Calculation and evaluation method for reliability of main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme operating conditions
By establishing and adjusting the fluid and solid domain models of the main pump static press seal and calculating the force balance under the limit operating conditions, the problem of operating reliability evaluation of the main pump static press seal under the limit operating conditions is solved, and the safety of the unit is improved and economic benefits.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202111350085.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2021-11-15
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-01
- Estimated Expiration
- 2041-11-15
AI Technical Summary
In the prior art, there is a lack of effective method for the reliability evaluation of the main pump static pressing shaft seal operating under extreme operating conditions, which makes it difficult to ensure the safety and economic benefits of the pump.
The calculation and evaluation method for building a main pump static pressing shaft seal is adopted, including establishing an initial solid domain model and a fluid domain model, calculating the opening and closing forces under the limit and rated operating conditions through flow field simulation analysis, adjusting the thickness of the liquid film until the force is balanced , evaluate the liquid film thickness to determine the reliability under the limit operating conditions.
It provides reliability evaluation of the main pump static pressurized shaft seal under extreme operating conditions, ensures its safe operation, and improves the safety and economic benefits of the unit.
Smart Images

Figure CN114169259B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of nuclear power main pump seals, and in particular to a calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of a main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions. Background Art
[0002] The reactor coolant pump is referred to as the main pump. It is the only rotating equipment in the primary circuit system. Its reliability directly affects whether the reactor can operate safely. The main pump mechanical seal assembly consists of three stages of mechanical seals in series. The first shaft seal is a liquid film seal that can control leakage, also known as a static pressure shaft seal. The second and third shaft seals are friction surface seals. The three seals are arranged in series to control the coolant leakage upward along the pump shaft 3.
[0003] like Figure 1 As shown in the figure, the main components of the hydrostatic shaft seal are the dynamic ring seat, the static ring seat, the dynamic ring 2, the static ring 1 and the clamping ring. During operation, the surfaces of the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 do not contact each other, but are separated by a layer of liquid film, otherwise they will wear out and cause excessive leakage. The hydrostatic shaft seal bears almost all the pressure difference of a circuit and belongs to the hydrostatic type. Under the pressure of the water injected into the hydrostatic shaft seal, a water film with a thickness of only a few microns is formed between the working planes of the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1. When the two planes of the dynamic and static rings move against each other, this layer of water film keeps the two planes from directly contacting each other and avoids wear, while also cooling and lubricating the sealing friction pair. The static ring 1 assembly is assembled on the outer circumference of the insert through a double triangular groove seal, and moves up and down along the outer circumference of the insert under the action of the liquid pressure difference and its own weight, realizing the compensation of the sealing force of the friction pair and forming a dynamic balance between the closing force and the repulsive force of the friction pair. Therefore, the liquid film thickness of the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 can be used as a standard for evaluating whether the hydrostatic shaft seal of the main pump can operate safely.
[0004] Currently in the nuclear power field, the main pump still has some potential problems that affect the safety and economic benefits of the unit, and it is necessary to conduct forward-looking research on the various factors that affect its reliable operation. For example, the technical specifications require that the main pump No. 1 seal pressure differential must be operated at a minimum of 1.4Mpa to ensure the safe operation of the main pump; however, in actual working conditions, the main pump No. 1 seal pressure differential can still ensure the safe operation of the main pump if it is lower than 1.4Mpa, but there is currently no specific verification method for how low the main pump No. 1 seal pressure differential can be. Summary of the invention
[0005] The technical problem to be solved by the present invention is to provide a calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of a main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions.
[0006] The technical solution adopted by the present invention to solve the technical problem is: constructing a calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the static pressure shaft seal of the main pump under extreme working conditions, comprising the following steps:
[0007] S10: Establish the initial solid domain model according to the structural dimensions of the static pressure shaft seal, and obtain the initial cone angle value δ of the dynamic ring of the static pressure shaft seal 0a , the initial cone angle value of the static ring δ 0b ;
[0008] S20: presetting the limit initial film thickness value h0 of the static pressure shaft seal and its working parameters under the limit working condition, importing into the flow field simulation software in combination with the initial solid domain model size, establishing the first limit fluid domain model and performing flow field analysis, and obtaining the first pressure distribution P0 and the first temperature distribution T0 between the dynamic ring and the static ring wall under the limit working condition;
[0009] S30: Based on the initial solid domain model size, combined with the first pressure distribution P0 and the limit working condition parameters, the corresponding limit opening force F1 and limit closing force F2 under the limit working condition are calculated;
[0010] Determine whether the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2; if not, readjust the film thickness value, recalculate the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 with the same limit working condition parameters, and judge again until the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2 after the i-th adjustment; obtain the corresponding limit liquid film thickness value h ip ;
[0011] S40: sorting out and obtaining the working parameters of the static pressure shaft seal under the rated working condition, and presetting the rated initial film thickness value h0' under the rated working condition, and importing it into the flow field simulation software in combination with the initial solid domain model size, establishing the first rated fluid domain model and performing flow field analysis, and obtaining the third pressure distribution P0' and the fourth temperature distribution T0';
[0012] S50: Based on the initial solid domain model size, combined with the third pressure distribution P0', the fourth temperature distribution T0' and the rated operating condition parameters, the corresponding rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are calculated;
[0013] Determine whether the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are equal; if not, readjust the film thickness value, recalculate the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 with the same rated operating parameters, and determine again until the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are equal after the i'th adjustment; obtain the corresponding rated liquid film thickness value h ip ';
[0014] S60: Determine the limit liquid film thickness value h ip Is it greater than or equal to the rated liquid film thickness value h ip '; If so, it is evaluated that the static pressure shaft seal can operate safely under the preset extreme operating parameters; if not, it is evaluated that the static pressure shaft seal cannot operate safely under the preset extreme operating parameters, and step S20 is re-executed.
