A method for evaluating the anti-slip safety of straddle-type cable clamps
By calculating the anti-slip safety factor K and adopting the Coulon friction law, considering the cable clamp structural form and sling connection form, the problem of the existing specifications failing to accurately calculate the friction resistance of the riding straddle cable clamp, and improving the anti-slip design and maintenance The accuracy reduces the cost of structural maintenance.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202210024441.X
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-01-10
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-29
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-01-10
AI Technical Summary
The existing design specifications for suspension bridges and building prestressed string support structures fail to accurately calculate and evaluate the friction resistance of the riding straddle cable clamp, resulting in excessive structural maintenance costs and reduced friction resistance of the cable clamp.
By calculating the anti-slip safety factor K of the cable clamp, considering the tightening effect of the sling wire rope on the cable clamp and the circumferential friction coefficient between the cable clamp and the main cable, the anti-slip resistance Ffr is calculated using the Coulon friction law and the principle of static equilibrium. , provide more accurate anti-slip safety assessment methods.
It improves the rationality of the anti-slip design of the straddle cable clamp and the accuracy of the maintenance plan, reduces unnecessary structural operation and maintenance costs, and ensures the stability of the friction resistance of the cable clamp during service.
Smart Images

Figure CN114358629B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The invention relates to the field of anti-slip safety design and assessment of cable clamps for suspension bridges and prestressed chord-supported structures of buildings, and in particular to an anti-slip safety assessment method for a straddle-type cable clamp. Background Art
[0002] The cable clamps for suspension bridges and prestressed chord structures are components for connection and load transfer, and must meet the requirements for anti-slip bearing capacity. Special anti-slip bearing capacity calculations are required for cable clamps during structural design. The calculation formulas for the anti-slip bearing capacity of cable clamps in current domestic and international relevant structural design codes (hereinafter collectively referred to as "codes"), such as my country's "Code for Design of Highway Suspension Bridges" (JTG / T D65-05-2015) (hereinafter referred to as "suspension bridge code") and European code BS EN 1993-1-11 Eurocode 3: Design of steel structures–Part 1-11: Design of structures with tension components (hereinafter referred to as "Eurocode"), are all highly empirical in nature, without considering the differences in the effects of the cable clamp structure and the different connection forms between the sling (or cable) and the cable clamp on the force and friction resistance of the cable clamp. However, these factors have an important influence on the friction resistance of the cable clamp. The existing code methods cannot accurately calculate and evaluate the friction resistance of the cable clamp. For details, see the paper Theoretical and numerical studies of the slip resistance of main cable clamp composed of an upper and a lower part [J]. Advances in Structural Engineering published by the inventor. Engineering, 2021, 24(4): 691-705. This paper establishes a calculation method for the anti-slip friction resistance of the pin-jointed cable clamp, revealing the significant influence of the cable clamp structure, the cable connection form, and the circumferential friction coefficient between the cable clamp and the main cable on the friction resistance of the cable clamp. The straddle-type cable clamp is an important structural form of cable clamp and is widely used. In order to improve the anti-slip design of this type of cable clamp and the maintenance level during service, an accurate and reasonable anti-slip safety assessment method is needed. Summary of the invention
[0003] The purpose of the invention is to provide a method for evaluating the anti-slip safety of a straddle-type cable clamp.
[0004] The technical solution for achieving the purpose of the present invention is:
[0005] A method for evaluating the anti-slip safety of a straddle-type cable clamp comprises:
[0006] Step 1: Calculate the anti-slip safety factor K of the cable clamp.
[0007]
[0008] Where, T is the total vertical tension of the sling wire rope, F is the installation angle of the cable clip; fr is the anti-sliding friction resistance of the cable clamp,
[0009]
[0010] In the formula, μ a is the axial friction coefficient between the inner wall of the cable clamp and the main cable surface; γ is the radial pressure transmission coefficient, which physically means the ratio of the radial pressure exerted by the steel wire rope on the outer wall of the cable clamp to the radial pressure exerted by the outer wall of the cable clamp on the main cable surface under such action, and its value is less than 1;
[0011] N r bolt is the radial contact pressure of the cable clamp on the main cable generated by the pre-tightening force of the cable clamp screw,
[0012]
[0013] N r rope The radial contact pressure on the outer wall of the cable clamp is generated by the tightening of the sling wire rope.
