Double-sheet superposition radiographic inspection method for butt joint of surfacing nickel base and carbon steel

By using a double-sheet stacked ray detection method at the joint between the nickel base and carbon steel, X-ray films with different photosensitive velocities and adjusting the exposure amount, the problem of uneven blackness caused by material differences in traditional detection methods is solved. , improves detection efficiency and defect detection rate, ensures the accuracy of detection and product safety.

CN118961767AInactive Publication Date: 2024-11-15FUNIS (NANJING) PIPELINE TECH CO LTD
View PDF 0 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410956894.5
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2024-07-17
Publication Date
2024-11-15
Estimated Expiration
Not applicable · inactive patent

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

When traditional ray flaw detection is used to treat joints between nickel base and carbon steel with large material differences, the uniform blackness and contrast of the welds cannot be guaranteed, resulting in invalid detection results, increasing the waste sheet rate and reducing defect detection. Rate.

Method used

The double-film stacked ray detection method is used to stack X-ray films with different photosensitive velocities (X-ray C5 type and buffered X-ray C3 type) on the back of the workpiece. The blackness is controlled by adjusting the exposure amount to ensure detection accuracy and efficiency.

Benefits of technology

Significantly reduces the waste sheet rate, improves detection efficiency and defect detection rate, and can accurately distinguish the blackness changes in the weld and base material areas under different materials and wall thickness changes, ensuring the accuracy of detection and product security.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure HDA0004949104540000011
    Figure HDA0004949104540000011
  • Figure HDA0004949104540000012
    Figure HDA0004949104540000012
  • Figure HDA0004949104540000013
    Figure HDA0004949104540000013
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The invention discloses a double-sheet superposition radiographic inspection method for surfacing a butt joint of a nickel base and carbon steel, which comprises the following steps of: respectively wrapping two different types of X negative sheets on the back of a workpiece by using a dark bag for superposition, and performing ray exposure on the butt joint of the nickel base and the carbon steel by using the same exposure parameter and different photosensitive speeds of the films to increase the allowable value interval of exposure quantity; and blackness changes of the surfacing welding seam position and the surfacing area base metal area position are distinguished. On the premise that the detection accuracy is guaranteed, waste pieces are remarkably reduced, and the detection efficiency is greatly improved.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of nondestructive flaw detection, and in particular to a double-sheet stacking ray detection method for dissimilar steel butt joints of cladding nickel-based and carbon steel. Background Art

[0002] The manufacturing industry at home and abroad attaches great importance to the development of cladding technology. Relevant academic institutions in industrially developed countries have set up special committees to coordinate and promote the development of cladding technology. As an economical and fast process for material surface modification, cladding is increasingly widely used in the manufacture or repair of parts in various industrial sectors. The cladding technology originated in my country in the late 1950s and developed almost in parallel with welding technology. In the early stage of development, it was mainly used in the field of repair, that is, to restore the shape and size of parts. In the 1960s, the restoration of shape and size was combined with surface strengthening and surface modification. After nearly 60 years of ups and downs in my country, cladding technology is not only a process method to extend the service life of materials or parts, but also the basis for the development of advanced manufacturing technology.

[0003] Radiography is widely used in non-destructive testing of products such as cast steel, aluminum, titanium, and various special material welds. Traditional radiography has always used single X-ray film, which is suitable for radiographic testing of products with relatively uniform wall thickness and single material. However, in this project, the base material, weld and cladding layer between the welds are made of different materials, resulting in different attenuation coefficients of different materials when the rays pass through the product, resulting in differences in the main contrast. Therefore, traditional testing cannot guarantee the uniform blackness of the weld, and cannot distinguish the contrast between the base material and the weld. It cannot provide appropriate exposure, resulting in the inability to obtain effective films, making the test results unrecognizable, invalid, and generating a large number of waste films, delaying production progress.

[0004] Practice has shown that the scrap rate of products with large material differences using traditional radiographic flaw detection is very high, which not only increases costs but also greatly reduces the detection rate of radiographic flaws. Therefore, it is necessary to develop new detection methods to overcome the above problems. Summary of the invention

[0005] Purpose of the invention: In view of the shortcomings and defects of the prior art, the present invention provides a double-sheet stacking X-ray detection method for the butt joints of nickel-based and carbon steel, which significantly reduces waste sheets and greatly improves detection efficiency while ensuring detection accuracy.

