Method and apparatus for determining fingerprints of performance parameters
By measuring the focus settings and performance parameters on the reference substrate, the focus error recognition problem in lithography equipment is solved, and the focus accuracy and productivity of lithography equipment is improved. It is suitable for thin resist and high-resolution lithography.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202110018882.4
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2016-10-25
- Filing Date
- 2017-06-22
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-05
- Estimated Expiration
- 2037-06-22
AI Technical Summary
During the lithography process, it is difficult for the prior art to effectively identify and correct focus errors and their sources, especially in thin resists and high resolution lithography processes, resulting in a decrease in productivity of lithography equipment and deterioration in product quality.
By performing focus measurements and other attribute measurements on the reference substrate, the fingerprint of focus settings and performance parameters is determined, thereby avoiding the use of focus targets on the product substrate, directly measuring focus settings, and optimizing lithography with aberration settings Focus of the equipment.
It improves the focus accuracy and productivity of lithography equipment, reduces the space occupied on the product structure, simplifies the focus error recognition and correction process, and is suitable for thin resist and high-resolution lithography processes.
Smart Images

Figure CN112631086B_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] This application is a divisional application of a patent application with an application date of June 22, 2017, an invention name of “Method and device for determining fingerprints of performance parameters” and an application number of 201780043341.9.
[0002] CROSS-REFERENCE TO RELATED APPLICATIONS
[0003] This application claims priority to European application 16178809.6 filed on July 11, 2016 and to European application 16195549.7 filed on October 21, 2016, the entire contents of which are incorporated herein by reference. Technical Field
[0004] The present invention relates to a method and apparatus for determining a fingerprint of a performance parameter of a lithographic substrate. More specifically, the present invention relates to a method and apparatus for determining a fingerprint of a focus parameter. Background Art
[0005] The photolithography process is a process of applying a desired pattern to a substrate (usually on a target portion of the substrate). For example, a photolithography apparatus can be used in the manufacture of integrated circuits (ICs). In this case, a pattern forming device, which can be alternatively referred to as a mask or a reticle, can be used to generate a circuit pattern to be formed on a single layer of the integrated circuit. The pattern can be transferred to a target portion (e.g., a portion of a die, one or more dies) on a substrate (e.g., a silicon wafer). The transfer of the pattern is usually accomplished by imaging the pattern forming device onto a layer of radiation-sensitive material (resist) disposed on the substrate through an optical system (e.g., a projection lens). Stepping and / or scanning motions may be involved to repeat the pattern at a continuous target portion on the substrate. The pattern can also be transferred from the pattern forming device to the substrate by imprinting the pattern onto the substrate.
[0006] An important property of interest is the critical dimension (CD). It is important to form structures with precise critical dimension control across a substrate (e.g., a wafer). During the lithography process, a key parameter for controlling the critical dimension is the position of the substrate relative to the focal plane of the lithographic apparatus (which may also be referred to as the "focus setting"). In particular, control of the focus setting must be carefully maintained during exposure of the substrate. This can be achieved by controlling the focusing characteristics of the projection lens, or by controlling the position of the substrate so that it remains close to the focal plane of the projection lens during exposure of the substrate.
[0007] Typically, the focus setting is determined by performing measurements on one or more focus targets. The focus target is positioned on a pattern forming device (e.g., a mask) and patterned onto a substrate using a lithography step. Typically, the pattern forming device also includes a structure associated with the pattern of a product (e.g., an IC), which is referred to as a "product structure." After patterning, the product structure and the focus target are present on the substrate. The focus target is measured (e.g., in a measurement or inspection device) and the focus setting is determined. The determined focus setting represents a specific deviation between a reference focus setting and an actual focus setting during exposure of the substrate. Knowledge of the focus setting can be used to correct the focus of the lithography apparatus in order to improve the performance of the lithography process. This correction can be achieved by adjusting optical elements within the projection lens of the lithography apparatus or by adjusting the position and / or orientation of the substrate relative to the focal plane of the projection lens of the lithography apparatus.
[0008] The determined focus setting represents a specific deviation between a desired focus setting and an actual focus setting during exposure of a substrate. Knowledge of the focus setting can be used to correct the focus of the lithographic apparatus in order to improve the performance of the lithographic process. The correction can be achieved by adjusting optical elements within a projection lens of the lithographic apparatus or by adjusting the position and / or orientation of the substrate relative to the focal plane of the projection lens of the lithographic apparatus.
[0009] However, the focusing target takes up space on the substrate. This directly reduces the number of product structures that can be placed on the substrate, which is undesirable. In addition, the positioning and characteristics of the focusing target may cause interference with nearby product structures, thereby potentially degrading the quality of these product structures.
[0010] Furthermore, in order to determine the focus setting, test and calibration procedures must be performed in addition to the measurement itself. Furthermore, such measurements must be performed using metrology or inspection equipment. As a result, the substrate being measured is delayed during the measurement process, which proportionally increases the production time and thus reduces the productivity of the lithographic equipment.
[0011] The known method measures the overall focus setting of the substrate, which includes all sources of focus errors. Therefore, it may be difficult to identify the root cause of any defect or source of focus error when using the above method and apparatus. The known method does not distinguish between different sources of focus errors (e.g. errors caused by the lithographic apparatus or errors caused by the lithographic process). Therefore, identifying and correcting focus errors and their sources may take a lot of time.
[0012] Typically, the focus targets used are placed on a production reticle (a reticle comprising product structures) and comprise diffractive structures having a pitch smaller than the pitch of the product structures. After patterning (exposing in a resist) these focus targets, the focus settings can be determined from diffraction-based measurements. Basically, the focus settings are reconstructed from the observed diffraction patterns. This method of measuring the focus settings is often referred to as "diffraction-based focus" (DBF) measurement. Its focus targets are called diffraction-based focus targets (e.g. "DBF targets").
[0013] The fact that the focus target and the product structure are patterned in the same lithography process is essential. The focus target is exposed under exactly the same conditions as the product structure (same dose settings, irradiation mode, lens settings, platform characteristics, etc.). Therefore, the measured focus setting represents the focus behavior of the lithography apparatus during production, i.e. the determined focus setting is related to both the focus target and the product structure.
[0014] The described diffraction-based methods for measuring the focus setting have been found to be less successful when the thickness of the resist is chosen to be very thin. This is the case, for example, in the case of extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography processes, where the resist has to be very thin to prevent too strong absorption gradients across the resist stack. In the case of thin resist stacks, e.g. thinner than 50-100 nm, the diffraction-based methods will be limited, since the radiation used to perform the diffraction-based metrology is increasingly reflected from structures beneath the resist pattern. Furthermore, the required pitch of the DBF target is proportional to the product structure pitch. Sub-resolution pitches of EUV processes, as required by DBF targets, will become increasingly challenging for the manufacturability of DBF targets on masks.
[0015] The present invention proposes a solution for measuring focus settings representative of the lithography process during production when thin resist and / or high resolution lithography processes (eg EUV or low k1-DUV processes) are employed. Summary of the invention
[0016] It is proposed to restrict the measurements performed on the focus target to those on a reference substrate. In addition to the focus measurements, measurements related to properties of the reference substrate are performed, such as a height map of the reference substrate. The use of the reference focus measurement and the measured height map allows determining a focus fingerprint for any product substrate for which a height map has been determined. Then, no direct focus measurement is needed to determine the focus setting related to the product substrate, thus avoiding the use of a spatially occupying focus target. In addition to the focus setting, other parameters related to the product substrate (called performance parameters) can also be determined in a similar way.
[0017] In a first aspect, the present invention provides a method for determining a fingerprint of a performance parameter associated with a substrate, the method comprising:
[0018] determining a reference fingerprint of a performance parameter associated with a reference substrate;
[0019] determining at least one reference substrate parameter associated with the reference substrate;
[0020] determining at least one substrate parameter associated with the substrate; and
[0021] The fingerprint of the performance parameter is determined based on the reference substrate parameter, the substrate parameter, and the reference fingerprint.
[0022] In a second aspect, the present invention provides a method for manufacturing a device, wherein device features are formed on a series of substrates by a lithography process, wherein properties of the processed substrates are measured by one or more measurement processes, and wherein the measured properties are used to determine a fingerprint of a performance parameter according to the above method.
[0023] The present invention also provides a lithographic apparatus comprising means for performing the method for determining a fingerprint of a performance parameter as provided above.
[0024] The present invention also provides a computer program product, comprising one or more machine-readable instruction sequences for implementing the above method.
