Method, computer program, system for designing a manufacturing product with mechanical function

By optimizing the continuous parameters of the CAD model, using shape difference measurement and gradient optimization methods, the problem that CAD systems in the prior art are difficult to deal with discrete representation format shapes is solved, and the efficient CAD model is realized to adapt to polygonal mesh shapes, improving design and manufacturing Product efficiency and accuracy.

CN119066790APending Publication Date: 2024-12-03DASSAULT SYSTEMES SA
View PDF 0 Cites 2 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202410710928.2
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Applications(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2023-06-01
Filing Date
2024-06-03
Publication Date
2024-12-03

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Existing computer-aided design (CAD) systems are difficult to efficiently handle shapes based on discrete representation formats when designing manufacturing products with mechanical functions, resulting in inefficient design.

Method used

By obtaining the first instance of the CAD model and the grid of the target boundary shape, the continuous parameters of the CAD model are optimized using the shape difference metric to minimize the shape difference metric, and a second instance of the CAD model similar to the target shape is generated. The method includes a gradient-based optimization method that uses sensitivity and symbol distance fields to minimize the shape difference metric.

Benefits of technology

It realizes efficient and general CAD model optimization, can automatically adapt to the shape of the polygonal mesh, maintain the parameterization and construction logic of the CAD model, and improves the efficiency and accuracy of designing and manufacturing products.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN119066790A_ABST
    Figure CN119066790A_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present disclosure relates to a computer-implemented method, system, computer program and computer-readable storage medium for designing a manufactured product having one or more mechanical functions. The method includes obtaining a first instance of the CAD model and a mesh representing a target boundary shape of the manufactured product, and determining a second instance of the CAD model. The CAD model includes a feature tree having a plurality of consecutive CAD parameters, and a set of one or more multi-parametric constraints specifying one or more mechanical functions. The first instance includes a first value for each continuous CAD parameter, respectively, and the second instance includes a second value for each continuous CAD parameter. Determining the second instance consists of calculating a second value by modifying at least part of the first value to minimize a shape difference measure between the boundary shape represented by the first instance of the CAD model and the target boundary shape.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present disclosure relates to the field of computer programs and systems, and more particularly to a method, system and program for designing an article having one or more mechanical functions. Background Art

[0002] There are a variety of systems and programs available on the market for designing, engineering and manufacturing objects. CAD is an abbreviation for computer-aided design, for example, and it refers to software solutions for designing objects. CAE is an abbreviation for computer-aided engineering, for example, and it refers to software solutions for simulating the physical behavior of future products. CAM is an abbreviation for computer-aided manufacturing, for example, and it refers to software solutions for defining manufacturing processes and operations. In such computer-aided design systems, graphical user interfaces play an important role in the efficiency of the technology. These technologies can be embedded in product lifecycle management (PLM) systems. PLM is a business strategy that helps companies share product data, apply common processes and exploit enterprise knowledge for product development from the concept of a product to the end of its lifecycle, within the scope of the concept of an extended enterprise. PLM solutions provided by Dassault Systèmes (under the trademarks CATIA, ENOVIA and DELMIA) provide an engineering center that organizes product engineering knowledge, a manufacturing center that manages manufacturing engineering knowledge, and an enterprise center that enables the enterprise to integrate and connect the engineering center and the manufacturing center. The entire system provides an open object model that links products, processes and resources to enable knowledge-based dynamic product creation and decision support to drive optimized product definition, manufacturing preparation, production and service.

[0003] Some solutions and products for designing manufactured products are already available. These solutions provide design output in the form of parametric CAD models or discrete representations. However, these solutions do not allow for efficient CAD model design based on shapes that only exist in discrete representation formats.

[0004] Given these circumstances, there remains a need for an improved computer-implemented method for designing a manufactured product having one or more mechanical functions. Summary of the invention

[0005] Therefore, a computer-implemented method for designing a manufactured product having one or more mechanical functions is provided. The method includes obtaining a first instance of a CAD model, and a mesh representing a target boundary shape of the manufactured product. The CAD model includes a feature tree having a plurality of continuous CAD parameters. The CAD model also includes a set of one or more parameterized constraints, wherein the set of parameterized constraints specifies one or more mechanical functions. The first instance includes a first value for each continuous CAD parameter. The method also includes determining a second instance of the CAD model from the first instance of the CAD model. The second instance includes a second value for each continuous CAD parameter. The determination of the second instance consists of calculating a second value by modifying at least a portion of the first value so as to minimize a shape difference measure (ERR) between a boundary shape represented by the first instance of the CAD model and a target boundary shape.

[0006] The method may include one or more of the following:

[0007] The shape difference metric is a difference metric between a first scalar field and a second scalar field, the first scalar field being defined based on a CAD model and the second scalar field being defined based on a mesh;

[0008] The first scalar field is defined based on a first shape enclosing the first instance of the CAD model, and the second scalar field is defined based on a second shape enclosing the target boundary shape; wherein, optionally, each of the first shape and the second shape is a respective bounding box;

[0009] The first scalar field is an application of a first function to a corresponding signed distance field of a first instance of the CAD model, and the second scalar field is an application of a second function to a corresponding signed distance field of the mesh; wherein, optionally, the first function and the second function are the same;

[0010] Each of the first scalar field and the second scalar field is a density field, wherein optionally, at least one of the first function and the second function is a smooth Heaviside function or an approximation of a smooth Heaviside function;

[0011] The difference measure between the first scalar field and the second scalar field is a measure of the square of the difference between the first scalar field and the second scalar field; wherein, optionally, the square of the difference measure comprises: the sum of the squares of the differences, the smoothed minimum of the squares of the differences, or the smoothed maximum of the squares of the differences;

[0012] The minimization uses a gradient-based optimization method that takes multiple continuous CAD parameters as free variables, and the shape difference metric is a differentiable function with respect to the free variables;

[0013] The optimization method uses sensitivities, each sensitivity being an approximation of a respective derivative of a respective shape difference metric with respect to a respective CAD parameter of a plurality of continuous CAD parameters;

[0014] The sensitivity is a combination of: respective derivatives of the shape difference metric with respect to the signed distance field, and respective derivatives of the signed distance field with respect to respective CAD parameters of the plurality of continuous CAD parameters;

[0015] Each of the respective derivatives of the shape difference metric with respect to the signed distance field comprises an analytical derivative;

[0016] The respective derivatives of the signed distance field with respect to the respective CAD parameters comprise approximate derivatives; the approximate derivatives optionally comprise finite differences; and / or

[0017] The CAD model also includes manufacturing specifications associated with portions of the feature tree, and both the first instance and the second instance are configured to be input to a manufacturing tool and manufactured according to the manufacturing specifications.

[0018] A computer program comprising instructions for performing the method is also provided.

[0019] A computer-readable storage medium is also provided, on which the computer program is recorded.

[0020] A system is also provided, comprising a processor connected to a memory having the computer program recorded thereon. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0021] Some non-limiting examples will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:

[0022] Figure 1 An example of a graphical user interface for the system is shown;

[0023] Figure 2 An example of a system is shown;

[0024] Figure 3-4 An example of a parametric CAD model is shown;

[0025] Figure 5 An example of a polygonal mesh is shown;

[0026] Figure 6 A graphical representation of an example application of the method is shown;

[0027] Figure 7 An example flow chart of the method is shown;

[0028] Figure 8-14 An example of the steps of the method is shown;

[0029] Fig.15A and 15B A mathematical formula summary of the method is shown;

[0030] Figure 16-18An example application of the method on a 3D linkage is shown;

[0031] 19-22 show an example application of the method to 2D shape imprints. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0032] A computer-implemented method for designing a manufacturing product (i.e., also referred to as a product to be manufactured, a manufacturable product, or an article) having one or more mechanical functions is presented herein. The method includes obtaining a first instance and a mesh of a CAD model. The CAD model includes a feature tree. The feature tree has a plurality of continuous CAD parameters. The CAD model also includes a set of one or more parametrization constraints. The set of one or more parametrization constraints specifies one or more mechanical functions. The first instance (of the CAD model) includes a first value for each continuous CAD parameter. The obtained mesh represents a target boundary shape of the manufacturing product. The target boundary shape refers to a boundary shape that is at least a target of the manufacturing product. The method further includes determining a second instance of the CAD model from the first instance of the (obtained) CAD model. The second instance includes a second value for each continuous CAD parameter. The step of determining the second instance (step) consists of calculating the second value by modifying at least a portion of the first value so as to minimize a shape difference measure between the boundary shape represented by the CAD model and the target boundary shape.

[0033] This method constitutes an improved solution for designing and manufacturing products by forming an efficient, universal and automatic method to optimize the CAD model to adapt to the provided grid. This means that, by providing a first instance of a CAD model that can be used as a template for a parametric CAD model on the one hand, and a grid on the other hand, the method is able to find the best parameters for modifying the template to obtain a shape that is as similar as possible to the provided grid. Therefore, the method determines a second instance of the template, which includes optimized values ​​of continuous CAD parameters of the template. By minimizing the shape difference measure between the boundary shape represented by the CAD model and the target boundary shape, it is achieved to obtain a shape similar to the provided grid. Therefore, the method is able to adapt the provided grid to a parameterized (i.e., parameterized) CAD model with the best similar boundary shape. The method does not impose any restrictions on the type of CAD operations in the CAD model. This makes the method universal for designing various manufactured products.

