Aero-engine redesign engineering method and system
By using aero-engine redesign engineering methods and systems, aero-engine products are systematically improved, solving the systemic deficiencies in the design and manufacturing of existing technologies, improving product quality and R&D capabilities, ensuring product conformity and the integrity of the manufacturing process, and continuously accumulating R&D experience.
Patent Information
- Application Number
- CN202410960131.8
- Authority / Receiving Office
- CN · China
- Patent Type
- Applications(China)
- Current Assignee / Owner
- Filing Date
- 2024-07-17
- Publication Date
- 2024-11-08
- Estimated Expiration
- 2044-07-17
AI Technical Summary
Existing aero-engine redesign methods lack systematicity and completeness, fail to improve product manufacturing and process, and fail to integrate model experience into the R&D system, resulting in insufficient improvement in product development capabilities.
This paper proposes an aero-engine redesign engineering method and system. By using a systems engineering V-model to examine the requirements-design-manufacturing-verification process in a forward direction, risks and problems are identified, and redesign, remanufacturing and reverification are implemented. In reverse, model experience is integrated to build an independent R&D system and improve product development quality and R&D capabilities.
It has achieved end-to-end improvement and verification of aero-engine products, improved product quality and R&D capabilities, ensured product conformity and manufacturing process integrity, continuously accumulated R&D experience, and supported product iterative development.
Smart Images

Figure CN118917010A_ABST
Abstract
Description
Technical Field
[0001] The present application belongs to the field of aircraft engine design, and in particular, relates to an aircraft engine redesign engineering method and system. Background Art
[0002] The aircraft engine redesign project is a process of using the results of the engine R&D system construction to re-examine and continuously improve the aircraft engine products after a project. It can improve and upgrade the product's technical status and create high-quality aircraft engine products. At the same time, by summarizing the model development experience, the product development experience can be introduced into the R&D system to build an advanced, complete and easy-to-use independent R&D system.
[0003] An aircraft engine is a complex thermal machine that is used repeatedly for a long time under harsh conditions such as high temperature, high pressure, high speed and alternating load. It has typical multidisciplinary deep coupling, complex and changeable working environment, extremely complex internal working mechanism, high reliability and long life development characteristics. Even after the engine has completed tens of thousands of hours of ground and flight tests, it still faces the need for continuous product upgrade and improvement, ultimately achieving the improvement of engine development quality and maximizing product research and development efficiency.
[0004] In the existing technology, the national standard "GB / T 26240-2010 Application and Management of System Engineering Process" puts forward the concept of "reengineering", emphasizing that reengineering is the redevelopment of products after a project, that is, after the product is produced, the process of correcting design deficiencies or making incremental improvements through modification to achieve product improvement or evolution of new products and improve product performance. However, the standard does not clearly define the specific requirements and practices for implementing reengineering, and has the disadvantages of insufficient executability and operability. In addition, the existing document "Research on the Application of Reanalysis, Redesign and Revalidation in Aerospace Products" implements "reanalysis, redesign and revalidation" (referred to as "three revalidations") for aerospace vehicles. Among them, "reanalysis" mainly focuses on the problems existing in the use of products and conducts key / important characteristics analysis; "redesign" mainly conducts secondary design based on the key / important characteristics determined by reanalysis; "revalidation" mainly conducts supplementary verification based on the results of redesign, which to a certain extent achieves the improvement of product technical status and system and whole machine integration verification, improves the inherent reliability of products, and effectively ensures the safety of product flight tests. However, the "three revalidations" method has the following three shortcomings:
[0005] 1) The "three re" method is mainly guided by failure problems, and "re-analysis, re-design and re-verification" are carried out for product failure problems and weak links. There is a lack of systematicity and completeness in product improvement. The depth and breadth of the analysis do not cover the entire product development process, resulting in insufficient systematic consideration of product improvement;
[0006] 2) Lack of "re-analysis" of product manufacturing and process, resulting in insufficient improvement of weak links in product technology;
[0007] 3) Although the “three agains” approach has achieved an improvement in product development quality to a certain extent, the new model experience gained from product improvement has not yet been integrated into the R&D system, and cannot achieve continuous improvement in product R&D capabilities and effective support for the development of new models.
[0008] Therefore, both of the above methods have application limitations and cannot improve product R&D capabilities. It is necessary to propose a new aero-engine product design improvement method to effectively improve product development quality and R&D capabilities. Summary of the invention
[0009] The purpose of the present application is to provide an aircraft engine redesign engineering method and system to solve or alleviate at least one problem in the background technology.
[0010] The technical solution of this application is: an aero-engine redesign engineering method, comprising:
[0011] Clarify the connotation of redesign engineering, which is to optimize and improve the products in production and use of aero-engines again. Positively, guided by demand, systematically analyze the integrity and compliance of the entire R&D process of product demand-design activities-production and manufacturing-test verification, identify and discover risks and problems in the product, and improve and upgrade the technical status of the engine by modifying the design or improving the process; negatively guided by model experience, refine model development experience and integrate it into the R&D system, continuously supplement and improve and build an advanced, complete and easy-to-use independent R&D system, and realize the accumulation and improvement of the product R&D system capabilities;
[0012] The process activities of the redesign project are clarified. The process activities of the redesign project include five process activities: reanalysis, redesign, remanufacturing, reverification and model experience re-refinement of aircraft engines. Among them, reanalysis, redesign, remanufacturing and re-verification are aimed at improving the design of engine models. The results of reanalysis are used as input to redesign, remanufacture and re-verify the products. The four are mutually confirmed and passed on layer by layer to reflect the end-to-end improvement and verification of product design improvements from demand to product delivery. Model experience re-refinement is aimed at accumulating and improving the capabilities of the product R&D system, including building a model experience refinement model and a product iterative development model to integrate multi-dimensional model experience into the R&D system.
[0013] Based on the connotation and process activities of the redesign project, the architecture of the redesign project is constructed.
[0014] In addition, the present application also provides an aircraft engine redesign engineering system, including:
[0015] The engine general requirement management module is used to characterize the general requirements of the engine at all levels to ensure the integrity and compliance of the model requirement definition, including: requirement number, requirement item, requirement classification, requirement source, responsible profession, feasibility analysis, feasibility analysis results, design verification criteria, design verification results, design compliance analysis, test verification criteria, verification level, verification resources, verification hours, test funds, test verification results, test compliance analysis, model problems, and design improvement measures data information;
[0016] The technical activity management module specifies the design activities, design verification activities and test verification activities required for product development based on the product development requirements, and ensures the integrity and compliance of the model development process, including: activity name, activity type, activity status, activity integrity check, activity compliance check, activity certification documents, model problems, and design improvement measures data information;
[0017] The technical key point management module, based on R&D activities, clarifies the key methods and criteria that must be followed in the execution of technical activities to ensure the accuracy of the execution of technical activities, including: the name of the technical key point, the reason for listing it as a technical key point, the mastery status of the technical key point, the normative documents based on it, and the data attributes of the technical key point improvement suggestions;
[0018] The product definition management module completely defines the design points, process points and inspection points of the product based on the product design results to ensure the integrity and compliance of the product manufacturing process, including: drawing number, product development requirements, product design points, implementation of engineering drawings, product definition risk analysis, product process points, product process control results, process risk analysis, product inspection points, product inspection results, and inspection process risk analysis data information;
[0019] The system element management module, based on model development experience, mines and refines model development experience in multiple dimensions and forms system elements, which is used to manage and control the extraction of model experience, the development and access of system elements, including: experience extraction dimensions, experience extraction names, experience extraction results, experience integration into system element types, system element names, system element file numbers, and system element status data information. BRIEF DESCRIPTION OF THE DRAWINGS
[0020] In order to more clearly illustrate the technical solution provided by the present application, the following is a brief introduction to the accompanying drawings. Obviously, the accompanying drawings described below are only some embodiments of the present application.
[0021] Figure 1 This is a flow chart of the aircraft engine redesign engineering method for this application.
[0022] Figure 2 The invention relates to an aero-engine redesign engineering framework for the present application.
[0023] Figure 3 A method for constructing universal requirements for all levels of the engine for this application.
[0024] Figure 4 A flow chart was prepared for the aircraft engine test of this application.
