Recovery trajectory tracking control method for suppressing continuous commutation failure of direct current power transmission system
By designing the desired recovery trajectory of the arc extinguishing angle and combining feedforward and error feedback control, the inverter side commutation failure caused by open-loop PI control in traditional high-voltage DC transmission systems is solved, and the safe and stable operation and fault recovery of the system are achieved.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410944949.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-15
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
AI Technical Summary
In traditional high-voltage DC power transmission systems, open-loop PI controllers are likely to cause inverter side phase commutation failure, resulting in continuous phase commutation failure, endangering the safe and stable operation of the power grid.
The desired recovery trajectory of the arc extinguishing angle is designed based on the actual response curve of the arc extinguishing angle after the fault. Combined with feedforward control and error feedback compensation control, the advance trigger angle command value is generated in real time, and the response delay is reduced through closed-loop control, suppress overshooting, and prevent subsequent Failed to exchange.
It effectively suppresses overshoot in traditional control, responds quickly to changes in arc extinguishing angles, prevents subsequent phase exchange failures, and ensures the safe and stable operation of the high-voltage DC transmission system.
Smart Images

Figure CN118920839A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention belongs to the technical field of power systems, and relates to inverter-side commutation failure recovery control in a conventional high-voltage direct current transmission project, and in particular to a recovery trajectory tracking control method for a system that suppresses continuous commutation failures in direct current transmission. Background Art
[0002] Commutation failure on the inverter side is the most common fault in HVDC transmission systems. Since thyristors only have self-conduction capability but not self-shutdown capability, when a fault occurs in the receiving AC system, commutation failure is prone to occur on the inverter side. During the commutation failure process, the DC power drops rapidly. At this time, the AC / DC hybrid operation system exhibits strong nonlinearity, the interaction is very complex, and the dynamic response characteristics of fault recovery are poor. The inverter side of traditional HVDC transmission uses an open-loop PI controller for control, which is prone to overshoot and thus causes continuous commutation failure. Continuous commutation failure seriously endangers the safe and stable operation of the power grid, and ultimately leads to DC system blocking, power transmission suspension, etc. Therefore, it is of great theoretical and practical significance to improve the control method of the HVDC transmission system to suppress continuous commutation failure. Summary of the invention
[0003] In view of the deficiencies in the above-mentioned prior art, the present invention proposes a recovery trajectory tracking control method for suppressing continuous commutation failure of a DC transmission system, so as to prevent the open-loop PI controller in a traditional high-voltage DC transmission system from overshooting and causing continuous commutation failure.
[0004] In order to achieve the above object, the present invention adopts the following technical solution: a recovery trajectory tracking control method for suppressing continuous commutation failure of a direct current transmission system, comprising the following steps:
[0005] Step (1), based on the maximum value of the arc extinction angle trajectory in the actual arc extinction angle response curve after the fault and the time elapsed since the commutation failure was detected, the rapid recovery time after the commutation failure is set according to the system tolerance, and the expected recovery trajectory of the arc extinction angle is designed;
[0006] Step (2), using the DC system operating parameters, ignoring the short-term fluctuation of the DC current, calculate the commutation failure critical voltage;
[0007] Step (3) generates the leading trigger angle command value in real time based on the designed arc extinction angle expected recovery trajectory and combining the feedforward control and error feedback compensation control methods.
[0008] Furthermore, in the step (1):
[0009] Design the expected recovery trajectory of the arc extinction angle, the formula is expressed as:
[0010]
[0011] Where: γ d (t) is the expected value of the arc extinction angle, γ r is the arc extinction angle rating, γ max is the maximum value of the arc extinction angle trajectory, t r is the fast recovery time after commutation failure, and t is the time elapsed since the commutation failure was detected.
[0012] Furthermore, in the step (2):
[0013] The critical voltage that does not cause commutation failure after a fault (commutation failure critical voltage) ΔU LC for:
[0014]
[0015] Where: X rpu is the per unit value of the equivalent commutation reactance on the inverter side, γ min It is the minimum arc extinction angle on the inverter side.
[0016] Furthermore, the step (3) comprises:
[0017] (3.1) According to the designed desired arc extinction angle trajectory, the advance firing angle command value is generated in real time through feedforward control. The calculation formula is:
[0018]
[0019] Where: β T The leading firing angle command value generated by the feedforward control, V m is the effective value of the AC bus voltage, X r is the equivalent commutation reactance on the inverter side, k is the transformation ratio of the inverter side converter transformer, i I_dc is the DC current on the inverter side.
