Quench protection device
By connecting the varistor in parallel in the superconducting magnet and electrically connecting it with the heater, the varistor quickly responds to voltage changes to heating, the problems of insufficient responsiveness of the super-loss protection device and the fusibility of traditional resistors in the prior art are solved, and a faster , reliable overspread propagation and energy dissipation enhance the protection of high-field and high-current density magnets.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202080064665.2
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Priority Date
- 2019-09-23
- Filing Date
- 2020-09-21
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
- Estimated Expiration
- 2040-09-21
AI Technical Summary
The existing protection devices for superconducting magnets that lose timeout are insufficiently responsive, especially under high field and high current density conditions, traditional resistors may melt or fail, resulting in uncontrolled grounding and arcing, and long start time of heater , limits the efficiency of passive and active protection.
Multiple varistors are used to connect in parallel to both ends of the superconducting magnet section and electrically connect to the heater. The varistor is used to quickly apply heating according to the voltage changes to accelerate the propagation of the de-overlability and energy dissipation. Combined with the active de-overlability protection system, it triggers through voltage detection. Heater.
Achieve faster and reliable over-overflow propagation, reduce local hot spot risks, improve the rapid dissipation of energy in magnets, enhance the protection of high-field and high-current density magnets, and avoid the melting and long response time of traditional resistors. The problem.
Smart Images

Figure CN114641838B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to a quench protection device and in particular to a quench protection device for a superconducting magnet, the device comprising a plurality of varistors connected across respective sections of a plurality of sections of the superconducting magnet. Background Art
[0002] A quench in a superconductor, particularly a superconducting magnet, is a sudden loss of superconductivity therein, and occurs when a portion of the magnet's coil returns to a normal resistive state. Various conditions can cause a quench to occur, typically an excessive field or its rate of change inside the magnet, or a physical defect. The rapid, localized Joule heating produced at the portion of the coil that is no longer superconductive in turn raises the temperature of the surrounding areas, which is caused by the high current that continues to flow at that location. These areas are thus caused to return to a normal resistive state, and a heating chain reaction is thus created, whereby the temperature across the entire magnet is raised above the superconducting threshold and the magnet returns to a normal state.
[0003] When a quench occurs, the sudden reduction in current can result in induced voltage spikes and arcing. Magnets and other components can be damaged by these high voltage and thermal effects. In addition, for "wet" magnets that are maintained at their low operating temperature by a cryogenic fluid, such as a liquid helium bath magnet, the rapid conversion of the large amount of energy stored in the magnet into heat when operating as a superconductor results in a sudden, potentially explosive vaporization of the cryogenic fluid. Furthermore, with these "wet" magnets, the vaporization of the aforementioned fluid can create a suffocation hazard.
[0004] A quench that occurs will result in a reduction in the current flowing due to the increased resistance in the coil. However, the current usually drops slowly, as the quench may take several seconds to propagate, depending on the size of the coil. In addition, magnet segments are often operated in series with one or more other segments, and in this case, if only one segment quenches, the inductance of the other magnets will produce a voltage that is directed so as to maintain the current, which can cause the energy stored in those connected magnet segments, as well as the energy in the magnet segment where the quench occurred, to be dumped into the latter.
[0005] It is known to equip superconducting magnets with safety devices adapted to stop or limit the current flow as quickly as possible after a quench has occurred and to avoid undesirable and potentially damaging concentrations of thermal energy within the quenched magnet by spreading or dissipating the generated heat to the greatest possible extent throughout the magnet segment and other magnet segments connected thereto. A known method for achieving this spreading effect is to initiate a quench in the other coils by deliberately heating the other coils when a quench is detected in the magnet coils.
[0006] The use of resistors and diodes across the inductive superconducting magnet sections is a known quench protection method. The resistors are typically made of nickel-chromium (NiCr), stainless steel, or other resistive materials with linear voltage-current characteristics at a given temperature. In such existing protection systems, the quench propagates through the coil set entirely passively by means of mutual inductance and the circulation of current into the resistors. This may be referred to as a "passive" protection method.
