Method for analyzing Sb in steel materials, method for controlling Sb concentration in molten steel during refining, and method for manufacturing steel materials.
The method of spark discharge optical emission spectrometry for Sb analysis in steel materials with martensite and bainite microstructure addresses inaccuracy issues, enabling precise Sb control during refining for improved steel production.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- JP2026545388
- Authority / Receiving Office
- JP · JP
- Patent Type
- Patents
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2025-05-16
- Filing Date
- 2026-05-12
- Publication Date
- 2026-11-11
- Estimated Expiration
- 2046-05-12
AI Technical Summary
Existing methods for measuring antimony (Sb) concentration in steel materials during refining are inaccurate at low concentrations, particularly at levels of tens of mass ppm, leading to deviations in the final product yield.
A method involving spark discharge optical emission spectrometry is used to analyze Sb concentration in steel materials, specifically when the microstructure is composed of martensite and bainite, with hardness-based selection criteria to ensure accuracy, and the addition of Sb is adjusted based on real-time analysis during refining.
Enables rapid and highly accurate measurement of Sb concentration, allowing precise control of Sb addition to molten steel, resulting in stable steel material production with improved yield.
Smart Images

Figure 0007948508000003 
Figure 0007948508000004 
Figure 0007948508000001
Abstract
Description
[Technical Field]
[0001] This invention relates to a method for analyzing Sb in steel materials, a method for controlling the Sb concentration of molten steel during refining, and a method for manufacturing steel materials. [Background technology]
[0002] Adding trace amounts of specific elements to steel materials is effective in improving properties and developing new functions, and is being put into practical use. For example, in the field of high-tensile steel, Nb or Ti is sometimes added to the steel material at levels of several hundred ppm by mass. This is because the Nb or Ti added to the steel material generates fine carbides, resulting in precipitation strengthening. Also, in the field of bearing steel, Sb is sometimes added to the steel material at levels of several tens of ppm by mass. This is because the Sb added to the steel material suppresses the decrease in fatigue strength due to surface decarburization during hot processes such as hot forming and quenching. Therefore, it is necessary to control the concentration of elements in the steel material with high precision in order to obtain the desired properties.
[0003] The concentration of components in steel materials can be adjusted during the refining of molten steel. Specifically, a portion of the molten steel is taken during refining to prepare an analytical sample, and the concentration of the target element (for convenience, referred to as "element A") contained in the prepared analytical sample is measured. Based on the measurement results, the amount of element A to be added to bring the concentration of element A to the target concentration is calculated, and element A is added to the molten steel based on the calculated amount. However, if measuring the concentration of element A takes time, the concentration adjustment may be carried out based on past performance or predicted values based on refining parameters, without knowing the concentration of element A in the molten steel. As a result, the concentration of element A in the steel material and the final product may deviate from the target concentration, potentially reducing the yield. Therefore, a method for rapidly measuring the elemental concentration of molten steel during refining is required.
[0004] One analytical method that can rapidly measure elemental concentrations in steel materials is spark discharge emission spectroscopy. Spark discharge emission spectroscopy is a method that repeatedly generates spark discharges between a metal material and an electrode, spectrally analyzes the excitation emission produced by each spark discharge, and measures the emission intensity of the target element.
[0005] For example, Patent Document 1 discloses a method for rapidly and accurately measuring the concentration of carbon in iron-rich metal materials such as steel materials using spark discharge emission spectroscopy. [Prior art documents] [Patent Documents]
[0006] [Patent Document 1] Japanese Patent Publication No. 2014-215113 [Overview of the project] [Problems that the invention aims to solve]
[0007] However, when a sample was prepared for analysis by taking a portion of the molten steel during refining using the method disclosed in Patent Document 1, and the Sb concentration was measured, it was found that the sensitivity was low and it was not possible to measure Sb concentrations at the level of tens of mass ppm with sufficient accuracy.
[0008] This invention has been made in view of the above points, and aims to provide an analytical method for rapidly and accurately measuring the Sb concentration in steel materials. [Means for solving the problem]
[0009] As a result of diligent research, the inventors have found that the above objective can be achieved by adopting the following configuration.
