Flexible DC transmission line fault discrimination method based on transient voltage waveform comparison
By employing a transient voltage waveform comparison method in flexible DC transmission lines, the rate of change of the first traveling wave of the line-mode voltage at one end of the line is calculated and normalized. Euclidean distance is used to determine faults inside and outside the transmission area, solving the problem of communication between converter stations required in existing technologies and achieving rapid and reliable fault identification and differentiation.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410893987.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-04
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-07-04
AI Technical Summary
Existing flexible DC transmission line protection methods require communication between converter stations, which is inconvenient and makes it difficult to quickly and reliably protect against faults inside and outside the grid, especially in the case of high-resistance faults.
The method based on transient voltage waveform comparison is adopted. The change rate of the first traveling wave of the line-mode voltage at one end of the line is calculated, normalized, and Euclidean distance is used to determine faults inside and outside the area. It only relies on local information and does not require communication between converter stations.
It achieves fast and reliable fault identification inside and outside the zone, has strong tolerance to transition resistance, can accurately distinguish between high resistance faults at the end of the zone and faults outside the zone, and simplifies the design of protection devices.
Smart Images

Figure CN118914741A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present invention relates to the technical field of direct current transmission of electric power systems, and in particular to a method for distinguishing faults of flexible direct current transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison. Background Art
[0002] Flexible DC transmission technology based on modular multilevel converter (MMC) is flexible and controllable, has low harmonic content, and has no commutation failure problem. It can absorb new energy on a large scale and has been widely used around the world. However, the damping of the flexible DC grid is small. After a short circuit fault occurs on the DC side, the capacitor of the converter station submodule discharges rapidly to the fault point, and the fault current increases rapidly. Within a few milliseconds, the fault current will reach several times or even dozens of times the rated current of the power electronic device, which will cause overcurrent damage to primary equipment such as the valve group of the converter. This requires the main protection to quickly isolate the fault, and the rapid identification of faults inside and outside the zone is the basis of DC line protection. Therefore, the rapid and reliable identification of faults inside and outside the zone of flexible DC lines is a key issue that needs to be solved urgently.
[0003] The existing methods usually utilize the differences in electrical information of the converter stations at both ends of the line when there are faults inside and outside the area, such as the correlation characteristics of the voltage calculated based on the line boundary of the current and the measured voltage, the amplitude characteristics of the forward and reverse traveling waves on both sides of the line, etc. However, this type of method requires communication between converter stations, which is not convenient enough.
[0004] In view of this, a fault identification method for flexible DC transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison is needed. Summary of the invention
[0005] In view of the problem that the difference in electrical information between converter stations at both ends of the line during in-zone and out-zone faults in the prior art requires communication between converter stations, which is not convenient, the present invention provides a flexible DC transmission line fault identification method based on transient voltage waveform comparison, which can identify in-zone and out-zone faults based only on local information, without the need for communication between converter stations, has good speed and reliability, and has a strong ability to withstand transition resistance, and can effectively distinguish in-zone terminal high-resistance faults from out-zone faults. The specific technical solution is as follows:
[0006] A method for identifying faults in a flexible direct current transmission line based on transient voltage waveform comparison comprises the following steps:
[0007] Based on the simplified fault model of flexible DC system, the expression of the first line wave change rate of line mode voltage for typical internal fault and external fault is calculated respectively.
[0008] The calculated line mode voltage first line wave change rate waveform is normalized, and the processed waveform is the reference waveform;
[0009] Measure the positive and negative line voltage and current at the protection measuring point at one end of the line;
[0010] The line mode components of voltage and current at the measuring point are obtained by using the phase mode transformation matrix;
[0011] Calculate the line mode fault voltage traveling wave to obtain the first traveling wave waveform, calculate its change and perform normalization to obtain the waveform to be compared;
[0012] Use the Euclidean distance to calculate the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform of the fault inside and outside the zone. If the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform inside the zone is smaller, it is judged as an inside fault, otherwise it is judged as an outside fault.