[0006] Technical solution: The double-film stacking radiographic detection method for the butt weld of nickel-based and carbon steel of the present invention is characterized in that two different types of X-ray films are respectively wrapped in dark bags and superimposed on the back of the workpiece, and the same exposure parameters are used to expose the nickel-based and carbon steel butt welds by using different photosensitivity speeds of the films, thereby increasing the allowable range of the exposure amount and distinguishing the blackness changes of the surfacing weld position and the base material area position of the surfacing area.

[0007] The double-sheet stacking radiographic detection method for the butt joint of cladding nickel-based and carbon steel of the present invention is characterized in that it specifically comprises the following steps:

[0008] 1) Use X-ray C5 film and buffered X-ray C3 film whose sensitivity is slower than that of X-ray C5 film;

[0009] 2) Overlay the X-ray C5 film and the buffered X-ray C3 film, with the X-ray C5 film close to the workpiece and placed on the inspection area on the back of the workpiece;

[0010] 3) Turn on the X-ray machine, perform X-ray transillumination on the butt weld of nickel-based and carbon steel dissimilar steels, and adjust the exposure to control the blackness of the two X-ray films; this meets the requirements of the testing specifications;

[0011] 4) After the irradiation, take out the two X-ray films and go through the development, washing, fixing and drying process in the red light room;

[0012] 5) Observe the two superimposed X-ray films after processing, observe the fast-sensitivity film separately; observe the characteristics of the cladding weld area, slow-sensitivity buffered X-ray film; observe the heat-affected zone of the cladding base material and the weld joint area; complete the double-film superimposed X-ray detection.

[0013] Wherein, in the step 1), the photosensitivity of the buffered X-ray C3 type film is 40% to 60% of the photosensitivity of the X-ray C5 type film.

[0014] Wherein, in the step 3), the exposure is adjusted to control the blackness of the two X-ray films to be 1.8 to 4.0 respectively.

[0015] Beneficial effects: Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following significant advantages: The present invention provides a dual X-ray film radiography method suitable for detecting products with large material differences, thereby significantly reducing waste films and greatly improving detection efficiency under the premise of ensuring detection accuracy. Two different types of X-ray films are wrapped in dark bags on the back of the workpiece and superimposed, and the same exposure parameters are used to expose the nickel-based and carbon steel butt welds using different photosensitive speeds of the film. This method can increase the allowable range of exposure, so that the subtle blackness changes in the position of the surfacing weld and the position of the parent material area of ​​the surfacing area can be distinguished. Even if the wall thickness of the workpiece changes greatly and the workpiece material is different, the same exposure can be used to increase the blackness tolerance of the film, thereby significantly improving the filming efficiency, and at the same time, it also improves the detection rate of heterogeneous steel defects by radiation, and discovers defects that are difficult to capture with a single film, thereby effectively improving the quality of radiographic flaw detection, ensuring both the construction period and the accuracy of detection, thereby ensuring the safety of the product. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0016] Figure 1 Schematic diagram of the ASME image quality meter of the present invention; the left, middle and right are Class 1A, Class 1B and Class 1C respectively;

[0017] Figure 2 It is a schematic diagram of longitudinal seam detection of the present invention;

[0018] Figure 3 It is a schematic cross-sectional view of a weld of the present invention;

[0019] Figure 4 A schematic diagram of the energy change of the rays of the present invention when penetrating different materials;

[0020] Figure 5 It is a schematic diagram of the blackness detection of two C5 X-ray films of the present invention; the left side is the weld side, and the right side is the film side;

[0021] Figure 6 It is a schematic diagram of the blackness detection of two C3 X-ray films of the present invention; the left side is the weld side, and the right side is the film side;

[0022] Figure 7 This is a schematic diagram of the blackness detection of the first C3 and the second C5 negative films of the present invention; the left side is the welding side, and the right side is the film side;

[0023] Figure 8 This is a schematic diagram of the blackness detection of the first C5 and the second C3 negative films of the present invention; the left side is the welding side, and the right side is the film side;

[0024] Fig. 9 It is the actual blackness appearance diagram of the weld side of the C5 X-ray film of the present invention;

[0025] Fig.10This is the actual blackness appearance diagram of the film side of the C3 X-ray film of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0026] The technical solution of the present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific implementation methods.

[0027] According to X-ray flaw detection theory, X-rays used for nondestructive testing have the ability to penetrate metals and can make X-ray films sensitive. The thickness or density of the workpiece being inspected varies due to the presence of internal defects. When X-rays penetrate the workpiece being inspected, the amount of radiation absorbed will also vary. If the original intensity of the radiation is I 0 , passing through a workpiece with a linear absorption coefficient of μ and a thickness of t, the intensity is absorbed and attenuated to I, and the relationship is I = I 0 ·e -μt After using X-ray film to receive rays with different attenuation, the X-ray film is developed to display the defects inside the inspected workpiece.