[0010] 1. A method for analyzing Sb in steel materials, A determination step to determine whether the structure of the steel material is mainly composed of martensite and bainite, or both; A method for analyzing Sb in steel materials, comprising: a quantification step of determining the Sb concentration by spark discharge optical emission spectrometry using the steel material, when the microstructure of the steel material is mainly composed of one or both of martensite and bainite.
[0011] 2. The method for analyzing Sb in a steel material according to claim 1, wherein in the determination step, when the hardness of the steel material is equal to or higher than a predetermined threshold, the microstructure of the steel material is determined to be mainly composed of one or both of martensite and bainite. The method for analyzing Sb in a steel material according to the above 1.
[0012] 3. The method for analyzing Sb in a steel material according to claim 1 or 2, wherein the steel material is produced by collecting molten steel during refining and cooling the collected molten steel. The method for analyzing Sb in a steel material according to the above 1 or 2.
[0013] 4. A method for managing the Sb concentration of molten steel during refining, comprising determining the addition amount of Sb to the molten steel during refining based on the Sb concentration determined by the method for analyzing Sb in a steel material according to the above 3.
[0014] 5. A method for producing a steel material, comprising adding Sb to the molten steel during refining based on the addition amount of Sb to the molten steel during refining determined by the method for managing the Sb concentration of molten steel during refining according to the above 4. [[ID=22】Effects of the Invention]
[0015] According to the present invention, it is possible to provide an analysis method for quickly and highly accurately measuring the Sb concentration in steel materials. Brief Description of the Drawings
[0016] [Figure 1] This is a graph with the Sb concentration determined by the method of the invention example on the vertical axis and the chemical analysis value on the horizontal axis. [Figure 2] This is a graph with the Sb concentration determined by the method of the comparative example on the vertical axis and the chemical analysis value on the horizontal axis. Modes for Carrying Out the Invention
[0017] First, we will explain the findings obtained by the inventors. The inventors measured the Sb concentration of analytical samples containing tens of mass ppm of Sb, prepared from molten steel during refining, using spark discharge emission spectroscopy. As a result, they found that the accuracy varied between good and bad measurements. They speculated that this was due to differences in the segregation state of Sb, and observed the analytical surface of the analytical samples. As a result, they found that there were differences in the microstructure of the analytical samples. Specifically, they found that when high-accuracy measurements were obtained, the analytical surface of the analytical sample had a microstructure mainly composed of one or both of the hard microstructures bainite and martensite, while when low-accuracy measurements were obtained, it contained a large amount of the soft microstructure pearlite. Based on the above findings, the inventors conducted various studies and completed the present invention.
[0018] The present invention will be described below. The following description illustrates preferred embodiments of the present invention, and the present invention is not limited in any way by the following description.
[0019] <Analysis method for Sb in steel materials> A method for analyzing Sb in steel materials according to one embodiment of the present invention comprises the following two steps. (1) A determination process for determining whether the structure of the steel material is mainly composed of martensite and bainite, or both. (2) A quantitative process to determine the Sb concentration using spark discharge emission spectroscopy when the microstructure of the steel material is mainly composed of martensite and bainite, or both.
[0020] (Steel materials) The steel material to be analyzed in this invention is not particularly limited, and any steel material such as cold-rolled steel sheets or hot-rolled steel sheets can be used. However, according to this invention, since the Sb concentration can be measured rapidly, the analysis results can be fed back into adjusting the Sb concentration in the refining process by analyzing the molten steel during refining. Therefore, as the steel material, a steel material made from molten steel during refining is preferred. Furthermore, the shape of the steel material is not particularly limited, but it can be a cylindrical or substantially cylindrical sample (a so-called bomb sample). The bomb sample can be, for example, about 33 mm in diameter and about 75 mm in height.
[0021] To prepare the steel material to be analyzed from molten steel, one simply needs to take a sample of the molten steel and cool it. The cooling method is not particularly limited. For example, cooling can be started from the austenite region, water-cooled at a rate of approximately 15°C / sec or higher, and completed within 60 seconds. In the case of a bomb sample, the time until the start of cooling should be within 60 seconds after taking the sample of molten steel. This makes it possible to prepare a steel material having a bainite-dominant structure, in the case of molten steel for bearings.
