A method for measuring residual stress of ultra-high strength steel welding assisted by numerical simulation of temperature field
Through the temperature field numerical simulation assists in dividing the region and selecting the strain flower size, combined with the small hole method to measure the accuracy and resource waste of ultra-high strength steel welding, and achieve efficient and accurate measurement of welding stress distribution.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202211707345.1
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Patents(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2022-12-29
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-12
- Estimated Expiration
- 2042-12-29
AI Technical Summary
During the welding process, it is difficult for the prior art to accurately measure the residual stress distribution of ultra-high strength steel welding, especially at the peak stress position, and the small-hole measurement method has problems such as wasting resources and high measurement costs.
With the assistance of numerical simulation of the temperature field, the low-stress area, the key detection area and the stress gentle area are divided, and the appropriate strain flower size and layout position are selected. Combined with the small hole method to accurately locate the peak stress position to improve measurement efficiency and accuracy.
Effectively save measurement costs, improve the possibility of capturing peak stress, more accurately reflect the welding residual stress distribution, and improve measurement efficiency and accuracy.
Smart Images

Figure CN115931197B_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of energetic material preparation technology, and in particular to a method for measuring ultra-high strength steel welding residual stress with the aid of temperature field numerical simulation. Background Art
[0002] The thermal deformation and structural deformation caused by the local uneven heat input of metal components during the welding process will inevitably produce welding residual stress due to the constraints of the component's own stiffness. During the service of the component, the superposition of welding residual stress and working load will affect its static load strength, fatigue life, stress corrosion resistance and other properties. Therefore, effectively measuring the residual stress of the weldment and clarifying the size and distribution of the welding residual stress generated by the specific material under the specific welding process play a vital role in the subsequent regulation of welding residual stress and evaluation of the reliability of the welded structure.
[0003] Compared with experimental measurement, with the improvement of computer science and computational welding mechanics, numerical simulation of welding process has become an important prediction method. Many examples have proved that it can effectively predict welding deformation and welding residual stress under the use of high-quality mesh models, accurate material parameters and appropriate boundary strips. At present, numerical simulation technology of welding process has become an important supplement to experimental measurement, and even can replace experimental measurement in some cases. However, the calculation of residual stress and deformation needs to be based on the calculation results of temperature field, and welding is a complex process involving multi-physical field coupling, with multiple nonlinear characteristics. In order to accurately simulate the distribution of welding residual stress, more stringent calculation conditions are required. If only the temperature field is simulated, a lot of resources can be saved.
[0004] The measurement of welding residual stress can be divided into two categories according to whether it causes damage to the component. (1) Destructive measurement: strip cutting method, block cutting method, layer peeling method and drilling strain method, etc. This method uses mechanical means to remove local material of the component, measure the released strain, and calculate the welding residual stress based on the constitutive relationship. (2) Non-destructive measurement: X-ray diffraction method, neutron diffraction method, ultrasonic method and magnetic detection, etc. This method will not cause damage to the component and belongs to non-destructive testing method.
[0005] The drilling strain method (small hole method) is divided into the through hole method and the blind hole method according to the depth of the drilled hole. This method has perfect theory, mature technology, little damage to components and simple equipment. It is suitable for measuring the residual stress near the surface of isotropic linear elastic materials. It has unique advantages in measuring the residual stress of welded structures with complex surface stress distribution. It is one of the most widely used welding residual stress measurement methods. However, the small hole method can only select a limited number of discrete positions on the component to arrange the strain rosette for measurement. Each position will change the stress distribution of the local area after drilling, affecting the selection of subsequent measurement positions. Therefore, how to effectively arrange the strain rosette to obtain satisfactory results has become a key issue in the small hole method for measuring welding residual stress. In addition, the small hole method obtains the average value of the residual stress in the local area of the drilled hole. In theory, the smaller the size of the strain rosette, the more accurately the data measured can reflect the actual situation of the residual stress at the drilling position. Considering the measurement cost, how to select the appropriate specification of the strain rosette in a targeted manner is also very important in actual production.
