Water-city co-fusion evaluation method

By constructing a three-dimensional evaluation index system for water-city integration based on pressure, state, and response, and employing the analytic hierarchy process (AHP), the problem of existing technologies being unable to comprehensively evaluate the level of urban water-city integration construction is solved, enabling quantitative evaluation of the water-city integration status and attention to the two-way impact.

CN118898413APending Publication Date: 2024-11-05BEIJING ENTERPRISES WATER GROUP LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202310485159.6
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2023-04-28
Publication Date
2024-11-05

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing technologies cannot comprehensively and intuitively evaluate the level of urban water-city integration, lack unified indicators and methods, and cannot reflect the interactive relationship between water and city.

Method used

A comprehensive evaluation index system for water-city integration was constructed, consisting of three dimensions: pressure, status, and response. The analytic hierarchy process (AHP) was used to select effective indicators, calculate the comprehensive index of water-city integration, and evaluate the level of water-city integration construction in the city.

Benefits of technology

It provides a complete set of indicators that can more comprehensively and intuitively evaluate the level of urban water-city integration, focusing on the two-way impact of water resources, water environment and urban construction, and is suitable for quantitative characterization of the state of water-city integration.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure BDA0004208371710000181
    Figure BDA0004208371710000181
  • Figure FDA0004208371700000021
    Figure FDA0004208371700000021
  • Figure HDA0004208371720000011
    Figure HDA0004208371720000011
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The embodiment of the invention provides a water-city co-fusion evaluation method, and belongs to the technical field of water-city co-fusion. The water-city co-fusion evaluation method comprises the following steps: S1, constructing a water-city co-fusion comprehensive evaluation index system; dividing a water-city co-fusion comprehensive evaluation index system into three dimensions; determining theme layers contained in each dimension, and screening a plurality of indexes in each theme layer to form an index layer; determining the meaning of each index and a calculation method, and calculating the score of each index; s2, screening effective indexes by using an analytic hierarchy process, and determining contribution weights of each index in each dimension, each theme layer and each index layer; s3, calculating a comprehensive evaluation score according to a water-city co-fusion comprehensive index calculation formula; and S4, according to the comprehensive evaluation score and based on a water-city co-fusion comprehensive index evaluation grade standard, determining a water-city co-fusion comprehensive evaluation grade. According to the water-city co-fusion evaluation method, the symbiotic interaction relationship between the water and the city is more fully considered, and the construction level of the water-city co-fusion of the city can be more comprehensively and intuitively evaluated.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present application relates to the technical field of water-city integration, and in particular to a method for evaluating water-city integration. Background Art

[0002] As a natural resource, water plays an irreplaceable role in human activities and is known as the "blood of the city". It has multiple functions and maintains the survival and development of the city. Water is not only the basis of human material life, but also gives the city vitality and spiritual temperament. The proposal of the goal of blue-green interweaving and water-city integration is a requirement for high-standard urban construction in the new era, and also reflects the people's yearning and expectation for a better life. With the advancement of urban construction, the construction of water-city integration in various places has begun to show results. However, there is currently no specific evaluation method for the specific effect and whether the water-city integration state has been achieved. Although there are a series of evaluation indicators and methods such as the "National Water Ecological Civilization City Evaluation Standard", the China Urban Sustainable Development Index, and the Livable City Evaluation Index System that are widely used, they cannot fully evaluate the state of water-city integration and are not suitable for the comprehensive evaluation of water-city integration.

[0003] At present, there are a few evaluation index results in water ecological civilization and other aspects. For example, the patent with publication number CN109948876A discloses a method for evaluating the effectiveness of water ecological civilization construction in water-scarce cities in the north, including deriving weight coefficients, constructing an index system, determining the criterion layer and evaluation index that can reflect the characteristics of water ecological civilization in water-scarce cities in the north, determining the standard value of each index, and determining the evaluation standard of water ecological civilization cities. The present invention constructs a water ecological civilization evaluation system covering 6 criterion layers and 21 indicators, including the most stringent water resources management, water resources optimization allocation, flood control and drainage system, water conservation management, water resources protection and water ecological restoration, and water culture construction, which provides more targeted guidance ideas for the evaluation of the effectiveness of water ecological civilization construction in water-scarce cities in the north. However, the indicators of the invention mainly select indicators in water resources management, water resources allocation, water resources protection and utilization, and the interactive relationship with the city is insufficient. For example, the patent with publication number CN115471356A discloses a "three waters" collaborative evaluation system, which reflects the comprehensive level and synergistic coupling state of the "three waters" through the comprehensive evaluation index T of water resources, water environment and water ecology and the coordinated development degree D. However, this invention only focuses on the characteristics of water itself, and pays insufficient attention to cities, with fewer indicators. In addition, the patent with publication number CN106682326A selects a total of 17 indicators from the three criteria layers of river water quality, ecosystem health, and ecological landscape suitability, and calculates and evaluates the ecological governance effect of urban rivers, but these indicators are limited to the water body itself, and the evaluation is not comprehensive enough and lacks something. Summary of the invention

[0004] The embodiment of the present application provides a water-city integration evaluation method, which can evaluate the construction level of urban water-city integration in a more comprehensive and intuitive manner.