[0025] Figure 5 This is a flow chart for analyzing the aero-engine test results of this application.
[0026] Figure 6 This is an empirical refinement model for the multi-dimensional model of aircraft engines for this application.
[0027] Figure 7 A structured experience extraction method based on the IPOCE model was compiled for this application.
[0028] Figure 8 The "W" model was iteratively developed for the aircraft engine improvement design of this application.
[0029] Fig. 9 This is the aircraft engine redesign engineering management system for this application. DETAILED DESCRIPTION
[0030] In order to make the purpose, technical solutions and advantages of the implementation of this application clearer, the technical solutions in the embodiments of this application will be described in more detail below in conjunction with the drawings in the embodiments of this application.
[0031] In order to achieve both improvement in the quality of aircraft engine product development and improvement in the capabilities of the R&D system, this application proposes an aircraft engine redesign engineering method and system. Based on the forward design concept of the system engineering V model and driven by demand, this application positively examines the integrity and compliance of the model development process, identifies model development risks and problems, and improves model quality through improved design; reversely refines model development experience and integrates it into the R&D system to accumulate and improve product R&D capabilities; supports the realization of high-quality and efficient R&D of aircraft engines, and provides more advanced and reliable aircraft engine products that meet user needs.
[0032] like Figure 1 As shown, the aero-engine redesign engineering method provided by the present application includes the following process:
[0033] Step S1, establish the redesign engineering framework: The aircraft engine redesign engineering framework mainly clarifies the connotation of the redesign engineering, process activities and the logical relationship between various activities, which is used to guide the implementation of the redesign engineering and ensure the systematicness and executability of the redesign engineering method.
[0034] Step S11, clarify the connotation of redesign engineering: aircraft engine redesign engineering is to optimize and improve the products in production and use of aircraft engines again, apply the system engineering V model method, take demand as the driving force, systematically analyze the integrity and compliance of the entire R&D process of product demand-design activities-production and manufacturing-test verification, identify and discover the risks and problems of the product, and improve and upgrade the technical status of the engine by modifying the design or improving the process, and create high-quality aircraft engine products; reversely, take model experience as the guide, refine model development experience and integrate it into the R&D system, continuously supplement and improve and build an advanced, complete and easy-to-use independent R&D system, and realize the accumulation and improvement of product R&D system capabilities. The essence of redesign engineering is the process of continuous improvement and improvement of models and continuous improvement of R&D capabilities.
[0035] Step S12, clarify the redesign engineering process activities: Based on the connotation of redesign engineering, in order to achieve dual improvement of product development quality and R&D capabilities, it is determined that the redesign engineering activities mainly include five process activities: aero-engine reanalysis, redesign, remanufacturing, reverification and model experience re-refinement. Among them, reanalysis, redesign, remanufacturing and re-verification are aimed at improving the design of engine models. With the "reanalysis" results as input, the product is redesigned, remanufactured and re-verified. The four are mutually confirmed and passed on layer by layer, reflecting the end-to-end improvement and verification of product design improvements from demand to product delivery. Model experience re-refinement is aimed at the accumulation and improvement of product R&D system capabilities, mainly including the construction of model experience refinement model and product iterative development model, so as to realize the integration of multi-dimensional model experience into the R&D system.
[0036] Step S13, forming a redesign project framework: Based on the connotation and process activities of the redesign project, construct the redesign project framework, such as Figure 2As shown, on the one hand, guided by model demand, firstly, the construction achievements of the R&D system are used to support the implementation of the model redesign project. By implementing "re-analysis", the integrity and compliance of the model R&D process (development demand-design activities-production and manufacturing-test verification) are reviewed throughout the process, risks and problems in the engine development process are identified, and product improvement needs and weak links are clarified; secondly, based on the results of re-analysis, demand-based product forward design is implemented to achieve product technical status improvement; thirdly, based on the product design results, the definition of product design key points-process key points-testing key points is implemented, remanufacturing is implemented, and product manufacturing compliance is improved; Finally, according to the demand-based product test planning, the whole process test process activities are implemented to improve the integrity and effectiveness of product test verification; finally, high-quality engine products that meet the needs of users are submitted; on the other hand, guided by model experience, through the establishment of a multi-dimensional model experience refinement model, the model development experience is summarized and refined, and the carrier type of model experience is clarified to form system elements (specifications / standards, instructions, templates and checklists, software tools, etc.), and incorporated into the product R&D system; at the same time, a "W" model of product improvement and iterative development is established to integrate the redesign engineering process activities into the R&D system, and ultimately achieve the improvement of the product R&D system capabilities.
[0037] Step S2, aircraft engine "re-analysis": Based on the method of the system engineering V model, use the latest achievements in the construction of the R&D system to be positively driven by demand, systematically analyze the integrity and compliance of the entire R&D process of product R&D needs-design activities-production and manufacturing-test verification, systematically and completely identify and discover the risks and problems of the product, clarify the improvement needs and weak links of the product, and ensure the integrity and effectiveness of the subsequent redesign.
[0038] Step S21, requirement integrity analysis: The aircraft engine requirement integrity analysis mainly builds common engine items and analyzes the applicability of common requirement items in combination with model development requirements. For requirement items that are applicable to the model but are not included in the model development requirements or lack clear technical indicator requirements, identify and discover the incompleteness of requirements during the model development process; for missing requirement content, identify risks and problems in the product.
[0039] The following mainly explains the requirement integrity analysis process from three steps: establishing general requirements for all levels of the engine, building model requirements, and requirement integrity analysis.
[0040] Step S211, establish general requirements for all levels of the engine: Figure 3First, establish a full-level engine demand architecture. Based on the engine product breakdown structure (PBS), clarify the engine whole machine layer, component / system layer and component layer demand management hierarchical architecture to achieve top-down demand decomposition and top-up demand verification; second, establish a general engine demand classification. According to the requirements of the "Regulations on the Preparation of Special Specifications for Weapon Equipment Development Projects" GJB 6387-2008, form a structured general engine demand classification from 26 aspects such as engine function, performance, integrity, combat applicability, general quality characteristics, durability, etc., to ensure the integrity of general requirements; finally, form general demand items. By sorting out model development requirements and summarizing the development experience of other similar models, sorting out foreign standards and materials, foreign cooperation experience, interpreting airworthiness standards and military standards, etc., in accordance with the principles of integrity, consistency, applicability, technicality, structuring, and itemization of demand items, summarize and refine the demand content, and construct general engine demand items at all levels; ensure the standardization, systematicity, integrity and operability of demand items.
[0041] For example, in this embodiment of the present application, in combination with the engine development requirement categories, according to the requirements of the "Regulations on the Preparation of Special Specifications for Weapon Equipment Development Projects" GJB 6387-2008, a general engine requirement architecture is formed, including 26 requirement categories such as function, performance, structural integrity, and general quality characteristics, as shown in Table 1; at the same time, according to Figure 3 The construction method of general requirements for all levels of the engine and the principles for writing general requirements form the general requirements for the engine as shown in Table 2.
[0042] Table 1 General engine requirements architecture
[0043] Serial number Demand Classification Serial number Demand Classification 1 Function 14 stability 2 performance 15 interface 3 Completeness 16 Affordability 4 Operational suitability 17 Computer Hardware and Software 5 Common Quality Characteristics 18 Size and volume 6 Durability 19 weight 7 Information Security 20 color 8 Airworthiness 21 Materials and Process 9 Concealment 22 Non-developmental projects 10 compatibility 23 Appearance quality 11 Transportability 24 Logo and code 12 Ergonomics 25 Main component characteristics 13 Interchangeability 26 standardization
[0044] Table 2 General requirements for engines
[0045]
[0046]
[0047] Step S212, construct model requirement items: First, analyze the applicability of general requirement items. Combined with the development requirements of the engine model, analyze the applicability of general requirement items one by one, and explain the reasons for the inapplicability of inapplicable general requirement items; second, construct model requirement items. According to the model specifications of the engine and the technical requirements of the components / systems, supplement the technical indicators of each general requirement item to form a complete model requirement item.
