Soil-plant system improvement method and soil-plant system improvement agent
By applying mixed improvers of sewage sludge, Chinese medicine residues and biochar in the soil, the pollution of antibiotics and resistance genes in the soil-plant system is solved, the antibiotic concentration and resistance gene number are reduced, and the soil environment and microorganisms are improved. Activity reduces the transport and absorption of antibiotics and increases soil fertility and oxygen content.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202311810585.9
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-06-08
- Filing Date
- 2023-12-26
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
AI Technical Summary
The concentration of antibiotics and the amount of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in the soil-plant system are too high, resulting in environmental pollution and human health risks, which are difficult to effectively reduce in the existing technology.
Improvers containing sewage sludge (SL), traditional Chinese medicine residues (CMHRs) and biochar (BC) were used to apply them to the soil by mixing different proportions of SL-CMHRs-BC to reduce the concentration of antibiotics and the number of ARGs in the soil.
It significantly reduces antibiotic concentration and ARGs abundance in soil and crop tissues, improves soil structure and microbial environment, weakens selection pressure, reduces antibiotic transportation and absorption, increases the nutrient and oxygen content of soil, and promotes antibiotics. Dissipate and degrade.
Smart Images

Figure CN118931545A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for improving a soil-plant system, and in particular to a method for reducing the concentration of antibiotics and / or the amount of antibiotic resistance genes (hereinafter referred to as "ARGs") in a soil-plant system, as well as an amending agent suitable for (but not limited to) amending a soil-plant system. Background Art
[0002] Sewage sludge (hereinafter referred to as "SL"), Chinese medicinal herb residues (hereinafter referred to as "CMHRs"), and biochar raw materials (hereinafter referred to as "BC") are usually disposed of as landfills. For example, according to a report released by the Environmental Protection Department of Hong Kong, China in 2018, more than one thousand tons of SL are squeezed into landfills in Hong Kong, China every day. In addition, 70 million tons of Chinese medicinal materials are used every year, and their residues are directly wasted in landfills in China and Hong Kong, China. As the population increases, it is foreseeable that more waste will be generated, and the saturation of landfills will cause serious problems for local sanitation and available land use.
[0003] SL is an organic waste product derived from the sewage treatment process. After sterilization (heating, acid-base treatment, dehydration and digestion), SL is a beneficial soil improvement ingredient that can reduce pathogenic and ecotoxicity levels. Applying sterilized and treated SL (also known as biosolids) to the soil can improve the soil's physical and chemical properties and water holding capacity, and provide essential nutrients such as nitrogen, phosphorus and potassium for better crop growth.
[0004] Biochar (BC) is widely used in soil to promote soil structural health and the development of soil microorganisms. The combination of BC-SL can increase carbon adsorption and fix organic pollutants (such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons), heavy metals and excess nutrients to avoid further eutrophication and pollution of aquatic environments. Similarly, the combination of BC and SL can make crops (such as shepherd's purse (Lepidium sativum) and corn (Zea mays)) grow better and increase yields.
[0005] Traditional Chinese medicine residues (CMHRs) are herbal waste or dregs extracted by decoction, which are composed of rich fibrous plant materials and organic carbon that can nourish the soil environment. Recent research focuses on the anti-pathogen capacity of CMHRs to reduce the pressure of soil-borne pathogens. For example, researchers have achieved the application of CMHRs in soil to promote the antagonism and fungal parasitism of some beneficial bacteria and fungi against soil-borne pathogens.
[0006] China is one of the largest producers and consumers of antibiotics. As of 2013, antibiotic production increased to about 200,000 tons, of which more than 50% was used in clinical and agricultural industries to ensure health safety and productivity. Overprescription and abuse of antibiotics have increased evolutionary pressure, leading to the emergence of antibiotic-resistant pathogens that are more tolerant to existing drugs. According to a report released in 2022, it is expected that 4.95 million deaths worldwide will be associated with infections with antibiotic-resistant pathogens. Bacteria usually acquire the ability to resist antibiotics through chromosomal mutations (such as release of antibiotic molecules through efflux pumps, reduced membrane permeability, modification of antibiotic target sites, and degradation or modification of target antibiotic structures). Unfortunately, the antibiotic resistance ability of bacteria is usually packaged into mobile elements, such as plasmids, and conferred to the surrounding population through transformation, transduction, and horizontal gene transfer. Tetracycline and sulfonamide resistance genes are two major antibiotic resistance genes ("ARGs") in bacteria that reproduce in terrestrial and marine environments. These genes gradually emerged due to over-reliance on tetracycline and sulfonamide drugs. Antibiotics and antibiotic-resistant bacteria are released as waste and enter the environment through a variety of ways such as wastewater irrigation and fertilizer application. They persist in the environment, expand their populations, contaminate the food chain, increase exposure to human pathogens, and ultimately reduce the effectiveness of clinical treatments.