[0005] The embodiment of the present application provides a water city integration evaluation method, and the evaluation method includes the following steps: S1, constructing a comprehensive evaluation index system for water city integration; starting from the water city integration construction goal, dividing the water city integration comprehensive evaluation index system into three dimensions: pressure dimension, state dimension and response dimension; classifying each dimension, determining the theme layer contained in each dimension, and based on each theme layer under each dimension, respectively screening a number of indicators in each theme layer to form an indicator layer; determining the meaning of each indicator and the calculation method of each indicator, and calculating the indicator score of each indicator; S2, using the hierarchical analysis method to screen effective indicators, and determine the contribution weights of each dimension, each theme layer and each indicator layer; S3, based on the contribution weights and indicator scores of each dimension, each theme layer and each indicator, according to the water city integration comprehensive index calculation formula, calculate the comprehensive evaluation score of water city integration; S4, according to the comprehensive evaluation score and based on the comprehensive index evaluation grade standard of water city integration, determine the comprehensive evaluation grade of water city integration.

[0006] In this plan, the comprehensive evaluation index system of water-city integration is divided into three dimensions: pressure, state and response, so that the evaluation index system reflects the interactive relationship between water and city, and adopts indicators from multiple aspects such as society, economy, resources, environment and management. Compared with the evaluation system in the existing technology, the evaluation index system in this plan is not only limited to the water body itself, water resource utilization, and water environment indicators. This plan pays more attention to the two-way impact of water resources and water environment on urban construction and quality, and has a wider coverage, including various indicators in each thematic layer of pressure, state and response, and finally calculates the comprehensive index value of water-city integration on the basis of hierarchical analysis method, so as to be able to more comprehensively and intuitively evaluate the construction level of urban water-city integration.

[0007] In some embodiments, in step S1, the pressure dimension includes three theme layers, namely social pressure, resource pressure and environmental pressure; the state dimension includes four theme layers, namely water resource status, water environment status, water ecological status and human settlement status. The response dimension includes three theme layers, namely management response, resource environment response and social response.

[0008] In some embodiments, in the pressure dimension, social pressure includes two indicators, namely, population density and the proportion of the primary and secondary industries in the total value generated in the region; resource pressure includes four indicators, namely, per capita construction land area, water source security, surface water development and utilization rate, and water consumption per unit GDP; environmental pressure includes two indicators, namely, COD emission intensity into rivers and ammonia nitrogen emission intensity into rivers.

[0009] In the above technical scheme, the social pressure theme layer includes two indicators: population density and the proportion of the primary and secondary industries in GDP, which reflect the basic social and economic pressures directly faced by the water system. The resource pressure theme layer includes four indicators: per capita construction land area, water source security, surface water development and utilization rate, and water consumption per unit of GDP, which reflect the pressure faced by water resource utilization and water system layout in urban construction and development. The environmental pressure theme layer includes two indicators: COD emission intensity into the river and ammonia nitrogen emission intensity into the river, which reflect the pollution load input pressure faced by the urban water system.

[0010] In some embodiments, in the status dimension, the water resource status includes two indicators, namely, the water surface area ratio and the river-lake connectivity; the water environment status includes four indicators, namely, the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class V and below, the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class III and above, the water quality compliance rate of the water functional area, and the water quality compliance rate of the outbound section; the water ecological status includes two indicators, namely, the biological habitat status index and the proportion of ecological coastline; the human settlement status includes two indicators, namely, per capita green space area and hydrophilic landscape.

[0011] In the above technical scheme, the water resource status theme layer includes two indicators: water surface area ratio and river-lake connectivity, which reflect the abundance of water resources and the rationality of the layout of the city. The water environment status theme layer includes four indicators: the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class V and below, the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class III and above, the water quality compliance rate of the water functional area and the water quality compliance rate of the outbound section. The common monitoring indicators are used to reflect the quality of urban water environment. The water ecology status theme layer includes two indicators: biological habitat status index and ecological shoreline ratio, which reflect the health status of water ecology at the urban scale. The human settlement status theme layer includes two indicators: per capita green space (including wetlands) area and hydrophilic landscape, which reflect the quality of human settlement related to the construction of water systems in the city.

[0012] In some embodiments, in the response dimension, the management response includes three indicators, namely, the ratio of water environment governance investment to GDP, the water resources monitoring and management capacity index, and the monitoring rate of sewage outlets into rivers; the resource and environmental response includes four indicators, namely, the sewage collection and treatment rate, the sewage recycling rate, the proportion of sponge cities in built-up areas, and the effective utilization coefficient of farmland irrigation water; the social response includes two indicators, namely, the coverage rate of water ecological civilization publicity and education and the satisfaction of citizens with the water environment in a sample survey.

[0013] In the above technical scheme, the management response theme layer includes three indicators: the ratio of water environment governance investment to GDP, the water resources monitoring and management capacity index, and the monitoring rate of sewage outlets into rivers, which reflect the city's investment in water resources and water environment management, which is also the basic guarantee for achieving water-city integration. The resource and environmental response theme layer includes four indicators: sewage collection and treatment rate, sewage recycling rate, proportion of sponge cities in built-up areas, and effective utilization coefficient of farmland irrigation water, which reflect the city's engineering investment in water resources utilization and water environment improvement. The social response theme layer includes two indicators: water ecological civilization publicity and education coverage rate and sample survey of citizens' satisfaction with the water environment, which reflect the relationship between the public and the water system in the city and the public's satisfaction with the construction of the water system.

[0014] In some embodiments, when determining the calculation method of each indicator of the indicator layer in step S1, the value of each indicator is obtained, analyzed and calculated based on literature statistics, measurement and on-site monitoring.