[0013] Preferably, taking the positive pole grounding fault of the flexible DC line at both ends as an example, the RCL series model is used as the equivalent MMC converter station, and the DC line adopts the Bergeron model. The simplified system model of the line midpoint fault is as follows: Figure 2 shown.
[0014] In the figure, L dc is the line smoothing inductance, Z C1 is the line mode wave impedance of the DC line, Z C0 is the ground mode wave impedance of the DC line, B t12_1 , B f12_1 , B f21_1 , B t21_1 is the traveling wave contour line mode voltage source, B t12_0 , B f12_0 , B f21_0 , B t21_0 is the traveling wave equivalent ground mode voltage source, Z MMC1 With Z MMC2 is the equivalent impedance of the converter stations at both ends of the line, R f is the fault resistance, Additional voltage source for faults within the zone.
[0015] Preferably, the calculation method of the first line wave change rate waveform of the line mode voltage of the zone fault is as follows:
[0016]
[0017] B t12_1 =2A1(s)U f1
[0018]
[0019] Among them, U R1 ,I R1 are the line mode voltage and line mode current at the protection measuring point, A1(s) is the line transfer function, U b1_in(s) is the complex frequency domain expression of the first wave of the line mode voltage at the protection measuring point. The time domain expression U is obtained by inverse Laplace transform. b1_in (t), and after taking the derivative, we get its rate of change waveform U' b1_in (t) is the typical in-area fault waveform.
[0020] Preferably, a simplified system model of a positive pole grounding fault after the flexible DC line current limiting reactor at both ends is as follows: Figure 3 shown.
[0021] In the figure, L dc is the line smoothing inductance, Z C1 is the line mode wave impedance of the DC line, Z C0 is the ground mode wave impedance of the DC line, B t12_1 , B t21_0 are the traveling wave equivalent line mode voltage source and the traveling wave equivalent ground mode voltage source, Z MMC1 With Z MMC2 is the equivalent impedance of the converter stations at both ends of the line, R f is the fault resistance, It is the fault additional equivalent voltage source of the out-of-zone fault. The calculation process of the first wave change rate of the line mode voltage is as follows:
[0022]
[0023] B t12_1 =2A1(s)U f
[0024]
[0025] Among them, U R1 ,I R1 are the line mode voltage and line mode current at the protection measuring point, A1(s) is the line transfer function, U b1_out (s) is the complex frequency domain expression of the first wave of the line mode voltage at the protection measuring point. The time domain expression U is obtained by inverse Laplace transform. b1_out (t), and after taking the derivative, we get its rate of change waveform U' b1_out (t) is the typical out-of-zone fault waveform.
[0026] Preferably, a linear function normalization is used to normalize the first line waveform of the typical internal and external fault voltage, specifically:
[0027]
[0028] Among them, U' b1_in (t) and U' b1_out (t) is the first wave of the typical fault line mode voltage inside and outside the zone obtained by the above calculation, U b1_in_std (t), Ub1_out_std (t) is the normalized waveform, i.e., the reference waveform of the fault inside and outside the zone.
[0029] Preferably, according to the positive and negative line voltages and currents measured at the line head end, the line mode voltage first line wave change rate waveform is calculated using the following method:
[0030]
[0031] Among them, U p , U n is the positive and negative line voltage measured at the measurement point, I p ,I n is the positive and negative line current measured at the measuring point, T is the phase mode transformation matrix, Z C1 is the line mode wave impedance of the DC line, U b1 (t) is the first wave of line mode voltage, U' b1 (t) is the waveform of the first wave change rate of the line mode voltage.
[0032] Preferably, the first wave of the line mode voltage measured at the above measuring point is normalized to obtain the waveform to be compared, and the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform inside and outside the area is calculated using the Euclidean distance, as follows:
[0033]
[0034]
[0035] Where D in D is the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform in the area. out is the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform outside the area.