[0025] It is further proposed that a focus setting determination phase is provided in which a production mask including a focus target is used to pattern one or more substrates before the volume manufacturing phase of the lithography process. Typically, the substrate belongs to one or more pre-sent batches including pre-sent substrates. The substrate is exposed under the same conditions (settings of the lithography equipment) as the product substrate (the substrate patterned during the volume manufacturing phase). The focus target is based on features with a sufficiently large pitch to ensure good manufacturability and accurate readings of the measurement tool. In order to enhance the response of the focus target to the focus setting, a certain amount of astigmatism is introduced into the projection lens of the lithography equipment while patterning the substrate. The patterned substrate is then measured on the measurement tool, and the focus setting is determined based on the measurement. The determined focus setting is used to optimize the focus setting of the lithography equipment during the volume manufacturing phase of the lithography process. In this way, it is not necessary to use a focus target that is incompatible with thin resist and / or high-resolution lithography processes.
[0026] On the other hand, the present invention provides a method for patterning multiple substrates using a lithography device, the method comprising: determining a focus setting based on measurements of structures on the substrates, wherein the substrates have been exposed by the lithography device under an aberration setting associated with an enhanced sensitivity of the measurements of the structures to changes in the focus setting; and patterning the multiple substrates using the lithography device under a corrected focus setting based on the determined focus setting.
[0027] The present invention also provides a lithography apparatus comprising a device for performing the method of patterning a plurality of substrates.
[0028] The present invention also provides a computer program product comprising one or more machine-readable instruction sequences for implementing the method of patterning a plurality of substrates.
[0029] Other aspects, features and advantages of the present invention and the structure and operation of various embodiments of the present invention are described in more detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings. Note that the present invention is not limited to the specific embodiments described herein. Such embodiments are provided herein for illustrative purposes only. Based on the teachings contained herein, other embodiments will be apparent to those skilled in the relevant art. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0030] Embodiments of the invention will now be described, by way of example only, with reference to the accompanying schematic drawings, in which corresponding reference numerals indicate corresponding parts, and in which:
[0031] Figure 1 depicts lithographic equipment and other equipment forming a production facility for semiconductor devices;
[0032] Figure 2 Shown in Figure 1 The step of exposing the substrate in a dual stage apparatus;
[0033] Figure 3 A method according to a first embodiment of the invention is described;
[0034] Figure 4 Shown is the method for executing Figure 3 system of methods;
[0035] Figure 5 is a schematic diagram of a method for determining a common grid layout of a plurality of measurement points; and
[0036] Figure 6 Shows known methods and Figure 3 An exemplary comparison between the methods of
[0037] Figure 7 A functional overview describing an embodiment of a focus setting optimization method is depicted. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0038] Before describing the embodiments of the present invention in detail, it is instructive to provide an exemplary environment in which the embodiments of the present invention can be implemented.
[0039] Figure 1 200 in the figure shows a lithographic apparatus LA as part of an industrial facility implementing a high-volume lithographic manufacturing process. In this example, the manufacturing process is suitable for manufacturing semiconductor products (integrated circuits) on substrates such as semiconductor wafers. The skilled person will understand that a variety of products can be manufactured by processing different types of substrates in variations of the process. The production of semiconductor products is only one example that has great commercial significance today.
[0040] In a lithographic apparatus (or simply "lithography tool" 200), a measurement station MEA is shown at 202 and an exposure station EXP is shown at 204. A control unit LACU is shown at 206. In this example, each substrate visits a measurement station and an exposure station to have a pattern applied. In an optical lithographic apparatus, for example, a projection system is used to transfer a product pattern from a patterning device MA to a substrate using conditioned radiation and a projection system. This is done by forming an image of the pattern in a layer of radiation-sensitive resist material.
[0041] The term "projection system" as used herein should be broadly understood to include any type of projection system suitable for the exposure radiation used or other factors (such as the use of immersion liquid or the use of vacuum), including refractive, reflective, reflective-refractive, magnetic, electromagnetic and electrostatic optical systems, or any combination thereof. The pattern forming device MA can be a mask or a reticle that imparts a pattern to a radiation beam transmitted or reflected by the pattern forming device. Well-known operating modes include stepping mode and scanning mode. It is well known that the projection system can cooperate with a support and positioning system for the substrate and the pattern forming device in various ways to apply the desired pattern to many target portions on the substrate. A programmable pattern forming device can be used instead of a reticle with a fixed pattern. For example, the radiation can include electromagnetic radiation in the deep ultraviolet (DUV) or extreme ultraviolet (EUV) band. The present disclosure is also applicable to other types of lithography processes, such as imprint lithography and direct write lithography, such as by electron beam.
[0042] The lithographic apparatus control unit LACU controls all movements and measurements of the various actuators and sensors to receive the substrate W and mask MA and implement the patterning operation. The LACU also includes signal processing and data processing capabilities to implement the required calculations related to the operation of the apparatus. In practice, the control unit LACU will be implemented as a system of many sub-units, each of which handles real-time data acquisition, processing and control of a subsystem or component within the apparatus.
[0043] Before the pattern is applied to the substrate at the exposure station EXP, the substrate is processed at the measurement station MEA so that various preparatory steps can be performed. The preparatory steps may include using a level sensor to map the surface height of the substrate, and using an alignment sensor to measure the position of the alignment marks on the substrate. The alignment marks are nominally arranged in a regular grid pattern. However, due to the inaccuracy of the marks and due to the deformation of the substrate that occurs during the entire process, the marks deviate from the ideal grid. Therefore, in addition to measuring the position and direction of the substrate, if the device is to print product features at the correct position with very high accuracy, the alignment sensor must actually measure the positions of many marks across the entire substrate area in detail. The device can be a so-called dual-stage type, which has two substrate stages, each substrate stage having a positioning system controlled by a control unit LACU. While a substrate on a substrate stage is being exposed at the exposure station EXP, another substrate can be loaded onto another substrate stage at the measurement station MEA so that various preparatory steps are performed. Therefore, the measurement of the alignment marks is very time-consuming, and setting two substrate stages can significantly improve the productivity of the device. If the position sensor IF is not capable of measuring the position of the substrate table both at the measurement station and at the exposure station, a second position sensor may be provided to enable the position of the substrate table to be tracked at both stations. The lithographic apparatus LA may, for example, be of a so-called dual-stage type having two substrate tables WTa and WTb and two stations - (i.e. an exposure station and a measurement station) - between which the substrate table can be exchanged.
[0044] Within a production facility, the apparatus 200 forms part of a "lithography unit" or "lithography cluster", which also includes a coating apparatus 208 for applying photoresist and other coatings to a substrate W for a patterning process by the apparatus 200. At the output side of the apparatus 200, a baking apparatus 210 and a developing apparatus 212 are provided for developing the exposed pattern into a solid resist pattern. Between all these apparatuses, a substrate handling system is responsible for supporting the substrates and transferring them from one apparatus to the next. These apparatuses are generally collectively referred to as tracks and are controlled by a track control unit, which itself is controlled by a management control system SCS, which also controls the lithography apparatus via the lithography apparatus control unit LACU. Thus, different apparatuses can be operated to maximize productivity and process efficiency. The management control system SCS receives recipe information R, which provides a very detailed definition of the steps to be performed to create each patterned substrate.
[0045] Once the pattern has been applied and developed in the lithography unit, the patterned substrate 220 is transferred to other processing equipment, such as shown at the marks 222, 224, and 226. Various processing steps are implemented by various equipment in a typical manufacturing facility. For example, the equipment 222 in this embodiment is an etching station, and the equipment 224 performs a post-etching annealing step. Further physical and / or chemical processing steps are applied in other equipment 226, etc. Many types of operations may be required to manufacture real devices, such as deposition of materials, modification of surface material properties (oxidation, doping, ion implantation, etc.), chemical mechanical polishing (CMP), etc. In fact, the equipment 226 may represent a series of different processing steps performed in one or more equipment.
[0046] As is well known, the manufacture of semiconductor devices involves multiple repetitions of such processing to build up device structures with appropriate materials and patterns layer by layer on the substrate. Thus, the substrates 230 arriving at the lithography cluster may be newly prepared substrates, or they may be substrates that have been previously processed completely in the cluster or in another device. Similarly, depending on the desired processing, the substrates 232 leaving the device 226 may be returned for subsequent patterning operations in the same lithography cluster, they may be patterned in a different cluster, or they may be finished products to be sent for dicing and packaging.