[0015] In some embodiments, in step S3, the calculation formula is: Among them, WCI is the comprehensive index of water city integration, F i is the weight of the i-th dimension, P j is the weight of the j-th topic layer, Q k is the weight of the kth evaluation index, W k is the value of the kth evaluation index, n is the number of dimensions, m is the number of topic layers, and k is the number of evaluation indicators.

[0016] In some embodiments, in step S4, the comprehensive index evaluation level standard of water city integration is divided into five levels, namely, initial stage, development stage, intermediate stage, stable stage and advanced stage.

[0017] The beneficial effects of this scheme are as follows: This evaluation method is reflected in the symbiotic and interactive relationship between water and city, and adopts indicators in many aspects such as society, economy, resources, environment and management, rather than being limited to the water body itself, focusing on water resource utilization and water environment indicators. This scheme pays more attention to the two-way impact of water resources, water environment and urban construction and quality. This evaluation method is in line with the current orientation of water-city integration construction, and can promptly assist local governments in providing quantitative characterization results of the water-city integration status. A complete set of indicator systems is provided for indicator selection. In specific applications, the hierarchical analysis method can be used to screen effective indicators and assign personalized weights to each indicator, which can better characterize the water-city integration status of the evaluation area.

[0018] Other features and advantages of the present application will be described in detail in the subsequent detailed description. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0019] In order to more clearly illustrate the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present application, the drawings required for use in the embodiments will be briefly introduced below. It should be understood that the following drawings only show certain embodiments of the present application and therefore should not be regarded as limiting the scope. For ordinary technicians in this field, other related drawings can be obtained based on these drawings without paying creative work.

[0020] Figure 1 A step hierarchy diagram of a water city integration evaluation method provided for some embodiments of the present application;

[0021] Figure 2 This is a schematic diagram of the indicator structure of each dimension, theme layer and indicator layer of the indicator system in this application. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0022] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the embodiments of the present application clearer, the technical solution in the embodiments of the present application will be clearly and completely described below in conjunction with the drawings in the embodiments of the present application. Obviously, the described embodiments are part of the embodiments of the present application, rather than all the embodiments. The components of the embodiments of the present application described and shown in the drawings here can be arranged and designed in various different configurations.

[0023] Therefore, the following detailed description of the embodiments of the present application provided in the accompanying drawings is not intended to limit the scope of the present application for which protection is sought, but merely represents selected embodiments of the present application. Based on the embodiments in the present application, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in the field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present application.

[0024] In the description of the embodiments of the present application, it should be noted that the indicated orientation or position relationship is based on the orientation or position relationship shown in the drawings, or the orientation or position relationship in which the product of the application is usually placed when in use, which is only for the convenience of describing the present application and simplifying the description, and does not indicate or imply that the device or element referred to must have a specific orientation, be constructed and operated in a specific orientation, and therefore cannot be understood as a limitation on the present application. For ordinary technicians in this field, the specific meanings of the above terms in this embodiment can be understood according to the specific circumstances.

[0025] Example

[0026] The inventors found that water is the lifeline of urban life and the material basis for urban survival and development. Blue sky and clear water are important symbols of ecological cities. The urban ecological water system integrates drainage, water supply, water quality protection, hydrophilic landscape, and water ecology, and integrates multiple functions such as water safety, water environment, water landscape, water culture, and water economy. It is the foundation and guarantee for the ecological livability and high-quality development of a city. It aims to achieve harmony between people and water and sustainable social and economic development, with efficient allocation of water resources, water ecological restoration and water ecological environment construction as the core, and attaches equal importance to water quantity, water quality, and water ecology. It also takes flood control, drainage, water supply, river management, and environmental improvement into consideration, providing urban residents with a good production and living environment. With the rapid development of modern cities, the importance of building a healthy and reasonable ecological water system pattern has become increasingly apparent. The construction of urban water systems should achieve the development of urban social economy and the safety of human settlements, the sustainable use of water resources, the significant improvement of water environment quality, the coordination and beauty of natural and cultural landscapes of water bodies, the display of historical culture and the improvement of urban taste, and ultimately achieve an urban water circle with beautiful environment, comfortable and pleasant environment, economic development, social progress, and a benign cycle of water ecosystem. Many cities across the country have proposed the goal of water-city integration, such as Beijing's sub-center and Xiong'an New Area. However, there is currently no unified indicator and evaluation method for how to evaluate the construction results of water-city integration and the state of water-city integration in a city or region. The existing water ecological civilization evaluation indicators mostly consider urban water resource endowment indicators, water-saving and water-use indicators, etc., but pay less attention to the health of the river itself and the interactive relationship between the river and the city, which cannot well reflect the integration of water and city.

[0027] In view of this, the present application embodiment provides a water city integration evaluation method, such as Figure 1 As shown, the evaluation method includes the following steps: S1, constructing a comprehensive evaluation index system for water-city integration; starting from the goal of water-city integration construction, the comprehensive evaluation index system for water-city integration is divided into three dimensions: pressure dimension, state dimension and response dimension; classifying each dimension, determining the theme layer contained in each dimension, and based on each theme layer under each dimension, screening several indicators in each theme layer to form an indicator layer; determining the meaning and calculation method of each indicator in the indicator layer, and calculating the score of each indicator; S2, using the hierarchical analysis method to screen effective indicators, and determine the contribution weights of each indicator in each dimension, each theme layer and each indicator layer; S3, based on the contribution weights and indicator scores of each indicator in each dimension, each theme layer and each indicator layer, using the water-city integration comprehensive index calculation formula to calculate the comprehensive evaluation score of water-city integration; S4, determining the comprehensive evaluation level of water-city integration in the city based on the comprehensive evaluation score and the comprehensive index evaluation level standard of water-city integration.

