Method and system for controlling thrust generated by multiple engines on an aircraft to assist in specific flight conditions
By actively managing engine thrust and monitoring longitudinal acceleration and other parameters, ensuring that the aircraft quickly recovers the nose downward at high angle of attack, solving the problems of complexity and cost in the prior art and improving performance and maintenance convenience.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN201910066064.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2018-02-06
- Filing Date
- 2019-01-24
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-05
- Estimated Expiration
- 2039-01-24
AI Technical Summary
The prior art increases system complexity, weight and cost when ensuring that the aircraft's head is recovered downwardly at a high angle of attack, which affects the performance and maintenance difficulty of the aircraft.
By monitoring the longitudinal acceleration and other control parameters of the aircraft, actively manage the thrust generated by multiple engines, reduce the thrust to ensure that the aircraft parameters are below the preset maximum value, realize the downward recovery of the nose, and use flight control computing equipment and propulsion control calculations The coupling system of the equipment performs thrust adjustment.
Without increasing the design complexity and cost of the aircraft, ensuring that the aircraft quickly recovers the nose downward at high angles of attack states, reducing system complexity and weight, and improving performance and maintenance convenience.
Smart Images

Figure CN110116815B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present disclosure relates generally to the operation of an aircraft and, more particularly, to a method of controlling thrust generated by a plurality of engines on an aircraft to assist in a nose-down recovery of the aircraft. Background Art
[0002] The aircraft or airplane must be able to recover quickly from a stall at any angle of attack (AOA) that the airplane is capable of achieving at any permissible power setting. This is required from a regulatory perspective, as specified in 14 CFR §25.145. Aircraft manufacturers may impose additional requirements and design guidelines applicable to this flight regime. Providing adequate recovery capability in this situation has traditionally resulted in compromises in airplane design that impact cost, complexity, and performance.
[0003] Existing approaches to providing adequate recovery capability have traditionally managed pitch-up and ensured rapid nose-down recovery from high AOA by: imposing constraints and modifications to the wing leading and trailing edge flap designs to reduce the magnitude of aerodynamic pitch-up; using stall strips and other flow control devices on the wing leading edges to manage the progression of airflow separation; imposing constraints and modifications to the wing anti-ice systems to reduce the magnitude of aerodynamic pitch-up in icing conditions; and adding areas to the horizontal tail to increase stability and pitch control forces.
[0004] Existing approaches impact system complexity, weight, maintenance and cost. In addition, these solutions may negatively impact aircraft performance by increasing operational speed (e.g., landing approach speeds that impact customer performance assurance and sales).
[0005] What is needed is a system that ensures rapid nose-down recovery of an aircraft under critical conditions without adding complexity, weight, and / or cost to the aircraft design. Summary of the invention
[0006] In one example, a method of controlling thrust generated by a plurality of engines on an aircraft to assist in a nose-down recovery of the aircraft is described. The method includes: selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter; measuring a value of the aircraft parameter while the aircraft is in flight; determining that the measured value exceeds the maximum value based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measured value; and reducing the thrust generated by each of the plurality of engines so that the measured value of the aircraft parameter is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter.
[0007] In another example, a non-transitory computer readable medium having instructions stored thereon that, when executed by one or more processors of a computing device, cause the computing device to perform functions including: selecting a maximum value for an aircraft parameter; measuring a value of the aircraft parameter while the aircraft is in flight; determining that the measured value exceeds the maximum value based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measured value; and reducing the thrust generated by each engine so that the measured value of the aircraft parameter is below the maximum value for the aircraft parameter.
[0008] In another example, a system is described that includes a flight control computing device having a processor and a memory storing instructions executable by the processor to: select a maximum value of an aircraft parameter of an aircraft; receive a measurement of the value of the aircraft parameter while the aircraft is in flight; determine that the measurement exceeds the maximum value based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measurement; and send a signal indicating a reduction in thrust generated by each of a plurality of engines of the aircraft so that the measurement is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter. The system also includes a plurality of propulsion control computing devices coupled to the plurality of engines of the aircraft, and a respective propulsion control computing device is coupled to a respective engine. Each propulsion control computing device has a processor and a memory storing instructions executable by the processor to receive a signal from the flight control computing device and control the thrust generated by a respective engine of the plurality of engines.
[0009] The features, functions, and advantages that have been discussed can be achieved independently in various examples or may be combined in yet other examples. Further details of the examples can be seen with reference to the following description and drawings. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0010] The novel features which are believed to be characteristic of the illustrative examples are set forth in the appended claims. However, the illustrative examples and their preferred modes of use, further objects and description will be best understood by reference to the following detailed description of illustrative examples of the present disclosure when read in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0011] Figure 1 A block diagram of an example aircraft is shown according to an example implementation.
[0012] Figure 2 is a flow chart illustrating example operation of an STL function according to one example implementation.
[0013] Figure 3 is an example illustration of an aircraft and forces acting on the aircraft according to an example implementation.
[0014] Figure 4 is a graph showing the longitudinal acceleration (n) of a light aircraft according to an example embodiment.x An example diagram of the relationship between )(g) and angle of attack (AOA) (degrees).
[0015] Figure 5 is a graph showing the longitudinal acceleration (n) of a heavy aircraft according to an example embodiment. x Another example graph of the relationship between )(g) and angle of attack (AOA) (degrees).
[0016] Figure 6 A flow chart illustrating an example method of controlling thrust generated by a plurality of engines on an aircraft to assist in a nose-down recovery of the aircraft, according to an example implementation.
[0017] Figure 7 A method for performing Figure 6 A flow chart of an example method of selecting a function of the method.
[0018] Figure 8 A method for performing Figure 6 A flow chart of another example method of selecting a function of a method.
[0019] Fig. 9 A method for performing Figure 6 A flow chart of another example method of selecting a function of a method.
[0020] Fig.10 A method for performing Figure 6 A flow chart of another example method of selecting a function of a method.
[0021] Fig.11 A method for performing Figure 6 A flow chart of another example method of selecting a function of a method.
[0022] Fig.12 A method for performing Figure 6 A flow chart of another example method of selecting a function of a method.
[0023] Fig.13 A method for performing Figure 6 A flow chart of another example method of selecting a function of a method.
