Evaluation method for the comprehensive performance of rubber compounds

Through the comprehensive performance evaluation method of rubber materials, the correlation equation is established and the weight coefficient is assigned by using normalization method and Pearson variable correlation analysis, which solves the problem of taking into account both rolling resistance, slippery and wear performance in the existing technology, and improves the problem of Accuracy and comprehensiveness of evaluation.

CN115267148BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-05SHUANGXING GRP CO LTD QINGDAO
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202210883047.1
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-07-26
Publication Date
2024-11-05
Estimated Expiration
2042-07-26

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The prior art cannot accurately take into account the rolling resistance, slippery and wear properties of tires. The single-value rolling resistance method has poor accuracy and cannot optimize the three performances at the same time.

Method used

The comprehensive performance evaluation method of rubber materials is adopted, through the selection and classification of rubber materials, and the establishment of weight coefficients of comprehensive indexes is established and the evaluation of comprehensive index weight coefficients. The correlation equation is established by normalization and Pearson variable correlation analysis, and the weight coefficients are assigned to evaluate rubber materials. Comprehensive performance of materials.

Benefits of technology

It improves the accuracy of the performance evaluation of the rubber material, can take into account both rolling resistance, slippery and wear performance, provides a more comprehensive performance evaluation, and solves the defect that traditional methods cannot take into account both three performances.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure RE-GDA0003833583100000061
    Figure RE-GDA0003833583100000061
  • Figure RE-GDA0003833583100000071
    Figure RE-GDA0003833583100000071
  • Figure RE-GDA0003833583100000081
    Figure RE-GDA0003833583100000081
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention proposes a method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of rubber materials, which belongs to the field of tire performance evaluation and can solve the technical problems that the traditional method of using a single value to characterize rolling resistance has poor accuracy and cannot take into account rolling resistance, wet and slippery and wear performance. The evaluation method includes: (1) rubber material selection and classification: different types of rubber materials are prepared and classified according to different performance requirements; (2) correlation equation establishment: various indicators related to a single performance are clarified, and a correlation equation is obtained by using normalization method and Pearson variable correlation analysis; (3) comprehensive indicator weight coefficient evaluation: according to the strong, weak or unrelated relationship between each indicator and a single performance, it is determined whether a weight coefficient is assigned to obtain the final correlation equation, and the result calculated by the correlation equation is compared with the preset target to evaluate the comprehensive performance of the rubber material. The present invention can be applied to the evaluation of tire rubber material performance.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention belongs to the field of tire performance evaluation, and in particular relates to a method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of a rubber material. Background Art

[0002] New energy vehicles not only bring convenience to people's travel, but also greatly reduce energy consumption and atmospheric pollution. Compared with traditional fuel vehicles, new energy vehicles no longer rely solely on the power output of the internal combustion engine as the power source of the vehicle, but mainly rely on the output of the electric motor or completely replace the output of the internal combustion engine as the power source. Therefore, the tire is required to take into account rolling resistance, anti-skid performance and wear. At present, the conventional performance test method is to test the three performances separately, and then choose them according to the needs of tire performance, but it is difficult to take into account the three performances and find the connection between different performances.

[0003] Chinese patent application CN114409980A discloses a wear-resistant and low rolling resistance rubber composition, wherein the rubber composition is microscopically phase-separated into two phases in the rubber material, which is manifested as a temperature scanning curve of the hysteresis factor tanδ having two peaks after the rubber composition is vulcanized, and the temperature corresponding to the lower peak is recorded as T 1 The temperature corresponding to the peak temperature is recorded as T 2 ; The T 1 With T 2 The relationship must satisfy 10℃<T 2 -T 1 <20℃, and T 1 and T 2 The peak point separation is not very obvious, and its wear resistance is improved without changing the tire rolling resistance.

