Interpolation algorithm for electromagnetic transient simulation considering multiple switching actions and reinitialization

By introducing multiple switch action and reinitialization interpolation algorithms in electromagnetic transient simulation, combined with implicit trapezoidal integral and linear interpolation methods, the problem of inefficiency in traditional electromagnetic transient simulation is solved, and higher simulation accuracy and efficiency are achieved. Suitable for complex power grids and real-time simulation.

CN114186377BActive Publication Date: 2024-11-08SOUTHEAST UNIV
View PDF 4 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202110856657.8
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-07-28
Publication Date
2024-11-08
Estimated Expiration
2041-07-28

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

Traditional digital electromagnetic transient simulation is inefficient when dealing with large-capacity flexible DC transmission and renewable energy access to the power grid, and cannot meet the requirements of simulation accuracy and time scale, especially in complex networks and real-time simulation.

Method used

An electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithm that considers the action of multiple switches and reinitialization is proposed. Through implicit trapezoidal integral method and linear interpolation method, combined with backward Euler method and resynchronization processing, the simulation calculation is optimized and the forced commutation of switches is reduced. The state amount is suddenly changed and the numerical oscillation.

Benefits of technology

It improves simulation accuracy and efficiency, is suitable for fixed-step EMTP simulation, realizes the balance of simulation characteristics, and significantly improves the simulation accuracy and efficiency of electromagnetic transient simulation.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN114186377B_ABST
    Figure CN114186377B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention discloses an electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithm considering multiple switch actions and reinitialization, comprising the following steps: step (1) detecting whether forced commutation occurs at time t, and if so, reinitializing and correcting the initial state; step (2) using an implicit trapezoidal method to integrate a step length to t+Δt, detecting the switch action at (t, t+Δt), and if no action occurs, skipping the subsequent steps and performing the next time step calculation; step (3) using linear interpolation at time t and t+Δt to obtain t d‑ State quantity at the moment; Step (4) uses the backward Euler method with a half-step length of Δt / 2 to integrate to t in two consecutive steps d +Δt / 2 and t d +Δt time; Step (5) is performed by t d +Δt / 2 and t d +Δt time to get t d+ The state quantity at the moment, and detect (t d+ , t d +Δt) switch is activated. If it is not activated, t d and t d The state quantity at time t+Δt is obtained by interpolating at time t+Δt to realize resynchronization, and then the next time step calculation is performed, otherwise go to step (3). The present invention improves the traditional interpolation algorithm, and further improves the simulation accuracy while ensuring high simulation calculation efficiency.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The invention relates to the technical field of electromagnetic transient simulation acceleration of power systems, and in particular to an electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithm considering multiple switch actions and reinitialization. Background Art

[0002] With the further application of large-capacity flexible direct current transmission and flexible alternating current transmission in the power grid, as well as the large-scale access of renewable energy, modern power systems are showing a trend of power electronics and increasing complexity. The simulation and analysis of the operating status of renewable energy is becoming increasingly important. Traditional digital electromechanical transient simulation can no longer meet the simulation requirements of power grids connected to a large number of power electronic devices in terms of simulation accuracy and time scale, and can no longer accurately simulate them. Digital electromagnetic transient simulation has gradually become an effective means to accurately simulate current and future power grids.

[0003] However, the frequent switching frequencies and complex control strategies of a large number of power electronic devices make the efficiency of traditional digital electromagnetic transient simulation extremely low, which is extremely inconsistent with the demand for simulation efficiency in today's power system research, production, simulation, etc. On the one hand, the traditional electromagnetic transient simulation modeling method is relatively simple. In order to ensure the simulation accuracy, the prediction correction method is often used, which will cause a great waste of computing power, which is contrary to the architecture requirements of the real-time simulation system; on the other hand, with the continuous increase in the scale of the power grid and the replacement of power electronic devices, coupled with the development of real-time simulation systems, traditional electromagnetic transient simulation is increasingly difficult to meet the simulation speed requirements of complex networks, and the problem of low computing efficiency is gradually becoming prominent. In addition to simplified modeling technology, the widely recognized electromagnetic transient simulation acceleration methods also include efficient parallel algorithms, hybrid simulation interfaces, and simulation interpolation algorithms. The simplification and improvement of the model does improve the efficiency of electromagnetic transient simulation, but it cannot fully meet the computational efficiency requirements of small-step simulation and real-time simulation. This also requires scientific researchers to focus on simulation algorithms and architectures to improve efficiency. Summary of the invention