[0024] Fig.14 A method for performing Figure 6 A flow chart of another example method of measuring functionality of a method.
[0025] Fig.15A method for performing Figure 6 A flowchart of an example method of reducing functionality of a method.
[0026] Fig.16 According to an example implementation, Figure 6 The method is shown in conjunction with a flow chart of an example method.
[0027] Fig.17 According to an example implementation, Figure 6 00136] A flowchart of another example method for use in conjunction with the method shown in FIG.
[0028] Fig.18 According to an example implementation, Figure 6 00136] A flowchart of another example method for use in conjunction with the method shown in FIG.
[0029] Fig.19 According to an example implementation, Figure 6 00136] A flowchart of another example method for use in conjunction with the method shown in FIG. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0030] The disclosed examples will now be described more fully below with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which some but not all of the disclosed examples are shown. In fact, several different examples may be described, and they should not be construed as limited to the examples set forth herein. Instead, these examples are described so that the disclosure will be thorough and complete, and will fully convey the scope of the disclosure to those skilled in the art.
[0031] In an example, a method and system for controlling engine thrust from an aircraft engine to modify the positioning of the aircraft during extreme / critical conditions is described. More specifically, the example method and system actively manages the amount of engine thrust generated by each engine of the aircraft for assisting in nose-down recovery in high angle of attack and high thrust flight conditions. The amount of thrust generated by all engines of the aircraft is actively managed to counteract adverse conditions that impede nose-down recovery, namely, nose-up pitching moments caused by aerodynamic flow separation over the wing and / or nose-up pitching moments generated by the engines.
[0032] Example methods and systems continuously monitor various control parameters of the aircraft and compare the monitored parameters to preset limit conditions. In one example, the system measures the longitudinal acceleration (n x ) (which is a measure of the excess engine thrust relative to the drag and weight of the aircraft) and compares this measure to a predetermined maximum value n x If the measured n x The value exceeds the predetermined maximum value n x, the system adjusts the engine thrust produced by each engine of the aircraft so that the measured n x This ensures a rapid nose-down recovery.
[0033] When the method and system are activated, the engine thrust is reduced by a predetermined amount to ensure continued safe operation of the aircraft. For example, the method and system may be activated only during critical control conditions and not interfere with normal operation of the aircraft. In addition, the predetermined maximum values set for the monitored aircraft parameters are limited to values that are greater than the capability of the performance of an aircraft having only a single engine, thereby eliminating the need for additional monitoring and detection, including engine failure. In other words, if the aircraft is operating on one engine, activation of the method and system will not be permitted. The method and system employs other control parameters in conjunction with the longitudinal acceleration n x Combined with or instead of longitudinal acceleration n x These other parameters include the vehicle's angle of attack, flight path angle, pitch angle, total energy state, etc.
[0034] Now referring to the accompanying drawings, Figure 1 A block diagram of an example aircraft 100 is shown according to an example implementation. The aircraft 100 includes a system 102 coupled to a plurality of engines 104. The plurality of engines 104 is shown to include two engines 106 and 108. Although the aircraft 100 is shown with two engines 106 and 108, more than two engines may be included, for example, and each engine may include substantially the same components.
[0035] The system 102 includes a flight control computing device 110, which is directly or indirectly and using wireless or wired means coupled to (one or more) propulsion control computing devices 112a-b. The system 102 is shown as including two propulsion control computing devices 112a-b, and each propulsion control computing device is independently coupled to a corresponding engine 106 and 108. In examples where the aircraft 100 includes more engines, more propulsion control computing devices are included, such as providing one propulsion control computing device for each engine. In addition, each propulsion control computing device 112a-b is identical and includes the same components.
[0036] Thus, system 102 includes a plurality of propulsion control computing devices coupled to the plurality of engines 104 of aircraft 100, with respective propulsion control computing devices coupled to respective engines. Propulsion control computing devices 112a-b are responsible for operating engines 106 and 108 to produce thrust in accordance with commands, some of which include, for example, commands for this function from a flight control computing device.
[0037] Each of the flight control computing device 110 and the propulsion control computing devices 112a-b has one or more processors 114 and 116, and also has communication interfaces 118 and 120, data storage 122 and 124, and output interfaces 126 and 128 connected to communication buses 130 and 132, respectively. The flight control computing device 110 and the propulsion control computing devices 112a-b also include hardware for implementing communications within the computing device and between the computing device and other devices (not shown). For example, the hardware includes a transmitter, a receiver, and an antenna.
[0038] Communication interfaces 118 and 120 can be wireless interfaces and / or one or more wired interfaces that allow both short-range communication and long-range communication with one or more networks or with one or more remote devices. Such wireless interfaces provide communication under one or more wireless communication protocols, Bluetooth, WiFi (e.g., Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) 802.11 protocols), long term evolution (LTE), cellular communications, near field communications (NFC) and / or other wireless communication protocols. Such wired interfaces include Ethernet interfaces, universal serial bus (USB) interfaces or similar interfaces that communicate with wired networks via wires, twisted pairs, coaxial cables, optical links, optical fiber links or other physical connections. Therefore, communication interfaces 118 and 120 are configured to receive input data from one or more devices, and are also configured to send output data to other devices.
[0039] Data stores 122 and 124 include or take the form of memory, such as one or more computer-readable storage media that can be read or accessed by processors 114 and 116. Computer-readable storage media may include volatile and / or non-volatile storage components, such as optical, magnetic, organic, or other memory or disk storage, which may be integrated in whole or in part with processors 114 and 116. Data stores 122 and 124 are considered to be non-transitory computer-readable media. In some examples, data stores 122 and 124 may be implemented using a single physical device (e.g., one optical, magnetic, organic, or other memory or disk storage unit), while in other examples, data stores 122 and 124 may be implemented using two or more physical devices.
[0040] Thus, data memories 122 and 124 are non-transitory computer-readable storage media and have stored thereon executable instructions 134 and 136. Instructions 134 and 136 comprise computer executable code. Data memories 122 of flight control computing device 110 also store aircraft parameters 138 (described more fully below).