[0048] Step S213, requirement integrity analysis: First, define the engine requirement integrity analysis attributes. Mainly including: general requirement number, general requirement item, requirement classification, responsible profession, applicability analysis results, inapplicability description, model requirement items and other 9 requirement attributes; secondly, based on the results of the applicability analysis of general requirement items, for the general requirement items of applicability, but the requirement items that are not included in the model development requirements or lack clear technical indicators, identify and discover the incomplete requirements in the model development process; finally, analyze the impact of missing requirement items on product development, and analyze the risks and problems of the model. Prepare according to the content of Table 3.
[0049] Table 3 Engine requirement completeness analysis table
[0050]
[0051] For example, in this embodiment of the present application, the model requirement applicability is analyzed item by item for the general requirement items, and the model technical indicators are supplemented to form the engine model requirement items as shown in Table 4.
[0052] Table 4 Engine requirement integrity analysis table
[0053]
[0054]
[0055] Step S22, R&D process integrity and compliance analysis: The aircraft engine R&D process integrity and compliance analysis mainly includes the design process, manufacturing process and verification process integrity and compliance analysis to identify risks and problems in the product R&D process.
[0056] Step S221, design process integrity and compliance analysis: First, establish a product development process. Based on the system engineering V model, build a forward product development process covering demand analysis-architecture design-component / subsystem design-structure development-test verification to achieve full coverage of product demand-design-verification process; second, establish a design activity combing matrix. Based on the product model development requirements, establish the relationship between the requirements and the design activities in the product development process, and clarify the design activities and design verification activities required to achieve the requirements. Among them, the design activities are mainly the calculation and analysis activities that need to be carried out to achieve the requirements themselves; the design verification activities are mainly to verify the compliance of the requirements through calculation, simulation analysis and analogy; ensure the integrity of the product design process; third, define the technical points for the execution of design activities. The technical points are the key methods and criteria required for the execution of process activities. Among them, the technical points of design activities and design verification activities mainly include five aspects: model accuracy, feature size, typical parameter rationality, working state and environmental load accuracy, boundary condition accuracy, etc., to ensure the accuracy and compliance of the execution of design activities; finally, complete the design activity integrity and compliance analysis. According to the results of the design activities and the technical points of the design activities, combined with the design output results of the engine, analyze the completeness and accuracy of the output results of each design activity item by item, complete the integrity and compliance analysis of the design process, and analyze the possible risks for incomplete and non-compliant design activities. Prepare according to the contents of Table 5.
[0057] Table 5 Engine design process integrity and compliance analysis table
[0058]
[0059] For example, in this embodiment of the present application, according to the established forward product development process, based on the defined model requirements, the design activities and design verification activities are sorted out and the technical key points are defined, and the design process integrity and compliance analysis is completed. The results of the engine design process integrity and compliance analysis are shown in Table 6.
[0060] Table 6 Engine design process integrity and compliance analysis table
[0061]
[0062]
[0063] Step S222, manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis: First, complete the product definition, and clarify the product design points based on the product design results. The product design points refer to the design requirements related to the processing and assembly processes of aircraft engine products (parts) proposed to meet the development requirements of product performance, structure, strength, etc., including dimensional requirements, technical requirements, standard requirements, etc. in product drawings. Secondly, complete the integrity and compliance analysis of product design key points, analyze the implementation of engine component engineering drawings based on the determined product design key points, and put forward suggestions for improving and perfecting the engineering drawings for missing or non-compliant product design key points; thirdly, based on the product design key points, process personnel complete the definition of product process key points and inspection key points. Product process key points refer to the process, process parameters, process assurance measures, etc. that need to be controlled during the product manufacturing and assembly processes in order to meet the aircraft engine product design key points; product inspection and testing key points refer to the inspection and testing means and methods, tools, parameters, etc. that need to be controlled during the inspection and testing of product manufacturing and assembly in order to meet the aircraft engine product design key points, and clarify the control requirements of the product manufacturing process; finally, analyze the integrity and compliance of the product manufacturing process, analyze the integrity and compliance of product design key points-process key points-inspection key points based on the process data and results of product manufacturing and processing, complete the compilation of Table 7, and put forward suggestions for manufacturing process improvement for existing problems.
[0064] Table 7 Engine manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis table
[0065]
[0066] For example, in this embodiment of the present application, the product design key points, process key points and inspection key points are defined based on the engineering drawings of the engine components, and the manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis is completed based on the actual manufacturing inspection results of the product. Taking the engine three-stage disc shaft as an example, the manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis results are shown in Table 8.
[0067] Table 8 Engine third-stage disc shaft manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis table
[0068]
[0069]
[0070] Step S223, verification process integrity and compliance analysis: First, establish a test plan based on requirements. Based on the product model development requirements, establish the relationship between the requirements and the verification activities in the product development process, clarify the test verification activities required to achieve the requirements, and the test verification mainly confirms the compliance of the verification requirements through test verification, assembly verification, testing and product use, so as to form a test verification plan based on requirements and ensure the integrity of the product development verification process; secondly, define the technical points of the test activities. It mainly includes five aspects: the integrity of the test items, the accuracy of the technical status of the test pieces, the integrity of the test procedures, the accuracy of the test conditions, and the validity of the test results, to ensure the accuracy and compliance of the execution of the test activities; finally, complete the integrity and compliance analysis of the verification process. According to the technical points of the test items and test activities in the test plan, combined with the verification results of the engine, analyze whether the output results of each verification activity are complete and accurate, complete the integrity and compliance analysis of the verification process, and analyze the possible risks for incomplete and non-compliant technical activities; and complete the compilation of Table 9.
[0071] Table 9 Engine Verification Process Integrity and Compliance Analysis
[0072]
[0073] For example, in this embodiment of the present application, based on the product model development requirements, the relationship between the requirements and the test verification activities in the product development process is established, and the test verification activities required to achieve the requirements are clarified; at the same time, based on the definition of technical points of the test activities, mainly including the integrity of the test items, the accuracy of the technical status of the test pieces, the integrity of the test procedures, the accuracy of the test conditions, the validity of the test results and other five aspects, to ensure the accuracy and compliance of the execution of the test activities. According to the technical points of the test items and test activities in the test planning, combined with the verification results of the engine, the integrity and compliance analysis of the verification process is completed. The results of the integrity and compliance analysis of the engine test verification process are shown in Table 10.
[0074] Table 10 Engine Verification Process Integrity and Compliance Analysis
[0075]
[0076] Step S23, demand compliance analysis: The demand compliance analysis is mainly based on the design and verification results of the model, proving the satisfaction of the design verification criteria and test verification criteria corresponding to the demand, and explaining the compliance results of the engine demand. First, construct a model demand verification matrix, clarify 12 attributes such as model demand number, model demand item, demand classification, design criteria, design results, design verification compliance, test verification criteria, etc., to form a model demand verification matrix; secondly, clarify the design verification criteria and test verification criteria of the demand. The demand verification criteria are the standards and requirements for proving the compliance of the demand. According to the product development specifications and guidelines, the design criteria and verification criteria of the model requirements are clarified item by item from the two dimensions of design verification criteria and test verification criteria; thirdly, analyze the compliance of the model requirements, as shown in Table 11. Based on the design and verification results of the model, prove the satisfaction of the design verification criteria and test verification criteria item by item, and explain the compliance results of the design verification and test verification of the engine demand; finally, analyze the model risks and problems. For the demand content that the design verification results or test verification results do not meet, explain the risks and problems of the model development, and provide support for the improvement of model design and the improvement of the R&D system capabilities.
[0077] Table 11 Engine Requirements Compliance Analysis
[0078]
[0079]
[0080] For example, in this embodiment of the present application, a model requirement compliance analysis matrix is constructed to clarify the design criteria and verification criteria of the requirements. Based on the design and verification results of the model, the satisfaction of the design verification criteria and test verification criteria is analyzed item by item, and the compliance results of the design verification and physical verification of the requirements are explained. The requirements compliance analysis results of the whole engine are shown in Table 12.
[0081] Table 12 Engine unit requirements compliance analysis table
[0082]
[0083]
[0084] Step S3, aircraft engine "redesign": aircraft engine "redesign" is to complete product "reanalysis" and obtain product improvement needs and weak links on the basis of risks and problems existing in R&D objects at all levels such as missing product development needs, incomplete and non-compliant R&D processes, and non-compliant development needs. It clarifies product improvement needs and weak links, and completes product redesign in accordance with the forward product development process of demand analysis-architecture design-component / subsystem design-structural development to achieve improvement and upgrade of technical status.
