System, method, and medium for configuring operation of a pilot plant for in-SITU extraction of hydrocarbon material

Statistical power analysis and staged operation of pilot plants optimize data collection to reduce inconclusiveness and duration in hydrocarbon material extraction, addressing inefficiencies in existing pilot plant operations.

CA3121491CActive Publication Date: 2026-11-03SUNCOR ENERGY INC
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CA3121491
Authority / Receiving Office
CA · CA
Patent Type
Patents
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-06-08
Publication Date
2026-11-03
Estimated Expiration
2041-06-08

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Pilot plants for hydrocarbon material extraction often produce inconclusive results due to high variability in oilfield conditions, leading to prolonged operations to avoid inconclusiveness, which is inefficient.

Method used

Implementing statistical power analysis to determine the required number of data samples and operating time for pilot plants, using historical and simulation data to estimate variability, and operating in stages to reduce data collection constraints.

Benefits of technology

Reduces the likelihood of inconclusive results and shortens the duration of pilot plant operations by optimizing data collection based on statistical power analysis and stage-wise operation.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

There are provided systems, methods, and processor-readable media for configuring operation of a pilot plant based on statistical power analysis. The pilot plant is configured for testing of hydrocarbon material extraction technologies. The statistical power analysis facilitates establishing an operating time interval, representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect a minimum number of pilot plant data samples sufficient to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits a pre-determined effect size relative to a baseline technology.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

SYSTEM, METHOD, AND MEDIUM FOR CONFIGURING OPERATION OF A PILOT PLANT FOR IN-SITU EXTRACTION OF HYDROCARBON MATERIAL FIELD

[0001] The present disclosure relates to testing of hydrocarbon material extraction technologies, and in particular to systems, methods, and processor- readable media for configuring operation of a hydrocarbon extraction pilot plant based on statistical power analysis. BACKGROUND

[0002] Production of oil and other hydrocarbon materials is a constantly evolving industry in which new technologies are regularly developed and tested for deployment in the field. In order to test a new hydrocarbon material extraction technology, an energy company typically builds and operates a pilot plant which uses the new technology to extract hydrocarbon materials from a subterranean formation for a set period of time, then compares the pilot plant results to conventional extraction techniques to determine whether the new technology should be deployed on a large scale.

[0003] Given the large degree of variation in oilfield conditions affecting production results, some such tests end up being inconclusive. The variability of the pilot data can be too great to yield a statistically reliable result based on the amount of pilot plant data collected during the duration of the pilot plant's operation. Such inconclusive pilot plant results are often not identified as such until after the pilot plant has ceased operation and been reconfigured, decommissioned, or otherwise made unavailable for collecting further data in relation to the 2021-05-13 / IS-418IRF (55520-3006) technology being tested. Accordingly, pilot plants can be operated for a longer duration than necessary in order to avoid an inconclusive result.

[0004] Accordingly, it would be useful to provide techniques for operating pilot plants to test new hydrocarbon material extraction technologies that reduce the likelihood of inconclusive pilot plant results and / or reduce the duration of operation of the pilot plant. SUMMARY

[0005] The present disclosure describes systems, methods, and processor- readable media for defining parameters for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology. Example embodiments can use a first dataset to estimate a variability measure, then apply statistical power analysis to determine a number of pilot plant data samples required to detect an effect size between a baseline technology and a test technology. The first dataset can include historical data, simulation data, and / or pilot plan data generated by the pilot plant using the baseline technology and / or another test technology. In some embodiments, the pilot plant operates in stages, and the data collected at each stage is used to estimate the variability measure used by the power analysis to determine the operating time interval of a subsequent stage.

[0006] The temporally serial nature of hydrocarbon material extraction from a subterranean formation, in which data samples can only be gathered in series from a given production well drilled into the subterranean formation, dictates that a second data sample can only be collected after the first data sample has been collected, and so on. This constrains the rate of data collection at the pilot plant, such that the number of data samples required to test the test technology can be used to estimate an operating time interval over which the pilot plant must operate. The pilot plant can then be operated for the operating time interval. In some examples, a projected variability measure of the pilot plant data samples can be reduced by averaging the pilot data sample values over multiple production wells of the pilot plant, thereby reducing the operating time interval.

[0007] As used herein, statements that a second item (e.g., a value, calculation, or determination) is "based on" a first item can mean that characteristics of the second item are affected or determined at least in part by characteristics of the first item. The first item can be considered an input to an operation or calculation, or a series of operations or calculations, that produces the second item as an output that is not independent from the first item.

[0008] In some aspects, the present disclosure describes a method for defining parameters for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology. The method comprises a number of steps. Statistical power analysis is performed based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process, to compute a minimum required sample size. The minimum required sample size indicates a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value. An operating time interval is computed based on at least the minimum required sample size. The operating time interval is representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples.

[0009] In some aspects, the present disclosure describes a system for defining parameters for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology. The system comprises a processor device, and a memory. The memory stores instructions that, when executed by the processor device, cause the system to perform a number of steps. Statistical power analysis is performed based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process, to compute a minimum required sample size. The minimum required sample size indicates a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value. An operating time interval is computed based on at least the minimum required sample size. The operating time interval is representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples.

[0010] In some aspects, the present disclosure describes a non-transitory computer-readable medium storing instructions thereon to be executed by a processor device. The instructions, when executed, cause the processor device to define parameters for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology. Statistical power analysis is performed based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process, to compute a minimum required sample size. The minimum required sample size indicates a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value. An operating time interval is computed based on at least the minimum required sample size. The operating time interval is representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples.

[0011] In some examples, the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated at the pilot plant.

[0012] In some examples, the pilot plant includes a production well, the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the production well, and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the production well.

[0013] In some examples, the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated from the same reservoir as the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology.

[0014] In some examples, the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells, and the variability information is computed based on processing of hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process, and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

[0015] In some examples, the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells, and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

[0016] In some examples, the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least historical data obtained from producing hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using a historical technology, and the historical data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the historical technology.

[0017] In some examples, both of: (i) the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology, and (ii) the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology, is effectuated from a first reservoir. The variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least historical data obtained from producing hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using a historical technology from a second reservoir that is different than the first reservoir. The historical data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the historical technology.

[0018] In some examples, the historical technology is a production- stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

[0019] In some examples, for the historical technology, the production- stimulating fluid of the historical technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the historical technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

[0020] In some examples, the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells, and the hydrocarbon material production data further includes: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process, and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

[0021] In some examples, the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells, and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

[0022] In some examples, the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least baseline data obtained from the producing of hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology. The baseline data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of a hydrocarbon material production metric for the baseline technology.

[0023] In some examples, the variability information is computed based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least simulation data comprising a predicted variability measure of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the test technology.

[0024] In some examples, the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells, and the hydrocarbon material production data further includes: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process, and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

[0025] In some examples, the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells, and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

[0026] In some examples, each one of the baseline technology and the test technology, independently, is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

[0027] In some examples, for the baseline technology, the production- stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid. The total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid. For the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid. The total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

[0028] In some examples, for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 1.0 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

[0029] In some examples, the baseline technology is SAGD, and the test technology is expanding solvent SAGD (ES-SAGD).

[0030] In some examples, for the baseline technology, the production- stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid. The total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid. For the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 0.1 volume % non-condensable gaseous material. The non-condensable gaseous material and the hydrocarbon material are co-operatively configured such that the non-compressible gaseous material is soluble within the hydrocarbon material.

[0031] In some examples, the test technology is a well stimulation technology comprising at least one of thermal stimulation, chemical stimulation, microbiological stimulation, or hydraulic fracturing.

[0032] In some examples, the test technology is a displacement technology.

[0033] In some examples, the displacement technology is a waterflooding technology.

[0034] In some examples, the test technology is an artificial lift technology.

[0035] In some examples, the hydrocarbon material production metric is at least one of the following: oil production rate, indicating an amount of oil extracted by a production well, steam to oil ratio (SOR), indicating a ratio between an amount of steam injected and an amount of oil extracted by a production well, water cut, indicating water as a proportion of fluids extracted by a production well, ultimate recovery, indicating an amount of oil that is potentially recoverable by a production well, and compositional change, indicating a change in the composition of fluids extracted by a production well.

[0036] In some examples, the pilot plant is operated, for the operating time interval, to produce hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction.

[0037] In some aspects, the present disclosure describes a method for defining parameters for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction in a plurality of stages, in sequence. For each one of the stages, the hydrocarbon material production is effected using a respective test technology, such that a plurality of test technologies are provided. The method comprises a number of steps. For each one of the stages, independently, statistical power analysis is performed based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process, to compute a minimum required sample size. The minimum required sample size indicates a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the respective test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value. For each one of the stages, independently, a respective operating time interval is computed based on at least the minimum required sample size. The respective operating time interval is representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples. For each one of the stages, independently, the pilot plant is operated, for the respective operating time interval, to produce hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the respective test technology.