[0047] Each layer of the product structure requires a different set of processing steps, and the type of equipment 226 used at each layer can be completely different. In addition, even in the case where the processing steps to be applied by the equipment 226 are nominally the same, in a large facility there may be several supposedly identical machines working in parallel to perform steps 226 on different substrates. Small differences in settings or failures between these machines may mean that they affect different substrates in different ways. Even for steps that are relatively common to each layer, such as etching (equipment 222), it can be achieved by several nominally identical etching equipment working in parallel to maximize productivity. In addition, in practice, different layers require different etching processes, such as chemical etching, plasma etching, and special requirements such as anisotropic etching, depending on the details of the material to be etched.
[0048] As just described, previous and / or subsequent processing may be performed in other lithographic equipment, and may even be performed in different types of lithographic equipment. For example, some layers in the device manufacturing process that are very demanding on parameters such as resolution and overlay may be performed in more advanced lithographic tools than other less demanding layers. Thus, some layers may be exposed in immersion lithography tools, while other layers are exposed in "dry" tools. Some layers may be exposed in tools operating at DUV wavelengths, while other layers are exposed using EUV wavelength radiation.
[0049] In order to correctly and consistently expose the substrate exposed by the lithography apparatus, it is necessary to check the exposed substrate to measure properties such as overlay errors between subsequent layers, line thickness, critical dimensions (CD), etc. Thus, the manufacturing facility in which the lithography cell LC is positioned also includes a measurement system MET, which receives some or all of the substrates W that have been processed in the lithography cell. The measurement results are provided directly or indirectly to the management control system SCS. If an error is detected, the exposure of subsequent substrates can be adjusted, especially when the measurement can be performed quickly and quickly enough so that other substrates of the same batch are still to be exposed. In addition, the already exposed substrates can be stripped and reworked - to improve the yield - or discarded, thereby avoiding further processing of substrates that are known to be defective. In the case where only some target parts of the substrate are defective, further exposure can be performed only on those target parts that are good.
[0050] Figure 1 Also shown in the figure is a metrology device 240, which is provided for measuring parameters of the product at a desired stage in the manufacturing process. A common example of a metrology device in a modern lithography production facility is a scatterometer, such as an angle-resolved scatterometer or a spectral scatterometer, and which can be applied to measure the properties of the developed substrate at the device 220 before etching in the device 222. Using the metrology device 240, for example, it can be determined that important performance parameters such as focus, overlay or critical dimension (CD) do not meet the specified accuracy requirements in the developed resist. Before the etching step, there is an opportunity to strip the developed resist and reprocess the substrate 220 through the lithography cluster. As is known, the metrology results 242 from the device 240 can be used to maintain accurate performance of the patterning operation in the lithography cluster by the supervisory control system SCS and / or control unit LACU206 making small adjustments over time, thereby minimizing the risk of products being manufactured out of specification and requiring rework. The metrology device 240 and / or other metrology devices (not shown) can be applied to measure the properties of the processed substrates 232, 234 and the incoming substrate 230.
[0051] Figure 2 Shows Figure 1 The step of exposing a target portion (e.g., a tube core) on a substrate W in a dual-stage device.
[0052] The steps performed at the measurement station MEA are on the left hand side within the dashed box, while the right hand side shows the steps performed at the exposure station EXP. Often, one of the substrate tables WTa, WTb will be at the exposure station, while the other is at the measurement station, as described above. For the purposes of this description, it is assumed that a substrate W has already been loaded into the exposure station. At step 200, a new substrate W' is loaded into the apparatus by a mechanism not shown in the figure. The two substrates are processed in parallel in order to increase the productivity of the lithographic apparatus.
[0053] Reference is initially made to a newly loaded substrate W', which may be a previously unprocessed substrate, prepared with a new photoresist for use in the first exposure in the apparatus. However, in general, the described lithographic process will be only one step in a series of exposure and processing steps, so that the substrate W' has passed through this apparatus and / or other lithographic apparatuses several times, and may also undergo subsequent processes. With particular regard to the problem of improving overlay performance, the task will be to ensure that the new pattern is applied accurately in the correct position on a substrate that has been subjected to one or more cycles of patterning and processing. These processing steps gradually introduce deformations in the substrate, which must be measured and corrected to achieve satisfactory overlay performance.
[0054] As just described, previous and / or subsequent patterning steps may be performed in other lithographic equipment, and previous and / or subsequent processing may even be performed in different types of lithographic equipment. For example, some layers in the device manufacturing process that are very demanding on parameters such as resolution and overlay may be performed in more advanced lithography tools than other layers that are less demanding. Thus, some layers may be exposed in an immersion lithography tool, while other layers are exposed in a "dry" tool. Some layers may be exposed in a tool operating at a DUV wavelength, while other layers are exposed using EUV wavelength radiation.
[0055] At 202, alignment measurements using substrate marks P1 etc. and an image sensor (not shown) will be used to measure and record the alignment of the substrate relative to the substrate table WTa / WTb. In addition, several alignment marks across the substrate W' will be measured using an alignment sensor AS. These measurements are used in one embodiment to establish a "wafer grid" that very accurately maps the distribution of the marks across the substrate, including any deformations from the nominal rectangular grid.
[0056] At step 204, a level sensor LS is also used to measure a wafer height (Z) map relative to the XY position. Traditionally, height maps are used only to achieve precise focus of the pattern after exposure. As will be further explained below, the apparatus of the present invention also uses height map data to supplement alignment measurements.
[0057] When loading substrate W', receive matching scheme data 206, it defines the exposure to be performed, and also defines the properties of the wafer, the previously generated pattern and the pattern to be generated on the wafer. The measurement values of the wafer position, wafer grid and height map performed at 202, 204 are added to these matching scheme data, so that a complete set of matching schemes and measurement data 208 can be delivered to the exposure station EXP. The measurement values of the alignment data include, for example, the X position and Y position of the alignment target formed in a fixed or nominally fixed relationship with the product pattern (the product pattern is the product of the lithography process). These alignment data obtained just before exposure are combined and interpolated to provide parameters of the alignment model. These parameters and alignment models will be used during the exposure operation to correct the position of the pattern applied in the current lithography step. Traditional alignment models may include four, five or six parameters, which together define the translation, rotation and scaling of the "ideal" grid in different dimensions. As further described in US 2013230797A1, advanced models using more parameters are known.
[0058] At 210, wafers W' and W are exchanged so that the measured substrate W' replaces substrate W and enters the exposure station EXP. Figure 1 In the example apparatus of , this exchange is performed by exchanging supports WTa and WTb within the apparatus so that the substrates W, W' remain accurately clamped and positioned on those supports to maintain the relative alignment between the substrate table and the substrate itself. Therefore, once the tables have been exchanged, in order to use the measurement information 202 and 204 for the substrate W (formerly W') to control the exposure steps, it is necessary to determine the relative position between the projection system PS and the substrate table WTb (formerly WTa). At step 212, reticle alignment is performed using mask alignment marks M1, M2. In steps 214, 216, 218, scanning movements and radiation pulses are applied to successive target locations across the substrate W so as to complete the exposure of a number of patterns.
[0059] By using the alignment data and height map obtained at the measurement station in performing the exposure step, these patterns are accurately aligned relative to the desired locations, and in particular, relative to features previously placed on the same substrate. At step 220, the exposed substrate, now labeled W", removed from the apparatus, is subjected to etching or other processes according to the exposed patterns.
[0060] As mentioned above, performing focus measurements in a known manner requires providing specific target structures on the substrate. The presence of such target structures reduces the surface area on the substrate that can be used for product structures. This reduces the number of product structures that can be provided on the substrate, directly reducing the product yield and increasing the product cost. In addition, determining the root cause of the focus error may be difficult, since known methods result in a total focus measurement of the substrate. For example, it is very important to determine whether the focus error is due to process-related effects or due to effects related to the lithographic equipment.
[0061] It is therefore desirable to dispense with the use of a focus target structure on a production substrate. However, this eliminates the ability to perform the above-mentioned focus measurements and in turn prevents the determination of a focus setting that will be used by the lithographic apparatus in order to correct for any focus errors in the system. In other words, removing the focus target structure may significantly reduce the accuracy of the lithographic apparatus.
[0062] Furthermore, it is desirable to provide a method of determining a focus setting for a location on a substrate being exposed in a lithographic apparatus, wherein individual sources of focus error can be separated. In other words, it is desirable to determine individual factors or properties that may change the desired focus setting and thereby potentially cause a focus error for any given location on the substrate.
[0063] The inventors have realised that focus settings for a lithographic apparatus can be determined without the need to perform measurements of the above-mentioned focus target structures on a product substrate. Instead of using such target structures on a product substrate, which reduces the yield of the product, the focus settings can be derived from focus measurements performed on one or more reference substrates and one or more sets of focus-related measurement data.