[0036] By comparing D in and D out The size of the fault is used to determine whether the fault is inside or outside the area:
[0037]
[0038] Compared with the prior art, the present invention has the following advantages and beneficial effects:
[0039] 1) The smoothing reactor of the DC system is a natural physical boundary, which has a band-stop characteristic for high-frequency components. The first wave of the out-of-zone fault voltage received at this end is severely distorted, and its characteristics are significantly different from those of the first wave of the in-zone fault voltage.
[0040] 2) The waveform data is limited to [-1,0] by using the normalization method. For systems with different voltage levels, there is no need to readjust the action threshold, and the principle is simple.
[0041] 3) Through simulation tests, the effectiveness and reliability of the proposed protection scheme are verified. It can accurately identify different types of internal and external faults and has a strong ability to withstand transition resistance.
[0042] 4) The judgment of faults inside and outside the area is based only on local information, and no communication between converter stations is required, so its speed and reliability are good. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0043] In order to more clearly illustrate the specific embodiments of the present invention or the technical solutions in the prior art, the following is a brief introduction to the drawings required for the specific embodiments or the description of the prior art. In all the drawings, similar elements or parts are generally identified by similar reference numerals. In the drawings, the elements or parts are not necessarily drawn according to the actual scale.
[0044] Figure 1 It is the topological structure diagram of the symmetrical bipolar MMC flexible DC transmission system;
[0045] Figure 2 f in Simplified model diagram of the system with positive ground fault;
[0046] Figure 3 f out Simplified model diagram of the system with positive ground fault;
[0047] Figure 4 The present invention is a flow chart of the method for distinguishing internal and external faults of flexible DC transmission lines based on the first wave distance of line mode voltage. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0048] The following will be combined with the drawings in the embodiments of the present invention to clearly and completely describe the technical solutions in the embodiments of the present invention. Obviously, the described embodiments are part of the embodiments of the present invention, not all of the embodiments. Based on the embodiments of the present invention, all other embodiments obtained by ordinary technicians in this field without creative work are within the scope of protection of the present invention.
[0049] It should be understood that when used in this specification and the appended claims, the terms "include" and "comprises" indicate the presence of described features, integers, steps, operations, elements and / or components, but do not exclude the presence or addition of one or more other features, integers, steps, operations, elements, components and / or combinations thereof.
[0050] It should also be understood that the terms used in the present specification are only for the purpose of describing specific embodiments and are not intended to limit the present invention. As used in the present specification and the appended claims, unless the context clearly indicates otherwise, the singular forms "a", "an" and "the" are intended to include plural forms.
[0051] It should be further understood that the term "and / or" used in the present description and the appended claims refers to any and all possible combinations of one or more of the associated listed items, and includes these combinations.
[0052] The present invention discloses a method for distinguishing between internal and external faults of flexible DC transmission lines, and aims to solve the problem of distinguishing between internal and external faults of flexible DC transmission lines. The method solves the expression of the rate of change of the first line wave of the line mode voltage at the measuring point when the DC line fails, normalizes it, and respectively calculates the distance between it and the internal and external fault reference waveforms. By comparing the two distances, accurate distinction between internal and external faults is achieved.
[0053] Example:
[0054] Taking the symmetrical bipolar MMC flexible DC transmission system as an example, the fault voltage traveling wave analysis is carried out. The system topology is as follows: Figure 1 As shown. The DC transmission line is a bipolar overhead line, L dc The current limiting reactor is used to suppress the rising rate of fault current. M and N are the protection installation locations at both ends of the DC line. Figure 1 The fault points of the reference waveforms of the faults inside and outside the calculation area are given, where f in is the fault point in the area, f out It is the fault point outside the area on the MMC1 side.
[0055] A method for identifying faults in a flexible DC transmission line based on transient voltage waveform comparison specifically comprises the following steps:
[0056] S1. Draw f in With f out Simplified model of the fault system during fault, and calculation of the first line wave change rate waveform of its line mode voltage.