[0034] In particular, this method helps designers and engineers in the design process. In the field of engineering, it is very common to perform a design process based on a provided mesh (e.g., a polygonal mesh) without having to obtain the corresponding CAD file of the provided mesh. Such a mesh can be retrieved from an internal database or downloaded from an online library. Additionally or alternatively, such a mesh can be obtained by a topology optimization method. As is known, a topology optimization method can provide a (e.g., voxel) mesh of the final design based on the value of a material density function. Furthermore, additionally or alternatively, such a mesh stored in the database may be a mesh generated / output by a software package that is no longer available to the designer. Furthermore, additionally or alternatively, such a mesh stored in the database may be a mesh generated / output by a scanning process.

[0035] In some examples, the method may obtain a mesh through a 3D scanning process. In other words, the method may include a scanning process of a physical sample of a mechanical product before obtaining the mesh. The scanning process may output a point cloud or a mesh representing the mechanical component. The method may convert the point cloud into a mesh. In such an example, the method may be particularly useful for obtaining a CAD model of a physical object through a scanning process. The method may obtain such a CAD model by deforming a template of the CAD model into the output of the scan. These applications are particularly relevant to reverse engineering using a sample of a physical object when the manufacturing details of the physical object are not available. For example, the method may be used to make a model of an existing manufactured product.

[0036] In an example of the method, the provided CAD model (or its first instance) may include manufacturing specifications or instructions. These specifications may include a set of high-level specifications for the CAD model manufacturing process (e.g., specifications for surface treatment, allowable tolerances and / or preferred manufacturing methods). Each specification may be associated with a corresponding portion of a feature tree. The corresponding portion of the feature tree includes one or more CAD features so that the CAD features obtained by the portion are associated with the specifications. In other words, each specification may be associated with one or more features of the CAD model represented by the union result of the portions of the feature tree. These manufacturing specifications are associated with any instance of the CAD model. In other words, the first instance and the second instance are configured to be input to a manufacturing tool and manufactured (e.g., directly and without further intervention by the user) according to the manufacturing specifications. The object manufactured has a physical shape corresponding to the geometry represented by the input (i.e., provided) mesh. These manufacturing processes will be discussed below.

[0037] "Designing a manufactured product" refers to any action or series of actions that may be at least part of a process of elaborating a (3D or 2D) modeled object for a manufactured product. The manufactured product may in particular be a mechanical component. The method may form such a process or at least form part of a process. In some examples, the elaboration process may include deforming a first design into a template for the manufactured product / mechanical component (e.g., based on a provided / acquired mesh). In such a deformation, the template of the parametric CAD model may be automatically instantiated to replicate a shape or follow a given mating surface while maintaining its clear and precise CAD structure.

[0038] Therefore, the method generally manipulates modeling objects, such as finite 3D meshes / 2D meshes or CAD models designed / output by the method. A modeling object is any object defined by data stored (e.g., in a database). By extension, the term "modeling object" refers to the data itself. Depending on the type of system, the modeling object can be defined by different types of data. The system can be any combination of a CAD system, a CAE system, a CAM system, a PDM system, and / or a PLM system. In these different systems, the modeling object is defined by corresponding data. Therefore, CAD objects, PLM objects, PDM objects, CAE objects, CAM objects, CAD data, PLM data, PDM data, CAM data, CAE data can be respectively mentioned. However, these systems are not mutually exclusive, because the modeling object can be defined by data corresponding to any combination of these systems. Therefore, a system can be both a CAD system, a CAE system, a PLM system, and / or a CAM system. The concepts of CAD and CAM systems will be discussed in detail below.

[0039] "A manufactured product having one or more mechanical functions" means that the manufactured product can achieve one or more specific functions. These functions can be achieved in cooperation with other components / products or independently. These functions may include mating functions, that is, functions achieved by contact with another component of the assembly. For example, a manufactured product may have one or more surfaces defined as support surfaces, and are arranged to be parallel to each other, and optionally one or more surfaces are fixed at a constant distance. In another example, a manufactured product may be provided with a through hole around a fixed axis, and optionally the through hole is a fixed diameter. In other examples, the manufactured product may be subject to one or more mating constraints. The mechanical function can be defined by one or more functional parts of the manufactured product. The so-called functional part refers to a part whose geometric shape and / or topological structure is to achieve the function of the product (i.e., functionality). In the example, the manufactured product may be a shaft, and the functional part of the shaft may be its locally cylindrical outer surface. In other words, although the local diameter of the shaft at each position or the length of the shaft may vary, any instance of a general shaft template has such a local cylindrical shape. In particular, this cylindrical shape is directly related to the function of the shaft in energy transfer. Other examples of such functional parts of the template CAD model may be keyways (although with different forms / lengths / depths) or gears (although with different tooth heights, gear angles or different diameters / widths). The manufactured product may also have other mechanical functions. These other mechanical functions are not specified by one or more parametric constraints of the acquired CAD model. These mechanical functions may not necessarily be maintained in the second instance of the CAD model.

[0040] As described above, the method includes obtaining a first instance and mesh of a CAD model. By "obtaining" is meant providing it to the method. The method may, optionally upon action by a user / designer, obtain a first instance and / or mesh of a CAD model from a local or online database. As known, a CAD model is a parametric model. In other words, a CAD model is defined using a set of parameters. An "instance" of a (parametric) CAD model refers to an instantiation (i.e., realization) of the CAD model when a corresponding value is assigned to the parameter set defining the CAD model. In an example, the parameter set may include one or more position parameters (e.g., coordinates of one or more points of the CAD model) and / or one or more size parameters (e.g., an angle and / or length or area between two surfaces). As further known, a (parametric) CAD includes a feature tree. The feature tree is defined at least in part by a parameter set. The feature tree of the CAD model has a plurality of continuous CAD parameters. A continuous parameter is a subset of the parameter set of the above-mentioned CAD model. A "continuous CAD parameter" refers to a CAD parameter that can be continuously varied within a corresponding range. For example, the length of a rod may vary continuously between a minimum length and a maximum length (e.g., as defined by an extrusion operator in a feature tree). In some examples, a plurality of continuous CAD parameters may include a plurality of coordinates of one or more points of a CAD model, such as points on a boundary of a CAD model. The CAD model may be 2D or 3D. In an example where the CAD model is a 3D CAD model, a plurality of continuous CAD parameters may include one or more parameters associated with a plurality of 2D surfaces forming a boundary of the CAD model. In an example where the CAD model is a 2D model, a plurality of continuous CAD parameters may include one or more parameters associated with a plurality of (1D) line segments. The plurality of line segments may be line segments defining a boundary of a CAD model. The continuous CAD parameters may further include one or more parameters associated with a plurality of control points, and / or one or more parameters associated with a plurality of splines.

[0041] In some examples, the feature tree of the CAD model may further include a set of discontinuous parameters. These discontinuous parameters remain constant in each instance of the CAD model, so these parameters are not free variables in the shape difference optimization for determining the second instance of the CAD model. In other words, these discontinuous parameters belong to the fixed parameters of the optimization. For example, the method can determine the optimal value of the radius of a fillet feature, the depth of a groove feature, or the angle of a thread. However, the method may not change binary or strongly discontinuous parameters such as the presence / absence of features or components (e.g., mirrors or wheels of a car) during the optimization process.

[0042] In addition to a plurality of continuous CAD parameters, the CAD model also includes a set of one or more parameterized constraints. The group can determine one or more individual parameters of one or more corresponding features in the feature tree, and / or one or more relationships between one or more corresponding features. The group can include one or more limits (i.e., upper / lower limits) of the corresponding range of one or more of the continuous CAD parameters. For example, any of the ranges can define the allowable value range of the extrusion length along the extrusion axis or the allowable value range of the rotation angle along the rotation axis. For another example, any of the ranges can define the presence of holes (e.g., through holes) in the manufacturing part by setting a non-zero minimum value of the aperture. Such holes can be particularly assigned to mechanical functions that accept shafts, fixtures, bearings, or screws. Additionally or optionally, the group can include one or more CAD operators (operators) that define (each instance of) the CAD model. For example, one or more CAD operators can be one or more of fillet, extrusion, cutting, and rotation. Additionally or optionally, the group can include one or more geometric constraints. Geometric constraints can establish a constraint relationship between two parameters of the CAD model. In some examples, a constraint can define the length ratio between two lengths of the CAD model (each instance). In other examples, the constraint may define a mating relationship between two surfaces of the CAD model (e.g., a parallel / perpendicular relationship between two faces). In other examples, the constraint may define one or more CAD operator features, for example, a constraint may define a hole in a (template) CAD model as a through hole. Therefore, each instance (i.e., each instantiation) may have different geometric dimensions, and the hole is still a through hole. The method may apply the constraint when modifying at least a portion of the first value of the CAD model so as to minimize the shape difference metric. In other words, the method may apply the constraint as a constraint to the minimization process.

[0043] The set of one or more constraints specifies one or more mechanical functions of the manufactured product represented by any instance of the CAD model. In other words, since each instance of the obtained CAD model includes the set of one or more parametric constraints that specify one or more mechanical functions, both the first instance and the second instance have the specified mechanical functions. As described above, the CAD model may have other mechanical functions that are not maintained during the design process of the method. These mechanical functions may be specified by other sets of one or more parametric constraints that are not included in the first instance of the obtained CAD model or that are not considered during the design process.

[0044] As described above, the first instance includes the first value of each continuous CAD parameter. In other words, the first value of each continuous CAD parameter is assigned to the (template) CAD model to form a first instance of the CAD model. Such an instance inherits the mechanical function of the (template) CAD model by including the parametric constraint group.

