Method for operating a heating device, computer program, regulating and control device and heating device
The method uses derivative-based signal analysis to enhance flame monitoring in heating devices, improving the detection of flame loss and flashbacks, addressing the limitations of existing technologies by providing robust and reliable monitoring within existing system constraints.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- EP2024174254
- Authority / Receiving Office
- EP · EP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2023-05-10
- Filing Date
- 2024-05-06
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-13
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-05-06
Smart Images

Figure IMGAF001_ABST
Abstract
Description
[0001] The invention relates to a method for operating a heating device, a computer program, a control and regulating device and a heating device.
[0002] A variety of heating devices are known which burn a mixture of fuel, in particular gas or hydrogen, and ambient air in a combustion chamber in order to generate heat to supply a building or to provide hot water.
[0003] Such heaters typically have a flame monitor that can detect flame extinguishment and thus prevent the escape of unburned fuel. Various flame monitoring options are known. Often, the ionization current of the flame is detected, although this is only possible to a limited extent with hydrogen-powered heaters because a hydrogen flame releases only a few charge carriers. To monitor a hydrogen flame, for example, the UV (ultraviolet) radiation emitted by the flame(s) can be detected. Another known method is the measurement of flame temperature using a suitable temperature sensor.
[0004] The inertia of the sensors or connected electronics, such as amplifiers or filters, can make it difficult to detect a loss of flame, especially to distinguish it from a regular reduction in the heater's power output.
[0005] DE 199 03 305 A1 discloses a vehicle heater in which flame monitoring is performed by evaluating a first, second, and third gradient from three temperature sensors. The disadvantage is that the arrangement of three temperature sensors is complex, and the proposed flame monitoring system cannot adequately detect flame losses in building heaters.
[0006] DE 10 2021 108 014 A1 describes a method for observing or monitoring flames in a combustion chamber of a heater. The temperature is measured at a measuring point in or on the combustion chamber and calculated using a mathematical model from other operating data measured or specified on the heater. The measured temperature and / or its temporal behavior is compared with the calculated temperature, and if deviations exceed a threshold value, a conclusion is drawn as to whether the flame has ignited or extinguished. It is desirable to further improve the monitoring, particularly with regard to robustness, in order to be able to distinguish between a loss of flame and a reduction in power even more reliably.
[0007] Based on this, the object of the invention is to propose a method for operating a heater that at least partially overcomes the described problems of the prior art. In particular, the method should enable reliable detection of a burner flame loss, in particular distinguishing between a flame loss and a regular reduction in the heater's power output. Furthermore, the method should enable the detection of an impending flashback.
[0008] Last but not least, the invention should at least not significantly increase the complexity of a heater, and require no or only minor structural changes to a heater and / or enable easy integration into an existing production process.
[0009] These objects are achieved by the features of the independent patent claims. Further advantageous embodiments of the solution proposed here are specified in the independent patent claims. It is pointed out that the features listed in the dependent patent claims can be combined with one another in any technologically expedient manner and define further embodiments of the invention. Furthermore, the features specified in the patent claims are further specified and explained in the description, with further preferred embodiments of the invention being presented.
[0010] A method for operating a heater contributes to this. The heater comprises a flame monitor for a burner of the heater with at least one sensor, wherein a comparison value is calculated taking into account a first derivative and a second derivative of the signal of the at least one sensor, and a flame state is determined based on a comparison of the first comparison value with a first predetermined threshold value, and / or the at least one sensor is a UV sensor and a first derivative of the signal of the sensor is compared with a second predetermined threshold value and the signal of the sensor is compared with a third predetermined threshold value, and a flame state is determined.
[0011] The method can be performed continuously and continuously during the operation of a heater and serves to reliably monitor the flame, with the aim of reliably distinguishing a loss of flame from a regular reduction in the heater's power output. Furthermore, the method enables the detection of an impending flashback.
[0012] The heater is, in particular, a gas heater designed to burn a fuel gas, such as natural gas or, in particular, hydrogen, with the addition of ambient air, and to generate thermal energy, for example, to heat a heat transfer medium in a heating circuit or to provide hot water. In particular, the heater can be a condensing boiler, which can preferably be designed to burn hydrogen or a hydrogen-containing mixture. The heater generally has a combustion chamber and a conveying device or fan, which can convey a mixture of fuel and combustion air via a mixture duct into a combustion chamber in which a burner is arranged. The combustion products can then be fed to an exhaust system through an exhaust duct of the heater.