[0007] Therefore, an object of the present invention is to provide a method for improving a soil-plant system, and an amendment suitable for (but not limited to) improving a soil-plant system, in which the above-mentioned disadvantages are alleviated or at least eliminated, or to provide the public with a useful alternative. Summary of the invention
[0008] According to a first aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method for reducing the concentration of antibiotics and / or the number of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in soil, comprising preparing an amendment comprising at least sewage sludge (SL), traditional Chinese medicine residues (CMHRs) and biochar (BC), and applying the amendment to the soil.
[0009] According to a second aspect of the present invention, there is provided an amendment for reducing the concentration of antibiotics and / or the amount of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in soil, comprising at least sewage sludge (SL), Chinese herbal medicine residues (CMHRs) and biochar (BC). BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0010] A soil-plant system improvement method according to an embodiment of the present invention and an amendment suitable for (but not limited to) improving a soil-plant system will now be described by way of example only with reference to the accompanying drawings, wherein:
[0011] Figure 1AThe concentrations of target antibiotics in soils irrigated with lettuce treated with wastewater treated with tetracycline (hereinafter referred to as “TC”) and sulfadimethoxine (hereinafter referred to as “SMZ”) at a concentration of 3 μg / L are shown. All data were statistically analyzed by one-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and post hoc Dunnett's test. * indicates significant at p < 0.05 compared with the control. Bars represent mean concentrations, and error bars represent standard deviations for all data (n = 5);
[0012] Figure 1B The concentrations of target antibiotics in soils irrigated with lettuce treated with wastewater at 30 μg / L were shown. All data were statistically analyzed by one-way ANOVA and post hoc Dunnett's test. * indicates significant at p < 0.05 compared with the control. Bars represent the mean concentration, and error bars represent the standard deviation of all data (n = 5);
[0013] Figure 2A The concentrations of target antibiotics in leaves / stems and roots of lettuce irrigated with wastewater treated with TC and SMZ at a concentration of 3 μg / L are shown. All data were statistically analyzed by one-way ANOVA and post hoc Dunnett's test. * indicates significance at p < 0.05 compared with the control. Bars represent mean concentrations (n = 5), and error bars represent standard deviations for all data (n = 5);
[0014] Figure 2B The concentrations of target antibiotics in leaves / stems and roots of lettuce irrigated with wastewater treated with TC and SMZ at a concentration of 30 μg / L are shown. All data were statistically analyzed by one-way ANOVA and post hoc Dunnett's test. * indicates significance at p < 0.05 compared with the control. Bars represent mean concentrations (n = 5), and error bars represent standard deviations for all data (n = 5);
[0015] Figure 3A The abundance of target ARGs in soil irrigated with low concentration (3 μg / L) antibiotic-contaminated water is shown. The data were analyzed using one-way ANOVA and post hoc Dunnett's test. Significant differences compared with the control sample are marked with * (p < 0.05). Each bar represents the mean of ARGs abundance, and each error bar represents the standard deviation of all data (n = 5);
[0016] Figure 3B The abundance of target ARGs in soil irrigated with high concentration (30 μg / L) antibiotic-contaminated water is shown. The data were analyzed using one-way ANOVA and post hoc Dunnett's test. Significant differences compared with the control samples are marked with * (p < 0.05). Each bar represents the mean of ARGs abundance, and each error bar represents the standard deviation of all data (n = 5);
[0017] Figure 4A The abundance of target ARGs in lettuce leaves / stems irrigated with low concentration (3 μg / L) antibiotic-contaminated water is shown. The data were analyzed using one-way ANOVA and post hoc Dunnett's test. Significant differences compared with the control samples are marked with * (p < 0.05). Each bar represents the mean of ARGs abundance, and each error bar represents the standard deviation of all data (n = 5); and
[0018] Figure 4B The abundance of target ARGs in lettuce leaves / stems irrigated with high concentration (30 μg / L) antibiotic-contaminated water is shown. The data were analyzed using one-way ANOVA and post hoc Dunnett's test. Significant differences compared with control samples are marked with * (p < 0.05). Each bar represents the mean of ARGs abundance, while each error bar represents the standard deviation of all data (n = 5).
