Method for verifying the results of a cleaning process of simulated chemical and / or microbiological contamination previously deposited on a test area
A method using a test liquid simulation and analysis addresses the lack of quantitative verification in existing cleaning verification methods, ensuring effective and reliable cleanliness verification.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2024529511
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Applications
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2021-11-19
- Filing Date
- 2022-11-08
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-15
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for verifying the cleanliness of surfaces after cleaning processes, such as the riboflavin test, lack quantitative verification of residual contamination, posing risks of hygiene and cross-contamination, especially in the pharmaceutical industry.
A method using a coated device with a cartridge containing a test liquid simulating chemical and/or microbiological contamination, applied to a test area, followed by a standardized cleaning process and analysis to verify the results, ensuring quantitative verification.
Provides efficient, reliable, and sensitive verification of cleaning effectiveness, ensuring surfaces are free of unacceptable residues, thereby reducing hygiene and cross-contamination risks.
Smart Images

Figure 2024542470000001 
Figure 2024542470000002 
Figure 2024542470000003
Abstract
Description
[Technical field]
[0001] The present invention relates to a method for verifying the results of a cleaning process of simulated chemical and / or microbiological contamination previously deposited on a test area, in particular a verification process for the functioning of automated washing equipment of the "Cleaning in Place" (CIP) and "Washing in Place" (WIP) type. [Background technology]
[0002] From US 3841973, a mechanical wiping device is known for automated microbiological sampling of surfaces. A motor-driven arm supports a swab, which moves over the surface to be inspected with a defined movement pattern and a defined pressure, the swab thus contaminated being subsequently analyzed. A similar device for automated cleaning validation of surfaces to be inspected is described in WO 2014 / 089320. Contamination residues that still remain on the surface after the cleaning process are picked up by the swab moving over the surface and quantified by analysis.
[0003] US Pat. No. 6,789,965 is directed to an apparatus and method for the high resolution, predefined deposition of microbiological or chemical material through a capillary tube for analytical purposes, such as DNA analysis.
[0004] The flyer "Cleanability of Surfaces - CSM Riboflavin Test" [https: / / www.ipa.fraunhofer.de / content / dam / ipa / en / documents / Expertises / Reinst-und-Mikroproduktion / Flyer_Cleanability_of_Surfaces.pdf] (fraunhofer.de) of the Fraunhofer Institute for Production Engineering and Automation (IPA) also deals with this subject. It describes a test method for checking the effectiveness of a complete cleaning / washing cycle on surfaces using a test liquid containing the water-soluble and extremely light-sensitive B2 (vitamin riboflavin).
[0005] For the test, the surfaces to be cleaned of the relevant equipment are first sprayed with an aqueous riboflavin solution. These surfaces are then sprayed with the cleaning solution in a time-controlled mode according to the burst cleaning method, followed preferably three times by time-controlled gravity drainage. After the completion of the cleaning phase, particularly extremely difficult surface areas are visually inspected using a black light and a telescopic mirror to ensure that the riboflavin solution has been completely removed. Visible fluorescence does not determine complete and proper cleaning. Moreover, if residue is found under the black light, the technician must recognize the insufficiently cleaned surface areas and adapt the strength and / or target direction of the spray device. [Prior art documents] [Patent documents]
[0006] [Patent Document 1] U.S. Pat. No. 3,841,973 [Patent Document 2] International Publication No. 2014 / 089320 [Patent Document 3] U.S. Patent No. 6,789,965 [Non-patent literature]
[0007] [Non-Patent Document 1] “Cleanability of Surfaces - CSM Riboflavin Test”[https: / / www.ipa.fraunhofer.de / content / dam / ipa / en / documents / Expertises / Reinst-und-Mikroproduktion / Flyer_Cleanability_of_Surfaces.pdf](fraunhofer.de) Summary of the Invention [Problem to be solved by the invention]
[0008] The Riboflavin test provides a somewhat qualitative check of the thoroughness of the cleaning carried out, but does not provide a quantitative verification as to whether the surfaces treated in the cleaning process are in fact completely free of sensitive or sensitive substances or are only exposed to contamination with very small amounts of, and thus still acceptable, residues in order to avoid hygiene or cross-contamination risks, which is essential for a competent verification.