[0006] In the process of practical application, in many cases, a large number of strain rosettes of the same type are evenly distributed on the weldment to be tested or arranged based on experience. These practices have the advantages of simplicity and convenience for common materials with wide application, but they cannot avoid the large investment of resources, and the welding residual stress itself has the characteristics of uneven distribution and large changes in stress gradient over the entire component. It is difficult to obtain satisfactory results according to the above practices. For ultra-high-strength steel or other materials with complex components, considering the solid phase transformation mainly based on martensite transformation during welding cooling and the softening of materials caused by heating process, this will further lead to the complexity of welding residual stress distribution. For load-bearing structures, the location of peak stress is particularly important. After solid phase transformation and softening problems occur, the actual location of peak stress may be different from the general empirical judgment. Therefore, in order to more accurately and efficiently utilize the numerical simulation technology of welding process and the small hole method to measure welding residual stress, especially for materials with high strength levels, it is necessary to develop an effective strain rosette arrangement method. Summary of the invention
[0007] In view of the above-mentioned problems existing in the prior art, the purpose of the invention is to provide a clear and definite guidance scheme for the process of measuring the residual stress of ultra-high-strength steel welding by the small hole method, improve the measurement efficiency, save the measurement cost, increase the possibility of capturing the peak stress, and make the measurement results more effectively reflect the actual situation of the residual stress distribution of ultra-high-strength steel welding.
[0008] To achieve the above object, the present invention adopts the following technical solution: a method for measuring ultra-high strength steel welding residual stress by numerical simulation of temperature field, comprising the following steps:
[0009] S1: Establish a 3D finite element model based on the geometric dimensions of the workpiece to be welded using existing modeling software (e.g., HyperMesh software). Use the established 3D finite element model and existing finite element software (e.g., SYSWELD software) to perform numerical simulation of the welding process according to the material properties of the workpiece to be welded and its welding process, and obtain the temperature field distribution trend of the workpiece to be welded during the entire welding process.
[0010] S2: Based on the temperature field distribution trend obtained in S1, the low stress area, key detection area and stress relief area are divided according to the peak temperature at each position and the material properties of the welded workpiece, and drilling measurement points are selected in each of the three areas;
[0011] S3: Select strain rosettes with a hole-center-segment center distance of less than 5 mm in the key detection area; there is no special requirement for the size of strain rosettes in other areas;
[0012] S4: Paste the strain rosette at the selected drilling measurement point, and measure and record the residual stress at each set position using the small hole method according to GB / T 31310-2014 or ASTM E837-13a standard. Specifically, since the stress gradient along the weld direction is small, the measurement results of the drilling measurement point can be projected onto a straight line perpendicular to the weld along the weld direction to establish a stress-distance from the weld center coordinate system.
[0013] Preferably, in the S2, the area where the peak temperature exceeds the melting point of the base material is taken as the low stress area; the area adjacent to the low stress area and about 3-4 times the width of the HAZ is taken as the key detection area; the remaining area is the stress relief area. For ultra-high strength steel, according to theoretical derivation, the residual stress in the area (weld metal) where the peak temperature exceeds the melting point of the base material is low, and compressive stress may even occur, and this part is divided into the low stress area; the residual stress gradient is the largest in the area where the peak temperature of the welded workpiece is near 2Tp~AC1. Since the upper limit of the temperature in this interval may exceed the melting point of the base material, it is believed that the stress gradient near the heat affected zone is the largest in the entire component range. Considering the size of the strain rosette itself and the solid phase transformation and softening problems during the welding process of ultra-high strength steel, in order to more effectively capture the peak stress and more truly reflect the transition of the stress gradient, the area wider than the heat affected zone (preferably 3-4 times the width of the HAZ) is taken as the key detection area; the remaining area is the stress relief area.
[0014] Preferably, when establishing a 3D finite element model in S1, the grid size of the weld zone of the welded workpiece in the width direction is less than 1 / 4 of the entire width, the grid size in the depth direction is less than 1 / 2, and the grid size in the length direction is less than the value of the welding speed.