[0085] Step S31, define product improvement requirements: Based on the requirements integrity analysis results, the R&D process integrity and compliance analysis results and the requirements compliance analysis results, define engine improvement requirements in the format of Table 13 for requirements that are missing from product development requirements, incomplete and non-compliant R&D processes, unsatisfied development requirements, and requirements that have been changed by users.
[0086] Table 13 Engine improvement requirements
[0087]
[0088]
[0089] For example, in this embodiment of the present application, according to the method of step S31, product improvement requirement items are formed as shown in Table 14.
[0090] Table 14 Engine improvement requirements
[0091]
[0092] Step S32, implement product forward design: first, based on the defined product improvement requirements, complete the product requirement analysis and form a list of design and design verification activities for the realization of the requirements according to the method of step S221; secondly, according to the forward product development process of requirement analysis-architecture design-component / subsystem design-structural development, carry out engine function design, logical architecture design and physical architecture design, and complete the engine whole machine design and design verification activities according to the technical activity list to form an engine whole machine design plan; thirdly, complete the engine component / system design, complete the design and design verification activities at the component / system level, and form a component system plan; finally, based on the design results of the engine component / system plan, complete the structural development of the engine components, form component engineering drawings, and determine the technical status of the improved engine.
[0093] Step S33, requirement compliance analysis: Based on the results of the engine redesign work, the compliance analysis of the improvement requirements is completed according to the method of step S23 to ensure that the design improvement results meet the engine improvement requirements.
[0094] Step S4, aircraft engine "remanufacturing": aircraft engine "remanufacturing" is to complete product redesign and obtain product design results, and systematically and completely implement the definition of product design points, process points and inspection points to ensure the integrity and compliance of the manufacturing process and achieve manufacturing results that meet product improvement requirements. Specific instructions are as follows:
[0095] Step S41, define product design points: based on the results of the redesign, the engineering drawings of the improved parts are formed. The designers complete the definition of product design points, starting from the view requirements, technical conditions, product technical documents, relevant requirements in the product reference standards, etc., combined with the product's strength calculation results, process implementation process, assembly process, historical failures and problems of similar products, etc., analyze and form all the design control points of the product to ensure that all design control points are defined in the engineering drawings and technical requirements, and can fully undertake improvement needs.
[0096] Step S42, define product process key points: on the basis of completing the definition of product design key points, the process personnel complete the definition of process key points item by item based on the defined product design key points, ensure that the process key points undertake all the design key points, and ensure the compliance of the manufacturing process. The definition of process key points is jointly carried out by production process personnel, special process personnel, tooling design process personnel, tooling manufacturing process personnel, and assembly process personnel, and designers should participate in the collaboration. Among them, production process personnel should comprehensively analyze the correlation between process steps, operating methods, various process parameters, tools and equipment used and other factors and various design points from the whole process of product realization, and clarify the process points corresponding to each design point; special process personnel should analyze the correlation between process steps, operating methods, various process parameters, equipment and other factors and various design points from the special process of the product and the whole process of special process implementation, and clarify the process points corresponding to each design point; tooling design and manufacturing process personnel should analyze the correlation between tooling use and various design points from the whole process of tooling use, and clarify the process points corresponding to each design point; assembly process personnel should analyze the correlation between various process steps, process parameters, tools and equipment used and other factors and various design points from the whole process of product combination and assembly, and clarify the process points corresponding to each design point; when determining the process points, designers should provide technical guidance to process personnel on issues such as understanding and implementation of design points.
[0097] Step S43, define product inspection points: on the basis of completing the definition of product process points, the inspection personnel shall complete the definition of product inspection points item by item based on the defined process points to ensure the conformity of the process results. Product inspection points should be jointly carried out by inspection and testing personnel and quality control personnel. Among them, the inspection and testing personnel shall analyze the relevance with various design points from the aspects of inspection and testing tools, methods, measurement methods and parameters in the product manufacturing process and finished product inspection process, and consider the detectability of the corresponding process points. Quality control personnel shall consider the relevance with various design points from the aspects of quality inspection methods, tools, parameters of process products and final products, and consider the detectability of the corresponding process points.
[0098] Step S44, manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis: Complete the manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis according to the method of step S222 to ensure that all defined design points, process points, and inspection points meet the requirements and achieve that the manufacturing results meet the requirements of the design results.
[0099] For example, in this embodiment of the present application, after completing the product redesign and obtaining the product design results, the definition of product design key points-process key points-testing key points is implemented to ensure the compliance of the product design key points, process key points and test key points in the manufacturing process, and improve the product manufacturing compliance. The integrity and compliance analysis results of the product design key points-process key points-testing key points of the third-stage disk shaft of the aircraft engine are shown in Table 15.
[0100] Table 15 Engine third-stage disc shaft manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis table
[0101]
[0102]
[0103] Step S5, aircraft engine "revalidation": aircraft engine "revalidation" refers to the implementation of demand-based test planning on the basis of completing product "remanufacturing", and the execution of the whole process of test demand analysis - test planning - test program design - test outline preparation - test preparation - test execution - test result analysis, to ensure the comprehensiveness and effectiveness of product test validation and improve the compliance of product requirements.
[0104] Step S51, establish a test plan based on demand: according to the defined engine improvement demand list, complete the product test demand analysis and clarify the test verification items to achieve the demand according to the method of step S221 to form a test plan; clarify the test planning attributes such as demand number, demand item, demand classification, test item, verification requirement, verification level, verification resources, verification hours, test funds, and complete the preparation of the contents of Table 16.
[0105] Table 16 Requirements-based aircraft engine test planning
[0106]
[0107] For example, in this embodiment of the present application, based on the defined engine improvement requirements, the product test requirements analysis is completed and the test verification items to be implemented are clarified according to the method of step S51, and a test plan based on the requirements is established as shown in Table 17.
[0108] Table 17 Requirements-based aircraft engine test planning
[0109]
[0110]
[0111] Step S52, define the test process activities: the test process activities mainly include five process activities, namely test plan design, test outline preparation, test preparation, test execution, and test result analysis. Among them, test plan design: mainly by the test personnel according to the test planning and the requirements of the test task book, design the specific test plan, the content of the test plan mainly includes the sample size of the test piece, test time, test plan, parameter data processing method, test interruption processing and recovery, test organization and division of labor, test safety (risk and handling plan), etc., to ensure the feasibility of the test plan. Test outline preparation: the test outline is the basis for the test personnel to perform the test, mainly describing the specific steps of the test operation, inspection indicators or judgment basis; the main content of the test outline should include the source of the task, test time, test location, test name, test nature and purpose, test content, test product technical status, test system technical status, test preparation technical status, test procedures, test risks and control measures, test result evaluation criteria, etc., to ensure the correctness and executability of the test method. Test preparation: the engine test preparation process is as follows Figure 4 , the test implementation unit shall be responsible for the preparation of test pieces and the construction of test equipment in accordance with the relevant requirements of the test outline, mainly including the installation of test pieces, equipment modification or debugging, test environment construction, test equipment calibration, pre-test inspection and other tasks, and the test shall be executed and implemented after the inspection. Test execution: The test execution is mainly carried out in accordance with the requirements and steps of the test outline and test cards to complete the operation of the test, the control of key processes and test risks, and the recording and collection of test data, to ensure that the test data and process information are accurate, reliable and detailed. Test result analysis: See the test result analysis process for details. Figure 5 , mainly completing the confirmation and summary of test data, completing the test result analysis according to the test objectives, preparing the test result analysis report and test report, and determining whether the test meets the test objective requirements.
[0112] Step S53, implement full-level test verification: Based on the test planning results and the full-process test flow activities, complete the full-level test verification of engine components-component systems-whole machine according to the method of step S52, focusing on improving product test verification from the aspects of test item integrity, test piece technical status accuracy, test status integrity, test procedure integrity and executable, test process data record integrity and accuracy, etc., to ensure the validity of the test results.
[0113] Step S54, test result compliance analysis: According to the requirement compliance method of step S23 and based on the test verification criteria, the compliance of the test results is analyzed to ultimately ensure that the product verification requirements are met.