[0038] In some examples, the variability information for each stage after a first stage is obtained by computing the variability measure of the hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process based on at least the pilot plant data samples collected during a previous stage.

[0039] In some examples, the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated at the pilot plant.

[0040] In some examples, the pilot plant includes a production well. The hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the production well. The hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the production well.

[0041] In some examples, the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated from the same reservoir as the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology.

[0042] In some examples, each one of the baseline technology and the test technologies, independently, is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology. The production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

[0043] In some examples, for the baseline technology, the production- stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid. The total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

[0044] In some examples, at least one of the test technologies is ES-SAGD.

[0045] In some aspects, the present disclosure describes a method for defining parameters for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology. The method comprises a number of steps. Statistical power analysis is performed based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process, to compute a minimum required sample size. The minimum required sample size indicates a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value. An operating time interval is computed based on at least the minimum required sample size. The operating time interval is representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples. The baseline technology is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology. The production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid. The total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid. The test technology is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology. The production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes steam and at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid. The total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least: (a) a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid, and (b) a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid. The solvent material and the hydrocarbon material are co-operatively configured such that the hydrocarbon material is soluble within the solvent material.

[0046] In some examples, the baseline technology is SAGD, and the test technology is ES-SAGD.

[0047] Embodiments described herein may exhibit one or more advantages over existing approaches to pilot plant operation for hydrocarbon material extraction from subterranean formations. By performing power analysis to determine a projected operating time interval for the pilot plant, some embodiments may reduce the likelihood of inconclusive pilot plant results and / or reduce the duration of operation of the pilot plant. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0048] Reference will now be made, by way of example, to the accompanying drawings which show example embodiments of the present application, and in which:

[0049] FIG. 1 is a schematic illustration of an embodiment of a pilot plant for production of hydrocarbon material;

[0050] FIG. 1A is a schematic illustration of another embodiment of a pilot plant for production of hydrocarbon material;

[0051] FIG. 2 is a block diagram of an example computing system suitable for implementing examples described herein;

[0052] FIG. 3 is a block diagram of an example pilot plant operation module, in accordance with example embodiments described herein; and

[0053] FIG. 4 is a flowchart showing operations of an example method for operating a pilot plant, in accordance with example embodiments described herein.

[0054] Similar reference numerals can have been used in different figures to denote similar components. DESCRIPTION OF EXAMPLE EMBODIMENTS

[0055] The present disclosure describes example systems, methods, and processor-readable media for defining parameters for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology. Statistical power analysis is performed based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process, to compute a minimum required sample size. The minimum required sample size indicates a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value. An operating time interval is computed based on at least the minimum required sample size. The operating time interval is representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples.

[0056] The operations of the example methods are described with reference to an example computing system executing an example pilot plant operation module, defined by processor-readable instructions stored on a non-transitory computer readable medium, to operate an example pilot plant.

[0057] Example Pilot Plant

[0058] FIG. 1 is a schematic illustration of a pilot plant 100 for performing in- situ hydrocarbon materials extraction from a subterranean formation 102. In some embodiments, for example, the pilot plant 100 is configured to operate to produce to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation 102 via in-situ extraction using a test technology.

[0059] Hydrocarbon material is a material that consists of a least one hydrocarbon compound. In some embodiments, for example, the hydrocarbon material being produced includes, or is substantially, a liquid hydrocarbon material. In some embodiments, for example, the hydrocarbon material includes bitumen. In some of these embodiments, for example, the bitumen is a liquid hydrocarbon material with an API gravity less than, or equal to, 10, and with an in situ viscosity of greater than 10,000 centipoise. In some embodiments, for example, the hydrocarbon material includes heavy oil.

[0060] In some embodiments, for example, the subterranean formation includes a hydrocarbon reservoir, and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation, is hydrocarbon material produced from the hydrocarbon reservoir. In some embodiments, for example, the hydrocarbon reservoir is an oil sands reservoir. In some embodiments, for example, the hydrocarbon reservoir is a heavy oil reservoir.

[0061] In some embodiments, for example, the test technology is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology. The production-stimulating technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating production of hydrocarbon material.

[0062] In some embodiments, for example, the production-stimulating fluid is a fluid configured for co-operating with the hydrocarbon material within the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating the production of the hydrocarbon material via at least thermal stimulation (e.g. steam).

[0063] In some embodiments, for example, the production-stimulating fluid is a fluid configured for co-operating with the hydrocarbon material within the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating the production of the hydrocarbon material via at least modulation of the flow characteristics of the hydrocarbon material, such as, for example, via viscosity reduction (e.g. steam, solvent).

[0064] In some embodiments, for example, the production-stimulating fluid is a fluid configured for co-operating with the hydrocarbon material within the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating the production of the hydrocarbon material via at least chemical conversion of the hydrocarbon material (e.g. fluid including bacteria).

[0065] In some embodiments, for example, the production-stimulating fluid is a fluid configured for co-operating with the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating the production of the hydrocarbon material via at least modulation of the permeability of the subterranean formation (e.g. hydraulic fracturing fluid)

[0066] In some embodiments, for example, the production-stimulating fluid is a fluid configured for co-operating with the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating the production of the hydrocarbon material via any combination of the mechanisms described above.

[0067] In some embodiments where the test technology is a production- stimulating fluid injection technology, for example, the test technology is a displacement process technology. In this respect, in some of these embodiments, the pilot plant will include two wells 104, 106. One of the wells 104, 106 is used as an injection well, for injection of a production-initiating fluid for stimulating hydrocarbon material extraction from a subterranean formation 102, and the other one of the wells 104, 106 functions as a production well for producing the extracted hydrocarbon material to the surface 110. Each one of the wells 104, 106, independently, includes a well monitoring device 208 for monitoring one or more hydrocarbon material production metrics and / or operating parameters of the respective well 104, 106.

[0068] Exemplary displacement technologies include steam assisted gravity drainage ("SAGD") technologies, expanding solvent – steam assisted gravity drainage ("ES-SAGD") technologies, and waterflooding technologies.

[0069] It is understood that, where the test technology is a displacement process technology, in some of these embodiments, the pilot plant includes more than two wells. An exemplary embodiment of such a pilot plant is illustrated in FIG. 1A, with a single injection well 104 and two production wells 106, 108.

[0070] It is understood that, for other test technologies that are production- stimulating fluid injection technologies, a single well can be used for both of the injection and production functionalities. Exemplary ones of such technologies include hydraulic fracturing technologies and "huff and puff" technologies.

[0071] Other test technologies effectuate production of hydrocarbon material by transferring energy to the hydrocarbon material by means other than by injection of a production-stimulating fluid, such as, for example, by artificial lift, by electrical heating, or both.

[0072] In some embodiments, for example, the test technology includes any combination of the above-described technologies.

[0073] To evaluate the efficacy of the test technology, the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology is compared to the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology. The producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology can be effectuated at the pilot plant 100.

[0074] In some examples, the baseline technology and the test technology are both production-stimulating fluid injection technologies. As discussed above, the production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material. In some embodiments, for example, the baseline technology can be a SAGD technology and the test technology is ES-SAGD. In some embodiments, for example, both of the baseline and test technologies can be solvent-based technologies (e.g. ES-SAGD, VAPEX) whose production stimulating fluid includes solvent material, and the solvent material of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology has a different composition relative to the solvent material of the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology, or there is a different content of solvent material within the baseline technology versus the production-stimulating technology.

[0075] In some embodiments, for example, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology (and, in some of these cases, the baseline technology) includes at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid (such as, for example, at least one (1) liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, such as, for example, at least five (5) liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, such as, for example, at least ten (10) liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, such as, for example, at least 15 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, such as, for example, at least 25 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, such as, for example, at least 50 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, such as, for example, at least 75 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid), and the production- stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid (such as, for example, at least 99.9 CWE volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid). The total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid. The total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

[0076] In some of embodiments, for example, in addition to solvent material, the production stimulating fluid of the test technology further includes steam (e.g. ES-SAGD). In this respect, in such embodiments, the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least the sum of: (a) a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid, and (b) a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

[0077] In those embodiments where both of the baseline technology and the test technology includes solvent material, in some of these embodiments, for example, for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid, for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is different than the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid the test technology. In some of these embodiments, for example, the ratio of one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid the test technology to the other one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology and the solvent material content of the production- stimulating fluid the test technology is at least 1.1, such as, for example, at least 1.2, such as, for example, at least 1.3. In some of these embodiments, for example, for each one of the baseline technology and the test technology independently, the solvent material content, of the production-stimulating fluid, is at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % (such as, for example, at least 1.0 liquid equivalent volume %, such as, for example, at least 5.0 liquid equivalent volume %) of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

[0078] "Cold water equivalent volume", as it relates to "steam", is the volume of water, at 15 degrees Celsius and atmospheric pressure, required to produce a volume of the steam within the production stimulating fluid. "Liquid equivalent volume", as it relates to "solvent material", is the volume of liquid solvent material, at 15 degrees Celsius and atmospheric pressure, required to produce a volume of the solvent material within the production stimulating fluid. "Liquid equivalent volume", as it relates to "production stimulating material", is the volume of liquid production stimulating material, at 15 degrees Celsius and atmospheric pressure, required to produce a volume of the production stimulating fluid.

