Method, device and program for optimally analyzing joining position of vehicle body, and method for manufacturing vehicle body
Through the optimization analysis method performed by computer, the joint wire configuration and component shape of the car body are optimized, which solves the problems of body rigidity and fatigue life under complex variable loads, and realizes the optimal configuration and component shape of the joint wire, which improves the improvement of the joint wire and the improvement of the shape of the part. Fatigue life and rigidity.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202380035780.0
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2022-05-25
- Filing Date
- 2023-03-14
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-26
AI Technical Summary
The prior art is difficult to simultaneously improve the rigidity of the automobile body and the fatigue life near the continuous joint wire under complex variable load conditions, and the fatigue performance of arc welding is affected by the shape of the component, and the existing optimization method fails to effectively consider the improvement of the fatigue life. .
Using computer-executed optimization analysis method, optimize joints by analyzing object model, joint line optimization analysis model, variable load condition setting, target fatigue life setting, joint line rigid sensitivity analysis and joint line/component shape optimization analysis Wire configuration and component shape to improve body rigidity and fatigue life and minimize bond wire length.
Under complex load conditions, the optimal configuration of the bonding wire and the optimization of the component shape are achieved, which improves the fatigue life and rigidity of the continuous bonding wire of the vehicle body and reduces welding costs.
Smart Images

Figure CN119032358A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to an optimization analysis method, device, and program for optimizing joining positions of an automotive body, and a method for manufacturing the automotive body. In particular, the present invention relates to an optimization analysis method, device, and program for optimizing joining positions of an automotive body, and a method for manufacturing the automotive body, for finding the optimal position of a weld line that improves the stiffness of the automotive body and the fatigue life near a weld line for bonding and joining parts assemblies of the automotive body, and a method for manufacturing the automotive body. Background Art
[0002] In recent years, especially in the automobile industry, the weight reduction of vehicle bodies due to environmental issues has been developing, and analysis based on computer aided engineering (hereinafter referred to as "CAE analysis") has become an indispensable technology in the design of vehicle bodies. In this CAE analysis, it is known that the improvement of rigidity and weight reduction can be achieved by using optimization techniques such as mathematical optimization, sheet thickness optimization, shape optimization, and topology optimization.
[0003] It is known that a structure such as a car body is formed by joining a plurality of parts as a component group by welding or the like. If the amount of joining of the parts as a component group is increased (for example, if the continuous joining line based on electric arc welding or laser welding is increased), the rigidity of the entire car body is improved. If the rigidity is improved, the stress generated in the entire part is also suppressed, and the fatigue life of the part is improved. However, on the contrary, there are also cases where the fatigue life is reduced due to the increase in local stress. Moreover, from the perspective of the manufacturing cost of the car body, it is desired to reduce the amount of joining as much as possible. In addition, it is also required to configure the optimal welding position so as to improve the fatigue performance for multiple input conditions at the same time.
[0004] Therefore, in order to reduce the manufacturing cost of the vehicle body and improve the rigidity and fatigue life of the vehicle body, a method of finding the joint position (continuously joined welding position such as laser and arc) where the parts are joined to each other has been proposed. As such methods, there are methods of determining the joint position through experience, intuition, etc., and methods of dealing with it by increasing the number of joint positions in the parts with high stress through stress analysis. In addition, in the case of responding to multiple performances, sometimes the welding position configured to meet a certain performance is evaluated for other performances and confirmed by trial and error.
[0005] However, the method of determining the joining position based on experience, intuition, etc. is not a method of finding the position of the joining line required for improving both rigidity and fatigue life. Therefore, there are cases where a position that is not required for improving rigidity and fatigue life is used as the joining line, and repeated trial and error is inefficient from a cost perspective.
[0006] In addition, in the method of adding joints at locations with high stresses through stress analysis, changes can be seen in rigidity and fatigue life compared to before the joint positions were determined through this method, but there are also many cases where the deformation of the location is suppressed, and the local stress increases on the contrary. Therefore, the joint position determined by this method is not necessarily optimal, and the result is a trial-and-error design, which is inefficient.
[0007] In contrast, Patent Document 1 discloses a method and apparatus for optimizing the joint position of point joining such as spot welding, continuous joining such as laser welding, arc welding or welding bonding, etc., which are used in joining a plurality of parts constituting a structural body model composed of two-dimensional elements and / or three-dimensional elements. In addition, Patent Document 2 discloses a device and method for determining a continuous joining application part of a structural body model, which can easily determine a part suitable for continuous joining without complicated operations in a structural body model composed of two-dimensional elements and / or three-dimensional elements constituting parts.
[0008] [Prior art literature]
[0009] [Patent Document]
[0010] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2013-025593
[0011] [Patent Document 2] Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2016-71770 Summary of the invention
[0012] [Problems to be Solved by the Invention]
[0013] During the driving of a car, a variable amplitude load whose amplitude, direction, etc. are not constant in time but change in a complex manner is input to the car body. Therefore, a technology is desired to find the optimal length and configuration of the joint line that can improve the rigidity of the car body and the fatigue life near the continuous joint line when a complex variable load is input to the car body. In the chassis / travel parts (chassis component or suspension part) of a car, many structures are observed in which parts are joined to each other by arc welding. However, it is known that even if the strength of the base metal of the part is improved, the fatigue strength around the arc welded part will not be improved due to the influence of the notch geometry of the arc welding terminal (weld toe). Therefore, in the future, for chassis / travel parts, in the process of expecting the expansion of the application of high-tensile steel sheets, the optimization of arc welding joint configuration becomes important. On the other hand, when the welding margin between parts is short, even if the arc welding joint configuration is optimized, the fatigue life may not be improved sufficiently. In order to ensure the welding margin, it is sometimes necessary to reconsider the shape of the parts. In addition, the fatigue performance of arc welding is greatly affected by the part shape, so technology that optimizes both the welding configuration and the part shape is required.
[0014] However, in the technologies disclosed in Patent Documents 1 and 2, as analysis conditions for optimization calculation, the volume ratio of material is set, the rigidity is maximized, the displacement is minimized, the stress is minimized, etc., and the optimal position of the spot joint or the continuous joint is obtained, and no consideration is given to improving the fatigue life of the spot joint or the continuous joint. In addition, the technology disclosed in Patent Document 2 mainly targets automobile bodies joined by spot welding, and the spot joint elements with a spot joint interval below a specified value are determined as the parts suitable for continuous joining, and there is also a problem that it cannot be applied to the chassis / travel parts of automobiles where parts are continuously joined to each other by arc welding or the like.
[0015] The present invention has been completed in view of the above-mentioned problems, and its purpose is to provide a method, device and program for optimizing the joint position analysis of a vehicle body, and a method for manufacturing a vehicle body, which can improve the rigidity of the vehicle body and the fatigue life of a continuous weld line that joins a component group on the vehicle body when a simple or variable load is input to the vehicle body, and at the same time achieve the optimal configuration of the weld line that minimizes the length of the weld line and the optimization of the component shape.
[0016] [Methods for solving the problem]
[0017] The present invention relates to a method for optimizing the joint position of a vehicle body, wherein a computer executes the following steps to perform optimization analysis on all or part of a vehicle body model, wherein the vehicle body model has a plurality of component models composed of beam elements, plane elements and / or solid elements, and has an initial joint line for joining the plurality of component models as a component group, wherein the optimization analysis obtains an optimal arrangement of the joint line for any one of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model, improving the fatigue life near the joint line for joining the component group in the vehicle body model, and minimizing the length of the joint line, and obtains an optimal shape of the component model joined by the joint line with a short fatigue life, wherein the optimization analysis method comprises: an analysis object model setting step of setting all or part of the vehicle body model as an analysis object model; and a joint line optimization analysis model generating step of generating a joint line optimization analysis model, wherein the joint line optimization analysis model sets all candidate joint lines that are candidates for the joint line of the optimal arrangement for the analysis object model. line); a variable load condition setting step, setting a variable load condition, wherein the variable load bar divides the variable load provided to the joint line optimization analysis model into a plurality of loading conditions of different vibration modes, and combines the loading conditions of the vibration modes into a sequence with a predetermined number of cycles; a target fatigue life setting step, providing the variable load condition to the analysis object model or the joint line optimization analysis model to perform stress analysis, calculating the fatigue life of the joint line of the analysis object model or the joint line optimization analysis model, and setting a target fatigue life with the number of sequences of the variable load condition based on the calculation result. life); a step of analyzing the rigidity sensitivity of a bonding line, setting an objective function (objectives) related to the rigidity performance of the bonding line optimization analysis model, constraints (constraints) related to the volume (volume) of the bonding line candidate, and a variable load condition provided to the bonding line optimization analysis model, performing sensitivity analysis of all the bonding line candidate lines constituting the bonding line optimization analysis model satisfying the objective function under the variable load condition and the constraint condition, and selecting a bonding line candidate line with high sensitivity to rigidity performance as a high-rigidity-sensitivity bonding line based on the sensitivity of the bonding line candidate line;A step of generating a joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, generating a joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, wherein the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model selects a component model to be joined using the high-rigidity sensitivity joint line and the joint line with a short fatigue life calculated in the target fatigue life setting step as an extension target component model, and sets a component extension portion, which is a three-dimensional element combined with the periphery of the extension target component model, and all the candidate joint lines of the joint line optimization analysis model as a design space; an optimization analysis condition setting step, in order to perform an optimization analysis using the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model as an optimization target, finding the number of cycles to failure near each candidate joint line according to each load condition of each vibration mode, finding the sum of the ratio of the number of cycles to the number of cycles of the load condition of each vibration mode and the number of cycles according to the number of sequences of the variable load condition set in the target fatigue life setting step as the cumulative damage degree of each candidate joint line. cumulativedamage), setting conditions related to the cumulative damage of the candidate joint line remaining after the optimization analysis, conditions related to the rigidity of the candidate joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, and conditions related to the length of the candidate joint line remaining after the optimization analysis as objective functions or constraints as optimization analysis conditions, and setting constraints related to the volume constraint ratio of the component extension part; and an optimization analysis step, providing the variable load condition set in the variable load condition setting step to the candidate joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, performing optimization analysis under the optimization analysis conditions, obtaining the configuration of the candidate joint line achieved for the purpose of reducing the cumulative damage of the candidate joint line, improving the rigidity of the optimization analysis model, and minimizing the length of the candidate joint line remaining as the optimal configuration of the candidate joint line, and obtaining the optimal shape of the extended component model including the portion corresponding to the component extension part based on the residual shape of the component extension part. ;
[0018] The optimization analysis step is a step of performing topology optimization based on a density method. In the topology optimization, a penalty coefficient may be set to 4 or more to perform discretization.