[0041] The processors 114 and 116 may be general purpose processors or special purpose processors (e.g., digital signal processors, application specific integrated circuits, etc.). The processor(s) 114 and 116 receive inputs from the communication interfaces 118 and 120 and from other sensors and process the inputs to generate outputs that are stored in the data stores 122 and 124 and used to control the plurality of engines 104. The processors 114 and 116 may be configured to execute executable instructions 134 and 136 (e.g., computer readable program instructions) that are stored in the data stores 122 and 124 and that are executable to provide the functionality of the computing devices 110 and 112a-b described herein.
[0042] Output interfaces 126 and 128 output information, such as outputting information from flight control computing device 110 to propulsion control computing devices 112a-b, or outputting information from propulsion control computing devices 112a-b to multiple engines 104. For example, flight control computing device 110 is coupled to each of propulsion control computing devices 112a-b to output information. In addition, propulsion control computing device 112a outputs information to engine 108, and propulsion control computing device 112b outputs information to engine 106. Then, for example, each engine can be independently controlled by the corresponding propulsion control computing device. Therefore, output interfaces 126 and 128 are similar to communication interfaces 118 and 120, and can also be wireless interfaces (e.g., transmitters) or wired interfaces.
[0043] The system 102 also includes (one or more) inertial reference units (IRUs) 140. The IRUs 140 are inertial sensors that include or use gyroscopes and accelerometers to determine changes in the rotational attitude (angular orientation relative to some reference frame) and translational position (typically latitude, longitude, and altitude) of the aircraft 100 over a period of time. The IRUs may also be referred to as inertial measurement units (IMUs). The IRUs 140 measure the values of (one or more) aircraft parameters while the aircraft 100 is in flight and output the measurements of the values of the aircraft parameters to the flight control computing device 110.
[0044] In one example, in operation, when the executable instructions 134 are executed by the processor 114 of the flight control computing device 110, the processor 114 is caused to perform functions including: selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter of the aircraft 100; receiving a measurement of the value of the aircraft parameter while the aircraft 100 is in flight; determining that the measured value exceeds the maximum value based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measured value; and sending a signal instructing to reduce the thrust generated by each of the engines 106 and 108 of the plurality of engines 104 of the aircraft 100 so that the measured value is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter.
[0045] The propulsion control computing devices 112a-b are coupled to the plurality of engines 104 of the aircraft 100 and, when the executable instructions 136 are executed by the processor 116 of the propulsion control computing devices 112a-b, cause the processor 116 to perform functions including receiving signals from the flight control computing device 110 and controlling the thrust generated by each engine 106 and 108 of the plurality of engines 104. The propulsion control computing devices 112a-b control the thrust generated by each engine 106 and 108 of the plurality of engines 104 independently of each other.
[0046] An aircraft (e.g., specifically an airplane) must be able to recover rapidly from a stall at any angle of attack (AOA) that the airplane is capable of achieving at any permissible power setting. The ability to recover from high AOA is required from a regulatory perspective as specified in 14 CFR §25.145. This requirement is summarized as follows: The airplane must have rapid nose-down recovery from any AOA that the airplane is capable of achieving at any permissible power setting, trimmed at any power setting down to speeds as low as 1.23VS1g, in any normal configuration (including speed brakes). Therefore, the aircraft should have sufficient nose-down pitch capability to ensure rapid acceleration from the stall speed to the trim speed with power on and off.
[0047] With respect to longitudinal control, the airplane must be capable of pitching the nose down at any point between the trim speed specified in 14 CFR §25.103(b)(6) and stall identification (as defined in §25.201(d)) so that it can rapidly accelerate to that selected trim speed when the airplane is trimmed at the trim speed specified in §25.103(b)(6), with the landing gear extended, the wing flaps (i) retracted and (ii) extended, and electrical power (i) off and (ii) at maximum continuous power for the engines.
[0048] In the example described herein, the flight control computing device 110 and the propulsion control computing devices 112a-b together execute executable instructions 134 and 136 to perform a symmetric thrust limiting (STL) function for the aircraft 100 to meet the above-mentioned design requirements. The STL function is a flight control law that actively manages excess engine thrust capability under certain conditions to ensure rapid recovery capabilities from high angle of attack (AOA) and high thrust conditions in order to meet or exceed the above-mentioned design requirements. For example, the STL function includes reliable and robust detection of conditions that trigger engine thrust changes. The system 102 utilizes easily measurable parameters, compares the measured parameter value to a predetermined maximum value, and adjusts the engine thrust generated by all multiple engines 104 to ensure rapid nose-down recovery of the aircraft 100 under critical conditions.
[0049] In an example, thrust control for nose-down recovery is applicable to an aircraft configuration in which the thrust acts below the center of gravity of the aircraft. For example, thrust control for nose-up control can also be used for nose-up control of an aircraft configuration in which the thrust acts above the center of gravity.
[0050] Figure 2 1 is a flow chart illustrating an example operation of the STL function according to one example implementation. First, a maximum value of an aircraft parameter is selected for monitoring. Many different aircraft parameters are used for the STL function, and examples include the longitudinal acceleration (n) of the aircraft 100. x )(For example, longitudinal acceleration (n x ) is a measure of excess engine thrust relative to the drag and weight of the aircraft 100), the angle of attack (AoA) of the aircraft 100, the flight path angle of the aircraft 100, and / or the pitch angle of the aircraft 100. In addition, more than one parameter may be selected and monitored. For example, a maximum value of the aircraft parameter is selected to be at a limit that provides recovery capability of the aircraft 100 at AOA above a threshold, and is selected based on the weight of the aircraft 100. In other examples, the maximum value of the aircraft parameter is selected to be a value greater than a value achievable by the aircraft 100 in flight in the event of a single engine failure. For example, for a twin-engine aircraft, the maximum value of the aircraft parameter is selected to be a value greater than a value achievable by the aircraft 100 in flight using a single engine of the plurality of engines 104.
[0051] Next, the IRU(s) 140 measure the value of an aircraft parameter while the aircraft 100 is in flight. For example, when the aircraft parameter is longitudinal acceleration (n x ), the IRU(s) 140 measure the longitudinal acceleration (n x ) and outputs the measured values to the flight control computing device 110.
