Method for evaluating the quality of fulvic acid solution and method for producing fulvic acid solution

By extracting the fulriacic acid solution from the mushroom bed, using pH and color evaluation combined with the Mensel color system, the problems of high cost and complex operations in the existing technology are solved, and the effect of obtaining high-purity fulriacic acid solution is achieved inexpensive and simple manner. , suitable for a variety of agricultural and feeding applications.

CN109813688BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-22JAPAN SOPHIKEN CO LTD
View PDF 6 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN201811253300.5
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Priority Date
2017-11-22
Filing Date
2018-10-25
Publication Date
2024-11-22
Estimated Expiration
2038-10-25

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing fullilic acid manufacturing methods have problems with high cost, complex operation and expertise requirements, and it is difficult to obtain large amounts of fullilic acid solutions inexpensively.

Method used

The fulligic acid solution was extracted from the mushroom bed, and the pH and color confirmation steps were used for evaluation. The advantages and disadvantages of the solution were judged in combination with the Mengsel color system, and the dissolution of fulligic acid was promoted by using wood vinegar liquid or bamboo vinegar liquid.

Benefits of technology

It has achieved cheap and easy access to a large amount of fulvic acid solution, reduced raw material costs, improved the purity and yield of fulvic acid, and is suitable for crops and seafood feeding and other applications.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN109813688B_ABST
    Figure CN109813688B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention relates to a method for evaluating the quality of a fulvic acid solution and a method for producing a fulvic acid solution. An evaluation method for obtaining a large amount of fulvic acid inexpensively and simply and a method for producing a fulvic acid solution are provided. A method for evaluating the quality of a fulvic acid solution and a method for producing a fulvic acid solution based on the evaluation method are provided. The evaluation method uses a cultured mushroom bed whose main component is sawdust, and the quality of the mushroom bed is judged based on the appearance and brittleness of the bed, and the quality of a solution derived from the mushroom bed is judged based on pH and color.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to a method for evaluating the quality of a fulvic acid solution and a method for producing a fulvic acid solution. Background Art

[0002] Fulvic acid is a general term for humus from dead and decayed plants. The International Humic Substances Society (IHSS) defines fulvic acid.

[0003] Fulvic acid is used for increasing the yield of rice cultivation (Patent Document 1), for seafood breeding, as a nutritional enhancer or cosmetic ingredient to improve health and beauty, etc.

[0004] However, the main component of humus is humic acid, and the research on fulvic acid, which is a trace component, has not been developed yet. In particular, the production of fulvic acid according to the method shown in IHSS has the problem of being time-consuming and expensive.

[0005] In this regard, the literature discloses: a production method in which immature bark compost, sawdust, straw, rice husk, dehydrated filter cake and other organic materials that have not been humified are immersed in an acidic solution (Patent Document 2); a production method in which humus is degraded by low-level carbon oxidation in high-temperature and high-pressure air and extracted using high-temperature hot water (Patent Document 3); and a production method in which humus collected from underground is matured and collected with water (Patent Document 4).

[0006] However, the invention of Patent Document 2 requires strong acid solutions such as sulfuric acid solution, hydrochloric acid, and acetic acid, which has cost problems and requires careful attention during handling. The invention of Patent Document 3 is the same. The invention of Patent Document 4 uses humus and water, but requires heating and drying in a plastic greenhouse and a aging process of the fulvic acid aqueous solution that takes years.

[0007] As a cheap raw material for producing fulvic acid, the possibility of using spent mushroom beds (mushroom beds after mushroom cultivation) has been disclosed (Non-Patent Document 1). However, the method shown in IHSS or a method based on this method has the same problems as described above.

[0008] Prior art literature

[0009] Patent Literature

[0010] Patent Document 1: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2006-151706

[0011] Patent Document 2: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2010-148398

[0012] Patent Document 3: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2004-269484

[0013] Patent Document 4: Japanese Patent Application Publication No. 2014-162723

[0014] Non-patent literature

[0015] Non-patent document 1: "Research and Demonstration Results Report on the Development of Biomass Fuel Technology for Abandoned Mushroom Beds and the Local Production and Local Consumption Model for the Development of Induced Technology for the Enhancement of CO2 Emission Reduction Measures in 2011" (Research and Demonstration Results Report on the Development of Biomass Fuel Technology for Abandoned Mushroom Beds in 2011) (March 2011) (Uenomura Mushroom Center Co., Ltd., Meisei University, Nippon Institute of Technology) Summary of the invention

[0016] Problem that the invention aims to solve

[0017] The problem to be solved by the present invention is to provide an evaluation method that can easily obtain a large amount of fulvic acid without expensive raw materials, drugs, complicated operations and even without specialized knowledge, and a method for producing a fulvic acid solution based on the above evaluation method.