[0004] Although the patent has improved the wear resistance and rolling resistance, its rolling resistance is characterized by the loss factor (tanδ value) at 60°C. This method does not take into account the effect of hardness on rolling resistance, which may cause deviations in rolling resistance performance. In addition, the patent distinguishes performance based on the temperature of the hysteresis factor tanδ, does not study the wet and slip performance, and does not establish the relationship between the various performances. It can be seen that the above method of using a single value to characterize rolling resistance has the defects of poor accuracy and inability to take into account rolling resistance, wet and slip and wear performance.

[0005] Therefore, how to develop a method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of rubber with high accuracy and taking into account rolling resistance, wet skid and wear performance is an urgent problem to be solved by those skilled in the art. Summary of the invention

[0006] In view of the technical problems that the traditional method of using a single value to characterize rolling resistance has poor accuracy and cannot take into account rolling resistance, wet-slip and wear performance, the present invention proposes a comprehensive performance evaluation method for rubber materials with high accuracy and the ability to take into account rolling resistance, wet-slip and wear performance.

[0007] In order to achieve the above object, the technical solution adopted by the present invention is:

[0008] The method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of rubber compound is used to evaluate the performance of tire tread rubber compound, comprising the following steps:

[0009] Rubber material selection and classification: According to different performance requirements, several different types of rubber materials are prepared and divided into reference rubber materials and rubber materials to be evaluated;

[0010] Establishment of correlation equation: After clarifying the indicators related to a single performance, the correlation equation between the indicators under a single performance item is obtained by using the normalization method and Pearson variable correlation analysis;

[0011] Evaluation of comprehensive index weight coefficient: Determine whether to assign a weight coefficient based on the strong, weak or unrelated relationship between each index and individual performance, and obtain the final correlation equation. After comparing the results calculated using this equation with the preset target, evaluate the comprehensive performance of the rubber compound.

[0012] In one embodiment, the step of establishing the correlation equation is specifically as follows:

[0013] After clarifying the indicators related to a single performance, the performance correlation coefficient is recorded as A and the indicators related to it are recorded as a using the normalization method and Pearson variable correlation analysis. 1 、a 2 、a n According to the correlation between the indicators, the correlation equation between the indicators under a single performance item is obtained; the principle of establishing the correlation equation is:

[0014] When there is a strong positive correlation between the indicators, each indicator in the correlation equation is represented by a multiplication sign;

[0015] When there is a strong negative correlation between the indicators, the indicators in the correlation equation are expressed as inverses;

[0016] When the indicators are uncorrelated or weakly correlated, each indicator in the correlation equation is represented by a plus sign.

[0017] In one embodiment, when the indicators are correlated, a higher correlation coefficient indicates a higher correlation, and when the indicators are uncorrelated, a lower correlation coefficient indicates a higher correlation.

[0018] In one embodiment, the correlation coefficient for the strong positive correlation and the strong negative correlation is ≥ 0.9, and the correlation coefficient for no correlation or weak correlation is ≤ 0.3.

[0019] In one implementation, the comprehensive index weight coefficient evaluation step is specifically as follows:

[0020] When all indicators under a single performance item are unrelated or weakly correlated, the correlation equation is A = a 1 +a 2 +a n Indicates that, giving the equation a weight coefficient, we get b 1 =a 1 / A,b 2 =a 2 / A,b n =a n / A, b 1 , b 2 、b n Compared with the preset target, the smaller the difference, the more the rubber performance meets the requirements;

[0021] When all indicators under a single performance item are strongly correlated, the correlation equation is A = a 1 ·a 2 ·a n It means that without assigning a weight coefficient, the larger the A value is, the more the rubber performance meets the requirements.

[0022] In one embodiment, the comprehensive index weight coefficient evaluation step further includes:

[0023] When all indicators under a single performance item are both unrelated and strongly correlated, first integrate the strongly correlated indicators into one indicator and use C 12 =a 1 ·a 2 Indicates that, according to the irrelevant or weakly correlated situations, the weight coefficient is assigned. n C n , D n Represents the weight coefficient assigned to it, and obtains D 12 =C 12 / (C 12 +C n ),D n =C n / (C 12 +C n ), D 12 , D n Compared with the preset target, the smaller the difference, the more the rubber performance meets the requirements.