[0015] Preferably, in S2, the drilling measurement position is in a part of the upper surface area where the temperature field on the workpiece is in a quasi-steady state throughout the whole process and the distance between the center of the drilling hole and the edge of the welded workpiece is greater than 3 times the center distance of the hole core plate. As many measurement points as possible should be arranged in the key detection area, while the measurement positions in other areas can be reduced to save resources. The distance between the centers of the strain gauge holes should be greater than 6 times the diameter of the drilled hole.
[0016] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has at least the following advantages:
[0017] The existing technology generally uses numerical simulation technology to predict or pinhole method to measure welding residual stress. The numerical simulation of welding stress field requires harsh calculation conditions and is time-consuming, while the selection of pinhole measurement positions and strain gauge rosettes are mostly based on experience or mechanical and rigid global equidistant arrangement, which not only makes it difficult to grasp the location of the peak stress, but also generates a lot of measurement costs.
[0018] Based on the characteristics of simple and fast numerical simulation of welding temperature field, the present invention numerically simulates the temperature field of the welded workpiece before performing the pinhole method measurement, divides the components to be measured into zones according to the numerical simulation results, and formulates the respective measurements according to the characteristics of each zone. In low stress areas and stress flat areas, select strain rosettes with lower prices and reduce the arrangement of measurement points to control costs; select strain rosettes with smaller sizes in key detection areas to improve measurement accuracy; in addition, the distribution characteristics of the welding temperature field through numerical simulation and the formation mechanism of welding residual stress can determine that the location of the peak stress will definitely fall in the key detection area. Therefore, this method can enhance the purposefulness of the pinhole method measurement process, improve measurement efficiency, save measurement costs, and increase the possibility of capturing peak stress. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0019] Figure 1 Finite element model.
[0020] Figure 2 Temperature field cloud diagram of the specimen.
[0021] Figure 3 Peak temperature curve and partition of the central cross section of the specimen.
[0022] Figure 4 Small hole drilling point arrangement diagram;
[0023] I: Low stress area BSF120-1.5CA-T
[0024] II: Key testing area BE120-1.5CA-K
[0025] III: stress relief zone BE120-2CA-K.
[0026] Figure 5 Distribution map of actual measurement locations.
[0027] Figure 6 Comparison of numerical simulation results and measurement results. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0028] The present invention is further explained below in conjunction with the accompanying drawings and specific embodiments. It should be understood that these examples are only used to illustrate the present invention and are not used to limit the scope of the present invention. After reading the present invention, modifications of various equivalent forms of the present invention by those skilled in the art all fall within the scope defined by the appended claims of the present application.
[0029] First, a finite element model is established according to the material, size and welding process of the welded workpiece, and the finite element method is used to perform numerical simulation of the welding process to obtain the change of the workpiece temperature field. According to the peak temperature of each area of the weldment and the physical properties of the material, the pinhole method punching measurement position and the size of the strain rosette are selected. The strain rosette is pasted at the selected measurement position, and the residual stress is measured by the pinhole method according to the corresponding standard. The measurement results of each point are projected onto a straight line perpendicular to the weld, and a stress-distance from the weld center coordinate system is established. Finally, the residual stress distribution measurement results of the welded workpiece are obtained.
[0030] The following is an example of measuring residual stress in welding of ultra-high strength steel for a special vehicle to illustrate the complete process of the present invention. The size of the welding specimen is 300 mm × 300 mm × 5 mm, the groove form is a V-shaped groove, the groove angle is 60°, the welding filler material is ER307Si stainless steel welding wire, the wire diameter is 1.2 mm, and the MIG welding method is used for single-pass welding.
[0031] First, feature modeling and meshing are performed according to the material and size of the workpiece to be welded, and the welding process is numerically simulated using finite element software to obtain the temperature distribution of the specimen, such as Figure 2 shown.
[0032] Take the peak temperature distribution curve of the central cross section of the specimen, such as Figure 3 According to the physical parameters of the ultra-high strength steel (melting point: 1450℃, A C1 : 720℃), the area 3mm away from the center of the weld is taken as the low stress area, the area of 3mm~20mm is the key detection area, and the rest is the stress gentle area.
