A robust physical layer security transmission method in a wireless cooperative relay system

By establishing a wiretap channel model and optimizing the CSI error range of channel state information in the wireless collaborative relay system, an effective artificial noise interference strategy is designed to solve the noise leakage problem caused by channel error, and improve the robustness and security of the system.

CN115499086BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-05SYST OVERALL RES INST INST OF SYST ENG ACAD OF MILITARY SCI
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202211122493.7
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2022-09-15
Publication Date
2024-11-05
Estimated Expiration
2042-09-15

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

In wireless collaborative relay systems, the orthogonality between the legal link and artificial noise is damaged due to the CSI error of channel state information, which affects the physical layer security performance of the system, especially the channel state information of the eavesdropping link is not possible. In the case of acquisition, how to improve the robustness and security of the system is a key issue.

Method used

By establishing a wireless collaborative relay eavesdropping channel model, setting the CSI error limit range of channel state information, optimizing and minimizing the transmission power of useful signals, meeting the minimum reception signal-to-interference noise ratio SINR constraint of the legal target node, and using S-Procedure and semi- The fixed relaxation principle turns the problem into a semi-definite planning problem, and solves it using the inner point method and Gaussian stochastic method to design an effective artificial noise interference strategy.

Benefits of technology

It reduces the system's sensitivity to channel state information CSI error, minimizes the reception quality of potential eavesdropping nodes, and ensures the reception performance of legitimate target nodes, and improves the security of wireless collaborative relay systems.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN115499086B_ABST
    Figure CN115499086B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention discloses a robust physical layer security transmission method in a wireless cooperative relay system. The method is as follows: firstly, a wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model is established. When a channel state information error occurs, the optimization problem is to minimize the transmission power of the useful signal, while satisfying the minimum received signal-to-interference-to-noise ratio constraint of the legal target node within the given channel state information error range and the power constraint of each relay node; then, the lower bound constraint of the received signal-to-interference-to-noise ratio of the legal target node is obtained by using the known channel state information error statistics knowledge; finally, the optimization problem is transformed into a semidefinite programming problem, and the interior point method is used for solving it. If the rank of the obtained solution is equal to 1, the global optimal solution is directly obtained by using matrix decomposition; if the rank of the obtained solution is not equal to 1, the Gaussian random method is used to transform the solution into an approximate solution of the optimization problem. The present invention improves the security of the wireless cooperative relay system.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of information communication networks, and in particular to a robust physical layer security transmission method in a wireless cooperative relay system. Background Art

[0002] The research on physical layer security technology has always attracted much attention. It makes full use of physical layer resources to achieve secure information transmission. Collaborative relay technology can increase communication capacity and expand information transmission range without increasing terminal size, while also improving the system's spectrum efficiency. It has been a research hotspot in recent years.

[0003] However, due to the broadcast characteristics of wireless communications, eavesdroppers within the range of wireless communications can intercept electromagnetic signals. In recent years, a large number of research works have been devoted to the study of physical layer security technologies for wireless cooperative relay systems. The results show that transmission based on cooperative relay technology can effectively enhance the physical layer security performance of the system. From the perspective of information security, the transmission scheme that achieves confidentiality capacity is optimal. A large number of literatures have studied the problem of maximizing the confidentiality rate of wireless relay eavesdropping channels. However, the calculation of confidentiality capacity usually requires the channel state information (CSI) of the known eavesdropping link, which is not available in the case of passive eavesdropping. Therefore, researchers proposed a masked beamforming scheme to enhance the physical layer security of the system. This scheme only requires the CSI of the legitimate link and can use artificial noise (AN) to interfere with the eavesdropping node.