[0014]
[0015] Where P tot is the total cable clamp screw preload, μ θ is the annular friction coefficient between the inner wall of the cable clamp and the main cable surface, is the friction coefficient between the sling wire rope and the surface of the cable groove on the outer wall of the cable clamp, and α is the wrap angle formed by the sling wire rope on the lower half of the cable clamp wall; Step 2, anti-slip safety assessment: if K>1, the cable clamp is anti-slip safe, if K=1, the cable clamp is in the anti-slip limit state, if K<1, the anti-slip friction resistance of the cable clamp is insufficient.
[0016] The anti-slip safety assessment method of the cable clamp disclosed in the present invention takes into account the tightening effect of the sling steel wire rope on the cable clamp and the circumferential friction coefficient between the cable clamp and the main cable in the calculation of the anti-slip friction resistance between the cable clamp and the main cable. Compared with the existing standard method, the calculation results of the friction resistance and anti-slip safety factor of the straddle-type cable clamp are more accurate and reliable. In the structural design stage, based on this method, the rationality of the anti-slip design of the straddle-type cable clamp can be improved, so as not to increase the structural cost due to excessive underestimation of the actual anti-slip ability of the cable clamp, such as the cable clamp length is too long, and the number and size of the bolt pair are too many and too large. The bolt pair has a long-term aging relaxation effect, so the friction resistance of the cable clamp will inevitably continue to decrease during the service (structural operation). It is necessary to regularly detect the bolt relaxation, calculate the residual friction resistance of the cable clamp and evaluate the anti-slip safety of the cable clamp based on this, so as to determine whether it is necessary to perform supplementary tensioning and tightening operations on the cable clamp bolt pair. This is an important routine work for the operation and management of such structures, which runs through the entire life of the structure. The existing suspension bridge specification method does not consider the tightening effect of the wire rope sling on the straddle-type cable clamp, so the obtained cable clamp friction resistance is smaller than the actual situation, which may lead to the cable clamp bolt tensioning work being carried out too early and too frequently during structural maintenance, increasing unnecessary structural operation and maintenance costs. The present invention can make a more reasonable and accurate assessment of the anti-slip safety of the cable clamp, which is conducive to the formulation of structural maintenance plans and maintenance measures. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0017] Figure 1 It is a three-dimensional schematic diagram of the connection between the straddle type cable clamp, sling wire rope and main cable.
[0018] In the above figure, 1-cable clamp; 2-main cable; 3-cable clamp bolt; 4-sling wire rope; 5-sling clamp; 6-conical casting block.
[0019] Figure 2 This is the stress state diagram when only the pre-tightening force of the cable clamp bolt is applied.
[0020] Figure 3 This is a diagram of the stress state under the tightening of the sling wire rope.
[0021] Figure 4 This is the stress state diagram of the sling wire rope microelement. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0022] The present invention is further described below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings.
[0023] like Figure 1As shown, the straddle-type cable clamp is a force-transmitting component that connects the main cable of a suspension bridge with the steel wire rope sling. The two halves of the cable clamp body are fastened on the main cable with a prestressed bolt pair. The steel wire rope sling is wrapped in the annular cable-bearing groove on the outer wall of the cable clamp and straddles the cable clamp. After the steel wire rope of the sling is tensioned, its lower part is anchored to the main beam. Since the cable clamp has a certain inclination angle, the tension of the sling will generate a downward force on the cable clamp along the axis of the main cable. This downward force needs to be balanced by the friction resistance between the cable clamp and the main cable. The calculation of anti-slip friction resistance is the key to the anti-slip design and anti-slip safety assessment of the cable clamp. The present invention takes into account the tightening effect of the sling steel wire rope on the cable clamp and the annular friction coefficient between the cable clamp and the main cable. Compared with the current standard method, the evaluation result is more accurate and reliable.
[0024] In the present invention, the anti-slip safety evaluation of the straddle type cable clamp uses the anti-slip safety factor K as an indicator.