[0045] The "mesh" obtained by the method refers to a mesh that at least represents the target boundary shape of the manufactured product. The mesh can be a 2D or 3D mesh representing the manufactured product. Examples of 2D and 3D meshes will be discussed in the section related to discrete geometric representation. The boundary shape is a shape that defines at least a portion of the boundary of the manufactured product. When the obtained mesh is a 3D mesh, the boundary shape can be a 3D surface of the manufactured product. The obtained 3D mesh can be a polygonal surface mesh. When the obtained mesh is a 2D mesh, the boundary shape can be a plurality of line segments or polylines. The "target" boundary shape refers to a portion of the boundary shape of the manufactured product designed according to the method.

[0046] The method then determines a second instance of the CAD model from the first instance of the CAD model. Similar to the first instance of the CAD model, the second instance includes values ​​for each CAD parameter, but is a second value (the second value set is different from the first value set). Determining the second instance of the CAD model consists of calculating the second value by modifying at least part of the first value. In other words, the method determines the second instance by keeping all other parameters of the first instance unchanged and modifying part of the first value. The method modifies the first value to minimize the shape difference measure between the boundary shape represented by the first instance of the CAD model and the target boundary shape. Therefore, the method solves the optimization (i.e., minimization) problem by an objective function (i.e., a shape difference measure between the boundary shape represented by the first instance of the CAD model and the target boundary shape).

[0047] In some examples, the shape difference metric may be a discrepancy measure between a first scalar field and a second scalar field. In such an example, the first scalar field may be defined based on a (acquired) CAD model and the second scalar field may be defined based on a (acquired) mesh. This provides an improved solution for comparing two models (i.e., one is a mesh and the other is a parametric CAD model) by using each of the models in two different formats to establish a scalar field. Applying a discrepancy measure between two scalar fields (containing only two spatial distributions of values) is significantly more efficient than comparing two 3D modeled objects. Each of the first scalar field and the second scalar field may be implemented (i.e., evaluated) on a respective gridding. This gridding may be the same for the first and second scalar fields but is not necessarily the same. Alternatively, each of the first scalar field and the second scalar field may correspond to (e.g., represent) a first instance of the acquired CAD model and an acquired mesh implemented (i.e., evaluated) on a respective subdivision. In these examples, the first and / or second scalar fields may be implemented at a plurality of points. Each of the plurality of points may correspond to an element of the subdivision. For example, the subdivision may be an unstructured tetrahedral subdivision and the corresponding points may be the centroids of each tetrahedron.Such a subdivision may be the same for the first and second scalar fields but need not be.

[0048] In some examples, the difference metric between the first scalar field and the second scalar field may include a point-by-point difference metric on at least a first region of the first scalar field and a second region of the second scalar field. The first region and the second region may correspond to a manufactured product. As described above, the respective meshing / subdivisions of the first and second scalar fields are not necessarily the same. In such an example, when the respective values ​​of the first region and the second region at the same point are unknown, the method may calculate the respective values ​​using interpolation known in the art. For example, the method may use linear interpolation, bilinear interpolation for 2D cases, and / or trilinear interpolation for 3D cases.

[0049] The first scalar field can be defined based on a first shape. The first shape englobes a first instance of the CAD model (the corresponding shape represented). On the other hand, the second scalar field can be defined based on a second shape that englobes a target boundary shape (the corresponding shape represented), and the obtained target mesh represents the target boundary shape. The so-called "defining a scalar field based on a shape" means that the scalar field has a value for each point inside or on the boundary of the shape. Each of the first shape and the second shape can be a respective bounding box.

[0050] In some examples, the first scalar field may be (the result of) the application of a first function on a corresponding signed distance field of a first instance of a CAD model. The second scalar field may be (the result of) the application of a second function on a corresponding signed distance field of a mesh. In some examples, the first function and the second function may be the same, i.e., the same function. "Signed distance field (SDF)" refers to a field defined based on a signed distance function (see https: / / en.wikipedia.org / wiki / Signed_distance_function). The so-called SDF of a CAD model (or more precisely, an instance of a CAD model) refers to the SDF calculated relative to the boundary of the CAD model. Similarly, the so-called SDF of a mesh refers to the SDF calculated relative to the boundary represented by the mesh. The signed distance field of a CAD model or mesh may take negative values ​​inside the respective boundaries and positive values ​​outside the respective boundaries. The value of the SDF on the boundary (of the CAD model or mesh) may be zero. As described above with respect to the first / second scalar field, each of the first SDF and the second SDF may be implemented (i.e., evaluated) on a respective meshing or subdivision. The meshing / subdivision of each SDF may be the same as the respective meshing / subdivision of the scalar field. In examples where the SDF is evaluated on a different mesh partitioning / tessellation than its corresponding scalar field, the method may use interpolation (eg, linear, bilinear, trilinear) to obtain the value of the corresponding scalar field, as described above.

[0051] Each first scalar field and second scalar field can be a density field. "Density field" refers to a scalar field whose value is in the range of [0,1]. This improves the performance of such examples because the function appearing in the minimization problem has a defined and known range. Optionally, at least the first function (in the example where the first scalar field is a density field) and the second function (in the example where the second scalar field is a density field) are smoothed Heaviside functions or approximations of smoothed Heaviside functions. Such a smoothed Heaviside function or its approximation can be any known function in the field (see https: / / en.wikipedia.org / wiki / Heaviside_step_function, analytical approximation section). The Heaviside function is used to filter out a large number of unnecessary function values ​​that appear in the minimization problem, thereby improving the efficiency of the minimization calculation. However, since the Heaviside function is a discontinuous function, these examples use a smoothed version of the Heaviside function to maintain the continuity of the objective function, thereby improving the solution process of the minimization problem, such as using any well-known gradient-based optimization method.

[0052] In some examples, the difference measure between the first scalar field and the second scalar field can be a measure of the squared differences between the first scalar field and the second scalar field. The difference measure can in particular be a differentiable function of its arguments. Optionally, the measure of the squared differences can include the sum of the squared differences, the smoothed minimum of the squared differences, or the smoothed maximum of the squared differences. The method can use, for example, any known smoothed maximum / minimum (see https: / / en.wikipedia.org / wiki / Smooth_maximum). Using some smoothness measures provides a clear and smooth objective function for the minimization problem, thereby improving computational efficiency.

[0053] In some examples, minimization can use a gradient-based optimization method. In these examples, the optimization method can take multiple CAD parameters as free variables. In these examples, the shape difference metric is a differentiable function with respect to the free variables. Differentiability improves the efficiency of solving the optimization problem.

[0054] In some examples, the optimization method may use sensitivities. Each sensitivity is defined as an approximation of the respective derivatives of the shape difference metric relative to each of the multiple CAD parameters. The method may compute said sensitivities as an integrated step in the optimization method. For example, the optimization method may include multiple iterations and compute these sensitivities in each iteration. For general problems, it may be very difficult and / or computationally expensive to calculate the analytical derivatives of the objective function. Therefore, using sensitivity as an approximation of the derivative provides a computationally efficient optimization method. It has been found (as shown in the numerical results below) that despite the use of a zero-order optimization scheme and an iterative method of approximating the derivative of the objective function, the method is able to gradually and smoothly modify the design from the initial state of the first instance to the converged state of the second instance.

[0055] The sensitivities mentioned above may be compositions of respective derivatives of the shape difference metric with respect to the signed distance field and respective derivatives of the signed distance field with respect to respective CAD parameters of the plurality of CAD parameters.

[0056] The derivatives of the shape difference metric with respect to the signed distance field may include analytical derivatives. On the other hand, the derivatives of the signed distance field with respect to the respective CAD parameters may include approximative derivatives. In these examples, the approximative derivatives may include finite differences. The method may calculate finite differences using perturbation sizes known in the art. Such perturbations may include slightly perturbing any or each continuous CAD parameter and obtaining the resulting perturbations in the SDF. The value of the perturbation size may be provided by the user or predefined.

[0057] The method can thus separate the derivative computation into a numerical and analytical part. This separation is advantageous because for highly nonlinear functions, numerical approximations of derivatives (e.g., using finite difference schemes) may not be very reliable. On the other hand, for shape difference metrics, analytical derivatives are perfectly feasible and yield exact solutions at negligible computational cost.

[0058] As described above, the system can be any combination of a CAD system, a CAE system, a CAM system, a PDM system and / or a PLM system. A CAD solution (e.g., a CAD system or CAD software) also includes any system, software or hardware, at least for designing a modeling object based on a graphical representation and / or a structured representation (e.g., a feature tree) of a modeling object, such as CATIA. In this case, the data defining the modeling object includes data that allows the modeling object to be represented. A CAD system can represent a CAD modeling object, for example, by an edge or line, and in some cases by a face or surface. Lines, edges or surfaces can be represented in various ways, such as non-uniform rational B-splines (NURBS). Specifically, a CAD file contains specifications, by which geometric figures can be generated, thereby allowing the generation of a representation. The specifications of a modeling object can be stored in one CAD file or in multiple CAD files. The typical size of a file representing a modeling object in a CAD system is typically in the range of about one megabyte per component. A modeling object can typically be an assembly of thousands of components.