[0079] The solvent material and the hydrocarbon material are co-operatively configured such that the hydrocarbon material is soluble within the solvent material under the conditions of the subterranean formation during the operation of the pilot plant. Solvent material is a non-aqueous fluid material defined by at least one solvent compound. The solvent compound is a compound that is co-operatively configured with the hydrocarbon material such that the hydrocarbon material is soluble within the solvent material under the conditions of the subterranean formation during the operation of the pilot plant. In some embodiments, for example, each one of the at least solvent compound, independently, is a hydrocarbon compound. Suitable hydrocarbon compounds include C1 to C30 hydrocarbon compounds, such as, for example, C2 to C10 hydrocarbon compounds, such as, for example, C5-C9 hydrocarbon compounds. Suitable solvent compounds include alkanes, such as, for example, pentane, hexane, heptane, octane, nonane, decane, undecane, dodecane, tridecane, tetradecane, and also include linear and cyclic paraffins. Exemplary solvent materials also include available hydrocarbon fractions such as condensate, gasoline, light naphtha, heavy nahptha, diluent, and kerosene, any combination thereof.

[0800] In some embodiments, for example, the test technology uses production-stimulating fluid including steam and at least 0.1 mol % non- condensable gaseous material, based on the total moles of the production- stimulating fluid (such as, for example, at least 0.5 mol % non-condensable gaseous material, based on the total moles of the production-stimulating fluid, such as, for example, at least one (1) mol % non-condensable gaseous material, based on the total moles of the production-stimulating fluid, such as, for example, at least two (2) mol % non-condensable gaseous material, based on the total moles of the production-stimulating fluid), and the baseline technology uses production- stimulating fluid, and the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid. The total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

[0081] The non-condensable gaseous material and the hydrocarbon material are co-operatively configured such that the non-compressible gaseous material is soluble within the hydrocarbon material under the conditions of the subterranean formation during the operation of the pilot plant.

[0082] "Non-condensable gaseous material" is a material that is defined by at least one non-condensable gaseous compound. A non-condensable gaseous compound is a compound that is disposed in the gaseous phase under the conditions of the subterranean formation during the operation of the pilot plant. Examples of non-condensable gaseous compounds include hydrogen, nitrogen, helium, molecular oxygen, methane, ethane, propane, butane, carbon dioxide, and carbon monoxide, or any combination thereof. Exemplary non-condensable gaseous material include air, combustion gases, flue gases, or any combination thereof.

[0083] In some examples, the pilot plant 100 can be used to test a plurality of test technologies. Each one of the various test technologies being tested by the pilot plant 100, independently, can be a respective production-stimulating technology which includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating production of hydrocarbon material technology. In some of these embodiments, for example, for each one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating fluid includes solvent material, and, for each one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating technology is defined by a respective test parameter, wherein the test parameter, for each one of the test technologies, is different. Exemplary test parameters include solvent composition, solvent injection pressure, solvent injection rate, solvent to steam injection ratios, and solvent recovery techniques, or any combination thereof. In some of these embodiments, for example, each one of the test technologies, independently, is a respective expanding solvent SAGD (ES-SAGD) technology. The baseline technology used by the pilot plant 100 as an experimental control for testing the various ES-SAGD test technologies can be conventional SAGD or a pre-existing production-stimulating technology which includes injecting of a production- stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating production of hydrocarbon material technology, wherein the production-stimulating fluid includes steam, solvent, or a mixture of steam and solvent.

[0084] In those embodiments where a plurality of test technologies are tested, in some of these embodiments, for example, the production-stimulating fluid of each test technology includes a different solvent material concentration, defined by a different equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid. In such cases, the baseline technology can use production-stimulating fluid, and the production- stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid (such as, for example, at least 99.9 CWE volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid). Alternatively, the baseline technology can use production- stimulating fluid including solvent material, but having a lower concentration of solvent material than the production-stimulating fluid of all of the test technologies.

[0085] In those embodiments where a plurality of test technologies are tested, in other ones of these embodiments, for example, the production- stimulating fluid of each test technology includes a different NCG material concentration, defined by mol % of solvent material, based on the total moles of the production-stimulating fluid. In such cases, the baseline technology can use production-stimulating fluid, and the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid (such as, for example, at least 99.9 CWE volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid). Alternatively, the baseline technology can use production-stimulating fluid including solvent material, but having a lower concentration of NCG material than the production-stimulating fluid of all of the test technologies.

[0086] Typically, a pilot plant will be planned and designed to operate for a fixed period of time in order to collect data relating to the hydrocarbon material production metric(s) in order to test a hypothesis with respect to the results of the test technology relative to the baseline technology used as an experimental control. The serial nature of hydrocarbon material extraction from a well limits data collection based on the number of wells, with data samples being collected over time as hydrocarbon material is extracted from the production well 106 of the pilot plant 100.

[0087] In some embodiments, for example, the one or more hydrocarbon material production metrics can include oil production rate, steam to oil ratio (SOR), water cut, ultimate recovery, and / or compositional change. Oil production rate indicates the rate at which oil is produced from the production well 106. Steam to oil ratio (SOR) indicates a ratio of the amount of steam injected into the subterranean formation via the injection well 104 to the amount of hydrocarbon material, stimulated by the injected steam and produced from the subterranean formation 102 by the production well 106. Water cut indicates water as a proportion of fluids produced by the production well 106. Ultimate recovery indicates an amount of hydrocarbon material that is potentially recoverable by the production well 106. Compositional change indicates a change in the composition of fluids produced by the production well 106 using the test technology versus the baseline technology.

[0088] In some embodiments, for example, the pilot plant 100 can be operated to produce hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 via in-situ extraction in a plurality of stages, in sequence. For each one of the stages, the hydrocarbon material production is effected using a respective test technology, such that a plurality of test technologies is provided. At each stage, statistical power analysis is performed, as described below. The statistical power analysis uses data collected from a previous stage to determine a minimum required sample size for a subsequent stage, which is used to determine an operating time interval for the subsequent stage. The pilot plant 100 is then operated for the respective operating time interval, to produce hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 via in-situ extraction by the respective test technology. In some embodiments, the baseline technology can be used by the pilot plant 100 to extract hydrocarbon material during one or more of the stages, thereby generating baseline data 328 during that stage of operation. In such embodiments, the baseline data 328 generated during a previous stage can be used to determine the minimum required sample size for a subsequent stage, which is used to determine an operating time interval for the subsequent stage.

[0089] In those embodiments where the pilot plant 100 is operated to produce hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 via in-situ extraction in a plurality of stages, in sequence, and, for each one of the stages, the hydrocarbon material production is effected using a respective test technology, such that a plurality of test technologies is provided, each one of the baseline technology and the test technologies, independently, is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material. In some embodiments, for example, for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

[0090] In some of these embodiments, for example, for one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid, for another one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid, and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid one of the test technologies is different than the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies. In some embodiments, for example, the ratio of one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid the test technology to the other one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid the another one of the test technologies is at least 1.1, such as, for example, at least 1.2, such as, for example, at least 1.3. In some embodiments, for example, for each one of the one of the test technologies and the another one of the test technologies, independently, the solvent material content, of the production-stimulating fluid, is at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % (such as, for example, at least 1.0 liquid equivalent volume %, such as, for example, at least 5.0 liquid equivalent volume %) of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

[0091] In those embodiments where a plurality of test technologies is being tested (in stages, as above-described), in some of these embodiments, for example, for one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating fluid includes a respective solvent material, and, for another one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating fluid includes a respective solvent material, and the solvent material of the production-stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is characterized by a different composition than the solvent material of the production-stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies.

[0092] Pilot plant data can be collected as a series of pilot plant data points from the production well 106. When a baseline technology is being used, the pilot plant data consists of baseline technology pilot plant data points. When a test technology is being used, the pilot plant data consists of test technology pilot plant data points. A data point collected from the production well 106 can represent a hydrocarbon material production metric applied to the output of the production well 106 (i.e., the material extracted from the production well) over a predetermined period of time, such as a day.