[0018] Solutions for solving problems

[0019] The first invention completed in order to solve the above-mentioned problems is a method for evaluating the quality of a fulvic acid solution, characterized in that when the fulvic acid solution is extracted from a cultured mushroom bed, the main component of the mushroom bed is sawdust, and the evaluation method comprises the following steps: a pH confirmation step: after the mushroom bed is sealed in a container, the pH of the solution dissolved to the bottom of the container is confirmed; a color confirmation step: confirming the color of the solution; and a judgment step: based on the pH confirmed in the pH confirmation step and the color confirmed in the color confirmation step, the solution is judged to be good if the pH is 4.0 or less and the color is 2.5YR to 10YR in the Munsell color circle (40 hues) of the Munsell color system when dissolved with water, and the hue is 10YR to 10Y when dissolved with wood vinegar or bamboo vinegar, or a mixture of wood vinegar and bamboo vinegar. In addition, the second invention is a method for producing a fulvic acid solution, characterized in that, in the method for producing a fulvic acid solution from a cultured mushroom bed, the main component of the aforementioned mushroom bed is wood chips, and the production method comprises the following steps: Step 1: A mushroom bed that can be visually confirmed to be covered with hyphae in the height, width, and length directions of the aforementioned mushroom bed as a whole and sensory evaluation shows that it is brittle is good, and other than that, it is poor; Step 2: The aforementioned mushroom bed is sealed in a container, and the solution is dissolved to the bottom of the aforementioned container; Step 3: For the mushroom bed evaluated as good in the aforementioned step 1, the aforementioned The pH of the dissolution solution of step 2 is confirmed; and, step 4: for the color of the solution with a pH of less than 4.0 confirmed in the aforementioned step 3 and the color of the solution of the aforementioned step 2 of the mushroom bed evaluated as inferior in the aforementioned step 1, the hue of either one is set to 0 in the Munsell hue circle (40 hues) of the Munsell color system, and when expressed by rotating +20 clockwise and -20 counterclockwise relative to the aforementioned hue, the solution with a hue of +4 to +6 or -4 to -6 is judged to be excellent, and the solution judged to be excellent in the aforementioned step 4 is used as the fulvic acid solution.In addition, the third invention is a method for producing a fulvic acid solution, characterized in that, in the method for producing a fulvic acid solution from a cultured mushroom bed, the main component of the culture bed is wood chips, and the method comprises the following steps: Step 1: evaluating a mushroom bed that can be visually confirmed to be covered with hyphae in the height, width, and length directions of the culture bed as a whole and having a high brittleness as a sensory evaluation as being excellent, and evaluating the other mushroom beds as being inferior; Step 2: sealing the mushroom bed together with wood vinegar or bamboo vinegar, or a mixture of wood vinegar and bamboo vinegar in a container, and allowing the solution to dissolve to the bottom of the container; Step 3: for the mushroom bed evaluated as excellent in the first step, treating the mushroom bed evaluated as excellent in the second step The pH of the dissolution liquid of the step is confirmed; and the fourth step: for the color of the solution whose pH is lower than the pH of the wood vinegar or the bamboo vinegar, or the mixture of the wood vinegar and the bamboo vinegar, and the color of the wood vinegar or the bamboo vinegar, or the mixture of the wood vinegar and the bamboo vinegar, the hue of either of them is set to 0 in the Munsell hue circle (40 hues) of the Munsell color system, and when the hue is rotated clockwise by +20 and counterclockwise by -20 relative to the hue, the solution whose hue is in the range of +4 to +6 or -4 to -6 is judged as excellent, and the solution judged as excellent in the fourth step is used as the fulvic acid solution. In the present invention, color refers to the constituent elements of color, for example, three attributes called hue, chroma, and brightness can be listed. In the present invention, color can be a factor useful for the above-mentioned superiority and inferiority judgment among the constituent elements of color, or it can be a comprehensive factor.