[0007] The initiation of a quench can be achieved by the rate of change of current in each section or by reaching a critical current. In some systems, a network of heaters is used to initiate a quench in an adjacent coil to accelerate the quench. This may be referred to as a "passive with heater" approach. The heater is driven by a voltage developed across a resistor on the section where the quench occurs and / or one of the other protected sections of the magnet.
[0008] Alternatively, the quench may be detected externally and in response a capacitor discharge or battery discharge may be caused which is used to ignite, ie trigger or drive, a heater within the magnet. This type of protection may be referred to as "active".
[0009] Existing solutions for quench protection have many disadvantages. For example, when conventional resistors are used in protection devices with high field magnets, if an overcurrent passes through those resistors, they may melt and fail due to an open circuit, which may cause arcing to ground and between parts of the magnet in an uncontrolled manner. In this case, damage to the magnet may occur. In addition, it may take a long period of time to establish the voltage across the magnet segment (typically about 100ms), which limits the responsiveness of the protection provided by passive arrangements and passive arrangements using heaters.
[0010] There is a need for an improved way to protect against quenching in superconducting magnets, for example by: more efficiently driving the heater in a "passive with heater" system; further increasing and accelerating energy dissipation; and specifically providing improved protection for compact high field and high current density magnets. Summary of the invention
[0011] According to a first aspect of the present invention, there is provided a quench protection device for a superconducting magnet, the device comprising: a superconducting magnet comprising a plurality of magnet segments; a plurality of varistors, wherein each of the plurality of varistors is electrically connected in parallel across a corresponding one of the plurality of magnet segments; and a heater device electrically connected to the plurality of varistors and configured to apply heat to each of the plurality of magnet segments in response to a change in voltage across any one or more of the plurality of varistors.
[0012] The inventors have realised that varistors can be used to advantage in cryogenic environments and can be used to improve protection against magnet quenching.A varistor is a resistor that has a resistance that varies according to an applied voltage, typically decreasing with increasing current. Figure 1A A comparison between the current-voltage relationship of a varistor and that of a fixed or linear resistor is shown. Varistors can therefore be understood as nonlinear electrical components that are voltage dependent. They can generally be characterized as having a high resistance at lower voltages, which decreases as the voltage increases, as described above. The response can be understood as generally following an sigmoidal curve. These components are generally used as voltage surge limiters in other technical fields. It has been found that varistors are used in protection circuits with low temperature superconductor (LTS) or high temperature superconductor (HTS) magnet sections. Such a device is capable of generating higher voltages and currents across the varistor at the onset of a magnet quench. This effect can be used to drive quench heaters for coils that are adjacent to or otherwise positioned to be able to apply heat to the quench coil to accelerate the quench, or to change the current distribution between the magnet sections to accelerate the quench across the entire magnet. In this way, using this device instead of a conventional resistor-based device, the propagation of the quench throughout the magnet can be achieved more quickly. Thus, the device can more reliably and responsively spread the quench throughout the magnet, thereby eliminating the adverse effects of highly localized heating. Advantageously, by promoting rapid energy dissipation in the magnet through the varistor device, the coil hot spots generated when a quench occurs can be reduced. The term "voltage" used in this disclosure can be understood to refer to a potential difference. That is, the voltage across a varistor can be understood to be the potential difference across it.
[0013] As mentioned above, the significance of using a varistor is that, generally, at low currents, the voltage across the varistor will be relatively high while remaining within a predetermined range at the maximum current. The properties of a varistor with respect to current can be described by the relationship V = CI β Approximation: where V is the voltage across the varistor; β is the nonlinear parameter; and C is the resistance when 1A current flows through the varistor. For any given material, these parameters are typically different at different operating temperatures. As a guide to order of magnitude, at room temperature, a varistor comprising silicon carbide (SiC) material may typically have a value of β ~ 0.5; a varistor comprising zinc oxide (ZnO) material may typically have a nonlinear parameter value of β ~ 0.05. Preferably, one or more of the plurality of varistors are selected based on the nonlinear and resistive properties, which are typically quantified by their β and C parameter values.