[0004] When the CSI of the legitimate link is ideal, artificial noise can be designed in the null space of the legitimate link channel. The artificial noise designed in this way will only deteriorate the reception quality of potential eavesdropping nodes, but will have no effect on the legitimate target nodes. However, in practical applications, due to factors such as non-ideal CSI estimation and Doppler spread, the CSI obtained by the sending node will have certain errors, which will destroy the orthogonality between the legitimate link and the artificial noise. The artificial noise designed according to the non-ideal CSI of the legitimate link will not only deteriorate the eavesdropping link, but also interfere with the reception performance of the legitimate target node. Therefore, how to improve the robustness of the physical layer security transmission of the wireless cooperative relay system is a key issue that needs to be solved. Summary of the invention

[0005] The object of the present invention is to provide a physical layer security transmission method in a wireless cooperative relay system, which can deteriorate the reception quality of potential eavesdropping nodes and improve the security of the wireless cooperative relay system.

[0006] The technical solution to achieve the purpose of the present invention is: a robust physical layer security transmission method in a wireless cooperative relay system, comprising the following steps:

[0007] Step 1: Establish a wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model, set the channel state information CSI error limit range, and calculate the received signal to interference and noise ratio SINR of the legitimate target node;

[0008] Step 2: When a channel state information (CSI) error occurs, the optimization problem is to minimize the transmit power of the useful signal while satisfying the minimum received signal-to-interference-and-noise ratio (SINR) constraint of the legal target node within the given channel state information (CSI) error range and the power constraint of each relay node.

[0009] Step 3: Using the known channel state information (CSI) generalized error statistics, the lower bound of the SINR received by the legal target node is obtained;

[0010] Step 4: transform the minimum received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) constraint of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error into the lower bound constraint of the received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error;

[0011] Step 5: Using the S-Procedure principle and the semidefinite relaxation principle, the optimization problem is transformed into a semidefinite programming problem and solved using the interior point method.

[0012] Step 6: If the rank of the solution is equal to 1, directly use matrix decomposition to obtain the global optimal solution; if the rank of the solution is not equal to 1, use the Gaussian random method to convert this solution into an approximate solution to the optimization problem.

[0013] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following significant advantages: (1) it reduces the system's sensitivity to channel state information (CSI) errors, and while meeting the reception performance requirements of legitimate target nodes, it deteriorates the reception quality of potential eavesdropping nodes to the greatest extent by increasing the artificial noise power; and (2) it improves the security of the wireless cooperative relay system. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0014] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the system model structure of a robust physical layer security transmission method in a wireless cooperative relay system. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0015] The technical solution of the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.

[0016] The present invention provides a robust physical layer security transmission method in a wireless cooperative relay system, which belongs to the field of information communication networks. The method is aimed at an eavesdropping scenario in a single-source, multi-relay, single-target node wireless cooperative relay communication system. It is assumed that both the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node are not within the electromagnetic signal coverage of the source node. Under the condition of unknown eavesdropping link channel state information (Channel State Information, CSI), for the situation where errors occur in the CSI from all relay nodes to the legitimate target node, a distributed beamforming scheme based on an artificial noise (Artificial Noise, AN) auxiliary strategy is designed. The invention effectively solves the noise leakage problem caused by the destruction of the orthogonality of the legitimate channel and AN due to the CSI error of the legitimate link, and can minimize the deterioration of the receiving performance of the eavesdropping node while ensuring the receiving quality of the legitimate target node.

[0017] Combination Figure 1 The present invention provides a robust physical layer security transmission method in a wireless cooperative relay system, comprising the following steps:

[0018] Step 1: Establish a wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model, set the channel state information CSI error limit range, and calculate the received signal to interference and noise ratio SINR of the legitimate target node;

[0019] Step 2: When a channel state information (CSI) error occurs, the optimization problem is to minimize the transmit power of the useful signal while satisfying the minimum received signal-to-interference-and-noise ratio (SINR) constraint of the legal target node within the given channel state information (CSI) error range and the power constraint of each relay node.

[0020] Step 3: Using the known channel state information (CSI) generalized error statistics, the lower bound of the SINR received by the legal target node is obtained;

[0021] Step 4: transform the minimum received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) constraint of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error into the lower bound constraint of the received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error;

[0022] Step 5: Using the S-Procedure principle and the semidefinite relaxation principle, the optimization problem is transformed into a semidefinite programming problem and solved using the interior point method.

