Redundant system and method for controlling redundant system

The redundant system in railway control systems addresses inefficiencies by stopping the slave system under specific conditions, reducing costs and improving utilization, through flexible switching between main and slave systems without requiring hardware fixes.

WO2024247556A1PCT designated stage expired Publication Date: 2024-12-05HITACHI LTD

Patent Information

Application Number
PCT/JP2024/015905
Authority / Receiving Office
WO · WO
Patent Type
Applications
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-05-26
Filing Date
2024-04-23
Publication Date
2024-12-05

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Current railway control systems with redundant main and slave systems face inefficiencies in stopping processes, particularly when the main system's failure has minimal impact, leading to increased operational costs and reduced equipment utilization.

Method used

Implementing a redundant system with a main control device and one or more slave control devices, where the slave system is stopped when certain predetermined conditions related to equipment status, future predictions, and operation density are met, allowing for flexible switching between main and slave systems without requiring hardware fixes.

Benefits of technology

This approach reduces operating costs by stopping the slave system when the main system's impact is minimal, enhancing equipment utilization efficiency and enabling flexible system switching without the need for constant hardware fixes.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure JP2024015905_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
    Figure JP2024015905_05122024_PF_FP_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

To provide a technology for stopping a sub-system if an influence is small when a main system is stopped in a railroad control device adopting redundancy, and to reduce costs and increase equipment utilization efficiency, the present invention provides a redundant system constituted by a main-system control device and one or more sub-system control devices, wherein, if state information of a controlled facility controlled by the main-system or sub-system control device satisfies a predetermined condition, sub-system processing by the sub-system control device is stopped.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Redundant system and method for controlling redundant system

[0001] The present invention relates to a redundant system having a primary system and a secondary system and a control method thereof, and is particularly suitable for use in a railway control device.

[0002] Railway control devices installed on the ground include electronic interlocking devices, automatic train control devices, traffic management devices, etc. These railway control devices often employ redundant systems consisting of a primary system and a secondary system to improve availability.

[0003] For example, Patent Document 1 discloses a train operation management device that is equipped with route control units for a main system and a secondary system, and each of the route control units installed at two different stations sends and receives its own survival information to the other system.However, when its own system is stopped, it cannot send its own survival information, nor can it receive survival information from the other system, so a technology is disclosed in which the next system is stopped upon receiving a stop command from the other system.

[0004] JP 2011-235682 A

[0005] In recent years, there has been a trend toward asset-light systems to reduce operational costs, even for the railway control equipment installed on the ground. As part of this trend, proposals have been made to migrate the control equipment to a cloud environment. However, because cloud migration incurs new costs such as network usage costs and security measures, it is necessary not only to simply migrate current facilities to the cloud, but also to implement measures to improve the efficiency of equipment use, such as equipment consolidation. Furthermore, even for redundant systems, it is necessary to consider computing uptime in order to reduce costs.

[0006] Furthermore, in Patent Document 1, when a primary or secondary system is stopped due to a failure, the system does not transmit its own survival information and cannot receive survival information of other systems, so the technology stops the system after receiving a stop command from the other system. However, this is only a process for stopping the primary or secondary system in the event of an abnormality, and is not intended to be a process for stopping under normal conditions.

[0007] Therefore, the present invention aims to provide a technology for shutting down a secondary system in a railway control device that employs a redundant system when the impact of stopping the primary system is small, thereby reducing costs and improving the efficiency of equipment utilization.

[0008] In order to solve the above problems, one of the representative redundant systems of the present invention is a redundant system consisting of a master control device and one or more slave control devices, and when the status information of the controlled equipment controlled by the master or slave control device satisfies a predetermined condition, the slave processing by the slave control device is stopped.

[0009] According to the present invention, it is possible to reduce operating costs by shutting down the secondary system when the impact of shutting down the primary system is small. Problems, configurations, and effects other than those described above will become clear from the following description of the preferred embodiment of the invention.