[0024] In one embodiment, the reference rubber compound can be selected from any one of several different types of rubber compounds, so as to achieve parameter index normalization and eliminate systematic errors in the rubber compound formula.

[0025] In one embodiment, the comprehensive performance includes anti-skid performance, wear resistance and rolling resistance performance.

[0026] Compared with the prior art, the advantages and positive effects of the present invention are:

[0027] 1. The method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of rubber materials proposed in the present invention first classifies different types of rubber materials, and then uses the normalization method and Pearson bivariate correlation to analyze the correlation between various indicators under different performance items, thereby establishing a correlation equation, and then determines whether to assign a weight coefficient according to the strong, weak or uncorrelated relationship between each indicator and a single performance, and obtains a comprehensive indicator weight coefficient evaluation equation. Finally, the result calculated by the comprehensive indicator weight coefficient evaluation equation is compared with the preset target to evaluate the comprehensive performance of the rubber materials;

[0028] 2. The comprehensive performance evaluation method of the rubber compound proposed in the present invention can not only solve the poor accuracy of using a single value to characterize rolling resistance, but also take into account rolling resistance, wet skid and wear performance at the same time, which is of great significance in evaluating the performance optimization and selection of new energy tires. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0029] The technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention are described clearly and completely below. Obviously, the described embodiments are only part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of them. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.

[0030] The embodiment of the present invention provides a method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of a rubber material, which is used to evaluate the performance of a tire tread rubber material, and comprises the following steps:

[0031] S1. Rubber material selection and classification: According to different performance requirements, several different types of rubber materials are prepared and divided into reference rubber materials and rubber materials to be evaluated;

[0032] In the above step S1, there is no limitation on the number of different types of rubber materials, and those skilled in the art can select them according to actual needs. In addition, regarding the selection criteria of the reference rubber material: the reference rubber material can be selected from any one of several different types of rubber materials, and its role is only as a reference. By comparing with it, the parameter index is normalized and the systematic error in the formula is eliminated. Considering the cost problem in actual production, the present invention uses the rubber material with the lowest cost as the reference rubber material. If the cost problem is not considered, the reference rubber material can be selected arbitrarily.

[0033] S2. Establishment of correlation equation: After clarifying the various indicators related to a single performance, the normalization method and Pearson variable correlation analysis are used to obtain the correlation equation between the indicators under a single performance item.

[0034] In the above-mentioned step S2, the present invention adopts the normalization method because: this method can eliminate the external errors of each indicator and minimize the influencing factors of the indicator after normalization; and Pearson variable correlation analysis is a common method for analyzing the linear relationship between two groups of variables. Through this analysis method, the correlation equation can be quickly constructed with high accuracy.

[0035] S3. Evaluation of comprehensive index weight coefficients: Determine whether to assign a weight coefficient based on the strong, weak or unrelated relationship between each index and individual performance, and obtain the final correlation equation. After comparing the results calculated using this equation with the preset target, evaluate the comprehensive performance of the rubber compound.

[0036] In a specific implementation, the step of establishing the correlation equation is specifically as follows:

[0037] After clarifying the indicators related to a single performance, the performance correlation coefficient is recorded as A and the indicators related to it are recorded as a using the normalization method and Pearson variable correlation analysis. 1 、a 2 、a n According to the correlation between the indicators, the correlation equation between the indicators under a single performance item is obtained; the principle of establishing the correlation equation is:

[0038] When there is a strong positive correlation between the indicators, each indicator in the correlation equation is represented by a multiplication sign;

[0039] When there is a strong negative correlation between the indicators, the indicators in the correlation equation are expressed as inverses;

[0040] When the indicators are uncorrelated or weakly correlated, each indicator in the correlation equation is represented by a plus sign.

[0041] In a specific embodiment, when the indicators are correlated, a higher correlation coefficient indicates a higher correlation, and when the indicators are uncorrelated, a lower correlation coefficient indicates a higher correlation.