[0019] The optimization analysis device for the joint position of the vehicle body according to the present invention performs optimization analysis on all or part of a vehicle body model by executing the following steps by a computer, wherein the vehicle body model has a plurality of component models composed of beam elements, plane elements and / or solid elements, and has an initial joint line for joining the plurality of component models as a component group, wherein the optimization analysis obtains the optimal arrangement of the joint line for any one of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model, improving the fatigue life near the joint line for joining the component group in the vehicle body model, and minimizing the length of the joint line, and obtains the optimal arrangement of the joint line for joining the component group in the vehicle body model with a short fatigue life. The optimal shape of the component model, the optimization analysis device comprises: an analysis object model setting unit, which sets all or part of the vehicle body model as the analysis object model; a joint line optimization analysis model generation unit, which generates a joint line optimization analysis model, the joint line optimization analysis model sets all the candidate joint lines that are candidates for the optimally configured joint lines for the analysis object model; a variable load condition setting unit, which sets the variable load conditions, which divide the variable load provided to the joint line optimization analysis model into load conditions of a plurality of different vibration modes, and combines the load conditions of each vibration mode into a sequence with a predetermined number of cycles; a target fatigue life setting unit; a setting unit, providing the variable load condition to the analysis object model or the joint line optimization analysis model to perform stress analysis, calculating the fatigue life of the joint line of the analysis object model or the joint line optimization analysis model, and setting the target fatigue life according to the sequence number of the variable load condition based on the calculation result; a joint line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit, setting an objective function related to the rigidity performance of the joint line optimization analysis model, a constraint condition related to the volume of the joint candidate line, and a variable load condition provided to the joint line optimization analysis model, and constructing the joint line optimization analysis model that satisfies the objective function under the variable load condition and the constraint condition. A sensitivity analysis of all candidate joining lines, and based on the sensitivity of the candidate joining lines, a candidate joining line with high sensitivity to rigidity performance is selected as a high-rigidity-sensitivity joining line; a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model generation unit, which generates a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model, wherein the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model selects a component model to be joined using the high-rigidity-sensitivity joining line and a joining line with a short fatigue life calculated by the target fatigue life setting unit as an extended component model, and sets a component extension unit, a three-dimensional element combined with the periphery of the extended component model, and all candidate joining lines of the joining line optimization analysis model as a design space;An optimization analysis condition setting unit, in order to perform an optimization analysis taking the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model as an optimization object, obtains the number of fracture repetitions near each joint candidate line according to each load condition of each vibration mode, obtains the ratio of the number of cycles of the load conditions of each vibration mode to the number of fracture repetitions, and the sum of the quantities according to the sequence number of the variable load conditions set by the target fatigue life setting unit as the cumulative damage degree of each joint candidate line, and sets a condition related to the cumulative damage degree of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis, a condition related to the rigidity of the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, and a condition related to the length of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis The objective function or constraint condition is defined as an optimization analysis condition, and the constraint condition related to the volume ratio of the component extension part is set; and the optimization analysis part provides the variable load condition set in the variable load condition setting part to the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, performs optimization analysis under the optimization analysis condition, and obtains the configuration of the joint candidate line achieved for the purpose of reducing the cumulative damage degree of the joint candidate line, improving the rigidity of the optimization analysis model, and minimizing the length of the remaining joint candidate line as the optimal configuration of the joint line, and obtains the optimal shape of the extended object component model including the portion corresponding to the component extension part based on the residual shape of the component extension part. ;
[0020] The optimization analysis unit may perform topology optimization based on a density method, in which a penalty coefficient is set to 4 or more for discretization.
[0021] The optimization analysis program for the joint position of the vehicle body according to the present invention performs optimization analysis on all or part of a vehicle body model, wherein the vehicle body model has a plurality of component models composed of beam elements, plane elements and / or solid elements, and has an initial joint line for joining the plurality of component models as a component group, wherein the optimization analysis obtains an optimal arrangement of the joint line for any one of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model, improving the fatigue life near the joint line where the component group in the vehicle body model is joined, and minimizing the length of the joint line, and obtains an optimal shape of the component model joined by a joint line with a short fatigue life, wherein the optimization analysis obtains an optimal shape of the component model joined by a joint line with a short fatigue life, and wherein the optimization The analysis program enables the computer to function as the following components: an analysis object model setting unit, which sets all or part of the vehicle body model as the analysis object model; a joint line optimization analysis model generation unit, which generates a joint line optimization analysis model, which sets all the candidate joint lines that are candidates for the optimally configured joint lines for the analysis object model; a variable load condition setting unit, which sets variable load conditions, which divide the variable load provided to the joint line optimization analysis model into load conditions of a plurality of different vibration modes, and combines the load conditions of each vibration mode into a sequence with a predetermined number of cycles; a target fatigue life setting unit; a part for providing the variable load condition to the analysis object model or the joint line optimization analysis model to perform stress analysis, calculate the fatigue life of the joint line of the analysis object model or the joint line optimization analysis model, and set the target fatigue life according to the sequence number of the variable load condition based on the calculation result; a joint line rigidity sensitivity analysis part for setting the objective function related to the rigidity performance of the joint line optimization analysis model, the constraint condition related to the volume of the joint candidate line, and the variable load condition provided to the joint line optimization analysis model, and constructing the joint line optimization analysis model that satisfies the objective function under the variable load condition and the constraint condition. A sensitivity analysis of all candidate joining lines, and based on the sensitivity of the candidate joining lines, a candidate joining line with high sensitivity to rigidity performance is selected as a high-rigidity-sensitivity joining line; a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model generation unit, which generates a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model, wherein the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model selects a component model to be joined using the high-rigidity-sensitivity joining line and a joining line with a short fatigue life calculated by the target fatigue life setting unit as an extended component model, and sets a component extension unit, a three-dimensional element combined with the periphery of the extended component model, and all candidate joining lines of the joining line optimization analysis model as a design space;An optimization analysis condition setting unit, in order to perform an optimization analysis taking the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model as an optimization object, obtains the number of fracture repetitions near each joint candidate line according to each load condition of each vibration mode, obtains the ratio of the number of cycles of the load conditions of each vibration mode to the number of fracture repetitions, and the sum of the quantities according to the sequence number of the variable load conditions set by the target fatigue life setting unit as the cumulative damage degree of each joint candidate line, and sets a condition related to the cumulative damage degree of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis, a condition related to the rigidity of the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, and a condition related to the length of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis The objective function or constraint condition is defined as an optimization analysis condition, and the constraint condition related to the volume ratio of the component extension part is set; and the optimization analysis part provides the variable load condition set in the variable load condition setting part to the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, performs optimization analysis under the optimization analysis condition, and obtains the configuration of the joint candidate line achieved for the purpose of reducing the cumulative damage degree of the joint candidate line, improving the rigidity of the optimization analysis model, and minimizing the length of the remaining joint candidate line as the optimal configuration of the joint line, and obtains the optimal shape of the extended object component model including the portion corresponding to the component extension part based on the residual shape of the component extension part. ;
[0022] The optimization analysis unit may perform topology optimization based on a density method, in which a penalty coefficient is set to 4 or more to perform discretization.
[0023] The method for manufacturing a vehicle body involved in the present invention optimally configures a joining line for joining a component group in a vehicle body, thereby improving the rigidity of the vehicle body and the fatigue life of the joining line, wherein the optimal shape of the extended object component model and the optimal configuration of the joining line are obtained using the optimization analysis method for the joining position of the vehicle body involved in the present invention, the shape of the corresponding vehicle body component is changed based on the optimal shape of the extended object component model, the joining position of the component group in the vehicle body is determined based on the obtained optimal configuration of the joining line, and the component group of the vehicle body is joined at the determined joining position.
[0024] [Effects of the invention]
[0025] According to the present invention, when a variable load that is not constant in time is input to a vehicle body as in actual automobile driving, the optimal position of the joining line and the optimized component shape that can be achieved for the purpose of minimizing the length of the candidate joining line, improving the rigidity of the analysis object model, and improving the fatigue life near the joining line where the component group is joined can be simultaneously obtained, and the fatigue life can be achieved beyond the optimal arrangement of the joining line. As a result, the optimal arrangement of the continuous joining line in the automotive body structure, the improvement of the fatigue life of the continuous joining line, and the optimization of the component shape can be achieved. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0026] [ Figure 1 ] Figure 1 This is a block diagram of the optimization analysis device for the joining position of the vehicle body according to the first embodiment of the present invention.
[0027] [ Figure 2 ] Figure 2 This is a diagram showing a rear subframe model serving as an analysis target model in the first embodiment of the present invention.
[0028] [ Figure 3 ] Figure 3 This is a diagram for explaining an initial joint line preset in a rear subframe model as an example of an analysis target model in the first embodiment of the present invention.
[0029] [ Figure 4 ] Figure 4 This is a diagram showing an example of an arc welded portion in which an initial joining line is modeled in calculation of the fatigue life of the initial joining line in the first embodiment of the present invention.
[0030] [ Figure 5 ] Figure 5 is a diagram showing an example of load conditions and constraint conditions applied to a first vibration mode and a second vibration mode of a rear subframe model as an analysis target model in the first embodiment of the present invention;
[0031] [ Figure 6 ] Figure 6 The diagram shows an example of an optimized analysis model in which an initial joining line pre-set for an analysis target model and an additional joining line added to the analysis target model are set as candidate joining lines in embodiment 1 of the present invention ((a) the entire optimized analysis model, (b) a partially enlarged view of the optimized analysis model).
[0032] [ Figure 7 ] Figure 7 This is a diagram showing an example of a variable load condition set in Embodiment 1 of the present invention.
[0033] [ Figure 8 ] Figure 8 This is a diagram for explaining an SN diagram (stress endurance diagram) used for calculating fatigue life under a variable load condition in the first embodiment.
[0034] [ Fig. 9 ] Fig. 9 This is a diagram showing an example of the results of the fatigue life of the initial joining line and the position of the initial joining line of the shortest fatigue life (minimum fatigue life) at the lower three points under the variable load condition in the first embodiment of the present invention. Fig. 9 (b) shows the state where the rear subframe model is viewed from the bottom.
[0035] [ Fig.10 ] Fig.10 This is a diagram showing the results of a sensitivity analysis on the rigidity performance with respect to the joint line of the rear subframe model as the target in the first embodiment of the present invention.
[0036] [ Fig.11 ] Fig.11 It is an explanatory diagram of the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model in Embodiment 1 and Examples of the present invention ((a) optimization candidate joint line, (b) optimization target component)).
[0037] [ Fig.12 ] Fig.12 This is a diagram showing another aspect of the method of setting the design space of the optimization target component in the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model.
[0038] [ Fig.13 ] Fig.13 FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of element density distribution of a bonding line and a component shape after optimization analysis of the bonding line / component shape optimization analysis model in the first embodiment of the present invention. Fig.13 In (b), regarding the component shape after the optimization analysis, a partial enlarged view showing only a portion with a high element density is also described.
[0039] [ Fig.14 ] Fig.14 is based on Fig.13 FIG. 1 is a diagram showing an example of optimization of a component shape based on the result of the optimization analysis shown.
[0040] [ Fig.15 ] Fig.15 This is a flowchart showing the flow of processing in the optimization analysis method of the joining position of the vehicle body according to the first embodiment of the present invention.
[0041] [ Fig.16 ] Fig.16 This is an explanatory diagram of rigidity evaluation points in a rear subframe model which is a part of a vehicle body model to be analyzed in the embodiment.
[0042] [ Fig.17 ] Fig.17 The diagram shows the optimum arrangement of the joining lines obtained by the optimization analysis in the comparative example in which the rear subframe model is used as the analysis object and the optimization analysis conditions related to the rigidity and the joining length are set in the embodiment. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0043] Before describing the optimization analysis method, device and program of the joint position of the vehicle body according to the first embodiment of the present invention, and the manufacturing method of the vehicle body according to the second embodiment, the vehicle body model as the object of the present invention is described. In the specification and drawings of the present application, the front-back direction of the vehicle body, the left-right direction of the vehicle body and the up-down direction of the vehicle body are respectively represented as the X direction, the Y direction and the Z direction. In the specification and drawings, the same reference numerals are attached to the elements having substantially the same functions and structures, and repeated descriptions are omitted.
[0044] <Body Model and Analysis Object Model>
[0045] The automotive body model used as the subject of the present invention is composed of a plurality of component models such as a body's frame part and a chassis component, and these component models are modeled using beam elements, plane elements, and / or solid elements.