[0010] Fig. 1 is a diagram showing an example of a system configuration according to a first embodiment of the present invention; Fig. 2 is a diagram showing an example of components constituting a control device that becomes a primary system or a secondary system according to each embodiment of the present invention; Fig. 3 is a diagram showing an example of a flowchart of a secondary system startup process executed by a secondary system startup processing unit; Fig. 4 is a diagram showing an example of a flowchart of a secondary system stop process executed by a secondary system stop processing unit; Fig. 5 is a diagram showing an example of a system configuration according to a second embodiment of the present invention;

[0011] Hereinafter, with reference to the drawings, a first embodiment and a second embodiment will be described as modes for carrying out the present invention. Note that the present invention is not limited to these first and second embodiments. In addition, in the drawings, the same parts are denoted by the same reference numerals.

[0012] The embodiment of the present invention is directed to an electronic interlocking device, which is one of the railway control devices installed on the ground, but is not limited to this and can also be applied to automatic train control devices or operation management devices, etc.

[0013] 1 is a diagram illustrating an example of a system configuration according to a first embodiment of the present invention. A redundant system 100 controls a controlled facility 130 and is composed of a primary control device 110 and at least one secondary control device 120. Hereinafter, the primary control device 110 will be referred to as the "control device (primary) 110," and the secondary control device 120 will be referred to as the "control device (secondary) 120." Hereinafter, the control device (primary) 110, the control device (secondary) 120, and the controlled facility 130 are interconnected via a network or the like, and transmit and receive necessary information to and from each other.

[0014] In the present invention, both the control device (primary system) 110 and the control device (secondary system) 120 are equipped with a secondary system startup processing unit 200 and a secondary system shutdown processing unit 300. This is intended to be installed as software, and is provided in both the primary system and the secondary system. This allows the control device (primary system) 110 to function solely as the primary system and the control device (secondary system) 120 to function solely as the secondary system, and each of the control devices 110 and 120 can be either the primary system or the secondary system. The present invention is characterized in that the primary control device operates the secondary system startup processing unit 200, and the secondary control device itself operates the secondary system shutdown processing unit 300.

[0015] 1, the control device (primary system) 110 has a secondary system startup processing unit 200, shown in a solid line frame, that is actively operating, and the control device (secondary system) 120 has a secondary system stop processing unit 300, also shown in a solid line frame, that is actively operating. On the other hand, the secondary system stop processing unit of the control device (primary system) 110 and the secondary system startup processing unit of the control device (secondary system) 120, shown in a dotted line frame, are in an inactive state.

[0016] Here, when the control device (secondary system) 120 is switched to the primary system and the control device (primary system) 110 is switched to the secondary system, the secondary system startup processing unit or secondary system stop processing unit that was in the dotted line frame becomes active (i.e., becomes a solid line frame), and the secondary system stop processing unit or secondary system startup processing unit that was in the solid line frame becomes inactive (i.e., becomes a dotted line frame).

[0017] It is also possible to fix the control device (primary) 110 to have only the secondary system startup processing unit 200 and the control device (secondary) 120 to have only the secondary system stop processing unit 300, but because the secondary system startup processing unit 200 and the secondary system stop processing unit 300 are each configured as software, it is easy for the control device (primary) 110 and the control device (secondary) 120 to have both the secondary system startup processing unit 200 and the secondary system stop processing unit 300, respectively, and this allows for flexible response. Of course, it is also possible for the secondary system startup processing unit 200 and the secondary system stop processing unit 300 to each be configured as hardware rather than as software.

[0018] 2 is a diagram showing an example of components constituting a control device (110 or 120) that is a primary or secondary system according to each embodiment of the present invention. The control device (110 or 120) is composed of an arithmetic unit 170, a memory 140, a storage device 190, an input device 160, an output device 150, and a communication device 180, similar to a general control device.

[0019] The memory 140 stores, as software, a secondary system startup processing unit 200 and a secondary system shutdown processing unit 300, and, as information (data), it stores ground equipment status information 400, control status information 500, a condition database (DB) 600, operation plan information 700, and train position information 800.

[0020] The wayside equipment status information 400 is status information related to the main wayside equipment of the railway, namely, signals, track circuits, and switches. For example, status information such as the color signal of a signal for a signal, whether the track circuit is down or up, and whether the switch is locked or unlocked can be included. This wayside equipment status information is output from each wayside equipment to an electronic interlocking device (not shown).

[0021] The control status information 500 is status information that indicates the control status, such as locking / unlocking, time counting, etc., used when interlocking and controlling the status of the interlocked ground equipment. This control status information is status information that is understood from the output mode from the electronic interlocking device (not shown).