[0019] Figure 5A , Figure 5B and Figure 5C The regression equation for the effect of antibiotic concentration on the abundance of ARGs is shown. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0020] Tetracycline (hereinafter referred to as "TC") and sulfadimethoxine (hereinafter referred to as "SMZ"), which are commonly used in human treatment and animal husbandry, are selected from different antibiotic classes. These two antibiotics have different physicochemical properties, such as molecular weight, physicochemical properties, and water solubility, which may affect their distribution and accumulation in soil and crops.
[0021] Table 1: Physicochemical properties of TC and SMZ
[0022]
[0023]
[0024] e was measured in the adsorption experiment.
[0025] pKa: ionization constant.
[0026] Log K ow : Logarithm of the octanol / water partition coefficient.
[0027] K oc : Soil adsorption coefficient.
[0028] SL was prepared from Stanley Sewage Treatment Plant, Hong Kong, China. It was aerobically fermented and dried for stabilization. BC was prepared from biochar (8-20 mesh, CAS No. 7440-44-0) from Sigma-Aldrich (Merck, Taipei, Taiwan, China). Before use, it was washed with river water, purified with deionized water, dried at 105°C, and heated in an oven to 600°C to obtain sterilized BC.
[0029] CMHRs were obtained from Herbaceous Teas (Hong Kong, China) and dehydrated and sterilized in an oven. For detailed processing methods, see Pan, M., Yau, PC, Lee, KC, Zhang, H., Lee, V., Lai, CY, Fan, HJ, 2021. Nutrient Accumulation and Environmental Risks of Biosolids and Different Fertilizers on Horticultural Plants. Water, Air & Soil Pollution 232, 480, the contents of which are incorporated herein as if fully repeated herein.
[0030] In this experiment, the prepared soil amendment components were mixed in the following proportions: (1) control soil; (2) SL-BC (5%, 1:1); (3) SL-BC (10%, 1:1); (4) SL-BC (20%, 1:1); (5) SL-CMHRs-BC (5%, 1:1:1); (6) SL-CMHRs-BC (10%, 1:1:1); (7) SL-CMHRs-BC (20%, 1:1:1).
[0031] Lettuce (Lactuca sativa L.) was selected as the target crop to evaluate the fate of antibiotic concentrations and ARGs in the soil-plant system. Lettuce seeds were first germinated in pots filled with blank soil (without antibiotics) and then transplanted into pots filled with 3-4 kg of blank soil and soil amendments at different ratios. Soil without the target soil amendment was used as a control. Five replicates were prepared for each pot with different soil amendments. The soil water holding capacity was kept at 70%, and 200 ml of water treated with different concentrations of TC and SMZ was used to irrigate the crop. Low (3 μg / L) and high (30 μg / L) were selected as the normal range of antibiotic concentrations in the water environment. The planting experiment was carried out in a greenhouse (25 ± 2 ° C; relative humidity 60%). All soil and lettuce tissues (leaves and stems) were collected for antibiotic concentration analysis until mature size.
[0032] The extraction and determination methods of antibiotics were optimized according to the methods disclosed in Pan, M., Chu, LM, 2018. Occurrence of antibiotics and antibiotic resistance genes in soils from wastewater irrigation areas in the Pearl River Delta region, southern China. Science of The Total Environment 624, 145-152 (hereinafter referred to as "Pan and Chu, 2018"), and the contents are incorporated herein as if fully repeated herein. First, internal standards of TC and SMZ were prepared and added to 1 gram of freeze-dried soil and plant samples (1 mg / L). Acetonitrile and 0.2 M citric acid (v:v=1:1, pH 4.4) were used as extraction buffers, and the samples were extracted 3 times by vortexing, ultrasound and centrifugation. The solid phase extraction (SPE) column was pretreated with methanol and Milli-Q water, and then the solution sample containing the internal standard was flowed through the column. The analyte was eluted from the column with methanol, dried under a gentle nitrogen stream, and then re-immersed in methanol. The extracts were finally filtered into amber glass bottles and stored at -18 °C for further analysis. All antibiotic extracts were measured by HPLC-MS / MS (Agilent HPLC 1100 series HPLC system coupled to Agilent 6410 triple quadrupole MS) equipped with an electrospray ionization (ESI) source (Agilent, USA) in multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) mode. The chromatographic column was a Waters BEH T3 (2.1 × 100 mm, 1.7 μm) column equipped with a poroshell 120 pre-column filter (3.0 mm, 0.2 mm). In the ESI source, 5 mM acetic acid and 0.1% formic acid were used as mobile phase A, while 5 mM acetic acid and acetonitrile were used as mobile phase B. The gradient conditions were monitored as follows: 0 min, 20% B; 0 min, 20% B. 4.5 min, 35% B; 5 min, 60% B; 10 min, 70% B; 11 min, 100% B and 13.1 min, 20% B. The recoveries of the antibiotics of interest ranged from 73-106% and 79%-104%, respectively. The limits of quantification (LOQ) of the antibiotics of interest in soil ranged from 0.70 to 4.63 and in crop extracts from 0.25 to 2.64 mg / kg, respectively. Ten concentrations from 0.5 to 500 mg / L were used for each antibiotic to calculate the calibration curve (R 2 >0.999).