[0009] Although the responsibility for verifying the defined cleaning (Performance Qualification PQ) of the equipment surfaces to be treated and the functional parts used by the washing equipment, especially in the pharmaceutical industry, still ultimately lies with the user, who also expects the manufacturer to provide a verification method to prove the required degree of cleaning. The problem underlying the present invention is therefore to propose a verification method whose use is efficient, reliable and sensitive in the applicable applications. [Means for solving the problem]
[0010] The method according to the invention is designed to verify the result of a cleaning process of a simulated chemical and / or microbiological contamination previously deposited on a test area, comprising: First, a coating device is provided having a filled cartridge, the cartridge containing a test liquid for simulating chemical and / or microbiological contamination, the test liquid including a predetermined type and concentration of chemical and / or microbiological contaminants; followed by selecting a predetermined test area and depositing a predetermined amount of test liquid onto the test area; Additionally, a standardized cleaning process is performed on the test areas where the test liquid has been applied. Finally, verify and record the results of the performed cleaning process; It has steps.
[0011] The following provides specific embodiments of the invention: After a predetermined amount of test liquid has been applied to the test area, the intensity, and sometimes also the type, of contamination present on the test area is determined and recorded before a standardized cleaning process of the test area to which the test liquid has been applied is carried out.
[0012] The test area is determined on the surface of the installation, for example on a containment for the production or research purposes of pharmaceutical or biotechnological products or in medical technology. The test area may also be determined on the surface of a functional part that can be used in the installation.
[0013] Alternatively, a separate piece of material in the form of an indicator plate is used as the test area, the material characteristics of which are identical to the material used for the material or functional parts in the installation structure and which is in any case acceptable as a reference material and may be provided, for example, as a film.
[0014] The coating device to be prepared for cartridges filled with test liquids to simulate chemical and / or microbiological contamination is of the inkjet printer type. Once fully constructed, the coating equipment is adjustable for different coating amounts and coating patterns and / or for differently sized test areas, and preferably has the form of a handheld device.
[0015] The contaminants to be added to the test liquid are particles and / or solvates. The test liquid consists mainly of a neutral solvent and a chemical and / or microbiological substance, such as a virus, fungus, spore, bacteria, protein or cell fragment, added to the neutral solvent in a predetermined concentration to simulate contamination on the test area.
[0016] Alternatively, the test liquid here consists mainly of a neutral solvent and a binary or multi-component mixture of chemicals and / or microbiological substances of the group of viruses, fungi, spores, bacteria, proteins and cell fragments contained in the neutral solvent in predetermined concentrations to simulate contamination on the test area.
[0017] The verification of the results of the performed cleaning process using the test area of the first form is carried out as follows: Wipe the previously contaminated and then cleaned surface of the test area with a neutral wiping element; The solvent removes the marks from the surface of the test area when wiped with the wiping element, Examining the traced solvent in an analyzer, The results of the analysis indicate that the cleaning process was normal or that residues of the contaminant-containing test solution remain on the test area beyond acceptable limits and that the cleaning process must be repeated or intensified to achieve acceptable cleanliness; It has steps.
[0018] The verification of the results of the performed cleaning process using the test area of the second form is as follows: treating the previously contaminated and then cleaned surface of the test area of the second form in a container with a solvent, Examining the traced solvent in an analyzer, The results of the analysis indicate that the cleaning process was normal or that residues of the contaminant test solution remain in the test area beyond acceptable limits and that the cleaning process must be repeated or intensified to achieve acceptable cleanliness; It has steps.