[0059] In the context of CAD, a modeled object may generally be a 2D or 3D modeled object, for example representing a product (such as a component or an assembly of components), or possibly an assembly of products. A 2D or 3D modeled object may be a manufactured product, i.e. a product to be manufactured. A "3D modeled object" refers to any object that is modeled by data that allows its 3D representation. The 3D representation allows the component to be viewed from all angles. For example, a 3D modeled object, when represented in 3D, can be manipulated and rotated about any of its axes or about any axis on the screen on which the representation is displayed. This specifically excludes 2D icons, which are not modeled in 3D. Displaying a 3D representation facilitates design (i.e., increases the speed at which the designer can complete his task). This speeds up the manufacturing process in industry, as product design is part of the manufacturing process.

[0060] A 2D or 3D modeled object may represent the geometry of a product that is to be manufactured in the real world after its virtual design has been completed using, for example, a CAD / CAE software solution or a CAD / CAE system, the product being, for example, a (mechanical) component or an assembly of components (or equivalently an assembly of components, since from a methodological point of view an assembly of components may be considered as one component, or the method may be applied independently to each component of the assembly), or more generally any rigid body assembly (e.g. a moving mechanism). CAD / CAE software solutions allow the design of products in various and unlimited industrial sectors, including: aerospace, architecture, construction, consumer goods, high-tech equipment, industrial equipment, transportation, marine and / or offshore oil / gas production or transportation. The 3D modeled objects designed by the method can therefore represent industrial products, which can be any mechanical parts, such as parts of ground vehicles (including, for example, automobile and light truck equipment, racing cars, motorcycles, truck and engine equipment, trucks and buses, trains), aircraft parts (including, for example, fuselage equipment, aerospace equipment, propulsion equipment, defense products, airline equipment, space equipment), parts of marine vehicles (including, for example, naval equipment, merchant ships, offshore equipment, yachts and workboats, marine equipment), general mechanical parts (including, for example, industrial manufacturing machinery, heavy mobile machinery or equipment, installation equipment, industrial equipment products, manufactured metal products, tire manufacturing products), electromechanical or electronic components (including, for example, consumer electronics products, safety and / or control and / or instrumentation products, computing and communication equipment, semiconductors, medical equipment and instruments), consumer products (including, for example, furniture, home and garden products, leisure products, fashion products, products of hard goods retailers, products of soft goods retailers), packaging (including, for example, food and beverage and tobacco, beauty and personal care, household product packaging).

[0061] A CAM solution is any solution, software or hardware suitable for managing the manufacturing data of a product. Manufacturing data typically includes data related to the product to be manufactured, the manufacturing process and the resources required. A CAM solution is used to plan and optimize the entire manufacturing process of a product. For example, it can provide the CAM user with information about the feasibility of a manufacturing process, its duration or the number of resources (such as a specific robot) that may be used in a specific step, allowing decisions to be made on management or the required investments. CAM is a subsequent process after the CAD process and potentially the CAE process. For example, a CAM solution can provide information on machining parameters or molding parameters that are consistent with an extrusion feature in the CAD model. Dassault Systèmes (Dassault Systèmes) is a global manufacturer of CAM products and services. Provide such CAM solutions.

[0062] Therefore, CAD and CAM solutions are closely related. In fact, CAD solutions focus on the design of a product or part, while CAM solutions focus on how to manufacture it. Designing a CAD model is the first step in computer-aided manufacturing. In fact, CAD solutions provide key functions such as feature-based modeling and boundary representation (B-Rep) to reduce the risk of errors and loss of precision in the manufacturing process handled by CAM solutions. In fact, the CAD model is intended for manufacturing. Therefore, it is a virtual twin of the object to be manufactured, also called digital twin, with the following two goals:

[0063] - Check the correct behavior of the object to be manufactured in a specific environment; and

[0064] - Ensure the manufacturability of the object to be manufactured.

[0065] The acquired mesh used as input by the method can be a 2D / 3D discrete geometric representation of the manufactured product. A discrete geometric representation is a data structure containing a discrete set of data fragments. Each data fragment can specify an element of the product / mechanical component and is called a discrete element. The discrete geometric representation can be 3D or 2D. Alternatively, the discrete geometric representation can be both 3D and 2D, i.e., containing a 3D part (i.e., a 3D discrete geometric representation) and a 2D part (i.e., a discrete geometric representation), such as a hybrid 3D-2D mesh (e.g., a thin part modeled with a 2D part, and a thick part modeled with a 3D part). The discrete geometric representation can contain more than 100, 1000, or 10,000 such data fragments in some examples.

[0066] In the case of a 3D discrete geometric representation, the 3D discrete geometric representation may be a skin 3D discrete geometric representation representing the skin of a manufactured product, such as a 3D surface mesh (such as a triangular surface mesh) or a tessellation. In this case, each data fragment may represent a corresponding geometric entity in a 3D space, and these data fragments form a representation of the skin of the mechanical product (i.e., a "skin 3D discrete geometric representation"). In this case, each geometric entity represents a corresponding position (i.e., a material point) on the outer surface of the 3D object (in other words, a corresponding portion of the outer surface of the volume occupied by the material constituting the entity represented by the object). The aggregation (i.e., union or juxtaposition) of the geometric entities together represents at least a portion of the outer surface of the object.

[0067] The modeling object output / designed by the method may be a CAD model, for example including or consisting of a feature tree. Such a model may be derived from a CAE model and may be the result of a CAE to CAD conversion process included in the initial stage of the method, for example.

[0068] The CAD model can be feature-based (e.g., it can include a feature tree and optionally obtain a corresponding B-Rep by executing the feature tree). The feature-based 3D model allows (e.g., during the determination of a manufacturing file or a CAM file as described below) the detection and automatic resolution of geometric errors in the CAD model, such as clashes that affect the manufacturing process. A clash is the mutual penetration between two parts in the 3D model due to relative motion. Furthermore, such clashes can sometimes only be detected by finite element analysis based on the CAD feature model. Therefore, the clash can be (automatically) resolved by the CAD solution by iteratively modifying the parameters of the features and performing a finite element analysis.

[0069] As another example, a feature-based 3D model allows the automatic creation of toolpaths for machines via computer numerical control (CNC) (e.g., during the determination of a manufacturing file or CAM file as described later). With CNC, each object to be manufactured has a customized computer program stored in and executed by a machine control unit, which is a microcomputer attached to the machine. The program contains the instructions and parameters that the machine tool will follow. Mills, lathes, engravers, grinders, and lasers are examples of common machine tools that can be automated via CNC.

[0070] A key feature of a CAD model is that it can be precisely and unambiguously designed by chaining a small number of high-level parametric design operations (including, for example, but not limited to, sketching, extrusion, chamfering), and edited by modifying its high-level parameters. This is a key distinction from polyhedral representations (such as triangular surface meshes), which can represent any 3D shape but do not provide the modification or parameterization capabilities required in an industrial design environment. The approach constitutes a solution that facilitates the acquisition of easy-to-use CAD models during the design process through its high-level parameterization.

[0071] Since CAD models are parametric models of parts / products, their memory footprint is lighter than other models (e.g. CAE models). In fact, CAD models allow storing lists of features and parameters instead of collections of discrete geometric elements (e.g. finite elements), making them lighter in terms of storage and memory footprint. Working with CAD models reduces the memory requirements of the underlying system compared to, for example, CAE models, while facilitating the editing of the models. This is equivalent to saying that the CAE to CAD conversion process actually compresses the CAE model into a CAD model that is lighter in terms of memory requirements (e.g. footprint), while converting the CAE model into a CAD model that is easier to edit.

[0072] Custom computer programs can be automatically generated from CAD files. Such generation therefore prevents errors and ensures perfect replication of the CAD model to the manufactured product. CNC is considered to offer greater precision, complexity, and repeatability than manual machining. Other benefits include greater accuracy, speed, and flexibility, as well as features such as contour machining, which allows contoured shapes to be machined, including those generated in 3D designs.

[0073] A B-Rep (i.e., Boundary Representation) is a 3D representation of a mechanical part. Specifically, a B-Rep is a persistent data representation that describes a 3D modeled object that represents a mechanical part. A B-Rep may be the result of a calculation and / or a series of operations performed in the process of designing a 3D modeled object that represents a mechanical part. When the modeled object is represented, the shape of the mechanical part displayed on the computer screen is a (e.g., tessellated) B-Rep. In some examples, a B-Rep represents a portion of a modeled object.

[0074] B-Rep includes topological entities and geometric entities. Topological entities include: faces, edges and vertices. Geometric entities are 3D objects: surfaces, planes, curves, lines, points. By definition, a face is a bounded portion of a surface, called the supporting surface; an edge is a bounded portion of a curve, called the supporting curve; a vertex is a point in 3D space. The relationship between them is as follows: the bounded portion of a curve is defined by two points (vertices) located on the curve; the bounded portion of a surface is defined by its boundary, which is a set of edges located on the surface. The boundaries of the edges of a face are connected by shared vertices. Faces are connected by shared edges. If two faces share an edge, they are adjacent. Similarly, if two edges share a vertex, they are adjacent. In the CAD system, B-Rep brings together the "bounded by..." relationship, the relationship between topological entities and supporting geometry, and the mathematical description of the supporting geometry in appropriate data structures. The internal edges of a B-Rep are edges shared by exactly two faces. By definition, a boundary edge is not shared, it only borders one face. By definition, a boundary surface is bounded by at least one boundary edge. A B-Rep is called a closed B-Rep if all its edges are interior edges. A B-Rep is called an open B-Rep if it includes at least one boundary edge. A closed B-Rep is used to model thick 3D volumes, as it defines an interior space that (virtually) encloses the material. An open B-Rep is used to model 3D shells, representing 3D objects whose thickness is negligible.