[0022] The condition database (DB) 600 is a database that stores conditions under which slave control devices can be stopped in relation to the above-mentioned ground facility status information 400 and control status information 500. Furthermore, when two or more slave control devices are provided, the minimum number of slaves to be activated among the two or more slave control devices may be stored.

[0023] The operation plan information 700 is a train operation plan, specifically, information on a so-called train timetable that indicates a plan such as when and where trains will be located within a line.

[0024] The train position information 800 is information on the position of nearby trains that are traveling outside the control range under the control of the control device. The train positions within the control range under the control of the control device can be determined from the status of the track circuits, which are ground equipment. However, the train positions within the control range may be stored in addition to the ground equipment status information 400.

[0025] Next, input / output modes and processing modes of the slave system activation processing unit 200 and the slave system stop processing unit 300 provided in each of the control units (110 or 120) that are the master and slave systems will be described.

[0026] The input data of the secondary system start-up processor 200 and the secondary system stop processor 300 are required data such as wayside equipment status information, control status information, and information stored in a condition database related to these information, and are optional data such as train operation plan information (or train operation forecast information) and train position information outside the control range.

[0027] On the other hand, as output data from the control device (110 or 120) that will be the master or slave, slave start instruction data for starting up the slave is sent from the master to the slave, but no data is sent from the slave to the master (as will be described later, the instruction to stop the slave is given by the slave itself (self-system instruction)).

[0028] As described above in the "Problem to be Solved by the Invention" section, the present invention stops the secondary system when the impact of stopping the primary system is small. Based on the above-mentioned status information, the following cases apply to cases where the impact of stopping the primary system is small.

[0029] That is, a state in which equipment control within the control range under management is not being performed, specifically, a state in which the following 1) to 3) are true (AND): 1) A state in which there are no trains within the range. For example, a state in which there are no trains within the station premises or between the station before it. 2) A state in which the equipment is locked and not in time counting.

[0030] 3) When no trains are coming within the control range for a while For example, when there are no trains approaching within a certain time frame according to the train operation plan, or when the secondary system is activated when setting the route without looking at the train operation plan, In addition to the above situations, when the train operation density is low, the impact of stopping the primary system is small. Although the conditions are slightly more relaxed than the above situations, for example, when trains are operating during off-peak hours or at night.

[0031] Next, specific processing modes of the secondary system startup processing and secondary system shutdown processing will be described. Figure 3 is a diagram showing an example of a flowchart of the secondary system startup processing executed by the secondary system startup processing unit 200. This flowchart is executed at predetermined regular intervals and is executed by the secondary system startup processing unit 200. Below, a description of the executing unit will be omitted.

[0032] In step S201, it is determined whether the secondary system is currently running. If it is already running (Yes), the secondary system startup processing flow ends. If it is not running (No), the process proceeds to step S202. In step S202, the content of the secondary system startup conditions is determined. The secondary system startup conditions will be described later, but they are the opposite conditions to the secondary system stop conditions.

[0033] In step S203, it is determined whether the slave system startup conditions are met. If the slave system startup conditions are met (Yes), the process proceeds to step S204. If the slave system startup conditions are not met (No), the slave system startup processing flow ends. In step S204, startup of the slave system is instructed, and then the slave system startup processing flow ends.

[0034] 4 is a diagram showing an example of a flowchart of the secondary system stop processing executed by the secondary system stop processing unit 300. Like the secondary system startup processing executed by the secondary system startup processing unit 200, this flowchart is also executed at a predetermined regular interval, and is executed by the secondary system stop processing unit 300. In the following, a description of the executing unit will be omitted.

[0035] In step S301, the content of the secondary system stop condition is determined. The secondary system stop condition, which will be described later, is a condition opposite to the secondary system start condition.

[0036] In step S302, it is determined whether the secondary system stop condition is satisfied. If the secondary system stop condition is satisfied (Yes), the process proceeds to step S303. If the secondary system stop condition is not satisfied (No), the secondary system stop processing flow ends.

[0037] In step S303, the secondary system is stopped, that is, the primary system which is the secondary system is stopped, and then the secondary system stop processing flow is terminated.

