An adaptive multi-scale coupling method for analyzing thermal-hydraulic characteristics of natural circulation systems

Through the adaptive multi-scale coupling method, combined with the coupling calculation of one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs, the initial flow rate and iterative step length are optimized, and the problem of low 3D flow feature simulation and calculation efficiency in thermal hydraulic characteristics analysis of natural circulation systems is solved, achieving rapid , accurate simulation and efficient calculation process.

CN114201871BActive Publication Date: 2024-12-03NORTHEAST DIANLI UNIVERSITY
View PDF 3 Cites 0 Cited by

Patent Information

Application Number
CN202111494309.7
Authority / Receiving Office
CN · China
Patent Type
Patents(China)
Current Assignee / Owner
Filing Date
2021-12-08
Publication Date
2024-12-03
Estimated Expiration
2041-12-08

AI Technical Summary

Technical Problem

The existing thermal hydraulic characteristics analysis method of natural circulation systems. When simulating complex structures such as reactor heat sources and tube heat exchangers, traditional one-dimensional analysis cannot capture the three-dimensional flow characteristics, and the coupling calculation of three-dimensional programs requires a huge grid quantity. This leads to high time cost, the convergence of fixed iteration steps is unstable, and the initial flow velocity setting depends on experimental experience, affecting the calculation results.

Method used

Adaptive multi-scale coupling method is adopted, through the coupling calculation of one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs, the variance of outlet temperature and voltage drop calculated by the three-dimensional program is used as the convergence standard, and the initial flow rate is adaptively optimized to achieve fast and accurate one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs. Converge and improve computational efficiency through adaptive iterative step length adjustment.

Benefits of technology

It realizes rapid and accurate simulation of thermal hydraulic characteristics of natural circulation systems, reduces calculation time cost, avoids the initial flow rate setting dependence on experimental experience, improves the adaptability and universality of calculations, and can accurately analyze the three-dimensionality of complex heat sources. Flow and temperature fields provide guidance for safety design.

✦ Generated by Eureka AI based on patent content.

Smart Images

  • Figure CN114201871B_ABST
    Figure CN114201871B_ABST
Patent Text Reader

Abstract

The present invention is an adaptive multi-scale coupling method for analyzing the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of a natural circulation system, and is characterized in that it includes establishing a natural circulation system, optimizing the initial flow rate, designing an adaptive convergence criterion for interactive parameters, and constructing an adaptive convergence standard function. The initial flow rate is optimized using the quantitative relationship between the driving pressure head and the total resistance pressure drop of the natural circulation system; the variance of the interactive parameters of the one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs is used as the convergence standard for judging whether the calculation parameters of the three-dimensional program have reached a stable or near-steady state, and an adaptive function for collecting the variance is constructed based on the coupled flow rate; the convergence standard is adaptively adjusted according to the interactive flow rates of the one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs, so that the coupled program converges to an accurate value. The present invention has the advantages of strong adaptive ability, high efficiency, ease of operation, and high robustness. It is particularly suitable for analyzing the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of a natural circulation system with a complex structural heat source.
Need to check novelty before this filing date? Find Prior Art

Description

Technical Field

[0001] The present invention relates to the field of flow and heat exchange numerical calculation, and is an adaptive multi-scale coupling method for analyzing the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of a natural circulation system, and is particularly suitable for quantitative analysis of the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of a natural circulation system with one-dimensional and three-dimensional flow characteristics. Background Art

[0002] As one of the main principles of passive safety technology, natural circulation is widely used in fields such as energy and chemical industry. In order to further improve the safety of nuclear power plants, third-generation nuclear power plants widely adopt passive design concepts. Due to the advantages of simple structure and good inherent safety of natural circulation systems, natural circulation passive safety systems are widely used in third-generation nuclear power plants. Therefore, the study of thermal-hydraulic characteristics based on natural circulation passive safety systems is crucial to the safety design of nuclear power plants.

[0003] At present, technicians in this field mainly use one-dimensional analysis programs based on the lumped parameter method to study the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of natural circulation systems. This program has the advantages of fast flow rate calculation and flexible parameter adjustment. However, for heat sources with complex structures, such as reactor heat sources and shell-and-tube heat exchangers, there are significant three-dimensional flow characteristics inside them, such as secondary flow, vortex, etc. Therefore, it is impossible to simulate the complex three-dimensional flow field inside them using traditional one-dimensional analysis programs. At the same time, if only a three-dimensional program is used to simulate the entire natural circulation system, a huge amount of grids is required, and the time cost is extremely high. Therefore, the present invention combines the advantages of one-dimensional program and three-dimensional program software, develops an adaptive coupling calculation method of one-dimensional program and three-dimensional program, and realizes the rapid and accurate simulation of the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of natural circulation systems with one-dimensional and three-dimensional flow characteristics, which can provide researchers with a valuable research tool.