[0020] Effects of the Invention

[0021] The present invention evaluates the quality of the cultured mushroom bed solution, which is a raw material of fulvic acid, based on pH and color, and thus can be expected to obtain a large amount of fulvic acid inexpensively and simply. In particular, the fact that the acidification of the spent mushroom bed is the main inhibitor of composting has not been paid attention to in the past, but the usefulness of the spent mushroom bed with increased acidification has been discovered through the above evaluation, and thus it can be expected to supply fulvic acid inexpensively for the purpose of cultivating crops, raising seafood, etc. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0022] Figure 1 This is a 3D fluorescence spectrum of a solution derived from a waste mushroom bed (the horizontal axis is the fluorescence wavelength (nm), the vertical axis is the excitation wavelength (nm), and the same applies to the following).

[0023] Figure 2 This is the 3D fluorescence spectrum of fulvic acid standard solution.

[0024] Figure 3 This is a 3D fluorescence spectrum of a solution derived from a mushroom bed during cultivation.

[0025] Figure 4 It is the 3D fluorescence spectrum of the liquid obtained after treating the spent mushroom bed with an autoclave. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0026] [Example 1]

[0027] Hereinafter, embodiments of the present invention will be described.

[0028] (1) Bacteria bed

[0029] As sawdust, a shiitake mushroom bed composed of broadleaf tree sawdust as the main component and bran, corn husks and roots, fossil shells, etc. as other auxiliary components is used. The sawdust of the mushroom bed is not limited to the composition, for example, it can be composed of sawdust alone. In addition, there is no limitation on the number of times the shiitake mushrooms are cultivated on the same mushroom bed, but the tendency that the concentration of fulvic acid in the solution increases with the number of cultivations is expected. It should be noted that the waste mushroom bed, the fungus, and the analysis method of fulvic acid described below in the present invention are the same as those in Non-Patent Document 1.

[0030] (2) Verification of the effect of waste mushroom bed

[0031] The components contained in the solution derived from the waste mushroom bed (Kitakan-type mushroom bed in Non-Patent Document 1) and the mushroom bed under cultivation were filtered using a filter (ADVANTEC 0.45 microfilter) and then subjected to 3D fluorescence spectrum analysis (the analysis results are shown in Table 1: Main eluted components) (device: F-4500 spectrofluorophotometer manufactured by Hitachi). The solution is a substance that naturally seeps out from the mushroom bed over time.

[0032] [Table 1]

[0033] Waste mushroom bed Cultivated mushroom bed Dissolved ingredients Fulvic acid Humic acid

[0034] The results of the analysis showed that the peaks observed in the waste bacterial bed solution were near the excitation wavelength of 340 nm and the fluorescence wavelength of 400 nm ( Figure 1 : The horizontal axis is the fluorescence wavelength, the vertical axis is the excitation wavelength, and the same applies to the following). This result suggests that the peak of fulvic acid ( Figure 2 ), indicating the presence of fulvic acid in the solution. The solution from the cultivated mushroom bed had peaks at a fluorescence wavelength of 530nm and an excitation wavelength of 430nm. The fluorescence position was significantly offset from that of the waste mushroom bed solution, suggesting that humic acid, the main component of humic components, may be present in a larger amount than fulvic acid ( Figure 3). The above results suggest that, regarding the extraction of fulvic acid from a mushroom bed by water, more fulvic acid and less impurities can be obtained from a waste mushroom bed compared to a growing mushroom bed (a higher quality raw material for producing fulvic acid). In addition, although a shiitake mushroom bed was used in this example, the same effect is also suggested for other mushroom beds.

[0035] (3) Judging the quality of waste mushroom beds

[0036] Fulvic acid analysis in water content of the mushroom bed was repeated using various mushroom beds. The results showed that a high-quality mushroom bed with a higher purity and a larger amount of fulvic acid can be visually determined by the appearance, that is, the distribution of hyphae on the surface of the mushroom bed. Specifically, the dissolution of fulvic acid can be confirmed when white to milky white hyphae are distributed on the surface of the mushroom bed as a whole.