[0013] In particular, the heater can adjust (modulate) the burner output to meet demand. To this end, upon detecting a change in heat demand, for example, taking into account the flow and return temperatures of a heating circuit connected to the heater, a control unit of the heater can adjust the heater fan output and thus the combustion air mass flow to the heat demand. At the same time, a control unit can adjust the fuel mass flow to be added to the changing combustion air mass flow.
[0014] The burner can comprise at least one perforated plate connected to a burner cavity. The burner cavity is connected to the mixture channel so that combustion mixture can flow through the cavity through the perforated plate and be burned. An ignition device can also be arranged in the region of the perforated plate, designed to ignite a mass flow of combustion mixture emerging through the perforated plate. The burner cavity, also referred to as the burner body, can in particular be designed as a cylinder (right circular cylinder), wherein a base area of the cylinder is connected to the mixture channel and the opposite base area can be closed. Alternatively, the burner cavity can also be cuboid-shaped, which is bounded on top by the perforated plate.
[0015] The burner can be located in the combustion chamber of the heater, inside a burner door. For this purpose, an opening in the burner door can connect the burner cavity to the mixture channel, and the burner can be attached to the burner door. A flame monitor can also be attached to or in the burner door.
[0016] The heater has a flame monitor that can detect or detects the presence of a flame at the burner. The flame monitor comprises, in particular, a sensor that delivers a signal suitable for detecting a flame. The sensor is, in particular, a UV sensor, i.e., a sensor for detecting the intensity of the ultraviolet radiation emitted by the flame, or a temperature sensor. The flame monitor can additionally comprise further sensors, such as an ionization electrode for detecting an ionization current of the flame. Furthermore, a signal from the flame monitor can be used to regulate and control the heater, in particular to determine and regulate a combustion air ratio of the gas mixture.
[0017] A UV sensor can be positioned so that a flame forming on the heater's burner is in the sensor's detection direction. The UV sensor can be located inside the combustion chamber or, protected from the high temperatures within the combustion chamber, outside the chamber, with detection through a viewing window. The UV sensor can provide a signal corresponding to the intensity of the detected UV radiation. The UV sensor can also have a saturation range, whereby the sensor emits a constant signal above a certain threshold radiation intensity.
[0018] A temperature sensor can be arranged to detect the temperature of the heater's flame. For this purpose, the temperature sensor can be located on or in the immediate vicinity of the heater's burner. The temperature sensor can be any suitable sensor, for example, a thermistor (NTC) or PTC (thermistor), or a semiconductor temperature sensor. The temperature sensor can also be a hot surface igniter (HSI), which can also function as the heater's igniter.
[0019] The heater may comprise a control and regulation device that may be configured to regulate or control its operation. In particular, the control and regulation device may set a predetermined combustion air ratio (also referred to as lambda) of the heater. A method proposed here is particularly suitable for implementation on the control and regulation device.
[0020] Determining a flame condition may, in particular, include detecting a loss of flame and / or a flashback. Determining a flashback may, in particular, include detecting an impending or imminent flashback.
[0021] Based on a mathematical first and second derivative (also referred to as first-order and second-order gradients) of the sensor signal, a reference value can be calculated and compared with a predefined first threshold value. The result of the comparison is the determination of flame loss. The first and second derivatives refer to the first and second derivatives, respectively, i.e., the tangent gradient of a function of the sensor signal. This can be done using numerical methods or by interpolating a function of the sensor signal.
[0022] According to one embodiment, the comparison value can be calculated by calculating the first and second derivatives and then multiplying each by a predetermined weighting factor, and determining an average value as the comparison value. In other words, the first derivative can be multiplied by a first factor and the second derivative by a second predetermined factor.
[0023] According to one embodiment, different first or second factors can be specified for different operating states. For this purpose, the factors can be specified, for example, in the form of a characteristic map for defined operating states or ranges of operating states.
[0024] The first and second factors can be determined in advance on a reference heater during laboratory tests. For a computer-implemented implementation of the method proposed here, the first and second factors can be stored in a memory, for example, in the heater's control unit. Calculating the comparison value based on the first and second derivatives can be particularly useful for inertial sensors. The sensor signal may already have been electronically processed (amplified, filtered), which can contribute to sensor inertia.
[0025] The first, second and / or third threshold value may also have been determined in advance in laboratory tests on a reference heater and stored in a memory of the control unit or the heater.
[0026] Alternatively or cumulatively, a first derivative of the sensor signal can be compared with a second predefined threshold and the sensor signal with a third predefined threshold, and a flame loss can be determined. This can, in particular, enable the detection of an impending or early detection of a flashback.