[0023] Step 6: If the rank of the solution is equal to 1, directly use matrix decomposition to obtain the global optimal solution; if the rank of the solution is not equal to 1, use the Gaussian random method to convert this solution into an approximate solution to the optimization problem.

[0024] Furthermore, in step 1, a wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model is established, a channel state information CSI error limit range is set, and a received signal to interference and noise ratio SINR of a legitimate target node is calculated, as follows:

[0025] Step 1.1: Establish a wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model, as follows:

[0026] A wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model is established, which consists of a sending node S, n relay nodes {R1, ···, R n}, a legitimate target node D and an eavesdropping node E, where the number of relay nodes n>1; all nodes are equipped with a single antenna and use half-duplex mode;

[0027] use represents the channel gain from the source node to all relay nodes, using represents the channel gain from all relay nodes to the legitimate target node, using represents the channel gain from all relay nodes to the eavesdropping node;

[0028] Set h sr ,h rd and h e Each element in is an independent and identically distributed complex Gaussian random variable. The relay node adopts the amplification and forwarding protocol. There is no direct communication link between the source node and the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node, that is, the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node are not within the electromagnetic signal coverage of the source node. The source node is assumed to use channel reciprocity to send training sequences to estimate the channel state information h of all legitimate links. sr and h rd , but the source node cannot obtain any channel state information h of the eavesdropped link e .

[0029] Step 1.2: Calculate the signals received by the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node under the ideal channel state information, as follows:

[0030] In the first transmission phase, the source node sends a signal to the relay node, and the signal x received by the relay node is r =(x r,1 ,…,x r,n ) T It is expressed as:

[0031]

[0032] Where P is the transmission power of the source node signal, is a matrix with covariance matrix Zero-mean Gaussian white noise vector, I n is the n×n unit matrix;

[0033] In the second transmission phase, the relay nodes use distributed beamforming technology to collaboratively forward the received signal. The relay nodes forward the received signal x r Multiply by the transmit beamforming matrix Then send it, then the signal y received by the legal target node d It is expressed as:

[0034]

[0035] in, The variance is Zero-mean Gaussian white noise;

[0036] The signal y received by the eavesdropping node e It is expressed as:

[0037]

[0038] in, The variance is Zero-mean Gaussian white noise.

[0039] Step 1.3: Calculate the signal-to-noise ratio (SINR) received by the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node under the ideal channel state information, as follows:

[0040] In the second stage, since the relay node uses distributed beamforming technology and sends artificial noise at the same time, the artificial noise sent by the relay node is recorded as Relay node pair x r Multiply by the transmit beamforming matrix W b , so the signal vector y sent by the relay node r =(y r,1 ,…,y r,n ) T It is expressed as:

[0041] y r =W b x r +n an

[0042] The power P of the useful signal sent by the relay node s It is expressed as:

[0043]

[0044] Where w=(w1,···,w n ) T , R sr =diag(|h sr,1 | 2,···,|h sr,n | 2 );

[0045] Assume the maximum transmission power of the i-th relay node is P i , in addition to sending useful signals, the relay node can use the remaining power to send artificial noise to interfere with potential eavesdropping nodes. The total power of artificial noise of n relay nodes is

[0046] The received signal y of the legal target node d Re-expressed as:

[0047]

[0048] Among them, n d The variance is Zero-mean Gaussian white noise;

[0049] The signal y received by the eavesdropping node e Re-expressed as:

[0050]

[0051] Among them, n e The variance is Zero-mean Gaussian white noise;

[0052] In order to prevent legitimate links from being interfered by artificial noise, the artificial noise Should be located at the legal link h rd On the null space of So, we can get:

[0053] n an =Πv

[0054] Where Π is h rd A set of orthogonal bases in the null space of and satisfying ΠΠ H =I n , v is an iid Gaussian random vector with zero mean and unit variance;

[0055] The receiving SINR of the legal target node can be expressed as:

[0056]

[0057] Among them, r h =(h sr,1 h rd,1 ,···,h sr,n h rd,n ) T , R rd =diag(|h rd,1 |2 ,···,|h rd,n | 2 );

[0058] The receiving SINR of the eavesdropping node is expressed as:

[0059]

[0060] Among them, r eh =(h sr,1 h e,1 ,···,h sr,n h e,n ) T , R e =diag(|h e,1 | 2 ,…,|h e,n | 2 ).