[0014] As an illustration, Figure 1B and Figure 2 The characteristic voltage-current diagram is shown for the comparison between a varistor with β=0.5 and C=15 and a 1Ω linear resistor. Figure 1B In , the response over the entire range of interest is plotted. Assume that the maximum allowed voltage across the protected magnet segment is 250V, which corresponds to a current of 250A using a 1Ω linear resistor. The voltage across the selected varistor will be within the voltage limit for this current. Figure 2 In the figure, an extended portion of the curve is shown at lower currents. In this region, the voltage across the varistor is higher than it would be if the same current were flowing through the varistor. A "passive" quench heater might require 100V to activate reliably, a voltage reached with less than 50A of current through the varistor, whereas it can be seen that a current of 100A would be required to flow through a 1Ω resistor in order to achieve this.
[0015] In various embodiments and configurations, the voltage change that causes heat to be applied to the magnet can be a positive or negative change in voltage value. Typically, the device is adapted to apply heat based on the voltage change satisfying a predetermined condition, which is preferably that the magnitude of the voltage change (i.e., the absolute value of the difference between the starting value of the voltage change and the value to which the voltage changes) meets or exceeds a configured or predetermined threshold difference.
[0016] In some preferred embodiments, the heater device is configured to apply heat in response to the voltage across any one or more of the plurality of varistors reaching a threshold value. In this way, the change may be such that the voltage across the segment becomes equal to or exceeds the threshold value. Typically, this includes the magnitude of the voltage exceeding the threshold value or its magnitude, as these values may be positive or negative, as described above.
[0017] The device as described in the present disclosure can advantageously rely on a specific manner in which when a quench occurs in a magnet segment having a varistor connected across it to heat the magnet or some other part of the magnet, the voltage across the varistor changes so as to mitigate the quench occurring in the initial segment. In principle, this can be achieved with a single heater. However, in a preferred embodiment, the heating device comprises a plurality of heaters. More preferably, one or more heaters are arranged to maximize the heat distribution around the entire superconducting magnet or at least a portion thereof in which the quench is induced by heating. Therefore, in some embodiments, the heater device comprises a plurality of heaters, wherein each of the plurality of heaters is positioned for applying heat to a corresponding one of the plurality of magnet segments, or is configured to apply heat to a corresponding one of the plurality of magnet segments in use. Providing each magnet segment with a corresponding heater configured to be activated when a quench occurs in any segment enables the energy in the magnet to be dissipated faster and more efficiently.
[0018] Some preferred embodiments may be understood to be similar to the "passive with heater" protection scheme described above. Thus, in some embodiments, the heater arrangement is configured to generate heat to be applied to each of the plurality of magnet segments by way of Joule heating due to a change in voltage across one or more of the plurality of varistors. Passively driving the heater by current generated or increased by one or more heaters connected to a protection circuit including varistors maintains the above benefits of the passive scheme while also achieving a significant improvement in the responsiveness of the arrangement to a quench in any portion of the magnet through the varistors.
[0019] Typically, the varistors connected at both ends of each magnet segment are provided as single varistor components. However, in a preferred embodiment, one or more or all of the multiple varistors include two or more varistor components. That is, in such an embodiment, each varistor component is individually a varistor, and in those applications, those components are configured together to operate in a group of varistors acting as varistors at both ends of a given magnet segment. In various embodiments, each of these composite varistors including multiple varistor components may contain two, three, four, five or more or any number of such components. For any two of the multiple varistors in the device, the number of varistor components in each varistor may be the same or different, for example depending on the structure of the superconducting magnet coil to which they are involved.
[0020] In the case of using a varistor comprising a plurality of varistor components grouped together, it may be advantageous to provide the grouped components in a stacked form. Therefore, preferred embodiments include these varistor components having a stackable geometry, such as, for example, a tile-like, plate-like or disc-like geometry. In some preferred embodiments, each varistor component is formed as a disc, and for each of one or more varistors comprising two or more of said varistor components, the varistor components are arranged in a stack.