[0020] (3.2) In view of the uncertainty and internal and external disturbances in the system, a PI controller is introduced to feedback control the error to achieve accurate tracking of the desired output trajectory and calculate the compensation value of the lead trigger angle:
[0021]
[0022] Where: β C is the leading trigger angle command compensation value, k p and k i are the proportional coefficient and integral coefficient of the PI controller respectively, and γ is the measured value of the arc extinction angle on the inverter side.
[0023] (3.3) Combining feedforward control and error feedback control, the inverter side leading firing angle command value is generated according to the control law based on recovery trajectory tracking:
[0024] β d =β T -β C
[0025] Where: β d To achieve the desired arc extinction angle γ on the inverter side of the HVDC system d The advanced firing angle command value required when
[0026] The beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows:
[0027] In order to solve the problem of overshoot in open-loop PI control in traditional HVDC transmission systems, a closed-loop control method based on recovery trajectory tracking is proposed. This method combines feedforward control and error feedback compensation control, significantly reduces the response delay in traditional control through closed-loop control, and quickly responds to changes in the arc extinction angle. In addition, trajectory tracking closed-loop control can effectively suppress overshoot, thereby preventing subsequent commutation failures and ensuring the safe and stable operation of the HVDC transmission system. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0028] Figure 1 The desired trajectory of the arc extinction angle designed for the present invention;
[0029] Figure 2 It is a schematic diagram of the control method of the present invention;
[0030] Figure 3 This is a simplified diagram of the CIGRE standard simulation model;
[0031] Figure 4 A schematic diagram of the inverter side control method after the present invention is applied to a conventional DC power transmission system;
[0032] Figure 5 Schematic diagram of the three-phase ground fault recovery response of the HVDC transmission system under different control methods. (a) Arc extinction angle on the inverter side; (b) AC bus voltage on the inverter side; (c) DC current; (d) DC power;
[0033] Figure 6 Schematic diagram of the single-phase ground fault recovery response of the HVDC transmission system under different control methods. (a) Arc extinction angle on the inverter side; (b) AC bus voltage on the inverter side; (c) DC current; (d) DC power; DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0034] The present invention provides a recovery trajectory tracking control method for suppressing continuous commutation failure of a direct current transmission system, comprising the following steps:
[0035] (1) Based on the maximum value of the arc extinction angle trajectory in the actual response curve of the arc extinction angle after the fault and the time since the commutation failure was detected, the rapid recovery time after the commutation failure is set according to the system tolerance, and the expected recovery trajectory of the arc extinction angle is designed, such as Figure 1 As shown in Figure 1, the trajectory is mainly divided into two parts: the fast recovery period and the stable recovery period. From the moment the system detects the commutation failure, the system enters the fault fast recovery period, and the arc extinction angle is set to the maximum value γ max , and then gradually decreases at a constant slope. After time t r , the arc extinction angle is reduced to the normal operating value γ r After that, it remains constant and the system enters a stable recovery period. The formula for the expected recovery trajectory of the arc extinction angle is expressed as:
[0036]
[0037] Where: γ d (t) is the expected value of the arc extinction angle, γ r is the arc extinction angle rating, γ max is the maximum value of the arc extinction angle trajectory, t r is the fast recovery time after commutation failure, and t is the time elapsed since the commutation failure was detected.
[0038] (2) Using the DC system operating parameters and ignoring the short-term fluctuations of the DC current, calculate the critical voltage for commutation failure, that is, the critical voltage ΔU that does not cause commutation failure after a fault. LC , the calculation formula is:
[0039]
[0040] Where: X rpu is the per unit value of the equivalent commutation reactance on the inverter side, γ min It is the minimum arc extinction angle on the inverter side.
[0041] (3) Based on the designed arc extinction angle expected recovery trajectory, combined with the feedforward control and error feedback compensation control methods, the leading trigger angle command value is generated in real time. It includes the following sub-steps:
[0042] (3.1) According to the designed desired arc extinction angle trajectory, the advance firing angle command value is generated in real time through feedforward control. The calculation formula is:
[0043]
[0044] Where: β T The leading firing angle command value generated by the feedforward control, V m is the effective value of the AC bus voltage, X r is the equivalent commutation reactance on the inverter side, k is the transformation ratio of the inverter side converter transformer, i I_dcis the DC current on the inverter side.