[0061] Step 1.4: Set the channel state information CSI error limit range and calculate the received signal to interference and noise ratio SINR of the legal target node under non-ideal channel state information, as follows:

[0062] In actual communication, due to the existence of factors such as Doppler spread, the channel state information obtained by the source node will have errors, so the channel state information error is limited to a spherical domain:

[0063] S={e rd ∈C n×1 :||e rd || 2 ≤nρ 2 ,ρ>0}

[0064] In the case of non-ideal channel state information, artificial noise is located in the channel state information estimate In the null space of , then the received signal-to-interference-noise ratio SINR of the legitimate target node under non-ideal channel state information is LI It can be expressed as:

[0065]

[0066] in,

[0067] Furthermore, in step 2, when a channel state information CSI error occurs, the optimization problem is to minimize the transmit power of the useful signal while satisfying the minimum receive signal-to-interference-and-noise ratio SINR constraint of the legal target node within the given channel state information CSI error range and the power constraint of each relay node, as follows:

[0068] When the channel state information CSI error occurs, the transmission power of the useful signal is minimized, while the legitimate target node meets the minimum receiving SINR constraint and the power of each relay node also meets certain constraints, and then the remaining power is used to send artificial noise to interfere with potential eavesdroppers. The optimization problem of this scheme is written as follows:

[0069]

[0070] Wherein, λ represents the receiving SINR ratio threshold under which the legitimate target node can achieve reliable communication.

[0071] Furthermore, in step 3, the lower bound of the SINR of the received signal to interference plus noise ratio of the legal target node is obtained by using the known channel state information CSI universal error statistics knowledge, which is as follows:

[0072] Using the known channel state information CSI error statistics knowledge ||e rd || 2 ≤nρ 2 , the lower bound of the SINR received by the legal target node is obtained as follows:

[0073] SINR LI ≥ SINR l

[0074] in,

[0075] Furthermore, in step 4, the minimum received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) constraint of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error is transformed into a lower bound constraint of the received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error, as follows:

[0076] The optimization problem (1) can be transformed into:

[0077]

[0078] The first constraint in the optimization problem (2) can be reformulated as:

[0079]

[0080] in,

[0081] Furthermore, in step 5, the optimization problem is transformed into a semidefinite programming problem by using the S-Procedure principle and the semidefinite relaxation principle, and the interior point method is used to solve it, as follows:

[0082] Step 5.1: Using the S-Procedure principle, formula (3) is re-expressed as:

[0083]

[0084] Transform problem (2) into the following problem:

[0085]

[0086] Step 5.2: Ignore the third non-convex constraint rank(W)=1 in the optimization problem (5), and use the semidefinite relaxation principle to further relax (5) to:

[0087]

[0088] Step 5.3: Use the interior point method to solve the optimization problem (6) and obtain the optimal value.

[0089] Furthermore, in general, the solution W obtained by using the semidefinite relaxation principle cannot guarantee that its rank is 1, so the optimal solution W obtained after using the semidefinite relaxation is only a suboptimal solution to the optimization problem (2), and this optimal solution needs to be further processed. At this time, we can use the Gaussian randomization procedure to transform the optimal solution W obtained by solving the optimization problem (6) into an approximate solution to problem (2). In addition, if the rank of W obtained is 1, then w can be directly obtained by matrix decomposition opt , this solution is globally optimal.

[0090] The present invention reduces the sensitivity of the system to channel state information CSI errors, and while meeting the reception performance requirements of legitimate target nodes, deteriorates the reception quality of potential eavesdropping nodes to the greatest extent by increasing artificial noise power, thereby improving the security of the wireless cooperative relay system.

