Method, device and system for evaluating operation effect of charging station
Through the gray fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method and the AHP-entropy weight method, the single problem of charging station operation evaluation is solved, comprehensive evaluation and optimization guidance on the operation level of charging stations is achieved, and operation and service quality is improved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202210389580.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-04-14
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-19
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-04-14
AI Technical Summary
The existing charging station operation evaluation methods are single and one-sided, and the operation level of the charging station cannot be accurately and comprehensively evaluated, resulting in the inability to effectively guide operation improvement and service improvement.
The gray fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method is adopted, based on the preset electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system and the weight of indicators at each level, the index weight is determined through the AHP-entropy weight method, and the gray fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model is used to perform the operation effect of the charging station operation effect. Comprehensive evaluation.
It has achieved accurate and comprehensive evaluation of the operation level of the charging station, guided operation optimization and service improvement, and improved the operational capabilities and customer service quality of the charging station.
Smart Images

Figure CN114742415B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the field of operation and optimization management of electric vehicle charging stations, and specifically relates to an operation effect evaluation method, device and system suitable for charging stations. Background Art
[0002] As an important means of transportation in modern society, cars provide people with convenient and comfortable services. However, the use of traditional fuel vehicles increases environmental pollution and makes us overly dependent on oil resources. Electric vehicles are a key technology to reduce air pollution in densely populated areas and are an expected choice to promote energy diversification and reduce greenhouse gas emissions. With the development of electric vehicles, the scale of electric vehicle charging stations has gradually expanded.
[0003] At present, the charging service network is developing rapidly, but the service level is uneven, exposing many problems, mainly reflected in: poor customer service quality, insufficient charging station operation capacity, untimely discovery and rectification of safety hazards, and great impact on the surrounding environment. In order to grasp the operating status and service capacity of charging stations, improve the operating level and service quality of charging stations, it is necessary to continuously evaluate the service level of charging stations and improve the service level. However, the existing evaluation system method is single and one-sided, and it cannot accurately and comprehensively evaluate the operating level of charging stations, and cannot make operational analysis based on historical big data, so as to guide the operation of charging stations and improve service levels. Summary of the invention
[0004] In response to the above problems, the present invention proposes a method, device and system for evaluating the operating effect of charging stations, which can accurately and comprehensively analyze and evaluate the operating level of charging stations based on historical big data, thereby guiding the operation of charging stations and improving service levels.
[0005] In order to achieve the above technical objectives and the above technical effects, the present invention is implemented through the following technical solutions:
[0006] In a first aspect, the present invention provides an operation effect evaluation method applicable to a charging station, comprising:
[0007] Obtaining a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model, wherein the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model is established based on a preset electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system and index weights of indicators at all levels, using a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method;
[0008] The grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model is used to comprehensively evaluate the actual operation data of the charging station to be evaluated and determine the operation effect of the charging station.
[0009] Optionally, the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system includes a target layer, a criterion layer and an index layer which are arranged in sequence;
[0010] The indicators of the criterion layer include stability and reliability of charging facilities, customer service quality, charging station operation capacity, safe operation of charging stations and environmental impact;
[0011] The indicators of the indicator layer include equipment downtime rate, equipment online rate, equipment stable operation rate, average failure rate, average offline rate, service complaint rate, complaint handling rate, user satisfaction, site supporting conditions, average queuing time, hourly charging cost, number of DC charging piles, number of AC charging piles, charging station accessibility, service radius, implementation of marketing activities, annual profit, illegal occupancy rate of charging parking spaces, utilization rate of charging piles, improvement of rules and regulations, safety accidents, safety of charging stations, impact on transportation network and impact on distribution network.
[0012] Optionally, the method for determining the indicator weights of indicators at each level includes:
[0013] The subjective weights of indicators at all levels were determined using the AHP method;
[0014] The objective weights of indicators at all levels are determined using the entropy weight method;
[0015] Based on the subjective weight and the objective weight, the AHP-entropy weight method is used to comprehensively determine the indicator weights of indicators at all levels.
[0016] Optionally, the method for determining the subjective weights of indicators at each level includes:
[0017] Construct a hierarchical model, the hierarchical model includes a criterion layer indicator set and an indicator layer indicator set, the criterion layer indicator set is: A = {A1, A2, ..., A i}; The indicator layer indicator set is: A i ={A i1 ,A i2 ,…,A ij}, where A i represents the ith indicator of the criterion layer, A ij Representation criteria layer A i The corresponding j-th index, where i,j=1,2…n;
[0018] Based on the hierarchical model, construct the judgment matrix X n×n , In the formula, x ij Indicates the importance of the i-th indicator compared to the j-th indicator;
[0019] Based on the judgment matrix X n×n The subjective weights of indicators at all levels are calculated using the sum-product method.
[0020] Optionally, the judgment matrix X n×nThe subjective weights of indicators at all levels are calculated by the sum-product method, which includes the following steps:
[0021] Normalize each column of the judgment matrix. The normalization formula is: Where i, j = 1, 2…n;
[0022] Sum the normalized column vector row by row, the summation formula is Where j = 1, 2…n;
[0023] Will Normalized to Where i = 1, 2…n;
[0024] Get the judgment matrix X n×n The maximum eigenvalue λ max , Where i = 1, 2…n, Q is the eigenvector, Q = (θ1, θ2,…, θ n );
[0025] Calculate the judgment matrix X n×n The consistency index is n×n When there is satisfactory consistency, solve for w i As the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, w i =Q = (θ1,θ2,…,θ i ).
[0026] Optionally, the method for determining the objective weights of indicators at each level includes:
[0027] A numerical matrix is constructed based on the indicators to be calculated. The expression of the numerical matrix is: Among them, y ij is the i-th index value of the j-th charging station to be evaluated;
[0028] Normalize the numerical matrix and use the maximum and minimum method to normalize the numerical matrix Y n×n Perform normalization processing to obtain the standardized matrix R = (r ij ) n×n ,in, or, or,
[0029] The numerical matrix is dimensionless, and we get
[0030] Based on Q j =1-P j Calculate the coefficient of variation, (When Z ij =0 or 1, Z ij ·ln(Z ij)=0);
[0031] Find the objective weight W of indicators at all levels j ,in,
[0032] Optionally, the method for determining the indicator weights of indicators at each level includes:
[0033] The indicator weights of indicators at all levels are calculated using the arithmetic average method. The calculation formula is: Among them, w i As the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, W i It is the objective weight of indicators at all levels.
[0034] Optionally, the method for establishing the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model includes:
[0035] Determine the criterion layer indicator set and the indicator layer indicator set, where the criterion layer indicator set is: A = {A1, A2, ..., A i}; The indicator layer indicator set is: A i ={A i1 ,A i2 ,…,A ij}, where A i represents the ith indicator of the criterion layer, A ij Representation criteria layer A i The corresponding j-th indicator;
[0036] Establish a sample matrix M for evaluating the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations. k is the number of experts in electric vehicle charging station operation and management; M jh represents the evaluation value of the h-th expert on the j-th indicator layer indicator, where h = 1, 2, …, k;
[0037] According to the evaluation level of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect, the evaluation gray category is determined to be e = {e1, e2, e3, e4} = {1, 2, 3, 4}. The specific gray category and whitening weight function are expressed as follows:
[0038] The first gray class is "excellent", e1 = 1, gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0039]
[0040] The second gray class is "good", e2 = 2, gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0041]
[0042] The third gray category is "medium", e3 = 3, gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0043]
[0044] The fourth gray category is "bad", e4 = 4, gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0045]
[0046] The sample matrix data of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation is processed by gray-class white weighting to obtain the index A of the index layer. ij The corresponding grey evaluation coefficient ε ije ,
[0047] Calculate the indicator A of the indicator layer ij The overall grey statistics of
[0048] Calculate membership
[0049] Finally determined by M jh The index membership matrix is R i , where r ij =(r ij1 ,r ij2 ,…,r ije ) represents the grey evaluation weight vector.