[0057] In one embodiment, f in The simplified system model of the positive ground fault is as follows: Figure 2 As shown in the figure, L dc is the line smoothing inductance, Z C1 is the line mode wave impedance of the DC line, Z C0 is the ground mode wave impedance of the DC line, B t12_1 , B f12_1 , B f21_1 , B t21_1 is the traveling wave contour line mode voltage source, B t12_0 , B f12_0 , B f21_0 , B t21_0 is the traveling wave equivalent ground mode voltage source, Z MMC1 With Z MMC2is the equivalent impedance of the converter stations at both ends of the line, R f is the fault resistance, It is an additional voltage source for the fault in the zone. The calculation process of the change rate of the first wave of the line mode voltage is as follows:
[0058]
[0059] B t12_1 =2A1(s)U f1
[0060]
[0061]
[0062] Among them, U R1 ,I R1 are the line mode voltage and line mode current at the protection measuring point, A1(s) is the line transfer function, U b1_in (s) is the complex frequency domain expression of the first wave of the line mode voltage at the protection measuring point. The time domain expression U is obtained by inverse Laplace transform. b1_in (t), and after taking the derivative, we get the line mode voltage first wave rate waveform U' b1_in (t), which is the typical in-area fault waveform.
[0063] In one embodiment, f out The simplified system model of the positive ground fault is as follows: Figure 3 As shown in the figure, L dc is the line smoothing inductance, Z C1 is the line mode wave impedance of the DC line, Z C0 is the ground mode wave impedance of the DC line, B t12_1 , B t21_0 are the traveling wave equivalent line mode voltage source and the traveling wave equivalent ground mode voltage source, Z MMC1 With Z MMC2 is the equivalent impedance of the converter stations at both ends of the line, R f is the fault resistance, It is the fault additional equivalent voltage source of the out-of-zone fault. The calculation process of the first wave change rate of the line mode voltage is as follows:
[0064]
[0065] B t12_1 =2A1(s)U f
[0066]
[0067] Among them, U R1 ,I R1are the line mode voltage and line mode current at the protection measuring point, A1(s) is the line transfer function, U b1_out (s) is the complex frequency domain expression of the first wave of the line mode voltage at the protection measuring point. The time domain expression U is obtained by inverse Laplace transform. b1_out (t), and after taking the derivative, we get the line mode voltage first wave rate waveform U' b1_out (t), which is the typical out-of-zone fault waveform.
[0068] S2. Use linear function normalization to normalize the typical in-zone and out-of-zone fault waveforms obtained by the above calculation.
[0069] In one embodiment, the first line wave change rate waveform U of the line mode voltage in the region is normalized by a linear function. b1_in (t) and the first wave change rate waveform of the line mode voltage outside the area U b1_out (t) Perform normalization:
[0070]
[0071] Among them, U' b1_in (t) and U' b1_out (t) is the typical in-zone and out-zone fault waveform obtained by the above calculation, U b1_in_std (t), U b1_out_std (t) is the normalized waveform, i.e., the reference waveform of the fault inside and outside the zone.
[0072] S3. Calculate the normalized line mode voltage first line wave change rate waveform according to the positive and negative line voltages and currents measured at the protection measurement point M.
[0073] In one embodiment, taking the measurement point M of the MMC converter station as an example, the measured positive and negative line voltages are U p , U n , the positive and negative line currents are I p ,I n After phase mode transformation, the line mode voltage U1 and line mode current I1 are obtained, and then the first line mode voltage wave U is calculated. b1 (t), and the derivative is used to obtain the line mode voltage first wave rate waveform U' b1 (t).
[0074]
[0075] Where Z C1 is the line mode wave impedance of the DC line, U b1 (t) is the first wave of fault voltage, U' b1 (t) is the waveform of the first wave change rate of the line mode voltage.
[0076] Normalize it:
[0077]
[0078] S4. Use Euclidean distance to calculate the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform inside and outside the area.
[0079]
[0080] Where D in D is the distance between the first wave of the fault voltage and the reference waveform in the area. out It is the distance between the first wave of fault voltage and the reference waveform outside the zone.