[0091] The above description is only a specific implementation of the present invention, but the protection scope of the present invention is not limited thereto. Any changes or substitutions that can be easily conceived by any technician familiar with the technical field within the technical scope disclosed by the present invention should be covered by the protection scope of the present invention.

Claims

1. A robust physical layer security transmission method in a wireless cooperative relay system, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Step 1: Establish a wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model, set the channel state information CSI error limit range, and calculate the received signal to interference and noise ratio SINR of the legitimate target node; Step 2: When a channel state information (CSI) error occurs, the optimization problem is to minimize the transmit power of the useful signal while satisfying the minimum received signal-to-interference-and-noise ratio (SINR) constraint of the legal target node within the given channel state information (CSI) error range and the power constraint of each relay node. Step 3: Using the known channel state information (CSI) generalized error statistics, the lower bound of the SINR received by the legal target node is obtained; Step 4: transform the minimum received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) constraint of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error into the lower bound constraint of the received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error; Step 5: Using the S-Procedure principle and the semidefinite relaxation principle, the optimization problem is transformed into a semidefinite programming problem and solved using the interior point method. Step 6: If the rank of the solution is equal to 1, the global optimal solution is obtained by directly using matrix decomposition; if the rank of the solution is not equal to 1, the Gaussian random method is used to transform the solution into an approximate solution to the optimization problem; The wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model described in step 1 is established, the channel state information CSI error limit range is set, and the received signal to interference and noise ratio SINR of the legal target node is calculated, as follows: Step 1.1, establish a wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model; Step 1.2, calculate the signals received by the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node under the ideal channel state information; Step 1.3, calculate the signal-to-noise ratio (SINR) received by the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node under the ideal channel state information; Step 1.4, setting the channel state information CSI error limit range, and calculating the received signal to interference and noise ratio SINR of the legal target node under non-ideal channel state information; The establishment of the wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model described in step 1.1 is as follows: A wireless cooperative relay eavesdropping channel model is established, which consists of a sending node S, n relay nodes {R1,…,R n }, a legitimate target node D and an eavesdropping node E, where the number of relay nodes n>1; all nodes are equipped with a single antenna and use half-duplex mode; use represents the channel gain from the source node to all relay nodes, using represents the channel gain from all relay nodes to the legitimate target node, using represents the channel gain from all relay nodes to the eavesdropping node; Set h sr 、h rd and h e Each element in is an independent and identically distributed complex Gaussian random variable. The relay node adopts the amplification and forwarding protocol. There is no direct communication link between the source node and the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node, that is, the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node are not within the electromagnetic signal coverage of the source node. The source node is assumed to use channel reciprocity to send training sequences to estimate the channel state information of all legitimate links h sr and h rd , but the source node cannot obtain any channel state information h of the eavesdropped link e ; The signals received by the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node under the ideal channel state information calculation described in step 1.2 are as follows: In the first transmission phase, the source node sends a signal to the relay node, and the signal x received by the relay node is r =(x r,1 ,…,x r,n ) T It is expressed as: Where P is the transmission power of the source node signal, is a matrix with covariance matrix Zero-mean Gaussian white noise vector, I n is the n×n unit matrix; In the second transmission phase, the relay nodes use distributed beamforming technology to collaboratively forward the received signal. The relay nodes forward the received signal x r Multiply by the transmit beamforming matrix Then send it, then the signal y received by the legal target node d It is expressed as: in, The variance is Zero-mean Gaussian white noise; The signal y received by the eavesdropping node e It is