[0028] In this plan, the comprehensive evaluation index system of water-city integration is divided into three dimensions: pressure, state and response, so that the evaluation index system reflects the interactive relationship between water and the city, and adopts indicators from multiple aspects such as society, economy, resources, environment and management. Compared with the existing evaluation system, the evaluation index system in this plan is not limited to the water body itself, water resource utilization, and water environment indicators. This plan pays more attention to the two-way impact of water resources and water environment on urban construction and quality, and has a wider coverage, including various indicators in each thematic layer of pressure, state and response, and finally calculates the comprehensive index value of water-city integration on the basis of hierarchical analysis method, so as to be able to more comprehensively and intuitively evaluate the construction level of urban water-city integration.

[0029] Among them, the analytic hierarchy process is an existing technology. It can be understood that the analytic hierarchy process, referred to as AHP, refers to a decision-making method that decomposes elements that are always related to decision-making into levels such as goals, criteria, and plans, and conducts qualitative and quantitative analysis on this basis. The analytic hierarchy process refers to treating a complex multi-objective decision-making problem as a system, decomposing the goal into multiple goals or criteria, and then decomposing it into several levels of multiple indicators (or criteria, constraints), and calculating the single ranking (weight) and total ranking of the levels through the fuzzy quantification method of qualitative indicators, as a systematic method for optimizing decision-making of goals (multiple indicators) and multiple plans. The analytic hierarchy process decomposes the problem into different components according to the nature of the problem and the overall goal to be achieved, and aggregates and combines the factors at different levels according to the mutual correlation and influence between the factors and the affiliation relationship, forming a multi-level analysis structure model, so that the problem is finally reduced to the determination of the relative importance weight of the lowest level (plans, measures, etc. for decision-making) relative to the highest level (overall goal) or the ranking of the relative order of superiority and inferiority.

[0030] In some embodiments, in step S1, the pressure dimension includes three theme layers, namely social pressure, resource pressure and environmental pressure; the state dimension includes four theme layers, namely water resource status, water environment status, water ecological status and human settlement status. The response dimension includes three theme layers, namely management response, resource environment response and social response.

[0031] In some embodiments, in the pressure dimension, social pressure includes two indicators, namely, population density and the proportion of the primary and secondary industries in GDP; resource pressure includes four indicators, namely, per capita construction land area, water source security level, surface water development and utilization rate, and water consumption per unit GDP; environmental pressure includes two indicator layers, namely, COD emission intensity into the river and ammonia nitrogen emission intensity into the river. The social pressure theme layer includes two indicators, population density and the proportion of the primary and secondary industries in GDP, to reflect the basic socio-economic pressures directly faced by the water system. The resource pressure theme layer includes four indicators, namely, per capita construction land area, water source security level, surface water development and utilization rate, and water consumption per unit GDP, to reflect the pressure faced by water resource utilization and water system layout in urban construction and development. The environmental pressure theme layer includes two indicators, COD emission intensity into the river and ammonia nitrogen emission intensity into the river, to reflect the pollution load input pressure faced by urban water systems.

[0032] In some embodiments, in the state dimension, the water resource state includes two indicators, namely, the water surface area ratio and the river-lake connection; the water environment state includes four indicators, namely, the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class V and below, the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class III and above, the water quality compliance rate of the water function area, and the water quality compliance rate of the outbound section; the water ecological state includes two indicators, namely, the biological habitat status index and the ecological coastline ratio; the human settlement state includes two indicators, namely, the per capita green area and the hydrophilic landscape. The water resource state theme layer includes two indicators, namely, the water surface area ratio and the river-lake connection, to reflect the richness of water resources and the rationality of the layout of the city. The water environment state theme layer includes four indicators, namely, the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class V and below, the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class III and above, the water quality compliance rate of the water function area, and the water quality compliance rate of the outbound section, to reflect the state of urban water environment quality through common monitoring indicators. The water ecological state theme layer includes two indicators, namely, the biological habitat status index and the ecological coastline ratio, to reflect the health of water ecology at the urban scale. The theme layer of human settlement status includes two indicators: per capita green space (including wetlands) area and hydrophilic landscape, which reflect the quality of human settlement related to water system construction in the city.

[0033] In some embodiments, in the response dimension, the management response includes three indicators, namely, the ratio of water environment governance investment to GDP, the water resources monitoring and management capability index, and the monitoring rate of sewage outlets into rivers; the resource and environmental response includes four indicators, namely, the sewage collection and treatment rate, the sewage recycling rate, the proportion of sponge cities in built-up areas, and the effective utilization coefficient of farmland irrigation water; the social response includes two indicators, namely, the coverage rate of water ecological civilization publicity and education and the satisfaction of citizens with the water environment in a sample survey. The management response theme layer includes three indicators, namely, the ratio of water environment governance investment to GDP, the water resources monitoring and management capability index, and the monitoring rate of sewage outlets into rivers, to reflect the city's investment in water resources and water environment management, which is also the basic guarantee for achieving water-city integration. The resource and environmental response theme layer includes four indicators, namely, the sewage collection and treatment rate, the sewage recycling rate, the proportion of sponge cities in built-up areas, and the effective utilization coefficient of farmland irrigation water, to reflect the city's engineering investment in water resources utilization and water environment improvement. The social response theme layer includes two indicators: the coverage rate of water ecological civilization publicity and education and the satisfaction of citizens with the water environment in a sample survey, which reflect the relationship between the public and the water system in the city and their satisfaction with the water system construction.