[0064] The inventors have also realised that by using multiple measurement data, the root cause of the focus error can be determined and isolated. This in turn may lead to improvements in the subsequent substrate design process.
[0065] Now refer to Figure 3 An exemplary method for determining a fingerprint of a performance parameter associated with a substrate is briefly outlined below. Figure 3 and Figure 4 for a more detailed discussion.
[0066] In a first step 301, a reference fingerprint 402 of a performance parameter associated with a reference substrate is determined. The fingerprint of the performance parameter is determined by patterning a plurality of measurement target structures from a pattern forming device onto a reference substrate, and then measuring one or more properties of the target structures. In an example, the target structure is designed to allow measurement of a focus setting. The focus setting may be measured in any suitable manner, for example, by using a lithographic apparatus or by using a dedicated measurement apparatus. It should be understood that although described below with respect to focus settings, other performance parameters may be determined equally well using the exemplary method. The measurement target structure may be designed to allow measurement of performance parameters such as (but not limited to): alignment, overlay, dose, or critical dimension (CD).
[0067] In a second step 302, reference substrate parameters 404 related to the reference substrate are determined. When the performance parameter is a focus setting, the reference substrate parameter may be, for example, a height map of the reference substrate (which may be measured, for example, by a level sensor of the lithographic apparatus). Other reference substrate parameters may be related to performance parameters related to, for example, overlay or CD performance, including, but not limited to: alignment fingerprints (by measuring alignment mark positions across a reference substrate) or stack characteristics related to the reference substrate. Stack characteristics may be related, for example, to resist thickness measurements or reflectivity measurements performed across the reference substrate.
[0068] In a third step 303, substrate parameters associated with a substrate (typically provided with one or more product structures) are determined 420. In one example, the substrate parameters are determined in substantially the same manner as reference substrate parameters, but by measuring a substrate (e.g., a product substrate containing product features) rather than a reference substrate.
[0069] In a fourth step 304, a fingerprint 424 of the performance parameter is determined based on the reference fingerprint 402, the reference substrate parameters 404 and the substrate parameters 420. Knowledge of the reference performance parameters and the fingerprint of the reference substrate parameters determined for the reference substrate allows the determination of the fingerprint of the performance parameter of the substrate, provided that the substrate parameters have also been determined. This eliminates the need to determine the fingerprint of the performance parameter directly on the substrate. In the example where the performance parameter is a focus setting, the above method enables the determination of the focus setting without the need to perform a focus measurement directly on the substrate, thereby avoiding the need for a focus target structure on the substrate surface.
[0070] It should be appreciated that, although described with respect to focus settings, in principle the above method can be used to determine a number of different performance parameters of a substrate. Therefore, the determination of focus settings should only be regarded as exemplary and should not be construed as limiting.
[0071] Now refer to Figure 3 and 4The above method is discussed in detail. As described, in a first step 301, a reference fingerprint 402 of a performance parameter related to a reference substrate is determined. In an example, the performance parameter is a parameter related to focus. In a specific example, the reference fingerprint is a focus setting that reflects the relative position of the reference substrate relative to the focal plane of the lithographic apparatus. As described above, it should be noted that this is for exemplary purposes only. Those skilled in the art can easily envision examples in which reference fingerprints are determined for other performance parameters (e.g., alignment, critical dimension, or overlay error).
[0072] In some examples, a reference fingerprint is determined based on one or more specific contributions. In general, contributions can be divided into two types: intra-field contributions and inter-field contributions. As described above, during exposure, the pattern forming device is imaged onto the surface of the substrate. Each exposure pattern on the substrate surface is called a field. Intra-field contributions refer to contributions that are repeated in each field, i.e., contributions that are repeated for each individual exposure. Inter-field contributions refer to contributions that are distributed over part or all of the substrate, i.e., they are not repeated for each field.
[0073] In an example, an inter-field contribution to a reference fingerprint is derived based on the first set of reference measurement data 406. The first set of measurement data may be obtained in any suitable manner. As described, the inter-field contribution describes a substrate-wide contribution to the reference fingerprint. In other words, the inter-field contribution describes an effect or contribution that varies across the surface of the substrate, including (but not limited to): deformation of the substrate and / or a substrate table on which the substrate is placed; or a defect in the surface of the base substrate. In an example, the first set of measurement data includes height data that describes height variations due to defects in the surface of the reference substrate.
[0074] Additionally or alternatively, the reference fingerprint may be determined based on other contributions. In one such example, an intra-field contribution 408 to the reference fingerprint is derived based on the second set of reference measurement data. As described, the intra-field contribution describes contributions to the reference fingerprint that are repeated in each field, including (but not limited to): deformation (e.g., bend) of the patterning device (reticle); or deformation of the projection lens.
[0075] In some examples, a reference fingerprint may be determined based on multiple sets of reference measurement data. In an example, multiple sets may be obtained by performing measurements on multiple reference substrates over a specific time period. This enables the deriving and consideration of time-dependent or time-evolving contributions to the reference fingerprint 410. It should be understood that multiple sets of reference measurement data may be used to derive one or both of the inter-field and intra-field contributions. For example, in one example, multiple sets of reference measurement data are used to derive the inter-field contribution. In another example, multiple sets of measurement data are used to derive the inter-field contribution and the intra-field contribution.
[0076] By performing reference measurements over a period of time, the focus stability of a reference substrate can also be determined. This stability information can then be used to simulate and / or predict the focus stability of subsequent batches of substrates.
[0077] In some examples, the reference measurement data includes information related to the characteristics of the lithographic apparatus. Since the reference substrate does not usually include any product structure, the reference measurement data will mainly reflect the properties of the various components of the lithographic apparatus. In one example, the information is related to the optical characteristics of the optical system of the lithographic apparatus. In a specific example, the information represents the aberrations in one or more optical elements (e.g., lenses) of the optical system (e.g., exposure system) of the lithographic apparatus. In another example, the information is related to the characteristics of the positioning system of the lithographic apparatus. In one such example, the information represents the positioning error of one or more movable elements or stages (e.g., substrate stages) of the lithographic apparatus.
[0078] It should be understood that the reference measurement data can be obtained in any suitable manner using any suitable measurement system or methodology. For example, when the information of the reference measurement data represents the optical properties of the optical system of the lithographic apparatus, the information can be obtained by measurement or calculation. In a specific example, the reference substrate has one or more focus targets for performing focus measurements provided on its surface. In other examples, other types of targets or target structures can be used to perform measurements. The measurement results are subsequently used to determine the aberrations in one or more lenses of the optical system of the lithographic apparatus. In other examples, the reference substrate includes targets or features for position or alignment measurements (e.g., target structures for measuring the alignment of a pattern forming device), the results of which can be used in some examples to obtain information representing position deviations or errors in one or more movable elements of the lithographic apparatus.
[0079] In a second step 302, reference substrate parameters 404 associated with the reference substrate are determined. The reference substrate parameters may be determined in any suitable manner. In some examples, the reference substrate parameters include a height map (or other height-related information) of the reference substrate. In a specific example, the height map includes height measurement data obtained by a level sensor. The height measurement data may be obtained at any convenient time. For example, the height measurement data may be obtained before the lithography process, or may be obtained as part of the lithography process. Alternatively, the height measurement data may include data obtained before the lithography process and data obtained during the lithography process.
[0080] Typically, when the performance parameter is (related to) focus setting, the reference substrate parameter is selected as a height map. When the performance parameter is (related to) overlay performance, it is more useful to include alignment measurement data associated with the reference substrate (because both overlay and alignment data relate to the location of features defined within the plane of the substrate). Therefore, it is advantageous to use alignment measurement data as the reference substrate parameter. When the performance parameter is critical dimension, stack characteristic data associated with the reference substrate can be used as the reference substrate parameter.
[0081] In some examples, the step of determining the reference substrate parameters also includes obtaining additional reference data 405. The additional reference data can be obtained by performing additional measurements, and can be performed, for example, to increase the accuracy of the height map. For example, the additional reference data may include correction information representing errors in the height map of the reference substrate, such as substrate stage positioning errors. In another example, the additional reference data of the reference substrate parameters include correction data information representing errors in the height map of the substrate (rather than the reference substrate). Improving the accuracy of the height map directly improves the control of the yield of the lithographic equipment. For example, increasing the accuracy of the height map allows to improve the ability to correct position errors (including height errors), which reduces the change in the height profile of the substrate. If the change in the height profile is not controlled, the risk of some product structures not being properly exposed and therefore not being of good quality is increased, which in turn has a negative impact on the yield and increases the price of each product structure.