[0021] In addition, or in lieu of utilizing a varistor to activate a "passive" protection circuit utilizing a heater, an active protection circuit may also benefit from the voltage response to a quench across the varistor. In particular, the use of a varistor and its ability to produce a rapid voltage increase when a quench occurs is useful for active schemes because the voltage change can be used as a signal or trigger to activate a protection device or system that is externally driven, powered, or configured, rather than being driven by current generated from a voltage change.
[0022] Thus, in some embodiments, the apparatus further comprises an active quench protection system, the active quench protection system comprising: a quench detector module configured to detect a quench occurring in one or more of the plurality of magnet sections based on the voltage across one or more of the plurality of varistors connected across one or more of the plurality of magnet sections reaching a predetermined quench threshold voltage value, the predetermined quench threshold voltage value may be the same as or different from the threshold voltage value mentioned previously. The active quench protection system may also comprise a quench inductor system configured to implement a quench condition in one or more of the plurality of magnet sections in response to the quench detector module detecting the occurrence of a quench. An advantage of such an apparatus is that the threshold voltage may be reached more quickly by employing varistors, which means that these active protection schemes may be triggered more quickly, which vary in the way they induce a quench throughout the magnet, as further explained below.
[0023] A particular benefit of the rapid rise in voltage across the varistors is that in the event of a quench occurring when the magnet current is low in proportion to the magnet operating current, the voltage across one or more varistors in the protection circuit may rise above a trigger level for active quenching, whereas in the case of conventional resistor protection the voltage would be below that level and the heater circuit would not trigger. It will generally be appreciated that in this context a "low" current typically corresponds to a current less than half the magnet operating current. Thus, in some embodiments employing an active protection system, the device may be configured such that a quench occurring in one or more of the plurality of magnet segments causes the voltage across one or more of the plurality of varistors to reach the predetermined quench threshold voltage value when the magnitude of the current through the magnet segments is less than 50% of a predetermined current value corresponding to the magnet operating current. In this way, such a device extends quench protection compared to conventional approaches. This may be achieved by the device in that, in particular, the varistors are configured such that the voltage condition for triggering active protection is satisfied at a current level below the current level at which the resistor-based protection device would be activated. In some preferred embodiments, the device may be configured such that when the current amplitude is less than 40%, 30%, 20% or 10% of the operating current, the voltage reaches a predetermined quench threshold voltage value.
[0024] The apparatus described in the present disclosure may be used to protect various types of superconducting magnets. In addition to low temperature superconductor (LTS) magnets, hybrid magnets that include high temperature superconductor (HTS) components as well as LTS components generally require alternative or additional apparatus to effectively protect HTS sections. Although some embodiments may employ the same quench protection for both types of superconductor coils, the quench protection methods typically applied to LTS may not necessarily be applicable to protecting HTS magnet sections, or may not be particularly effective in protecting HTS magnet sections.
[0025] The "stability margin" of HTS relative to LTS can be understood as the minimum quench energy density, which is typically three orders of magnitude greater for HTS than for LTS coils. This is explained, for example, in the following article: "Case Studies in Superconducting Magnets" by author Iwasa in Springer (2nd edition 2009), section 6.2.6, with particular reference to Table 6.4. This means that magnets wound with HTS conductors are generally more stable against disturbances than LTS windings, and are less likely to quench.
[0026] Although HTS windings may not quench, it is not necessary that the HTS magnet sections cannot be damaged. In particular, in magnets where the HTS sections are arranged to be inserted into or, in use, housed within an LTS magnet, damage is possible. Typically in such a configuration, as the current in the LTS winding decays, an increased current is induced in the HTS winding due to inductive coupling according to Lenz's law. One possible damage mechanism is that the resulting additional stress overstrains the magnet windings.
[0027] Greater stability also means that it is considerably more difficult to provoke a quench for protection of the magnet using the devices or schemes normally applied to LTS magnets. Furthermore, if a quench is induced locally in an HTS coil, it is unlikely to propagate through the conductor windings for the same reasons. Thus, an inappropriately applied local heater may have the undesirable effect of creating hot spots, leading in principle to overheating damage in the HTS.