[0027] According to one embodiment, the sensor can be a UV sensor that does not operate in the saturation range. Noise in the sensor signal may occur immediately before a flashback, but a comparison of the sensor signal with a third threshold and the first derivative with a second threshold still allows for reliable detection of a loss of flame and / or a flashback.
[0028] According to one embodiment, the sensor signal for this purpose can be the raw sensor data. Raw data refers to a sensor signal that has not been further electronically processed, in particular, that has not been electronically amplified or filtered. Due to the inertia of electronic signal processing circuits, the time required to detect a flame loss or flashback can be shortened by using raw sensor data.
[0029] It is noted that the method can also be performed for multiple sensors, for example a combination of a UV sensor and a temperature sensor.
[0030] As a precaution, it should be noted that the numerals used here ("first", "second", ...) primarily serve (only) to distinguish between several similar objects, quantities, or processes, and therefore do not necessarily specify any interdependence and / or sequence of these objects, quantities, or processes. Should a dependence and / or sequence be required, this is explicitly stated here or will be obvious to the person skilled in the art upon studying the specifically described embodiment. To the extent that a component can occur multiple times ("at least one"), the description of one of these components may apply equally to all or part of the majority of these components, but this is not mandatory.
[0031] According to a further aspect, a heating device is also proposed, configured for combustion of a fuel in a burner and comprising flame monitoring with at least one sensor. The heating device may comprise a control and regulating device on which a method proposed here can be carried out. Furthermore, the heating device may comprise means adapted to carry out a method proposed here.
[0032] According to a further aspect, a computer program is also proposed, comprising instructions that cause a heating device proposed here to execute a method proposed here. In other words, this relates in particular to a computer program (product) comprising instructions that, when the program is executed by a computer, cause the computer to execute a method proposed here.
[0033] According to a further aspect, a control and regulating device for a heater is also proposed, configured to carry out a method proposed here. For this purpose, the control and regulating device can, for example, have and / or be equipped with a processor. In this context, the processor can, for example, execute the method stored in a memory (of the control and regulating device). Advantageously, the memory of the control and regulating device can also store data necessary for carrying out the method, for example a first, second and / or third threshold value and / or a first and / or second factor or a characteristic map thereof.
[0034] The details, features, and advantageous embodiments discussed in connection with the method may also be present in the control and regulation device, the computer program, and / or the heater presented here, and vice versa. In this respect, reference is made in full to the explanations therein for a more detailed characterization of the features.
[0035] Thus, a method for operating a heater, a computer program, a control device, and a heater are provided, which at least partially solve the problems described with reference to the prior art. In particular, the method, a computer program, a control device, and a heater, as well as the use thereof, at least contribute to providing particularly reliable flame monitoring that enables robust and reliable detection of a flame or flame loss across the entire modulation range of a heater. Furthermore, the method proposed here can enable early detection of a flashback.
[0036] Particularly advantageous is that the implementation of a method specified here does not require any structural changes to a heating device, but rather it can be implemented by implementing software.
[0037] The invention and the technical environment are explained in more detail below with reference to the accompanying figures. It should be noted that the invention is not intended to be limited by the exemplary embodiments cited. In particular, unless explicitly stated otherwise, it is also possible to extract partial aspects of the facts explained in the figures and combine them with other components and findings from the present description. In particular, it should be noted that the figures, and in particular the proportions shown, are only schematic. They show: Fig. 1: a heating device proposed here, Fig. 2: a sequence of a method proposed here, and Figs. 3 and 4: parameter curves that can occur when carrying out a method proposed here.
[0038] Fig. 1 shows, by way of example and schematically, a heating device 1 proposed here with a flow direction 16. This can have an air supply 4 for combustion air, in which a conveying device 2 for conveying a mass flow of combustion air is arranged. A gas valve 5 can add a mass flow of fuel gas from a gas supply 8 to the mass flow of combustion air conveyed by the conveying device 2. The mixture of fuel gas and combustion air can be fed to a burner 3 via a mixture channel 12 and burned. A heat exchanger 13 can be arranged on the burner 3, which can transfer heat generated during combustion to a heating circuit 14 with a flow line 6 and a return line 9.
[0039] An igniter 17 can be arranged on the burner 3, designed to be heated to a temperature to ignite the combustion mixture exiting the burner 3. The igniter 17 can, for example, be a glow igniter, which can be used as a temperature sensor for carrying out a method proposed here.
