Method for enhancing binding force of thermal barrier ceramic coating of turbine blade
The microstructure of the thermal barrier coating of the turbine blades was prepared by femtosecond laser and sprayed with ceramic layers, which solved the problem of insufficient adhesion of the thermal barrier coating of the turbine blades, achieved efficient mechanical interlocking effect, significantly improved the combination of coatings Strength and durability, suitable for harsh environments of aircraft engines.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410960291.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-17
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-19
- Estimated Expiration
- Not applicable · inactive patent
AI Technical Summary
The existing turbine blade thermal barrier ceramic coatings are prone to failure and peeling due to insufficient adhesion in high temperature environments, and traditional processes have microcracks and thermal stress problems, making it difficult to meet the demanding service environment needs of aircraft engines.
High-quality microstructures with different patterns are prepared on the NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer by femtosecond laser. The surface sprayed with ceramic layer prepared by femtosecond laser increases the contact surface area between layers and prevents cracks from spreading, achieving mechanical interlocking effect, thereby improving the The bonding strength and peel resistance of the coating to the substrate.
It significantly enhances the adhesion and durability of ceramic coatings, improves the application performance of thermal barrier coatings, and verifies the improvement of adhesion performance by different microstructure designs through scratch experiments, and grid-type microstructures are the most obvious.
Smart Images

Figure CN118979227A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of turbine blade coating enhancement, and in particular to a method for enhancing the bonding strength of a turbine blade thermal barrier ceramic coating. Background Art
[0002] With the development of aerospace technology, the temperature of turbine front inlet is constantly increasing. Ceramic thermal barrier coating (TBC) technology is an effective means to improve the high temperature resistance of turbine blades. The most widely used thermal barrier coating system is composed of a base layer, a bonding coating and a top ceramic layer. Each layer plays an important role in the thermal barrier coating system. At present, YSZ and NiCoCrAlY are the main materials for ceramic coatings and metal bonding layers. Electron beam physical vapor deposition (EB-PVD) columnar coating is the most widely used method for preparing TBC. The coating prepared by EB-PVD has the advantages of good thermal shock resistance, controllable microstructure, low thermal conductivity, good adhesion, and low coating surface roughness. Unfortunately, this layered coating also leads to many defects, spherical voids and microcracks between the internal plates of the coating, resulting in reduced coating adhesion. When the thermal barrier coating is subjected to high temperature for a long time, the topcoat (TC) is usually in a tensile or compressive stress state, which promotes the formation and extension of cracks. In addition, a layer of thermally grown oxide (TGO) will be produced at the interface between the bonding layer and the ceramic layer. This oxide will promote the propagation of interface cracks and rapidly degrade the interface toughness. During this process, the ceramic layer will undergo a phase change, changing the microstructure of the thermal barrier coating, thereby affecting the thermal conductivity of the coating and increasing the stiffness of the coating, further causing significant peeling of the coating.
[0003] In order to improve the life of thermal barrier coatings, researchers at home and abroad have adopted many methods to improve the bonding performance of the bonding layer and the ceramic coating. For example, the interface performance of the bonding layer / TGO is improved by using the method of active element doping modification. The addition of precious metal elements such as Hf and Re to the NiCoCrAlY bonding layer improves the bonding performance of the NiCoCrAlY bonding layer and the ceramic layer. However, most of the current research uses a single active element for doping, and there is less research on multi-element doping. With the continuous development of aero-engines, the doping of a single element can no longer meet the needs of harsh service environments. In the traditional process of preparing thermal barrier coatings, degreasing and sandblasting processes are often used before thermal spraying. The degreasing agent induces chemical modification of the surface and removes organic matter on the surface, while sandblasting changes the surface morphology by generating random roughness, thereby promoting the mechanical anchoring of the incoming particles on the substrate. Although such a process is very effective for most materials, there may be a risk of microcrack nucleation on the surface, and the appearance of inclusions will reduce the adhesion of subsequent coatings. In addition, during the service process, large thermal stress is easily generated at the interface, resulting in coating failure, and then the coating fails and falls off. Therefore, a new method is needed to improve the bonding performance between the bonding layer and the ceramic layer of the thermal barrier coating system. Summary of the invention
[0004] The purpose of the present invention is to overcome the shortcomings of the prior art and provide a method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings for turbine blades. The method uses a femtosecond laser to prepare high-quality microstructures of different patterns on a NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer. The wall surface of the microstructure is smooth, without an obvious heat-affected zone, and without processing defects such as microcracks, holes, and molten droplets. A ceramic layer is sprayed on the surface of the bonding layer after the microstructure is prepared by the femtosecond laser. This method can not only increase the contact surface area between the layers, but also prevent the cracks from extending along the interface, thereby obtaining a unique obtuse-angle mechanical interlocking effect. This mechanical anchoring can also effectively improve the bonding strength and spalling resistance between the coating and the substrate. The coating will fill the microscopic depressions on the surface of the substrate during the deposition process, thereby increasing the bonding strength between the coating and the substrate. The present invention can effectively enhance the adhesion and durability of the ceramic coating, improve the application performance of the thermal barrier coating, and has an excellent prospect for application and promotion.