[0093] In some examples, a pilot plant 100 with multiple production wells 106, 108 can operate the production wells simultaneously to produce multiple data points of pilot plant data in a predetermined period of time. In other examples, the data from multiple production wells can be smoothed using an averaging function, such as a mean function, thereby generating only a single data point of pilot plant data during the predetermined period of time, but generating pilot plant data having a lower level of variation due to the smoothing of the data over multiple production wells.

[0094] The injection well 106 and the production well, 108 of the pilot plant 100 can be operated using a given technology (e.g. a baseline technology or a test technology) according to known methodologies pertaining to the particular technologies. Operating a pilot plant 100 using a given technology can involve performance of specific operations at the injector well 104, potentially using specific inputs (such as steam, solvents, or other injected materials). Similarly, operation of the pilot plant 100 using a given technology can involve performance of specific operations at the production well 106 to extract hydrocarbon materials.

[0095] The hydrocarbon material production metric(s) for the production well 106 can be measured based on data collected downhole, on the surface at the well, or at another location (such as within a processing facility of the pilot plant 100). The well monitoring device 208 for the production well 106 can use surface and / or downhole sensors, such as seismic sensors, temperature sensors, pressure sensors, and / or chemical sensors, to measure the hydrocarbon material production metric(s). In some examples, the hydrocarbon material production metric(s) can be determined based on analysis of the materials extracted from the production well 106, either at the well monitoring device 208 or at another location. The analysis of the materials extracted from the production well 106 can also include information from the injection well 104, and can generate information such as the composition of the extracted material (e.g. proportions or amounts of oil, water, and solvent), steam to oil ratio (SOR), and / or other measurements.

[0096] Example Computing System

[0097] FIG. 2 is a block diagram of an example computing system 200 including computing hardware suitable for implementing examples described herein. In some embodiments, computing system 200 can be an electronic computing device, such as a networked server. In other embodiments, the computing system 200 can be a distributed computing system including multiple devices (such as a cloud computing platform) or a virtual machine running on one or more devices in mutual communication over a network. Other examples suitable for implementing embodiments described in the present disclosure can be used, which can include components different from those discussed below. Although FIG. 2 shows a single instance of each component, there can be multiple instances of each component in the computing system 200.

[0098] The computing system 200 can include one or more processor devices (collectively referred to as processor device 202). The processor device 202 can include one or more processor devices such as a processor, a microprocessor, a digital signal processor, an application-specific integrated circuit (ASIC), a field- programmable gate array (FPGA), a dedicated logic circuitry, a dedicated artificial intelligence processor unit, or combinations thereof.

[0099] The computing system 200 can include one or more network interfaces (collectively referred to as network interface 210) for wired or wireless communication over a network. The network interface 210 can include wired links (e.g., Ethernet cable) and / or wireless links (e.g., one or more antennas). The computing system 200 can communicate with one or more user devices 206 (such as user workstation computers) and / or one or more well monitoring devices 208 via the network interface 210. In some examples, the user devices 206 and / or well monitoring devices 208 can communicate with the computing system 200 through other means, such as an input / output interface of the computing system 200 (not shown) or through an intermediate device in communication with the computing system 200.

[0100] The computing system 200 can include one or more non-transitory memories (referred to collectively as a memory 214), which can include a volatile or non-volatile memory (e.g., a flash memory, a random access memory (RAM), and / or a read-only memory (ROM)). The memory 214 can also include one or more mass storage units, such as a solid state drive, a hard disk drive, a magnetic disk drive and / or an optical disk drive.

[0101] The memory 214 can store instructions for execution by the processor device 202 to carry out examples described in the present disclosure. The instructions can include instructions for implementing and operating the pilot plant operation module 300 described below with reference to FIG. 3. The memory 214 can include other software instructions, such as for implementing an operating system and other applications / functions. In some examples, the computing system 200 can additionally or alternatively execute instructions from an external memory (e.g., an external drive in wired or wireless communication with the computing system 200) or can be provided executable instructions by a transitory or non- transitory computer-readable medium. Examples of non-transitory computer readable media include a RAM, a ROM, an erasable programmable ROM (EPROM), an electrically erasable programmable ROM (EEPROM), a flash memory, a CD-ROM, or other portable memory storage.

[0102] The computing system 200 can also include a bus 216 providing communication among components of the computing system 200, including those components discussed above. The bus 216 can be any suitable bus architecture including, for example, a memory bus, a peripheral bus or a video bus, or it can be another communication link such as a network interface 210.

[0103] Example Pilot Plant Operation Module

[0104] FIG. 3 illustrates an example pilot plant operation module 300. The pilot plant operation module 300 is executed by a computing system 200 to perform the methods and operations described herein. The pilot plant operation module 300 includes a number of sub-modules 302, 304, 308, 312, 316 as described below.

[0105] A user interface submodule 302 receives information from a user (e.g., via user device 206) indicating various types of information to be used in operating the pilot plant 100. The user provides technology information 320 indicating the various technologies to be used by the pilot plant 100, including a baseline technology and one or more test technologies, as described above. The technology information 320 can indicate operating parameters used for operating the pilot plant 100 using the various technologies, such as steam injection parameters, solvent injection parameters, etc.

[0106] The user provides effect information 322 representative of one or more effect sizes to be detected in operating the pilot plant 100 to test each of the test technologies. The effect sizes can each be representative of a respective degree of difference of a respective hydrocarbon material production metric between a given test technology and the baseline technology. For example, an effect size of +20% oil production rate (also referred to as 20% oil uplift) between a SAGD baseline technology and an ES-SAGD test technology can indicate that the pilot plant 100 is being used to test whether producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 via in-situ extraction using the ES-SAGD test technology exhibits 20% higher oil production rate than producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 via in-situ extraction using the SAGD baseline technology.

[0107] The user provides confidence information 324 indicating one or more target confidence values to be used in operating the pilot plant 100 to test each of the test technologies. The target confidence values can each be representative of a statistical confidence value to be achieved in testing whether each respective test technology exhibits its respective effect size relative to the baseline technology. Example target confidence values include measures of statistical confidence such as maximum alpha values (i.e. the probability of a false positive or type I error), maximum beta values (i.e. the probability of a false negative or type II error), minimum power values (i.e. one minus beta), and / or combinations thereof. In some embodiments, the target confidence values included in the confidence information 324 include at least a maximum alpha value and a maximum beta value, each indicating a maximum threshold for the respective value, thereby requiring that enough pilot data samples are collected to ensure that alpha falls below the maximum alpha value and beta falls below the maximum beta value. In some examples, the target confidence values include a maximum sum or a maximum weighted sum of the alpha value and the beta value of the effect size test performed using the pilot plant data.

[0108] The user interface submodule 302 can provide the information received from the user to various other submodules, such as the power analysis submodule 308 and planning submodule 316, as described below. The user interface submodule 302 can also receive additional user input information from the user and / or generate and send user output information to the user in some examples.

[0109] A variation projection submodule 304 receives variability information from one or more sources. The variability information can be representative of a variability measure of one or more of the hydrocarbon material production metrics: for example, the variability information can indicate or represent a variance or standard deviation of data collected from a production well (of the pilot plant 100 or another hydrocarbon material extraction facility) using the baseline technology or a historical technology. The variation projection submodule 304 uses the variability information to compute a projected variability measure 306 of the pilot plant data.

[0110] In some examples, the variability information 326 can include, or can be computed based on, historical data 326 collected from one or more other hydrocarbon material extraction facilities in the past using a historical technology. The historical data can include a plurality of data points, each indicating a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric applied to in-situ extraction of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 using the historical technology. In some examples, the historical technology is the same as the baseline technology used by the pilot plant 100 (such as SAGD as the historical technology and the baseline technology, and ES-SAGD as the test technology); in other examples, the historical technology can be closely related to the baseline technology (such as SAGD as the historical technology, a known ES-SAGD technology as the baseline technology, and a new ES-SAGD technology as the test technology).

[0111] In some embodiments, each of the historical technology, the baseline technology, and the test technology, independently, is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology. Each production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation 102 for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

[0112] In some examples, the variability information 326 can include, or can be computed based on, simulation data 327. The simulation data 327 can include a simulated variability measure of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the test technology, generated using a simulation or model of the test technology. For example, a geological model can be used to predict the behavior of the formation 102 in response to stimulation by the test technology, thereby generating a predicted level of oil production rate from a production well over time. The production well's oil production rate data samples over time predicted by the geological simulation constitute simulation data 327 that can be used by the variation projection submodule 304 to compute a projected variation measure 306 (such as variance or standard deviation) of the pilot plant data. In some examples, the model or simulation used to generate the simulation data 327 can be based on measured characteristics of the formation 102 from which the pilot plant 100 extracts hydrocarbon materials, thereby potentially yielding a more accurate simulation of the variability measure of the pilot plant data.