[0075] A key advantage of B-Rep over any other type of representation used in CAD modeling is its ability to accurately represent arbitrary shapes. All other used representations, such as point clouds, distance fields and meshes, approximate the shape by discretizing it. B-Rep, on the other hand, contains the surface equations that represent the exact design and therefore constitutes the true "master model" for further manufacturing, whether it is the generation of tool paths for CNC or discretization to the right sampling density for a specific 3D printing technology. In other words, with B-Rep, the 3D model can be an accurate representation of the manufactured object. B-Rep also has advantages in simulating the behavior of 3D models. In terms of stress, thermal, electromagnetic or other analyses, it supports local refinement of the simulation mesh to capture physical phenomena, and in terms of kinematics, it supports the modeling of realistic contacts between surfaces. Finally, B-Rep allows for a smaller memory and / or file footprint. Firstly, because the representation contains only parametric-based surfaces. In other representations, such as meshes, the equivalent surface consists of up to thousands of triangles. Secondly, because B-Rep does not contain any history-based information.

[0076] The method may be included in a production process, which may include, after executing the method, producing a physical product corresponding to the modeled object designed by the method. The production process may include the following steps:

[0077] Applying the method (e.g. automatically) to obtain a CAD model output by the method; and

[0078] The product is manufactured using the obtained CAD model.

[0079] Manufacturing using a CAD model refers to any real-world action or series of actions that involves manufacturing the product represented by the CAD model. Manufacturing using a CAD model may include, for example, the following steps:

[0080] Editing the obtained CAD model;

[0081] Performing simulations based on the CAD model or a corresponding CAE model (e.g., the CAE model is obtained from the CAD model through a CAE to CAD conversion process), such as simulations for verifying mechanical, usage and / or manufacturing properties and / or constraints (e.g., structural simulations, thermodynamic simulations, aerodynamic simulations);

[0082] Edit CAD models based on simulation results

[0083] Optionally (i.e. depending on the manufacturing process used, the production of the mechanical product may or may not include this step), determining (e.g. automatically) a manufacturing file / CAM file based on the (e.g. edited) CAD model for the production / manufacturing of the manufactured product;

[0084] Sending CAD files and / or manufacturing files / CAM files to the factory; and / or

[0085] The mechanical product initially represented by the model output by the method is manufactured based on the determined manufacturing file / CAM file or CAD model (e.g. automatically). This may include inputting the manufacturing file / CAM file and / or CAD file (e.g. automatically) to a machine that performs the manufacturing process.

[0086] The final manufacturing step may be referred to as a manufacturing step or a production step. This step, for example, manufactures / processes the component / product based on the CAD model and / or CAM file when the CAD model and / or CAD file is input into one or more manufacturing machines or a computer system that controls the machine. The manufacturing step may include performing any known manufacturing process or a series of manufacturing processes, such as one or more additive manufacturing steps, one or more cutting steps (e.g., laser cutting or plasma cutting steps), one or more stamping steps, one or more forging steps, one or more bending steps, one or more deep drawing steps, one or more forming steps, one or more machining steps (e.g., milling steps), and / or one or more stamping steps. As the design method improves the design of the model (CAE or CAD) representing the component / product, manufacturing and its productivity are also improved.

[0087] Editing a CAD model may include editing of one or more CAD models by a user (i.e., a designer), for example, using a CAD solution. Modifications to a CAD model may include one or more modifications to the geometry and / or parameters of the CAD model. These modifications may include any modification or a series of modifications performed on the feature tree of the model (e.g., modifications of feature parameters and / or specifications), and / or modifications performed on the display representation of the CAD model (e.g., a B-Rep). A modification is a modification that maintains the technical functionality of the component / product (e.g., the mechanical functionality described above), i.e., the user performs modifications that may affect the geometry and / or parameters of the model, but the purpose is to make the CAD model more technically compliant when used downstream and / or manufacturing components / products. Such modifications may include any modification or a series of modifications that technically complies with the machine specifications used in the downstream manufacturing process. These modifications may additionally or alternatively include any modification or a series of modifications that technically complies with the further use of the CAD model after the product / component is manufactured, such as a modification or a series of modifications based on simulation results.

[0088] The method may include performing a manufacturing step after obtaining (i.e., providing) a mesh and a first instance of a CAD model. In an example, when a user triggers a corresponding function of a method embedded in the CAD software, the software may initiate the method to automatically deform the mesh into a second instance of the CAD model. Under possible further triggering by the user, the software may initiate a manufacturing step, for example, by directly converting the second instance of the CAD model into a CAM file and then manufacturing it.

[0089] The CAM file may include the manufacturing steps after the model is obtained from the CAD model. The manufacturing steps may include all data required to manufacture the mechanical product so that it has a geometry and / or material distribution corresponding to the geometry and / or material distribution captured by the CAD model, possibly with manufacturing tolerance errors. Determining the production file may include applying any CAM (Computer Aided Manufacturing) or CAD to CAM solution (e.g., automatically) to determine the production file from the CAD model (e.g., any automated CAD to CAM conversion algorithm). Such CAM or CAD to CAM solutions may include one or more of the following software solutions that automatically generate manufacturing instructions and tool paths for a given manufacturing process based on the CAD model of the product to be manufactured:

[0090] Fusion 360,

[0091] FreeCAD,

[0092] CATIA,

[0093] SOLIDWORKS,

[0094] NC Shop Floor Programmer from Dassault Systèmes, see https: / / my.3dexperience.3ds.com / welcome / fr / compass-world / rootroles / nc-shop-floor-programmer,

[0095] NC Mill-Turn Machine Programmer from Dassault Systèmes, see https: / / my.3dexperience.3ds.com / welcome / fr / compass-world / rootroles / nc-mill-turn-machine-programmer, and / or

[0096] Powder Bed Machine Programmer from Dassault Systèmes, see https: / / my.3dexperience.3ds.com / welcome / fr / compass-world / rootroles / powder-bed-machine-programmer.

[0097] The product / part may be an additively manufactured part, i.e. a part manufactured by additive manufacturing (i.e. 3D printing). In this case, the production process does not include a step of determining a CAM file, but directly enters a production / manufacturing step by directly (and, for example, automatically) inputting a CAD model into a 3D printer. The 3D printer is configured to directly and automatically perform 3D printing according to the CAD model when a CAD model representing a mechanical product is received (e.g., when a 3D printer operator starts 3D printing). In other words, the 3D printer receives a CAD model, which is (e.g., automatically) input into the printer, the printer (e.g., automatically) reads the CAD model, and prints the part by, for example, adding material layer by layer (e.g., automatically) to reproduce the geometry and / or material distribution captured by the CAD model. The 3D printer adds material so as to accurately reproduce in reality the geometry and / or material distribution captured by the CAD model, up to the resolution of the 3D printer, and optionally with or without tolerance errors and / or manufacturing corrections. Manufacturing may include determining such manufacturing corrections and / or tolerance errors, for example by a user (e.g., a 3D printer operator) or automatically (by the 3D printer or a computer system controlling it), for example by modifying a CAD file to match the specifications of the 3D printer. The production process may additionally or alternatively include determining (e.g., automatically by the 3D printer or a computer system controlling it) a printing direction from the CAD model, for example to minimize overhang volume (as described in European Patent No. 3327593, which is incorporated herein by reference), layer slicing (i.e., determining the thickness of each layer), and layer path / trajectory and other characteristics of the 3D print head (e.g., for a laser beam, such as path, speed, intensity / temperature and other parameters).

[0098] The product / component may also be a machined component (i.e. a component manufactured by machining), such as a milled component (i.e. a component manufactured by milling). In this case, the production process may include a step of determining a CAM file. This step may be automatically performed by any suitable CAM solution, automatically obtaining a CAM file from a CAD model of the machined component. Determining the CAM file may include (e.g. automatically) checking whether the CAD model has any geometric characteristics (e.g. errors or artifacts) that may affect the production process, and (e.g. automatically) correcting these characteristics. For example, if the CAD model still contains sharp edges, machining or milling based on the CAD model may not be possible (because the machining or milling tool cannot create sharp edges). In this case, determining the CAM file may include (e.g. automatically) rounding or filleting these sharp edges (e.g., the fillet or fillet radius corresponds to the radius of the cutting head of the machining tool, such as substantially equals upto a tolerance error (corresponds, eg substantially equals upto a tolerance error, the radius of the cutting head of the machining tool)) so that machining or milling can be performed based on the CAD model. More generally, determining that the CAM file may automatically include rounding or chamfering geometry in the CAD model that is incompatible with the radius of a machining or milling tool for machining / milling. This check and possible correction (e.g., rounding or chamfering of geometry) may be performed automatically as previously described, but may also be performed manually by a user (e.g., a machining engineer) in the CAD and / or CAM solution, e.g., the solution constrains the user to perform corrections that bring the CAD model into compliance with the specifications of the tool used in the machining process.