[0028] In order to accurately evaluate the internal defects of workpieces, it is necessary to introduce the concept of contrast. The degree of attenuation of ray intensity depends on the attenuation coefficient of the material and the thickness of the ray penetration in the material. The difference in its intensity is the fundamental reason for the contrast on the X-ray film, so ΔI / I is called the main cause contrast, which is related to the penetration thickness, attenuation coefficient and scattering ratio. Film contrast can be regarded as the amplification factor of the main cause contrast. When penetrating a material with a small attenuation coefficient, the ray intensity is reduced by ΔI / 2. For materials with a large attenuation coefficient, ΔI may be attenuated to ΔI / 4. The transmitted energy ΔI will produce different blackness effects on the film, so the weld inspection of different materials in this description will produce films with seriously different blackness.

[0029] Based on the above theory, it can be seen that when the material differences between the workpieces exceed a certain range, it is difficult to obtain an ideal overall field of view using only one X-ray film. If a low exposure is selected, although the blackness of the area with a reduced attenuation coefficient is conducive to evaluating defects, the area with a higher attenuation coefficient has a lower contrast and does not meet the standard and cannot be evaluated for defects; on the contrary, if a high exposure is selected, the blackness of the area with a reduced attenuation coefficient is conducive to evaluating defects, and the area with a reduced attenuation coefficient cannot be identified and evaluated because the blackness is too high (like a blackboard).

[0030] In order to achieve the above purpose, the double-film stacking radiographic detection method for cladding nickel-based and carbon steel butt welds of the present invention wraps two different types of X-ray films in dark bags on the back of the workpiece and overlaps them, uses the same exposure parameters and different photosensitivity of the films to perform radiographic exposure on the nickel-based and carbon steel butt welds, increases the allowable range of the exposure, and distinguishes the blackness changes of the cladding weld position and the cladding area parent material area position. Specifically, it includes the following steps:

[0031] 1) Use X-ray C5 film and buffered X-ray C3 film whose photosensitivity is slower than that of X-ray C5 film; the photosensitivity of buffered X-ray C3 film is 40% to 60% of that of X-ray C5 film;

[0032] 2) Overlay the X-ray C5 film and the buffered X-ray C3 film, with the X-ray C5 film close to the workpiece and placed on the inspection area on the back of the workpiece;

[0033] 3) Turn on the X-ray machine, perform X-ray transillumination on the butt weld of nickel-based and carbon steel dissimilar steels, and adjust the exposure to control the blackness of the two X-ray films; meet the requirements of the inspection specifications; adjust the exposure to control the blackness of the two X-ray films at 1.8 to 4.0 respectively;

[0034] 4) After the irradiation, take out the two X-ray films and go through the development, washing, fixing and drying process in the red light room;

[0035] 5) Observe the two superimposed X-ray films after processing, observe the fast-sensitivity film separately; observe the characteristics of the cladding weld area, slow-sensitivity buffered X-ray film; observe the heat-affected zone of the cladding base material and the weld joint area; complete the double-film superimposed X-ray detection.

[0036] To facilitate the explanation of the problem, the concepts of △D and △Dmin are introduced here. △D is the contrast, which indicates the difference between the blackness of the defect area and the blackness of the defect surrounding area on the X-ray film; △Dmin is the minimum visible contrast, which indicates the minimum blackness difference that can be distinguished by the naked eye. Since conventional X-ray films are non-sensitized films, when they are at the lower limit of blackness, their contrast △D is very low, which is not conducive to defect detection; while within a reasonable blackness range, the contrast △D will increase significantly with the increase of blackness, while the minimum visible contrast △Dmin increases slowly, so the gap between these two parameters can be widened, so that the sensitivity of defect detection can be increased. However, when the blackness exceeds the critical point, the rising speed of the minimum visible contrast △Dmin will also become faster, and the rising speed of the contrast △D will slow down, resulting in a decrease in the sensitivity of defect detection. The above method uses two X-ray films with a sensitivity speed of about twice the difference, in which the X-ray film with a slow sensitivity speed plays a sufficient buffering role when transmitting thin wall areas. When the blackness of the two X-ray films is controlled between 1.8 and 4.0, it can be ensured that the contrast △D is greater than the minimum visible contrast △Dmin in both single-film evaluation and double-film evaluation, thereby achieving the purpose of defect detection.