[0113] In some examples, the variation projection submodule 304 can obtain the variability information 326 from operations of the pilot plant 100 itself. The variability information 326 can be obtained by operating the pilot plant to perform in-situ extraction of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 using the baseline technology, thereby collecting baseline data 328 (also referred to herein as pilot plant baseline technology data 328). The baseline data 328 can include a plurality of baseline technology data points, each indicating a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the baseline technology as collected by the pilot plant. The variation projection submodule 304 can compute the projected variability measure 306 based at least in part on the baseline data 328.

[0114] Similarly, in some examples, the variability information 326 can be obtained by operating the pilot plant to perform in-situ extraction of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 using one or more of the test technologies, thereby collecting test data 330 (also referred to herein as pilot plant test technology data 330). The test data 330 can include a plurality of baseline technology data points, each indicating a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for one of the test technologies as collected by the pilot plant. The variation projection submodule 304 can compute the projected variability measure 306 based at least in part on the test data 330; for example, embodiments in which the pilot plant 100 operates in stages (as described above with reference to FIG. 1) can use test data 330 from a previous stage to compute the projected variability measure 306 for a subsequent stage.

[0115] It will be appreciated that the various data sources used for obtaining the variability information (e.g., historical data 326, simulation data 327, baseline data 328, and / or test data 330) can be non-uniform in terms of its effectiveness in determining the projected variability measure 306. For example, baseline data 328 collected from a production well 106 of the pilot plant 100 can vary over time as measured by the hydrocarbon material production metric: e.g., the rate of oil production of a production well 106 can increase or decrease in variance over time, and the more recent data can be more reflective of a projected variance of a subsequent stage of operation of the pilot plant 100. Thus, if the pilot plant 100 is operated to perform hydrocarbon material extraction from a production well 106 using a baseline technology 328 during a first stage from day 1 to day 100, a projected variability measure 306 for stage 2 (to begin on day 101) can be computed based on only the last 10 days of baseline data 328 (i.e., the baseline data 328 from day 91 to day 100).

[0116] Production well information 332 can also be obtained by the variation projection submodule 304, indicating a number of production wells 104, 108 of the pilot plant 100. The production well information 332 can be used by the variation projection submodule 304 in some examples to compute the projected variability measure 306. For example, two or more of the production wells can be designated by the variation projection submodule 304 for use in computing averaged or otherwise smoothed pilot plant data points, as described above with reference to FIG. 1. In some embodiments, the multiple production wells of the pilot plant 100 can be used to compute smoothed pilot plant data points (as determined by the variation projection submodule 304), to generate multiple pilot plant data points per predetermined time period (as determined by the duration prediction submodule 312 described below), or some combination thereof. Thus, the variability information can be computed by processing information representative of a variability measure of the hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process (e.g. historical data 326, simulation data 327, baseline data 328, and / or test data 330) as well as information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant information (i.e. the production well information 332) to compute the projected variability measure 306.

[0117] A power analysis submodule 308 performs statistical power analysis to determine a sample size of pilot plant data samples that must be collected by the pilot plant 100 in order to predict that the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to the baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value. The statistical power analysis is performed based on at least the effect size information 322, the confidence information 324, and the variability information 326 in order to compute a minimum required sample size 310. Thus, for example, the power analysis submodule 308 can receive effect size information 322 indicating a hypothetical effect size of +20% oil production rate (i.e. a 20% increase in a hydrocarbon material production metric, namely oil production rate, by the test technology relative to the baseline technology), confidence information 324 indicating a maximum alpha value of 0.05 and a maximum beta value of 0.05, and variability information 326 (e.g., a projected variability measure 306, derived from a variability measure of the historical data, for the pilot plant data samples) indicating a projected standard deviation of k barrels of oil per day for the pilot plant data collected from a pilot project 100 with a single production well 104. Based on these different pieces of information, the power analysis submodule 308 can apply known statistical power analysis techniques to compute the minimum required sample size 310 as the sample size (number of pilot plant data points) necessary to detect the effect size (20% higher oil production rate in the test technology relative to the baseline technology) with the target confidence value (i.e. alpha <semantics>≤0.05<annotation encoding="application / x-tex">\leq 0.05< / annotation>< / semantics> and beta <semantics>≤0.05<annotation encoding="application / x-tex">\leq 0.05< / annotation>< / semantics>). In some examples, the statistical power analysis performed by the power analysis submodule 308 can include an inequality T-Test with two independent sample groups (e.g. baseline data 328 and test data 330). The T-Test can assume equal variance as between the two sample groups, or it can allow unequal variance between the two sample groups. The effect size can be defined by a mean value for each sample group or a difference between the mean values of the sample groups. However, it will be appreciated that any suitable statistical power analysis technique can be used to determine a minimum required number of data samples to demonstrate the effect size at the target confidence value.

[0118] In some examples, such as examples in which the pilot plant 100 uses baseline data 328 to compute the projected variability measure 306, the power analysis performed by the power analysis module 308 computes a minimum required sample size that includes only test data 330. For example, a pilot plant 100 that has already collected a large number of samples of baseline data 328 can perform power analysis to determine a minimum required number of samples of test data 330 that must be collected in order to demonstrate the effect size with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value. This type of power analysis can also be performed by embodiments in which the pilot plant 100 operates in stages, and the projected variability measure 306 used for a subsequent stage is computed based at least on pilot plant data points collected during a previous stage.

[0119] In some embodiments, the power analysis submodule 308 can be implemented using existing statistical analysis and modeling software. In some embodiments, the power analysis submodule 308 can be configured to determine a relationship between effect size, target confidence value, the variability measure of the variability information 326, the number of production wells indicated in the production well information 332, and the minimum required sample size 310, such that graphs or other representations of the relationships between these variables can be generated. These representations can be presented to the user as user output information via the user interface submodule 302, and / or can be used to automatically select an optimal set of values for the effect size, target confidence value, number of production wells, and minimum required sample size 310, for example by using the planning submodule 316 to apply one or more planning metrics as described below. A new pilot plant 100 can then be planned and designed, and / or an existing pilot plant can be operated, in accordance with the selected variable values.

[0120] In embodiments using historical data 326 and / or simulation data 327 to provide the variability information to the variation projection submodule 304, the number of pilot data samples indicated by the minimum required sample size 310 can be the sum of two numbers: a test number, indicating a number of pilot data samples to be collected using the test technology (i.e. a test group sample size), and a control number, indicating a number of pilot data samples to be collected using the baseline technology (i.e. a control group sample size). Relative sizes of the test group and control group (i.e. respective sampling fractions of the minimum required sample size 310 allocated to the control group and test group) can be determined using known statistical techniques.

[0121] In embodiments using baseline data 328 to provide the variability information to the variation projection submodule 304 (i.e. the control data has already been collected), the number of pilot data samples indicated by the minimum required sample size 310 can simply be the test number, indicating the number of pilot plant data samples to be collected using the test technology (i.e. the test group sample size).

[0122] A duration prediction submodule 312 computes an operating time interval 314 based on the minimum required sample size 310. The operating time interval 314 is representative of a duration that the pilot plant must be operated that is sufficient to collect the number of pilot plant data samples indicated by the minimum required sample size 310. In some embodiments, the number of production wells indicated by the production well information 332 is also used to compute the operating time interval 314; for example, if two or more production wells 104, 108 are designated for collection of multiple pilot plant data samples simultaneously (instead of being used to reduce the variability measure through smoothing as described above), the operating time interval 314 can be reduced in a linear relation to the number of production wells simultaneously collecting pilot plant data points. Thus, in some embodiments the operating time interval 314 can be computed as the number of pilot plant data samples indicated by the minimum required sample size 310 multiplied by the predetermined period of time over which a single pilot plant data sample is collected, divided by the number of production wells simultaneously collecting pilot plant data points. In examples wherein two or more wells are grouped together to generate a single smoothed pilot plant data point per predetermined period of time, a single group of such wells can be treated as a single well for the purpose of computing the operating time interval 314.

[0123] In some examples, the predetermined period of time over which a single pilot plant sample is collected can be intentionally varied. For example, some pilot plants 100 can collect a pilot plant data point by analyzing a sample of extracted hydrocarbon material in a laboratory; such analysis can be performed based on a predetermined sampling rate, such as two times per week. In some examples, the sampling rate can be varied by testing three times per week or one time per week. In some examples, a user can specify a sampling rate via the user interface submodule 302, thereby changing the operating time interval 314 required to collect a given number of pilot data samples as computed by the duration prediction submodule 312. In some examples, such a change in sampling rate can also change the computations of the variation projection submodule 304 and / or the power analysis module 308, as a change in sampling rate can be expected to result in a different projected variance measure 306 in some contexts.