[0005] In order to achieve the above technical effects, the following technical solutions are adopted:
[0006] A method for enhancing the bonding strength of a thermal barrier ceramic coating of a turbine blade comprises the following steps:
[0007] Step S1: Preparation of metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY
[0008] The NiCoCrAlY metal powder was sprayed on the surface of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy DD6 of the turbine blade by the EB-PVD method. The NiCoCrAlY metal powder target was evaporated by a high-energy electron beam with a current of 70-85A and a voltage of 20-25V to generate NiCoCrAlY metal vapor. The NiCoCrAlY metal vapor was then evaporated by an Ar / H 2 The plasma gas is brought out to deposit on the surface of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy DD6 of the turbine blade to form a uniform and dense NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer; after the deposition, a high-quality coating is formed on the surface of the substrate by condensation, ensuring good bonding performance and coating integrity; the deposition process conditions are: spraying current is 50-75A; spraying voltage is 15-25V; plasma gas is 75% Ar and 25% H by volume 2 mixture, the plasma gas flow rate was 70 slpm; the deposition time was 60 minutes, and the bias voltage was -140A.
[0009] Step S2: Preparation of microstructure on the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY
[0010] Using a femtosecond laser system and a three-axis displacement platform, the optical routing of the femtosecond laser system is composed of a beam expander, a reflector, a CCD camera system for real-time monitoring and precise positioning of the workpiece, and a scanning galvanometer system for quickly and accurately directing the laser beam and controlling the scanning path and position of the laser beam on the workpiece;
[0011] Use a field lens to focus the laser beam directly on the surface of the NiCoCrAlY coating obtained in step S1, and control the three-axis displacement platform to perform multiple scans to complete the microstructure preparation according to the microstructure to be prepared, so as to ensure the material removal rate, optimize the oxidation degree, and ensure the quality of the micro grooves and the surface accuracy, so as to perform fine processing on the coating without thermal damage;
[0012] Step S3: Depositing a ceramic coating on the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY of the prepared microstructure
[0013] On the surface treated by femtosecond laser in step S2, 8YSZ ceramic powder is sprayed by EB-PVD method; 8YSZ ceramic powder target is evaporated by high-energy electron beam with current of 50-75A and voltage of 15-25V to generate 8YSZ ceramic powder vapor, and Ar with volume ratio of 75% and H with volume ratio of 25% is used to generate 8YSZ ceramic powder vapor. 2 The plasma gas with a flow rate of 75slpm was used to carry out the deposition, and a ceramic coating was formed on the surface of the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY prepared with a microstructure by condensation; the deposition process conditions were: spraying current of 50-75A; spraying voltage of 15-25V; plasma gas of 75% Ar and 25% H by volume 2mixture, the plasma gas flow rate was 75 slpm; the deposition time was 90 minutes, and the bias voltage was -120A.
[0014] Furthermore, in the step S1, the composition of the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY is as follows: the nominal chemical composition of the NiCoCrAlY coating is: chromium (Cr) 18.0-23.0%, cobalt (Co) 10.0-15.0%, aluminum (Al) 8.0-12.0%, yttrium (Y) 0.1-0.5%, and nickel (Ni) content of 49.5%-63.9%.
[0015] Furthermore, in step S2, the femtosecond laser has a pulse width of 300fs-2ps, a wavelength of 1030nm and a repetition frequency of 25kHz-5000kHz.
[0016] Furthermore, in step S2, the focal length of the midfield lens is 100-150 mm.
[0017] Furthermore, in step S2, the laser beam is directly focused on the surface of the NiCoCrAlY coating, with a spot diameter of 30-40 μm and a focal depth of 0.1-0.15 mm.
[0018] Furthermore, in step S2, the laser scanning speed is 800-1000 mm / s; the laser energy density is 2.831-3.137 J / cm 2 .
[0019] Furthermore, the number of scans in step S2 is 40-45 times.
[0020] Furthermore, the microstructures prepared in step S2 are surface microstructures of linear LT, grid GT, and sinusoidal SWT with different spacings.
[0021] Furthermore, the thickness of the ceramic coating and the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY is 100-120 μm.
[0022] A thermal barrier ceramic coating for enhanced turbine blades is prepared by any one of the above preparation methods.