[0052] Flight control computing device 110 references stored aircraft parameters 138, which include a selected or stored maximum value for each aircraft parameter, to compare the measured aircraft parameter to the stored maximum value. Figure 2 As shown, the flight control computing device 110 measures the longitudinal acceleration (n x ) and the stored longitudinal acceleration (n x_reference). Based on the comparison of the maximum value and the measured value, flight control computing device 110 may determine whether the measured value exceeds the maximum value. In the event that the measured value exceeds the maximum value, flight control computing device 110 sends a signal to propulsion control computing device 112a-b instructing to reduce the thrust generated by each of engines 106 and 108 in plurality of engines 104 so that the measured value of the aircraft parameter is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter.
[0053] The propulsion control computing devices 112a-b then operate the plurality of engines 104 to reduce thrust in a desired manner. In one example, the amount by which the thrust is reduced is proportional to the amount by which the measured value exceeds the maximum value. The propulsion control computing devices 112a-b set a maximum amount of thrust reduction to maintain the desired climb capability. To determine the amount of thrust reduction, the propulsion control computing devices 112a-b reduce the thrust produced by each of the engines 106 and 108 by a first amount (e.g., approximately 20% of the maximum thrust produced by all operating engines), and then, after reducing the thrust, the STL function monitors the aircraft response 142, such as by measuring a second value of an aircraft parameter. Next, based on the second measured value exceeding the maximum value, the propulsion control computing devices 112a-b reduce the thrust produced by each of the engines 106 and 108 by a second amount that is greater than the first amount (e.g., an additional 5%). Propulsion control computing devices 112a-b perform engine thrust reduction on an iterative basis, eg, iteratively measuring a value of an aircraft parameter and reducing thrust produced by each of engines 106 and 108 until the measured value of the aircraft parameter is below a maximum value of the aircraft parameter.
[0054] like Figure 2 As shown, in real time (during the flight of the aircraft 100), the flight control computing device 110 measures n x Relative to n x_reference The comparison is performed, and if the output of the sum function is negative, the STL function is not triggered. However, if the aircraft 100 is in the measured n x Higher than n x_reference If the flight condition is such that the flight control computing device 110 sends a signal to reduce the engine thrust by a certain amount, x When it starts to decrease and the output of the sum function approaches zero, the STL function terminates.
[0055] Thus, the output of the summing point represents an error, which can be multiplied by a gain to determine the amount of thrust reduction for each engine. If the error is a high value, a maximum thrust reduction (e.g., approximately 20% thrust reduction) can be commanded, or if the error is low, a slight / low thrust reduction is commanded. The amount of thrust reduction is then proportional to the error, and the STL function is a closed-loop function that operates in an iterative manner to drive the error closer to zero. The maximum amount of thrust reduction can be limited to an amount that will make the total thrust capability of the aircraft 100 greater than the capability in the event of a single engine failure. As a result, any erroneous activation of the STL function is still able to achieve a safe thrust level for the aircraft 100, and this ensures that the required climb capability is not lost. The limitation can be enforced by the flight control computing device 110 and independently enforced by the propulsion control computing devices 112a-b.
[0056] Once the measured value of the aircraft parameter is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter, nose-down recovery of aircraft 100 is improved and pilot command of a nose-down pitch attitude is now permitted.
[0057] In the example scenario, at high AOA, there are two main sources of nose-up pitching moments on the aircraft that impede nose-down recovery. First, the nose-up pitching moment is caused by aerodynamic flow separation over the wing of the aircraft 100, and this is typically caused by the outboard portion of the wing losing airlift before the inboard portion of the wing. This can also occur in the case of ice accumulation on the wing leading edge.
[0058] Second, a nose-up pitch moment can be generated by multiple engines 104, and the source of the pitch-up is composed of direct thrust contribution and indirect thrust contribution. The direct thrust contribution to the pitch-up is the result of the magnitude of the thrust vectors of multiple engines 104 multiplied by their moment arms below the center of gravity of the aircraft. The contribution of indirect thrust to the pitch-up is caused by the change of aerodynamic flow on the wings of the aircraft under higher thrust settings. The sum of the direct and indirect thrust components is usually negligible at idle thrust, but significant at maximum thrust. At high AOA, aerodynamic and thrust pitch-up components can be combined to cause slow nose-down recovery or unrecoverable stalls, even in the case of full nose-down pitch control. Some traditional methods of managing this pitch-up include changes in wing leading edge flaps and wing trailing edge flaps, changes in wing anti-ice coverage, larger horizontal tails, and restrictions on the rear center of gravity range at light weight.
[0059] However, using the STL functionality described herein, actively managing engine thrust under specific control conditions mitigates the engine-induced pitch-up and ensures that rapid nose-down recovery capability is available at all achievable AOAs. The STL functionality enables an additional degree of freedom for the vehicle designer that can be used to find the appropriate balance of system complexity, vehicle performance, center of gravity range, and vehicle cost.
[0060] Figure 3 is an example illustration of an aircraft 100 and the forces acting on the aircraft 100 according to an example embodiment. By dividing the measured longitudinal acceleration (n x ) and the reference maximum value n x The comparison is made to determine the excess engine thrust capability and the longitudinal acceleration (n x ). For example, when measuring n x Exceeding reference n x When activated, the STL function of the system 102 will issue a command to reduce the thrust of all engines 106 and 108 in the plurality of engines 104.
[0061] Longitudinal acceleration (n x ) is a measure of excess engine thrust capability (e.g., if excess engine thrust capability is high, then n x high, and if the excess engine thrust capability is low, then n x Low). In order to calculate n x , the sum of the forces acting on the aircraft 100 is as follows:
[0062]
[0063] Next, the longitudinal acceleration (n x )Solve:
[0064]
[0065] Where T NET is the net thrust (lb), F AEROx Yes X BODY aerodynamic force in the axis (lb), W is the gross weight of the aircraft (lb), and n x It is along X BODY Acceleration factor of the axis (g).
[0066] Figure 4 is a graph showing the longitudinal acceleration (n) of a light aircraft according to an example embodiment. x An example diagram of the relationship between )(g) and angle of attack (AOA) (degrees). Figure 5is a graph showing the longitudinal acceleration (n) of a heavy aircraft according to an example embodiment. x Another example graph of the relationship between )(g) and angle of attack (AOA) (degrees).
[0067] In an example, for example, a light aircraft may be considered to be approximately less than 1.25 OEW (operation empty weight), while a heavy aircraft may be considered to be above a maximum landing weight (MLW) up to a maximum take-off weight (MTOW). Such absolute weights, for example, depend on the aircraft.