[0124] In some embodiments, a planning submodule 316 can be used to determine whether the technology information 320, effect size information 322, the confidence information 324, and the operating time interval 314 satisfy one or more planning metrics. The planning metrics can be used to determine whether a given course of action can or should be taken with respect to operation of the pilot plant 100. For example, the planning metrics can include a financial expenditure metric for computing a financial expenditure required to operate the pilot plant 100 for the operating time interval 314 using the baseline technology and / or the one or more test technologies, based on the operating parameters of the various technologies (e.g., amounts and formulations of solvents required to operate the pilot plant 100 over the operating time interval 314 using an ES-SAGD technology). The financial expenditure can be compared to an expected return (e.g. an increase in profits if a test technology is demonstrated to exhibit a given effect size and subsequently deployed at scale in the field) to generate a cost-benefit or return on investment (ROI) analysis. The planning metrics can also include an environmental impact metric for determining one or more environmental impacts of operating the pilot plant 100 over the operating time interval 314, such as an amount of solvent or hydrocarbon material dispersed into the ground. The environmental impact metric can be used to determine whether operation of the pilot plant 100 will comply with legal regulations or organizational policies governing environmental practices, and / or can be included in a cost-benefit analysis along with the outputs of one or more other planning metrics. The planning metrics can also include a temporal urgency metric for determining whether the pilot plant 100 can be operated to generate reliable data on the test technology(ies) before a deadline, or otherwise determine whether the operating time interval 314 is too long to meet temporal criteria.

[0125] In some examples, the planning metrics can be factored in to the representation of the relationship between the various data parameters (e.g. effect size, target confidence value, and operating time interval 314) such that one or more planning metric values is optimized by a selection of a set of mutually compatible data parameter values. For example, a financial expenditure metric can be used to identify an optimal combination of effect size (defined by the effect size information 322), target confidence value (defined by the confidence information 324), and ES-SAGD solvent injection parameters (defined by the technology information 320), resulting in an operating time interval 314 such that the operation of the pilot plant 100 using the ES-SAGD solvent injection parameters over the operating time interval 314 to demonstrate the effect size at the target confidence value is likely to maximize a projected return (e.g. increased oil production rate resulting in increased revenue) on investment (e.g. solvent costs, pilot plant operating costs). An environmental metric can further be applied as a constraint on this optimization operation to limit the amount of solvent, and / or the amount of a particular component of the solvent, that is predicted to be unrecoverable from the subterranean formation given the other data parameters. A temporal urgency metric could be further applied as a further constraint on the optimization operation to limit the operating time interval 314 to ensure that a specific deadline is met. In addition, or in the alternative, the environmental metric and / or the temporal urgency metric could be included as weighted values in the optimization computation itself, with environmental impact and / or lost time being assigned a value equivalent to financial value.

[0126] In some embodiments, no planning submodule 316 is included in the pilot plant operation module 300, and no planning metrics are used. The planning metrics can be considered to be automatically satisfied in such embodiments.

[0127] In response to determining that the planning metric(s) are satisfied, the pilot plant 100 can be operated to perform in-situ extraction of the hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation 102 for the operating time interval 314, thereby collecting the required number of pilot plant data samples.

[0128] Example Pilot Plant Operation Method

[0129] The operations of the computing system 200 in executing the pilot plant operation module 300 will now be described with reference to example methods for operating a pilot plant 100.

[0130] FIG. 4 is flowchart showing operations of an example method 400 for defining parameters for operation of a pilot plant 100 to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology.

[0131] At 402, the user interface submodule 302 of the pilot plant planning module 300 obtains the effect size information 322. At 404, the user interface submodule 302 obtains the confidence information 324. At 406, the variation projection submodule 304 obtains the production well information 332. Γ0132] At 408, the variation projection submodule 304 obtains the variability information 326. In different embodiments, operation 408 can include operations 408a, 408b, and / or 408c. At 408a, historical data 326 is obtained by the variation projection submodule 304. At 408b, simulation data 327 is obtained by the variation projection submodule 304. At 408c, baseline data 328 is obtained by the variation projection submodule 304 by operating the pilot plant 100 using the baseline technology to collect the pilot plant baseline technology data 328, as described above with reference to FIG. 3.

[0133] At 410, the variation projection submodule 304 determines a projected variability measure 306 of the pilot plant data. At 412, the power analysis submodule 308 performs power analysis, as described above, to compute the minimum required sample size 310. At 414, the duration prediction submodule 312 computes the operating time interval 314 based on the minimum required sample size 310 and optionally the production well information 332, as described above with reference to FIG. 3.

[0134] At 416, the planning submodule 316 determines whether the planning metric(s) are satisfied. If the planning metrics are satisfied, the method 400 proceeds to operation 418. If one or more of the planning metrics is not satisfied, the method 400 can terminate or can return to operation 402 to prompt the user for a different set of user inputs (e.g. a different effect size, target confidence value, test technology, and / or baseline technology, and / or identification of different data sources for determination of the variability measure) that will satisfy the planning metrics. In some embodiments, user output information can be generated and sent to the user device 206 via the user interface submodule 302 indicating to the user one or more details of why the user input provided does not satisfy the planning metrics and / or information indicating user input values or ranges thereof that can be more satisfactory.

[0135] At 418, the pilot plant 100 is operated over the operating time interval 314 to generate the number of pilot data samples indicated by the minimum required sample size 310. As described above, the pilot data samples can include test data 330 and / or baseline data 328 in different examples. The pilot plant data samples generated at operation 418 are collected at operation 420.

[0136] As described above, some embodiments can operate the pilot plant 100 in stages. In some such embodiments, a first iteration of operating the pilot plant 100 at operation 418 constitutes a first stage using a first test technology. After the first iteration of operation 418 is complete, the method 400 can proceed to operation 422, in which the pilot plant 100 is operated for one or more additional stages, wherein each additional stage uses a different test technology. Each subsequent stage after the first stage can begin by returning to operation 410 to determine a projected variability measure 306 of the pilot data to be collected during the subsequent stage. In some embodiments, the projected variability measure 306 for the subsequent stage is computed based on the pilot plant data samples collected during a previous stage, such as the immediately previous stage.

[0137] After operation 410 is complete for the subsequent stage, the method proceeds as described above, repeating operations 412, 414, 416, 418, and 420, and proceeding to operation 422 if additional stages remain to be performed.

[0138] Thus, for example, a pilot plant 100 can perform a first stage using a baseline technology, such as SAGD, to collect baseline data 328. The SAGD baseline data 328 can be used by the variation projection submodule 304 to determine a projected variability measure 306 for the second stage. The second stage can be performed using a first test technology. The test data 330 collected during the second stage can be used by the variation projection submodule 304 to determine a projected variability measure 306 for the third stage. The third stage can be performed using a second test technology. The test data 330 collected during the third stage can be used by the variation projection submodule 304 to determine a projected variability measure 306 for the fourth and final stage. The fourth stage can be performed using a third test technology.

[0139] General

[0140] Although the present disclosure describes functions performed by certain components and physical entities, it should be understood that, in a distributed system, some or all of the processes can be distributed among multiple components and entities, and multiple instances of the processes can be carried out over the distributed system.

[0141] Although the present disclosure describes methods and processes with steps in a certain order, one or more steps of the methods and processes can be omitted or altered as appropriate. One or more steps can take place in an order other than that in which they are described, as appropriate.

[0142] Although the present disclosure is described, at least in part, in terms of methods, a person of ordinary skill in the art will understand that the present disclosure is also directed to the various components for performing at least some of the aspects and features of the described methods, be it by way of hardware components, software or any combination of the two. Accordingly, the technical solution of the present disclosure can be embodied in the form of a software product. A suitable software product can be stored in a pre-recorded storage device or other similar non-volatile or non-transitory computer readable medium, including DVDs, CD-ROMs, USB flash disk, a removable hard disk, or other storage media, for example. The software product includes instructions tangibly stored thereon that enable a processing device (e.g., a personal computer, a server, or a network device) to execute examples of the methods disclosed herein. In general, the software improves the operation of the hardware in one or more ways.

[0143] The present disclosure can be embodied in other specific forms without departing from the subject matter of the claims. The described example embodiments are to be considered in all respects as being only illustrative and not restrictive. Selected features from one or more of the above-described embodiments can be combined to create alternative embodiments not explicitly described, features suitable for such combinations being understood within the scope of this disclosure.