[0034] like Figure 2 As shown, the meaning and calculation method of each indicator in the indicator layer are explained below:

[0035] (1) Population density

[0036] 1) Index meaning: Population density is the number of people per unit area of ​​land. Population density is an important indicator for studying the characteristics and pattern of urban population distribution. The characteristics of urban population distribution are closely related to the environment and are one of the hot topics in urban geography research.

[0037] 2) Calculation method: Population density = population of the assessed area / area of ​​the assessed area (person / km2) 2 )

[0038] The standard value is 3500 people / km 2 , indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value

[0039] (2) Proportion of primary and secondary industries in GDP

[0040] 1) Meaning of the indicator: The proportion of the total output value of the primary and secondary industries in the regional GDP.

[0041] 2) Calculation method: The proportion of primary and secondary industries in GDP = the sum of the output value of primary and secondary industries / regional GDP × 100%

[0042] The standard value is 55%, indicator score = 1-indicator calculation value / standard value

[0043] (3) Per capita construction land area

[0044] 1) Indicator meaning: The urban construction land area in the town where the city and county people's government are located divided by the number of permanent residents in the central urban area (township). The per capita construction land area is closely related to urban planning and development.

[0045] 2) Calculation method: Per capita construction land area = urban construction land area / permanent population

[0046] The standard value is 120m 2 / person, indicator score = 1-indicator calculation value / standard value

[0047] (4) Water source security

[0048] 1) Meaning of the indicator: In what proportion of special drought years can the city's water supply be fully met. The degree of water source security can represent the scientific structure of water sources, the realization of multi-source water supply, and the ability to resist sudden water pollution incidents.

[0049] 2) Calculation method: Calculated based on water resources model

[0050] The standard value is 95%, and the indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value

[0051] (5) Surface water development and utilization rate

[0052] 1) Meaning of the indicator: The percentage of surface water supply to surface water resources.

[0053] 2) Calculation method: Surface water development and utilization rate = surface water supply / surface water resources × 100%

[0054] Index score = 1-index calculation value

[0055] (6) Water consumption per unit of GDP

[0056] 1) Meaning of the indicator: refers to the amount of water used to produce one unit of regional GDP.

[0057] 2) Calculation method: Water consumption per unit of GDP = water consumption in the assessment area / total GDP of the assessment area (m 3 / Yuan)

[0058] The standard value is 150m 3 / yuan, indicator score = 1-indicator calculation value / standard value

[0059] (7) COD emission intensity into the river

[0060] 1) Index meaning: The total amount of COD discharged into the river per unit of GDP of the assessed area

[0061] 2) Calculation method: COD emission intensity per unit GDP = (COD industrial emissions in the assessed area + COD domestic source emissions - additional COD reduction in the year) / gross national product of the assessed area

[0062] The standard value is calculated with reference to the total COD emission limit target and GDP target in the planning of the assessed area.

[0063] Index score = 1-index calculated value / standard value

[0064] (8) Ammonia nitrogen emission intensity into rivers

[0065] 1) Index meaning: The total amount of ammonia nitrogen discharged into the river per unit of GDP of the assessed area

[0066] 2) Calculation method: Ammonia nitrogen emission intensity per unit GDP = (ammonia nitrogen industrial emission in the assessed area + ammonia nitrogen domestic source emission - new ammonia nitrogen reduction in the year) / gross national product of the assessed area

[0067] The standard value is calculated based on the total ammonia nitrogen emission limit target and GDP target in the planning of the assessed area.

[0068] Index score = 1-index calculated value / standard value

[0069] (9) Water surface area ratio

[0070] 1) Meaning of the indicator: Water surface usually refers to the surface of water bodies formed by rivers (rivers, canals, etc.), lakes (natural or artificial lakes), reservoirs, wetlands (natural or artificial wetlands), etc. The water surface area ratio refers to the ratio of the area carrying water functions within a certain area to the total area of ​​the area. The so-called water function refers to the functions of the water area to directly provide available water sources, regulate regional water resources, degrade pollutants and absorb nutrients, protect biodiversity, leisure tourism, shipping, and regulate climate. Suitable water surface area can not only regulate temperature and humidity, purify air, absorb dust and reduce noise, improve urban microclimate, and improve the ecological environment of the city, but also promote the development of the economy and tourism of the entire city, thereby achieving the two major goals of improving the ecological quality of urban areas and improving the quality of urban living space.

[0071] 2) Calculation method: Water surface area ratio = area of ​​the region carrying water area function / total area of ​​the region × 100%

[0072] The standard value is 12%, and the indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value

[0073] (10) River-lake connectivity

[0074] 1) Meaning of the indicator: The number of water surface breakpoints per 100 km of river length can reflect the connectivity and controllability of the water system.

[0075] 2) Calculation method: W = N / L, W = connectivity index, N - the number of river surface breakpoints (such as gates, dams, etc.), gates and dams with fish-passing facilities, small waterfalls and overflow dams that do not affect the passage of fish, and water diversion facilities built in plain water network areas to improve the water environment and gates and dams that are in a diversion state for more than 60% of the year are not included in the statistical scope; L - the length of the river. The rivers participating in the evaluation are those with a basin area of ​​100km 2 Above the river.

[0076] Index score = 1-index calculation value

[0077] (11) The proportion of water quality in the monitored sections that is Class V or below

[0078] 1) Meaning of the indicator: The ratio of the number of monitored sections with water quality of Class V or below to the total number of monitored sections.