[0046] Generally, vehicle body frame parts, chassis parts, and the like are mainly formed of metal sheets with a thin sheet thickness, and therefore, the component models constituting the vehicle body model may be composed of only plane elements.
[0047] The vehicle body model has an initial joint line for joining a plurality of component models as a component set. The initial joint line is obtained by modeling a joint line of arc welding or laser welding for joining a plurality of automobile components as a component set using plane elements and three-dimensional elements.
[0048] For example, when two component models composed of plane elements are joined by an initial joining line modeled by the plane elements, the plane element of the initial joining line is combined with both the plane elements of the two component models.
[0049] Furthermore, when the initial joint line is modeled by a solid element, in order to distribute the translational force acting on the initial joint line to the component model, the plane element of the component model and the solid element of the initial joint line are connected by a rigid body element.
[0050] The present invention analyzes the deformation caused by the variable load acting on the analysis target model (described later) as the whole or a part of the vehicle body model, so each component model in the vehicle body model is modeled as an elastic body, a viscoelastic body, or an elastic-plastic body. In addition, the material properties, element information, and information related to the initial joint line in each component group of each component model constituting the vehicle body model are stored in the vehicle body model file 101 (refer to Figure 1 ).
[0051] [Implementation Method 1]
[0052] <Analysis device for optimizing the joint position of a vehicle body>
[0053] The structure of the optimization analysis device for the joint position of the vehicle body (hereinafter simply referred to as “optimization analysis device”) according to the first embodiment of the present invention will be described below.
[0054] An optimization analysis device is a device for performing optimization analysis, which takes the whole or part of the vehicle body model as the analysis object model, and obtains the optimal configuration of the joining line for the analysis object model with the purpose of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model, improving the fatigue life of the joining line of the joining component group in the vehicle body model, and minimizing the length of the joining line.
[0055] Figure 1 FIG. 2 shows an example of the structure of the optimization analysis device 1 according to the first embodiment. The optimization analysis device 1 is composed of a PC (personal computer) and the like. Figure 1As shown, the optimization analysis device 1 includes a display device 3, an input device 5, a memory storage 7, a work data memory 9, and an arithmetic processing unit 11. The display device 3, the input device 5, the memory storage 7, and the work data memory 9 are connected to the arithmetic processing unit 11, and perform their respective functions according to instructions from the arithmetic processing unit 11. The functions of the components of the optimization analysis device 1 according to the first embodiment are described below.
[0056] Display Device
[0057] The display device 3 is used to display the vehicle body model, the analysis target model, the analysis results, etc., and is composed of a liquid crystal monitor (LCD monitor) or the like.
[0058] Input Device
[0059] The input device 5 is used for the vehicle body model file 101 ( Figure 1 ) and the input of operator's instructions, such as reading of the vehicle body model and display of the analysis object model, etc., is composed of a keyboard, a mouse, etc.
[0060] Storage Device
[0061] The storage device 7 is used for the vehicle body model file 101 ( Figure 1 ) and other files, analysis results, etc., and is composed of a hard disk, etc.
[0062] 《Data storage for operation》
[0063] The working data memory 9 is used for temporary storage and calculation of data used by the calculation processing unit 11 , and is composed of a RAM (Random Access Memory) or the like.
[0064] 《Calculation Processing Department》
[0065] like Figure 1 As shown, the operation processing unit 11 includes an analysis object model setting unit 13, a welding line optimization analysis model generation unit 15, a variable load condition setting unit 17, a target fatigue life setting unit 18, a welding line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit 19, a welding line / component shape optimization analysis model generation unit 20, an optimization analysis condition setting unit 21, and an optimization analysis unit 23, and is composed of a CPU (central processing unit) such as a PC. These parts function by executing a predetermined program by the CPU. The functions of each part of the operation processing unit 11 are described below.
[0066] (Analysis object model setting section)
[0067] The analysis target model setting unit 13 acquires a vehicle body model from the vehicle body model file 101 , and sets the entirety or a part of the acquired vehicle body model as an analysis target model.
[0068] An example of the processing of the analysis target model setting unit 13 is described below. First, the operator instructs the vehicle body model to be read from the vehicle body model file 101 through the input device 5, and the vehicle body model is read from the storage device 7. Next, according to the operator's instruction, the vehicle body model is displayed on the display device 3. And, according to the operator's instruction, a part to be the object of optimization analysis is specified in the vehicle body model displayed on the display device 3. The analysis target model setting unit 13 sets the specified part as the analysis target model.
[0069] Figure 2 2 shows an example in which a simplified rear subframe model 111 of a rear suspension subframe (hereinafter, rear subframe) as a chassis component is set as an analysis target model.
[0070] exist Figure 2 In the rear subframe model 111 shown, as a component model, the right side frame upper part (subframe upper) 112 and the side frame lower part (subframe lower) 113 are joined by arc welding to form a side frame R211. Similarly, the left side frame upper part 114 and the side frame lower part 115 are joined by arc welding to form a side frame L212. The cross member upper part (cross member upper) 116 and the cross member lower part (cross member lower) 117 on the front side of the vehicle body are joined by arc welding to form a cross member front part (cross member front) 213. The cross member front part 118 and the cross member rear part (cross member rear) 119 on the rear side of the vehicle body are joined by arc welding to form a rear cross member (rear cross member) 214. These side frame R211, side frame L212, cross member front part 213 and rear cross member 214 are further joined by arc welding to form a parallel cross structure. Furthermore, brackets 120, 121, and 122, which are components for mounting a suspension support and a link mechanism to the tire, are joined to the crisscross structure by arc welding. Figure 2 Only the right side is shown, but the same bracket is also installed on the left side.) These component models are modeled as plane elements. Figure 2In FIG. 1 , the components connecting the tire input point 100 with the brackets 120 , 121 , 122 and the rear cross member 214 are simplified by straight lines representing bar elements.
[0071] And, if Figure 3 As shown in FIG. 1 , the rear subframe model 111 is pre-set with an initial joining line 131 for joining each component model as a component group, and the length of the initial joining line is 6540 mm. Figure 4 As shown, the initial joint line 131 is modeled by a plane element connected to the plane element of the component model in a shared manner. The thickness of the initial joint line 131 is set to the thinner plate thickness of the component model to be joined. In addition, the material property value of the initial joint line 131 is the same as that of the component model.
[0072] In addition, in order to set the variable load conditions and constraint conditions applied to the rear subframe model 111 by the variable load condition setting unit 17 described later, as shown in FIG. Figure 5 As shown, the brackets 120, 121, 122 and the rear cross beam 214 are connected to the tire input point 100 (refer to Figure 2 ) are connected by rod elements. The tire input point 100 is used as the load input point A, and the four points of the mounting bushing a, b, c, and d in the figure are used as complete restraint points.
[0073] (Joint line optimization analysis model generation department)
[0074] like Figure 6 As shown, the welding line optimization analysis model generation unit 15 generates a welding line optimization analysis model 151 in which all welding line candidates that are the welding line optimally arranged with respect to the analysis target model, that is, the maximum welding line that can be set, are set.
[0075] Figure 6 The joint line optimization analysis model 151 generated by setting the joint candidate line 155 in the rear subframe model 111 is shown. Figure 6 (b) shows a part of the weld line optimization analysis model 151 in an enlarged manner, where the solid line represents the initial weld line 131 and the dotted line represents the additional weld line 153. Figure 6In (a), these initial joining lines 131 and additional joining lines 153 are indicated as candidate joining lines 155. The additional joining lines 153 may be added by connecting the intermittently set initial joining lines 131 (b-1, b-2), extended at the ends of the initial joining lines 131 (b-3), or changed in shape when there is no space for setting the additional joining lines 153. The additional joining lines 153 may be modeled with a plane element or a three-dimensional element, similarly to the initial joining lines 131 described above.
[0076] (Variable load condition setting section)
[0077] The variable load condition setting unit 17 divides the variable load applied to the optimization analysis model into load conditions of a plurality of different vibration modes, and sets variable load conditions in which the load conditions of the vibration modes are combined in a predetermined number of cycles to form one sequence.
[0078] The variable load refers to the load input to the analysis target model. One or more of the magnitude, position and direction of the load is divided into different vibration modes, and each vibration mode is combined with a predetermined number of cycles to simulate the variable load input to the vehicle body that changes with time when the actual vehicle is running. In addition, the variable load conditions are given in the calculation of the fatigue life of the initial joint line 131 and the joint candidate line 155 described later.
[0079] The variable load condition setting unit 17 may divide the variable load into loads of a plurality of different vibration modes, and set a variable load condition combining these loads and a constraint condition for constraining the analysis target model for each variable load condition.
[0080] In the first embodiment, the variable load condition is set to completely constrain the mounting bushings a to d mounted on the vehicle body in the rear subframe model 111, and the tire input point 100 on the right side of the vehicle body is used as the load input point A. Figure 5 The load condition of the first vibration mode is as shown in (a) of FIG. 1 , where a variable load of ±2.5 kN is input in the forward and backward direction (input 1) and Figure 5 As shown in (b), the condition of the second vibration mode is that a variable load of ±6.0 kN is input in the inner / outer direction (input 2).
[0081] Moreover, varying load conditions such as Figure 7 As shown in the schematic diagram of the variable load history, one cycle of the first vibration mode load condition and five cycles of the second vibration mode load condition are combined as one series of variable load conditions. In addition, the fatigue life under the load variable condition is considered. Figure 7The graph shown is a graph schematically showing a variable load in which the magnitude of the load under the load condition of the first vibration mode and the load condition of the second vibration mode are reversed as the amplitude in order to represent the number of cycles of each of the load condition of the first vibration mode and the load condition of the second vibration mode under a sequence of variable load conditions.
[0082] (Target fatigue life setting department)
[0083] The target fatigue life setting unit 18 performs stress analysis by applying load variation conditions to the analysis object model (rear subframe model 111) or the joint line optimization analysis model 151 in which the initial joint line 131 is set, calculates the fatigue life of the joint line of the analysis object model or the joint line optimization analysis model 151, and sets the target fatigue life based on the calculation result with the number of sequences of the varying load conditions.
[0084] As the target fatigue life of the joint line optimization analysis model 151, the load conditions of the vibration mode under the variable load conditions set by the variable load condition setting unit 17 are given to the analysis object model, and stress analysis is performed separately. The fatigue life is calculated using commercially available fatigue life prediction software, and the target fatigue life is set based on the shortest fatigue life. In addition, a predetermined number of sequences may be used as the target fatigue life based on a conventional empirical rule.
[0085] Generally, the actual load input to the vehicle body is not constant over time, so it can be considered as a stress state in which stresses of various amplitudes are randomly generated in the initial joint line 131. In order to evaluate the fatigue life of the initial joint line 131 under such a stress state, the cumulative fatigue damage rule (linear cumulative damage rule) is used.
[0086] In the cumulative fatigue damage rule, first, a state in which stresses of various amplitudes are randomly generated is considered as σ1, σ2, σ3, ... σ m Next, suppose that stresses of different amplitudes σ1, σ2, σ3, ... σ m ,from Figure 8 The SN graph shown reads the number of repetitions (fracture repetition number) N1, N2, N3 ... N before fracture (fatigue fracture) at each stress amplitude. m Repeat these stress amplitudes n1, n2, n3…n m The damage degree is considered to be n1 / N1, n2 / N2, n3 / N3…nm / N m .
[0087] In the cumulative fatigue damage rule, as shown in formula (1), the sum of the damage degrees under each stress amplitude is calculated, that is, the cumulative damage degree dm. Moreover, when the cumulative damage degree dm ≥ 1, fatigue failure occurs. Under the condition of irregular repeated variable loads, the Rainflow Counting method can also be used to determine the stress amplitudes σ1, σ2, σ3, ...σ m and the number of repetitions n1, n2, n3…n m .