[0004] In the existing literature, there are few studies on the adaptive multi-scale coupling of one-dimensional programs and three-dimensional programs. Among them, Zhang Yinxing et al. proposed a multi-scale coupling method for one-dimensional user programs and three-dimensional programs STAR-CCM+ (Zhang Yinxing, Gao Puzhen, He Xiaoqiang, et al. Coupling method of STAR-CCM+ and one-dimensional user programs [J]. Journal of Harbin Engineering University, 2020, 41(11): 1669-1674.). This method describes a data interaction method between one-dimensional user programs and three-dimensional programs STAR-CCM+. By presetting a fixed number of iterations in STAR-CCM+ to stabilize its calculation parameters, data is then interacted with the one-dimensional user program. However, in actual applications, it is found that when the fixed number of iterations is too large, the time for coupling convergence will increase significantly. When the fixed number of iterations is too small, the interaction parameters do not reach a steady state or close to a steady state, and data interaction will cause the calculation of the coupling program to diverge. In addition, this method has high requirements for the setting of the initial flow rate of the one-dimensional user program and needs to rely on experimental experience. The coupling calculation can only converge when the deviation between the initial flow rate and the stable value of the natural circulation flow rate under actual working conditions is small. In summary, the one-dimensional and three-dimensional multi-scale coupling methods using fixed iteration steps have the disadvantages of poor adaptability, the initial flow rate affecting the convergence ability of the coupling program, and dependence on experimental experience. Summary of the invention

[0005] In view of the limitations of the one-dimensional and three-dimensional program coupling methods based on fixed iteration steps in the prior art, the purpose of the present invention is to propose a scientific, reasonable, adaptive and high-application-value adaptive multi-scale coupling method for analyzing the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of natural circulation systems. The method of the present invention can achieve rapid and accurate convergence of one-dimensional and three-dimensional coupling programs under arbitrary initial flow rates. At the same time, the method can also be used to calculate and analyze the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of natural circulation systems containing other complex heat sources.

[0006] The technical solution adopted to achieve the purpose of the present invention is an adaptive multi-scale coupling method for analyzing the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of a natural circulation system, which is characterized in that it includes the following steps:

[0007] 1) Establish the one-dimensional flow resistance and heat transfer calculation program of the first pipeline, the second pipeline, the third pipeline and the fourth pipeline of the natural circulation system and the three-dimensional flow and heat transfer calculation program of the heat source;

[0008] 2) Let the initial velocity be v i , and v i As the inlet velocity boundary condition of the three-dimensional calculation program, the pressure drop ΔP and outlet temperature T of the heat source are calculated using the three-dimensional program. out ;

[0009] 3) Calculate the outlet temperature T obtained by the three-dimensional program out and pressure drop ΔP reThe convergence criterion δ is the heat source outlet temperature T calculated by the three-dimensional program. out and heat source pressure drop ΔP re , calculate the variance based on the historical values ​​of n consecutive iterations and use it as the parameter convergence criterion for the heat source outlet temperature and pressure drop. Specifically, and I is the three-dimensional program iteration step, n is the number of interval iterations;

[0010] 4) When the outlet temperature T out and pressure drop ΔP re The variance of is less than the convergence criterion δ, and the outlet temperature T calculated by the three-dimensional program is out and pressure drop ΔP re Passed to the one-dimensional calculation program and calculate the driving pressure head ΔP d And the total resistance pressure drop ΔP z ;

[0011] 5) When ΔP d ≤ΔP z / 2, for the initial flow velocity v i Optimize according to the driving pressure head ΔP d And the total resistance pressure drop ΔP z The size of the initial flow velocity v i Optimize, the specific optimization method is:

[0012] For two-phase operation, when |(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )|<0.5, v i =v i [1+(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )]; when |(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )|≥0.5, v i =0.5v i .