[0079] 2) Calculation method: The proportion of monitored sections with water quality of Class V or below = the number of sections in the assessed area that meet the "Surface Water Environmental Quality Standard" with water quality of Class V or below (including Class V) / the total number of monitored sections × 100%

[0080] Index score = 1-index calculation value

[0081] (12) Proportion of water quality in monitored sections that is Class III or above

[0082] 1) Meaning of the indicator: The ratio of the number of monitored sections with water quality of Class III or above to the total number of monitored sections.

[0083] 2) Calculation method: The proportion of monitored sections with water quality of Class III or above = the number of sections in the assessed area that meet the "Surface Water Environmental Quality Standard" Class III or above (including Class III) / the total number of monitored sections × 100%

[0084] Index score = Index calculation value

[0085] (13) Water quality compliance rate of water functional areas

[0086] 1) Meaning of the indicator: In a certain water system (river, lake), the ratio of the number of water functional areas (river length, area) that meet their water quality targets to the total number of water functional areas evaluated (total river length, total area).

[0087] 2) Calculation method: Water quality compliance rate of water functional areas = number of water quality compliance areas in the evaluated water functional areas / total number of water functional areas participating in the evaluation × 100%

[0088] The standard value is 100%, and the indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value

[0089] (14) Water quality compliance rate at outbound sections

[0090] 1) Meaning of the indicator: The assessment section is evaluated using monthly manual monitoring values ​​or automatic water quality monitoring values, and the percentage of monitoring times that achieve the planning target in the total annual monitoring times.

[0091] 2) Calculation method: Water quality compliance rate of outbound sections = number of compliance times of the assessment section / total number of monitoring times of the assessment section × 100%

[0092] The standard value is 100%, and the indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value

[0093] (15) Biological habitat condition index

[0094] 1) Indicator meaning: Biological habitat is a combination of physical and chemical conditions at multiple scales that have direct or indirect impacts on aquatic organisms. Biological habitat quality assessment is to assess the suitability of the physical and chemical conditions, hydrological conditions and river geomorphological characteristics of the river for the biological community. River biological habitat is related to the biological food chain and energy flow process, and directly reflects the health of the river.

[0095] 2) Calculation method: The biological habitat survey procedure divides the watershed into several overall river sections, and selects representative local river sections from the overall river sections. In each local river section, the habitat is scored and evaluated using factors such as hydrology, vegetation type, land use, habitat type, river cross section, river bank slope characteristics, river bottom quality, and aesthetic value.

[0096] Grading Standard:

[0097] grade excellent good middle Difference inferior state nature good generally interference Loss Points 85-100 75-84 60-74 50-59 1-49

[0098] The standard value is 100, and the indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value

[0099] (16) Ecological coastline ratio

[0100] 1) Indicator meaning: It refers to the ratio of the length of ecological revetments to the total length of artificial revetments in the assessed area, except for river sections where flood control clearly requires hardened revetments.

[0101] 2) Calculation method: Proportion of ecological revetments of rivers and lakes = length of ecological revetments in the assessed area / total length of artificial revetments × 100%

[0102] Index score = index calculation value

[0103] (17) Green space (including wetlands) per capita

[0104] 1) Indicator meaning: Urban green space refers to land covered with artificial (or natural) vegetation within the urban built-up area or planning area, and it has various forms. Green space area refers to the area of ​​various green spaces used for gardening and greening, including public green space, residential green space, unit-affiliated green space, protective green space, production green space, road green space and scenic forest area. Per capita green space (including wetlands) area refers to the average green space area that citizens can enjoy, that is, the average green space area that each person can own.

[0105] 2) Calculation method: Agm = (Ag1 + Ag2 + Ag3 + Ag4) / Np (m 2 / people)

[0106] Where Agm is the per capita green area (m 2 / person); Ag1——park green area (m 2 ); Ag2——production green area (m 2 ); Ag3——protective green space area (m 2 ); Ag4——Attached green area (m 2 );Np——urban population (person).

[0107] The standard value is 16m 2 / person, indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value

[0108] (18) Waterfront Landscape

[0109] 1) Meaning of indicators: The landscape construction has a prominent water culture theme and distinct characteristics; the water project is integrated with the surrounding environment and the landscape effect is good; there are water conservancy scenic spots, wetland parks, nature reserves, etc. at or above the provincial level.

[0110] 2) Calculation method: Expert scoring method, scoring is based on several aspects involved in the meaning.

[0111] Grading Standard:

[0112] grade excellent good middle Difference inferior state nature good generally interference Loss Points 85-100 75-84 60-74 50-59 1-49

[0113] The standard value is 100, and the indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value

[0114] (19) Ratio of water environment management investment to GDP

[0115] 1) Meaning of the indicator: The percentage of investment in water ecological environment projects in the evaluated city’s GDP.

[0116] 2) Calculation method: The ratio of water environment governance investment to GDP = water environment governance investment of the assessed area / total GDP of the assessed area × 100%

[0117] The standard value is 2%, and the indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value

[0118] (20) Water resources monitoring and management capability index

[0119] 1) Indicator meaning: The monitoring team, plan, facilities and equipment basically meet the requirements for monitoring and evaluating changes in aquatic ecosystems.

[0120] 2) Calculation method: The score of this indicator is obtained by calculating the arithmetic average of the scores of the three sub-indicators respectively. The three sub-indicators are: water withdrawal metering rate, water quality monitoring and evaluation rate of water functional areas, and monitoring rate of sewage outlets into rivers.