[0025]
[0026] The anti-slip safety factor K is expressed as the anti-slip friction F of the cable clamp. fr and sliding force When the K value is greater than 1, it indicates that the cable clamp is safe against sliding. When the K value is 1, it indicates that the cable clamp is in the anti-sliding limit state. When the K value is less than 1, it indicates that the anti-sliding friction resistance of the cable clamp is insufficient, and the cable clamp will slip and fail.
[0027] The anti-sliding friction resistance of the straddle type cable clamp is derived based on Coulomb's friction law and the principle of static equilibrium. fr Calculate using formula (2):
[0028] F fr =μ a (N r bolt +γN r rope ) (2)
[0029] In the formula, μ a is the axial friction coefficient between the inner wall of the cable clamp and the main cable surface. The suspension bridge specification recommends a value of 0.15, N r bolt is the radial contact pressure of the cable clamp on the main cable caused by the pre-tightening force of the cable clamp bolt pair, N r rope is the radial contact pressure on the outer wall of the cable clamp generated by the tightening action of the sling wire rope, and γ is the radial pressure transmission coefficient, which physically means the ratio of the radial pressure generated by the wire rope on the outer wall of the cable clamp to the radial pressure generated by the outer wall of the cable clamp on the main cable surface under this action. Because the radial pressure generated by the wire rope on the outer wall of the cable clamp will not be 100% transmitted to the main cable surface through the cable clamp wall, the value of γ is less than 1.
[0030] N rbolt Calculate using formula (3):
[0031]
[0032] Where P tot is the total preload force of the cable clamp screw. During the operation of the structure, the preload force of the cable clamp screw can be measured by ultrasonic stress measurement technology, μ θ It is the annular friction coefficient between the inner wall of the cable clamp and the surface of the main cable. Its value can be determined by referring to the statistical data of the friction coefficient between steel and steel, or by making a friction pair test piece between the steel wire and the inner wall of the cable clamp and measuring the friction coefficient through experiments.
[0033] N r rope Calculate using formula (4):
[0034]
[0035] In the formula, α is the wrap angle formed by the sling wire rope to the lower half of the cable clamp wall, T is the total vertical tension of the sling wire rope, It is the friction coefficient between the steel wire rope of the sling and the surface of the cable groove on the outer wall of the cable clamp. Its value can be determined by referring to the statistical data of the friction coefficient between steel and steel, or by making a friction pair specimen between the steel wire rope and the outer wall of the cable clamp and measuring the friction coefficient through experiments.
[0036] The basic idea of the present invention is to obtain the bolt preload and the radial contact pressure of the sling wire rope on the clamp and the main cable respectively according to the force balance principle for the connection between the straddle type clamp and the sling wire rope, and then obtain the anti-sliding friction resistance of the straddle type clamp according to the Coulomb friction law. r rope The derivation process of the calculation formula (4) is as follows:
[0037] Figure 3 The figure shows the contact force of the wire rope on the outer surface of the cable clamp, including radial compressive stress and circumferential shear stress. The wrap angle formed by the wire rope on the lower half of the cable clamp wall is recorded as α, and α is also the angle between the wire rope segment tangent to the outer wall of the cable clamp and the vertical direction. Figure 4 shown.
[0038] In the radial direction, the force balance of the microelement can be obtained
[0039] F N =qR
[0040] Where q is the radial compressive stress of the sling wire rope on the outer wall of the cable clamp, R is the radius of the outer wall of the cable clamp, and F N is the tension of the sling wire rope.
[0041] In the annular direction, the force balance of the microelement and the boundary conditions give
[0042]
[0043] Where F is the tension of the wire rope section tangent to the outer wall of the cable clamp, is the friction coefficient between the wire rope and the cable groove surface of the outer wall of the cable clamp, substitute F N =qR, the equation of the radial compressive stress q of the wire rope on the cable clamp wall is:
[0044]
[0045] Integrating q(θ) within the range of the wire rope around the clamp and taking into account the symmetry, we can obtain the total pressure N of the wire rope on the outer wall of the clamp: r rope for
[0046]
[0047] Because the total vertical tension of the wire rope acting on the cable clamp is T = 2F cosα, the above formula can be further arranged into
[0048]
[0049] That is formula (4).