[0050] Calculate the grey evaluation matrix G of the index layer = [G1, G1, …, G i ] T , G i =R i ×ω i =(g i1 ,g i2 ,…,g im );ω i is the indicator weight set of the indicator layer, ω i ={ω i1 ,ω i2 ,...,ω ij}, i,j=1,2…n;
[0051] The comprehensive weight vector of the criterion layer is calculated as H = G × V T , V represents the set of operation effect evaluation terms;
[0052] The calculation formula for the operating effect of the charging station to be evaluated is obtained, S oe =ω×H, ω is the weight set of the criterion layer indicators, ω={ω1,ω2,…,ω n}.
[0053] In a second aspect, the present invention provides an operation effect evaluation device applicable to a charging station, comprising:
[0054] An acquisition module is used to acquire a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model, wherein the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model is established based on a preset electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system and index weights of indicators at all levels, using a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method;
[0055] The evaluation module is used to use the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model to comprehensively evaluate the actual operation data of the charging station to be evaluated and determine the operation effect of the charging station.
[0056] In a third aspect, the present invention provides an operation effect evaluation system applicable to a charging station, comprising a storage medium and a processor;
[0057] The storage medium is used to store instructions;
[0058] The processor is configured to operate according to the instructions to execute the method according to any one of the methods in the first aspect.
[0059] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following beneficial effects:
[0060] The present invention proposes an operation effect evaluation method, device and system suitable for charging stations, constructs an operation effect evaluation index system for electric vehicle charging stations from five aspects: stability and reliability of charging facilities, customer service quality, charging station operation capacity, safe operation of charging stations and environmental impact, and establishes an operation effect evaluation model for electric vehicle charging stations based on a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method, uses the AHP-entropy weight method to determine the indicator weights of indicators at all levels, uses the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method to calculate the comprehensive score of the operation effect of the charging station electric vehicle charging station, and then obtains the operation effect evaluation grade of the charging station electric vehicle charging station, which can accurately and comprehensively analyze and evaluate the operation level of the charging station based on historical big data, thereby guiding the operation of the charging station and improving the service level. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0061] In order to make the content of the present invention more clearly understood, the present invention is further described in detail below based on specific embodiments and in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, wherein:
[0062] Figure 1 The present invention is a flowchart of a method for evaluating the operating effect of a charging station according to an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0063] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the present invention more clearly understood, the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are only used to explain the present invention and are not intended to limit the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0064] The application principle of the present invention is described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0065] Example 1
[0066] An embodiment of the present invention provides an operation effect evaluation method applicable to a charging station, comprising the following steps:
[0067] Step (1) obtaining a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model, wherein the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model is established based on a preset electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system and index weights of indicators at all levels, using a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method;
[0068] Step (2) uses a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model to comprehensively evaluate the actual operating data of the charging station to be evaluated to determine the operating effect of the charging station, wherein the actual operating data of the charging station to be evaluated is the charging big data of the electric vehicle charging station.
[0069] like Figure 1 As shown, in the specific implementation process, the evaluation method in the embodiment of the present invention specifically includes the following steps:
[0070] Step 1: Construct an evaluation index system for the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations;
[0071] Step 2: Use the AHP-entropy weight method to determine the weights of indicators at all levels in the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system;
[0072] Step3: Construct grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model;
[0073] Step 4: Combined with the actual operation of the charging station to be evaluated, the grey comprehensive fuzzy evaluation model is used to evaluate the operation effect of the electric vehicle charging station, and a comprehensive evaluation result is obtained to determine the operation effect of the charging station.
[0074] In a specific implementation of the embodiment of the present invention, the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system includes a target layer, a criterion layer and an index layer which are arranged in sequence;
[0075] The indicators of the criterion layer include the stability and reliability of charging facilities (A1), customer service quality (A2), charging station operation capacity (A3), charging station safe operation (A4), and environmental impact (A5); the indicators of the indicator layer include equipment downtime rate (A 11 ), equipment online rate (A12 ), equipment stable operation rate (A 13 ), average failure rate (A 14 ), average offline rate (A 15 ), service complaint rate (A 21 ), complaint handling rate (A 22 ), user satisfaction (A 23 )、Site supporting conditions (A 24 ), average queuing time (A 25 ), hourly charging cost (A 26 ), number of DC charging piles (A 31 ), number of AC charging piles (A 32 ), charging station accessibility (A 33 ), service radius (A 34 ), implementation of marketing activities (A 35 )、Annual profit (A 36 ), illegal occupancy rate of charging parking spaces (A 37 ), charging pile utilization rate (A 38 ) Improvement of rules and regulations (A 39 )、Safety Accidents(A 41 ), charging station safety (A 42 ), impact on transportation network (A 51 ), impact on distribution network (A 52 )wait.
[0076] In the specific implementation process, the construction of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system includes the following steps:
[0077] 1. The stability and reliability level of charging facilities mainly evaluates indicators of equipment operation stability and reliability, including: equipment downtime rate, equipment online rate, equipment stable operation rate, average failure rate, and average offline rate.
[0078] (1) Equipment downtime rate is the ratio of equipment downtime hours to equipment operation hours in the statistical period, which represents the equipment downtime in the period. The calculation formula is:
[0079]
[0080] (2) Equipment online rate is the ratio of equipment online hours to the total hours in operation in a certain period (usually one year), which represents the online operation status of the equipment in the period. The calculation formula is:
[0081]
[0082] (3) The equipment stable operation rate is the ratio of the number of hours during the statistical period other than the equipment downtime due to failure to the total number of hours in operation, which represents the stable operation of the equipment during the period. The calculation formula is:
[0083]
[0084] (4) The average failure rate is the ratio of equipment failure hours to operation hours during the statistical period, which represents the failure status of the equipment during the period. The calculation formula is:
[0085]
[0086] (5) The average offline rate is the ratio of the equipment offline hours to the operating hours during the statistical period, which represents the offline status of the equipment during the period. The calculation formula is:
[0087]
[0088] 2. The customer service quality level mainly evaluates indicators that are directly related to customers and directly affect their service experience, including: service complaint rate, complaint handling rate, user satisfaction, venue supporting conditions, average waiting time, and hourly charging costs.
[0089] (1) The service complaint rate is the ratio of the number of complaint orders to the total number of orders during the statistical period. The calculation formula is:
[0090]
[0091] (2) The complaint handling rate is the ratio of the number of complaint tickets handled during the statistical period to the total number of complaint tickets. The calculation formula is:
[0092]
[0093] (3) User satisfaction refers to the score given by users after the charging service is completed, which is obtained by comprehensive statistics of user scores from the backend.
[0094] (4) Site supporting conditions include the intelligence level of the site, rest and catering facilities, etc. "Excellent" is 90-100 points; "Good" is 80-90 points; "Average" is 70-80 points; "Poor" is 60-70 points or less than 60 points.
[0095] (5) Average queuing time refers to the expected time it takes for a vehicle to charge from the time it arrives at the charging location. The calculation formula is:
[0096]
[0097] Where: T i,line represents the actual queuing time of the i-th vehicle; n represents the total number of service vehicles during the sampling period.
[0098] (6) The hourly charging fee is the ratio of the total amount of charging electricity fees, charging service fees, and charging parking fees generated by all users during the statistical period to the total number of charging hours for all users. The calculation formula is:
[0099]
[0100] 3. The charging station operation capacity level mainly includes indicators related to the operation of charging stations, including: the number of DC charging piles, the number of AC charging piles, the accessibility of charging stations, the service radius, the implementation of marketing activities, annual profits, the illegal occupancy rate of charging parking spaces, the utilization rate of charging piles, and the improvement of rules and regulations.