[0081] S5, according to the waveform distance D in , D out Determine whether the fault is an internal or external fault:
[0082]
[0083] So far, the present invention proposes a method for fault identification of flexible DC transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison. The specific process is as follows: Figure 4 As shown, including:
[0084] (1) Calculate the first line change rate waveform of line mode voltage for typical internal and external faults;
[0085] (2) The line mode voltage first line wave change rate waveforms of typical internal and external faults are normalized to obtain the internal and external fault reference waveforms;
[0086] (3) Calculate the rate of change of the first wave of the line mode voltage based on the positive and negative line voltages and currents measured at the measuring points, and obtain the waveform to be compared after normalization;
[0087] (4) Using the Euclidean distance, calculate the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform of the fault inside and outside the area respectively;
[0088] (5) If the distance between the waveform to be compared and the in-zone fault reference waveform is smaller, it is judged to be an in-zone fault; otherwise, it is an out-of-zone fault.
[0089] The present invention is further described below through a specific simulation example.
[0090] This embodiment builds the following in PSCAD / EMTDC: Figure 1 The double-terminal flexible DC transmission system model shown in the figure is simulated and tested. The converter stations all adopt the MMC model, and the specific model parameters are shown in Table 1. The DC transmission line adopts a frequency-variable parameter model, and the system sampling frequency is selected as 10kHz.
[0091] Table 1 Model parameters
[0092]
[0093] The protection algorithm is written on the MATLAB platform, and the fault simulation data of the PSCAD model is imported to verify the discrimination of internal and external faults. Internal and external faults with different fault types and different transition resistances are set at different locations on the DC transmission line TLine, and the simulation results are shown in Table 2.
[0094] Table 2 Results of fault identification inside and outside the zone
[0095]
[0096]
[0097]
[0098] From Table 2, we can see that for different fault distances and transition resistances under intra-zone faults, the distance D between the first wave of the line mode voltage received at the line measurement point M and the intra-zone reference waveform is in are all smaller than the distance D between them and the reference waveform outside the area out , can accurately identify the fault as an internal fault; for the external fault after the smoothing reactor at the end of the DC line, the distance D between the first wave of the line mode voltage received at the line measurement point M and the internal reference waveform in are greater than the distance D between them and the reference waveform outside the area out , can accurately identify the fault as an out-of-zone fault. Therefore, the proposed protection scheme is basically not affected by transition resistance and fault distance.
[0099] Finally, it should be noted that the above embodiments are only used to illustrate the technical solutions of the present invention, rather than to limit it. Although the present invention has been described in detail with reference to the aforementioned embodiments, those skilled in the art should understand that they can still modify the technical solutions described in the aforementioned embodiments, or replace some or all of the technical features therein by equivalents. These modifications or replacements do not make the essence of the corresponding technical solutions deviate from the scope of the technical solutions of the embodiments of the present invention, and they should all be included in the scope of the claims and specification of the present invention.
Claims
1. A method for fault identification of flexible DC transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison, characterized in that: The following steps are involved: Based on the simplified fault model of flexible DC system, the expressions of the first wave change rate of line mode voltage for typical intra-zone faults and extra-zone faults are calculated respectively. The calculated line mode voltage first line wave change rate waveform is normalized, and the processed waveform is the reference waveform; Measure the positive and negative line voltage and current at the protection measuring point at one end of the line; The line mode components of voltage and current at the measuring point are obtained by using the phase mode transformation matrix; Calculate the line mode fault voltage traveling wave, extract the first traveling wave data, solve the first traveling wave change rate information and perform normalization processing to obtain the waveform to be compared; The Euclidean distance is used to calculate the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform. If the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform within the zone is smaller than the distance between the reference waveform outside the zone, it is judged as an within-zone fault, otherwise it is judged as an outside-zone fault.