[0038] Next, the secondary system activation condition and the secondary system stop condition will be explained. As described above, the secondary system activation condition and the secondary system stop condition are mutually inverse, so below, the secondary system stop condition, which is the key point of the present invention, will be explained first.

[0039] <Secondary System Stop Condition> The secondary system stop condition is a condition determined in step S301 of the secondary system stop processing flow shown in FIG. 4, and the secondary system start condition is a condition determined in step S202 of the secondary system start processing flow shown in FIG.

[0040] For both conditions, "A) Conditions related to the current state," described below, is a required condition, and at least one of "B) Conditions related to future predictions" and "C) Conditions related to operation density," described below, is an optional condition.

[0041] That is, the items that fall under "A) Conditions related to the current state" are always determined as conditions for stopping the secondary system. On the other hand, at least one of the items that fall under "B) Conditions related to future prediction" and "C) Conditions related to operation density" is determined as an option, and is not necessarily determined together with "A) Conditions related to the current state," but is determined as needed.

[0042] Furthermore, when determining whether at least one of the options "B)" and "C)" is true, even if the required option "A)" is not established and the secondary system is not stopped, if at least one of these options "B)" and "C)" is not established, the primary system, which is the secondary system, will be stopped.

[0043] Specific judgment conditions are as follows: A) Conditions related to the current status A) Input information - Ground equipment status information: Status information on signals, track circuits, and switches - Control status information: Status information related to locking status and time elements

[0044] (i) Judgment Conditions The condition for a stop is that the input information (i.e., the status indicated by the wayside equipment status information and the control status information) matches the set values ​​in the condition database (DB). Here, the set values ​​in the condition database (DB) are based on the default values ​​for the wayside equipment status and the control status. These default values ​​include "no train on the track," "route not set," "equipment not locked," and "time counting not in progress." If the AND condition of these default values ​​is met, the stop condition is met.

[0045] However, there are cases where it is no problem to stop the secondary system even when the default value is not used, such as when "route setting" is in progress in the case of reverse position holding, or when "train on track" is in the case of stagnant trains, etc. Therefore, the settings in the condition database (DB) can be handled flexibly.

[0046] B) Conditions for future predictions A. Input information: Train operation plan information or train operation forecast information, and train position information outside the control range

[0047] The stop condition is met when the route decision timing within the control range is greater than a pre-specified threshold in the train operation plan or train operation forecast. Specifically, the stop condition is met when there is sufficient time before the train enters the control range.

[0048] C) Conditions related to operation density A. Input information Train operation plan information or train operation forecast information

[0049] In the train operation plan or train operation forecast, the stop condition is met when the route setting frequency within the control range is less than a predetermined threshold for a predetermined time span from the current time. Specifically, the stop condition is met when the train operation density within the control range is sufficiently low.

[0050] <Secondary System Activation Condition> On the other hand, the secondary system activation condition is the reverse of the secondary system stop condition as described above, and will be described below in accordance with the secondary system stop condition.

[0051] A) Conditions related to the current state A) Input information This is the same information as in the case of the secondary system stop condition.

[0052] (i) Judgment condition: The condition for activation is that the input information does not correspond to any of the default values ​​for the ground equipment status and control status, which are the settings in the condition database (DB).

[0053] B) Conditions for future predictions A. Input information This is the same information as in the case of the secondary system stop condition.

[0054] The activation condition is met when the route decision timing within the control range is less than a predetermined threshold in the train operation plan or train operation forecast. Specifically, the activation condition is met when there is not enough time before the train enters the control range.

[0055] C) Conditions related to operation density A. Input information This is the same information as in the case of the secondary system stop condition.

[0056] The activation condition is met when the route setting frequency within the control range is greater than a predetermined threshold value for a predetermined time span from the current time in the train operation plan or train operation forecast. Specifically, the activation condition is met when the train operation density within the control range is high.

[0057] FIG. 5 is a diagram illustrating an example of a system configuration according to a second embodiment of the present invention. In the second embodiment, the configuration of the redundant system 100 according to the first embodiment is expanded to multiple control ranges, and multiple combinations of primary and secondary systems are provided. As shown in FIG. 5, the system is configured with a primary control device 110 and a secondary control device 120 for controlled equipment in control range 1, and a primary control device 110' and a secondary control device 120' for controlled equipment 130' in control range 2. Both primary and secondary control devices include a secondary system startup processing unit 200 and a secondary system shutdown processing unit 300. The same relationship applies to a configuration with three or more control ranges.