[0015] Preferably, step S30 includes the following sub-steps:
[0016] S31: According to the first pressure distribution P0, substitute into formula (1) to calculate the limit opening force F1:
[0017]
[0018] Among them, F k is the opening force, where k can be 1 or 3; θ is the circumferential angle of the opening force acting on the static ring; P(R) is the first pressure distribution or the third pressure distribution along the radial direction, or the pressure distribution along the radial direction corresponding to the i-th or i'th adjustment;
[0019] S32: According to the initial solid domain model size and the limit working condition parameters, substitute into formula (2) to calculate the limit closing force F2;
[0020]
[0021] where F c is the closing force, where c can be 2 or 4; G is the gravity of the static ring assembly in the static pressure shaft seal; Pa is the inlet pressure value in the corresponding operating parameters; Pz is the outlet pressure value in the corresponding operating parameters; Ro is the outer diameter of the static ring; Ra is the inner diameter of the static ring; Rb is the distance between the pump shaft and the side wall of the step part of the static ring.
[0022] Preferably, in step S30, if the liquid film thickness value is adjusted, when the limit opening force F1 is greater than the limit closing force F2, the liquid film thickness value is increased; when the limit opening force F1 is less than the limit closing force F2, the liquid film thickness value is decreased.
[0023] Preferably, in step S30, the following sub-steps are also included:
[0024] S33: When adjusting the film thickness for the first time, when the limit opening force F1 is greater than the limit closing force F2, the first liquid film thickness value h1 is:
[0025] h1=h0+0.05·h0 (3)
[0026] When the limit opening force F1 is less than the limit closing force F2, the first liquid film thickness value h1 is:
[0027] h1=h0-0.05·h0 (4)
[0028] Among them, h0 is the assumed limit initial film thickness value, h1 is the first liquid film thickness value adjusted for the first time;
[0029] When the film thickness is adjusted for the i-1th time, linear interpolation is performed based on the i-2nd film thickness value, the i-3rd film thickness value, and the corresponding unbalanced force to obtain the i-1th liquid film thickness value h i-1 for:
[0030]
[0031] When the film thickness is adjusted for the i-th time, linear interpolation is performed based on the i-1-th film thickness value, the i-2-th film thickness value, and the corresponding unbalanced force to obtain the limit liquid film thickness value h i for:
[0032]
[0033] Wherein, when the limit opening force F1 is greater than the limit closing force F2, the plus and minus signs in the formula are minus signs, and when the limit opening force F1 is less than the limit closing force F2, the plus and minus signs in the formula are plus signs; i represents the i-th adjustment of the liquid film thickness, and when the liquid film thickness value is adjusted for the i-th time, the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2; h i represents the thickness value of the i-th adjustment; ΔF is the unbalanced force, which is equal to the value of the limit opening force F1 minus the limit closing force F2 corresponding to the i-th adjustment; ΔF i-1 Represents the unbalanced force in the i-1th adjustment, ΔF i-2 Represents the unbalanced force in the i-2th adjustment.
[0034] Preferably, in step S30, the following sub-steps are also included:
[0035] S34: Using the first pressure distribution P0 and the first temperature distribution T0 as boundary conditions, the force field analysis software is used to calculate the structural deformation of the dynamic ring and the static ring, and the cone angle value δ of the second dynamic ring after deformation is obtained. ia 、The second static ring cone angle value δ ib ;
[0036] S35: According to the second moving ring cone angle value δ ia 、The second static ring cone angle value δ ib And the limiting liquid film thickness h ip , correct the structure of the initial solid domain model and obtain the second limit solid domain model; based on the second limit solid domain model, the cone angle values of the dynamic ring and the static ring are recalculated in combination with the limit working condition parameters to obtain the third dynamic ring cone angle value δ (i+1)a 、The third moving ring cone angle value δ (i+1)b ;
[0037] S36: Determine the cone angle value δ of the third moving ring (i+1)a Is it equal to the cone angle value δ of the second moving ring? ia , and the cone angle value of the third static ring is δ i+1bIs it equal to the cone angle value of the second static ring δ ib If yes, the static ring is in a state of force balance under the evaluation limit condition, and the corresponding limit liquid film thickness value is obtained. hip ; Otherwise, re-execute step S20.
[0038] Preferably, step S20 includes the following sub-steps:
[0039] S21: sorting out bench test data of the static pressure shaft seal under normal operation to obtain corresponding normal operating condition parameters and a first normal film thickness value;
[0040] S22: Based on the initial solid domain model size, the conventional working condition parameters are substituted into the flow field simulation software to calculate the second conventional film thickness value based on the model;
[0041] S23: If the second conventional film thickness value is equal to the first conventional film thickness value, the first limiting fluid domain model does not need to be corrected; otherwise, the first limiting fluid domain model is corrected.
[0042] Preferably, in step S10, when the deviation between the second conventional film thickness value and the first conventional film thickness value is no more than 10%, it is determined that the size of the first limiting fluid domain model is correct.
[0043] Preferably, in step S30, when the difference between the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 is less than a first preset convergence criterion, it is determined that the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2.
[0044] Preferably, in step S36, the third dynamic ring cone angle value δ (i+1)a The cone angle value of the second moving ring δ ia When the difference between is less than the second preset convergence criterion, the two are judged to be equal;
[0045] The third static ring cone angle value δ i+1b The cone angle value of the second static ring δ ib When the difference between is less than the second preset convergence criterion, it is determined that the two are equal.