[0022] Examples of the above-mentioned steel materials include steel materials with a carbon concentration of 0.1 to 1.5%. By producing steel materials under appropriate conditions using molten steel for bearing steel, the microstructure of the steel material can be made to be mainly composed of bainite, making steel materials produced from molten steel for bearing steel suitable for use. The carbon concentration of bearing steel is, for example, 0.95 to 1.10%. Furthermore, according to the present invention, analysis can be performed with high accuracy even with trace amounts of Sb, so the present invention can be suitably used for steel materials with an Sb concentration of 100 ppm or less.
[0023] (Judgment process) In the determination step, it is determined whether the microstructure of the steel material to be analyzed is mainly composed of martensite, bainite, or both. By using a sample with a microstructure mainly composed of martensite and bainite, or both, quantitative analysis can be performed with higher accuracy compared to other microstructures, such as those containing a large amount of pearlite. Furthermore, variations in the microstructure of steel materials can occur due to variations in the manufacturing conditions of the steel material (for example, cooling conditions when analyzing steel material made from molten steel). Therefore, it is necessary to determine whether the microstructure of the steel material meets the conditions and then perform the quantitative analysis step described later based on the determination result.
[0024] The method of determination is not particularly limited. For example, one method is to observe steel materials under a microscope. When observing steel materials under a microscope, the steel material can be embedded in resin, polished, and the determination can be made by observing the polished surface. In this case, if the total area ratio of martensite and bainite is 70% or more, it can be determined that one or both of martensite and bainite are the main components.
[0025] Furthermore, from the viewpoint of further shortening the analysis time, it is preferable to make the determination using methods based on the manufacturing conditions of the steel material or methods based on the hardness of the steel material.
[0026] When making a determination based on the manufacturing conditions of steel materials, the determination can be made by first understanding the manufacturing conditions of the steel materials required to satisfy the determination criteria. To do this, it is necessary to evaluate in advance the relationship between the manufacturing conditions of the steel materials and the microstructure of the steel materials.
[0027] Furthermore, since martensite and bainite are harder than other structures, the determination can be made based on the hardness of the steel material. Specifically, if the hardness of the steel material is above a predetermined threshold, it can be determined that the structure of the steel material is mainly composed of either martensite or bainite, or both. The threshold (lower limit of hardness) can be determined by measuring the structure and hardness for each type of steel. By making the determination based on hardness, variations in the manufacturing conditions of the steel material can be tolerated, which makes it possible to shorten the analysis time and simplify the equipment used in the manufacturing of steel materials.
[0028] As for hardness, Vickers hardness HV, Brinell hardness HB, Rockwell hardness HR, Shore hardness HS, and Lieb hardness HL can be used. Among these, Vickers hardness HV and Lieb hardness HL can be measured with a portable hardness tester and are preferable because they allow for faster analysis. Of the hardness values, Vickers hardness HV is more preferred. Furthermore, any of these hardness values can be converted to different hardness values based on the measured value. Therefore, converted values may be used as hardness values.
[0029] In the determination process, there is no limit to the number of steel materials to be determined. Determination may be performed on one steel material, or on multiple steel materials. Furthermore, steel materials that meet the above-mentioned determination conditions may be selected from among multiple steel materials as analytical samples.
[0030] (Quantitative process) In the quantitative analysis step, if the microstructure of the steel material consists mainly of martensite and / or bainite, the Sb concentration is determined using spark discharge emission spectroscopy with the steel material. In other words, if the criteria for determination in the above determination step are met, the steel material is used for analysis; otherwise, it is not used for analysis.
[0031] In the quantitative process, specifically, a spark discharge emission spectrometer is used to measure the emission intensity of Sb contained in the steel material. Sbis measured, and the Sb concentration in the steel material can be determined based on the obtained measured value. By using spark discharge optical emission spectrometry, rapid measurement becomes possible.
[0032] The spark discharge optical emission spectrometer is not particularly limited, and a commercially available apparatus may be used. In addition, the emission intensity I of Sb Sb measurement conditions are not particularly limited, and standard analysis conditions can be used. As the wavelength of the Sb emission line, Sb(I) 217.58 nm may be used. That is, the peak intensity at the relevant wavelength is measured, and the emission intensity I of Sb Sb may be taken as the measured value.