[0033] The DNA extraction method is described in detail in Pan and Chu, 2018. Rapid DNASPIN kit for soil and plant (Bio 101 Inc., Vista, Canada) was used to extract DNA from soil and crop samples. They were further analyzed by spectrophotometer (NanoDrop Technologies, Wilmington) and 1.5% agarose gel electrophoresis to check the purity and concentration of DNA.
[0034] Specific primers for 11 targeted ARGs (tet A, tet B, tet C, tet E, tet M, tet O, tetS and tet X, sul I, sul II and sul III) were selected (Table 2). The extracted DNA samples were first processed by KAPA Taq PCR kit (KAPA Biosystems, Georgia) in a 50 μL volume reaction. After amplification, PCR products were determined by electrophoresis on a 1.5% agarose gel containing 1×TAE buffer. Sterile Mili-Q water was added as a negative control in each run. The PCR products in the gel were excised and purified by an agarose gel DNA purification kit (Omega Bio-tek, Georgia).
[0035] Table 2: Meaning of primer sequences for quantitative polymerase chain reaction of antibiotic resistance genes
[0036]
[0037] The quantitative levels of target ARGs were measured by qPCR, where the detection and quantification methods are described in Pan and Chu, 2018. Briefly, samples were analyzed by Bio-Rad IQ5 instrument (Bio-Rad, USA). qPCR reactions were performed in 25 μL reaction volume and in 96-well plates using 10 μL SYBR Green (KAPA Fast qPCR Master Mix), 0.2 μM of each primer, and 2 μL template DNA. The detailed protocol was as follows: 94°C for 4 min; 94°C for 40 s, annealing at different temperatures for 45 s, 72°C for 1 min, 40 cycles; the final extension phase was 72°C for 6 min. The calibration curve was quantified by a standard curve created from the purified target ARGs samples after PCR amplification. The purified samples were ligated to the pMD19-T vector (TaKaRa, Japan) and cloned into Escherichia coli DH5α (TaKaRa, Japan). The plasmid carrying the target gene was extracted using QIAprepTM Spin Miniprep Kit (QIAGEN, Germany) for generating a calibration curve.
[0038] The DNA quality and concentration in the plasmid were analyzed by agarose gel electrophoresis and spectrophotometer analysis. Since the length of the pMD19-T vector and the target gene is known, the abundance of ARGs genes in each μL of plasmid solution can be simply calculated by the method mentioned in Liang, DW, Zhang, T., Fang, HHP, 2008. Real-time quantifications of dominant anaerobes in an upflow reactor by polymerase chain reaction using a TaqMan probe. Water Science and Technology 57, 1851-1855. Real-time quantification of dominant anaerobic bacteria in an upflow reactor was performed using a TaqMan probe by polymerase chain reaction. Ten-fold serial dilutions of the plasmid carrying the target gene were used to generate all standard curves for qPCR, starting from 10 1 to 10 8 Abundance number. The standard curve correlation coefficient (r)>0.991, the amplification efficiency is 96% to 101%. Each reaction is performed three times. According to the standard curve, the abundance number of the corresponding gene is calculated using the Ct value of the unknown sample.
[0039] All data were analyzed using one-way ANOVA and Dunnett’s test (p < 0.05) in SPSS version 22 to evaluate the comparison of different means of antibiotic concentrations and ARGs abundance between amended and control soils. Formula regression was performed using quadratic equations in SPSS to depict the correlation between antibiotic concentrations and ARGs abundance.