[0037] Here, the term "distributed as a whole" does not mean that the hyphae must cover the entire surface of the mushroom bed, but it is sufficient as long as it can be confirmed with the naked eye that the hyphae are generally covered in the height, width, and length directions of the mushroom bed. In addition, the color of the hyphae varies depending on the type of mushroom, so the white to milky white situation is just an example. In addition, for the waste mushroom beds provided for this analysis, it is known that the color of the high-quality mushroom beds themselves looks darker than the color of the low-quality mushroom beds, and it can also be judged by color. It can be seen that the appearance information of the waste mushroom beds is useful as a factor for judging quality.

[0038] In addition, it is known that: not only the appearance of the hyphae is confirmed, but also the brittleness of the mushroom bed is confirmed to determine whether it is a high-quality mushroom bed for obtaining fulvic acid. In the present invention, brittleness refers to the degree to which the mushroom bed is easily destroyed. For the mushroom bed before planting or during mycelium cultivation, the degree of brittleness is as follows: by holding the upper part of the mushroom bed with one hand and lifting it upward with a force to a certain extent, the held part is easily peeled off. On the other hand, the mushroom bed from which a large amount of fulvic acid can be obtained is hardened as if the entire surface is coated, and the mushroom bed will not be easily peeled off even if the mushroom bed is held with the same force as applied to the aforementioned mushroom bed or a stronger force. It is difficult to strictly define the brittleness of the mushroom bed. However, in the present invention, through repeated analysis, when simply evaluating without strict inspection, the surface of the mushroom bed can be directly touched and evaluated by the following sensory evaluation: "hard (the surface of the mushroom bed is in a hardened state, and even if the side of the mushroom bed placed on the table is pressed with a finger with a force that causes the mushroom bed to move horizontally, the finger will not sink into the mushroom bed)", "slightly soft (the surface of the mushroom bed is slightly soft, and when pressed with a finger in the same way as above, the finger easily sinks into the inside of the mushroom bed)", "neither (neither soft nor hard)". This suggests that: in the case of a mushroom bed with low brittleness (brittle), the obtained fulvic acid solution is mixed with impurities such as humic acid and sawdust dissolved from the mushroom bed constituents; in the case of a mushroom bed with high brittleness (not easy to break), the obtained fulvic acid solution has different color regions in the height direction. Here, having different color regions means, for example, as long as the solution has different hues (there are many cases where sediments remain at the bottom of the solution, and the entire solution is not necessarily the same hue). That is, it is suggested that a mushroom bed with high brittleness can obtain a fulvic acid solution with fewer impurities.

[0039] Based on these insights, the quality of the mushroom bed used to obtain fulvic acid can be considered as shown in the following table (Table 2). For the mushroom bed judged to be good, there is a tendency that humic acid is not easily dissolved and fulvic acid is easily dissolved. Here, the quality of the mushroom bed in the present invention should not be strictly interpreted as the statement in the following table, and can also be replaced by other substantially equivalent indicators.

[0040] [Table 2]

[0041]

[0042] ○: Excellent

[0043] (4) Judging the quality of fulvic acid solution

[0044] As a method for collecting fulvic acid solution, there are the following methods: a method of sealing the mushroom bed in a container and collecting the material that flows out of the mushroom bed to the bottom of the container over time; a method of sealing the mushroom bed in a container while immersing it in water, waiting for the fulvic acid to flow out and then collecting it. There is no limitation on the container here, and metal containers, glass containers, and resin containers can be used. There is no limitation on the capacity. As for whether the container is sealed, it is desired to be sealed in order to prevent the solution from vaporizing, but it does not mean that it is a strictly sealed state. There is no problem with the solution collection environment at room temperature and pressure, but it is desired to be below 15°C to avoid the reproduction of microorganisms. Here, 300 g of purified water is added to about 20 g of finely crushed waste mushroom bed, and the treatment is carried out at 121°C and 2 atmospheres for 20 minutes using an autoclave. As a result, a liquid with a different hue from the aforementioned fulvic acid solution (black) is obtained. Based on the results of 3D spectrum analysis ( Figure 4 ) confirmed that a large amount of impurities were dissolved together with fulvic acid, suggesting that forced extraction of fulvic acid under high temperature environment is not suitable for obtaining high-purity fulvic acid.