[0082] The additional reference data may be obtained in any suitable manner. In some examples, the additional reference data is obtained by barometer measurements performed at appropriate times during the lithography process. Alternatively, in other examples, the additional reference data is obtained by entering positioning errors of one or more movable components of the lithographic apparatus (e.g., substrate or reticle stage positioning errors), which are particularly relevant when the reference substrate parameters are correlated with the alignment measurement data.
[0083] The first step and the second step together enable the derivation of a device fingerprint 412 (which may also be referred to as a "scanner fingerprint") representing properties of the lithographic apparatus. The device fingerprint may be derived in any suitable manner. In an example, the device fingerprint is derived by subtracting the reference substrate parameters 404 and the additional reference data 405 from the reference fingerprint 402:
[0084] Device fingerprint = reference fingerprint - (substrate parameters + additional reference data)
[0085] It should be understood that the above-mentioned contributing factors of device fingerprints are merely exemplary and should not be interpreted in any limiting manner. Those skilled in the art can easily think of other examples in which additional or alternative contributing factors of device fingerprints are used.
[0086] In a third step 303, substrate parameters 420 associated with a substrate (typically provided with one or more product structures) are determined. In some instances, the substrate parameters are determined in a manner similar to the reference substrate parameters but for the substrate rather than the reference substrate. Therefore, it should be understood that the various examples and method steps described with reference to the reference substrate parameters may also be applied to the substrate parameters. Typically, the method for obtaining the substrate parameters is substantially the same as the method for obtaining the reference substrate parameters.
[0087] In some examples, the substrate parameters include a height map of the substrate. The height map may include height data for a portion or the entire surface of the substrate. In an example, the height map includes height data obtained after at least the first patterning step. In another example, the height map includes height data obtained after at least the first processing step.
[0088] In yet other examples, the height map comprises multiple sets of height data, each set of height data being obtained after one of a plurality of patterning and / or further processing steps. It should be appreciated that, in principle, any suitable number of sets of height data may be obtained at any suitable time during the lithography process. Furthermore, in principle height data from a previous substrate or batch of substrates may be utilized.
[0089] In some examples, the step of determining substrate parameters also includes obtaining additional substrate data 425, similar to the reference substrate parameters 404 described above. The substrate parameters and additional substrate data can be collectively referred to as a process fingerprint 422. The process fingerprint can be determined in any suitable manner. In one example, the process fingerprint 422 is equal to the sum of the substrate parameters 420 and any additional substrate data 425:
[0090] Process fingerprint = substrate parameters + additional substrate data
[0091] In some examples, the additional substrate data additionally or alternatively includes information representing one or more process-related effects. For example, product structures are becoming more and more complex with an increasing number of layers and the use of an increasing number of different materials. Each material may have unique optical properties. Certain materials may be opaque at certain wavelengths and transparent at other wavelengths. Therefore, it is necessary to compensate for any measurement errors caused by such material-related effects. In some examples, it is assumed that the process-related effects are constant (i.e., the process dependence is stable over time). In such examples, the contribution associated with the process-related effects is constant. However, in other examples, it can be determined that the process-related effects vary over time or depending on process parameters.
[0092] In a fourth step 304 , a fingerprint 424 of a performance parameter is determined based on the reference fingerprint 402 , the reference substrate parameters 404 and the substrate parameters 420 .
[0093] The fingerprint of the performance parameter may be determined in any suitable manner. In some examples, the fingerprint of the performance parameter is obtained by a simple summation, namely:
[0094] Performance parameters = process fingerprint + device fingerprint
[0095] It should be understood that this is merely exemplary and not limiting. Those skilled in the art may think of many specific determination methods. For example, a fingerprint of a performance parameter may be obtained by using the above summation, wherein one or more other parameters (e.g., the additional parameters described below) are added.
[0096] It should be understood that the characteristics and parameters used to determine the fingerprint of the performance parameters described above are only exemplary. In principle, the fingerprint of the performance parameters can also be determined by using alternative or additional parameters and characteristics.
[0097] In some examples, in addition to the above characteristics and parameters, one or more additional characteristics are used to determine the fingerprint of the performance parameter. For example, this may include characteristics that exhibit time variation, or it may include characteristics that otherwise depend on the substrate map or a single field map. The additional characteristics may be used to derive an additional fingerprint 426 of the substrate. The additional fingerprint may also be referred to as a "temporal fingerprint."
[0098] In one example, the additional fingerprint 426 includes movement information 428 of one or more movable parts of the lithographic apparatus. For example, the movement information can be related to the movement of a level sensor during a measurement phase. In a specific example, the movement information is related to the difference between the movement pattern of the level sensor when performing measurements on a reference substrate and the movement pattern of the level sensor when performing measurements on a product substrate. In another example, the movement information is related to the movement of the pattern forming device during the exposure step. For example, the movement information can be specifically related to the movement error during the exposure step, such as the difference between the programmed movement and the actual movement.
[0099] It should be noted that the above-described movement of the level sensor and / or patterning device is relative to the substrate being measured. Thus, it can be appreciated that the level sensor or patterning device can also be stationary while the substrate is being moved. Alternatively, both the level sensor or patterning device and the substrate can be moved during measurement.
[0100] In other examples, the additional fingerprint includes one or more temporal characteristics 430 of the optical system of the lithographic apparatus. In one such example, the temporal characteristics are associated with temperature-dependent changes in optical properties of one or more optical components of the optical system of the lithographic apparatus. It is well known that the optical properties of optical components, in particular optical lenses, may depend on the temperature of the components (this effect may sometimes be referred to as "lens heating").
[0101] In yet other examples, the additional fingerprint includes one or more physical properties 432 of components of the lithographic apparatus. In one such example, the additional fingerprint includes characteristics of the patterning device, such as variations in the patterning device or deformations of the patterning device. As described above, during the lithography process, the pattern on the patterning device is transferred to the substrate. Therefore, any defects or deformations of the patterning device will affect the quality of the pattern transferred to the substrate. For example, deformations of the patterning device will affect the focus setting of the lithographic apparatus. Therefore, if such variations can be determined, the focus setting can be modified accordingly, thereby improving the accuracy of the lithographic apparatus.
[0102] It will be appreciated that in addition to the above-mentioned characteristics and parameters, statistics and / or data obtained during previous measurements 434 may also be used. For example, these data may have been obtained from a previous substrate or batch of substrates. In this way, variations between batches of substrates may be identified and corrected.
[0103] It should be understood that all of the above data sets (such as but not limited to reference fingerprints, reference substrate parameters, substrate parameters, and additional fingerprints) are composed of multiple discrete data points arranged in a suitable manner. In some examples, the data points are arranged in a regular grid layout. In other examples, the data points are arranged to cover specific portions of the substrate surface, such as key product structures or components.
[0104] In the above, purely for exemplary purposes, it is assumed that the data points of each set of data have been arranged in the same grid layout. In practice, this may not always be the case, so it is necessary to modify the data set to enable the fingerprint of the performance parameter to be determined. Figure 5 An example of such a process, which will also be referred to as "remeshing," is shown in FIG. 1 . It should be understood that the grid layout shown in the figure is purely for exemplary purposes.
[0105] Figure 5 The case of using three sets of data (e.g., measurement or calculation results) is shown. The first set of data 502 is arranged into a first grid layout 504. Similarly, the second set of data 506 is arranged into a second grid layout 508, and the third set of data 510 is arranged into a third grid layout 512. It can be seen that each of the three grid layouts is different from the other two grid layouts.
[0106] Figure 5 A fourth grid layout 514 is also shown. For comparison with the first, second and third grid layouts, data points 516 of the fourth grid layout are shown as dashed lines overlaid on these grid layouts. It can be seen that in order to comply with the fourth grid layout, it is necessary to at least partially derive new data points for each of the first, second and third sets of data. This derivation can be performed in any suitable manner. In some examples, the derivation can be performed by linear interpolation. It should be appreciated that in principle any suitable interpolation method can be used.
[0107] The properties of the fourth grid layout, such as the horizontal and vertical distances between data points on the substrate surface, can be determined in a suitable manner. Figure 5 In the example shown, the fourth grid layout has a horizontal spacing equal to that of the second grid layout and a vertical spacing equal to that of the first grid layout. However, it should be understood that this is purely for exemplary purposes and that other grid layouts may be envisioned by the skilled person. In one example, the data points of the first, second, and third grid layouts are re-gridded to match the grid layout with the lowest density of data points.
[0108] Back to Figure 4 , you can Figure 4 The remeshing step is performed at any suitable time during the measurement process shown. Typically, however, the remeshing step 436 is performed just prior to determining the fingerprint of the performance parameter.
