medium capable of being accessed by a computer, such as read only memory (ROM), random access memory (RAM), a hard disk drive, a compact disc (CD), a digital video disc (DVD), or any other type of memory. A “non-transitory” computer readable medium excludes wired, wireless, optical, or other communication links that transport transitory electrical or other signals. A non-transitory computer readable medium includes media where data can be permanently stored and media where data can be stored and later overwritten, such as a rewritable optical disc or an erasable storage device.
[0107] It may be advantageous to set forth definitions of certain words and phrases used throughout this patent document. The terms “application” and “program” refer to one or more computer programs, software components, sets of instructions, procedures, functions, objects, classes, instances, related data, or a portion thereof adapted for implementation in a suitable computer code (including source code, object code, or executable code). The term “communicate,” as well as derivatives thereof, encompasses both direct and indirect communication. The terms “include” and “comprise,” as well as derivatives thereof, mean inclusion without limitation. The term “or” is inclusive, meaning and / or. The phrase “associated with,” as well as derivatives thereof, may mean to include, be included within, interconnect with, contain, be contained within, connect to or with, couple to or with, be communicable with, cooperate with, interleave, juxtapose, be proximate to, be bound to or with, have, have a property of, have a relationship to or with, or the like. The phrase “at least one of,” when used with a list of items, means that different combinations of one or more of the listed items may be used, and only one item in the list may be needed. For example, “at least one of: A, B, and C” includes any of the following combinations: A, B, C, A and B, A and C, B and C, and A and B and C.
[0108] The description in the present application should not be read as implying that any particular element, step, or function is an essential or critical element that must be included in the claim scope. The scope of patented subject matter is defined only by the allowed claims. Moreover, none of the claims invokes 35 U.S.C. § 112(f) with respect to any of the appended claims or claim elements unless the exact words “means for” or “step for” are explicitly used in the particular claim, followed by a participle phrase identifying a function. Use of terms such as (but not limited to) “mechanism,”“module,”“device,”“unit,”“component,”“element,”“member,”“apparatus,”“machine,”“system,”“processor,” or “controller” within a claim is understood and intended to refer to structures known to those skilled in the relevant art, as further modified or enhanced by the features of the claims themselves, and is not intended to invoke 35 U.S.C. § 112(f).
[0109] While this disclosure has described certain embodiments and generally associated methods, alterations and permutations of these embodiments and methods will be apparent to those skilled in the art. Accordingly, the above description of example embodiments does not define or constrain this disclosure. Other changes, substitutions, and alterations are also possible without departing from the spirit and scope of this disclosure, as defined by the following claims.
Claims
1. A method comprising:determining one or more control values to be applied by a compressor control application to control operations being performed by a compressor system, wherein determining the one or more control values includes:determining that a transmitter of data indicative of an operational parameter of the compressor system has failed,determining an alternative input value for the operational parameter of the control system that was previously provided by the transmitted that has failed; andproviding, through a Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT), the alternative input value to the compressor control application for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value,wherein determining the alternative input value comprises using a Last Good Value provided by the transmitter prior to the failure of the transmitter based on a determination that the compressor system is operating in a steady state condition despite the failure of the transmitter, and using an estimated value for the alternative input value when a determination is made that the compressor system is not operating in a steady state condition following the failure of the transmitter.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein the operational parameter represents a required control input parameter to the process control application in order to maintain control of the compressor system.
3. The method of claim 1, wherein a steady state condition of the operation of the compressor system is defined as having data provided for the operating parameters of the compressor system from a set of all transmitters that have not failed and that are providing data indicative of operating parameter values that are all within ranges determined to represent normal operating ranges for each of the parameters.
4. The method of claim 1, further comprising:continuing to operate the compressor system using a primary signal value comprising the Last Good Value that existed prior to the failure of the transmitter.
5. The method of claim 1, wherein the determination that the compressor system is operating in a steady state condition despite the failure of the transmitter uses the physical principles of turbomachinery operation to determine whether the compressor system is or is not operating in a steady-state condition.
6. The method of claim 1, wherein the Last Good Value for use as the alternative input value is generated internally by the VRT based on a plurality of input signals provided to the VRT from an input signal processing algorithm operating on a plurality of input signals provided by a plurality of transmitters of the compressor system.
7. The method of claim 1, further comprising:providing the Last Good Value as the alternative input value to the compressor control application for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value while the compressor system remains operating in the steady state condition;determining that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition; andproviding the estimated value for the alternative input value for the continued operation of the compressor system based on the determination that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition.