[0088] [Number 1]
[0089]
[0090] The specific steps of calculating the target cumulative damage degree of the initial joint line 131 under the variable load condition by the target fatigue life setting unit 18 are as follows.
[0091] First, the stress acting on each initial joint line 131 obtained by performing stress analysis for each load condition of each vibration mode under the variable load condition is defined as different stress amplitudes σ1, σ2, σ3, ..., σ generated in the initial joint line 131 under the variable load condition. m .
[0092] Next, the target fatigue life setting unit 18 sets the target fatigue life according to the SN diagram ( Figure 8 ) Calculate the number of repetitions (fracture repetition number) N1, N2, N3, ... N until the initial bonding line 131 breaks when each stress amplitude is generated independently in the initial bonding line 131 m .
[0093] Next, the number of repetitions until fracture (fracture repetition number) N1, N2, N3, ... N m The number of cycles n1, n2, n3, ... n of the load conditions of each vibration mode in one sequence of the variable load conditions m Substituting into formula (1), the cumulative damage degree dm in one sequence is calculated. Furthermore, the cumulative damage degree DM when one sequence (K sequence) of the variable load condition is repeated K times continuously is calculated by formula (2). Then, the number of sequences K when the cumulative damage degree DM is greater than 1 is calculated as the fatigue life of the initial joint line 131 under the variable load condition.
[0094] [Number 2]
[0095]
[0096] Based on the fatigue life of each initial joining line 131 calculated in this way, the target fatigue life setting unit 18 sets the target fatigue life of the joining line optimization analysis model 151. The target fatigue life is a fatigue life that should be satisfied by the candidate joining line 155 (described later) remaining after the optimization analysis. In the first embodiment, the target fatigue life is at least a fatigue life greater than the shortest fatigue life (shortest fatigue life) among the initial joining lines 131 calculated by the target fatigue life setting unit 18.
[0097] Fig. 9 Indicates that the rear subframe model 111 is given Figure 7 The varying load conditions and Figure 5 An example of the results of the positions and fatigue lives of three initial joining lines 131 from the shortest one among the fatigue lives of the initial joining lines 131 obtained as a result of the stress analysis of the constraint conditions shown.
[0098] Fig. 9 The fatigue life of the initial joint line 131 shown is calculated under the variable load condition. Under the variable load condition, in the rear subframe model 111, the mounting bushings a~d installed on the vehicle body are fully constrained, the tire input point 100 on the right side of the vehicle body is used as the load input point A, the first vibration mode of the variable load of ±2.5 kN input in the front-rear direction (input 1) is used as one cycle, and the second vibration mode of the variable load of ±6.0 kN input in the inner / outer direction (input 2) is used as five cycles combined as one sequence.
[0099] Regarding the fatigue life calculated for the initial joint line 131 of the rear subframe model 111, Fig. 9 As shown in FIG. 1 , the joints between the side frame lower portion 113 and the bracket 122 are at the 44000 sequence and the 53000 sequence, and the joint between the side frame upper portion 112 and the bracket 120 is at the 64000 sequence, which are three joint lines from the shorter fatigue life side. Based on this result, the target fatigue life setting unit 18 sets the fatigue life of the 44000 sequence or more of the initial joint line 131 joining the side frame lower portion 113 and the bracket 122 as the target fatigue life.
[0100] In the calculation of the fatigue life by the target fatigue life setting unit 18, as described above, commercially available fatigue life prediction analysis software may be used. For example, when the fatigue life of the initial joint line 131 modeled as a plane element is calculated using commercially available fatigue life prediction analysis software, the fatigue life of the initial joint line 131 can be calculated by inputting conditions such as the stress of the initial joint line 131 into the fatigue life prediction analysis software. As the stress of the initial joint line 131, the stress value of the plane element of each component model connected to the plane element of the initial joint line 131, or the nominal structural stress (nominal structural stress) obtained from the force and moment acting on both ends of the plane element of the initial joint line 131 can be used.
[0101] In addition, the SN diagram sometimes changes depending on the load state, for example, even if the stress amplitude is the same, the average stress is compressive stress or tensile stress, etc., but you can refer to the value of fatigue life prediction analysis software or experimental value. Alternatively, when using nominal structural stress to calculate fatigue life, you can also use an SN diagram that includes different load states. And, if Figure 8 As shown, the SN diagram can also be expressed by applying various rules such as Miner's rule that does not determine fracture below the fatigue limit on the low stress side and modified Miner's rule that counts damage below the fatigue limit.
[0102] In the above description, the target fatigue life is set based on the fatigue life found for the initial joint line 131 , but the target fatigue life may be set based on the fatigue life found for the candidate joint line 155 of the joint line optimization analysis model 151 .
[0103] (Joint wire rigidity sensitivity analysis department)
[0104] The bonding line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit 19 sets an objective function related to the rigidity performance of the bonding line optimization analysis model 151, a constraint condition related to the volume of the bonding candidate line 155 constituting the bonding line optimization analysis model 151, and a variable load condition applied to the bonding line optimization analysis model 151, and performs sensitivity analysis of the bonding candidate line 155 satisfying the objective function under the variable load condition and the constraint condition, and selects the bonding candidate line 155 with high sensitivity to rigidity performance as a high rigidity sensitivity bonding line based on the sensitivity of the bonding candidate line 155. High sensitivity means high contribution to rigidity performance.
[0105] In the first embodiment, as objective functions related to the rigidity performance set by the welding line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit 19, there are, for example, minimization of the sum of strain energy, minimization of displacement, minimization of maximum principal stress, maximization of rigidity, etc. in the welding line optimization analysis model 151. In addition, as constraint conditions set by the welding line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit 19, there are volume constraint ratios that specify the volume ratio of the welding candidate wire 155, etc. In addition, the welding line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit 19 sets, for example, Figure 5 (a) and Figure 5 The variable load conditions (input 1, input 2) and constraint conditions (constraint condition) illustrated in (b) are used as variable load conditions assigned to the joint line optimization analysis model 151. Furthermore, the joint line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit 19 uses the density method in topology optimization to calculate the density (element density (mesh density)) of each element (mesh model of plane elements) of the joint candidate line 155 calculated by the topology optimization as sensitivity. The element density is a hypothetical density representing the filling state of the material in the element, and takes a value of 0-1. That is, if the element density is 1, it means a state in which the element is completely filled with material, if it is 0, it means a state in which the element is not filled with material and is completely empty, and if the element density is an intermediate value between 0 and 1, it means that the element is neither a material nor a void. In addition, among the element densities calculated by topology optimization, among the elements that contribute greatly to the rigidity performance, the element density is a value close to 1, indicating that the sensitivity to the rigidity performance is high. In contrast, in the elements that contribute little to the rigidity performance, the element sensitivity is close to 0, indicating that the sensitivity to the rigidity performance is small. In this way, the element density calculated by topological optimization becomes an indicator representing the sensitivity of each element to the rigidity performance. As an example of sensitivity analysis of the joint candidate line 155 calculated by the joint line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit 19, as an objective function related to the rigidity performance, the minimization of the sum of strain energy in the joint line optimization analysis model 151 is set, and as a constraint condition, the volume constraint rate of the joint candidate line 155 is set to 50%, and as a variable load condition assigned to the joint line optimization analysis model 151, it is set Figure 5 (a) and Figure 5The density of the candidate joint lines 155 calculated by the topology optimization is calculated as sensitivity using the density method in the topology optimization based on the variable load conditions (input 1, input 2) and constraint conditions shown in (b). Then, based on the sensitivity of the candidate joint lines 155, the candidate joint lines 155 with high sensitivity to rigidity performance, for example, the candidate joint lines 155 with a sensitivity of 0.8 to 1.0 are selected as the high rigidity sensitivity joint lines. The candidate joint lines 155 are modeled by plane elements (shell elements), and the joint line model and the component model are joined by sharing nodes.
[0106] Fig.10 An example of sensitivity analysis results of all candidate joint lines 155 constituting the joint line optimization analysis model 151 is shown. A candidate joint line 155 having a high sensitivity to rigidity performance of 0.8 or more exists at the joint between the side frame lower portion 113 and the bracket 122. The candidate joint line 155 at the joint between the side frame lower portion 113 and the bracket 122 is selected as a joint line with high rigidity sensitivity.
[0107] (Joint line / component shape optimization analysis model generation department)
[0108] The welding line / component shape optimization analysis model generation unit 20 selects a component model that is welded by a welding line with high rigidity sensitivity and a welding line with short fatigue life calculated by the target fatigue life setting unit 18 as an expansion target component model. Fig. 9 The fatigue life of the initial joint line 131 of the rear subframe model 111 shown is 44000 series at the joint between the side frame lower part 113 and the bracket 122, which is the joint line with the lowest fatigue life. In addition, as described above, the joint line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit 19 selects the joint candidate line 155 of the joint between the side frame lower part 113 and the bracket 122 as the rigidity high sensitivity joint line ( Fig.10 ). Therefore, in the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model generation unit 20, the bracket 122 is selected as the extension target component model. In this way, the component model joined by the joint line that has a high contribution to the rigidity performance and a short fatigue life is selected as the extension target component model. In addition, the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model generation unit 20 generates a joint line / component shape optimization analysis model 156 in which the component extension unit 159, which is a three-dimensional element connected to the periphery of the bracket 122 as the extension target component model, and all the joint candidate lines 155 of the joint line optimization analysis model 151 are set as the design space. Specifically, as Fig.11 As shown in (a-1) and (a-2), the three-dimensional elements constitute the joint candidate line 155, such as Fig.11As shown in (a-3) of FIG. 1 , the three-dimensional element constituting the candidate joining line 155 is joined to the planar element constituting the side frame upper portion 112 and the bracket 121 through a beam element (dashed line in the figure). Fig.11 As shown in (b), at the end of the bracket 122 that is the extension target component model, a component extension portion 159 is provided by a solid element, and is connected to the end of the bracket 122 by a beam element (not shown). Then, a joint line / component shape optimization analysis model 156 is generated in which the joint candidate line 155 and the component extension portion 159 are set as the design space. The joint candidate line 155 is set as a solid element because it is optimized together with the component extension portion 159 as a solid element.
[0109] The component extension part 159 shown above is a component extension part added to the end of the existing bracket 122. Fig.12 As shown by the dotted line, the existing bracket 122 may be replaced with a portion equivalent to the entire bracket including the existing portion as the component extension portion 159 .
[0110] (Optimization analysis condition setting section)
[0111] In order to perform optimization analysis with the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model 156 as the optimization object, the optimization analysis condition setting unit 21 calculates the number of fracture repetitions near each joining candidate line 155 for each load condition of each vibration mode set by the variable load condition setting unit 17, calculates the ratio of the number of cycles of the load conditions of each vibration mode to the number of fracture repetitions, and calculates the sum of the quantities according to the sequence number of the variable load conditions set by the target fatigue life setting unit 18 as the cumulative damage degree DM of the said each joining candidate line 155, and sets the conditions related to the cumulative damage degree of the joining candidate line 155 remaining after the optimization analysis, the conditions related to the rigidity of the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model 156, and the conditions related to the length of the joining candidate line 155 remaining after the optimization analysis as the objective function or constraint conditions of the optimization analysis conditions, and further sets the constraint conditions related to the volume ratio of the component expansion part 159.
[0112] There are two types of optimization analysis conditions: objective function and constraint conditions. Only one objective function is set according to the purpose of the optimization analysis. As objective functions, conditions related to rigidity, conditions related to fatigue life, and conditions related to joint length can be cited.