[0101] (1) The number of DC charging piles refers to the number of DC charging piles connected to the charging station.
[0102] (2) The number of AC charging piles refers to the number of AC charging piles connected to the charging station.
[0103] (3) The accessibility of the charging station reflects the rationality of the location of the charging station and the surrounding traffic conditions. It can be scored by organizing experts to evaluate the accessibility of the charging station. The score is 90-100 points for "excellent", 80-90 points for "good", 70-80 points for "average", and 60-70 points or less than 60 points for "poor".
[0104] (4) The service radius represents the service capacity and coverage level of regional stations and is planned before the construction of charging stations.
[0105] (5) The implementation status of marketing activities includes the number of marketing activities formulated, the implementation status, the economic benefits brought about, etc., which are scored by relevant experts. "Excellent" is 90-100 points; "Good" is 80-90 points; "Average" is 70-80 points; and "Poor" is 60-70 points or less than 60 points.
[0106] (6) Annual profit refers to the annual profit of the charging station, which represents the economic benefits of the charging station operation.
[0107] (7) The illegal occupancy rate of charging parking spaces refers to the situation of motor vehicles illegally occupying charging pile parking spaces during the statistical period. The calculation formula is:
[0108]
[0109] (8) Charging pile utilization rate refers to the ratio of equipment charging hours to the number of hours in operation during the statistical period. The calculation formula is:
[0110]
[0111] (9) The perfection of rules and regulations represents the perfection level of management system: “excellent” is 90-100 points; “good” is 80-90 points; “average” is 70-80 points; and “poor” is 60-70 points or less than 60 points.
[0112] 4. The safe production operation level mainly includes indicators related to the safety of charging station operations, including: safety accidents and charging station safety.
[0113] (1) Safety accidents are a veto item. If an accident occurs, the evaluation level will be considered poor.
[0114] (2) The safety of charging stations includes insulation performance, protection level and safety warning angles, which are obtained by organizing relevant experts to score according to national guidelines, policies, laws and industry standards and regulations.
[0115] 5. The environmental impact level mainly represents the impact of charging station operations on the relevant environment, including: impact on the transportation network and the distribution network.
[0116] (1) Impact on the traffic network refers to the impact of charging station operations on surrounding traffic, including traffic congestion and traffic accidents caused by the gathering of a large number of charging vehicles.
[0117] (2) Impact on the distribution network refers to the degree of influence of the operation of the charging station on the access grid, including the harmonic pollution of the charging station to the grid and the power consumption pressure brought to the grid by the charging peak. It depends on the capacity of the charging station, the performance of the charging pile, the level of power configuration and auxiliary facilities.
[0118] In a specific implementation of the embodiment of the present invention, a method for determining the indicator weights of indicators at each level includes:
[0119] The subjective weights of indicators at all levels were determined using the AHP method;
[0120] The objective weights of indicators at all levels are determined using the entropy weight method;
[0121] Based on the subjective weight and the objective weight, the AHP-entropy weight method is used to comprehensively determine the indicator weights of indicators at all levels.
[0122] The method of using the AHP method to determine the subjective weights of indicators at all levels includes the following steps:
[0123] 1. Build a hierarchical model
[0124] Through the established electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system, the various influencing factors of the specific evaluation object (i.e. the electric vehicle charging station to be evaluated) are divided into levels, and a hierarchical model for the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation is constructed.
[0125] Assume that the criterion layer index set is: A={A1,A2,...,Ai}; The indicator layer indicator set is: A i ={A i1 ,A i2 ,...,A ij}, where A i represents the ith indicator of the criterion layer, A ij Representation criteria layer A i The corresponding j-th indicator.
[0126] 2. Construct the judgment matrix X based on the nine-point scaling method n×n
[0127] On the basis of constructing the hierarchical model, experts in the industry were selected to compare the evaluation indicators pairwise according to the nine-point scaling method to obtain the judgment matrix X n×n :
[0128]
[0129] In the formula, x ij is the importance of the i-th indicator relative to the j-th indicator.
[0130] 3. Calculate the subjective weights of indicators at all levels
[0131] The process of using AHP to find the weight of the operating effect index of electric vehicle charging stations is actually to find the maximum eigenvalue λ in matrix theory. max and eigenvector Q = (θ1, θ2, …, θ n ).
[0132] The weights of indicators at all levels are calculated by the sum-product method:
[0133] (1) Normalized judgment matrix X n×n Each column of
[0134] where i,j=1,2…n
[0135] (2) Sum the normalized column vector row by row
[0136] where j = 1, 2…n
[0137] (3) Normalized to
[0138] Where i=1,2…n
[0139] (4) Finally, we get the judgment matrix X n×n The maximum eigenvalue λ max , Where i = 1, 2…n, Q is the eigenvector, Q = (θ1, θ2,…, θn );
[0140] 4. Judgment matrix X n×n Perform consistency check
[0141] Judgment matrix X n×n Consistency indicators:
[0142]
[0143] Judgment matrix X n×n The random consistency ratio of:
[0144] Where RI is the judgment matrix X n×n The average random consistency index of
[0145] When CR<0.1, the judgment matrix X n×n With satisfactory consistency, the solution w i is the effective weight, i.e. the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, w i =Q = (θ1,θ2,…,θ i ); when CR>0.1, the judgment matrix X n×n Cannot pass the consistency test, then the solution w i For invalid weights, the judgment matrix X n×n Reassessment was performed until CR < 0.1.
[0146] Determining the objective weight using the entropy weight method specifically includes the following steps:
[0147] 1. Construct a numerical matrix
[0148] Construct a numerical matrix Y based on the indicators to be calculated n×n .
[0149]
[0150] Among them, y ij is the i-th indicator value of the j-th charging station to be evaluated.
[0151] 2. Numerical matrix standardization
[0152] Use the maximum and minimum method to log the numerical matrix Y n×n Perform normalization processing to obtain the standardized matrix R = (r ij ) n×n , where r ij ∈[0,1].
[0153] (1) Based on actual business, if the selected indicator is a positive indicator, that is, the larger the indicator value, the better, its standardized formula is:
[0154]
[0155] (2) Based on actual business, if the selected indicator is a reverse indicator, that is, the smaller the indicator value, the better, its standardized formula is:
[0156]
[0157] (3) From the perspective of actual business, if the selected indicator is a moderation indicator, that is, the closer the indicator value is to a certain value, the better, its standardized formula is:
[0158]
[0159] 3. Dimensionless Matrix
[0160]
[0161] 4. Calculate the coefficient of variation
[0162] Find P j :
[0163] (When Z ij =0 or 1, Z ij ·ln(Z ij )=0)
[0164] Calculate the coefficient of variation Q j :
[0165] Q j =1-P j
[0166] 5. Find the objective weight (i.e. entropy weight) W of indicators at all levels j
[0167]
[0168] The method of comprehensively determining the weights by using the AHP-entropy weight method specifically includes the following steps:
[0169] When calculating the comprehensive weight, the arithmetic average method, which is relatively quick and insightful, is used to calculate the weight ratio combination, namely:
[0170]
[0171] Among them, w i As the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, W i is the objective weight of indicators at all levels;
[0172] When i is the subjective weight of the criterion layer indicator, W iis the objective weight of the criterion layer indicator, then the criterion layer indicator weight set is: ω={ω1,ω2,…,ω n};
[0173] When i is the subjective weight of the indicator layer, W i is the objective weight of the indicator layer, then the indicator layer weight set is: i ={ω i1 ,ω i2 ,...,ω in}, (i=1,2,…,n).