8. The method of claim 1, further comprising:determining regions of the operation of the compressor system where it is safe to use the estimated value for the alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system.
9. The method of claim 1, further comprising:applying a statistical correlation, covering both a static and a dynamic behavior of the compressor system, for determining the validity of using the estimated value as an alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system.
10. The method of claim 1, further comprising:automatically adjusting a configuration of the compressor system, including adjusting the configuration of the anti-surge system, so that a surge margin increases when Last Good Value or the estimated value is used.
11. The method of claim 1, further comprising:performing a mathematical transformation of a secondary signal being provide by a healthy transmitter operating to provide data indicative of an operational parameter of the compressor system to match a value of a primary signal previously being provided by the failed transmitter.
12. A process control system for controlling the operation of a compressor system, the process control system comprising:a computer system including a processor and at least one memory device communicatively coupled to the processor, the at least one memory device including program instructions, which when executed by the processor, cause the processor to:determine one or more control values to be applied by a compressor control application to control operations being performed by a compressor system while the compressor system is operating to receive a gas or vapor at an input to the compressor system at a first pressure, and to output the gas or vapor in a compressed state at an output of the compressor system at a second pressure that is higher than the first pressure; wherein the instructions for determining the one or more control values include instructions to cause the processor to:determine that a transmitter of data indicative of an operational parameter of the control system has failed, determining an alternative input value for the operational parameter of the control system that was previously provided by the transmitted that has failed; andprovide, through a Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT), the alternative input value to the compressor control system for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value,wherein determining the alternative input value comprises using a Last Good Value provided by the transmitter prior to the failure of the transmitter based on a determination that the compressor system is operating in a steady state condition despite the failure of the transmitter, and using an estimated value for the alternative input value when a determination is made that the compressor system is not operating in a steady state condition following the failure of the transmitter.
13. The process control system of claim 12, wherein the process control system is configured to continue to operate the compressor system using a primary signal value comprising the Last Good Value that existed prior to the failure of the transmitter.
14. The process control system of claim 12, the process control system further configured to:provide the Last Good Value as the alternative input value to the compressor control application for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value while the compressor system remains operating in the steady state condition;determine that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition; andprovide the estimated value for the alternative input value for the continued operation of the compressor system based on the determination that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition.
15. The process control system of claim 12, wherein the process control system is further configured to determine regions of the operation of the compressor system where it is safe to use the estimated value for the alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system.
16. The process control system of claim 12, wherein the process control system is further configured to apply a statistical correlation, covering both a static and a dynamic behavior of the compressor system, for determining the validity of using the estimated value as an alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system.
17. The process control system of claim 12, wherein the process control system is further configured to perform a mathematical transformation of a secondary signal being provide by a healthy transmitter operating to provide data indicative of an operational parameter of the compressor system to match a value of a primary signal previously being provided by the failed transmitter.
18. A non-transitory computer readable medium storing computer readable instructions that, when executed by a processor, cause the processor to:determine one or more control values to be applied by a compressor control application to control operations being performed by a compressor system while the compressor system is operating, wherein the instructions for determining the one or more control values include instructions to cause the processor to:determine that a transmitter of data indicative of an operational parameter of the control system has failed, determining an alternative input value for the operational parameter of the control system that was previously provided by the transmitted that has failed;provide, through a Virtual Redundant Transmitter (VRT), the alternative input value to the compressor control system for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value,wherein determining the alternative input value comprises using a Last Good Value provided by the transmitter prior to the failure of the transmitter based on a determination that the compressor system is operating in a steady state condition despite the failure of the transmitter, and using an estimated value for the alternative input value when a determination is made that the compressor system is not operating in a steady state condition following the failure of the transmitter.
19. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 18, wherein the computer readable instructions, when executed by the processor, cause the processor to apply a statistical correlation, covering both a static and a dynamic behavior of the compressor system, for determining the validity of using the estimated value as an alternative input value for controlling the operation of the compressor system.
20. The non-transitory computer readable medium of claim 18, wherein the computer readable instructions, when executed by the processor, cause the processor to:provide the Last Good Value as the alternative input value to the compressor control application for the continued operation of the compressor system using the alternative input value while the compressor system remains operating in the steady state condition;determine that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition; andprovide the estimated value for the alternative input value for the continued operation of the compressor system based on the determination that the compressor system is no longer operating in the steady state condition.