[0033] The emission intensity I of Sb Sb In order to determine the Sb concentration based on the measured value, the Sb concentration may be determined based on the pre-obtained relationship between the emission intensity I of Sb Sb and the Sb concentration and the aforementioned measured value. However, by using Fe as an internal standard element and using the ratio I of the emission intensity of Sb to the emission intensity of Fe Sb / I Fe , various fluctuations during measurement can be corrected, and the Sb concentration can be determined with high accuracy. Therefore, it is preferable to use I Sb / I Fe . Specifically, it is preferable to determine the Sb concentration based on the pre-obtained relationship between I Sb / I Fe and the Sb concentration, the measured value of I Sb and the measured value of I Fe . Here, as the wavelength of the Fe emission line, Fe(I) 287.2 nm may be used. That is, the peak intensity at the relevant wavelength is measured, and the emission intensity I of Fe Fe may be taken as the measured value.
[0034] When measuring the emission intensity, the discharge energy is not particularly limited. That is, according to the present method, even for an apparatus that has difficulty in measurement at low energy, high accuracy of analysis can be achieved. Therefore, the discharge energy may be, for example, 0.10 J or more.
[0035] <Method for managing Sb concentration in molten steel during refining> In the method for controlling the Sb concentration of molten steel during refining according to one embodiment of the present invention, the Sb concentration is determined by the analysis method for Sb in the steel material described above. Here, a steel material produced by sampling and cooling molten steel during refining is used. Then, based on the determined Sb concentration, the amount of Sb to be added to the molten steel during refining is determined. This makes it possible to determine the amount of Sb to be added with high accuracy and speed, and enables real-time adjustment of the Sb concentration of the molten steel during refining. As the molten steel to be used for refining, molten steel produced by any method using a converter, electric furnace, induction furnace, etc., can be used.
[0036] (Determination of the amount of Sb to add) The method for determining the amount of Sb to add to molten steel during refining, based on the Sb concentration obtained by the above analytical method, is not particularly limited. For example, the amount of Sb to add can be determined from the difference between the target Sb concentration and the Sb concentration obtained by the above analytical method, and from the mass of the molten steel. Alternatively, since Sb is highly volatile, the amount of Sb to add may be determined based on the expected yield. More specifically, the amount of Sb to add may also be determined based on the molten steel temperature.
[0037] <Method of manufacturing steel materials> In the steel material manufacturing method according to one embodiment of the present invention, Sb is added to the molten steel during refining based on the amount of Sb added to the molten steel during refining determined by the method for controlling the Sb concentration of the molten steel during refining described above. As a result, the amount of Sb added to the molten steel during refining can be controlled with high precision, making it possible to manufacture steel materials with stable properties in a high yield.
[0038] (Manufacturing of steel materials) The method for obtaining steel material from molten steel to which Sb has been added is not particularly limited, but methods such as continuous casting and ingot-molding rolling can be used. The steel material produced is also not particularly limited, but examples include slabs, blooms, and billets. [Examples]
[0039] The present invention will be described below based on examples. The present invention is not limited to these examples.
[0040] <Experiment 1> In Experiment 1, spark discharge emission spectroscopy was performed on analytical samples prepared from molten steel during refining, and the discrepancy with chemical analysis values was evaluated.
[0041] (Example of an invention) In the method described in the invention example, a portion of the molten steel was first taken from the molten steel being refined at the time it was tapped for bearing steel (SUJ2 or SUJ3, whose component composition is shown in Table 1). Here, a total of 40 charges of samples were taken from three types of molten steel: molten steel without added Sb, molten steel with Sb added to a target of 7 ppm, and molten steel with Sb added to a target of 30 ppm. Forty cylindrical cast samples (approximately 33 mm in diameter and 75 mm in height) were produced by cooling the obtained molten steel.
[0042] [Table 1]
[0043] Forty cast samples were obtained, and each was sliced crosswise. The sheared surface was then polished using a belt sander (grit size: #80) to prepare analytical samples. The time required from sampling the molten steel to preparing the analytical samples was approximately 5 minutes.