[0046] Preferably, the first preset convergence criterion is 1 / 100.
[0047] The implementation of the present invention has the following beneficial effects: a calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme operating conditions provided by the present invention can be used to explore the reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme operating conditions, provide data support for whether the main pump static pressure shaft seal can operate safely under extreme operating conditions, and improve the safety and economic benefits of the unit. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0048] The present invention will be further described below with reference to the accompanying drawings and embodiments, in which:
[0049] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the structure of the static pressure shaft seal of the main pump in the prior art under the cross section;
[0050] Figure 2 It is a program flow chart of the calculation and evaluation method of the main pump static pressure shaft seal operating reliability under extreme working conditions of the present invention. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0051] In order to have a clearer understanding of the technical features, purposes and effects of the present invention, specific embodiments of the present invention are now described in detail with reference to the accompanying drawings.
[0052] It should be noted that the flowcharts shown in the accompanying drawings are only exemplary and do not necessarily include all the contents and operations / steps, nor do they have to be executed in the order described. For example, some operations / steps can be decomposed, while some operations / steps can be combined or partially combined, so the actual execution order may change according to the actual situation.
[0053] The block diagrams shown in the accompanying drawings are merely functional entities and do not necessarily correspond to physically independent entities. That is, these functional entities may be implemented in software form, or in one or more hardware modules or integrated circuits, or in different networks and / or processor devices and / or microcontroller devices.
[0054] like Figure 1-Figure 2 As shown, a calculation and evaluation method for the reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions in the present invention is to obtain the liquid film thickness value of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions and compare it with the liquid film thickness value of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under rated working conditions to evaluate the reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions; the present invention can be used to provide data support for whether the main pump static pressure shaft seal can operate safely under extreme working conditions, and can improve the safety and economic benefits of the unit. Among them, the calculation and evaluation method for the reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions includes the following steps:
[0055] S10: Establish the initial solid domain model according to the structural dimensions of the static pressure shaft seal and obtain the initial cone angle value δ of the dynamic ring of the static pressure shaft seal 0a , the initial cone angle value of the static ring δ 0b ;
[0056] It can be understood that the above-mentioned hydrostatic shaft seal refers to the hydrostatic shaft seal that needs to be evaluated. In the prior art, the main pump mechanical seal includes a hydrostatic shaft seal, a No. 2 seal and a pump shaft 3; the hydrostatic shaft seal includes a dynamic ring seat, a static ring seat, a dynamic ring 2, a static ring 1 and a clamping ring; the specific structure of the main pump mechanical seal can refer to the prior art. Specifically, the external dimension data of the main pump mechanical seal can be measured on site based on the mechanical seal drawing in combination with the use of a three-dimensional measuring instrument; and the main pump mechanical seal spare parts are used to use a three-dimensional profile measuring instrument (FRT) to measure the key parameters of components such as the hydrostatic shaft seal. The key parameters include: the inner diameter, outer diameter, height, inflection radius, cone angle value of the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1, and the size of the step 11 in the static ring 1. It should be noted that the initial cone angle value δ of the dynamic ring 2 is 0a 、The initial cone angle value δ of static ring 1 0b It refers to the initial cone angle value measured when the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 are not in operation. As the static pressure shaft seal is in operation, the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 will undergo structural deformation, and the corresponding cone angle value will change.
[0057] S20: presetting the limit initial film thickness value h0 of the static pressure shaft seal and its working parameters under the limit working condition, importing into the flow field simulation software in combination with the initial solid domain model size, establishing the first limit fluid domain model and performing flow field analysis, and obtaining the first pressure distribution P0 and the first temperature distribution T0 between the dynamic ring and the static ring wall under the limit working condition;
[0058] It can be understood that the purpose of the present invention is to study whether the main pump static pressure shaft seal can still operate safely under various extreme operating conditions; by assuming various extreme operating conditions, comprehensively considering the influence of temperature and fluid pressure on structural deformation, and also considering the influence of structural deformation on flow field, the sealing characteristic parameters of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under various extreme operating conditions are obtained, and then the reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme conditions is evaluated. The operating parameters of the main pump static pressure shaft seal include inlet pressure, outlet pressure, inlet temperature and pump shaft speed; wherein, the extreme operating parameters include extreme inlet pressure, extreme outlet pressure, extreme inlet temperature and extreme pump shaft speed. The sealing characteristic parameters include liquid film thickness value and leakage amount. The liquid film thickness value is the gap size between the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 in the static pressure shaft seal. If the liquid film thickness is too large, excessive leakage will occur. By assuming the operating parameters of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme operation, and judging whether the liquid film thickness under the assumed extreme condition meets the benchmark, it is evaluated whether the main pump static pressure shaft seal can still operate safely under the assumed extreme condition.
[0059] Furthermore, the establishment of the fluid domain model requires the data of the initial solid domain model and the spacing data between the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1, and the spacing between the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 can only be obtained after the main pump mechanical seal is running. Therefore, in step S20, the spacing between the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 is preset, that is, the liquid film thickness value between the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 is preset, and the accuracy of the liquid film thickness value is adjusted and verified in the following steps. Optionally, the parameter values in the rated working condition and the normal working condition can be referred to to preset the limit initial film thickness value h0 of the static pressure shaft seal and its working condition parameters under the limit working condition.
[0060] Preferably, the flow field simulation software can be selected from Ansys Fluent simulation software, which is a computer software used to simulate the flow and heat conduction of fluids with complex shapes. It can simulate and analyze the fluid flow and heat transfer phenomena in complex collective areas. The specific method of making the fluid domain model can refer to the existing technology and will not be explained here.