[0113] As a condition related to rigidity, for example, a predetermined position in the analysis object model can be used as a rigidity evaluation point, and the displacement or strain of the rigidity evaluation point can be used as an index. Moreover, under variable load conditions, for example, the value obtained by adding the displacements of the rigidity evaluation point A under the load conditions of each vibration mode, or the displacement of the rigidity evaluation point A under the load conditions of each vibration mode can be minimized as a condition related to rigidity. As a condition related to fatigue life, it can be set to a condition greater than the target fatigue life set by the target fatigue life setting unit 18. In addition, regarding the joint length, for example, it can be set to a ratio relative to the entire joint length.
[0114] The constraint condition is a constraint imposed on performing the optimization analysis, and a plurality of constraints may be set as necessary.
[0115] In the first embodiment, the condition that the fatigue life of the candidate joint line 155 is greater than the target fatigue life set by the target fatigue life setting unit 18 can be set as a constraint condition. The number of fracture repetitions of the candidate joint line 155 is the same as the number of fracture repetitions of the initial joint line 131 under the variable load condition described above, and can be used. Figure 8 Calculated from the SN diagram shown.
[0116] The conditions related to fatigue life are not limited to directly giving the target fatigue life set by the target fatigue life setting unit 18 as a constraint condition, but a constraint condition may be given that the cumulative damage degree DM of the number of sequence times of the target fatigue life set by the target fatigue life setting unit 18 of the joining candidate line 155 under variable load conditions is DM<1 which does not cause fatigue failure.
[0117] The cumulative damage degree DM of the candidate joining line 155 can be calculated by, for example, using the stress of the plane element of the component model connected to the plane element of the candidate joining line 155, the nominal structural stress calculated from the force and moment acting on both ends of the plane element, etc., similarly to the cumulative damage degree DM of the initial joining line 131 described above. Figure 8 The SN line diagram shown and formula (2) are used for calculation.
[0118] Furthermore, regarding the condition of the length of the candidate joining line 155, the length of the remaining candidate joining line 155 can be set to a predetermined value. In the first embodiment, a constraint condition is set such that the length of the remaining candidate joining line 155 is less than or equal to the length of the initial joining line 131. Furthermore, a constraint condition of 30 mm or more is set so that each candidate joining line 155 does not become a finely divided joining line.
[0119] Regarding the optimization analysis condition related to the length of the candidate joining line 155, when the density method is applied in the topology optimization in the optimization analysis of the optimization analysis unit 23, the volume of the candidate joining line 155 calculated based on the density of the element (plane element, solid element, etc.) modeled as the candidate joining line 155 can be given as a constraint condition. In addition, regarding the constraint condition related to the volume ratio of the component extension portion 159, the volume ratio of the remaining component extension portion 159 can be set to a predetermined value. In the first embodiment, the constraint condition of making the volume ratio of the remaining component extension portion 159 50% or less is set.
[0120] (Optimization Analysis Department)
[0121] The optimization analysis unit 23 assigns the variable load conditions set by the variable load condition setting unit 17 to the optimization analysis model, performs optimization analysis under the optimization analysis conditions, and obtains the configuration of the joining candidate line 155 achieved for any one of the purposes of reducing the cumulative damage degree of the joining candidate line 155, improving the rigidity of the optimization analysis model, and minimizing the length of the remaining joining candidate line 155 as the optimal configuration of the joining line, and based on the residual shape of the component extension portion 159, obtains the optimal shape of the extension object component model (bracket 122) including the portion relative to the component extension portion 159.
[0122] As the optimization analysis by the optimization analysis unit 23, topology optimization can be applied. When the density method is used in topology optimization, a normalized virtual density having a value between 0 and 1 is given as a design variable for an element (a plane element, a solid element, etc.) modeled as the joint candidate line 155, and a density value that satisfies the optimization analysis condition is calculated.
[0123] Furthermore, if the calculated density value is 1, it means that the joint candidate line 155 is completely present, if it is 0, it means that the joint candidate line 155 does not exist, and if it is an intermediate value, the joint of the component group based on the joint candidate line 155 is in an intermediate state.
[0124] Therefore, when the intermediate density is large when the density method is applied in topology optimization, it is preferable to discretize using a penalty coefficient as shown in Formula (3).
[0125] [Number 3]
[0126] K M (ρ) = ρ p K …(3)
[0127] in,
[0128] K M : A stiffness matrix that imposes a penalty on the stiffness matrix of the elements
[0129] K : rigidity matrix of the elements
[0130] ρ: normalization density
[0131] p :penalty coefficient
[0132] The penalty coefficient often used in discretization is 2 or more, but in the optimization analysis of the joining position of the present invention, the penalty coefficient is preferably 4 or more.
[0133] The optimization analysis unit 23 may perform optimization analysis based on topology optimization as described above, or may perform optimization analysis based on other calculation methods.
[0134] Fig.13 1 shows the density distribution of the candidate joining lines 155 and the component extension parts 159 obtained by the optimization analysis unit 23 using the density method in the topology optimization. Fig.13 In (b), a partial enlarged view showing only the portion remaining due to high density is also described with respect to the component shape after the optimization analysis. The shape of the bracket 122 including the portion corresponding to the component extension portion 159 may be determined based on the remaining shape of the three-dimensional element as a result of the optimization analysis.
[0135] Fig.14 An example of the shape of the bracket 122 determined in this manner is shown. Fig.14 (a) is a diagram in which the end portion of the original shape including the upper surface portion is enlarged and extended by a length corresponding to the residual shape portion. Fig.14 (b) is based on the assumption that there is no residual shape on the upper surface of the residual shape part (low density), and it is assumed that Fig.14 (a) shows that the upper surface portion is thinned using TWB (tailor welded blank) material to reduce the weight of the component. Fig.14 (c) is a diagram in which the end of the original shape is enlarged and extended by a length corresponding to the residual shape portion, and a cutout portion 160 is formed in a portion with low element density. The effects of the optimal arrangement of the bonding wires found in the first embodiment will be described in the examples described below.
[0136] <Optimization analysis method of the joint position of the vehicle body>
[0137] In the optimization analysis method for the joining position of the vehicle body of the first embodiment of the present invention (hereinafter referred to as the "optimization analysis method"), for all or part of the vehicle body model having a plurality of component models composed of beam elements, plane elements and / or three-dimensional elements and having an initial joining line 131 for joining the plurality of component models as a component group, a computer executes the following steps to perform optimization analysis to find the optimal configuration of the joining line for the purpose of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model, improving the fatigue life near the joining line for joining the component group in the vehicle body model, and minimizing the length of the joining line, and find the optimal shape of the component model joined by the joining line with a short fatigue life. Fig.15 As shown, the optimization analysis method includes an analysis object model setting step S1, a joint line optimization analysis model generation step S3, a variable load condition setting step S5, a target fatigue life setting step S6, a joint line rigidity sensitivity analysis step S7, a joint line / component shape optimization analysis model generation step S8, an optimization analysis condition setting step S9, and an optimization analysis step S11. These steps are described below. The following steps are performed by an optimization analysis device 1 ( Figure 1 )conduct.
[0138] 《Analysis object model setting steps》
[0139] The analysis target model setting step S1 sets all or part of the vehicle body model as the analysis target model.
[0140] In the first embodiment, in the analysis target model setting step S1 , the analysis target model setting unit 13 sets the rear subframe model 111 , which is a part of the vehicle body model, as the analysis target model.
[0141] 《Steps for generating a joint line optimization analysis model》
[0142] In the welding line optimization analysis model generation step S3 , all the candidate welding lines 155 that are candidates for the welding lines of the optimal arrangement are set in the analysis target model to generate the welding line optimization analysis model.
[0143] In the first embodiment, in the joint line optimization analysis model generation step S3 , the joint line optimization analysis model generation unit 15 generates additional joint lines 153 between the initial joint lines 131 preset in the rear subframe model 111 , and sets both the initial joint lines 131 and the additional joint lines 153 as candidate joint lines 155 .
[0144] 《Steps for Setting Variable Load Conditions》
[0145] In the variable load condition setting step S5 , the variable load applied to the joint line optimization analysis model 151 is divided into load conditions of a plurality of different vibration modes, and the load conditions of the vibration modes are combined in a predetermined number of cycles to form a series of variable load conditions.
[0146] In the first embodiment, in the variable load condition setting step S5, the variable load condition setting unit 17 of the optimization analysis device 1 sets Figure 5 (a) shows one cycle of the load condition of the first vibration mode with Figure 5 The five cycles of the load condition of the second vibration mode shown in (b) are combined as one series of variable load conditions (refer to Figure 7 ), and, if Figure 5 As shown, constraint conditions for constraining constraint points a to d are set.
[0147] 《Steps for Setting Target Fatigue Life》
[0148] The target fatigue life setting step S6 sets the target fatigue life of the joint line optimization analysis model 151 with the sequence number of the variable load condition set in the variable load condition setting step S5. As the target fatigue life of the joint line optimization analysis model 151, the load condition of the vibration mode under the variable load condition set in the variable load condition setting step S5 may be applied to the analysis target model, and a stress analysis may be performed separately. The sequence number of the variable load condition that becomes the fatigue life under the variable load condition of the initial joint line 131 or the joint candidate line 155 of the analysis target model is calculated using the result of the stress analysis. The sequence number of the variable load condition that becomes the target fatigue life is set based on the calculated sequence number of the variable load condition that becomes the fatigue life of the initial joint line 131 or the joint candidate line 155. Alternatively, a predetermined sequence number of the variable load condition may be used as the target fatigue life based on a conventional empirical rule.
[0149] The target fatigue life is the fatigue life that the candidate joining line 155 to be optimized should satisfy, and at least the number of sequences of the variable load conditions that become the shortest fatigue life (shortest fatigue life) of each initial joining line 131 calculated in the target fatigue life setting step S6 is set as the target fatigue life.
[0150] 《Joint Line Stiffness Sensitivity Analysis Procedure》
[0151] The bonding line rigidity sensitivity analysis step S7 is the following step: setting an objective function related to the rigidity performance of the bonding line optimization analysis model 151, constraints related to the volume of the bonding candidate line 155 constituting the bonding line optimization analysis model 151, and variable load conditions applied to the bonding line optimization analysis model 151, performing a sensitivity analysis of the bonding candidate line 155 that satisfies the objective function under the variable load conditions and the constraints, and based on the sensitivity of the bonding candidate line 155, selecting the bonding candidate line 155 with high sensitivity to rigidity performance as a high-rigidity sensitivity bonding line.
[0152] 《Joint line / component shape optimization analysis model generation steps》
[0153] The joining line / component shape optimization analysis model generation step S8 is the following step: a component model that is joined using a rigid high-sensitivity joining line and a joining line with a short fatigue life calculated in the target fatigue life setting step is selected as an extension object component model, and a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model 156 is generated in which a three-dimensional element, namely a component extension portion 159, which is connected to the periphery of the bracket 122 as the extension object component model, and all the joining candidate lines 155 of the joining line optimization analysis model 151 are set as the design space.
[0154] 《Steps for setting optimal analysis conditions》
[0155] In the optimization analysis condition setting step S9, in order to perform an optimization analysis with the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model 156 as the optimization object, the fracture repetition number of each joining candidate line 155 is calculated for each load condition of the different multiple vibration modes in the variable load condition setting step S5, and the ratio of the number of cycles of the load conditions of each vibration mode to the fracture repetition number is calculated. The sum of the number of sequences of the variable load conditions set in the target fatigue life setting step S6 is used as the cumulative damage degree DM of each joining candidate line 155, and the conditions related to the cumulative damage degree of the joining candidate line 155 remaining after the optimization analysis, the conditions related to the rigidity of the joining line optimization analysis model 151, and the conditions related to the length of the joining candidate line 155 remaining after the optimization analysis are set as the objective function or constraint conditions as the optimization analysis conditions, and then the constraint conditions related to the volume ratio of the component extension part 159 are set.