[0044] Next, hardness measurements were performed on 40 analytical samples, and 20 analytical samples with a Vickers hardness of 700 HV or higher were selected (judgment step). Specifically, the Vickers hardness was measured at two points on the polished surface of each analytical sample, and those with an average value of 700 HV or higher were selected for analysis. A portable hardness tester (JFE Advantech SONOHARD SH-21A) was used for hardness measurement. The time required for hardness measurement was a few seconds per point, and even with two-point analysis, the judgment was completed in approximately one minute or less.
[0045] Next, the Sb concentration was determined for the selected analytical samples (quantification step). In the quantification step, a commercially available spark discharge emission spectrometer (ARL4460, Thermo Fisher Scientific) was used to perform spark discharge emission spectroscopy (measurement diameter 12 mmφ) on the polished surface of the analytical sample where Vickers hardness measurement was not performed, and the emission intensity of Sb I was determined. Sb and the emission intensity of Fe I Fe The following was measured. Here, the peak intensity at a wavelength of 217.58 nm, which is the emission line of Sb, was defined as the emission intensity of Sb I. Sb It was used as follows. In addition, the peak intensity at the wavelength of Fe(I), which is the emission line of Fe, at 287.2 nm was used as the emission intensity of Fe I. Fe It was used as such. The obtained I Sb / I Fe The Sb concentration was determined by substituting the values into a pre-prepared calibration curve. Here, the calibration curve was created using standard samples with known Sb concentrations, and the ratio of the emission intensity of Sb to the emission intensity of Fe is calculated as I Sb / I Fe This was created by determining a regression equation between the Sb concentration and the Sb concentration.
[0046] Furthermore, the accuracy of spark discharge emission spectrometry was confirmed using chemical analysis. A small sample of several grams of chips was taken from the analytical sample after spark discharge emission spectrometry, and a portion of it was dissolved in acid to determine the Sb concentration using ICP mass spectrometry (chemical analysis method).
[0047] (Comparative example) On the other hand, in the comparative example method, the hardness of the analytical samples was not measured, and 20 analytical samples were arbitrarily selected from 40 analytical samples prepared using the same method as in the inventive example. Then, the Sb concentration was determined by spark discharge emission spectroscopy using the same method as in the inventive example, and compared with the results of chemical analysis.
[0048] Figure 1 shows a graph with the Sb concentration obtained using the method of the inventive example on the vertical axis and the chemical analysis value on the horizontal axis. Figure 2 shows a graph with the Sb concentration obtained using the method of the comparative example on the vertical axis and the chemical analysis value on the horizontal axis. When using the method of the inventive example, the Sb concentration obtained by spark discharge emission spectroscopy agreed well with the Sb concentration obtained by chemical analysis. The σd value, which indicates accuracy, was 1.1 ppm. On the other hand, when using the method of the comparative example, there was a large discrepancy between the Sb concentration obtained by spark discharge emission spectroscopy and the chemical analysis value, and σd was 4.5 ppm.
[0049] Furthermore, SEM observation of the microstructure of the analytical samples used in the inventive example and comparative example revealed that in the inventive example, all 20 samples had a microstructure with a bainite area ratio of 70% or more. On the other hand, in the comparative example, 4 out of 20 samples had a microstructure with a bainite area ratio of 70% or more, or with a combined area ratio of martensite and bainite of 70% or more, while 16 samples had a microstructure with a pearlite area ratio of 70% or more. Thus, in the inventive example, steel materials having a microstructure mainly composed of one or both of martensite and bainite were selected, whereas in the comparative example, the steel materials were not appropriately selected. In the method of the inventive example, by performing Sb analysis using steel materials having a microstructure mainly composed of one or both of martensite and bainite, highly accurate analytical values could be obtained.
[0050] Furthermore, in the method described in the invention, the total time from sample preparation to analysis was approximately 10 minutes. Thus, by using spark discharge emission spectroscopy, analytical values can be obtained quickly, and the analysis time can be further reduced by determining whether or not to use steel material for analysis based on the hardness of the steel material.
[0051] <Experiment 2> In Experiment 2, the amount of Sb added was adjusted according to the results of spark discharge emission spectroscopy analysis in order to achieve the target Sb value in the manufacturing of the steel material.