[0040] Figure 1A and 1BThe dissipation of the two target antibiotics in soil under different SL-CMHRs-BC treatments after harvest is shown. The retention of antibiotics in soil can reflect the distribution and transport of antibiotics in the terrestrial environment. Two antibiotics were detected in the soil during the growth of lettuce. The control soil (not treated with SL-CMHRs-BC) planted with lettuce captured the highest antibiotic concentration residues under low and high antibiotic contaminated water irrigation. After harvest, TC concentrations dissipated by 30.7% and SMZ concentrations dissipated by 40.8% under 20% SL-CMHRs-BC treatment and 3μg / L irrigation compared with the control. In most cases, when a higher proportion of SL-CMHRs-BC was applied, the soil dissipated a large amount of antibiotics (p<0.05). Under 3μg / L irrigation, 10% SL-CMHRs-BC had the highest removal rate of TC in soil, followed by 20% SL-CMHRs-BC and 5% SL-CMHRs-BC. 20% SL-CMHRs-BC had the highest removal rate of SMZ in soil, followed by 10% SL-CMHRs-BC and 5% SL-CMHRs-BC. In general, the degradation effect of antibiotics in soil by SL-CMHRs-BC treatment was better than that by SL-BC treatment. For example, under 30 μg / L irrigation, TC decreased from 530 ng / g (control) to 299 ng / g (20% SL-CMHRs-BC) and 363 ng / g (20% SL-BC), respectively. Under 30 μg / L irrigation, SMZ decreased from 54.7 ng / g (control) to 28.4 ng / g (20% SL-CMHRs-BC) and 30.2 ng / g (20% SL-BC), respectively. The data showed that the dissipation effect of antibiotics in soil by SL-CMHRs-BC treatment was better than that by SL-BC treatment. However, no antibiotics were detected in the leached water of each SL-CMHRs-BC treatment during the planting period. The reduction in antibiotic concentration in soil was much greater than the amount absorbed by lettuce tissue; this suggests that the SL-CMHRs-BC treatment can enhance the dissipation of antibiotics through decomposition or degradation of contaminated soil. The dissipation rate of the selected antibiotics under SL-CMHRs-BC treatment at 3 μg / L irrigation was slightly higher than that under 30 μg / L irrigation. This is due to the continuous daily irrigation with wastewater containing antibiotics, which increases their availability for degradation and decomposition in the soil. The results of nutrient tests, toxicity tests, and phytotoxicity tests showed that SL-CMHRs-BC is able to provide more nutrients to the soil environment, increase soil fertility and microorganisms. It can have anti-pollution properties in the soil by promoting pollutant-digesting microorganisms.
[0041] Previous studies have reported that sterilized soil can extend the half-life of antibiotics to almost twice that of non-sterilized soil. Combined with similar results from other studies, it is speculated that soil microorganisms are essential for the dissipation of antibiotics. For example, bacteria such as Microbacterium sp., Ochrobactrum sp., and Labrys portucalensis are responsible for the degradation of SMZ. The co-application of SL-CMHRs-BC in soil can enhance the activity of degrading microorganisms by supporting nutrients and relieving soil conditions. In addition, CMHRs are also a good filler that can increase soil porosity and increase oxygen content in the soil. Antibiotics are expected to degrade faster in aerobic environments compared to anaerobic environments. Therefore, CHMRs can promote the flow of available air and water, producing better aerobic soils. The efficacy of dissipating antibiotics from soil may also be limited to the initial antibiotic concentration and the concentration of soil amendments. Soils with higher initial antibiotic concentrations retain more antibiotics than soils with lower concentrations.
[0042] The concentration of antibiotics in plant tissues under SL-CMHRs-BC treatment of lettuce is shown in Figure 2A and 2B The stems and leaves of lettuce were tested under different SL-CMHRs-BC treatments and under irrigation with low and high antibiotic contaminated water. TC was detected in all lettuce tissues, while SMZ was not detected in lettuce stems and leaves under different treatments. The highest concentrations of both antibiotics were found in control lettuce tissues that were not treated with any SL-CMHRs-BC. The concentrations of TC ranged from 3.56 to 21.4 ng / g; SMZ ranged from 0 to 0.017 ng / g under 3μg / L and 30μg / L irrigation, respectively. Under 3μg / L irrigation, the concentrations of TC in lettuce tissues ranged from 1.23-3.56 ng / g, while SMZ was undetectable in stems and leaves. Under 30μg / L irrigation, TC had the highest concentrations in lettuce tissues (10.3-18.1 ng / g), while only trace amounts of SMZ (0-0.02 ng / g) were detected in stems and leaves.