[0023] The beneficial effects of the present invention are:
[0024] The present invention is a method for enhancing the bonding force of a ceramic coating in a thermal barrier coating system of a turbine blade: in order to avoid failure and peeling of the blade thermal barrier coating due to insufficient adhesion and to ensure the service performance of the blade thermal barrier coating, the present invention uses a femtosecond laser to prepare a microstructure in a NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer, and increases the bonding force between the coating and the metal substrate by increasing the mechanical interlocking method between the ceramic layer and the metal bonding layer. The present invention uses processing parameters specially adapted to the optimized NiCoCrAlY material to prepare high-quality microstructures with different texture patterns, the wall surface of the microstructure is smooth, there is no obvious heat-affected zone, no microcracks, holes, molten droplets and other processing defects, and a ceramic layer is sprayed on the bonding layer surface after laser microstructure treatment. This method can not only increase the contact surface area between the layers, but also prevent cracks from expanding along the interface, thereby obtaining a unique obtuse mechanical interlocking effect. This mechanical anchoring can also effectively improve the bonding strength and peeling resistance between the coating and the substrate. The coating fills the microscopic depressions on the substrate surface during the deposition process, thereby increasing the bonding strength between the coating and the substrate.
[0025] The present invention prepares a microstructure on the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY by femtosecond laser, and deposits a ceramic coating by electron beam physical vapor deposition (EB-PVD), which significantly enhances the adhesion of the ceramic coating. The microstructures prepared by femtosecond laser, such as sinusoidal lines, straight stripes and grids, increase the effective contact area of the metal surface and provide more binding sites for the ceramic coating. The columnar crystal structure formed by the EB-PVD process has a highly ordered vertical arrangement and a pointed top morphology, which can be filled and tightly embedded in the microstructure to produce a unique mechanical interlocking effect. This mechanical interlocking effect significantly improves the mechanical stability and anti-stripping properties of the coating through the mutual support and embedding of columnar crystals. The coating adhesion of samples with different designs was tested by scratch test. The results showed that the ceramic coating prepared by this method performed well in the bonding test. The three different microstructure patterns, linear, sinusoidal, and grid, improved the bonding performance by 58.04%, 76.12%, and 91.91%, respectively. The grid-like microstructure design with a groove spacing of 95 μm had the most obvious effect on improving the coating adhesion. nc1 、F nc2 、F nc3 They are 44.03 N, 57.81 N, and 79.23 N. In summary, the present invention can effectively enhance the adhesion and durability of the ceramic coating and improve the application performance of the thermal barrier coating. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0026] In order to more clearly illustrate the embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the drawings required for use in the embodiments or the description of the prior art will be briefly introduced below. The drawings in the following description are merely embodiments of the present invention. For ordinary technicians in this field, other drawings can be obtained based on the provided drawings without paying any creative work.
[0027] Figure 1 This is a schematic diagram of a femtosecond laser processing device according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0028] Figure 2 Schematic diagram of different microstructures on the surface of the NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0029] Figure 3 The SEM top view of different microstructures on the surface of the NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer of the embodiment of the present invention; (a) sinusoidal line spacing 75μm (SWT75); (b) sinusoidal line spacing 95μm (SWT95); (c) sinusoidal line spacing 115μm (SWT115); (d) sinusoidal line spacing 135μm (SWT135); (e) linear spacing 75μm (LT75); (f) linear spacing 95μm (LT95); (g) linear spacing 115μm (LT115); (h) linear spacing 135μm (LT135); (i) grid spacing 75μm (GT75); (j) grid spacing 95μm (GT95); (k) grid spacing 115μm (GT115); (l) grid spacing 135μm (GT135);
[0030] Figure 4 This is a schematic diagram of an EB-PVD processing equipment according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0031] Figure 5 This is a cross-sectional view of a ceramic coating and a metal bonding layer according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0032] Figure 6 This is a cross-sectional element distribution diagram of the ceramic coating and the metal bonding layer in an embodiment of the present invention;
[0033] Figure 7 This is a scratch result diagram of an untreated comparative sample of an embodiment of the present invention;
[0034] Figure 8 This is a scratch result diagram of a microstructure pattern with a linear spacing of 75 μm (LT75) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0035] Fig. 9 This is a scratch result diagram of a microstructure pattern with a linear spacing of 95 μm (LT95) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0036] Fig.10This is a scratch result diagram of a microstructure pattern with a linear spacing of 115 μm (LT115) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0037] Fig.11 This is a scratch result diagram of a microstructure pattern with a linear spacing of 135 μm (LT135) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0038] Fig.12 This is a graph showing the scratch results of a microstructure pattern with a grid spacing of 75 μm (GT75) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0039] Fig.13 This is a graph showing the scratch results of a microstructure pattern with a grid spacing of 95 μm (GT95) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0040] Fig.14 This is a graph showing the scratch results of a microstructure pattern with a grid spacing of 115 μm (GT115) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0041] Fig.15 This is a graph showing the scratch results of a microstructure pattern with a grid spacing of 135 μm (GT135) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0042] Fig.16 This is a graph showing the scratch results of a microstructure pattern with a sinusoidal line spacing of 75 μm (SW75) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0043] Fig.17 This is a graph showing the scratch results of a microstructure pattern with a sinusoidal line spacing of 95 μm (SW95) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0044] Fig.18 This is a graph showing the scratch results of a microstructure pattern with a sinusoidal line spacing of 115 μm (SW115) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0045] Fig.19 This is a graph showing the scratch results of a microstructure pattern with a sinusoidal line spacing of 135 μm (SW135) according to an embodiment of the present invention;
[0046] Fig. 20 Schematic diagram of adhesion results of an embodiment of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0047] In order to make the purpose, technical solution and advantages of the present invention more clearly understood, the present invention is further described in detail below in conjunction with the embodiments. It should be understood that the specific embodiments described herein are only used to explain the present invention and are not used to limit the present invention.