[0114] Step S6, "re-refinement" of model experience: "re-refinement" of model experience is to refine model experience and incorporate it into system elements based on new experience and understanding formed in the process of engine improvement, so as to ensure the continuous accumulation and improvement of product R&D capabilities; at the same time, summarize the experience of redesign engineering implementation, establish a "W" model for product improvement iterative development, integrate redesign engineering process activities into the R&D system, support the iterative development of products, and achieve optimal product development.
[0115] Step S61, engine multi-dimensional model experience extraction: The multi-dimensional model experience extraction of aircraft engines is aimed at the new experience and understanding formed in the process of engine improvement. It is summarized and extracted from five dimensions, such as mature technology, model specification documents, fault problems, research results, and test projects, to form R&D system elements, so as to transform the "implicit" development experience of the model into "explicit" system elements and incorporate them into the R&D system, so as to achieve the continuous accumulation and improvement of product R&D capabilities. The specific instructions are as follows:
[0116] Step S611, establish an engine multi-dimensional model experience refinement model: The aircraft engine multi-dimensional model experience refinement model is as follows Figure 6 . First, by summarizing the experience of model development, clarify the direction of mining and refining from five dimensions, including mature technology (core key technology above level 5), model specification documents (model specification documents formed in the process of model development), fault problems (faults and problems that have been reset to zero), research results (key technology research and completion), and test projects (test projects that have completed verification); secondly, establish a structured experience compilation method to compile complete and executable model experience from the dimensions of process activities, methods / criteria, and software tools; thirdly, clarify the type of system element carrier from aspects such as process activities, process documents, and software tools; finally, in accordance with the work requirements of system development and access, realize the integration of model experience into the R&D system.
[0117] Step S6111, model experience extraction method based on mature technology: The aircraft engine technology tree implements the step-by-step decomposition of technology according to the forward method of product breakdown structure (PBS)-work breakdown structure (WBS)-technology breakdown structure (TBS). The model experience extraction method based on mature technology is to extract the technology list with technology maturity level 5 or above in the technology tree, analyze the system element carrying results of each technology item by item, and extract system elements from specifications / standards, guidelines, software tools and databases for mature technology experience that is not carried by system elements. At the same time, clarify the process activities supported by system elements. The model experience extraction method based on mature technology is shown in Table 18.
[0118] Table 18 Model experience extraction method based on mature technology
[0119]
[0120]
[0121] Step S6112, experience extraction method based on model specification documents: The experience extraction method based on model specification documents mainly extracts model-specific specifications / standards and other documents formed in the process of model improvement. For specification / standard documents that have not yet formed system elements, the two dimensions of the document's application scope (whether the whole machine verification is carried out) and maturity (above level 5) are used to determine whether they meet the conditions for inclusion in the system elements. For model specification / standard guidance documents that have access, the system element carriers that carry technology and experience are clearly defined. The experience extraction method based on model specification documents is shown in Table 19.
[0122] Table 19: Experience extraction method based on model specification documents
[0123]
[0124]
[0125] Step S6113, model experience extraction method based on fault problems: The model experience extraction method based on fault problems mainly extracts faults and problems that have been zeroed out during model development, and mainly extracts new tools, methods, criteria and other experiences from the solutions to faults and problems; clarifies the carriers of system elements and incorporates them into the system. The model experience extraction method based on fault problems is shown in Table 20.
[0126] Table 20 Model experience extraction method based on fault problems
[0127]
[0128] Step S6114, model experience extraction method based on research results: Model experience extraction based on research results mainly extracts new methods, tools, criteria and other experiences from the results of completed technical research and project completion, and clarifies the system element carriers that need to be added and improved. The model experience extraction method based on research results is shown in Table 21.
[0129] Table 21 Model experience extraction method based on research results
[0130]
[0131]
[0132] Step S6115, model experience extraction method based on test projects: The model experience extraction based on test projects is mainly aimed at test projects that have completed test verification. According to the full test process activities such as test planning-test plan design-test outline-test preparation-test execution-test result analysis, the new methods and tools and other experiences gained in the whole test process are analyzed, and the newly added and improved system element carriers are clarified. The model experience extraction method based on test projects is shown in Table 22.
[0133] Table 22 Model experience extraction method based on test items
[0134]
[0135] Step S612, construct a structured experience extraction and compilation method: Based on the IPOCE model, a complete and executable model experience requires a complete description of the application scenario and other inputs, load conditions, operating conditions, test conditions and other control items, using professional knowledge background and thinking model and other enabling items to perform experience mining and extraction activities, output and form knowledge experience, such as Figure 7 Therefore, in order to ensure the completeness and accuracy of experience extraction, the structural components of model experience should include the following components: model experience (precautions and experience criteria) = input (application scenario) + control conditions (load conditions, working conditions, test conditions, etc.) + enabling conditions (professional knowledge and skills).
[0136] Step S613, clarify the type of system element carrier: according to the different types of model experience (process activities, methods / criteria, software tools, etc.), clarify the type of system element carrier from the aspects of process activities, specifications / standards, instructions, templates, checklists and software tools. First, for the new process activities extracted from the model experience, clarify the technical processes that need to be supplemented and improved; secondly, for the formation of new methods and criteria, clarify the specifications / standards, instructions, templates, checklists that need to be improved; finally, for the formation of new software tools, clarify the software tools that need to be supplemented and improved.
[0137] Step S614, development and access of system elements: In accordance with the standardization requirements and access requirements of the R&D system, complete the development and access of system elements, incorporate them into the product R&D system, support model sharing, form an interactive model of "models feed back to the system, and the system supports models", and realize the continuous accumulation of R&D system capabilities.
[0138] In this embodiment of the present application, according to the method of step S61, the model development experience is summarized and refined from five dimensions, including mature technology (core key technology above level 5), model specification documents (model specification documents formed during the model development process), fault problems (faults and problems that have been reset to zero), research results (key technology research and completion), and test projects (test projects that have completed verification) to form system elements. The results of the refinement are shown in Tables 23 to 27.
[0139] Table 23 Model experience extraction results based on mature technology
[0140]
[0141] Table 24 Model experience extraction results based on model specification documents
[0142]
[0143] Table 25 Model experience extraction results based on fault problems
[0144]
[0145]
[0146] Table 26 Model experience extraction results based on research results
[0147]
[0148] Table 27 Results of model experience extraction based on test items
[0149]
[0150] Step S62, establish the product improvement iterative development "W" model: First, summarize the process and methods of redesign engineering, such as Figure 1 ; Secondly, refine the process activities of redesign engineering, which mainly include four model improvement process activities such as reanalysis, redesign, remanufacturing and reverification for product design improvement; Thirdly, establish the "W" model of product improvement iterative development, and integrate the redesign engineering process activities into the product development process by optimizing and improving the existing product development process, such as Figure 8 , realize the transformation of product R&D model from the traditional V model to the "W" model, support the iterative development of products, and ensure the systematicness and effectiveness of product design improvements.
[0151] In order to achieve standardized control and unified centralized management of all-level requirements, full-process technical activities, all-level verification activities and system elements in the aircraft engine redesign project, the present application also provides an aircraft engine redesign project management system, which mainly includes an engine general requirement management module 110, a technical activity management module 120, a technical key point management module 130, a product definition management module 140, and a system element management module 150. Fig. 9 , the functions of each module are described as follows:
[0152] The engine general requirement management module 110 is used to characterize the general requirement items of the engine at all levels to ensure the integrity and compliance of the model requirement definition, mainly including: requirement number, requirement item, requirement classification, requirement source, responsible profession, feasibility analysis, feasibility analysis results, design verification criteria, design verification results, design compliance analysis, test verification criteria, verification level, verification resources, verification hours, test funds, test verification results, test compliance analysis, model problems, design improvement measures and other data information.
[0153] The technical activity management module 120 is mainly based on product development requirements, clarifies the design activities, design verification activities and test verification activities required to achieve the requirements, and ensures the integrity and compliance of the model development process. It mainly includes: activity name, activity type, activity status, activity integrity check, activity compliance check, activity certification documents, model problems, design improvement measures and other data information.
[0154] The technical point management module 130 is mainly based on R&D activities, clarifies the key methods and criteria that must be followed in the execution of technical activities, and ensures the accuracy of the execution of technical activities. It mainly includes: technical point name, reason for listing as a technical point, technical point mastery status, based on normative documents, technical point improvement suggestions and other data attributes.