[0013] For single-phase working condition calculation, according to the heat balance relationship Q = ρvAc p,ave ΔT, Q is the heat source power, ρ is the heat source inlet density, A is the flow area, c p,ave is the average constant pressure specific volume of the heat source, ΔT is the temperature difference between the heat source inlet and outlet. The initial velocity is optimized based on the subcooling degree of the heat source outlet fluid of 20℃, specifically: v i =Q / [ρAc p,ave (Tsat -T in -20)], and return to step 3), when ΔP d >ΔP z / 2, according to the formula v i+1 =v i [1+(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )], and get the updated flow velocity v i+1 ;

[0014] 6) According to the flow rate v i and v i+1 Update the convergence criterion δ in step 4), specifically δ = C | v i+1 -v i | / max(v i+1 ,v i ), C is a constant, i is the number of data interactions, max() is the maximum value function, and δ adaptively updates the convergence criterion according to the interaction flow rate of the one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs to achieve the convergence of the coupled program to the exact value;

[0015] 7) Update the flow rate v i+1 Pass it to the three-dimensional calculation program and go to step 3) until v i With v i+1 Similarly, the adaptive multi-scale coupling of one-dimensional program and three-dimensional program is completed.

[0016] The beneficial effects of the adaptive multi-scale coupling method for analyzing the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of a natural circulation system of the present invention are:

[0017] 1. An efficient and accurate adaptive multi-scale coupling method of one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs was established to calculate and analyze the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of natural circulation systems with complex heat sources;

[0018] 2. Based on the coupled flow velocity, an adaptive criterion for the convergence of the calculation parameters of the three-dimensional program is constructed, and an adaptive coupling calculation method for the one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs is proposed to achieve the adaptive iterative convergence of the coupling program, thereby improving the efficiency of the coupling program while ensuring accuracy;

[0019] 3. An initial flow rate optimization method for one-dimensional and three-dimensional coupling programs is proposed. Under single-phase conditions, the initial flow rate is optimized according to the heat source heat balance equation; under two-phase conditions, the flow rate is optimized according to the binary strategy to avoid the divergence of coupling calculations caused by unreasonable initial flow rate settings;

[0020] 4. It can be used for quantitative analysis of the flow and heat transfer characteristics of natural circulation systems under any working conditions, can replace the complex process of artificial experimental measurement, and can obtain the three-dimensional flow field and temperature field of the coolant in the complex structure heat source with three-dimensional flow characteristics in real time, and can provide guidance for the optimal design of the natural circulation system;

[0021] 5. The setting of the initial speed does not rely on experimental experience and is not affected by the initial parameters. It is applicable to both beginners in this field and those outside the field, and has strong universality;

[0022] 6. The method is scientific and reasonable, has strong adaptability and high application value. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS

[0023] Figure 1 It is a schematic diagram of the structure of a natural circulation system;

[0024] Figure 2 It is a flowchart of the adaptive coupling between the one-dimensional user program and the three-dimensional program;

[0025] Figure 3 The results of the present invention are compared with the experimental results;

[0026] Figure 4 Comparison results between the fixed iteration step method and the method of the present invention;

[0027] Figure 5 This is the convergence result of the coupled flow velocity for the petal-shaped fuel assembly;

[0028] Figure 6 It is the velocity vector diagram of the central section of the petal-shaped fuel assembly;

[0029] Figure 7 Temperature contour diagram of the central cross section of a petal-shaped fuel assembly. DETAILED DESCRIPTION

[0030] The essential contents of the present invention are further described below in conjunction with the drawings and embodiments, but the contents of the present invention are not limited thereto.

[0031] Figure 1 A schematic diagram of the structure of a natural circulation system is shown, including: a heat source 1, a first pipeline 2, a cold source 3, a second pipeline 4, a third pipeline 6, a preheater 7 and a fourth pipeline 8 are connected, and a stabilizer 5 is arranged on the second pipeline 4 and the third pipeline 6.

[0032] Reference Figure 2 The present invention provides an adaptive multi-scale coupling method for analyzing the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of a natural circulation system, comprising the following steps:

[0033] 1) Establish Figure 1The one-dimensional flow resistance and heat transfer calculation program of the first pipeline 2, the second pipeline 4, the third pipeline 6 and the fourth pipeline 8 of the natural circulation system and the three-dimensional flow and heat transfer calculation program of the heat source 1;

[0034] 2) Let the initial velocity be v i , and v i As the inlet velocity boundary condition of the three-dimensional calculation program, the pressure drop ΔP and outlet temperature T of the heat source 1 are calculated using the three-dimensional program. out ;

[0035] 3) Calculate the outlet temperature T obtained by the three-dimensional program out and pressure drop ΔP re The convergence criterion δ is:

[0036] The outlet temperature T of heat source 1 calculated by the 3D program out and heat source 1 pressure drop ΔP re , calculate the variance based on the historical values ​​of n consecutive iterations, and use it as the parameter convergence criterion for the outlet temperature and pressure drop of heat source 1. Specifically, and I is the three-dimensional program iteration step, n is the number of interval iterations;

[0037] 4) When the outlet temperature T out and pressure drop ΔP re The variance of is less than the convergence criterion δ, and the outlet temperature T calculated by the three-dimensional program is out and pressure drop ΔP re Passed to the one-dimensional calculation program and calculate the driving pressure head ΔP d And the total resistance pressure drop ΔP z ;

[0038] 5) When ΔP d ≤ΔP z / 2, for the initial flow velocity v i To optimize:

[0039] According to the driving pressure head ΔP d And the total resistance pressure drop ΔP z The size of the initial flow velocity v i Optimize, the specific optimization method is:

[0040] For two-phase operation, when |(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )|<0.5, v i =v i [1+(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z)]; when |(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )|≥0.5, v i =0.5v i .