[0042] In a specific embodiment, the correlation coefficient for the strong positive correlation and the strong negative correlation is ≥ 0.9, and the correlation coefficient for no correlation or weak correlation is ≤ 0.3.

[0043] In a specific implementation, the comprehensive index weight coefficient evaluation step is specifically as follows:

[0044] When all indicators under a single performance item are unrelated or weakly correlated, the correlation equation is A = a1 +a 2 +a n Indicates that, giving the equation a weight coefficient, we get b 1 =a 1 / A,b 2 =a 2 / A,b n =a n / A, b 1 , b 2 、b n Compared with the preset target, the smaller the difference, the more the rubber performance meets the requirements;

[0045] When all indicators under a single performance item are strongly correlated, the correlation equation is A = a 1 ·a 2 ·a n It means that without assigning a weight coefficient, the larger the A value is, the more the rubber performance meets the requirements.

[0046] In a specific implementation, the comprehensive index weight coefficient evaluation step further includes:

[0047] When all indicators under a single performance item are both unrelated and strongly correlated, first integrate the strongly correlated indicators into one indicator and use C 12 =a 1 ·a 2 Indicates that, according to the irrelevant or weakly correlated situations, the weight coefficient is assigned. n C n , D n Represents the weight coefficient assigned to it, and obtains D 12 =C 12 / (C 12 +C n ),D n =C n / (C 12 +C n ), D 12 , D n Compared with the preset target, the smaller the difference, the more the rubber performance meets the requirements.

[0048] In a specific embodiment, the comprehensive performance includes but is not limited to anti-skid performance, wear resistance and rolling resistance performance.

[0049] In order to more clearly and in detail introduce the evaluation method of the comprehensive performance of the rubber material provided in the embodiment of the present invention, it will be described below in conjunction with specific embodiments.

[0050] Example 1

[0051] This embodiment provides a method for preparing a common tire rubber compound, which is as follows:

[0052] (1) One-stage mixing: the rotor speed is 60 rpm, the upper plug pressure is 6.0 MPa, and the following order is added: raw rubber system, reinforcing system (carbon black or white carbon black and silane coupling agent), the temperature is controlled at 85°C, mixing for 30 seconds, raising the plug, staying for 3 seconds, mixing for 60 seconds, and obtaining a masterbatch. The prepared masterbatch is placed in the air to naturally cool to room temperature and parked for 8 hours;

[0053] Among them, the mixing process parameters are: mixing time 210s, debonding temperature 153℃;

[0054] (2) Second stage mixing: Add the first stage masterbatch, stearic acid, zinc oxide, antioxidant, resin mixture and softener into an internal mixer and mix for 30 seconds, then raise the bolt, hold for 3 seconds, mix for 60 seconds to obtain the second stage masterbatch, and place the prepared second stage masterbatch in the air to naturally cool to room temperature and leave for 8 hours;

[0055] (3) Final mixing: The rotor speed is 45 rpm, the upper bolt pressure is 5 MPa, the second-stage masterbatch, sulfur and accelerator are added to the internal mixer, mixed for 80 seconds, the bolt is raised, the bolt is pressed, mixed for 40 seconds, the bolt is raised, the bolt is pressed, and the mixing is performed until the rubber is discharged at 115° C. A 2 mm thick rubber sheet is obtained by an open mixer, and it is left for 4 hours. After passing through a flat vulcanizer, 5 common tread rubbers are finally prepared. The performance of these 5 rubber materials is also tested in this embodiment. The specific test methods and test results are as follows:

[0056] Test method: Rubber hardness test is carried out in accordance with GB / T531.1; rubber tensile performance is carried out in accordance with GB / T528; rubber tear performance is carried out in accordance with GB / T529; Akron abrasion is carried out in accordance with GB / T1689; DIN abrasion is carried out in accordance with GB / T9867; DMA is carried out in accordance with GB / T9870.1, and compression heat generation is carried out in accordance with GBT1687.3.