[0048] It should be noted that the following detailed descriptions are exemplary and are intended to provide further explanation of the present invention. Unless otherwise specified, all technical and scientific terms used herein have the same meanings as those commonly understood by those skilled in the art to which the present invention belongs.
[0049] It should be noted that the terms used herein are only for describing specific embodiments and are not intended to limit exemplary embodiments according to the present invention. As used herein, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise, the singular form is also intended to include the plural form. In addition, it should be understood that when the terms "comprising" and / or "including" are used in this specification, it indicates the presence of features, steps, operations and / or combinations thereof.
[0050] Embodiment 1:
[0051] The purpose of an embodiment of the present invention is to provide a method for enhancing the adhesion of ceramic coatings in a thermal barrier coating system for turbine blades. A microstructure is prepared on a metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY by a femtosecond laser, and then an electron beam physical vapor deposition (EB-PVD) method is used to deposit the ceramic coating, thereby significantly enhancing the bonding strength of the ceramic coating. This method can effectively improve the adhesion of the ceramic coating and solve the problem of cracks, failure and peeling of the ceramic layer.
[0052] This embodiment uses a femtosecond laser system and a three-axis displacement platform. The femtosecond laser has a pulse width of 300fs-2ps, a wavelength of 1030nm and a repetition frequency of 25kHz-5000kHz. Figure 1 As shown in the figure, the optical path consists of a beam expander, a reflector, a CCD camera system for real-time monitoring and precise positioning of the workpiece, and a scanning galvanometer system for quickly and accurately directing the laser beam and controlling the scanning path and position of the laser beam on the workpiece. A field lens with a focal length of 100 mm is used to focus the laser beam directly on the surface of the NiCoCrAlY coating, with a spot diameter of 35 μm and a focal depth of 0.1 mm. For the NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer, a laser scanning speed of 800 mm / s and a laser beam density of 2.831 J / cm 2 The laser energy density is 40 times, which can ensure the material removal rate, optimize the degree of oxidation, and ensure the quality of micro grooves and surface accuracy, and perform fine processing on the coating without thermal damage. Figure 2 Schematic diagrams of different surface microstructure patterns are given. Surface microstructures of linear type (LT), grid type (GT), and sinusoidal type (SWT) with different spacings are prepared respectively. The SEM top view of the microstructure is shown in Figure 3 As shown, Figure 3 (a) Sinusoidal line spacing 75 μm (SWT75); Figure 3 (b) Sinusoidal line spacing 95 μm (SWT95); Figure 3 (c) Sinusoidal line spacing 115 μm (SWT115); Figure 3 (d) Sinusoidal line spacing 135 μm (SWT135); Figure 3 (e) linear spacing 75 μm (LT75); Figure 3 (f) linear spacing 95 μm (LT95); Figure 3 (g) linear spacing 115 μm (LT115); Figure 3 (h) linear spacing 135 μm (LT135); Figure 3 (i) Grid spacing 75 μm (GT75); Figure 3 (j) grid spacing 95 μm (GT95); Figure 3 (k) Grid spacing 115 μm (GT115); Figure 3 (l) Grid spacing 135μm (GT135).
[0053] The present invention sprays 8YSZ ceramic powder on the surface after femtosecond laser treatment by using an EB-PVD method, wherein the method utilizes a high-energy electron beam to evaporate a target material, generates steam, and forms a coating on the surface of a substrate through condensation.
[0054] The specific steps include:
[0055] Step S1: Preparation of metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY
[0056] The NiCoCrAlY metal powder was sprayed on the surface of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy DD6 of the turbine blade by the EB-PVD method. The NiCoCrAlY metal powder target was evaporated by a high-energy electron beam with a current of 70-85A and a voltage of 20-25V to generate NiCoCrAlY metal vapor. The NiCoCrAlY metal vapor was then evaporated by an Ar / H 2 The plasma gas is brought out to deposit on the surface of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy DD6 of the turbine blade to form a uniform and dense NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer; after the deposition, a high-quality coating is formed on the surface of the substrate by condensation, ensuring good bonding performance and coating integrity; the deposition process conditions are: spraying current is 50-75A; spraying voltage is 15-25V; plasma gas is 75% Ar and 25% H by volume 2 mixture, the plasma gas flow rate was 70 slpm; the deposition time was 60 minutes, and the bias voltage was -140A.