[0004] In order to solve the above technical problems, the present invention provides an electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithm considering multiple switching actions and reinitialization, comprising the following steps:

[0005] Step 1: According to the control signal at time t, confirm whether forced commutation occurs at this moment. If it occurs, the inductor is equivalent to a current source and the capacitor is equivalent to a voltage source at the switching moment. The equivalent power supply value is the value of the state quantity at the moment before switching; change the switch state at the switching moment and rebuild the equivalent circuit topology, and calculate the initial value of the system state quantity after forced commutation at time t;

[0006] Step 2: Check whether a switch action occurs in the next time step of the time t. If an action occurs, locate the switch time t. d, if no action is taken, the subsequent steps are skipped and the next time step is calculated;

[0007] Step 3: Linearly interpolate from t and t+Δt to t d At this moment, the value obtained is the state quantity at the moment of natural phase change of the switch td-;

[0008] Step 4: Use the backward Euler method to integrate to t in two consecutive steps with a half-step size of Δt / 2 d +Δt / 2 and t d +Δt moment;

[0009] Step 5: By t d +Δt / 2 and t d +Δt time extrapolated to t d+ Perform numerical oscillation correction at all times and detect (t d +, t d +Δt) whether there is a switching action; if not, then t d and t d +Δt time to obtain the state quantity at time t+Δt to achieve resynchronization, and then proceed to the next time step calculation, otherwise go to step (3).

[0010] On the other hand, it also relates to a computer-readable storage medium storing computer instructions, which can implement the above-mentioned electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithm when executed.

[0011] Optionally, in step (2), the principle of implicit trapezoidal integration method is specifically:

[0012] The numerical integration method is the first issue to be considered in the EMTP program. The implicit integration method is insensitive to changes in the integration step size and is more stable than the explicit method. It is the mainstream algorithm for electromagnetic transient simulation. The implicit trapezoidal method is a commonly used implicit integration method with absolute stability. The implicit trapezoidal method integration formula is:

[0013]

[0014] Among them, x represents the system state quantity, x i 、x i+1 Represent the state quantity of the current moment and the next moment respectively; y represents the non-state quantity of the system, y(x i )、y(x i+1 ) respectively correspond to the non-state quantity of the system at the current moment and the next moment, y'=f(x,y); R i is the truncation error of the implicit trapezoidal method integration in the i-th step; h is the integration step length.

[0015] The implicit trapezoidal method truncation error is R i =O(h 3), with high accuracy. Considering the characteristics of electromagnetic transient simulation and the need for simulation calculation accuracy, the implicit trapezoidal integration method is used as the main numerical integration method.

[0016] Optionally, in step (3), the linear interpolation calculation method is specifically:

[0017] Linear interpolation is used to accurately locate the switching time point. The principle is as follows:

[0018]

[0019] Among them, x represents the independent variable at the current calculation time, x i 、x i+1 They represent the independent variable at the previous moment and the independent variable at the next moment respectively; f(x) represents the size of the dependent variable corresponding to the independent variable x, f(x i )、f(x i+1 ) represent the independent variable x i 、x i+1 Corresponding to the size of the dependent variable; R x is the truncation error caused by the interpolation algorithm.

[0020] The linear interpolation method is efficient, effective, and simple to implement. It assumes that the system characteristics between two adjacent switching actions can be fitted by a linear relationship. In the fixed-step EMTP simulation system, the simulation calculation and solution at each moment can be written in the form of the basic electromagnetic transient solution equation I=GU, that is, the simulation calculation at each time step is a linear equation, which meets the conditions for applying linear interpolation fitting. At the same time, the electromagnetic transient simulation step size is small, and the error is acceptable when the step size is small. The linear interpolation method is suitable for application in electromagnetic transient simulation, has sufficient numerical accuracy, and does not affect the stability of the algorithm.