[0043] Studies have shown that the transport factors and enrichment factors of antibiotics are related to lipophilicity. Different compounds with different properties will affect the transport speed during plant translocation and bioaccumulation. For example, fat-soluble compounds are easily absorbed by plant cells during plant transport, resulting in slow absorption and transport processes. As for TC, its chemical structure and properties are hydrophilic, which makes TC easier to be absorbed, transported and accumulated by plants. After the antibiotics are absorbed by the roots, they enter the branches and leaves of the plant through the xylem under transpiration. It has been observed that TC is more easily adsorbed from the soil. After being absorbed by the roots, it is transported to the leaves and stems of the plant through the xylem. For SMZ, due to its Kd value and hydrophobicity, making it difficult to be absorbed through the cell membrane and transported to the upper crop tissues. The antibiotic removal effect in lettuce was positively correlated with the SL-CMHRs-BC treatment ratio (p<0.05). Under the 20% SL-CMHRs-BC treatment, TC concentrations were significantly reduced by 65.5% and 52.1% (p<0.05) at 3μg / L and 30μg / L irrigation, respectively. The results in crop tissues were consistent with those in soil, where the removal rates of SL-CMHRs-BC treatments were similar as follows: 20% SL-CMHRs-BC>10% SL-CMHRs-BC>5% SL-CMHRs-BC. For example, under 30μg / L irrigation, TC decreased from 21.4ng / g (control) to 10.3ng / g (20% SL-CMHRs-BC) and 15.3ng / g (20% SL-BC), respectively. In contrast, the antibiotic concentrations detected in crop tissues were much lower in soil. This suggests that SL-CMHRs-BC treatment can reduce antibiotic concentrations through the decomposition or degradation of contaminated soil and inhibit the transport and absorption of antibiotics in the soil-plant system. Therefore, the higher the soil contamination level, the higher the accumulation rate in crop tissues. For example, the antibiotic concentration detected in lettuce under 30μg / L irrigation conditions was higher than that under 3μg / L irrigation conditions. Previous studies have also shown that crops grown in soils treated with wastewater or animal manure with higher levels of TC and SMZ contamination accumulated more antibiotics than those in soils with lower levels of contamination. The study also found that the capture concentrations of TC and SMZ in cucumbers, cherry tomatoes, and lettuce were the highest under 20mg / kg antibiotic application, followed by 10mg / kg and 5mg / kg treatments. In essence, the co-application of SL-CMHRs-BC can reduce antibiotics in the soil and avoid some of the antibiotics being absorbed by crops.
[0044] Figure 3A and 3B The changes in the occurrence of nine ARGs in soil and lettuce leaves / stems under the influence of SL-CMHRs-BC are shown. Except for tet B, which was undetectable in 20% SL-CMHRs-BC soil and growing lettuce, all ARGs were measured in soil and lettuce leaves / stems. For example, under 3 μg / L irrigation conditions, the accumulation of tet A, tet C, and tet O in soil was relatively high, with an average ARG abundance of 0.28, and sul I, sul II, and sul III were 0.32. In addition, under 3 μg / L irrigation conditions, the average ARG abundance of tet A, tet C, and tet O in lettuce leaves / stems was 7.54×10 -2 , while the average ARGs abundance of sul I, sul II and sul III was 1.15×10-1 The average abundance of ARGs of tet B, tet E, and tet M in soil and lettuce leaves / stems was lower than that in other components. The average abundance of ARGs of tet B, tet E, and tet M was lower than that in other components, with an average of 1.15×10 -2 , the average for lettuce leaves / stems is 1.45×10 -2 . The differences between ARGs may be caused by selection pressure. Bacteria are often equipped with mobile genetic elements, such as integron genes, to disperse ARGs into the population through horizontal gene transfer. It was observed that some genes (e.g., tet A, tet C, tet G, tet BP, sul I, and sul II) were significantly correlated with the abundance of class 1 integron (intI1). ARGs that interact more obviously with intI1 (e.g., insertion of sul I gene into the 3' conserved region of intI1 gene) can persist longer in soil microbial communities.
[0045] The control soil and its grown lettuce captured the highest ARGs abundance under irrigation with low (3 μg / L) and high (30 μg / L) antibiotic-contaminated water, where the ARGs abundance in the soil ranged from 5.32 × 10 -5 to 3.56, while in lettuce leaves / stems it was 2.11×10 -5 The abundance of ARGs was negatively correlated with the application ratio of SL-CMHRs-BC (p<0.05). The lowest abundance of ARGs appeared in the soil with 20% SL-CMHRs-BC (3.67×10 -6 -1.16×10 -2 , 3.74×10 -5 -1.18×10 -1 ), followed by 10% SL-CMHRs-BC soil (9.53×10 -6 -2.26×10 -2 and 8.16×10 in 30 μg / L -5 -2.24×10 -1 ), and 5% SL-CMHRs-BC soil (1.35×10 -5 -3.15×10 -2 , 1.48×10 -4 -3.45×10 -1). The trend in lettuce leaves / stems was consistent, that is, in terms of the reduction degree of ARGs in lettuce leaves / stems, 20% SL-CMHRs-BC>10% SL-CMHRs-BC>5% SL-CMHRs-BC. 20% SL-CMHRs-BC is considered to be the most favorable ratio for controlling the spread of ARGs in the environment. tet A was one of the most abundant ARGs in irrigated soil and lettuce, with a concentration of 1.64×10 in 3 μg / L irrigated soil. -4 -4.0×10 -1 , and 1.67×10 in 30μg / L irrigated soil -3 -6.62×10 -2 , but in the 20% SL-CMHRs-BC treatment, more than 99% of the ARGs were excreted and reduced. After irrigation with 3μg / L and 30μg / L antibiotic-contaminated water, it was found that in the absence of CMHRs, not only were more ARGs accumulated in the soil and lettuce leaves / stems, but all ARGs (except tetB) were ubiquitously present in the soil and lettuce tissues.