[0061] S30: Based on the initial solid domain model size, combined with the first pressure distribution P0, the first temperature distribution T0 and the extreme working condition parameters, calculate and obtain the corresponding extreme opening force F1 and extreme closing force F2 under the extreme working condition;
[0062] Determine whether the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2; if not, readjust the film thickness value, recalculate the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 with the same limit working condition parameters, and judge again until the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2 after the i-th adjustment; obtain the corresponding limit liquid film thickness value h ip ;
[0063] It can be understood that the closing force refers to the force acting downward from the top of the static ring 1 and acting on the upper wall of the static ring 1. Specifically, there is a high-pressure area 5 above the static ring 1, and a closing force is applied to the static ring 1, causing the static ring 1 to move downward. The closing force depends on the inlet pressure and the outlet pressure. When the inlet and outlet pressures remain unchanged, the closing force will not change. The opening force refers to the force acting upward from the bottom of the static ring 1 and acting on the lower wall of the static ring 1. The injected fluid will flow from the gap between the static ring 1 and the dynamic ring 2 to the low-pressure area 4, forming an opening force, causing the static ring 1 to move upward relative to the position of the dynamic ring 2. The larger the distance between the static ring 1 and the dynamic ring 2, the smaller the opening force; the smaller the distance between the static ring 1 and the dynamic ring 2, the larger the opening force; the static ring 1 will move back and forth longitudinally relative to the position of the dynamic ring 2 until the opening force is equal to or approximately equal to the closing force, and the distance between the static ring 1 and the dynamic ring 2 is relatively stable, at which time the liquid film thickness value can be obtained.
[0064] Specifically, step S30 includes the following sub-steps:
[0065] S31: According to the first pressure distribution P0, substitute into formula (1) to calculate the limit opening force F1:
[0066]
[0067] Among them, F k is the opening force, where k can be 1 or 3; θ is the circumferential angle of the opening force acting on the static ring 1; P(R) is the first pressure distribution or the third pressure distribution along the radius, or the pressure distribution along the radius corresponding to the ith or i'th adjustment; it should be noted that the opening force F1 is the force acting on the lower wall of the static ring 1, and the opening force is equal to the sum of the opening forces acting on each tiny geometric unit on the lower wall of the static ring 1, and R is the distance from each tiny geometric unit in the static ring 1 to the center of the static ring 1.
[0068] S32: According to the initial solid domain model size and the limit working condition parameters, substitute into formula (2) to calculate the limit closing force F2;
[0069]
[0070] where F c is the closing force, where c can be 2 or 4; G is the weight of the static ring assembly in the static pressure shaft seal; Pa is the inlet pressure value in the corresponding working condition parameters; Pz is the outlet pressure value in the corresponding working condition parameters; Ro is the outer diameter of the static ring; Ra is the inner diameter of the static ring; Rb is the distance between the pump shaft and the side wall of the step portion of the static ring 1. Specifically, the static ring assembly includes the static ring 1, the static ring seat, and the static ring clamping ring. The mass of the static ring assembly can refer to the data provided by the manufacturer, or the mass of the static ring assembly can be obtained by weighing, and the gravity of the static ring assembly can be calculated by the gravity calculation formula (F=mg); further, the gravity of the static ring assembly in the static pressure shaft seal to be tested is substituted into G, the limit inlet pressure is substituted into Pa, the limit outlet pressure is substituted into Pz, the outer diameter and inner diameter of the static ring 1 in the static pressure shaft seal to be tested, and the distance between the pump shaft 3 and the side wall of the step 11 of the static ring 1 are substituted into Ro, Ra, and Rb respectively, so as to calculate the limit closing force F2.
[0071] It can be understood that the closing force is the force acting on the wall of the static ring 1, such as Figure 1 As shown in the figure, the inlet pressure acts on the top of the static ring 1, and the outlet pressure acts on the step 11 in the static ring 1. Therefore, the closing force is related to the inlet pressure and the outlet pressure. The pressure distribution obtained in the Ansys Fluent simulation software includes the pressure value of each tiny geometric unit on the wall between the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1; the opening force is the force acting on the lower wall of the static ring 1, and the opening force is equal to the sum of the pressure values acting on each point on the lower wall of the static ring 1.
[0072] Further, in step S30, if the liquid film thickness value is adjusted, when the limit opening force F1 is greater than the limit closing force F2, the liquid film thickness value is increased; when the limit opening force F1 is less than the limit closing force F2, the liquid film thickness value is decreased.
[0073] Specifically, S33: when adjusting the film thickness for the first time, when the limit opening force F1 is greater than the limit closing force F2, the first liquid film thickness value h1 is:
[0074] h1=h0+0.05·h0 (3)
[0075] When the limit opening force F1 is less than the limit closing force F2, the first liquid film thickness value h1 is:
[0076] h1=h0-0.05·h0 (4)
[0077] Among them, h0 is the assumed limit initial film thickness value, h1 is the first liquid film thickness value adjusted for the first time;
[0078] When the film thickness is adjusted for the i-1th time, linear interpolation is performed based on the i-2nd film thickness value, the i-3rd film thickness value, and the corresponding unbalanced force to obtain the i-1th liquid film thickness value h i-1 for:
[0079]
[0080] When the film thickness is adjusted for the i-th time, linear interpolation is performed based on the i-1-th film thickness value, the i-2-th film thickness value, and the corresponding unbalanced force to obtain the limit liquid film thickness value h i for:
[0081]
[0082] Wherein, when the limit opening force F1 is greater than the limit closing force F2, the plus and minus signs in the formula are minus signs, and when the limit opening force F1 is less than the limit closing force F2, the plus and minus signs in the formula are plus signs; i represents the i-th adjustment of the liquid film thickness, and when the liquid film thickness value is adjusted for the i-th time, the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2; h i represents the thickness value of the i-th adjustment; ΔF is the unbalanced force, which is equal to the value of the limit opening force F1 minus the limit closing force F2 corresponding to the i-th adjustment; ΔF i-1 Represents the unbalanced force in the i-1th adjustment, ΔF i-2 Represents the unbalanced force in the i-2th adjustment.