[0156] In the first embodiment, in the optimization analysis condition setting step S9, the optimization analysis condition setting unit 21 sets the maximization of the rigidity of the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model 156 (minimization of the displacement of the rigidity evaluation point A) as the objective function, and sets the constraint conditions that the fatigue life of the joint candidate line 155 is greater than the target fatigue life, the constraint conditions that the length of the remaining joint candidate line 155 is less than the length of the initial joint line 131 and the length of each joint candidate line 155 is greater than 30 mm, and the constraint conditions that the volume ratio of the remaining component extension portion 159 is less than 50% as the optimization analysis conditions.
[0157] As a condition related to rigidity, for example, a predetermined position in the analysis target model may be used as a rigidity evaluation point, and the displacement or strain of the rigidity evaluation point may be used as an index. Furthermore, under a variable load condition, for example, the variable load may be divided into each vibration mode and the displacement of the rigidity evaluation point A under the load condition of each vibration mode may be added to minimize the value, or the displacement of the rigidity evaluation point A under the variable load condition may be minimized as a condition related to rigidity.
[0158] In addition, the condition related to fatigue life is not limited to directly giving the target fatigue life set in the target fatigue life setting step S6 as a constraint condition. For example, a constraint condition that the cumulative damage degree DM of the joining candidate line 155 is less than the cumulative damage degree equivalent to the target fatigue life can also be given.
[0159] 《Optimization Analysis Steps》
[0160] The optimization analysis step S11 provides the variable load conditions set in the variable load condition setting step S5 to the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model 156, performs optimization analysis under the optimization analysis conditions, and obtains the configuration of the joining candidate line 155 achieved for the purpose of reducing the cumulative damage degree of the joining candidate line 155, improving the rigidity of the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model 156, and minimizing the length of the remaining joining candidate line 155 as the optimal configuration of the joining line, and based on the residual shape of the component extension portion 159, obtains the optimal shape of the extension object component model (bracket 122) including the portion relative to the component extension portion 159.
[0161] In the first embodiment, in the optimization analysis step S11, the optimization analysis unit 23 performs optimization analysis on the candidate joining line 155 and the component extension part 159 set in the rear subframe model 111 as optimization objects, and obtains the configuration of the candidate joining line 155 that satisfies the optimization analysis conditions as the optimal configuration of the joining line 157. Then, the shape of the bracket 122 including the portion corresponding to the component extension part 159 is determined ( Fig.14 (a)~(c)).
[0162] <Analysis program for optimizing the joint position of the vehicle body>
[0163] Embodiment 1 of the present invention can be configured as an optimization analysis program for the joint position of a vehicle body that enables various parts of the optimization analysis device 1 for the joint position of a vehicle body constituted by a computer to function. That is, the optimization analysis program for the joint position of a vehicle body involved in embodiment 1 of the present invention uses the whole or a part of the vehicle body model as an analysis object model, obtains the optimal configuration of the joint line for the purpose of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model, improving the fatigue life near the joint line of the joint component group in the vehicle body model, and minimizing the length of the joint line for the analysis object model, and performs optimization analysis to obtain the optimal shape of the component model joined by a joint line with a short fatigue life. Figure 1 As shown in the figure as an example, the optimization analysis program for the joining position of the vehicle body in embodiment 1 of the present invention enables the computer to function as an analysis object model setting unit 13, a joining line optimization analysis model generation unit 15, a variable load condition setting unit 17, a target fatigue life setting unit 18, a joining line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit 19, a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model generation unit 20, an optimization analysis condition setting unit 21, and an optimization analysis unit 23.
[0164] As described above, according to the optimization analysis method, device, and program of the joint position of the vehicle body involved in the first embodiment, the whole or part of the vehicle body model is used as the analysis object model, and the joint line optimization analysis model 151 is generated in which the joint candidate line 155 to be joined as a component group is set for the analysis object model. The optimization analysis conditions (objective function or constraint conditions) related to the remaining line length, fatigue life, and rigidity of the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model 156 of the joint candidate line 155 to be optimized are set to perform optimization analysis on the joint candidate line 155. In this way, when a variable load whose amplitude, direction, etc. changes with time is input to the vehicle body, the optimal arrangement of the joint line and the optimization of the component shape can be simultaneously obtained for the purpose of minimizing the length of the joint candidate line 155, improving the rigidity of the analysis object model, and improving the fatigue life of the joint line of the component group. In this way, by simultaneously taking the joint line and the component shape as the optimization object, the optimization of both (joint line and component shape) that affect each other can be efficiently achieved. As a result, the fatigue life that exceeds the optimal arrangement of the joint line can be achieved.
[0165] In the above description, a vehicle body model that models the entire vehicle body is obtained, and the rear subframe model 111 that is a part of the vehicle body model is set as the analysis target model. However, the present invention may use the entire vehicle body model as the analysis target model, or may use a portion of the vehicle body model other than the rear subframe model 111 as the analysis target model. In addition, a vehicle body partial model that is a part of the vehicle body model may be obtained, and the obtained vehicle body partial model may be used as the analysis target model.
[0166] In addition, the above description takes the case where the initial joint line 131 is preset to 6540 mm in the rear subframe model 111 as an example, but the length of the initial joint line 131 is not limited thereto.
[0167] In addition, the initial joint line 131 is previously set in the rear subframe model 111 by an operator or other means. However, in the present invention, the initial joint line 131 may be set by an operator anew in the analysis target model setting unit or in the analysis target model setting step, or may be set by adding the initial joint line 131 to the analysis target model in which the initial joint line 131 has already been set.
[0168] In the first embodiment, the rear subframe model 111 is set Figure 5 The load conditions and constraint conditions shown in the figure are as follows. However, the present invention only needs to appropriately set the variable load conditions and constraint conditions by assuming the variable loads acting on the part of the vehicle body to be analyzed or the actual vehicle body.
[0169] In the example of the first embodiment, the target performance of the fatigue life of the candidate joining line 155 is set based on the shortest fatigue life (shortest fatigue life) of the initial joining line 131 set in the analysis target model.
[0170] However, the present invention can calculate the additional bonding line 153 set on the initial bonding line 131 before the optimization analysis (see Figure 6 ) of the joining line optimization analysis model 151, determines the shortest fatigue life among the calculated fatigue lives of the joining candidate lines 155, and sets the target fatigue life in the optimization analysis in a manner that satisfies the following relationship.
[0171] (The shortest fatigue life of the initial joint line) ≤ (the target fatigue life of the candidate joint line) ≤ (the shortest fatigue life of the candidate joint line for which the joint line before the optimization analysis is set)
[0172] Furthermore, in the above description, both the initial joining line 131 and the additional joining line 153 are used as the candidate joining line 155 for optimization analysis, but only the additional joining line 153 can be used as the candidate joining line 155, and the initial joining line 131 is not used as the object of optimization analysis, but the optimal configuration of the joining line added to the initial joining line 131 is obtained.
[0173] Furthermore, if the initial weld line 131 is set to be included in the candidate weld line 155 for optimization analysis, the candidate weld line 155 that is joined as a component group in the optimization analysis disappears, the component group becomes scattered, and the optimization analysis may not be performed. In such a case, at least one fixed weld line that is not the object of optimization analysis may be set in each component group.
[0174] For example, a fixed weld line may be arbitrarily selected from the initial weld lines 131 , or a candidate fixed weld line may be set as a candidate for the fixed weld line and stress analysis or optimization analysis of the analysis target model may be performed separately, and the fixed weld line may be selected from the candidate fixed weld lines based on the results.
[0175] In the above description, the fatigue life of the candidate joining line 155 or the rigidity of the joining line optimization analysis model 151 is used as the objective function. However, the length of the candidate joining line 155 may be used as the objective function, and the fatigue life and rigidity may be used as constraints.
[0176] [Implementation Method 2]
[0177] The optimization analysis method of the joint position of the vehicle body according to the first embodiment performs the following optimization analysis: the optimal arrangement of the joint line is achieved for the purpose of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model having the initial joint line 131 where a plurality of component models are joined as a component group, improving the fatigue life of the joint line of the joint component group in the vehicle body model, and minimizing the length of the joint line. However, the present invention can be configured as a vehicle body manufacturing method for manufacturing a vehicle body, the vehicle body manufacturing method optimizes the arrangement of the joint line of the joint component group in the vehicle body, and improves the rigidity of the vehicle body and the fatigue life of the joint line.
[0178] In the manufacturing method of the vehicle body of the second embodiment, the optimization analysis method of the joining position of the vehicle body of the first embodiment is used to find the optimal configuration of the joining lines for all or part of the vehicle body model having an initial joining line for joining a plurality of component models as a component group. In addition, in the manufacturing method of the vehicle body of the second embodiment, the optimal shape of the extended object component model joined by the joining line with a high contribution to the rigidity performance and a short fatigue life is found. Then, based on the optimal shape of the extended object component model, the shape of the corresponding vehicle body component is changed. Furthermore, based on the found optimal configuration of the joining line of the vehicle body model, the joining position of the component group in the vehicle body is determined. Then, the component group of the vehicle body is joined at the determined joining position. As a method of changing the shape of the corresponding vehicle body component based on the optimal shape of the extended object component model, the following method can be exemplified.
[0179] When the density method of topological optimization is used in the optimization analysis, the shape obtained by combining the residual shape of the component extension part (element density distribution above a specified threshold value) as a result of the optimization analysis with the extended object component model is the optimal shape of the extended object component model. As a specific example of a method of changing the shape of a body component, the three-dimensional position data of the residual shape of the component extension part is input into a CAD / CAM program, and CAD processing such as smoothing and shape optimization processing is performed in accordance with the constraints during the actual manufacture of the body component to change the CAD data of the body component corresponding to the extended object component model. The CAD data of the stamping die is produced based on the CAD data of the changed body component, and the stamping die is produced based on the CAD data of the produced stamping die. Then, using the produced stamping die, a body component having an outer shape that can improve the fatigue life of the joint line is produced by stamping.
[0180] There are molds for stamping and molds made of castings and steel. In the case of a stamping mold made of castings, full mold casting (lost foam casting) is used. The full mold casting is to make a casting mold model from a raw material that disappears at high temperature, such as foamed polystyrene, by NC processing using an NC machine tool. In addition, in the case of a stamping mold made of steel, it is necessary to perform mechanical processing (cutting, grinding, and polishing) on the steel by NC processing. The CAD data of the stamping mold made based on the CAD data of the changed body parts is input into a CAD / CAM program that cooperates with the NC machine tool and converted into NC data (NC program) for NC processing. The NC machine tool performs mechanical processing on the casting mold model made of foamed polystyrene or the steel mold. Then, using the obtained NC data (NC program), the casting mold model made of foamed polystyrene or the steel mold is made by the NC machine tool to make the actual stamping mold.
[0181] As a method for determining the joining position of a component group in a car body, the following method can be exemplified. As a specific example of the method for determining the joining position, the position data of the three-dimensional coordinates of the optimal arrangement of the joining line of the car body model obtained by using the optimization analysis method of the joining position of the car body is input into a CAD / CAM program that cooperates with the NC unit of the welding robot configured in the car body welding process, and is converted into NC data (NC program) for the welding robot. In addition, as a specific example of the method for joining the component group in the car body, the welding robot configured in the car body welding process is operated using the converted NC data, so that the component group of the car body is joined at the determined joining position. In this way, according to the manufacturing method of the car body of the third embodiment, it is possible to achieve the optimal arrangement of the welding position of arc welding and the like in the car body structure, improve the fatigue life near the joining line, and improve the rigidity of the car body, and it is possible to achieve the reduction of welding cost and the high rigidity and light weight of the car body.