[0057] Step S2: Preparation of microstructure on the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY
[0058] Using a femtosecond laser system and a three-axis displacement platform, the optical routing of the femtosecond laser system is composed of a beam expander, a reflector, a CCD camera system for real-time monitoring and precise positioning of the workpiece, and a scanning galvanometer system for quickly and accurately directing the laser beam and controlling the scanning path and position of the laser beam on the workpiece;
[0059] Use a field lens to focus the laser beam directly on the surface of the NiCoCrAlY coating obtained in step S1, and control the three-axis displacement platform to perform multiple scans to complete the microstructure preparation according to the microstructure to be prepared, so as to ensure the material removal rate, optimize the oxidation degree, and ensure the quality of the micro grooves and the surface accuracy, so as to perform fine processing on the coating without thermal damage;
[0060] Step S3: Depositing a ceramic coating on the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY of the prepared microstructure
[0061] On the surface treated by femtosecond laser in step S2, 8YSZ ceramic powder is sprayed by EB-PVD method; 8YSZ ceramic powder target is evaporated by high-energy electron beam with current of 50-75A and voltage of 15-25V to generate 8YSZ ceramic powder vapor, and Ar with volume ratio of 75% and H with volume ratio of 25% is used to generate 8YSZ ceramic powder vapor. 2 The plasma gas with a flow rate of 75slpm was used to carry out the deposition, and a ceramic coating was formed on the surface of the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY prepared with a microstructure by condensation; the deposition process conditions were: spraying current of 50-75A; spraying voltage of 15-25V; plasma gas of 75% Ar and 25% H by volume 2 mixture, the plasma gas flow rate was 75 slpm; the deposition time was 90 minutes, and the bias voltage was -120A.
[0062] First, the NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer is sprayed on the sample surface using EB-PVD technology, and then the 8YSZ ceramic coating is sprayed on it, as shown in the schematic diagram. Figure 4 As shown. By precisely controlling the deposition parameters, including plasma gas flow rate, current and voltage, the uniformity and density of the metal bonding layer and ceramic coating are ensured. This method can not only achieve high-quality coating deposition, but also ensure the excellent bonding between the coating and the substrate, thus laying a solid foundation for subsequent performance testing and microstructure analysis. The process parameters are shown in Table 1. Due to its unique evaporation and deposition mechanism, the coating prepared by EB-PVD has a unique microstructure, especially a columnar crystal structure, which shows significant advantages in improving coating performance. The coating thickness of the ceramic layer and the metal bonding layer is 100μm, and the deposition rate and substrate temperature are controlled to ensure that the coating evenly covers the microstructure. By Figure 5It can be seen that the columnar crystal structure inside the ceramic layer can be clearly observed. The ceramic coating is well deposited inside the microstructure. The columnar crystal is dense inside and has excellent corrosion resistance and oxidation resistance. These columnar crystal particles grow vertically to form a dense and regular arrangement. The high orientation and multi-level structure of the columnar crystal structure significantly improve the thermal barrier effect and effectively block the transfer of heat to the substrate. During the growth process of the columnar crystal structure, the top gradually becomes sharp, forming a pointed structure similar to a roof. These pointed structures not only increase the surface area of the coating, but also produce a unique mechanical interlocking effect in the microstructure. The pointed part of the columnar crystal structure supports each other on both sides, forming a structure similar to mutual support. This interlocking support method significantly enhances the mechanical stability of the ceramic coating and effectively prevents the peeling and cracking of the coating. In the microstructure area, the columnar crystal structure fills the pits or grooves, increasing the interface contact area. At the same time, the formation of the pointed structure causes the coating to produce a blunt-angle mechanical interlocking effect at the interface, further improving the bonding strength between the ceramic coating and the metal bonding layer. And it can be clearly seen Figure 5 The columnar crystals in the grooves completely fill the interior without any gaps. Through the analysis of the cross-sectional energy dispersive spectroscopy (EDS) spectrum, Figure 6 It can be clearly observed that the Ni element is distributed along the groove contour prepared by the femtosecond laser, forming a clear groove morphology. The Zr element uniformly and completely fills the groove area without any missing or gaps. This shows that during the EB-PVD process, the Zr-based ceramic coating has a significant deposition effect on the microstructure surface with good coverage and uniformity, which ensures the density of the coating and reduces potential defects.