[0099] After checking, determining the CAM file may include (e.g., automatically) determining a machining or milling path, i.e., a path for a machining tool to perform machining. The path may include a set of coordinates and / or a parameterized trajectory to be followed by the machining tool when performing machining, and determining the path may include (e.g., automatically) calculating these coordinates and / or trajectories based on the CAD model. This calculation may be based on a boundary calculation of a Minkowski subtraction represented by a CAD model and a CAD model of the machining tool, such as described in European patent application EP21306754.9 filed by Dassault Systemes on December 13, 2021, which is incorporated herein by reference. It should be understood that the path may be a single path, such as a tool that continuously follows the single path without breaking contact with the material to be cut. Alternatively, the path may be a sequence of sub-paths that the tool follows continuously in a certain order, such as in each sub-path that the tool follows continuously without breaking contact with the material to be cut. Optionally, determining the CAM file may include, for example, based on the determined path and machine specifications, (e.g., automatically) setting machine parameters, including cutting speed, cutting / piercing height, and / or mold opening stroke. Optionally, determining the CAM file may include (eg, automatically) configuring the nesting, wherein the CAM solution determines the optimal orientation of the component to maximize machining efficiency.

[0100] In the case of machining or milling a part, determining a CAM file generates and outputs a CAM file containing machining paths and optionally set machine parameters and / or configuration nesting specifications. This output CAM file can be input (e.g., directly and automatically) to a machining tool, and the machining tool can be programmed (e.g., directly and automatically) by reading the file, after which the production process includes a manufacturing step in which the machine, e.g., by directly and automatically executing the production file, performs product machining in accordance with the production file. The machining process includes the machining tool cutting a block of material in the real world to reproduce the geometry and / or material distribution captured by the CAD model, e.g., to a tolerance error (e.g., tens of microns for milling).

[0101] The product / component may also be a molded part, i.e. a part manufactured by molding (e.g. injection molding). In this case, the production process may include a step of determining a CAM file. This step may be performed automatically by any suitable CAM solution, automatically obtaining the CAM file from the CAD model of the molded part. Determining the CAM file may include (e.g. automatically) performing a series of molding checks based on the CAD model to check whether the geometry and / or material distribution captured by the CAD model is suitable for molding, and if the CAD model is not suitable for molding, (e.g. automatically) performing appropriate corrections. Performing the checks and appropriate corrections (if any) may be performed automatically, or by a user (e.g. a molding engineer), for example using a CAD and / or CAM solution that allows the user to perform appropriate corrections on the CAD model, but constrains his / her corrections to make the CAD model conform to the specifications of the molding tool. The checks may include verifying that the virtual product represented by the CAD model is consistent with the dimensions of the mold and / or verifying that the CAD model contains all the draft angles required for demoulding (as known in molding). Determining the CAM file may then further include determining the amount of liquid material to be used for molding and / or the time to allow the liquid material to harden / cure in the mold based on the CAD model, and outputting a CAM file containing these parameters. The production process then includes (e.g., automatically) performing molding based on the output file, wherein the mold shapes the liquid material into a shape corresponding to the geometry and / or material distribution captured by the CAD model within the determined hardening time, such as reaching a tolerance error (e.g., including the incorporation or modification of a draft angle for demolding).

[0102] The product / component may also be a stamped part, which may also be referred to as a "stamping", i.e. a part manufactured in a stamping process. In this case, the production process may include (e.g. automatically) determining a CAM file based on a CAD model. The CAD model represents a stamped part, for example, if the part includes one or more flanges, the CAD model represents the part that may include these flanges, and in the latter case, may include additional material that needs to be removed to form the expanded state of one or more flanges of the part, as known in stamping. Therefore, the CAD model includes a portion representing a portion without flanges (in some cases the entire part), and may include an external additional patch portion (patch portion) representing the flange (if any), and therefore may include additional material (if any). This additional patch portion may present g2 continuity over a certain length and then g1 continuity over a certain length.

[0103] In such a stamping situation, determining the CAM file may include determining (e.g., automatically) the parameters of the stamping machine, such as the size and / or punch force of the stamping die or punch, based on the geometry and / or material distribution of the virtual product captured by the CAD model. If the CAD model also contains a representation of additional material that needs to be removed to form the unfolded state of one or more flanges of the component, the additional material may, for example, be cut by machining, and determining the CAM file may also include determining the corresponding machining CAM file, for example as described above. If there are one or more flanges, determining the CAM file may include determining the geometric specifications of the g2 continuity and g1 continuity portions, which allow the flange to be folded along the g2 continuous length toward the inner surface of the stamped part during the folding process after the stamping itself and the removal of the additional material. Therefore, the determined CAM file may include: the parameters of the stamping tool, the optional specifications of the folded flange (if any), and the optional machining production file for removing the additional material (if any).

[0104] The stamping production process can then, for example, directly and automatically, output a CAM file and (for example, automatically) perform a stamping process based on the file. The stamping process can include stamping (for example, punching) a portion of the material to form the product represented by the CAD file, which may include an unfolded flange and additional material (if any). Where appropriate, the stamping process can then include cutting the additional material based on the machining production file and folding the flange based on specifications for folding the flange, thereby folding the flange along its g2 continuous length and giving the outer edge of the part a smooth appearance. In the latter case, the shape of the manufactured part differs from its virtual counterpart represented by its CAD model because the additional material is removed and the flange is folded, while the CAD model represents the part including the additional material and the flange in an unfolded state.

[0105] The method is computer-implemented. This means that the steps (or substantially all of the steps) of the method are performed by at least one computer or any similar system. Therefore, the steps of the method are performed by a computer, possibly fully automatically or semi-automatically. In some examples, the triggering of at least some of the steps of the method may be performed by user-computer interaction. The required level of user-computer interaction may depend on the desired level of automation and is balanced with the need to achieve the user's wishes. In an example, this level may be defined and / or predefined by the user.

[0106] For example, the user / designer may be involved in performing the acquisition of a first instance of a CAD model. In this case, the user / designer may automatically propose a first instance by importing an instance of the CAD model from a database or a previous session, and optionally based on the acquired mesh, for example as described above. The user / designer may then modify or replace this method's automatic proposal based on her / his knowledge and potential application of the manufactured product.

[0107] A typical example of a computer-implemented method is the execution of the method using a system adapted for this purpose. The system may include a processor and a graphical user interface (GUI) connected to a memory on which is recorded a computer program containing instructions for executing the method. The memory may also store a database. The memory is any hardware suitable for such storage, and may include multiple physically distinct parts (e.g., one for the program and possibly another for the database).

[0108] "Database" refers to a collection of data (i.e., information) organized for search and retrieval (e.g., a relational database based on a predetermined structured language, such as SQL). When stored in memory, a database allows a computer to quickly search and retrieve. Databases are indeed structured to facilitate the storage, retrieval, modification, and deletion of data in conjunction with various data processing operations. A database may consist of one or a group of files, which may be broken down into records, each of which consists of one or more fields. A field is the basic unit of data storage. Users can retrieve data primarily through queries. Using keywords and sorting commands, users can quickly search, rearrange, group, and select fields among many records, retrieve or create reports summarizing specific data according to the rules of the database management system being used.

[0109] Figure 1 An example of a GUI of a system is shown, wherein the system is a CAD system.The 3D modeled object 2000 may be an example of a first instance of an acquired CAD model, an example of an acquired mesh, or an example of a second instance of a determined CAD model according to the method.

[0110] GUI 2100 may be a typical CAD-like interface, with standard menu bars 2110, 2120, and bottom and side toolbars 2140, 2150. These menus and toolbars contain a set of user-selectable icons, each associated with one or more operations or functions, as known in the art. Some of these icons are associated with software tools, suitable for editing and / or processing 3D modeling objects 2000 displayed in GUI 2100. Software tools can be grouped into workbenches. Each workbench includes a small group of software tools. In particular, one of the workbenches is an editing workbench, suitable for editing geometric features of modeling products 2000. In operation, a designer can, for example, pre-select a portion of an object 2000, and then initiate an operation (e.g., change size, color, etc.) or edit geometric constraints by selecting an appropriate icon. For example, a typical CAD operation is the modeling of a punch or the folding of a 3D modeling object displayed on the screen. The GUI can, for example, display data 2500 associated with the displayed object 2000. In the example in the figure, data 2500 displayed as a "feature tree" and its 3D representation relate to a brake assembly including a brake caliper and a brake disc. The GUI can also display various types of graphical tools 2130, 2070, 2080, such as for facilitating 3D positioning of objects, triggering simulation of editing product operations, or presenting various properties of displayed products. The cursor 2060 can be controlled by a haptic device, allowing the user to interact with the graphical tools.

[0111] Figure 2 An example of a system is shown, where the system is a client computer system, such as a user's workstation.

[0112] The client computer of this example includes a central processing unit (CPU) 1010 connected to an internal communication bus 1000, and a random access memory (RAM) 1070 also connected to the bus. The client computer is also equipped with a graphics processing unit (GPU) 1110, which is associated with a video random access memory 1100 connected to the bus. Video RAM 1100 is also known in the art as a frame buffer. A mass storage device controller 1020 manages access to a mass storage device such as a hard disk drive 1030. Mass storage devices suitable for embodying computer program instructions and data include all forms of non-volatile memory, including, for example, semiconductor memory devices such as EPROM, EEPROM, and flash memory devices; magnetic disks such as internal hard disks and removable disks; and magneto-optical disks. Any of the above may be supplemented or included by a specially designed ASIC (application specific integrated circuit). A network adapter 1050 manages access to a network 1060. The client computer may also include a tactile device 1090, such as a cursor control device, a keyboard, etc. The cursor control device is used in the client computer to allow the user to selectively position the cursor at any desired location on the display 1080. In addition, the cursor control device allows the user to select various commands and input control signals. The cursor control device includes a plurality of signal generating devices for inputting control signals to the system. Typically, the cursor control device can be a mouse, and the buttons of the mouse are used to generate signals. Alternatively or additionally, the client computer system may include a sensitive board and / or a sensitive screen.