[0052] (Example of an invention) Molten steel was sampled during the refining process at the time of tapping for bearing steel SUJ3 (target Sb value 30±10 ppm), specifically at the end of converter blowing. Analytical samples were prepared and selected based on hardness measurement using the method described in Experiment 1, and analytical samples meeting a Vickers hardness of 700 HV or higher were prepared. Next, the Sb concentration of the prepared analytical samples was determined by spark discharge emission spectroscopy using the method described in Experiment 1.
[0053] Furthermore, based on the determined Sb concentration, Sb was added to adjust the Sb content in the semi-finished product (bloom) after melting to 30 ± 10 ppm. Here, Sb pellets were used as the raw material for Sb addition. In addition, considering the yield of highly volatile Sb, the appropriate amount of Sb to add was calculated from the target amount of molten steel and molten steel temperature. Sb was added at the start of the RH (Ruhrstahl-Hausen) vacuum degassing method.
[0054] Using the method described above, a total of 20 blooms (A1 to A20) were produced for each charge. Chemical analysis of the obtained blooms was performed by ICP mass spectrometry to evaluate the actual Sb concentration in the blooms relative to the target Sb concentration range.
[0055] (Comparative example) Molten steel was sampled during the refining process at the time of tapping for bearing steel SUJ3 (target Sb value 30±10 ppm), specifically at the end of converter blowing. The sampled molten steel was prepared using the method described in Experiment 1, without selection based on hardness measurement.
[0056] Using a process similar to that of the invention example, the Sb concentration of the analytical sample was determined, and the Sb concentration in the semi-finished product was adjusted to 30 ± 10 ppm. Using the above method, a total of 20 blooms (B1 to B20) were produced for each charge, and the obtained blooms were subjected to chemical analysis by ICP mass spectrometry to evaluate the actual Sb concentration in the blooms relative to the target Sb concentration range.
[0057] Table 2 shows the Sb concentration in the bloom determined by chemical analysis. All 20 samples in the inventive example met the target Sb value of 30 ± 10 ppm. Thus, by using the method in the inventive example, it was possible to adjust the Sb concentration in the bloom to the target concentration range. In the method in the inventive example, high-quality samples with less segregation, etc., could be identified by hardness measurement, which allowed for a more accurate determination of the Sb concentration during smelting, and as a result, precise control of the amount of Sb added to the molten steel was achieved. On the other hand, in the 20 samples in the comparative example, one sample fell outside the lower limit and two samples fell outside the upper limit. Thus, when using the method in the comparative example, some samples had Sb concentrations in the bloom that fell outside the target concentration range. In the comparative example, it is thought that the measurement of low-quality samples with poor accuracy and precision in Sb analysis during refining was sometimes performed, making it impossible to precisely control the amount of Sb added.
[0058] [Table 2]
[0059] As described above, the present invention demonstrates that by accurately performing Sb analysis during refining, it is possible to reliably control the Sb concentration in the bloom, a semi-finished product, within the target control range.
Claims
1. A method for analyzing Sb in steel materials, A determination step to determine whether the structure of the steel material is mainly composed of martensite and bainite, or both; A method for analyzing Sb in a steel material, comprising a quantitative step of determining the Sb concentration using the steel material by spark discharge emission spectroscopy when the microstructure of the steel material mainly consists of one or both martensite and bainite.
2. In the determination step, if the hardness of the steel material is above a predetermined threshold, it is determined that the structure of the steel material is mainly composed of martensite and bainite, or both. The method for analyzing Sb in a steel material according to claim 1.
3. The aforementioned steel material is produced by taking molten steel during refining and cooling it. The method for analyzing Sb in a steel material according to claim 1 or 2.
4. A method for controlling the Sb concentration of molten steel during refining, wherein the amount of Sb to be added to the molten steel during refining is determined based on the Sb concentration obtained by the method for analyzing Sb in steel material described in claim 3.
5. A method for producing a steel material, comprising adding Sb to molten steel during refining based on the amount of Sb added to molten steel during refining determined by the method for controlling the Sb concentration of molten steel during refining described in claim 4.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
JP1975063989A
Field analysis of liquefied conductive material
JP1987011130A
Emission spectrochemical analysis
JP1989013440A
Emission spectroscopic analyzing method and apparatus
JP1996050097A
Segregation evaluation method and segregation evaluation device by emission spectrometric analysis
JP2014020839A