[0121] Water metering rate = water consumption based on measured data / total water consumption in the evaluation area × 100%, standard value 100%, index score = index calculation value / standard value;

[0122] Water quality monitoring and evaluation rate of water functional areas = number of water quality monitoring areas in water functional areas / total number of water functional areas × 100%, standard value 100%, index score = index calculation value / standard value;

[0123] Detection rate of sewage outlets into rivers = number of sewage outlets into rivers monitored regularly or online / total number of sewage outlets into rivers in the assessed area × 100%, standard value 100%, indicator score = indicator calculation value / standard value;

[0124] The comprehensive index score is the arithmetic mean of the above three sub-indicators.

[0125] (21) Monitoring rate of sewage outlets into rivers

[0126] 1) Indicator meaning: The ratio of the number of sewage outlets into the river monitored regularly or online to the total number of sewage outlets into the river in the assessed area.

[0127] 2) Calculation method: Detection rate of sewage outlets into rivers = number of sewage outlets into rivers monitored regularly or online / total number of sewage outlets into rivers in the assessed area × 100%.

[0128] The standard value is 100%, and the indicator score = indicator calculated value / standard value.

[0129] (22) Wastewater collection and treatment rate

[0130] 1) Meaning of the indicator: The ratio of the amount of domestic and industrial wastewater treated in the assessed area that meets the standards to the total amount of wastewater discharged.

[0131] 2) Calculation method: Sewage collection and treatment rate = wastewater treatment volume that meets standards / wastewater discharge volume × 100%.

[0132] The standard value is 100%, and the indicator score = indicator calculated value / standard value.

[0133] (23) Wastewater recycling rate

[0134] 1) Indicator meaning: ratio of annual sewage treatment and reuse volume to annual sewage treatment volume.

[0135] 2) Calculation method: The amount of sewage treatment reuse includes three parts: effluent from the reclaimed water plant; the effluent from the sewage treatment plant is introduced into the water-using enterprises through a dedicated water supply pipeline, and the water is used after deep treatment by the water-using enterprises; the effluent from the sewage treatment plant meets the water conservancy industry standard "Reclaimed Water Quality Standard" and is directly used for ecological environmental replenishment and agricultural irrigation.

[0136] Water recycling rate = annual sewage treatment reuse volume / annual sewage treatment volume × 100%.

[0137] The standard value is 70%, and the indicator score = indicator calculated value / standard value.

[0138] (24) Proportion of sponge cities in built-up areas

[0139] 1) Indicator meaning: The rapid development of cities has changed the natural pattern of the surface and the precipitation pattern over the city (rain island effect), causing distortion of the water cycle process. Sponge cities can alleviate urban waterlogging, increase rainwater utilization, and reduce runoff pollution. The proportion of sponge cities in built-up areas is the proportion of sponge city construction area in the built-up area to the total urban area.

[0140] 2) Calculation method: Sponge city ratio = sponge city construction area / total urban area × 100%

[0141] The standard value is 50%, and the indicator score = indicator calculated value / standard value.

[0142] (25) Effective utilization coefficient of agricultural irrigation water

[0143] 1) Meaning of the indicator: During the irrigation period, the ratio of the actual effectively utilized water volume on the irrigated area, excluding deep seepage and field loss, to the total water inflow at the canal head. It is related to factors such as the natural conditions of the irrigation area, engineering conditions, water use management level, and irrigation technology.

[0144] 2) Calculation method: Effective utilization coefficient of agricultural irrigation water = actual effective utilization of water in the irrigation area excluding deep seepage and field loss / total water inflow at the channel head.

[0145] The standard value is 0.7, and the indicator score = indicator calculated value / standard value.

[0146] (26) Water ecological civilization publicity and education coverage rate

[0147] 1) Index meaning: the ratio of the number of people who directly participated in the publicity and education activities related to water culture, water ecology, etc. in the evaluated area to the permanent population. The number of direct participants includes the number of visitors to educational bases, museums, cultural festivals and other carriers with the main nature of publicity and education, but does not include the number of visitors to water conservancy scenic spots, wetland parks, nature reserves and other carriers with the main nature of scenic spots.

[0148] 2) Calculation method: Water ecological civilization publicity and education coverage rate = number of direct participants in water culture, water ecology and other related publicity and education activities in the assessed area / total permanent population × 100%.

[0149] The standard value is 100%, and the indicator score = indicator calculated value / standard value.

[0150] (27) Sample survey of citizens’ satisfaction with water environment

[0151] 1) Meaning of the indicator: The proportion of respondents who are satisfied with the overall water environment in the region. The indicator value is obtained through a sampling survey conducted by professional statistical departments.

[0152] 2) Calculation method: Citizens’ satisfaction with the water environment in the sample survey = the number of respondents who are satisfied with the overall water environment in the region / the total number of respondents in the sample survey × 100%.

[0153] The standard value is 100%, and the indicator score = indicator calculated value / standard value.

[0154] In some embodiments, when determining the calculation method of each indicator in step S1, the value of each indicator is obtained, analyzed and calculated based on literature statistics, measurement and on-site monitoring.

[0155] In some embodiments, in step S3, the calculation formula is:

[0156] Among them, WCI is the comprehensive index of water city integration, F i is the weight of the i-th dimension, P j is the weight of the j-th topic layer, Q k is the weight of the kth evaluation index, W k is the value of the kth evaluation index, n is the number of dimensions, m is the number of topic layers, and k is the number of evaluation indicators.