[0083] It should be noted that i is a positive integer. When the liquid film thickness does not need to be adjusted, it corresponds to the limit initial film thickness value h0.
[0084] It can be understood that based on the limit initial film thickness value h0, the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 are calculated to be unequal; then the first adjusted liquid film thickness value is calculated by formula (3) or formula (4), and the flow field analysis is performed again in the flow field simulation software with the adjusted film thickness value and the same limit operating condition parameters, and the second pressure distribution P1 is obtained, which is substituted into formula (1) and formula (2) again to calculate the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 after the first adjustment, and make a judgment; if they are still unequal, continue to introduce formula (5) to calculate the liquid film thickness value adjusted for the i-1th time, and repeatedly calculate and compare whether the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 are equal; until the liquid film thickness is adjusted for the ith time, at this time, the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 are equal, and the next step can be carried out. At this time, according to the spacing between the static ring 1 and the dynamic ring 2, the corresponding limit liquid film thickness value hip is obtained. Optionally, when the difference between the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 is less than a first preset convergence criterion, it can be determined that the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2; preferably, the first preset convergence criterion is 1 / 100.
[0085] Furthermore, during the operation of the main pump static pressure shaft seal, the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 undergo structural deformation, and the relative cone angle also undergoes deformation. At this time, although the distance of the static ring 1 relative to the dynamic ring 2 tends to be stable, and the opening force and the closing force are equal, the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 still have the possibility of deformation; if the deformation continues, the opening force and the closing force will change again. At this time, the static ring 1 has not reached the true force balance state, and the obtained liquid film thickness value has an error. Therefore, it is necessary to check whether it has reached the equilibrium state.
[0086] Specifically, in step S30, the following sub-steps are also included:
[0087] S34: Using the first pressure distribution P0 and the first temperature distribution T0 as boundary conditions, the force field analysis software is used to calculate the structural deformation of the dynamic ring and the static ring, and the cone angle value δ of the second dynamic ring after deformation is obtained. ia 、The second static ring cone angle value δ ib ;
[0088] S35: According to the second moving ring cone angle value δ ia 、The second static ring cone angle value δ ib And the limiting liquid film thickness h ip , correct the structure of the initial solid domain model and obtain the second limit solid domain model; based on the second limit solid domain model, the cone angle values of the dynamic ring and the static ring are recalculated in combination with the limit working condition parameters to obtain the third dynamic ring cone angle value δ (i+1)a 、The third moving ring cone angle value δ (i+1)b ;
[0089] S36: Determine the cone angle value δ of the third moving ring(i+1)a Is it equal to the cone angle value δ of the second moving ring? ia , and the cone angle value of the third static ring is δ i+1b Is it equal to the cone angle value of the second static ring δ ib If yes, the static ring is in a state of force balance under the evaluation limit condition, and the corresponding limit liquid film thickness value is obtained. hip ; Otherwise, re-execute step S20.
[0090] Optionally, the force field analysis software can be Ansys Structure analysis software, which can provide a complete tool for structural analysis, with general statics, dynamics and nonlinear analysis capabilities as well as composite materials, fracture, fatigue, optimization and other analysis functions. The specific operation and analysis of the structural deformation of the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 can refer to the existing technology and will not be explained here.
[0091] It can be understood that when the fluid acts on the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1, the static ring 1 moves longitudinally back and forth relative to the dynamic ring 2. At this time, the structures of the static ring 1 and the dynamic ring 2 will be deformed, so their respective cone angle values will also change. The structural deformation caused by the pressure distribution and temperature distribution on the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 can be analyzed by the AnsysStructure analysis software, so as to know the cone angle value δ of the second dynamic ring ia 、The second static ring cone angle value δ ib Furthermore, during the i-th adjustment, the corresponding pressure distribution and temperature distribution are used as boundary conditions, and the structural deformation of the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 is calculated in the force field analysis software to obtain the corresponding second dynamic ring cone angle value δ ia 、The second static ring cone angle value δ ib。
[0092] After obtaining the cone angle values of the deformed dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1, the cone angle values are tested to determine whether the static ring 1 is in a force equilibrium state; however, since the cone angle values of the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1, and the gap between the dynamic ring and the static ring 1 change after experiencing the fluid, it is necessary to modify the first limit fluid domain model. According to the second cone angle value δ of the dynamic ring 2 obtained, ia 、The second cone angle value δ of the static ring 1 ib And the corresponding limiting liquid film thickness value h i The structure of the initial solid domain model is modified and the second limit solid domain model is obtained; on the basis of the second limit solid domain model, the same limit operating condition parameters are imported into the flow field simulation software for flow field analysis, and the second limit fluid domain model based on the second limit solid domain model and its corresponding pressure distribution and temperature distribution are obtained (at this time, the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 based on the second limit fluid domain model are equal); the pressure distribution and temperature distribution based on the second limit fluid domain model are used as boundary conditions, and the third dynamic ring cone angle value δ is calculated by the force field analysis software.(i+1)a 、The third moving ring cone angle value δ (i+1)b It can be understood that the calculation method is the same as the second dynamic ring cone angle value δ ia 、The second static ring cone angle value δ ib The methods for obtaining are basically the same, please refer to the above for details.