[0155] The product definition management module 140 is mainly based on the product design results, and completely defines the design points, process points and inspection points of the product to ensure the integrity and compliance of the product manufacturing process. It mainly includes: drawing number, product development requirements, product design points, implementation of engineering drawings, product definition risk analysis, product process points, product process control results, process risk analysis, product inspection points, product inspection results, inspection process risk analysis and other data information.
[0156] The system element management module 150 mainly mines and refines the model development experience in multiple dimensions and forms system elements based on the model development experience, which is used to control the model experience extraction, system element development and access. It mainly includes: experience extraction dimension, experience extraction name, experience extraction result, experience integration system element type, system element name, system element file number, system element status and other data information.
[0157] Compared with the prior art, the method and system of the present application have the following advantages:
[0158] 1) The connotation and structure of aero-engine redesign engineering are proposed, the process activities and logical relationships of redesign engineering are clarified, and the problem of the unexecutable concept of "reengineering" in the national standard is solved; the "five re" process activities are proposed to make up for the lack of weak links in the product manufacturing process of the "three re" design method; at the same time, the traditional single product-oriented perspective is transformed into a dual perspective oriented to products and capabilities, and the connotation of "reengineering" in the national standard is expanded, and the method is executable; it has wide versatility;
[0159] 2) A demand-based "reanalysis" method for aircraft engines was established to positively examine the integrity and compliance of the model development process (design process, manufacturing process and verification process), solve the problem that traditional product improvements are fault-oriented and insufficient product risk identification leads to insufficient systematicness and integrity of design improvements, and improve the effectiveness and integrity of model design improvements; a demand-based model "redesign" improvement method was established to form a demand-based product design improvement (requirements analysis-architecture design-component / subsystem design-structure development-test verification) workflow and method, improve the integrity and compliance of model requirements and development processes, and ensure the effectiveness of model design improvements and compliance with requirements;
[0160] 3) Established an aircraft engine "remanufacturing" method based on product definition (design key points - process key points - inspection key points) to solve the problem that the existing "three re" method is insufficient to improve the weak links of product manufacturing process and ensure the conformity of product manufacturing; established a demand-based aircraft engine "revalidation" method, proposed a demand-based test planning method, and established a full-process test activity covering test demand analysis - test planning - test outline - test preparation - test execution - test result analysis to solve the problems of incomplete test validation items and non-standard test process in the product development process and ensure the integrity and effectiveness of product validation;
[0161] 4) A method for “re-refining” model experience was established to solve the problem of insufficient integration of model experience refinement into the R&D system in the past, to achieve the refinement of model development experience and integrate it into the elements of the R&D system, to achieve effective inheritance and reuse of model development experience, to continuously improve product R&D capabilities, and to effectively avoid the recurrence of fault problems; at the same time, a “W” model for product improvement and iterative development was established to integrate redesign engineering process activities into the R&D system, to ensure the systematicness and effectiveness of product design improvements;
[0162] 5) It solves the problems of incomplete records of product design improvement process, insufficient inheritability and reusability of model experience, and has the information management and control function of the whole process of product "R&D needs-design activities-product definition-verification activities-experience extraction", realizing standardized records and unified centralized management of aircraft engine product design improvement process. At the same time, the model experience formed in the product improvement process is included in the system element management, realizing the co-construction, common use and sharing of system elements between professions and models, which can provide support and reference for the development of other models.
[0163] The above is only a specific implementation of the present application, but the protection scope of the present application is not limited thereto. Any changes or substitutions that can be easily thought of by a person skilled in the art within the technical scope disclosed in the present application should be included in the protection scope of the present application. Therefore, the protection scope of the present application shall be based on the protection scope of the claims.
Claims
1. An aero-engine redesign engineering method, characterized in that: include: Clarify the connotation of redesign engineering, which is to optimize and improve the products in production and use of aero-engines again. Positively, guided by demand, systematically analyze the integrity and compliance of the entire R&D process of product demand-design activities-production and manufacturing-test verification, identify and discover risks and problems in the product, and improve and upgrade the technical status of the engine by modifying the design or improving the process; negatively guided by model experience, refine model development experience and integrate it into the R&D system, continuously supplement and improve and build an advanced, complete and easy-to-use independent R&D system, and realize the accumulation and improvement of the product R&D system capabilities; The process activities of the redesign project are clarified. The process activities of the redesign project include five process activities: reanalysis, redesign, remanufacturing, reverification and model experience re-refinement of aircraft engines. Among them, reanalysis, redesign, remanufacturing and re-verification are aimed at improving the design of engine models. The results of reanalysis are used as input to redesign, remanufacture and re-verify the products. The four are mutually confirmed and passed on layer by layer to reflect the end-to-end improvement and verification of product design improvements from demand to product delivery. Model experience re-refinement is aimed at accumulating and improving the capabilities of the product R&D system, including building a model experience refinement model and a product iterative development model to integrate multi-dimensional model experience into the R&D system. Based on the connotation and process activities of the redesign project, the architecture of the redesign project is constructed.
2. The aircraft engine redesign engineering method according to claim 1, characterized in that: The aircraft engine reanalysis process includes: Step S21, requirement completeness analysis: by constructing engine common items, the applicability of common requirement items is analyzed in combination with model development requirements, wherein, for the requirement content applicable to the model, but not included in the model development requirements or lacking clear technical indicator requirements, the incompleteness of the requirements in the model development process is identified and discovered; for the missing requirement content, the risks and problems of the product are identified, including the following processes: Step S211, establishing general requirements for all levels of the engine: first, establishing a general requirements architecture for the engine, based on the engine product decomposition structure, clarifying the requirements management hierarchical architecture of the engine whole machine layer, component / system layer and component layer, and realizing top-down requirements decomposition and top-up requirements verification; second, establishing a general engine requirements classification, in accordance with the requirements of the "Regulations on the Preparation of Special Specifications for Weapon Equipment Development Projects" GJB 6387-2008, forming a structured general engine requirements classification from multiple aspects including engine function, performance, integrity, combat applicability, general quality characteristics, and durability, to ensure the integrity of general requirements; finally, forming general requirements items, by sorting out model development requirements and summarizing the development experience of other similar models, sorting out foreign standards and materials, foreign cooperation experience, interpreting airworthiness standards and military standards, and in accordance with the principles of integrity, consistency, applicability, technicality, structuring, and itemization of the requirements items, summarizing and refining the requirements content, and constructing general requirements for all levels of the engine; Step S212, constructing model requirement items: first, analyzing the applicability of general requirement items, combining the development requirements of the engine model, analyzing the applicability of general requirement items item by item, and explaining the reasons for the inapplicability of inapplicable general requirement items; secondly, constructing model requirement items, supplementing the technical indicators of each general requirement item according to the model specifications of the engine and the technical requirements of the components / systems, and forming a complete model requirement item of the system; Step S213, requirement integrity analysis: First, define the engine requirement integrity analysis attributes, including: general requirement number, general requirement item, requirement classification, responsible profession, applicability analysis results, non-applicability description, and requirement attributes of model requirement items; second, based on the results of the applicability analysis of general requirement items, identify and discover incomplete requirements in the model development process for general requirement items that are applicable but are not included in the model development requirements or lack clear technical indicator requirements; finally, analyze the impact of missing requirement items on product development, and analyze the risks and problems of the model; Step S22, R&D process integrity and compliance analysis: The aircraft engine R&D process integrity and compliance analysis includes the design process, manufacturing process and verification process integrity and compliance analysis, identifying the risks and problems in the product R&D process, including the following processes: Step S221, design process integrity and compliance analysis: First, establish a product development process, based on the system engineering V model, build a forward product development process covering demand analysis-architecture design-component / subsystem design-structure development-test verification, and achieve full coverage of product demand-design-verification process; secondly, establish a design activity combing matrix, based on the product model development requirements, establish the relationship between the requirements and the design activities in the product development process, and clarify the design activities and design verification activities required to achieve the requirements. Among them, the design activities are the calculation and analysis activities that need to be carried out to achieve the requirements themselves, and the design verification activities are to verify the compliance of the requirements through calculation, simulation