[0182] [Example]
[0183] Since an analysis was performed to confirm the effect of the present invention, this will be described. Fig.16 As shown, the optimum arrangement of the joining line is obtained by optimization analysis, in which the rear subframe model 111 that models the rear subframe is taken as an object and the component models constituting the rear subframe model 111 are joined as a component group.
[0184] The rear subframe model 111 is a component model as described in the first embodiment. The side frame upper portion 112 and the side frame lower portion 113 are joined by arc welding to form the side frame R211. The side frame upper portion 114 and the side frame lower portion 115 are joined by arc welding to form the side frame L212. The cross beam upper portion 116 and the cross beam lower portion 117 are joined by arc welding to form the cross beam front portion 213. The cross beam front portion 118 and the cross beam rear portion 119 are joined by arc welding to form the rear cross beam 214. These side frames R211, side frames L212, cross beam front portion 213 and rear cross beam 214 are further joined by arc welding to form a cross-shaped structure. These component models are modeled as plane elements.
[0185] In the rear subframe model 111, an initial joining line 131 for joining component models into a component group is set in advance. The initial joining line 131 is modeled by a plane element connecting nodes of the plane elements of the component models, and the length of the initial joining line 131 is 6540 mm.
[0186] <Invention Example>
[0187] In the invention example, first, based on Figure 7 The target fatigue life is set based on the fatigue life of the initial bond line 131 under the varying load conditions shown.
[0188] Figure 7 The variable load conditions shown are the load conditions for the first vibration mode where a variable load of ±2.5 kN is input in the forward and backward directions (input 1) (refer to Figure 5 (a)) and the second vibration mode condition with a variable load of ±6 kN input in the inner / outer direction (input 2) (refer to Figure 5 (b)). In addition, regarding the variable load condition, one cycle of the load condition of the first vibration mode and five cycles of the load condition of the second vibration mode are combined to form one sequence of variable load conditions.
[0189] Next, according to the load condition of the first vibration mode ( Figure 5 (a)) and the load condition of the second vibration mode ( Figure 5 (b) ) A stress analysis of the rear subframe model 111 is performed to obtain the stress generated at the initial joint line 131 under the load conditions of each vibration mode.
[0190] Next, according to the SN line diagram ( Figure 8 ) Calculate the number of repetitions N1 and N2 of different stress amplitudes σ1 and σ2 generated at the initial bonding line 131 under the variable load condition until the initial bonding line 131 breaks when they are generated alone at the initial bonding line 131.
[0191] Then, the number of repetitions N1 and N2 until fracture at each stress amplitude, and the number of cycles n1 (= 1 cycle) and n2 (= 20 cycles) of the load conditions of the first vibration mode and the load conditions of the second vibration mode under one sequence of variable load conditions are substituted into formula (1) to calculate the cumulative damage degree dm under one sequence.
[0192] Furthermore, the sequence number K when the cumulative damage degree DM calculated using equation (2) is 1 or more is calculated as the fatigue life of the initial joint line 131 under the variable load condition, and the target fatigue life is set based on the shortest fatigue life among the fatigue lives of the initial joint lines 131 .
[0193] Then, if Figure 6 As shown, additional joint lines 153 are set between the initial joint lines 131 in the rear subframe model 111, and the joint line optimization analysis model 151 is generated in which the initial joint lines 131 and the additional joint lines 153 are set as joint candidate lines 155.
[0194] Then, an objective function related to the rigidity performance is set for the bonding line optimization analysis model 151, and a sensitivity analysis of the bonding candidate line 155 constituting the bonding line optimization analysis model 151 relative to the variable load conditions is performed. Based on the sensitivity of the bonding candidate line 155, the bonding candidate line 155 with high sensitivity to the rigidity performance is selected as the rigidity high-sensitivity bonding line.
[0195] Specifically, as shown in the first embodiment, the total amount of strain energy in the component model constituting the weld line optimization analysis model 151 is minimized, the volume constraint rate of the weld candidate line 155 as a constraint condition is 50%, and the variable load condition given to the weld line optimization analysis model 151 is set to Figure 5 (a) and Figure 5 The density method in topology optimization is used to perform sensitivity analysis using the density of the candidate joint line 155 calculated by topology optimization under the variable load conditions (input 1, input 2) and constraint conditions shown in (b) of FIG. The sensitivity analysis results show that a high joint line with a sensitivity to rigidity performance of 0.8 or more exists at the joint between the side frame lower portion 113 and the bracket 122, and therefore it is selected as a high rigidity sensitivity joint line.
[0196] In addition, the bonding line of the bracket 122 bonded by the rigid high-sensitivity bonding line is also a bonding line with a short fatigue life calculated in the target fatigue life setting step, so the bracket 122 is selected as the extension target component model. Then, the component extension part 159 as a three-dimensional element is combined around the bracket 122 as the extension target component model, and the bonding line / component shape optimization analysis model 156 is generated in which the component extension part 159 and the bonding candidate line 155 composed of three-dimensional elements are set as the design space. In the invention example, this bonding line / component shape optimization analysis model 156 is used as the optimization target.
[0197] <Comparative Example>
[0198] In the comparative example, the component shape is not optimized, but the aforementioned weld line optimization analysis model 151 is optimized.
[0199] Next, the invention examples and comparative examples were given Figure 5 The optimization analysis is performed for each load condition and constraint condition shown, and the candidate joining line 155 satisfying the optimization analysis conditions is obtained. In the optimization analysis, topology optimization based on the density method is applied, and the penalty coefficient is set to 4 in the topology optimization to perform discretization.
[0200] Table 1 shows the combination of objective function and constraint function for optimizing analysis conditions.
[0201] [Table 1]
[0202]
[0203] The objective function related to rigidity is set as the rigidity evaluation point A (refer to Fig.14 ) is less than the displacement of the rigidity evaluation point A when stress analysis is performed on the rear subframe model 111 having the initial joint line 131 set.
[0204] In addition, regarding the constraint condition related to fatigue life, the cumulative damage degree DM of the candidate joint line 155 under the variable load condition is calculated in the same manner as the initial joint line 131 described above. Moreover, the fatigue life calculated based on the cumulative damage degree DM of each candidate joint line 155 is greater than the target fatigue life. Furthermore, the length of the candidate joint line 155, that is, the objective function and constraint condition related to the joint length are set to a condition that the length of the candidate joint line 155 remaining through the optimization analysis is less than the length of the initial joint line 131. The constraint condition of the component shape in the inventive example is to set the volume ratio of the rigid low-sensitivity component to less than 50%.
[0205] The remaining candidate joining line 155 and the result of the component shape in the example of the invention are as shown in the first embodiment. Fig.13 In addition, the result of the remaining bonding candidate line 155 in the comparative example is shown in Fig.17 middle.
[0206] In the present invention, the component extension portion 159 set on the bracket 122 is as follows: Fig.13 As shown, the two side wall portions are in a residual shape, and the candidate joining lines 155 are arranged more sparsely than the initial joining lines 131 .
[0207] In addition, although there is no significant difference compared to the comparative example, the joining line (see Fig.13 and Fig.17 The portion surrounded by the dotted line) is sparsely arranged in the invention example compared with the comparative example.
[0208] Next, in order to evaluate the performance of the invention example and the comparative example, for the invention example, the candidate bonding lines 155 remaining after the optimization analysis were used as the optimally arranged bonding lines 157 (see Fig.13 ), and the part corresponding to the component extension is Fig.14 (a)~ Fig.14 The optimal rear subframe model with a joint line also arranged in the part shape shown in (c) of FIG. 1 was used as the object, and the analysis model with the joint candidate line 155 remaining after the optimization analysis was set as the object for the comparative example, and the rigidity and fatigue life of the joint line were calculated. Fig.14 In the method shown in (b), the plate thickness is set to two modes: (2.6T / 1.0T) and (2.0T / 1.0T).
[0209] In the calculation of rigidity and fatigue life, Figure 5 The load conditions of the first vibration mode and the load conditions and constraints of the second vibration mode shown in FIG. 1 are applied to the optimal weld line rear subframe model 161 to perform stress analysis. With regard to rigidity, the rigidity evaluation point A (see FIG. 1 ) obtained by stress analysis under the load conditions of the first vibration mode and the load conditions of the second vibration mode is Figure 5 )’s displacements are used as indicators respectively.
[0210] Regarding the fatigue life, the shortest fatigue life among fatigue lives calculated using the stress of the joint line obtained by stress analysis of the optimal joint line rear subframe model 161 is used as an index.
[0211] The evaluation results are shown in Table 2. The shape of the bracket 122 of Inventive Example 1 in Table 2 is as follows: Fig.14 As shown in (a), Example 2 (Case 1) is Fig.14 (b) and the plate thickness is (2.6T / 1.0T), Example 2 (Case 2) is Fig.14 (b) and the plate thickness is (2.0T / 1.0T), Example 3 of the invention is Fig.14 Table 2 also shows the weld length (weld length) (length of the bonding wire) and the component weight.
[0212] [Table 2]
[0213]
[0214] The improvement rate of stiffness of inputs 1 and 2 is calculated by the following formula.
[0215] [Number 4]
[0216]
[0217]
[0218] It can be confirmed that the welding lengths of Inventive Example 1, Inventive Example 2 (Case 1, Case 2) and Inventive Example 3 are shorter than those of the original parts and the comparative examples, and the performance (fatigue life, rigidity) can be improved. In particular, the fatigue life exceeds 10 times that of the original parts and can be significantly improved to more than 2 times that of the comparative example.
[0219] [Industrial Application Possibility]
[0220] According to the present invention, a method, device and program for optimizing the joint position of a vehicle body, as well as a method for manufacturing a vehicle body can be provided, which can improve the rigidity of the vehicle body and the fatigue life of the continuous joint line that joins the component group in the vehicle body when a simple or variable load is input to the vehicle body, and at the same time achieve the optimal configuration of the joint line that minimizes the length of the joint line and the optimization of the component shape.