[0028] To address these differences, alternative devices have been used to protect HTS magnets and HTS windings composed of hybrid magnets. There are many examples of different HTS protection schemes that are triggered based on voltage signals or detection of changes or another indication that the magnet has quenched. One example is to open a switch to dissipate energy from the coil to the outside of the magnet. Another example is to actively apply an alternating current so as to cause heating locally within the body of the winding rather than at the surface of the coil. An apparatus according to the latter example is explained in EP 3014634 B1, where it is called "coupling loss induced quench".
[0029] In some embodiments, existing devices for protecting HTS magnets and magnet components may be employed, wherein the LTS / HTS hybrid superconducting magnet is to be protected. In such embodiments, the superconducting magnet segment comprises at least one low temperature superconductor LTS magnet segment and at least one high temperature superconductor HTS magnet segment, and wherein the quench protection device comprises an HTS quench protection system adapted to apply quench protection to each of the at least one HTS magnet segment in response to the voltage across any one or more of the plurality of varistors reaching a threshold voltage value. As described above, typically, the HTS segment is arranged to be an insert within the LTS magnet segment in use. Various configurations for combining the HTS insert portion of the magnet with the LTS portion may be used, which may be referred to as an "outsert". For example, the LTS and HTS portions may be powered using two power supplies, respectively, which may be different, for example, they may operate at different currents. In some embodiments, the two portions may be connected in series to operate with a single power supply and may operate at the same current. Other configurations are also possible and may involve inductive coupling to excite the segments. In particular, when a quench occurs in any magnet section, HTS systems typically use a voltage condition as a trigger to implement techniques for protecting the HTS sections.
[0030] As described above, the HTS quench protection system is adapted to apply quench protection by any one or more of: dissipating energy from the at least one HTS magnet segment to a body external to the magnet; and applying an alternating current having a predetermined frequency and amplitude configured to induce Joule heating within the coil of the at least one HTS magnet segment. The energy may be dissipated by opening a switch to transfer energy from the coil to an externally connected component.
[0031] In various embodiments, different types of varistors may be used to connect across the magnet segments, including the types mentioned earlier in this disclosure. Preferably, due to their properties, the device comprises silicon carbide (SiC) varistors. More preferably, one or more or a subset of the plurality of varistors comprises silicon carbide, and more preferably, each of the plurality of varistors comprises silicon carbide.
[0032] In some preferred embodiments, the varistors included in the device are high energy silicon carbide varistors. These components typically include silicon carbide, typically in particulate form, typically dispersed or otherwise disposed in a matrix formed by one or more binders and / or additives. Typically, the matrix is formed of a clay material. Each varistor typically has the form of a disk comprising (one or more) of the material, wherein electrical contacts are typically attached to the disk.
[0033] Typically, a varistor is selected based on the specific characteristics required for a given application, including any of the voltage, current, and energy properties of the varistor. Additionally, a varistor may be selected based on the degree of nonlinearity in the resistance of the component. This nonlinearity is typically quantified in terms of the beta value of the varistor.
[0034] Additionally, due to the failure mode of short circuits in localized areas of the disk of a typical varistor according to the present protection device, the varistor may face challenges close to failure of its components. The robust material composition of the varistor according to the typical embodiment is advantageously maintained in a cryogenic environment, which generally allows magnet testing to be completed without arcing to ground and subsequent damage to the magnet coil.
[0035] A variety of SiC varistors are suitable for use in the present device. The inventors have surprisingly found that using a varistor that is traditionally used for room temperature applications in a cryogenic environment can allow a quench protection device to be provided that provides a number of advantages over existing protection systems. The varistor and other components of the device, such as the protection circuit and / or the heater circuit, are typically configured to operate in a cryogenic environment.
[0036] Advantageously, the device may facilitate incorporation into protection circuits that exploit the unique properties of varistors to accelerate quenching in a variety of ways.
[0037] This arrangement can be beneficial because high voltages are involved at low currents, and low voltages at high currents, which can reduce the risk of damage to the magnets while maximizing the current density in the varistor (which is typically maintained at higher levels than conventional resistor circuits). Typically, the initial high voltage for lower currents, followed by a subsequent drop in resistance, means that the varistor can be configured in a way that avoids building up high currents in the magnet segments.