2. A method for fault identification of flexible DC transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison according to claim 1, characterized in that: Taking the positive pole grounding fault of the flexible DC line at both ends as an example, the calculation method of the first line wave change rate waveform of the line mode voltage of the fault in the area is as follows: B t12_1 =2A1(s)U f1 Among them, U R1 ,I R1 are the line mode voltage and line mode current at the protection measuring point, A1(s) is the line transfer function, U b1_in (s) is the complex frequency domain expression of the first wave of the line mode voltage at the protection measuring point. The time domain expression U is obtained by inverse Laplace transform. b1_in (t), and after taking the derivative, we get its rate of change waveform U' b1_in (t) is the typical in-area fault waveform, L dc is the line smoothing inductance, Z C1 is the line mode wave impedance of the DC line, Z C0 is the ground mode wave impedance of the DC line, B t12_1 , B f12_1 , B f21_1 , B t21_1 is the traveling wave contour line mode voltage source, B t12_0 , B f12_0 , B f21_0 , B t21_0 is the traveling wave equivalent ground mode voltage source, Z MMC1 With Z MMC2 is the equivalent impedance of the converter stations at both ends of the line, R f is the fault resistance, Additional voltage source for faults within the zone.
3. The method for fault identification of flexible DC transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison according to claim 2 is characterized in that: The calculation method of the first line change rate waveform of the line mode voltage of the out-of-zone fault is as follows: B t12_1 =2A1(s)U f Among them, U R1 ,I R1 are the line mode voltage and line mode current at the protection measuring point, A1(s) is the line transfer function, U b1_out (s) is the complex frequency domain expression of the first wave of the line mode voltage at the protection measuring point. The time domain expression U is obtained by inverse Laplace transform. b1_out (t), and after taking the derivative, we get its rate of change waveform U' b1_out (t) is the typical out-of-zone fault waveform.
4. The method for identifying faults in a flexible DC transmission line based on transient voltage waveform comparison according to claim 3 is characterized in that: The linear function normalization is used to normalize the waveform of the first line change rate of the fault voltage inside and outside the typical area, specifically: Among them, U' b1_in (t) and U' b1_out (t) is the first line voltage change rate waveform of the typical fault line mode voltage inside and outside the zone obtained by the above calculation, U b1_in_std (t), U b1_out_std (t) is the normalized waveform, i.e., the reference waveform of the fault inside and outside the zone.
5. The method for fault identification of flexible DC transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison according to claim 1 is characterized in that: According to the positive and negative line voltages and currents measured at the head end of the line, the following method is used to calculate the first line wave change rate waveform of the line mode voltage: Among them, U p , U n is the positive and negative line voltage measured at the measurement point, I p ,I n is the positive and negative line current measured at the measuring point, T is the phase mode transformation matrix, Z C1 is the line mode wave impedance of the DC line, U b1 (t) is the first wave of line mode voltage, U' b1 (t) is the waveform of the first wave change rate of the line mode voltage.
6. A method for fault identification of flexible DC transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison according to claim 5, characterized in that: The measured line mode voltage first line wave change rate waveform is normalized to obtain the waveform to be compared, as follows:
7. A method for identifying faults in flexible DC transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison according to claim 6, characterized in that: The Euclidean distance is used to calculate the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform inside and outside the area, as follows: Where D in D is the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform in the area. out is the distance between the waveform to be compared and the reference waveform outside the area.
8. The method for fault identification of flexible DC transmission lines based on transient voltage waveform comparison according to claim 7 is characterized in that: By comparing D in and D out The size of the fault is used to determine the fault inside and outside the area, as follows:
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Direct-current power distribution network protection method based on voltage characteristic traveling wave similarity measurement
CN108923398A
In-area and out-area fault protection method based on cosine similarity
CN111983376A
Multi-terminal DC power grid reclosing method and system based on waveform similarity matching
CN113659541A
Multi-terminal flexible DC power grid single-terminal quantity setting-free protection method based on first traveling wave similarity
CN116316463A
Flexible DC power grid fault direction criterion method based on waveform correlation coefficient
CN116388178A