[0157] In some embodiments, in step S4, the comprehensive evaluation level standard of water-city integration is divided into five levels, namely, initial stage, development stage, intermediate stage, stable stage and advanced stage.

[0158] Specifically, referring to the evaluation levels of ecological civilization construction at home and abroad, the evaluation levels are divided into 5 levels in the comprehensive evaluation of water-city integration, and the value of the Water-City Integration Comprehensive Index (WCI) is used as the evaluation standard, as shown in the table.

[0159] Table Water City Inclusion Comprehensive Index Evaluation Level

[0160]

[0161] Specific implementation cases

[0162] In order to respond to the goal of building a water city in the sub-center of Beijing, the sub-center of Beijing was selected as the research area, and the "Statistical Yearbook of Tongzhou District, Beijing (2018)", "Statistical Yearbook of Tongzhou District, Beijing (2017)", "Statistical Bulletin of National Economic and Social Development of Tongzhou District (2017)",

[0163] The indicators were collected and calculated based on the literature such as Beijing Water Statistical Yearbook (2017), Administrative Division of Tongzhou District People's Government of Beijing (2018), Water Pollution Prevention and Control Work Plan of Tongzhou District (2018), and Progress Report on Water Pollution Prevention and Control Work in Tongzhou District in the First Three Quarters of 2018. Through comprehensive calculation, the comprehensive water-city integration index of Beijing's sub-center in 2018 was 0.32, which belongs to the development stage. The future city positioning was studied, and the values ​​of various indicators of the sub-center in 2035 were estimated in combination with various plans of the sub-center. The WCI comprehensive index should be 0.83, which belongs to the advanced stage.

[0164] The above description is only the preferred embodiment of the present application and is not intended to limit the present application. For those skilled in the art, the present application may have various modifications and variations. Any modification, equivalent replacement, improvement, etc. made within the spirit and principle of the present application shall be included in the protection scope of the present application.

Claims

1. A water-city integration evaluation method, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: S1. Construct a comprehensive evaluation index system for water-city integration; Starting from the goal of water city integration construction, the comprehensive evaluation index system of water city integration is divided into three dimensions: pressure dimension, state dimension and response dimension; each dimension is classified to determine the theme layer contained in each dimension, and based on each theme layer under each dimension, several indicators in each theme layer are selected to form an indicator layer; the meaning of each indicator and the calculation method of each indicator are determined, and the indicator score of each indicator is calculated; S2. Use the analytic hierarchy process to screen effective indicators and determine the contribution weights of each indicator in each dimension, theme layer and indicator layer; S3. Based on the contribution weights and indicator scores of each dimension, each theme layer and each indicator layer, the comprehensive evaluation score of water city integration is calculated according to the calculation formula of the comprehensive index of water city integration; S4. Determine the comprehensive evaluation grade of water city integration according to the comprehensive evaluation score and based on the evaluation grade standard of the comprehensive index of water city integration.

2. The water-city integration evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S1, the stress dimension includes three subject layers, namely social stress, resource stress and environmental stress; The state dimension includes four thematic layers, namely, water resource state, water environment state, water ecological state and human settlement state; The response dimension includes three subject layers, namely management response, resource and environmental response, and social response.

3. The water-city integration evaluation method according to claim 2, characterized in that: In the pressure dimension, the social pressure includes two indicators, namely population density and the proportion of the primary and secondary industries in the regional GDP; the resource pressure includes four indicators, namely per capita construction land area, water source security, surface water development and utilization rate, and water consumption per unit GDP; the environmental pressure includes two indicators, namely COD emission intensity into rivers and ammonia nitrogen emission intensity into rivers.

4. The water-city integration evaluation method according to claim 2, characterized in that: In the status dimension, the water resource status includes two indicators, namely, the water surface area ratio and river-lake connectivity; the water environment status includes four indicators, namely, the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class V and below, the proportion of water quality in the monitoring section at Class III and above, the water quality compliance rate of the water functional area, and the water quality compliance rate of the outbound section; the water ecological status includes two indicators, namely, the biological habitat status index and the proportion of ecological coastline; the human settlement status includes two indicators, namely, per capita green space area and hydrophilic landscape.

5. The water-city integration evaluation method according to claim 2, characterized in that: In the response dimension, the management response includes three indicators, namely, the ratio of water environment governance investment to GDP, the water resources monitoring and management capacity index, and the monitoring rate of sewage outlets into rivers; the resource and environmental response includes four indicators, namely, sewage collection and treatment rate, sewage recycling rate, proportion of sponge cities in built-up areas, and effective utilization coefficient of farmland irrigation water; the social response includes two indicators, namely, the coverage rate of water ecological civilization publicity and education and the satisfaction of citizens with the water environment in a sample survey.

6. The water-city integration evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: When determining the calculation method of each indicator of the indicator layer in step S1, the value of each indicator is obtained, analyzed and calculated based on literature statistics, measurement and on-site investigation and monitoring.

7. The water-city integration evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S3, the calculation formula is: Among them, WCI is the comprehensive index of water city integration, F i is the weight of the i-th dimension, P j is the weight of the j-th topic layer, Q k is the weight of the kth evaluation index, W k is the value of the kth evaluation index, n is the number of dimensions, m is the number of topic layers, and k is the number of evaluation indicators.

8. The water-city integration evaluation method according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step S4, the comprehensive index evaluation level standard of water-city integration is divided into five levels, namely, initial stage, development stage, intermediate stage, stable stage and advanced stage.