[0058] A feature of the second embodiment is that it is possible to start up a control device in a control range 2 from a control range 1 of different control ranges. For example, the configuration shown in Fig. 5 makes it possible to start up a control device in a control range 2 from a control range 1 (the reverse pattern is also possible). In other words, even if the primary control device 110' in the control range 2 goes down, the primary control device 110 in the control range 1 becomes a backup and performs the startup process for the secondary control device 120' in the control range 2. This backup method is also the same when the control range 1 goes down as described above.

[0059] Although Examples 1 and 2 have been described above as embodiments of the present invention, the present invention is not limited to the above-described examples, and various modifications are possible within the scope of the gist of the present invention.

[0060] 100...Redundant system, 110...Control device (primary system), 120...Control device (secondary system), 130...Control target equipment, 140...Memory, 150...Output device, 160...Input device, 170...Calculating device, 180...Communication device, 190...Storage device, 200...Secondary system startup processing unit, 300...Secondary system shutdown processing unit

Claims

1. A redundant system consisting of a master control device and one or more slave control devices, characterized in that when status information of the controlled equipment controlled by the master or slave control device satisfies a predetermined condition, the redundant system stops slave processing by the slave control device.

2. A redundant system according to claim 1, characterized in that the slave control device itself stops the slave processing.

3. A redundant system as claimed in claim 1 or 2, characterized in that if the predetermined condition is not satisfied when the slave processing is stopped, the control device of the main system starts up the slave processing.

4. A redundant system as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 3, characterized in that, when the number of slave control devices is two or more, a minimum number of control devices that need to be started as slave devices is set, and stop and start processes are performed for the slave control devices according to the minimum number.

5. A redundant system according to any one of claims 1 to 4, characterized in that the control devices of the primary and secondary systems have a condition database for storing the predetermined conditions.

6. A redundant system according to any one of claims 1 to 5, characterized in that the equipment to be controlled is ground equipment provided in a railway interlocking device.

7. A redundant system as described in claim 6, characterized in that the specified condition is at least one of a state in which equipment control is not being performed on the ground equipment within a control range that manages the presence of trains on the line, a state in which no trains are approaching within the control range for a specified period of time, and a state in which the train operation density is less than a specified threshold value.

8. A redundant system as described in claim 7, characterized in that a master control device and a slave control device are provided for each of a plurality of said control ranges, and the master control device activates the slave processing in a control range different from its own control range.

9. A control method for a redundant system consisting of a master control device and one or more slave control devices, comprising: determining whether or not status information of a controlled equipment controlled by said control device satisfies a predetermined condition; and, if said predetermined condition is satisfied, stopping slave processing by said slave control device.

10. A method for controlling a redundant system according to claim 9, characterized in that the control device of the slave system itself stops the processing of the slave system.

11. A method for controlling a redundant system according to claim 9 or 10, characterized in that if the predetermined condition is not satisfied when the slave processing is stopped, the control device of the main system starts up the slave processing.

12. A method for controlling a redundant system according to any one of claims 9 to 11, characterized in that, when the number of slave control devices is two or more, a minimum number of control devices that need to be started as slave devices is set, and stop processing and start processing of the slave control devices according to the minimum number is executed.

13. A method for controlling a redundant system according to any one of claims 9 to 12, characterized in that the equipment to be controlled is ground equipment provided in a railway interlocking device.

14. A method for controlling a redundant system as described in claim 13, wherein the specified condition is at least one of a state in which equipment control is not being performed on the ground equipment within a control range that manages the presence of trains on the line, a state in which no trains are approaching within the control range for a specified period of time, and a state in which the train operation density is less than a specified threshold value.

15. A method for controlling a redundant system as described in claim 14, comprising providing a control device for the primary system and a control device for the secondary system in each of a plurality of said control ranges, and the control device for the primary system starts up the processing of the secondary system in a control range different from its own control range.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Train operation control system

    JP2011235682A

  • Monitoring control system

    JP2012079292A

  • Data input method in redundant system

    JP2013088826A

Cited By

  • Damaged ship equipment task capability assessment method, device, equipment and medium

    CN121639042A