[0093] At this time, if the cone angle value of the third moving ring δ (i+1)a Equal to the cone angle value of the second moving ring δ ia , and the cone angle value of the third static ring is δ i+1b Equal to the second static ring cone angle value δ ib , it is judged that the static ring 1 is in a state of force balance under the limit working condition, and according to the distance between the dynamic / static rings in this state, the limit liquid film thickness value when the static ring 1 is in a state of force balance under the limit working condition is obtained. hip Otherwise, re-execute step S20. Optionally, the third dynamic ring cone angle value δ (i+1)a The cone angle value of the second moving ring δ ia The difference between the second static ring cone angle δ i+1b Equal to the second static ring cone angle value δ ib When the difference between and is respectively less than a second preset convergence criterion, it can be determined that the corresponding two are equal; preferably, the second preset convergence criterion is 1 / 100.
[0094] S40: sorting out and obtaining the working parameters of the static pressure shaft seal under the rated working condition, and presetting the rated initial film thickness value h0' under the rated working condition, and importing it into the flow field simulation software in combination with the initial solid domain model size, establishing the first rated fluid domain model and performing flow field analysis, and obtaining the third pressure distribution P0' and the fourth temperature distribution T0';
[0095] S50: Based on the initial solid domain model size, combined with the third pressure distribution P0', the fourth temperature distribution T0' and the rated operating condition parameters, the corresponding rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are calculated;
[0096] Determine whether the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are equal; if not, readjust the film thickness value, recalculate the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 with the same rated operating parameters, and determine again until the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are equal after the i'th adjustment; obtain the corresponding rated liquid film thickness value h ip ';
[0097] It can be understood that step S40 is used to obtain the liquid film thickness of the medium static pressure shaft seal under rated conditions as a basis for judging whether the extreme operating conditions can be safely operated. The static pressure shaft seal combed in the rated operating conditions can be other static pressure shaft seals with the same structure as the static pressure shaft seal that needs to be tested and evaluated, or it can be the same static pressure shaft seal that needs to be tested and evaluated. The method of obtaining the liquid film thickness of the medium static pressure shaft seal under rated conditions is basically the same as the method of obtaining the liquid film thickness of the medium static pressure shaft seal under extreme conditions mentioned above, and the difference between the two is that the input operating condition parameters are different; further, the liquid film thickness values initially assumed under rated conditions and extreme conditions can be the same or different.
[0098] Specifically, the operating parameters of the static pressure shaft seal under rated operating conditions are sorted out, including the rated inlet pressure, the rated outlet pressure, the rated inlet temperature and the rated pump shaft speed; the rated initial film thickness value h0' under rated operating conditions is preset, and combined with the initial solid domain model size, it is imported into the flow field simulation software, the first rated fluid domain model is established and the flow field analysis is performed to obtain the third pressure distribution P0' and the fourth temperature distribution T0'; based on the above-obtained data, it is substituted into equations (1) and (2) to obtain the corresponding rated opening force F3 and rated closing force F4; it is determined whether the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are equal; if not, the film thickness value is readjusted, the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are recalculated, and it is determined again until the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are equal after the i'th adjustment; at this time, the corresponding rated liquid film thickness value h can be obtained according to the distance between the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1. ip The method of adjusting the film thickness value in the rated working condition can refer to the above step S33.
[0099] Of course, the rated film thickness h ip The reliability of the test result is verified; wherein step S50 also includes the following sub-steps:
[0100] S51: Using the third pressure distribution P0' and the fourth temperature distribution T0' as boundary conditions, the structural deformation of the dynamic ring and the static ring is calculated in the force field analysis software to obtain the cone angle value δ of the fourth dynamic ring after deformation ia ', the fourth static ring cone angle value δ ib ';
[0101] S52: According to the fourth moving ring cone angle value δ ia ', the fourth static ring cone angle value δ ib ' and rated film thickness h ip , modifying the structure of the initial solid model to obtain a second rated solid domain model and a second rated fluid domain model;
[0102] Based on the second rated solid domain model and the second rated fluid domain model, the cone angle values of the dynamic ring and the static ring are recalculated by force field analysis software and flow field simulation software in combination with the rated working condition parameters to obtain the fifth dynamic ring cone angle value δ (i+1)a '、The fifth static ring cone angle value δ (i+1)b ';
[0103] S53: Determine the cone angle value δ of the fifth moving ring (i+1)a Is ' equal to the cone angle value of the fourth moving ring δ ia ', and the fifth static ring cone angle value δ (i+1)b Is ' equal to the cone angle value of the fourth static ring δ ib '; If so, the static ring is in a force balance state under the rated working condition, and the corresponding rated liquid film thickness value h is obtained ip ; Otherwise, modify the liquid film thickness value again.
[0104] It is understandable that how to obtain the fourth dynamic ring cone angle value δia', the fourth static ring cone angle value δib', and the fifth dynamic ring cone angle value δ (i+1)a '、The fifth static ring cone angle value δ (i+1)b 'Please refer to the above text and I will not explain it here.
[0105] S60: Determine the limit liquid film thickness value h ip Is it greater than or equal to the rated liquid film thickness value h ip '; If so, it is evaluated that the static pressure shaft seal can operate safely under the preset extreme operating parameters; if not, it is evaluated that the static pressure shaft seal cannot operate safely under the preset extreme operating parameters, and step S20 is re-executed.