[0068] Longitudinal acceleration (n x ) is a measure of the excess engine thrust relative to drag and weight. High n x Expresses the acceleration that changes airspeed and / or counter-gravity at a given weight. Figure 4 As shown, the limiting maximum value n can be selected to provide sufficient recovery capability at high AOA in critical conditions where controllability is threatened. x For example, if n x The limit is set above the achievable thrust level for level flight and idle thrust, but below the maximum thrust for a given AOA, so that the aircraft is still able to apply thrust for recovery purposes if necessary. Figure 5 As shown, for heavy aircraft, even at high AOA, the limiting maximum value n x It will not reduce thrust either, because the greater weight results in a lower level of n x The maximum thrust is experienced.
[0069] As shown in the figure, when n x When n is high, the aircraft can use energy to climb or accelerate as needed, but when n x When n is low, this capability will be reduced. Therefore, setting n x A threshold or limit below which the aircraft is known to have adequate recovery capabilities and which is set above a level at which activation of the STL function is undesirable.
[0070] Thus, active management of the maximum thrust on the engines 106 and 108 of the aircraft 100 can be provided under certain conditions that affect the controllability of the aircraft. The STL function manages the maximum thrust of both engines 160 and 108 while maintaining the required climb capability. For conditions that are not critical to the nose down recovery capability, the STL function is not active and therefore does not interfere with normal aircraft operations. The STL function includes logic to detect critical control limit conditions and logic to command and adjust the thrust on both engines to ensure prompt nose down recovery.
[0071] like Figure 4-5 As shown, the maximum limit n can be selected x, which provides adequate recovery capability at high AOA for critical situations where controllability may be at risk, while providing the thrust required for normal and emergency situations. x Such high availability inertial signals may make STL functionality available in most, if not all, aircraft operating conditions.
[0072] As described above, the STL function is only available during the flight of the aircraft 100 and when, for example, the measured n x Above the preset threshold n x Once triggered, the STL function causes the engine thrust of engines 106 and 108 on the aircraft 100 to be reduced, and the amount of reduction is limited to limit the risk of suffering from the removal of all thrust capacity. For example, the thrust reduction limit can be set to a maximum value of about 20% on both engines 106 and 108, about 10% on both engines 106 and 108, and / or between about 5% and about 20%. For example, the thrust reduction limit can be set to any range between greater than 0% and a maximum reduction of 20%.
[0073] The STL function will not be activated if only one engine fails on the aircraft 100, or if less than a threshold number of engines are operating in the plurality of engines 104 on the aircraft 100. Thus, the STL function only manages engine thrust when all engines are operating at high thrust, and the STL function will not limit thrust during climb-limited conditions such as engine-out operation.
[0074] In the example of an aircraft 100 having two engines, if only one engine is operating, the aircraft 100 may not be able to sustain a 20% thrust reduction on the one operating engine and still maintain the ability to climb. Therefore, to avoid this situation, the STL function sets the aircraft parameter threshold to a lower threshold than that activated in a single engine situation, so that the STL function will not activate in a single engine situation. For example, using n x As a monitored aircraft parameter, high n occurs only when both engines are running at high power relative to the total aircraft weight. x Therefore, n x The threshold can be set sufficiently above the thrust capability of a single engine, and above other engine flameout control limits. x The threshold value depends on the aircraft, and an example range may include, for example, between about 0.4 and about 0.5 g. x Setting the threshold above a certain level eliminates the need for the STL function to require a separate engine detection loss signature, which reduces overall system complexity and potential failure modes.
[0075] Figure 6A flow chart is shown of an example method 200 of controlling thrust generated by a plurality of engines 104 on an aircraft 100 for assisting in a nose-down recovery of the aircraft 100, according to an example implementation. For example, Figure 6 The method 200 shown in FIG. 1 presents a method that can be used with Figure 1 Examples of methods for use with the aircraft 100 or with components of the aircraft 100 are provided. In addition, a device or system may be used or configured to perform Figure 6 202-208. The method 200 includes one or more operations, functions or actions as shown in one or more of the blocks 202-208. Although the blocks are shown in a continuous order, these blocks can also be executed in parallel and / or in an order different from the order described herein. Moreover, various blocks can be combined into fewer blocks, divided into additional blocks and / or removed based on the desired implementation.
[0076] It should be understood that for this and other processes and methods disclosed herein, the flow chart illustrates the functions and operations of a possible implementation of this example. To this end, each box or part of each box represents a module, section or part of a program code, which includes one or more instructions that can be executed by a processor for implementing a specific logical function or step in the process. The program code is stored on any type of computer-readable medium or data storage, for example, such as a storage device including a disk or hard drive. In addition, the program code can be encoded in a machine-readable format on a computer-readable storage medium, or encoded on other non-transitory media or products. Computer-readable media include non-transitory computer-readable media or memories, for example, computer-readable media that store data for a short time such as register memory, processor cache memory, and random access memory (RAM). Computer-readable media also include non-transitory media, for example, secondary or persistent long-term storage such as read-only memory (ROM), optical disk or disk, optical disk read-only memory (CD-ROM). Computer-readable media can also be any other volatile or non-volatile storage system. For example, a computer-readable medium can be considered to be a tangible computer-readable storage medium.
[0077] in addition, Figure 6Each block or portion of each block in the other processes and methods disclosed herein may represent circuits that are wired to perform specific logical functions in the process. Alternative implementations are included within the scope of the examples disclosed herein, where functions may not be performed in the order shown or discussed, including substantially simultaneously or in reverse order, depending on the functions involved, as will be reasonably understood by those skilled in the art.
[0078] At block 202 , method 200 includes selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter.
[0079] Figure 7 A flow chart of an example method for performing the selection shown in block 202 is shown according to an example implementation. At block 210, the function includes selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter including selecting a longitudinal acceleration (N x ). Example Maximum longitudinal acceleration (N x ) value can be in the range of about 0.4g to about 0.5g.
[0080] Figure 8 A flow chart of an example method for performing the selection shown in block 202 is shown according to an example implementation. At block 212, the function includes selecting a maximum value for an aircraft parameter including selecting a maximum value for an angle of attack (AoA) of the aircraft. The AoA of the aircraft depends on the aircraft, and an example maximum value for the AoA is generally higher than the stick shaker AoA.