[0057] Table 1 Rubber performance test results

[0058]

[0059] After various performance tests on the above five types of tread rubbers, it was found that these five types of rubbers all meet the normal rubber production process in terms of Mooney viscosity, hardness, density and vulcanization process time, and the obtained rubbers can be industrially produced.

[0060] Example 2

[0061] This embodiment provides a method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of a rubber compound. The data used in the evaluation method are the test data of the five tread rubber properties measured in Embodiment 1 (see Table 1), specifically:

[0062] (1) The performance test data shown in Table 1 were normalized and analyzed, and the obtained data are shown in Table 2, where the normalization method is as follows:

[0063] Normalization method: anti-skid index a 1 The value is the ratio of the value of DMA (tan delta, 0℃) of 2-5# rubber compound divided by the value of DMA (tan delta, 0℃) of 1# reference rubber compound. 1 No unit; similarly, DMA rolling resistance index a 2-1 It is the reciprocal of the ratio of the value of 2-5# rubber in DMA (tan delta, 60℃) divided by the value of 1# DMA (tan delta, 60℃); hardness index a 2-2 It is the ratio of the hardness of 2-5# rubber divided by the hardness of 1# rubber; rolling resistance index a 2 is the DMA rolling resistance index a 2-1 and hardness index a 2-2 The product of wear resistance index (DIN) a 3-1 It is the ratio of the DIN abrasion index of 2-5# rubber divided by the DIN abrasion index of 1# rubber to the hardness of the rubber; wear resistance index (Akron) a 3-2 It is the reciprocal of the ratio of the Akron abrasion value of 2-5# rubber divided by the Akron abrasion value of 1# rubber.

[0064] Table 2 Normalization results of rubber indexes

[0065]

[0066] After normalizing various rubber materials, correlation analysis was performed on the values ​​of various indicators. The correlation coefficients were compared by using the function CORREL to compare the arrays. The specific correlation coefficients are shown in Table 3, the data correlation analysis matrix.

[0067] Table 3 Data correlation analysis matrix

[0068] index <![CDATA[a 1 ]]> <![CDATA[a 2-1 ]]> <![CDATA[a 2-2 ]]> <![CDATA[a 2 ]]> <![CDATA[a 3-1 ]]> <![CDATA[a 3-2 ]]> <![CDATA[a 1 ]]> 1.000 -0.977 -0.969 -0.982 0.086 0.131 <![CDATA[a 2-1 ]]> -0.977 1.000 0.946 0.998 -0.200 -0.341 <![CDATA[a 2-2 ]]> -0.969 0.946 1.000 0.964 -0.288 -0.137 <![CDATA[a 2 ]]> -0.982 0.998 0.964 1.000 -0.226 -0.310 <![CDATA[a 3-1 ]]> 0.086 -0.200 -0.288 -0.226 1.000 0.589 <![CDATA[a 3-2 ]]> 0.131 -0.341 -0.137 -0.310 0.589 1.000

[0069] From the data shown in Table 3, it can be seen that a 2-1 、a 2-2 、a 2 with a 1 The relationship between the two is negatively correlated, with correlation coefficients of 0.977, 0.969 and 0.982 respectively. 2 with a 1 According to the establishment principle of the correlation equation and the calculation principle of the comprehensive performance evaluation formula, the relationship between the two should be C 12 =a1 / a 2 .

[0070] The wear index can be expressed by DIN wear and hardness, or by Akron wear, hardness and rebound. In this embodiment, DIN wear and hardness are used as an example to characterize the wear index:

[0071] Wear index C 3122 The value of is a 3-1 and a 2-2 Numerical product, exponent C 3122 No units. Calculate C 3122 and C 12 The correlation coefficient between them shows that there is no correlation between them, and the value is 0.009. If there is no correlation between them, the weight coefficient can be used for judgment. 3122 The weight coefficient is used to determine, where D 3122 =C 3122 / (C 3122 +C 12 ). According to the comprehensive index weight coefficient evaluation method, the following results are obtained, see Table 4:

[0072] Table 4 Evaluation results of comprehensive index weight coefficient

[0073]

[0074]

[0075] According to the comprehensive index weight coefficient evaluation method, the present invention uses C 3122 The weight factor is used as the preset target, and combined with the test results in Table 1, the rubber compound ranking is the same as the expected result.