[0050] Then, using the superposition principle, the total radial pressure N between the straddle clamp and the main cable is r Expressed as
[0051] N r =N r bolt +γN r rope
[0052] Where γ is the radial pressure transmission coefficient, N r bolt It is the radial contact pressure on the outer wall of the cable clamp generated by the tightening action of the sling wire rope. Because the radial pressure generated by the wire rope on the outer wall of the cable clamp will not be 100% transmitted to the main cable surface through the cable clamp wall, the value of γ is less than 1. The theoretical research results based on the finite element method by the inventor show that the value of γ is about 0.8.
[0053] Finally, according to the classical Coulomb friction law, the anti-sliding friction resistance of the straddle type cable clamp is expressed as
[0054] F fr =μ a (N r bolt +γN r rope )
[0055] That is formula (2).
[0056] In order to further illustrate the purpose and advantages of the present invention, the following takes the anti-slip bearing capacity model test of a cable clamp as an example, and uses the calculation method disclosed in the present invention and the standard method of suspension bridge to analyze the anti-slip bearing capacity of the cable clamp (whose component is the anti-slip friction resistance), and compares the theoretical analysis results with the test results.
[0057] The anti-sliding friction F of the cable clamp given by the standard method of suspension bridge fr The calculation formula is
[0058] F fr = kμP tot
[0059] Where k is the clamp tightening pressure coefficient, which is fixed at 2.8, μ is the friction coefficient between the clamp and the main cable, and P tot is the total preload force of the cable clamp screw. For both pin-type cable clamps and straddle-type cable clamps, the specification adopts this calculation method.
[0060] The model test restored the actual stress state and sliding failure process of the straddle-type cable clamp and the pin-type cable clamp in the suspension bridge. Both the straddle-type cable clamp and the pin-type cable clamp are pre-tightened with four screws, and the vertical tension is applied to the cable clamp by a double-leg hanger in conjunction with a tensioner. The tension of all screws and hangers is measured by a separate through-type pressure sensor, and the sliding displacement of the cable clamp relative to the main cable is measured by a displacement meter and a micrometer. Therefore, during the test, it is possible to accurately determine whether the cable clamp has reached the anti-slip bearing limit state and understand the stress of the cable clamp under various loading states. The actual inclination of the cable clamp is measured by an inclinometer, and the change is small during the loading process. It is considered as 23° in theoretical analysis. In addition, for the test device, the maximum static friction coefficient between the inner wall of the cable clamp and the main cable strand was tested separately. The results of 20 groups of tests showed that the friction coefficient between the test cable clamp and the main cable was distributed between 0.22 and 0.35, with an average value of 0.30.
[0061] The comparison of the anti-slip bearing capacity theory and test results of the straddle type cable clamp is shown in Table 1. In each group of tests, the cable clamp hanger tension was loaded to more than 610kN, and the cable clamp did not show any slip failure behavior, indicating that the anti-slip bearing capacity of the straddle type cable clamp is greater than this loading value. According to the total screw preload, friction coefficient, hanger tension and measured values of the cable clamp inclination, the theoretical anti-slip bearing capacity of the cable clamp can be obtained by the suspension bridge standard method and the calculation method of the present invention, and the calculation results are listed before and after the semicolon in the table. It can be seen from Table 1 that because the suspension bridge standard method does not consider the tightening effect of the sling wire rope on the cable clamp, its calculation result of the anti-slip bearing capacity of the straddle type cable clamp is smaller than the calculation result of the method of the present invention; the anti-slip bearing capacity of the cable clamp obtained by the method of the present invention is greater than the tensile load value of the test suspender rod, so it can be concluded that the cable clamp will not fail due to slippage, which is consistent with the test results; however, using the suspension bridge standard method, for the test group with a total screw preload of 212kN, even if calculated according to the measured maximum friction coefficient of 0.35, its anti-slip bearing capacity is only 532kN, which is much smaller than the tensile load value of the test suspender rod of 617kN, that is, much smaller than the actual anti-slip bearing capacity of the cable clamp. From the analysis of Table 1, it can be concluded that the calculation method of the friction resistance (component of the anti-slip bearing capacity) of the straddle type cable clamp and the anti-slip safety assessment method of the cable clamp disclosed by the present invention are more accurate and reliable in analysis and evaluation results than the existing standard methods.