[0081] Fig. 9 A flow chart of an example method for performing the selection shown in block 202 according to an example implementation is shown. At block 214, the function includes selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter including selecting a maximum value of a flight path angle of the aircraft. For example, the maximum value of the flight path angle of the aircraft is about 15 degrees or more.
[0082] Fig.10 A flow chart of an example method for performing the selection shown in block 202 according to an example implementation is shown. At block 216, the function includes selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter including selecting a maximum value of a pitch angle of the aircraft. For example, the maximum value of the pitch angle of the aircraft is approximately above 25 degrees.
[0083] Fig.11 A flow chart of an example method for performing the selection shown in block 202 is shown according to one example implementation. At block 218, the functionality includes selecting the maximum value to be at the limit of providing recovery capability of the aircraft at an angle of attack (AOA) above a threshold.
[0084] Fig.12A flow chart of an example method for performing the selection shown in block 202 is shown according to an example implementation. At block 220, the functionality includes selecting the maximum value to be a value greater than the value achievable by the aircraft in flight using a single engine of the plurality of engines. As an example, for longitudinal acceleration, the maximum n that is achievable only at light weight, high thrust, and high AoA is selected. x_reference , which by definition means that the use of this reference value will not exceed a single engine operation. In other words, if n x_reference Set to about 0.4g and using a single engine, the vehicle only reaches 0.15g, so the feature will not activate in a single engine scenario.
[0085] Fig.13 A flow chart of an example method for performing the selection shown in block 202 is shown according to an example implementation. In block 222, the function includes selecting based on the weight of the aircraft (e.g., Figure 4-5 Select the maximum value of the aircraft parameter.
[0086] In a further example, the selection shown in block 202 includes defining the parameter as the total energy state of the aircraft. For example, the longitudinal acceleration n x is directly related to the total energy state of the aircraft 100. It can robustly identify the thrust, altitude, and airspeed combinations that are critical for high AOA pitch recovery.
[0087] like Figure 7-13 Any parameters described in may be used in method 200 alone or in any combination to trigger the following functions of method 200 .
[0088] return Figure 6 At block 204 , method 200 includes measuring a value of an aircraft parameter while the aircraft is in flight. Fig.14 A flow chart is shown of an example method for performing the measurements shown in block 204 according to one example implementation. At block 224, the functionality includes measuring longitudinal acceleration, where longitudinal acceleration is a measure of excess thrust relative to the drag and weight of the aircraft.
[0089] return Figure 6 At block 206, method 200 includes determining that the measured value exceeds the maximum value based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measured value. For example, flight control computing device 110 compares the maximum value selected for the aircraft parameter with the measured value of the aircraft parameter during flight to determine whether the measured value exceeds the maximum set value.
[0090] At block 208, method 200 includes reducing the thrust generated by each of the plurality of engines so that the measured value of the aircraft parameter is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter. In one example, the amount of thrust reduction for each engine is the same so as to provide a symmetrical thrust reduction for all engines on aircraft 100. As described above, for example, a limit of approximately 20% may be imposed on the amount of maximum thrust reduction on an engine.
[0091] The thrust reduction may be performed symmetrically on each of the aircraft's engines 106 and 108 such that thrust is reduced in the same manner and at the same time (ie, simultaneously) for each engine.
[0092] In an example, thrust is limited as a function of a thrust coefficient (e.g., total thrust divided by dynamic pressure) and / or limited to a specific thrust schedule (e.g., schedule by airspeed, AoA, θ, flight path). For example, thrust schedules may replace a feedback path of an aircraft parameter to reduce thrust by increments.
[0093] Fig.15 A flow chart of an example method for performing a reduction as shown in block 208 is shown according to an example implementation. At block 226, the function includes reducing the thrust by an amount proportional to the amount by which the measured value exceeds the maximum value. In this example, the comparison of the measured value to the maximum value is analogous to the amount of error, and when the observed error is high, a larger reduction may be made for a larger corrective action.
[0094] Fig.16 A flow chart of an example method for use with method 200 according to an example implementation is shown. At block 228, the functionality includes setting a maximum amount by which thrust is reduced to maintain the required climb capability. As described above, the maximum thrust reduction may be limited, and here is limited to a value that still maintains the required climb capability for a particular flight requirement.
[0095] Fig.17 A flow chart of an example method for use with method 200 according to an example implementation is shown. At block 230, the functionality includes determining that a nose-down recovery condition exists. By dividing the measured longitudinal acceleration n x With the maximum value n x By comparing, reliable and robust critical condition detection can be performed. For example, n can be directly sensed by (one or more) IRUs 140. x Next, based on the determination of a nose-down recovery condition, the functionality includes measuring a value of an aircraft parameter while the aircraft is in flight and reducing the thrust produced by each engine so that the measured value of the aircraft parameter is below a maximum value of the aircraft parameter, as represented by blocks 232 and 234 .
[0096] However,x is just one method of detecting a critical controllability condition. There may be other parameters that could be used that are equally valid, such as angle of attack, flight path angle, pitch angle, or vehicle total energy calculation. Any of these parameters may be used alone or in combination with one another to accomplish detection of an STL triggering condition.
[0097] Fig.18 A flow chart of an example method for use with method 200 is shown according to an example implementation. At block 208 of method 200, reducing the thrust generated by each of engines 106 and 108 includes reducing the thrust by a first amount, and additional functionality includes, after reducing the thrust, measuring a second value of the aircraft parameter, and based on the second measured value exceeding a maximum value, reducing the thrust generated by each of engines 106 and 108 by a second amount that is greater than the first amount, as shown in blocks 236 and 238.
[0098] Fig.19 A flow chart of an example method for use with method 200 is shown according to one example implementation. At block 240, functionality includes iteratively measuring a value of an aircraft parameter and reducing thrust produced by each of engines 106 and 108 until the measured value of the aircraft parameter is below a maximum value of the aircraft parameter.
[0099] In the examples described herein, the STL function actively manages excess thrust capability in certain critical conditions to meet design requirements while mitigating the impacts that have affected previous solutions. STL provides additional degrees of freedom in aircraft design and construction that can be used to find the right balance of system complexity, aerodynamic performance, load capacity, and aircraft cost. That is, the STL function actively manages the thrust produced by all engines to ensure rapid nose-down recovery of the aircraft in critical conditions without having to increase the complexity of the aircraft design, increase weight and / or cost, which are typically associated with managing such conditions. This advantage can include performance improvements and cost savings (both recurring and non-recurring).