[0021] Optionally, in step (5), the resynchronization principle is specifically as follows:

[0022] Fixed-step electromagnetic transient simulation requires outputting calculation results at the full-step time point. The resynchronization process refers to the technology that synchronizes the simulation time point after interpolation with the original time series while ensuring the accuracy of the algorithm through strategy adjustment, because the simulation time series obtained after interpolation does not correspond to the original time series, so as to ensure that the simulation always runs at the full-step time point. For example, when the interpolation algorithm locates t d After the moment, it is necessary to resynchronize the simulation time to return to the full-step time point, and then simulate the original full-step time series.

[0023] Consider the switching instant t obtained by interpolation d The state quantity at the moment is integrated for a time step Δt to t d +Δt time, then according to t d Time and t dThe state quantities at time +Δt are interpolated for the second time to obtain the state quantities at time t, and then the simulation calculation time series is restored to the original sequence.

[0024] The beneficial effects of the present invention are as follows: compared with the traditional interpolation algorithm, the improved interpolation algorithm takes into account the order of multiple switch actions, and the simulation accuracy of multiple switch actions is improved; the re-initialization at the moment of forced switch action is taken into account, and the error and numerical oscillation introduced by the sudden change of the state quantity during forced switching of the switch are reduced, and the accuracy of the algorithm is improved without increasing too much calculation; the resynchronization processing is added, and the applicability in the fixed-step EMTP simulation is higher. The interpolation algorithm proposed in the present invention will greatly improve the simulation accuracy and efficiency of electromagnetic transient simulation, and realize the consideration of simulation characteristics. It plays a guiding role in the research of future electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithms, and is of great significance to the in-depth exploration of electromagnetic transient simulation acceleration methods. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0025] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the method flow of the present invention.

[0026] Figure 2 It is a schematic diagram of the electromagnetic transient simulation model of the Boost chopper circuit of the present invention.

[0027] Figure 3 The traditional linear interpolation, half interpolation and improved interpolation under the simulation step size of 1μs correspond to the low-voltage side power supply output power, point A voltage and switch S 1 Current waveform comparison chart.

[0028] Figure 4 The traditional linear interpolation, half interpolation and improved interpolation under the simulation step size of 5μs correspond to the low-voltage side power supply output power, point A voltage and switch S 1 Current waveform comparison chart.

[0029] Figure 5 The traditional linear interpolation, half interpolation and improved interpolation under the simulation step size of 10μs correspond to the low-voltage side power supply output power, point A voltage and switch S 1 Current waveform comparison chart.

[0030] Figure 6 The traditional linear interpolation, half interpolation and improved interpolation under 50μs simulation step size correspond to the low-voltage side power supply output power, point A voltage and switch S 1 Current waveform comparison chart. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0031] The technical solution of the invention is described in detail below with reference to the accompanying drawings.

[0032] The present invention discloses an electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation method considering multiple switching actions and reinitialization, such as Figure 1 As shown, the following steps are included:

[0033] Step (1) confirms whether forced commutation occurs at this moment according to the control signal at time t. If it occurs, according to the conservation of capacitor charge and inductor flux, at the switching moment, the inductor is equivalent to a current source, and the capacitor is equivalent to a voltage source. The equivalent power supply value is the value of the state quantity at the moment before switching; but if forced commutation directly disconnects the inductor branch or short-circuits the two ends of the capacitor, the equivalent power supply value should be 0. Change the switch state at the switching moment and reconstruct the equivalent circuit topology, and calculate the initial value of the system state quantity after forced commutation at time t.

[0034] Step (2) Use the implicit trapezoidal method to integrate a step from time t to t+Δt, and detect whether a switching action occurs at (t, t+Δt). If an action occurs, locate the switching time t d If no action is taken, the subsequent steps are skipped and the next time step is calculated.

[0035] Step (3) Linearly interpolate from time t and t+Δt to t d The obtained value is the instant when the switch changes phase naturally, t d- Moment state quantity.

[0036] Step (4) uses the backward Euler method with a half-step length of Δt / 2 to integrate to t in two consecutive steps d +Δt / 2 and t d +Δt moment.