[0041] For single-phase working condition calculation, according to the heat balance relationship Q = ρvAc p,ave ΔT, Q is the power of heat source 1, ρ is the inlet density of heat source 1, A is the flow area, c p,ave is the average constant pressure specific volume of heat source 1, and ΔT is the inlet and outlet temperature difference of heat source 1. The initial velocity is optimized based on the subcooling degree of the fluid at the outlet of heat source 1 being 20℃, specifically: v i =Q / [ρAc p,ave (T sat -T in -20)], and return to step 3), when ΔP d >ΔP z / 2, according to the formula v i+1 =v i [1+(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )], and get the updated flow velocity v i+1 ;

[0042] 6) According to the flow rate v i and v i+1 Update the convergence criterion δ in step 4):

[0043] The adaptive convergence standard expression is established according to the interaction flow rate, specifically δ=C|v i+1 -v i | / max(v i+1 ,v i ), C is a constant, i is the number of data interactions, max() is the maximum value function, and δ adaptively updates the convergence criterion according to the interaction flow rate of the one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs to achieve the convergence of the coupled program to the exact value;

[0044] 7) Update the flow rate v i+1 Pass it to the three-dimensional calculation program and go to step 3) until v i With v i+1 Similarly, the adaptive multi-scale coupling of one-dimensional program and three-dimensional program is completed.

[0045] Verification 1: Experimental verification

[0046] The correctness of the present invention is verified by the flow measurement experiment of the natural circulation system containing 3×3 rod bundle channels under single-phase conditions. Figure 3 This is a comparison chart of the coupling calculation results and experimental results of the invention. Figure 3 It can be seen that the results obtained by the present invention are consistent with the experimental measurement results. Under the same geometric and thermal parameters, the maximum deviation between the natural circulation flow calculated by the one-dimensional and three-dimensional adaptive coupling program of the present invention and the experimental results is within 10%. This shows that the present invention can accurately simulate the natural circulation flow under natural circulation.

[0047] Verification 2: Comparative verification between the fixed iterative step method and the method of the present invention

[0048] During the data transfer process between the one-dimensional program and the three-dimensional program, the fixed iterative step method given in the literature is used to perform one-dimensional and three-dimensional coupled numerical simulations of the natural circulation system under the same geometric and thermal parameters. Since the convergence of the existing literature methods is greatly affected by the initial velocity, it is necessary to obtain the minimum fixed iterative step that satisfies the coupling convergence through the algorithm. The experimental conditions are: the operating pressure is 0.3MPa, the initial velocity is 0.25m / s, the heating power is 14kW, the heating section is a 3×3 rod bundle channel, and the inlet subcooling is 50°C. Under the condition that convergence can be met, the trial algorithm is used to obtain the minimum iterative step required for two adjacent data interactions of the fixed iterative step method, which is 450 steps. The adaptive coupling calculation method proposed in the present invention can adaptively change the step size according to the coupling speed. Figure 4 The figure is a comparison between the fixed iteration step calculation method and the method of the present invention. The three-dimensional geometry and numerical model used in the above two methods are the same. The time consumed by the coupled calculation is mainly in the three-dimensional calculation. Therefore, the three-dimensional program calculation iteration step is positively correlated with the actual running time. Figure 3 It can be seen that the fixed iteration step calculation method requires 6151 steps to complete the coupling convergence. Then, the method of the present invention only requires 656 steps to achieve the coupling simulation convergence. The one-dimensional and three-dimensional coupling convergence speed of the method of the present invention is 9.376 times that of the fixed iteration step method, which fully demonstrates the high efficiency of the present invention. In addition, the present invention is not only applicable to the one-dimensional and three-dimensional coupling calculation of the natural circulation system containing the rod bundle heat source component, but also applicable to the natural circulation system containing other complex heat sources (such as petal-shaped heat source components, etc.).