[0221] [Explanation of Reference Numerals]
[0222] 1 Optimization of analytical equipment
[0223] 3 Display device
[0224] 5 Input Devices
[0225] 7 Storage Devices
[0226] 9 Data storage for operation
[0227] 11. Calculation processing unit
[0228] 13 Analysis object model setting section
[0229] 15 Joint line optimization analysis model generation department
[0230] 17 Variable load condition setting section
[0231] 18 Target fatigue life setting section
[0232] 19 Bonding line rigidity sensitivity analysis section
[0233] 20 Joint line / component shape optimization analysis model generation department
[0234] 21 Optimization analysis condition setting section
[0235] 23 Optimization Analysis Department
[0236] 31 Optimization analysis device
[0237] 33. Calculation Processing Unit
[0238] 34 Optimization Analysis Department
[0239] 100 Tire Input Points
[0240] 101 Car body model file
[0241] 111 Rear subframe model
[0242] 112 Side frame upper part
[0243] 113 Side frame lower part
[0244] 114 Side frame upper part
[0245] 115 Side frame lower part
[0246] 116 Upper beam
[0247] 117 Lower part of beam
[0248] 118 Front of beam
[0249] 119 Rear of beam
[0250] 120, 121, 122 brackets
[0251] 131 Initial bonding line
[0252] 141 Arc welding department
[0253] 151 Bonding Line Optimization Analysis Model
[0254] 153 Additional bonding line
[0255] 155 Joining candidate line
[0256] 156 Joint Line / Component Shape Optimization Analysis Model
[0257] 157 Bonding Wire
[0258] 159 Component Extension
[0259] 160 Notch
[0260] 211 Side frame R
[0261] 212 Side frame L
[0262] 213 Front of beam
[0263] 214 rear crossbeam
Claims
1. A method for optimizing the joint position of a vehicle body, wherein a computer executes the following steps to optimize the whole or part of a vehicle body model, wherein the vehicle body model has a plurality of component models composed of beam elements, plane elements and / or solid elements, and has an initial joint line for joining the plurality of component models as a component group, wherein the optimization analysis obtains an optimal arrangement of the joint line for any one of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model, improving the fatigue life near the joint line for joining the component group in the vehicle body model, and minimizing the length of the joint line, and obtains an optimal shape of the component model joined by the joint line with a short fatigue life, wherein the optimization analysis method comprises: an analysis object model setting step of setting all or part of the vehicle body model as an analysis object model; a step of generating a joining line optimization analysis model, wherein the joining line optimization analysis model sets all candidate joining lines that are candidates for the optimally arranged joining lines for the analysis target model; A variable load condition setting step of setting a variable load condition, wherein the variable load condition is divided into load conditions of a plurality of different vibration modes, and the load conditions of the vibration modes are combined into one sequence with a predetermined number of cycles; a target fatigue life setting step of providing the variable load condition to the analysis object model or the joint line optimization analysis model to perform stress analysis, calculating the fatigue life of the joint line of the analysis object model or the joint line optimization analysis model, and setting the target fatigue life according to the sequence number of the variable load condition based on the calculation result; a step of analyzing the rigidity sensitivity of a bonding line, setting an objective function related to the rigidity performance of the bonding line optimization analysis model, a constraint condition related to the volume of the bonding line candidate, and a variable load condition provided to the bonding line optimization analysis model, performing sensitivity analysis of all the bonding line candidate components constituting the bonding line optimization analysis model satisfying the objective function under the variable load condition and the constraint condition, and selecting a bonding line candidate having a high sensitivity to rigidity performance as a high rigidity sensitivity bonding line based on the sensitivity of the bonding line candidate components; A step of generating a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model, wherein the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model selects a component model to be joined using the rigid high-sensitivity joining line and the joining line with a short fatigue life calculated in the target fatigue life setting step as an extension target component model, and sets a component extension portion, which is a three-dimensional element connected to the periphery of the extension target component model, and all the candidate joining lines of the joining line optimization analysis model as a design space; an optimization analysis condition setting step, in order to perform an optimization analysis taking the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model as an optimization object, finding the number of fracture repetitions near each joint candidate line according to each load condition of each vibration mode, finding the ratio of the number of cycles of the load conditions of each vibration mode to the number of fracture repetitions, and the sum of the number of sequences of the variable load conditions set by the target fatigue life setting step as the cumulative damage degree of each joint candidate line, setting conditions related to the cumulative damage degree of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis, conditions related to the rigidity of the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, and conditions related to the length of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis as objective functions or constraints as optimization analysis conditions, and setting constraints related to the volume ratio of the component extension portion; and An optimization analysis step, providing the variable load condition set in the variable load condition setting step to the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model, performing optimization analysis under the optimization analysis condition, obtaining the configuration of the joining candidate line achieved for the purpose of reducing the cumulative damage degree of the joining candidate line, improving the rigidity of the optimization analysis model, and minimizing the length of the remaining joining candidate line as the optimal configuration of the joining line, and based on the residual shape of the component extension part, obtaining the optimal shape of the extended object component model including the portion corresponding to the component extension part.
2. The method for optimizing the joint position of a vehicle body according to claim 1, wherein: The optimization analysis step performs topology optimization based on a density method, and in the topology optimization, a penalty coefficient is set to 4 or more to perform discretization.
3. An optimization analysis device for a joint position of a vehicle body, wherein a computer executes the following steps to perform optimization analysis on all or part of a vehicle body model, wherein the vehicle body model has a plurality of component models composed of beam elements, plane elements and / or solid elements, and has an initial joint line for joining the plurality of component models as a component group, wherein the optimization analysis obtains an optimal arrangement of the joint line for any one of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model, improving the fatigue life near the joint line for joining the component group in the vehicle body model, and minimizing the length of the joint line, and obtains an optimal shape of the component model joined by a joint line with a short fatigue life, wherein the optimization analysis device comprises: an analysis target model setting unit that sets all or part of the vehicle body model as an analysis target model; a joining line optimization analysis model generating unit that generates a joining line optimization analysis model that sets all candidate joining lines that are candidates for the optimally arranged joining lines for the analysis target model; a variable load condition setting unit for setting a variable load condition, wherein the variable load condition is divided into load conditions of a plurality of different vibration modes, and the load conditions of the vibration modes are combined in a predetermined number of cycles as one sequence; a target fatigue life setting unit that provides the variable load condition to the analysis target model or the joint line optimization analysis model to perform stress analysis, calculates the fatigue life of the joint line of the analysis target model or the joint line optimization analysis model, and sets the target fatigue life with the order of the variable load condition based on the calculation result; a bonding line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit, which sets an objective function related to the rigidity performance of the bonding line optimization analysis model, a constraint condition related to the volume of the bonding line candidate, and a variable load condition provided to the bonding line optimization analysis model, performs sensitivity analysis of all bonding line candidate components constituting the bonding line optimization analysis model satisfying the objective function under the variable load condition and the constraint condition, and selects a bonding line candidate having a high sensitivity to rigidity performance as a high rigidity sensitivity bonding line based on the sensitivity of the bonding line candidate; a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model generating unit, generating a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model, wherein the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model selects a component model to be joined using the rigidity high-sensitivity joining line and the joining line with a short fatigue life calculated by the target fatigue life setting unit as an extension target component model, and sets a component extension unit, which is a three-dimensional element connected to the periphery of the extension target component model, and all the candidate joining lines of the joining line optimization analysis model as a design space; an optimization analysis condition setting unit, for performing an optimization analysis with the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model as an optimization object, obtaining the number of fracture repetitions near each joint candidate line according to each load condition of each vibration mode, obtaining the ratio of the number of cycles of the load conditions of each vibration mode to the number of fracture repetitions, and the sum of the number of sequences of the variable load conditions set by the target fatigue life setting unit as the cumulative damage degree of each joint candidate line, setting conditions related to the cumulative damage degree of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis, conditions related to the rigidity of the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, and conditions related to the length of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis as objective functions or constraints as optimization analysis conditions, and setting constraints related to the volume ratio of the component extension portion; and An optimization analysis unit provides the variable load condition set in the variable load condition setting unit to the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model, performs optimization analysis under the optimization analysis condition, obtains the configuration of the joining candidate line achieved for any one of the purposes of reducing the cumulative damage degree of the joining candidate line, improving the rigidity of the optimization analysis model, and minimizing the length of the remaining joining candidate line as the optimal configuration of the joining line, and based on the residual shape of the component extension part, obtains the optimal shape of the extended object component model including the portion corresponding to the component extension part.
4. The optimization analysis device for the joint position of the vehicle body according to claim 3, wherein: The optimization analysis unit performs topology optimization based on a density method, and discretization is performed by setting a penalty coefficient to 4 or more in the topology optimization.
5. A program for optimizing the joint position of a vehicle body, which performs optimization analysis on all or part of a vehicle body model, wherein the vehicle body model has a plurality of component models composed of beam elements, plane elements and / or solid elements, and has an initial joint line for joining the plurality of component models as a component group, wherein the optimization analysis obtains an optimal arrangement of the joint line for any one of improving the rigidity of the vehicle body model, improving the fatigue life near the joint line for joining the component group in the vehicle body model, and minimizing the length of the joint line, and obtains an optimal shape of the component models joined by a joint line with a short fatigue life, wherein the optimization analysis program causes a computer to function as the following component: an analysis target model setting unit that sets all or part of the vehicle body model as an analysis target model; a joining line optimization analysis model generating unit that generates a joining line optimization analysis model that sets all candidate joining lines that are candidates for the optimally arranged joining lines for the analysis target model; a variable load condition setting unit for setting a variable load condition, wherein the variable load condition is divided into load conditions of a plurality of different vibration modes, and the load conditions of the vibration modes are combined in a predetermined number of cycles as one sequence; a target fatigue life setting unit that provides the variable load condition to the analysis target model or the joint line optimization analysis model to perform stress analysis, calculates the fatigue life of the joint line of the analysis target model or the joint line optimization analysis model, and sets the target fatigue life with the order of the variable load condition based on the calculation result; a bonding line rigidity sensitivity analysis unit, which sets an objective function related to the rigidity performance of the bonding line optimization analysis model, a constraint condition related to the volume of the bonding line candidate, and a variable load condition provided to the bonding line optimization analysis model, performs sensitivity analysis of all bonding line candidate components constituting the bonding line optimization analysis model satisfying the objective function under the variable load condition and the constraint condition, and selects a bonding line candidate having a high sensitivity to rigidity performance as a high rigidity sensitivity bonding line based on the sensitivity of the bonding line candidate; a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model generating unit, generating a joining line / component shape optimization analysis model, wherein the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model selects a component model to be joined using the rigidity high-sensitivity joining line and the joining line with a short fatigue life calculated by the target fatigue life setting unit as an extension target component model, and sets a component extension unit, which is a three-dimensional element connected to the periphery of the extension target component model, and all the candidate joining lines of the joining line optimization analysis model as a design space; an optimization analysis condition setting unit, for performing an optimization analysis with the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model as an optimization object, obtaining the number of fracture repetitions near each joint candidate line according to each load condition of each vibration mode, obtaining the ratio of the number of cycles of the load conditions of each vibration mode to the number of fracture repetitions, and the sum of the number of sequences of the variable load conditions set by the target fatigue life setting unit as the cumulative damage degree of each joint candidate line, setting conditions related to the cumulative damage degree of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis, conditions related to the rigidity of the joint line / component shape optimization analysis model, and conditions related to the length of the joint candidate line remaining after the optimization analysis as objective functions or constraints as optimization analysis conditions, and setting constraints related to the volume ratio of the component extension portion; and An optimization analysis unit provides the variable load condition set in the variable load condition setting unit to the joining line / component shape optimization analysis model, performs optimization analysis under the optimization analysis condition, obtains the configuration of the joining candidate line achieved for any one of the purposes of reducing the cumulative damage degree of the joining candidate line, improving the rigidity of the optimization analysis model, and minimizing the length of the remaining joining candidate line as the optimal configuration of the joining line, and based on the residual shape of the component extension part, obtains the optimal shape of the extended object component model including the portion corresponding to the component extension part.
6. The optimization analysis program for the joint position of the vehicle body according to claim 5, wherein: The optimization analysis unit performs topology optimization based on a density method, and discretization is performed by setting a penalty coefficient to 4 or more in the topology optimization.
7. A method for manufacturing a vehicle body, wherein a joint line for joining a component group in a vehicle body is optimally arranged to improve the rigidity of the vehicle body and the fatigue life of the joint line, wherein: Using the optimization analysis method for the joining position of the vehicle body described in claim 1 or 2, the optimal shape of the extended object component model and the optimal configuration of the joining line are calculated, the shape of the corresponding vehicle body component is changed based on the optimal shape of the extended object component model, the joining position of the component group in the vehicle body is determined based on the determined optimal configuration of the joining line, and the component group of the vehicle body is joined at the determined joining position.