[0076] In summary, the evaluation method provided by the present invention not only reflects the relationship between rolling resistance, wet slip and wear, but also takes into account the factors affecting the performance, so that the evaluation method more comprehensively reflects the comprehensive performance of the rubber. In addition, the method uses the normalization method and Pearson bivariate correlation analysis to reduce the error of the evaluation method and improve the accuracy of the evaluation method, which can solve the technical problems of the traditional method of using a single value to characterize rolling resistance, which has poor accuracy and cannot take into account rolling resistance, wet slip and wear performance.

Claims

1. A method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of a rubber compound, characterized in that: Used to evaluate tire tread rubber performance, including the following steps: Rubber material selection and classification: According to different performance requirements, several different types of rubber materials are prepared and divided into reference rubber materials and rubber materials to be evaluated; Establishment of correlation equation: After clarifying the various indicators related to a single performance, the correlation equation between the various indicators under a single performance is obtained by using the normalization method and Pearson variable correlation analysis; Comprehensive index weight coefficient evaluation: According to the strong, weak or irrelevant relationship between each index and individual performance, determine whether to assign a weight coefficient, obtain the final correlation equation, compare the result calculated by the equation with the preset target, and evaluate the comprehensive performance of the rubber compound; The specific steps for establishing the above correlation equation are: After clarifying the indicators related to a single performance, the performance correlation coefficient is recorded as A using the normalization method and Pearson variable correlation analysis, and the indicators related to it are marked as a1, a2, a n According to the correlation between the indicators, the correlation equation between the indicators under a single performance is obtained; the principle of establishing the correlation equation is: When there is a strong positive correlation between the indicators, each indicator in the correlation equation is represented by a multiplication sign; When there is a strong negative correlation between the indicators, the indicators in the correlation equation are expressed as inverses; When the indicators are uncorrelated or weakly correlated, each indicator in the correlation equation is represented by a plus sign; The specific steps of the above comprehensive indicator weight coefficient evaluation are as follows: When all indicators under a single performance item are unrelated or weakly correlated, the correlation equation is A=a1+a2+a n It means that by giving the equation a weight coefficient, we get b1=a1 / A, b2=a2 / A, b n =a n / A, b1, b2, b n Compared with the preset target, the smaller the difference, the more the rubber performance meets the requirements; When all indicators under a single performance item are strongly correlated, the correlation equation is A=a1·a2·a n It means that without assigning a weight coefficient, the larger the A value is, the more the performance of the rubber compound meets the requirements; When all indicators under a single performance item are both unrelated and strongly correlated, first integrate the strongly correlated indicators into one indicator and use C 12 =a1·a2 means that the weight coefficient is assigned according to the irrelevant or weakly correlated situation. n C n , D n Represents the weight coefficient assigned to it, and obtains D 12 =C 12 / (C 12 +C n ),D n =C n / (C 12 +C n ), D 12 , D n Compared with the preset target, the smaller the difference, the more the rubber performance meets the requirements.

2. The method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of rubber materials according to claim 1, characterized in that: When the indicators are correlated, a higher correlation coefficient indicates a higher correlation, and when the indicators are uncorrelated, a lower correlation coefficient indicates a higher correlation.

3. The method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of rubber materials according to claim 2, characterized in that: The correlation coefficient for the positive strong correlation and the negative strong correlation is ≥0.9, and the correlation coefficient for the uncorrelated or weakly correlated is ≤0.

3.

4. The method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of rubber materials according to claim 1, characterized in that: The reference rubber material can be selected from any one of several different types of rubber materials, which is used to achieve parameter index normalization and eliminate systematic errors in the rubber material formula.

5. The method for evaluating the comprehensive performance of rubber materials according to claim 1, characterized in that: The comprehensive performance includes anti-skid performance, wear resistance and rolling resistance performance.