[0113] The computer program may include computer executable instructions, including means for causing the above-mentioned system to perform the method. The program may be recorded on any data storage medium, including the memory of the system. The program may be implemented, for example, in a digital electronic circuit, or in computer hardware, firmware, software, or a combination thereof. The program may be implemented as a device, such as a product tangibly embodied in a machine-readable storage device, for execution by a programmable processor. The method steps may be performed by a programmable processor that executes an instruction program, performing the functions of the method by operating on input data and generating output. Thus, the processor may be programmable and connect a data storage system, at least one input device, and at least one output device to receive data and instructions from the data storage system, at least one input device, and at least one output device, and to send data and instructions to the data storage system, at least one input device, and at least one output device. The application may be implemented using a high-level procedural programming language or an object-oriented programming language, or, if desired, may be implemented using an assembly language or a machine language. In any case, the language may be a compiled or interpreted language. The program may be a complete installer or updater. Applying the program to the system generates instructions for executing the method in any case. Alternatively, the computer program can be stored and executed on a server in a cloud computing environment, and the server communicates with one or more clients via a network. In this case, the processor executes instructions containing the program, thereby causing the method to be executed on the cloud computing environment.

[0114] Implementation of this method will now be discussed.

[0115] The implementation relates to product design, mechanical engineering, structural optimization and shape deformation. More specifically, the implementation aims to automatically deform / adjust CAD models to fit arbitrary target shapes represented by polygonal meshes. Designers and engineers often retrieve polygonal meshes (e.g., downloaded online from many 3D mesh sharing websites or obtained by topology optimization methods) and then have to create and adjust parametric CAD models to fit this shape. The implementation provides an efficient, general and automatic method to optimize CAD models to match / reproduce a provided polygonal mesh. This means that templates / parametric CAD models can be automatically instantiated / deformed to replicate shapes or follow given mating surfaces while maintaining their clear and accurate CAD structure.

[0116] Embodiments formulate this deformation or morphing / adjustment as a gradient-based optimization to achieve real-time performance. Embodiments also aim to do this in a way that preserves the original CAD construction logic. This is particularly important for industrial applications where CAD drawings are always required. Thus, embodiments provide an improved approach over methods that morph between two polygonal meshes, which can produce nonsensical results.

[0117] As mentioned above, embodiments are particularly relevant to two well-known forms of shape representation: parametric CAD models and polygonal meshes.

[0118] Figure 3 and Figure 4 Different examples of parametric CAD models are shown. As known, these models are the de facto standard modeling technique for industrial applications. Models represent 2D or 3D shapes through a series (or Directed Acyclic Graph) of explicit operations (primitives, sketches, extrusions, pockets, fillets, surfaces, NURBs, Boolean operations, etc.), usually with many geometric constraints (orthogonality, alignment, continuity, tangency, etc.). Parametric CAD models are "exact" representations of objects, since parametric CAD models have a theoretically infinite resolution. The benefit of these models is that they rely on a small number of high-level (i.e. manually editable, human-understandable) parameters that can be easily edited by designers or engineers.

[0119] Figure 5 Different examples of different parameterized polygonal meshes are shown. A polygonal mesh is a collection of planar polygonal faces (usually triangles) that discretize the surface of an object into common edges and vertices. These meshes can come from many different sources: surface tessellation of a CAD model, a scan of a real-world object, a digital sculpt, or isosurfaces extracted from a volumetric representation. A polygonal mesh is defined by a large number of low-level (algorithm-editable, machine-understandable) parameters, which are the vertex positions.

[0120] A key difference between CAD models and polygonal meshes is that any shape (including CAD models) can be easily and fully automatically converted to a polygonal mesh. In contrast, converting a polygonal mesh into a clean and simple CAD model is an extremely challenging open problem. This is because a CAD model contains high-level information about the design's purpose and construction logic, while a polygonal mesh is merely a discretization / sampling of that design's surface. In this sense, the difference between CAD and polygonal 3D models is similar to the difference between vector graphics and pixel grids in 2D images.

[0121] As is known, CAD models cannot be directly compared to polygonal meshes, as the two representations are fundamentally different in nature. Therefore, embodiments of the method propose a workflow where the target polygonal mesh and the CAD model are first converted to a common scalar field representation and then compared via a selected similarity measure. Furthermore, these conversions and similarity measures are differentiable, allowing for the computation of total derivatives with respect to the CAD parameters. These total derivatives are stable and accurate, allowing for the use of gradient-based schemes to drive the optimization of the CAD model.

[0122] Such an embodiment enables deformation and optimization of complex 2D or 3D CAD models with many more parameters than previously possible. The optimization is also more efficient, requires fewer iterations, and exhibits smooth convergence. Furthermore, the embodiment preserves the parameterization, construction logic, and feature tree of the input CAD model, thereby ensuring that the optimized model meets the original length scale, geometry, manufacturing, or assembly constraints imposed by the designer.

[0123] Figure 6 A graphical representation of an embodiment is shown. In this example, the method is provided with an initial CAD model 610 and a target triangulated shape 620. The embodiment then performs an optimization to obtain an optimized CAD model 630. The convergence of the optimization is shown as 640 based on a similarity metric and a number of iterations.

[0124] Reference now Figure 7 These implementations are discussed further step by step.

[0125] Figure 8 810 and 820 illustrate a connecting rod.

[0126] In this example embodiment, an initial CAD model can be quickly produced by a designer and, due to the constraints imposed in the CAD parameterization, can be manufactured through industrial machining processes through construction. In contrast, a polygonal model (POLY) is a more complex, organic, curved shape. The polygonal model is more efficient in terms of quality and physical properties, but the cost and difficulty of manufacturing through machining are significantly increased. The embodiment automatically modifies the CAD model to reproduce the target shape based on the POLY model and its superior properties, while ensuring that the manufacturability of the CAD model is preserved.

[0127] Fig. 9 Shown Figure 7 Steps 1 and 2 of the flowchart in FIG. 1 are to calculate the signed distance field to the polygonal mesh and the signed distance field to the CAD entity.

[0128] In step 1 and step 2, an embodiment discretizes the spatial region containing the CAD model and the polygonal model into a grid of volumetric elements of two instances. The volumetric element can be any of a tetrahedron, a hexahedron, or a regular cube. For each cell, an embodiment evaluates the distance of the cell to the surface of the CAD model or polygonal model, for steps 1 and 2, respectively. This distance value is signed, indicating whether the cell is inside or outside the entity described by the model. By convention, a negative distance indicates that the cell is inside the (polygonal / CAD) model and a positive distance indicates that the cell is outside the (polygonal / CAD) model.

[0129] An embodiment specifies two signed distance fields (SDFs) as functions of the CAD model and the polygonal model as follows:

[0130]

[0131] where ω is the set of cells used for a given discretization.

[0132] Embodiments may use a regular grid discretization which allows for the most efficient computation of the signed distance field. The SDF is computed as known in the art (https: / / en.wikipedia.org / wiki / Signed_distance_function).

[0133] Fig.10 Shown Figure 7 Steps 3 and 4 of the flowchart in . In these steps, the two signed distance fields are converted into two density fields (RHO) with values ​​0≤ρ≤1 using a smoothed Heaviside projection. The density fields are calculated as follows:

[0134]

[0135] Where α≥0 is the steepness coefficient of the smoothed Heaviside projection, and l is the average size of cells in the discretization. Embodiments may set α=1.0 by default.

[0136] Implementations may use any other function that approximates the Heaviside function, with an appropriate output range and a well-defined first-order derivative. Examples of such approximations can be found at https: / / en.wikipedia.org / wiki / Heaviside_step_function.

[0137] Fig.11 Shown Figure 7 Step 5 of the flowchart in . Once the two models are represented by density fields on the same grid discretization, they can be compared using various similarity measures. For the chosen metric, this allows the calculation of an error score. The simplest metric is the sum of the squares of the differences between the two fields, as follows:

[0138]

[0139] Another option is to use a smooth approximation of the max or min operator instead of the sum (https: / / en.wikipedia.org / wiki / Smooth_maximum). Once the error score is evaluated, it needs to be differentiated with respect to the CAD parameterization in order to be used in an efficient gradient-based optimization scheme.

[0140] Fig.12 Shown Figure 7 Step 6 of the flowchart in . Because the selected similarity measure is differentiable, embodiments can formulate its analytical derivative with respect to density. In the case of the sum of squared differences, the derivative is as follows:

[0141]

[0142] Fig.13 Shown Figure 7 Step 7 of the flowchart in FIG. In this step, similar to step 6, since the density projection is differentiable with respect to the signed distance field, an embodiment calculates its analytical derivative as follows:

[0143]

[0144] Fig.14 Shown Figure 7 Step 8 of the flowchart in . In this step, finally, the derivative of the signed distance field with respect to the CAD parameterization is approximated using finite differences. This is done by applying a small perturbation hm to each CAD parameter in turn and observing the effect on the SDF value, as follows:

[0145]

[0146] Where Ω param is the set of CAD parameters to be optimized.

[0147] Separating the density projection from the SDF allows the use of separate differentiation strategies. This is advantageous because finite difference schemes can be less robust for highly nonlinear functions such as this density projection step. On the other hand, for a chosen smooth Heaviside projection, analytical derivatives are fully tractable and produce an exact solution at negligible computational cost.