[0033] When analyzing welding residual stress, in order to clearly show the stress distribution characteristics perpendicular to the weld direction, it is necessary to obtain the residual stress measurement results on the center line L1 of the upper surface of the plate as densely as possible. However, in actual measurement, considering that a certain distance needs to be maintained between strain rosettes, it is impossible to densely arrange strain rosettes on a straight line. Therefore, when measuring the residual stress distribution on the L1 line, the measurement position can be appropriately offset along the weld direction, and the measured residual stress value can be projected to the corresponding position on L1.
[0034] The distribution of small hole drilling measurement points is as follows: Figure 4 As shown in the figure, the residual stress of 11 drilling measurement points was measured. The key detection area was measured with the 3-axis strain rosette BE120-1.5CA-K, the low stress area was measured with the 3-axis strain rosette BSF120-1.5CA-T, and the stress gentle area was measured with the 3-axis strain rosette BE120-2CA-K. Figure 5 This is the actual measurement location distribution map.
[0035] After selecting the small hole drilling measurement point, the test area of the specimen is polished and cleared, and then the strain rosette is pasted. It is left to stand at room temperature for 10 to 12 hours, and then the small hole method residual stress measurement is carried out.
[0036] Taking the 3-axis strain gauge BSF120-1.5CA-T as an example, the residual stress is measured using the ASM1.0 stress and strain monitor, and the elastic modulus E is set to 210 GPa and the Poisson's ratio is v The diameter of the hole is 0.27, the center distance of the hole is 2.5mm, the hole radius is 0.75mm, the release coefficient A is -0.057, and the release coefficient B is -0.164. Install the RSD1 residual stress punching device, the drill diameter is 1.5mm, and the punching depth is 2mm. Before punching, the strain values of the three channels need to be cleared. When punching, the current of the speed regulator is controlled at 45~50A. After punching, the measurement results are printed after the readings are stable. The measurement process meets the standard ASTM E837-13a.
[0037] In order to more intuitively show the effect of using this measurement method, the material model considering solid phase transformation and softening effect is used to perform thermo-elastic-plastic finite element calculation to obtain the welding residual stress distribution of the workpiece, and then plot it in the same coordinate system for comparison with the experimental measurement results, such as Figure 6 The measured results are in good agreement with the simulation results, and the peak stress position is successfully captured, reflecting the accuracy of the temperature field numerical simulation technology in assisting the measurement of ultra-high strength steel welding residual stress.
Claims
1. A method for measuring ultra-high strength steel welding residual stress by numerical simulation of temperature field, characterized in that: The steps include: S1: Establish a 3D finite element model using existing modeling software according to the geometric dimensions of the workpiece to be welded. Use the established 3D finite element model and existing finite element software to perform numerical simulation of the welding process according to the material properties of the workpiece to be welded and its welding process, and obtain the temperature field distribution trend of the workpiece to be welded during the entire welding process; When establishing a 3D finite element model, the mesh size of the weld zone in the width direction of the welded workpiece is less than 1 / 4 of the entire width, the mesh size in the depth direction is less than 1 / 2, and the mesh size in the length direction is less than the value of the welding speed; S2: According to the temperature field distribution trend obtained by S1, the low stress area, key detection area and stress relaxation area are divided according to the peak temperature at each position and the material properties of the welded workpiece. Drilling measurement points are selected in the three areas of low stress area, key detection area and stress relaxation area; the area with a peak temperature exceeding the melting point of the base material is taken as the low stress area; the area adjacent to the low stress area with a width of about 3-4 times the HAZ is taken as the key detection area; the remaining area is the stress relaxation area; The drilling measurement position is in the upper surface area where the temperature field on the workpiece is in a quasi-steady state throughout the whole process and the distance between the center of the drilling hole and the edge of the welded workpiece is greater than 3 times the center distance of the hole core plate. The distance between the centers of the strain gauge rosette drilling holes should be greater than 6 times the diameter of the drilled hole; S3: Select the strain rosette with a hole-center distance of less than 5 mm in the key detection area; S4: Paste the strain rosette at the selected drilling measurement point, and measure and record the residual stress at each set position using the small hole method according to GB / T 31310-2014 or ASTM E837-13a standard.
Citation Information
Cited By
Welding residual stress simulation method
CN119538427A