expressed as: in, The variance is Zero-mean Gaussian white noise; The SINR received by the legitimate target node and the eavesdropping node under the ideal channel state information calculation described in step 1.3 is as follows: Since the relay node uses distributed beamforming technology and sends artificial noise at the same time, the artificial noise sent by the relay node is recorded as Relay node pair x r Multiply by the transmit beamforming matrix W b , so the signal vector y sent by the relay node r =(y r,1 ,…,y r,n ) T It is expressed as: y r =W b x r +n an The power P of the useful signal sent by the relay node s It is expressed as: Where w=(w1,…,w n ) T , R sr =diag(|h sr,1 | 2 ,…,|h sr,n | 2 ); Assume the maximum transmission power of the i-th relay node is P i , in addition to sending useful signals, the relay node uses the remaining power to send artificial noise to interfere with potential eavesdropping nodes. The total power of artificial noise of n relay nodes is The received signal y of the legal target node d Re-expressed as: Among them, n d The variance is Zero-mean Gaussian white noise; The signal y received by the eavesdropping node e Re-expressed as: Among them, n e The variance is Zero-mean Gaussian white noise; In order to prevent legitimate links from being interfered by artificial noise, the artificial noise Should be located at the legal link h rd On the null space of So we get: n an =Pv Where Π is h rd A set of orthogonal bases in the null space of and satisfying ΠΠ H =I n , v is an iid Gaussian random vector with zero mean and unit variance; The received SINR of the legal target node is expressed as SINR L : Among them, r h =(h sr,1 h rd,1 ,…,h sr,n h rd,n ) T , R rd =diag(|h rd,1 | 2 ,…,|h rd,n | 2 ); The received SINR of the eavesdropping node is expressed as SINR E : Among them, r eh =(h sr,1 h e,1 ,…,h sr,n h e,n ) T , R e =diag(|h e,1 | 2 ,…,|h e,n | 2 ); The channel state information CSI error limit range is set as described in step 1.4, and the received signal to interference and noise ratio SINR of the legal target node under non-ideal channel state information is calculated as follows: In actual communication, due to the existence of Doppler spread, the channel state information obtained by the source node has errors, so the channel state information error is limited to a spherical domain: S={e rd ∈C n×1 :||e rd || 2 ≤nρ 2 ,ρ>0} In the case of non-ideal channel state information, artificial noise is located in the channel state information estimate In the null space of , then the received signal-to-interference-noise ratio SINR of the legitimate target node under non-ideal channel state information is LI It is expressed as: in, In step 2, when a channel state information CSI error occurs, the optimization problem is to minimize the transmit power of the useful signal while satisfying the minimum received signal-to-interference-and-noise ratio (SINR) constraint of the legal target node within the given channel state information CSI error range and the power constraint of each relay node, as follows: When the channel state information CSI error occurs, the transmission power of the useful signal is minimized, while the legitimate target node meets the minimum receiving SINR constraint and the power of each relay node also meets certain constraints, and then the remaining power is used to send artificial noise to interfere with potential eavesdroppers. The optimization problem of this scheme is written as follows: Among them, λ represents the receiving SINR ratio threshold under which the legitimate target node can achieve reliable communication; Step 3 uses the known channel state information CSI generalized error statistics knowledge to obtain the lower bound of the SINR received by the legal target node, as follows: Using the known channel state information CSI error statistics knowledge ||e rd || 2 ≤nρ 2 , the lower bound of the SINR received by the legal target node is obtained as follows: SINR LI ≥SINR l in, The minimum received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) constraint of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error described in step 4 is transformed into a lower bound constraint of the received signal to interference plus noise ratio (SINR) of the legal target node within the range of the channel state information (CSI) universal error, as follows: The optimization problem (1) is transformed into: The first constraint in the optimization problem (2) can be reformulated as: in, 2. The method for robust physical layer security transmission in a wireless cooperative relay system according to claim 1, characterized in that: Step 5 uses the S-Procedure principle and the semidefinite relaxation principle to transform the optimization problem into a semidefinite programming problem and solve it using the interior point method, as follows: Step 5.1: Using the S-Procedure principle, formula (3) is re-expressed as: Transform problem (2) into the following problem: Step 5.2: Ignore the third non-convex constraint rank(W)=1 in the optimization problem (5), and use the semidefinite relaxation principle to further relax (5) to: Step 5.3: Use the interior point method to solve the optimization problem (6) and obtain the optimal value.