[0037] Step (5) is performed by t d +Δt / 2 and t d +Δt time extrapolated to t d+ Perform numerical oscillation correction at all times and detect (t d+ , t d +Δt) to see if there is any other switching action. If there is no switching action, it is determined by t d and t d +Δt time to obtain the state quantity at time t+Δt to achieve resynchronization, and then proceed to the next time step calculation, otherwise go to step (3).

[0038] Step (11) reinitialization correction is specifically as follows:

[0039] The purpose of reinitialization is to eliminate the error and numerical oscillation introduced by the sudden change of state quantity when the switch is forced to commutate. Forced commutation means that the forced device performs commutation according to the control signal, which will cause sudden changes in the state variables in the system. When designing the algorithm, the initial value of the system state quantity must be recalculated, otherwise there will be certain errors in the simulation results.

[0040] According to the conservation of inductor flux and capacitor charge, the inductor current and capacitor voltage do not change suddenly at the moment of forced commutation. Therefore, the capacitor and inductor are equivalent to voltage source and current source respectively at the moment of commutation, and the values ​​are the values ​​of the state quantity before switching; but if the forced commutation directly disconnects the inductor branch or shorts the two ends of the capacitor, the value of the equivalent power supply should be 0. This equivalent circuit can be pre-analyzed inside each submodule, and the state quantity at the moment after the switch action can be directly calculated in the simulation. Then, based on the full circuit topology, the initial value of the state quantity of the whole system at the moment after switching is obtained, which is the initial value of the state quantity used for the simulation calculation and solution in the next time step.

[0041] The principle of implicit trapezoidal integration method in step (21) is as follows:

[0042] The numerical integration method is the first issue to be considered in the EMTP program. The implicit integration method is insensitive to changes in the integration step size and is more stable than the explicit method. It is the mainstream algorithm for electromagnetic transient simulation. The implicit trapezoidal method is a commonly used implicit integration method with absolute stability. The implicit trapezoidal method integration formula is:

[0043]

[0044] Among them, x represents the system state quantity, x i 、x i+1 Represent the state quantity of the current moment and the next moment respectively; y represents the non-state quantity of the system, y(x i )、y(x i+1 ) respectively correspond to the non-state quantity of the system at the current moment and the next moment, y'=f(x,y); R i is the truncation error of the implicit trapezoidal method integration in the i-th step; h is the integration step length.

[0045] The implicit trapezoidal method truncation error is R i =O(h 3 ), with high accuracy. Considering the characteristics of electromagnetic transient simulation and the need for simulation calculation accuracy, the implicit trapezoidal integration method is used as the main numerical integration method.

[0046] The linear interpolation calculation method in step (31) is specifically as follows:

[0047] Linear interpolation is used to accurately locate the switching time point. The principle is as follows:

[0048]

[0049] Among them, x represents the independent variable at the current calculation time, x i 、x i+1 They represent the independent variable at the previous moment and the independent variable at the next moment respectively; f(x) represents the size of the dependent variable corresponding to the independent variable x, f(x i )、f(x i+1) represent the independent variable x i 、x i+1 Corresponding to the size of the dependent variable; R x is the truncation error caused by the interpolation algorithm.

[0050] The linear interpolation method is efficient, effective, and simple to implement. It assumes that the system characteristics between two adjacent switching actions can be fitted by a linear relationship. In the fixed-step EMTP simulation system, the simulation calculation and solution at each moment can be written in the form of the basic electromagnetic transient solution equation I=GU, that is, the simulation calculation at each time step is a linear equation, which meets the conditions for applying linear interpolation fitting. At the same time, the electromagnetic transient simulation step size is small, and the error is acceptable when the step size is small. The linear interpolation method is suitable for application in electromagnetic transient simulation, has sufficient numerical accuracy, and does not affect the stability of the algorithm.

[0051] The specific principle of resynchronization in step (51) is as follows:

[0052] Fixed-step electromagnetic transient simulation requires outputting calculation results at the full-step time point. The resynchronization process refers to the technology that synchronizes the simulation time point after interpolation with the original time series while ensuring the accuracy of the algorithm through strategy adjustment, because the simulation time series obtained after interpolation does not correspond to the original time series, so as to ensure that the simulation always runs at the full-step time point. For example, when the interpolation algorithm locates t d After the moment, it is necessary to resynchronize the simulation time to return to the full-step time point, and then simulate the original full-step time series.