[0038] Additionally, in some embodiments, the voltage from the varistor can be used to drive the heater more efficiently, particularly in terms of the speed with which a quench can be initiated in one or more of the other coils. This can also improve the reliability of the heater in different quench scenarios, since the heater voltage is typically at least somewhat self-limiting.
[0039] Preferably, the varistor is configured so that voltage clamping occurs. Thus, a safe voltage can be maintained, whereby the magnet coil is protected regardless of excessive current. The size of the SiC particles comprised by the one or more varistors can be selected so as to optimize the clamping voltage and / or current density.
[0040] Furthermore, an "active" protection circuit preferably has a larger segment voltage initially, and this generally enables faster triggering (positive and negative) at a set voltage threshold.
[0041] In some embodiments, a combination of both an active protection circuit and a "passive" arrangement using a heater, each of which is based on a varistor, as described above, is beneficial. For example, for a magnet that includes both LTS and HTS elements, this combination is particularly valuable because it enables two different protection schemes to be applied to the elements for which they are most suited. This will be discussed in more detail below.
[0042] In some preferred embodiments, a varistor is connected in series with a back-to-back diode across the protected magnet segment. The device may include a protection circuit designed to draw more current and fire the heater, particularly in a "passive with heater" scenario. In these embodiments, the already discovered advantageous properties of varistors are advantageously exploited.
[0043] Passive quench protection can also be provided in an improved manner by the device, in particular under low temperature conditions, for example at T=4.2 K, and in this way fail-safe operation can be provided.
[0044] As has been explained previously in this disclosure, a key advantage that can be achieved by the described apparatus is that a quench occurring in a given magnet section can be propagated more quickly to other magnet sections. This is achieved by providing as part of the apparatus a protection circuit to which one or more heaters are connected in a manner that rapidly applies heat across the magnet. Preferably, the heater means is associated with a plurality of varistors such that when a quench occurs in one of the plurality of magnet sections, the voltage developed across the varistor causes the heating means to provide heat to at least one further magnet section of the plurality of magnet sections.
[0045] According to a second aspect of the present invention, there is provided a method for protecting a superconducting magnet, the superconducting magnet comprising a plurality of magnet segments, wherein each of a plurality of varistors is electrically connected in parallel across a corresponding one of the plurality of magnet segments, and a heater device is electrically connected to the plurality of varistors, the method comprising applying heat to each of the plurality of magnet segments in response to a change in voltage across any one or more of the plurality of varistors. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0046] Examples of the present invention will now be described with reference to the accompanying drawings, in which:
[0047] Figure 1A and Figure 1B are graphs showing a comparison of the characteristics of a typical varistor with a typical linear resistor and a comparison of the characteristics of an exemplary varistor with a resistor, respectively, within a range of interest;
[0048] Figure 2is a graph comparing the characteristics of a varistor and a linear resistor at lower currents;
[0049] Figure 3 is a schematic diagram of a cross section of a magnet test coil used to model quench behavior, wherein a varistor is used instead of a resistor in a magnet quench protection device;
[0050] Figure 4 is a graph showing a comparison of modeled coil voltages across a two section magnet having a quench section protected with a varistor and a quench section protected by a fixed resistor;
[0051] Figure 5 is a graph showing modeled coil current through a magnet in which both coils are quenched and showing the current when the magnet is protected with a varistor and when it is protected with a linear resistor;
[0052] Figure 6 is a schematic diagram of an exemplary protection device showing a protection circuit associated with a superconducting magnet circuit, wherein the magnet shown is a simplified example having only two coil sections;
[0053] Figure 7 is a schematic diagram of a comparison between a protection circuit including a protection device according to the present invention and an equivalent circuit according to the prior art, wherein the protection circuit is across a protected coil section; and
[0054] Figure 8 is a schematic diagram showing an exemplary apparatus and protection circuit according to the present invention, in which a trigger for internally activated quench heaters on an LTS magnet is combined with an externally activated quench protection for an HTS insert in the magnet. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0055] To demonstrate the capability of a varistor in a quench protection device, quench modeling has been performed. For simplicity, and given the tendency for more complex modeling scenarios to make the effects of the varistor less clear or lead to systematic modeling errors, a simple dual coil design has been used to test the concept. This is for illustrative purposes only, and it is envisioned that a quench protection device can be implemented with any number of magnet coils. Computer software has been used to model the coil configuration and quench modeling.