[0045] (3.2) In view of the uncertainty and internal and external disturbances in the system, a PI controller is introduced to feedback control the error to achieve accurate tracking of the desired output trajectory and calculate the compensation value of the lead trigger angle:
[0046]
[0047] Where: β C is the leading trigger angle command compensation value, k p and k i are the proportional coefficient and integral coefficient of the PI controller respectively, and γ is the measured value of the arc extinction angle on the inverter side.
[0048] (3.3) Figure 2 As shown, by combining feedforward control and error feedback control, the inverter side leading trigger angle command value is generated:
[0049] β d =β T -β C
[0050] Where: β d To achieve the desired arc extinction angle γ on the inverter side of the HVDC system d The advanced firing angle command value required when
[0051] The present invention is further described below by means of an embodiment in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0052] Example 1
[0053] This embodiment uses PSCAD / EMDTC electromagnetic transient simulation software to perform simulation analysis based on the CIGRE standard model.
[0054] like Figure 3 As shown in Figure 1, the CIGRE standard model consists of a single-stage HVDC transmission system consisting of a 12-pulse converter. The main parameters of the system are shown in Table 1.
[0055] Table 1 Main parameters of high voltage DC system
[0056]
[0057] First, according to step (1), the maximum value of the arc extinction angle trajectory is set to 15 degrees, and the fast recovery time after commutation failure is set to 0.5 seconds. The formula for the expected recovery trajectory of the arc extinction angle is expressed as:
[0058]
[0059] Secondly, according to step (2):
[0060] The critical voltage ΔU that does not cause commutation failure after a fault LC for:
[0061]
[0062] Where: X rpu is the per unit value of the equivalent commutation reactance on the inverter side, γ min is the minimum value of the arc extinction angle on the inverter side. The critical voltage of commutation failure is calculated to be 0.87pu.
[0063] The leading firing angle command value is generated in real time according to step (3), specifically:
[0064] (3.1) According to the designed desired arc extinction angle trajectory, the advance firing angle command value is generated in real time through feedforward control. The calculation formula is:
[0065]
[0066] Where: β T The leading firing angle command value generated by the feedforward control, V m is the effective value of the AC bus voltage, X r is the equivalent commutation reactance on the inverter side, k is the transformation ratio of the inverter side converter transformer, i I_dc is the DC current on the inverter side.
[0067] (3.2) In view of the uncertainty and internal and external disturbances in the system, a PI controller is introduced to feedback control the error to achieve accurate tracking of the desired output trajectory. The proportional coefficient and integral coefficient of the PI controller are taken as 1 and 2 respectively, and the compensation value of the lead trigger angle is calculated:
[0068]
[0069] Where: β C is the compensation value of the leading trigger angle command, and γ is the measured value of the arc extinction angle on the inverter side.
[0070] (3.3) Figure 2 As shown, by combining feedforward control and error feedback control, the inverter side leading trigger angle command value is generated:
[0071] β d =β T -β C
[0072] Where: β d To achieve the desired arc extinction angle γ on the inverter side of the HVDC system d The advanced firing angle command value required when
[0073] Based on the traditional constant current control and fixed arc extinction angle control, a trajectory tracking controller is constructed in the CIGRE standard model according to the above steps. The control method is as follows: Figure 4 In general, the leading trigger angle on the inverter side takes the maximum value of the fixed current control, fixed arc extinction angle control and trajectory tracking control:
[0074] β I =max{β I_CC ,β I_CEA ,β d}
[0075] Where: β I It is the leading trigger angle command value of the system inverter side.
[0076] When a fault occurs in the inverter-side AC system, the AC bus voltage drops rapidly. When the voltage amplitude is less than the set critical voltage for commutation failure, trajectory tracking control begins to work. This control method will quickly increase the Echizen trigger angle to the expected value and perform tracking control according to the set trajectory to suppress system overshoot and subsequent commutation failure.
[0077] The fault recovery responses under the following two control methods are compared and analyzed respectively:
[0078] Method 1: CIGRE standard system control method.
[0079] Method 2: The present invention adds a proposed recovery trajectory tracking control method based on Method 1.