[0046] For example, in the 20% SL-BC soil irrigated with 30 μg / L antibiotic-treated water, the residual value of tet A was 4.04 × 10 -3 In the 20% SL-CMHRs-BC soil, when irrigated with 30 μg / L antibiotic-treated water, the residual value of tet A was 1.67×10 -3 ARG abundance. Without CMHRs, the residual abundance of tet A in soil was 29 times higher. As another example, the residual abundance of tet O in 20% SL-BC lettuce leaves / stems irrigated with 3 μg / L antibiotic-treated water was 3.65×10 - 4 ARG abundance. The residue value of tet O in leaves / stems was 3.15×10 -5 ARG abundance. By comparison, the residue values of tet O in lettuce leaves / stems without CMHRs were found to be 11 times higher than those with CMHRs. The sulI content captured by lettuce leaves / stems was 9% higher under 30 μg / L irrigation compared with 3 μg / L irrigation. It is believed that higher levels of antibiotic contamination will enhance the selection pressure in soil and crops by promoting higher rates of horizontal gene transfer (Guo et al., 2018; Heuer et al., 2011). Notably, the abundance of ARGs in 20% SL-CMHRs-BC soil and lettuce tissue decreased when irrigated with water with low antibiotic contamination. When irrigated with 30 μg / L antibiotic-treated water, the abundance of ARGs in 20% SL-CMHRs-BC lettuce tissue was 1.83×10 -3When irrigated with 3 μg / L antibiotic-treated water, the abundance of ARGs was 1.86×10 -2 In the 20% SL-CMHRs-BC soil, the abundance of ARGs was 3.83×10 -3 When irrigated with 30 μg / L antibiotic-treated water, the abundance of ARGs was 3.51×10 -4 .
[0047] The results showed that the co-application of SL-CMHRs-BC helped reduce ARGs in soil and crop tissues, and that SL-CMHRs-BC could alter microbial communities by (1) inhibiting potential microbial ARG transporters and (2) attenuating selection pressure. SL-CMHRs-BC could expel host bacteria that have the potential to spread ARGs because it could limit the abundance of mobile genetic elements (e.g., intI1 genes), thereby hindering the spread of ARGs through horizontal gene transfer. CMHRs are composed of abundant plant residues (e.g., safflower (Carthamus tinctorius L.)) and are rich in alkaloids and flavonoids. These components have antimicrobial effects and may reduce host bacteria by limiting DNA synthesis and promoting apoptosis. In addition, SL-CMHRs-BC may accelerate the dissipation of antibiotics and attenuate selection pressure in soil. Soil amendments, especially CMHRs, are excellent fillers. They can improve soil porosity and water holding capacity to form an optimal aerobic environment. Compared with anaerobic environments, aerobic environments can promote relatively high antibiotic degradation rates. In addition, SL-CMHRs-BC can provide fertile and healthy soil conditions. The improvement of the soil sphere can promote the growth of more complex and diverse soil microorganisms, which are essential for the degradation of antibiotics in the environment. Microbacterium sp., Ochrobactrum sp., and Labrysportucalensis are common examples that effectively digest norfloxacin, sulfadimethoxine, and erythromycin.