[0049] Embodiment 1:

[0050] In order to further verify the universality of the present invention, the present invention is used to perform one-dimensional and three-dimensional coupled simulations on the flow characteristics of petal-shaped reactor fuel assemblies under natural circulation, wherein the operating pressure is 0.3MPa, the heating power is 2kW, and the inlet subcooling is 50°C. Figure 5 The natural circulation velocity convergence curve of the coupled calculation method of the present invention is given. Figure 5It can be seen that the initial assumed flow velocity is 0.15 m / s. Through one-dimensional and three-dimensional coupling calculations, the final converged flow velocity is 0.181 m / s, and the natural circulation flow of the system is obtained.

[0051] In addition, the petal-shaped heat source 3D program simulation results are as follows Figure 6 and Figure 7 As shown. Figure 6 It can be seen from the figure that due to the spiral geometry of the petal-shaped rod bundle channel, the transverse mixing of the coolant is enhanced, which can enhance the heat transfer. This results in a lower coolant temperature in the central sub-channel; the coolant flow rate in the side channel is lower and the heat transfer capacity is weaker, resulting in a higher coolant temperature in the side channel, such as Figure 7 shown.

[0052] The specific implementation of the present invention is only an example, but the application scope of the present invention is not limited thereto. Any other implementations derived from the technical solution of the present invention by any person familiar with the technology in this field also belong to the scope of protection of the claims of the present invention.

Claims

1. An adaptive multi-scale coupling method for analyzing the thermal-hydraulic characteristics of a natural circulation system, characterized in that: It includes the following steps: 1) Establish the one-dimensional flow resistance and heat transfer calculation program of the first pipeline, the second pipeline, the third pipeline and the fourth pipeline of the natural circulation system and the three-dimensional flow and heat transfer calculation program of the heat source; 2) Let the initial velocity be v i , and v i As the inlet velocity boundary condition of the three-dimensional calculation program, the pressure drop ΔP and outlet temperature T of the heat source are calculated using the three-dimensional program. out ; 3) Calculate the outlet temperature T obtained by the three-dimensional program out and pressure drop ΔP re The convergence criterion δ is the heat source outlet temperature T calculated by the three-dimensional program. out and heat source pressure drop ΔP re , calculate the variance based on the historical values ​​of n consecutive iterations and use it as the parameter convergence criterion for the heat source outlet temperature and pressure drop. Specifically, and I is the three-dimensional program iteration step, n is the number of interval iterations; 4) When the outlet temperature T out and pressure drop ΔP re The variance of is less than the convergence criterion δ, and the outlet temperature T calculated by the three-dimensional program is out and pressure drop ΔP re Passed to the one-dimensional calculation program and calculate the driving pressure head ΔP d And the total resistance pressure drop ΔP z ; 5) When ΔP d ≤ΔP z / 2, for the initial flow velocity v i Optimize according to the driving pressure head ΔP d And the total resistance pressure drop ΔP z The size of the initial flow velocity v i Optimize, the specific optimization method is: For two-phase operation, when |(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )|<0.5, v i =v i [1+(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )]; when |(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )|≥0.5, v i =0.5v i ; For single-phase working condition calculation, according to the heat balance relationship Q = ρvAc p,ave ΔT, Q is the heat source power, ρ is the heat source inlet density, A is the flow area, c p,ave is the average constant pressure specific volume of the heat source, ΔT is the temperature difference between the inlet and outlet of the heat source, and the initial velocity is optimized based on the subcooling degree of the fluid at the heat source outlet of 20°C, specifically: v i =Q / [ρAc p,ave (T sat -T in -20)], and return to step 3), when ΔP d >ΔP z / 2, according to the formula v i+1 =v i [1+(ΔP d -ΔP z ) / (ΔP d +ΔP z )], and get the updated flow velocity v i+1 ; 6) According to the flow rate v i and v i+1 Update the convergence criterion δ in step 4), specifically δ = C | v i+1 -v i | / max(v i+1 ,v i ), C is a constant, i is the number of data interactions, max() is the maximum value function, and δ adaptively updates the convergence criterion according to the interaction flow rate of the one-dimensional and three-dimensional programs to achieve the convergence of the coupled program to the exact value; 7) Update the flow rate v i+1 Pass it to the three-dimensional calculation program and go to step 3) until v i With v i+1 Similarly, the adaptive multi-scale coupling of one-dimensional program and three-dimensional program is completed.

Citation Information

Patent Citations

  • Thermal hydraulic multi-scale partition simulation method of nuclear power device main-coolant system

    CN108875212A

  • Self-adaptive multi-scale coupling method for analyzing passive characteristics of nuclear power unit

    CN114201870A

  • Multi-fractal heatsink system and method

    US20190021186A1