[0053] Consider the switching instant t obtained by interpolation d The state quantity at the moment is integrated for a time step Δt to t d +Δt time, then according to t d Time and t d The state quantities at time +Δt are interpolated for the second time to obtain the state quantities at time t, and then the simulation calculation time series is restored to the original sequence.

[0054] The following compares three different electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithm waveforms to illustrate the technical advantages of the electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithm that takes into account multiple switching actions and reinitialization.

[0055] A simulation model is built for a boost chopper system. The relevant parameters of the boost chopper are shown in Table 1. The electromagnetic transient simulation model of the boost chopper circuit is shown in Table 1. Figure 2 The simulation waveforms of traditional linear interpolation, semi-interpolation in PSCAD and improved interpolation are shown in Figure 2. Figure 3-Figure 6 As shown, Figure 3 The output power of the low-voltage power supply, the voltage at point A, and the switch S under the simulation step size of 1μs 1 Current comparison, Figure 4 This is a waveform comparison chart under a simulation step size of 5μs. Figure 5 This is a waveform comparison chart under a simulation step size of 10μs. Figure 6 This is a waveform comparison chart under a simulation step size of 50μs.

[0056] Table 1 Boost chopper circuit parameters

[0057] Boost chopper related parameters Parameter size <![CDATA[Magnitude U of the DC voltage source on the low-voltage side dc1 (V)]]> 360 <![CDATA[Internal resistance r of the DC voltage source on the low-voltage side dc1 (Ω)]]> 0.001 <![CDATA[DC load on the high voltage side, R load (Ω)]]> 5 <![CDATA[Low-voltage side voltage stabilizing capacitor C dc1 (mF)]]> 5 <![CDATA[High-voltage side voltage stabilizing capacitor C dc2 (mF)]]> 5 Freewheeling inductance L(mH) 2 Duty cycle D 0.64 <![CDATA[Carrier frequency f T (Hz)]]> 5000

[0058] Depend on Figure 3-Figure 6 It can be seen that under a larger simulation step size, the waveform of the improved interpolation algorithm (thin solid line) is closer to the waveform under a small simulation step size than the waveform of the semi-interpolation algorithm (thick dotted line) and the traditional linear interpolation algorithm (thick dashed line). The electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithm proposed in this paper that considers multiple switching actions and re-initialization can improve the simulation accuracy of the simulation algorithm and further promote the realization of a balance between simulation accuracy and efficiency. Figure 3-Figure 6 It can be seen that the simulation results of the proposed interpolation algorithm and the semi-interpolation algorithm are basically the same in steady state, which illustrates the effectiveness of the method proposed in the embodiment of the present application; and the change of state quantity at the state switching moment is more accurate. In the above system, under the premise of not affecting the simulation speed, the electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation algorithm proposed in this paper considering multiple switching actions and reinitialization has higher accuracy, and the simulation efficiency has not decreased significantly, achieving a balance between simulation accuracy and efficiency.

[0059] In some examples of the present invention, there is also a computer-readable storage medium storing instructions. When the instructions are executed, the electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation method in any of the above examples can be implemented. More specifically, the instructions can be a computer-readable language. The above-mentioned computer can be a general-purpose computer device or a special-purpose computer device. In a specific implementation, the computer can be a desktop computer, a portable computer, a network server, a PDA (Personal Digital Assistant), a mobile phone, a tablet computer, a wireless terminal device, a communication device or an embedded device. The storage medium can be any available medium that can be accessed by the computer or a data storage device such as a server or a data center that includes one or more available media. For example, the storage medium is, for example, but not limited to, a magnetic medium (for example, a floppy disk, a hard disk, a tape), an optical medium (for example, a digital versatile disc (Digital Versatile Disc, DVD)), or a semiconductor medium (for example, a solid-state drive (SSD)).