[0174] In a specific implementation of the embodiment of the present invention, the construction of the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model includes the following steps:
[0175] Step 3.1: Determine the indicator set
[0176] The electric vehicle charging station operation rating index system is divided into two levels of indicators: the criterion level and the indicator level. Therefore, the indicator set of the criterion level is determined as follows:
[0177] A={A1,A2,…,A n}
[0178] The indicator layer indicator set is:
[0179] A i ={A i1 ,A i2 ,...,A ij}
[0180] Among them, A i represents the ith indicator of the criterion layer, A ij Representation criteria layer A i The corresponding j-th indicator.
[0181] Step 3.2: Determine the comment set
[0182] Combined with the actual business situation of electric vehicle charging station operation, the operation effect evaluation phrase set is determined:
[0183] V={V1,V2,V3,V4}={excellent,good,fair,poor}={90,80,70,60}
[0184] Step 3.3: Establish a sample matrix for evaluating the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations
[0185] An evaluation matrix M for the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations is established. At the same time, k experts in the operation and management of electric vehicle charging stations are invited to evaluate m indicators based on the comment set, and a sample matrix for the evaluation of the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations is obtained:
[0186]
[0187] M jh It represents the evaluation value of the h-th expert on the j-th indicator layer indicator, where h = 1, 2, …, k.
[0188] Step 3.4: Determine the gray category for evaluation
[0189] According to the evaluation level of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect, the evaluation gray category is determined to be e = {e1, e2, e3, e4} = {1, 2, 3, 4}. The specific gray category and whitening weight function are expressed as follows:
[0190] The first gray class is "excellent" (e1=1), gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0191]
[0192] The second gray class is "good" (e2 = 2), gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0193]
[0194] The third gray category is "medium" (e3=3), gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0195]
[0196] The fourth gray class "bad" (e4 = 4), gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0197]
[0198] Step 3.5: Evaluation coefficient and membership matrix
[0199] The sample matrix data of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation is processed by gray-class white weighting to obtain the index A of the index layer. ij The corresponding grey evaluation coefficient ε ije , the evaluation coefficient calculation process is as follows:
[0200]
[0201] Calculate the index A of the evaluation index layer of the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations ij The overall grey statistics of ij Indicates that:
[0202]
[0203] Find the degree of membership:
[0204]
[0205] Finally determined by M jh The index membership matrix is R i , where r ij =(r ij1 ,r ij2 ,...,r ije ) represents the grey evaluation weight vector.
[0206] Step 3.6: Grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation
[0207] 1. Comprehensive evaluation of grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation matrix
[0208] The indicator weight set of the indicator layer is: i ={ω i1 ,ω i2 ,...,ω ij}(i=1,2,…,n)
[0209] G i =R i ×ω i =(g i1 ,g i2 ,…,g im )
[0210] Thus, the grey evaluation matrix of the indicator layer can be obtained:
[0211] G=[G1,G1,...,G i ] T
[0212] The weight set of the criterion layer indicators is: ω={ω1,ω2,…,ω n}
[0213] The comprehensive weight vector of the criterion layer is H = G × V T , V represents the set of operation effect evaluation terms.
[0214] 2. Determine the operating effect of the charging station to be evaluated, that is, build a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model:
[0215] S oe =ω×H.
[0216] The method in the embodiment of the present invention is described in detail below in conjunction with the following specific implementation manner.
[0217] Step 1: Construct an evaluation index system for the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations
[0218] According to the relevant standards and specifications for the operation of electric vehicle charging stations, this implementation case has identified 24 evaluation indicators from five aspects: stability and reliability of charging facilities, customer service quality, charging station operation capacity, safe operation of charging stations, and environmental impact, forming an evaluation index system for the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations. The specific index system is shown in Table 1.
[0219] Table 1
[0220]
[0221]
[0222] Step 2: Use AHP-entropy weight method to determine the indicator weight;
[0223] Step 2.1: Determine the subjective weight using the AHP method;
[0224] Construct the judgment matrix X of the criterion layer:
[0225]
[0226] Construct the judgment matrix X1 of the indicator layer:
[0227]
[0228] Construct the judgment matrix X2 of the indicator layer:
[0229]
[0230] Construct the judgment matrix X3 of the indicator layer:
[0231]
[0232] The judgment matrix X4 X5 contains only two indicators with the same importance, so they are directly weighted [0.5, 0.5];
[0233] According to the AHP related formula, the eigenvalue λ and eigenvector w of each judgment matrix are calculated;
[0234] The eigenvalue λ and eigenvector w of the judgment matrix X of the criterion layer are:
[0235] λ=5.152467, w=[0.3374,0.0586,0.1672,0.3374,0.0993]
[0236] The eigenvalue λ1 and eigenvector w1 of the judgment matrix A1 of the indicator layer:
[0237] λ1=5.4045, w1=[0.3610,0.2917,0.1529,0.1650,0.0294]
[0238] The eigenvalue λ2 and eigenvector w2 of the judgment matrix A2 of the indicator layer:
[0239] λ2=6.349887,w2=[0.2788,0.2029,0.2216,0.1385,0.0884]
[0240] The eigenvalue λ3 and eigenvector w3 of the judgment matrix A3 of the indicator layer are:
[0241] λ3=9.517921
[0242] w3=[0.2831,0.0639,0.0295,0.0263,0.1420,0.1420,0.1420,0.1420,0.0293]
[0243] The judgment matrix is checked for consistency, and its rationality is checked by its random consistency ratio CR:
[0244]
[0245] in, RI is the average random consistency index of the judgment matrix, and its values are shown in Table 2.
[0246]
[0247]
[0248] By calculation, the CR values of the judgment matrices X, X1, X2, and X3 are 0.0340, 0.0903, 0.0564, and 0.0446, respectively, which are all less than 0.1. It can be concluded that the inconsistency of the judgment matrix is within the allowable range and has high rationality. Its eigenvector can be used as the weight vector.
[0249] The subjective weights determined by the hierarchical analysis method are shown in Table 4:
[0250] Table 4 Results of subjective weights of AHP
[0251]
[0252] Step 2.2: Determine the objective weight using the entropy weight method
[0253] Construct a numerical matrix as shown in Table 5:
[0254] Table 5
[0255]
[0256] The numerical matrix is normalized to obtain the normalized matrix, as shown in Table 6:
[0257] Table 6
[0258]
[0259] The numerical matrix is dimensionless, and the matrix is shown in Table 7:
[0260] Table 7
[0261]
[0262] The difference coefficient is calculated and the entropy weight of each indicator is obtained according to the difference coefficient, and the objective weighting result of the entropy weight method is obtained, as shown in Table 8.