[0109] Figure 6 The correlation between the actual focus setting measurements as they relate to the dedicated focus target (along the X-axis 602) and the calculated focus settings that have been derived using the above method (along the Y-axis 604) is shown. Line 606 shows a high correlation between the measured and calculated results. Figure 6 As can be seen in FIG. 1 , the above method can be used to determine the focus setting on a substrate without having to perform dedicated measurements on the focus target structure.
[0110] The embodiments described so far are intended to dispense with the use of focus targets on production reticles; e.g., reticles comprising production structures. Using a reference reticle comprising a focus target, once printed on a reference substrate, the focus target is measured using a metrology tool based on analysis of the diffraction pattern produced by the interaction of the measurement beam and the printed focus target. This is generally considered to be the best way to determine the focus setting or focus fingerprint associated with a lithographic apparatus or lithographic process.
[0111] As mentioned above, performing focus measurements in a known manner requires a focus target that is compatible with a metrology tool based on scatterometry and / or diffraction pattern measurement. For thin resists and / or high resolution processes (EUV based processes), the architecture of a focus target based on a diffraction / scatterometer becomes impractical. In a patent application, application number PCT / EP2016 / 062259 (not yet published at the time of writing this article), a solution is proposed, in which the diffraction based focus target is replaced with a focus target consisting of two features, each with a different orientation. An example of such a focus target is a target consisting of horizontally oriented lines (or spaces) and vertically oriented lines (or spaces), as provided on a mask including a product structure. The mask including the focus target is exposed while introducing an astigmatic aberration 'AST' in the projection lens of the lithographic apparatus. The astigmatic aberration results in a different defocusing effect for horizontal features relative to vertical features. This is modeled as a shift of the Poisson (Bossung) curve associated with the horizontal features relative to the Bossung curve associated with the vertical features. The Bossung curve represents the response of a feature parameter (usually the critical dimension, often abbreviated as CD) as a function of the magnitude of the deviation of the focus setting 'F' from a reference. In general, the Bossung curve can be approximated as a quadratic relationship of the parameter (CD) with respect to the focus setting 'F': CD = a*(Fb)^2+c. Parameter 'a' is related to the curvature of the Bossung, parameter 'b' is related to the focus offset of the Bossung relative to a reference focus level, and parameter 'c' is the target CD of the feature. The introduction of astigmatic aberration will change the position of the focal plane of the projection lens, resulting in a Bossung shift; parameter 'b' will depend on the level of AST introduced. When the astigmatic aberration has an axis of symmetry aligned with the direction of the feature (horizontal-vertical), a focus offset 'b' for the horizontal feature H and a focus offset '-b' (opposite sign) for the vertical feature V will be introduced. According to CD_H = a*(Fb)^2+c, the CD of feature H (CD_H) depends on F: and according to CD_V = a*(F+b)^2+c, the CD of feature V (CD_V) also depends on F. When subtracting the two CDs, the following relationship is obtained: CD_H-CD_V=d*F, the parameter 'd' being a constant. By measuring the difference in CD between horizontal and vertical features, the focus setting 'F' can be reconstructed, which is usually related to the focus error of the lithographic equipment. It should be mentioned that in addition to measuring CD (using a scanning electron microscope SEM or a scatterometer), another parameter that exhibits the Bossung curve behavior through focusing can also be determined. When using a scatterometer metrology tool, this parameter can be related to the intensity distribution of the zero-order beam after interacting with the focusing target. When using a metrology tool based on diffraction measurement, a parameter based on the comparison between the energy and / or phase content of various orders (-1, +1, etc.) can be used.
[0112] The focus setting 'F' is defined relative to a reference focus setting, typically corresponding to the focus setting for which the Bossung curve shows a maximum or minimum value of CD or other parameter of interest. It is important to emphasize that the focus settings in this literature are always related to the operating mode of the lithographic apparatus before the introduction of the introduced astigmatic errors. Astigmatic aberrations do change the focus setting of the lithographic apparatus, but when referring to the reference focus setting, the effects related to the focus setting are meaningful, except for the intentionally introduced astigmatic aberrations.
[0113] In addition to the introduction of astigmatic aberrations, other aberrations may be introduced where their introduction enhances the focus sensitivity of the structure being measured. For example, spherical aberration may be selected where the focus target is based on the principle of a phase shift mask. In addition to manipulating the projection lens, aberrations may be introduced by other methods. For example, the reticle height (the distance between the reticle and the focal plane of the projection lens measured along the optical axis of the projection lens) may be adjusted to introduce spherical aberration.
[0114] The inventors have realised that the above principles can be used to determine the focus setting of a lithographic apparatus in a volume production environment. Figure 7 The arrows show the sequence of steps and products when the mass production method proposed by the inventor is adopted. The steps and arrows in dashed lines refer to optional steps.
[0115] A focus setting 1300 for the lithographic apparatus is determined based on the measurement 1200. The measurement 1200 is performed on a focus target on the substrate 1010 that has been exposed during step 1100. The exposure 1100 is performed while introducing an aberration 1105 (typically AST). The focus target can be selected from a number of structures that are sensitive to the focus setting of the lithographic apparatus, in particular when aberrations (astigmatism, spherical aberration) are introduced.
[0116] In one embodiment, the focus target structure is a line and space oriented along two or more directions, such as a pair of lines and spaces, one structure oriented along a horizontal direction and the other structure oriented along a vertical direction.
[0117] In another embodiment, the focus target is a single feature for which a first metric related to a first direction and a second metric related to a second direction are determined. An example of this embodiment is the selection of a contact hole as a single feature for which horizontal and vertical dimensions are determined. Similar to the previously described case of a target consisting of horizontal and vertical lines, a metric based on subtracting a second parameter from a first parameter can be used to obtain a metric that linearly depends on the deviation of the focus setting from a reference focus setting.
[0118] In another embodiment, instead of a dedicated focus target structure, the product structure is selected to determine the focus setting. This is useful if there is a difference between product structure features, which combined with the introduced astigmatism can be used to derive the focus setting of the lithographic apparatus. For example, (CD) measurements of horizontal and vertical features of the product structure can make this a viable solution. The advantage is that in this case, there is no need to provide a focus target for the reticle, leaving more design freedom and a larger usable area for the product structure.
[0119] In another embodiment, it is desired to determine aspects of the time evolution of the focus settings. It is then desirable to extend the focus setting determination across more than one substrate. After exposing substrate 'i', substrate 'i+1' is selected for exposure 1100 and measurement 1200 to determine focus settings 1300 representative of the lithographic apparatus during exposure of substrate 'i+1'. Exposure of multiple substrates may be useful because (optical) components of the lithographic apparatus may heat up during exposure, resulting in significantly different focus behaviors of the lithographic apparatus. Components such as the reticle, projection lens, and the substrate itself are susceptible to heating effects resulting from prolonged use of the lithographic apparatus (exposure). The light used to expose the reticle causes heating of the reticle, projection lens, and substrate. The result is a drift in the focus settings of the lithographic apparatus. By selecting multiple substrates (e.g., repeating step 1005 of selecting substrate 'i+1', where 'i' refers to the ID of the most recently exposed substrate) for exposure and subsequent focus setting measurements, a typical focus setting evolution during exposure of a (production) batch of substrates can be established.
[0120] In another embodiment, a model is fitted to the focus setting evolution characteristics. The model may for example be a focus fingerprint (spatial distribution of focus settings across the substrate) where each focus setting value is modeled as a parameterized exponential function over time.
[0121] In another embodiment, the radiation dose used to pattern the substrate 1000 for determining the focus setting is higher than the dose used during the patterning step of the product substrate 1400. The effect is a stronger heating effect of the component, which leads to a reduction of the substrate 1000 required in terms of the time evolution of the focus setting 1300.
[0122] In another embodiment, a plurality of substrates 1000 are selected in a batch of substrates for subsequent exposure 1100 , measurement 1200 , and determination of focus settings 1300 .
[0123] In another embodiment, one or more substrates in a batch of substrates are selected for subsequent exposure 1100 , measurement 1200 , and determination of focus settings 1300 .
[0124] In another embodiment, the substrate 1000 used to determine the focus setting 1300 belongs to one or more pre-send batches comprising pre-send substrates. When astigmatic aberrations 1105 are introduced during exposure of a production reticle, in many cases the patterned substrate is used only to determine the focus setting associated with the lithographic equipment. Focusing of critical product features may be affected by the intentionally introduced astigmatism and the patterned substrate needs to be reworked. This concept is generally related to the "pre-send" principle; pre-send substrates 1000 from a pre-send batch are exposed and measured in order to provide improved machine settings at which subsequent (production) substrates 1400 will be exposed.