[0106] It can be understood that the rated operating condition is the long-term operating condition of the main pump mechanical seal on site, and its reliability can be guaranteed. Therefore, it is necessary to use it as the judgment standard for the limit operating condition. The rated operating condition mainly refers to the main pump mechanical seal at an inlet pressure of 15.71MPa, an outlet pressure of 0.21MPa, and an injection water temperature of 15.5℃ to 65℃; by judging the limit liquid film thickness value h ip Is it greater than or equal to the rated liquid film thickness value h ip ', so the limiting liquid film thickness h ip Whether the minimum requirement of avoiding contact between the dynamic ring 2 and the static ring 1 is met, that is, whether the static pressure shaft seal meets the requirements for safe operation. However, it is worth noting that if other operating conditions are also fully verified on site, they can also be used as a criterion to determine the safety range of extreme operating conditions.
[0107] In some embodiments of the present invention, step S20 includes the following sub-steps:
[0108] S21: sorting out bench test data of the static pressure shaft seal under normal operation to obtain corresponding normal operating condition parameters and a first normal film thickness value;
[0109] S22: Based on the initial solid domain model size, the conventional working condition parameters are substituted into the flow field simulation software to calculate the second conventional film thickness value based on the conventional working condition in the model;
[0110] S23: If the second conventional film thickness value is equal to the first conventional film thickness value, the first limiting fluid domain model does not need to be corrected; otherwise, the first limiting fluid domain model is corrected.
[0111] It can be understood that in order to ensure the accuracy of the established first limiting fluid domain model, the bench test data under normal operating conditions are used to calibrate the calculation model. Normal operating conditions refer to the operating conditions of the main pump mechanical seal under daily conditions, which are different from the rated operating conditions; in order to pursue higher safety, the operating conditions set for normal operation are more conservative. The bench test under normal operating conditions is a leakage characteristic test of the main pump mechanical seal under normal operating conditions, among which the bench test data include the dynamic ring cone angle value, static ring cone angle value, liquid film thickness value, inlet and outlet pressure difference, water inlet temperature, pump shaft speed and leakage of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under normal operating conditions.
[0112] Specifically, the dynamic ring cone angle value and the static ring cone angle value under the conventional working condition are combined to modify the initial three-dimensional geometric model, and the conventional working condition parameters and the conventional liquid film thickness value are imported into the flow field simulation software to establish the first conventional fluid domain model, and the flow field analysis is performed to obtain the fifth pressure distribution and the sixth pressure distribution under the conventional working condition; combined with the fifth pressure distribution and the conventional working condition parameters, the above calculation of the opening force F can be referred to. k and closing force F c (i.e., equation 1 and equation 2) to obtain the second conventional film thickness value based on conventional working conditions in the model. For more specific steps, please refer to the above, which will not be described here.
[0113] The liquid film thickness value under normal working conditions under the bench test is used as the calibration standard. When the second liquid film thickness value based on normal working conditions in the model is equal to the first liquid film thickness value under the bench test, it can be considered that the first limiting fluid domain model does not need to be corrected; otherwise, the first limiting fluid domain model is modified. It should be noted that the first limiting fluid domain model is based on the initial solid domain model. Optionally, the first limiting fluid domain model is judged to be correct when the deviation between the second normal film thickness value and the first normal film thickness value is not greater than 10%.
[0114] It can be understood that the above embodiments only express the preferred implementation modes of the present invention, and the descriptions thereof are relatively specific and detailed, but they cannot be understood as limiting the patent scope of the present invention. It should be pointed out that, for ordinary technicians in this field, the above technical features can be freely combined without departing from the concept of the present invention, and several deformations and improvements can be made, which all belong to the protection scope of the present invention. Therefore, all equivalent changes and modifications made to the scope of the claims of the present invention should belong to the coverage of the claims of the present invention.
Claims
1. A calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: S10: Establish the initial solid domain model according to the structural dimensions of the static pressure shaft seal, and obtain the initial cone angle value δ of the dynamic ring of the static pressure shaft seal 0a , the initial cone angle value of the static ring δ 0b ; S20: presetting the limit initial film thickness value h0 of the static pressure shaft seal and its working parameters under the limit working condition, importing into the flow field simulation software in combination with the initial solid domain model size, establishing the first limit fluid domain model and performing flow field analysis, and obtaining the first pressure distribution P0 and the first temperature distribution T0 between the dynamic ring and the static ring wall under the limit working condition; S30: Based on the initial solid domain model size, combined with the first pressure distribution P0 and the limit working condition parameters, the corresponding limit opening force F1 and limit closing force F2 under the limit working condition are calculated; Determine whether the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2; if not, readjust the film thickness value, recalculate the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 with the same limit working condition parameters, and judge again until the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2 after the i-th adjustment; obtain the corresponding limit liquid film thickness value h ip ; S40: sorting out and obtaining the working parameters of the static pressure shaft seal under the rated working condition, and presetting the rated initial film thickness value h0' under the rated working condition, and importing it into the flow field simulation software in combination with the initial solid domain model size, establishing the first rated fluid domain model and performing flow field analysis, and obtaining the third pressure distribution P0' and the fourth temperature distribution T0'; S50: Based on the initial solid domain model size, combined with the third pressure distribution P0', the fourth temperature distribution T0' and the rated operating parameters, the corresponding rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are calculated; Determine whether the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are equal; if not, readjust the film thickness value, recalculate the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 with the same rated operating parameters, and determine again until the rated opening force F3 and the rated closing force F4 are equal after the i'th adjustment; obtain the corresponding rated liquid film thickness value h ip '; S60: Determine the limit liquid film thickness value h ip Is it greater than or equal to the rated liquid film thickness value h ip '; If so, it is evaluated that the static pressure shaft seal can operate safely under the preset extreme operating parameters; if not, it is evaluated that the static pressure shaft seal cannot operate safely under the preset extreme operating parameters, and step S20 is re-executed.