analysis and analogy, so as to ensure the integrity of the product design process. ; Secondly, clarify the technical points of the execution of design activities. The technical points are the key methods and criteria required for the execution of process activities. Among them, the technical points of design activities and design verification activities include model accuracy, characteristic dimensions, rationality of typical parameters, accuracy of working conditions and environmental loads, and accuracy of boundary conditions, to ensure the accuracy and compliance of the execution of design activities; finally, complete the integrity and compliance analysis of design activities. According to the results of the design activities and the technical points of the design activities, combined with the design output results of the engine, analyze the output results of each design activity item by item to see if they are complete and accurate, complete the integrity and compliance analysis of the design process, and analyze the possible risks for incomplete and non-compliant design activities; Step S222, manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis: First, complete the product definition, and clarify the product design points based on the product design results. The product design points refer to the design requirements related to the processing and assembly processes of aviation engine products proposed to meet the development requirements of product performance, structure, and strength, including the size requirements, technical requirements, and standard requirements in the product drawings; secondly, complete the integrity and compliance analysis of the product design points; analyze the implementation of the engine component engineering drawings based on the determined product design points, and put forward suggestions for improving and perfecting the engineering drawings for missing or non-compliant product design points; thirdly, based on the product design points, the process personnel complete the product Definitions of process key points and inspection key points: Product process key points refer to the process, process parameters, and process assurance measures that need to be controlled during the product manufacturing and assembly processes in order to meet the aircraft engine product design key points; Product inspection and testing key points refer to the inspection and testing means, methods, tools, and parameters that need to be controlled during the inspection and testing of product manufacturing and assembly in order to meet the aircraft engine product design key points, and clarify the control requirements of the product manufacturing process; Finally, analyze the integrity and compliance of the product manufacturing process; Based on the process data and results of product manufacturing and processing, analyze the integrity and compliance of product design key points-process key points-inspection key points, and put forward suggestions for manufacturing process improvement for existing problems; Step S223, verification process integrity and compliance analysis: First, establish a test plan based on demand, based on the product model development requirements, establish the relationship between the requirements and the verification activities in the product development process, clarify the test verification activities required to achieve the requirements, and confirm the compliance of the verification requirements through test verification, assembly verification, testing and product usage methods, so as to form a test verification plan based on demand and ensure the integrity of the product development verification process; secondly, define the technical points of the test activities, including the integrity of the test items, the accuracy of the technical status of the test pieces, the integrity of the test procedures, the accuracy of the test conditions, and the validity of the test results, so as to ensure the accuracy and compliance of the execution of the test activities; finally, complete the verification process integrity and compliance analysis, according to the test items and the technical points of the test activities in the test plan, combined with the verification results of the engine, analyze whether the output results of each verification activity are complete and accurate, complete the verification process integrity and compliance analysis, and analyze the possible risks for incomplete and non-compliant technical activities; Step S23, requirement compliance analysis: The requirement compliance analysis proves the satisfaction of the design verification criteria and test verification criteria corresponding to the requirements based on the design and verification results of the model, and explains the compliance results of the engine requirements; first, construct a model requirement verification matrix, clarify the attributes of the model requirement number, model requirement item, requirement classification, design criteria, design results, design verification compliance, and test verification criteria, and form a model requirement verification matrix; secondly, clarify the design verification criteria and test verification criteria of the requirements. The requirement verification criteria are the standards and requirements for proving the compliance of the requirements. According to the product development specifications and guidelines, the design criteria and verification criteria of the model requirements are clarified item by item from the two dimensions of design verification criteria and test verification criteria; thirdly, analyze the compliance of the model requirements, and based on the design and verification results of the model, prove the satisfaction of the design verification criteria and test verification criteria item by item, and explain the compliance results of the design verification and test verification of the engine requirements; finally, analyze the model risks and problems, and explain the risks and problems of the model development for the requirements that the design verification results or test verification results do not meet, so as to provide support for the improvement of model design and the improvement of the R&D system capabilities.
3. The aircraft engine redesign engineering method according to claim 2, characterized in that: The aircraft engine redesign process includes: Step S31, defining product improvement requirements: based on the requirements integrity analysis results, the R&D process integrity and compliance analysis results, and the requirements compliance analysis results, the engine improvement requirements are clarified for the requirements that are missing from product development requirements, incomplete and non-compliant R&D processes, unsatisfied development requirements, and requirements that are changed by users; Step S32, implement product forward design: first, based on the defined product improvement requirements, complete product requirement analysis and form a list of design and design verification activities for requirement realization according to the method of step S221; second, according to the forward product development process of requirement analysis-architecture design-component / subsystem design-structural development, carry out engine function design, logical architecture design and physical architecture design, and complete engine whole machine design and design verification activities according to the technical activity list to form an engine whole machine design plan; third, complete engine component / system design, complete component / system layer design and design verification activities to form a component system plan; finally, based on the engine component / system plan design results, complete the structural development of engine components, form component engineering drawings, and determine the technical status of the improved engine; Step S33, requirement compliance analysis: Based on the results of the engine redesign work, the compliance analysis of the improvement requirements is completed according to the method of step S23 to ensure that the design improvement results meet the engine improvement requirements.
4. The aircraft engine redesign engineering method according to claim 3, characterized in that: The aircraft engine remanufacturing process includes: Step S41, defining product design points: based on the redesign results, the engineering drawings of the improved parts are formed. The designer completes the definition of product design points. Starting from the view requirements, technical conditions, product technical documents, and relevant requirements in the product reference standards, combined with the product's strength calculation results, process implementation process, assembly process, and historical failures and problems of similar products, all design control points of the product are analyzed and formed to ensure that all design control points are defined in the engineering drawings and technical requirements, and can fully meet the improvement needs; Step S42, define product process key points: on the basis of completing the definition of product design key points, the process personnel complete the definition of process key points item by item based on the defined product design key points, ensure that the process key points undertake all the design key points, and ensure the compliance of the manufacturing process; the definition of process key points is jointly carried out by production process personnel, special process personnel, tooling design process personnel, tooling manufacturing process personnel, and assembly process personnel, and the designers should participate in the collaboration. Among them, the production process personnel should comprehensively analyze the correlation between the process steps, operation methods, various process parameters, tools and equipment factors used and various design key points from the whole process of product realization, and clarify the process key points corresponding to each design key point; the special process personnel should Analyze the correlation between process steps, operation methods, various process parameters, equipment factors and various design points in the whole process of special process and special process implementation, and clarify the process points corresponding to various design points; tooling design and manufacturing process personnel should analyze the correlation between tooling use and various design points from the whole process of tooling use, and clarify the process points corresponding to various design points; assembly process personnel should analyze the correlation between various process steps, process parameters, tools and equipment factors used and various design points from the whole process of product combination and assembly, and clarify the process points corresponding to various design points; when determining the process points, designers should provide technical guidance to process personnel on the understanding and implementation of design points; Step S43, define product inspection key points: on the basis of completing the definition of product process key points, the inspection personnel shall complete the definition of product inspection key points item by item based on the defined process key points to ensure the conformity of the process results; product inspection key points shall be jointly carried out by the inspection and testing personnel and the quality control personnel, among which the inspection and testing personnel shall analyze the relevance with various design key points from the aspects of inspection and testing tools, methods, measurement methods and parameters in the product manufacturing process and finished product inspection process, and consider the detectability of the corresponding process key points; the quality control personnel shall consider the relevance with various design key points from the aspects of quality inspection methods, tools and parameters of process products and final products, and consider the detectability of the corresponding process key points; Step S44, manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis: Complete the manufacturing process integrity and compliance analysis according to the method of step S222 to ensure that all defined design points, process points, and inspection points meet the requirements and achieve that the manufacturing results meet the requirements of the design results.