[0263] Table 8
[0264]
[0265] Step 2.3: AHP-entropy weight method comprehensively determines the weight
[0266] The AHP-entropy weight method comprehensively determines the weights, as shown in Table 9:
[0267]
[0268]
[0269] Step 3: Constructing grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model
[0270] Step 3.1: Determine the indicator set of the criterion layer and the indicator set of the indicator layer
[0271] Step 3.2: Determine the comment set
[0272] Combined with the actual business situation of electric vehicle charging station operation, the operation effect evaluation phrase set is determined:
[0273] V={V1,V2,V3,V4}={excellent,good,fair,poor}={90,80,70,60}
[0274] Step 3.3: Establish a sample matrix for evaluating the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations
[0275] Taking charging station C as an example for comprehensive evaluation, an evaluation sample matrix is established, as shown in Table 10:
[0276]
[0277]
[0278] Step 3.4: Determine the gray category for evaluation
[0279] Determine the evaluation gray category according to the evaluation level of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect: e = {1, 2, 3, 4}
[0280] Step 3.5: Evaluation coefficient and membership matrix
[0281] Through calculation, the weight matrix of the stability and reliability of charging facilities is obtained
[0282]
[0283] By calculation, we get the weight matrix of customer service quality (A2)
[0284]
[0285] Through calculation, the weight matrix of charging station operation capacity (A3) is obtained
[0286]
[0287] Calculate the weight matrix of the safe operation of the charging station (A4)
[0288]
[0289] Through calculation, we get the weight matrix of environmental impact (A5)
[0290]
[0291] Step 3.6: Grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation
[0292] 1. Comprehensive evaluation of grey evaluation matrix
[0293] The indicator weight set of the criterion layer is:
[0294] ω1={0.3008,0.3018,0.1390,0.1839,0.0744}
[0295] ω2={0.3967,0.0988,0.0889,0.1396,0.0906}
[0296] ω3={0.1715,0.0958,0.0847,0.0511,0.0910,0.2463,0.0898,0.1222,0.0476}
[0297] ω4={0.4860,0.5140}
[0298] ω5={0.5245,0.4755}
[0299] Thus, the grey evaluation matrix of the criterion layer can be obtained:
[0300] G1=(0.3858,0.2694,0.1971,0.1478)
[0301] G2=(0.5860,0.5930,0.4686,0.3525)
[0302] G3=(0.3931,0.2572,0.2028,0.1468)
[0303] G4=(0.5722,0.1974,0.1316,0.0987)
[0304] G5=(0.4071,0.2724,0.1832,0.1374)
[0305] Calculate the comprehensive evaluation matrix:
[0306] H=(78.9310,77.0621,78.9664,82.4320,79.4911)
[0307] 2. Determine the operating effect of the charging station to be evaluated
[0308] The comprehensive evaluation result of the target layer is obtained by multiplying the weight set ω = {0.2579, 0.2284, 0.2343, 0.1931, 0.0862} with the comprehensive evaluation matrix H:
[0309] S oe =ω×H=79.2329
[0310] According to the evaluation results, the comprehensive evaluation score of the operating effect of Charging Station C is 79.2329, and the evaluation level is medium. The evaluation scores of each sub-item are respectively the stability and reliability of charging facilities (78.9310), customer service quality (77.0621), charging station operation capacity (78.9664), charging station safe operation (82.4320), and environmental impact (79.4911). Except for the safe operation which is at "good", the other sub-items are at "medium" level. It can be seen that Charging Station C still has a lot of room for improvement.
[0311] Example 2
[0312] Based on the same inventive concept as that of Embodiment 1, an operating effect evaluation device applicable to a charging station is provided in an embodiment of the present invention, comprising:
[0313] An acquisition module is used to acquire a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model, wherein the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model is established based on a preset electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system and index weights of indicators at all levels, using a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method;
[0314] The evaluation module is used to use the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model to comprehensively evaluate the actual operation data of the charging station to be evaluated and determine the operation effect of the charging station.
[0315] like Figure 1 As shown, in the specific implementation process, the evaluation method in the embodiment of the present invention specifically includes the following steps:
[0316] Step 1: Construct an evaluation index system for the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations;
[0317] Step 2: Use the AHP-entropy weight method to determine the weights of indicators at all levels in the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system;
[0318] Step3: Construct grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model;
[0319] Step 4: Combined with the actual operation of the charging station to be evaluated, the grey comprehensive fuzzy evaluation model is used to evaluate the operation effect of the electric vehicle charging station, and a comprehensive evaluation result is obtained to determine the operation effect of the charging station.
[0320] In a specific implementation of the embodiment of the present invention, the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system includes a target layer, a criterion layer and an index layer which are arranged in sequence;
[0321] The indicators of the criterion layer include the stability and reliability of charging facilities (A1), customer service quality (A2), charging station operation capacity (A3), charging station safe operation (A4), and environmental impact (A5); the indicators of the indicator layer include equipment downtime rate (A 11 ), equipment online rate (A 12 ), equipment stable operation rate (A 13 ), average failure rate (A 14 ), average offline rate (A 15 ), service complaint rate (A 21 ), complaint handling rate (A 22 ), user satisfaction (A 23 )、Site supporting conditions (A 24 ), average queuing time (A 25 ), hourly charging cost (A 26 ), number of DC charging piles (A 31 ), number of AC charging piles (A32 ), charging station accessibility (A 33 ), service radius (A 34 ), implementation of marketing activities (A 35 )、Annual profit (A 36 ), illegal occupancy rate of charging parking spaces (A 37 ), charging pile utilization rate (A 38 ) Improvement of rules and regulations (A 39 )、Safety Accidents(A 41 ), charging station safety (A 42 ), impact on transportation network (A 51 ), impact on distribution network (A 52 )wait.
[0322] In the specific implementation process, the construction of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system includes the following steps:
[0323] 1. The stability and reliability level of charging facilities mainly evaluates indicators of equipment operation stability and reliability, including: equipment downtime rate, equipment online rate, equipment stable operation rate, average failure rate, and average offline rate.
[0324] (1) Equipment downtime rate is the ratio of equipment downtime hours to equipment operation hours in the statistical period, which represents the equipment downtime in the period. The calculation formula is:
[0325]
[0326] (2) Equipment online rate is the ratio of equipment online hours to the total hours in operation in a certain period (usually one year), which represents the online operation status of the equipment in the period. The calculation formula is:
[0327]
[0328] (3) The equipment stable operation rate is the ratio of the number of hours during the statistical period other than the equipment downtime due to failure to the total number of hours in operation, which represents the stable operation of the equipment during the period. The calculation formula is:
[0329]
[0330] (4) The average failure rate is the ratio of equipment failure hours to operation hours during the statistical period, which represents the failure status of the equipment during the period. The calculation formula is:
[0331]
[0332] (5) The average offline rate is the ratio of the equipment offline hours to the operating hours during the statistical period, which represents the offline status of the equipment during the period. The calculation formula is:
[0333]
[0334] 2. The customer service quality level mainly evaluates indicators that are directly related to customers and directly affect their service experience, including: service complaint rate, complaint handling rate, user satisfaction, venue supporting conditions, average waiting time, and hourly charging costs.
[0335] (1) The service complaint rate is the ratio of the number of complaint orders to the total number of orders during the statistical period. The calculation formula is:
[0336]
[0337] (2) The complaint handling rate is the ratio of the number of complaint tickets handled during the statistical period to the total number of complaint tickets. The calculation formula is:
[0338]
[0339] (3) User satisfaction refers to the score given by users after the charging service is completed, which is obtained by comprehensive statistics of user scores from the backend.
[0340] (4) Site supporting conditions include the intelligence level of the site, rest and catering facilities, etc. "Excellent" is 90-100 points; "Good" is 80-90 points; "Average" is 70-80 points; "Poor" is 60-70 points or less than 60 points.
[0341] (5) Average queuing time refers to the expected time it takes for a vehicle to charge from the time it arrives at the charging location. The calculation formula is:
[0342]
[0343] Where: T i,line represents the actual queuing time of the i-th vehicle; n represents the total number of service vehicles during the sampling period.
[0344] (6) The hourly charging fee is the ratio of the total amount of charging electricity fees, charging service fees, and charging parking fees generated by all users during the statistical period to the total number of charging hours for all users. The calculation formula is:
[0345]
[0346] 3. The charging station operation capacity level mainly includes indicators related to the operation of charging stations, including: the number of DC charging piles, the number of AC charging piles, the accessibility of charging stations, the service radius, the implementation of marketing activities, annual profits, the illegal occupancy rate of charging parking spaces, the utilization rate of charging piles, and the improvement of rules and regulations.
[0347] (1) The number of DC charging piles refers to the number of DC charging piles connected to the charging station.