[0148] By definition, the signed distance varies linearly when moving away from the point closest to the CAD model surface. Therefore, the finite difference scheme is very reliable in capturing the first derivative of the SDF. Note that the current formulation uses a central finite difference scheme, but other finite difference schemes are also applicable. In addition, the current finite difference is strictly a geometric procedure and is therefore computationally inexpensive.

[0149] In step 9, the derivatives calculated in steps 6, 7, and 8 are combined using the chain rule to obtain the derivative of the error score with respect to the CAD parameter as follows:

[0150]

[0151] In step 10, the CAD parameters are updated based on the derivatives calculated in the previous steps using a gradient descent optimization scheme known in the art (https: / / en.wikipedia.org / wiki / Gradient_descent). This process is repeated until a predetermined number of iterations or convergence criteria is reached.

[0152] Table 1 below summarizes the symbols used in the discussion of the above embodiments:

[0153] Table 1

[0154] CAD Parametric CAD drawing to be optimized POLY The shape of the target represented by a polyhedral surface (triangular mesh) SDF Signed Distance Field ERR Error metric to measure the similarity between CAD and target shapes <![CDATA[n∈Ω param .]]> Advanced Optimization Variable Set i∈ω Low-level optimization variable set h The size of the perturbation as a fraction of the allowed range β Smoothing coefficient for soft-max or soft-min formula

[0155] Fig.15A and 15B A summary of the complete mathematical formula is shown.

[0156] Fig.15A The dimensions of each term in the derivative of the error score with respect to the CAD are shown. In other words:

[0157] Derivative The size is 1×|Ω param |;

[0158] Derivative The size of is 1×|ω|;

[0159] Derivative The size of is |ω|×|ω|; and

[0160] Derivative The size is |ω|×|Ω param |;

[0161] where |Ω param | is the size of the high-level optimization variable set, and |ω| is the size of the low-level optimization variable set. Fig.15A As shown, the dimension size of the CAD model (of each instance) is |Ω param |, the dimension of SDF is |ω|, the dimension of density field RHO is |ω|, and the dimension of CAD model of error metric is 1.

[0162] Fig. 15B The mathematical relationship between the steps of the implementation described above is shown. The left column shows the forward evaluation of the error metric at each iteration, while the right column is the steps of the backward sensitivity analysis.

[0163] Two implementation examples are now discussed.

[0164] Results of 3D Linkage

[0165] In a first example, the implementation optimizes Fig.16 The CAD model on the left is given Fig.16 The target polygon mesh on the right. Note that the CAD model has an actual connection point consisting of two components assembled by bolts. In contrast, the target shape has a more complex connection geometry with curved surfaces, but lacks assembly capabilities. An implementation allows the designer to optimize the CAD parameters to fit the target shape. In this case, the parameters to be optimized are the inner hole radius and position and the connection curve.

[0166] Fig.17 The optimization process is shown. The optimization runs in seconds on a laptop and converges smoothly even with many nonlinear and heterogeneous CAD parameters. The present invention achieves this efficiency by using derivatives on an intermediate field representation to rigorously capture the complex interactions between all CAD parameters. The resulting optimized model is a valid CAD representation and satisfies the same constraints as the initial CAD model. In this case study, the constraints in the CAD parameterization ensured the manufacturability and assembly of the connecting rod model. The internal field representation and derivatives produced by the present invention can provide insights into the optimization process and its results.

[0167] Fig.18 A comparison between the initial CAD model and the optimized CAD model is shown, with the color based on how well it matches the target shape (i.e., the derivative of the error score). Lighter areas indicate where the CAD model perfectly matches the target shape, while darker colors indicate areas where the CAD model exceeds or falls short of the target shape, respectively.

[0168] 2D shape imprint results

[0169] The next use case is the reconstruction problem of a 2D scanned imprint of a geometric shape. The goal is to provide a simple CAD sketch and automatically adapt it to the scanned target shape. Fig.19A A target shape 1910 is shown which is defined as the inner area of ​​a target outline 1915. The target shape 1910 is an initial arbitrary shape, obtained, for example, from an STL file of a CATIA application. The designer seeks to obtain a CAD model that is as close to the target shape 1910 as possible. Fig.19B An initial sketch 1920 of the CAD model, i.e., a first instance of the CAD model, is shown. The initial sketch 1920 consists of 12 nodes forming a polyline 1925. Such an initial polyline sketch 1920 may be manually created by a user by clicking 12 points close to the target contour 1915. Fig.19C A graphical representation of a similarity metric evaluated on a target shape 1910 is shown. The graphical representation shows the partial derivative of the similarity function between the target shape 1910 and the polyline sketch 1920. Dark grey areas 1930 show negative derivatives, i.e., areas where there is not enough material for the CAD model, while light grey areas 1935 show positive derivatives, i.e., areas where there is too much material for the CAD model. As shown in Figures 19A to 19C As seen in FIG. 1 , regions 1930 and 1935 match the shape differences between 1910 and 1920 very well, and thus embodiments tend to determine a second instance of the CAD model that extends toward the target shape model in region 1930 and contracts toward the target shape model in region 1935 .

[0170] Next Steps Fig. 20 , 21 The three examples in Figures 1 and 22 show how the proposed method optimizes different CAD parameterizations. Each parameterization is visualized at iterations 0, 5, and 20.

[0171] The first parameterization ( Fig. 20 ) simply uses the initial polyline to generate a design consisting of 12 line segments. This results in 24 CAD sketch parameters corresponding to the planar locations of the 12 sketch nodes.

[0172] The second parameterization ( Fig.21 ) Using automatic subsampling of the initial polyline, control nodes are added to the contour. This results in 96 CAD sketch parameters corresponding to the planar locations of the 48 sketch nodes.

[0173] The third parameterization ( Fig. 22) Using a smooth spline profile, 24 CAD sketch parameters are generated that correspond to the planar positions of the 12 control points that define the spline curve.

Claims

1. A computer-implemented method for designing a manufactured product having one or more mechanical functions, the method comprising: Get: a first instance of a CAD model, the CAD model comprising a feature tree having a plurality of continuous CAD parameters, the CAD model further comprising a set of one or more parametric constraints, the set of parametric constraints specifying the one or more mechanical functions, the first instance comprising a first value for each of the continuous CAD parameters, and a mesh (POLY) representing a target boundary shape of the manufactured product; and Determining a second instance of the CAD model from the first instance of the CAD model, the second instance comprising a second value for each of the continuous CAD parameters, determining the second instance comprising calculating the second value by modifying at least a portion of the first value to minimize a shape difference measure (ERR) between a boundary shape represented by the first instance of the CAD model and the target boundary shape.

2. The method of claim 1, wherein: The shape difference metric is a difference metric between a first scalar field defined based on the CAD model and a second scalar field defined based on the mesh.

3. The method of claim 2, wherein: The first scalar field is defined based on a first shape surrounding the first instance of the CAD model, and The second scalar field is defined based on a second shape surrounding the target boundary shape; Wherein, optionally, each of the first shape and the second shape is a corresponding bounding box.

4. The method according to claim 2 or 3, wherein The first scalar field is a corresponding signed distance field (SDF) of applying a first function (ρ) to the first instance of the CAD model, The second scalar field is a corresponding signed distance field (SDF) of the grid by applying a second function (ρ); in, Optionally, the first function and the second function are the same.

5. The method of claim 4, wherein: Each of the first scalar field and the second scalar field is a density field, wherein, optionally, at least one of the first function and the second function is a smooth Heaviside function or an approximation of a smooth Heaviside function.

6. The method according to any one of claims 2 to 5, wherein: The difference measure between the first scalar field and the second scalar field is the first scalar field (ρ i (SDF(CAD))) and the second scalar field (ρ i The square of the difference between (SDF(POLY)) i (SDF(CAD))-ρ i (SDF(POLY))) 2 ) measurement; Wherein, optionally, the measure of the square of the difference includes: - the sum of the squares of the differences, - the smoothed minimum of the squared differences, or -The smoothed maximum of the squared differences.

7. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, wherein: The minimization uses a gradient-based optimization method with the plurality of continuous CAD parameters as free variables, the shape difference metric being a differentiable function with respect to the free variables.

8. The method of claim 7, wherein: The optimization method uses sensitivities, each of which is a shape difference measure (ERR) relative to a corresponding CAD parameter (CAD n ) is an approximation of the corresponding derivative of 9. The method of claim 8, wherein the sensitivity is a combination of: - the corresponding derivative of the shape difference metric with respect to the signed distance field, and - a respective derivative of the signed distance field with respect to a respective CAD parameter of the plurality of continuous CAD parameters.

10. The method of claim 9, wherein each of the respective derivatives of the shape difference metric with respect to the signed distance field comprises an analytical derivative.

11. The method of claim 9 or 10, wherein the respective derivatives of the signed distance field with respect to the respective CAD parameters comprise approximate derivatives; the approximate derivatives optionally comprising finite differences.

12. The method according to any one of claims 1 to 11, wherein: The CAD model further includes manufacturing specifications, each of which is associated with a corresponding portion of the feature tree, and the first instance and the second instance are both configured to be input into a manufacturing tool and manufactured according to the manufacturing specifications.

13. A computer program comprising instructions for performing the method as claimed in any one of claims 1 to 12.

14. A computer-readable storage medium having recorded thereon the computer program according to claim 13.

15. A system comprising a processor connected to a memory having recorded thereon the computer program of claim 13.

Citation Information

Cited By

  • Test tube thread assembly simulation method and system constructed for robot body operation data

    CN122508920A

  • A test tube thread assembly simulation method and system for robot body operation data construction

    CN122508920B