[0063] Table 1 NiCoCrAlY coating spraying conditions
[0064]
[0065] The main bonding type between ceramic coating and metal bonding layer is embedded bonding, which is mainly formed in the groove area. The coating material is embedded in the depression or irregular area on the surface of the substrate, thus forming a strong mechanical bond. Since the materials are embedded in each other, the bonding strength is high, and crack extension needs to overcome more energy barriers. This bonding method helps to improve the adhesion strength and crack extension resistance of the coating. During the coating deposition process, the coating material is deposited on the convex area on the surface of the substrate, and an embedded bonding is formed through mechanical bite. Most of the existing laser surface treatment methods produce ridges and form a retention type of bonding. This is due to the remelting layer produced by laser ablation. The ridge structure formed by the remelting layer is often difficult to control evenly, resulting in irregular surface morphology. The uneven surface morphology will cause stress concentration and increase the risk of coating failure. In addition, laser treatment will cause rapid heating and cooling of the material, resulting in changes in microstructure such as grain refinement or recrystallization. Rapid cooling may form metastable phases or amorphous structures. These structures may be unstable during subsequent use. These defects will reduce the mechanical properties of the material and increase the risk of crack extension, thereby affecting the durability of the coating. The process parameters of the present invention avoid the generation of a heat-affected zone and a remelting layer, and avoid the generation of a retaining type of bonding.
[0066] The bonding strength of different samples was evaluated by scratch test, and the effect of grooves with different morphologies on coating performance was further explored. Since the thermal barrier coating system of turbine blades includes a metal substrate layer, a metal bonding layer and a top ceramic coating, there are two layers of coating, so the bonding strength between the coating and the metal substrate is measured by three critical strengths F nc1 、F nc2 and F nc3 To evaluate, the first critical load F nc1 Represents the initial damage of the ceramic coating in the thermal barrier coating system. This load point is the load value at which the surface coating begins to fail significantly under the action of gradually increasing mechanical loads. The second critical load F nc2 Corresponds to the complete peeling of the ceramic coating in the thermal barrier coating system and the initial destruction of the metal bonding layer. This load point indicates that the surface coating is completely detached or failed along the entire scratch path, exposing the second layer of coating. The third critical load F nc3 Corresponding to the destruction of the metal bond coating in the thermal barrier coating system. This load point marks the beginning of obvious failure of the metal bond coating under the action of gradually increasing mechanical load.
[0067] The scratch test results are shown in the figure below. Figure 7-Figure 19 As shown in Figure 2, the acoustic signal, friction coefficient and scratch force curves of different samples in the scratch test are shown in Figure 2. Figure 7-Figure 19 As shown, for samples with different patterns, the scratch results show a common signal fluctuation trend. Figure 7This is the scratch result of the untreated control sample. When the scratch force increases to 23.91N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 23.91N (F nc1 ) increased to 31.53N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 31.53N (F nc2 ) increased to 43.61N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0068] Figure 8 For a linear sample with a spacing of 75 μm (LT75), when the scratch force increases to 19.12 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 19.12N (F nc1 ) increased to 34.56N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 34.56N (F nc2 ) increased to 52.56N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0069] Fig. 9 For a linear sample with a spacing of 95 μm (LT95), when the scratch force increases to 35.34 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 35.34N (F nc1 ) increased to 49.76N(F nc2), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 49.76N (F nc2 ) increased to 58.87N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0070] Fig.10 For a linear sample (LT115) with a spacing of 115 μm, when the scratch force increases to 29.34 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 29.34N (F nc1 ) increased to 39.87N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 39.87N (F nc2 ) increased to 55.87N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0071] Fig.11 For a linear sample (LT135) with a spacing of 135 μm, when the scratch force increases to 27.26 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 27.26N (F nc1 ) increased to 36.76N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 36.76N (F nc2 ) increased to 50.32N(F nc3), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0072] Fig.12 For a grid sample (GT75) with a spacing of 75 μm, when the scratch force increases to 30.36 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 30.36N (F nc1 ) increased to 52.12N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 52.12N (F nc2 ) increased to 68.65N(F nc3 ), the last time there was an obvious fluctuation in the acoustic signal and the friction coefficient, and the friction coefficient curve and the friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off at the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in the friction coefficient and friction force.