[0062] Table 1 Comparison of theoretical and experimental results of anti-sliding bearing capacity of straddle type cable clamp
[0063]
[0064] The comparison between the theoretical value of the anti-slip bearing capacity of the pin-connected cable clamp obtained according to the suspension bridge code method and the test results is shown in Table 2. Each group of test cable clamps are loaded until they fail due to sliding, so the actual measured anti-slip bearing capacity value can be obtained. It can be seen from the table that even if the friction coefficient is considered according to the recommended value of 0.15 in the suspension bridge code (less than the actual situation), the anti-slip bearing capacity of the cable clamp obtained according to the code method may still be greater than the measured result.
[0065] Table 2 Comparison between the standard method results and test results of the anti-sliding bearing capacity of pin-connected cable clamps
[0066]
[0067] In summary, it is not difficult to conclude that the existing suspension bridge specification method underestimates the anti-slip bearing capacity of the straddle-type cable clamp and overestimates the anti-slip bearing capacity of the pin-connected cable clamp. The reason is that the specification method does not consider the significant difference in the anti-slip bearing capacity caused by the different cable clamp structure and the corresponding sling and cable clamp connection forms. The test results have shown that this difference is significant. Therefore, it is very necessary to consider the influence of the tightening effect of the sling wire rope when calculating the friction resistance of the straddle-type cable clamp in the method of the present invention, which is also the advanced nature of the method.
[0068] Next, the accuracy of the method of the present invention is discussed. According to the force balance principle, the key to the rationality of the anti-slip safety assessment of the cable clamp lies in accurately calculating the friction resistance F of the cable clamp. fr According to Coulomb's friction law, the key to calculating the friction resistance of the cable clamp is to accurately calculate the radial contact pressure between the cable clamp and the main cable. Currently, there is no technical means to measure this surface contact pressure, so the finite element simulation method is used to verify the accuracy of the method of the present invention. Still taking the model test as an example, the finite element method is used to simulate the loading process of the test model. The comparison of the calculation results of the two methods is shown in Table 3. It can be seen that the difference between the two is very small, both within 5%. Therefore, the calculation accuracy of the method of the present invention is verified.
[0069] Table 3 Comparison of the calculation results of radial contact pressure between the straddle type cable clamp and the main cable
[0070]
Claims
1. A method for evaluating the anti-slip safety of a straddle-type cable clamp, characterized in that: include: Step 1: Calculate the anti-slip safety factor K of the cable clamp. Where, T is the total vertical tension of the sling wire rope, F is the installation angle of the cable clip; fr is the anti-sliding friction resistance of the cable clamp, F fr =μ a (N r bolt +γN r rope ); (2) In the formula, μ a is the axial friction coefficient between the inner wall of the cable clamp and the main cable surface; γ is the radial pressure transmission coefficient, which physically means the ratio of the radial pressure exerted by the steel wire rope on the outer wall of the cable clamp to the radial pressure exerted by the outer wall of the cable clamp on the main cable surface under such action, and its value is less than 1; N r bolt is the radial contact pressure of the cable clamp on the main cable generated by the pre-tightening force of the cable clamp screw, N r rope The radial contact pressure on the outer wall of the cable clamp is generated by the tightening of the sling wire rope. Where P tot is the total cable clamp screw preload, μ θ is the annular friction coefficient between the inner wall of the cable clamp and the main cable surface, is the friction coefficient between the sling steel wire rope and the surface of the cable groove on the outer wall of the cable clamp, and α is the wrap angle formed by the sling steel wire rope to the lower half of the cable clamp wall; Step 2: Anti-slip safety assessment: If K>1, the cable clamp is anti-slip safe; if K=1, the cable clamp is in the anti-slip limit state; if K<1, the anti-slip friction resistance of the cable clamp is insufficient.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
PE cable and cable clamp ball connecting performance test method
CN105258929A
Pin joint type cable clamp pair for cable with anti-skid rope clamp and anti-skid calculation method
CN109487690A