[0048] Correlation formulas were calculated to examine the correlation between antibiotic concentrations in irrigated soil and lettuce (Table 3), and a significant decrease in TC and SMZ concentrations in SL-CMHRs-BC soil was observed. These results provide another insight into determining whether the effects of SL-CMHRs-BC in soil affect antibiotic concentrations and ARGs abundance. All ARGs showed significant correlations with antibiotic concentrations (R 2>0.9). The dependent Y-axis (ARGs abundance) was generally closely dependent on the independent X-axis (antibiotic concentration) in soil and lettuce leaves / stems. For example, the slope coefficient of tet A concentration in SL-CMHRs-BC soil (3 μg / L: 0.1625; 30 μg / L: 0.06) was lower than that in the lettuce it grew in (3 μg / L: 0.1726; 30 μg / L: 0.3653). Similar results were observed for tet O, where the slope coefficient of SL-CMHRs-BC (3 μg / L: 0.0341; 30 μg / L: 0.0125) was relatively lower than that in the lettuce it grew in (3 μg / L: 0.0849; 30 μg / L: 0.1796). This correlation equation can also be applied to other antibiotics or ARGs in soil and plant systems, providing more information about antibiotic contamination and the environmental risks of different antibiotics. The results showed that the abundance of ARGs was strongly affected by the concentration of antibiotics in soil and lettuce tissue, suggesting that soil is a major reservoir of ARGs and antibiotics, which can be directly transmitted to crops during nutrient absorption or interact with the rhizosphere microbiome of crops and translocate throughout crop tissues. The results are similar to those reported by Pan and Chu, 2018, and Pearson correlation analysis depicted a significant positive correlation between antibiotic concentrations and the number of specific ARGs in wastewater-irrigated soils. Statistically significant correlations were also observed by determining the abundance of ARGs (tet A, tet C, tet E, tet G, tet M, tet O, and tet S) in soil and antibiotic concentration (oxytetracycline). These studies suggest that high levels of antibiotic application may exert greater selection pressure on microorganisms in soil and crops. Notably, crops contain a large number of bacteria (i.e., bacteria are the most prevalent microorganisms in the phyllosphere), which are potential vectors driving ARGs from soil to humans. Crops may contain abundant bacteria that promote the spread of ARGs. Some bacteria in crop tissues are closely related to human pathogens. Direct exposure to pathogens may generate widespread selection pressure and accelerate drug failure. For example, Salmonella subsp. typhimurium, which can persist in the soil and invade crops from the roots to the leaves and fruits of tomatoes, is a common human pathogen found in the gut. In fact, most crop bacteria are not pathogenic to humans, but they may equip ARGs from the rhizosphere and promote the spread of ARGs to similar bacterial genera that act as human pathogens through horizontal gene transfer. Overall, anti-resistance genes in the soil may spread to crops and contaminate the food web. Human ingestion of crops contaminated with ARGs will increase exposure to ARGs, thereby weakening the efficacy of related antibiotics and increasing healthcare costs.
[0049] The regression equation for the effect of antibiotic concentration on ARGs abundance is as follows: Figure 5A , Figure 5Band Figure 5C shown.
[0050] The co-application of SL-CMHRs-BC can attenuate antibiotic concentrations and selection pressure, thereby reducing the abundance of ARGs, which is a potential solution to mitigate environmental risks and promote food safety, although factors such as soil physicochemical properties, irrigation water sources, and the number of mobile genetic elements that may affect ARGs in the environment should not be ignored.
[0051] It should be understood that the above only shows and describes examples in which the present invention may be implemented, and that modifications and / or changes may be made thereto without departing from the spirit of the present invention.
[0052] It should be understood that, for the sake of clarity, certain features of the present invention described in the context of separate embodiments may also be provided in combination in a single embodiment. Conversely, for the sake of brevity, various features of the present invention described in the context of a single embodiment may also be provided individually or in any suitable sub-combination.
Claims
1. A method for reducing the concentration of antibiotics and / or the number of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in soil, include: An amendment comprising at least sewage sludge (SL), Chinese medicinal herb residues (CMHRs) and biochar (BC) is prepared, and the amendment is applied to soil.
2. The method according to claim 1, wherein said SL, said CMHRs and said BC constitute substantially 5% to 20% (dry weight basis) of said improver.
3. The method of claim 1 or 2, wherein the ratio between the dry weight of the SL, the dry weight of the CMHRs and the dry weight of the BC is substantially 1:1:
1.
4. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the SL is aerobically fermented and dried for stabilization before preparing the improving agent.
5. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the BC is purified with ionized water, dried at 105°C and heated to 600°C before preparing the improver.
6. The method according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the CMHRs are dehydrated and sterilized before preparing the improving agent.
7. An amendment for reducing the concentration of antibiotics and / or the amount of antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs) in soil, comprising at least sewage sludge (SL), Chinese herbal medicine residues (CMHRs) and biochar (BC).
8. The improver according to claim 7, wherein the SL, the CMHRs and the BC substantially account for 5% to 20% (dry weight basis) of the improver.
9. The improver according to claim 7 or 8, wherein the ratio between the dry weight of the SL, the dry weight of the CMHRs and the dry weight of the BC is substantially 1:1:1.