[0045] 3D fluorescence spectroscopy was performed on the solution derived from the mushroom bed and the immersion water when the mushroom bed was immersed in water to confirm whether there is a relationship between pH and fulvic acid. The results confirmed that: when the pH is below 4.0 (the lower the pH), the amount of fulvic acid increases; when the pH is above 5.0, the amount of fulvic acid is small and the amount of humic acid increases. The solution obtained from the mushroom bed judged to be excellent in (3) above has a tendency to decrease in pH to below 4.0 over time.

[0046] Similarly, it was confirmed whether there is a relationship between the solution derived from the mushroom bed and the color of the immersion water when the mushroom bed is immersed in water and fulvic acid. In the Munsell color system (40 hues), when the hue of the solution derived from the mushroom bed judged as excellent in the above-mentioned step 3 and the solution derived from the mushroom bed judged as inferior is set to 0 and expressed by +20 clockwise rotation and -20 counterclockwise rotation, when the hue of the other is within the hue range of +4 to +6 or -4 to -6 based on the hue 0, it can be confirmed that the amount of fulvic acid in the solution derived from the mushroom bed judged as excellent is increased, and when it is not within the above range, the amount of humic acid is increased. It should be noted that there is a tendency that the hue of the solution derived from the mushroom bed judged to be good is 2.5YR to 10YR, the lightness is 5, and the chroma is around 5; the hue of the solution derived from the mushroom bed judged to be bad is 10RP to 10R, the lightness is 2, and the chroma is around 2.

[0047] The quality of the fulvic acid solution can be judged as shown in the following table (Table 3). The solution judged to be good has a tendency to dissolve humic acid less easily and dissolve fulvic acid more easily. Here, the quality of the fungal bed in the present invention should not be strictly interpreted only by the hue range of the Munsell hue circle (40 hues) in the following table, but can also be replaced by other substantially equivalent indicators.

[0048] [Table 3]

[0049]

[0050] ○: Excellent

[0051] The moisture content of the mushroom bed used in the above analysis is approximately 50-60% (by weight). A sufficient amount of solution can be recovered as long as the moisture content is at least 50%. The main waste mushroom bed used in this analysis should be covered with a cover after cultivation to avoid wind, rain, and direct sunlight for storage. These waste mushroom beds do not require a maturation period, and it is expected that the waste mushroom beds after cultivation will be used for solution recovery as soon as possible. Although it is not necessary to crush them, they can be crushed in a way that adapts to the size of the solution recovery container or when immersed in water. In the present invention, the aforementioned moisture content does not only refer to the situation where the mushroom bed used for quality evaluation contains moisture, but also refers to the situation where water is added to the mushroom bed in a dry state. When water is added and the mushroom bed is immersed in a container, there is no upper limit on the amount of water added.

[0052] In addition, instead of water, wood vinegar or bamboo vinegar or a mixture of wood vinegar and bamboo vinegar can also be given. As wood vinegar, it is not limited, for example, the material extracted from Japanese blue oak (Quercus glauca Thunb) can be listed. When using wood vinegar or bamboo vinegar or a mixture of wood vinegar and bamboo vinegar, the dissolution of fulvic acid can be promoted compared with water, and there is an advantage of obtaining a large amount of fulvic acid in a shorter time. The mixture of wood vinegar and bamboo vinegar can use a mixture of any mixing ratio. When the waste fungus bed is immersed in the wood vinegar of pH 4.0, at least making the pH lower than 4.0 is the first condition for judging the dissolution of fulvic acid. In addition, the following situation is used as the second condition for judging the dissolution of fulvic acid: in the Munsell hue circle (40 hues) of the Munsell color system, for the hue of the wood vinegar solution before soaking the waste fungus bed and the hue after the dissolution of fulvic acid, the hue of either one is set to 0, and when it is expressed by +20 clockwise and -20 counterclockwise, the hue of the other is in the hue range of +4 to +6 or -4 to -6 based on the hue 0. It is judged to be excellent when both the first and second conditions are met. It should be noted that the main thing is that the hue of the wood vinegar solution used for dissolving fulvic acid in repeated tests is 7.5R to 7.5YR, the lightness is 7, the chroma is 12, and the hue of the fulvic acid solution is 10YR to 10Y, the lightness is 2, and the chroma is 1. There is no restriction on the pH, dosage, and immersion time of the wood vinegar solution, and the pH is preferably below 4.0. In addition, it was confirmed that the case of using bamboo vinegar also had substantially the same result as the case of using wood vinegar.