[0144] All values and sub-ranges within disclosed ranges are also disclosed. Also, although the systems, devices and processes disclosed and shown herein can include a specific number of elements / components, the systems, devices and assemblies could be modified to include additional or fewer of such elements / components. For example, although any of the elements / components disclosed can be referenced as being singular, the embodiments disclosed herein could be modified to include a plurality of such elements / components. The subject matter described herein intends to cover and embrace all suitable changes in technology.

Claims

1. A method for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology, comprising: defining parameters for operation of the pilot plant, comprising: performing, using one or more computer systems, statistical power analysis based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process to compute a minimum required sample size, the minimum required sample size indicating a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value; computing, using the one or more computer systems, an operating time interval based on at least the minimum required sample size, the operating time interval being representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples; outputting, using the one or more computer systems, the operating time interval; and operating the pilot plant, for the operating time interval, to produce the hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction and collect the minimum required sample size of pilot plant data samples.

2. The method of claim 1; wherein: the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated at the pilot plant.

3. The method of claim 1 or 2; wherein: the pilot plant includes a production well; the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the production well; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the production well.

4. The method of claim 3; wherein: the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated from the same reservoir as the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology.

5. The method of any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein: the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells; and the variability information is computed based on processing of hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process; and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

6. The method of claim 5; wherein: the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

7. The method of any one of claims 1 to 3; wherein: the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least historical data obtained from producing hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using a historical technology; and the historical data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the historical technology.

8. The method of claim 4; wherein: both of: (i) the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology, and (ii) the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology, is effectuated from a first reservoir; the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least historical data obtained from producing hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using a historical technology from a second reservoir that is different than the first reservoir; and the historical data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the historical technology.

9. The method of claim 7 or 8; wherein: the historical technology is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

10. The method of claim 9; wherein: for the historical technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the historical technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the historical technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

11. The method of any one of claims 7 to 10, wherein: the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material production data further includes: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process; and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

12. The method of claim 11; wherein: the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

13. The method of any one of claims 1 to 3; wherein: the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least baseline data obtained from the producing of hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology; and the baseline data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of a hydrocarbon material production metric for the baseline technology.

14. The method of any one of claims 1 to 3; wherein: the variability information is computed based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least simulation data comprising a predicted variability measure of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the test technology.

15. The method of claim 13 or 14; wherein: the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material production data further includes: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process; and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

16. The method of claim 15; wherein: the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

17. The method of any one of claims 1 to 16; wherein: each one of the baseline technology and the test technology, independently, is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production- stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

18. The method of claim 17; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid; and for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

19. The method of claim 18; wherein: for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 1.0 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

20. The method of claim 19; wherein the baseline technology is SAGD; and the test technology is expanding solvent SAGD (ES-SAGD).

21. The method of claim 17; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid; and for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 0.1 volume % non-condensable gaseous material, wherein the non-condensable gaseous material and the hydrocarbon material are co-operatively configured such that the non-compressible gaseous material is soluble within the hydrocarbon material.

22. The method of claim 17; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is different than the solvent material content of the production- stimulating fluid the test technology.

23. The method of claim 22; wherein: the ratio of one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology and the solvent material content of the production- stimulating fluid the test technology to the other one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid the test technology is at least 1.1.

24. The method of claim 22 or 23; wherein: for each one of the baseline technology and the test technology independently, the solvent material content, of the production-stimulating fluid, is at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

25. The method of any one of claims 22 to 24; wherein: each one of the baseline technology and the test technology, independently, is ES-SAGD.

26. The method of any one of claims 1 to 16; wherein: the test technology is a well stimulation technology comprising at least one of thermal stimulation, chemical stimulation, microbiological stimulation, or hydraulic fracturing.

27. The method of any one of claims 1 to 16; wherein: the test technology is a displacement technology.

28. The method of claim 27; wherein: the displacement technology is a waterflooding technology.

29. The method of any one of claims 1 to 16; wherein: the test technology is an artificial lift technology.

30. The method of any one of claims 1 to 29, wherein the hydrocarbon material production metric is at least one of the following: oil production rate, indicating an amount of oil extracted by a production well; steam to oil ratio (SOR), indicating a ratio between an amount of steam injected and an amount of oil extracted by a production well; water cut, indicating water as a proportion of fluids extracted by a production well; ultimate recovery, indicating an amount of oil that is potentially recoverable by a production well; and compositional change, indicating a change in the composition of fluids extracted by a production well.

31. The method of any one of claims 7 to 16; further comprising: receiving measurements using a plurality of surface or subterranean sensors, wherein at least some of the hydrocarbon material production data is based on the received measurements.

32. A method for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction in a plurality of stages, in sequence, wherein, for each one of the stages, the hydrocarbon material production is effected using a respective test technology, such that a plurality of test technologies are provided, comprising: for each one of the stages, independently: performing statistical power analysis based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process to compute a minimum required sample size, the minimum required sample size indicating a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the respective test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value; computing a respective operating time interval based on at least the minimum required sample size, the respective operating time interval being representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples; and operating the pilot plant, for the respective operating time interval, to produce hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction by the respective test technology.

33. The method of claim 32; wherein: the variability information for each stage after a first stage is obtained by computing the variability measure of the hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process based on at least the pilot plant data samples collected during a previous stage.

34. The method of claim 32 or 33; wherein: the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated at the pilot plant.

35. The method of any one of claims 32 to 34; wherein: the pilot plant includes a production well; the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the production well; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the production well.

36. The method of claim 35; wherein: the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated from the same reservoir as the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology.

37. The method of any one of claims 32 to 36; wherein: each one of the baseline technology and the test technologies, independently, is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production- stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

38. The method of claim 37; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

39. The method of claim 38; wherein: at least one of the test technologies is ES-SAGD.

40. The method of claim 38; wherein: for one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; for another one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid one of the test technologies is different than the solvent material content of the production- stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies.

41. The method of claim 40; wherein: the ratio of one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid the test technology to the other one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid the another one of the test test technologies is at least 1.1.

42. The method of claim 40 or 41; wherein: for each one of the one of the test technologies and the another one of the test technologies, independently, the solvent material content, of the production- stimulating fluid, is at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

43. The method of claim 41 or 42; wherein: each one of the one of the test technologies and the another one of the test technologies, independently, is ES-SAGD.

44. A system for for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology, comprising: a processor device; and a memory storing instructions that, when executed by the processor device, cause the system to: define parameters for operation of the pilot plant by: performing statistical power analysis based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process to compute a minimum required sample size, the minimum required sample size indicating a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value; and computing an operating time interval based on at least the minimum required sample size, the operating time interval being representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples; and . operate the pilot plant, for the operating time interval, to produce the hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction and collect the minimum required sample size of pilot plant data samples.

45. The system of claim 44; wherein: the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated at the pilot plant.

46. The system of claim 44 or 45; wherein: the pilot plant includes a production well; the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the production well; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the production well.

47. The system of claim 46; wherein: the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated from the same reservoir as the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology.

48. The system of any one of claims 44 to 46, wherein: the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells; and the variability information is computed based on processing of hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process; and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

49. The system of claim 48; wherein: the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

50. The system of any one of claims 44 to 46; wherein: the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least historical data obtained from producing hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using a historical technology; and the historical data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the historical technology.

51. The system of claim 47; wherein: both of: (i) the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology, and (ii) the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology, is effectuated from a first reservoir; the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least historical data obtained from producing hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using a historical technology from a second reservoir that is different than the first reservoir; and the historical data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the historical technology.

52. The system of claim 50 or 51; wherein: the historical technology is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

53. The system of claim 52; wherein: for the historical technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the historical technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the historical technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

54. The system of any one of claims 50 to 53, wherein: the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material production data further includes: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process; and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

55. The system of claim 54; wherein: the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

56. The system of any one of claims 44 to 46; wherein: the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least baseline data obtained from the producing of hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology; and the baseline data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of a hydrocarbon material production metric for the baseline technology.

57. The system of any one of claims 44 to 46; wherein: the variability information is computed based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least simulation data comprising a predicted variability measure of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the test technology.

58. The system of claim 56 or 57; wherein: the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material production data further includes: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process; and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

59. The system of claim 58; wherein: the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

60. The system of any one of claims 44 to 59; wherein: each one of the baseline technology and the test technology, independently, is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production- stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

61. The system of claim 60; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid; and for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

62. The system of claim 61; wherein: for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 1.0 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

63. The system of claim 62; wherein the baseline technology is SAGD; and the test technology is expanding solvent SAGD (ES-SAGD).