[0348] (2) The number of AC charging piles refers to the number of AC charging piles connected to the charging station.
[0349] (3) The accessibility of the charging station reflects the rationality of the location of the charging station and the surrounding traffic conditions. It can be scored by organizing experts to evaluate the accessibility of the charging station. The score is 90-100 points for "excellent", 80-90 points for "good", 70-80 points for "average", and 60-70 points or less than 60 points for "poor".
[0350] (4) The service radius represents the service capacity and coverage level of regional stations and is planned before the construction of charging stations.
[0351] (5) The implementation status of marketing activities includes the number of marketing activities formulated, the implementation status, the economic benefits brought about, etc., which are scored by relevant experts. "Excellent" is 90-100 points; "Good" is 80-90 points; "Average" is 70-80 points; and "Poor" is 60-70 points or less than 60 points.
[0352] (6) Annual profit refers to the annual profit of the charging station, which represents the economic benefits of the charging station operation.
[0353] (7) The illegal occupancy rate of charging parking spaces refers to the situation of motor vehicles illegally occupying charging pile parking spaces during the statistical period. The calculation formula is:
[0354]
[0355] (8) Charging pile utilization rate refers to the ratio of equipment charging hours to the number of hours in operation during the statistical period. The calculation formula is:
[0356]
[0357] (9) The perfection of rules and regulations represents the perfection level of management system: “excellent” is 90-100 points; “good” is 80-90 points; “average” is 70-80 points; and “poor” is 60-70 points or less than 60 points.
[0358] 4. The safe production operation level mainly includes indicators related to the safety of charging station operations, including: safety accidents and charging station safety.
[0359] (1) Safety accidents are a veto item. If an accident occurs, the evaluation level will be considered poor.
[0360] (2) The safety of charging stations includes insulation performance, protection level and safety warning angles, which are obtained by organizing relevant experts to score according to national guidelines, policies, laws and industry standards and regulations.
[0361] 5. The environmental impact level mainly represents the impact of charging station operations on the relevant environment, including: impact on the transportation network and the distribution network.
[0362] (1) Impact on the traffic network refers to the impact of charging station operations on surrounding traffic, including traffic congestion and traffic accidents caused by the gathering of a large number of charging vehicles.
[0363] (2) Impact on the distribution network refers to the degree of influence of the operation of the charging station on the access grid, including the harmonic pollution of the charging station to the grid and the power consumption pressure brought to the grid by the charging peak. It depends on the capacity of the charging station, the performance of the charging pile, the level of power configuration and auxiliary facilities.
[0364] In a specific implementation of the embodiment of the present invention, a method for determining the indicator weights of indicators at each level includes:
[0365] The subjective weights of indicators at all levels were determined using the AHP method;
[0366] The objective weights of indicators at all levels are determined using the entropy weight method;
[0367] Based on the subjective weight and the objective weight, the AHP-entropy weight method is used to comprehensively determine the indicator weights of indicators at all levels.
[0368] The method of using the AHP method to determine the subjective weights of indicators at all levels includes the following steps:
[0369] 1. Build a hierarchical model
[0370] Through the established electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system, the various influencing factors of the specific evaluation object (i.e. the electric vehicle charging station to be evaluated) are divided into levels, and a hierarchical model for the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation is constructed.
[0371] Assume that the criterion layer index set is: A={A1,A2,...,A i}; The indicator layer indicator set is: A i ={A i1 ,A i2 ,...,A ij}, where A i represents the ith indicator of the criterion layer, A ij Representation criteria layer A i The corresponding j-th indicator.
[0372] 2. Construct the judgment matrix X based on the nine-point scaling method n×n
[0373] On the basis of constructing the hierarchical model, experts in the industry were selected to compare the evaluation indicators pairwise according to the nine-point scaling method to obtain the judgment matrix X n×n :
[0374]
[0375] In the formula, x ij is the importance of the i-th indicator relative to the j-th indicator.
[0376] 3. Calculate the subjective weights of indicators at all levels
[0377] The process of using AHP to find the weight of the operating effect index of electric vehicle charging stations is actually to find the maximum eigenvalue λ in matrix theory. max and eigenvector Q = (θ1, θ2, …, θ n ).
[0378] The weights of indicators at all levels are calculated by the sum-product method:
[0379] (1) Normalized judgment matrix X n×n Each column of
[0380] where i,j=1,2…n
[0381] (2) Sum the normalized column vector row by row
[0382] where j = 1, 2…n
[0383] (3) Normalized to
[0384] Where i=1,2…n
[0385] (4) Finally, we get the judgment matrix X n×n The maximum eigenvalue λ max , Where i = 1, 2…n, Q is the eigenvector, Q = (θ1, θ2,…, θ n );
[0386] 4. Judgment matrix X n×n Perform consistency check
[0387] Judgment matrix X n×n Consistency indicators:
[0388]
[0389] Judgment matrix X n×n The random consistency ratio of:
[0390] Where RI is the judgment matrix X n×n The average random consistency index of
[0391] When CR<0.1, the judgment matrix X n×n With satisfactory consistency, the solution w i is the effective weight, i.e. the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, w i =Q = (θ1,θ2,…,θ i ); when CR>0.1, the judgment matrix X n×n Cannot pass the consistency test, then the solution w i For invalid weights, the judgment matrix X n×n Reassessment was performed until CR < 0.1.
[0392] Determining the objective weight using the entropy weight method specifically includes the following steps:
[0393] 1. Construct a numerical matrix
[0394] Construct a numerical matrix Y based on the indicators to be calculated n×n .
[0395]
[0396] Among them, y ij is the i-th indicator value of the j-th charging station to be evaluated.
[0397] 2. Numerical matrix standardization
[0398] Use the maximum and minimum method to log the numerical matrix Y n×n Perform normalization processing to obtain the standardized matrix R = (r ij ) n×n , where r ij ∈[0,1].
[0399] (1) Based on actual business, if the selected indicator is a positive indicator, that is, the larger the indicator value, the better, its standardized formula is:
[0400]
[0401] (2) Based on actual business, if the selected indicator is a reverse indicator, that is, the smaller the indicator value, the better, its standardized formula is:
[0402]
[0403] (3) From the perspective of actual business, if the selected indicator is a moderation indicator, that is, the closer the indicator value is to a certain value, the better, its standardized formula is:
[0404]
[0405] 3. Dimensionless Matrix
[0406]
[0407] 4. Calculate the coefficient of variation
[0408] Find P j :
[0409] (When Z ij =0 or 1, Z ij ·ln(Z ij )=0)
[0410] Calculate the coefficient of variation Q j :
[0411] Q j =1-P j
[0412] 5. Find the objective weight (i.e. entropy weight) W of indicators at all levels j
[0413]
[0414] The method of comprehensively determining the weights by using the AHP-entropy weight method specifically includes the following steps:
[0415] When calculating the comprehensive weight, the arithmetic average method, which is relatively quick and insightful, is used to calculate the weight ratio combination, namely:
[0416]
[0417] Among them, w i As the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, W i is the objective weight of indicators at all levels;
[0418] When i is the subjective weight of the criterion layer indicator, W i is the objective weight of the criterion layer indicator, then the criterion layer indicator weight set is: ω={ω1,ω2,…,ω n};
[0419] When i is the subjective weight of the indicator layer, W i is the objective weight of the indicator layer, then the indicator layer weight set is: i ={ω i1 ,ω i2 ,...,ω in}(i=1,2,…,n).
[0420] In a specific implementation of the embodiment of the present invention, the construction of the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model includes the following steps:
[0421] Step 3.1: Determine the indicator set
[0422] The electric vehicle charging station operation rating index system is divided into two levels of indicators: the criterion level and the indicator level. Therefore, the indicator set of the criterion level is determined as follows:
[0423] A={A1,A2,…,A n}
[0424] The indicator layer indicator set is:
[0425] A i ={A i1 ,A i2 ,...,A ij}
[0426] Among them, A i represents the ith indicator of the criterion layer, A ij Representation criteria layer A i The corresponding j-th indicator.