[0125] In another embodiment, the substrate used to determine the focus setting is included in the set of patterned production substrates. When the product structures are not susceptible to astigmatic aberrations (for example when they are unidirectional), the measured substrate can be included in the set of production substrates. Figure 7 This is shown by the dashed arrow between the measurement step 1200 and the box representing the end product; a patterned production substrate 1410 .
[0126] After the focus settings 1300 have been determined, the lithographic apparatus will be configured to start a patterning step 1500 of the product substrate 1400. Typically, the product substrate will be exposed with different aberration settings than during the exposure 1100 of the substrate 1000. The aberration settings of the lithographic apparatus will be updated during step 1510, but this is not necessary in case of limited sensitivity of the product structure to astigmatic aberrations.
[0127] In another embodiment, a correction of the focus setting is applied based on the determined focus setting 1300. The correction may involve adjusting the projection lens and / or positioning the substrate 1400 closer to or more parallel to the focal plane of the projection lens. When the focus setting 1300 includes a model describing the time-evolving characteristics, the correction may be dynamic; for example, adjusting the focus setting according to the exposure history of the lithographic apparatus.
[0128] In another embodiment, complementary focus setting data (different from data 1300) will be used to configure exposure 1500 of the product substrate 1400. This additional focus setting data is referred to as situation data 1600. The situation data 1600 may include substrate geometry data, leveling data, aberration measurement data, knowledge of the topography of layers on the substrate (based on the product structure layout), or focus setting data related to substrates measured on other lithographic equipment.
[0129] In another embodiment, the configuration of the lithographic apparatus is not changed between exposure 1100 and exposure 1500, except for the aberration settings 1510. The illumination mode, illumination dose settings, reticle and substrate table parameters are kept substantially the same so that the determined focus settings 1300 are as representative as possible of actual production conditions during production exposure 1500. The choice to keep the settings equal between exposures 1100 and 1500 is based on the need for the heating characteristics of the reticle, projection lens and substrate to be substantially the same during focus setting determination and volume production conditions.
[0130] In another embodiment, exposure 1100 and measurement 1200 of a substrate is performed once, or at very long time intervals (weeks, months), since typically the focus setting behavior of the lithographic apparatus during exposure of a batch of substrates will be stable during regular production. This typically applies to short-term evolving characteristics (focus drift during exposure of a batch) or long-term evolving characteristics (focus drift during exposure of a large number of batches; for example during a period longer than a day).
[0131] Further embodiments of the invention are listed in the following numbered aspects:
[0132] 1. A method for determining a fingerprint of a performance parameter associated with a substrate, the method comprising:
[0133] the step of determining a reference fingerprint of a performance parameter associated with a reference substrate;
[0134] a step of determining at least one reference substrate parameter associated with said reference substrate;
[0135] the step of determining at least one substrate parameter associated with said substrate; and
[0136] The step of determining said fingerprint of said performance parameter based on said first reference substrate parameter, said substrate parameter and said reference fingerprint.
[0137] 2. A method according to clause 1, wherein the method further comprises the step of adjusting the operation of the lithographic apparatus based on the fingerprint of the performance parameter.
[0138] 3. A method according to clause 1, wherein the performance parameter is a focus setting reflecting the relative position of the substrate or a reference substrate with respect to a focal plane of the lithographic apparatus.
[0139] 4. A method according to clause 3, wherein the reference fingerprint is determined by measuring the focus setting across the reference substrate.
[0140] 5. The method according to any of the preceding aspects, wherein the reference substrate parameters comprise a reference height map of the reference substrate.
[0141] 6. A method according to clause 5, wherein the reference height map comprises height measurement data obtained by a level sensor.
[0142] 7. The method of clause 6, wherein the step of determining the reference substrate parameters further comprises obtaining additional reference data.
[0143] 8. A method according to clause 7, wherein the additional reference data includes correction information representing errors in the reference height map.
[0144] 9. The method of clause 7, wherein the additional reference data includes correction information representing errors in the substrate height map.
[0145] 10. The method according to any of the preceding aspects, wherein the substrate parameters comprise a substrate height map of the substrate.
[0146] 11. The method of clause 10, wherein the substrate height map comprises height data of the substrate obtained after at least the first patterning step.
[0147] 12. A method according to clause 10 or 11, wherein the substrate height map comprises height data of the substrate obtained after at least the first processing step.
[0148] 13. The method of any of clauses 10-12, wherein the substrate parameters include a plurality of substrate height maps representing a corresponding plurality of patterned layers on the substrate.
[0149] 14. The method according to any of the preceding aspects, wherein the step of determining the fingerprint of the performance parameter comprises performing a summation of each of the reference fingerprint, a reference substrate parameter and the substrate parameter.
[0150] 15. The method according to any of the preceding aspects further includes a step of adjusting at least one of the reference fingerprint, the reference substrate parameter and the substrate parameter so that data points of each of the reference fingerprint, the reference substrate parameter and the substrate parameter overlap in a reference grid on the surface of the substrate.
[0151] 16. The method according to any of the preceding aspects, further comprising the step of determining an additional fingerprint of at least one parameter of the substrate or of a reference substrate.
[0152] 17. The method according to any of the preceding aspects, wherein the step of determining a reference fingerprint comprises deriving an inter-field contribution to the reference fingerprint based on the first set of reference measurement data.
[0153] 18. The method according to any of the preceding aspects, wherein the step of determining a reference fingerprint comprises deriving an intra-field contribution to the reference fingerprint based on the second set of reference measurement data.
[0154] 19. The method according to any of the preceding aspects, wherein the step of determining a reference fingerprint comprises deriving the reference fingerprint based on a plurality of sets of reference measurement data.
[0155] 20. A method according to any of clauses 17 to 19, wherein the reference measurement data comprises information relating to characteristics of the lithographic apparatus.
[0156] 21. A method according to clause 20, wherein the information relates to optical properties of an optical system of the lithographic apparatus.
[0157] 22. A method according to clause 20 or 21, wherein the information is related to a characteristic of a positioning system of the lithographic apparatus.
[0158] 23. A method for manufacturing a device, wherein device features are formed on a series of substrates by a photolithography process, wherein properties of the processed substrates are measured by one or more measurement processes, and wherein the measured properties are used to determine a fingerprint of a performance parameter according to the method described in any one of aspects 1 to 22.
[0159] 24. A lithographic apparatus comprising means for performing the method of any one of clauses 1 to 23.
[0160] 25. A lithographic apparatus according to clause 24, comprising:
[0161] an illumination optics system arranged to illuminate the pattern; and
[0162] a projection optical system arranged to project an image of the pattern onto a substrate;
[0163] Wherein the lithographic apparatus is arranged to use the determined fingerprint of the performance parameter when applying a pattern on a further substrate.
[0164] 26. A computer program product comprising one or more sequences of machine-readable instructions for implementing the method according to any one of aspects 1 to 23.
[0165] 27. A method according to aspect 1 or 2, wherein the performance parameter is an overlap-related parameter.
[0166] 28. The method of clause 27, wherein the reference fingerprint is determined by measuring overlapping features across the reference substrate.
[0167] 29. A method according to clause 27 or 28, wherein the reference substrate parameters comprise a map of alignment mark locations of a reference substrate.
[0168] 30. The method of clause 29, wherein the alignment mark location map comprises alignment measurement data obtained by an alignment sensor.
[0169] 31. The method of clause 1 or 2, wherein the performance parameter is a critical dimension related parameter.
[0170] 32. The method of clause 31, wherein the reference fingerprint is determined by measuring a critical dimension across the reference substrate.
[0171] 33. A method according to clause 31 or 32, wherein the reference substrate parameters comprise a stack property map of the reference substrate.
[0172] 34. The method of clause 33, wherein the stack property map comprises resist thickness data.
[0173] 35. A method according to clause 33 or 34, wherein the stack property map comprises reflectivity data.
[0174] 36. A method for patterning a plurality of substrates using a lithographic apparatus, the method comprising:
[0175] determining a focus setting based on measurements of structures on a substrate, wherein the substrate has been exposed by the lithographic apparatus at an aberration setting associated with an enhanced sensitivity of the measurements of the structures to variations of the focus setting; and
[0176] The plurality of substrates are patterned using a lithographic apparatus at a corrected focus setting based on the determined focus setting.
[0177] 37. A method according to clause 36, wherein the aberration setting is related to the introduction of astigmatism.