[0056] Figure 3A cross section through half of a cylindrical coil as modeled in this general example is shown. The coil is shown as a cylindrical block centered at R=0 (corresponding to the y-axis in the figure) and extending in the z-direction (parallel to the x-axis in the figure). Coil 1 and Coil 2 are both composed of niobium titanium (NbTi) wire of the same size and the coils have been chosen to have comparable resistance and inductance for simplicity and in order to compare the quench modeling results with analytical calculations derived from approximate theory. The varistor parameters used are derived from experimental measurements of their voltage-current characteristics at low temperatures. During magnet design, the superconducting wire and other material properties and other internal model parameters used have long been established and reliably used in the quench model computer program and in the analysis of magnet test results.
[0057] The effect of varistor-based quench protection on the derived voltage across the quench zone has been demonstrated by modelling a quench starting in coil 2. It has been found that the use of a varistor instead of a resistor to protect the magnet results in a significantly faster rise in voltage than the case where the quench zone is protected by a conventional resistor. Figure 4 From the data shown in , it can be seen that by using an appropriate varistor in the protection circuit instead of a resistor, the quench heater can be triggered approximately 50ms earlier.
[0058] In order to demonstrate the effect of using a varistor on the maximum overcurrent induced in a coil in a quench, a model has been run in which both modelled coils are quenched. The results therefore illustrate the situation in which the quench heaters on all coils have been triggered. This will also approximate the situation in which the effect from the coil in which the quench started can be used to induce a quench in the other coil shortly after the first coil started to quench.
[0059] The model shows that the peak current in the slowest quench region is greatly reduced when the magnet is protected by a varistor compared to a magnet protected by a conventional resistor. Figure 5 The data shown in Figure 2 show that by using appropriate varistors in the protection circuit instead of conventional resistors, the peak overcurrent can be reduced by more than half.
[0060] Figure 4 and Figure 5 An exemplary output of quench modeling is shown.
[0061] An example of a quench protection device employing the principles demonstrated by quench modeling is now described.
[0062] In some examples, a varistor is preferably connected in series with a "back-to-back" diode across the protected magnet segment, wherein the derived voltage is used to activate the heater in the "passive with heater" scenario described above. A protection scheme such as that described in GB2514372B is suitable for being implemented as a method of protecting the magnet coil in response to a voltage change across a varistor.
[0063] Figure 6 is a schematic representation of a first example apparatus, wherein for simplicity a magnet with only two coil sections is shown. Applications of the apparatus are envisaged to include significantly more protected magnet coil sections than this simplified example.
[0064] Figure 7 Shown are schematic representations of an example protection circuit comprising a varistor on the right side of the figure and a circuit according to the prior art comprising a linear resistor on the left side of the figure.
[0065] In another example particularly suited for protecting an LTS magnet including one with an HTS insert, different protection schemes are used for the LTS coil and the HTS coil, respectively. The two magnet sections may be operated in parallel using separate power supplies, or may be operated in series. This example employs the same "passive with heater" scheme to protect the LTS section as the previous example apparatus. In addition, the apparatus is configured to detect voltage changes across the LTS magnet protection element more quickly than is possible with prior art apparatuses in order to externally activate the quench protection scheme for the HTS magnet. This combination of protection schemes for these hybrid magnets is mentioned above. Figure 8 The additional elements involved in this example are shown schematically.
[0066] Details of example SiC varistors and superconducting magnet quench protection devices including them are now described.
[0067] As mentioned above, the varistor characteristics can be expressed by the relationship V = CI β The "beta value" (β), which defines the degree of nonlinearity of the varistor, affects the discharge speed. This can be modified by dopants in the varistor material and process adjustments.
[0068] Some example varistors are fabricated from SiC particles in a clay matrix to produce a disc-shaped or tile-shaped semiconductor device.