[0037] In summary, by using the method of the present invention to superimpose double X-ray films on the back of a workpiece, the allowable range of exposure can be increased. With the combination of two X-ray films, an image that can be used to evaluate defects can always be selected. Even if the material of the workpiece changes significantly, there is no need to make special adjustments to the exposure. Therefore, waste films in the filming process are significantly reduced. In particular, defects that are difficult to capture with a single X-ray film can be discovered with the help of superimposed X-ray films, thereby effectively improving the defect detection rate and the quality of workpiece radiographic flaw detection.

[0038] Choice of double chip stacking technology:

[0039] 1) Use two dark bags, place regular X-ray C5 film in each bag, and place the image quality meter index 1B across the weld, overlapping the carbon steel and nickel-based 43 thickness weld for exposure. Use low exposure voltage 240KV, exposure time 5min. Film blackness see Figure 5 .

[0040] Using this method, a darker film can be obtained with a lower exposure.

[0041] 2) Use two dark bags, place buffered photosensitive X-ray C3 film in each bag, and place the image quality meter index 1B across the weld, overlapping the carbon steel and nickel-based 43 thickness weld for exposure. Use high exposure voltage 280KV, exposure time 5min once. Film blackness see Figure 6 .

[0042] This method can be used to obtain a film with lower blackness using a lower exposure.

[0043] 3) Use two dark bags, place regular X-ray C5 film and buffered photosensitive X-ray C3 film respectively, with the image quality meter index 1B across the weld, C5 film close to the back of the weld, C3 film overlapped with the back of C5 film, use low exposure voltage 240KV, exposure time 4min. Film blackness see Figure 7 .

[0044] This method can be used to obtain two negatives with uneven blackness at a lower exposure.

[0045] 4) Use two dark bags, place regular X-ray C5 film and buffered photosensitive X-ray C3 film respectively, with the image quality meter index 1B across the weld, C3 film close to the back of the weld, C5 film overlapped with the back of C5 film, use high exposure voltage 280KV, exposure time 5min once. Film blackness see Figure 8 .

[0046] This method can be used to obtain two negatives with uneven blackness at a lower exposure.

[0047] The double film stacking technology includes four combinations: two X-ray C5 films with faster photosensitivity, two X-ray C3 films with slower photosensitivity, one X-ray C5 film with faster photosensitivity and one X-ray C3 film with slower photosensitivity, which are stacked at different positions close to the weld. The weld film assessment area meets the ASME standard blackness range of 1.8 to 4.0 through the control of exposure. Through experimental methods, it is found that using C5 film close to the back of the weld and C3 film overlapping the back of C5 film can reduce the exposure and obtain two suitable blackness X-ray films. This method can obtain two X-ray films that meet the requirements of the weld and the base material of the cladding layer through one exposure, which not only improves efficiency, but also improves the effective detection rate of dissimilar steels and defects in the cladding layer.

[0048] Double-sheet stacking X-ray detection:

[0049] By using C5 type film close to the back of the weld, C3 type film overlapping the back of C5 type film, two dark bags filled with two different types of films are used to perform surfacing on the attenuation coefficient of dissimilar metals, and the longitudinal circumferential seam is tested.

[0050] 1) Each negative is cut into 360*100 films with a cutting knife, and 0.03mm lead type intensifying screens are placed on both sides of the film. They are wrapped in dark bags and exposed to natural light.

[0051] 2) Place the corresponding product task number on each film, place the standard mass spectrometer wire perpendicular to the weld and the thin wire facing outward at one-fourth of the dark bag, first place the X-ray C5 film close to the weld, cover the X-ray C3 behind the C5 film, and fix it on the carbon steel and nickel-based dissimilar steel welds with ropes or tapes.

[0052] 3) According to the X-ray exposure machine used, find the corresponding X-ray exposure curve, and at the selected focal length L=700, select the appropriate exposure amount (15mA*min) according to the process regulations to expose the double film.

[0053] 4) After the irradiation is completed, the two X-ray films are taken out, and the two films are developed, washed, fixed, and dried in the red light room in the same manner to obtain two X-ray films with different blackness.

[0054] 5) Use a black and white densitometer to measure the blackness of the weld and the base material on the obtained X-ray C5 type weld side film, and record it: Use a black and white densitometer to measure the blackness of the base material and the weld on the obtained X-ray C3 type film side film, and record it.