[0427] Step 3.2: Determine the comment set
[0428] Combined with the actual business situation of electric vehicle charging station operation, the operation effect evaluation phrase set is determined:
[0429] V={V1,V2,V3,V4}={excellent,good,fair,poor}={90,80,70,60}
[0430] Step 3.3: Establish a sample matrix for evaluating the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations
[0431] An evaluation matrix M for the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations is established. At the same time, k experts in the operation and management of electric vehicle charging stations are invited to evaluate m indicators based on the comment set, and a sample matrix for the evaluation of the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations is obtained:
[0432]
[0433] M jh It represents the evaluation value of the h-th expert on the j-th indicator layer indicator, where h = 1, 2, …, k.
[0434] Step 3.4: Determine the gray category for evaluation
[0435] According to the evaluation level of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect, the evaluation gray category is determined to be e = {e1, e2, e3, e4} = {1, 2, 3, 4}. The specific gray category and whitening weight function are expressed as follows:
[0436] The first gray class is "excellent" (e1=1), gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0437]
[0438] The second gray class is "good" (e2 = 2), gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0439]
[0440] The third gray category is "medium" (e3=3), gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0441]
[0442] The fourth gray class "bad" (e4 = 4), gray number Its whitening function is expressed as:
[0443]
[0444] Step 3.5: Evaluation coefficient and membership matrix
[0445] The sample matrix data of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation is processed by gray-class white weighting to obtain the index A of the index layer. ij The corresponding grey evaluation coefficient ε ije , the evaluation coefficient calculation process is as follows:
[0446]
[0447] Calculate the index A of the evaluation index layer of the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations ij The overall grey statistics of ij Indicates that:
[0448]
[0449] Find the degree of membership:
[0450]
[0451] Finally determined by M jh The index membership matrix is R i , where r ij =(r ij1 ,r ij2 ,...,r ije ) represents the grey evaluation weight vector.
[0452] Step 3.6: Grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation
[0453] 1. Comprehensive evaluation of grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation matrix
[0454] The indicator weight set of the indicator layer is: i ={ω i1 ,ω i2 ,…,ω ij}(i=1,2,…,n)
[0455] G i =R i ×ω i =(g i1 ,g i2 ,…,g im )
[0456] Thus, the grey evaluation matrix of the indicator layer can be obtained:
[0457] G=[G1,G1,…,G i ] T
[0458] The weight set of the criterion layer indicators is: ω={ω1,ω2,…,ω n}
[0459] The comprehensive weight vector of the criterion layer is H = G × V T , V represents the set of operation effect evaluation terms.
[0460] 2. Determine the operating effect of the charging station to be evaluated, that is, build a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model:
[0461] S oe =ω×H.
[0462] Example 3
[0463] Based on the same inventive concept as in Example 1, an embodiment of the present invention provides an operation effect evaluation system applicable to a charging station, including a storage medium and a processor;
[0464] The storage medium is used to store instructions;
[0465] The processor is used to operate according to the instructions to execute the method according to any one of the methods described in embodiment 1.
[0466] Those skilled in the art will appreciate that the embodiments of the present application may be provided as methods, systems, or computer program products. Therefore, the present application may adopt the form of a complete hardware embodiment, a complete software embodiment, or an embodiment in combination with software and hardware. Moreover, the present application may adopt the form of a computer program product implemented in one or more computer-usable storage media (including but not limited to disk storage, CD-ROM, optical storage, etc.) that include computer-usable program code.
[0467] The present application is described with reference to the flowcharts and / or block diagrams of the methods, devices (systems), and computer program products according to the embodiments of the present application. It should be understood that each process and / or box in the flowchart and / or block diagram, as well as the combination of the processes and / or boxes in the flowchart and / or block diagram, can be implemented by computer program instructions. These computer program instructions can be provided to a processor of a general-purpose computer, a special-purpose computer, an embedded processor, or other programmable data processing device to generate a machine, so that the instructions executed by the processor of the computer or other programmable data processing device generate instructions for implementing the processes in the flowchart and / or block diagram. Figure 1 A process or multiple processes and / or boxes Figure 1 A device that provides the functions specified in a block or multiple blocks.
[0468] These computer program instructions may also be stored in a computer-readable memory capable of directing a computer or other programmable data processing device to operate in a specific manner, so that the instructions stored in the computer-readable memory produce an article of manufacture comprising an instruction device, which implements the process Figure 1 A process or multiple processes and / or boxes Figure 1 A function specified in one or more boxes.
[0469] These computer program instructions can also be loaded onto a computer or other programmable data processing device so that a series of operating steps are executed on the computer or other programmable device to produce a computer-implemented process, thereby providing instructions for implementing the process. Figure 1 A process or multiple processes and / or boxes Figure 1 The steps for the functions specified in one or more boxes.
[0470] The embodiments of the present invention are described above in conjunction with the accompanying drawings, but the present invention is not limited to the above-mentioned specific implementation methods. The above-mentioned specific implementation methods are merely illustrative and not restrictive. Under the enlightenment of the present invention, ordinary technicians in this field can also make many forms without departing from the scope of protection of the purpose of the present invention and the claims, which all fall within the protection of the present invention.
[0471] The above shows and describes the basic principles and main features of the present invention and the advantages of the present invention. It should be understood by those skilled in the art that the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments. The above embodiments and descriptions are only for explaining the principles of the present invention. Without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention, the present invention may have various changes and improvements, which fall within the scope of the present invention to be protected. The scope of protection of the present invention is defined by the attached claims and their equivalents.
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the operation effect of a charging station, characterized in that: include: Obtaining a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model, wherein the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model is established based on a preset electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system and index weights of indicators at all levels, using a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method; The grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model is used to comprehensively evaluate the actual operation data of the charging station to be evaluated and determine the operation effect of the charging station; The electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system includes a target layer, a criterion layer and an indicator layer which are arranged in sequence; the indicators of the criterion layer include the stability and reliability of charging facilities, customer service quality, charging station operation capacity, charging station safe operation and environmental impact; The indicators of the indicator layer include equipment downtime rate, equipment online rate, equipment stable operation rate, average failure rate, average offline rate, service complaint rate, complaint handling rate, user satisfaction, site supporting conditions, average queuing time, hourly charging cost, number of DC charging piles, number of AC charging piles, charging station accessibility, service radius, implementation of marketing activities, annual profit, illegal occupation rate of charging parking spaces, utilization rate of charging piles, improvement of rules and regulations, safety accidents, safety of charging stations, impact on transportation network and impact on distribution network; The methods for determining the indicator weights of indicators at all levels include: The subjective weights of indicators at all levels were determined using the AHP method; The objective weights of indicators at all levels are determined using the entropy weight method; Based on the subjective weight and objective weight, the AHP-entropy weight method is used to comprehensively determine the indicator weights of each level of indicators; The methods for determining the subjective weights of indicators at all levels include: Construct a hierarchical model, the hierarchical model includes a criterion layer indicator set and an indicator layer indicator set, the criterion layer indicator set is: A = {A1, A2, ..., A i }; The indicator layer indicator set is: A i ={A i1 ,A i2 ,...,A ij }, where A i represents the ith indicator of the criterion layer, A ij Representation criteria layer A i The corresponding j-th index, where i,j=1,2…n; Based on the hierarchical model, construct the judgment matrix X n×n , In the formula, x ij Indicates the importance of the i-th indicator compared to the j-th indicator; Based on the judgment matrix X n×n The subjective weights of indicators at all levels are calculated by the sum-product method; Based on the judgment matrix X n×n The subjective weights of indicators at all levels are calculated by the sum-product method, which specifically includes the following steps: Normalize each column of the judgment matrix. The normalization formula is: Where i,j=1,2…n; Sum the normalized column vector row by row, the summation formula is Where j = 1, 2…n; Will Normalized to Where i = 1, 2…n; Get the judgment matrix X n×n The maximum eigenvalue λ max , Where i = 1, 2…n, Q is the eigenvector, Q = (θ1, θ2,…, θ n ); Calculate the judgment matrix X n×n The consistency index is n×n When there is satisfactory consistency, solve for w i As the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, w i =Q = (θ1,θ2,…,θ i ); The methods for determining the objective weights of indicators at all levels include: A numerical matrix is constructed based on the indicators to be calculated. The expression of the numerical matrix is: Among them, y ij is the i-th indicator value of the j-th charging station to be evaluated; the numerical matrix is standardized, and the maximum and minimum method is used to normalize the numerical matrix Y n×n Perform normalization processing to obtain the standardized matrix R = (r ij ) n×n ,in, or, or, The numerical matrix is dimensionless, and we get Based on Q j =1-P j Calculate the coefficient of variation, (When Z ij =0 or 1, Z ij ·ln(Z ij )=0); Find the objective weight W of indicators at all levels j ,in, The methods for determining the indicator weights of indicators at all levels include: The indicator weights of indicators at all levels are calculated using the arithmetic average method. The calculation formula is: Among them, w i As the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, W i It is the objective weight of indicators at all levels.