[0060] The above shows and describes the basic principles, main features and advantages of the present invention. Those skilled in the art should understand that the present invention is not limited to the above embodiments, and the above embodiments and descriptions are only for explaining the principles of the present invention. Without departing from the spirit and scope of the present invention, the present invention may have various changes and improvements, and these changes and improvements all fall within the scope of the present invention to be protected.

Claims

1. An electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation method, The following steps are involved: Step 1: According to the control signal at time t, confirm whether forced commutation occurs at this moment. If it occurs, the inductor is equivalent to a current source and the capacitor is equivalent to a voltage source at the switching moment. The equivalent power supply value is the value of the state quantity at the moment before switching; change the switch state at the switching moment and rebuild the equivalent circuit topology, and calculate the initial value of the system state quantity after forced commutation at time t; Step 2: Detect whether a switch action occurs in the next time step of the moment t. If an action occurs, locate the switch moment td. If no action occurs, skip the subsequent steps and proceed to the next time step calculation. Step 3: Linearly interpolate from t and t+Δt to t d The obtained value is the instant when the switch changes phase naturally, t d - Momentary state quantity; Step 4: Use the backward Euler method to integrate to t in two consecutive steps with a half-step size of Δt / 2 d +Δt / 2 and t d +Δt moment; Step 5: By t d +Δt / 2 and t d +Δt time extrapolated to t d+ Perform numerical oscillation correction at all times and detect (t d +, t d +Δt) whether there is a switching action; if not, then t d and t d +Δt time to obtain the state quantity at time t+Δt to achieve resynchronization, and then perform the next time step calculation, otherwise go to step 3.

2. The electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation method according to claim 1, Features: If the forced commutation in step 1 directly disconnects the inductor branch or short-circuits the two ends of the capacitor, the equivalent power supply value is 0; the equivalent circuit can be pre-analyzed inside each sub-module, and the state quantity at the moment after the switch action can be directly calculated in the simulation; then based on the full circuit topology, the initial value of the state quantity of the entire system at the moment after the switching is obtained, that is, the initial value of the state quantity used for the simulation calculation and solution in the next time step.

3. The electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation method according to claim 1, Features: The implicit trapezoidal method is used for integration to calculate the time step: The implicit trapezoidal method integration formula is: Among them, x represents the system state quantity, x i 、x i+1 Represent the state quantity of the current moment and the next moment respectively; y represents the non-state quantity of the system, y(x i )、y(x i+1 ) respectively correspond to the non-state quantity of the system at the current moment and the next moment, y'=f(x,y); R i is the truncation error of the implicit trapezoidal method integration in the i-th step; h is the integration step length.

4. The electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation method according to claim 1, Features: In step 3, the linear interpolation calculation method is specifically as follows: Linear interpolation is used to accurately locate the switching time point. The principle is as follows: Among them, x represents the independent variable at the current calculation time, x i 、x i+1 They represent the independent variable at the previous moment and the independent variable at the next moment respectively; f(x) represents the size of the dependent variable corresponding to the independent variable x, f(x i )、f(x i+1 ) represent the independent variable x i 、x i+1 Corresponding to the size of the dependent variable; R x is the truncation error caused by the interpolation algorithm.

5. The electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation method according to claim 1, Features: In step 5, the resynchronization step is: When the interpolation algorithm locates t d After the moment, it is necessary to resynchronize the simulation moment to return to the full-step time point, and then simulate the original full-step time series; Consider the switching instant t obtained by interpolation d The state quantity at the moment is integrated for a time step Δt to t d +Δt time, and then according to t d Time and t d The state quantities at time +Δt are interpolated for the second time to obtain the state quantities at time t, and then the simulation calculation time series is restored to the original sequence.

6. A computer-readable storage medium storing computer instructions, It is characterized in that When the instruction is executed, the electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation method described in any one of claims 1 to 5 can be implemented.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Electromagnetic transient simulation interpolation method of state variable oriented nodal analysis combination frame

    CN103455668A

  • Micro-grid real-time simulation method for processing multi-break switches of power systems

    CN106407492A

  • Electromagnetic transient simulation method, device and equipment considering occurrence of multiple events

    CN112487629A

  • Electromagnetic transient analysis method and device for switching circuit

    WO2018058869A1