[0019] A positioning device is used to precisely align the indicator plate under the print head of the coating instrument before the coating instrument is used to deposit test fluid onto the indicator plate in an area selected as the test area. DETAILED DESCRIPTION OF THE PREFERRED EMBODIMENTS
[0020] The method provided for verifying the result of a cleaning process, in particular carried out by a cleaning device, of simulated chemical and / or microbiological contamination previously deposited on a test area comprises the following sequence of steps:
[0021] Step 1 A coating device is provided with a filled cartridge. The cartridge contains a test liquid for simulating chemical and / or microbiological contamination, the test liquid comprising a predetermined type and concentration of chemical and / or microbiological contaminants. The contaminants to be added to the test liquid are particles and / or solvates. The test liquid mainly consists of a neutral solvent and a predetermined concentration of chemical and / or microbiological substances, such as viruses, fungi, spores, bacteria, proteins or cell fragments, added to the neutral solvent to simulate contamination on the test area. Alternatively, the test liquid here mainly consists of a neutral solvent and a binary or multi-component mixture of chemicals and / or microbiological substances of the group of viruses, fungi, spores, bacteria, proteins and cell fragments, contained in the solvent, to simulate contamination on the test area, to simulate contamination.
[0022] The coating device to be prepared for cartridges filled with test liquids to simulate chemical and / or microbiological contamination is of the inkjet printer type. When fully constructed, the coating device is adjustable for different coating amounts and coating patterns and / or for differently sized test areas, and preferably has the form of a handheld device.
[0023] Step 2 A predefined test area is selected and a predefined amount of the test liquid is applied to the test area. The test area is determined on a surface of the installation, for example on a containment for the production of pharmaceutical or biotechnological products or for research purposes or in medical technology. The test area may also be determined on a surface of a functional part usable for the installation. Alternatively, a separate piece of material is used as the test area. This piece of material has material properties identical to the material used in the installation construction or for the functional part and is in any case acceptable as a reference material. The test area may therefore be determined in two different forms. The first form is an actual surface part of the installation or of a functional part usable in the installation. In contrast, the second form is a single piece of material identical to the actual surface part or a small indicator plate made of a suitable reference material. After applying a predefined amount of the test liquid to the test area according to the first or second form, the strength and possibly also the type of contamination present on the test area is determined and recorded before carrying out a standardized cleaning process of the test area to which the test liquid has been applied. The application of the test liquid to the test area is preferably carried out by spraying, in particular by printing.
[0024] Step 3 A standardized cleaning process of the test area with the first or second form of applied test liquid is carried out, preferably by spraying the cleaning solution in a time and intensity controlled mode, optionally in multiple cycles. The drainage of the cleaning solution is suitably carried out by gravity drainage or suction.
[0025] Step 4 The preceding steps are followed by a verification and recording of the results of the performed cleaning process. The overall method sequence can then be summarized as follows, whereby a distinction is made depending on whether the test area is selected in the first or second form. In short, according to step 2, an actual surface area of the installation or of a functional part usable in the installation is determined as the test area in the first form, or an indicator plate is determined as the test area in the second form.
[0026] Method steps using test areas in the first form (actual surface area) According to step 1, a predetermined amount of test liquid is applied to the test area by the coating device, followed by the execution of a standardized washing process of the test area to which the test liquid was applied, according to step 3.
[0027] Finally, in step 4, the results of the performed cleaning process are checked for their acceptability as specified. For this purpose, the surface of the test area, which was initially contaminated and then cleaned in step 3, is wiped with a neutral wiping element. Following this, the traces left by wiping the surface of the test area with the cleaning element are detached by a solvent and examined in an analyzer. The analysis result shows that the cleaning process was normal or that residues of the test liquid containing the contaminants remain on the test area beyond the permissible limits, so that the cleaning process must be repeated or intensified from the beginning to obtain an acceptable degree of cleanliness.
[0028] Method procedure using the test area of the second form (indicator plate) Based on proven practice, an indicator plate, technically called a "coupon", corresponding to the aforementioned features is used as the test area. Before applying the test liquid to the indicator plate by means of the coating device according to step 1, the indicator plate is inserted into a positioning device under the printer head of the coating device for its correct alignment. There, a predetermined amount of test liquid is also applied, followed by a standardized washing process of the indicator plate with the applied test liquid according to step 3. Preferably, the indicator plate then remains in the positioning device.