2. The method for evaluating the operating effect of a charging station according to claim 1, characterized in that: The method for establishing the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model includes: Determine the criterion layer indicator set and the indicator layer indicator set, where the criterion layer indicator set is: A = {A1, A2, ..., A i }; The indicator layer indicator set is: A i ={A i1 ,A i2 ,...,A ij }, where A i represents the ith indicator of the criterion layer, A ij Representation criteria layer A i The corresponding j-th indicator; Establish a sample matrix M for evaluating the operation effect of electric vehicle charging stations. k is the number of experts in electric vehicle charging station operation and management; M jh represents the evaluation value of the h-th expert on the j-th indicator layer indicator, where h = 1, 2, …, k; According to the evaluation level of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect, the evaluation gray category is determined to be e = {e1, e2, e3, e4} = {1, 2, 3, 4}. The specific gray category and whitening weight function are expressed as follows: The first gray class is "excellent", e1 = 1, gray number Its whitening function is expressed as: The second gray class is "good", e2 = 2, gray number Its whitening function is expressed as: The third gray category is "medium", e3 = 3, gray number Its whitening function is expressed as: The fourth gray category "poor", e4 = 4, gray number Its whitening function is expressed as: The sample matrix data of the electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation is processed by gray-class white weighting to obtain the index A of the index layer. ij The corresponding grey evaluation coefficient ε ije , Calculate the indicator A of the indicator layer ij The overall grey statistics of Calculate membership Finally determined by M jh The index membership matrix is R i , where r ij =(r ij1 ,r ij2 ,…,r ije ) represents the grey evaluation weight vector; Calculate the grey evaluation matrix G of the index layer = [G1, G1, ..., G i ] T , G i =R i ×ω i =(g i1 ,g i2 ,…,g im );ω i is the indicator weight set of the indicator layer, ω i ={ω i1 ,ω i2 ,...,ω ij }, i,j=1,2…n; The comprehensive weight vector of the criterion layer is calculated as H = G × V T , V represents the set of operation effect evaluation terms; The calculation formula for the operating effect of the charging station to be evaluated is obtained, S oe =ω×H, ω is the weight set of the criterion layer indicators, ω={ω1,ω2,…,ω n }。 3. An operating effect evaluation device suitable for a charging station, characterized in that: include: An acquisition module is used to acquire a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model, wherein the grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model is established based on a preset electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system and index weights of indicators at all levels, using a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation method; An evaluation module is used to use a grey fuzzy comprehensive evaluation model to comprehensively evaluate the actual operation data of the charging station to be evaluated and determine the operation effect of the charging station; The electric vehicle charging station operation effect evaluation index system includes a target layer, a criterion layer and an indicator layer which are arranged in sequence; the indicators of the criterion layer include the stability and reliability of charging facilities, customer service quality, charging station operation capacity, charging station safe operation and environmental impact; The indicators of the indicator layer include equipment downtime rate, equipment online rate, equipment stable operation rate, average failure rate, average offline rate, service complaint rate, complaint handling rate, user satisfaction, site supporting conditions, average queuing time, hourly charging cost, number of DC charging piles, number of AC charging piles, charging station accessibility, service radius, implementation of marketing activities, annual profit, illegal occupation rate of charging parking spaces, utilization rate of charging piles, improvement of rules and regulations, safety accidents, safety of charging stations, impact on transportation network and impact on distribution network; The methods for determining the indicator weights of indicators at all levels include: The subjective weights of indicators at all levels were determined using the AHP method; The objective weights of indicators at all levels are determined using the entropy weight method; Based on the subjective weight and objective weight, the AHP-entropy weight method is used to comprehensively determine the indicator weights of each level of indicators; The methods for determining the subjective weights of indicators at all levels include: Construct a hierarchical model, the hierarchical model includes a criterion layer indicator set and an indicator layer indicator set, the criterion layer indicator set is: A = {A1, A2, ..., A i }; The indicator layer indicator set is: A i ={A i1 ,A i2 ,...,A ij }, where A i represents the ith indicator of the criterion layer, A ij Representation criteria layer A i The corresponding j-th index, where i,j=1,2…n; Based on the hierarchical model, construct the judgment matrix X n×n , In the formula, x ij Indicates the importance of the i-th indicator compared to the j-th indicator; Based on the judgment matrix X n×n The subjective weights of indicators at all levels are calculated by the sum-product method; Based on the judgment matrix X n×n The subjective weights of indicators at all levels are calculated by the sum-product method, which specifically includes the following steps: Normalize each column of the judgment matrix. The normalization formula is: Where i, j = 1, 2…n;… Sum the normalized column vector row by row, the summation formula is Where j = 1, 2…n;… Will Normalized to Where i = 1, 2…n;… Get the judgment matrix X n×n The maximum eigenvalue λ max , Where i = 1, 2…n, Q is the eigenvector, Q = (θ1, θ2,…, θ n ); Calculate the judgment matrix X n×n The consistency index is n×n When there is satisfactory consistency, solve for w i As the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, w i =Q = (θ1,θ2,…,θ i ); The methods for determining the objective weights of indicators at all levels include: A numerical matrix is constructed based on the indicators to be calculated. The expression of the numerical matrix is: Among them, y ij is the i-th indicator value of the j-th charging station to be evaluated; the numerical matrix is standardized, and the maximum and minimum method is used to normalize the numerical matrix Y n×n Perform normalization processing to obtain the standardized matrix R = (r ij ) n×n ,in, or, or, The numerical matrix is dimensionless, and we get Based on Q j =1-P j Calculate the coefficient of variation, (When Z ij =0 or 1, Z ij ·ln(Z ij )=0); Find the objective weight W of indicators at all levels j ,in, The methods for determining the indicator weights of indicators at all levels include: The indicator weights of indicators at all levels are calculated using the arithmetic average method. The calculation formula is: Among them, w i As the subjective weight of indicators at all levels, W i It is the objective weight of indicators at all levels.
4. An operating effect evaluation system applicable to a charging station, characterized in that: including storage media and processors; The storage medium is used to store instructions; The processor is configured to operate according to the instructions to execute the method according to any one of claims 1 to 2.