64. The system of claim 60; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid; and for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 0.1 volume % non-condensable gaseous material, wherein the non-condensable gaseous material and the hydrocarbon material are co-operatively configured such that the non-compressible gaseous material is soluble within the hydrocarbon material.

65. The system of claim 60; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is different than the solvent material content of the production- stimulating fluid the test technology.

66. The system of claim 65; wherein: the ratio of one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology and the solvent material content of the production- stimulating fluid the test technology to the other one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid the test technology is at least 1.1.

67. The system of claim 65 or 66; wherein: for each one of the baseline technology and the test technology independently, the solvent material content, of the production-stimulating fluid, is at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

68. The system of any one of claims 65 to 67; wherein: each one of the baseline technology and the test technology, independently, is ES-SAGD.

69. The system of any one of claims 44 to 59; wherein: the test technology is a well stimulation technology comprising at least one of thermal stimulation, chemical stimulation, microbiological stimulation, or hydraulic fracturing.

70. The system of any one of claims 44 to 59; wherein: the test technology is a displacement technology.

71. The system of claim 70; wherein: the displacement technology is a waterflooding technology.

72. The system of any one of claims 44 to 59; wherein: the test technology is an artificial lift technology.

73. The system of any one of claims 44 to 72, wherein the hydrocarbon material production metric is at least one of the following: oil production rate, indicating an amount of oil extracted by a production well; steam to oil ratio (SOR), indicating a ratio between an amount of steam injected and an amount of oil extracted by a production well; water cut, indicating water as a proportion of fluids extracted by a production well; ultimate recovery, indicating an amount of oil that is potentially recoverable by a production well; and compositional change, indicating a change in the composition of fluids extracted by a production well.

74. The system of claim 48 further comprising: receiving measurements using a plurality of surface or subterranean sensors, wherein at least some of the hydrocarbon material production data is based on the received measurements.

75. A non-transitory computer-readable medium storing instructions thereon to be executed by a processor device, the instructions, when executed, causing the processor device to operate of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology by: defining parameters for the operation of the pilot plant, comprising: performing statistical power analysis based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process to compute a minimum required sample size, the minimum required sample size indicating a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value; and computing an operating time interval based on at least the minimum required sample size, the operating time interval being representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples; and operating the pilot plant, for the operating time interval, to produce hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction and collect the minimum required sample size of pilot plant data samples.

76. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 75; wherein: the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated at the pilot plant.

77. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 75 or 76; wherein: the pilot plant includes a production well; the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the production well; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the production well.

78. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 77; wherein: the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology is effectuated from the same reservoir as the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology.

79. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 75 to 77, wherein: the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells; and the variability information is computed based on processing of hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process; and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

80. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 79; wherein: the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

81. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 75 to 77; wherein: the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least historical data obtained from producing hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using a historical technology; and the historical data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the historical technology.

82. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 78; wherein: both of: (i) the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology, and (ii) the producing of hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology, is effectuated from a first reservoir; the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least historical data obtained from producing hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using a historical technology from a second reservoir that is different than the first reservoir; and the historical data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the historical technology.

83. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 81 or 82; wherein: the historical technology is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production-stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

84. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 83; wherein: for the historical technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the historical technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the historical technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid.

85. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 81 to 84, wherein: the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material production data further includes: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process; and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

86. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 85; wherein: the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

87. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 75 to 77; wherein: the variability information is obtained by computing the variability information based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least baseline data obtained from the producing of hydrocarbon material via in-situ extraction using the baseline technology; and the baseline data comprises a plurality of data points, each one of the data points, independently, being representative of a value of a hydrocarbon material production metric for the baseline technology.

88. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 75 to 77; wherein: the variability information is computed based on hydrocarbon material production data, wherein the hydrocarbon material production data includes at least simulation data comprising a predicted variability measure of the hydrocarbon material production metric for the test technology.

89. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 87 or 88; wherein: the pilot plant includes a plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material production data further includes: (i) information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon material production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process; and (ii) information representative of a number of the production wells of the pilot plant.

90. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 89; wherein: the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the test technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells; and the hydrocarbon material, produced from the subterranean formation via in- situ extraction by the baseline technology, is produced via the plurality of production wells.

91. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 75 to 90; wherein: each one of the baseline technology and the test technology, independently, is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology, wherein the production- stimulating fluid injection technology includes injecting of a production-stimulating fluid into the subterranean formation for stimulating production of the hydrocarbon material.

92. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 91; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid; and for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

93. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 92; wherein: for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 1.0 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

94. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 93; wherein the baseline technology is SAGD; and the test technology is expanding solvent SAGD (ES-SAGD).

95. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 91; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid; and for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes at least 0.1 volume % non-condensable gaseous material, wherein the non-condensable gaseous material and the hydrocarbon material are co-operatively configured such that the non-compressible gaseous material is soluble within the hydrocarbon material.

96. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 91; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a solvent material content expressed as a liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is different than the solvent material content of the production- stimulating fluid the test technology.

97. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 96; wherein: the ratio of one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology and the solvent material content of the production- stimulating fluid the test technology to the other one of the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology and the solvent material content of the production-stimulating fluid the test technology is at least 1.1.

98. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 96 or 97; wherein: for each one of the baseline technology and the test technology independently, the solvent material content, of the production-stimulating fluid, is at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the one of the test technologies is defined by at least a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid.

99. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 96 to 98; wherein: each one of the baseline technology and the test technology, independently, is ES-SAGD.

100. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 75 to 90; wherein: the test technology is a well stimulation technology comprising at least one of thermal stimulation, chemical stimulation, microbiological stimulation, or hydraulic fracturing.

101. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 75 to 90; wherein: the test technology is a displacement technology.

102. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 101; wherein: the displacement technology is a waterflooding technology.

103. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 75 to 90; wherein: the test technology is an artificial lift technology.

104. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of any one of claims 75 to 103, wherein the hydrocarbon material production metric is at least one of the following: oil production rate, indicating an amount of oil extracted by a production well; steam to oil ratio (SOR), indicating a ratio between an amount of steam injected and an amount of oil extracted by a production well; water cut, indicating water as a proportion of fluids extracted by a production well; ultimate recovery, indicating an amount of oil that is potentially recoverable by a production well; and compositional change, indicating a change in the composition of fluids extracted by a production well.

105. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of claim 81; further comprising: receiving measurements using a plurality of surface or subterranean sensors, wherein at least some of the hydrocarbon material production data is based on the received measurements.

106. A computer implemented method for operation of a pilot plant to produce hydrocarbon material from a subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a test technology, comprising: performing, using one or more computer systems, statistical power analysis based on at least effect size information representative of an effect size to be detected, confidence information representative of a target confidence value, and variability information representative of a variability measure of a hydrocarbon production metric of a hydrocarbon material producing process to compute a minimum required sample size, the minimum required sample size indicating a minimum number of pilot plant data samples required to predict that producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using the test technology exhibits the effect size relative to producing hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction using a baseline technology with a statistical confidence indicated by the target confidence value; computing, using the one or more computer systems, an operating time interval based on at least the minimum required sample size, the operating time interval being representative of a time interval, for operating the pilot plant, sufficient to collect at least the minimum number of pilot plant data samples; wherein: the baseline technology is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology; wherein: the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology includes at least 99.8 cold water equivalent ("CWE") volume % of steam, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the baseline technology is defined by at least a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid; the test technology is a production-stimulating fluid injection technology wherein: the production-stimulating fluid of the test technology includes steam and at least 0.5 liquid equivalent volume % of solvent material, based on the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid, wherein the total liquid equivalent volume of the production stimulating fluid of the test technology is defined by at least: (a) a total CWE volume of steam within the production stimulating fluid, and (b) a total liquid equivalent volume of solvent material within the production stimulating fluid; and the solvent material and the hydrocarbon material are co- operatively configured such that the hydrocarbon material is soluble within the solvent material; outputting, using the one or more computer systems, the operating time interval; and operating the pilot plant, for the operating time interval, to produce hydrocarbon material from the subterranean formation via in-situ extraction and collect the minimum required number of pilot plant data samples.

107. The method as clamed in claim 106; wherein: the baseline technology is SAGD; and the test technology is ES-SAGD.

108. The method of claim 107; wherein: for the baseline technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a respective solvent material; for the test technology, the production-stimulating fluid includes a respective solvent material; and the solvent material of the production-stimulating fluid of the baseline technology has a different composition than the solvent material of the production- stimulating fluid the test technology.

109. The method of claim 108; wherein: for one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating fluid includes a respective solvent material; for another one of the test technologies, the production-stimulating fluid includes a respective solvent material; and the solvent material of the production-stimulating fluid one of the test technologies has a different composition than the solvent material of the production-stimulating fluid of the another one of the test technologies.