[0073] Fig.13 For a grid sample (GT95) with a spacing of 95 μm, when the scratch force increases to 44.74 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 44.74N (F nc1 ) increased to 60.51N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 60.51N (F nc2 ) increased to 80.65N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0074] Fig.14 For a grid sample (GT115) with a spacing of 115 μm, when the scratch force increases to 38.26 N (F nc1), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 38.26N (F nc1 ) increased to 57.45N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 57.45N (F nc2 ) increased to 66.91N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0075] Fig.15 For a grid sample (GT135) with a spacing of 135 μm, when the scratch force increases to 37.14 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 37.14N (F nc1 ) increased to 49.52N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again, and the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 49.52N (F nc2 ) increased to 58.26N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0076] Fig.16 For a sinusoidal sample with a spacing of 75 μm (SWT75), when the scratch force increases to 23.31 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 23.31N (F nc1 ) increased to 39.51N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 39.51N (F nc2 ) increased to 59.21N(Fnc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0077] Fig.17 For the sinusoidal line sample with a spacing of 95 μm (SWT95), the scratch force increased to 36.76 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 36.76N (F nc1 ) increased to 54.76N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again, and the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 54.76N (F nc2 ) increased to 66.21N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0078] Fig.18 For a sinusoidal sample (SWT115) with a spacing of 115 μm, when the scratch force increases to 28.21 N (F nc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 28.21N (F nc1 ) increased to 57.10N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 57.10N (F nc2 ) increased to 62.95N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0079] Fig.19 For a sinusoidal sample (SWT135) with a spacing of 135 μm, when the scratch force increases to 32.16 N (Fnc1 ), an obvious acoustic signal appeared and the friction coefficient fluctuated greatly, indicating that the ceramic coating began to crack and peel off. Then, when the load was increased from 32.16N (F nc1 ) increased to 41.17N(F nc2 ), the acoustic signal fluctuated significantly again. At this time, the friction coefficient and friction force fluctuated significantly, indicating that the ceramic coating was completely peeled off and failed, exposing the metal bonding layer. As the load continued to increase from 41.17N (F nc2 ) increased to 54.42N(F nc3 ), there was an obvious acoustic signal fluctuation and friction coefficient fluctuation for the last time, and the friction coefficient curve and friction force curve rose linearly afterwards, indicating that the two layers of coating were completely peeled off under the third critical load, and the scratch tester probe contacted the metal substrate layer, and there was no more fluctuation in friction coefficient and friction force.
[0080] The best adhesion performance among the sinusoidal texture patterns is the one with a spacing of 95 μm. nc1 、F nc2 and F nc3 They are 36.76N, 54.76N and 66.21N respectively. Compared with the linear sample with a spacing of 115μm with the best adhesion performance, F nc1 、F nc2 and F nc3 The adhesion performance of the sinusoidal texture pattern is stronger than that of the straight texture. The best adhesion performance of the grid texture pattern is the grid sample with a spacing of 95μm. nc1 、F nc2 and F nc3 are 44.74N, 60.51N and 80.65N respectively. Compared with the linear sample with a spacing of 115μm, F nc1 、F nc2 and F nc3 The results of all samples were compared. Fig. 20 As shown in Figure 2, most of the surfaces treated with surface texturing have significantly improved adhesion compared to the untreated surface F nc1 、F nc2 and F nc3 They are 23.91N, 31.53N and 43.61N respectively. The F of GT95 sample nc1 、F nc2 and F nc3The increase was 87.11%, 91.91% and 84.94% respectively. Due to its multi-directional mechanical bite and multi-directional mechanical locking, the grid texture provides higher adhesion and better stress dispersion than the straight texture and sinusoidal line. Compared with the straight and sinusoidal line microstructures, the ceramic layer with grid microstructure has the best adhesion performance, which increased by 58.04%, 76.12% and 95.15% respectively.
[0081] In summary, the present invention discloses a method for enhancing the bonding force of a ceramic coating in a thermal barrier coating system of a turbine blade: in order to avoid failure and peeling of the blade thermal barrier coating due to insufficient adhesion and to ensure the service performance of the blade thermal barrier coating, the present invention uses a femtosecond laser to prepare a microstructure in a NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer, and increases the bonding force between the coating and the metal substrate by increasing the mechanical interlocking method between the ceramic layer and the metal bonding layer. The present invention uses processing parameters specially adapted to the optimized NiCoCrAlY material to prepare high-quality microstructures with different texture patterns, the wall surface of the microstructure is smooth, there is no obvious heat-affected zone, no microcracks, holes, molten droplets and other processing defects, and a ceramic layer is sprayed on the bonding layer surface after laser microstructure treatment. This method can not only increase the contact surface area between the layers, but also prevent cracks from expanding along the interface, and obtain a unique obtuse mechanical interlocking effect. This mechanical anchoring can also effectively improve the bonding strength and anti-stripping between the coating and the substrate. The coating fills the microscopic depressions on the substrate surface during the deposition process, thereby increasing the bonding strength between the coating and the substrate.
[0082] At this point, those skilled in the art recognize that, although the embodiments of the present invention have been shown and described in detail herein, many other variations or modifications that conform to the principles of the present invention can still be directly determined or derived based on the contents disclosed in the present invention without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention. Therefore, the scope of the present invention should be understood and recognized as covering all such other variations or modifications.