[0100] The STL capability further reduces shortcomings associated with accurate pre-flight predictions of aerodynamic pitch-up at high AOA, which may be required prior to flight testing and certification. In some cases, different pitch-up characteristics were discovered during flight testing compared to predicted levels requiring late modifications to the design. These late discoveries can negatively impact program schedule, cost, and further loss of performance capability.
[0101] Additionally, an aircraft operating with STL functionality is able to meet high alpha recovery requirements, thereby balancing anti-ice span coverage with engine bleed air or power generation capabilities and with pitch up (which impacts build cost and aircraft weight), may allow for the anti-ice system to be removed entirely or replaced with an alternative electrical ice protection concept (which impacts system complexity, weight, engine bleed air / electrical requirements), allow for a simplified leading edge design by removing automatic leading edge slats (which impacts system complexity and build cost), enable a stronger inboard leading edge to improve landing performance by reducing approach speed (which impacts performance), and allow for the removal of aft center of gravity cutback at light weight (which impacts payload capability).
[0102] The terms "substantially" and "approximately" as used herein mean that the characteristic, parameter or value described need not be achieved precisely, but rather that deviations or changes including, for example, tolerances, measurement errors, measurement precision limitations and other factors known to those skilled in the art may occur in an amount that does not eliminate the effect that the characteristic is intended to provide.
[0103] Different examples of (one or more) systems, (one or more) devices, and (one or more) methods disclosed herein include various components, features, and functions. It should be understood that various examples of (one or more) systems, (one or more) devices, and (one or more) methods disclosed herein may include any combination or sub-combination of any of the components, features, and functions of any other examples of (one or more) systems, (one or more) devices, and (one or more) methods disclosed herein, and all of these possibilities are intended to be included within the scope of the present disclosure.
[0104] In addition, this disclosure includes examples according to the following clauses:
[0105] Clause 1. A method (200) of controlling thrust generated by a plurality of engines (104) on an aircraft (100) to assist in nose-down recovery of the aircraft (100), the method comprising:
[0106] (202) selecting a maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138);
[0107] (204) measuring a value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight;
[0108] (206) determining, based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measured value, that the measured value exceeds the maximum value; and
[0109] (208) reducing the thrust generated by each of the plurality of engines (104) such that the measured value of the aircraft parameter (138) is below the maximum value of the aircraft (100) parameter.
[0110] Clause 2. The method of clause 1, wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises (210) selecting a longitudinal acceleration (N x )’s maximum value.
[0111] Clause 3. The method of clause 1, wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises (212) selecting a maximum value of an angle of attack (AoA) of the aircraft (100).
[0112] Clause 4. The method of clause 1, wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises (214) selecting a maximum value of a flight path angle of the aircraft (100).
[0113] Clause 5. The method of clause 1, wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises (216) selecting a maximum value of a pitch angle of the aircraft (100).
[0114] Clause 6. The method of clause 1, wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises:
[0115] (218) The maximum value is selected to be at a limit that provides recovery capability of the aircraft (100) at angles of attack (AOA) above a threshold.
[0116] Clause 7. The method of clause 1, wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises:
[0117] (220) The maximum value is selected to be a value greater than a value achievable while the aircraft (100) is in flight if one of the plurality of engines (104) fails.
[0118] Clause 8. The method of clause 1, wherein selecting the maximum value (138) of the aircraft parameter comprises:
[0119] (222) Selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) based on a weight of the aircraft (100).
[0120] Clause 9. The method of clause 1, wherein measuring the value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight comprises:
[0121] (224) Measuring longitudinal acceleration, wherein the longitudinal acceleration is a measure of excess thrust relative to the drag and weight of the aircraft (100).
[0122] Clause 10. The method of clause 1, wherein reducing the thrust generated by each of the engines comprises:
[0123] (226) reducing the thrust by an amount proportional to the amount by which the measured value exceeds the maximum value.
[0124] Clause 11. The method of clause 1, further comprising:
[0125] (228) Set the maximum amount by which the thrust may be reduced to maintain the required climb capability.
[0126] Clause 12. The method of clause 1, further comprising:
[0127] (230) determining that a nose-down recovery condition exists; and
[0128] Based on said determination of said nose-down recovery condition,
[0129] (232) measuring a value of a parameter of the aircraft (100) while the aircraft (100) is in flight; and
[0130] (234) reducing the thrust generated by each of the engines so that the measured value of the aircraft parameter (138) is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138).
[0131] Clause 13. The method of clause 1, wherein reducing the thrust generated by each of the engines comprises reducing the thrust by a first amount, and the method further comprises:
[0132] (236) after reducing said thrust, measuring a second value of said aircraft parameter (138); and
[0133] (238) based on the second measured value exceeding the maximum value, reducing the thrust generated by each of the engines by a second amount, the second amount being greater than the first amount.
[0134] Clause 14. The method of clause 1, further comprising:
[0135] (240) iteratively measuring the value of the aircraft parameter (138) and reducing the thrust generated by each of the engines until the measured value of the aircraft parameter (138) is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138).
[0136] Clause 15. A non-transitory computer-readable medium (122) having stored thereon instructions (134) that, when executed by one or more processors (114) of a computing device (110), cause the computing device (110) to perform functions comprising:
[0137] selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter (138) of the aircraft (100);
[0138] measuring a value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight;
[0139] determining that the measured value exceeds the maximum value based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measured value; and
[0140] The thrust generated by each of a plurality of engines (104) on the aircraft (100) is reduced so that the measured value of the aircraft parameter (138) is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138).
[0141] Clause 16. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of Clause 15, wherein measuring the value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight comprises:
[0142] Longitudinal acceleration is measured, wherein the longitudinal acceleration is a measure of excess thrust relative to the drag and weight of the aircraft (100).
[0143] Clause 17. The non-transitory computer-readable medium of clause 15, wherein reducing the thrust generated by each of the engines comprises:
[0144] The thrust is reduced by an amount proportional to the amount by which the measured value exceeds the maximum value.