5. The aircraft engine redesign engineering method according to claim 4, characterized in that: The aircraft engine revalidation process includes: Step S51, establish a test plan based on demand: according to the defined engine improvement demand list, complete the product test demand analysis and clarify the test verification items to be realized according to the method of step S221, and form a test plan; clarify the test plan attributes including demand number, demand item, demand classification, test item, verification requirement, verification level, verification resource, verification hours, and test funds; Step S52, define the test process activities: the test process activities include test plan design, test outline preparation, test preparation, test execution, and test result analysis. Among them, the test plan design is designed by the test personnel according to the requirements of the test planning and test task book, and the specific test plan is designed. The content of the test plan includes the sample size of the test piece, test time, test plan, parameter data processing method, test interruption processing and recovery, test organization and division of labor, and test safety to ensure the feasibility of the test plan; test outline preparation: the test outline is the basis for the test personnel to perform the test, which is used to explain the specific steps of the test operation, inspection indicators or judgment basis; the test outline content includes the task source, test time, test location, test name, test nature and purpose, test content, test product technical status, test system technical status , test preparation technical status, test procedures, test risks and control measures, test result evaluation criteria to ensure the correctness and executability of the test method; test preparation is in accordance with the relevant requirements of the test outline, and the test implementation unit is responsible for test piece preparation and test equipment construction, including test piece installation, equipment modification or debugging, test environment construction, test equipment calibration, pre-test inspection, and test execution and implementation after inspection; test execution is in accordance with the requirements and steps of the test outline and test cards to complete the test operation, key process and test risk control and test data recording and collection, to ensure the accuracy, reliability and detailedness of the test data and process information; test result analysis completes the test data confirmation and summary, completes the test result analysis according to the test objectives, prepares the test result analysis report and test report, and determines whether the test meets the test objective requirements; Step S53, implement full-level test verification: Based on the test planning results and the full-process test flow activities, complete the full-level test verification of engine components-component systems-whole machine according to the method of step S52, focusing on improving product test verification from the aspects of test item integrity, test piece technical status accuracy, test status integrity, test procedure integrity and executable, and test process data record integrity and accuracy to ensure the validity of the test results; Step S54, test result compliance analysis: According to the requirement compliance method of step S23 and based on the test verification criteria, the compliance of the test results is analyzed to ultimately ensure that the product verification requirements are met.
6. The aircraft engine redesign engineering method according to claim 5, characterized in that: The model experience re-refining process includes: Step S61, engine multi-dimensional model experience extraction: The multi-dimensional model experience extraction of aircraft engines is aimed at the new experience and understanding formed in the process of engine improvement. It is summarized and extracted from mature technologies, model specification documents, fault problems, research results, and test projects to form R&D system elements, so as to transform the "implicit" development experience of the model into "explicit" system elements and incorporate them into the R&D system, so as to achieve the continuous accumulation and improvement of product R&D capabilities, including: Step S611, establish a multi-dimensional engine model experience extraction model: first, by summarizing the model development experience, clarify the mining and extraction direction from multiple dimensions such as mature technology, model specification documents, fault problems, research results, and test projects; second, establish a structured experience compilation method to compile complete and executable model experience from the dimensions of process activities, methods / criteria, and software tools; third, clarify the system element carrier type from the aspects of process activities, process documents, and software tools; finally, according to the work requirements of system development and access, realize the integration of model experience into the R&D system; Step S6111, a method for extracting model experience based on mature technology: the aircraft engine technology tree implements a step-by-step decomposition of technology according to the forward method of product breakdown structure-work breakdown structure-technology breakdown structure, extracts a list of technologies with a technology maturity level of 5 or above from the technology tree, analyzes the system element carrying results of each technology item by item, and extracts system elements from specifications / standards, guidelines, software tools and databases for mature technology experience that is not carried by system elements; at the same time, clarifies the process activities supported by the system elements; Step S6112, experience extraction method based on model specification documents: extract model-specific specification / standard documents formed in the process of model improvement, and determine whether the specification / standard documents that have not yet formed system elements meet the conditions for inclusion in system elements from the two dimensions of application scope and maturity of the documents. For model specification / standard guidance documents that have been approved, clarify the system element carriers that carry technology and experience; Step S6113, model experience extraction method based on fault problems: extract faults and problems that have been zeroed out during model development, extract new tools, methods and criteria from the solutions to the faults and problems; clarify the carriers of system elements and incorporate them into the system; Step S6114, model experience extraction method based on research results: by extracting new methods, tools and criteria for the results of completed technical research and project conclusion, clarify the system element carriers that need to be added and improved; Step S6115, model experience extraction method based on test items: for test items that have completed test verification, according to the full test process of test planning - test plan design - test outline - test preparation - test execution - test result analysis, analyze the new methods and tools experience gained in the whole test process, and clarify the newly added and improved system element carriers; Step S612, constructing a structured experience extraction and compilation method: Based on the IPOCE model, a complete executable model experience needs to fully describe the application scenario input, load conditions, working conditions, test condition control items, use professional knowledge background and thinking model enablers, perform experience mining and extraction activities, and output and form knowledge experience; Step S613, clarify the type of system element carrier: for the model experience that has been formed, clarify the type of system element carrier from the aspects of process activities, specifications / standards, instructions, templates, checklists and software tools according to the different types of model experience; first, for the new process activities extracted from the model experience, clarify the technical processes that need to be supplemented and improved; secondly, for the formation of new methods and criteria-type experiences, clarify the specifications / standards, instructions, templates, checklists that need to be improved; finally, for the formation of new software tools, clarify the software tools that need to be supplemented and improved; Step S614, development and access of system elements: according to the standardization requirements and access requirements of the R&D system, complete the development and access of system elements, incorporate them into the product R&D system, support model sharing, form an interactive model of "models feed back to the system, and the system supports models", and realize the continuous accumulation of R&D system capabilities; Step S62, establish a W model for iterative development of product improvement: first, summarize the process and methods of redesign engineering; second, refine the process activities of redesign engineering, including reanalysis, redesign, remanufacturing and reverification improvement process activities for product design improvement; third, establish a W model for iterative development of product improvement, and integrate the redesign engineering process activities into the product development process by optimizing and improving the existing product development process, so as to realize the transformation of the product R&D model from the traditional V model to the W model, support the realization of iterative product development, and ensure the systematicness and effectiveness of product design improvement.
7. An aircraft engine redesign engineering system, used to implement the aircraft engine redesign engineering method according to any one of claims 1 to 6, characterized in that: include: The engine general requirement management module (110) is used to characterize the general requirement items of the engine at all levels to ensure the integrity and compliance of the model requirement definition, including: requirement number, requirement item, requirement classification, requirement source, responsible profession, feasibility analysis, feasibility analysis results, design verification criteria, design verification results, design compliance analysis, test verification criteria, verification level, verification resources, verification hours, test funds, test verification results, test compliance analysis, model problems, and design improvement measures data information; A technical activity management module (120) specifies the design activities, design verification activities and test verification activities required for realizing the requirements based on the product development requirements, and ensures the integrity and compliance of the model development process, including: activity name, activity type, activity status, activity integrity check, activity compliance check, activity certification documents, model problems, and design improvement measures data information; The technical point management module (130) clarifies the key methods and criteria to be followed in the execution of technical activities based on R&D activities, and ensures the accuracy of the execution of technical activities, including: the name of the technical point, the reason for listing it as a technical point, the mastery status of the technical point, the standard documents based on it, and the data attributes of the technical point improvement suggestions; The product definition management module (140) completely defines the design key points, process key points and inspection key points of the product based on the design results of the product to ensure the integrity and compliance of the product manufacturing process, including: drawing number, product development requirements, product design key points, implementation of engineering drawings, product definition risk analysis, product process key points, product process control results, process risk analysis, product inspection key points, product inspection results, and inspection process risk analysis data information; The system element management module (150) is based on the model development experience, multi-dimensionally excavates and refines the model development experience and forms system elements, which are used to control the extraction of model experience, the development and access of system elements, including: experience extraction dimension, experience extraction name, experience extraction result, experience integration system element type, system element name, system element file number, and system element status data information.
Citation Information
Patent Citations
Numerical-control remanufacturing method of old heavy horizontal lathe and control device for numerical-control remanufacturing of old heavy horizontal lathe
CN105345036A
Novel electric, thermal and mechanical property collaborative environment for electronic product packaging
CN113128166A
Mars rover dormancy awakening function verification method based on FSM
CN113900423A
System fatigue reliability prediction method for large aviation planetary mechanism
CN115438543A
Cited By
Equipment digital main line construction method based on product decomposition structure
CN121258150A
Equipment digital main line construction method based on product breakdown structure
CN121258150B
Airplane power distribution system test confirmation automatic distribution system and method based on demand matrix
CN122155755A