[0053] Industrial Applicability

[0054] According to the present invention, the quality of the cultured mushroom bed is judged based on the appearance and brittleness of the bed, and the quality of the solution is judged based on the pH and hue. Therefore, it is useful as a technology that can obtain a large amount of fulvic acid inexpensively and simply.

Claims

1. A method for evaluating the quality of a fulvic acid solution, characterized in that: When extracting fulvic acid solution from the cultured mushroom bed, the main component of the mushroom bed is sawdust. The evaluation method comprises the following steps: pH confirmation step: after the mushroom bed is sealed in a container, the pH of the solution dissolved to the bottom of the container is confirmed; Color confirmation step: confirming the color of the solution; and Judging step: Based on the pH confirmed in the pH confirming step and the color confirmed in the color confirming step, the solution is judged to be excellent when the pH is below 4.0 and the color is in the Munsell color circle of the Munsell color system, the hue is 2.5YR to 10YR when dissolved with water, and the hue is 10YR to 10Y when dissolved with wood vinegar or bamboo vinegar, or a mixture of wood vinegar and bamboo vinegar, and the Munsell color circle is 40 hue.

2. An application of a cultured mushroom bed in evaluating a fulvic acid solution, characterized in that: The main component of the mushroom bed is sawdust. The evaluation method comprises the following steps: Step 1: A mushroom bed is evaluated as good if it can be visually confirmed that hyphae are fully distributed in the height, width and length directions of the mushroom bed and the sensory evaluation shows that the mushroom bed is highly brittle, and the other mushroom beds are evaluated as poor; Step 2: sealing the mushroom bed in a container, allowing the solution to dissolve to the bottom of the container; Step 3: For the mushroom bed evaluated as excellent in the step 1, the pH of the elution solution in the step 2 is confirmed; and Step 4: With respect to the color of the solution having a pH value of 4.0 or less confirmed in the step 3 and the color of the solution of the step 2 of the mushroom bed evaluated as inferior in the step 1, when the hue of either one is set to 0 and expressed by +20 clockwise and -20 counterclockwise relative to the hue in the Munsell color circle of the Munsell color system, the solution whose hue is in the range of +4 to +6 or -4 to -6 is judged as excellent, wherein the Munsell color circle has 40 hues. The solution judged to be excellent in the fourth step is used as the fulvic acid solution.

3. An application of a cultured mushroom bed in evaluating a fulvic acid solution, characterized in that: The main component of the mushroom bed is sawdust, and the evaluation method comprises the following steps: Step 1: A mushroom bed is evaluated as good if it can be visually confirmed that hyphae are fully distributed in the height, width and length directions of the mushroom bed and the sensory evaluation shows that the mushroom bed is highly brittle, and the other mushroom beds are evaluated as poor; Step 2: sealing the mushroom bed and wood vinegar or bamboo vinegar, or a mixture of wood vinegar and bamboo vinegar, into a container, and allowing the solution to dissolve to the bottom of the container; Step 3: For the mushroom bed evaluated as excellent in the step 1, the pH of the elution solution in the step 2 is confirmed; and Step 4: For the color of the solution whose pH confirmed in the step 3 is lower than the pH of the wood vinegar or the bamboo vinegar, or the mixture of the wood vinegar and the bamboo vinegar, and the color of the wood vinegar or the bamboo vinegar, or the mixture of the wood vinegar and the bamboo vinegar, when the hue of either one is set to 0 and the hue of the other is within the hue range of +4 to +6 or -4 to -6 when expressed by rotating +20 clockwise and 20 counterclockwise relative to the hue in the Munsell color system, the Munsell color circle is 40 hues, The solution judged to be excellent in the fourth step is used as the fulvic acid solution.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Method for producing fulvic acid from low-grade coal using high-temperature water under pressure

    JP2004269484A

  • Composition for agriculture

    JP2006151706A

  • Method for producing artificial humic soil

    JP2010148398A

  • Fulvic acid aqueous solution derived from humic substances and production method thereof

    JP2014162723A

  • Method for catalytic humification of sludge organic matters

    CN106187460A