[0069] Failure mode testing of example devices has been conducted in liquid nitrogen and involved increasing the energy to more than five times the energy of the device at room temperature. It was found that a non-propagating hot spot formed on the varistor disc, which failed by short circuiting and continued to pass current. This is a particularly useful property for magnet protection. The SiC material of the example varistor maintains its integrity under cryogenic conditions, and through material optimization, it is envisioned that further examples may provide an effective replacement for linear dump resistors.
Claims
1. A quench protection device for a superconducting magnet, the device comprising: a superconducting magnet comprising a plurality of magnet sections; a plurality of varistors, wherein each varistor of the plurality of varistors is electrically connected in parallel across a corresponding one of the plurality of magnet segments; as well as A heater device is electrically connected to the plurality of varistors and is configured to apply heat to each of the plurality of magnet segments in response to a change in voltage across any one or more of the plurality of varistors.
2. The device according to claim 1, wherein: The heater device is configured to apply heat in response to a voltage across any one or more of the plurality of varistors reaching a threshold voltage value.
3. The device according to claim 2, wherein: The heater arrangement includes a plurality of heaters, wherein each heater of the plurality of heaters is positioned to apply heat to a respective one of the plurality of magnet sections.
4. The device according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein: The heater arrangement is configured to generate heat to be applied to each of the plurality of magnet segments by Joule heating due to a voltage change across the one or more varistors of the plurality of varistors.
5. The device according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein: One or more varistors of the plurality of varistors each include two or more varistor components.
6. The device according to claim 5, wherein: Each varistor component is formed as a disk, and for each varistor of one or more varistors comprising two or more of the varistor components, the varistor components are arranged in a stack.
7. The device according to any one of claims 1 to 3, further comprising an active quench protection system, wherein the active quench protection system comprises: a quench detector module configured to detect a quench occurring in one or more of the plurality of magnet sections based on a voltage across one or more of the plurality of varistors reaching a predetermined quench threshold voltage value; as well as A quench inductor system is configured to implement a quench condition in one or more magnet sections of the plurality of magnet sections in response to the quench detector module detecting the occurrence of a quench.
8. The apparatus of claim 7 , configured such that a quench occurring in one or more of the plurality of magnet segments causes a voltage across the one or more of the plurality of varistors to reach the predetermined quench threshold voltage value when the magnitude of the current passing through the magnet segment is less than 50% of a predetermined current value corresponding to an operating current of the magnet.
9. The device according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein: The magnet sections include at least one low temperature superconductor (LTS) magnet section and at least one high temperature superconductor (HTS) magnet section, and wherein the quench protection device includes an HTS quench protection system adapted to apply quench protection to each of the at least one HTS magnet section in response to a voltage across any one or more of the plurality of varistors reaching a threshold voltage value.
10. The device according to claim 9, wherein: The HTS quench protection system is adapted to apply the quench protection by any one or more of: dissipating energy from the at least one HTS magnet segment to a body external to the at least one HTS magnet segment; and applying an alternating current having a predetermined frequency and amplitude arranged to induce Joule heating in a coil of the at least one HTS magnet segment.
11. The device according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein: Each varistor of the plurality of varistors includes silicon carbide.
12. The device according to any one of claims 1 to 3, wherein: The heater device is associated with the plurality of varistors such that when a quench occurs in one of the plurality of magnet sections, a voltage developed across the varistor causes the heater device to provide heat to at least one other of the plurality of magnet sections.
13. A method of protecting a superconducting magnet, the superconducting magnet comprising a plurality of magnet segments, wherein: Each of a plurality of varistors is electrically connected in parallel across a corresponding one of the plurality of magnet segments, and a heater device is electrically connected to the plurality of varistors, the method comprising applying heat to each of the plurality of magnet segments in response to a change in voltage across any one or more of the plurality of varistors.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Ac-current induced quench protection system
EP3014634B1
Quench protection system for a superconducting magnet
GB2514372B
Quench-of-superconductivity protection circuit and quench-of-superconductivity protection method for superconducting magnet system
CN106558869A
Quench protection arrangement for a superconducting magnet
GB2422958A
Waveform correction filters
US20070222299A1