Claims
1. A method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings on turbine blades, characterized in that: The method comprises the following steps: Step S1: Preparation of metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY The NiCoCrAlY metal powder is sprayed on the surface of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy DD6 of the turbine blade by the EB-PVD method. The NiCoCrAlY metal powder target is evaporated by a high-energy electron beam with a current of 70-85A and a voltage of 20-25V to generate NiCoCrAlY metal vapor, which is carried out for deposition by Ar / H2 plasma gas with a flow rate of 70%, and deposited on the surface of the nickel-based high-temperature alloy DD6 of the turbine blade to form a uniform and dense NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer; after the deposition, a high-quality coating is formed on the surface of the substrate by condensation, ensuring good bonding performance and coating integrity; the deposition process conditions are: the spraying current is 50-75A; the spraying voltage is 15-25V; the plasma gas is a mixture of Ar with a volume ratio of 75% and H2 with a volume ratio of 25%, and the plasma gas flow rate is 70slpm; the deposition time is 60 minutes, and the bias voltage is -140A. Step S2: Preparation of microstructure on the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY Using a femtosecond laser system and a three-axis displacement platform, the optical routing of the femtosecond laser system is composed of a beam expander, a reflector, a CCD camera system for real-time monitoring and precise positioning of the workpiece, and a scanning galvanometer system for quickly and accurately directing the laser beam and controlling the scanning path and position of the laser beam on the workpiece; Use a field lens to focus the laser beam directly on the surface of the NiCoCrAlY coating obtained in step S1, and control the three-axis displacement platform to perform multiple scans to complete the microstructure preparation according to the microstructure to be prepared, so as to ensure the material removal rate, optimize the oxidation degree, and ensure the quality of the micro grooves and the surface accuracy, so as to perform fine processing on the coating without thermal damage; Step S3: Depositing a ceramic coating on the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY of the prepared microstructure On the surface treated by femtosecond laser in step S2, 8YSZ ceramic powder is sprayed by EB-PVD method; the 8YSZ ceramic powder target is evaporated by high-energy electron beam with current of 50-75A and voltage of 15-25V to generate 8YSZ ceramic powder vapor, which is carried out for deposition by plasma gas with volume ratio of 75% Ar and volume ratio of 25% H2 and flow rate of 75slpm, and a ceramic coating is formed on the surface of NiCoCrAlY metal bonding layer with microstructure prepared by condensation; the deposition process conditions are: spraying current of 50-75A; spraying voltage of 15-25V; plasma gas is a mixture of volume ratio of 75% Ar and volume ratio of 25% H2, and the plasma gas flow rate is 75slpm; deposition time is 90 minutes, and bias voltage is -120A.
2. A method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings for turbine blades as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the femtosecond laser has a pulse width of 300fs-2ps and a wavelength of 1030nm.
3. A method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings for turbine blades as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the femtosecond laser has a repetition frequency of 25kHz-5000kHz.
4. A method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings for turbine blades as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the focal length of the midfield lens is 100-150 mm.
5. A method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings for turbine blades as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the laser beam is directly focused on the surface of the NiCoCrAlY coating, with a spot diameter of 30-40 μm and a focal depth of 0.1-0.15 mm.
6. A method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings for turbine blades as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: In step S2, the laser scanning speed is 800-1000 mm / s; the laser energy density is 2.831-3.137 J / cm 2 .
7. A method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings for turbine blades as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The number of scans in step S2 is 40-45 times.
8. A method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings for turbine blades as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The microstructures prepared in step S2 are surface microstructures of linear LT, grid GT, and sinusoidal SWT with different spacings.
9. A method for enhancing the bonding strength of thermal barrier ceramic coatings for turbine blades as claimed in claim 1, characterized in that: The thickness of the ceramic coating and the metal bonding layer NiCoCrAlY is 100-120 μm.
10. A thermal barrier ceramic coating for enhanced turbine blades, characterized in that: The ceramic coating is prepared by any one of the preparation methods in claims 1-9.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Laser powder deposition method for regulating and controlling interface morphology of thermal barrier coating
CN104451672A
Coating preparation method for improving binding force of thermal barrier coating and substrate
CN104928607A
Method for preparing thermal barrier coating on heavy gas turbine blade
CN105369202A
Treatment method for controlling microstructure on surface of thermal barrier coating bonding layer through laser shock
CN111334744A
Method for preparing surface of CMAS erosion resistant thermal barrier coating through ultrafast laser reconstruction
CN113549879A
Cited By
Titanium-aluminum alloy blade high-temperature coating homogenizing deposition method based on profiling fastening clamp
CN120738610A
Method for improving bonding strength of thermal barrier coating
CN121674882A
NiCoCrAlY high-temperature coating reinforced by femtosecond laser surface microstructure and preparation method and application of NiCoCrAlY high-temperature coating
CN122235634A
Thermal barrier coating based on ultrafast laser-induced interface nucleation and pinning effect and preparation method thereof
CN122446121A