2. The calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In step S30, the following sub-steps are included: S31: According to the first pressure distribution P0, substitute into formula (1) to calculate the limit opening force F1: Among them, F k is the opening force, where k can be 1 or 3; θ is the circumferential angle of the opening force acting on the static ring; P(R) is the first pressure distribution or the third pressure distribution along the radial direction, or the pressure distribution along the radial direction corresponding to the i-th or i'th adjustment; S32: According to the initial solid domain model size and the limit working condition parameters, substitute them into formula (2) to calculate the limit closing force F2; where F c is the closing force, where c can be 2 or 4; G is the gravity of the static ring assembly in the static pressure shaft seal; Pa is the inlet pressure value in the corresponding operating parameters; Pz is the outlet pressure value in the corresponding operating parameters; Ro is the outer diameter of the static ring; Ra is the inner diameter of the static ring; Rb is the distance between the pump shaft and the side wall of the step part of the static ring.
3. The calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In step S30, if the liquid film thickness value is adjusted, when the limit opening force F1 is greater than the limit closing force F2, the liquid film thickness value is increased; when the limit opening force F1 is less than the limit closing force F2, the liquid film thickness value is decreased.
4. The calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions according to claim 3 is characterized in that: In step S30, the following sub-steps are also included: S33: When adjusting the film thickness for the first time, when the limit opening force F1 is greater than the limit closing force F2, the first liquid film thickness value h1 is: h1=h0+0.05·h0 (3) When the limit opening force F1 is less than the limit closing force F2, the first liquid film thickness value h1 is: h1=h0-0.05·h0 (4) Among them, h0 is the assumed limit initial film thickness value, h1 is the first liquid film thickness value adjusted for the first time; When the film thickness is adjusted for the i-1th time, linear interpolation is performed based on the i-2nd film thickness value, the i-3rd film thickness value, and the corresponding unbalanced force to obtain the i-1th liquid film thickness value h i-1 for: When the film thickness is adjusted for the i-th time, linear interpolation is performed based on the film thickness value of the i-1th time, the film thickness value of the i-2th time, and the corresponding unbalanced force to obtain the limit liquid film thickness value h i for: Wherein, when the limit opening force F1 is greater than the limit closing force F2, the plus and minus signs in the formula are minus signs, and when the limit opening force F1 is less than the limit closing force F2, the plus and minus signs in the formula are plus signs; i represents the i-th adjustment of the liquid film thickness, and when the liquid film thickness value is adjusted for the i-th time, the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2; h i represents the thickness value of the i-th adjustment; ΔF is the unbalanced force, which is equal to the value of the limit opening force F1 minus the limit closing force F2 corresponding to the i-th adjustment; ΔF i-1 Represents the unbalanced force in the i-1th adjustment, ΔF i-2 Represents the unbalanced force in the i-2th adjustment.
5. The calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In step S30, the following sub-steps are also included: S34: Using the first pressure distribution P0 and the first temperature distribution T0 as boundary conditions, the force field analysis software is used to calculate the structural deformation of the dynamic ring and the static ring, and the cone angle value δ of the second dynamic ring after deformation is obtained. ia 、The second static ring cone angle value δ ib ; S35: According to the second dynamic ring cone angle value δ ia 、The second static ring cone angle value δ ib And the limiting liquid film thickness h ip , correct the structure of the initial solid domain model and obtain the second limit solid domain model; based on the second limit solid domain model, the cone angle values of the dynamic ring and the static ring are recalculated in combination with the limit working condition parameters to obtain the third dynamic ring cone angle value δ (i+1)a 、The third dynamic ring cone angle value δ (i+1)b ; S36: Determine the cone angle value δ of the third moving ring (i+1)a Is it equal to the cone angle value δ of the second moving ring? ia , and the cone angle value of the third static ring is δ i+1b Is it equal to the cone angle value of the second static ring δ ib If yes, the static ring is in a state of force balance under the evaluation limit condition, and the corresponding limit liquid film thickness value is obtained. hip ; Otherwise, re-execute step S20.
6. The calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In step S20, the following sub-steps are included: S21: sorting out bench test data of the static pressure shaft seal under normal operation to obtain corresponding normal operating condition parameters and a first normal film thickness value; S22: Based on the initial solid domain model size, the conventional working condition parameters are substituted into the flow field simulation software to calculate the second conventional film thickness value based on the model; S23: If the second conventional film thickness value is equal to the first conventional film thickness value, or there is a deviation of no more than 10% between the second conventional film thickness value and the first conventional film thickness value, the first limiting fluid domain model does not need to be corrected; otherwise, the first limiting fluid domain model is corrected.
7. The calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions according to claim 1 is characterized in that: In step S30, when the difference between the limit opening force F1 and the limit closing force F2 is less than the first preset convergence criterion, it is determined that the limit opening force F1 is equal to the limit closing force F2.
8. The calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions according to claim 5 is characterized in that: In step S36, the third dynamic ring cone angle value δ (i+1)a The cone angle value of the second moving ring δ ia When the difference between is less than the second preset convergence criterion, the two are judged to be equal; The third static ring cone angle value δ i+1b The cone angle value of the second static ring δ ib When the difference between is less than the second preset convergence criterion, it is determined that the two are equal.
9. The calculation and evaluation method for the operating reliability of the main pump static pressure shaft seal under extreme working conditions according to claim 7 is characterized in that: The first preset convergence criterion is 1 / 100.