[0029] Finally, in step 4, it must be checked whether the performed cleaning process has produced satisfactory results. For this purpose, we treat the indicator plate, which has been intentionally contaminated and then cleaned in step 3, with a solvent in a container. The residues thus detached are checked in an analyzer. The analysis results in the realization that the cleaning process was sufficiently effective or that an unacceptable amount of residues remained on the indicator plate from the contaminant-containing test liquid and therefore cleaning must be repeated or intensified from the beginning in order to obtain the required degree of cleanliness.
Claims
1. 1. A method for verifying the results of a cleaning process of a simulated chemical and / or microbiological contamination previously deposited on a test area, comprising: a) providing a coating device having a loaded cartridge, the cartridge containing a test liquid for simulating chemical and / or microbiological contamination, the test liquid including predetermined types and concentrations of chemical and / or microbiological contaminants; b) selecting a predetermined test area and depositing a predetermined amount of test liquid onto the test area using a coating device; c) performing a standardized cleaning process of the test area to which the test liquid was applied; d) verifying and recording the results of the cleaning process carried out; A method having the steps.
2. 2. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that after applying a given amount of test liquid to the test area and before carrying out a standardized cleaning process of the test area to which the test liquid has been applied, the intensity and possibly also the type of contamination present on the test area is determined and recorded.
3. In the first form, a) facilities, such as those for the production of pharmaceutical or biotechnological products or for research purposes or for containment in medical technology, or b) The functional parts available within the facility determining a test area on the surface; 3. The method according to claim 1 or 2, characterized in that
4. In a second alternative form, a separate piece of material in the form of an indicator plate is used as the test area, the material characteristics of which are identical to the material used for the material or functional parts in the installation structure and which is in any case acceptable as a reference material.
5. 5. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that the coating device is of the inkjet printer type.
6. 6. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that the coating equipment is adjustable for different coating amounts and coating patterns.
7. 7. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that the coating device is adjustable to differently dimensioned test areas.
8. 8. The method according to claim 1, wherein the coating device is configured as a handheld device.
9. 9. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that the contaminants to be added to the test liquid are particles and / or solvates.
10. The test solution is a) an aprotic solvent; b) a predetermined concentration of chemical and / or microbiological substances, such as viruses, fungi, spores, bacteria, proteins or cell fragments, contained in a solvent to simulate contamination on the test area; 10. The method according to claim 1, characterized in that it comprises:
11. The test solution is a) an aprotic solvent; b) binary or multi-component mixtures of chemicals and / or microbiological agents of the group of viruses, fungi, spores, bacteria, proteins and cell fragments, in a solvent, in predetermined concentrations to simulate contamination on the test area; 11. The method of claim 10, comprising:
12. Verification of the results of the performed cleaning process is carried out as follows: a) wiping the previously contaminated and then cleaned surface of the test area in the first form with a neutral wiping element; b) the solvent removes the mark from the surface of the test area when wiped with the wiping element; c) examining the traced solvent in an analyzer; At that time, d) The analytical results indicate that the cleaning process was normal or that residues of the contaminant-containing test solution remain on the test area beyond acceptable limits, so that the cleaning process must be repeated or intensified to achieve acceptable cleanliness.
12. The method according to claim 1, further comprising the steps:
13. To verify the results of the cleaning process carried out, a) treating the surface of the test area in the second form, which has been previously contaminated and then cleaned, in a container with a solvent; b) examining the traced solvent in an analyzer; At that time, c) The analytical results indicate that the cleaning process was normal or that residues of the contaminant-containing test solution remain in the test area beyond acceptable limits, so that the cleaning process must be repeated or intensified to achieve acceptable cleanliness.
12. The method according to claim 1, 2 and / or 4 to 11, characterized in that it comprises the steps:
14. 14. The method according to at least one of claims 1, 2, 4 to 11 and 13, characterized in that a positioning device is used to accurately align the indicator plate under a print head of the coating equipment before depositing the test liquid on the indicator plate selected as the test area using the coating equipment.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Apparatus for microbiological sampling
US3841973A
Dot printer with off-axis loading
US6789965B2
Automatic cleaning validation swabbing devices, methods, and systems
WO2014089320A1