[0178] 38. A method according to clause 36 or clause 37, wherein a metric is defined as representing a deviation of the focus setting from a target focus setting.
[0179] 39. A method according to clause 38, wherein the structure is a focusing target.
[0180] 40. A method according to any one of aspects 38 to 39, wherein the structure comprises two features.
[0181] 41. A method according to clause 40, wherein the metric is based on a first metric related to the first feature and a second metric related to the second feature.
[0182] 42. A method according to any one of aspects 36 to 41, wherein the structure is a product structure.
[0183] 43. A method according to any one of clauses 36 to 42, wherein the plurality of substrates are patterned using the lithographic apparatus at a second aberration setting different from the aberration setting associated with the enhanced sensitivity of the measurement to changes in focus setting.
[0184] 44. A method according to any one of clauses 36 to 43, wherein the measurement is based on analysis of a diffraction pattern of the structure.
[0185] 45. A method according to any one of clauses 36 to 44, wherein the measuring is based on analysis of an image of a structure on the substrate acquired by a metrology tool based on electron beam imaging.
[0186] 46. A method according to any one of clauses 36 to 45, wherein the measuring is based on scatterometry.
[0187] 47. A method according to any one of clauses 36 to 46, wherein the plurality of substrates belong to one or more batches of substrates.
[0188] 48. The method of clause 47, wherein the plurality of batches of substrates are associated with a volume manufacturing process.
[0189] 49. A method according to any one of clauses 36 to 48, wherein the measurements are performed on structures on one or more substrates belonging to a pre-shipped batch.
[0190] 50. A method according to any of clauses 36 to 49, wherein the measurements are performed on a plurality of focus targets on one or more substrates.
[0191] 51. A method according to clause 50, wherein the focus setting comprises modeling the temporal behavior of the focus setting during the step of patterning a plurality of substrates.
[0192] 52. The method of clause 51, wherein during the patterning of the plurality of substrates, a corrected focus setting is dynamically adjusted.
[0193] 53. A method according to any of clauses 36 to 52, wherein the corrected focus setting is based on the determined focus setting and additional situation data.
[0194] 54. A method according to clause 53, wherein the situation data comprises one or more of: levelling or levelling data, substrate geometry data, alignment data, aberration data, reticle data.
[0195] 55. A method according to clause 54, wherein the measuring is performed on a substrate belonging to a plurality of substrates.
[0196] Although specific reference has been made above to the use of embodiments of the invention in the context of optical lithography, it will be appreciated that the invention may be used in other applications, such as imprint lithography, and is not limited to optical lithography where the context permits. In imprint lithography, the topology in a patterning device defines the pattern produced on a substrate. The topology of the patterning device may be imprinted into a layer of resist provided to the substrate, the resist being cured by application of electromagnetic radiation, heat, pressure, or a combination thereof. The patterning device is removed from the resist, leaving the pattern behind after the resist has cured.
[0197] The terms "radiation" and "beam" as used herein with respect to a lithographic apparatus include all types of electromagnetic radiation, including ultraviolet (UV) radiation (e.g., having a wavelength equal to or approximately 365 nm, 355 nm, 248 nm, 193 nm, 157 nm or 126 nm) and extreme ultraviolet (EUV) radiation (e.g., having a wavelength in the range of 5 nm to 20 nm) as well as particle beams such as ion beams or electron beams.
[0198] The term "lens," where the context allows, may refer to any one or combination of various types of optical components, including refractive, reflective, magnetic, electromagnetic, and electrostatic optical components.
[0199] The foregoing description of specific embodiments will fully reveal the general nature of the invention, and by applying knowledge within the technical scope of the art, others can easily modify and / or adapt such specific embodiments for various applications without excessive experimentation, without departing from the overall concept of the invention. Therefore, based on the teachings and guidance given herein, these changes and modifications are intended to fall within the meaning and range of equivalents of the disclosed embodiments. It should be understood that the wording or terminology herein is for illustrative purposes rather than restrictive purposes, so that the terms or wording of this specification will be interpreted by those skilled in the art based on the teachings and guidance.
[0200] The breadth and scope of the present invention should not be limited by any of the above-described exemplary embodiments, but should be defined only in accordance with the following claims and their equivalents.
Claims
1. A method for patterning a plurality of substrates using a photolithography apparatus, the method comprising: include: determining a focus setting based on measurements of structures on a substrate, wherein the substrate has been exposed by a lithographic apparatus at an aberration setting associated with an enhanced sensitivity of the measurements on the structures to changes in the focus setting; and The plurality of substrates are patterned using a lithographic apparatus at a corrected focus setting based on the determined focus setting.
2. The method according to claim 1, in, The aberration setting is related to the introduction of astigmatism.
3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the deviation of the focus setting from a target focus setting is defined as a metric.
4. The method according to claim 3, in, The structure is the focus target.
5. The method according to claim 3, in, The structure includes two features.
6. The method according to claim 5, in, The metric is based on a first metric associated with the first feature and a second metric associated with the second feature.
7. The method of claim 1 or 2, wherein the structure is a product structure.
8. The method of claim 1 or 2, wherein the plurality of substrates are patterned using the lithographic apparatus at a second aberration setting different from the aberration setting associated with an enhanced sensitivity of the measurement to changes in a focus setting.
9. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the measurement is based on analysis of the diffraction pattern of the structure.
10. The method of claim 1 or 2, wherein the measuring is based on analysis of images of structures on the substrate acquired by a metrology tool based on electron beam imaging.
11. The method of claim 1 or 2, wherein the measuring is based on scatterometry.
12. The method of claim 1 or 2, wherein the plurality of substrates belong to one or more batches of substrates.
13. The method of claim 12, wherein the plurality of batches of substrates are associated with a volume manufacturing process.
14. The method of claim 1 or 2, wherein the measurements are performed on structures on one or more substrates belonging to a pre-shipped batch.
15. The method of claim 1 or 2, wherein the measurements are performed on a plurality of focus targets on one or more substrates.
16. The method of claim 15, wherein the focus setting comprises modeling the temporal behavior of the focus setting during the step of patterning a plurality of substrates.
17. The method of claim 16, wherein during the patterning of the plurality of substrates, a corrected focus setting is dynamically adjusted.
18. The method of claim 1 or 2, wherein the corrected focus setting is based on the determined focus setting and additional situation data.
19. The method of claim 18, wherein the situation data comprises one or more of: leveling or leveling data, substrate geometry data, alignment data, aberration data, reticle data.
20. The method of claim 19, wherein the measuring is performed on a substrate belonging to a plurality of substrates.
21. A method for configuring a lithographic apparatus, the method include: deriving a focus setting based on measurements of structures on a substrate, wherein the substrate has been exposed to the structures by a lithographic apparatus at an aberration setting associated with an enhanced sensitivity of the measurements on the structures to changes in the focus setting; and The lithographic apparatus is configured based on the focus setting.
22. The method according to claim 21, in, The aberration setting is related to the introduction of astigmatism.
23. The method of claim 21 or 22, wherein the deviation of the focus setting from a target focus setting is defined as a metric.
24. The method according to claim 21, in, The structure is the focus target.
25. The method according to claim 21, in, The structure includes two features.
26. The method according to claim 25, in, A deviation of the focus setting from a target focus setting is defined as a metric, and the metric is based on a first metric associated with the first feature and a second metric associated with the second feature.
27. The method of claim 21 or 22, wherein the structure is a product structure.
28. A method according to claim 21 or 22, wherein the measurement is based on analysis of the diffraction pattern of the structure.
29. The method of claim 21 or 22, wherein the measuring is based on analysis of images of structures on the substrate acquired by a metrology tool based on electron beam imaging.
30. A method according to claim 21 or 22, wherein the measurements are performed on structures on one or more substrates belonging to a pre-shipped batch.
31. A storage medium for a computer program, comprising computer readable instructions to perform a method of configuring a lithographic apparatus, the instructions being configured to: determining a focus setting based on measurements of structures on a substrate, wherein the substrate has been exposed by a lithographic apparatus at an aberration setting associated with an enhanced sensitivity of the measurements on the structures to changes in the focus setting; and The lithographic apparatus is configured based on the focus setting.
32. A storage medium for a computer program according to claim 31, wherein the aberration setting is related to the introduction of astigmatism.
33. A storage medium for a computer program according to claim 31 or 32, wherein the instructions are further configured to define a metric related to a deviation of the focus setting from a target focus setting.
34. The storage medium for a computer program according to claim 33, in, The structure includes two features.
35. The storage medium for a computer program according to claim 34, in, The metric is based on a first metric associated with the first feature and a second metric associated with the second feature.