[0080] 1) Set a three-phase ground fault at the inverter side commutation busbar, and the ground inductance L f The fault recovery response of the system using method 1 and method 2 is as follows: Figure 5 shown.
[0081] Depend on Figure 5 (a) It can be seen that when method 1 is used, the turn-off angle drops to 0 twice in a row, resulting in continuous commutation failure. Figure 5 (c)(d) It can be seen that the DC current and DC power fluctuated greatly during the commutation failure, which seriously threatened the system safety. When method 2 was used, after the fault occurred, under the action of the closed-loop trajectory tracking control method, the rise of DC current was suppressed in about 1.15 seconds, and the system did not experience subsequent commutation failure. The DC current, DC voltage and DC power were also able to stabilize quickly. As the fault disappeared, the arc extinction angle remained at about 15 degrees, and the system gradually returned to normal steady-state operation.
[0082] 2) Set a single-phase ground fault at the inverter side commutation busbar, and the ground inductance L fis 0.392H, the fault starts at 1s, lasts for 0.5s, and the fault is cleared in 1.5s. Under this fault condition, the fault recovery response of the system using method 1 and method 2 is as follows Figure 6 shown.
[0083] Depend on Figure 6 It can be seen that under a single-phase grounding fault, four commutation failures will occur when using method 1. When using method 2, after the fault occurs, under the action of the closed-loop trajectory tracking control strategy, the rise of DC current after the first commutation failure is effectively suppressed, and the system does not have subsequent commutation failures. The DC current and DC power can also be stabilized quickly. Through analysis, it can be seen that the recovery trajectory tracking control strategy can effectively suppress the occurrence of subsequent commutation failures in both three-phase grounding and single-phase grounding faults.
Claims
1. A recovery trajectory tracking control method for suppressing continuous commutation failure of a DC transmission system, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: (1) Based on the maximum value of the arc extinction angle trajectory in the actual response curve of the arc extinction angle after the fault and the time elapsed since the commutation failure was detected, the rapid recovery time after the commutation failure is set according to the system tolerance, and the expected recovery trajectory of the arc extinction angle is designed; (2) Using the DC system operating parameters and ignoring the short-term fluctuations of the DC current, calculate the critical voltage for commutation failure; (3) Based on the designed arc extinction angle expected recovery trajectory, the advance trigger angle command value is generated in real time through feedforward control and error feedback compensation control methods.
2. The recovery trajectory tracking control method for suppressing continuous commutation failure of a DC power transmission system according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In the step (1), the expected recovery trajectory of the arc extinction angle is designed, and the formula is expressed as: Where: γ d (t) is the expected value of the arc extinction angle, γ r is the arc extinction angle rating, γ max is the maximum value of the arc extinction angle trajectory, t r is the fast recovery time after commutation failure, and t is the time elapsed since the commutation failure was detected.
3. The recovery trajectory tracking control method for suppressing continuous commutation failure of a DC power transmission system according to claim 1, characterized in that: In step (2), the commutation failure critical voltage ΔU LC The calculation formula is: Where: X rpu is the per unit value of the equivalent commutation reactance on the inverter side, γ min It is the minimum arc extinction angle on the inverter side.
4. The recovery trajectory tracking control method for suppressing continuous commutation failure of a DC power transmission system according to claim 1, characterized in that: The step (3) comprises the following sub-steps: (3.1) According to the designed desired arc extinction angle trajectory, the advance firing angle command value is generated in real time through feedforward control. The calculation formula is: Where: β T is the leading trigger angle command value, V m is the effective value of the AC bus voltage, X r is the equivalent commutation reactance on the inverter side, k is the transformation ratio of the inverter side converter transformer, i I_dc is the DC current on the inverter side; (3.2) A PI controller is introduced to feedback control the error to achieve accurate tracking of the desired output trajectory; the compensation value of the lead trigger angle is calculated: Where: β C is the leading firing angle command value, k p and k i are the proportional coefficient and integral coefficient of the PI controller respectively, and γ is the measured value of the arc extinction angle on the inverter side; (3.3) Combining feedforward control and error feedback control, the leading firing angle command value on the inverter side is generated according to the control law based on recovery trajectory tracking: βd d =β T -β C Where: β d To achieve the desired arc extinction angle γ on the inverter side of the HVDC system d The advanced firing angle command value required when