[0145] Clause 18. A system (102) comprising:
[0146] A flight control computing device (110) having a processor (114) and a memory (122) storing instructions (134) executable by the processor (114) to:
[0147] selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter (138) of the aircraft (100);
[0148] receiving a measurement of a value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight;
[0149] determining that the measured value exceeds the maximum value based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measured value; and
[0150] sending a signal instructing to reduce the thrust generated by each of a plurality of engines (104) of the aircraft (100) so that the measured value is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138); and
[0151] A plurality of propulsion control computing devices (112a-b) coupled to the plurality of engines (104) of the aircraft (100), wherein a respective propulsion control computing device is coupled to a respective engine, and wherein each propulsion control computing device has a processor (116) and a memory (124) storing instructions (136) executable by the processor (116) to receive the signals from the flight control computing device (1100) and control thrust generated by a respective engine of the plurality of engines (104).
[0152] Clause 19. The system of clause 18, wherein the plurality of propulsion control computing devices (112a-b) control thrust generated by each of the plurality of engines (104) independently of one another.
[0153] Clause 20. The system of clause 18, further comprising:
[0154] An inertial reference unit (IRU) (140) is configured to measure the value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight and output the measured value of the value of the aircraft parameter (138) to the flight control computing device (110).
[0155] Descriptions of different advantageous arrangements have been given for purposes of illustration and description, and are not intended to be exhaustive or limited to examples of the disclosed form. Many modifications and variations will be apparent to those of ordinary skill in the art. In addition, different advantageous examples may describe different advantages compared to other advantageous examples. The selected one or more examples are selected and described in order to best explain the principles of the examples, practical applications, and to enable other persons of ordinary skill in the art to understand the various examples of the present disclosure that are suitable for various modifications of the intended specific use.
Claims
1. A method (200) of controlling thrust generated by a plurality of engines (104) on an aircraft (100) to assist in nose-down recovery of the aircraft (100), the method comprising: selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter (138) indicative of a critical controllability condition; measuring a value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight; determining, based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measured value, that the measured value exceeds the maximum value; setting a maximum amount by which thrust generated by each of the plurality of engines (104) may be reduced to maintain a desired climb capability; as well as reducing the thrust produced by each of the plurality of engines (104) within the maximum amount so that the measured value of the aircraft parameter (138) is below the maximum value of the aircraft (100) parameter only when all of the plurality of engines are operating at high thrust, Wherein if less than a threshold number of engines of the plurality of engines on the aircraft are operating, thrust reduction is prohibited.
2. The method of claim 1, wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises selecting a longitudinal acceleration (N x ), or selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) includes selecting the maximum value of the angle of attack AOA of the aircraft (100).
3. The method of claim 1 , wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises selecting a maximum value of a flight path angle of the aircraft (100), or selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises selecting a maximum value of a pitch angle of the aircraft (100).
4. The method of claim 1 , wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises: The maximum value is selected to be at a limit that provides recovery capability of the aircraft (100) at angles of attack (AOA) above a threshold.
5. The method of claim 1 , wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises: The maximum value is selected to be a value greater than a value achievable while the aircraft (100) is in flight in the event of a failure of one of the plurality of engines (104).
6. The method of claim 1, wherein selecting the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) comprises: The maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) is selected based on a weight of the aircraft (100).
7. The method of any one of claims 1-6, wherein measuring the value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight comprises: Longitudinal acceleration is measured, wherein the longitudinal acceleration is a measure of excess thrust relative to the drag and weight of the aircraft (100).
8. The method of any one of claims 1-6, wherein reducing the thrust generated by each of the engines comprises: The thrust is reduced by an amount proportional to the amount by which the measured value exceeds the maximum value.
9. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, further comprising: Determine that a nose-down recovery condition exists; and Based on said determination of said nose-down recovery condition, measuring the value of the parameter of the aircraft (100) while the aircraft (100) is in flight; and The thrust generated by each of the engines is reduced so that the measured value of the aircraft parameter (138) is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138).
10. The method of any one of claims 1-6, wherein reducing the thrust generated by each of the engines comprises reducing the thrust by a first amount, and the method further comprises: After reducing the thrust, measuring a second value of the aircraft parameter (138); and Based on the second value measured exceeding the maximum value, the thrust generated by each of the engines is reduced by a second amount, the second amount being greater than the first amount.
11. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, further comprising: The value of the aircraft parameter (138) is iteratively measured and the thrust generated by each of the engines is reduced until the measured value of the aircraft parameter (138) is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138).
12. A system (102) for controlling thrust generated by a plurality of engines (104) on an aircraft (100) to assist in nose-down recovery of the aircraft (100), comprising: A flight control computing device (110) having a processor (114) and a memory (122) storing instructions (134) executable by the processor (114) to: selecting a maximum value of an aircraft parameter (138) of the aircraft (100) indicative of a critical controllability condition; receiving a measurement of a value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight; determining, based on a comparison of the maximum value and the measured value, that the measured value exceeds the maximum value; setting a maximum amount by which thrust generated by each of the plurality of engines (104) may be reduced to maintain a desired climb capability; as well as sending a signal instructing to reduce the thrust generated by each of a plurality of engines (104) of the aircraft (100) within the maximum amount so that the measured value is below the maximum value of the aircraft parameter (138) only when all of the plurality of engines are operating at high thrust, wherein the thrust reduction is inhibited if less than a threshold number of the plurality of engines on the aircraft are operating; as well as A plurality of propulsion control computing devices (112a-b) coupled to the plurality of engines (104) of the aircraft (100), wherein a respective propulsion control computing device is coupled to a respective engine, and wherein each propulsion control computing device has a processor (116) and a memory (124) storing instructions (136) executable by the processor (116) to receive the signal from the flight control computing device (110) and control thrust generated by a respective engine of the plurality of engines (104).
13. The system of claim 12, wherein the plurality of propulsion control computing devices (112a-b) control thrust generated by each of the plurality of engines (104) independently of one another.
14. The system according to claim 12 or 13, further comprising: An inertial reference unit (IRU) (140) is configured to measure the value of the aircraft parameter (138) while the aircraft (100) is in flight and output the measured value of the value of the aircraft parameter (138) to the flight control computing device (110).