[0040] In addition, a flame monitoring sensor 15 can be arranged on the burner 3. Sensor 15 can, in particular, be a UV sensor or a temperature sensor.
[0041] Downstream of the burner 3, an exhaust pipe 10 can supply combustion products to an exhaust system 11. A control and regulating device 7 of the heater 1 can be electrically connected to at least the gas valve 5, the sensor 15, the igniter 17, and the conveying device 2.
[0042] Fig. 2 shows an example and schematically the sequence of a method proposed here. From a signal 18 y(t) of the sensor 15, a differential 19 dt , i.e. the first derivative of the signal 18, can be formed. Subsequently, a further differential 19 d y ˙ dt be formed, so that now the first derivative dy dt and the second derivative d y ˙ dt These can each be fed to a weighting 20, where the first derivative dy dt and the second derivative d y ˙ dt multiplied by a weighting factor. Subsequently, an average value 21 can be calculated. The determined average value can be fed to an evaluation logic 22, which compares the average value with a first threshold value and outputs a flame state 23 as the result.
[0043] Fig. 3 shows, by way of example, a signal 18 of a sensor 15 which is designed as a UV sensor and which is not in the saturation range. At time 24, a flashback may occur. Noise in the signal 18 can be detected prior to time 24 when a flashback occurs. In particular, a comparison of a first derivative dy dt of the signal 18 of the sensor 15 with a second predetermined threshold value and of the signal 18 of the sensor 15 with a third predetermined threshold value enable a reliable and early detection of the flame flashback.
[0044] Fig. 4 shows a signal 18 of the sensor 15 according to Fig. 2 , whereby the sensor 15 is not in the saturation state. It can be seen that only very slight noise occurs in the run-up to the time 24 when a flashback occurs. Here, too, a comparison of a first derivative dy dt of the signal 18 of the sensor 15 with a second predetermined threshold value and of the signal 18 of the sensor 15 with a third predetermined threshold value enable a reliable and early detection of the flame flashback. List of reference symbols
[0045] 1Heater 2Feeding device 3Burner 4Air supply 5Gas valve 6Flow 7Regulating and control unit 8Gas supply 9Return 10Exhaust pipe 11Exhaust system 12Mixing channel 13Heat exchanger 14Heating circuit 15Sensor 16Flow direction 17Igniter 18Sensor signal 19Differential 20Weighting 21Averaging 22Evaluation logic 23Flame state 24Time of flashback
Claims
1. Method for operating a heater (1), comprising a flame monitor for a burner (3) of the heater (1) with at least one sensor (15), wherein a comparison value is calculated on the basis of a first derivative and a second derivative of the signal (18) of the sensor (15) and a flame state (23) is determined on the basis of a comparison of the first comparison value with a first predetermined threshold value, and / or the at least one sensor (15) is a UV sensor and a first derivative of the signal (18) of the sensor (15) is compared with a second predetermined threshold value and the signal of the sensor (15) is compared with a third predetermined threshold value and a flame state (23) is determined.
2. Method according to claim 1, wherein the comparison value is calculated by calculating the first derivative and the second derivative, each multiplying them by a predetermined weighting factor (20) and determining an average value as a comparison value by means of averaging (21).
3. Method according to claim 2, wherein different weighting factors (20) are specified for different operating states of the heater (1).
4. Method according to one of the preceding claims, wherein determining the flame condition (23) includes determining a loss of flame and / or a flashback.
5. Method according to one of the preceding claims, wherein raw data of the signal (18) of the sensor (15) designed as a UV sensor are used for comparison with the third threshold value.
6. The method according to claim 5, wherein the UV signal of the sensor (15) is not in a saturation range and raw data of the signal (18) of the sensor (15) are compared with the third threshold value.
7. Method according to one of the preceding claims, wherein the heating device (1) is operated with hydrogen as fuel.
8. Control and regulation device (7) configured to carry out a method according to one of claims 1 to 7.
9. Heating device (1) arranged to burn a fuel on a burner (3), and comprising a flame monitor with at least one sensor (15), and means adapted to carry out the steps of a method according to one of claims 1 to 7.
10. A computer program comprising instructions causing a heating device (1) according to claim 9 to carry out a method according to any one of claims 1 to 7.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Flame monitoring in vehicle heating device involves performing additional evaluation of temp. gradient values for flame detection
DE19903305A1
Method and arrangement for observing flames in a combustion chamber of a heating appliance that can be operated with hydrogen or hydrogen-containing fuel gas
DE102021108014A1
Burner control
US8333584B2