[0055] Test 1: Use two dark bags containing two C5 films with a fast sensitivity, and adjust the blackness with a low exposure. Figure 5, observe the nickel-based weld and the parent metal weld, the voltage is 240KV, 4min film blackness. When the blackness of the C5 film weld side and the nickel-based weld side meets the requirements, the blackness of the parent metal has exceeded the standard.

[0056] Conclusion: When C5 film with faster sensitivity is used for overlap, the weld can easily meet the requirements, but the parent material cannot meet the requirements.

[0057] Test 2: Use two dark bags with two slow-sensitivity C3 films and adjust the blackness with a higher exposure. Figure 6 , observe the nickel-based weld and the parent metal weld, the voltage is 280KV, 5min film blackness. When the blackness of the C3 film weld side and the nickel-based weld side meets the requirements, the blackness of the parent metal still exceeds the standard.

[0058] Conclusion: When C3 film with faster sensitivity is used for overlap, the weld can easily meet the requirements, but the parent material still cannot meet the requirements.

[0059] Test 3: Use two dark bags, place regular X-ray C5 film and buffered photosensitive X-ray C3 film respectively, C3 film is placed close to the back of the weld, C5 film overlaps with the back of C3 film, use high exposure voltage 280KV, exposure time 5min once. Figure 7 , observe the nickel-based cladding weld and the parent material weld, the voltage is 280KV, 5min film blackness. When the blackness of the nickel-based cladding weld on the C3 weld side and the C5 film side meets the requirements, the blackness of the parent material is still exceeded.

[0060] Conclusion: When the C3 film with a slower sensitivity speed is overlapped with the C5 film with a slower sensitivity speed, the weld can easily meet the requirements, but the parent material still cannot meet the requirements.

[0061] Test 4: Use two dark bags, place regular X-ray C3 film and buffered photosensitive X-ray C5 film respectively, C5 film is placed close to the back of the weld, C3 film overlaps with the back of C3 film, use high exposure voltage 240KV, exposure time 4min once. Figure 8 , observe the nickel-based cladding weld and the base metal weld, the voltage is 240KV, 4min film blackness. When the C5 nickel-based weld is in the ideal blackness range, the C3 carbon steel side blackness also meets the requirements.

[0062] Comparison of 4 groups of tests proves that the present invention must select appropriate films of different photosensitive speeds, and stack them with C5 on the inside and C3 on the outside to achieve the required blackness requirements. When the nickel-based composite pipe Φ620*(30+3) and the iron-based flange Φ610*(25+3) are butt-jointed, different types of double films can be selected for stacking to obtain the ideal blackness range on the weld side and the parent material side. See the measured appearance Fig. 9 and Fig.10 .

Claims

1. A double-sheet stacking radiographic detection method for cladding nickel-based and carbon steel joints, characterized in that: Two different types of X-ray films were wrapped in dark bags and superimposed on the back of the workpiece. The same exposure parameters were used to expose the nickel-based and carbon steel butt welds using different photosensitivity speeds of the films to increase the allowable range of exposure and distinguish the changes in the blackness of the cladding weld position and the base material area of ​​the cladding area.

2. The double-sheet stacking radiographic detection method for the butt joint of nickel-based cladding and carbon steel according to claim 1 is characterized in that: The specific steps include: 1) Use X-ray C5 film and buffered X-ray C3 film whose sensitivity is slower than that of X-ray C5 film; 2) Overlay the X-ray C5 film and the buffered X-ray C3 film, with the X-ray C5 film close to the workpiece and placed on the inspection area on the back of the workpiece; 3) Turn on the X-ray machine, perform X-ray transillumination on the butt weld of nickel-based and carbon steel dissimilar steels, and adjust the exposure to control the blackness of the two X-ray films; this meets the requirements of the testing specifications; 4) After the irradiation, take out the two X-ray films and go through the development, washing, fixing and drying process in the red light room; 5) Observe the two superimposed X-ray films after processing, observe the fast-sensitivity film separately; observe the characteristics of the cladding weld area, slow-sensitivity buffered X-ray film; observe the heat-affected zone of the cladding base material and the weld joint area; complete the double-film superimposed X-ray detection.

3. The double-sheet stacking radiographic detection method for the butt joint of nickel-based cladding and carbon steel according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In the step 1), the photosensitivity of the buffered X-ray C3 type film is 40% to 60% of the photosensitivity of the X-ray C5 type film.

4. The double-sheet stacking radiographic detection method for the butt joint of nickel-based cladding and carbon steel according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In the step 3), the exposure is adjusted to control the blackness of the two X-ray films to be between 1.8 and 4.0 respectively.